200 Mr. W. Shanks on Period of the [ Feb. 19 , III .
u On the Number of Figures in the Period of the Reciprocal of every Prime Number below 20,000 .
" By William Shanks .
Communicated by the Rev. George Salmon .
Received December 2 , 1873* .
The following Table , in reality the joint production of the Rev. George Salmon , F.R.S. , and myself , was commenced , and indeed nearly completed , before either calculator was distinctly aware that Burckhardt , Jacobi , or Desmarest had written or published any thing on the same subject .
This fact is perhaps to be regretted ; but it has led to the independent recalculation , by two different methods , both of Burckhardt 's ( Jacobi 's Table is professedly a reprint of Burckhardt 's ) and of Desmarest 's Table , and has resulted in the detection of several errors , which have , as far as I know , never before been pointed out .
These errors , in the first place regarded as discrepancies , have been carefully examined ; in fact every case has been reworked by me , with the view of either proving or disproving the accuracy of such numbers as differ from those in our Table .
The result is , that such discrepancies are found to be errors both in Burckhardt and Desmarest .
The two lists of errors are given below .
I now proceed to give the theorems used , and some account of the means employed by me in forming the Table .
Let P be any prime number , except 2 and 5 .
Then , from Fermat 's 1QP-1 ^ theorem , we have \#151 ; j\gt ; \#151 ; =1 ; or , adopting the usual notation , 10p x=l .
Again , since the number of figures in the period of the reciprocal of all primes is not P\#151 ; 1 ( or , in other words , since 10 is not a primitive root of all primes ) , P-1 .
Let 10 \#187 ; =1 , where n is even or odd , not less than 2 , and not greater than P-1 Then we have ( 1 ) The number of figures in the period of the reciprocal of P is either P \#151 ; 1 or a submultiple of P \#151 ; 1 .
jq\#171 ; ( 2 ) Let a and b be integers , and let m be the remainder from -p \gt ; that is , let 10"=m ; then 10a5=m6 .
_ '\#166 ; ] In practice b is never greater than 2 , at least little or no advantage is gained by putting b higher .
Also oh need not be greater than g Cor. When m is greater than \#151 ; q\#151 ; we may obviously use P w\#187 ; , or simply \#151 ; m ; for ( P\#151 ; m)2=P2-2Pm+m2==m2 , or , because b being 2 .
( 3 ) Let 10"==m , and 105=n ; then 10 In practice a-\-b is never greater than P\#151 ; 1 .
^ Cor. 1 .
When m and n are each of them less than P , we may with advantage use \#151 ; m and \#151 ; n ; that is , we may subtract rn and n severally from P ; for ( P - m)(P\#151 ; n)=P2 - P(m+\#171 ; )+\#187 ; \#187 ; =(-m)(\#151 ; \#187 ; ) .
Cor. 2 .
When m is \gt ; " o- \#166 ; \gt ; and n is \lt ; \#151 ; g * or v^ce versa ' we may use * The part from 17,000 to 20,000 was received January 8 , 1874 .
1874 .
] Reciprocal of every Prime Number below 20,000 .
201 -m and n , or vice versa , obtaining a negative result , which becomes positive by being subtracted from P. p_________^ ( 4 ) Let 2c and 3c , not greater than \#151 ; \lt ; 5\#151 ; , be submultiples of P \#151 ; 1 ; and let 10c= + S , and 102c=S \#151 ; 1 ; then 103c= ip 1 .
This is evident from ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) .
p_i Prom ( 1 ) we have 10 2 = + l , according as the submultiple of P \#151 ; 1 is even or odd .
On these theorems and adjuncts my calculations have been based .
ILt . .
10p_1 They enable us to find the remainder either from \#151 ; ^\#151 ; , or from any or from any figure in io*-1 and , if required , submultiple , such as p , ^ Compared with other methods , such for instance as the figure itself .
Dr. Salmon 's * , mine may seem tedious , requiring as it does much multiplication and division .
All I can say is , I did not find it so , though I am free to admit that the calculation of such a Table as ours demands very considerable labour .
It would be foreign to my purpose to enter upon the consideration of primitive roots , or even of prime numbers .
If we have found 10 to be a primitive root of a great many prime numbers between 10,000 and 20,000 , we have contributed something , as far as I know , quite new .
In addition to this we have found the number of figures in the period of each of the other primes between 10,000 and 20,000 , and have corrected upwards of 70 errors in Burckhardt 's and Desmarest 's Tables .
I beg to refer to the works of Euler , Lagrange , Legendre , Gauss , Poinsot , Cauchy , and J acobi ( mentioned by Desmarest ) , and to Desmarest himself , for valuable information touching prime numbers and primitive roots .
I cannot , however , refrain from quoting from Desmarest 's ' Theory des Nombres ' the view of Euler as to prime numbers and primitive roots :\#151 ; " On no peut saisir entre un nombre premier et les raeines primitives qui lui appartiennent , aucune relation d'ou l'on puisse deduire un seule de ces racines , de sort que la loi qui regne entre else parait aussi profonde-ment cachee que celle qui existe entre les nombres premiers eux-memes .
Not discouraged by Euler 's remark , Desmarest thus writes :\#151 ; " Car pourquoi nous serait-il defendu d'ajouter que nous croyons que 1 intelligence humaine n'a pas , sir ce point , dit son dernier mot , et que les operations nombreuses que nous avons du fair sir les nombres , no nous ont pas convaincu de l'impossibilite de saisir , sinon l'ensemble , du moins quelques-uns des anneaux de la chain mysterieuse qui unit les racines primitives aux nombres premiers .
