On the Structure and Development of the Skull of the Common Fovwl ( Gallus domesticus ) .
By WILLIAM KITCHEN PARKER , F.R.S. Received November 25 , 1868.--Read February 11 , 1869 .
Introductory Remarks .
IN my former paper , which treated of the structure and development of the skull in the Ostrich-tribe* , I proposed to write a series of such papers on the skull of the Vertebrata , and that the first of these should be confined to that of the Common Fowl .
This Bird is selected for several reasons , the first of which is the readiness with which it may be obtained ; but , as far as science is concerned , a still more important reason lies in the fact that it not only forms a good halfway subject between the Ostrich and the Singing-bird , but , in a wider survey , it serves as an excellent stand-point from which to look backward to the Fish , and forward to the higher Mammalian forms .
The present paper is much more special than the last , which treated of the skull of several kinds of Struthious Birds , in just as many stages as I was able to obtain : this time an essay has been made to describe , step by step , the whole process of growth of the skull , face , and sense-capsules from the fourth day of incubation to extreme old age .
My reason for not describing the earliest stages is , that I find it done to hand already ; and although I have repeatedly verified the observations of other authors on the primary condition of these parts , yet I have nothing more to add to what is already known .
The latest and best description that I have seen of the primordial condition of the head of the chick is to be found in Professor HUXLEY'S 'Elements of Comparative Anatomy , ' pp. 136-142 , and figs. 57 A-G .
My starting-point is at that stage which is the last but one in Professor HUXLEY'S series-namely , figs. 57 F and F ' ( p. 138 ) ; my second stage agrees with his fig. 57 G. In describing the Struthious skull , I did not depend merely upon what an examination of those types revealed , but had already made a large number of observations ( and drawings ) on the development of the skull in various Families of Birds , and also in many types from the other Vertebrate Classes .
It was shown me , however , by my most judicious friend , Professor HUXLEY , that my work missed its end , in some degree , from its diffuseness , and that it would be better to get a perfect history of one type of skull , than an imperfect knowledge of any number whatever .
So , to be thorough , it must content me to cultivate a small and modest plot at one time , trusting in the Unity of Nature for the value of the results , and confident that , if I can read the meaning of the Fowl 's skull , my eyes will be opened to see very much more , below , above , and around .
There will be now a necessity for some modification of the nomenclature used in the former paper , both with regard to the tissues and the various morphological regions ; for in both these departments of my wprk I trust there has been some extension of knowledge , as well as rectification of former errors .
The ossific process , than which nothing is more confusing to the morphologist , has of late received a more definite nomenclature ( see ' On the Shoulder-girdle and Sternum , ' Ray Soc. 1868 , p. 4 ) ; the new terms will be used here .
These are:-(1 ) " ectostosis , " for that tract of osseous deposit which is formed between the perichondrium and the cartilaginous mass ; ( 2 ) endostosis , " for that deposit which takes place primarily in the intercellular substance of hyaline cartilage , or between the cells of simple cartilage ; and ( 3 ) " parostosis , " for all ossifications of mere fibrous tracts .
In the paper 'On the Shoulder-girdle ' ( p. 10 ) I have spoken of a modification of the growth-process in the Warm-blooded Classes , which , until fairly understood , cost me much perplexing thought ; this is where a parosteal patch of bony matter grafts itself upon a cartilaginous plate , setting up , first , an ectosteal deposit close upon the cartilage-mass , and then an endosteal process between the cells themselves .
In this case we have the coexistence of the three types of " ostosis " to form a single osseous centre ; and this state of things , so different from what is seen in the Cold-blooded Classes , and by no means to be confounded with after-coalescence , must be looked upon as a very important metamorphic modification in the skeleton of the higher types .
As far as I can see at present , an explanation of this deliquescence , as it were , of the histological process in the formation of bone will greatly smooth the difficulties that have hitherto stood in the way of the homological part of this science ; it will thus be seen that nothing is more unsafe than hasty decision upon representative parts in the various types .
There is much to be done in the study of cartilage with regard to morphological regions , and their comparison in the various types ; for in some cases differentiation and chondrification are synchronous , and , in a sense , synonymous ; whilst in others the fission of the cartilage does not take place until it is thoroughly consistent and even dense .
This after-splitting may be perfect , or more or less imperfect ; in the latter case a cartilaginous plate becomes notched in some instances , and fenestrate in others ( see 'Shoulder-girdle and Sternum , ' p. 4 ) .
But as hyaline cartilage is merely to be considered a consolidated primordial cellmass , and a very fast-growing tissue also , it is not surprising to find it running riot over a large number of morphological territories ( op .
cit. p. 4 ) : this takes place to the greatest extent in the lowest and most generalized types , which , however large ( even gigantic ) they may become , are nevertheless mere embryos throughout life , in respect of their morphological development .
The sharp distinction between the skull and the vertebrae is well seen in this-that X In the Amphibia no definite line can be drawn between parastoses and ectostoses , and the most typical endosteal deposit is merely an ossification of that part of the fibrous laminae which immediately enesses the cartilage .
756 whilst the whole of the notochordal region of the skull belongs to the occiput , this region , if it had suffered fission , would have sufficed to form a whole series of vertebrae .
Thus that cranial region which has most of the vertebral nature in it cannot answer to one actual vertebral segment , seeing that it contains ( subjected to the law of a new type of growth ) several potential segments .
As the skull proper cannot be shown to conform to the vertebral column , so neither can the facial arches be put into the same category with the ribs ; for the present they must wait until their development has been worked out perfectly in a considerable number of Vertebrate types : I mention this to excuse myself from all controversy concerning them in the present communication .
The mouth and the fauces ( the faucial region is of great extent in the Cyclostomous Fishes ) are hedged in by what are evidently one class of cartilages ; these may be either free rods or fenestrate plates : I propose to call these the " facio-faucial " skeleton .
These bars extend beyond the skull , and are very variably attached to it-in some of the lowest Vertebrates ( as the Cyclostomi , the Chimeroids , and the Lepidosiren ) being , anteriorly , mere outgrowths of the skull , whilst in the higher Classes they have a very independent development .
In the Bird there are only three poststomal arches developed , whilst in the gill-bearing " Ichthyopsida " there are several .
It seemed to me to be necessary to preface the description that is to follow with these remarks ; but I must now let the Bird 's head tell its own tale .
What there may be in this account which will not harmonize with the descriptions given in the former paper will be duly noted from time to time , and the reasons for a modified nomenclature will be given .
Structure of the Chick 's Skull , First Stage.-Head of Embryo 3 lines long : 4th Day of Incubation .
The appearance of the chick 's head and face on the 4th day , as seen from below , is well shown in Professor HUXLEY'S figure ( op .
cit. p. 139 , fig. 57 F ) ; another figure ( F ' ) shows the cartilaginous cranium of the same .
In Plate LXXXI .
figs. 1 &amp; 2,1 have given what appears to me to be the state of things at this early stage ; fig. 1 , however , the lower view , is somewhat diagrammatic , as I have in it anticipated the differentiation of the pterygo-palatine bar ( p.g.pa .
) from the next stage ; these show the parts as magnified 9 diameters .
The visceral clefts ( Plate LX : XXI .
fig. 1 , 1,2,3 ) are still evident ; and the fronto-nasal process ( f.n. ) is , as yet , free at its sides , so that the anterior nares ( n. ) are still mere clefts the foremost or prestomal clefts .
The great mouth-cleft ( m. ) is four-sided , with concave sides and produced angles ; and the anterior angles run into the nasal clefts : these clefts , and their intervening arches , all evidently belong to one category ; the arches surround , and the clefts open into the oro-faucial cavity .
To show the character of the skull-floor , a chick 's head at this stage has been sliced completely through , horizontally ( fig. 2 ) , the second and third cerebral vesicles have been completely removed , and the first vesicle , the subdividing rudiment of the hemispheres , has had its upper half removed ; the lower half of each eyeball is shown also in situ .
757 The notochord ( n.c. ) is seen to be half the length of the head , or a line and a half , and to reach within a very slight distance of the pituitary space ( p.t.s. ) : this relative but not real retreat of the notochord now bespeaks the first appearance of the postpituitary part of the basisphenoidal region .
The notochord is clubbed at its fore end , it then is narrower , then thicker between the auditory sacs ( c.l. ) , and is again somewhat diminished as it passes into the atlantal region .
The broad , thick plate of cartilage ( shown as somewhat sliced away , horizontally , above the cochlear cavities , c.l. , in the figure ) which lies right and left of the notochord , is the " investing mass " ( i.v. ) of RATHKE* .
At this stage the " investing mass " is rapidly passing from simple cartilage into the solid hyaline variety ; it is most dense nearest the notochord , and becomes more and more gelatinous as it is traced upwards into the wall of the cranium .
Hence the commencement of the spinal chord is not as yet bridged over by a cartilaginous superoccipital plate , and the cartilage in which the upper part of the auditory sacs are imbedded is still in a soft condition .
Here it may be at once remarked that no separate cartilaginous auditory capsule is formed in the chick ( such as can be plainly seen in the Tadpole ) , but the two moieties of the investing mass grow into one continuous " occipito-otic " cartilage t. At a small distance in front of the cochlear cavity ( c.l. ) the investing mass is suddenly narrowed : this is where the fifth nerve passes out ; and this nerve divides the occipito-otic region from the posterior sphenoidal .
At most , the clubbed anterior end of the notochord is wedged into the very end of the basisphenoidal region ; and afterwards it will be seen that the whole of its cranial portion becomes the axis of the basioccipital .
All the nerves between the fifth cranial and the first spinal are related to the investing mass ; so that even if it were ceded that the occipital region is essentially vertebral in its nature , yet it must then be looked upon , not as one segment , but the non-segmented counterpart of several .
On each side of the end of the notochord the investing mass at first grows outwards in an angular manner ( shown in Professor HUXLEY'S fig. 57 F ' , and in Plate LXXXI .
fig. 2 , l.g. ) ; these angles are the rudiments of the cartilaginous " lingulae sphenoidales ; " these parts arise from the roots of the trabeculce4 .
The trabecular roots are transversely crested ( the somewhat diagrammatic figure 2 shows this but feebly ) ; this is the angle of that bend formed by the early skull called the " cranial flexure " ( HUXLEY , Elem .
p. 137 ) .
This crest becomes very large , and is persistent , notwithstanding the after-straightening of the cranio-facial axis ; it is connected with the high " ' posterior clinoid wall .
" The anterior , smaller moiety of the cranio-facial axis is bent , first at an acute , and afterwards at an obtuse angle ; it is becoming obtuse on the fourth day ; all this fore part is formed by the " paired trabeculae : " these are flat bands of , at present , soft or simple cartilage ; they are now about oof an inch in width , and are moderately thick in proportion .
These bands are gently curved outwards at first , to enclose an elegantly ovoidal membranous space , the pituitary space ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 2 , tr .
, p.t.s. ) ; this space is enclosed by the early coalescence of the symmetrical bands in front of it ; and this coalesced part is nearly equal in length to the pituitary region .
The trabecule maintain a similar size to their extremities , but at their coalesced part they have begun to form an arched outgrowth on each sde ; these symmetrical expansions are the rudiments of the " aliethmoidal " and " aliseptal " cartilages of the nasal labyrinth .
This broadened ethmoidal part of the trabecule is bent backwards in a rounded manner on itself , so that the remaining part of the trabeculhe lies on a lower plane , parallel with the pituitary floor , and with the free ends looking directly backwards ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 1 , c.tr .
) ; the free ends are slightly divergent , and are separated by a space about equal to their own width .
These free retral ends of the trabecule are the " trabecular horns ; " they form the soft skeleton of the " ' fronto-nasal lamina " ( f.n. ) , and are developed into the " ale nasi " or " alinasal lamina , " and do not coalesce to form the intermaxillary axis or " prenasal cartilage , " as I once supposed ( see former paper , pp. 121 &amp; 122 ) .
The " fronto-nasal laminae " will have united with the " maxillary rudiment " ( m.r. ) to enclose the anterior nares ( n. ) before the " intermaxillary axis " will be evident : this will be described in the next stage .
Here one may pause to remark that the nasal labyrinth is formed continuously with the primordial cranium , just as is the case with the otic capsule ; any segmentation that may appear afterwards will thus be a secondary morphological process ; and thus the eyeballs are sharply distinguished from the other sensecapsules , which , from their undefined skeletal growth , and their relations to the visceral arches , form a most puzzling problem to the morphologist .
It will be seen from this description that the " anterior sphenoidal region " is scarcely at all represented at this stage ; for the somewhat narrowed waist formed by the trabeculae immediately in front of the pituitary body is all that has yet appeared of the " anterior clinoids , " the prepituitary part of the basisphenoid , and the presphenoid .
This latter part is , indeed , feebly represented in the adult Bird , and only occupies an angular space above the junction of the perpendicular ethmoid with the basisphenoid .
At present there is a curved , clubbed , subocular bar , the " maxillary rudiment " ( m.r. ) , which comes very close at its anterior clubbed end to the " fronto-nasal lamina , " but has not yet united with it to enclose the anterior nares ( n. ) .
In fig. 1 the cartilaginous differentiation of 759 ST/ RUCTURE AND the pith of this bar , my study of which has been from fine transverse sections in the next stage , is somewhat anticipated .
The axis of this soft bar is converted into the palatal and pterygoid rods ( pa. , pg .
) ; and from the outer edge of each of these bent clubs a lamina grows downwards ( see HUXLEY , op .
cit. fig. 57 G , 1 .
) , in the internal fibrous stroma of which the maxillary and jugal bones are afterwards formed .
The axis of the maxillary rudiment never has any cartilaginous connexion , anteriorly , in the Bird , with the ethmoidal lamina ( prefrontal ) ; and , behind , the chondrification of the pterygoid portion of this axis is quite distinct from , and much later than , that of the " quadrate .
" Here we see that the " subocular arch " is much modified from what is seen in the Ichthyopsida .
The primordial skull figured by Professor HUXLEY ( fig. 57 F ' ) must have been from a less mature embryo than that which I am here illustrating as my first stage ; for in that figure the quadrate ( qu .
) is shown as continuous with the antero-external part of the " investing mass .
" In my specimen ( Plate LXXXI .
figs. 1 &amp; 2 , u. ) the quadrate is already a very distinct tuberous mass of consistent cartilage , rapidly becoming hyaline .
MECKEL'S cartilage ( n.k. ) is also very distinct and solid , and its articular end has a sinuous face , answering to that on the lower end of the quadrate ; whilst the posterior and internal angular outgrowths have already appeared ( fig. 1 , m.k. ) .
These Meckelian rods are very short in proportion to their thickness , are gently curved forwards , and nearly meet at the mid line by rounded ends .
These axial parts of the first pair of poststomal laminae are surrounded by very delicate blastema the parent tissue of the splints , muscles , and skin of the lower jaw ; the outline of this primordial mandible is emarginate at the mid line .
That which is perhaps the most noteworthy in the first poststomal arch at this stage is its position with regard to the auditory capsule ; its pier , the quadrate , is segmented from the antero-external angle of the investing mass , directly in front of the periotic capsule , and opposite the junction of the anterior with the middle third of the cranial part of the notochord ; whilst the fifth nerve ( 5 ) passes out in front of it .
This normal position is lost and then regained before the chick is ripe .
Close behind the quadrate there is the first poststomal cleft ( 1 ) , ready to become converted into the complex tympanic cavity .
In the obtuse angle formed by the Meckelian rods , and lying on a higher plane than those rods , we find the distal arrested cartilages that belong to the second poststomal arch ; these are the " cerato- " and " basi-hyals " ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 1 , c.h. , b.h. ) .
At present these are merely thickened masses of blastema , their outline being somewhat indistinct , as the young cells of which they are composed are not sharply separated from the formative substance which will become their perichondrial investment .
The ceratohyals ( c.h. ) are even now only half the size of the mandibular rods ; but this is the greatest relative size they attain , for they diminish much afterwards .
There is no proper skeletal substance between the top of the cerato-hyals and the tissue that forms the auditory " columella " ( stapes ) : this latter part is not differentiated sufficiently to be described at present ; it is both late in appearance , and also very minute .
760 The basi-hyal ( b.h. ) , although formed in the united edges of symmetrical laminae , is , even as a defined mass of thickened blastema , quite azygous ; it is tear-shaped , the narrow end lying between the lower ends of the cerato-hyals ; this basal part is better defined than the arches , and chondrifies first .
Behind the second fast-closing cleft ( 2 ) there is now to be seen a pair of well-defined rods , nearly as large as the Meckelian cartilages , and as early in their chondrification ; these are the " branchials " ( c.br .
) , answering to the first branchial arch of the Ichthyopsida .
There is a less distinct upper piece , pointed and small ( e.br .
) , and a delicate streak of ill-defined blastema behind and between ( b.br .
) ; this latter is formed into the long slender so-called uro-hyal , the counterpart of the " basibranchial band .
" Behind the branchial arch a chink still indicates the place of the third visceral cleft ( 3)* .
At this early stage the arch of the tongue has begun to lie within the mandibular arch , just as the lessened first branchial arch comes to lie within the massive hyoid arch in the Osseous Fish .
Already the third visceral arch of the Bird has outgrown the second-a state of things universal in the Class of Birds .
Before leaving this stage , it may be noted , as instructively parallel with that which is persistent in Cartilaginous Fishes , that there is no exo-skeleton , no praemaxillee , maxillse , dentaries , angulars , or the like ; the mouth and unenclosed nostrils are entirely below the head : these , and the rudimentary tympanic cavities , open freely into each other , and are all lined with dermal tissue , which is , as it were , tucked in between the visceral laminae from the outer surface of the head .
Second Stage.-IHead of Embryo from 4 to 5lines long : 5th to 7th Days of Incubation .
In the course of twenty-four hours great changes have taken place in the chick 's skull and face .
