308 The Astronomer Royal on a supposed [ April 25 , Combination , arising from the coexistence of different things , objectively or subjectively , in the same aggregate ; ' Consistency , arising from the coexistence of different events affirmed by different assertions .
Succession generates : Logical inference , Sequence in Space , in Time , and in Action .
^ # # Mixed cases arise from combining assertions of different kinds .
Composition , combination , and consistency only are considered in the present paper .
Composition constitutes the primary , and consistency the secondary propositions of Boole .
Combination has not been distinctly re-cognized in logical works , but is constantly implied in Boole 's and De Morgan 's treatments of Composition , whereby its real character has been overlooked .
Logical Inference is partially considered in the treatment of Composition , Combination , and Consistency .
Sequence in Space , Time , and Action is not treated at all .
Thomson 's , De Morgan 's , and Boole 's notations are carefully interpreted .
Particular attention is paid to Boole 's results for Consistency , and the nature of the error which he committed in accommodating those results to Composition , together with the value of his accommodated results , is exactly determined .
The ascertainment of these errors by a fundamental reconsideration of the bases of the relations of Composition and Consistency , and a purely logical method of obtaining precise results , forms the distinctive character , as it was the special object , of the present investigation .
II .
" On a supposed Periodicity in the elements of Terrestrial Magnetism , with a period of 26- } days.'* By George Biddell Airy , Astronomer Royal .
Received March 26 , 1872 .
In a paper published in the ' Proceedings of the Imperial Academy of Sciences of Vienna , ' vol. lxiv .
, Dr. Karl Hornstein has exhibited the results of a series of observations which appeared to show that the earths magnetism undergoes a periodical change in successive periods of 26 } days , which might with great plausibility be referred to the rotation of the sun .
" It appeared to me that the deductions from the magnetic observations made at the Royal Observatory of Greenwich , and which are printed annually in the * Greenwich Observations , ' or in the detached copies of ' Results of Magnetical and Meteorological Observations made at .
the Royal Observatory of Greenwich , * would afford good materials for testing the accuracy of this law , as applicable to a series of years .
The mew results of the measured hourly ordinates of the terrestrial magnetic ele* ments are given for every day , and it is certain that there has been no change of adjustments of the declination and horizontal-force instruments in the course of each year .
Por the horizontal-force instrument the te\#174 ; 1872 .
] Periodicity in Terrestrial Magnetism .
309 perature of the room has been maintained in a generally equable state , and in later years it has been remarkably uniform .
It is easy to see that an error of a single day , or of a large fraction of a day , in the beginning of each period , is of no importance , provided that the errors are not permitted to accumulate .
It was allowable , therefore , to take successive periods of 26 , 26 , 27 , 26 , 26 , 2/ , \amp ; c. days ; and in instances when a single day was omitted , or even two days , no sensible error would be introduced by interpolating between the numbers for the days immediately preceding and following the omitted days .
The years selected for this examination were 1850 , 1851 , 1852 , 1868 , 1869 , 1870 ; and the beginning of the first period in each year after the first was thus found :\#151 ; Fourteen periods of 26-^- days each amount to 368-3 days .
For convenience after completion of the annual winter adjustments , the first period in 1850 was made to commence on January 17 ; therefore the first period in 1851 was commenced on January 21 , and that in 1852 on January 25 .
Similarly , the first periods in 1868 , 1869 , 1870 commenced on January 1 , 4 , and 8 respectively ; and the beginnings in the three later years are not unconnected with those in the three earlier years : for , from 1852 , January 25 , to 1868 , January 1 , are 5820 days , and 221 periods of 26^ days each are 5819f- days ; but as the years are widely separated , and a small error of period would produce a large discordance , it has appeared best to exhibit the results of the two three-years5 groups separately .
Some periods , in which there were unusually large interruptions , or which were partly occupied with experiments , were omitted entirely .
Ihe following is a complete list of periods omitted :\#151 ; In 1850 , that beginning with December 24 for horizontal force ; in 1851 , that beginning with March 14 or western declination , and those beginning with March 14 , June 28 , July 24 , for horizontal force ; in 1852 , those beginning with February 20 , May 9 , December 6 , for both elements ; in 1868 , those beginning with February 2.3 for declination , and January 1 , January 27 , February 23 , and December 8 for horizontal force ; in 1869 , those beginning with October 21 and December 12 for both elements ; and in 1870 , those beginning with ?