" * Note by Dr. Salmon.\#151 ; The method here referred to is explained , ' Mathematics ' ( 1872 ) , p. 49 .
It is founded on the remark that if we have , \gt ; 10*== 2 ?
, we may deduoe 10a\#171 ; -*P==l .
Thus , let the prime be 251 , wecan at once write rlnwn *y1a ominHnna io3= \#151 ; 22 , 24=10\ whence immediately 102'\#151 ; \#151 ; 1 , 1050==1 .
iT\amp ; gtZf f"JLotions \#171 ; \#166 ; =\#187 ; , Kfe2-3\#171 ; , lte\#187 ; , we deduce that the number of figures in the period of the reciprocal of the prime is a(mr\#151 ; nq)+b(np\#151 ; rl)+c(lq\#151 ; mp ) .
By the application of these principles I calculated the results obtained in the following Table as far as 18500 .
For the primes above that number Mr. Shanks is solely responsible ; but my experience of his accuracy gives me confidence in his results .
__________ o Mr. W. Shanks on the Period of the [ Feb. 19 , Table I. List of Errors in Desmarest 's Table .
Primes .
No. of figures in period of reciprocal .
No. of figures in period of reciprocal .
] Primes .
No. of figures in period of reciprocal .
1 No. of figures in period of .eciprocal .
omitted j " 277 317 397 449 787 1409 1657 1733 1889 2087 32.53 3373 3413 35*7 354i 3547 3637 3677 3769 3821 39 " 4049 4167 | should be j- 4I57 J 4397 4621 4651 5871 1 should be [ .
4871 J 4943 5081 5107 54'7 5479 5 519 omitted 138 158 198 224 786 1408 276 433 59 8 9 271 562 853 1758 60 3546 3636 9I9 942 1910 3910 1012 157 4620 2325 2471 254 ' 5106 901 5478 1 55i8 should be a a it it 5 i \gt ; \gt ; \gt ; \gt ; J ) it J ) 5\gt ; It J ) J5 \gt ; \gt ; ?
5 \gt ; 5 \gt ; \gt ; it If if \gt ; t tt tt 1 " 1 69 79 99 32 393 32 552 866 118 298 542 843 1706 879 20 1773 9'9 1838 1884 3820 1955 2024 3i4 924 , 465 ' 4942 1270 2.553 1802 2739 2759 5557 5779 5827 6101 6277 6287 8421 1 should be l 6421 J 6781 6997 7001 7127 7481 7561 77x7 7741 7841 7853 1 omitted j 8011 8087 8093 8101 8219 8423 8521 8609 8681 8893 8999 9067 9187 9397 952X 9629 9649 9941 1389 5778 582 3050 3138 3I43 678O 3498 35 ' ' 509 3740 3780 3858 2 *|8o 392 omitted T 33 5 4'43 8092 8100 4io9 f8422 1 14211 J 355 538 4340 4446 8998 9066 9186 4698 952 4814 1206 9940 should be ft it a a a tt a a it a a it it a a a a tt it a tt a a a a a it 5* a ft it a 926 2889 ; 2913 | 1220 i 1569 6286 1356 1749 I75 ' IOl8 748 1890 1929 860 56 3926 267O 8086 4O46 l620 82l8 8422 710 IO76 868 2223 4499 4533 4593 81 595 9628 603 1988 N.B. There are 64 errors , 3 misprints , 2 omissions , viz. 3 and 7853 Table II .
List of Errors in Burckhardt 's and Jacobi 's Tables .
Burckhardt and Jacobi Burckhardt ... ... ... .
Jacobi ... ... ... ... .
Burckbardt and Jacobi ... Primes .
No. of figures in period of reciprocal .
9ii 450 should be 1979 346* | should be J- 3467 J 1976 ft 1213 1212 If 1597 266 a 1831 9*5 a 1951 39 ' a 1993 1992 a 2311 462 it 2437 !
2436 ft 3 67 3466 1 ' Ts .
B. There are 3 misprints and 8 errors .
No. of figures in period of reciprocal .
i33 3'5 i95 JLZli-r____ 1874 .
] Reciprocal of every Prime Number below 20,000 .
203 In the left-hand columns of Table III .
are primes ; in the right-hand columns , immediately opposite , is the number of figures in the period of the reciprocal of each prime .
Table III .
3 1 311 155 69I 230 1109 IIO8 1567 1566 7 6 3*3 31* 701 700 1117 558 1571 i57o II 2 317 79 709 708 1123 56i 1579 1578 6 33i no 719 359 1129 564 1583 I582 17 16 337 336 7*7 726 1151 575 1597 x33 19 18 347 173 733 61 Ix53 1152 1601 200 *3 22 349 116 739 246 1163 58i 1607 1606 29 28 353 3* 743 74* 1171 I I7O 16O9 201 3i *5 359 179 ' 751 .
