PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY .
Section B.\#151 ; Biological Sciences .
Address of the President , Lord Rayleigh , O.M. , , at the Anniversary Meeting on November 30 , 1908 .
Since the last Anniversary the Society has sustained the loss of eighteen Fellows and four Foreign Members .
The deceased Fellows are:\#151 ; The Right Hon. Lord Kelvin , died December 17 , 1907 .
Sir Alfred Baring Garrod , died December 28 , 1907 .
Robert Lewis John Ellery , died January 14 , 1908 .
Prof. James Bell Pettigrew , died January 31 , 1908 .
William Ashwell Shenstone , died February 3 , 1908 .
Sir John Denis Macdonald , died February 7 , 1908 .
Lieutenant-General Sir Richard Strachey , died February 12 , 1908 .
Dr. William Edward Wilson , died March 6 , 1908 .
Dr. Henry Clifton Sorby , died March 9 , 1908 .
Sir John Eliot , died March 17 , 1908 .
The Duke of Devonshire , died March 24,1908 .
Dr. James Bell , died March 31 , 1908 .
Colonel Andrew Wilson Baird , died April 2 , 1908 .
Sir John Evans , died May 31 , 1908 .
Lord Blythswood , died July 8 , 1908 .
Arthur Lister , died July 20 , 1908 .
The Earl of Rosse , died August 29 , 1908 .
Prof. William Edward Ayrton , died November 8 , 1908 .
VOL. lxxxi.\#151 ; B. B Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
[ Nov. 30 , The deceased Foreign Members are:\#151 ; Pierre Jules Cesar Janssen , died December 23 , 1907 .
Franz von Ley dig , died April , 1908 .
Henri Becquerel , died August 25 , 1908 .
Sleuth ere JClie Nicolas Mascart , died August 26 , 1908 .
The list of deaths this year is exceptionally heavy , and includes the name of one of the most eminent scientific men of our generation , who occupied the Presidency of this Society from 1890 to 1895\#151 ; I refer , of course , to Lord Kelvin .
We are fortunate in having secured for our ' Proceedings ' a review of Kelvin 's life and work , written by one who is especially well qualified for the difficult task .
I do not doubt that Professor Larmor is right in placing in the forefront of that work those fundamental advances in Thermodynamics which date from the middle of the last century .
It was Kelvin who first grasped the full scope of the principle known as the Second Law , a law which may indeed well be considered to stand first in order of importance , regarded from the point of view of man 's needs and opportunities .
It would be futile to attempt here a re-survey of the ground covered by Professor Larmor .
My acquaintance with Kelvin was limited , until about 1880 , a time when I was occupied with measurements relating to the electrical units , and received much appreciated encouragement .
From then onwards until his death I enjoyed the privilege of intimacy and , needless to say , profited continually from his conversation , as I had done before from his writings .
Our discussions did not always end in agreement , and I remember his admitting that a certain amount of opposition was good for him .
Such discussions often invaded the officers ' meetings during the time that we were colleagues , not always to the furtherance of the Society 's business .
But I must not linger over these reminiscences , interesting as they are to me .
We shall never see his like .
By the death of Sir Bichard Strachey we have lost a man well known to the senior Fellows , who served repeatedly upon the Council and whose advice was always valued .
He was a born administrator ; and by his work in India and afterwards at the Meteorological Office he rendered splendid service .
Dr. Sorby 's researches extended over many fields , and in several of them he was a pioneer .
I suppose that his greatest achievement was the introduction of the method in which thin slices of rock are examined under the microscope .
Among his many interesting observations are those upon the retardation of freezing in capillary tubes .
It appears that the walls exercise 1908 .
] Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
an influence at distances much greater than those usually regarded as molecular\#151 ; evidence apparently of structure upon an extended scale .
Dr. Sorby belonged to a class on whom England has special reason to congratulate herself , men who pursue science unprofessionally .
The names of Cavendish , Young , Joule , and Darwin at once suggest themselves .
