Mr. G. M. Whipple .
Results of an [ Jan. 15 , II .
" Results of an Inquiry into the Periodicity of Rainfall .
" By G. M. Whipple , B.Sc. , F.R.A.S. , Superintendent of the Kew Observatory .
Oommunicated by Robert H. Scott , :i F.R.S. Received January 8 , 1880 .
The exceptionally heavy rainfall of the past spring and summer directed a large amount of attention to the records of rainfall in this country , and more than one investigator stated that he had found a s : certain periodicity existing in the quantity of rain annually collected .
Dr. Meldrum , Professor Balfour Stewart , Mr. Hennessey , Professor Stanley Jevons , Dr. Hunter , and others , have also widely published fj theories based upon the assumption that the variation in the yearly ; amounts of fall depends in some manner upon solar phenomena as exhibited by the changes in the appearance of the sun 's surface , thereby indicating a cycle of approximately ten or eleven years ' duration ; but even among the supporters of this so-termed " sun-spot " theory of 1 rainfall there are differences of opinion as to the exact nature of the I influence an increase of sun-spots would exert upon the rainfall of any locality .
Mr. G. J. Symons , in " Nature , " vol. vii , p. 143 , has partially investigated these theories , and shown the ten-year period does not obtain universally .
After reading a paper by Professor Stewart , in the Proc. Roy .
Soc. , ' vol. xxix , p. 106 , " On a Method of detecting the unknown Inequalities of a Series of Observations , " it occurred to me to try the method he employed upon terrestrial magnetic changes , upon the annual values of the rainfall , in order to deduce from the observations themselves the true periodicity , if one existed .
With a view of dealing with the largest mass of material possible , I took the long series of rainfall observations made at Paris from 1689 to 1875 , published by M. Marie Davy , in the " Annuaire de l'Observa-toire de Montsouris .
" These I proceeded to discuss on Professor Stewart 's plan , but finding it entailed great labour , and held out little prospect of eventually giving a good result , I soon abandoned it , and after several experiments , adopted the following method , which would detect at once the presence of a cycle of an integral number of years in duration .
Starting with an assumption of a period , which I first made five years in length , and subsequently extended , I grouped all the observations together , first in five-year groups , then in six-year , then in seven-year , and so on , year by year , until I reached thirteen years .
The means of these furnished a set of curves , showing the variation from the mean in the amount of annual rainfall for each of the years comiy80 .
] Inquiry into the Periodicity of Rainfall .
71 posing the series under consideration .
Perhaps I shall make the opera-tion clearer by explaining in detail the actual method of working finally ^Taking the table of yearly totals , the dates were written down on paper side by side , in horizontal rows , in red chromographic ink , and then the corresponding rainfalls in blue .
From this sheet a number of impressions were worked off , each of which was cut into slips , afterwards gummed together , so as to form a long strip , exhibiting in a straight line the whole table of rainfall .
The strips were next divided into short lengths corresponding to the period to be investigated ( e.y. , for a five-year period , each piece contained the values for five consecutive years ) , and then gummed on a sheet of paper one beneath the other , so that eventually we had five columns of figures , the means of which represented the average rainfall for each of the years represented by ( 1 + 5 ) ... ... ( 1 + 2-5 ) ... ... ( 1 + 8-5 ) ... ... ( l + w5 ) ( 2 + 5 ) ... ... ( 2 + 2-5 ) ... ... ( 2 + 3-5). . .
... ( 2 + w5 ) ( 3 + 5 ) ... ... ( 3 + 2-5 ) ... ... ( 3 + 3-5 ) ... ( 4 + 5 ) ... ... ( 4+2-5 ) ... ... ( 4+3-5). . .
... ( 4 + w5 ) ( 5+5 ) ... ... ( 5 + 2-5 ) ... ... ( 5 + 3-5 ) ... ... ( 5 + \#187 ; 5 ) The mean of the whole series also being known , it became possible to form a curve , showing the variation in the amount of rainfall upon the assumption of a five-year period .
By applying the same process to other copies , curves were finally drawn for cycles extending respectively over six , seven , eight , nine , ten , eleven , twelve , and thirteen years , and the points of maximum and minimum noted for each curve .
Tables I to IX , and figs. 1 and 2 , exhibit the result of this process us applied to the whole series of observations discussed , including the Paris results .
Next , the whole of the observations were plotted down , and a long curve was drawn through them ; from this the maximum years of fall were determined and noted .
The dates of these maxima and minima were then compared with the dates of corresponding maxima and minima of a curve based upon the five-year cycle , as determined above , and the number of coincidences and non-coincidences noted .
The same operation was performed with each of the cycles , and finally the ratio existing between the number of coincidences and non-coincidences was calculated .
The results are given in Table X. This table shows that in no one case is there any indication of a period of any integral number of years from five to thirteen inclusive running through them .
Hence , whatever period of variation in rainfall there may be , coincident with fluctuations in the spotted surface of the sun , either of ten , \lt ; 1 to m- f z ?
?s* m\#187 ; *7 w I p o + -II uy l | in o \amp ; i zgn z " ?
" .
+ 5 4J i .
' ?
} .
V W .
, Q 0 \lt ; 1 o H* S. Hb E- H-l \lt ; 1 P p o p Q o 8 .
Or g- M CO CD P s ?
* Q fcr M .
V .n 5 " Of .
GO C-4 P B h-* Oi 1880 .
] Inquiry into the Periodicity of Rainfall .
73 eleven , or twelve years , this method of treatment shows it to be completely masked ( in a long series of observation ) by other variations .
