II .
" On the Conditions , Extent , and Realization of a Perfect Musical Scale on Instruments with Fixed Tones .
" -By ALEXANDER J. ELLIS , B.A. , F.C.P.S. Communicated by C. WHEATSTONE , Esq. , F.R.S. Received January 7 , 1864 .
EULER* , perceiving that the relative pitches of all musical notes might be represented by 2m .
3n .
5P , formed different " I genera musica " by allowing n and p to vary from O to fixed limits .
His " genus diatonicum hodiernum " ( op .
cit. p. 135 ) limits n to 3 and p to 2 , and consists of 12 tones .
These tones and 12 others are contained in his " genus cujus exponens est 2- .
37 .
52 , , " that is , which limits n to 7 and p to 2 .
He has further ( i1 .
p. 161 ) given a scheme in which each manual of an instrument should represent two sounds , the primary belonging to the first 12 tones , and the secondary to the additional 12 .
He says ( ib. p. 162 ) , " Soni secundarii summo rigore ab iisdem clavibus edi nequeunt , quia vero tam parum a primariis discrepant , ad eos exprimendos hae claves sine isensibili harmonice jactura tuto adhiberi possunt .
Nam etiamsi ab acutioribus auribus comma secu diasckisma , quibus intervallis soni secundarii a primaris differunt , distingui queat , tamen quia soni secundarii cum primariis neque in eademn consonantia neqaGe in duarum consonantiarum successione misceri possunt , error etiam ab acutissimo auditu percipi non poterit .
" It will appear in the sequel that these assertions , when tested by experiments on instruments with fixed tones , are all incorrect .
The musical scale has formed the subject of many recent investigations * ; but I have been unable to find a complete account of the necessary coiw ditions to be fulfilled by a perfect scale , the least number of fixed tolnes required , and the practical means of producing them uncurtailed without inconvenience to the performer , although instruments which produce a limited number of just tones have been practically used by Gen. Perronet Thompson , Mr. Poole , Prof. Hlelmholtz , Prof. Wheatstone , myself , and others .
This is therefore the subject of the present paper .
The following notation is employed .
I have introduced it for the purpose of supplying a want which has been greatly felt by all writers on the theory of music .
It is founded on the principle of retaining the whole of the usual notation unaltered , but restricting its signification so as to prevent ambiguity , and introducing the smallest possible number of additional signs to express the required shades of sound with mathematical accuracy , selecting such signs as are convenient for the printer , and harmonize with the ordinary notation of accidentals on the staff .
A letter , as C , called a ntoie , will represent both a certain tone and its pitch , defined to be the liunuber of double vibrations in one second , to which the tone is due .
The letters D , E , F , G , A , B represent other tones and pitches , so that 8D=9C , 4E=5C , 3F=4C , 2G=3C , 3A=5C , 8B=15C .
Small and numbered letters will be so used that 1I 1418 c=_c =C _1=. .
a2C=4 C4 =8 ell and similarly for other letters .
The pitch of c is that of the " tenor or middle c , " usually written on the leger line between the treble and bass staves ; and the other letters are noted on the staff as usual in the scale of C major .
The following symbols always represent the fractionis , and are called by the names written against them : 1 .
Following a Note .
135 = sharp , or greater limma .
-12-8 _ -18 = flat , or hypolimma .
x== double sharp ; b= b. = double flat .
2 .
Preceding a Note .
t 81 = acute , or comma .
80 1= = grave , or hypocomma .
639§ 63septime ( an inverted 2 ) .
32808 1-001129150390625 schisma .
327168 3278 0 99887212315 = hyposchisma .
The name and pitch of the tones represented by any such notes as 80 135 25 +c# = grave csharp = C.c.l2 =2c , teb-=acute e flat =_ 8( .
e. , 135 = 4e , and the ratio of their pitches to the corresponding notes in the scale of C major is therefore precisely indicated .
In ordinary musical notation on the staff , it is only necessary to prefix the signs t , 1 , Z , , L , to those already in use .
These symbols suffice for writing any tone whose index is the producit 2m .
3n .
5p .
72 ( see Tables I. and 1II .
) .
For equally tempered tones , when it is necessary to distinguish them , the sign 11 is prefixed to the usual names , and read " equal .
" Since 11g : c &gt; 27 : 1=0 998871384584 x3 and L:c 0 99887212315 x 2 , Ve may without sensible error consider lyg = 16g , and hence represent the equally tempered scale C , d !
2,2 IId , lljj , IeI , lelf , If# , l , 1Y 0 ) 11fa , lbb , 1lb by ncacl atig _2 relative pit1ces or interval , nd a1 questin2b s o5tb m In calculating relative pitches or inltervals , and in all q^uestions of temperament , it is most convenient to use ordinary logarithms to five places , becauise the actual pitches , and the length of the monochord ( which is the reciprocal of the relative pitch ) , can be thus most easily found .