It is to be feared that specialisation and the increasing cost and complication of experimental appliances are having a prejudicial effect in this regard .
On the other hand , the amateur is not without advantages which compensate to some extent .
Certainly , no one who has the root of the matter in him should be deterred by fears of such difficulties , and the example of Sorby suffices to show how much is open to ingenuity unaided by elaborate appliances .
The name of Sir John Evans must not pass without special notice .
There are few in recent years to whom the Society has been more indebted .
Many of our Fellows hardly realise how important and laborious are the services rendered in the office of Treasurer .
Evans ' scientific attainments , his knowledge of the world and of business , and his personal characteristics specially qualified him for office .
An appreciation , signed by well-known initials , has recently appeared in our ' Proceedings .
' On the Foreign List also the losses are heavy .
We have especially to condole with our colleagues in France upon the havoc caused by death within the last year or two .
Janssen , and Mascart , who was much missed at the recent Electrical Conference , had reached a full age .
But Becquerel was in the full tide of life , and we had hoped to learn much more from him ; as the discoverer of radio-activity , he had opened up inquiries whose significance seems ever on the increase .
Science has lost a leader ; his friends and the-world a charming personality .
During the time that I was Secretary , and - so concerned with the passing of mathematical papers through the Press , I was much struck with the carelessness of authors in the arrangement of their manuscript .
It is frequently forgotten that a line of print in the ' Transactions ' and in the new form of the ' Proceedings ' will hold much more than a line of ordinary manuscript , unless , indeed , the handwriting is exceptionally small .
Unless , the authors ' indications were supplemented , it frequently occurred that several lines of print were occupied by what might equally well , and in~my judgment much better , be contained in one line .
Even practised writers would do well , when they regard their manuscript as complete so far as regards matter and phrasing , to go over it again entirely from the point of view of the printing .
In this way much expense and space would be spared , and the appearance of the printed page improved .
Professor Larmor has b 2 Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
[ Nov. 30 , drawn up a paper which has received the sanction of the Council and is appended to this Address , and will , it is hoped , be of service at once to authors and to the Society .
( The paper is printed in Series A only .
) Apart from questions of printing , the choice of symbols for representing mathematical and physical quantities is of some importance , and is embarrassed by varying usages , especially in different countries .
A Committee now sitting is concerned with the selection of symbols for electrical and magnetic quantities , but the question is really much wider .
One hesitates to suggest another international conference , and perhaps something could be done by discussion in scientific newspapers .
Obviously some give and take would be necessary .
When the arguments from convenience are about balanced , appeal might be made to the authority of distinguished men , especially of those who were pioneers in the definition and use of the quantity to be represented .
As an example of the difficulties to be faced , I may instance the important case of a symbol for refractive index .
In English writings the symbol is usually and on the Continent n. By the early optical writers it would seem that no particular symbol was appropriated .
In 1815* Brewster has m. The earliest use of that I have come across is by Sir John Herschel , f and the same symbol was used by Coddington ( 1829 ) and by Hamilton ( 1830 ) , both distinguished workers in optics .
On the other hand , n was employed by Fraunhofer ( 1815 ) , and his authority must be reckoned very high .
As regards convenience , I should suppose that the balance of advantage would incline to / x , since n is wanted so frequently in other senses .
Another case in which there may be difficulties in obtaining a much to be desired uniformity is the symbol for electrical resistance .
On a former occasion I indulged in comment upon the tendency of some recent mathematics , which were doubtless understood as the mild grumbling of an elderly man who does not like to see himself left too far behind .
In the same spirit I am inclined to complain of what seem unnecessary changes in mathematical nomenclature .
In my youth , by a natural extension of a long established usage relative to equations , we spoke of the roots of a function , meaning thereby those values of the argument which cause the function to vanish .
In many modern writings I read of the zeroes of a function in the same sense .
