" Experiments , made at Watford , on the Vibrations occasioned by Railway Trains passing through a Tunnel .
" By Sir JAMES SOUTH , LL. D. , F.R.S. , &amp;c. , one of the Visitors of the Royal Observatory of Greenwich .
Received June 17 , 1863* .
In the year 1846 an attempt was made to obtain the consent of the Lords of the Admiralty to run a railway through Greenwich Park , distant only 860 feet from the Royal Observatory , which would in the opinion of many competent judges have been most injurious to that Establishment .
Such consent their Lordships refused ; but as I was assured on high authority that this attempt was to be repeated , and that too with the fullest confidence of success on the part of its projectors and supporters , I determined to make experiments which might bear more decisively on the question of railway tremors , as affecting that Observatory , than those previously made by myself and others .
For this purpose it seemed indispensable that the station selected for making them should geologically resemble that of Greenwich , and that the astronomical means employed to detect the existence and determine the intenisity of the tremors should be , optically , at least equal to the telescope of the Greenwich Mural Circle .
As much importance"was attributed by the advocates of this railway to the supposed power of a tunnel to render the vibrations imperceptible , it was also desirable that it should be one of the conditions of these trials .
Having but little more than a popular knowledge of geology , I relied on my old and valued friend the late Mr. Warburton , who had recently been President of the Geological Society , to guide me in the choice of a station ; and it was on his authority that I fixed on the Watford Tunnel and its immediate vicinity .
There , under a light gravelly soil of 18 or 20 inches deep , lies a bed of gravel of considerable but variable thickness , sometimnes compact , at other times loose , and immediately under it chalk with occasional flints .
The tunnel , of which the bearing is 41§ 19t to N.W. of the meridian , and by my measurement is 1812 yards long , passes principally through chalk ; its arch is about 24 feet in diameter , the crown of it being about 215 feet above the rails .
The thickness of the brickwork is about 18 inches ; the meani thickness of the chalk above the crown of the arch about 50 feet , whilst that of the gravel , though subject to great irregularity , may perhaps be regarded as 14 feet .
If so , we have outside the tunnel above the horizontal plane of the rails 87 feet of chalk , flint , gravel and soil , constituting an assemblage of which the power of transmitting tremors must be comparatively feeble .
There are five shafts in the tunnel , four of which are circular , 8-5 feet diameter , and one quadrangular , about 26 feet by 34 .
The tuinnel runs under the park of the Earl of Essex ; and though I had not the honour of a personal acquaintance with the Noble Earl , nor any introduction to him , yet on learning my objects he transmitted to me by return of post , from Carlsbad , a carte-blanche to erect my observatory wherever I pleased , though it were in the very heart of his choicest game preserves .
To him therefore is mainly due whatever benefit may accrue to science or to the Royal Observatory from the experiments recorded in this communication .
The point I selected was 302 yards distant from the centre of the line ; and the perpendicular from it on the axis of the tunnel meets that at a point 567 yards from the southern or London end of the tunnel , 124.5 yards from the Tring or north enzd , and 594 5 from the fourth shaft .
This is the centre of the Observatory which I erected there : it is of wood , as small as is consistent with the necessary accommodation , both for portability , and that it might be less agitated by the wind .
It is quadrangular , 12 feet by 10 , and its length is in the meridian ; the eaves are 85 feet , and the ridge of the roof 10 feet above the floor , this last-being 4 iilches above the grounid , which is nearly level with that over the tunnel .
The roof is covered with tarpaulins very well secured , so as not to be torn by a gale of wiYd .
In the south and west sides are four wilndows , which can be opened or shut at pleasure , to light the Observatory by day , or to see powder or other signals at night .
In the roof is no opening ; but in its northern side there is one which can be shut as required : it is little larger tihanwhat is absolutelynecessaryto allow the reflected rays from thePole-star to pass uninterruptedly to the observer 's eye through its whole revolutioni .
At its centre , parallel with its sides and resting on the undisturbed gravel 4 feet below the surface , is a mass of brickwork laid in excellent Roman cement , 8 by 3,5 feet at bottom , 7 by 3-5 at top , its length ruinning east and west .
On this stand two piers of similar brickwork , 18 inches by 14 , and 46 inches higher than the floor : they are capped by two Portland stones of similar horizontal section 8 inches thick .
In the interior faces of these stones are firmly fixed the Y-plates , which carry the Is on which the instrument 's pivots rest .
Eighteen inches north of the brick massive , but in the same plane with its base , is the centre of the base of another pier , brought up also in Roman cement , 24 inches from N. to S. , 18 from E. to W. ; and it rises 12 inches above the floor .
The upper surface is perfectly horizontal , and serves to support a vessel which contains mercury .
Both this pier and the massives are insulated from the floor , and touch the ground only at their bases .
The mercury-vessel was 18 inches by 43 , with its length in the meridiani .
The transit-instrument of the Campden Hill Observatory is far too precious to be exposed to the risks of such an expedition ; I therefore had one constructed which might be considered an excellent substitute .
The objectglass ( which under favourable circumstances will bear a power of 1000 ) is 87 inches focus and 4 75 aperture .
The tran-sverse axis is 31 inches ; and the Y has sufficient azimuthal motion to enable me to follow the Pole-star in its whole course , so that at any hour ( if clear ) I could have the reflected image of the star in the mercurial vessel ready to testify against the tremors caused by a train .
Supported by timber passing into the ground , but unconnected with the floor and convenient to a writing-desk which occupies the S.E. angle of the building , stands a journeyman clock .
It is set by my excellent gold pocketchronometer , Molyneux No. 963 , and rarely deviates from that more than oneor two-tenths of a second in three or four hours .