In an embryo with a head 4 lines long ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 3 , 6 diam. ) , a vertical section shows the notochordal region to be shorter than that formed by the trabecule ; and this anterior moiety of the cranio-facial axis has become much straighter , the head having now to a great extent recovered from the " cranial flexure .
" The " investing mass " has become more solid ; and a distinct swelling on each side , posteriorly , shows how the occipital condyle ( o.c. ) is formed-very reptilian , however , in shape , at first .
On each side , a thin soft lamina of cartilage ( e.o. ) is growing up behind the third cerebral vesicle ( c.v. 3 ) ; this is the commencement of the occipital plane .
At the angle formed by the bending of the primordial cranium upon itself , a transverse crest of cartilage has grown rapidly upwards and backwards ; this , the " posterior clinoid wall , " protects the pituitary body behind , and lies in the midst of a quantity of delicate stroma , which eventually becomes the fore part of the " tentorium cerebelli .
" The internal carotid artery ( i.e. ) is seen to be entering the skull in front of this wall .
The greater part of the investing mass may now be treated of as the basioccipital region ( b.o. ) ; anteriorly the nascent fibrous tissue is thickening below this part to become a bed for the deposit of the basitemporal .
The pituitary space is now much foreshortened , very deep , and is indicated in the figure by the entrance of the internal carotid artery ( i.e. ) ; the cartilage has become high , even below and between the optic nerves ( 2 ) ; and close in front of the pituitary body the anterior clinoid ridge ( a.cl .
) has commenced .
But in front of the optic nerves the greatest and most sudden change has taken place , the very short broad waist between the pituitary space and the rudimentary ethmoidal alae shown in fig. 2 being at this stage greatly elongated and altogether developed into a high crest : this is the ethmo-presphenoidal plate ( p.sp .
, eth .
) .
This plate , which is rapidly passing into hyaline cartilage , is somewhat higher behind than before , is nearly straight above , is oblique behind , above the optic nerves , concave below , and has a gently convex margin in front .
The alae of the nasal labyrinth are not shown in this section ; but above and below the line where these have been cut away on the left side , two projections are seen .
The upper of these is the retral spike , in which the ethmoid ends behind above the olfactory crura* ; whilst the lower process is one of the greatest importance in the morphology of the face , it being the prenasal or snout-cartilage ( p.n. ) .
This part , which is the endoskeletal axis of the premaxillary region , grows at first backwards as well as downwards , having the same direction as the " fronto-nasal lamina , " and being an azygous outgrowth from the crest which forms between the trabecular cornua the rudimentary septum nasi , continuous with the ethmo-presphenoidal plate .
The cornua themselves , as I have already asserted , develope themselves into the ale nasi .
This condition of the prenasal cartilage is like what is seen in the ripe embryo of the Green Turtle ( Chelone mydas ) ; in that animal , however , it is less rounded in shape , and projects further downwards , forming a soft core to the premaxillariest .
The thick arcuate inferior edge of the ethmo-presphenoidal plate has already begun to be underlain by that fibrous stroma which afterwards thickens very much between the basis cranii and palatal skin to form a nidus for the rostral part of the " parasphenoid .
" Below , and on each side of the basis cranii , the maxillary rudiment has begun to send downwards the facial lamina in which the maxillary and jugal bones are afterwards developed , and to have a more distinct rod on the inner side , which becomes the palatine ( pa. ) and the pterygoid ( p.g. ) ; but this will be best studied in a chick a day or two older .
I shall also leave the mandibular ( m.k. ) and hyoid cartilages ( h. ) for description from an older embryo .
The development of the parts goes on very rapidly , so that when the head is 5 lines in length a much clearer idea of the structure of the parts can be obtained .
A vertical section , left-hand of the septum , of such a skull is shown in Plate LXXXI .
fig. 4 , and a side view in fig. 5 , both magnified 6 diameters ; in these views the cerebral vesicles are not figured .
A low ornithic type , such as is persistent in the Ostrich , is now attained .
I have already had to compare the skull of the chick with that of a Plagiostome and of a Turtle ; after the Struthious stage has been passed , many of the higher ornithic specializations will rapidly appear .
The straightening of the cranio-facial axis has gone on so as to make the face much more prognathous ; and the axis of the anterior part of the face ( p.n. ) is especially altered , so as to have already taken on an ornithic character ; the boundary , also , between the nasal and orbital regions can now be seen .
One landmark has become especially visible , on account of the denser condition of the cartilage ; this is the bridge for the nasal nerve ( n.n. ) : in the adult bird this is seen near the free postero-inferior angle of the nasal septum .
For some distance behind this bridge the cartilage continues thicker than we find it between the eyeballs ; the larger , thinner , posterior part of the craniofacial axis answers to the whole of the presphenoid and the posterior or interorbital part of the perpendicular ethmoid .
The grooves for the olfactory nerve ( 1 ) can be well seen ; and the retral spike of the ethmoid surmounting the nerve-grooves has become much more defined , and has begun to take a backward direction instead of the vertical and human direction it had a day or two before ( see Plate LXXXI .
fig. 3 , eth .
) .
This is now the highest part of the cranio-facial axis , whereas the presphenoid was the highest in the last embryo .
The whole base of the prepituitary part of the primordial skull is very thick and rounded ; and its thickness from side to side increases in the prenasal cartilage ( p.n. ) , which now shows itself to be a very fit model on which the premaxillaries of any type of Bird might be formed ; in no Bird whatever , let the shape of its face be what it will , is the type of the first model or platform wholly lost , although in every case the primordial structure ( into the type of which they were cast , as it were , ) undergoes very early wasting .
Between the palatal skin below , and the still very arcuate skull-base above , a considerable mass of stroma is formed , which is cordiform in section , and which soon becomes the seat of the rostral ( or anterior parasphenoidal ) ossification : this rostral stroma ( r.st .
) is shown in fig. 6 , magnified 12 diameters .
This tract is composed of thin-walled baggy cells , which never chondrify ( except on the surface in certain birds , as the Psittacinae and Ardeine ) , but develope either into bone ( internally ) or into periosteum ( externally ) .
In fig. 7 the differentiation of the tissues that underlie the skull-base in the posterior ethmoidal region is shown , magnified 160 diameters .
The ethmoid ( eth .
) is already formed of ordinary hyaline cartilage , with abundant intercellular substance and tear-shaped cells ; next below this is a tract of very delicate granular 52 763 stroma ( gr.st .
) , then a deep layer of the larger-celled young connective tissue ( r.st .
) , and below this the epithelium of the palate ( ep.l .
) .
The aggregation of a thick bed of nascent fibrous tissue between the skull-base and the palate and fauces , and the conversion of the greater part of this mass into bone in a very early stage , is common to many of the Vertebrata-for instance , the Ganoid and Teleostean Fishes , the Amphibians and Ophidians ; the Lizards show this structure much more feebly .
The thickened and solidified postpituitary part of the basis cranii shows this superfaucial mass the seat of the " basitemporal " ossifications ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 4 , bt.st .
) ; the fibrous layer thins out towards the occipital condyle .
The parts of the primordial skull can now be made out more clearly ; the exoccipital lamina ( e.o. ) is growing upwards to meet its fellow in the superoccipital region ( s.o. ) , and thus enclose the spinal chord .
Above the meatus internus ( m.i. ) the anterior semicircular canal is seen to bulge inwards and to grow backwards ; below and behind the meatus is seen the eighth nerve ( 8 ) , below and in front of it the cochlear elevation ( c.l. ) nearing the mid line .
The low anterior clinoid elevation ( a.cl .
) and the high posterior clinoid wall ( p.dl .
) are well seen , and the notochord ( n.c. ) mounting up between the moieties of this wall , which now begin to coalesce across their middle ; they do not unite , however , either above or below .
A thin lobe of cartilage ascends the side wall of the skull outside and behind the posterior clinoid wall ; this is the rudiment of the alisphenoid ( a.s. ) ; it is connected with the periotic capsule by a bridge of cartilage , which arches over the trigeminal nerve ( 5 ) .
The internal carotid artery ( i.e. ) finds its way into the pituitary space ( p.t.s. ) through a mass of soft fibrous stroma .
On the outer side of the primordial skull other parts can be seen ; this view is given in fig. 5 ; here the facial arches are also shown .
The nasal labyrinth developes with extraordinary rapidity , so that by the end of the first week all the main parts can be seen .
Anteriorly the flat trabecular horn has expanded into the alinasal cartilage ( al.n .
) , with its enclosed turbinal or vestibular flap ( n.t. ) ; behind this is the aliseptal region ( al.s .
) enclosing the inferior turbinal co and posteriorly there is the alietethe thmoidal lamina , which is continued downwards between the nose and the eye as the anteorbital plate or " pars plana " ( p.p. ) ^ .
Fig. 6 shows a transversely vertical section ( 12 diam. ) through the ethmoidal region , immediately in front of the anteorbital laminae ( p.p. ) , which are seen to be continuous with the aliethmoidal coil ( al.e .
) , and to have no distinct " middle turbinal " outgrowth on their anterior face .
In this view part of the cartilaginous sclerotic ( scl .
) is shown , and the section is also made through the middle of the palatine bar ( pa. ) .
Here is seen the true " schizognathous " condition of the palate ; the mouth* The " ' pars plana " is continuous with the rest of the nasal labyrinth in all Birds ; my earlier studies of these parts misled me ; and in my paper " On the Osteology of the Gallinacee ?
( Zool. Trans. , 1863 , vol. v. p. 179 ) I spoke of this plate as being " autogenous in its cartilaginous state , as well as in its ossified condition .
" In the paper on the Ostrich 's skull ( p. 127 et seq. ) this part was described as continuous with the rest of the nasal labyrinth .
764 cavity being continuous , between the narrow palatines , with the plicated nasal sac , although the chink between the rostral stroma ( r.st .
) and the anteorbital plate is very narrow .
Seen from the outside , the alisphenoid ( a.s. ) shows an oblique crest ; this is the postfrontal plate ( p.f ) ; it is largely developed in Fishes , but entirely absent ( as is also the alisphenoid itself ) in the Lizards and Chelonians .
Infero-laterally the cartilage of the auditory region is scooped to form the tympanic cavity ; but at present this part is filled with a gelatinous stroma , which grows very rapidly for a week or two and is then absorbed .
The horizontal ( h.s.c. ) and posterior ( p.s.c. ) semicircular canals now shine out through the occipital cartilage , and the exoccipital region ( e.o. ) has developed its tympanic wing .
The quadrate cartilage ( q. ) has received a large and peculiar development , and , like the uncloven orbito-nasal septum , has attained a struthious condition .
Anteriorly the little nodule figured in the First Stage ( Plate LXXXI .
figs. 1 &amp; 2 , q. ) has grown into an arched blunt-pointed " orbital process ; " inferiorly it has become a thick bar with two oblique condyles for articulation with the mandible ; whilst posteriorly it has grown into a long arched crus , which not only articulates with the periotic capsule , above the junction of the prootic and opisthotic regions , but also with the exoccipital in front of the root of its tympanic wing .
This articulation is shown in fig. 5a ( 16 diam. ) and fig. 5 ( 6 diam. ) , and it is seen to answer to what is depicted in my former paper on the Ostrich-tribe ( Plates VII.-XIv .
) ; in the Tinamou ( Plate xv .
fig. 1 , q. ) some recovery of the original position is attained * .
Where the quadrate cartilage articulates with the cranium , the side wall is somewhat scooped ; but further down two small clefts appear , which , however , never go beyond the condition of fenestrne : these are the " fenestra ovalis " and " f. rotunda " ( or f. vestibuli and f. cochleme ) .
The fenestra ovalis is , properly speaking , an aperture in the fundus of the cup-shaped articular cavity in which the head of the stapes ( Plate LXXXI .
figs. 5 &amp; 5a , st. ) is articulated , and is morphologically like the acetabular fenestra of the Bird , and the glenoid fenestra of the Proteus and Cryptobranchus ( see ' Shoulder-girdle and Sternum , ' pl. 3 , figs. 1 &amp; 3 , gl .
) .
From the first the parts of the hyoid arch are very inferior in size and later in development than those of the mandible ; at this stage , after the quadrate has undergone so much modification and is so well chondrified , the stapes can only now be distinctly seen ; and its outgrowths are mere bud-like projections from the main shaft .
It is seen that the head of the quadrate projects some distance behind that of the stapes ; but this truly ornithic modification is , exceptionally , only of short duration in the Fowl .
At present the stapes is relatively a much more massive bar than afterwards ; seen from the front and side ( Plate LXXXI .
figs. 9 &amp; 10 , 24 diam. ) it appears as a flattened rod , curved forwards , with an oval head and a trilobate flattened base , the leading ray of which is most curved forwards and outwards* .
There is still a considerable tract of cartilage to be described in the proximal part of the face , namely the pterygo-palatine bar .
The prenasal cartilage ( already described ) is an azygous prestomal counterpart of the Meckelian rods , although it does not become cloven from the primordial skull , and is never related to a free proximal cartilage , like the Meckelian bars ; but the pterygo-palatine bar is perhaps the most difficult part of the cephalic skeleton to interpret .
Seeing its primordial independence of the skull in the chick , and noting its early subdivision into a posterior short , and an anterior longer bar , it seems to be very feasible to compare its two divisions with the quadrate and the Meckelian rod .
It lies above and in front of the great stomal cleft , much as the mandibular rods lie below and behind ; but its point of suspension is a great difficulty ; and the mind of the observer will revert to its various development in the Ichthyopsida .
In the Chimaeroids and in the Lepidosiren this part is not only continuous with the skull-base , but also with the prenasal cartilage in front , and with the common pier of the mandibular and hyoid arches ( MULLER , 'Myxinoids , ' pl. v. fig. 2 ; and HUXLEY , op .
cit. p. 196 , fig. 78 , and p. 209 , fig. 85 ) ; in the Frog the palatine passes , anteriorly , directly into the prefrontal cartilage ( op .
cit. p. 216 , fig. 87 ) .
In the chick , the position of the pterygo-palatine bar is below and external to the basis cranii ( figs. 5 &amp; 6 ) , from which it is separate from its first differentiation ; it has , however , a much more intimate connexion with the quadrate , but is well differentiated from it on the fourth day ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 1 , p.g. , g. ) , and , indeed , has very different'histological characters .
The suspensorial parts of the pterygo-palatine bar are feebly developed , and are late in their appearance ; these come to be below the optic foramen for the pterygoid , and below the prefrontal plate for the palatine : these will be described hereafter .
At present the relation of the palatine bar to the prefrontal plate ( fig. 6 , p.p. , pa. ) is totally unlike what is seen in the Frog ; for , between the two , there is not only the thick fibrous stroma in which the delicate palatine bar is imbedded , but also the open channel which connects the cavity of the mouth with the interior of the nasal labyrinth .
I would much rather interpret this bar by its specialized and freed condition in the Bird , than by what is seen in the low Vertebrate types , where the rampant growth of cartilage masks the proper morphological boundaries ; and yet even in the high type the bar would seem to bear two interpretations-namely , that it may be a single arch , like the mandibular , the pterygoid being the equivalent of the quadrate ; or , on the other hand , the pterygoid and the palatine may be proximal parts of two arches , neither of which has a free descending ray ; but I am extremely doubtful about the latter interpretation , and strongly incline to regard the mandibular , pterygo-palatine , and trabecular rays as true serial counterparts .
The true histological growth and development of the pterygo-palatine bar has cost me much labour ; only by examining sections made at many stages , and by seeing these under very high powers , has the meaning been made apparent .
In a fresh-made section at this stage ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 6 ) the tissues composing the ethmoid ( eth .
) , the rostrum ( r.st .
) , the palatine ( pa. ) , and the sclerotic ( scl .
) do not appear very much unlike when seen by low powers ; afterwards their differing characters may be seen .
The cells composing the sclerotic ( scl .
) are smaller than those which make up the ethmoid ( eth .
) ; but they rapidly form hyaline cartilage ; and both these tracts are more translucent than the rostral stroma or the cells composing the palatine .
The latter can , however , be seen to transmit the light better than the rostral mass ; and by the use of high powers ( 320 diam. ) the structure of the rod becomes sharply distinguished from the nascent cellular tissue in which it is imbedded , and also from the more advanced connective-tissue cells of the rostrum .
Much the greater part of the palatine bar ( fig. 11 ) is composed of delicate , sharp-ended , fusiform cells of simple cartilage* , having large granular nuclei ; but the pith of the bar is composed of still more delicate and smaller cells having an oval form , and without apparent nuclei-at least as seen magnified 320 diameters ; it is this pith which is the first to ossify ; and the transformation of the simple cartilage into bone is so rapid as to give the deposit the appearance of a membrane bonet .
The further development of the palatine bar will be described hereafter ; and the pterygoid ( p.g. ) , which is at present composed of simple cartilage similar to that of the palatine region , will be considered at the same time .
There now remain for description the free part of the facial ( poststomal ) arches ; and the keystones that complete them .
There is no keystone to the mandibular arch , which is entirely composed of the articulo-meckelian rod .
This rod ( Plate LXXXI .
figs. 5 &amp; 12 , m.k , are .
) is a gently curved very solid bar of hyaline cartilage ; it bulges and narrows two or three times , but does not greatly diminish in size even at its rounded anterior end .
The articular portion is scooped in harmony with the swellings on the lower face of the quadrate ; and from this part there project two finger-shaped processes ; these are the internal ( i.a.p ) and posterior ( p.ap .
) angular processes .
Already these processes show the type to which the bird belongs ; for they have a peculiar development in the whole " Gallo-Anserine " series , and in one or two mixed cognate forms ( for instance , in the Flamingo ) ; they attain their most extraordinary development in the " ( Tetraonine " subgroup of the Gallina , and especially in Tetrao utrogallzs .
In a somewhat earlier stage ( head of embryo 41 lines long , see Plate LXXXI .
fig. 12 , 12 diam. ) , notwithstanding the rapid elongation of the Meckelian bar ( m.k. ) , these processes are scarcely more developed than in the Struthious Birds ( see former paper , Plates II.-XIV .