There may be reasons for this change ; but the new expression seems to need precaution in its use ; otherwise we are led to such flowers of speech as " zeroes with real part positive , " which I recently came across . !
* 'Phil .
Trans. , ' 1815 .
t ' Phil. Trans. , ' 1821 , p. 230 .
J ' Proc. Math. Soc. , ' vol. 31 , p. 266 .
Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
1908 .
] But though I may use a little my privilege of grumbling over details , I hope I shall not be misunderstood as undervaluing the progress made in recent years , which , indeed , seems to me to be very remarkable and satisfactory , , regarded from the scientific point of view .
On the other hand I cannot help feeling misgivings as to the suitability of the highly specialised mathematics of the present day for a general intellectual training , and I hope that a careful watch may be maintained to check , in good time , any evil tendencies that may become apparent .
Among the notable advances of the present year is the liquefaction of helium by Professor Onnes of Leiden .
It is but a few years since Sir J. Dewar opened up a new field of temperature by his liquefaction of hydrogen , and now a further extension is made which , if reckoned merely in difference of temperature , may appear inconsiderable , but seen from the proper thermodynamical standpoint is recognised to be far-reaching .
The exploration of this new field can hardly fail to afford valuable guidance for our ideas concerning the general properties and constitution of matter .
Professor On lies ' success is the reward of labours well directed and protracted over many years .
The discovery and application by Rutherford and Geiger of an electrical method of counting the number of a-particles from radio-active substances constitutes an important step , and one that appears to afford better determinations than hitherto of various fundamental quantities .
It would be of interest to learn what interpretation is put upon these results by those who still desire to regard matter as homogeneous .
Another very interesting observation published during the year is that of Hale upon the Zeeman effect in sun-spots , tending to show that the spots are fields of intense magnetic force .
Anything which promises a clue as to the nature of these mysterious peculiarities of the solar surface is especially welcome .
Until we understand better than we do these solar processes , on which our very existence depends , we may do well to cultivate a humbler frame of mind than that indulged in by some of our colleagues .
A theoretical question of importance is raised by the observations of Nordmann and Tikhoff showing a small chromatic displacement of the phase of minimum brightness in tire case of certain variable stars .
The absence of such an effect has been hitherto the principal argument on the experimental side for assuming a velocity of propagation in vacuum independent of frequency or wave-length .
The tendency of the observations would be to suggest a dispersion in the same direction as in ordinary matter , but of almost infinitesimal amount , in view of the immense distances over which the propagation takes place .
Lebedew has pointed out that Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
[ Nov. 30 , this conclusion may be evaded by assuming an asymmetry involving colour in the process by which the variability is brought about , and he remarks that although the dispersions indicated by Nordmann and Tikhoff are in the same direction , the amounts calculated from the best available values of the parallaxes differ in the ratio of 30 to 1 .
In view of this discrepancy and of the extreme minuteness of the dispersion that would be indicated , the probabilities seem at the moment to lie on the side of Lebedew 's explanation ; doubtless further facts will be available in the near future .
I cannot abstain from including in the achievements of the year the remarkable successes in mechanical flight attained by the brothers Wright , although the interest is rather social and practical than purely scientific .
For many years , in fact ever since I became acquainted with the work of Penaud and Wenham , I have leaned to the opinion that flight was possible as a feat .
This question is now settled , and the tendency may perhaps be to jump too quickly to the conclusion that what can be done as a feat will soon be possible for the purposes of daily life .
But there is a very large gap to be bridged over ; and the argument urged by Professor Newcomb and based on the principle of dynamical similarity , that the difficulties must increase with the scale of the machines , goes far to preclude the idea that regular ocean service will be conducted by flying machines rather than by ships .
But , as the history of science and invention abundantly proves , it is rash to set limits .
Por special purposes , such as exploration , we may expect to see flying machines in use before many years have passed .
The Report of the National Physical Laboratory for the year again indicates remarkable growth .