The clock of the Watford Station was compared with the chronometer , going and generally returning , for the purpose of identifying particular trains .
These details will , I hope , suffice to prove that every precaution was taken to obtain accurate results , and that those which I did obtain may be fairly considered as identical with what would have been found in a first-class observatory under the same circumstances of locality and traffic .
I was at my post to commence observations on December 22nd , 1846 ; but that and the three following nights were starless .
The 26th was fine , but , owing to the irregularity of the trains , and the want of well-organized signals , I could only satisfy myself that all was in good working order , and that the trains caused great disturbance .
For thirteen following nights I was at my post , but in vain ; all was dark , with the thermometer from 220 to 310 .
On January 11th , 1847 , it cleared , and I observed seven trains with decisive results , being able to announce their presence before it was known to my assistants , who were on the watch outside the observatory .
The Pole-star 's image as reflected from the mercurial surface , when no train was near , appeared As a very small , perfectly steady disk , thus .
( I. ) which as the train approached broke up into a quin } .
( 2 .
) tuple , thus-As the disturbance increased , the form be- ' came linear at right angles to the length. .
' eo O o. .
( 3 .
) of the mercury-vessel , thus ... j00 When the train was considerablyadvanced I -iu the tunnel , a cross formed , thus- .
( 4 .
) And when near the perpendicular from the ] observatory , three parallel lines of disks ap*0.00 " " .
, ... ( 5 .
) peared , thus.j still parallel to No. 3 .
As the tremors became more distant , these transformations of the image take place in a reverse order , until the star resumes its original disk-like form .
These results were strongly conspicuous even in a fully illuminated field , and equally so whether the magnifying power was 60 , 200 , or 750 .
The phenomena are very striking , from the contrast between the smaller images , which are blue , while the larger ones are reddish , and from the sudden way in which they break out .
The nights of the 13th and 14th were fine , and so thoroughly confirmed my previous observations that I felt it my duty to lose no time in informing the late Lord Auckland , then First Lord of the Admiralty , of the preceding details and of my conclusions from them , that a tunnel did not prevent great tremors from being propagated from it when a train was traversing it , certainly to the distance of 643 yards , and probably much fuLrther .
The impression which these facts -made on his Lordship he expressed in the following letter .
Copy of a Letter from the Earl of Auckland to Sir James South .
" Admiralty , January 26th , 1847 .
" SIn , -I have to return you many thanks for the very interesting report which you sent to me of your experiments upon the distance to which the vibration caused by steam-carriages within a tunnel extend ; and I cannot but admire the enterprise and ability with which these experiments were conducted .
They would be quite conclusive if the question of carrying a tunnel through Greenwich Park were again to be agitated .
" I am , very faithfully yours , " ' To Sir James South , A e. Syc .
" " AUCKLAND .
" The reserve with which I spoke of that further distance arose from the circumstance that I was not in possession of the exact measurements of the tunnel and the position of its shafts .
'I had twice applied for them in vain to the railway authorities , and was obliged at last to execute the measures myself * This consumed some time , and the observations were not completely resumed till February 24 , 1847 .
The process was this .
About 600 yards before the entrance of the tunnel a rocket was fired as a signal for attention .
At the instant that the engine passed the south end of the tunnel , one of Lord Essex 's game-keepers fired one barrel of 'his gun , and the other about a second after , which was necessary to distinguish this from the shots of poachers , who were often at work around me .
Similar shots were fired when the engine was at the centre of the 4th shaft ( which could be seen from above ) .
The times of these signals were taken by an assistant .
During this time I was at the telescope , and noticed the second when any peculiar phase of disturbance appeared .
The computation of the distance of the engine from the eye at a given time is very simple .
From the known distance of the south end of the tunnel and the 4th shaft from the eve , we know the times taken by the sound of the gun to reach the observatory .
The temperature was during the whole series so near 32 ?
that the velocity of sound for that temperature , 36313 yards , may be used without sensible error .
The effect of wind must also have been insensible .
Hence the signal from the south entrance was 15 77 too late , that from the shaft 19-84 .
Correcting the times and dividing by their difference the distance of the shaft from the entrance , 162 yards , we have the velocity of the train ( which , however , I have given in miles per hour , as affording a more familiar measure of the disturbing power ) .
Then the difference of the time of phase and corrected time of entrance gives the place of the engine on the line , and the perpendicular is given .
In the following record of the observations , the first column contains the number , the second the times , the third the facts observed , and the fourth gives the distance , then follow occasional remarks .
In the disturbances , I specially recorded as most definite the cross ( 4 ) , and the arrangement of bars of parallel stars ( 5 ) .
The slighter disturbances which precede or follow the former were seldom entered , though quite sensible .
1847 , February 24._I .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarks .
hmsI7 I8 43 Cross very distinct .
845 Velocity II'oo , miles an hour ; weight 7 19 21 Shaft gun .
of train 77 5 tons ; twelve carriages .
7 22 .
57 South gun .
27 23 8 Lost sight of cross ... 704 II .
37 34 ?
Cross ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 699 Velocity I6-6 miles ; train 69-5 tons , 34 8 Shaft gun .
231 feet long ; ten carriages .
There .
36 31 South gun .
mometer 24 ' .
4 36 48 Lost sight of cross ... ... .
780 III .
57 44 40 Cross ; star very faint ... 68o Velocity 13 8 miles .
Star invisible to 44 44 Shaft gun .
the naked eye .
Train 58'5 tons ; 47 38 South gun .
engine I4-5 tons ; length i85 feet .
67 47 42 Lost cross ... ... ... 678 February 24.-IV .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remiiarks .
hms7 59 6 Shaft gulni .
Velocity II'4 miles ; train 89'5 tons ; 82 30 Star became visible .
enlgine i8 ditto ; length 308 feet .