In Table I. the principal intervals are given as fractions , logarithms , and degrees .
If we call 0-00568 one degree , then 53 degreess030Q104=log 2-0-00001 , and 31 degrees-017608=log a3-000001 .
If we moreover represenit the addition and subtraction of 0-00035 ( or one-sixteenth of a degree ) by an acute or grave accent respectively , then 17 ' degrees=0 09691 =log , and 1 ' degree=0 00533=_log8 8-0 00007 .
Two numbers of degrees which differ by a single accent of the same kind , as 17 ' , 17 " represent notes whose real interval is a schisma ( thus e has 17 ' degrees ; and dx , =T ?
e , has 17 " degrees ) , having a difference of logarithm=0-00049 or 0 ' degrees + 0-00014 .
By observing this , degrees may be very conveniently used for all calculation of intervals between tones of pitches represented by 2 " ' .
3 " .
5 " .
Table IV .
contains a list of tones which differ from each other by a schisma , and will be useful hereafter .
The conditions of a perfect musical scale are not discovered by taking all the tones which can be expressed by one of Euler 's " Cexponents , " nor by forming all the tones which are consonant with a certain tone , and then all the tones consonant with these , as Drobiscli has done .
Such processes produce many useless , and omit many necessary tones .
Since modern music depends on the relations of harmonies , and not on scales , it is necessary to find what consonant chords of three tones are most closely connected Three tones whose pitches are as 4 : 5 : 6 , or 10 12 : 15 form a major or minor consonant chord respectively .
The same names are used when any one or more of the pitches is multiplied or divided by a power of 2 , notwithstanding the dissonant effect in some cases .
Thus , C : E : G4 : 5 ; 6 is a major , and c : te:g=10:12 : 15 is a minor chord , and the same names are applied toe::g " : C4=5 : 2x 6 : 22 X4 , and G te : : 15 : 2x 12 : 22 x 10 , although these chords are really dissonant ( Helmholtz , ib. p. 333-4 ) .
I shall consequently use a group of capitals , as CGE G , to Tepresent a major chord , and a group of small letters , as ?
tefg , to represent a minor chord , irrespective of the octaves .
The three notes in this order , being the first , third and fifth of the major or minor scale commencing with the first , are called the first , third and fifth of the chords respectively .
Both chords contain a fifth , a major and a minor third .
If the interval of the fifth is contained by the same tones in a major and minor chord , as There are consonant chords of four tones , such as gb d2 f2 and these are insisted on by Poole ( loc. cit. ) ; but , though they are quite consonant and aoreeable , and much pleasanter than the dissonant chords by which they are replaced , such as gb dtf2 , they do not form a part of modern music , for reasons clearly laid down by H Imholtz ( op .
cit. p. 295 ) .
Dissonant chords mnst always arise from the union of tonies belonging to two consonant chords , or from the inversions of consonant chords ; and therefore their tones are determined with those of the others .
C E G , c tet g , or A E , ac e , the chords are here termed &amp; ynonymous .
If the interval of the major third is contained by the same tones , as CE G , ae e ; or tEb G tBt , C tel g , they are termed relative .
If two chords , major or minor , have the fifth tone of the one the same as the first tone of the other , as FA C , CE G ; fta7 c , c te5 g ; fta5 , CE G ; FA C , c te g , they are here termed dominative .
If a chain of three such dominative chords 'be formed ( as FA C , CE G , GB D , or f tab c , c tee g , g t6L d , the minor and major chords being interchanged at pleasure ) , the first is called the subdominant , the second the tonic , and the third the dominant .
Three such chords contain seven tones , and if such octaves of these tones are taken that all seven tones may lie within the compass of one octave they form a scale , of which 24 varieties can be formed by varying the major and minor chords , and beginning with the first of any one of the three chords .
These scales include all the old ecclesiastical modes and several others .
If all three chords are major and the scale begins on the first of the tonic chord , the result is the major scale , C , D , E , F , G , A , 1X , c. If all three chords are minor and the scale begins on the first of the tonic chord , the result is the minor descending scale , c ' , t 6 , g , f , te ' , d , c. If the first and second are mninor , and the third major , or if the first and third are major and the second minor , we have the two usual ascending minor scales , c , d , teb , f , g , tab , 6 , c , or c , d , te , f &gt; , g , a 6 , eq. Three major chords may therefore be considered to represent a major scale , but both major and minor chords are necessary for the various minor scales .
