IV .
" Remarks on the Great Nebula in Orion .
" In a Letter addressed to Prof. G. G. STOKES , Sec. R.S. By W. LASSELL , F.R.S. 1-e ceiveed February 28 , 1868 .
I have beeni so much initerested by the perusal of Lord Oxmantown 's observations and drawing of the Great Nebula in Orion , published in the present volume of the 'Transactions , ' that I venture to offer you a few remarks upon them the more readily , as I may be supposed to be somewhat familiar with that object , thoug-h observed with less advantage of optical power .
On comparing the present drawing with my own1 , madle with the fourfeet equatorial during my late sojourni at Malta , I find that of the 93 niew stars in Lord Oxmaitowni 's list , there are , I believe , only 24 within the more limited area of my drawing .
A good maniy of these have escaped my notice , while , on the other hand , I have cletected several which I do not find in the presenit Catalogue .
The following are instanices of a few : Three stars north-preceding No. 119 ; four stars about the hypothlenuse of the liearly right-angled triangle formed by the stars 47 , 52 , and 53 ; two stars in the triangle formed by 30 , 32 , and 35 ; a delicate point about 20 " from 104 , with several others .
Somne of these I have so repeatedly and certainly seem , that I wonder not to find them here .
The explanation of this discrepancy may possibly in some instlances be found in variability , bu1t must , I think , be rather sought for in the inifluenice which the state of atmosphere has on such delicate objects , whYenl the highest combinations of light and power are brought to bear upon them .
As this is a nebuIla of great extent , it is possible , and indeed probable , that there may be some spots on which the concentrated attention of any single observer has not beeni given unider the most favourable circumstances .
In my own observations , the question of resolvability appeared always an interesting one to settle , and therefore I gave quite as much attention to the detection of stars as to the tracing of the nebula .
The present drawing embracing much more of the extenit of this nebula than mine ( if not , indeed , the whole of it ) , I any able to compare mine with it only in part ; but , so far as my limits extelnd , the representations are generally very coincident .
In some parts there is a greater hardness than I have seein ; but it is scarcely possible to convey a tue inpression of the -form of the convolutions of the nebula without intensifying them in some degree .
I recognized in my own observations more of the spiral or scrolllike character of the nebula about the stars 51 and 57 , first pointed out , I believe , by Mr. Bond , than I find in this drawing .
In an engraving sent to me by Mr. Bond in 1863 , in which photography had , as I utnderstood , been emnployed , this scroll-like appearance is strongly marked .
On the question of a real charnge of form of the nebtula , lno positive conclusion can , I think , as yet be arrived at ; but as we have probably now.reached much more nearly to the practical limit of optical power in our telescopes , future observations may be expected to b)e much more comparable with existing drawings than these are with those formerly made .
The evidence of r esolvability seems to me to be rather on the negative side-my own deductions from what I have seen have been always in that directioni ; and such of the present observations as apparenitly look the other way are , I consider , too vague and wanting in precision and certainty , to establish it positively .
[ Receivocl April 17 , 1868 .
] In the account of my observations in Malta with the four-foot equatorial , published in the 36th volume of the Memoirs of the Royal Astronomical Society , there is but a slight reference to the Great Nebula of Orion ; the immediate reason for which was , that the drawing I had made was on too large a scale for appearing therein as an engraving , and I was ulnlwilling to subject it to a reduction of size .
Moreover , as Lord Oxmantown 's elaborate descriptioni and drawings of this incomparable object have recenitly appeared in the Transactions of the Royal Society , and as the subject may be presumed to be a very interesting one , I beg leave to request of the Society their acceptance of my original drawing ( forwarded this day ) , which contains the sum of all I have been able to make out ( bolth of the details of the nebula and of the stars therein ) with the above telescope dt iring may three-years ' residen1ce in the Island of MDlalta .
I also subjoin from my Journial the folloWing few notes relative to some of the more interesting stars .
The fifth star of the trapezium is reddish , and has a pretty broad and not very brilliant disk , -much larger than that of the sixth , which is more brilliant , and whiter .
