VII .
A comparison of the diurnal changes oj intensity in the dipping and horizontal needles , at Port Bowen .
By Lieutenant Henry Foster , R.N. F.R.S. Communicated February 25 , 1826 .
A he following comparative observations on the intensity of the dipping and horizontal needles , were made with a particular object in view , which will be proper to explain before giving the details .
It was found by observation , that the intensity of the horizontal needle was hourly varying : this appeared by the results already given to this Society in a former paper : but it was doubtful , whether this variation of horizontal intensity of a needle , proceeded from an actual variation in the intensity of the terrestrial magnetism , or from a variation in the amount of its direction , as indicated by the dip itself .
The power of the horizontal needle varying as the cosine of the dip , a change to the amount of a few minutes in the dip , at places where it is very great , would be sufficient to explain all the variations of intensity observed in the horizontal needle , without supposing any change to have taken place in the intensity of the terrestrial magnetic force .
The variation in dip , however , if it did occur , was too small to be detected by direct observation ; and I failed also , to render it sensible by the application of magnets , as stated in a former communication .
My object therefore in making the experiments contained in the following Table , was to ascertain , by several series of vibrations made with the same needle , mounted alternately as a dipping needle , and as a horizontal one , whether or no a corresponding variation of intensity would manifest itself in these two positions respectively ; as ought to be the case , if the diurnal changes of intensity in the horizontal needle proceeded from a general change of intensity in the terrestrial magnetic power .
But on the other hand , if the force indicated by the dipping needle should be found to remain constant , then it would be equally clear , that the variations of intensity in the horizontal needle proceeded from an actual change of clip only .
As this question is of considerable importance in the theory of terrestrial magnetism , I regret that I had not an opportunity of making a more extended series of experiments of this kind ; but , as far as they go , they certainly appear to indicate , that the alterations of intensity in the horizontal needle , are due rather to a daily change in the amount of the dip , than to any variation in the general intensity of the earth 's magnetic force ; although some change in this also is observable by the vibrations of the dipping needle This explanation of the cause of the change of horizontal intensity , it may be remarked , is consistent with the observations made in Europe , which likewise show an alteration of intensity in the horizontal needle during the day , but in a much less degree than at Port Bowen .
Now , if the variation in question really proceed from a change of dip , to the amount of 3 , 4 , or 5 minutes of a degree , the change of intensity in the horizontal needle will be less and less obvious , as the dip decreases ; but if it proceed from a change in the actual intensity of the earth 's magnetism , it ought to be constant in all parts of the world , which is contrary to observation .
In making these experiments , a dipping apparatus by DoLLOND , belonging to the Board of Longitude , was used .
This instrument had a needle 1 1\#163 ; inches in length , of an oblong shape , and rounded at its extremities ; it was placed in the magnetic meridian , on a pedestal built of stones , and thus afforded the means for ascertaining the variations of intensity in the earth 's magnetism , as indicated by the vibrations of the dipping needle .
But as I had not a suitable apparatus for ascertaining the variations in horizontal intensity with the same needle ; a cubical box 12 inches high was prepared , for which I was indebted to the kindness of Captain Hoppner .
This box had glass ends , to admit of the vibrations of the needle being observed , and contained at the bottom a horizontal circle , divided to every 5 degrees , for the purpose of measuring the arc of vibration ; it was likewise fitted with a contrivance , by which the needle could be made to vibrate in any arc at pleasure , and the top was so constructed as to allow the suspension of the needle , to be placed directly over the centre of the circle .
The suspension consisted of a few fibres of floss silk , attached to one of the extremities of the axis of the needle , just sufficient to sustain its weight , and several inches in length , to lessen the effects of torsion .
This box was also mounted on a pedestal , similar to the one on which the dipping apparatus stood , and both were protected from the weather by being placed in a house built of snow .
For observing the horizontal vibrations of this needle , a small telescope , having a vertical wire fixed in the focus of the eye-piece , was placed on a stand firmly frozen to the ground , at the distance of about eight feet from the middle of the box , in the direction of the magnetic meridian : when the needle was at rest in its natural direction , a fine thread of light reflected from its end , was bisected by the vertical wire in the telescope ; the telescope having a lateral sliding motion for the purpose of accomplishing this adjustment .
In making a set of these observations , the following mode was pursued : the needle being suspended horizontally , the adjustment of the telescope above described was first completed , after which , the needle was made to vibrate at the commencement , in an arc of 60 degrees , by the contrivance already alluded to ; the time at which the reflected thread of light passed the wire in the telescope , was noted by means of a chronometer , and also at every tenth vibration following , until one hundred were completed : the needle was then removed from the box , and placed on its axis in the dipping apparatus ; the time of its performing one hundred vibrations ( commencing as before in an arc of 60 degrees ) was in like manner noted ; the passage of the central point in this case being determined by means of a lens , fixed over that part of the vertical circle to which the needle pointed , When freely supported on its axis and at rest .
