432 Mr. J. N. Lockyer .
Discussion of \#166 ; [ Mar. 20 , \#166 ; , IY .
Spectrum stowing the Ba line at 4553 4 trumpeting .
Here the line , after proceeding to a considerable distance from the hottest region of the arc as a fine reversed line , gradually expands towards its extremity .
Flame-spectrum of Mn , showing the reversal of the triplet in the arc-flame .
Flame-spectra of Ca , showing the gradual extinction first of K and then of H as the ; 4||r flame recedes farthest from the arc .
III .
Discussion of " Young 's List of Chromospheric Lines .
" | ( Note I. ) By J. Norman Lockyer , F.R.S. Received I March 5 , 1879 .
[ Plate 9 .
] In my paper read on the 12th December , 1878 , I called attention to the fact that , in the case of the metals discussed in that paper , with 1 the exception of hydrogen , there was a considerable discrepancy be- 1 tween the intensities of the lines seen in onr laboratories and the I number of times the lines had been seen by Young in his careful ' researches on the chromosphere . .
In a preliminary note " On the Substances which produce the Chro- I mospheric Lines " I pointed out that the lines visible in the spectrum 1 of the chromosphere when a metallic prominence is observed are for the I most part basic lines , that is to say , with few exceptions , the longest I and brightest lines visible in the spectra of the so-called elements are 1 conspicuously absent ; instead of them we find fainter lines , which | Thalen has , in many instances , mapped as common to two elements .
Since these papers were communicated to the Society I have con- J tinued this line of inquiry , and I now propose to state what I have 1 thus far done :\#151 ; 1 .
The maps of the spectra of calcium , barium , iron , and manganese , submitted to the Society in an incomplete state when the preliminary note was read , have been completed .
In these the lengths of the lines in the spectra of the metallic elements represent the intensities .
given by Thalen , whose lines and wave-lengths I have followed in all cases , while those of the lines visible in solar storms , represent the number of times each line has been seen in the spectrum of the chromosphere by Professor Young , to whose important work I have drawn special attention in my last two communications .
An inspection of these maps is sufficient to show that there is no connexion whatever beyond that of wave-length between the spectra ; it will be gathered from the maps how the long lines seen in our laboratories are suppressed and the feeble lines exalted in the spectrum of the chromosphere , see Plate 9 .
The Mh map has been omitted on account of its excessive complication .
0 2 .
I have discussed the coincidences recorded in Angstrom 's map and Thalen tables in the sheets of the " Spectre Normal , " comprising Proc. Roy .
ooc .
iron .
c A L c I u M. BARIUM , riiioa \amp ; $em JLllif Sjm\amp ; isbis \#163 ; *4 we .
" Young 's List of Chromospheric Lines ' ' .
1879 .
] the wave-lengths 4120\#151 ; 5400 .
I have discussed in each case the possibility or impossibility of such coincidence having arisen from the presence of an impurity .
Any person going over this table after he has taken the trouble to acquire the information necessary to understand it , will see that in a large number of cases the coincidences cannot be ascribed to the existence of impurities .
In many cases , it is true , the coincidences may arise from the presence of impurities , but this is by no means a proof that they do so .
Indeed it does not appear to have struck all who have considered this question , that , as I have before shown , the presence of B existing with A as an impurity and in A as a base , will , up to a certain point , give the same results ; the ascribing of lines , therefore , to impurities , without a demonstration of the impurity , is an unscientific proceeding .
In this table , as in the maps , it will be seen how the faintest lines are apt to be most frequently seen in the chromosphere .
( See pp. 434\#151 ; 439 .
) 3 .
I have attacked Young 's complete list from another point of view , discussing , in connexion with Angstrom 's map and Thalen 's tables , all lines seen less than one hundred and more than fourteen times , to determine whether , when treated in this way , there was any connexion between the intensities of the lines , as given by Thalen , and the number of reversals , including , of course , those cases in which Thalen has assigned the line to two metals .
Of the forty-one lines given in the following table , no less than five have exactly the same readings in two metals according to Thalen , and three more have very small differences .
It will be observed that only one line of the 1st order of intensity in the spectrum of iron appears in the list .
This was observed three times , while two lines of the 3rd order have been seen no less than forty times .
No line of manganese above the 3rd order has been observed , and of the two recorded , a 5th order line has been observed twenty times , and a 3rd order line fifteen .
It will be seen , further , from the last column in the table , that , as a rule , when we leave out of discussion the lines visible in Sirius , the more intense adjacent lines of the same metals have either not been seen at all by Young , or have been seen less frequently .
( See pp. | 440 , 441 .
) 4 .
I have made some preliminary observations on the presence in , or absence from , metallic spectra of some of the lines most frequently seen by Young , for if the lines observed so frequently by Young in solar storms and recorded as common to two substances at least by Thalen be really basic , it becomes highly probable that these lines are J really present in the spectra of many bodies but have been overlooked by previous observers in consequence of their faintness .
