On the Arc Spectrum , Vanadium .
" On the Arc Spectrum of Vanadium .
" By Sir Norman Lockyer , K.C.B. , F.B.S. , and F. E. Baxandall , A.B.C.S. Beceived March 19 , \#151 ; Bead March 28 , 1901 .
The spectrum of vanadium is so important , especially on account of the prominent part which lines of that element play in the spectra of sun-spots , and the existing records of vanadium lines differ so considerably , that it has been thought desirable to publish a list of the lines reduced some time ago from the Kensington photographs of the arc spectrum .
These photographs were obtained by Mr. C. P. Butler with a 6-inch Kowland concave grating of 21J feet focal length and 14,438 lines to the inch .
The region of the spectrum investigated extends from A 3887 to A 4932 , and occupies on the plates a length of 16| inches .
The sources of the spectra were ( 1 ) vanadium chloride , and ( 2 ) a pure sample of vanadium oxide supplied by Sir Henry Boscoe , to whom we wish to express our thanks .
In each case they were volatilised in the arc between poles of the purest silver which could be obtained , and which were kindly placed at our disposal by Sir W. C. Boberts-Austen .
These are used because the number of lines due to the poles themselves is so small compared with that produced when carbon poles are employed , that it is much easier to detect the lines really due to the substance under consideration .
Lists of lines in the arc spectrum of vanadium have been published by Bowland and Harrison* and by Hasselberg.f The former investigators used some compound of vanadium ( not stated in their paper ) volatilised on carbon poles ; the latter employed poles made of the metal itself .
The three records naturally contain a large number of lines in .common , but there are many differences between any two of them for which it is difficult to account .
To show these differences it has been considered best to give side by side in tabular form the lines in the thiee lists , and analyse the lines special to any one list , with the object of either properly establishing their claim to be accepted as true lines of vanadium , or possibly tracing them to their real origin .
It may be safely assumed that lines common to any two of the lists really belong to vanadium .
To eliminate lines due to impurities , the vanadium spectrum has been directly compared with the arc spectra of all the other elements available at Kensington , photographed exactly on the same scale .
If the " strongest " lines of an element are not represented in the vanadium spectrum , apparent coincidences with any of the " weaker " lines are * ' Astro.-Phys .
Jour .
, ' vol. 7 , p. 273 , 1898 .
t ' Sveuska Vetenskaps Akad .
Handl .
, ' toI .
32 , No. 2 , 1899 .
190 Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
not accepted as furnishing any proof of the existence of that element as an impurity in the vanadium .
This comparison shows that , in addition to those belonging to silver , the only lines which with any degree of probability can be attributed to other metals , are traces of the very strongest lines only of iron , manganese , chromium , cobalt , calcium , strontium , aluminium , and lead .
Such lines ( a list of which is given later in the paper ) have been left out of the following table .
Although Rowland gives his wave-lengths to one-thousandth of a tenth-metre , for convenience of comparison with the other records his values are quoted , throughout the present paper , to the nearest hundredth of a tenth-metre .
A brief reference must be made to Rowland 's scale of intensities .
In his paper he states that the scale he has adopted is from 1 to 15 .
There are , however , several intensities given which are beyond these limits ; but they are probably due to typographical errors .
Such cases are indicated in the column for remarks .
It would seem rather difficult to reconcile his adoption of such a scale with the opinion expiessed in the introduction to his " Preliminary Table of Solar Spectrum Wave-lengths " to the effect that " the ordinary scale from 1 to 10 or from 1 to 6 is far too limited for the spectral lines , especially for the metallic spectra ; 1 to 1000 is hardly great enough for the enormous difference in intensity .
The small range , 1 to 10 , ordinarily used gives an entirely wrong idea to the worker in this subject , and many books with spectroscopic theories might have been saved by using a scale from 1 to 1000 .
" Vanadium Arc Lines .
Comparison of Kensington Records with Hasselberg 's and Rowland 's .
Kensington .
llasselberg .
Rowland .
Int. | Int. Int. A. Max. A. Max. A. Max. = 10 .
= 4-5 .
= 15 .
38S7 '69 \lt ; i 88 -20 2 3888 -23 1 88 *47 3 88-50 2 89-36 1-2 89 -91 \lt ; 1 90-30 7 90-33 3 3890 -30 4 91 -25 5 91 -27 2 91 -88 1 92 -53 2\#151 ; 3 92-47 4 92 95 6-7 93 -03 3 93-88 \lt ; 1 94 -16 4-5 94-19 2 95 -86 2-3 96-29 4 96-29 2 96-26 2 'Remarks .
On the Arc Spectrum of Vanadium .
I anadiumArc Linen\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
Int. Int. Int. A. Max A. Max. X. Max = 10 .
_ !
=4-5 .
= 15 .
3896 -83 2 \#151 ; - 97-20 4 3897-22 2 98-17 6 98-15 3 3898 -08 1 98 -44 3 99 -23 3-4 99 -30 1 3900 -29 4-5 3900 -33 2-3 01 -28 4-5 01 -30 2-3 01 -81 2 02-45 10 02 -40 3-4 3902 -37 7 02-71 1 03-32 3-4 03 -42 1-2 03 -86 !
\lt ; 1 04-51 3-4 04-63 1 06-92 4 06 -89 2 07 33 2 08-46 3 09-58 \lt ; 1 09-96 9 10 -01 3 09 -99 5 10 -57 \lt ; 1 10-92 j 4 10 -95 2 11-90 1 12 -35 5 12-36 2-3 13-04 3 13-03 2 13-71 1 14 -08 \lt ; 1 14 -49 4 14 -44 1 15 -30 1-2 15-57 2 16 -57 3-4 16-55 1-2 19 -60 1 20-10 1 20-15 1 20-67 4 20-65 | 1-2 22-11 4 22 -15 2 22 -02 1 22 *57 5 22 -58 2-3 22 -55 3 24 -85 5 24-84 2-3 24 -77 3 25 -36 5 25 -36 2 25 -35 3 26 -64 \lt ; 1 26 -86 1-2 28 -07 5 28 -64 1-2 29-93 1 30-19 6 30 -19 2\#151 ; 3 31 -46 5 f 31-40 1 34 -18 5-0 \ 31 -50 2 33-77 3 34-16 3-4 35 -28 4-5 35-28 2-3 36 -43 3-4 36 -42 2 37-65 3 37-68 2 38 -37 3 38 -35 2 39 -04 1-2 39 -49 3 39-48 2 Remarks .