The discrepancies exhibited in the first tables obtained made it very desirable to extend the field of inquiry , by including as many observations in the discussion as possible ; but having fixed upon the arbitrary limit of fifty years as the least number of years of observations suitable for dealing with after my method , the materials for doing so were not very abundant .
Eventually I was able to collect the following ten series :\#151 ; Station .
Periods .
No. of years .
Authority .
Paris 1689\#151 ; 96 , 1699\#151 ; 1754 , Annuaire de l'obseryatoire 1773\#151 ; 97 , 1804\#151 ; 75 .
161 de Montsouris , 1879 " Pfldnn .
1725 to 1878 154 MSS .
from P. Denza England ( Symons ' table ) . .
1726 to 1865 140 B. A. Report , 1866 Milan 1764 to 1878 115 MSS .
from P. Denza London ... .
1813 to 1878 66 Dines and Symons " Nature , " vol. xviii , p. 565 Smithsonian Tables , p. 97 Madras , t , . .
1813 to 1877 65 Philadelphia . .
1810 to 1867 58 Edinburgh ... .
1822 to 1878 57 " Nature , " yol .
xyiii , p. cf7 New Bedford . .
1814 to 1867 54 / Smithsonian Tables , p. 90 Rome 1825 to 1878 54 MSS .
from P. Denza To these I added an eleventh one , forming a series by combining together the annual rainfall for 1822 to 1875 at London , Paris , and Edinburgh .
This increased the total number of years of observations used in the discussion to 978 .
The result of the extended investigation in no way affected the conclusion pointed out by the observations previously treated , viz. , that taking the series of annual totals directly as they , there is no marked indication of the presence of a short cycle to be found .
There are a few exceptions , notably in the case of the nine-year period for New Bedford and Philadelphia , the eleven-year cycle for Madras , and the ten-year cycle for London , Paris , and Edinburgh combined , in all of which cases the coincidences but slightly preponderate over the non-coincidences .
Again on consideration of the differences in Tables I to IX , it will be seen that for the same epoch the curves of variation differ widely for localities comparatively close together .
For example , taking the eleven-year cycle for Padua and Milan , stations only about 130 miles apart , both well situated for observing rain , and no mountain range intervening , the variation curves are as follows :\#151 ; Mr. G. M. Whipple .
Results of an [ Jan. 15 , Year 1800 + ll\#187 ; t 1801 + llw 1802 + 11ti 1803 + llu 1804 + llw 1805 + Un 1806 + llu 1807 + II11 1808 + llrt 1809 + lln 1810 + lln Padua Milan -1*3 -5*0 -0*3 + 1-5 \#151 ; 1 *7 + 0*2 + 1-1 -1*9 +4*2 -2*5 + 4*2 0-0 \#151 ; 4 *9 + 3-0 + 3 *4 + 4*7 -2*8 -5*6 -2-8 +2-6 + 1-7 +3-3 These show that the years of greatest rainfall at Padua are repre-sented by the formula [ 1804 or 5 + 11 % ] , and of least by [ 1806 + llw ] , whilst for Milan the maximum occurs at [ 1807 + 11\#187 ; ] , and the minimum \#166 ; n at [ 1808+ lln ] .
Fio .
2 .
Curves of Rainfall Variation in Cycles of 5 to 13 Years .
RAINFAL l _CYC LE SCALE I N CENTIMETRES + 10 + 5 PARIS -0 MEANS -----\#151 ; m + 5 PADUA 0 MEAN S _c *1 MILAN 0lL4 MEANS _ 5I ROME MEAN S-5 -10 f- Further inspection of the tables will show numerous other instances of incongruity to be found in every one of the cycles , leading forcibly to the conclusion that either no short term of exactly five , six , seven , eight , nine , ten , eleven , twelve , or thirteen years exists in the annual amount of rainfall at any of the stations whose observations have been here discussed , or that the effect of abnormal falls is so great that it cannot be eliminated by upwards of a hundred years ' observations .
In any case , I think it may now be stated with certainty that all predictions as to rainy or dry years , based upon existing materials , must in future be considered as utterly valueless .
My thanks are due to Mr. R. H. Scott , Director of the Meteorological Office , for several valuable suggestions , and to Padre F. Denza , Director of the Moncalieri Observatory , for manuscript copies of the Italian observations .
Table I.-\#151 ; 5-year Rainfall Cycle .
Stations .
Means .
1800 + 5w .
1801 + 5n .
l 1802 + 5\#187 ; .
1 1803 + 5n .
1804 + 5\#187 ; .
1 r Means ... ... J Ratios .
\ 908 94*6 976 94-4 94-4 Symons ' English - Differences. .
\ 943 J -3-5 + 0-3 + 33 + 0-1 + 01 Dines ' London 4 r Means L Differences. .
f inches .
1 \ 24-6 j 239 -0-7 26-3 + 1-7 24-6 -00 246 -00 23-8 -0-8 j r Moans ... ... 264 254 269 29-1 266 240 Edinburgh . . . . .
4 Differences. .
-10 + 0-5 + 2-7 + 0-2 -2-4 p Means 701 70-0 721 71-0 69-9 67-7 London , Edinburgh , and Pans \lt ; Differences. .
-01 + 20 + 0-9 -02 -2-4 f Means 48-4 463 50-2 541 47-1 44-3 Madras h Differences . .
-21 + 1-8 + 5-7 -1-3 \#151 ; 4*1 Philadelphia ' Means ... . .
' L Differences. .
41-6 42-4 + 0*8 00 00 ca \#187 ; H CO | 43-2 + 1-6 41-4 -0-2 41-2 -0-4 New Bedford -j [ Means ... ... 414 42-2 42-2 41-2 39-8 41-5 [ Differences. .