i*5 1181 Il80 l6l3 403 37 3 367 366 757 *7 1187 593 1619 1618 41 5 373 186 761 380 H93 1192 l62l 1620 43 21 379 378 769 192 1201 200 1627 271 47 46 383 3S2 773 193 1213 202 1637 4 ' 9 53 13 389 388 787 393 1217 1216 1657 552 59 58 397 99 797 199 1223 1222 1663 1662 6l 60 401 200 809 202 1229 1228 1667 833 67 33 409 204 8ll 810 1231 41 1669 556 7i 35 419 418 821 820 1237 206 1693 423 73 8 421 140 8*3 822 1249 208 i697 1696 79 13 431 215 827 413 1259 1258 1699 566 8.3 4i 433 43* 829 276 1277 638 1709 1708 89 44 439 219 839 419 1279 639 1721 430 97 96 443 221 853 213 1283 641 1723 287 IOI 4 449 3* 857 856 1289 92 1733 866 103 34 457 15* 859 26 1291 1290 1741 1740 107 53 46l 460 863 862 1297 1296 1747 291 IC9 108 463 154 877 438 i3'x 130 ' 1753 584 113 112 467 *33 881 440 1303 1302 1759 879 127 42 479 239 883 441 1307 653 1777 1776 131 13 ' 487 486 887 886 1319 659 1783 1782 137 8 491 490 9'7 151 1321 55 1787 893 139 46 499 498 911 455 1327 1326 1789 1788 149 148 503 502 919 459 1361 680 1801 900 IS1 75 509 508 9*9 464 1367 1366 1811 1810 157 78 5*1 5* 937 936 1373 686 1823 1822 163 81 5*3 261 941 940 1381 1380 1831 3'5 167 166 54i 540 947 473 1399 699 1847 1846 173 43 547 91 953 952 1409 3Z l86l i860 179 178 557 278 967 3** 1423 158 1867 933 181 180 563 281 97i 970 1427 7i3 187I 935 191 95 569 284 977 976 1429 1428 1873 1872 193 192 57i 570 983 982 1433 1432 1877 938 197 98 577 576 991 495 1439 719 1879 3r3 199 99 587 *93 997 166 1447 1446 1889 118 - Q ~ 211 30 593 59* 1009 252 1451 290 1901 38 ' 223 222 599 *99 1013 253 1453 726 1907 953 227 113 601 300 IOI9 1018 1459 162 1913 1912 229 228 607 202 1021 1020 1471 735 1931 386 ^33 232 613 51 I03I 103 I48l 740 1933 21 239 7 617 88 io33 1032 1483 247 1949 1948 241 .30 619 618 i'39 5i9 1487 i486 1951 195 C. 251 5 ' 63I 3i5 io49 524 1489 248 1973 90O 257 256 64I 3* I'5I i'5 ' 1493 373 1979 1978 263 262 643 107 1061 212 1499 214 1987 331 269 268 647 646 1063 1062 15 " 755 1993 664 271 5 653 3*6 1069 1068 1523 761 1997 998 277 69 659 658 1087 1086 i53i 153 ' 1999 999 281 28 661 220 1091 1090 1543 1542 2003 1001 283 141 673 224 io93 273 1549 1548 2011 670 293 146 677 338 i'97 1096 1553 1552 2017 2016 307 i53 683 341 1103 1102 1559 779 2027 1013 q 2 Mr. W. Slianks on the Period of the Table III .
( ) .
[ Feb. 19 , 214I 2l6l 23S1 *357 237I 2-393 253* 1119 1121 2250 1*33 2268 2272 " 73 " 75 I84 I2l8 3'5 *37 271 x 27*3 i 2903 29O9 2917 2927 2939 2953 2957 29^3 i3'4 26l6 3'37 3'4X 3'49 3'79 3io9 31x9 3121 3137 3x67 3x69 3l8l 3i87 447 3I9I 2686 32'3 42 3209 1346 .
3217 2698 3221 1353 3229 1355 3251 2712 3253 1359 3257 682 3259 2730 3271 2740 32-99 916 33'i 2752 33'7 2766 3313 2776 3 319 2788 3323 31 3329 699 3331 1400 3343 1401 3347 2818 3359 2832 336* 709 337i 1421 3373 2850 3389 408 3391 2860 34'7 1439 34i3 2886 3433 2896 3449 2902 3457 2908 3461 1458 3463 2926 3467 2938 3469 984 3491 1478 3499 1481 35 " 371 3517 2970 3527 1499 3529 1500 3533 3010 3539 3018 354i i54i I58l 33 ' ' 33 " 333 ' 1680 337 ' 34'6 357i 358i 37'i 37'9 37r9 3863 3877 3881 3889 39'7 39 " 3917 3919 3923 357 ' " 94 9'9 37'8 382 ' 77 ' 194 ' 1953 195 5 *95 653 I96I 491 131 ' 4'5 ' 4'57 4'73 4'79 4'9I 4'93 4'99 4111 4I27 4I29 4*53 4*57 4*59 4i77 439i 44'9 4423 4441 4447 445i 4457 4463 448i 4483 4493 45'7 4513 4517 45*9 4523 4547 4549 4561 4'72 1432 4326 43 36 4338 '4348 242 2181 i'93 2195 314 55i 4420 4422 2220 4446 445 ' 445 6 4462 2240 75i I5'4 1874 .
] Reciprocal of every Prime Number below 20 , COO .
Table III .
( ) .