) , and the ends of these short processes are very knobbed .
In this instance the nascent connective fibres surrounding these parts were quite free from osseous deposit , and so was the rest of the primordial skull , now representing the Cartilaginous Fishes ; but in one a day or so older the splint-bones had commenced outside the perichondrium of the Meckelian rod ( fig. 13 , su .
) .
Here the upper view of the articular part of the mandible shows that it is a bifurcating or partially double ray , which developes a grooveand-ridged articular surface on its upper face , at the point of bifurcation .
The next poststomal cephalic arch ( the hyoid ) is slow of growth , feeble in development , and rapidly gains an enclosed position , instead of maintaining its proper surface parallelism with the mandibles .
The arches themselves ( the cerato-hyals ) are mere distal rudiments , such as we often see in the costal arches , a long space of mere fibrous tissue intervening between the arch and the pier .
Their chondrification is late , as a correlate of their feeble growth .
A somewhat earlier and stouter piece of cartilage appears between and behind them , the basi-hyal ( b.h. ) ; it is tear-shaped , with the pointed end foremost .
Behind this , with its pointed end looking backwards , a longer and narrower piece appears ; this is the so-called uro-hyal ( b.br .
) , an azygous bar answering to the basi-branchial series of the Fish-class generally , and not to the " uro-hyal " of the Osseous Fish-which is a fibrous bone , a " basi-branchiostegal .
" The first branchial arch of the Fish is here represented by a stout ray segmented into an upper smaller ( e.br .
) , and a lower larger segment ( c.br .
) : these are they that suffer such extraordinary development in the Humming-birds and Woodpeckers , and which in typical birds always surmount the occipital plane , whilst in the typical Struthionide ( op .
cit. Plates un .-xIv .
) they are arrested at the stage here described in the chick .
Third Stage.-Head of Embryo from 8 to 9 lines long : middle of 2nd Week of Incubation .
Henceforth my work will fill both hands at once ; for now the skeleton of the skin and its enfoldings will everywhere present itself side by side with the proper primordial 768 parts of the skull-building ; and , unlike what the easier problem of the lower types , as a rule , presents , we shall see the outer works growing upon and grafting themselves into the inner works , and afterwards both the skeletons becoming compacted together and growing into the simplest brain-casket in one part , and the most mobile prehensile organ in the other .
This third stage is in some respects parallel with what is seen in certain Teleostean Fishes , in which there is a free development of the cartilaginous endoskeleton , which is but little ossified , whilst the secondary or splint-skeleton is very frail and delicate ; such skeletons are possessed by the Lump-fish ( Cyclopterus ) , and by the Salmon .
In , the illustrations of this stage the figures are drawn and magnified from embryos with the head two-thirds of an inch long ; here several of the ectosteal patches have appeared within the perichondrium , and the splint-bones are all present .
The primordial skull , when stripped of its infoldings and seen from below , presents the appearance shown in Plate LXXXII .
fig. 1 ( magnified 10 diam. ) ; here the nasal labyrinth is not shown .
T1he prenasal cartilage ( p.n. ) has increased in size , and has become straightened so as to lie nearly on the same line as the septum nasi ( s.n. ) and ethmoid ( eth .
) ; it has not yet reached the acme of its growth , but has become spatulate at its end , and now well represents its large counterpart in the Plagiostomous Fishes , namely their azygous snout-cartilage .
The base of the ethmo-vomerine plate ( s.n. , eth .
) gradually narrows to a pair of free plates ( a.p. ) , and then a pair of continuous lobes or outgrowths ( .g .
) .
These free plates have , to me , only received an explanation after many years of work ; on referring to my former paper ( Plate vii .
fig. 4 , a.p. ) , it will be seen that in an embryo of Struthio camelus , the counterpart in development with this stage of the chick , the " anterior pterygoid processes " ( " basipterygoids " of HUXLEY ) grow directly out of the roots of the trabeculae , in front and on each side of the pituitary space : the same thing takes place in the other Struthionide ( op .
cit. Plate ix.-xv .
) ; and this state of things is also seen in the Lacertilia generally , and exceptionally in the Mammalia ( for instance , Cavia aperea* ) .
Collateral work has prepared me for seeing into the metamorphic modification of the skull-base of the Fowl as compared with that of the Ostrich .
If the reader refer to the memoir on the " Shoulder-girdle and Sternum " ( plates 16 &amp; 17 ) , he will see a precisely similar modification of parts that form the shoulder-arch ; for , whilst the precoracoid of the Ostrich ( plate 17 .
figs. 5 &amp; 6 , p.cr .
) is continuous with the rest of i MRE .
WK .
K PARKER ON THE STRUCTURE AND the shoulder-plate , in the Pheasant ( plate 16 .
fig. 4 , p.cr .
) it is a distinct segment , later and feebler in its chondrification than the main bar .
All Birds above the Ostriches agree in this ; whilst all the typical Struthionide have a Reptilian continuity in these parts : in this they agree also with certain low Mammalia , e. g. the Monotremata .
The manner in which the simple clavicular membrane-bone gra-fts itself upon the detached precoracoid of the Fowl is precisely similar to the behaviour of the splints of the skullbase of the same and other birds .
Like the precoracoidal segment , the basipterygoid plates ( a.p. ) are late in their appearance , as compared with the rest of the basisphenoidal region ; their further development will be described hereafter .
Ultimately it will be seen that there is nothing in the adult bird to distinguish them from those of the Ostrich , their smaller size and more forward position not being of any essential importance .
In the first stage ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 2 , tr .
) the roots of the trabecule were seen to project outwards ; in the next ( fig. 8 , I.g. ) a retral lobe could just be distinguished on each side of the pituitary space ; now a very perfect differentiation of this part is manifest , and a pair of very notable ear-shaped processes ( Plate LXXXII .
figs. 1 &amp; 3 , I.g. ) are seen projecting backwards , one on each side of the deep " sella turcica .
" At present these parts are entirely cartilaginous , and present a peculiar appearance ; for the cells in their interior are crowded together and full of granules ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 16 , magnified 250 diam. ) , so as to present the appearance of a very dark pith : this is similar to what is seen in the persistent trabecular rods of the Ophidia .
The remarkable ornithic modification which these parts undergo will be described by and by ; at present I make bold to assert that they answer to the unossified " lingulae sphenoidales " of the human embryo : they receive their osseous deposit from another source , namely from the azygous parasphenoidal piece* ; but to interpret the primordial skeleton by the after-deposits of bone is to study the mask , and not the face .
Behind the pituitary space the base of the skull , in its thick part , forms a very narrow waist ; and the moieties of this pinched part are also contracted at their inner edge .
This lateral retreat of the fore part of the " investing mass " gives rise to RATIIKE'S " posterior basicranial fontanelle " ( p.b.f ) ; it is occupied along its mid line by the notochord ( Plate LXXXII .
figs. 1 &amp; 3 , n.c. ) : it is not , as I once supposed , the hinder part of the original hypophysial or pituitary space , cut off by the formation of the " posterior clinoid wall , " but it is a subsequent modification , caused by the opening-up and widening of the primordial fissure in which the notochord lies ; for the moieties of the investing mass are seen to press closely on the notochord in the first stage ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 2 ) the chink is larger in the second stage ( fig. 8 ) ; and by the end of the second week a wide lozenge-shaped space is formed ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 2 , p.b.f. ) .
Gradually , as the skull outgrows the notochord , this region becomes the shelving postpituitary part of the basisphenoid .
The thin part on each side of the fontanelle is the root of the alisphenoid ( a.s.)* From a careful comparison of these parts in the lower Maammalia with those of Man , I feel satisfied that the bony " lingula " in that Class answer to the " basitemporal " rudiments of the ' " parasphenoid .
" 770 which is a crest of cartilage altogether continuous with the investing mass , and the root of the corresponding trabecula : this part will be better shown in the description of the fourth stage .
On each side , and a little behind the posterior fontanelle , the investing mass rises into an elegant mammillary swelling ; this is seen both above and below , and arises from the enclosed cochlea , the cavity of which , and the lower otoconial deposit , can be well seen when the skull is viewed by transmitted light ( see Plate LXXXI .
figs. 1 &amp; 3 , c.l. ) .
These swellings reach to within a small distance of the notochord ( n.c. ) ; on the outside they are bounded , on the lower face of the skull , by the carotid groove ( c.g. ) , and posteriorly they nearly reach to the foramen for the vagus nerve ( 8 ) .
The notochord ( n.c. ) , which lies above as well as between the moieties of the investing mass , has relatively receded , through the more rapid growth of the surrounding structures ; it is now at its fullest development , and osseous tissue has appeared on its upper surface , behind .
Although belonging , in the early embryo , to the basioccipital region only , the notochord becomes constricted in several places ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 3 , n.c. ) as if it were ready , if the investing mass were so disposed , to undergo hourglass-like segmentation .
The cells of which the swollen parts are composed are oval , thin-walled , and contain many granules ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 5 , 250 diam. ) ; they form a good instance of cellular or indifferent tissue , as the intercellular substance is almost inappreciable .
The osseous deposit takes place at first on the posterior third , on the upper face of the rod ( fig. 3 ) , and it appears as a fenlestrate ectosteal plate ( fig. 6 , n.c. , 250 diam. ) : when once set up , the parent cells below soon disappear ; and after a while the bony substance spreads over the investing mass ( i.v. ) on each side , and sets up endostosis in that part which , soon acquiring an inferior ectosteal place by the extension of ossification through the primordial chink , lays the foundation of the triple basioccipital bone .
Posteriorly another pair of smaller , but more convex mammillke , are formed ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 1 , o.c. ) , these are the occipital condyles ; between these , which have coalesced largely below , and in some degree above ( fig. 3 , o.e. , n.c. ) , a portion of the notochord projects , part of which belongs to the " ' atlas .
" Outside the carotid groove the periotic portion of the investing mass becomes scooped into an oblong rounded sulcus .
This sulcus has only a low wall in front , but is bounded behind by a large ear-like flap of the exoccipital lamina ; this latter is the " tympanic wing of the exoccipital : " and the sulcus is the rudiment of the tympanic cavity ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 1 , tie .
) ; at present it is filled with a soft flocculent stroma , soon to be absorbed .
The upper head of the quadrate is loosing its connexion with the occipital ala at the end of the sulcus , and is acquiring a cup-and-ball articulation with the fore part .
The low ridge bounding the sulcus externally is the rudiment of the " tegmen tympani " of the Mammal ; the lower lip of the tympanic cavity is supplied by the fibrous skeleton , there being no such cartilaginous lamina as is seen in the highest Class .
At present the whole of the periotic capsule is unossified ; but , besides the notochordal shaft , the occipital region has acquired a pair of triangular bony patches ; these are the exoccipitals ( Plate LXXXII .
figs. 1 &amp; 2 , e.o. ) : they extend from the posterior selvedge 5K2 771 to the vagus foramen ; the bony matter is deposited on the inner face of the perichondrium , and soon sets up endostosis in the subjacent cells .
Although commencing on the outside , the deposit soon spreads round the selvedge , along the inner face of the cartilage ( Plate LXXX1I .
fig. 3 , e.o. ) .
The superoccipital lamina ( Plate LXXXII .
figs. 1 &amp; 2 , s.o. ) is notched both above and below at the mid line ; it is soft at present , but in a day or so acquires a small external bony patch on each side of the mid line : this is a mammalian character ; and I know of only one genus ( e. g. Turdus ) in which the superoccipital is azygous .
The symmetrical bony deposits seen in fig. 1 ( b.s. ) are borrowed , and will be described with the splint bones ; the palatines ( Plate LXXXII .
figs. 1 &amp; 7 , pa. ) are thoroughly ossified , and their subsequent increase is , in the Fowl , entirely at the expense of the fibrous investment , their primordial cartilaginous rod being the most transitory of any in the body ; their ossification is by endostosis , the deposit commencing in the central pith of oval cells .
As far as I know , this is the only instance of " primary endostosis " in the skull of the chick ; in the old bird I shall describe a few endosteal patches in the nasal labyrinth * .
But the pterygoid , which is best studied at this stage , is ossified , like an ordinary shaft-bone , by " primary ectostosis " ( Plate LXXXII .
figs. 2 &amp; 2B , p.g. ) , although but little of the cartilage ever becomes hyaline .
The ectosteal deposit ( fig. 10 , ect .
) soon spreads amongst and ossifies the cartilage-cells , which are large , extremely thin-walled , fusiform externally , and passing into almost polyhedral cells towards the interior : they contain a large granular nucleus .
These simple cells are rapidly converted into bone , but much later than in the palatine bar .
An ectosteal patch has appeared on the broadest part of the quadrate ( fig. 2 , q. ) , and an ectosteal ring on the lower branchial ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 15 , c.br .
) : these are all the bony deposits to be seen in the endoskeletal parts of the head at this stage .
The stapes ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 14t , st. ) has advanced very considerably in development , although entirely unossified ; there can now be seen : the wedge-shaped shaft ( st. ) , the " extrastapedial " process ( e.st .
) , which turns forward to apply its outer edge to the membrana tympani ; the long antero-inferior process , the " infra-stapedial " ( i.st .
) , which grows forward to apply itself to the lower lip of the tympanic cavity , and then becomes related to the basitemporal ; and the crested postero-superior process , the " suprastapedial " ( s.st .
) , to which is attached an ascending ligament .
In fig. 14 the relation of the stapes to the fenestra vestibuli ( f.o. ) is shown ; and in the section the squamosal ( sq .
) is seen outlying the periotic wall ; then there is an open space above , which in the embryo is filled with an evanescent gelatinous tissue ; mesiad of this is a section of the anterior semicircular canal ( a.sc .
) : the vestibule ( v.b. ) is laid open ; and the back wall of the cochlea shows by transmitted light the cavity itself , and the enclosed lower otoconial mass .
Mesiad of the stapes the internal carotid ( i.e. ) is seen as it runs forward to gain the open pituitary space ; and the section shows also how completely continuous the periotic cartilage is with the investing mass ( i.v. ) .
This section is viewed from behind ; and being somewhat oblique , the left side shows the cochlea ( c.l. ) laid quite open , and the curled plate of calcareous granules ( ot .
) is seen lying in the inner end of the sac .
The delicate distal ceratohyals ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 15 , c.h. ) have coalesced at both ends , a primordial chink being left along the mid line ; the basihyal ( b.h. ) , basibranchial ( b.br .
) , and the branchials ( c.br .
, e.br .
) have assumed much of their persistent form .
All the membrane bones have commenced , and several of them may be described at once ; the relations of the remainder will be seen best in the next stage .
The premaxillaries ( Plate IXXXII .
figs. 2 &amp; 2A , p.x. ) appear in the thick , soft , fibrous investment of the prenasal cartilage ( p.n. ) outtside the perichondrium ; they are triangular at first , and then rapidly develope their nasal ( fig. 2A ) , marginal , and palatine processes ( fig. 2 ) , The maxillaries* ( fig. 2 , m.x. ) are developed at some distance from the endoskeleton , in the fore part of that flap which grows downwards from the maxillary rudiment ( see HUXLEY , Elem .
Comp. Anat .
p. 138 , fig. 57 G , 1 ) ; they are at first a delicate thread septum nasi , and is the rudiment of the palatine aplate or " maxillo-palatine .
" A much smaller style lies in the cheek-flap behind the maxillary ; it is pointed at both ends , and its anterior end lies outside the end of the maxillary : this is the jugal ( j. ) .
Behind the jugal is the quadrato-jugal ( q.j. ) ; it is twice as large as the jugal , passes within it for some distance , becomes rather thick , and then curves inwards at its end to articulate with the quadrate .
The nasals , frontals , parietals ( not figured in the illustration of this stage ) are delicate dendritic deposits in the soft fibrous tissues of the superethmoidal and cranial regions ; the squamosal forms a bony eave to the prootic region ( Plate LXXXI .
fig. 14 , sq .
) , and is formed , like the frontals and parietals , in the inner layer of the scalp , outside the perichondrium of the related cartilage .
With all these calcifying membranes every one is familiar ; not so with those that substruct the base of the primordial skull .
My description of these parts will differ considerably from that given in my former paper , as in my earlier observations I had mistaken the cellular tissue composing the " rostrum " for simple cartilage , and the two parosteal tracts behind it ( the basitemporals ) for ectosteal plates ; the layer of cartilage , also , which I supposed ( " Struthious Skull , " p. 117 ) to form a floor to the pituitary space , has no existence in the Bird .
Professor HUXLEY ( Op. cit. p. 170 ) first showed that the so-called " basipresphenoid " of osseous Fishes is nothing but a membrane bone ; in them , and in the Amphibia , a thick tract of cpalato-fatucial subcutaneous fibrous tissue is converted into a large beam of bone , which runs forwards beneath the nasal region anteriorly , and backwards below the temporal region behind .
This bone is well developed in the Anmphibia ( HUXLEY , op .
cit. p. 214 , fig. 86 , B , x ) , and its posterior or temporal wings are outspread , whereas in the Fish they are often turned very sharply upwards .
In the chick , in the next stage to be described , there is exactly such a tract of bone , but it has formed strong bony attachments to the true skull-base ; at present this connexion has begun , but it is slight , and easily detached : but , besides this , the osseous matter is in three separate territories , instead of being one continuous sheet as in the Fish and Frog .
The anterior , narrow ossicle , the " rostrum , " is styloid ; it is formed by the conversion into bone of the rostral stroma figured in Plate LXXXI .
figs. 6 &amp; 7 , r.st .
; posteriorly osseous matter has run from it into the lower edge of the walls of the pituitary space ; here the innermost part of a parosteal tract has become the ectosteal layer to the cartilage , and parostoses , ectostoses , and endostoses all run into each other , the first being the " cue " to the second and third : this I call the grafting of an exoskeletca splint bone ulpon an endoskceletal region .