Ca ( K ) .
192 Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
Remarks .
A. Int. Max. = 10 .
A. Int. Max. = 4-5 .
A Int. Max. = 15 .
3940 -75 2 3940 -75 1 41 *40 3 41 .
40 1-2 42 -18 4 42-16 2 43 -81 5 43 -77 2-3 3944 -13 3 Al .
45 -36 1 46 -04 \lt ; 1 48-79 3 50 -38 4 50 -37 2 52-12 5 52-09 2 52 -07 1 61 -65 5 Al .
63 -78 3 63 -77 2 64*64 1-2 68 -29 3 68 -24 2 68 -59 1 Ca ( II ) .
72 -12 2 72-10 1 73 -53 i 73 -49 1 73 -79 3-4 73 -79 2 75 -48 1-2 77 -88 2 79 -31 3 79 -30 2 79 -61 3 79-59 2 79 -54 80-66 3 80-66 2 81 -78 4-5 84 -5L 3 84 -78 3-4 84 -75 2 88 -21 \lt ; 1 88 -98 4 88 -97 1 2 89 -95 1 90-72 7 90-71 3 90 -69 5 91 -22 1 92 -95 7 92 -95 3 92-92 3 95 -08 2 97 -31 3-4 97-30 1-2 98 -91 7 98 -87 3 98-85 3 4000 -24 2 4000 -24 1 03 -12 3 03 -10 1-2 03 -70 2-3 03 -70 1-2 05 -90 4-5 05 -86 2 4005 -84 1 08 -33 \lt ; 1 09 -99 1-2 09 -94 1 11 -50 2-3 11 -45 1 13 -69 \lt ; 1 15 -26 1 15-20 1 16 -86 \lt ; 1 19-18 \lt ; 1 19 -58 \lt ; 1 20 -73 1 22 -07 2-3 22 -04 1 23 -28 2-3 23 -48 3-4 23 -50 2 23-51 1 24 -63 \lt ; 1 i On the Arc Spectrum of Vanadium .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
A. Int. Max \#151 ; 10 .
A. Int. Max. = 4-5 .
A. Int. Max = 15 .
Remarks .
4025 -47 i 4025-46 i 30 -05 1-2 30 -04 1\#151 ; 2 31 -36 2 31 -37 1-2 31 -99 4 31-98 2 4031 -96 1 32 '64 1-2 32 -62 1-2 33 *00 1 33 -01 1 33 19 3 Mn .
34-62 2 Mn .
35-77 4 35 -77 2 36 -93 2 36-93 1 39-76 \lt ; i 40 *43 1-2 40-46 1 41 -66 2-3 41 -72 2 42 -80 3-4 42*78 2 42-76 1 46 -99 i 47-05 1 48 -77 2-3 48 -77 2 51 -10 5 51-11 2-3 51-52 5 51 -48 2-3 52-60 1 52-60 1 53 -41 2-3 53 -81 \lt ; 1 - 57 -21 5 57 -21 3 57 -21 2 i 57 -96 1 Pb 61 -00 1 60 -97 1 61-76 1 62 -92 1 64-11 4-5 64-09 2-3 64 -06 2 65 -54 1-2 67 '96 2-3 67 -90 1-2 68-16 2-3 70 -94 2-3 71 -67 4-5 71-67 2-3 71-66 2 72 -28 2-3 72 -30 2 77-85 1 S:* .
78 -10 1 : 83 -07 3-4 : 83 -44 \lt ; 1 84 *92 \lt ; 1 88 -00 \lt ; 1 90 05 1 90 -74 8 90 *70 3 90-70 5 92-08 3 92 -09 1-2 92 -55 4 92-54 2 92-53 2 92 -81 8 92 -83 3 93-61 3-4 93 -65 2 94-38 3 94 -42 2 I 95-60 7 95 -64 3 95 -61 5 i 97-05 2-3 97-09 1-2 98 -50 3-4 98 -54 2 98 -51 1 98 -99 1 i 99 -94 9 99-93 3-4 99 -92 7 1 4101 -99 1-2 l Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
Viinadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
i Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
Infc .
Int. Tnt .
Remarks .
A. Max. A. Max. A. Max .
= 10 = 4-5 .
= 15 .
4101 -65 \lt ; 1 1 02 -25 6-7 4102 -32 3 4102 -28 03 -54 1-2 04 -52 4 04-55 2 04 -52 2 04-93 3-4 04 -92 2 05 -33 7 05-32 3 .
06 -08 1 07 -60 3 07-64 1-2 07-60 1 08 -32 4 08 -36 2 09 -20 2 09 -89 8 09-94 3-4 09 -91 7 10 -86 1 11 -22 \lt ; 1 12-00 10 11-92 4 11 -92 5 12-50 4 12-47 1-2 13-62 5 13 -65 2-3 13 -64 3 14 -69 3 14 -69 1-2 ' 15 -33 9 .
15-32 3-4 15 -31 7 16 64 8 16 -64 3 16 -63 9 16-85 1 *2 18 -34 4-5 18-34 2 *3 18 -32 1 18-76 4-5 18-73 2 1 19-23 1 19 -56 ; 4-5 19 -58 2 19 -57 3 20 -65 4-5 20 -69 2 20-65 2 21 -08 2 21 -13 1 2175 2-3 22 -45 1 22 -94 \lt ; 1 23-30 3 23 -59 7 23 -65 3 24-15 3-4 24-23 2 24-20 1 27 -15 1 27 -56 \lt ; 1 28 -20 9 28-25 3-4 28 15 7 28-94 4 29 -00 2 39-28 \lt ; 1 30 -44 1 31 -07 \lt ; 1 31 26 1 31 -32 1 31 -30 1 32 -08 9 32-13 3-4 32-13 6 : 32 -93 1 33-86 3 33 -92 2 34-61 9 34-61 3-4 34 -62 7 | 35 -40 1 36 -27 3 36 -25 2 36 -55 2-3 36 -52 37 -06 1 37 -36 \lt ; 1 38 -17 2 39 -34 3-4 39 -39 2 41 -50 3 On the Arc Spectrum of .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
1 s Remarks .