4603 2JOI 5*47 4621 924 5153 4637 6l 5i67 4639 *319 5*7* 4643 2321 5*79 4649 7 5i89 4651 4650 5197 4657 *552 52'9 4663 222 5227 4673 4672 523* 4679 2339 5233 4691 469O 5237 47 ' 3 47'2 5261 4721 2360 5273 4723 2361 5279 4729 1182 5281 4733 1183 5297 4751 2375 5303 4759 2379 5309 4783 4782 5323 4787 2393 5333 4789 228 5347 4793 4792 53 51 4799 2399 5381 48OI 800 5387 4813 802 5393 4817 4816 5399 483* 805 54'7 486I 97 2 54i3 4871 2435 54*7 4877 1219 54*9 4889 2444 543* 4903 1634 5437 49'9 1636 544* 4919 2459 5443 493* 493 ' 5449 , 4933 2466 547* 4937 4936 5477 4943 4942 5479 4951 2475 5483 4957 4*3 55'* 4967 4966 55'3 4969 828 55'7 4973 226 55*9 4987 2493 552* 4993 1664 5527 4999 357 553* 5003 2501 5557 5009 626 5563 5011 1670 55 % 5021 5020 5573 5'23 1674 558i 5'39 25*9 559* 5Q51 * 5 ' 5623 5059 5058 5639 5'77 2538 5641 5081 1270 5647 5087 5086 565* 5'99 5098 5653 5101 1700 5657 .
5io7 2553 5659 5**3 , \gt ; 704 5669 5**9 853 5683 2573 5689 316 5*52 5693 1423 5166 57'* 57 ' ' no 57** 57* 5*78 57*7 1429 5188 5737 5736 433 574* 574 ' 372 5743 5744 2613 5749 5748 2615 5779 2889 5232 5783 5784 77 579* 965 1052 5801 1450 5272 5807 5806 2639 58*3 2906 264O 5821 5820 5296 5847 49*3 5302 5839 29*9 5308 5843 2921 2661 5849 1462 *333 585* *95 ' 2673 5857 5856 2675 5861 5860 5380 5867 2933 2693 5869 5868 5392 5879 2939 2699 5881 2940 1802 5897 5896 2706 5903 59'2 54*6 5923 296I 5418 5927 5926 2715 5939 5938 *359 5953 1984 2720 598* 5980 9'7 * 5987 2993 2724 6007 858 547 60II 6010 1369 6029 6028 2739 6037 3018 274* 6043 3'21 55 ' ' 6047 6046 55'2 6053 3026 4753 6067 3\lt ; \gt ; 33 2759 6073 6072 345 6079 1013 5526 6089 761 553 ' 609I 2030 926 6lOI 1220 2781 6ll3 6112 1392 6l2l 3060 i 2786 6I3I 6130 558o 6133 1533 4795 6143 6142 5622 615I 1025 2819 6163 79 470 6173 3086 1882 6197 3098 565 ' 9*99 3'99 4826 6203 443 5656 6211 6210 5658 6217 6216 5668 6221 6220 2841 6229 J 2076 6247 6246 6803 6457 6256 6823 6263 6262 6827 6269 6268 6829 6271 1045 6833 6477 1569 6841 6287 6286 6857 6299 94 6863 6301 6300 6869 6317 3*58 6871 6323 3161 6883 6329 3*64 6899 6337 6336 6907 6343 6342 6911 6353 6352 6947 6359 3*79 6949 6361 1590 6959 6367 6366 6961 6373 1062 6967 6379 2126 6971 6389 6388 6977 6397 78 6983 6421 2140 6991 6427 1071 6997 6449 1612 7001 6451 t 2I5 ' 7013 6469 924 7019 6473 6472 7027 6481 270 7039 649* 1298 7043 6521 815 7057 6549 1088 7069 6547 1091 7079 655* 3275 7103 6553 6552 7109 6563 3281 7141 6569 1642 7147 657* 6570 7*49 6577 2192 7*5* 6581 13*6 7*59 6599 3299 7*77 6607 2202 7*87 6619 6618 7*93 6637 474 7207 6653 3346 7211 6659 6658 7413 6661 6660 72*9 6673 6672 7229 6679 3339 7437 6689 1672 7243 6691 6690 7447 6701 6700 7253 6703 6702 7283 6709 6708 7297 67*9 3359 7307 6733 3366 73'9 6737 6736 7321 6761 1690 733* 6763 161 7333 6779 6778 7349 6781 *356 735* 6791 679 7369 6793 6792 7393 344i 1750 35'6 7018 1171 5'3 710a 356 ' 103 ' 7*348 Mr. W. Slianks on the Period of the [ Feb. 19 ; Table III .
( ) .