The osseous deposit , so far forth as it has immediate.relation to the cartilage of the pituitary region , forms a pair of basisphenoidal ossicles the equivalents of the symmetrical basisphenoidals of the Lizard and of Man ; these are figured as detached from the " rostrum " in Plate LXXXII .
figs. 1 &amp; 3 , b.s. ; on the upper surface ( fig. 3 ) it is shown how the bony matter creeps round and into the trabecular root* .
The rest of the basis cranii is quite separable from the thick subcutaneous floor , and the breadth suddenly expands behind the pituitary region ; so also the faucial portion of the fibrous mat is of great breadth ( fig. 2 , b.t. ) .
In shape this layer is like the leaf of a Bauhinia , the " rostrum " answering to the leaf-stalk : the posterior margin of the bilobate mass is exaggerated , as to distinctness , in the figure ; but in reality the web thins out rapidly in front of the exit of the vagus nerves ( 8 ) : this sudden change in the thickness of the cranial floor is very remarkable , even in the adult bird .
Two large tracts of osseous deposit , the basitemporals , having a somewhat reniform outline , have already appeared in this thick fibrous web ( fig. 2 , b.t. ) ; they are elegantly In certain osseous Fishes ( for example the Perch , Pike , Gurnard &amp;c. ) the prepituitary portion of the basisphenoidal cartilage is invested by a delicate ectosteal sheath ; this azygous basisphenoid is thus confined to the front of the pituitary space through the remarkable development of the prootic floor , which takes up so much of the investi-ng mass anteriorly .
774 coral-like in appearance , and a row of feeble osselets lying along the grooved mid line are ready , in a few hours , to connect together the whole basitemporal tract .
Not only do these symmetrical plates rapidly coalesce , but the " ' rostrum " also will have united with them by the time they have melted into each other ; then the " parasphenoid ?
' of the Ichthyopsidan will be fully represented , and the open pituitary space will be filled in below by the extraneous plate .
It cannot be void of interest that the ornithic embryo is thus seen to arrive at its further goal by passing , at first , along Ichthyopsidan paths ; not only is this seen in the skull-base , but also in all the outworks of the face .
The anterior termination of the " rostrum " is very thin ; it lies in the midst of a large mass of stroma ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 7 , r.b.s. ) underlying the perpendicular ethmoid ( eth .
) , and above and between the laminar palatines ( pa. ) : this section shows well how thorough the amalgamation of the trabecule becomes .
Conjijgation of symmetrical bands of simple cartilage at the mid line is a frequent phenomenon in the development of the skeleton .
Where the moieties of the " investing mass " embrace the pituitary body , and thus become trabecule ( all the prenotochordal part of the early skull-base is trabecular ) , there the cartilage grows upwards into the alisphenoid ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 4 , a.s. ) , and downwards to form a steep wall to the pituitary space ( p.t.y. ) : these walls are flanked by the " lingule " ( I.g. ) ; their nature , as outgrowths of the trabecular roots , and the dark appearance of their interior , is shown in this figure .
Fourth Stage.-Ifead of Embryo 10 to 12 lines long : end of 2nd , and beginning of 3rd Week of Inczubation .
The primordial skull undergoes very rapid changes day by day ; this will be seen at once if the figures in Plate LXXXII .
are compared with those in Plate LXXXIII .
All the figures in Plate LXXXIII .
and figs. 8-12 in Plate LXXXII .
are from a chick at the commencement of the third week of incubation , the head being an inch in length , or one-third larger than that from which the figures 1 to 7 in Plate LXXXII .
are given ; this stage , however , will be drawn nearer to the last by showing the structure of some younger embryos .
The basal view of the skull cannot be shown as merely primordial ; so that fig. 1 in Plate LXXXIII .
must be compared with figs. 1 &amp; 2 in Plate LXXXII .
: in this latter Plate the inner view of the skull-floor is only partially given , whilst in Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 2I am able to show the entire primordial skull from above , the grafted splints below not being focused .
But one of the most important changes to be noticed , and which was commencing but not described in the third stage , makes it profitable to compare the second with the fourth .
We saw that in the second stage ( Plate LXXXI .
figs. 4 &amp; 5 ) the cranio-facial axis had attained to a Struthious condition ; in Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 4 this part is seen to be rapidly passing into the Tinamine stage , the region common to the ethmoid and nasal septum having become largely fenestrate ; this is intermediate between what is seen in 775 Tinamcns robusttus , where the " fenestra " becomes a " notch " ( Struthious Skull , Plate xv .
fig. 8 , c.f.c ) and T. ariegatus , where it has not appeared , the skull in this respect being perfectly Struthious .
The distinction between the perpendicular ethmoid and the septum nasi is merely histological in the Mammal ; but here we see a true morphological cleft , which is now imperfect above and below , and never , in the Fowl , quite complete above , although this is common in the higher arboreal types .
The vertical orbito-nasal septum has undergone fission between the eyes , as well as between the olfactory sacs : a considerable series of these clefts appear in this plate in some birds , all after one fashion ; but in the Fowl there are only two , and in the Struthionidae only one .
This posterior cleft divides the ethmoid ( eth .
) from the presphenoid ( _p.s .
) : this latter region is very feebly developed ; for the fenestrate cleft ends below at a great distance from the base , and the ethmoidal and basisphenoidal regions meet below it .
The bar which encloses the anterior cleft below is very instructive ; it is at present of considerable thickness ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 2 , s.v. .
) , although it is absorbed in a few days after this period .
It is alate ; and I propose to call the alar outgrowths the " supervomerine laminae , " to connect them with their persistent and more largely developed counterparts in the Frog and the Crocodile .
They have their largest development behind ( see Plate LXXXII .
fig. 11 , which shows them magnified 20 diam. , and from below ) ; the vomer commences below the middle bar at their front end ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 1 , v. ) ; when there are symmetrical vomers ( as in Piczis ) they commence in the fibrous tissue below the laminas .
The posterior edge of the nasal septum is also alate ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 4 , s.n. ) , and has , in front of the ale , an upper and a lower thickening , and a groove connecting these enlargements ; this is caused by the burrowing of the nasal nerve as it passes downwards and forwards .
In fig. 4 the aliethmoidal , aliseptal , and alinasal outgrowthls are cut away ( al.e .
, al.s .
, al.x .
) ; the rounded and flattened prenasal cartilage ( p.n. ) is seen to have a somewhat downward direction .
The rostrum , or " anterior parasphenoid , " is still quite distinct from the ethmoid , and a little also from the front of the basisphenoidal region ; but directly beneath the optic nerves ( 2 ) it has grown into the substance of the cartilage , and the sella turcica is ossifying fast .
The basitemporals ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 4 , b.t. ) are also rapidly coalescing with this common osseous mass , and they form a floor to the pituitary space ( pt.s .
) and also to the " posterior basicranial fontanelle " ( p.bf .
) .
The notochordal shaft is now fast developing into the basioccipital bone , which still encloses the starving remains of the notochord ; behind , in the unossified condyle ( o.c. ) , it is still soft ( figs. 1 &amp; 4 , n.c. ) .
X This cranio-facial cleft ( c./ .c .
) is a perfectly ornithic character , and in Tinamus robustus is a beautiful correlate of the segmentation of the shoulder-girdle across the glenoid facet and the acuteness of the angle at which the scapula and coracoid are bent upon each other .
On the 9th day of incubation the scapulo-coracoid bar of the chick is falcate and partly segmented ; but by the time the cranio-facial cleft is well formed n14th to 16th day ) the scapula has acquired a typical condition .
776 An upper view of the primordial skull at this period shows much that is noteworthy ( see Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 2 , magnified 4 diam. , and with the basal parts left out of focus ) .
The nasal labyrinth is relatively very large , and posteriorly overhangs the orbital region ; it is at once seen how large and important the structures are that are trabecular in their origin ; their territory ranges from the pituitary space ( p.t.s. ) behind , to the end of the prenasal cartilage ( p.z. ) in front ; the postpituitary .
or notochordal region is short , but very broad .
In this upper view of the skull-base the basioccipital ( b.o. ) is seen to have the form of a flint spear-head : it has a longitudinal ridge arising from the enclosed notochordal shaft ; its point lies between the divisions of the occipital condyle ( o.c. ) , and its blunt end lies between the cochlear elevations ( c.l. ) .
The cartilage does not extend far beyond the cochleae , antero-mesially , but has retired far from the mid line ; this state of things , combined with the rapid growth of the investing mass and the arrest of the notochord , has caused the " posterior basicranial fontanelle " ( p.b.f. ) to become a large lozenge-shaped space , merely filled with delicate stroma .
The exoccipitals ( e.o. ) are spreading ; and the superoccipitals ( s.o. ) are large , and are approaching the mid line .
The prootics ( pro .
) are rapidly developing as ectosteal plates , in front of and below the ampulla of the anterior semicircular canal ( a.s.c. ) ; and a large ectosteal tract covers the middle part of the alisphenoidal region .
The pituitary space ( p.t.s. ) is enclosed with derived bony matter ; but a considerable amount of the anterior ( a.cl .
) and posterior ( p.cl .
) clinoid walls are still soft .
All the rest of the skull ( its trabecular portion ) is still soft , and the notochordal regions are also , to a large extent , cartilaginous .
The temporal wings of the exoccipital and the postfrontal outgrowths of the alisphenoid ( pf .
: , a.s. ) are seen to be large masses of cartilage .
The foramina ovalia ( 5 ) are very large fenestral spaces between the alisphenoidal and periotic regions ; and the foranmina rotunda ( 5 a. ) are oval in shape , and pierce the root of the " greater wing .
" The centre of the alisphenoid is occupied by a fenestrate cleft ( a.s.f. ) ; this is cordate , with the apex downwards , and tends to divide the ala into two bars-an antero-mesial and a posteroexternal .
The alisphenoids are wide apart mesially ( exaggerated in the figure ) , and there is no more cartilage until we reach the mid line , occupied by the knife-shaped presphenoid ( p.s. ) .
Thus not only is the roof of the primordial skull occupied by an enormous fontanelle , but there are two mesial fontanelles in the lowest part of the floor , and its anterior or upper division is almost entirely membranous .
The division between the two basal fontanelles ( the posterior clinoid wall ) is imperfect above ; in my former paper ( Plate VII .
fig. 1 , &amp; Plate ix .
fig. 1 , p.cl .
) this is shown to be perfect in the Struthionide .
In the embryo of Struthio camelus ( Plate vnii .
fig. 1 , o.s. ) there is also a considerable tract of cartilage underlying the fore part of the hemispheres ; this is formed of the lesser wings ( orbito-sphenoids ) : these are aborted in the Fowl* .
The broad roof-like frontal surface of the ethmoid ( Plate LXXXIII .
figs. 2 , 4 &amp; 5 , eth .
) ends in a long retral spur , which surmounts the olfactory grooves : there is no " crista galli .
" A deep chink on each side separates the aliethmoidal ( al.e .
) from the aliseptal ( al.s .
) regions , and a lesser chink marks the posterior boundary of the alinasal ( al.n .
) region .
The diverging terminations of the ala nasi retain their primary form as the out-turned trabecular horns ; they closely embrace that azygous outgrowth of the trabecule which I have called the " prenasal cartilage " ( p.n. ) ; this snout-cartilage is now at its full size .
In the under view ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 1 ) I have depicted the splints that show themselves on the basal plane , whilst the lacrymals ( 1 .
) and frontals cf. ) are merely indicated by a dotted outline .
The superoccipitals ( Plate LXXXII .
figs. 8 &amp; 9 , s.o. ) have nearly met above the foramen magnum ( fin .
) ; the exoccipitals ( e.o. ) have enclosed the vagus ( 8 ) , and are enclosing the ninth nerve ( 9 ) ; behind they mount over the posterior semicircular canal ( 2.S.G .
) , and are spreading along the tympanic wings of the occipital cartilage .
The occipital condyle ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 8 , and Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 1 , o.c. ) has a piece of the notochord ( n.c. ) projecting from its dimpled end ; in froint it ends below the basioccipital , which is under-floored , anteriorly , by the huge .
expanding , almost coalesced basitemporals ( b.t. ) .
On each side the lower edge of the squamosal ( sq .
) is seen dipping between the postfrontal and exoccipital outgrowths .
The rostrum ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 1 , r.b.s. ) is blunt-pointed anteriorly ; it lies on a somewhat higher plane than the basitemporals , and has lost its former distinctness and simplicity , having ossified much of the lower part of the basisphenoidal cartilage ( b.s. ) .
But not only has this centre affected the overlying cartilage , it has grown into short wings between the heads of the pterygoids , forming the roots of the " anterior pterygoid processes " ( a.p. ) , and into huge pretemporal wings ( the " posterior pterygoid processes " ) ( p.r.p. ) .
The anterior pterygoid processes are capped with a cartilaginous plate ( to be described anon ) , and the posterior wings have the " lingulal sphenoidales " as their cartilaginous or endoskeletal root : this will be dilated upon when the sections are explained .
There is one more basicranial splint the vomer ( v. ) ; this is a very small style , at present emarginate anteriorly , and blunt behind ; but it changes its shape afterwards ; it is developed in the same general tract of subcutaneous tissue as the " rostrum .
" The rest of the base of the cartilaginous axis is enveloped in soft fibrous stroma , which is only subject to ossification from lateral symmetrical points .
These symmetrical ossicles are developed in the subcutaneous stroma of the facial laminae ; they are the premaxillaries ( _p. .
) , maxillaries ( m.x. ) , jugals ( j. ) , and quadrato-jugals ( g.j. ) : all these have acquired considerable density since the last period .
The palatines ( pa. ) are thoroughly ossified , and the pterygoids have lost most of their simple cartilaginous pith ; a hyaline plate abuts against the anterior pterygoid processes , and the capped , unossified posterior end is acquiring considerable density .
778 The ectosteal sheath of the quadrate ( g. ) has spread largely ; but the upper and lower condyles and the orbital process are still soft .
The occipito-otic region , when seen from within ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 9 ) , shows how the superoccipital bony plates spread over the posterior part of the anterior semicircular canals , and how the " prootic " ectosteal plate has , begun to grow over the ampulla of the same canal .
Between the great anterior canal and the edge of the occipital plane , there is a large irregular fossa , filled now with gelatinous tissue , and afterwards with ingrowths from the parietal and squamosal .
The alisphenoidal isthmus ( a.s. ) , and the investing mass ( i.v. ) , where it bounds the " posterior basicranial fontanelle , " have been cut through .
The left half of the same preparation , seen as an interno-lateral view , is shown in Plate LXXXII .
fig. 10 ; here , besides a better view of the foramina , we see an additional proper periotic bony ( ectosteal ) plate the opisthotic ( o.p. ) ; two more plates have yet to appear-namely , the " ' pterotic " and " epiotic " ( mastoid ) .
The skull at this stage is still farther illustrated by a posterior view ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 8 ) ; and here the roof-bones are shown .
The great upper fontanelle is being obliterated by the frontals ( f. ) and the parietals ( p. ) ; these are formed by an infinity of rapidly coalescing bony grains formed in the subcutaneous web : they are flanked by the squamosals ( sq .
) , which have a similar nature .
The two ascending occipital laminae , although they have coalesced at the mid line , yet have left traces of their original distinctness in the upper and lower notch ; the superoccipitals ( s.o. ) have not yet invaded this mesial part , nor have they reached the ascending edge of the fast-growing exoccipitals ( e.o ) .
Above the selvedge bounding the foramen magnum ( f.m. ) is seen the sinus canal ( s.c. ) ; and in the broad interspace between the superand exoccipitals the horizontal ( h.sc .
) and posterior ( p.sc .
) semicircular canals shine out , and are seen to cross each other .
Externally , and below the exoccipital region ( e.o. ) , the elegant tympanic wings of the occipital cartilage form a thick crescentic selvedge .
In Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 4 the postorbital aspect of the skull is given ; this is from a less mature specimen than that shown in figs. 1 &amp; 2 .
Here , on each side above the optic nerves ( 2 ) , and reaching to the olfactory crura ( 1 ) , there is nothing but the laminar presphenoid , for a great extent , except membrane .
This membrane is becoming bony by extension of the orbital plates of the frontals ( f. ) ; and infero-externally we have the alisphenoids ( a.s. ) , which pass , to some extent , within the orbital plates .
Much of the alisphenoidal lamina is still cartilaginous ; but the left has an irregular ectosteal tract ( a.s.1 .
) between the inner selvedge and the fenestra ( a.sf ) .
Another bony tract ( a.s. 2 ) lies above the foramen ovale ( 5 ) ; on the right side these two plates have coalesced* .
In my former paper ( Plate vII .
fig. 1 , p. 125 ) I showed that the alisphenoid ( independent of its postfrontal outgrowth ) had two bony centres in Strztthio and some other birds : this appears to be the rule ; but the postfrontal ossicle is not present in some of the higher ( Passerine ) types .
The space between the " posterior pterygoid processes " ( .r.p .
) and the basitemporals ( b.t. ) is filled with soft stroma , afterwards to be absorbed .
In Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 5 , a lateral view of the nasal labyrinth , orbital septum , and palatine is given , which shows how loose and membranous is the connexion between the ascending ( orbital ) plate of the palatine and the prefrontal or pars plana ( '.p ) .
The continuity of this anteorbital portion of the nasal labyrinth with the upper ethmoid ( eth .
) , the aliseptal ( al.s .
) , and with the alinasal ( al.n .
) is clearly shown : these parts will be better understood by reference to the sectional views ; and by this means we shall also come to a fuller understanding of the rest of the skull at this stage .
I shall describe the sections from before backwards ; and the first of these transversely vertical sections ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 6 ) passes through the middle of the prenasal rod : these sectional views are magnified from 8 to 16 diameters , and are given in Plates LXXXIII .
&amp; LXXXIV .