Yet the first impression of the fifth on the eye is more forcible than that of the sixth .
Adopting Herschel 's niuimibers , 57 is much less bright than 51 .
The star marked 11 is nearly as bright as 57 ; but the two stars south-following II are the smallest points visible .
Of the delicate pair preceding s of the trapezium , the following star is the brightest .
The minute stars preceding and north-following 93 , were undoubtedly verified ; but there seemed a want of precision in the image of the latter ( if one may so speak of such a faint thing ) which suggested the idea of its being double .
Herschel 's 78 , 82 , and 91 have on no occasionl been recognized ; a star , however , bas been seen as laid down in the drawing , a very little southfollowing the place of 78 .
In the drawing , Herschel 's numbers are adopted throughout ; and for convenience of reference and identification , they are attached in minute figures to each star .
Its scale , as given at the foot , is 1 00"= 1 194 inch .
All the stars which have been certainly and repeatedly seen are inserted , and , I believe , no others .
Some attempt at indication of respective magnitude has been made in depicting the stars , but their estimated magnitudes are more precisely given in the margins , right and left of the pictuire .
They are , however , more fully laid down in the following Catalogue of the stars contained in the map , the places being principally taken from Liaponov 's measures .
A good many of the stars , however , I have independently measured , and though my mealns for this especial purpose were probably inferior to those of M. Liaponov , I have added a list of my measures for comparison or identification .
W. LASSELL .
Ray Lodge , April 1868 .
Catalogue .
L. =Tiaaponov .
LI .
= Lassell .
S. =Struve .
H. =Herschel .
h. 78 , 82 , 90 , 91 , and ( V. ) not seen..agniDistance from .
Designation and Authority tude .
for P ?
lace .
I2 preceding I047 171 S. 9 975 12 N. h. 5 L. 12-5 943 333 S. 13 938 408 N. place un certain .
8-5 927 676 N. h.6 II6 13'5 926 657 ' 8 .
I3 5 922 310 S. h. 8 L. 8 920 823 S. h1 7 f. I13 906 55 8 .
9 888 8i6 S. h.9 I. I25 870 630 S. 125 862 653 S. 9 849 241 S. h. io L. I25 843 439 9 82g94 S. h1.11 Hf .
I2 823 46I S. h. IS S. 9 769 64 N. h1.2 Lz I 2 .
7749 69 S. 11h.3 LII 729 73 8 .
h. I4 L. 105 722 525 S. h. i6 L. 11-5 7 i8 S1 .
13 710 5I8 N. place un certain .
13'5 708 4.94 N. place unicertain .
I ? ?
703 46 8 .
h. 17 c. 13 696 634 N. place un certain .
14 ~~69~i 657 N. ? ?
9 686 253 S. h. i8 L. 13-5 67I 487 N place un certain .
1 35 654 718 S. II-5 ~647 15 N. h1 .
19 L. II 631 31 8 .
h.2zi L : I3 5 626 697 S. 12 6io 538 S. h1 .
227 I3 ~~594 768 S8 .
I3 579 7694 S13 567 412z 8 .
I0 561 786 N. h1.25 H. I2 549 647 N. h.28 II .
IO 547 1036 S. h.29 H. 9 546 7I S. h.27 L. I0 5544 208 S. h. 6L 12 531 32 N. h- .
30 L. z2-5 508 178 N. I 8-5 493 289 N. h. 32 L. I3'5 478 747 N. 13 477 5442 S. 105 466 io8 S. h. 3 3IL .
13 462 756 N. 13 462 , i4 N. ?
I2z5 459 963 S. 13-5 4-53 82 8 .
6 4532 659 S. h. 34 L. 125 preceding 424 844 S. Catalogue ( continued ) .
MagniDistance from 0 .
Designation and Authority tude .
for Place .
I35 preceding 40 ? ?
72,7 N. 8-5 398 273 N. h. 35 .
I2 384 46 S. h36 L. 13 5 382 115 S. 9 357 592 S. h. 37 L. I3 5 3I2 5I0 N. h. 39 H. 7-5 311 424 S. h.4o L. 10 306 5 N. h. 38 .