Up to the present time my work has been somewhat restricted in this Mr. J. N. Lockyer .
Discussion of [ Mar. 20 , Ph c3 jn s r3 EH o .
a CD Tj .
rH o .a o O o .
iH r"H \lt ; d { =1 .2 h3 rt o3 H bo .S .a c3 ~3 -+=\gt ; CD CD r-3 OQ m rg C3 a CD M ^ \#166 ; .a S I.a iilli g.vlj 1 a f a* o'eg \#174 ; O \#174 ; \lt ; * 1 j pH \#169 ; fl _g h Pr .2 VO rj CO\#171 ; Hu VO O " \#174 ; .
.S-c S o P* '.ll " In rl Pi g 3 * | So " \#174 ; \#174 ; \#171 ; \#174 ; a o3 r\#169 ; o ~ -4-3 \lt ; v\#163 ; h \#169 ; -iH ^ ^ \#171 ; a .a g 1 I s'\#174 ; CH \#174 ; O .**3 ** .\#166 ; 6-Sw _ , Tp Ph 9 CO '"1 " 1 vO 2 P\#171 ; 9 S 8 a sjS s \#166 ; *\#187 ; 9 *w c3 o \#169 ; w .2 o r2 'So \#169 ; cT ^ H QQ 4-3 4-4 S PS P\#151 ; 1 GQ \#169 ; \#169 ; \lt ; sj I'E .-\#166 ; 44 \#169 ; a ph g.s a ^T-l q3 \#166 ; a so \#169 ; C+h ' \#171 ; a \gt ; \#187 ; M\gt ; .2'S .i^i *\#163 ; l.i j e \#174 ; \#174 ; \amp ; a * 2 S\lt ; \#163 ; H PS S .
o la 1* ' ^ * lifitjM'S S Ph l=i 5 ^ o 44 \#169 ; .a S a .p \#163 ; *.g Sill in |.2^|| a| ^S|1Sl n'S .2 \#174 ; all s s* Hi \#169 ; \#169 ; o3 Z*t o \#174 ; g c3 S d 8 80 sT 0^0 _ \#169 ; \#169 ; .ap=( \#174 ; go5 ^\#163 ; 8 \#174 ; *Sa- h p J ps a e5 .
rH .
_| " \#169 ; \#163 ; S 03 d J-ai \#163 ; \#169 ; \#163 ; *tH d o g'p a , 0 \#169 ; ST a^= o K\#171 ; 0 1 3,3 s \#171 ; -S g a |SI Js-s h3 \#169 ; \#169 ; 02 Ph ptj o3 la* J'SS pH o S I-Ms .a g p\#174 ; sjs j-S MS '1 s\#163 ; .a gfcr2 -s *1 t- \#169 ; ^\gt ; rK4 S3 44 ; ^ S'^ g3.2 " \#166 ; 73 O \#169 ; \#169 ; .# ' , -4 ^ a .9 1^1 a ifjfl 31 !
* fxT2*Spc\lt ; S rS 9 ^ -S | ^ ^ \#169 ; C+H 9 g\#171 ; 2,1 .a SI'S 5 8.^ a\#187 ; '3 \#171 ; r \#174 ; \#174 ; 5p n \#166 ; gs s \#174 ; S g^\#171 ; 2 .2 agrS gf*S frK|a , r,1 , fH QQ # \#166 ; gg a a \#171 ; a2\#171 ; g ( u O O 44 ' i S*c| e* slis S.a\#171 ; !5 \#169 ; ^ \#169 ; 'S 4 \#169 ; ^ a P \#171 ; P \#171 ; H O J- \#174 ; o\#171 ; fe -\#174 ; ^ i " S 2\gt ; J ^ -g .S " .a5 * S i .s.a^ g H o gfli2 - g.a a *3 i 8\#163 ; i8 ^ \#169 ; \#169 ; n3 o i S SoI k il o p-s O \#166 ; +3 w OD tifll S * " g*\#171 ; a .a ic-g^ \#166 ; sl o i| P ,44 ^ C3 a-g l'| !
0'S : | \amp ; p/ 3 i ^ OD _ j\#153 ; , a H 5J.^ I.s^.s S .2 g \#169 ; .
w S S ' .a s s Hi *rS EH \#169 ; \#169 ; o Pro \#169 ; o3 FHO \#169 ; c3 \#169 ; O P=iOHO r\#174 ; kg \#169 ; o FHO T ?
^P \lt ; \#163 ; .
\lt ; p ip ^P 00 00 rpi tH ^p tP JS 00s d \lt ; M ( M vo vO 00 00 ^P rH 05 05 VO VO CO cc co CO rP tP VO lO 4p ^P CO co \#169 ; \#169 ; a S \#169 ; CO CO VO vO CO CO vo VO \lt ; M ( M \lt ; M CM VO vO vO vO CM CM vo vo ( N CM vo vo .
^ Sh CO VO ^VO^O r-1 iO 50 k , CM ?