A section through the fore part of the beak ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 6 ) passes through the broadest part of the prenasal cartilage , which is seen to be more convex above than below : it lies in the midst of a mass of fibrous stroma which is being rapidly converted into the solid part of the premaxillaries ( p.x. ) ; these are thickest above , have a cultrate edge laterally , and have , already , a small marrow cavity .
A section made a little further back ( fig. 7 ) shows the narrower cylindrical part of the prenasal rod , and passes through the tips of the trabecular horns , or fore part of the ale nasi ( al.n .
) .
Here the premaxillaries ( p.x. ) are composed of three parts the nasal process ( n.px .
) above , the dentary margin ( d.px .
) laterally , and the palatine process ( p.px .
) on each side of the prenasal rod ; the section also shows the end of the maxillary ( mn.x ) .
The next section ( fig. 8 ) has caught the fore part of the septum nasi , and has passed through the alinasal fold ( al.n .
) , the lateral nasal wall ( l.n.w. ) , the nasal turbinal ( n.t.b ) , the fore part of the maxillary ( im. .
) and palatine ( pa. ) , and the attenuated portions of the premaxillaries ( n.px , d.px , p.px .
) .
Fig. 9 shows the formation of the inferior turbinals ( i.t.b. ) ; the section is made where the lateral nasal wall is deficient , so that the aliseptal plate turns abruptly upwards and inwards to form the inferior turbinal scroll , which has exactly two turns .
The nasals ( n. ) and nasal processes of the premaxillaries surmount the labyrinth ; and , leaving out other bony parts , I have shown the relation of the palatine plates of the maxillaries ( maxillo-palatines , p.mx .
) to the thick base of the the septum nasi .
The 10th figure illustrates the structure of the ethmoid behind the anteorbital plates ; the ethmoidal roof ( a.e. ) is seen to be concave at the mid line , and convex laterally , the perpendicular plate ( p.e. ) to be thinnest at the middle , and the basal part to have the same bulbous outline as the septum nasi .
Here , surrounded by a web of fibrous tissue , is seen the crescentic section of the rostrum " ( r.b.s. ) , and on each side the shelving section of the palatines ( pa. ) at their broadest part .
780 The next section ( fig. 11 ) passes through the interorbital fenestra ( io.f .
) .
Above is seen that part of the presphenoid ( p.s. ) which runs into the perpendicular ethmoid anteriorly ; it is only thickened above , and the orbito-sphenoidal regions ( o.s. ) are merely fibrous .
The middle of the section is nothing but fibre-that of the fenestra ; and below , the lower part of the presphenoid ( _p.s .
) passes insensibly into the basisphenoid ( b.s. ) .
Here the c ; rostrum " ( r.b.s. ) is thicker , and the palatines ( pa. ) are cut through their thick but narrow pterygoid extremity .
Only the lower part of the next two sections is given : in fig. 12 the soft fore end of the pterygoids ( p.g. ) is cut through , showing the enclosed cartilaginous pith ; in fig. 13 the pterygoids ( p.g. ) are cut through where they interpose a cartilaginous plate between themselves and the " rostrum " ( r.b.s. ) .
But the structure here indicated is better displayed in a section ( fig. 14 , 16 diameters ) made through the basisphenoidal cartilage , exactly below the exit of the optic nerves , and immediately in front of the anterior clinoid wall .
Here the section of the : coalesced trabeculze has a pyriform outline , the narrow end being upwards ; this is enclosed in much fibrous tissue .
Imbedded in this stroma is the rostrum ( r.b.s. ) , which is here much broader , but less deep .
Outside the upturned part of the rostrum there is , on each side , a plate of hyaline cartilage ( a.p. ) , then a synovial cavity , then a similar plate of cartilage which is formed in the perichondrium of the pterygoid ( p.g. ) and outside its ectosteal tube .
This is very different from what obtains in the Lizard and in the Ostrich ( First Paper , Plate viI .
fig. 4 , a.p. ) : in them the anterior pterygoid processes are direct outgrowths of the roots of the trabecule , and on their ends cartilage remains for articulation ; in the Lizard this is very apt to acquire a rudimentary distinctness as a feebly ossified epiphysis ; il both the Lizard and the Ostrich a cartilaginous plate appears on the corresponding part of the pterygoid .
Notwithstanding the different manner in which the basipterygoids of the Ostrich and the Lizard are ossified ( namely , in the former from the extraneous " rostrum , " and in the latter from the symmetrical basisphenoidal ectostoses ) , yet , morphologically , they correspond .
This dying-out of the cartilaginous shaft of the basipterygoid outgrowth in typical birds is very instructive , being an instance of morphological subdivision in a higher type of that which is continuous ( uncleft ) in a lower or more generalized form .
In the Fowl the " rostrum , " insinuating itself between the basis cranii and the basipterygoid articular plate , becomes one with the true basis cranii , and , ossifying the inner face of the articular plate , leaves the rest soft for articulation with the pterygoid* .
The relation of the basitemporals to the basisphenoid is shown in section in Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 4 , which displays the postorbital region .
In Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 1 , the lower portion of this section is shown , magnified 10 diameters .
This transversely vertical slice shows that the roots of the trabecule ( tr .
) are pyriform in outline ( the broad part below ) where they enclose the pituitary fontanelle .
They are enclosed in a strong ectosteal sheath , the origin of which I showed , in Plate LXXXII .
fig. 1 , as being from the inner layer of the parosteal " rostrum ; " the section is taken where the grcfting first commenced .
The bulbous base of these trabecular roots passes directly , behind , into the foremost part of the investing mass , where it encloses the posterior fontanelle ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 1 , y.bf .
) , and also into the posterior clinoid wall ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 3 , p.cl .
) .
This section well shows the absence of all cartilage under the pituitary body , and how the " sella turcica " is finished below by extraneous fibrous bone as in the Osseous Fish .
The slice of cartilage seen on each side of the trabecular roots ( front view ) belongs proximally and below to the " lingule " ?
( I.g. ) , and further outwards to the posterior clinoid wall , where it ascends into , and becomes the root of , the alisphenoidal lamina ( see Plate LXXXIII .
figs. 2 &amp; 3 , al.s .
, p.cl .
) .
There is no more cartilage below the thick-edged trabeculae ; the rest of the section is entirely formed at the expense of the thick cushion of stroma which intervenes between the primordial skull and the faucial skin .
The broadening end of the " rostrum " ( anterior parasphenoid " ) , after forming an ectosteal plate to the roots of the trabecule and to the " lingulae " ( Plate LXXXII .
fig. 1 , &amp; .s .
, l.g. ) , performs the same function for the anterior part of the posterior clinoid wall ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 1 , _p.l .
) ; and this it does until it reaches the lower alisphenoidal centre ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 3 , p.cl .
, a.s. 2 ) .
Wholly below the cartilage , however , the bony matter , which originally commenced in a fibrous tract , breaks away again from the primordial skull , and converts large tracts of fibrous tissue into bony wings .
Outside the bony deposit , shown at fig. l,.cl .
, the outstretching fibrous bands become bony ; below the posterior clinoid wall , a strong double pillar of bone grows down from the mid line ( fig. 1 ) ; and below , transverse aponeuroses are ossified , so as , with the upper wings , to enclose a large space , which becomes the " anterior tympanic recess " ( a.t.r. ) .
Between the lower wings there is a central tract of bone and two open spaces ; and here , at every available point , the basitemporals ( b.t. ) are forming adhesions with the wings that grow out from the basisphenoid ( " posterior pterygoid processes " of former paper , or , more accurately , " tympanic wings of basisphenoid " ) .
Laterally the lower basisphenoidal outgrowths have not united with the basitemporals ; thus there is a space ( em. ) in which the eustachian tube is formed .
Between the basitemporals there is another space ; this becomes the back part of the commonl vestibule , in which the eustachian tubes meet at the mid line .
The histology of the thick cushion of stroma which intervenes between the primordial skull and the so-called mucous membrane of the fauces is peculiar .
I have spoken of the aponeurotic bands in which the bony matter runs , and must now mention that the " anterior tympanic recess " ( a.t.r. ) and the eustachian passages ( em. ) are , at present , full of a delicate gelatino-granular stroma , of a consistence little more dense than the mucous tissue of the umbilical cord of the Mammal ; this soft sarcodal substance is soon absorbed to form the highly labyrinthic tympanic cavities .
782 Horizontal sections through the pituitary fontanelle throw light upon the perplexing morphology of this region.of the skull* .
The lowest of these ( Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 15 ) shows the internal carotids ( i.c. ) coming up from below ; also the bony ring which surrounds the lower part of the pituitary body , the bony matter of which has spread right and left , ossifying a thick fibrous band ( f. ) .
Behind these " posterior pterygoid processes " is an open space , from which the gelatinous tissue has been removed , showing the formation of the anterior tympanic recess ( a.t.r. ) ; and behind this space the section passes through the lower part of the " posterior clinoid wall " ( p.cl .
) , where it is growing up from the investing mass ( i.v. ) .
Between the moieties of this mass is seen the fore part of the " posterior basicranial fontanelle " ( p.b.f. ) , which is being walled-in with bony matter .
Higher up ( fig. 16 ) , above the " recess , " the pituitary space is lined with a thin bony layer , which has grown up from below , whilst in front the bony substance ( the same as seen at p.cl .
in fig. 1 ) is just growing into the cloven " posterior clinoid wall .
" Behind this wall there is a thin layer of bony matter , which has crept up from the " posterior fontanelle " ( fig. 15 , p.b.f. ) .
Near the top ( fig. 17 ) the thick cleft clinoid wall ( p.cl .
) is notched on each side , and the bony matter has risen up in front on each side of the notch .
Another transversely vertical section ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 2 ) shows , in a very instructive manner , the structure of the posterior sphenoid a little further back .
The " posterior clinoid wall " ( p.cl .
) is seen to be connected by an isthmus above the fore part of the " posterior fontanelle " ( p.bf .
) ; the bony matter of the " posterior pterygoid processes " ( p.r.p. ) touches the cartilage mesiad , and helps to roof-ia the " anterior tympanic recess " ( a.t.r. ) .
The moieties of the investing mass ( i.v. ) are here very steep , and they rest in de-pressions on the top of the thickest part of the massive basitemporals ( b.t. ) .
This .
section has been made behind the junction of the basisphenoidal outgrowths with the basitemporals , and well shows the membranous nature of the latter the " posterior parasphenoids , " the counterparts of the cross bars in the Fish and the Frog .
A section through the forwardly turned cochlear cavities ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 3 , c.l. ) shows the thickness of the periotic portion of the investing mass ( pr.c .
) , and how the prootic ectosteal plate ( pro .
) is affecting this cartilage above , and the posterior pterygoid processes ( pr.p .
) are curling round it below .
Below this latter plate is seen part of the " anterior tympanic recess " ( a.t.r. ) , filled with gelatinous tissue .
The floor is formed by the lower tympanic lip of the basitemporal ( b.t. ) , which further inwards underlies the cochlear cavity ( c.l. ) , and at the mid line makes a secondary floor to the large open chink in the cranial floor the " posterior basicranial fontanelle " ( p.b.f. ) .
The cochlear otoconial deposit ( I.ot .
) is seen , folded upon itself , in the end of the cochlear sac .
A section made a little further backwards ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 4 ) shows the sudden lessening of the thickness of the investing mass ( i.v. ) behind the cochlear elevation ( c.l. ) .
The last section ( fig. 3 ) was made in front of the notochord ; but here we come across its fore end ( n.o. ) , which is enclosed in its own ectosteal sheath ; this bony deposit is seen to grow upwards and outwards into the surrounding cartilage ( i.v. ) , and is especially developing itself below , where it forms the lower plate of the basioccipital ( b.o. ) .
We are here close behind the basitemporal , in the broadest part of the basioccipital ( see Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 1 , b.o. , b.t. ) .
This section and the next to be described , well show the triple nature of the basioccipital , and also teach how small a portion of the morphology of the skeleton is involved in the mere consideration of the form and number of the separate bones .
The next section ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 5 ) is made where the skull-floor is thinnestnamely , just a little in front of the occipital condyle ( see Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 1 , b.o. , o.c. ) .
External to the basioccipital bony centre ( b.o. ) with the enclosed notochord ( n.c. ) , the cartilaginous investing mass ( i.v. ) first becomes thicker and then thins out again ; here it becomes enclosed within an upper and a lower ectosteal plate the exoccipital ( e.o. ) : this is more clearly shown in a more enlarged figure of this part of the section , given in Plate LXXXII .
fig. 12 .
The rest of the section passes through the otic region ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 5 ) , and shows the inner wall , imperfect below ( pr.c .
) , the vestibular or upper otoconial mass ( z.ot .
) , the ampulla of the anterior semicircular canal ( a.sc .
) , the ampulla and arch of the horizontal canal ( h.sc .
) , part of the tympanic cavity ( tie .
) , and part of the squamosal ( sq .
) .
This bone is separated from the periotic mass by a quantity of the same kind of gelatinous tissue as that which fills the tympanic cavity .
The space between the squamosal and the periotic mass is very large , because of the deep angular fossa which runs along the outside of the anterior canal : this fossa is shown in Plate LXXXII .
fig. 9 , and in Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 2 , as well as in this section ; it may be called the " upper periotic fossa .
" Fifth Stage.-Head of Embryo 15 lines long ; 2nd Day after Iatching .
The skull of the ripe chick ( Plate LXXXIV .
figs. 6-12 ) is interesting in many respects : it is profitable for comparison with the skull of the Fish , the Reptile , and the immature Mammal ; and , looked at in its general form , it comes much closer to that of the nearest congeners of the typical Fowl than the skull of the adult bird .
The types suggested by a view of the chick 's skull are the HIemipodiine , Pterocline , and Columbine outliers of the Gallinaceous Family ( see Trans. Zool. Soc. vol. v. plates 34-38 ) : the skull of the adult Fowl has receded greatly from that of its lower and 784 more generalized relatives on one hand , and from its higher and more specialized congeners on the other .
The period of a week has sufficed for very great changes in chondrous and fibrous tracts ; and now is the best nick of time for catching the true form of many of the osseous territories , although some have already lost their distinctness , whilst others have not yet appeared .
The ectosteal tracts have set up " endostosis " in the cartilage lying between their plates , so that the true endoskeletal bones are being enlarged intrinsically as well as from the immediate fibrous layers .
Save in the instance of the early grafted parasphenoids , the parosteal tracts ( splint bones ) are still altogether free from union with the endoskeleton , whether bony or cartilaginous .
The hyaline cartilage furnishing the interspaces and headlands of the ectosteal plates has become very dense through the abundance of the cheese-like intercellular substance ; it is semitransparent when thick , and , for the most part , of a lilac colour .
The splint bones are still fibrous , but are beginning to become smooth through the fresh and fresh ossification of aponeurotic layers ; as a correlate of this exogenous growth , the first deposit of bony matter is beginning to be absorbed in many directions , so as to form diploe : this is most advanced in the basitemporals and squamosals .
The drawings given of the ripe skull might , with very little modification , serve as diagrams to illustrate the structure of the skull in any bird above the Struthionidae ; with the " Preecoces " they answer as to period ; but they correspond to nestlings of the " Altrices " at about the end of the first week after hatching .
The increased development of the occipital region is shown in Plate LXXXIV .
figs. 6-10 .
The basioccipital ( figs. 6 &amp; 10 , b.o. ) has nearly obliterated the notochord , and the bolny substance is spreading both laterally and backwards into the cartilaginous condyle ; anteriorly ( fig. 10 ) it has obliterated the spheno-occipital synchondrosis at the mid line .
The form of the basioccipital is reptilian ( lozenge-shaped ) above ( fig. 10 ) , and mammalian ( almost oblong ) below ( fig. 6 ) .
The exoccipitals ( e.o. ) are growing into large wings , which reach up to the mastoid ( epiotic ) region externally and above , and approach the superoccipitals at the foramen magnum ( fig. 9 ) ; inside ( fig. 7 ) they are still quite distinct from the opisthotic ( op .
) ; and both outside ( fig. 8 ) and inside ( fig. 10 ) they have enclosed the anterior and posterior condyloid foramen ( 9 ) and the vagus-foramen ( 8 ) .
On the outer occipital plane ( fig. 9 ) , the exoccipitals trespass extensively upon the mastoid portion of the periotic cartilage ( fig. 9 , h.sc .
, p.sc .
) ; the true mastoid ( epiotic ) has not yet appeared .
The superoccipitals ( fig. 4 , s.o. ) are fused together in their lower two-thirds , and form now a large shield of bone ; internally ( fig. 7 ) they enclose the whole crown of the huge anterior semicircular canal ( a.s.c. ) and the sinus canal ( s.c. ) , which burrows along the outer face of the arch and escapes near the inferior angle ( figs. 7 &amp; 9 ) .
The three periotic ectosteal plates which have at present made their appearance are all inside the cranial cavity ( fig. 7 ) .
These are the front ( prootic , ro .
) , the hinder ( opisthotic , op .
) , and the small representative of the great otic wing of the osseous Fish ( the pterotic , pt.o .
) ; this latter bone can now be seen in the " lateral cerebellar fossa , " on its front face .
A deep fossa partly subdivides the periotic mass from the occipital ring on the inside ( fig. 3 , op .
, e.o. ) ; but the osseous centres are here not quite accurate landmarks of morphological regions , as the four periotic bones fail to wall-in the zfpper , outer , and lower portions of the auditory labyrinth : this is a reptilian state of things .
The prootic ( pro .
) is the earliest and , as a correlate of this , by far the most potent osseous growth of the four .
The crested fore edge of the periotic mass helps , in front of and above the labyrinth , to enclose the cerebral mass ; but the lateness of the small pterotic allows this cranial wing , both in the Bird and in the Mammal ( see HUXLEY , op .
cit. p. 245 , fig. 97 , Pr .
O. , which shows this part in the skull of a Beaver ) , to be ossified by the early prootic ; whereas in the Osseous Fishes the massive cranial wall is very greatly indebted to the pterotic , which is in them the largest of the periotic bones .