7411 7410 7937 7936 8543 8542 , 9io3 9102 9649 603 7417 2472 7949 7948 8563 4281 9io9 9IO8 9661 1380 7433 743 2 7951 3975 8573 4286 9127 3'42 9677 2419 7451 7450 7963 3981 8581 2860 913 3 1522 9679 1613 7457 7456 7993 2664 8597 2149 9137 9136 9689 346 7459 745 8 8009 2002 8599 1433 9I5I 1525 9697 9696 7477 3738 8011 2670 8609 1076 9157 4578 9719 4859 7481 748 8017 8oi6 862,3 8622 9161 229 972i 4860 7487 7486 8039 4019 8627 43*3 917 3 4586 9733 2433 7489 I872 8053 4026 8629 2876 9181 3060 9739 9738 7499 7498 8059 8058 8641 432 ' 9x87 4593 9743 9742 75'7 3753 8069 8068 8647 8646 9*99 4599 9749 9748 7 517 3758 8081 2020 8663 8662 9203 4601 9767 9766 7523 3761 8087 8086 8669 8668 9209 2302 9769 4884 7529 l882 8089 1348 8677 723 9221 9220 9781 9780 7537 2512 8093 4046 8681 868 9227 4613 9787 4893 7541 7540 8101 1620 8689 2172 92-39 4619 9791 4895 7547 3773 8m 8ll 8693 4346 9241 4620 9803 4901 7549 2516 81x7 2029 8699 869s 9257 9256 9811 98l0 7559 3779 8123 4061 8707 4353 9277 4638 98i7 9816 7561 1890 8147 4073 87J3 8712 9281 928 9829 9828 7573 631 8161 1020 87x9 4359 9283 *547 9833 9832 7577 7576 8167 2722 8731 8730 9293 2323 9839 4919 7583 7582 8171 8170 8737 2912 9311 4655 9851 9850 7589 1084 8i79 8178 8741 8740 9319 4659 9857 9856 7591 3795 819I 1365 8747 4373 9323 4661 9859 3286 7603 1267 82O9 4104 8753 8752 9337 3112 9871 4935 7607 7606 8219 8218 8761 876 9341 934 ' 9883 4941 7621 508 8221 2740 8779 22 9343 9342 9887 9886 7639 38i9 8231 4115 8783 8782 9349 3116 9901 12 7643 3821 8*33 8232 8803 1467 937i 937 ' 99'7 4953 7649 1912 8237 4118 8807 8806 9377 9376 9923 4961 7669 284 8243 4121 8819 8818 9391 4695 9929 1241 7673 7672 8263 8262 8821 8820 9397 81 993i 9930 7681 1920 8269 8268 8831 4415 9403 1567 9941 1988 7687 7686 8273 8272 8837 4418 94i3 47'6 9949 \#166 ; 9948 7691 769O 8287 8286 8839 4419 9419 554 9967 9966 7699 7698 8291 8290 8849 553 9421 9420 9973 554 77'3 7702 8293 2073 8861 8860 943i 4715 IOOO7 10006 77J7 J929 8297 8296 8863 8862 9433 1048 IOOO9 5''4 _ Q r 772-3 1287 8311 4*55 8867 4433 9437 47l8 IOO37 3OO 7727 7726 83j7 462 8887 8886 9439 1573 IOO39 5019 7741 860 8329 1041 8893 2223 9461 9460 I006l 10060 7753 7752 8353 8352 8923 1487 9463 3J54 IOO67 5'33 10068 7757 19 39 8363 4181 8929 144 9467 4733 IOO69 7759 3^79 8369 4i84 8933 2233 9473 9472 IOO79 5'39 7789 2596 8377 8376 8941 2980 9479 4739 I OO9 I IOO9O 7793 7792 8387 599 8951 4475 9491 9490 IOO93 2523 3366 7817 7816 8389 8388 8963 4481 9497 949 6 IOO99 7823 7822 84j9 2806 8969 4484 9511 1585 10103 IO102 7829 7828 8423 8422 8971 8970 9521 595 101 n 5'55 7841 7853 56 3926 8429 8431 8428 42I5 8999 9001 4499 1125 9533 9539 2383 9538 10133 10139 2533 10138 7867 3933 8443 4221 9OO7 3002 9547 4773 10141 10140 7873 7872 8447 8446 9011 9010 955i 955 10151 5'75 7877 7879 7883 3938 3939 3941 8461 8467 85OI 2820 4233 8500 9OI3 9029 9041 2253 9028 1130 9587 960I 9613 4793 4800 267 10159 10163 10169 5'79 5081 5084 10176 10180 7901 7900 8513 8512 9'43 4521 96i9 3206 9622 9628 10177 10181 7907 7919 3953 3959 8521 8527 710 2842 9'49 9'59 4524 9058 9623 9629 10193 10192 10210 7927 7926 8537 8536 9067 4533 9631 4815 10211 10222 7933 3966 8539 2846 9091 10 9643 4821 10223 1874 .
] Reciprocal of every Prime Number below 20,000 ; 207 Table III .
( ) .
I0243 !
569 10847 I0846 " 447 11446 12049 !