+ 0-8 + 0-8 -0-2 -1-6 +o-i Paris *j \ Means f centime .
1 47-8 48-7 49-5 471 49-4 [ Differences . .
i 48-5 J -07 + 0-2 + ro -1-4 + 09 Padua f Means ... ... 860 t .
83-7 85-9 862 88-8 858 [ Differences . .
-23 -01 + 0-2 + 2-8 \#151 ; 0-2 Milan *1 f Means ... ... 975 96-6 96-9 98-7 100-6 926 [ Differences . .
-0-9 -0-6 + 1-2 + 31 \#151 ; 4'9 Rome - , i f Means5 . . .
* . .
76-2 77-2 74-9 75-8 791 78-3 1 Differences. .
+ro -1-3 -0*4 -2-9 \#151 ; 2'9 1880 .
] Inquiry into the Periodicity of Rail Table II.\#151 ; 6-year Rainfall Cycle .
Stations .
Means .
1800 + 6n .
1801 + 6n .
1802 + 1803 + 1804 + Qn .
1805+ 6\#187 ; .
Symons ' English f Means ... .
[ Differences f Ratios .
1 1 94-3 J 995 + 5-2 91-9 -2-4 88-1 -6-2 91-5 -2-8 96-5 + 2-2 98-2 + 3-9 Dines ' London - f Means ... .
[ Differences f inches .
1 L 24-6 f 27'8 + 3-2 23-8 -0-8 22-4 -2-2 24o -01 23-8 -0-8 25-5 + 0-9 Edinburgh f Means ... .
[ Differences 26-4 28-6 + 2-2 25-1 -13 25-2 -1-2 25-2 -1-2 27-0 + 0-6 27-1 + 0-7 London , Edinburgh , and , Paris ^ Means ... .
Differences 701 78-2 + 8-1 686 -1-5 67-0 -31 67-8 -2-3 68-7 -1-4 70-4 + 0-3 Madras \#171 ; " Means ... .
[ Differences 48-4 47-4 -10 423 \#151 ; 6T 47-6 -0-8 50-9 + 2-5 CO lO + 49-3 + 0-9 Ph adelphia j r Means ... .
L Differences 416 41-4 -0-2 41-5 -0-1 42-0 .
+0-4 41-6 -o-o 38-7 -2-9 44-6 + 30 New Bedford \#171 ; j r Means ... .
L Differences 41-4 41-0 -0'4 40-2 -1-2 40-4 -10 42-9 + 1-5 38-8 -2-6 451 + 3-7 Paris \lt ; j r Means ... .
L Differences f centims. " 1 1 48-5 f 52-0 + 35 48-8 + 0-3 44-9 -36 48-7 + 0-2 49-4 + 0-9 47-4 -11 Padua j r Means ... .
* Differences 86-0 916 + 5-6 853 -0-7 88-1 + 2-1 88-9 + 2-9 77-5 -8-5 85-1 -0-9 Milan j " Means ... .
_ Differences 975 1000 + 2-5 101-3 + 3-8 101-7 + 4-2 101-6 + 4-1 941 -3-4 861 -11-4 Rome j r Means ... .
w Differences 76-1 80-0 + 39 65-9 -10-2 82-7 + 6-6 85-1 + 9-0 1 68-2 -7-9 ^ 74-8 -1-3 .
i Mtiiiii , , ; ;---------- .
I . .
1 .
_ t u \#166 ; --i - \#151 ; t \#166 ; \#166 ; Mr. G. M. Whipple .
Results of an [ Jan. 15 , Table III.\#151 ; 7-year Rainfall Cycle .
Stations .
Means .
1800 + 7 n. 1801 1 + 7 n. 1802 + 7 n. 1803 + 7 n. 1804 + 7n .
1805 ( 1806 + 7w .
+7 1 'Means Differences . .
f Ratios .
" 1 t 94-3 J 961 + 1-8 912 -31 90-5 -3-8 100-6 + 6-3 94-4 + 01 91-9 -2-4 95-5 + 1-2 Dines ' London .
*j Means Differences . .
J inches .
" 1 \ 24*6 J 24-7 + 01 23-7 ' -0-9 24*5 -01 27-1 + 2-5 24-8 + 0-2 22-5 -21 251 + 0-5 Edinburgh ' " j " Means .
Differences . .
' 26-4 259 -0-5 264 -00 27*4 + 10 27-4 + 10 26-3 -01 23-7 -2-7 28-0 + 1*6 London , Edinburgh , and Paris ... .-\lt ; r Means _ Differences . .
701 651 -50 69-7 \#151 ; 0-4 70*5 + 0*4 77*1 +7-0 71-5 + 1-4 65-4 -4-7 70-9 + 0-8 " Means Differences . .
48-4 45-4 -30 490 + 06 49*1 +0*7 51-4 +30 48-2 -0-2 480 -0-4 47-8 -0-6 Philadelphia.- ... -| [ Means [ Differences . .
416 40-9 \#151 ; 0'7 43-2 + 1-6 41-0 -0-6 42-2 + 0-6 41-4 -0*2 41-1 -0-5 41*1 -0-5 New Bedford \ [ Means [ Differences . .
41-4 375 -3-9 431 + 1-7 44-6 + 32 42-5 + 1-1 379 -3-5 42-9 + 1-5 41-6 + 0-2 Paris 4 ( " Means 1 Differences . .
f cms .
1 1 48-5 J 47-5 -10 46-9 -1-6 50-7 + 2-2 48-4 -01 511 + 2*6 48-0 -0-5 46-8 -1-7 Padua 4 f Means ... ... [ Differences . .