The prootic of the Fowl ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 7 , pro .
) , besides the scooped anterior crest , the front of which is notched for the trigeminal nerve ( 5 ) , forms a large , backwardly turned , oblong plate , pierced along its middle for the compound seventh nerve .
It is bifurcate above , where it creeps over the inside of the ampulla of the anterior canal , and also passes , in its posterior fork , td the other end of the arch ; here it encloses the ovoidal pterotic plate ( p.t.o. ) .
The opisthotic ( fig. 7 , op .
) is now a semnielliptical wedge of bone , with its straight margin separated by a very narrow line of cartilage from the prootic , and its crescentic margin lying as a bank in front of the occipito-otic fossa ; the line of separation between the opisthotic and the exoccipital ( e.o. ) is a very narrow band of cartilage .
The complex basisphenoidal region has now only one osseous centre , which , macerated away from the rest of the cranium , forms a most perplexing bone to one who has not followed its earlier history .
Seen from below ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 6 ) , we have its rostrum ( r.b.s. ) , its great posterior wings ( pr.p .
) , and its basitemporal floor ( b.t. ) .
Towards the end of the rostrum the low ant perior pterygoid processes ( a.p. ) look downwards and forwards , and are covered with a meniscoid plate of cartilage .
Behind them , at the mid line , the eustachian tubes openl into one commonil vestibule , floored by the tips of the coalesced basitemporals .
A notch , filled with tense membrane , is seen between the great upper wings and the basitemporals-these parts , in their meeting , not forming X This fourth periotic bone ( the so-called " mastoid , " in the Fish , of CUVIER and OWEN ) was first determined by me , in a note to Professor H-UXLEY , who spoke very cautiously about it at first ( see his I Elem .
Comp. Anat .
' p. 188 ) .
In my former paper I described this bone ( which is very common in the Bird-class ) as the epiotic ( see Plates xi.-XII .
, ep .
) ; but it is too far forward for that bone ; the true " epiotic " ( see First Paper , Plate vii .
figs. 4 &amp; 8 , op .
) is formed over the crown of the posterior semicircular canal .
My error of taking the little pterotic for the epiotic misled me in naming the latter , which I sLpposed to be an otter ectosteal plate to the opisthotic element ; and in the First Paper it will be seen that the letters op .
indicate both a posterointernal ( true opisthotic ) and a supero-external ( true mastoid or epiotic ) patch of bone .
I am indebted to Professor HUXLLEY for leading me to see which was the true epiotic ; then the pterotic unconsciously assumed its true name .
78G a perfect floor to the " anterior tympanic recess .
" The basitemporal plate is notched on each side , where it forms a floor to the tympanic cavity , and all along its posterior margin , where it partly underlies the basioccipital ( b.o. ) .
The side view ( fig. 8 ) shows the high prepituitary part of the basisphenoid ( b.o. ) below the optic nerve ( 2 ) , the rostrum ( r.b.s. ) , and the tympanic lip of the basitemporal ( b.t. ) .
The sectional view ( fig. 7 ; the rostrum , r.b.s. , and anterior pterygoid process , a.p. , are not cut through ) shows the rostrum , articular plate , prepituitary and postpituitary portions , the opening for the internal carotid ( i.c. ) in the fundus of the pituitary cup , and the thickness of the fast-growing basitemporals ( b.t ) where they underlie the equally thick shelving postpituitary part of the bone ; the declivity is caused by the height of the posterior clinoid wall ( p.cl .
) .
The end view ( fig. 9 ) shows how the posterior margin of the basitemporals ( b.t. ) underlies the anterior end of the basioccipital ( b.o. ) and the surrounding cartilage .
The horizontal section ( fig. 10 ) passes through the middle of the " 5 sella turcica , " cutting away much of the anterior and posterior walls , exposing the internal carotids , showing the basisphenoidal part of the cranial floor and the obliteration of the spheno-occipital synchondrosis at the mid line .
Here the posterior or tympanic wings ( p.r.p. ) are seen to be thick and cellular , and to give attachment to the fore part of the membrana tympani ( m.t. ) in the long " anterior recess ; " the prootic ( pro .
) helps to wall-in this recess behind .
The pedate tract of cartilage bounded by the basisphenoid , basioccipital , and prootic contains the cochlea , which is indebted to all these bones for its outer wall .
The open fontanelle ( p.b.f : ) seen at the mid line in Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 2 , is here filled up by the rapidly growing basisphenoid ; a chink , however , remains for a long time .
The windowed alisphenoids ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 8 , a.s. ) are now well ossified , all but the outstanding " postfrontal " ( p.f. ) ; the suture between the alisphenoid and basisphenoid remains long distinct .
On each side a large postorbital fontanelle still exists , reaching down to.the optic nerves ( figs. 7 &amp; 8 , 2 ) below , and iipwards to the frontal plate of the ethmoid ( eth .
) , traversing the whole of the orbito-sphenoidal region , which is devoid of cartilage .
The orbital plate of the frontal ( f. ) is gradually encroaching on this unwalled space .
The whole of the presphenoid ( p.s. ) and the hinder third and lower selvedge of the perpendicular ethmoid is still unossified ; but a large antero-superior tract of the latter is now ossified by a double ( right and left ) ectosteal plate ( figs. 7 &amp; 8 , eth .
) , the cartilage within undergoing endostosis .
The lower boundary of the cranio-facial cleft ( fig. 7 , c.f.c. ) has been entirely absorbed , so that the ethmoid is now merely connected by an isthmus to the postero-superior angle of the septum nasi .
Through this cleft ( notch ) the inferior turbinal coil ( i.t.b. ) can be seen ; and below this cleft the vomer ( v. ) lies , in a perfectly ornithic condition , in the base of a plate of fibrous tissue , far away from the cranio-facial axis , and ready to lay hold on the fore spurs of the palatines ( fig. 6 , v. , pa. ) .
5M2 787 The nasal branch of the ophthalmic has left its burrow in the hinder part of the septum nasi , which has bridged it over both above and below .
The rather strong septum nasi ( fig. 7 , s.n. ) ends in a rounded manner in front , and still retains , as a rostral process , the fast-diminishing prenasal or snout-cartilage ( p.n. ) .
The swelling alinasal folds ( al.n .
) , with their internal turbinal plate ( al.t .
) , are best seen in fig. 8 ; and in it also can be seen the " pars plana " -(p.p .
) or lower part of the prefrontal plate .
The outer nasal wall ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 6 , o.n.w. ) and the prenasal bar ( p.n. ) are clearly seen from below , in the fore part of the palate .
The palatines ( figs. 6 &amp; 8 , pa. ) , the pterygoids ( p.g. ) , the quadrate ( q. ) , and the stapes ( st. ) have all made a great approach to the adult condition .
The pterygoids and palatines are well ossified ; but the former have a cartilaginous cup for articulation with the quadrate , and a meniscoid plate ( fig. 11 , p.y. ) for articulation with a similar disk on the anterior pterygoid process ( a.p. , r.b.s. ) .
The meniscus which articulates the pterygoid to the basipterygoid facet is composed of typical hyaline cartilage ( fig. 12 , 200 diam. ) ; this is separated from another tract of cartilage in immediate contact with the bone-cells ; towards the fissure the cells are very much flattened ; those in contact with the endosteal deposit are baggy simple cartilagecells .
Hence it is evident that this facet of the pterygoid is a proper segment of cartilage , and not a mere remnant of the main rod such as is seen on the quadrate end of the pterygoid .
The Fowl agrees with the Struthionidae in having no mesopterygoid , contrary to what I once supposed ( see Zool. Trans. , vol. v. p. 157 ) ; in the Anatine series it exists as an exogenous spur to the pterygoid ; in other Carinatse it is segmented off .
The axis of the mandible ( Plate LXXXIV .
figs. 7 &amp; 8 , art .
, m.k. ) has acquired an ectosteal ring round its internal angular process ( " manubrium mallei"o ) ; all the rest is soft , and the anterior end of this cartilage has begun to shrink ( fig. 7 , m.k. ) ; this is an anticipation of what becomes of its counterpart ( " processus gracilis mallei " ) in the Mammal .
The stapedial shaft-bone ( st. ) is shown in figs. 8 &amp; 10 .
The ectosteal sheaths of the " basihyal " and branchials " have advanced considerably .
Part of the fibrous skeleton has been described in connexion with the basisphenoidal " stock " on which it is grafted ; the splints are easily separable from the primordial cranium .
One pair only of these have coalesced at the mid line : these are the premaxillaries ( fig. 6 , p.x. ) ; these have already become truly Gallinaceous , although in a generalized manner they have the " habit " of those of the adults of the lower types .
In figs. 6 &amp; 7 it is shown how these bones are causing , as it were , the absorption of the axis ( p.n. ) on which they were modelled* .
" ' This is in conformity with what is so common in the building-up of the skull and face in the Warm-blooded\Tertebrata the " hoarding " and the scaffolding " being formed subsequently to the proper walls and gates , which walls and gates have to be taken down to a great extent to let the hoarding and the scaffolding stand alone 788 The premaxillaries , anterior to their mesial coalescence , are normally ichthyic , with the exception that each bone developes a palatine process ( fig. 6 ) , as in the Mammal .
But the maxillary ( figs. 6-8 , m.x. ) of the Fowl , above that of all other Birds , is ichthyic in a very remarkable manner ; it is a perfect " os mystaceum ; " and if the papillae of the horny beak covering the premaxillaries may be considered ( as in truth they are ) to be potential teeth , then the maxillary is absolutely edentulous as in ordinary Teleostean Fishes : it is a very small , delicate style of bone , and , as in the Fish , has a double head , the anterior division articulating with the premaxillary , and the posterior with the palatine ; as in the Fish , the posterior process is turned backwards .
The manner in which the Bird looks both ways ( backwards to the Fish , and forwards to the Mammal ) is well shown in the maxillary .
In those low untypical Rodents , the Leporidse , the dentary portion of the maxillary is abortively developed in front ; and the second division of the palatine part of the Fowl 's maxillary reappears in them as a narrow backwardly placed palatine plate .
In most Mammals the palatine plate is truncated anteriorly to form the posterior boundary of the " anterior palatine foramen ; " but in some , for instance the Pangolin ( Manis ) and the Hedgehog ( Erinaceus ) , the palatine plate is sharply wedged-in anteriorly between the dentary and palatine processes of the premaxillaries , exactly as in the Fowl ( Plate LXXXIV .
fig. 6 , p.x. , m.x. ) .
The retral posterior palatine plates of the Fowl 's maxillaries ( maxillo-palatines of HUXLEY ) are very thin , scarcely reach the vomer ( v. ) , are fibrous , and are less developed than in any family except the Picinae , where they only just appear mesiad of the inner edge of the palatine ( see HUXLEY " On the Classification of Birds , " Zool. Proc. 1867 , pp. 448-450 , figs. 30 &amp; 31 , mxp ) .
The rest of the maxillary of the Fowl is mere style ( a zygomatic process ) , and ends free in the upper lip , having the jugal ( j. ) mounted on and overlapping it , exactly as in those Teleostean Fishes which possess a jugal .
The jugal ( Plate LXXXIV .
figs. 6 &amp; 8 , j. ) is similar in form and size to the zygomatic process of the maxillary , and is less than the quadrato-jugal ( q.j. ) , which finishes the fixing-bar to the quadrate ( q. ) .
The quadrato-jugal , like the rest of the facial splints , continues distinct from its surroundings .
The nasals ( fig. 8 , n. ) overlie the frontal part of the ethmoid imperfectly , as in Struthious B13irds ; they have a concave semielliptic margin anteriorly ; this is bounded by an upper process , which outlies the nasal process of the premaxillary , and a descending facial wall-plate , which articulates with the premaxillary and maxillary below : this lower process is a typically ornithic structure , and is aborted in the Struthionide ( see First Paper , Plates vI.-xvI .
, n. ) .
The lacrymal ( figs. 6 &amp; 8 , 1 .
) has a ' large superorbital and a thickish , twisted , anteorbital plate ; these two parts are distinct bones in the Lizard .
The frontals ( fig. 8 , f. ) are at present very elegant shell-like bones , rounded and smooth over the cranium , hollow and scooped over the eye , and having a strong superorbital ridge .
The thin dentated orbital plate only partly walls-in the orbital fontanelle ( of .
) .
The oblong , curved , four-sided parietals ( figs. 7 &amp; 8 , p. ) are overlapped behind by the 789 frontals ( fig. 8 ) ; between the four bones , on the upper surface , is the well-known fontanelle ( fig. 9 , fo .
) .
The posterior margin of the parietal has just reached the superoccipital ( s.o. ) .
There is something very mammalian in the huge squamosals ( Plate LXXXIV .
figs. 6-9 , sq .
) ; they are , however , perfectly ornithic , having little of the Batrachian character such as is seen in the Struthionidoe ; they are twice as large , relatively , as in Birds generally , and show a large square plate on the inside of the skull ( fig. 7 ) , thus supplementing the wall-plate of the prootic ( pro .
) and the alisphenoid ( a.s. ) .
The squamosals of the Fowl do not show the bifurcate character so well as in the other families of Birds and of several mammalian types-for instance , Cavia , Arvicola , Lepus , &amp;c. It is here ( fig. 8 , sq .
) that the squamosal overlaps the whole side of the skull , over the piers of both the mandibular and the hyoid arches ; thus , whilst it is the counterpart of the principal " supratemporal " of the Ganoid Fish , it extends over the region occupied by the " pterotic : " the posterior portion of the squamosal has a separate counterpart in the Lacertilia , just as in them the descending portion of the lacrymal is separately *ossified .
In the mandible , however , the splint bones are as numerous in the Bird as in the Lizard ; but the Fowl is exceptional in possessing no " coronoid " piece .
The dentary ( Plate LXXXIV .
figs. 7 &amp; 8 , d. ) runs backwards almost to the articular facet ; the splenial ( fig. 7 , sp. ) is oblong , equidistant from the ends of the ramus , and hides half the Meckelian rod .
The surangular ( figs. 7 &amp; 8 , su .
) is more external than internal ; the angular ( a. ) belongs equally to both faces , being laid on below ; it flanks the long posterior angular process of the endoskeletal ray .
Sixth Stage.-Chickens about 3 Weeks old .
At first sight there appeared to be but little alteration , except general advancement of the ossification , in this stage ; but the specimens examined were feebly grown , and had died in a somewhat atrophied condition .
They yielded two new pairs of ossific centres the postfrontals ( pf .
) and the epiotics ( ep.)-which I had never before succeeded in demonstrating in the Fowl ; these are shown in Plate LXXXIV .
figs. 13 &amp; 14 .
I am rather inclined to suppose that these bony patches were more distinct on account of the arrested growth of the chickens ; at any rate , they are very instructive , and the Fowl is thus seen to agree with the Osseous Fish and with many families of its own Class in the separate formation of these bones .
In my former Paper ( p. 129 ) I stated that the postfrontal of the Bird is an ichthyic bone , the so-called postfrontal of the Lizard being a postorbital subcutaneous scale .
In this , as in many other respects , it is not the Lizard but the Teleostean Fish which is the proper forerunner of the Bird .
The epiotics ( fig. 13 , ep .
) are small four-sided ectosteal plates , formed over the arch of the posterior canal , and having a somewhat indistinct and very transitory separateness from the exoccipital ( e.o. ) .
790 Seventh Stage.-Chicken 2 Months old .
In this much more advanced condition of the skull many of the sutures still remain , the two new bones described in the last stage have already lost their distinctness , and two new pairs of osseous centres have appeared .
In Plate LXXXV .
fig. 1 , the left half of the skull is shown from the inside , and the orbital septum , not touched by the saw , is shown on its right side ; this figure is magnified 3 diameters .
Altogether the structures have begun to acquire that massiveness which characterizes the skull of the Fowl equally with that of the Ostrich .
The delicately toothed sutures above , between the roof-bones , and the narrow synchondrosial tracts in the primordial skull , make this a very fitting stage for comparison with the skull of a Reptile .
The notochord is now fairly vanished from the basioccipital ( b.o. ) ; but the vertical dimple in the condyle is a permanent remembrancer of what once existed ; the bony mass which has swallowed it up and replaced it is now a massive lozenge , capped with cartilage behind .
It is surmounted on each side by the exoccipital ( e.o. ) , the smoothfaced wedge-like opisthotic ( op .
) , and by the postero-inferior margin of the many-sided prootic ( pro .
) .
Crowning all these , there is the large elegantly sculptured superoccipital ( s.o. ) , half of which is occupied by the arch of the great anterior canal ( a.s.c. ) , which is margined by the sinus fossa and canal ( s.c. ) .
The prootic ( pro .
) is seen to be connected by its wall-piece to the four-cornered alisphenoid ( a.s. ) , a narrow synchondrosis uniting them ; the latter has not lost its fenestra ( a.s.f. ) .
The pterotic ( pt.o.)is seen in the anterior aspect of the lateral cerebellar fossa .
There is now a basisphenoid ( b.s. ) as massive as the basioccipital , and containing , between its two clinoid walls ( a.cl .
, p.cl .
) , the elegant cup-shaped cavity for the " infundibulum , " pierced below for the internal carotids ( i.c. ) .
In front of this cup the basisphenoid forms a thick low wall , above which the optic nerves diverge .
Beneath the spheno-occipital synchondrosis the thick skull-base is made doubly thick by the massive basitemporal ( b.t. ) .
In front of this superaddition the basal part of the equally extraneous rostrum ( r.b.s. ) is capped on each side by the basipterygoid cartilaginous meniscus ( a.p. ) .
The presphenoidal region ( p.s. ) is still soft , and the basisphenoid and perpendicular ethmoid are a long distance apart below ; but along the thick upper edge of the presphenoidal cartilage there are now two pairs of bony plates the fibrous representatives of the orbito-sphenoids .