In this way all the results in the following Table have been obtained ; it may not , however , be unimportant to state , that although the needle , in each of its different positions , always vibrated in the same arc at the commencement , viz. 60 degrees ; yet the terminal arc , in either position/ generally varied .
The Table is divided into two parts ; the first contains the observations on the times of vibration of the* needle in its horizontal position ; and the second , those on it when used as a dipping needle .
In the first column of each part , is inserted the day of the month ; in the second , the hour and minute at which the observations were commenced ; the third column of each part , contains the mean time in seconds taken by the needle in its different positions , to perform one hundred vibra\#171 ; tions ; and in the fourth , is inserted the temperature of the needle at the time of observation .
ist Part , sdPart , Horizontal Needle .
Dipping Needle.\#171 ; v en Mean time in Mean time in Date\#171 ; v m^c^ ' menceraent .
en Sf'n^ &gt; OIper ' TemPFan* .
Date .
TuneofComseconds , of perTemp .
menceraent .
forming 100 Fan* .
mencement .
forming 100 perTemp .
Fah\#171 ; .
|n _ vibrations .
' vibrations .
1825 .
h. m. s. o 1825 .
h. m. 8 .
o Feb. 1 2th A.M. 635 2128,6 -17 Feb.i2thA .
M. 11 58 405^ 17\#191 ; 1054 2127,6 -17 P.M. o 30 405,7 i7l P.M. 132 2079,9 -17 13th P.M. 3 41 410,0 ~i7i 13th P.M. 142 2103,1 17 14th A.M. 1034 408,0 ---19 } .
A..M254 2152,5 '7e P.M. o 12 406,5 -20 14th .
A. M.i i 21 2088,2 -20 8 33 408,4 -22 P.M. i 14 2067,7 -20 1000 409,0 21J 9 00 2086,0 -22 11 ia 408,7 -21 A 15th A.M. 041 2107,0 22 15th A. M. 134 ^n^i 22 1048 2115,5 2I IO 32 410,0 -.21 P.M. 844 2064,2 -23 11 35 4o9,6 -21 1029 2071,0 -23 P.M. 89 409,2 -23 l6t\#163 ; A.M. n4 2077,4 -27 943 4o8 &gt; 7 _23 17th A.M. 10 18 2071,0 -22 11 r5 409,2 -22 11 12 2058,2 -21 16th A..M .
10 38 409,9 -28 P. M\#171 ; o 29 2079,5 20 11 46 409,1 -27 19th A^M .
10 l8 2092,2 22J 17th A. M\#187 ; 9 , 42 409,0 -22 u 54 408,5 20 P.M. 1 10 409,0 20\#191 ; i9thA .
M.iooo 408,5 23 10 58 408,1 -22 * Mean ... .
2092,33 20J .
Mean ... .
408,65 zi ' * The dip of the needle resulting from these elements is 87o 48^8 N. The above results show , that the mean of all the observed times which the horizontal needle required to make one hundred vibrations was 2092,33 seconds , but that differences appear in these times amounting to 94,3 seconds , or ~j part of the interval ; whereas in the dipping needle , in which the mean of the times required to perform one hundred vibrations was 408,65 seconds , the greatest difference is only 5,7 seconds , or -1 part of the interval , which is a much less proportional change than the former .
As an additional confirmation , however , that the intensity of the earth 's magnetism is not subject to much variation , I have given in the following Table the results of observations I made on it at the same place in November , 1824 , January and June , 1825 .
These exhibit the times in which the needle completed one hundred vibrations in the magnetic meridian , deduced from the mean of the times of its performing four hundred vibrations , with the face of the instrument on each side of the vertical , and the needle reversed on its axis in the two positions .
-m'aai~ Ti\#8482 ; *\#187 ; of Mean time in seconds\#187 ; * .
-m'aai~ Obtrotion !
Ti\#8482 ; *\#187 ; of of performing 100 Temperature .
vibrations .
J ?
an ' h. ro .
s. o November 8th A.M. 10 20 4'4 &gt; 94 !
3e January 10th A.M. n 45 404,69 22 June 27th A. M. 9 30 406,50 + 47 These results also show , taking into consideration the different temperatures under which they have been obtained , that little or no change in the intensity took place , notwithstanding the observations were made at different hours of the day , as well as at different parts of the year .
Therefore , as has been stated , the clange of intensity in the horizontal needle is due , principally , to a daily variation in the amount of the dip ; not tp a real change of intensity in the terrestrial magnetic force .
This at least appears to be a legitimate deduction from the preceding observations ; from which circumstance , and that of the daily variation in the direction of the horizontal needle , we are naturally led to the conception of a small variatipn in position of the magnetic axis , corresponding to a revolution of the pplar point round its mean position as a centre , prpduced by the action of the sun , on the magnetism of the parts of the earth , successively exposed to its influence .
And , moreover , it seems by no means improbable , that the annual variation of the positipn of the magnetic pole may ultimately be traced to thp s^pye universal cause .
