" On the Calculus of Symbols.-Fourth Memoir .
With Applications to the Theory of Non-Linear Differential Equations .
" By W. H. L. RUSSELL , Esq. , A.B. Received July 31 , 1863* .
In the preceding memoirs on the Calculus of Symbols , systems have been constructed for the multiplication and division of norn-commutative symbols subject to cer tain laws of combination ; and these systems suffice for linear differenitial equations .
But when we eniter upon the consideration of non-linear equations , we see at once that these methods do not apply .
It becomes necessary to invent some fresh mode of calculation , and a new notation , in order to bring non-linear functions into a conidition which admits of treatment by symbolical algebra .
This is the object of the following memoir .
Professor Boole has given , in his I Treatise on Differential Equations , ' a mnethod due to M. Sarrus , by which we ascertain whether a given non-linear function is a complete differential .
This method , as will be seen by anyonie who will refer to Professor Boole 's treatise , is equivalent to finding the conditions that a non-linlear fiuncetion may be externally divisible by the symbol of differentiation .
In the following paper I have given a niotation by which I obtain the actual expressions for these conditions , and for the symbolical remainiders arising in the course of the division , and have extended my investigations to ascertaining the results of the symbolical division of non-linear functions by linear functions of the symbol of differenitiation .
Let F ( x , y , Yl y2 , y3..-. .
y , , ) be any non-linear function , in which Yi ' Y2 , y3 *. .
y. , deniote respectively the first , second , third , nth differential of y with respect to ( x ) .
Let Ur denote fdyr , i. e. the integral of a function involving X , Y y1 , Y2 with reference to y , alone .
Let YV in like manner denote - ?
when the differentiation is supposed die , effected with reference to y , .
alone , so that V. U , F=F .
The next definition is the most important , as it is that oln which all our subsequenit calculations will depend .
WVe may suppose F differentiated ( in ) times with reference to y , , l or Yn-2 , &amp;c. , and y , y , , ' or y , _2 , &amp;c. , as the case may be , afterward equated to zero .
We shall denote this entire process by Z( } ' , Z,62 ' , Z , ( " - , &amp;c. The following definition is also of importance : we shall denote the expression d. JrIy d+ / 2 die Jr Y3 dC + d+ 8 ' d by the symbol Yr .
Having thus explained the notation I propose to make use of , I proceed d to determine the conditions that F may be externally divisible by d- , or , in other words , that F may be a perfect differential with respect to ( X ) .
It will be seen that the above notation will enable uis to obtain expressions for the conditions indicated by the process of M. Sarrus .
It is obvious that if we expand F in terms of y ?
, in order that the symbolical division with reference d-may be possible , the terms involving yn2 y3 &amp;c. must vanish .
Hence V , 2F=O , and consequently F=ZOF + y , Z ' ?
F , where , of course , ZOF , Z ' , F do not contain in .
Hence we have d ( U , ,1Z nF ) -Y , - , U , -1Z ' , F +y , ,Zf , ,F , and therefore F becomes d ( U2_1Z n)+ ZOF-Y , 1UJn-1Z IIF and if R , be the first remainder , ]1t=Z , OF-YI-YU , ,-Z/ F. The condition that this may be divisible by dd will be , as before , d xVY_PR1O= ; hence R1 becomes Zo-,1ZF -Z -1Y1U , ,-.Z ' F + ?
I , -(Z 1- , ,ZOF Z ?
F-IY ?
/lU ?
I-Z ?
IF ) .
Now dd -U , -2(Z n , - , ZOF Z , l-1Y ?
F- , U , ?
- , Z F ) Yn-2U-2z n-1Z ?
F ?
-2U ?
^-2Z ?
l-IYn _lu , ,_1Z , ,F +Y21-1(Z n-1Z}zF Z n-1Y ?
U ?
I -1 IZ ?
Y ) ; and if R2 be the second remainder , we find R2JZ'-1Z ?
FI-F Z ?
- , ?