June 15 and December 16 for declination , and that beginning with December 16 for horizontal force .
Interpolations of three days occur only in the following instances:\#151 ; 1850 , ( dec. ) Feb. 4-6 , ( h. f. ) Feb. 9\#151 ; 11 , July 23-25 ; 1851 , ( dec. ) Feb. 18-20 , Oct. 20-22 , ( li .
f. ) June 9-11 ; 1852 , ( dec. ) Feb. 7-9 ; 1868 , ( dec. ) Feb. 15-17 , ( h. f. ) none ; 1869 , ( dec. ) June 6-8 , ( h. f. ) June 6-8 ; 1870 , ( dec. ) Sept. 24-26 , ( h. f. ) Sept. 24-26 .
the mean values of each element for each progressive day in every period of the several years , uncorrected for the proportional part of secular change through the 26 days , and omitting the imperfect 2/ th day , are as follows :\#151 ; von .
xx .
z 310 The Astronomer Royal on a supposed [ Apr. 25 , CO \lt ; M 23-17 18-63 17*20 13*34 05 CO 52*51 CO to CM 05 to to co CO CO 3 CM CM 1 05 00 Kft ( M I 23-471 18*53 16*97 12*95 CM CO 52*65 !
CO CO CM S to B CO 3 00 oo to CM \#187 ; o 1 00 .
1 oo - a $ \lt ; M S 'S3 18*49 06-91 I 13*05 s 52*33 OO T* CM 05 CO to CM tH CO 3 00 CO Tfl CM CO 00 91 co -|| CO 23-24 18*36 CO CM b^ 13*11 05 to 00 CM to to 00 CM to tH to CM to CO CO 05 CM to CM CM oo oo ; -i CM cm 23-32 18*59 17*01 13*05 to 4* 52*91 s CM CO to to CO to CO 00 05 CM CO 05 CM o 05 s 23-21 18*64 05 CO oo 2 B 53*09 CM CM 3 to *4 CO CO \#169 ; CO co CM o S jj cm 2 -^00 18*45 r-H 12*67 00 00 05 CM to CM CM CM CM to to CO 00 05 CM b CM 05 2 05s 1 #g i 23-03 18*11 GO b- 12*66 05 CO 4* 52*73 \#163 ; 1 CO CM to CO to CO o CO CO 00 CM to / CM 05 oo tO 18*17 OO CO b^ 12*77 3 to CM co to 05* CO CO CO CO CM CO to to T* CO CO 00 05 CM 2 CO CM CM 05 ; b- 2 - , CM CM 18*38 05 ip b^ 12-75 CO to 53*18 00 CO 00 a CM CM s to 2 Tjl CO 00 CM 3 CM 00 " CO !
i 05 CO 05 CO OO CO CO oo #g s\gt ; CM CM tO 2^-06 18*35 16*99 t\#169 ; CM 00 Th 53*29 o 9*4 WO T* CM QO to 00 oo CO O CO b CM CO tH 05 rd 1 3 8 'S3 \amp ; oo 00 CM b- 12*99 CM CO T* 00 CO to m CM to GO g CO to CM 00 CO to 05 CO 8 CM tH 00 CM o eo 05 \#166 ; \lt ; c8 \lt ; D 3 1 22-83 18*79 s b- 12*84 oo T* 53*22 s CM CO 00 to CO to CO 3 CM O CO to to 05 ; \#163 ; no 2 oo g 2 2 'S3 19*22 16*92 12*50 tH 53*36 2 s* GO a \#169 ; GO 00 05 to 00 oo CO 05 CM o CO 3 05 g *0Q 00 Q 2 5 oo 23-56 tO CM 2 16*82 05 tO CM g CM OO to O CM to CO to \#169 ; r* op T* CM 3 CM CM 1 05 \amp ; 1 rH .3 cm \lt ; M 05 CO , -\#187 ; cb cm 00 2 CO 00 \#171 ; b 12*47 CM to 3 oo to \#169 ; H b\#163 ; g CM to CM 00 CO to tH 8 OO CM s CM 3 05 O .J 1 23-64 18*32 17*30 B CM S 53*42 1 i g CM 00 CM to CO 00 CO to CO CM B CM CO j 05 05 o *1 \#169 ; \#169 ; r*\ co **CM cm 18*32 17*49 13*17 oo T* 53*54 \#169 ; o g CM 05 CM 8 to I CM CM CM to 05 CM 8 ; 05 3 OO 23-00 17*90 17*36 CM 2 .3 T# 53*62 3 o .N o w CO 05 CM to to to s CO 00 to CM 3 CM 8 05 b\#187 ; H ^00 CM 3 !