H ( M VO lO ItH .1879 .
] Young 's List of Chromospheric % a \#169 ; | S -g.s iS.s \#166 ; gTS \#174 ; g \#174 ; S ^ \#169 ; 4^0 0 ci g h ^ S'o +3 -a O .\#187 ; H QQ Vi .
5 \lt ; D V rP 2 a8 jjls \#171 ; -a ?
f a g^li slUS .s is 11 .23'a.g : 11 Hi \#169 ; ^ \#169 ; QQ CD O P-l \#169 ; \#174 ; a Is c3 CO .S S|.9TJ-el ii \lt ; $"\#171 ; on 8 ' ^ \lt ; 35 T. \#169 ; P P .
rH s s^\#171 ; S a i^sij iifA ffjll iff S S s ^ \#163 ; * 1 g '* !
I| s S.s g-frl .75 ^ .s \#169 ; pi .aI S ' ?
8 ^ ^ o o*5 ||Ma al Mis* Sf Ikst !
p ] ^ j\#163 ; * O J3 \#174 ; 3 ^ -g o ^ 3 k pH \#174 ; WflrSPf'S-O *g S ..S\#166 ; 2-1'I !
o'S o.aS-.S .
i\#163 ; *s fl'tj-3-9 -g \#163 ; ^ -g -M ^ Hg 3 , '%g g a'g a a g|f=H u\#163 ; S , \lt ; S S2^12.1-a 8 45 \#163 ; \#187 ; 5 * ^ a o a o.rt\#174 ; S a S a " S g \#171 ; ^*l*a g ^ 43 * 8 8 s 8 -g .g 8 M ) \#163 ; 3 .S 3 .S -S -r \#174 ; .-a a !
Eh EH \amp ; H -4-i H-J 0 o p p " .2 ^ \#174 ; \#169 ; a Tfl S.a \#187 ; \#151 ; i \#169 ; fe .
V I .H-3 GO flS 1 8 .9 p __ .
\#169 ; '73 ^ " " S \#169 ; \#169 ; *P *\#169 ; si d\#171 ; a fl .a at \#169 ; T-l pH \#174 ; y ^\#187 ; EH ( U* " S Ph | a.9 M 2 * fl \#171 ; o O Sog ^ \#174 ; ft 3^3 o-s a S -e * S | *\#187 ; \#171 ; \#174 ; 2 .2 \amp ; rg M Eh .rH a o _ .
/ \#151 ; s/ ^N CO rH WHW^ ^s/ ^b ( M |H / ~N w \#169 ; \#169 ; CO \lt ; M .2 vg 8 8^3 \#169 ; Vi \#169 ; %4 \#169 ; *pH PhOPhi^ \#169 ; bfi \#169 ; *rH \#169 ; *rH \#169 ; ^ \#169 ; 03 co \#169 ; ^ l\gt ; 00 CO J\gt ; 1\gt ; \#169 ; \#169 ; 00 00 Ol ( ?
q 3 \#171 ; -g \#169 ; \#169 ; CO CO 00 00 \#169 ; o \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; LO \#169 ; ( M Cq CO \#169 ; rH rH ^ H1 OO CO ^ ^ \#169 ; \#169 ; HH S a* ( M Ol lO lO \lt ; N ( M H H lO lO lO lO rH rH LO lO rH rH \#169 ; \#169 ; H H H H \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; }\#163 ; * !
s *\gt ; l 8 S 3 Sh a .1 o^o rH on 1\gt ; N ^ H H rH \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; o ** CO VO |X rH \#169 ; ( M CO rH ^ rf( CO Lh rH rH \#169 ; ^ 10 0*0 Mr. J. N. Lockyer .
Discussion of [ Mar. 20 , cn c3 rii.s Jjf J.^l ^ \#174 ; S .\#171 ; fi ^3 ( 3 o .
4-S O sS \#174 ; .S'\#174 ; \#163 ; .8 ^-S^2 ns ^ 0 2 S S::3 \lt ; 2-1 .a-if a lllf ln3 S ft H \#174 ; 3 QQ \#174 ; 8 3 \#174 ; CD g } Fq J 2^2 'o3 #-p I 3f 8 .S3 S3 O .r\lt ; \#171 ; I 2f | a .2 -2 Jp .
\lt ; D al ^ 8 U.-a a J \#174 ; ^ is -s.a is bo 's .8 ?
\#187 ; \lt ; D 453 -o'C \#163 ; ^ CC fl m , S S^S o^l -* s o CD c3 \lt ; 15 p3 O P* ^ \#187 ; \#174 ; J5|\#163 ; I'M .as Jo 4s \#163 ; * al .\#174 ; S " ^ .a 1 is fl PR nS -SO 'So S 8-2 .1* J-S =S :S 2 \#163 ; 5 p -a \#163 ; *8 .