I have not attempted to enter into any minute calcul^tipns on this subject , but I believe it will be found , that if the r^cjius of the circle , described by the pole of the general magnetic axis of the earth during the day , be supposed tp subtend at the centre an angle of 2 or % ' minutes , it will reconcile , to a considerable degree of precision , nearly all the observations on the daily variation of the direction , and daily change pf intensity of the horizontal needle , made both in Eurppe arid within the Arctic Circle .
If , also , we suppose the magnetic north pole , during the passage of the sun over its merijdi^p , when lying between the pole of the world and the sun , to advance more to the westward , or in a direction contrary to the rotation of the earth on its axis , than it returns tp the eastward , or in the direction of rotation of the earth during the sun 's passage over the opposite meridian , , when the pplp of the world lies between the magnetic pole and the sun , then it follows , that in some certain number of years the magnetic north pole will perform a revolution from east to west round the pole of the earth , and produce an annual change in the variation of the compass in that direction , which is known to obtain .
' That this may be the case , is rendered probable , by considering that the sun at present approaches nearer to the magnetic north pole in its southern , than in its northern passage over the meridian , by twice the north polar distance of the magnetic pole ; and although the reverse takes place on the south pole , yet , as the sun is longer on the northern than on the southern side of the equator , there will be a preponderance of action to carry the north pole forward to the westward , and consequently the south pole to the eastward , as is supposed to be the case by many eminent philosophers in this country .
However , these observations will , of course , require to be repeated in other parts of the world , before this hypothesis can be considered as fully confirmed by experiment .
In this concluding communication relative to our recent northern magnetic experiments , I beg leave again to express my obligations to Mr. Barlow and to Mr. Christie .
To Mr. Christie , for his kindness in permitting the observations on the dip and magnetic intensity to be made in his garden at Woolwich , and for the valuable assistance he rendered me in the equipment of the magnetical instruments supplied to the Expedition , To Mr. Barlow , I stand indebted in a manner which I find it difficult to describe ; indeed it is no more than due to the scientific liberality of this Gentleman to state , that on many occasions , when I have shown him my experiments on the different magnetical subjects wherein I have been engaged , he has kindly given such a direction to my thoughts , as materially to assist me in arriving at the conclusions I have drawn .
P.S.That the magnetic pole moves in an orbit round the pole of the earth , was first conceived , I believe , by Mr , Derham , as appears from the Appendix to Philosophical Essays , in three parts , by R. Lovett , lay clerk of the cathedral church at Worcester , published in 1766 , which was put into my hands by a friend , on mentioning to him the theoretical views advanced in this paper .
This Appendix contains a brief theory of the north magnetic pole adopted by him from q. passage in Derham 's Physico-Theology , which I shall tran\#187 ; scribe in Mr , Derham 's own words , who , after stating the various discoveries of Norman , Gellibrand , and others , proceeds to say ; " To these discoveries , I hope the reader " will excuse me if I add one of my own , which I deducecji " some years ago , from some magnetical experiments an$ " observations I made ; which discovery I also acquainted " our Royal Society with some time since , viz. that as thp " common horizontal ncedle is continually varying towards " the east and west , so is the dipping needle varying up and " down , towards or from wards the zenith , with the magne* " tick tendency describing indeed a circle round the pole of " the world , as I conceive , or some other point ; so that if " we could procure a needle so nicely matfe , as to point ex " actly according toits magnetic direction* it would in gptfte t\#8364 ; certain number of years describe a circle of about i$gf .
" radius round the magnetic poles northerly and southerly.\#8364 ; \#8364 ; This I have for several years suspected , and have had some H reason for it too ; and three or four years ago , mentioning " it at a meeting of our Royal Society , they were pleased to " cause it to be entered in the Journals ; but I have not yet " been so happy to procure a tolerable good dipping needle , " or other proper one to my mind , to bring the thing to " sufficient test of experience ; as in a short time I hope &lt; c to do , having lately hit upon a contrivance that may do " the thing/ ' Mr. Lovett next proceeds to illustrate Mr. Derham 's theory by appropriate diagrams , and then to compute the latitude of the magnetic pole from the best recorded observations at the time on the variation of the compass at two well known places .
Having thus obtained 13o 51 ' for the north polar distance of the magnetic pole , or radius of the orbit which it describes round the pole of the earth , he then fixes the year of no variation of the magnetic needle in London to be 1660 , from the observations of Dr. Halley in 1672 ; and from a similar observation by Dr. Bradley in 1750 , he deduces the longitude of the pole for that time , and by this interval of 90 years , he infers the progressive rate of the pole westerly to be in longitude 70 i 12 " every ten years .
With these data he has computed a table of variations of the compass for every ten years between 1660 and 1910 , in which he has predicted , with near approximation to what has since been observed , considering the distance of time and want of correct knowledge of its quantity , not only the amount of the variation , but the year in which the magnetic pole arrives at its maximum westerly position .
He also states , that in 191 a\#163 ; the magnetic pole will again be on the meridian of London , and that it requires 505 years , 215 days , 8 hours , and 24 minutes , to make a complete revolution round the pole of the world .