17*66 13*42 co 05 to 1 05 to CM S to to CO to CO CM 3 CM o 05 CO 23-13 18*03 17*70 13*09 CO 05 TH CM OO to GO CM Tit to 05 CO to CM \#169 ; CM to 00 00 \#166 ; 'S3 cm 05 b. 3 bj 12*90 00 00 53*13 CM CO CM 3 to 00 t* CO 8 CM 3 CM 00 00 II 00 !
| t* S3 'S3 OO 00 CO 05 b- CM s o to CO to oo to 05 CO CM 00 CO to to CM CO b- CO CO b- CM 3 00 ^ CO ?
'S3 18*26 CM OO CO 00 CM CO to CO 00 to CM 3 to CM CO CO 05 05 CM r#l 00 CM 00 00 CM g 'S3 18*25 17*88 13*16 CO to 00 CM oo to 00 oo CM B to B CO T* 00 CM CM CO CO \#187 ; o 00 - S 'S3 tO 05 b- CO 05 b t\#169 ; CO CO CO to to 3 OO to \#169 ; CO CM OO to 00 CO CO oo CM s s | CM CO Year .
1 1851 .
1852 .
1868 .
1869 .
\#163 ; oo 1850 .
1851 .
1852 .
1868 .
$ 00 8 , 3 1872 .
] T3 II 5 -S P-l 2 g. O .
05 ^ nd JS ' \amp ; C o P .
rH ^ CO r'p r\#151 ; 4 \amp ; ' 6 o cd 0 P I * \#169 ; ' oo te Periodicity in Terrestrial Magnetism .
\lt ; D .s S3 C3 " J 1 Is S 3 X u i\#151 ; ( \lt ; D \#171 ; .
^ eS S3 Cj ?
H .8 1 1-3 o bf ) \#163 ; \#187 ; ro 02 ~ S is cd J s 1 8-+ C/ 2 rH-\lt ; \#171 ; .
' 5-i \lt ; D 02 h_\gt ; c3 s * gibs H " E \lt ; D 0^ O 7/ 3 Cd r\#151 ; t Js c \#171 ; S Z-z *S o " 2 tn 8 CD q b ^ g 8 s E \#171 ; s SJs e ~ 8 g .J \lt ; s \lt ; 2 r\#171 ; s \#171 ; 15 ^ * 3 l g ?
D CM 10*29 4-13 83 72 UU CM 10-25 4-00 GO VO fc- b- \lt ; M 10-06 3-86 CO OS ( X ) oo CO CM 10-15 4-03 VO rH CO CM CM OO CM rH O -H.O CO GO t- 00 S t- \lt ; M os cb rH CO CO 00 s \#187 ; \gt ; .
O OS h^o cb 00 CO VO GO 2 3 g o GO O GO t- " os cb \#163 ; g os VO CO OS GO 02 0Q 02 GO CM t- OS " OS 05 1 02 .s 8 | p .S 9-96 3-88 .s 8 ^ - t- \lt ; M O Os 'g 1 S 1 TO S .
\#171 ; +H 02 be S U rfC rH 00 O " OS ^ rH nd S CO O OS O 2 OS O os o " OS P TO S OS \lt ; M OS O c3 \lt ; U \#171 ; w 3 rH CO OS OS " 6s cb .g 02 bfi S Vt \lt ; s OS CO 00 OS \amp ; nd 02 'm XJ1 02 fc I 2 Pi 2 TO ert 02 rS t- CM O GO cb CM rH OS O 2 .g \lt ; b iO ( M rH t\#151 ; , o cb 02 _g ( M CO O oo H Sq CM gD .J CO cm GO OO " 6s oo 0 CO J 1 CO O OS O o Ir- lO os tp-"6s cb CO GO OS Oa g '\#166 ; s 9-71 4-03 02 S s L\#151 ; VO t- O- GO 1 p g OS CO \#187 ; p OS " 6s cb p 3 o .2 o w VO CO OS GO t- 02 18 02 O GO CM " 6s 4h VO rH b- 00 \lt ; CO rH OS t- oo " 6s cb t- rH t- t- \#187 ; \lt ; 0 00 rH iO b- " OS ( b 00 O OO GO UO IQ OO OS " 6s \lt ; b VO GO t- b* CO GO CM OO t'\#171 ; " OS CO \lt ; M CO t- t\#151 ; O lO t- os " 6s cb rH CO o GO rH CO o GO rH " OS rH / ^Ajp OS CM rH / ^AP .