If to each of three domninative major chords we form the relative and synonymous minor chords , the synonymous and relative majors of these , and the relative minor of this synonymous major , we shall have a group of 9 major and 9 minor chords , which I shall call the k7ey of the first of the tonic chord .
Thus the following is the Key of C. RELATIVE MA .
Synonymous PRIMARY Relative SYNO N. MA .
( Sub- ) Rela(of Syn .
Mi .
) .
Minor .
MAJOR .
Minor .
( of Rel .
Mi .
) .
tive Minor .
tAb C tEb f tab eFA C:cl f aSD +FJ A tb tcd tf $ tEb G tBb Cteb gCEGaceA tC# E tfo a cs tBbID tF gtb dGBDe gb E +GB O These chords contain 16 tones , which , when reduced to the compass of the same octave , form the complex scale c , tc# , td , d , teD , e , f , ( tf ) , $tf t g , Jg# , take , a , t6 , ( lb ) , c &gt; , of which the acute fourth ( tf ) , and the grave seventh ( lb ) , have been enclosed in parentheses , as being of rare occurrence .
, From this complex scale 54 scales of 7 tones each may be formed , similar to the 24 scales already named .
A selection of 12 tones , suich as c , t14 , d , ted , e , f , If , g , tab , a , 6I , , 6 , c0 forms the so-called chromatic scale , which , however , has no proper existence except in equal temperament .
Now proceed to form a series of seven dominative major chords , as E1ITGSB , 4 IDF FAC , CEG GIG BD , DFf tA tC city .
and form the five related chords of each as before .
The result will be five keys , as those of BL , F , C , G , D , such that the primary major scales of each wilI have either two major chords , or one major chord in common with the originial primary major scale .
I call these five keys the postdominant,.subdominant , tonic , dominant , and stuperdominant keys , and the whole group of 21 major and 21 minor chords , with the 30 tones which they contain , I term the systern of the first tone of the toici chord of the original primary major scale , which tone may be called the tonic of the system .
A piece of muisic is written in a certain system .
, determinied by the compass or quality of tone of the instruments or voices which have to perform it , and rarely exceeds that system .
It is only in the system that the true relation of the tones of a piece of music , the course and intentioni of the modulation , and the return to the original key or scale can be appreciated .
I have not yet found these relations fully expressed in any theoretical work on music ; but their full expression was necessary to the solution of the problem here proposed .
It will be found practically that only II systems are used in music .
These are , in dominative order , the systems of 42Db , ic , Ei , Bb , F , C , G , D , tA , tE , tBJ , which contain the II keys of the same name , together with the 4 keys of +0C , G7 , and tF# , tCB .
In Table V. , columns III .
to VIII .
, the whole of the major and minor chords of these 15 keys are exhibited in dominative order ? .
This Table , therefore , furnishes the tones which mutst be contained in a perfect musical scale of fixed tones , or the conditions of the problem .
on examination it will be found that these six columns contain 72 different notes .
Hence the extent of a perfect scale is fixed at 72 tones to the octave .
It is therefore six times as extensive as the equally tempered scale .
Some means of reducing this unwieldy extent is required .
The most obvious is that proposed by Euler , in the passage already quoted , namely , the use of certaini tones for others which differ from them by a comma or diaschisma .
Such substitution within the same chord creates intolerable dissonance .
But in melody and in successions of chords it might seem feasible .
I have had a concertina tuned , so that the three chords of The u-se of the eqLially tempered scale has muiELch climinished the fee6ing for th relations otf the system , by confoLudinu tonies originally distinct , and has thus led to the confusion of the corresponding niotes .
Thus such a note tas jgy will have to be readl as jg# , g , tu ; T4b , a or tcO , according to the requhirements of the system , for all six tones are representec by one on the eqLually tenpered seal . ?
The Table of ey-relationships ( ToncG7tenveivazncltsc/ h , tte-t ) in Gottfried Webr 's lIeoric clr Tonsetzktwst ( 3rd ed. 1830 , vol. ii .
p. 8G ) , may be form from Table V. , by suLppressing , the sigons , Ii supposing all the niotes to represent temiipered tones , contracting the n mies of the chords to their first notes , and extending the Table indefinitely in all directions .
the major scale of D are played as GB D , D F , tA , and A +Cj E , instead of tA C : tE .
The dominant chord is therefore too flat by a comma , and in passing from the chord of A to that of D , as in the ordinary cadence , the note A has to be changed into tA .
If A is the highest or lowest note in the chords , the effect is decidedly bad .
The flatness of the " leading note " 4C# , in place of C# , although only a comma in extent , is felt as annoying in the sLiccession +c+ , d. The result is such that it would not be worth while to invent new instruments with such a defect in common scales .