:S* S'| , .3 U g-g ft S 5 8 g 8 -1-s^ S"|-a 'S 58 eo 4-\gt ; 4^ .
rH Is 1-a EH \gt ; H a P s k*\#174 ; 8 a.a is ft. J f \#166 ; S iffjfii .1 111 If I 9 8.3 \#163 ; *S I **t s -S 8 \#171 ; a .9* o bo tx , g *8 8 k* a\gt ; \#166 ; g 8 I-.S \#163 ; S o 05 fl -2,2 S 2 \#163 ; h 'o Id aS iS J *sJS 8 2 H s .a \#163 ; * ^ 8 |2 I j. \#174 ; \lt ; s " ii m \#171 ; \#151 ; * \#163 ; *\#163 ; cj \#174 ; \#174 ; 05 3*3 CD 5 \amp ; .\#166 ; S. !
i-1 31| || i 1s-s4:\#171 ; " e*S|- ; 5 r5 SnSH P Ago .3 43 ^ S 'o ji : \#174 ; -2 *o 8 cb i|S O ^ 43 P 43 03 .S \#171 ; 4-3 453 O o3 .a a rfH * y o o rd 05 \#174 ; $.s \#166 ; S o O 53 s* \gt ; 3 r/ 2 433 S O -4_i QQ .S a 4^ O ao *jh ?
H fcJO Crt CD ^ .2 P * lgSJif 3 dr\#174 ; CD ^ Sh S cl ^ g g .M F4 g 4S ^.S^g-S.2 8\#169 ; g^ SSSdSSS^\#174 ; S \#171 ; 43 " S 2 " fl S .
w \#174 ; \#174 ; .2 43 -g t*l \#174 ; .
*\#187 ; S .
E , ^h^^.s j j Bn.a jg-s H I * " ~ as i O Jo l-s S1 o 1=1 m .
*H A.13 i-s .a ^ 11 \#166 ; S3 S.l rs^f 8 \#174 ; d-g'l^ S\#171 ; O \#174 ; CO S3 03 \#169 ; .2^o3pr 'S S .|'vg | * !
hi g 8-2 03 g 43 r4 .
rH S S 2^s * J " S a s HD r 05 o *r_l ^ , S \#163 ; . ?
'\#171 ; .
rH \amp ; J .a .2 43 t\gt ; S* no i\gt ; .r-( 05 tg ^33 ' .
\#187 ; iH 03 Szj.13 o ^ H .S S ^ s ^ o , a h \#174 ; 8 O ?
H O ' \#169 ; o a 5-a y ib w S3 o3 4^ *H \#169 ; S S H o5 -.a\#171 ; O ^ oj .3^8 \lt ; \#169 ; \#163 ; \#166 ; ** S SL'tf *s ag e. 03 .
80S P-r^ S3 .S S \#169 ; 8|\amp ; ^|cS O 43 \#163 ; sa 1|\#163 ; \#174 ; |8 a \#163 ; \gt ; \#174 ; |\#171 ; \#171 ; ^ \#174 ; S .2 03 'ft ( *\lt ; 4 S .a\#171 ; s g^a \#174 ; -S g SEH 8 if !
\#187 ; 1 T5 / '""\#166 ; n rH rH f^S t ?
tP 05 05 rH rH O O O lO f^S iSS fSs \#163 ; 8 / -S / ^S/ -N rH .
CQ CO \#169 ; 03 PRO / ^S / ^V^N rH CQ CO CD CO CO 00 CO CD CD OO CO CO OO DO 00 00 OO 05 05 05 05 ID ID Tp Tp rp Tp ID \p rp^l OO ^P ^p l\gt ; t\gt ; 0505 ID ID 00 00 J\gt ; \#187 ; COCO 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 rp rp ^p ^ ^ rp ^p rp \gt ; \gt ; .
.a .
S fS .2 rP CO CO CO CO 05 ID ID rp CD CO CO ID rp O 00 05 CD i CO 00 rP 00 N 05 CO ID 00 I I 05 rp 05 rP Op op 00 S ^ ilf if Sheet contai 1879 .
] " Young 's List of Chromospheric Lines .
" 8* OQ is rCl EH o o n3 bD .2 o d .2 CD c3 a \lt ; D \#171 ; .i s .a ss .2d I rj n o \lt ; 5 CD W a I d QQ rj SOQ l-s I \#163 ; o3 |F ji S a \#174 ; s ^ 9^'S |Its S " fa 1/ f.al I PH __A_ J3 H \#169 ; ^ ^ co o to -+o no -gis \#171 ; S co 03 5 m 2 ^ r3 \#174 ; \#169 ; S ^ ' 0Q 03 *H rd cd 43 \#169 ; gs ii CD of .gfc S-S \#171 ; H 03 n*g .3\#163 ; \gt ; \#169 ; s ^ \amp ; *g.S .r fl S fl sja .a 3 ^ *H S CD \#169 ; g'S'S lli p S g in Is a .al I t Jl a.s \#174 ; .
sj^** 2||.i 111 i !
f\#171 ; l .'-a S i Si'S g a |'| | I'pI .S| Ic^l I o-2^o g\#171 ; \#166 ; * S \#166 ; a a a " \#174 ; ~ | g.si ISJ mhf Mlj sIn \#169 ; SPSS'S 'w ' \lt ; D -rH \lt ; D *rH P-t \#169 ; \#169 ; ?