IY , Y ? ?
2U 2Z 'n-jZnF + Yn-2U ?
, -2z ?
21-1y.-IU ?
1-1Z jF : the next condition is YVz_2R2=0 , and therefore R2= Zn2Z7 ?
1-_Z ?
F --70 rB ri/ ww0 rT / t0 -2 " n Y , -1U .
-1/ Z/ F -Z-2Y 2U 2 ' ?
-1Z ?
+ n2Yn-2TJn-2Zn-1Yn-1U ?
I-1z 21 ZF2( ?
..21IZ .
I.1ZOF + Z'n-2Z ?
UJ-1YZ-1U1 ?
-Yz1 ?
IF ZI ?
&amp; -2y ?
4-2U , ,-2Z ?
, I-ZLF + Z ?
1-2.Y ?
-2U , ?
-2Z Ii-etY ?
gt ?
-Z ?
But df dx { U , ,-3(Z ' , -2Z ?
1-Z ?
F-Z5'-2Z ?
- , Y , ,- , U , -Iz FZ I-2Yn2UTn2Z ' 1Z 1F + Z'2 y-2T.2U Z ' -lYnnUIT.itl Z'F ) }Z 0-ZF Z'n-Z'-Y , ,_U , ,Z'F =Yn -3U-n--3(Z-'n-2 i-ti n -2n -I i-Z Z-2Yn-2UUnZ'ni-ZnF + z.-2y , -2U.-2Z '-Iy , ,-IUn-Z F ) + Y , -2 ( Z n-2 ?
-_ ?
wF n_ ?
-1Y ?
, -l Un _ Z , F -Z ' I2Y.i-2Un-2Z'n-1ZOF+ Z'-2Yn-2iJq,.2Z'n-lYn .
Un..Z'nF ) whence we find R3=Zn'-Z , ?
^lZi ?
F-Z ?
-2Z ?
b1lY2slUblul-Z 2F Z ?
2Yn-2 , Un2Z'n-1ZOF + ZZ ?
2Yi-2UJn.-Z ' , , IYni-IUn-Z'nF -YnU-3U , -3Z ' -Z%%F ?
YnI3UZiOZ'n,2Z ?
-YTTU2Z'nlF + Yni3UnIJ3Z ' n_2YnT2UnJ2Z'n.Z nF Yn-3,.T-3ZI n-2Yn-2Un-2 In .
YnlIUn 1Z'j F. Hence we infer the followin)g rule for the formation of Jr , Construct the term In .-rU .
J-JZ'n-r+lyY -r+n.Un-r+IZ ' ni-rr+2yn-r+2( t-rv+2Z n-r+2 *. .
Yn-2Un-iZ'n-iYn-lUn-1Z n. In any symbol Z ' .
the accent may be changed into a zero , i. e. we may at pleasure substitute Z ?
anywhere for Z ' , , , ; but in such case the previous symbolical factor In iU , mi must be omitted .
This term is positive or negative according as the symbol Z ' occurs an even or an odd number of times in it ; the aggregate of all the terms thus formed constitute the remainder Rr , and the conditions that F may be externally divisible by are d7xd VT"F=O , Vn-_lR1=0 , V,1 2R2=0 , Vn-_3A307 &amp; C. We shall now investigate the conditions that d +P may externally divide F where P is a function of ( x ) and ( y ) .
As before , VYF=O , and in consequence F =ZOnF +ynZ'nF .
Now ( +P +P\UtiZ'nF =YniIJ V_Z'nF + PU1 , Z Z ' F+ynZ ' , F. Hence we shall have R,1 CZOF-Yw_-U , ,-1Z ' , ,F-PJn-iZ ' , F. We have Y , _R=O in order that this remainder may contain only the first power of Yn- , and R1=Z ?
_1Z ?
FZ ' YtLU1Z'.F -Z PU , -lZ'nF +yn-i(Z ' , IZOF-Z ' -iY -Un_lZ ' F-'Z'I-..PUn-.Z'nF ) , 2i siince + U'i2(z , -ZOFZ'YTJ111-1U1-Z ' ?