82 34 South gun ; star bright .
Wind E. Tlherm .
24g .
783 Io Cross disappeared. .
834-5 1847 , February 27.-I .
7 28 o Slhaft gun .
Velocity I5'4 miles ; train 54 to^ns ; 29 7 Cross first seei , but star enginie 14'5 tons ; length of train very faint .
17z feet .
30 34 Soutll guln .
87 30 44 Cross lost ; star very faiiit ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 722 II .
97 44 43 Cross seen ... ' .
" " ' ' 736 Velocity 25z 6 miiiles ; tailn 49-5 tons ; 7 4451 Shaft gun .
engillc 145 tons ; length of train I0 45 8 Cross very strong ... ... 470 150 feet .
I1 45 27 Line veiry stronlg .
326 46 24 South guni .
I2 46 46 Cross lost .
915 III .
13 7 56 2I Cross seen .
706 Velocity 17-6 miles ; train 270 5 tons ; 56 3i Souith gtin .
two engines z9'5 tolls ; length of 14 57 45 Coss very strong 3I4 traini 663 feet ; 37 carriages .
S8 46 Shaft gun .
I51 58 53 Cross lost ... ... .
736 IV .
I6 83 36 Cross very strong 736 Velocity 3I'7 miles ; train IIz tons ; 3 44 Shaft gun .
engine 2I tons ; length of train 17 46 Cross very fine .
377 394 feet ; carriages 17 .
Wind N.E. i8 4 I4 Triple line , upper and Thermometer 26 ? .
lower stars blue .
3I9 4 59 South gun .
I95 28 Cross lost ... ... ... ... . .
o86 V. 20 8 IO 56 Cross seen ... ... ... ... ... 7z7 |Velocity i87 miles ; train 51-5 tons ; II 8 South gun .
engine I2'5 tons ; length of train 21 sI 56 Triple line strong .
322 187 feet .
A train of empty cattle13 15 Shaft gun .
waggons .
Cross lost from cloud ... lost March 11.-I .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarks .
h ra s 23 7 I8 44 Cross very distinct ... 802 Velocity 17-7 ; train 147-5 tons ; en .
I9 6 South gun .
gin 125 tons ; length of train 355 2I 20 Shaft gun , cloud .
feet .
II .
8 25 3 Shaft giin , cloud .
Velocity 33-0 miles ; train I22 tons ; z6 I5 South gun , cloud cleared enginie zI tons ; lengtli of train 41 6 23 z6 32 Cross lost by cloud ... ... 92I feet .
Cross so strong , lbut for the cloud it might have been seen I5 or even more seconds longer .
1847 , March 12.-I .
24 6 56 22 Cross very distinct ... ... z 822 Velocity z8 33 miles ; train 68 tons ; 56 38 South gun .
engine 15 tons ; length of train 23 1 25 56 52 Cross very strong ... ..46I feet ; many carriages but mostly 26 57 i6 Star tossed about 3 or 4 empty , many wheels and axles ; of its diaineters ... 3O24 agitation excessive .
Seemed to 58 2 Shaft gun .
keep time with the jolts of the 27 58 8 Cross lost ... 766 train .
II .
28 7 13 15 Cross plain .
8I Velocity 35-5 miles ; train 59-5 tons ; 13 26 Shaft gun .
engine 15 tons ; length of train I92 29 13 44 Cross very strong 392 feet .
Train does not stop at Wat30 I3 56 Triple line very strong .
305 ford .
31 14 20 0Cross very stronig ... . .
480 I 43 3 Southl gunl .
32 14 58 Cross lost ... ... ..1074 III .
33 7 57 i6 Image much agitated ... 1077 Velocity 30 9 miles ; train 's weight 34 57 30 Cross .
877 1 24 .
tOnsl ; two enlgines 2I tons and 57 47 Shaft gun .
I4 tons ; length of train 375 feet .
35 58 o Cross very strong 478 Wind N. , very weak .
Thermometer 36 58 IO Parallel lines ( 5 ) very 3 O.5 , strong .
374 37 58 I6 ( 5 ) still stronger. .
329 38 58 25 ( 5 ) ten Iiiues , quite cover field of telescope ... ... 3o2 39 58 45 Cross very strong .
431 59 4 South gun .
40 59 14 Cross strong. .
803 4I 59 31 Cross lost .
1045 March 12.-IV .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarks .
hm s 42 8 40 1x Cross .
X ... ... ... .
855 Velocity 37-7 miles ; train 5o tons ; 40 24 Shaft gun .
engine I4z5 tons ; train 's length 43 40 38 Cross very strong ... , 428 I5z feet .
44 40 54 Parallel lines ; image trembles ... ... ... ... . .
3o0 The image trembled very much du45 41 10 Strong lines.v.v 4I6 ring the whole time of passage 41 z7 South gun .
through the field .
46 4I 48 Cross lost..II. .
1847 , March 15.-I .
47 7 21 14 Cross ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 1176 Velocity 20'5 miles ; train x25*5 tons ; 48 22 6 Cross strong.686 engine z2 tons ; length of train 409 22 io Shaft gun .
feet ; i8 carriages .
49 22 37 Line brilliant ; changed 430 suddenly to 50 22 50 Parallel lines ( 5 ) 349 5I 23 5 ( 5 ) very strong .
303 52 23 I5 ( 5 ) still strong ... ... ... 311 53 23 22 Cross very strong 335 54 24 6 South gun ; cross very strong .
55 24 51 Cross still seen ... ... ... 1 078 II .
56 7 25 55 Cross ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 775 Velocity zz-6 miles ; train 20og5 tons ; 26 io South gun .
length of train 172 feet ; slow goods 57 27 I Parallellines verystrong 3o3 train .