860 908 + 4-8 82-0 -4-0 85*0 -1*0 82-7 -33 84-4 -1*6 90-7 + 4*7 86-7 + 0-7 Milan 4 I " Means ... ... [ Differences . .
97'5 102-5 + 50 93-5 \#151 ; 4'0 1021 + 4-6 940 -3-5 97-9 + 0-4 94-3 -3-2 98-0 + 0-5 Borne * f Means [ Differences . .
761 70-5 -5-6 79-1 + 30 79-6 + 3-5 74*1 -20 78-2 + 2-1 820 + 5'9 69-4 -6-7 1880 J Inquiry into this Periodicity of Rainfall* Table IV.\#151 ; 8-year Rainfall Cycle .
Stations .
Means .
1800 + 8\#187 ; .
1801 + 8m .
1802 + 8\#187 ; .
1803+ 8\#187 ; .
1804 + 8\#187 ; .
1805 + 8\#187 ; .
,1806 + 8* 11807 + 8\#187 ; .
Symons ' English \lt ; \ Means ... .
[ Differences .
f Ratios .
" 1 \ 94*3 J 992 + 4*9 95-3 + 10 893 -5-0 920 -2*3 94-4 + 01 901 \#151 ; 42 95-7 + 1*4 97-9 + 3-6 Dines ' London * f Means ... .
[ Differences .
f inches .
1 L 24-6 25-4 + 0-8 250 + 0-4 21-9 -2-7 250 + 0-4 27*1 + 2*5 24-9 + 0-3 24-4 -0-2 23-4 -1-2 Edinburgh f Means ... .
[ Differences .
264 28-3 + 1-9 240 -2-4 21-4 -50 27-0 + 0-6 29-9 + 3-5 28-3 + 1-9 283 + 1-9 241 -2-3 London , Edinburgh , and , Paris r Means ... .
Differences .
70-1 731 + 30 69-6 -0-5 616 -8-5 611 -90 79-7 + 9-6 68-5 -1*8 720 + 1-9 66-4 \#151 ; 3*7 Madras 4 r Means ... .
[ Differences .
48*4 469 -1-5 50-2 + 1-8 51-4 + 30 49-4 + 1*0 476 -0-8 40-7 -7-7 51-4 + 30 50-5 + 21 Philadelphia \lt ; f Means ... .
[ Differences .
41-6 384 -3-2 450 + 3-4 401 -1*6 422 + 0*6 41*6 -00 39-6 -20 42'6 +ro 43-6 + 20 New Bedford f Means ... .
[ Differences .
| 41-4 397 -1-7 387 -2-7 41-9 + 0-5 461 + 4*7 37*5 -3*9 42-8 + 1-4 40-9 -0-5 43-3 + 1-9 Paris \#171 ; j f Means ... [ Differences .
f cm3 .
1 L 48-5 J .
51-4 + 2-9 47-5 -10 45*7 -2-8 48-7 + 0-2 511 + 2-6 49-8 + 1-3 46-5 -20 472 -1-3 Padua *j f Means ... .
[ Differences .
860 837 -23 84-7 -1-3 CO CO 86-8 + 0*8 909 + 4-9 86-8 + 0-8 81-7 \#151 ; 4-3 87-4 + 1-4 Milan | Means ... .
Differences .
97*5 960 -1-5 94-7 -2-8 98-9 + 1*4 939 -3-6 101-0 + 3-5 98-8 + 1-8 98-6 + 1*1 97-9 + 0-4 Rome .
| Means ... .
Differences .
761 760 -o-i 651 -no 72-7 -34 770 + 0-9 73-4 -2-7 80-0 + 3-9 85-6 + 9-5 79-5 + 3-4 J Mr. G. M. Whipple .
Results of an [ Jan. 15 , Table V.\#151 ; 9-year iiainlail Cycle .
Stations .
Means .
1800 + 9\#187 ; .
1801 + 9 n. 1802 + 9\#187 ; .
1803 + 9\#187 ; .
1804 + 9 n. 1805 + 9\#187 ; .
1806 + 9\#187 ; .
1807 + 9\#187 ; .
1808 + 9\#187 ; .
Symons ' English ... .
- ' Means Differences. .
J Ratios 1 1 94-3 J '98-9 + 4-6 97'1 + 2-8 92-6 -1-7 92-4 -1-9 89-5 -4-8 92-3 -2-0 94-9 + 06 95-9 + 1-6 94-9 + 06 Dines ' London ' Means Differences . .
J inches .
1 1 24 6 J 241 -05 231 -1-5 22-6 -20 27-7 + 31 231 -1-5 24-7 + 0-1 26-5 + 1-9 25-3 + 0-7 24-4 -0-2 Edinburgh ... ... ... .
-1 r Means Differences. .
26-4 297 -33 263 -01 26-8 + 0-4 27-7 + 1-3 27-0 + 0-6 28-1 + 1-7 241 -2-5 24-8 -1-6 23-3 -31 London , Edinburgh , f and Paris . .
\ Means Differences . .
70*1 74-0 + 39 68-5 -1-6 69-5 -0-6 763 + 6*2 69-3 -0-8 69-7 -0-4 68-6 -1-5 680 -21 670 -31 Madras .
f \ * " Means ... ... L Differences. .
48-4 599 + 11-5 47*7 -0-7 560 + 7-6 46-9 -1-5 42-6 -5-8 391 -9-3 410 -7-4 52-9 + 4-5 51-6 + 3-2 Philadelphia j f Means [ Differences . .