I2 292 498 S. h. 43 L. 12 290 693 N. h-4'2 H. 12 282 31 S. h. 4I L. 12 247 i6 N. h. 44 I. 9 243 117 S. h. 45 L. 13 222 824 N. 13 22I 471 N. h. 46 H. 13 207 589 S. 13 206 889 S. I2 197 400 .
h. 47 1 .
13 184 335 S. 14 184 805 N. 9 184 909 N. I. L. 13 178 379 S. 951 75 51 N. h48 I. 14 I 68 303 S. 6-5 I163 666 N. hl 49 L. 10-5 16o II9 S. h. 50 L. I2.5 '59 238 S. '3'5 II6 749 S. I I.5 107 396 S. h. 52 L. 14 10o 15 S. 8 95 272 S. li.53IL 13 90 513 S ?
h 55 12 88 177 S. h. 5c IL 825 85 24 S. h. 5 S. II 79 387 N. h. 56 L. 13'5 75 157 S. I I-5 65 89I S. ?
h. 58 I3 5 57 511 S. 13-5 57 23 S h. 57 S. ? ?
135 55 434 5 .
13 49 786 S. 115 37 453 S. h. 62 L. 10-5 34 966 S. h59 H. 12 34 769 S h.6o H. 13 26 993 S. 12 22 947 S. 14 I7 '8 N. 14 .
12 Ig N. II 10 12 N. h. 64=E .
L. 12 9 949 S. h. 63 798 N. h. 65=A .
I. 13-5 9 504 N. h. 66 12.5 7 28 S. IL .
S. 85 i6 N. h. 67=B. .
14 0 35 5 . ?
nebulous patch .
45 preceding oo h. 69z=C .
I II*5 following 32S h. h 7I=-F .
Catalogue ( continued ) .
iMagniDitnefo .
Designationi and Authority tudcle , Distance from 0 .
for Place .
95 following 3 953 S. h.74 L. 956 98 N. h.70 L. I4 7 I0 5 .
13-5 8 107 N. IIT .
S. 14 5 II 47 N. ? ?
6 12 7 N. h. 73z-D .
L 14 i6 596 S. I9 8 S. ?
I3 5 20 575 8 .
13 21 968 8 .
125 21 39 N7 S. 7II 25 407 N. li.79 T. I3 5 28 48 N. II-5 30 172 N. I. 76 T. 115 34 433 N. h.83 I. II5 36 I65 N. h. SoT .
I2 54 146 N. h. 84. .
12.5 57 196 S. ?
, .
SI S. I3 58 856 S. 8-5 6I 85x N. h.85 T. 9 62 I00 N. h.87 7 .
9.5 63 674 N. h. 86 .
I2 69 24 8 .
h.88 T. 135 70 200 8 .
14 74 430 8 . ?
II 74 854 N. I13 5 76 467 S. I4 77 96 S. I35 78 27 S. I2 Si 173 N. 11 .
89 T. 14 88 109 5 . ? ?
5 98 94 .
h.g3 9i .
12 I02 673 S. i.92 IT .
13 102 742 N. 10 117 442 S. .
95 .
14 117 79 5 .
13 122 743 N. h. 94 12 I26 8I4 N. h , 97 13 I39 734 N. h. 96 133 140 427 S. 10 142 494 N. 13 , 102 L. I0 146 612 N. 1I .
99 I0-5 146 884 N. h. 98 II 149 134 S. 1 .
100 .
10.5 149 251 h. 103 .
6 150 96 S. 11.io Ti .
14 i6o 782 N. 14 170 i85 S. I4 5 178 95 S. 8-5 I8 174 S. h.I04 L0 .
I1 i85 693 ' .
11 .
105 H. II*5 202 824 N. l. 107 II .
II 208 567 S. h.I06 Ti .
14'5 209 130 5 .
14 21Z 59 S. 13 214 273 N. I 109 TL .
5fOllowing 217 445 N. h. io8 i Ctttalogute ( continued ) .