58 27 so Do .
do .
very beautiful ... 324 27 55 Shaft gun .
59 28 x8 Cross lost. .
92z III .
60 7 31 19 Cross ... ... ... .0 ... ... xo32 Velocity zrI6 miles ; train9I 5 tons ; 6i 31 52 Cross very strong 706 engine 14-5 tons ; train 's length 31 58 Shaft gun .
3I9 feet .
62 32 30 Single line very strong 384 63 32 32 Changed to ( 5 ) parallel lines .
371I5 64 32 48 ( 5 ) very strong ... ... ... 308 33 48 South gun .
65 34 22 Cross lost .
992 IV .
66 7 43 37 Cross .
786 Velocity 14-8 miles ; train 49'5 tons ; 67 43 44 Cross strong.740 engine 14'5 tons ; train 's length 43 57 Shaft gun .
Io feet ; six carriages .
68 44 22 Line strong .
502 69 45 0 Cross very strong ... ... 328 70 45 I8 Traceof ( s)parallellines 302 7I 45 37 Line very strong ... ... ... 336 72 45 52 Cross strong ... 391 46 38 South gun .
[ leaving the tunnel .
73 46 42 Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... 679 I never saw it cease so soon after March 15.-V .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarks .
hms 74 8 I0 i6 Cross ... ... ... ... ... ..1029 Velocity 33-O miles ; train Io6 tons ; 75 I0 35 Cross very strong ... ... 741 engine zi tons ; train 's length 364 I0 42 Shaft gun .
feet .
76 I0 52 Line very strong ... ... ... 504 77 i I6 ( 5 ) brilliant ... ... ... ... .
, 303 II 54 South gun , cross very strong .
78 I2 I6 Cross lost ... ... ... ... .
997 VI .
79 8 25 57 Cross ... .'.'.'.'. .
854 Velocity 15'9 miles .
This train could 26 25 Shaft gun .
not be identified .
80 28 I2 Cross very strong ... ... 394 28 54 South gun .
8i 29 Iz Cross lost .
782 VII .
8 ' 8 4.I 29 Cross.9z6 Velocity 23-7 miles .
Newcastle Ex41 55 Shaft gun .
press .
83 42 z2 ( s ) parallel bars .
406 43 35 South gun .
84 44 2 Cross lost .
950 1847 , March 16.-I .
85 6 44 49 Cross ... ... 1157 Velocity 34miles ; train 75 tons ; en45 z2 Shaft gun .
gin iS tons ; length of train 282 86 46 8 Cross very strong 393 feet .
46 z8 South gun ; cross very strong .
87 46 58 Cross last seen. .
57 II .
88 6 54 14 Cross..935 Velocity 24-8 miles ; train 67 tons ; 54 42 South gun .
engine 54 tons ; length of train 89 55 34 ( 5 ) parallel lines ... 3 14 231 feet .
56 i8 Shaft gun .
9o 56 42 Lost cross , but cart within hearing 959 III .
9I 6 58 I8 Cross ... ... ..| 915 Velocity 11-4 miles ; train 322 tons ; 59 9 Shaft gun .
engine 14 tons ; train 's length 857 92 7o ii Line very strong .
382 feet .
A heavy goods train .
93 0 20 ( s ) very strong ... ... ... 3 5z 94 0 30 ( 5 ) magnificent ... ... ... 328 95 0 40 Cross very strong ... ... 38 96 0 55 Cross double..--.very 309 beautiful .
2 36 South gunI ; cross very strong .
97 44 Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... 0 .
Ii| March 16.-lV .
No. Time .
Observationis .
Yards .
Remarks .
hms 98 78 50Cross ... ... ... ... ... . .
870 Velocity zi,9 miIes .
8 30 Soutit gun .
Io iS Shlaft gun .
99 Io 38 Lost cioss ... ... ... .
878 V. IOO 7 I8 32 Cross. .
1038 |Velocity 25-7 miles ; weight of train 19 5 Shaft guin .
69 5 tons ; engine I4 5 tons ; train 's so 37 Souith gun .
length 194 feet .
IOI 2I 5 Lost C0oss ... ... ... ... ... 988 VI .
102 7 42 2 Cr-oss ... ... ... ... ... . .
824 VelocitY 35 8 miles ; train 53-5 tons ; 42 14 Shaft gun .
enginie 145 tons ; traini 's length I03 42 43 ( 5 ) ... ... ... ... ... .
305 I68 feet .
43 20 SouIth gun .
104 43 45 Lost cross ... ... ... ... ... 1079 VII .
1O5 8 3 !
42 Cross .
846 Velocity 369 miles ; train 98-5 tons ; 31 55 Shaft gun .
engine Ii tons ; length of traini i2z IO6 32 9 ( 5 ) ' ' ... ... ' ' .
' ' ' " .
4A28 feet .
Wind S.E. ; fresh .
32 59 South gun .
107 33 22 Lost cross ... ... ... ... ... Isa8 VTIII .
IO8 8 43 48 Cross very faint ... ... ... 668 Velocity 20-I miles ; tirain 55 75 tons ; 43 5 ?
Shaft guin .
engine 2.375 tOlns ; train 's lengtl 45 48 South guin .
146 feet .
Trem-ors uniusually small .
log 46 8 Lost the cross ... ... ... ... 821 1847 , March 17.-I .
110 6 42 45 Cross ... ... ... ..|..055 Velocity 33-9 miles ; train IO4 tons 43 12 Shaft gun .
enginie I9 tons ; leng-th of traini | IsI 43 40 ( 5 ) beautifuil ... ... ... ... 318 362 feet .
I 12 43 55 ( 5 ) ditto ... ... ... ... ... ... 337 44 22 South guin ; cross very stronig .