41-6 41-0 -0-6 383 -3-3 42-3 + 0-7 41-0 -0-6 43-3 + 1-7 483 + 6-7 42-5 + 0-9 38-5 -31 39-7 -1-9 New Bedford j f Means [ Differences. .
41-4 441 + 27 35-3 -61 41-3 -01 41-8 + 0-4 42-5 + 11 46-8 + 5-4 39-8 -1-6 40-7 -0-7 40-2 -1-2 Paris f Means 1 Differences . .
J " cms .
" 1 \ 48-5 J 50-4 + 1-9 51-8 + 3-3 47-8 -0-7 521 + 3-6 47-8 -0-7 46'2 -2-3 48-3 -0-2 47-8 -0-7 44*4 -41 Padua - f Means [ Differences. .
860 95-2 + 9-2 85-9 -01 81-2 -4-8 85-7 -0-3 82-8 -3-2 87-6 + 1-6 89-9 .
+ 3-9 751 -10-9 910 + 5-0 Milan \ f Means ... ... [ Differences . .
975 102-3 + 4-8 106-9 + 9-4 910 -65 971 -0-4 99-8 + 2-3 971 -0-4 1031 + 5-6 85-4 -121 93-7 -3-8 Borne .
\lt ; f Means [ Differences. .
761 85-7 + 96 78-7 + 2-6 81-3 + 5-2 78-8 + 2-7 680 -81 73-2 -2-9 83-2 + 7-1 54-5 -21-6 81-7 + 5-6 1880 .
] Inquiry into the Periodicity of Rainfall .
Table VI.\#151 ; 10-year Rainfall Cycle .
' Stations .
Means .
1800 +10m .
1801 + 10 Yl .
1802 + 10m .
1803 +10m .
1804 +10m .
1805 + 10m .
1806 + 10m .
1807 + 10m .
1808 + 10m 1809 + 10m .
Symons ' English .
f Means [ Differences J Ratios .
1 1 94-3 891 -5-2 926 -1-7 98-7 + 4-4 94-3 -00 94-6 + 0-3 92-4 -1-9 966 + 2-3 966 + 2-3 94-5 + 0-2 93-8 -0-5 Dines ' London f Means 1 , Differences \ inches .
" 1 1 24-6 / 232 -1*4 263 -1-7 26-8 + 2'2 24-2 -0-4 22-3 -2-3 24-6 -00 26-3 + 1-7 22-7 -1-9 250 + 0-4 25-5 + 0-9 Edinburgh # f Means l_ Differences 264 26-8 + 0-4 25'0 -1-4 28-2 + 1-8 25-2 + 1-2 23-5 -2-9 24-2 -2-2 28-5 + 2-1 300 + 3-6 280 + 1-6 24-6 -1-8 London , Edinburgh , and Paris .
f Means t Differences 701 730 + 2-9 70-0 -01 73'2 + 31 67-8 -2-3 64-7 -5-4 675 -2-6 74-2 + 41 68-4 -1-7 72-4 + 2-3 714 + 1-3 Madras 4 f Means L Differences 48-4 500 + 1-6 510 + 2-6 49-9 + 1-5 45-1 -3-3 46-1 -2-3 431 -5-3 49-4 + 1-0 57-7 + 9-3 51-7 + 3-3 422 -62 Philadelphia -j f Means L Differences , .
41-6 44'2 + 2-6 41-7 + 0-1 41-7 +o-i 44-3 + 2-7 41-2 -0-4 40-7 -0-9 38-0 -3-6 44-8 + 3-2 37-8 -3-8 41-2 -0-4 New Bedford j r Means L Differences 41-4 456 + 4-2 47-0 + 5-6 396 -1-8 430 + 1-6 40-7 -0-7 39*3 -21 38-2 -3-2 42-5 + ri 366 -4-8 42-6 + 1-2 Paris -j r Means Differences f cms .
" I 1 48-5 J 496 + 11 481 -0-4 50-1 + 1-6 46-7 -1-8 47-1 -1-4 46-1 -2-4 49-2 + 0-7 48-9 + 0-4 47-7 -0-8 521 + 3-6 Padua j " Means Differences 860 80-6 \#151 ; 54 82-0 -4'0 87'9 + 1-9 90-5 + 4-5 831 -29 867 + 0-7 89-6 + 3-6 84-5 -1-5 87-1 + 1-1 88-6 + 2-6 Milan j " M eans Differences 97'5 941 -3-4 93-9 -36 104-5 + 7-0 104-6 + 7-1 94-1 -3-4 98-8 + 1-3 103-8 + 63 93-3 -4-2 96-8 -0-7 911 -6-4 Rome J Means Differences 76-1 74-6 -1-5 71-8 -4-3 79-8 + 3-7 79-4 + 3-3 \#166 ; 73-6 -2-5 \#166 ; up 79-3 + 3-2 775 + 1-4 72-5 -3-6 78-8 + 2-7 73 0 -3-1 .XdL " nmmmmmmmm .
i mil , i j. jm i irillliljpipi , , .
..111,1,1 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... I I l I .
i ... ... I ... . .
1 .
... .
' . . .
\#166 ; Ou o Mr. Gr .
M. Whipple .
Results of an [ Jan. 15 , .XXX i a me v ii.\#151 ; x\#177 ; -y ear xtaiHi\amp ; il vJy cm , Stations .
Means .
1800 +11m .
1801 +11m .
18C2 + 11m . !
1803 + 11m .
1804 + 11m .
1805 + 11m .
1806 + 11m .
1807 + 11m .
1808 + 11m .
1809 1 + lln .
1810 + 11m .