MagniDistance fom o. Designation and Authority tude .
for Place .
12.5 n-f .
h. I08 14'5 folloWing 22 3 427 S. only seen z4th Nov. i 864 75 225 I10 S. h. .
iio .
8 230 582 5 .
hL .
II .
237 x6i S. ?
nebu lous knot I3 5 242 340 S. 10-5 2 465 S i. 112 II .
I35 246 406 S ' 1 2.5 272 870 N. ? ?
14 280 474 N. 8 281 669 N. h.3 Ti , 14-5 285 460 N. 13'5 286 345 S. 12.5 299 129 N. h. II4 If .
14 312 650 S. ? ?
13 313 850 S , ?
h. 115 13 5 3I6 878 N. I2 319 184 S. IV .
Li .
13'5 340 882 N. 13-5 following 344 366 N. 11 .
II6 13'5 var .
359 243 S. I2z5 360 624 N. I I5 362 213 S. h.II7 1 .
I2 var .
369 69I N. h.x8 H. II following 369 846 N. b.9 H. 9-5 370 I96 N. b. I20 10 385 284 S. h. i3 Li .
125 385 742 Sh.122 Iz .
9'5 387 588 N. h. 124 L. XI.5 409 778 S. h. 125 .
13 417 I8z N. 417 669 N. ? ?
105 417 753 N ... II 418 514 S. h. i6 Ti .
13 437 6I7 N. I2z5 453 334 N. h.128 5 .
10 459 393 N. hl .
12 T. 13 504 714 S. h. I31 I0 505 1015 S. li.132 H. 8 51I 303 8 .
h. 133 T. I2 514 418 N. h. 30 13 518 499 N. '3 532 319 S. .
L134 HI35 following 563 i85 S. 6 dup .
574 85I 8 .
h. 135 T. I4'5 593 33 S. ? ?
13-5 597 96 S. 75 6z8 64 N. l. I36 L. I10 641 984 S. b. I38 H 14 656 25 N. I12 666 364 N. h. I37 Ll .
12 784 z67 N. h. 14I H. 10-5 797 254 S. 1i 142 T. 14 877 83I 8 .
5'5 following 889 916 I. L. 143 _ i. Remeasurement of some of the Stars of the above Catactogue .
Stars SouLtl of 0 Orionis .
Stars South ( continued ) .
h. 17 preceding 70z 7 4z 8 h. 54 preceding 8 57 1L751 I8 683 7 2441I 6z 39 449 3z6 536 z 207-6 88 followi ng 66 7 24 4 27 543 3 71-8 9I I8 53 8 33 4633 31 i36 93 963 93 Z 36 3~827 9o6 95 1I39 440 5 37 35 53 5833 3 103 150.1 248 1 40 3172z 420-9 101 i5r5 972z 4I 270'6 36 f 04 7587 170 ?
5 43 290g5 483 ' III 227I 591 45 24I8 117 ?
9 1 Ii2 39 6 457 47 I92z6 397 8 II7 359'5 213z 50 I63-6 I I6 7 123 380'4 284 4 52 1055 398 3 126 4i2'6 503 553 91*4 273-1 133 507'301-7 51 prececling 84 z zi38 142 following 78 36 254 9 Stars North of 0 Orionis .
Stars Northl ( continued ) .
h. 12 preceding 776-8 h ?
5 h. 86 following 63 -4 669 o I9 639-9 10Z 87 61i 99-8 32 498 286-4 1 99 14588 6IIz34 400'2 2 70'4 IO2 I44-6 48850 38 304.0 o0o !
o09 2144 272 8 44 z46-8 8-6 1o8 z IO07 440-3 48 172-9 5021I 113 277 7 658-9 49 i6vz 663 9 I2O 367 3 195 3 56 prececldng 86 r 380-4 124 38 48 584-7 70 following 9-0 96-6 129 459 0 387 975 Z~42 41,5 3j6 6z5-5 65'7 76 32 I663 137 following 666 I 363 9 79 following zI20 400 ?
4