113 44 54 Cross lost ... ... ... II66 II .
1 I4 66 Cross ... ... ... ... ,.|O 1076 Velocity z8'7 miles ; train 70 tons ; 56 I SoUth gun .
etnginc 12 tons ; train 's lengtl 247 ; IIISI 56 37 ie of staL s vnry beaue 3o4 .
feet .
Winid S.E. ; scarcely sensitifil .
se ble ; image very unisteadv .
|6 56 46 ( 5 ) ... ... ... | 315 1 57 234 Clsaft ver .
s 832 |1 17 |57 35 2 Coss still veg-y stroig ... .
83 II I8 7 47 Clross l0st ... ... ... ... ... , ICO4 March 17.-III .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarks .
hm s II9 7 IO 23 Cross ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 828 Velocity 22 9 miles ; train 74 5 tons ; IO 43 South gun .
engine I2V5 ; train 's length I 7I feet .
120 II 32 Cross strong .
' .
' ' .
302 I2 II 45 Line strong .
336 I2 27 Shaft gun .
I22 I2 47 Cross lost.892 1847 , March 18.-I .
I23 6 i8 I2 Cross well seen .
961 Velocity 27-3 miles ; train 's weight i8 38 South gun 87 tons ; engine I5 tons ; length 124 19 25 ( 5 ) strong .
3I4 of train 345 feet .
125 20 3 Cross strong ... ... ... ... 666 20 5 Shaft gun .
I26 20 20 Cross still strong ... ... ... 875 I27 20 26 Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... 95o The image oscillating in everydirection .
II .
iz8 6 38 32 Cross strong ... ... ... ... 902 Velocity 30-4 miles ; train 78 tons ; 38 5 Shaft gun .
engine ig tons ; length of train 246 129 39 20 ( 5 ) very strong ... ... ... 331 feet .
4o 9 South gun .
130 40 II Strong cross ... ... ... ... 692 I31 40 24 Cross lost .
870 II[.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 132 655 II Cross ... ... ... ... ... .
992 Velocity 2-56 miles ; train 63 tons ; I33 55 32 Line strong .
746 engine I4 tons ; train 's length ziz 55 It 3 Sotuth gun .
feet .
134 56 22 Cross very strong ... ... 307 135 56 33 ( 5 ) beautiful ... ... ... ... 3 13 57 x6 Shaft gun .
I36 57 43 Cross lost .
1003 IV .
I37 7 14 12 Cross strong ... ... ... ... 824 Velocity 3I6 miles ; train 72'5 tons ; 14 25 Shaft gun .
engine I4-5 toIsI ; train 's length 138 15 0 ( 5 ) beautiful ... . .
, .
, 303 254 feet .
139 I5 12 ( 5 ) still fine.343 140 15 26 Cross strong ... . .
484 15 40 South gun .
14I i6 7 Cross lost ... .,1057 V. 142 7 2I 59 Cross ... ... ... ... . .
| 705 Velocity 22 ?
9 miles ; a light goods 22 7 South gun .
train .
143 22 45 Cross strong .
326 23 51 Shaft gun .
I44 24 5 Cross lost .
830 March 18.-VI .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarli-s .
hms 145 7 36 54 Cross ... ... ... ... ... . .
888 Velocity 18+2 miles ; train 's weight 84 37 26 South gun .
tons ; engine i6 tons ; train 's length 146 38 20 Cross stron .
311 187 feet .
All the inages inosculated 147 38 30 All confusion .
303 during the train 's passage through 148 38 40 Line very strong .
320 the tunnel ; yet when it was gone 39 .
37 Shaft gun .
the star was perfectly steady .
Wol149 40 3 Cross lost .
895 verton goods train..~~~~~~~Vl VII .
150 7 41 o Cross ... ... . .
| 896 Velocity 29'7 miles ; train 's weight 15 !
4I 13 Cross strong.* '.'.'.72I 6z-5 tons ; engine 14'5 tons ; train 's 4I I9 Shaft gun .
length 204feet .
As in last the images 152 41 43 ( 5 ) *.-.* ... . .
373 inosculated ; even the lines of ( 5 ) ran 153 42 0 ( 5 ) stroig.303 into each other .
Peterborough light 42 39 South gun .
train .
154 43 14 |Cross lost.1141 VIII .
155 7 59 5 Cross .
I II Velocity 40'2 miles ; traini i28 tonS ; x56 59 25 Cross very strong 740 engine I9 tons .
; length of train 458 59 3 !
Shaft gun .
feet .
I57 80 I0 ( 5).367 0 30 South gun .
158 0 54 Cross lost .
II5 Ix .
159 8 38 36 Cross ... ... ... ... ... . .
8x8 Velocity 4l-6z miles ; train 6I25 tons ; 38 46 Shaft gun .
enginie 23-75 tons ; length of train x6o 39 o Cross very strong 4o6 144 feet .
x6x 39 I0 ( 5 ) ... ... ... ... ... ... 310 I62 39 I8 Cross ... ... .
' ... 48 !
1 39 43 South gun .
163 40 3 Cross lost.1 1076 1847 , Alarch 19.-I .
I64 6 39 55 Cross seen ... ... .
| 858 Velocity 37 9 miles ; train 9275 tolls .
; 40 8 Shaft gun .
enlgine 23 75 tons ; train 's length i65 40 0o Line very distinct .
6o6 284 feet .
I66 40 25 Cross extremely bright| 390 41 o South gun .
I67 41 37 1Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... I ziz8 Observed by the Marquis of Blandford March 19.-II .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarks .
hms i68 6 56 52 Cross .
919 Velocity 3288 miles ; train 67 tons ; 57 12-5 South gun .
engine i4 tons ; train 's length 731 I69 57 30 Cross very bright ... ... 397 feet .