Symons* English f Means f Eatios .
" 1 \ 94-3 J 975 + 3-2 960 + 1-7 95-8 + 1'5 252 + 0-6 940 - 03 898 -4-5 960 + 1-7 95-4 + 11 936 -07 1011 + 6-8 881 -6-2 90-7 -3-6 [ Differences . .
Dines* London f Means f inches .
1 \ 24 6 J 25-5 + 09 242 -0-4 22-6 -2 ; 0 23-5 -11 260 + 1-4 253 + 0-7 23-2 -1-4 26-2 + 1-6 24-2 -0-4 25-2 + 0-6 [ Differences . .
Edinburgh * f Means 26-4 262 -0-2 275 + 11 270 + 06 24-8 -1-6 240 -2-4 28-4 + 20 272 + 0-8 280 + 1-6 28-2 + 1-8 23-6 -2-8 25-8 -0-6 L Differences . .
London , Edinburgh , and Paris I Means 701 67-0 -31 70-2 + 01 726 + 25 658 -43 66-8 -33 760 + 5-9 732 + 31 730 + 29 750 + 4-9 64-4 -5-7 66-5 -3-6 [ Differences . .
Madras * f Means 48-4 483 -o-i 350 -13-4 490 + 0-6 49-0 + 0-6 583 + 99 508 + 2-4 50-5 + 21 54-3 + 5-9 52-8 + 4-4 450 -3-4 36-8 -11-6 Differences . .
Philadelphia -j f Means . .
... .
41-6 40-5 -11 430 + 1-4 41-2 -0-4 40-4 -1-2 39-8 -1-8 396 -20 438 + 2-2 40-6 -10 43-8 + 2-2 44-2 + 2-6 420 + 0-4 [ Differences . .
New Bedford -j Means ... ... 414 372 -4-2 430 + 1-6 38-5 -2-9 386 -2*8 410 -0-4 398 -re 41-8 + 0-4 ' 45-8 + 4'4 44*4 + 30 40-2 -1-2 44-6 + 3-2 L Differences . .
Paris j F Means f cms .
1 l 48-5 / 49-4 + 0-9 46"4 -2-1 48-1 -0-4 471 -1-4 463 -2-2 52-2 + 3-7 531 + 4-6 464 -21 49-9 + 1-4 45-3 -3-2 48-9 + 0-4 [ Differences . .
Padua -j r Means 860 84-7 -1-3 85-7 -0-3 843 -17 871 +ri 90-2 + 4-2 90-2 + 4-2 81-1 -4-9 89-4 + 3-4 83-2 -2-8 83-2 -2-8 87-7 + 1-7 L Differences . .
Milan ... .
.j P Means 875 92-5 -50 990 + 1-5 97-7 + 0-2 95-6 -1*9 950 -2-5 975 o-o 1005 + 30 102-2 + 4-7 91-9 -5-6 1001 + 2-6 100-8 + 3-3 " Differences . .
Rome T t | 'Means 76-1 706 -5-5 77-2 + 11 81-0 + 4-9 69-8 -6*3 75-4 -07 726 -3-5 74-6 \#151 ; 1*5 80-8 + 4-7 750 -ri 95*2 + 19-1 660 -101 .
Differences . .
1880.1 Inquiry into the Periodicity of liar Table VTII.\#151 ; 12-year Rainfall Cycle .
Stations , Means .
1800 + 12w .
1801 +12\#187 ; .
1802 +12\#187 ; .
1803 +12\#187 ; .
1804 +12\#187 ; .
1805 + 12\#187 ; .
1806 + 12a .
1807 + 12w .
, 1808 + 12\#187 ; .
1809 + 12\#187 ; .
1810 +12\#187 ; .
1811 + 12m .
Symons ' English . .
- f Means J Ratios .
1 t 94-3 J 1002 + 5-9 90-8 - 3-5 86-8 -7-5 87-9 -6-4 100-3 + 6-0 92-4 -1-9 98-6 + 4-3 931 -1-2 89-5 -4-8 95-4 + 11 92-7 -1-6 1040 + 9-7 Differences. .
Dines ' London ... .-* r Means f inches .
1 1 24-6 J 30-8 + 6-2 22-3 -2-3 22-6 -2-0 23-6 -1-0 25-8 + 1-2 27-2 + 2-6 254 + 0-8 256 + 10 222 -2-4 254 + 0-8 21-4 -3-2 23-4 -1-2 Differences . .
Edinburgh \lt ; r Means . .
/ . . .
264 320 + 5-6 25-4 -10 25-2 -1-2 26-4 -o-o 29-2 + 2-8 28-8 + 2-4 25-2 -1-2 24-7 -1-7 25-2 -1-2 23-7 -2-7 24-8 -1-6 25-4 -10 Differences. .
London , Edinburgh , and Paris f Means 701 850 + 149 681 - ?
'0 66-8 -3-3 68-8 -1:8 740 + 3-9 730 + 29 697 -0-4 69-2 -0-9 67-2 -2-9 66-5 -36 64-4 -5-7 68-4 -1-7 L Differences . .
Madras -j f Means . .
... .
48-4 47-2 -1-2 46-5 -1-9 47-2 -1-2 58-8 + 10-4 46-5 \#151 ; T9 470 -1-4 47-6 -0-8 37-2 \#151 ; 11*2 !
48-2 -0-2 41"4 -7-0 60-2 + 11-8 52-0 + 3-6 1 Differences . .