; Int. Max = 10 .
Infc .
Max. = 4-5 .
Int. Max = 15 .
4141-91 1-2 4141 -96 1-2 -i \#151 ; \#151 ; 42 -80 1-2 42 -75 1-2 43 -02 1 43 -02 i 43 -47 \lt ; 1 45 -62 2 46 15 \lt ; i 47-90 2 49-01 2-3 49 -02 1-2 50 -22 \lt ; 1 50-80 2-3 50 -84 2 51 -46 \lt ; i 51 -52 i 52 -80 2-3 52-81 2 53 -47 2-3 53 -49 1-2 54-16 \lt ; 1 55 -34 \lt ; 1 55-39 1 55 -95 1 56 -00 1-2 56 -65 \lt ; 1 58 -11 1 58-14 1 58 -58 \lt ; 1 59 -82 5 59 -84 2-3 4159 -82 2 60-48 1 60 -57 1 62 -48 \lt ; 1 62 -51 1 66 -86 1-2 67 -15 1 69-08 \lt ; 1 69 -37 2-3 69 -40 1\#151 ; 2 71 -42 3\#151 ; 4 71 -45 2 74-13 4 74-18 2 74 -16 1 75 -24 1 75-30 1 !
76-85 .
\lt ; 1 76 -83 1 77 -00 \lt ; 1 77-02 1 77 -19 3 77-25 1 77 -67 1 78 -53 1 79-54 6 79 -53 2-3 80-12 1 80-95 1 80-99 1 '82-21 2\#151 ; 3 82 -23 1-2 j 82 -74 5-6 82 -74 2-3 82 -73 1 83 -07 4 83 '45 1 83-43 | 1 83 -60 2-3 83-59 !
1 84 -55 \lt ; 1 j 86 -91 1 86-95 | 1 87 -74 1 87-82 1 1 89 -95 5-6 89-99 2-3 90 -01 2 91 -69 5-6 91 -70 2-3 I 94 -13 1-2 94 -17 1 i i 95 -73 2-3 ; !
97 -43 1 97 -45 1 97 -74 3-4 97 -77 2 !
98 -74 3-1 98 -78 2 ' ' 1 , Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
Fimadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hass el berg .
Rowland .
X. Int. Int. Int. Remarks .
Max A. Max. A. Max = 10 .
= 4-5 .
= 15 .
4199-75 \lt ; i 99-97 i 4200 -30 3 4200 -35 2 01 -05 1-2 02 -50 2-3 02-52 1 4202 -51 | 2 04 -34 \lt ; i 04 -67 \lt ; i 04 -67 1 05 -28 2-3 05 -23 1 05 -20 2 06-73 i 10-00 4-5 09-98 2-3 10 -oo 5 f Probably masked in Ken10 -55 11 02 1 . . . .
I sington photograph by a 1 * * j strong broad line of Ag l at X4212 -1 16 *50 1 16 -52 1 18*89 3-4 18-86 2 19 *66 1-2 ] 9 -65 1-2 21 *22 1 21 -17 i , 22 *54 1-2 22 -49 1 23 15 1 i 24 -36 3-4 24 -30 2 1 25 *41 1-2 25 -40 1 25 -37 1 26-78 2 . . . .
f Probably masked by Ca line 1 at A 4226 *91 .
26 -87 4 Ca. 27 -92 3-4 27 -90 2 29 92 3-4 29-87 2 32 -68 5-6 32-62 3 32-60 1 7 33 -09 5-6 33-09 3 33-11 1 7 34-18 5-6 34-12 3 34-15 7 34 -71 4 34 -70 2-3 34-67 7 35 -92 4-5 35-90 : 2-3 35-91 | 4 36 *78 \lt ; 1 39-15 2 39 -12 1-2 39 -80 \lt ; 1 40 -29 2-3 40*25 2 40-54 3 40*53 i 2 41 -52 3 41 *48 1 2 .
46-91 1 47 -43 1 47*46 1 51 *42 \lt ; 1 51*45 1 \#166 ; 53 -00 1-2 53*02 1 *2 55 -59 \lt ; 1 55 *60 1 *2 57 -50 4 57 *53 2 57-52 4 59 *47 4 59 *46 2 59-45 4 60-00 1 60 -28 1 60 -46 1 61 -32 2-3 61 *37 2 62 30 4 62 *32 2 62 -31 4 65 -25 3 65*28 2 66 07 2 On the Arc Spectrum of Vanadium .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
Tnt .
Int. Infc .
A. Max A. Max. A. Max. = 10 .
= 4-5 .
= 15 .
4267 -48 2 4267-50 1-2 68-78 6 68-78 3 4268-79 o* * ?
( 10 ) 69 -89 3-4 69 -92 2 70 -51 3-4 70 -49 2 71 -75 6 71-71 3 71 -71 17# * ?
( 7 ) 72 -93 \lt ; 1 73 -50 \lt ; 1 76 -50 \lt ; 1 77 -10 5-6 77 -12 3 77 -10 7 78 -53 \lt ; 1 79 -12 2 79-12 1-2 83 -08 3-4 83-06 2 84 -19 6 84-19 3 84 -21 5 86-57 3\#151 ; 4 86-57 ; 2 87-93 3-4 87-97 1 2 89 -00 1 91-45 3 91 -46 2 91 -96 5-6 91 -97 3 91 -98 1 96-30 5 96 -28 2\#151 ; 3 96-27 7 97-29 1 97 -85 4-5 97 -86 2-3 97 -84 7 ; 98-17 4-5 98-17 2-3 98 -79 \lt ; 1 99-27 1-2 99 -24 1 4302 -32 1-2 03-70 05-64 2-3 4303 -70 2 4303 -70 2 06 -40 5 06-35 2-3 06-76 \lt ; 1 07 32 5 !
07-33 J 2-3 08-61 \lt ; 1 09-75 2 j 09-69 ; 1\#151 ; 2 09-95 5 09-95 3 09 -95 7 11-66 1 !
1 1 11-83 1 .