6024 12613 63c 6 10247 IO246 10853 5426 " 467 5733 12071 I 355 12619 4206 10253 2563 10859 IO858 11471 5735 12073 12072 12637 3i59 10259 10258 IO86I 10860 11483 574i 12097 4032 12641 2i6o 10267 5133 10867 l8ll II489 2872 12101 I2J00 12647 12646 10271 79 IO883 5441 " 491 766 12107 6053 12653 6326 10273 10272 10889 2722 " 497 11496 12109 4036 12659 12658 10289 5r44 IO89I 1210 " 5'3 11502 12113 121 12 12671 1S1 10301 IO3OO IO9O3 IO902 11519 5759 12119 6059 12689 793 10303 3434 IO9O9 1212 11527 3842 I2I43 I2I42 12697 12696 10313 1031 2 10937 10936 " 549 11548 12149 I2148 I2703 4234 10321 2580 10939 10938 11551 1925 I2I57 2026 12713 12712 10331 2066 10949 IO948 " 579 11578 12161 6080 12721 2120 10333 5166 Io957 2739 11587 I931 12163 608I l2739 4246 ic.337 10336 10973 2743 " 593 11592 l2I97 3049 l2743 12742 l0343 10342 10979 IO978 " 597 579s 12203 6lOl I2757 2126 I03 5 7 5178 IO987 5493 I l6l7 I l6l6 12211 4'7 ' 12763 709 IO369 2592 10993 IC992 Il62I Il620 12227 6113 12781 12780 I039I 5195 11003 5501 H633 I 1632 12239 6119 12791 6395 10399 1733 I 1027 5513 11657 I 1 656 12241 6120 I2799 2133 IO427 52I3 11047 I IO46 11677 5838 I22SI 12250 12809 6404 IO429 948 11057 IIO56 Il68l 5840 12253 3063 12821 12820 10433 104^2 11059 IIO58 II689 487 12263 12262 12823 12822 1 '45 3 5226 I IO69 II068 H699 11698 12269 12268 12829 4276 10457 IO456 IIO7I 615 I 1701 I I 700 12277 3069 12841 6420 10459 10458 11083 1847 11717 2929 12281 6140 " 853 459 IO463 10462 II087 482 11719 5859 12289 384 12889 3222 io477 1746 11093 2773 11731 11730 12301 2460 12893 3223 10487 10486 IIII3 3704 " 743 " 742 12323 6161 12899 12898 10499 10498 IIII7 2779 " 777 11776 12329 3082 12907 6453 10501 3500 IIH9 5559 " 779 3926 i2343 4H4 12911 *H55 10513 10512 HI31 11130 11783 11782 12347 6173 12917 6458 10529 5264 III49 11148 11789 11788 i2373 6186 12919 2153 1 '5 31 Io53o 11159 5579 11801 295 ' 12377 123 76 12923 6461 io5 59 5279 11161 310 11807 11806 12379 l2378 12941 I294O 10567 1 10566 11171 11170 11813 59o6 12391 6195 " 953 12952 10589 10588 XII73 5586 11821 11820 12401 1240 12959 6479 10597 5298 11177 11176 11827 5913 12409 6204 12967 4322 10601 1060 11197 2799 11831 169 12413 6206 12973 2l62 10607 10606 11213 2803 " 833 11832 12421 12420 12979 12978 10613 758 11239 56i9 11839 5919 12433 4144 12983 12982 10627 5 313 U243 5621 11863 11862 12437 6218 13001 l625 10631 5 315 1 1251 2250 11867 5933 12451 l245o 13''3 6501 10639 5319 11257 II256 11887 11886 12457 " 456 13007 I 3O06 1 0651 IO65O 11261 2252 " 897 11896 12473 12472 13009 2l68 10657 IO656 11273 II272 11903 11902 12479 6239 13033 4344 IO663 10662 11279 5639 11909 11908 12487 12486 13037 6518 10667 5333 11287 I 1286 11923 5961 12491 12490 13043 6521 IO687 10686 11299 I I298 11927 I I926 12497 12496 13049 3262 13062 IO69I 10690 11311 377 " 933 .
5966 12503 12502 13063 IO7O9 10708 11317 943 " 939 U938 12511 2085 13093 2182 13098 IO7I I 595 11321 1132 " 941 I 1940 12517 149 13099 IO723 5361 11329 1888 " 953 H952 12527 12526 13103 13x02 13108 6560 13126 IO729 ' 596 11351 5675 " 959 5979 12539 12538 1 3io9 10733 2683 II353 " 352 11969 352 12541 4180 13x21 1073 9 10738 11369 812 11971 11970 12547 6273 13127 1 '7 5 3 10771 3584 2154 11383 " 393 11382 11392 11981 1x987 11980 5993 12553 12569 12552 6284 I3I47 13151 939 1315 10781 10789 10799 10831 i'^37 10780 107S8 5399 5415 63 11399 11411 11423 " 437 11443 5699 2282 11422 2859 1907 12007 12011 12037 12041 12043 4002 12010 3009 6020 2007 12577 12 583 12589 12601 12611 12576 12582 12588 6300 12610 23259 13163 I3I7I 23177 13183 2193 6581 4390 13176 4394 Mr. W. Shanks on the Period of the [ Feb. 19 , Table III .
( ) .
13187 6593 13807 13806 14461 4820 15061 5020 I5629 15628 1*12.17 I32l6 13829 13828 14479 7239 15073 15072 15641 391 i32I9 4406 13831 2305 14489 7244 15077 7538 15643 7821 13229 13228 13841 6920 14503 14502 15083 7541 15647 15646 13241 1655 13859 13858 14519 7259 15091 3018 15649 489 13249 288 13873 13872 14533 519 15101 604 15661 5220 13259 1894 13877 3469 14537 14536 *5io7 7553 I5667 7833 13267 737 13879 6939 14543 14542 15121 7560 15671 1567 13291 13290 13883 6941 14549 14548 15131 3026 15679 2613 13297 13296 13901 I39 ' ' 14551 485 11137 15136 15683 7841 133'9 4436 13903 13902 14557 2426 I5I39 15138 15727 15726 13 313 13312 13907 409 14561 7280 x5*49 15148 15731 15730 I3327 4442 i39J3 I3912 14563 809 15161 3790 15733 2622 13331 13330 13921 696 14591 7295 1517 3 7586 15737 15736 13337 13336 13931 13930 14593 14592 15187 7593 15739 15738 13339 13338 13933 6966 14621 14620 15193 15192 15749 15748 13367 13366 13963 6981 14627 7313 15199 7599 1576i 394 13381 1338 ' 13967 13966 14629 14628 15217 152,16 15767 15766 13 3 97 6698 13997 6998 14633 14632 15227 7613 15773 7886 13 3 99 957 13999 2333 14639 7319 15233 15232 15787 7893 13411 1341 ' I4OO9 3502 14653 3663 15241 3810 15791 7895 13417 4472 I4OI I 14010 14657 14656 15259 15258 15797 3949 13421 13420 14029 14028 14669 14668 15263 15262 15803 79'i 13441 6720 14033 14032 14683 2447 15269 1388 15809 3952 13451 1345 ' 14051 2810 14699 14698 15271 7635 15817 5272 13457 13456 14057 14056 14713 14712 15277 3819 15823 15822 13463 13462 I4O7 I 7035* 14717 7358 15287 15286 15859 15858 13469 13468 14081 1760 14723 7361 15289 I274 15877 567 13477 6738 14083 7041 14731 1473 ' 15299 15298 15881 7940 13487 13486 14087 14086 14737 14736 15307 7653 15887 15886 J3499 13498 14107 2351 14741 14740 15313 5104 15889 3972 13 513 4504 14H3 14147 .