On the same instrument I have the three chords of the major scale of A tuiied as D F# tA , A +C# E , E+G# B , in which the subdominant chord is now a comma too sharp .
As the subdominant is a much less important chord than the dominant , the effect is better , but trouble arises from having occasionally to alter the tonic note A itself .
Even the dissonance of the dominant seventh , when played as E+GS Bd is perceptibly harsher than the correct E+G# B td ( both forms lie on the instrument ) , although the added seventh d now forms a true minor third with the fifth B , whereas the correct note td forms a dissonant Pythagorean minor third with the same note B. When , however , the first E is omitted , the chord of the diminished fifth 4G# B 4d is not so pleasant as GB d. Again , on the same instrument , instead of having 4D +FA , as the synonymous major of +df a in the scale of a miinor , I have only D F1 $ tA , which is a comma too sharp .
The rarity of the chord , however , renders the bad effect of less importance .
Again , I am obliged to modulate from D major to td minor instead of d minor .
Even here the error of a comma is perceptible .
The general result , therefore , is that commatic mbstitution , even within the same melody or succession of chords , is inadmissible in just intonation .
Professor I-Ielmholtz ( op .
cit. pp. 433 &amp; 484 ) has suggested what may be termed schismatic substitution , or the use of one note for another which only differs from it by a schisma , the eleventh part of a comma .
Having one concertina tuned to equal temperament , and another to just intervals , the equation Jlg= Lg has enabled me to test this suggestion by practice .
I find that in slow chords , the altered fifth c j6g , the altered major third 16b 6 , and the altered minor third e L6g are all decidedly , though only slightly , dissonant .
In rapid chords the effect would be necessarily much less perceptible .
Such chords as CESG , e Ig b are far superior either to the Pythagorean C tE C , teg tb ( of which I can produce the counterparts F tA4 C , df ta ) , or the still worse tempered chords C IIE I1 G , Ile I1g lb. If we modified Professor Helmholtz 's suggestion , and , where practicable , used only entire chords which are too flat or too sharp by a schisma , so that the schismatic errors would only occtur in harmonies where a note was prolonged from a chord to which it belonged into another for which it was too sharp or too flat by a schisma , then there could be no objection whatever to schismatic substitution , which would be quite inappreciable in melody .
Now schismatic substitutio-n will materially reduce the numilber of diffferenit tonies required .
By referring to Table IV .
it will be seen that all the tones in Table V. , lines 1 to 8 , throughout all the columns are exactly one schismaflatter than the corresponding tones in lines 10 to 17 .
Hence we only require the tones in lines 5 to 13 in order to reproduce the whole Table , with the help of schismatic substitution .
It is , however , more convenient to use columns III .
, IV .
, lines 14 to 17 , in place of columns I. and II .
, lines 5 to 8 ; and columns VII .
, VIII .
, liines I to 4 , in place of columns IX .
and X. , lines 10 to 13 .
In this case only 48 tones will be required .
If the schismatic substitution of 4f , ab , cb for e : , gy , tb were allowed , which would introduce three schismatic errors of no great importance , the number of tones would be reduced to 45 , which is the lowest possible number of tones by which a complete scale can be played .
All these tones are enumerated in Table III .
There are several ways of realizing such a scale in whole or in part* .
The following appears to be the most feasible , as it would render the mere mechanism of playing a perfect scale on an organ or harmonium easier than that of playing the tempered scale on the same instruments .
On a board of manuals similar to that now in use for the organ , introduce two additional red manluals ( of the same shape as the black , but with a serrated front edge to be recognizable by blind and colour-blind performers , as in some cases on General Perronet Thompson 's organ ) in the two gaps between B and U , and between E and F , so as to make 14 manuals in all .
Let there be 16 stops worked as pedals with the foot , as in Mr. Poole 's Euharmonic Organi ( loc. cit. p. 209 ) .
Let one of these stops give the equally tempered tones to the manuals , so that any piece could be played in the tempered scale , and thus compared with the same piece when played with just intervals .
Let the 15 other stops give the tones required for the 15 keys tC to C# , as shown in Table II .
, and be numbered 7b , 6 b ... 1 b , natural , 1 ... 7 # .
When any pedal is put down , let the seven white manuals give the seven tones of the primary major scale of the corresponding key , and the seven coloured manuals give seven out of the nine other tones required to complete the key , omitting the acute fourth ( which would be found in the key of the dominant ) and the grave seventh ( which would be found in the key of the subdominant ) .
To the right of each white manual let there be its conjugate coloured manual , of such a value that , if the seven tones of the major scale be indicated by the numbers 1 to 7 , the tones corresponding to the manuals in any key may be Coloured. .
1 II 2 t3b 14# 15# t6b t7b White ... .
123456 7 .