12-58 1 12*56 j 1 14-11 2-3 14-06 1-2 15-02 2 15 -95 \lt ; 1 16-02 1 18 -04 \lt ; 1 18 -80 2 Ca. 20-15 \lt ; 1 20-49 i 1\#151 ; 2 20 -46 1 22 53 : 1-2 22-51 i !
29 90 \lt ; 1 30- 18 : 31- 28 i 6 1 30 *18 3 i 30-18 0* * ?
( 10 ) .
32-60 2 32-56 1-2 !
32-96 6 32-98 3 32-98 10 34-25 S 3 34 -23 i 1-2 35 06 \lt ; 1 35-69 \lt ; 1 Remarks .
198 Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
Int. lilt .
Int. Remarks .
A. Max. A. Max. A. Max. = 10 .
=4-5 .
= 15 .
433633 2-3 4336 *29 1-2 39 31 \lt ; i 41 *19 7 41 -15 3 4341 -16 10 42-39 2-3 42 -36 1-2 43 02 3-4 43-00 2 45 39 \lt ; 1 47 02 \lt ; 1 47-64 1 50 -86 1 50 -97 2\#151 ; 3 52-68 2 53-02 7 53-02 4 53 -04 18* * ?
( 8 ) .
53 -54 2 55 -14 3-4 55 -09 2 55 -14 4 56 14 4-5 56-10 2-3 56 -10 4 56-98 2 57-64 2 57 -60 1-2 57 -86 1 57 -82 1 60-77 2-3 60-75 1-2 61-24 1\#151 ; 2 61 -18 1 61 -58 2-3 61 -57 1-2 63 -54 \lt ; 1 63-48 1 63-75 3-4 63 -69 2 63 -69 4 64-40 3-4 64-37 2 64 -38 4 65-94 2-3 65-92 1-2 66-76 \lt ; 1 1 67 -26 1 67 -24 1 68 -23 5 68 -25 2 68 -78 3-4 68 -76 1-2 68-76 4 | 69 -24 2 69-25 1 : 71 -98 \lt ; 1 73 -40 4 73-40 2 73-38 6 1 74 -01 3-4 73-99 2 73-98 !
3 | 74 -38 \lt ; 1 75-28 1-2 75-51 3-4 75 -47 2 I 76 *25 1-2 j 76-25 1 I 77 -05 \lt ; 1 77 -33 \lt ; 1 78*13 2-3 !
7.8 -06 2 79 -44 10 79-38 4-5 79-39 !
1* # P ( 10 ) .
Strongest line in 80-75 4 80-69 2 80-72 ; 4 i the whole spectrum .
81 -21 2 81-19 i i 81-43 1 81 -93 1 83 -39 \lt ; 1 84-13 1 84-07 1 84-42 2 84-37 1 84 92 9 84 -87 4-5 84 *87 i i* * ?
( 10 ) .
Yerj strong line .
85-53 2 87 -42 2-3 87 -40 1-2 88-32 1 i 1 1 On the Arc Spectrum of Vanadium .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Ifasselberg .
Kensington .
Rowland .
Remarks .
90 -79 91 -84 92 -24 93- 26 94- 01 94- 98 95- 40 92-28 93- 26 94- 00 94-03 95-05 95-42 95-38 95-77 96-93 97- 56 98- 09 99 63 4400-74 01- 34 01 -91 02- 79 03- 87 05 -20 06 33 06-80 07- 83 08- 35 08-67 12- 33 13 -60 13- 90 14- 74 15- 25 16 -71 17 -83 18-88 20 -14 21- 77 22 -42 22- 71 23- 40 24- 11 24-77 03-86 03 -83 05 -20 06-28 06-80 06-80 07 -85 07 -80 08-36 08-37 08-67 08-66 12-30 12-30 Kot due to Fe .
16-63 16-63 25-95 26-17 27-49 28-72 29-95 31-36 32-28 200 Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Ilasselberg .
Rowland .
A. Int. Max. = 10 .
A. Int. Max. = 4-5 .
A. Int. Max = 15 .
Remarks .
4433 -09 2 34 -80 4 4434 *80 2 35-60 1 36-33 6 36-31 3-4 4436 -31 7 38 -02 7 38 -02 3-4 38 -00 7 39 -19 2 41-90 7 41-88 3-4 41 -85 2 43-56 4 43-52 2 43-51 4 44 39 6-7 44 *40 3-4 44 -38 3 46 -04 1 49 -78 3-4 49-77 2-3 49-74 4 51-13 3-4 51 -09 2 51 -07 4 52-19 7 52-19 4 52 -18 8 52 -91 2-3 52 -91 2 53-30 1-2 54 -34 1 54 -94 1 Ca. 56-07 1 Ca. 56-68 2-3 56 -68 2 56-67 3 57 -67 5 57-65 3-4 57 -63 3 58-00 4 j 57 -97 2\#151 ; 3 58-57 2 58 -91 1 59-96 6-7 59-93 4 59 -92 8 60-52 7 60 -46 4-5 60-46 : 10 60-85 4 61-18 3-4 i 1 62-52 6 62-56 3-4 62 -53 10 64-46 1 2 3 64-95 2-3 65-69 2-3 65-67 !
3 67 -09 2\#151 ; 3 67 -04 2 67-87 \lt ; 1 68-23 4-5 68 -19 2-3 68-17 i 3 68 -95 3-4 68-94 2 68-93 | 3 69 -87 6 69 -88 3-4 69-87 j 7 70-87 | 1 71 -51 \lt ; i 71-96 \lt ; i 73 -45 \lt ; i 74-22 5 74-21 !
3 74-21 7 74-91 5-6 74-89 : 3-4 74-90 | 7 # 76 06 2 Probably masked by strong Ag line at X 4476 " 29 .
77 -48 \lt ; 1 80-21 4 1 80-20 2-3 80-21 1 3 84 -24 1 !
86 -39 \lt ; 1 86-44 !
1 ; 89 -08 7 89 06 ' 3-4 89-10 7 | 90 -99 4-5 90-95 !
2-3 90-98 4 91 -36 2 9135 1-2 91 34 2 l 91 -65 1 91 66 1 91-65 1 On the Arc Spectrum of Vanadium .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg . ! !
Int. .
Int. A. !
Max = 10 .