170 57 49 ( 5 ) very distinct ... ... .
306 58 2.5 Shaft gun .
171 58 44 Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... . .
978 Observed by the Marquis of Blandford .
III .
172 7 15 20 Cross ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 697 Velocity 3z I miles ; train 68-5 tOlns ; 15 24 Shaft gun .
engine I4 tons ; train 's length 234 173 I5 45 Cross still distinct ... ... 383 feet .
174 I5 55 ( 5 ) slightly ... ... ... ... ... 313 I6 38 South gun .
175 i6 46 Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... 78i Observed by Lord Alfred Churchill .
IV .
176 7 24 4o Cross .
1042 Velocity 24-0 miles ; train 98-5 tons ; 177 24 57 Cross very strong .
848-5 engine i'tons ; train 's length 16 25 i8 South gun .
feet .
This night very unfavourable .
178 26 5 Cross extremely strong 302 Many observations lostfrom clouds , 179 26 IO ( 5 ) ... ... ... ... ... ... 3o9 and the stars when seen often faint .
26 57 Shaft gun .
I80 27 26 Cross lost ... ... ... . .
1005 1847 , March 22.-I .
i8I 7 22 I2 !
Cross ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 759 Velocity z3'6 miles ; train 86'5 tons ; 22 24 -South giin .
engine I12.5 tons ; train 's length 203 182 23 22 Cross strong.323 feet .
24 5 'Shaft gun .
I83f 24 33 Across lost ... ... ... ... ... 964 II .
184 7 38 32 Cross ... ... ... ... 2. .
105 Velocity 20-7 miles ; train 68 tons ; I85 39 IO Cross strong ... ... ... ... 668 engine I4 5 tons ; train 's length 233 39 1z Shaft gun .
feet .
i86 40 12 ( 5). .
304 41 7 South gun .
187 41 36 Cross lost .
950 III .
i88 7 58 20 Cross .
827 Velocity 3I14 miles ; train 88 tons ; 58 33 Shaft gun .
engine 2I tons ; length of train 288 I89 59 4 ( 5 ) beautiful .
311 feet .
59 47 South gun .
190 6o 8 Cross lost. .
97l G March 29.-I .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarks .
hms I9I 6 54 58 Cross 837 Velocity 33-I miles ; train Iog tons ; 55 13 South gun ; cross very two engines , 15 tons and 13 tons ; strong .
train 's length 334 feet .
I92 55 4 ?
Cross extremely strong. .
310 193 56 o All lost in a flare ... ... 374 56 25 Shaft gun .
194 56 49 Cross lost ... ... ... ... . .
, I057 II .
595 7 36 o Cross ... ... . .
0 849 Velocity 33-4 miles ; train 67 5 tons ; 36 I4+ Shaft gun .
engine 14-5 tons ; train 's length 196 36 40 Cross very strong 333 226 feet .
At 36m 45S the stars lost 37 25 South gun .
shape and were inosculated with 197 37 43 Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... 940 each other .
III .
7 47 43 Shaft gun .
Velocity zo'8 miles ; train 48 tons ; '98 48 0o Cross first seen ... ... ... 4z6 engine 13 tons ; traini 's length 150 199 48 41 Cross strong .
30z feet .
It was stopped by the police 49 37 South gun .
at the entrance of the tunntel , and 200 49 39 Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... 677 went slowly through it-"crawling , " in the words of the signal-nan .
IV .
201 846 Cross ... ... ... .
698 Velocity 33X4 miles ; train 92X5 tons ; 04 lo Shaft gun .
engine I5 tons ; train 's length 328 202 4 45 Cross strong .
30 feet .
5 2i South gun .
203 5 44 Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... IOI8 V. 204 8 33 12 Cross .
774 Velocity 39-5 miles ; train 55-5 tons ; 33 20 Shaft gun .
engine 2I tons ; train 's length 144 34 20 South gun .
feet .
'Ine night unfavourable from 205 34 37 Cross lost_ ... ... ... ... ... 978 clouds .
1847 , March 30.-I .
2o6 6 49 ?
6 Cross. .
771 Velocity ?
9go miles ; train 12z tons ; 49 36 Shaft gun .
engine I8 tons ; train 's length 404 207 50 IO ( s)twofaintparallellines 314 feet .
2o8 50 so Stars entirely confused .
302 Observed by the late Professor James , l 50 58 South gun .
McCullagh , of Trinity College , 209 I i6 ICross lost ... ... ... ... ... .1 899 Dublin .
March 30.-II .
No. Time .
Observations .
Yards .
Remarks .
hms 2IO 6 57 57 Cross ... ... ... ... ... .
940 Velocity 38'4miles ; train 89'5 tons ; 211 58 IO Cross strong ... 714 eingine ig tons ; length of train 293 58 I6 South gin .
feet .
212 58 40 ( 5 ) but confused ... ... ... 313 59 x8 Shaft gun .
213 59 36 Cross lost ... ... ... . .
1014 Observed by Prof. James McCullagh .
III .
2I4 72 2 !
Cross ... ... ... ... . .
798 Velocity 2g-o miles .
; a pilot engine .
2 I4 Shaft gun .
215 3 36 South gun .
Star which had been faint was now totally clouded .
Observed by Prof. James McCullagh .
IV .
2I6 7 17 25 Cross. .
883 Velocity 43'I miles ; train 49'5 tons ; 17 38 Shaft gun .
engine 14'5 tons ; length 150 feet .
217 17 58 ( 5 ) ... ... ... .330 I8 33 South gun .
2I8 I8 48 Cross lost.969 V. 219 7 44 17 Cross .