The hinder pair evidently correspond to the ectosteal bars that appear behind the fenestra in the huge orbito-sphenoids of the Lizard ; but as there are no cartilaginous " alae minores , " the ectosteal plate degenerates into a thickish " parostosis , " and then grafts itself upon the indistinct orbito-sphenoidal lips of the presphenoid .
The additional pair are very common in Birds ; and I have mentioned the existence of two centres in the Emu in my former paper ( p. 137 ) , where they are described as part of the pre791 .
sphenoid ; they do cause its ossification .
The anterior bone ( o.s. , 1 ) is irregularly oval ; the larger posterior piece ( o.s.,2 ) is somewhat square in shape , and is fast wedged-in between the postero-superior margin of the presphenoid and the superoanterior margin of the alisphenoid : these ossicles are still quite separable from the presphenoid , although afterwards they set up ossification in it* .
If the narrowest part of the tract of cartilage above the interorbital fenestra were quite asborbed , it would then be plainly seen what should be considered the true morphological boundaries of the perpendicular ethmoid ( p.e. , eth .
) .
This does take place in some birds , as in the Cormorant , the Sun-bittern , and the Stilt-plover ; and then the cleft also runs across to the common optic foramen , so that the small presphenoid is completely severed from the ethmo-basisphenoidal band below .
In the Bird the presphenoid is to be regarded as a wedge with its sharp end below , cleaving the basal region where the basisphenoid and vertical ethmoid meet : this is a remarkable modification of the Vertebrate skull .
The frontal and perpendicular regions of the ethmoid are not separately ossified as in the Struthionide ( First Paper , p. 127 et seg .
) , but the ectosteal plates ( right and left ) work upwards through the frontal plate .
At this stage the ethmoid is an irregularly oblong plate , finished in front but deficient above , below , and behind .
The notched front margin is the posterior boundary of the great craniofacial cleft .
In the figure the isthmus of cartilage is seen as cut through ; below , there is a small hook of cartilage , the remnant of the lower boundary of the " fenestra " of the fourth stage ; this piece partly lies in the grooved fore end of the rostrum .
The position , relation , and advanced development of the three great splints ( f. , p. , sg. ) that wall-in the skull are shown in Plate LXXXV .
fig. 1 ; anteriorly the frontal is seen to retire at the mid line , thus exposing the ethmoid above .
An outer side view of this stage of the skull is shown in Plate LXXXV .
fig. 2 , where the superoccipital is seen to be still quite separate , and the epiotic ( ep .
) nearly coalesced with the exoccipital .
In the large sulcus behind the oblique cartilaginous selvedge of the prootic ( pro .
) is seen a wedge-like plate of bone ( pt.o .
) , part of which appears on the outstanding edge of the exoccipital , in front of and below the remnant of the epiotic suture .
This is the pterotic , the first ectosteal plate of which appears in the front and outer part of the " lateral cerebellar fossa " ( fig. 1 , pt.o .
) : its subsequtent development is by endostosis ; at this : stage it has worked to the outer surface ; and here it appears bethind the prootic ( pro .
) , in front of and external to the epiotic ( ep .
) and above the opisthotic ( op .
) .
No one familiar with the skull of the Cod , Perch , or Halibut will fail to see how true the geograp7hical relations of this little bony territory are to those of the great ichthyic " pterotic " * .
The coalescence of the epiotic with the exoccipital is a Reptilian character ; but there is a tendency towards that affinity of the periotic centres for each other that we see in the Mammalia , inasmuch as the prootic , pterotic , and opisthotic unite together before they coalesce with the surrounding bones .
Yet this is not very perfectly maintained ; for the opisthotic begins to coalesce with the exoccipital about the same time that it loses its distinctness from the prootic ( see Plate LXXXV .
fig. 3 , op .
, e.o. ) .
The formation of the tympanic cavity in the Bird is extremely instructive ; the space itself is the remnant of the primordial cleft between the first and second poststomal arches : this stage illustrates it well .
In Plate LXXXV .
fig. 2 the occipito-otic mass is seen from the outside ; in fig. 3 part of the same is shown , but the skull was tilted so as to give an infero-lateral view : it is magnified one half more than fig. 2 .
The floor of the ear-drum , instead of being formed primarily of the inferior periotic lip , and secondarily of the tympanic bone , as in the Mammal , is here altogether formed by the basitemporal splints .
This massive bone ( b.t. ) underlies the eustachian tube ( fig. 1 , eu .
) , the " anterior tympanic recess , " and the main part of the chamber .
The great wings ( p.r.p. ) that grow widely from the " lingular " bud of cartilage form a roof and side wall to the " anterior recess ; " the prootic ( pro .
) forms the roof of the main chamber , and the exoccipital ( e.o. ) by its large crescentic wing forms the posterior wall .
Where the prootic and exoccipital meet above the opisthotic ( op .
) , there is formed a very large air-cavity--"the upper tympanic recess " ( m.t.r. ) ; the two ear-drums communicate with each other through the diploe that lies between these upper recesses .
The outer part of the opisthotic is seen on the inner side of the drum-cavity , as an oblique bar separating the fenestra ovalis from the fenestra rotunda .
Above , the opisthotic cochlear bar has coalesced with the exoccipital ( fig. 3 ) ; below and in front it is still separate from the prootic .
The outer notched edge of the prootic ( from which the squamosal has been removed ) is still soft at its selvedge , and a synchondrosial tract is seen running between this bone and the crescentic wing of the exoccipital .
Halfway between the outer selvedge of the prootic and the fenestra ovalis there is seen a thickened rib of bone , which passes directly forwards , and is terminated by an oblique , subconcave , oval facet ; this is the point of articulation of the inner head or prootic facet of the os quadratum ( Plate LXXXV .
fig. 8 , g. , pr./ : ) ; the other facet of the quadrate is much larger , and articulates with the squamosal ( fig. 8 , sqf .
) .
This facet for the quadrate lies a little behind the great outgrowths of the basisphenoid ( pr.p .
) .
This articular facet marks the great difference between the Fowl 's skull and that of Birds generally ; for this is the primordial point of attachment , which was once lost ( Plate LXXXI .
figs. 1 , 2 , 5 &amp; 5a , q. ) , and then regained , and has become persistent .
This small cup on the outside of the prootic ( a large distance from the front of the exoccipital ) is very similar to that for the short crus of the " incus " in the foetal Lamb .
The Psittacinae make some approach to the Fowl in the articulation of the os quadratum .
It is in the Fowls-in the Common Fowl especially , and in the whole Gallo-anserine series to a great degree-that the basitemporals have their most massive development .
This is correlative of the abortion of the " tympanics , " which figure largely in many families of typical birds the chief of the tympanic chain representing the " interopercular " of the Osseous Fish and the crown of the inverted arch of the tympanic ring of the Mammal .
In the Fowl and in the true Gallinaceve ( " Alectoromorphe ' , " Huxley ) I find scarcely a trace of ossification in the tendinous ring surrounding the " membrana tympani .
" In the Peafowl , however , a tympanic appears which is ornithically unique , although many birds have a chain of tympanics : this is formed in the posterior part of the shallow " ' meatus externus " ( see Memoir on Balceniceps , p. 316 ) , and therefore answers to the posterior part of the bony meatus of the Mammal ; and lying as it does directly beneath the posterior process of the squamosal " supratemporal , " it may represent the ichthyic " opercular " splint-bone* .
Eighth Stage.-Chickens 3 Months old .
The parts especially worthy of notice in this stage are the occipital , periotic , and posterior sphenoidal regions ( Plate LXXXV .
figs. 4-7 ; fig. 6 magnified 3 diameters , and the others twice the natural size ) .
The degree of coalescence of parts at this stage is illustrated by figures of the skullbasin .
All but the parasphenoidal splints , which are so early engrafted upon the skullbase , are separable by maceration ; only the symmetrical premaxillaries and dentaries have united at the mid line , the former very early , and the latter soon after hatching .
In the regions figured several of the smaller sutures are closed , and those that are still open are mostly narrow , so that the true shape of the bony territory is well shown .
An upper and a lower notch still attest the original symmetry of the superoccipital ( Plate LXXXV .
figs. 5-7 , s.o. ) .
The exoccipital ( e.o. ) has completely absorbed the epiotic , which is now a mere region ( e.p. ) .
The basioccipital ( b.o. ) is a thick , lozenge-shaped mass of bone , underlain by the basitemporal below ( Plate LXXXV .
fig. 4 , b.t. , b.o. ) , and articulating above ( fig. 5 ) with the basisphenoid , a notch in the mid line marking the end of the chink-like remnant of the " posterior basicranial fontanelle .
" The more enlarged side view ( fig. 6 ) should be compared with the like figure of the last stage ( Plate LXXXV .
fig. 2 ) ; and then it will be seen that the remnant of the epioticooccipital suture is gone , and also the whole of that surrounding the outer part of the pterotic ( _pt.o .
) ; its sutures have also disappeared from the inner face of the skull .
The suture between the prootic and exoccipital ( pro .
, e.o. ) is dying out at the middle , and on the inside only the upper part of the suture between the prootic and opisthotic remains ; there is just a trace also , inside , of the suture between the exoccipital and the opisthotic .
The whole para-basisphenoidal mass has long been one bone ; the posterior wings ( p.r.rp .
) strongly clamp the infero-anterior edge of the prootic ( pro .
) , both above ( fig. 5 ) and below ( fig. 6 ) .
There are a pair of anterior clinoid spurs ( fig. 5 , a.cl .
) ; behind these a pair of lateral spurs ; and the posterior clinoid chink ( fig. 5 , _p.cl .
) is filled up with a mass of periosteal bone ; behind this mass is the primordial chink , the remnant of the posterior fontanelle .
The prepituitary part of the basisphenoid ( figs. 5 &amp; 6 , bs .
) has not nearly reached the perpendicular ethmoid ; the latter part , with its surrounding cartilage , has been macerated away , leaving the rostrum ( r.b.s. ) as a long grooved style , having at its root the anterior pterygoid processes with their cartilaginous facets ( a.p. ) .
The alisphenoids were still connected with the basal mass by synchondrosis , so that these do not appear in the figures .
The head of the quadrate at this stage is shown in fig. 8 ; the squamosal facet is a hemisphere deficient at the inner side ; there is then a ligamentous line , and below this , on the inside , a somewhat reniform subconvex facet for the subconcave facet on the fore end of the rod-shaped rib of the prootic ( fig. 6 , pro .
, g.c. ) .
Ninth Stage.-Y-oung Fowls of the 1st Winter ; from 7 to 9 Months old .
The next stage may be considered to cover a period of two or three months , the specimens examined being such as were hatched in spring and killed at Christmas ; here the approaches by which the adult condition is obtained are plainly shown .
A sectional view at the earlier part of this stage ( Plate LXXXVI .
fig. 14 ) displays the growing massiveness of the skull and the gradual closure of the sutures .
Two extensive regions of the skull , namely the posterior sphenoid and the occipito-otic , now form one mass of bone ( fig. 14 , s.o. , e.o. , b.o. , b.t. , b.s. , r.b.s. , ?
ro .
, op .
) ; but the larger ( a.s. ) and lesser ( o.s. ) wings of the/ sphenoid are still separate .
The huge perpendicular ethmoid ( fig. 15 , eth .
; fig. 14 , p.e. ) now , more than ever , displays its special ornithic development .
I have failed to trace any upper osseous centre such as appears in the aberrant Struthionidae ; but the right and left ectosteal plates , continuous in front , set up endostosis in the enclosed wall of cartilage , and spread upwards , downwards , and backwards .
Here the triangular osseous patch which appears on the upper surface of the skull , between the diverging frontals ( fig. 15 , eth .
, f ) , is not the same bone as that which shows itself in the same gap on the Ostrich 's head ( First Paper , Plate vii .
fig. 3 , eth .
) : that is an upper ethmoid ; in the Fowl it is merely a continuation of the perpendicular plate .
The bony substance spreads at the top laterally into ' the roots of the aliethmoids , forwards into the cranio-facial isthmus ( between eth .
and s.n. in fig. 14 ) , and backwards into the retral process which overlies the olfactory grooves ( 1 ) .
Also below these grooves ossification is spreading into the ethmo-presphenoidal bar ; in this specimen it 5N2 795 has reached the foremost orbito-sphenoidal patch ( o.s. 1 ) ; towards the base it is growing towards the fore part of the basisphenoid ( b.s. ) .
All the rest of the cranio-facial axis is still soft ; and we now see the large size of the separating cleft , through which the upper and lower turbinals ( u.tb .
and i.tb .
) are seen .
The grooves for the nasal nerve ( n.n. ) almost cut off the gnawed postero-inferior angle of the septum nasi ( s.n. ) ; over the lower part of each groove there is a ridge of cartilage , from which in many birds there is an outgrowth partially occluding the nostrils , and strongly cemented to the lateral splints .
The prenasal cartilage ( p.n. ) still lingers in front of the rounded fore end of the septum ; after this it rapidly disappears ; indeed it seldom lasts so long , this specimen being exceptional .
The splint-bones are beginning to coalesce with the endoskeletal tracts ; the parietals ( p ) and the squamosals ( sq .
) are partly fixed : the latter show a considerable surface on the inner side ( Plate LXXXVI .
fig. 14 ) .
All the rest of the splint-bones can be macerated away ; their relations are shown from above in fig. 15 , where the nasals ( n. ) are seen to have a considerable frontal portion .
The vomer ( fig. 14 , v. ) is attached to the maxillo-palatine plate ( n.x. ) , being widely dislocated from the base of the cranio-facial axis .
In the mandible the dentary ( fig. 14 , d. ) and the splenial ( sp. ) are still separable from the fast-shrinking Meckelian rod ( m.k. ) ; but the angular ( a. ) and the surangular ( stu .
) are partly anchylosed to the articular ( are .
) ; this part , the counterpart of the bulk of the malleus , is now nearly ossified .
A more advanced skull is shown in Plate LXXXV .
figs. 10 &amp; 11 , and Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 1 : here the free edge of the exoccipital wing ( e.o. ) and that of the postfrontal ( p ; f. ) are still unossified ; but the latter is now one with the alisphenoid , which is still separable from the basisphenoid ( a.s. , pf.,.s .
) .
A narrow suture now separates the perpendicular ethmoid from the basisphenoid ( Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 1 , p.e. , b.s. ) ; they now meet below the still unossified part of the presphenoid ( p.s. ) , which has , at last , appeared as a curved bony plate articulated by suture with the middle bar of the perpendicular ethmoid .
Essentially a distinct bony patch , yet the presphenoid did not appear until the posterior orbito-sphenoid ( o.s. 2 ) had affected its perichondrium ; this process differs nothing from the grafting of the rostrum on the cartilage below .
The alisphenoids are seen ( Plate LXXXV .
fig. 11 ) to be almost completely transverse in their position ; but they overhang the postorbital space , being a continuation of the roof formed antero-superiorly by the orbital plates of the frontals ( Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 1 , .
) .
The alisphenoidal fenestrae ( Plate LXXXV .
fig. 11 , a.sf .
) are nearly filled-in by periosteal layers .
The squamosal is quite Batrachian in the Struthionidle ; it now suddenly foreshadows its counterpart in the highest Class .
I have already shown its large inrner face ( Plate LXXXVI .
fig. 14 , sq .
) ; but its outer face is enormously expanded ( compare Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 1 with those in my former paper , Plates ix.-xiv .
) .
The zygomatic process , in front of the articular facet , has not 796 yet appeared ; but above the facet the bone spreads equally forwards and backwards , in front overlapping the postfrontal and frontal , and behind covering the upper part of the mastoid and exoccipital regions ; the hinder lobe overlies the root of the hyoid arch .
When the coalescing roof-bones are removed by a saw , there is displayed what is seen in Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 2 : anteriorly the ethmoidal ossification ( eth .
) has advanced halfway to the isthmus , and backwards along the upper and middle bars ; behind the latter is seen the small presphenoid ( p.s. ) , having the hinder orbito-sphenoids ( o.s. 2 ) on each side ; in front of these is seen the smaller pair ( o.s. 1 ) .
The alisphenoids ( a.s. ) are attached by a fibrous band to the posterior orbito-sphenoids ; the large oblique groove for the 5th nerve ( 5 ) is seen to burrow them behind .
Behind the deep perforate " sella " is still seen the primordial fissure ( p.bf .
) or fontanelle ; and at some distance behind this is the ridge formed by the notochordal shaft-bone .
The saw has passed through the periotic territory , so that the whole of the horizontal semicircular canal with its ampulla ( h.s.c. ) is seen also its connexion behind with the ascending posterior canal , the ampulla of which ( p.s.c. ) and that of the great anterior canal ( a.s.c. ) are seen lying in the same plane ; outside the ampulla of the horizontal canal the upper tympanic recess ( u.t.r. ) is exposed .
The under view of a similar skull with the lower part of the basitemporal removed , is shown in Plate LXXXV .
fig. 9 : here the common opening of the eustachian tubes ( eu .
) is laid bare , the posterior pterygoid processes ( p.r.p. ) are cut through , and the carotid canals ( i.e. ) and cochlea ( c.l. ) are exposed .
The tympanic cavity ( tie .
) is seen growing forwards into the anterior recess ( a.t.r. ) , and the opening into the upper recess ( u.t.r. ) is seen behind the double quadrate condyle ( q.c. ) .
Another section , more highly magnified , is shown in Plate LXXXV .
fig. 8 ; it is an upper view , and the saw has passed through a lower plane than in Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 2 .
Here the stapes is seen in situ , and the membrana tympani ( mn.t .
) is seen passing over its triradiate end to be attached , anteriorly , to the great posterior pterygoid process .
Behind the vestibule ( v.b. ) is seen the base of the ampulla of the posterior canal ( p.s.c. ) , and a section of the lower part of its arch .
Mesiad of the ampulla is seen the opening for the vagus ( 8 ) , and further inwards still that for the 9th ( 9 ) .