A. Max. = 4-5 .
4495 -17 1 4495 -16 1-2 96-24 5 96-26 3 97-00 4 97 -03 2 97 -55 3 97 -57 2 4501 -00 01 -45 1-2 1 4501-01 2 02*12 5-6 02-12 3 06 -30 2-3 06-30 2 06-40 1 06-41 1-2 06 -73 1-2 06-77 2 08-10 \lt ; 1 08 -11 1 09-46 2-3 09-49 2 11 *63 2-3 11 -64 2 13-83 2-3 13-79 2 14-36 4 14-36 2-3 15 -73 2 15-74 1-2 17-75 3 17-77 2 20-35 2-3 20-31 2 20-71 2 20 -67 1-2 24-39 5-6 24 -38 3 25 -33 3-4 25-31 2 28-19 3-4 28-16 2-3 28-64 2 28 -60 2 29-50 2-3 29 -47 2 29 -78 5 29-76 2\#151 ; 3 30-98 34-08 3 3 30-97 2 37-83 3-4 37 -84 2 40-18 3-4 40-18 2 41-60 1 41 -57 1 45 -56 7 45 -57 3-4 49-79 6 49-81 3 52 -03 3 52 -05 2 53-25 55-59 5-6 \lt ; 1 53 -25 2-3 60-89 7 60-90 3 64 -79 1 64-76 1 70-62 3-1 70 -60 2 71 -97 6 71-96 3 77-33 8 77-36 4 78-89 5-6 78 -92 3 79 -38 3-4 79 -38 2\#151 ; 3 80- 57 81- 40 8 1 80-57 4 83 -96 3 83-96 2 86 -20 1 86-15 1-2 86-51 9 86-54 4-5 88-97 1 88-94 1 91 -41 5-6 91 -39 2-3 94-27 10 94-27 4-5 4600 -41 1 4600-34 1-2 A. In Ma = ii 4496 -23 5 97-57 5 4501 -00 2 01-41 1 02-12 4 06-74 1 09 -46 2 11 -60 2 13-79 2 14-36 4 15-73 1 17-74 3 20-33 2 20 -69 2 24-38 5 25 -34 2 28 -17 3 29 -48 2 30-97 3 34-11 3 37-83 4 40-18 4 45-57 10 49 -82 8 52 -02 2 *52-73 5 60-89 7 64 -76 1 71-96 5 77-35 7 78 -91 5 79 -37 2 80 -56 8 81 -41 1 83-97 2 86 -55 8 91 -41 5 94 -22 10 Remarks .
\#166 ; * ?
53 -27 .
202 Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
A. Tnt .
Max = 10 .
A. Int. Max. = 4-5 .
s A Int. Max. = 15 .
4603 -15 i I 06*33 5 4606 -33 2-3 4606 -32 4 07-42 1 07 -40 1-2 07 -39 1 08-63 1 | 09-84 2-3 09 -84 2 09 -82 4 j : 11 -11 1-2 11-10 1-2 11-10 1 11 -95 2 11-92 2 13-98 1 14 -10 \lt ; i 14-08 1 14 -09 1 16-20 \lt ; i 16-18 1 16-19 11* * ?
( 1 ) .
17-00 \lt ; i 17-03 1 18-00 \lt ; i 18-00 1 19 00 1 19-92 7-8 / 19-85 \ 19 -97 2 2-3 19 -90 o# * ?
( 10 ) .
21 -42 1 21 -43 1 21 -43 1 24-61 5 24-62 2 24 -58 4 26*66 4-5 26 -67 2 26-67 4 30 -25 \lt ; 1 30 -24 1 30-24 1 35-38 6 35-35 2-3 35-35 7 36-36 1 36 -34 1-2 36-34 1 40 -27 4 40 -25 2 40-23 5 40 -92 4 40-92 2 40 -92 5 44-24 \lt ; 1 44 -24 1 44 -66 2 44-64 2 44-62 2 46-20 \lt ; 1 46-17 1 46 16 1 46-52 6 46 -59 2-3 46 -57 8 48-08 1 48 -08 1 48 -05 1 49 07 2 49 -08 1-2 49 -07 2 53-13 1 53 -15 1 53 11 1 54-80 1 54 -84 1-2 55-50 \lt ; 1 55 -47 1 55-41 1 57 -17 1 57-17 1 57 14 1 61-00 \lt ; 1 61 -01 1 62 -00 \lt ; 1 62 -02 1 62 -60 1 62-61 1 63-31 3 66-34 2-3 66-33 2 69 -50 \lt ; 1 69-50 1 69-49 1 70-66 6-7 70 66 4 70-67 8 72 -48 1 72 -48 1 \gt ; 73-83 1 73 -83 1 73 -84 1 79 -68 1 79 -65 1 80-03 12 79-95 1-2 79-96 1 81 -12 1-2 81 -07 1-2 81 -07 1 82-09 \ 82-93 1 84 57 2 84-64 2 84 -63 3 87-11 3-4 87 10 2-3 87-10 5 88 -24 \lt ; 1 88 24 i 1 90-45 1-2 90-45 1 90 *44 1 99-52 | 2 99-50 1 2 i : Remarks .
On the Arc Spectrum Vanadium .
1 Imodium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
Int. | Lit. lilt .
X. Max. X. Max. X. Max. = 10 .
= 4-5 .
= 15 .
' 4702 -70 1 4702-69 1 05 -23 | 2-3 4705 -26 2 05 -28 3 06 -38 4 06 -34 1 2-3 06 36 5 06-76 5 06 75 I 2-3 06 76 5 07 -64 2-3 07-62 j 2 07 -63 3 | 08-40 1 09 -13 1 09 -93 2-3 10 -75 5 10-74 j 2-3 10 -75 5 13 -65 1 13 -61 1-2 13 -64 1 14-29 4\#151 ; 5 14 -28 2-3 15-50 \lt ; i I 15 -49 1 15 62 2 15-61 !
1-2 15-65 1 16 11 3 16-08 2 16 -08 4 1639 1-2 16 -36 1-2 16-38 1 17-89 4-5 17 85 2-3 17 -87 5 21 -40 \lt ; 1 21 *42 j 1\#151 ; 2 21 -44 1 21 -71 3-4 21 -70 !
2-3 1 21 -70 4 23 -06 4 23 -06 !
2-3 !
23 06 4 23-65 \lt ; 1 23 -65 1 !