Philadelphia ... ... -j r Means ... ... 41-6 40-2 \#151 ; 1-4 38-6 -30 44'8 + 3-2 41-0 -0-6 410 -0-6 460 + 4-4 42-6 + 1-0 44'4 + 2-8 38-5 -31 42-2 + 0-6 36-4 -5-2 43-2 + 1-6 [ Differences . .
New Bedford ... ... \lt ; f Means 41-4 38-5 -2-9 36-5 -4-9 42-8 + 1-4 450 + 3-6 39-8 -1-6 44'2 + 2-8 430 + 1-6 43-2 + 1-8 375 \#151 ; 39 40-2 -1-2 375 -3-9 46-2 + 4-8 [ Differences . .
Paris J f Means f cms .
1 1 48-5 J 55-4 + 6-9 490 + 0-5 42-7 -5-8 45-3 -3-2 510 + 2-5 44-6 -3-9 47-9 -0-6 48:6 + 01 47-2 -1-3 51-6 + 31 47-9 -0-6 49-9 + 1-4 [ Differences . .
Padua. . .
-j f Means 860 92-8 + 6-8 82-3 -3-7 87-3 + 1-3 863 + 0-3 801 -5-9 83-6 -2-4 90-5 + 4'5 886 + 2-6 89-1 + 31 91-4 + 54 74-8 -11-2 866 + 0-6 L Differences . .
Milan J f Means 975 106-6 + 91 101-6 + 4-1 104-9 + 7-4 103-3 + 5-8 90-8 -6-7 89-3 -8-2 93-5 -4-0 1010 + 3-5 98-2 + 0-7 99-8 + 2-3 97-8 + 0-3 82-5 -15-0 1 Differences . .
Rome i |_ ^ ; f Means 761 850 + 8-9 61-2 -149 j 860 + 9-9 90-4 +14-3 IK i \#166 ; \#166 ; : i 63-2 -12-9 79-2 + 31 sp. *3.1 f 76-0 -01 71-7 } 78-5 \#151 ; 4-4 J +2-4 , 78-5 + 2-4 j 74-5 -1-6 j 69-2 \#151 ; 6*9 j L Differences. .
Mr. Gr .
M. Whipple .
Results of an [ Jan. 15 , J Table IX.\#151 ; 13-year Rainfall Cycle .
Stations .
Means .
1800 + 13 % .
1801 + 13 % .
1802 +13 % .
1803 + 13 % .
1804 + 13m .
1805 + 13m .
1806 + 13m .
1807 + 13m .
1808 + 13\#187 ; .
1809 + 13m .
1810 + 13m .
1811 + 13 % .
1812 +13 % .
Symons ' English . .
\lt ; r Means ... .
L Differences f Ratios .
1 \ 94-3 J 992 + 4-9 89-9 \#151 ; 4-4 102-4 + 8-1 91-9 -2-4 971 + 2-8 90-7 -3-6 87-7 -6-6 96-2 + 1-9 95-5 + 1-2 951 + 0-8 96-3 + 2-0 891 -5-2 95-4 +ri Dines* London ... .-\lt ; f Means ... . .
[ Differences f inches .
1 t 24-6 / 28-2 + 36 24-8 + 0-2 25-0 + 0-4 25-0 + 0-4 24-4 -0-2 23-4 -1-2 22-0 -2-6 26-6 + 2-0 25-2 + 0-6 23-8 -0-8 25-8 + 1-2 23-2 -1-4 22-2 -2-4 Edinburgh - ' Means ... .
Differences 264 242 -22 267 + 0-3 25-7 -0-7 240 -2-4 26-7 + 0-3 230 -3-4 24-2 -22 290 + 2-6 26-2 -0-2 27-2 + 0-8 29-2 + 2-8 270 + 0-6 29-2 + 2-8 London , Edinburgh , ^ and Paris " Means. . . .
Differences 701 72-2 -21 73-2 -31 73-5 + 3-4 64-7 -5-4 72*0 + 1-9 60-5 -9-6 60-5 -96 76-2 + 6-1 70-2 + 01 69-6 -0-5 76-0 + 5-9 67-2 -2-9 640 -61 Madras ... * H r Means ... .
L Differences 48-4 54-8 + 6-4 53-2 + 4-8 438 -4-6 374 -110 450 -3-4 62-4 + 140 39-2 -9-2 63-2 + 14-8 | 49-4 + ro 51-2 + 2-8 374 -110 39-2 -9-2 52-8 + 4'4 Philadelphia \#171 ; j r Means. . . .
L Differences 416 432 + T6 42-8 + 1-2 47-2 + 5-6 410 -0-6 40-5 -11 40-5 -ri 360 -5-6 47-0 + 5-4 39-0 -2-6 375 -41 41-2 \#151 ; 0"4 43-6 + 2-0 39-6 -20 New Bedford j r Means ... .
[ Differences 414 435 + 21 42-4 + 10 420 + 0-6 420 + 0-6 43-2 + 1-8 41-2 -0-2 410 -0-4 38-7 -2-7 40-0 -1-4 400 -1-4 410 -0-4 43-2 + 1-8 39-5 -1-9 Paris r Means..* , [ Differences / cms .
1 \ 48-5 J 51-7 + 3 2 455 -30 53-5 + 50 47--2 -1-3 521 + 3-6 500 + 1-5 465 -20 47-8 -0-7 48-7 + 0-2 45-1 -3-4 48-6 + 01 45-4 -31 48-8 + 0-3 Padua \#171 ; | f Means ... .
[ Differences 860 861 + 01 80-6 -54 801 -5-9 88-0 + 2-0 81-9 -41 821 -3-9 88-2 + 2-2 92-7 + 6-7 82-7 -3-3 83-8 -2-2 87-5 + 1-5 93-9 + 7-9 90-5 + 4*5 Milan '4 f Means ... .