F slllee ~~~z 2-pulIZ Y Y1t_ + .
2)U 2-2 " FIE , ,-20F3t , -2Z ' , -lUlt-lu2zlI F-Z1 4l -PU2z_YZ'l , PF ) = PU , i-2_ / n ?
A_ Yn-2 n1Jn9Z'1iYin ... i1J-l iZ ' F 7121J7 2Z ' ?
PlJ , -1Z')1F -I yil-.1(Z ' ?
1-1Z ?
b 11Y lJ ?
^ 1Z ' , ^F -Z '^_1PIJ ?
f ... Z ' ?
F ) -+ P lJ_2Z 'z-1Z2F PU2_ zli_-ll $ dPu2z 21-YU91-1 } / 1 t Wheince we find that d+P divides R1 with a remainder , -ZO-IPU- , Z ' , nF Y , U72 , ,-2 _z1-ZOF +Y ?
i-24T.1-2Zf ?
1l-Y2-ITT1-1 Z'7F+ 1F-2U'Lz-2Z'n.-lPu'T-lZ'nF PUn,2Z ',1ZPU , F + PU , ,- , Z ' , -1Y1 , -lF.-1 ?
, F +P U-S , _2z n-1 Ip un-1 z IIF .
Putting Yj_2R2=0- , we find in like manniier , R3=Z ?
Z ?
JZ-Z)L-2Z ?
l-1Yt , Un1Z'nF Z1-2Z ?
1- , PU ?
L , -Z ' , ?
F -Z1-2Yn-2Un-2 ' ?
l- , ZF 4Z-27 IJU2Z'Z1Y1U , -l-lZt'F + F+z2 1-2 , ,IJZ , -.POIJlZ nF -Z72PU.-2Z'n IZ % F+ Z)O ?
2P , -2Z ' ?
-lY.-niIT1Z-1'7 + Z &gt; t-2PU , _2Z ',1PU , _1 ' , , FIE ?
-3I -3Z ' , ,-Z IZ % +Yn2.-13Z'71Z , -PUJn-iZ'nt -I Y , Z3IJ,3Z , ?
t-jY2U- , IT , Z ?
, t-T1Z ?
, F ?
Y.-3Un-3Z ?
2P-2U it 1Z ?
F in_(3U( ?
n-'z nP-2UnIZ1 ' ?
-PIu .
Z- ?
F +f Yt3Uzl_33 ?
F q-2P.-2TJ-2 z ?
1 lIZylF Y ?
t-31T ?
1-3ZI ?
l-2yit-2 ?
1-2Z 2t-l ?
l-U-ul- % ?
I -Y ?
-_3U ?
1 3Xn ?
_2YnJ*-2Un 2z 11 ?
U2G_1-1 Zf -PUE ?
t3 Z',2Z%.1Z ; &amp; F + PU ?
I3Z '12Z}$1 ?
[ 1U,1Z ' ?
1F + PUJI-3ZnZ ?
2 iPU ?
Z'n + nPUnZ ' ? ?
2Yn UnZ 27J nF P1TJ ?
3 AZ12z2LT , n2Z , ?
1Y-,1YluJ-1ZI , ,F -Yt-U.-3z 1 ?
-2Y}l-inR-2 % ?
&amp; -IPUII-l ?
7 , F 4PIJ , ,.3Z,2i [ l-IT , ,.9%2 ' , ,1Z ?
F PU , _3Z ' , ,2PU , 2 PU,1Y , , Y-1U-1 Z ?
YF -PU J3Z'7 2 PUJ 12PU-1PUZ , -1ZF YF .
We see at once that the v lue of J{ in this case can be formed from that calcllated in the last example , by writing P at pleasure for any one or more of the symbols Y , and taking the aggregate of the terms so formed .