23 63 1 24-07 \lt ; 1 | 24 -07 1 28-85 \lt ; 1 28 -85 1 !
28 -84 1 29 -77 3-4 29 73 2 ; 29 -72 5 30-58 2-3 30 57 2 i 30 -57 2 31 -40 i 1 31-42 !
1-2 31 -44 1 31 -80 1 31 -74 1-2 31 -74 1 32-17 1 32-12 ; 1-2 32 11 1 37-90 1 1-2 37-91 1 37 92 1 38-60 !
\lt ; 1 38-51 1-2 38-50 1 39 -80 !
1 39 -79 1 39-85 1 42-86 : 3 42 -79 2 42-82 5 46 -87 3 46-81 2 46 83 5 47-30 \lt ; 1 47 -30 1-2 47 31 1 48 -70 3-4 48 -70 2 48 -72 5 51-18 3-4 51-16 \#166 ; 2 51 -21 5 51 -45 1 51-45 1 51 -46 1 51 -79 3 51-75 2 1 51 -76 5 52 05 1 52 -04 1 54-13 3-4 54-13 2-3 57 -62 5-6 f57-55 l57 -68 2 2-3 57-69 4 58-95 ' \lt ; 1 58-92 | 1-2 58 94 1 59-20 I \lt ; 1 59 -21 1 64-22 1 64 -22 1 65 -91 \lt ; 1 65-84 ; 1-2 65-86 1 66 -82 5 66 -80 2-3 66-84 7 72-76 69-21 1 1 72-74 1 72-78 1 73-29 1 73-25 1-2 73 26 1 76 -63 6 J 76 -54 176-70 2 3 76 -64 1 81-51 1 Remarks .
VOL. LXVIII .
Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland .
Int. Int. Int. A. Max. X. Max. A. ; Max. = 10 .
= 4-5 .
= 15 .
4784-72 2-3 4784- -65 2 4784 -66 5 86-71 5-6 86 -70 3 86 -71 7 89 10 1 93 -15 1-2 93-10 2 93 -13 2 94 -73 1 95-35 1 95-27 2 95 -29 2 97 -08 5-6 97 -07 3 97-12 8 98 19 \lt ; i 98-12 1-2 98-15 1 99-20 1 99 -20 1 99 -21 1 99-98 2-3 99-94 2 99-97 j 4 4802 -37 1 | 4803-24 \lt ; i 03 -24 1 07 -73 5-6 4807-70 3-4 i 07 -74 10 08 -84 1 08 -84 1 19 -23 1 19-22 1-2 19-22 1 2 .
23 03 27 -63 6 27-62 3-4 27-64 1 10 29 -00 1 29 -00 1-2 29 -01 1 29 -43 1 30-90 | 1 30-86 : 1-2 30-88 1 31 -85 6 31-80 3-4 31 -84 8 32-61 6 32-59 3 32 62 8 33 24 1-2 33-17 j 2 33-21 3 34-00 1 34 -01 1 | 34 -26 1 !
35 -04 1 43 -20 \lt ; 1 43 -16 1\#151 ; 2 43 19 2 46 -80 !
\lt ; 3- | !
46-80 1 49-05 !
i 48-98 !
i-2 !
49-00 1 1 49 26 i 1 49-46 1 51-69 !
7 51-65 4 51-69 1 io j 52-15 1 54 -11 1 i 55-55 1 57-20 \lt ; 1 !
57-24 1 58-80 i \lt ; 1 j 58 -81 2 !
i 59-38 \lt ; 1 59 *34 2 !
62 -83 2 62-83 2 ; 62 -80 i ' 4 | 64 -92 7 64-93 4 !
64-94 io !
70 -33 i 71 -50 2 71 -46 2 71 -45 3 i | 73 -17 i !
75 -71 7 75 -66 4 75 -67 io !
80 -82 !
3 80-77 2-3 80 -75 o j 81-75 i 7-8 81 -75 4 81 -75 10 82 36 \lt ; 1 i 82 36 2 85 -89 1 85 -86 2 : 85-83 2 | 87 -03 1 87 -02 2 86 -99 2 90 -30 1-2 90 32 1-2 90 -26 1 91 40 j 1 | 91-43 1 1-2 91-41 2- !
1 91 -74 1 1 ' 91 -81 1 2 ; | 9177 3 i Remarks .
On the Arc Spectrum of Vanadium .
Vanadium Arc Lines\#151 ; continued .
Kensington .
Hasselberg .
Rowland . !
Int. Int. lilt .
Remarks .
A. Max. Max. A. Max. ; =io .
= 4-5 .
= 15 .
4894-42 i 4894 -43 2 4894 -40 3 \#151 ; | 4900-82 2-3 4900 84 2-3 4900-82 3 04 -60 3-4 01-59 3 04-57 5 05 05 1 05 10 1-2 05 05 3 06 05 \lt ; 1 06-06 1 07 05 1 08 -90 1 08-92 1 08 -88 1 13 -28 1 16-46 1 16 -48 1\#151 ; 2 16-44 1 19 -17 1 22 -60 1 22 -60 1-2 22 54 1 25 -87 3-4 25 83 2-3 25-84 7 32 23 2 32-24 2 32 21 3 1 Inference to the foregoing table will show that the Kensington list and Hasselbergs contain many lines in common which are missing from Rowland 's .
This is probably due to the fact that the latter used carbon poles , which furnish so many lines themselves that it is extremely difficult to pick up all the lines really due to the substance volatilised on them .
As an instance of this , in the region between A 4130 and A 4216 , throughout which the structure lines in the carbon fluting which commences at the latter wave-length are most crowded , Rowland records only eleven lines , whereas in the corresponding region Hasselberg gives forty-nine , and the Kensington photograph shows seventy-five .
rI aking Hasselberg s list as a basis we find that the few lines given below occur only in his list .
Lines given by Hasselberg only .
Hasselberg .
Remarks .
A. Int. Max. 4-5 .
390271 4116 -85 4210-55 4211 -02 4226 -78 4476 06 4682 -09 1 1-2 1 1 2 2 1 1 Probably masked in the Kensington photograph by J a broad line of Ag at A 4212 .
1 .
Probably masked by line of Ca at A 4226 -91 .
\#187 ; \#187 ; " Ag at A 4476 -29 .