4 ^OaOCOCD^^fi^ C5 05 00WWCD\#169 ; I\gt ; l\gt ; CCCOCDCDCOCO Tft ^ T ?
Tf\lt ; r~i " sfl \#169 ; C3 f=\lt ; 0 CO CO no nO 00 00 no nO ^ Tjl \lt ; D C3 \#169 ; 08 \#169 ; \#174 ; 3 PRQ^QPqM 00 00 CO CD Tf\#171 ; OOQOOO^^ oo oo *\gt ; x\gt ; tM cq lO lO iO lO lO lO T ?
xfi Tfl Tft ^ \lt ; o d nO HO CD CD \#166 ; 5-P'S , \#174 ; * ?
g P \amp ; J \#174 ; a sa i^ill ii 00 OD f CD O CO CD o CD no ^ X\gt ; CO CD CD Tfi ^ ^ no go no Tfi 00 CO ^ to _ . . .
^ .
IQ O 00 ^ ^ CD rH 00 ( M t\gt ; | 00 kj no no no ^ ^ Tfl Tfi Tfi ^fi Mr. J. N. Lockyer .
Discussion of [ Mar. 20 GO d a pf d IS 3.9 ^ ^ bo d o gg 0 * m 0 1 f 'f | J 1 S jfH a \#169 ; a S1-s '"\#166 ; 8-f a ^ S ^ d -p BB d ft GO \#171 ; h .
\#169 ; biD-S rS Bh H \#166 ; p q-i .
S * Ug 2 \#166 ; BB r\amp ; ^ GO 1 \#166 ; a \#169 ; d \#169 ; o rSn \amp ; Sh \amp ; HU \#166 ; \#169 ; -+3 \#187 ; " H O O rQ P d d w " 0^9 \\#174 ; \#169 ; CO 1 ?
3 MBs \#166 ; A P=l g - 3 .9jl ^ d \lt ; p S 3 S \#171 ; p -3 s O ' c3 Hi BB 1*1-S *h \#174 ; \#171 ; c3S O d M o pi g \#151 ; m S s 1 js| H 1-al \#166 ; o a Bfl pi *\#163 ; 2 C8 ?
jrd rg IH BB *Sg \#166 ; | p \#169 ; GO d\#169 ; a ' \#166 ; I * \#166 ; s fsP GO d \#169 ; B B \lt ; w\gt ; \#169 ; \#169 ; r2 -g p O aT \#166 ; Iff d .
o |.3 \#171 ; CM .9 3 ^ xfi |-S .g \#166 ; go pi d \#166 ; .3 Tj \#169 ; r\#177 ; 4 g\#163 ; H S3 if vGo ca 5s d d I JOQ .
I HI BH HI \#166 ; B 0 In cd .S *d S ft EH ' ^QQ V\#169 ; iflEm 9 \#174 ; \amp ; . !
o \#187 ; R o 'g-S g'g \#166 ; bb h\#174 ; 9 3 ' ."S \#174 ; Iffl 58 \#174 ; R S3 eq pi hh ft ft K d ph a \#163 ; \#169 ; GO *P d gB| d GO EH nH .s ^ / ^N HBl ^ ' ft ft 00 00 HE \#169 ; \#169 ; M CD CD CM CM Tfl rft HP ^ ^ CO 4i3 \#169 ; S cb d d .
05 cm \#174 ; |1 K \#166 ; .9 S .s S \amp ; \#166 ; S'S .1^ r-s .
2\#171 ; S'g \#169 ; M TO i h pd o fe\#174 ; r\#174 ; ^ S S 3 ^ 3 " 2 \#174 ; .
n -S g -g I gn\#174 ; ^ 1 mm BBH BHi \#166 ; m d \#169 ; w *\#187 ; H \#169 ; O GO \lt ; H w d ^ -p \#169 ; .S 9 gfci \#166 ; \amp ; \lt ; 2^ 1 - S c3 O d .
\#166 ; H | \#151 ; \#174 ; mB i HB i I B \amp ; ( \#174 ; H P-l \#163 ; 3 3 I g 3 9 cS \#163 ; B lo l.ad B S " 43 HHfl g 8 S " S o 'i S..2 \#169 ; I |.2 BH ^ .
o 2 g 43 \#169 ; * 0 \#163 ; \#171 ; *h \#169 ; .P \#169 ; P .S ^\#169 ; o ' ( M rd U \#169 ; c3 \#169 ; \#166 ; B *d .p o c3 / -\#151 ; s/ ^s \#169 ; d i\gt ; j\gt ; i\#151 ; I rH rfr ^ *#1 \#163 ; S S\amp ; iS\amp ; \amp ; \amp ; \amp ; 6 ^ ^ ^\gt ; J\gt ; T-IrH(MViOCOCC lO lO 03 00 OO MW II ^ 1 rH l 00 O ip CO J\gt ; rH 05 00 X\gt ; CM CM CM ^P\lt ; ^ ^ 1879 .