The conditions of division will be , as before , VYF = 0 , VnzP1R1 = 0 , VY-2R= 0 * Now 7 fUl-4(Z'n-2Z , -lZ ?
FZ n-2Z IXY.-2U , -2Z'.F i t'-2XY ?
Z3Ui.3 1ZnF + z ?
-2XY ?
t-3U.-3Z n-IX ?
$-21i ?
W-2z I+Z nZXfL.-31Ti-3Z-XZfF + Zn-2XZ i-IXY , -2T ?
n-2Z.F + Z-2XZ-1XZ ' , ,F Z,2XZ ' , -1Z , ' , F ) XYn4Un-4Z ?
-2 %%1zoF ` -XYfj-4U-4Z fl-2Z , IXYl-2UlJ-2Z , lF %-4tJ ?
$-4 ?
-2 ) --3U ?
7 T ?
&amp; n_lZnF +XYn-4U1n-4Z ' ?
e2XZ'-3 J-XZ_ 1JZ'F + XY.g-4T ?
.-4z ?
I2XYn ?
-3TJnXnAn-2U ?
122 it +XYf ?
-4Ufl-4Z -2XZl-1XZ ' iF -XYfl.4U ?
, -4Z ?
1-2XZ ' ?
l1Z ?
&amp; F XY.-4 n2-4n 2XZYl XYZIY2UnIZ , F ?
F -F ~ so + XY ' 1-41Un-4 , 2X ?
1-3IZ ?
1-l F -I 4 XZ 42X ?
1-XZF-XZ ?
X2XZ'FZ ?
F)y ?
( Z ' -2Z ?
-1Z ?
lF -Z ' , ?
2Z%1Xy , -2U-2Z ' ?
F Z'fl-IXIYfl3lIJ-3l'. .
-ZfllZlF + Zfl..2IXIYf..3U.13Zt.-lIXIYfIUfl-2ZflF + n-2xY.-3Un-3zf ?
+ 12n 2 +x I1-AYZ11-3un-Z ? ?
1n-2XY .
2U-2ez)f2F +X So ; oInlF3 ?
-2 % ?
-XYI-2Un-X2-IZ IY XZ/ S-2XT ?
D_UI ?
$-l Zi-2U.+2Z1F2T^3 ?
-Z $-X ?
U$2 + XZ-2XZO7-3XZ ' , lFZ ?
XZ'1Z FXZ yf- , O)1-2 +An-4UniA -Z27 -2 , --XYn-2U 2Z , Yfl ?
t4ITfl4Z ?
W2IXIY3U ?
, -3Z'f ?
1-X1Yfl9ITF2 ' -KY ITZ IXF Zfl-42fl-4 31-IZ F3 +3Zfl2XI,3 ?
lP-3z 2XU ?
1 -Kn2Y nU I3Z ?
- , IXZ'1XFYZU-2Z ' -X,12 ?
, Z ' , -xY UZ2XZ01-3X ?
IF3XZ'F_jZ ?
F Wt 1-4 l-4fl-f -flD ?
Yfl-4Ufl-4Z012XZfl-1ZI ?
A +(XZ .
; -IZFl-ZXY-2Ul-Ir XY-2XZU ?
-2Z , ZF-F zn-2 ] ?
3T +2XY ?
-23U-3Z ?
1-IZO ?
+ ZOz -XZ ~~~2 n12X13U ?
-3 n1-I-,2U , -2Z F -XZ , -2XYn-37Un-3Z ?
lXZ'lF-XZ2XZ ' 1XYZ OU"2Z'3 + X'44-2Z ?
w +XY2t , -Z , F 3 Let us now assume Rr=NM , +NrYnl..r Then Mr is formed according to the following rule:-Form the term n-IIr-1tUJn-r-1z ti-i+X+11e-i-U'li-i , Z } &amp; -i+2 X eI-r+I en-r+I.^ n-r+3 Z 'm may in any place be chaniged into Z ?
, ; but in this case either the preceding XYm-2UTrn2 must be omitted , or the succeeding XYfl%4U , U-1 .
changed into X. The signs of the terms follow this law .