Table II .
shows the tones associated with the manuals in each stop ; capital letters indicate white manuals , small letters black , and small capitals red* , By this arrangement the fingering of every key would be the same .
The performer would disregard the signature except as naming the pedal , and play as if the signature were natural .
Table V. would inform him whether the accidentals belonged to the key , its dominant , or any other key ; and if they indicated another key , he would change the pedal .
It would be convenient to mark where a new pedal had to be used ; but no change would be required in the established notation ? .
Mr. Poole 's organ , which suggested the above arrangement , has 11 stops , from 5b to 5# , and only 12 manuals , which appear to be associated with the following tonies on each stop : Black1. .
3/ 2 ( t2# , ) ( 4# , ) t,5# g7b WAhite. .
1234567 The two manuals whose notes are put in parentheses are inadequately described .
Mr. Poole 's scale does not include the synonymous minor chords , which he plays by commatic substitution .
Another method of realizing such a scale is by additional manuals and additional boards of manuals .
Thus three boards of manuals , each with 23 manuals , containing the tones in Table V. cols .
III .
to VIII .
, lines 4 to 8 , 7 to 11 , and 10 to 14 respectively would be nearly complete .
The manuals might be similar to those on General T. Perronet Thompson 's Eiiharrnonic Organ , which has 3 boards , with 20 , 23 and 22 manuals respectively , and contains the chords in Table V. cols .
III .
, lines 6 to 11 ; IV .
6 to 12 ; V. , VI .
, VII .
, 5 to 12 ; VIII .
and IX .
, 6 to 12 ( four chords belonging to col .
IX .
, lines 6 to 9 , are not in the Table , but can be readily supplied , as well as the additional lines 0 , 1 , niamed below ) .
Euler 's " genus cujus exponens est 2- .
37 .
52 , " as developed in his T'entamen , p. 161 , must be considered as adapted for an instrument with two boards of ordinary manuals , such as some harmoniums are now constructed .
His " soni primarii " would occupy the lower , and his " I soni secundarii " the uipper board .
If to these we add their schismatic equivalents , enclosed in brackets , and distinguish white and black manuals by capital an(I small letters as in Table II .
, Euler 's scheme will appear as follows , where the notation interprets his arithmetical expressions of pitcl ( " soni " ) , and not his notes ( " signa sonora " ) , which are too vaguie .
EULER'S DOUBLE SCHEME .
Upper Board .
Schism .
Equiv.al ... [ I el Td , &gt; , ID , ef , F &gt; , IF , tl# , I G/ , a5l , 103 , 1551c aSoni Secuindarii " B$ : , ct , Cx , dZ ?
tE , E#1t ; ffl F x , r/ 2 t-41 tacl tB .
Lower Board .
" Soni Primarii " .
0 , tc# , D , td# , En IF f , G , ig , A , aC , B Schism .
Equival ... [ htP ' , ttd , Ebb , te5 , JF21 t d2 , 41Ig , A ?
b , a0 , tBk , tb &gt; , tI I Although it is evident from his notation that Euler regarded schismatic equivalents as identities , he has not especially alluded to them .
The above scheme would contain Table V. col .
V. , lines 0 to 14 , and the major thiird trF tA4 in 15 ( with the schismatic error of 1 ?
B &gt; ?
TD F for B &gt; 9 tD F ) , col .
VI .
1 to 15 ; VII .
9 to 24 ; VIII .
10 to 24 ; IX .
18 to 24 ; III .
-1 to 5 ; IV .
0 to 6 .
It would be therefore niearly complete in major scales , but would have only td , a , e , 6 , fi , c4 , g : minor , and their comparatively useless schismatic equivalents .
It would have no single complete key , and would therefore require many commatic substitutions in modulation , and the use of the Pythagorean major third in the major chords of the comparatively common minor scales of Tf , tc , tg .
If only the " soni primarii " of the lower board are used the substitutions become very harsh , as for example A# D F , D F:A for B5 tD F , D F$ tA .
Euler 's " soni primarii " may be compared with Rameau 's scale * , which was as follows , c , t tD , te5 , E IF Tf ?
j GI t4l A , f 6 &gt; , B , and therefore only colntained the following perfect harmonies , and two perfect scales , A major and a minor : -tD FFAC tdfa tDtF$ , A tLt GLtB , c tbg CEG ace A4ICcE gtb GB egb E4IG#B .
Prof. Helmholtz has tuned an harmoniium with two boards of manuals , somewhat in Euler 's manner , as follows : HELMHOLTZ'S DOUBLE SCHEME .
Upper Board .
Schism .
equiv. [ tjC , db , t-D , die , ^b F , q9j tGI a5 , Al 61 ( 62 Tones tuned. .