* -924 Velocity 28'3 ; train 53-5 tons ; engine 44 39 Shaft gun , cross very 14-5 tons ; length of train 167 feet .
strong .
220 45 8 ( 5 ) brilliant .
All the 346 stars blue except the cenitre .
22 I 45 27 ( 5 ) clianges to cross 31:6 46 3 Souith gun .
222 46 26 Cross lost.958 VI .
223 8I9 Cross.965 iVelocity 34-4 miles ; train 114-5 tons ; I 30 Shaft gun .
engine zi toils ; length of trail 408 224 I 44 ( 5 ) ... ... . .
, ... ... 446 feet .
225 2 12 ( 5 ) very strong .
335 2 39 South gun .
226 3z Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... 0 IO29 VII .
227 8 39 20 Cross | I..6 Velocity 45-6 miles ; train so 5 tons ; 39 34 Sliaft gun .
engine I5 tons ; train 's length I52 228 39 55 ( ). .
313 feet .
Newcastle Express .
40 26 South gun .
229 | 40 47 |Cross lost ... ... ... ... ... i| I6 Date .
Across ( 5 ) ( ) Cross xi ri ' ri ' begins .
begins .
ends .
ends .
velo .
weight .
i847 .
yards , yards .
yards .
yards .
m'iles .
tons .
Feb. 24 845 ... . .
704 S. lEO0 77-5 699 ... ... 780 a. i 6'6 69'5 68o ... .
67'8 S.13'S 58'5 ... . .
~8 34'5 S. I11I4 89'5 Feb. 2 7 ... . .
722 S. 15'4 54'0 736 ... .
915 a. z5'6 49'5 706 ... .
736 w. 17'6 270'5 736 319 ... io86 a. 31-7 11z 727 32 .
, .
cloud i8'7 ' 51'5 Mar. S oz. , , , , cloud 17'7 147'5 cloud ... . .
921-f S.33'0 1 -2 Mar. i2 Szz 303. .
766 N. 28'3 68 Silr 305 .
, 1074S .
3 53 59'5 877 374 302+ 104.5 S. 30-9 124 Image much agitated at 855 30z 416 103 !
S. 3 7'7 50 1077 yards .
MNar.xI5 1176 349 311+ 1078+ S. 2-0'5 12535 Train very long .
775 303 32z4+ 922 N. 2zz'6 209'5 1032 37 ' 308+ 992 S. 2 '6 g '5 786 302 ... 679 s. I14 , S 49.5 1019 303 ... 997 s. 33'0 xo6 854 ... ... 782 S. 15'9 9z6 406 ... 950 S. 23'7 Jar .
i6 1157 , ... . .
1157 S. 3 54 75 935 314 ... 959 N. 24'S 67 915 352 308+ 1110 s. I'-4 .
3l Train-ver lonig .
870 ... . .
878 N. '19 1038 .
, .
, 988 S. 57 69'5 84 305 , 1079.3 5'8 5 3'5 846 428 ... xo8 5 .
36'9 98'5 Lo-ng trainU .
668.,. .
8i S. 20 ' !
55-75 Mkar .
17 1055 318 337+ 1166 S. 3 3'9 104 Rtather long .
1076 315 ... 1004 N. '87 70 82,8 ... ... 9g N. 2z '9 74-'5 Mar. iS8 961 31T4 f950 N. z7'3 87 Image oscillating .
902z 313I 870 S. 30'4 78 992 313. .
1003 JN .
25-6 63 84 303 343 1057 s5 , 316 72 '5 705 ... , 830 N. 2 '. .
Light goods train .
SoS 303 32.0 895 N. i8'z 84 .
Imiages conifused .
896 373 303+ 1141 s. 297 6z'3 -Ditto ditto .
1111 ... ... 111 5 .
40'2 128 Long traini .
SiS 310 ... 1076 S. 41-6 61i2z5 Mar. 19 859 T. .
u1x8 S. 379 97 { Observed bythe Marquis 919 306. .
978 N- .
32-8 67 jof Blandford , 697 3 13 .
781 S. 3Z.i 1 68 5 Observed by Lord Alfred 1042 , 309. .
1005 jN .
24'0 98'5 Churchill .
Mar.zz2 759 ... ... 964 .
N. 23'6 86'5 1025 j 04 ... 950 S. 20-7 68 827 32z ... 972 S. 3I-4 88 Mar.z29 837 374 ... 1057 N. 33 0 Lonig train .
849 -. .
940 S. 33'4 I675 li ages confused .
4z6 ... . .
677 S. oS48 Stopped at entrance 698 ... ... 1 S. 3 34 923 ' 774 ... ... 978 S. 39'5 55'5 Clouidy .
Mar. 4Q 771 314 ... 899 S. 29 12 beve yPrfso 940 313 ... 1014 N. 38'4 895 James M0Cullagh .
798 - ... ... .
S. 29 pilot 883 330. .
969 s. 43'I 49'5 924 346 3x6 958 S. 28'3 5 3'5 965 446 335 1029 ' 5 .
pp3q4 14-5 Long and heavy engi'ne .
916 313 .
iii6 S. 45'6 50'5 That these results may be more easily appreciated , I have condensed the most importalnt of them into the preceding Table , which gives in one view the distance at which that amount of disturbance begins and ends which produces the cross , that at which the far greater one occurs causing the appearance ( 5 ) ( a system of three or more parallel rows ) wherever it does appear , and the velocities and weights of the trains when known .
It is evident from this Table that the tremor which is sufficient to produce that disturbance of the mercury which shows a cross of stars is propagated to considerable distances-in one case to 11 76 yards ; and 24 per cent. of the entire are above 1000 .
Such distances do not pass the northern end of the tuninel , but go far beyond the southern .