A term not containing X introduced in place of XYU is positive if Z ' occurs in it an even number of times , negative in the contrary case .
But every X introduiced in place of XYU occasions a change of sign .
The aggregate of all the terms thus formed will give Mr. We form N thus : construct the term XZn-r+rXYnjrTJn.rZ'n.r+2XYn.1+iJrUn_rtl ... ... Z'1F , and a precisely similar rule holds good .
R , is subject to the condition V2__rRr=O , VY-r-lYn-ArR0@ Let us now investigate the criterion that F may be divisible by d-+ pd Q dx2 dx where P and Q are functions of ( x ) and ( y ) .
Proceeding as before , we have X2 + P ) + QUUn 2Z ' d6 + P ) ( Y'_2 + Y2I-IVn-2)Unw-2z nF + QU.-2Z nF ( XY-2+ PYn-2+ Q)Un-2ZF + yZF ( X + P)Z'lF+yflZ ' , F. The form of this equation gives us the following rule to ascertain the successive remainders .
Construct the remainder in the last case as before , and substitute at pleasure Q in any place where XY is found , P in any place where X is found .
The aggregate of the term thuis formed will give the remainder in this case .
We now investigate the condition that Ci3 may be an external factor of F. We put , as before , F=Z3F+y , ,Z ' , F , where Z ' , F must contain neither y _nor Yla-2 , which gives the conditions nlF=O , V , ,Y-YF= 0 , VY-2v:F= O. Now we have dX(U,3Z'F ) Y3+Y-2V-3)U -3ZAF -d2 ( In _3U^n3Z'F + yn-2Z'f , F ) _X2Y , -3KU,3Z'_1F + y.-2X2Z ' , IF + 2y , l XZ'F ?
yX Z ' , F. And we consequelntly obtaiin R1=Z ?
F-X2Y 3UT_3Z ' , F-y , 2X2Z ' , :F-2y , ,-XZ ' , F. Introducing the coniditions itIR1=0 , Vn-2V.-1iR1-=0 , Vn-nY1R1 = 0 , and expanding in terms of Y^_i , we have R1 = ( Z0_ Z0F_ SO _1X2Y , _3U3Z ' , F ) ?
( Zi " &gt; -Z ?
FZ ' X2Y " , 3 , so " , Ffi-10 JX2Z '2tFy.-y flyn-2Z fl21 X2Z , F-2y , ,_ SO _1XZ'0F .
As the coefficient of yl_in this cannot contain Yn-2 ' we may write this expression , Rl= ( Z_1Z ?
F -Z ?
_1X2YnX3Un3Z'%F)-y-2Z ?
1X2Z'7bF +~~ 3U , Z fF 2ZO 2ZO_1XZ ' , ,F)y , ,_ .
+ ( Zn , -2Z n- , ZOzF-ZO , -2Z _1-X2y , , 3TT , _-3Z 2a 1 2 , 2 ?
1Z , })7-1 Let us now assume R. ) &gt; ^-=Lm , + M , ,+yn- , ,^_I + Nm , Yn-v , z ) where Rm is the mth remainder , and Nt , , does not contain y or yn-w--2 .
Henice , expanding in terms of , we have -I-(Z ?
~I~ -I-L , + , ,Z , ,L , )I 2AzLM + Z_ , M , y &amp; , l + Z ?
-j-+ Now dx { U 1-m_3 ( Z4 ?
1-miZ 21ILM 4 Z+ 4_ , l_Z^ ?
b_ , ,N2n ) I -d7 1 Y.1-m-3 + ?
gn-me-2vnk-7n-31T_ ; }t- ?
n-3 { Z J , Z_7s , q Z , -p , -1 ?
_ , N , + X2(Z ?
_ " , _IZ ' , _ " , zL , ,+Z_ , _l07z77 * +,7z + 2X(Z ?