BZ , tc# , Cx , d : , tE , tE# , tf# ) , Fx , g , Gx , ta , tB .
Lower Board .
Tones tuned. .
C , c$ , D , td ) , E , E : , f# , G , tg# , tA , at , B Schism .
equiv. [ t_Db , tdb , Ebb , 1eb , J^ tF , to , Abb , take , 0fb , tb5 , I 0 ] This scheme has nearly the same extent and the same defects as Euler 's .
The concertina , invented by Prof. Wheatstone , F.R.S. , has 14 manuals to the octave , which were originally tuned thus , as an extenision of Euler 's 12-tone scheme .
C ' , tc# , D , td# , E , ) F , f , G , yGI , A , fatO , B , tbO .
It possessed the perfect major and minor scales of C and E. The harshness of the chords tB9 ' D , F , D F$ A , for lb tD F , D F4 tA has , however , led to the abandonment of this scheme , and to the introduction of a tempered scale .
I have taken advanitage of the 14 manuals to contrive 4 different methods of tuning , so that 4 concertinas would play in all the commoi major and minor scales .
Two of these I have in use , and find them effective and very useful for experimental purposes .
The following gives the arrangement of the manuals in each , together with the scales possessed by each instrument , major in capitals , and minor in small letters .
Where commatic substitution makes the dominant chord too flat in major scales , parentheses ( ) are used ; where it makes the subdominant chord too sharp , brackets [ ] are used .
Minor scales in brackets have only the subdominant tone too sharp .
The major chord GBD and the tone C being common to all four instruments , determine their relative pitch .
The method of tuning these and all justly intoned or teleon * instruments is very simple .
C being tuned to any standard pitch , the fifths above and below it are tuned perfect .
To any convenient tone thus formed , as C itself , form the major thirds above , as EL , $0# , tB# , &amp;c. , and below as tAb , tFb &amp;c. , and then the fifths above and below these tones .
The namnes of the tones thus tuned are apparent from Table V. This tuning is much simpler than any system of temperament , and can be successfully conducted by ear ornly , taking care to avoid all beats in the middle octave e to C2 .
SCHEME FOR FouR CONCERTINAS .
1 .
tAb Concertina .
Manuials. .
C b6 , _D d &gt; , E te , F Prf , G jg , A ta7 , B tbb , Scales ... .D &gt; , tAL , tE &gt; , ( t^B ) , [ F ] , C ; [ h ] , f , c. 2 .
tB &gt; C1oncertina .
Manuals. .
C te , D c# , tE 1r'2 , F f : , G tg , tA ta5 , B fbt , Scales ... .
tE &gt; , tB , tF1 ( tC ) , [ G ] , D ; [ c ] , g , d. 3 , C Concertina .
Manuals. .
C ; te , tDd , E tdj , F f$ .
G t4 ) A rta , B b5n Scales .
II , C , G,1 ( D ) , [ A ] , E ; [ td ] , a , e. 4 .
D Concertina .
Manuals C c# , D td# , E te , EB : ft , GO g# , tA at , B tb , Scale ... .e GI DI tA , [ tE ] [ B]~:F# [ e ] b , ft In Table III .
the first column shows the number of degrees of any tone , two tones whose degrees differ by one-sixteenth being schismatic equivalents .
The second column contains the notes of the tones .
The third column contains the loogarithm .
of the ratio of their pitch to that of c , whence the ratio itself , the absolute pitch , and the length of the monochord are readily found .
In the fourth column E marks Euler 's primary , and E2 his secondary tones ; H , H2 the tones on Helmholtz 's lower and upper board ; T , the 40 tones of General T. Perronet Thompson 's Enharmonic Organ ; Pi the 50 tones of Mr. Poole 's Euharmolnic Organ ; t , the 72 tones of Table V. , cols .
III .
to VIII .
; 8 , the 24 tones out of these 72 which may be played as their adjoining schismatic substitutes without injuring the harmony ; se , the 3 tones which , if played as their schismatic equivalents , would produce a slight but sensible error ; t , not followed by either s or se , the 45 tones which form the minimum number of a justly intoned or teleon scale ; et , the 12 tones of the equally tempered scale .
The seven tones of the major scale of C are printed in capitals in the second column .
TABLn I.-Principal Musical Intervals .
Name .
Example .
Ratio , or Log. Deg .
Unison , ... , , , , , ... . .
c : c 1:1 1:1 '00000 0 ?
T Schisma ... ... .
, , , , , , , tB a : G 32805 : 32768 39 , 5:211 00049 0 ' t4 iDiaschisma ... ... ... . .
c : B# 2048 : 2025 211:34,52 00491 1 " t Comma ... , , , , , te : G 81:80 34:24.5 *00540 1 ' t ?