The various new buildings , which have been erected and equipped during recent years at a cost of about \#163 ; 33,000 , are now occupied ; and the result is that both researches and test work can be carried out with much greater ease and efficiency than previously .
The Executive Committee in charge of the Laboratory is indebted in the first instance to H.M. Government , and then to the numerous friends whose assistance has made this possible .
At the same time , the needs for buildings are not nearly satisfied .
There has been during the year a very marked and important growth in the demand by manufacturers and others for assistance in metallurgical enquiries , which require investigations , frequently of a very complex character ; and with the present accommodation for much of the Metallurgical Department this demand is difficult to satisfy .
Thanks in great measure to the Goldsmiths ' Company , the chemical side of this department is well provided for ; but new buildings for the other branches of metallurgy are an urgent want .
1908 .
] Anniversary Address by Lord .
The Report of the Treasury Committee of Inquiry referred to in the address of last year was communicated by the Treasury to the Royal Society , with the intimation that Their Lordships accept the recommendations of the Committee , and trust that the Royal Society may see their way to do the same .
In their reply the President and Council , with the concurrence and advice of the Executive Committee of the Laboratory , expressed their readiness to use their best endeavours to carry the Report into effect .
The Report has since been presented to Parliament .
The buildings of the Magnetic Observatory at Eskdalemuir are now occupied ; but , unfortunately , difficulty has arisen in making the magnetograph rooms which are underground completely watertight , and the recording apparatus is not yet properly installed .
The third and fourth volumes of ' Collected Researches ' of the Laboratory have been published during the year , and testify to the vigorous scientific activities of the staff .
The third volume is occupied chiefly with the account of the prolonged series of experiments on electric units carried out at the Laboratory by Prof. Ayrton , Mr. Mather , Dr. Lowry , and Mr. Smith .
These researches proved of great value in the discussions at the International Conference on Electric Units , for which recently the Society provided accommodation and entertainment at the request of the Government .
The progress of the ' Royal Society Catalogue of Scientific Papers ' has advanced a definite stage during the year , through the publication by the Cambridge University Press of the Index Volume of Pure Mathematics for the Nineteenth Century .
Owing to the magnitude of the material to be indexed in the several sciences , it has been necessary to adopt drastic measures of compression , and the 40,000 entries involved in the present section have thus been condensed into one royal octavo volume of some 700 pages .
An essential element in this saving of bulk has been the grouping of titles within each heading so as to avoid reprinting the leading words .
It was , perhaps , inevitable that this device would occasionally be mistaken for an attempt at organic classification within the limits of the main headings , which are substantially those of the yearly 'International Catalogue of Scientific Literature .
' This had , indeed , been foreseen in the preface of the volume .
As regards new actual sub-headings which have been introduced occasionally , the Committee remark that " These minor classifications , being often made mechanically on the basis of the explicit mention of the sub-heading , are not to be taken as exhaustive ; cognate entries may be found elsewhere under the same main heading .
The unit of classification is thus the complete numbered heading .
" The Committee of the Catalogue have indeed been fully conscious Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
[ Nov. 80 , throughout of the difficulties of the task which they supervise ; and it must he gratifying to the Director of the Catalogue and his staff to have the support of high authorities , not confined to this country , in their decision that in so extensive an undertaking practical feasibility must be the aim rather than an elusive theoretical perfection .
One advantage , at any rate , will accrue from bringing out a single volume well in advance , in that the Committee will be able to profit in the future work from the experience they have acquired .
Through the kindness of Dr. Schuster I had the opportunity of submitting to the Council , before the expiry of my term of office , a generous proposal which he makes for instituting a fund of \#163 ; 1500 , the interest of which is to be applied to pay the travelling expenses of delegates of the Society to the International Association of Academies .
Dr. Schuster felt that the absence of such a provision laid a burden upon delegates , and might operate to limit the choice of the Society .
I was empowered by the Council to convey their cordial thanks to Dr. Schuster , and I have now the pleasure of making his benefaction known to the Society at large .