In the latter case the vibrations are excited while the train is in arn open cutting ; and those who suppose that the tinnel has much power in deadening them would of course expect that they would be sensible at a greater distance than at the other end .
This does not seem , however , to be the case : and the Table shows that in this respect there is very little difference , if we take into account another cause of inequality , namely , that the tremor is manifested further at the exit than at the entrance of the train .
The column headed " Exit " shows by s. that the exit was at the South end , and the entrance at the North .
Now , when the observations are examined where both were noted , we find that the limit of the cross is greater at the exit than at the entrance in 29 out of 39 , or 74 per cent. of s. , and 12 out of 16 , or 75 per cent. of N. The reason of this , I suppose , is that the long-continued action of the train on the rails tends to produce a greater and more prolonged undulation in the mercury .
But the equal percentage shows that there is really no protecting power in the tunnel against the lateral propagation of tremors , whatever may be the case immediately above the crown .
In general one might expect trains to produce disturbance in proportion to their speed and their weight .
To a certain degree this is true ; but the exceptions are sufficient to show that other influences must be taken into consideration .
Examples of high speed with comparatively small effect are afforded by the observations on March 18 , II .
; 19 , III .
; and 29 , V. Others of the reverse conditions are given by February 24 , I. , II .
; March 18 , VI .
; and specially March 16 , III .
, in which with a velocity of only 11 4 miles the cross was shown at 1110 yards .
This it may be remarked is a decisive proof that any plan of protecting an observatory by slackening the speed of trains passing near it is entirely useless , even if it could be enforced .
It is probable that one cause of this high disturbing-power in slow trains is that already referred to , the long-continued accumulation of vibration , the quick ones passing beyond distance before the mercury has got into full vibration , the others having full time to do their work though with less intrinsic force .
On this account also long trains are more disturbing than short .
The engine is not so paramount a disturber as might be expected , the heaviest , and even a pair of them , not causing more tremor than occurs with the smaller ones .
In taking the cross of stars as the test of disturbance , I must observe that I do so , not because it is the earliest which appears , but because it marks distinctly an agitation greater than what is likely to occur at an observatory subject to ordinary perturbations .
These produce in such a mercuiryvessel as I used a single line of stars perpendicular to the length of the vessel .
It should seem that then only one set of undulations fit to produce these images is excited in the mercury , the direction of which is regulated by the sides of the vessel * .
The existence of the cross shows that a secolnd set of waves perpelndicular to the first has been developed : this always happens if the sides of the vessel are equal ; and its occurring when they are so unequal as in the present case seems to indicate a corresponding excess of the power which causes them .
If the agitation be still greater , it seems as if each of the images which form the cross became the origini of a row of secondary images , the result of which is the form ( 5 ) , a series of parallel rows of stars varying from two to ten , or even filling the whole field .
This token of ultra disturbance isconfined between lines making angles of 45 ?
with the perpendicular to the rails-in other words , to distances under 427 yards , and when the train is nearly in the centre of the tunnel .
It is ( except in two instances ) only seen when the cross is visible beyond 1000 vards : when the agitation is still further increased the images vibrate in every direction , and with yet more of it the whole becomes a mass of nebulous light ; of both which some examples may be found in these observations .
The opinion maintained by the late Mr. Robert Stephenson , that much of these railway tremors were due to the sound of the train , although not probable , induced me to try some experiments by firing cannon , maroons , and rockets at various distances .
One of these cannons ( for I had two , each of a pound calibre ) heavily loaded , at 300 yards produced ( 5 ) , cross , and line simultaneously with my hearing the reports ; but all disturbance was over in about 1-5 second .
At 2020 yards there was the cross synchronous with the report , and of the same momentary character ; and even at 3000 yards the cross could be traced .
This seems to have been due to the momentary impulse of the sound-wave , for the continuous roar of two-pound rockets fired at 82 feet from the mercury , though very loud , disturbed it very little ; while the explosions of eight ounces of powder in their heads about 800 yards above the ground produced all , the ( 5 ) , cross , and line .
A still more interesting experiment was , firing the cannon in the tunnel at the point where the perpendicular from the observatory met it .
In this case two disturbances were seen-one propagated through the ground , the other through the air with about a second of time interval .
The sound probably made its way chiefly through the shafts ; but even had they been closed , it seems unquiestionable that the report , and of course the sound of a train , would travel through the earth * .
I should have prosecuted these researches further , especially in reference to the velocity with which these tremors are propagated through the ground , but that Lord Auckland 's letter to me led me to hope that all danger to the Royal Observatory was past , never to return .
I therefore contented myself with reducing the observations I had made .
As , however , the Railway Moloch seems never likely to be satiated with victims , and as the observatories of Oxford , Armagh , and again that of Greenwich have been marked for sacrifice , it seems to me a duty to place before the public the facts which had been collected at a great expense of labour , nand some pecuniary outlay .
They were made without any bias , or any motive but a desire to ascertaini the actual truth ; and in addition to their bearing on practical astronomy , I hope that they may not be without use in reference to some other departments of science .
An interesting fact was observed with the maroons .
They were fired vertically from a mortar twenty feet from the observatory , and had fuses which gave them .
flight for six seconds .
The mercury showed the usual intense disturbance when the mortar was fired , and also at the explosion of the maroons in the air .
But there was also an initerrnediate disturbance which I cannot explain but by supposing it to be as it were an eclio of the earth-wave caused by the dischlarge of the mortar and reflected from the masonzry of the tunnel .
I showed it to the Marquis of Blandford , to Lord Alfred Churchill , and to Professor James MeCullagh ; unfortunately the nights Dr. Robiinson and Mr. Warburton accompanied me to Watford , not a sin-le star was visible .
On repeating the experiments at Campdeni Hill , notling of the sQrt occurred ,