206 Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
Four of these may be present in the Kensington photograph , being probably hidden by lines of Ag and Ca. With regard to the others , reference to unpublished lists of lines in the arc spectra of many other elements suggests no origin which can be assigned to them .
In addition to these lines , Hasselberg has apparently observed as double the following lines recorded as single in the other two lists .
Lines recorded as Double by Hasselberg .
Ilasselberg .
Kensington , j . .
Rowland .
Remarks .
Int. lilt .
Int. X. Max. X. Max. 1 X. Max. 4-5 10 .
15 .
3931 -40 3931.50 2 } 3931 -46 5 4423 32 4423 -41 1-2 ) 1-21 4423-40 4 4423-37 8 461985 4619 *97 2 l 2-3 ) 4619 -92 7-8 4619 -90 0* * ?
( 10 ) .
4757-55 4757-68 A } !
4757-62 5-6 4757 -69 4 4776 -54 4776-70 2 1 3 I 4776-63 | 6 4776 -64 5 In considering Rowlands list in relation to the two others , it is found that the following lines are recorded by* him only .
Some of Lines given by Rowland only .
Rowland .
; Rowland .
i Rowland .
1 Int. .
Remarks .
Tnt .
Remarks .
Int. 1 Remarks .
A. Max. A. Max. X. Max. 15 .
15 .
15 .
3919 -60 1 4456-07 1 Ca. 4823 -03 1 3933 -77 3 Ca(K ) .
i 4458 -91 1 4829 43 1 3944 -13 3 Al .
i 4460-85 4 4834-26 1 3961 -65 5 1 Al .
1 4470-87 1 483504 1 3968 -59 1 ; Ca(II ) .
4552-73* 5 4849-26 1 4033 19 3 ; Mil . !
4608-63 1 4849 -46 1 4034-62 2 Mn .
i 4613-98 1 4852-15 1 4057 -96 1 !
:Pb . !
4663-31 3 485411 1 I 4077 '85 1 Sr. 4708 -40 1 4855 -55 1 1 4183 07 4 4709 -13 1 4870 -33 1 | 4226-87 4 1 Ca. * 4769-21 1 4873-17 1 | 4318-80 2 I Ca. 4781 -51 1 4907-05 1 | 4397-39 1 4789 -10 1 4913-28 1 4425-59 1 !
Ca. !
4794-73 1 4919-17 1 4454-94 1 I Ca. !
4802 -37 1 * Possibly misprint for 4553 -27 .
If so , should not appear in this list .
0)1 the Arc Spectrum of Vanadium .
207 them are obviously due to other metals existing as impurities either in the poles or in the compound of vanadium which was used , and although several of these lines occur in the Kensington photograph , they have been discarded .
Attempts to trace the remaining lines to other origins have been unsuccessful .
W ith reference to the lines which are absent from Rowland 's list , but which appear in the other two , it seems certain that many genuine and strong lines of vanadium have either not been identified by him , or have for some reason been discarded from his list .
In this connection , it may be stated that many of the lines recorded by Rowland in his " Table .
of Solar Wave-lengths " as being due to vanadium , do not appear in his list of vanadium arc lines , though nearly all of them occur as strong lines in both Hasselberg 's and the Kensington records .
A list of these is given on the next page .
Those marked with a f are taken from a list of corrections which he has given* to his " Tables of Solar Wave-lengths .
" The remainder are taken from his original tables .
( Includ ; ed in this list are seven lines possibly identical with lines in Rowland 's arc spectrum , though the difference in his two recorded wave-lengths of the possibly corresponding arc and solar lines varies from ten to nineteen hundredths of a tenth-metre , a difference which is greatly in excess of what he claims to be*his limiting error in the estimation of wave-lengths .
In the Kensington list there are 194 lines which do not appear in either Hasselberg 's or Rowland 's .
It will serve no useful purpose to enumerate these in a special table , as they can be easily referred to m the general comparison table given in an earlier part of the paper .
An analysis of their intensities shows that seventy-seven are very weak lines , of intensity designated \lt ; 1 , fifty-three of intensity 1 , thirty-nine of intensity 2 , twenty of intensity 3 , three of intensity 4 , and two of intensity 5 , the maximum intensity adopted being 10 .
No other probable origin has been found for any of them , although the 'vanadium spectrum has been compared directly with the arc spectra of the following elements Ag , Au , Ba , Bi , Ca , Cd , Ce , Co , Cr Cs Cu , Di , Fe , Hg , In , Ir , Iv , La , Li , Mg , Mn , Mo , Na , Ni , Os , Pb , Pd , Rb , Rh , Ru , Sc , Sn , Sr , Ta , Te , Th , Ti , Tl , U , W , Yt , Zn , Zr .
As these lines appear in the spectrum when either the oxide or chloride of vanadium is used , there seems to be no reason to doubt that they are really due to vanadium .
Several of them are evidently present in Hasselberg 's photograph , as in his comparison of certain vanadium lines with lines of equal or nearly equal wave-length belonging to other metals he records tho following , but has left them out of bis comprehensive list of vanadium mes , presumably as being due to other metals which exist as impurities m his vanadium .
* ' Ast.-Phys .
Jour .
, ' vol. 6 , p. 384 , 1897 .
Sir Norman Lockyer and Mr. F. E. Baxandall .
Lines previously recorded as V by Rowland in liis " Table of Solar Wave-lengths , " which are not included in his Vanadium Arc Lines , Vanadium arc lines .
Solar\#151 ; V lines ( Rowland ) A. Hasselberg .
Kensington .
Remarks .
Tnt .
lilt .
A. Max. A. Max. 4-5 .
10 .
3893 -03 3893 -03 3 3892 -95 6-7 94 , -17+ 94 -19 2 94 16 4-5 3903 *40+ 3903*42 1-2 3903 -32 3-4 04 *31f 10 -98 10 -95 2 10 -92 4 12 -34 12-36 2-3 12-35 5 34-Ilf 34 -16 3-4 3418 5-6 41 -32+ 41 -40 1-2 41 -40 3 42 -16f 42-16 2 42 18 4 43 -72f 43 -77 2-3 43 81 5 48 -82f 48-79 3 73 -80t 73 -79 2 73 -79 3-4 75-51f 75 -48 1-2 4036 -92f 4036*93 1 4036 -93 2 51 -20 69 -76+ 1 51 -11 2-3 51-10 5 72 -30f 72 -30 1 2 72-28 2-3 83 -09f 83-07 3-4 92 -82 I 92-83 3 92 -81 !