In taking leave of the honourable office which I have occupied for three years , I desire to thank the Society and especially my colleagues , the officers , for the consideration which they have uniformly shown me .
All the omens indicate that the Society will be represented by one well versed in its affairs , and whose scientific distinction and wide experience justify the highest hopes for his tenure of the chair .
MEDALLISTS , 1908 .
Copley Medal .
The Copley Medal is awarded to Dr. Alfred Russel Wallace , E.R.S. It is now sixty years since this distinguished naturalist began his scientific career .
During this long period he has been unceasingly active in the prosecution of natural history studies .
As far back as 1848 he accompanied the late Henry Walter Bates to the region of the Amazon , and remained four years there , greatly enriching zoology and botany , and laying at the same time the basis of that wide range of biological acquirement by which all his writings have been characterised .
Erom South America he passed to the Malay Archipelago and spent there some eight fruitful years .
It was during his stay in that region that he matured those broad views regarding the geographical distribution , of plants and animals which on his return to this country he was able to elaborate in his well-known classic volumes on Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
1908 .
] that subject .
It was there , too , amid the problems presented by the infinite variety of tropical life , that he independently conceived the idea of the theory of the origin of species by natural selection which Charles Darwin had already been working out for years before .
His claims to the admiration of all men of science were recognised by the Eoyal Society forty years ago , when , in 1868 , a Eoyal Medal was awarded to him .
Again , when in 1890 , the Darwin Medal was founded , he was chosen as its first recipient .
He is still full of mental activity and continues to enrich our literature with contributions from his wide store of experience and reflection in the domain of Natural History .
As a crowning mark of the high estimation in which the Eoyal Society holds his services to science , the Copley Medal is now fittingly bestowed on him .
Eumford Medal .
The Eumford Medal is awarded to Prof. H. A. Lorentz , For .
Mem. E.S. Prof. Hendrik Antoon Lorentz , of Leiden , has been distinguished during the last quarter of a century by his fundamental investigations in the principles of the theory of radiation , especially in its electric aspect .
His earliest memoirs were concerned with the molecular equivalents which obtain in the refractive ( and dispersive ) powers of different substances ; in them he arrived at formulae that still remain the accepted mode of theoretical formulation of these phenomena .
The main result , that ( p.2\#151 ; l)/ ( ya2 + 2 ) is proportional jointly to the density of distribution of the molecules , and to a function of the molecular free periods and the period of the radiation in question , rests essentially only on the idea of propagation in some type of elastic medium ; and thus it was reached simultaneously , along different special lines , by H. A. Lorentz originally from Helmholtz 's form of Maxwell 's electric theory , and by L. Lorenz , of Copenhagen , from a general idea of propagation after the manner of elastic solids .
The other advance in physical science with which Prof. Lorentz 's name is most closely associated is one of greater precision , the molecular development of Maxwell 's theory of electro-dynamics .
This subject was never entered upon by Maxwell himself , on the ground , probably , that the general relations of the mther , and in particular their dynamical bearings , offered a definite field which must be fully probed and explored before the uncertainties connected with molecular complexity became ripe for effective detailed treatment .
But the theoretical difficulties connected with the simple law of the astronomical aberration of light , and particularly with the entire absence of any effect of the Earth 's uniform motion in space on Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
[ Nov. 30 , terrestrial phenomena involving radiation , had more recently rendered this problem urgent .
Following on various purely optical papers on the phenomena of moving bodies , Prof. Lorentz , in 1892 , elaborated a general molecular treatment in the memoir " La Theorie Electro-magnetique de Maxwell , et son Application aux Corps Mouvants , " which appeared in the 4 Archives N^erlandaises , ' and contains substantially the main root ideas of the subject .