] Young 's List of Chromospheric Lines .
" .
i\#151 ; i S \#166 ; M .s^ B 1 \#166 ; D \lt ; DH 8 S \lt ; D 11 g \#174 ; II go 's ,3 |2| W ..Sj.ai : j-s g\#171 ; s s'g ; -2 ^-s f Jo \#166 ; \#166 ; I \lt ; D MOW ^ \amp ; \#169 ; _* " g \#163 ; \gt ; ,3 'a .
' 11 ' I \#166 ; o q_ , 43 \#169 ; mfHBI 9HB \amp ; S. s-fc-3 bD crt I Sif4l ?
61 'n I G \#169 ; .-\#163 ; GG \#169 ; o ' aj " \#166 ; ^ s ^ mu Ph 111..2 ^ s a ' mu \#166 ; S \#166 ; \#166 ; \#166 ; |HHHG[ g.a Mml \#151 ; ( || S | |aslo|||F S I I J .9 \#163 ; a I n Hil \#169 ; 'c s s H ghkh .I iBH sa^i0^8^SSdS\#174 ; S 's g|--Sa N^l g , =2 ls\lt ; 5.s*:S.ga.g H \#166 ; EH a .a ifi " S Jt\gt ; \#166 ; \#166 ; m S J s .+- ) q_ , \#166 ; I K \#166 ; \gt ; a .-*3 1\#174 ; E \#166 ; fa eh a \#166 ; .g * i-S 1 \#169 ; d | a g a S\#166 ; \#166 ; \#166 ; \#166 ; \#169 ; m a 4^ a s \#166 ; i ^ CO rg bp rg .
S 5 \#163 ; |3 S 1 \#174 ; jg ij \#174 ; \#169 ; ' s * ?
\#163 ; :S-a \#166 ; a i| r \#166 ; HI H \#166 ; \#166 ; \#166 ; \#153 ; \#166 ; Mi HB Ss n S i-a g ' \#163 ; 'f 1^1 I ^ '\amp ; \gt ; \#163 ; S ' \#163 ; S .g -S H Eh o 1P^ r-H^ rH^H* H^lP \lt ; D c3 s-i O e3 \#174 ; .@3 Ph O O .
Pq o Ph o 05 05 Q 00 00 up up CO CO CO OS OS I\gt ; x\gt ; \#187 ; H5 lO lO H\lt ; HP H H S2a S223 H* HI H1 HH* h HI c3 o pH *S S I \#166 ; \#166 ; S \#169 ; S1 rtf \#169 ; II 21 B I3 .S.\#169 ; \#166 ; 43 O ' I a II B \#166 ; 2 ' o 2s \#166 ; \#166 ; " d 9^ \#166 ; gJ I S \#166 ; W 40 OQ O .rH p| o a \amp ; \amp ; O o @ 3 ^10990099000 rH o 10 VO i\gt ; l\gt ; COCOCOl\gt ; HvOHH CO CO H H CO CO CO CO N ( M 00 00 1M\gt ; -^1 ^ 00 00 OQ Cv| OQ ( M OQ OQ yH r-^ rH rH rH rH rH rH rf( 5P 13 J 03 H m S'g5 \#166 ; I B i os co v^o 00 up OS XH -H H=\#171 ; up oo ?
VO ? ? ?
eo rH CD 'H rH CO k , CQ 00 X\gt ; CQ FH ( M rH rH H Hi ^ ^ rH UP CO rH -H CO H H Mr. J. N. Lockyer .
Discussion of [ Mar. 20 , S o , rH GG rl \#169 ; .
*4^ m \#169 ; .
|fl | f J O iSfSatSfe o a\gt ; go \#169 ; \#169 ; r\#151 ; f r-H bejS \#169 ; s a -8 \#166 ; 8 \#166 ; 8 QJ Id * c3 \#169 ; s cq , \#169 ; W1 ?
IS O \#163 ; -N^- S / * S H H CO ^ CO c3 \#169 ; d \#169 ; ryH O \lt ; 30 00 -l\gt ; O 4\gt ; CO CO CD 00 CD ( M lO \0 CO 00 ( MOiOOH O 3f\lt ; 3P lO ID x\#151 ; js c3 \#169 ; 5h \#151 ; s rj^rH \#169 ; c3 S3 be \#169 ; Ph pq r-H .
pH 00 05 CO CO c3 EH PP CO s^B 9\#171 ; cq 05 \#166 ; ?S t\#151 ; 1 CM ID ID / ^S .