Pythagorean Comma ?
ttB3 : c 631441:52488 312 : 219 '00589 1 tt4 Diesis ... ... ... db : tcl 128 : 125 27 : 53 01030 2 " ' t Minor Semitone. .
t , jet : c 25:24 52 23.3 '01773 3 " j4Limma ... ... ... ... . .
c tB 256:243 28:35 '02263 4 : harp , or Greater Limma c : : 135:128 335 .
27 '02312 4 ' tL7W Equal Semitone* .
e lc 1V2 : 1 *294 : 349 , ,57 02509 4-7Greater Semitone ... .
a : B1 6 : 15 24 3 .
5 02803 5 ' Greatest Semitone ... ... t4 : c 2187 ; 2048 37:211 '02852 5 Greatest Limma ... .
6 .
td : c : 27 : 25 33 : 52 03343 6 " Minor Tone ... ... ... ... o : d 10 9 2.5 : 32 04576 8 ' Greater Tone ... ... ... ... d : c 9 : 8 32 : 23 05115 9 Extended Tone ... ... ... g : f 8 : 7 23 : 7 05799 10 } Contracted 3rd ... ... ... .
gf d 7:6 7 : 2 .
3 06695 114 Pythagorean Minor 3rd f : d 32 : 27 25:33 '07379 13 Minor 3rd A ... ... ... g : e 6:5 2.3:5 07918 14 ' Major 3rd ... ... ... ... . .
e : c54 5:22 '09691 17 ' Pythagorean Major 3rd .
to : c 81 : 64 34:2 '10231 18 Fourth , or Perfect 4th ... f : c43 23 3 '12494 22 False 4th ... ... .
, , , , , , , , d : A 27 : 20 32 22.5 '13033 23 ?
Contracted 5th ... ... ... .
f : b 7 : 5 7:5 14613 25r Diminished 5th ... ... . .
f : b 64::4 26 : 32 5 '15297 27 ' False 5th ... ... ... . .
a : d 40 : 27 232 5:33 '17070 30 ' Eqcjal 5th ... .j .
lig c V27 : 1 *214 : 37 .
5 '17560 31 ' Fifth , or Perfect 5th g : c32 3 : 2 '17609 31 Pythagorean Minor 6th:tE 128 : 81 27 : 34 19872 35 Minor 6th.a : E85 23:5 '20461 36 ' Major 6th ... ... ... ... .
a : c53 5 : 3 '22185 39 ' Pythagorean Mlajor 6th ta : c 54 : 32 2 .
33 , : 25 '22724 40 Diminished 7th ... ... ... .
f : 128 : 75 2 : 3 .
52 23215 41 " Extended 6th ... ... ... .
d:gF 12:7 22 .
3:7 '2340841-3 Perfect 7th ... ... . .
gf : G 7 : 4 7 : 22 '24304 424 Minor 7th ... ... ... ... . .
f : G 16:9 24 : 32 '24988 445 Acute Minor 7th ... ... . .
tbb : c 9 : 5 32:5 '25527 45 ' Major 7th ... ... ... ... . .
b : c 15 : 3.5:23 '27300 48 ' Octave ... ... ... ... ... .
a : C21 2:1 '30103 53 ?
Hence the symbol ?
for Pythagoras , with the t ( comma ) prefixed .
@ Approximately .
=P1 u 4 .
&gt; . .
&gt; .
4+:4-14t +4+4+4+4 +4 +P4 +4q +4 R PP PR : 0i ____________________4 -4 4 -1 -F 02 tmI Ae 1--2n ee d-%n 11 d AU4 " eM ce e Ca -H-+-+H+ - , ~~~~ +-4-4_HI_ _ __ __ __,.._ __ | |________ _____ &lt; 4-______ 4 +-H-++4+44--+ 4-4cd C o_ _ _)I ________________ _L1m 5a .
III I$L O~~~ * ... p.c Ij +4+4+ O ( Q _ .
_ , _ __ __ ... ... ... . .
____ P-4 ~~~~Og ~~~~~00 4-WCWCcccH4+C4 IC4 C+eC+~44C9 CH 0 +44-~~~~~+-I +++ 6j ~~~~~~~~~~+4-+H--l-++-+ 4 4 , C , A V. 1II AAAN o om 0 II .
_ 0 " ~~~~~~~~~~++ 1++ 4 4---4--4--~ 00I _4 I-..I a _____..'-,.-.-.- ... - .
U0 +4+4 0I2 4-+ ++ 4-+ +-+ ++ -4--+440 +4+4+4+4 +4 +4+4+44+4+4+4 + +4+4-+4 -~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~ --4 4 ; -+ I+ 4IP-4V1 3Ma Cd ++ 4+4+44+4+ +43 __ *~~~~I~ __ __zCN qy 4xo(Ct TABLE III .