[ Differences 975 101-8 -4-3 105-3 + 7-8 84-9 -12-6 981 + 0-6 98-4 + 0-9 85-7 -11-8 100-5 + 30 99-4 + 1-9 94-8 -2-7 90-6 -69 1030 + 5-5 103-2 + 5-7 101-5 + 4-0 Rome L Differences 761 79-6 + 3-5 672 -8-9 66-8 -9-3 87-0 + 10-9 687 -74 78-8 + 2-7 78-5 + 2-4 84-8 + 8-7 73-7 -2-4 69-5 -6-6 87-7 + 11-6 75-7 -0-4 716 -4-5 K5 S g. Cb I* g- o\#171 ; w 00 oo 1880 .
] Table X.\#151 ; Rainfall Periodicity .
Comparison of calculated epochs of maximum and minimum annual rainfall with the actual maxima and minima observed .
Stations .
Symons ' English .
Dines ' London .
Edinburgh .
London , Edinburgh , and Paris .
Madras .
Philadelphia .
New Bedford .
Paris .
Padua .
Milan .
Rome .
Years of 1726 to 1865 1813 to 1878 1822 to 1878 1822 to 1875 1813 to 1877 1810 to 1867 1814 to 1867 1689 to 1875 1725 to 1878 1764 to 1878 1825 to 1878 Totals .
Observation .
( 140 ) .
( 66 ) .
( 57 ) .
( 54 ) .
( 65 ) .
( 58 ) .
( 54 ) .
( 161 ) .
( 154 ) .
( 115 ) .
( 54 ) , Coincidences * E ti ti li ' ti si ts ti Coincidences = 110 .
\#151 ; For .
Non-coin .
s ' I i s ' I 1 0 1 6 '\#166 ; S s 1 1 S ' 1 1 s ' I 1 * I Patio .
s ' | s 1 s .1 1 s I .i For .
1 Ratio .
= Against .
\lt ; 3 Ph Ph Ph \#171 ; Ph \lt ; 1 Pn \lt ; Ph Ph \lt ; 1 \amp ; c E* En \lt ; P* ( 2 \lt ; 3 Cycles : 16 40 ... 8 15 ... 7 14 8 13 ... 5 21 ... 17 30 ... 8 13 ... 37 92 12 50 12 34 12 31 Non-coins .
5-year ... ... 25 ... ... 19 ... ... 20 ... ... 16 ... ... 42 ... ... l8 ... ... 16 ... ... 25 ... ... 42 ... ... 28 ... ... 26 277 6-year 20 26 ... 13 9 ... 6 13 11 7 ... 6 16 ... 12 8 ... 18 18 ... 35 71 ... 30 73 ... 12 26 13 23 ... ... 13 ... ... 7 ... ... 21 ... ... 6 ... ... 27 ... ... 7 ... ... 10 ... ... 20 ... ... 24 ... ... 22 ... ... 18 175 7-year 31 49 ... 14 23 ... 13 17 13 17 ... 5 14 ... 11 22 14 17 ... 25 67 9 35 23 43 9 21 ... ... 16 \#151 ; ... 16 ... ... 13 ... ... 13 ... ... 28 ... ... 20 ... ... 12 ... ... 27 ... ... 39 ... ... 19 ... ... 23 226 8-year 29 40 ... 15 17 ... 12 16 20 20 ... 6 27 ... 22 22 ... 22 18 ... 31 49 21 56 ... 15 42 8 20 ... ... 14 ... ... 11 ... ... I3 ... ... 10 ... ... 45 ... ... 10 ... ... 8 ... ... 16 ... ... 27 ... ... 28 ... ... 25 207 9-year 9 22 ... 14 16 ... 9 16 10 14 ... 11 18 ... 15 11 ... 16 8 24 48 24 45 19 32 12 12 ... ... 24 ... ... 11 ... ... 18 ... ... 14 ... ... 18 ... ... 7 ... ... 5 ... ... 20 ... ... 19 ... ... 17 ... ... 10 163 10-year ... 23 34 ... 16 23 ... 8 23 14 8 ... 4 22 ... 15 14 ... 17 15 ... 29 66 26 66 ... 15 31 10 23 ... ... 15 ... ... H ... ... 29 ... ... 6 ... ... 55 ... ... 9 ... ... 9 ... ... 23 ... ... 25 ... ... 21 ... ... 23 229 11-year ... 35 42 ... 10 26 ... 9 12 8 12 ... 6 5 ... 11 21 ... 16 13 25 35 24 88 ... 19 45 10 19 ... ... ... 12 ... ... 26 ... ... 13 ... ... i5 ... ... 8 ... ... 19 ... ... *8 ... ... 14 ... ... 36 ... ... 24 ... ... *9 194 12-year ... 42 51 ... 15 17 ... 9 10 12 7 ... 7 15 ... 21 17 14 13 37 45 28 50 ... 13 25 16 24 ... ... 12 ... ... 11 ... ... 11 ... ... 9 ... ... 21 ... ... *8 ... ... 9 ... ... 12 ... ... 18 ... ... i9 ... ... 15 145 13-year ... 40 45 ... 11 20 ... 14 18 ... 17 17 ... 13 17 17 10 8 11 42 81 17 54 15 37 11 23 ... 11 ... ... 18 ... ... 13 ... ... 10 ... ... 13 ... ... *6 ... ... 14 ... ... 19 ... ... 32 ... ... 25 ... ... 21 182 * In the columns headed ratio are given the computed number of non-coincidences for every ten ,