( Z , , , 1_',1LZ , L+ ( ZO11_M(Z 1Z',21 , ,-L I+ Z ?
211-lZ,1_9N , )y1N .
Hence RI , il =(Z=4-1-X 'Yt , _n3T-%-m-3201 7,1)L Zf , -(X2Y1j Z. .
nmL 7Z '1m P 2 , m-.])n _(X2Z0^_7sl_IZ 21_7 , " L1 , l+ X2Z*l7_Z , ,^_Izo-NT")/ t &gt; ( 2X , Z-O_Z11 &gt; l , Z,4_,6 , f + 2XZ11_-$ lz-l sN1)t-Now consider for a moment the equations Lrn+l Gm , ,lL))j + I-IJ , ,VIm , + Km , INl , s , N"1+1 Git P [ Ja7 { fE '1m , and suppose that L3 , +1 AiLmo^ -+ ivji , ~M2 , ^_+ VlIN &amp; -l =\2L ; 2 -+1.2jM , _2 4 V2NI = &amp; C. =XLI -r + rlnrn + &amp;c. Then we find =G G1Lf-IlG I.i -2 + R^II7m-IGIi -2+Kin. .
i,1-Rm-2 4 GlnIX)n-iGI 3m-2 + 4IJ-1Gl ' m21O KMK.2 + In ' -G if2M -23 X3= GqzG .
IG2n-2G)n-3 + IIG Inm-AnG.-A2Gin.-3 + K , )UGlG.,3(3 , ,,..3(3.m3 + G. , JI " , n.CG%n22G(m-3 + H. 11 [ I4-3Gfn-2Gm -3+ Km'iITm-2G , l(G)n-3 + GIRI2KsIn-G iS'n-An,3 + I. , VIK Ix$lG'teezG 11inR_3 + W.,2zK"1 ' , ,-_G ' ' .
, m2Gm- , _3+ Gj , ljGjjj_IHv ?
,2G 'jj-3 + Il2)tG2n-113[1n-2G m-3 + IK1MG .
I)'J-rTlnG'jm0-3 + G.)nHjl-lml ' , m-2G',.n-3 + Jl , llm-1JlE-2GR m-3 + ( A , IIH(1 ?
l{Hm-2G0 r-3 +4 J lJ , m"'(n-I1I(m 2Gm.-3 + Gwoban H the fllowRIng-3 +r Hfr thIne d rinatIo o-3 down thGeeirml .
G , m2G , ?
n-3 + may.sub-stittKe-2G Hn-3 ?
HKIIIGI I)n1KImz_2G I fm3 + GeVIH i )nl_KIm-l2G 11 -3 ?
G)sz ?
XI-IK 11 m1-2G ll m-3 + HRXIvlOl_K 11 z_2R ?
2 i-3 + KIIXK 21 )1-IKif ?
in-R if)1-3 , Ilence we obtain the followinog rule for the determination of AX , _--rite down the term G , , , G , , , -IG , ,-2 I Gl-rl We may substitute H and Ki at pleasure for G anywhere except in the last factor , which is always G. Whenever we put II for G , the succeeding letter is to receive a single accent ; whenever K for G , the succeeding letter receives a double accent .
The aggregate of all the terms thus formed will be X. , and we may of course obtain similar expressions for r , &amp; ' Now if we put Gt ?
z= )I ?
n1 i Y-l21-3T-Tit-i-3zon-nzt-IZ ?
t-t ?
HIM= 0 , JHI= 0 , K,1 , 1 --2Z 1lt-l K1 =2XZO- , iitlZo1m,1 we shall find the above equations satisfied ; and consequently the last investigation gives the law of the form'ation of the remainders .
Each remainder will of course be subject to the three conditions already exhibited .
These results point out the foundations on which symbolical division , as applied to non-linear functionis , lmust rest .
We have confined our attention to external division , as more particularly applicable to these functions .
When a non-linear equation is proposed for reduction , we mllust ascertain whether it admits of an external factor by employing the method of divisionr as already explained .