V\#169 ; EH .
s~ ' TJ1 1:1 g S II .|Tl rrH " \#169 ; r\#174 ; .S *\#171 ; \gt ; r\#171 ; \#174 ; \g ' H ^SSSSSSSSSSSSSS-I^S^I ^ 3\#151 ; so be g " " S be g \gt ; v ' CM o3 o3 .^P\amp ; p c3 .
c3 |o OggpqaQ^ifecBO^0Q^|2irS .
\#171 ; gP^o \lt ; s ^ pq \#169 ; pq g .gO\#187 ; ob'pw99cowHowwfQ .
H 0iorQ*^'2ooS^co ^OOC^^CO^OOOiiOlDlOCOCOOOOO t\gt ; ^\#169 ; g lO k. \#163 ; FS 05 ^ CO in \#166 ; \#166 ; ^ COOOi\gt ; OOCOCOOOOiHHN(MCOCOr^^ g CO 4h \#169 ; 05 CO 12 CO CO " OiOiHHlOlOOOOO^OlOiaiHH^ 3 ^00 Oio rH t-i HCOCOVOlO)OlOiOlOTfl^'^'^iOiO ^io ID ID 8 S *H P-\ / ^v^s rH CM be \#169 ; \#169 ; ^ 9 o x\gt ; i\gt ; o tz ' * 'Jz ^ CD CO ^ CD CD .\lt ; !
\#166 ; \#174 ; i ^02 .53 0 cj *rH CO a -g :g 1 " ^ So p , gHHHH^ HH 5 CO q CO Cq CO lO 00 S c3 OJ H CO 1 - - Is 1\#151 ; 1 -g \#163 ; r ?
bD $ a * .-S^4 .
\#163 ; o \#169 ; \#169 ; r*H oc 1\gt ; SSSS S S ^ ^ ^ CO CO ro m co co co co 00 \#166 ; 5 \#163 ; IT I \#169 ; \#169 ; ^ to I S 05 00 O O rH \#169 ; \#169 ; 00 rH CO 05 ip 0^ 00 CO ^ O tp t- 9 4\gt ; cq cq co rfi CO CO X\gt ; 00 00 05 1(0 lO 00 05 rH 00 cq 00 CD VO cq lO ID CO Tp 05 rH 00 ID 05 cq CO rH X\gt ; CD i\#151 ; l CD |D 05 05 r\#151 ; 1 rH 1\#169 ; CO CO lO iO o oo oo cq lO lO ^ 05 s ID i\#169 ; cq cq 00 05 05 o rfl T ?
^ ID O rH ID ID cq ID .1879 .
] " Young 's List of Chromospheric Lines .
' ' bserved in \gt ; re .
If so , lie times .
75 8 50 10 10 3 12 I 'll pSli M Yes 5428 *8 5534-1 Yes No No No Yes Yes No No No No Yes .
No No Nearest strong line of each metal .
1=brightest .
3968-0 Ca ( 1 ) 54286 Ti ( 2 ) 5534-5 Ba ( 1 ) No long Ba line near .
4443 0 Ti ( 1 ) 4498 -2 Mn ( 2 ) 4919-8 Fe ( 1 ) 5296 -7 Ti ( 1 ) 5370-5 Fe ( 1 ) 4226 -3 Ca ( 1 ) 4249-8 Fe ( 1 ) 4498 " 2 Mn ( 2 ) 4526-1 Ti ( 1 ) 4638*8 Ti ( 1 ) 5268 -5 Fe ( 1 ) 5348-6 Ca ( 2 ) 5657-6 Fe ( 1 ) Metallic coincidences ( Thalen ) and intensities .
1=brightest .
4077 Ca ( 3 ) 5425-0 Ti ( 3 ) 5425-0 Ba ( 3 ) 6140 -6 Ba ( 1 ) None .
4468-5 Ti ( 1 ) 4491 " 0 Mn ( 5 ) 4918-2 Fe ( 2 ) 5282-8Ti ( 1 ) ?
5361-9 Fe ( 4 ) Not in Thalen 's tables .
4233-0 Ca ( 5 ) 4233 -0 Fe ( 3 ) None .
4489 -5 Mn ( 3 ) Marked in map as Fe also , but not in Thal6n 's tables .
4500-7 Ti ( 1 ) None .
46290 Ti ( 3 ) None .
5269 -5 Fe ( 1 ) 5269 -4 Ca ( 2 ) This seems to be a Ba line , but there is a mistake in tables or map .
5661-5 Fe ( 3 ) None .
Intensity of line in Sun .
1 = darkest .
3 Not in Angstrom 's map .
2 5 3 5 2 Notin Angstrom 's map .
3 4 } 4 4 2 3 3 5 2 4 3 2 No. of reversals seen by Young .
888888 883 33 33333 3 33 Wave-length of line reversed .