Genleral List of Musical Tones .
Deg .
Note .
Log. Remarks .
Deg .
Note .
Log. Remarks .
0C 00000 E , H , T , P , t , et .
19 ' tte 10770 t. 0 ' fb : 00049 t , s. 20 " ttf 11365 t. r tc 00540 T , t. 20 " ' te 11464 T. 2 " ' ttc : 01233 T. 204 gf 11810 P. 21 gtdb 01579 P. 21 ' tf 11954 T , P , t. 3 ' ttdb 01724 t , s. 21 " e 12003 E2 , H , P , t , se .
3 " , tc : 01773 E , T , P , t. 22 F 12494 E , T , P , t. 4 tdb 02263 P , t , s. 22 ' te : 12543 H2 , t , s. 4 ' c 02312 E2 , H , T , P , t. - .
llf 1et=_e_ .
I ~~~~22 17 If 12543 et=te~ .
4-v jjc~ -02509 et. .
___________ _____ ____02509_et .
23 ' tf 13033 T , t. 5 ' d7 02803 T , t. 237 gtg 14073 P. 5 tc : 02852 Hf2 , P , t , s. 25 " tf : 14267 T , P , t. 7 " , ttd 04036 t. 26 to 14757 P , t , s. 77 gd 04431 P. 26 ' f : 14806 E , H , T , P , t. 8 ' td -04576 T , P , t. __ 8t cx 044625 E2 f2 ; t , 2 26-1 ljf : 15051 et .
8 Ilid -05017 et .
27 ' gt.15297 T , t. 8 lld 27 tfb 15346 E2 , H2 , PI t s. 9 ' ebb 05066 t , s. 28 ' ttf : *15886 t. 9D 05115 E , H , T , P , t. 29 " ttg 16530 t. 10 ' td 05655 t. 29 " ' tf x l6579 T. 11 " ' ttd : 06349 T. 294 gg 16925 P. 117 geb 06695 P. 30 ' tg 17070 T , P , t. 12 ' teb 06839 t , s. 30 " fx 17119 E2 , 1H2 , Pt s. 12"1 td : -06888 El HI T , P , t. 31 ' abb -17560 t , s. 13 e5 -07379 T , P , t. 13 ' d &gt; 07428 E2 , 12 , p , t , s. 3OTA lig 17560 1t=a2 .
13~ ld : 07526 et .
3'1 G 17609 E , H , T , P , t. ____ ____________ 32 ' tg -18149 t. 14 ' te5 07918 T , t. 33 " ' Qlg : 18843 T. 14 td : 07967 t , s. 337 ga5 19189 P. 16 " te 09151 T , P , t. 34 ' ta1 19333 t , s. 164 gte 09547 P. 34 " Tg# 19382 E , H , T , P , t. 17 t1f 09642 t , s. 35 &amp; 19873 T , P , t. 17 ' E 09691 E , H , T , P , t. 35 ' g 19922 E2 , H2 , P , t , se .
172 Ile 10034 et .
351 1I14 20068 et .
18 1e 10181 t , s. 36 ' tgb 20412 T , t. 18 te -10231 E2 , H2 , T , P , t. 36 tg : -20461 t , s. TABLE III .
( continued ) .
Deg .
Note .
Log. Remarks .
Deg .
Note .
Log. Remarks .
38 ta 21645 T , P , t. 45 ' tb~ 25527 T , t. 3846 gta 22040 P. 457 gc C 26567 P. 39 ' A 22185 E , T , P t. 47 " lb 26761 ' T , P , t. 39 " ' gX *22234 H2 , t , s 48 tcb 27251 t , s. -.T lla 22577 et .
48 ' B 27300 E , H , T , P , t. 39 Ia -22577 et.274-40 ' bbb~ 22675 tt ~ 48-1 Ilb *27594 et .
40 ta 22724 E2 , H , T , P , t. 49 ' cb 27791 t. 41 ' tta -23264 t. 49 tb 27840 E2J H2 , P ) t7 Se .
42 " ttb5 23908 t. 50 ' tb -28380 t. 42 ta# -23958 T. 51 Ilec -29024 t. 424 gb5 -24304 P. 51 " ' tb# 29073 T. 43 ' jb7 -24448 P , t , s. 514 so -29419 P. 43"1 a# 24497 E , H , T , P , t. 52 ' to -29563 T , P , t. 44 bb 24988 T , P , t. 52"1 b# 29612 E , EH2 , P ) t , S. 44 ' ta# -25037 E2 H2 , P , t , s. 44j Ila# 25086 et .