H\#187 ; 2hP\gt ; xZZT i *s 1 P3 W \lt ; A \#171 ; oi o 2S2S 1850- 1852 .
1868- 1870 .
If J O ' Ph iQ .rH W ^ ri O O 5 -M *rH \amp ; C a-\gt ; H-3 ( C PU #JS IS o 3 td S g a Cd .rr 3 sff'g S l 3 2 s aa s .o5 .
ST .g O Pd W cu 00 is ^ 8 .9 g b cd i = i 11 QJ r*^H cd .JP o rP \#163 ; p 2 m \#166 ; 3 ^ \#163 ; *SS r* ts -g 1 r3 S CD fl ts a \amp ; | S r-H ( V ) a\#163 ; CQ 4J Cd C/ 2 O g O s Ctt^ c ?
Td i-hIco \#163 ; .
d .
pH .
rH T3 ^ \#171 ; P pd cr* cd 02 P l-S.S s a ^ ^ .
2 \#171 ; S B 2 1 o \amp ; ra J 2 2^20 *-4jC0 \#166 ; 55 -S n - r^ 2 *"2 cd *5 O ^ P-H cd 00 o .a .\#151 ; .
P PS p o .2 .
rH rrH 5h 2 3 02 _ , -1 s o g s s \amp ; fl .\#177 ; 5 o cd -^2 cd tn .
rH m QJ .
Ph * , rH \gt ; , 02 CQ .
.S .3 g'.S II S1 !
$ " \#166 ; s 3 s S I g s \#171 ; Jh CL O ^ P F\gt ; '\#187 ; r"d O l ?
Sa 3\#171 ; \#171 ; 2 312 On a supposed Periodicity in Terrestrial Magnetism .
[ Apr. 25 , .9 8 03 .tl I -350 .1 .
S ' \#166 ; ?
S .g'-fi1 fl *\#187 ; dj H O .-O j3 ?
-\lt ; g3 \#187 ; i\#151 ; \lt ; cd ^ ^ Ph g 2 52 g S3 P-t 'qq .
a\gt ; : \#163 ; * \#163 ; QQ ^ \lt ; D gS m 4m o 43 S3 S3 13 " 3 \#171 ; _* QQ 1-8 o \lt ; d SudS *T3 C QL ) .
iH S m a\gt ; a-\#187 ; Xtl 45 *s w !
\#171 ; 6* .3 % 3 I 1 \lt ; 2 ^Ifli ft ' -I- g\#171 ; T* g .9 2 * \#174 ; I o-i| s s ?
s \#163 ; i | * a Is 2 s ' *rs ^ b\amp ; - ^ \#171 ; .2 " S .s QJ rO g \lt ; 0 .4-5 \lt ; / ] \lt ; 0 \#163 ; n\gt ; rt \#171 ; rQ t3 5 J , B u 'S 3 -f ^ S 8 ) ?
g \lt ; B C U-gf !
I S It 1 .
o 2 ^ , r\gt ; S No -4-5 ) _Q \#187 ; H -4- ) 5J .S- b ~ 2 I s. ; \#174 ; " 3 S *2 S -S H Pu qq P h3 NJ ^ eg \lt ; 0 3 cb -p cS 2 p p S a , gi B " \#171 ; - S S \#171 ; S 8 8 Q QO II11 | ; \#174 ; | 11II .sill OQ ^ S \lt ; 0 P t\gt ; a fee o c3 rj | \#171 ; ) " I b| 1-11 !
i s* \#174 ; o .* \#163 ; Jg '43 *\gt ; H N-5 O , JZj \lt ; n 83 SP .