4077-0 5424 -5 6140 -6 6676 -9 4468-5 4490 -9 4918 -2 5283 *4 5361*9 6429-9 4233 0 4394-6 4489-4 4500-3 4583 -2 4629 0 5197 0 5269-5 5518 -7 5661-5 6515 -5 VOL. XXVIII .
Mr. J. N. Lockyer .
Discussion of [ Mar. 20 , direction , since , as I have been anxious to avoid any question arising from the known impurity of carbon poles , I have limited myself to the use of double metallic poles or experimented on very volatile substances , the impurities carried up by which are easily detected .
I append a provisional table of the results I have already obtained .
I do not hold to its absolute accuracy , but I know it is sound in the main .
( See p. 443 .
) The dispersion I have employed ( Rutherford 's grating , 17,000 lines second order ) has been so great that the observations would have been more satisfactory if the light of the arc had been less reduced by dispersion .
We may therefore feel assured that we are dealing with lines of the same wave-length , identical , that is , within the range of the most powerful instrumental methods ordinarily employed .
In all cases a battery of thirty Grove cells was used , and the lines were successively observed at the intersection of two cross-wires in the field of view , everything remained unchanged and rigid except the poles between which the arc was made to pass .
For the lines between H and G an inspection of photographs has taken the place of eye observations , and for this not only my own series of photographs has been used , but a most valuable one placed at my disposal by Professor Roscoe .
The list in its present very incomplete state leads to very remarkable conclusions ; the line at 1474 has been found in several spectra , while Lorenzoni 's / is markedly absent from the spectra of forty-two metallic elements ; this result , I think , justifies the suspicion long ago stated that / belongs to the same substance , or at least is nearly related to that which produces I)3 .
It will be seen too that a line coincident with the h line of hydrogen has been photographed in the spectra of several substances besides indium , G being absent , and F also , as I have gathered from an inspection of Dr. Roscoe 's photographs .
I may add that I have reason to suspect the existence of the C line alone in the spectra of some chemical substances .
These observations have compelled me to make rapid surveys of the arc-spectra of most of the metallic elements , and have again brought to the front , in a very striking way , the view I expressed to the Royal Society some five or six years ago , that many of the lines in line-spectra are the brightest portions\#151 ; the remnants\#151 ; of flutings and possibly of other rhythmic structui'e .
I am at present engaged in investigating this question of rhythm , and I have already found that many of the first order lines of iron may probably arise from the superposition or integration of a number of rhythmical triplets .
All this goes to show how long the series of simplifications is that we bring about in the case of the so-called elementary bodies by the application of a temperature that we cannot as yet define .
Indeed the more one studies spectra in detail , and especially under varying 1879 .
] " Young 's List of Chromospheric Lines " i i i i i i i i i i ii i i i i i i i i ii i i IIU + 5S i i ^^+i i i i i i m i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i i ii o + + + + + I I MMMMiiM j : : : : : : : : : : : mmn 2 k 2 444 On " Young 's List of Chromospheric Lines ' ' [ Mar. 20 , conditions of temperature which enable us to observe the reversal now of this set of lines , now of that , the more complex becomes the possible origin .
Some spectra are full of doublets : sodium and potassium , as ordinarily mapped , may be said indeed to consist exclusively of doublets ; others , again , are full of triplets , the wider member being sometimes on the more , sometimes on the less , refrangible side .
Doublets and triplets , as a rule , reverse themselves more freely than the irregular lines in the same spectrum\#151 ; which particular doublet or triplet will reverse depending upon the temperature , as if the cooler vapour to which the reversal is due varied as in the case of fractional distillation .
Some lines are clean cut in their reversal ; others , again , to use the laboratory phrase , are fluffy to a degree that must be seen to be appreciated , so much so , that when photographed they appear merely as blurs upon the plate .
The above results , which have been foreshadowed in my previous papers , have led me to examine especially the intensities of the various Fraunhofer lines , and to compare the intensities of the metallic lines confronted with them in arc and sun photographs .
I have done this because it is worse than useless to proceed with this construction of the large map now that four years ' work has shown that the method of impurity elimination has proved insufficient , until some other method , embodying a higher law , can be used ; and to get this we want work over the whole field .
This examination I am making , not only from K to G , over which my own photographs extend , but even to b , by means of another series taken by Professor Roscoe , which he has allowed me to inspect .
In short , in this survey I have about 300 photographs to work upon .
I exhibit several of these photographs to the Society in anticipation of a further communication .
The upshot of this inquiry even already is as follows:\#151 ; The discrepancy which I pointed out , six years ago , between the solar and terrestrial spectra of calcium is not an exceptional , but truly a typical case .
Variations of the same kind stare us in the face when the minute anatomy of the spectrum , of almost every one of the so-called elements is studied .
If , therefore , the argument for the existence of our terrestrial elements in extra-terrestrial bodies , including the sun , is to depend upon the perfect matching of the wave-lengths and intensities of the metallic and Praunhofer lines , then we are driven to the conclusion that the elements with which we are acquainted here DO NOT EXIST IN THE SUN .