In 1905 it was re-expounded with further development in a tract entitled 44 Yersuch einer Theorie der Electrischen und Optischen Erscheinungen in Bewegten Korpern , " the main feature being the elimination of the dynamical element in the previous discussion in favour of a formulation by a system of abstract equations , after the way first set out by Maxwell himself as a summary of his final definite results as distinct from the formative ideas underlying them , and afterwards brought into prominence by the expositions of Heaviside and Hertz .
By these writings Prof. Lorentz has taken a predominant place in the modern evolution of electric and optical theory .
He has since been active in special applications , of which the best known has been his theoretical prediction of the physical features of the alteration of the lines of the spectrum in a magnetic field , which had been discovered and has since been developed by his colleague Zeeman .
Boyal Medals .
The assent of His Majesty the King , our Patron , has been graciously signified to the following awards of the Medals presented annually by him to the Society .
A Royal Medal to Prof. John Milne , F.R.S. , for his work on Seismology .
In 1875 , Dr. Milne accepted the position of Professor at Tokyo , which was offered to him by the Imperial Government of Japan .
His attention was almost immediately attracted to the study of earthquakes , and he was led to design new forms of construction for buildings and engineering structures with a view to resisting the destructive effects of shocks .
His suggestions have been largely adopted , and his designs have been very successful for the end in view .
Incidentally he studied the vibrations of locomotives , and showed how to obtain a more exact balancing of the moving parts , and thus to secure smoother running and a saving of fuel .
Here again his suggestions were accepted , and his work was recognised by the Institution of Civil Engineers .
He next devoted himself to the study of artificial shocks produced by the explosion of dynamite in borings .
He then studied actual shocks as observed at nine stations connected by telegraph wires .
A seismic study of Tokyo , and subsequently of the whole of northern Japan , followed .
In this 1908 .
] Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
latter work he relied on reports from 50 stations .
The Government then took up the matter , increased his 50 stations to nearly 1000 , and founded a Chair of Seismology for Mr. Milne .
It is due to his energy , skill , and knowledge that the Japanese School of Seismology stands as the first in the world .
While still in Japan he attempted to obtain international co-operation through the representatives of 13 nationalities .
This first effort failed ; but subsequently , on his return to England in 1895 , he succeeded , and reports are now received by him from some 200 stations furnished with trustworthy instruments , and scattered all over the world .
On his return to England he at once established his own observatory at Shide , in the Isle of Wight , and the work has been carried on continuously from that time up to now , mainly by his own industry and resources .
In Great Britain we owe everything in seismology to the British Association .
Their Committee was founded in 1880 , and since that date Milne has been the moving spirit in the long career of its activity .
He has been the author of 29 annual reports , and these form in effect a history of the advance of seismology since it has been recognised as a definite branch of science .
The knowledge which we have now acquired as to the internal constitution of the earth is more due to Milne than to any other man .
The work of Dr. Henry Head , F.R.S. , on which is founded the award of the other Boyal Medal , forms a connected series of researches on the Nervous System ( made partly in conjunction with Campbell , Rivers , Sherren , and Thompson ) , published for the most part in 'Brain ' at various times since 1893 up to the present date , and constituting one of the most original and important contributions to neurological science of recent times .
His first paper ( 1893 ) , founded on minute and laborious clinical investigation , established in a more precise manner than had hitherto been done the relations between the somatic and visceral systems of nerves .
He confirmed from the clinical side the experimental researches of Sherrington on the distribution of the posterior roots of the spinal nerves .
An inquiry into the pathology of Herpes Zoster ( 1900 ) , which he proved abundantly to be due to inflammation of the posterior root ganglia , indicated that the areas of referred pain in visceral disease corresponded specially with the distribution of the fibres of the posterior roots subserving painful cutaneous sensibility .
Continuing his investigations on the peripheral nerves , partly by experiments on himself , in conjunction with Rivers , and partly by examination of eases of accidental injuries to nerves , Head was led to formulate ( 1905 ) an Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
[ Nov. 30 entirely novel conception and differentiation of the functions of the peripheral nerves , and of the paths for the respective forms of sensibility which they convey\#151 ; epicritic , protopathic , and deep sensibility .