^ *3 S b -3 rP O -4\#151 ; 5 -4-5 -4-5 ?
o ( M 9 " 3 12*19 12*73 13*07 i 11*58 12*53 9 1 2 ] | 1 s 50 \lt ; p 50 CO 05 50 04 04 00 oo CO Tt\lt ; \#169 ; 05 CS -i fH oo 04 04 2 \#169 ; 2 1 S3 50 04 50 CO 00 00 o 04 04 50 i 00 Si -2 O oo rH rH 04 JO 04 50 00 05 tH o OO cp \#169 ; 50 04 Sq *9 rH cb 04 rH 04 \#169 ; CO ?
3 m JO 00 04 s So 04 cp 04 ^pH r3 04 O rH JO 04 a 50 50 s o 00 rp \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; 04 o 00 04 05 04 JO 04 CO b- M O 50 00 2 3 \#169 ; 04 04 iH oo 00 o iH 50 23 ?
s 00 -x\gt ; \#166 ; H CO 50 04 00 04 50 04 \#169 ; *P rH ^ 1 OO O HJ \#169 ; CO 00 S a 04 I 04 CO CO 05 00 I oo \#169 ; '2 o HH ^ 1 04 O 2 00 04 O 04 tO ? !
$ \#169 ; 04 50 50 '2 iH S 04 2 cb Hj 04 a 04 JO CO r\#151 ; 4 00 04 2 S3 : rH -2 r4 JO OO rH Jh Ttt - CO ?
o 50 50 00 o \#169 ; \#169 ; 00 cp '2 rH 00 04 o HJ 00 04 50 CO T ?
o CO \#169 ; HH 50 04 ^4 '2 00 HJ cb .H 2 3 Hj 05 CO 04 05 04 ] op po S3 \#169 ; * CO 5p '2 04 OO 2 00 3 JO 3 04 f 04 05 9 9 CO 00 \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; CO '3 rH 00 04 50 2 is pH ?
CO 04 2 00 T ?
OO o \#169 ; pH '3 iH 04 00 cb Hj 05 o S3 s 04 'Op 04 00 1 50 04 CO $ \#169 ; 50 rH '2 04 04 - 3 2 2 9 04 op io tr- \lt ; 35 5p 50 \lt ; 35 s S \#169 ; '2 04 tb * 00 2 2 50 3 S3 iH 50 CO S CO \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; \#169 ; -O CO 04 04 2 \#169 ; 2 S a 05 JO 00 5p 00 5p So 00 \#169 ; -2 o 00 04 04 04 JO 05 ?
50 \#171 ; o 50 50 HP \#169 ; \#169 ; 00 00 '3 00 rH 2 00 Hj JO 3 50 H4 O CO 00 CO \#169 ; oo oo \#169 ; op '3 rH 04 S- \#163 ; s 04 2 04 1 53 04 50 ?
rrH 00 5p CO 04 50 \#169 ; -2 rH 2 !
04 2 50 2 \lt ; o a 50 \#171 ; o .50 i 05 ' 00 50 5Q 04 \#169 ; cp \gt ; .H4 o iH rH 50 C4 04 H 00 \gt ; o 50 05 50 qp \lt ; oo CO \#169 ; CO \#169 ; a " 3 o iH 04 \#169 ; rH Hj 04 S CO op 50 04 O Oi CO \#169 ; \#169 ; 50 \lt ; 35 rH -1 rH 04 2 rH iH \#169 ; 04 range of years .
1850 .
| 1851 .
1852 .
1850- 1852 .
00 CO 00 1869 .
1870 .
1868- 1870 .
S ' ?
S \#171 ; II OG TJ 0 h rC 03 * * -o 0 * 3 45 .
' ?
\#187 ; .2 .\amp ; * I -.a 1 ?
o s \#171 ; u \#174 ; JU 05 d a ) S3 \#163 ; rP r- , -4-5 i\#151 ; I q d .3 \#174 ; s \#174 ; ofi rfl rP ^ 4-5 \#171 ; t .
00 rS \#174 ; S J ^ .2 3 | M4 \#166 ; s \#174 ; ' 5 rH Ch 0 0 1 ^ I g 1S rH 0 rP rP V 2^ \#163 ; S3 3 % 8\gt ; o i ; : 'S 8 'M ^ S 8* .3 0 ?
D ^3 00 4-\gt ; rH \#169 ; P ni nH o oo *C - M OQ ^