8 4104-62 4104 -55 2 4104 -52 4 J Possibly Rowland 's Y arc L line at A 4104"52 04 -91 04-92 .
2 04 -93 3\#151 ; 4 05 -32 05 -32 3 05 -33 7 23 -66 23 -65 3 23 -59 7 28 -25 28 -25 3-4 28 *20 9 Ditto at A 412815 .
79 -54 79 -53 2-3 79 -54 6 4232 -76 4232*62 3 4232-68 5-6 Ditto at , A 4232"60 .
33 -09 33 09 3 33-09 5-6 Ditto at A 4233 01 .
92 *14 91 -97 3 91 -96 5 6 Ditto at A 4291-98 .
4375 -10 4420 -10 4420 -08 2-3 4420 -14 4-5 29 -96 29-95 3 30 -02 5 44 '57 44 *40 3\#151 ; 4 44 -39 6-7 Ditto at A 4444-38 .
57 94 57 -97 2-3 58 -00 4 88 -93 ' 89-06 3-4 89 -08 7 Ditto at A 4489-10 .
On the Are Spectrum Vanadium .
Hasselherg .
Kensington .
Ilasselberg 's imputed origin .
Remarks .
A. Infc .
1 A. Tut .
3975 -51 1 3975-48 1-2 !
53a , Co n 4013 -67 1 4013 -69 \lt ; 1 Ti | There is no evidence that- 4020 09 | 1 4020-73 1 Fe !
the lines in the Kensing4123 *35 1 2 4123 -30 3 Ti , Mn !
j ton photograph are due 4315-00 | 1\#151 ; 2 4315 -02 2 Ti j to any of these metals .
4618-96 1 1 4619-10 1 Fe The following lines occur in the photograph , but have been left out of the Kensington record as they are considered to be undoubtedly due to other metals .
Lines of other Metals which occur in the Kensington Vanadium Spectrum .
A. Infc .
in Y. Origin .
A. Int. in Y. Origin .
j 1 3933 -83 5 Ca 4215-66 \lt ; 1 Sr 44-16 1-2 A1 26 -91 6 Ca 61 -68 2 A1 50-93 \gt ; \lt ; 1 Fe 68 -63 5 Ca 54 -49 2 Cr 81-87 4-5 Ag 74-91 2 Cr 95-46 2-3 Co 89-87 1 Cr 4030-92 3-4 Mn 4302-68 \lt ; 1 Ca 33 -22 3 Mn 07 96 1 Fe 34-64 2-3 Mn 11 -21 1-2 Ag 45-90 2 Fe !
25 -92 1-2 Fe 55-44 10 Ag 83-70 2 Fe 57 -97 3 Pb 4404 -70 \lt ; 1 Fe 63 -63 1-2 Fe | 76-29 6 Ag 4121 -48 2-3 Co 4668 -70 7 Ag 4212 -10 10 Ag | 1 j All these lines are the very strongest in the spectra to ivhich they respectively belong , and although in the vanadium spectrum there are other lines apparently identical in position with some of the weaker lines of Fe , Mn , Co , and Cr , a comparison of their relative intensities in the two spectra shows that they cannot reasonably be ascribed to the presence of such metals as impurities in the vanadium , but must be accepted as genuine lines of both metals , so far as the dispersion employed enables us to form an opinion .
These are given in order of wave-length in the following table :\#151 ; 210 Prof. E. Warren .
On the Development of the Coincidences of Vanadium Lines with Lines of other Metals .
A ( Kensing- ton ) .
Origin of coincident line .
Int. in y. Int. of coincident line . .
A ( Kensing- ton ) .
Origin of coincident line .
Int. in V. Int. of 1 coincident line .
3894 -16 Cr 4-5 4 4427 -49 Fe 4 7 3913-71 Fe 1 2-3 67 -09 Co 2-3 4 77-88 Fe 2 4-5 97 -00 Cr 4 5-6 4052 -60 Mil 1 4 4514 -36 Fe 4 \lt ; l 68-16 Fe 1 Mn 2-3 3 | 5 17 -75 Fe 3 1 70-94 Fe 2-3 2-3 25 -33 Fe 3-4 4 83 -07 Mn 3-4 7 34 -08 Co 3 4 90 -05 Mn 1 4 49 -79 Co 6 5 90-74 Mn 8 1-2 4603 -15 Fe 1 5 4224 -36 Fe 3-4 3 26 -66 Mn 4-5 5 34-18 Co 5-6 1-2 54 -80 Fe 1 4 4408-35 Mn 5 4 4709 -93 Mn 2-3 7 15-25 Fe 3 10 4871 -50 Fe 2 6 " A Preliminary Account of the Development of the Free-swimming Nauplius of LeptodoTct ( Lillj .
) .
Lie Ernest Warren , D.Sc .
, Assistant Professor of Zoology , University College , London .
Communicated by Professor Weldon , F.R.S. Received February 4 , \#151 ; Read February 28 , 1901 .
Leptodora appears to be a primitive daphnid in retaining a long , markedly segmented abdomen , and for this reason it seemed likely that an investigation on the development of the winter-generation might throw some light on the vexed ( questions in Crustacean development .
It was more particularly desired to ascertain whether any vestige of a coelom occurred , and that if so , whether any remnant of it peisists in the adult .
With this object in view , it was necessary to inquire into the origin of the genital cells and of the antennary and maxillary glands .
In April , 1898 , Professor Hickson obtained a few nauplii from Lake Bassenthwaite , Cumberland , and later in the year a large number of adults .
This material was most generously placed at my disposal by Professor Weldon , and I wish to express to him my sincere thanks .
^ The material was insufficient for my purpose ; and in the following spring I visited Lake Bassenthwaite to try to obtain fresh material , but I met with very little success .
Last spring , however , sufficient material was obtained to continue the investigation.* The preserving reagent employed was Flemming 's solution ( strong formula ) .
* I am indebted to the Royal Society for a Government Grant in connection with obtaining this material .