This is generally regarded by neurologists as a research of quite exceptional originality and ability .
Following the course of afferent impulses , Head next showed ( 1906 ) that , the sensory paths of the peripheral nerves at their first synaptic junction with the spinal cord become re-arranged , and ascend in different relations in certain definite tracts .
Davy Medal .
The Davy Medal is awarded to Prof. William Augustus Tilden , F.K.S. The researches of Prof. Tilden extend into many domains .
His work on the specific heats of the elements in relation to their atomic weights , described to the Society in the Bakerian Lecture for 1900 and in two later papers published also in the * Philosophical Transactions/ was of high theoretical importance .
The employment of liquid oxygen as an ordinary laboratory reagent , rendered possible by the researches of Dewar and others , enabled Prof. Tilden to test the validity of Dulong and Petit 's Law and of Neumann 's Law over a much wider range of temperature than was possible before , and gave a truer estimate of the nature of their validity .
In the region of organic chemistry , he has carried out important researches on the terpenes , such as that on the hydrocarbons from Pinus sylvestris , on terpin and terpinol , and on limettin .
In inorganic chemistry , his investigation on aqua regia and on nitrosyl chloride are especially noteworthy .
He has assisted much in clearing up many points with regard to aqua regia about which obscurity remained .
His introduction of nitrogen peroxide and especially of nitrosyl chloride as reagents has proved , in his own hands and in those of other workers , to be of very high value .
Darwin Medal .
The Darwin Medal is awarded to Prof. August Weismann for his contributions to the study of evolution .
He was one of the early supporters of the doctrine of evolution by means of natural selection , and wrote in support of the Darwinian theory in 1868 .
His great series of publications from that date onward must always remain a monument of patient inquiry .
In forming an estimate of his work it does not seem essential that we should 1908 .
] Anniversary Address by Lord Rayleigh .
decide on the admissibility of his germ-plasm theory .
It is in like manner unimportant that he was , in certain respects , forestalled by Galton , and that his own views have undergone changes .
The fact remains that he has done more than any other man to focus scientific attention on the mechanism of inheritance .
By denying the possibility of somatic inheritance , he has compelled the world to look at this question with a closeness of criticism that is wanting in all earlier inquiries .
In the opinion of what is perhaps the majority of naturalists , he has achieved much more than this\#151 ; he has convinced them that the solution of the problem of evolution must be sought along the lines of his doctrine of germinal continuity .
Thus the preformist 's point of view , for which he has done so much , forms the basis on which Mendelians and Mutationists are at work .
Weismann 's work was highly estimated by Mr. Darwin .
Thus he writes , in 1875 ( 'More Letters/ i , 356 ) , of Weismann 's paper on Seasonal Dimorphism : " No one has done so much as you on this important subject , i.e. , on the causes of variation .
" Again ( ' Life and Letters/ iii , 198 ) : " I have been profoundly interested by your essay on ' Amblystoma/ and think you have removed a great stumbling block in the way of evolution .
" And , once more , in January , 1877 ( 'Life and Letters/ iii , 231 ) , Darwin wrote of Weismann 's ' Studien sir Descendenzlehre ' : " They have excited my interest and admiration in the highest degree , and whichever I think of last seems to me the most valuable .
" Hughes Medal .
The Hughes Medal is awarded to Prof. Eugen Goldstein .
Prof. Goldstein was one of the early workers on the modern detailed investigation of the electric discharge in rarefied gases , and by long continued researches has contributed substantially to the systematic analysis of the complex actions presenting themselves in that field .
Of these researches may be mentioned his observations of the effect of magnetic force on striations , of the phosphorescence produced by the cathode rays , and of the reflection of cathode rays .
By his discovery of the so-called Kanal-Strahlen , or positive rays , he has detected an essential feature of the phenomenon , which , in his own hands and in those of other workers , has already thrown much needed light on the atomic transformations that are involved .