14747 7373 15319 7659 15901 15900 13523 6761 14149 524 14753 14752 15329 7664 15907 7953 13537 13536 14153 14152 14759 7379 15331 5110 15913 15912 13553 1936 14159 7079 14767 14766 15349 15348 15919 7959 13567 4522 14173 3543 14771 21x0 15359 7679 15923 7961 13577 13576 14177 14176 14779 14778 15361 256 15937 5312 I3591 1359 14197 91 14783 14782 15373 1281 15959 7979 13597 3399 14207 14206 14797 3699 15377 15376 i597i 1597 ' 13613 6806 14221 2844 14813 7406 15383 15382 15973 121 13619 1238 14243 7121 14821 4940 15391 7695 i599i 7995 13627 6813 14249 7124 14827 2471 15401 275 I 600 I 2000 136 3 3 4544 14251 14250 14831 1483 15413 7706 16007 16006 13649 853 14281 1190 14843 7421 15427 77l3 16033 16032 13669 13668 14293 1191 14851 99 ' 15439 7719 16057 1784 13679 6839 14303 14302 14867 7433 15443 7721 l6o6l 3212 13681 3420 14321 3580 14869 4956 15451 5150 I6063 5354 13687 4562 14323 1023 14879 7439 15461 15460 I6067 8033 1369 !
13690 14327 14326 14887 14886 15467 7733 I6069 5356 13693 326 14341 14340 14891 14890 15473 15472 16073 16072 13697 13696 14347 7173 14897 14896 15493 7746 IOO87 5362 137'9 13708 14369 449 14923 7461 15497 1192 I609I 16090 13711 6855 14387 7193 14929 1866 155H 7755 16097 16090 13721 6860 14389 4796 14939 14938 15527 15526 16103 16102 13723 6861 14401 3600 14947 7473 15541 740 l6lll 1611 r _ \#163 ; 13729 3432 I44'7 686 14951 1495 15551 7755 l6l27 l6l20 13751 6875 I44H 2882 14957 7478 11559 2593 l6l39 1613d 13757 362 I44I9 4806 14969 7484 15569 7784 l6l4I 3228 13759 6879 *4423 14422 14983 4994 15581 15580 l6l83 l6l82 13763 6881 *443 * 555 15013 3753 15583 15582 l6l87 8093 13781 13780 14437 218 15017 15016 *5601 39 ' l6l89 852 13789 13788 14447 14446 15031 7515 15607 I5606 16193 l6l92 r , c. 13799 6899 14449 3612 15053 3763 15619 I56l8 16217 162IO 1874 .
] Reciprocal of every Prime Number below 20^000 .
209 Table III .
{ continued ) .
16223 16222 16889 8444 16229 16228 169OI 3380 16231 8115 169O3 5634 16249 1354 I692I 423 162*53 8126 16927 5642 16267 8133 16931 16930 16273 16272 16937 16936 16301 3260 16943 16942 16319 8159 16963 8481 16333 4083 16979 16978 16339 16338 1698I 16980 16349 16348 16987 8493 16361 1636 16993 16992 16363 8181 17011 17010 16 369 264 17021 3404 16381 5460 17027 8513 16411 16410 17029 17028 16417 16416 17033 17032 16421 16420 17041 2840 16427 8213 17047 5682 16433 16432 17053 1421 16447 16446 17077 2846 16451 16450 17093 4273 16453 2742 17099 17098 16477 4n9 17107 8553 16481 2060 17117 4279 16487 16486 17123 8561 16493 4*23 17137 5712 16519 2753 17159 8579 16529 8264 17167 17166 16547 8273 17183 17182 165 5 3 16552 17189 17188 16561 8280 17191 8595 16567 16566 17203 2867 16573 8286 17207 17206 16603 8301 17209 4302 16607 16606 I723I 8615 16619 16618 17239 8619 16631 8315 17257 17256 16633 5544 I729I 17290 16649 8324 17293 1441 16651 3330 17299 1922 16657 I6656 17317 1443 16661 16660 x7321 8660 16673 I6672 17327 17326 16691 I669O 17333 8666 16693 2782 I734I 5780 16699 I 6698 i735i 8675 16703 I67O2 17359 2893 16729 697 17377 17376 16741 16740 17 3^ 3 17382 16747 8373 17387 8693 16759 931 17389 17388 16763 29 17393 17392 16787 8393 17401 435 ' 16811 *362 17417 17416 16823 16822 17419 I74l8 16829 16828 i743i 8715 16831 8415 17443 8721 16843 401 17449 4362 16871 1205 17467 8733 16879 2813 17471 8735 j 16883 8441 17477 8738 8741 18097 6032 18719 9359 2186 18119 9'59 18731 3746 17490 18121 2265 18743 I8742 17496 18127 18126 18749 I8748 5836 18131 490 18757 3i26 8759 18133 9066 18773 9386 5846 18143 18142 18787 9393 2925 18149 1396 18793 18792 2928 18169 9084 18797 127 4393 18181 6060 18803 9401 17578 18191 9'95 18839 94*9 17580 18199 9099 18859 18858 4399 18211 18210 18869 18868 2-933 18217 18216 18899 18898 8804 18223 6074 189 ji 9455 *958 18229 18228 18913 18912 8813 18233 424 18917 4729 17656 18251 18250 18919 9459 5886 18253 9126 18947 9473 17668 18257 2608 18959 9479 1105 18269 18268 18973 *53 8841 18287 18286 18979 18978 8853 18289 9144 19001 2375 17712 18301 18300 19009 4752 1108 18307 3Q51 19013 4753 17736 18311 9155 19031 95*5 8873 18313 18312 i9'37 95*8 17748 18 32.9 4582 19051 6350 8880 18341 18340 19069 6356 17782 18353 18352 i9'73 19072 17788 18367 6122 19079 9539 8895 18371 3674 19081 795 I7806 18379 18378 19087 6362 89*3 18397 9198 19121 9560 9i 18401 4600 i9*39 19*38 8919 18413 4603 19141 19140 714 18427 3071 19*57 4789 I7862 18433 6144 19*63 9581 2235 18439 9219 19181 19180 I789O 18443 9221 19*83 6394 17902 18451 6150 19207 19206 17908 18457 18456 I92II 3842 2985 18461 18460 192*3 9606 8960 18481 132 ' 19219 I92l8 8961 18493 4623 19231 96i5 8964 18503 18502 19237 4809 17938 18517 3086 19249 3208 8978 18521 9260 19259 19258 8979 18523 9261 19267 9633 17970 *2539 18538 i9273 19272 856 18541 3708 19289 4822 17980 18553 6184 19301 3860 8993 18583 18582 19309 19308 5996 18587 9293 193*9 9659 9006 18593 18592 19333 4833 220 l86l7 i432 19373 4843 29I 18637 93l8 19379 19378 2578 l866l 18660 *9381 1292 I 128 I867I I867 19387 323* 18058 18679 3TI3 1939* 1385 18060 1869I 18690 19403 9701 4519 I87OI 3740 19417 19416 9'44 18713 1 18712 I942I 19420 I7483 *74s9 I75'9 *75*9 I7569 I7623 I788l *7929 I798l l8'43 l8o6l 210 Mr. H. F. Blaiiford on the [ Feb. 26 , Table III .
( continued ) .
19423 3237 i95'i 780 19681 9840 19777 6952 19913 19912 19427 9713 19507 9753 19687 19686 19793 19792 19919 9959 19429 1942 8 195 31 651 ' 19697 19696 19801 9900 19927 19926 * 19+33 19432 19 541 19540 19699 19698 19813 4953 19937 2848 I9+41 1620 19543 19542 19709 19708 19819 19818 19949 19948 19447 19446 19559 9779 19717 9858 19841 1984 19961 9980 19457 19456 19571 19570 19727 19726 19843 33'7 19963 3327 19463 19462 19577 19576 19739 19738 19853 9926 19973 9986 19469 19468 19583 195 82 19751 9S75 19861 6620 19979 19978 19471 9735 19597 4899 19753 19752 19867 6622 19991 9995 19477 3246 I9603 3267 19759 9879 19889 9944 19993 19992 19483 19489 9741 406 I9609 I966I 9804 19660 19763 9881 19891 6630 19997 9998 February 26 , 1874 .
JOSEPH DALTON HOOKER , C.B. , President , in the Chair .
The following Papers were read :\#151 ; I. " The Winds of Northern India , in relation to the Temperature and Vapour-constituent of the Atmosphere/ ' By Henry P. Blanford , F.G.S. , Meteorological Reporter to the Government of Bengal .
Communicated by Major-General Strachey , R.E. Received May 25 , 1873 .
( Abstract .
) The object of this paper is to describe the normal wind-currents of Northern India , and their annual variation , and to trace out their origin and causes , so far as these can be discovered hi the local physical changes of the atmosphere .
After referring to the data on which his conclusions are based , the author goes on to describe the winds of the principal geographical regions of North India in detail .
Part I. Description of Winds .
1 .
The Punjab.\#151 ; As a rule currents from the westward predominate on an average throughout the year ; and this is also found to be the case in other parts of North India .
In the most northern part of the Punjab , westerly winds prevail in the cold and hot dry months , easterly in the rainy months .
In the central districts northerly winds preponderate over southerly , having in the cold months a westerly tendency , but drawing round to the north-east as the hot weather comes on , while as the rainy season sets in the winds tend to east and south-east , returning to west after the rain ceases in September .
In the southern part of the Punjab ( and this is also the case in Sindh ) easterly winds never prevail ,