A bristle is figured as traversing the right drum-cavity and eustachian tube ( eu .
) ; and on each side of the eustachian opening the internal carotids ( i.e. ) come up .
The part seen in shade , as the floor of the drum-cavity , is the basitemporal ( b.t. ) .
The right stapes is shown in Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 3 ( 6 diam. ) , from above , and at its base .
The base is irregularly oval ; the shaft , which with the base is ossified by ectostosis , is very slender ; it widens , and then breaks out into a complex triradiate cartilage .
The antero-inferior bar of this cartilage ( " infrastapedial , " i.st .
) is slender and arcuate ; the middle part ( " extrastapedial , " e.st .
) is much broader and is spatulate ; it curves forwards and downwards , and touches the postero-internal face of the quadrate .
The posterosuperior bar ( " supra-stapedial , " s.st .
) is bifurcate at its free part , and from its lower edge there is a broad thin lamina which is continuous with the free end of the " extrastapedial , " or middle process ; a fenestra ( f. ) separates this oblique plate from the proximal part of the extrastapedial* .
This stage will be further illustrated by sections ( principally transversely vertical , more highly magnified ) ( Plate LXXXVI .
) ; these , for the most part , relate to the olfactory labyrinth , and complete what I partially described in the fourth stage ( Plate LXXXIII .
) .
A view of the nasal labyrinth from within ( fig. 10 ) and from above ( fig. 11 ) will help to explain the larger sectional figures , which are magnified 4 times ; the inner and upper views are one-half larger than the objects .
A section through the most swollen part of the alinasal folds ( Plate LXXXVI .
fig. 1 ) cuts through the thickest part of the nasal processes of the premaxillary ( n. , px .
) and through its sharp dentary edge ( dpx .
) .
The styloid end of the maxillary ( mx. ) and of the palatine ( pa. ) are seen below the palatine plate of the premaxillary ( p.px .
) .
Here the septum nasi ( s.n. ) is deep and thin , thicker towards the top , where it spreads into the arched alinasal folds ( al.n .
) ; these end free opposite the middle of the septum .
Halfway from their origin the alinasals give rise to the nasal turbinal ( n.t.b. ) ; the whole of this is seen in fig. 10 , on its inner aspect .
It first bends directly inwards , then passes downwards nearly parallel with the septum , and then curls outwards and upwards to its free edge .
But the nasal passage ( n.p. ) is rendered doubly valvular by a forward constriction of the cartilaginous nasal wall ( n.w. ) , which ( see fig. 11 , al.s .
, n.w. ) is continued far forwards beyond the root of the inferior turbinal , or , properly speaking , beyond the aliseptal plate .
The section of this wall of the nose is here elegantly S-shaped ; it ends as a thick free edge near the roof , and as a thin free edge below ; and there it is only separated from the base of the septum by the na~al nerve ( n.n. ) .
A little further backwards ( Plate LXXXVI .
figs. 2 &amp; 11 ) the section passes through the alinasal ( al.n .
) where it is dying out behind ; here the nasal wall ( n.w. ) is cut through obliquely , and it is seen to end ( below ) much further from the septum .
Here the nasal turbinal ( n.tb .
) is further from the mid line , and diverges outwards outwards to a greater extent below ; this section shows the thickest ptat of the dentary edge of the hpremaxillary ( d.px .
) .
The next section ( fig. 3 ) shows a front view of the inferior turbinals ( Ut.t .
) ; these are also seen from the inside in fig. 10 ; they are coiled outgrowths of the aliseptal plate ( al.s .
) , which is seen to divide halfway down , giving rise to the nasal wall ( n.w. ) .
This section happily passes through the very important bridge for the nasal nerve ( n.* .
) , X See also Professor HUXLEY 's figures and descriptions , Proc. Zool. Soc. 1869 , p. 398 , figs. 5 , A , B ; and p. 406 , fig. 8 , C. These figures will be best iunderstood by reference to what is seen in the Ouaran Lizard ( Psammosaurus ) , where the bridge connecting the " extra- " and " suprastapedial " bars and the " fenestra " are absent : here the tensor muscle , which arises behind the " parotic bar , " and above and behind the head of the qutadrate , sends its tendon between the forks of the " suprastapedial " -which is bilobate as in the Fowl-to be inserted into the upper edge of the extrastapedial at its free end : the " infrastapedial " is shorter than in the Fowl .
I here use these terms provisionally , as my researches into the structure of these parts in the Batrachia have satisfied me that these prefixces should have been set before the term " incuLdal .
" 798 DEVELOPMiENT OF THE SKULL OF THE COMMON ' FOWL .
against which the aliseptal fold terminates as a free lamina , closely tied by fibrous tissue to the nerve-bridge .
Besides the proper nasal floor , we have here a true bony palatine floor ; for here the palatine plates of the maxillaries ( mx. , p.mx .
) are at their fullest development , and are expanded where they nearly meet each other and have the vomer ( v. ) wedged in between them below .
A section through this part of the skull in the Turtle ( Chelone ) , in the Pangolin ( Manis ) , or in the Cat ( Pelis ) would show precisely the same disposition of these parts , the vomer wedging itself in between the palatine plates of the maxillaries , which fail , where the vomer crops out , to meet each other at the mid line .
At this part the upper and lower crura of the nasal ( n. ) are cut through ; the dentary part of the premaxillary ( d.px .
) is becoming thin , the maxillary is at its greatest breadth , and the palatine is growing thicker .
The feeble , ichthyic maxillaries ( m.x. ) , instead of protecting the side of the face , are seen to be almost entirely at its base .
The next section ( fig. 4 ) is taken where the large chink is seen in the upper view ( fig. 11 , between al.e .
and al.n .
) ; here the aliseptal fold ends exactly where it has given off the inturned inferior turbinal coil ( i.t. ) ; this coil has exactly two turns .
Below , the posterior edge of the nasal wall ( n.w. ) is seen curving a little upwards where it touches the nasal nerve ( n.n. ) .
This section also passes through the maxillo-vomerine floor ( p.mx .
, v. ) ; and here the nasal processes of the premaxillaries ( n.px .
) are flat , and the dentary processes ( d.px .
) are very small ; the saw has passed through the nasals ( n. ) close in front of their bifurcation .
The next section ( fig. 5 ) cuts through the nasals behind their bifurcation , and just this section-namely , the zygomatic process and the posterior edge of the palatine plate .
As this section is taken behind the lateral chink , the nasal wall ( n.w. ) reappears below the inturned inferior turbinal outgrowth ( i.tb .
) .
The nasal nerves ( n.n. ) are seen turning downwards , and by their close contiguity they have aborted the septum nasi at this part ; in many Birds , especially the Raptores , the postero-inferior angle of the septum is almost sawn off by these nerves .
Another branch is seen to perforate the winged top of the septum , close below the nasal processes of the premaxillaries ( nyx .
} .
In the next section ( fig. 6 ) a front view is given of the end of the inferior turbinal ( i.tb .
) , and of the anterior face of the upper turbinal ( n.tb .
) ; this section passes through the cranio-facial isthmus , which is still surmounted by the flat ends of the nlasal processes of the premaxillaries ( n.px .
) .
On each side , the nasals ( n. ) form the roof-bones , which are flanked by the lacrymals ( 1 .
) .
The upper turbinal ( u.tb .
) , like the lower , is seen to be an involution or outgrowth of the nasal wall ( n.w. ) ; and here at this point they lie one above the other ; this is also shown in the lateral view in fig. 10 .
In the next section ( fig. 7 ) the inferior turbinal is cut away , and the interior of the upper turbinal ( z.tb .
) is exposed .
Although appearing as a distinct outgrowth anteriorly ( fig. 6 , u.tb ) , the upper turbinal is a mere bagged condition of the aliethmoidal lamina ( al.e .
) further back ( see figs. 7 &amp; 10 ) .
799 A s ection through the fore part of the ethmoid ( fig. 8 , eti .
, p.e. ) , showing the sharp front edge of the perpendicular plate , gives a front view of the back wall of the nasal labyrinth : in this figure the outer bones are not given .
This large back wall is the prefrontal plate , and much of it answers to the pars plana of anthropotomy .
In this section the upper turbinal ( Z.tb .
) is seen to be , at its posterior end , an outgrowth from the posterior wall of the nasal labyrinth ; so that , although it is a mere swelling bag at its middle ( figs. 7 &amp; 10 ) , yet it is a fixed outgrowth from the walls of the labyrinth at both ends .
If the inner view of the left half of the cartilaginous labyrinth ( fig. 10 ) be compared with the front view of its back wall , from which the turbinals have been cut away , leaving their roots , it will be seen that the inferior turbinal ( i.ib .
) is an outgrowth of the pars plana , posteriorly , and that its root there is continuous with that of the upper turbinal ( u.tb .
) .
Here there is no differentiation of a middle turbinal , except a small lamina ( n.tb .
) which grows upwards from the inner side of the root of the lower turbinal ; in this respect the Galline , like most other birds , are inferior to the Struthionidae ( First Paper , Plates vIII.-xiv .
m.t.b. ) , which show a rudiment of those outgrowths which are so largely developed from the front face of the Mammalian " pars plana .
" In this section the nasal nerves ( fig. 8 , n.n. ) are seen entering the labyrinth close below the roots of the cartilaginous aliethmoid ( al.e .
) ; whilst the smaller olfactory crura ( 1 ) enter between the widening part of the perpendicular ethmoid ( p.e. ) and the convex margin of the crescentic root of the upper turbinal ( tt.tb .
) , clos e above a little horn-like process growing from the supero-internal angle of the pars plana ( p.p. ) .
The rostrum of the basisphenoid ( r.b.s. ) reaches so far forwards as to underlie the cultrate fore edge of the perpendicular ethmoid .
A section ( fig. 9 ) made through the most solid part of the ethmomost solid part of the ethmoid displays much that is instructive .
The nasal processes of the premaxillaries ( n.px .
) are reduced to delicate flat styles ; the nasals ( n. ) are still of considerable breadth , and overlie the wedge-like fore ends of the frontals ( f. ) .
The lacrymals ( 1 .
) send out here their broad superorbital plate , and grow downwards into an imperforate styloid anteorbital process ; on the inside of each lacrymal , in the recess between this bone and the nasal labyrinth , is seen the pyriform nasal gland ( n.g. ) .
The huge perpendicular ethmoid ( p.e. ) has here grown out largely into the aliethmoidal wings ( al.e .
) , only leaving the very edge soft , from which a narrow isthmus grows downwards , outside the nasal nerve , connecting the * broad top of the ethmoid with the supero-external angle of the anteorbital ( prefrontal ) plate .
This flat , smooth , subconvex sheet of cartilage , the anteorbital , is oblong in general form , and has sinuous edges , the inner of which , although quite distinct from , yet lies close to the perpendicular plate .
In the Fowl , even to old age , it is soft ; but in many birds it is ossified , and is extremely apt to form bony adhesion with the perpendicular plate .
Below the anteorbitals the median plate becomes suddenly thin , swelling a little below , where it lies in the grooved rostrum ( r.b.s. ) .
In this section the thick outer and the sharp orbital parts of the palatines are seen ; 800 the latter processes lie near the rostrum , and are enveloped in the same stroma ; this projecting part forms an imperfect septum between the middle nasal passages ( m.n. ) , which open into each other below ( compare this figure with Plate LXXXIII .
fig. 10 , y.e. , p.a. , r.st .
) .
The whole nasal labyrinth is continuous ; the prefrontal wall , the outer wall , the turbinals , and the alae nasi are all developed from that tract of the primordial skull which curls downwards , in front of the pituitary space , into the frontal wall of the embryonic skull ( Plate LXXXI .
figs. 1 &amp; 2 ) .
This free growth of cartilage into so many morphological territories is correlative to the simplicity of the tissue , which rises but a step or two beyond protoplasm , is ready to be metamorphosed into any other skeletal tissue , and yet serves as a persistent skeleton to many parts , especially those of the nasal labyrinth .
The quadrate end of the pterygoid is lined with flat-celled hyaline cartilage ( Plate LXXXVI .
fig. 12 , c. ) , and the contiguous osseous tissue ( o. ) is formd by endosteal metamorphosis of more swollen cells .
When the cartilage-cells of the articular facet are viewed endwise ( fig. 13 , c. ) , they are seen to have an oval outline .
The meniscoid facet has not changed , except in size , since the time of hatching .
Tenth Stage.-Fowls several years old .
By the time the young Fowl is a year old most of the cranial sutures are completely closed ; and then , year by year , the skull becomes more and more dense , the periosteal layers filling-in every vacant space not needed for the transmission of vessels and nerves .
Thus in the skull of an aged bird ( Plate LXXXVII .
figs. 4-10 ) the occipital , otic , posterior and anterior sphenoidal , and the ethmoidal regions have become one continuous bone , with the old landmarks all removed , and scarcely a sign left of its once highly complex condition .
This state of things , for a bird , is quite normal ; and although carried to a very high degree in the Fowl , yet in some more typical birds the obliteration of all signs of the once composite condition of the skull is still more perfect .
The present paper is linked on to the first by the description of the skull in the aberrant Struthionidae ( Tinaminme , or Dromseognathae ) ; in those birds there is some falling away from what is typically struthious , and some approach to what we have here in the higher Gallinae .
In the skull , however , the Tinamous , wherein they diverge from the Ostrich-tribe , do not equally approach the Gallinae , but rather show affinity to the Charadriomorphous types .
This , however , is not all ; for the Tinamous have a tincture of the Reptilian nature in them ; and whilst the sutures close very perfectly in the Ostrich , as in the Fowl and other typical birds , in them several of the most important of those landmarks remain throughout life ( see First Paper , pp. 174-178 , Plate xv .
) .
MdDCCCLXIX .
5o 801 In the side view* of the skull of an old male ( Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 1 ) we see how largely the face has gained upon the skull as compared with what had obtained in the ripe chick ( Plate LXXXIV .
figs. 6-9 ) , where the face had the feebleness seen in the Sand-grouse ( Syrrhaptes ) .
A zygomatic process has grown downwards from the squamosal ( Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 4 , sq .
) , and this has formed a bridge over the lower part of the temporal fossa by coalescence with the postfrontal ( pf : ) .
The fenestre in the posterior orbital wall are all filled up , and the olfactory opening ( 1 ) is merely large enough for the nerve , whereas it once lay in a sheet of membrane .
In Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 4a trace of the interorbital space ( i.o.s. ) still exists ; but in another specimen ( fig. 8 ) the periosteal layers of bone have completely obliterated it ; in the same figure which shows the inside of the cranial cavity and the left side of the orbital septum , it is seen that the rostrum ( r.b.s. ) has completely coalesced with the base of the perpendicular ethmoid ( p.e. ) , and that the upper part of the ethmoid ( eth .
) has stopped its ossification at the cranio-facial isthmus .
The nasal labyrinth , which is nof displayed in these figures , is but little altered since the first winter ( Plate LXXXVI .
) ; but four small endosteal patches have appeared ( Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 10 ) in front of the ethmoid ( eth .
) .
One of these is in the isthmus ; another , close in front of it , is formed in the postero-superior margin of the septum nasi ( s.n. ) ; and on each side of these there is one formed in that thick bridge of cartilage which protects the upper branch of the nasal nerve ( Plate LXXXVI .
fig. 14 , n.n. ) .
In the late , arrested condition of the nasal ossicles , the Fowl differs much from a large number of Birds , especially the aerial Desmognathae ; and many also of the Schizognathae are less Reptilian in this respect than the Fowlt .
The nasal bones ( figs. 4 &amp; 6 , n. ) have coalesced posteriorly with the frontals ( f. ) ; but the latter are wedge-like , and divergent in front , and thus expose the upper surface of the ethmoid ( eth .
) : this is a Struthious character ; originally , however , it answers to the skull of the Osseous Fish ; it is occasionally seen in the Lizards , for instance the Iguana .
The nasal processes of the premaxillaries ( n.px .
) have neither coalesced with each other , nor with the surrounding parts ; the maxilloe ( mx. ) , the jugals ( j. ) , the quadrato-jugals ( q.j. ) , and the lacrymals ( 1 .
) keep their distinctness to old age .
On the lower surface ( Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 5 ) the palatines ( pa. ) maintain their separateness from the palatine plates of the premaxillaries ( p. ) , and also from those of the maxillaries ( mx. ) .
The small vomer ( v. ) also is merely attached to its surroundings by bands of fibrous tissue .
The pterygoids ( p.y. ) are attached to the palatines by a rough sort of hinge , and to the quadrate ( behind ) by a shallow cup , which receives the pterygoid facet of the quadrate .
This latter bone ( q. ) acquires a strong trochanter in front of its upper head ; below it is deeply notched , where it projeicts backwards from the mandibular facets , for the quadrato-jugal , which is curved to wind round the base of the qua .
drate ( see Plate LXXXVII .
figs. 4 &amp; 5 , qg .
, q. ) .
The mandibles vary considerably in individuals : in the one figured ( fig. 4 ) there is scarcely a trace of the great fenestra seen in the Tetraonidae ( Zool. Trans. vol. v. pl. 36 , fig. 9 ) ; but in others it is present .
There is generally some trace of the suture between the posterior wedge of the dentary and the angular and surangular ; but all the other sutures close ; the dentaries anchylose with each other early , like the premaxillaries .
In the hyoid arch the stapes undergoes no further change ; the lesser cornua of the hyoid ( Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 11 , c.h. ) coalesce to form a glosso-hyal ; but the tip of the coalesced cartilage continues soft , and a fontanelle is persistent between the bony part ; this elegant sagittiform tongue-piece articulates with the basihyal ( b.h. ) by a synovial hinge .
The basihyal is carinate above , and behind articulates by a small synovial joint with the long , slender , proximally ossified basibranchial ( b.br .
) .
The branchial arch articulates below by a gliding synovial joint to the end of the basihyal ; but the proximal piece , or " cerato-branchial " ( c.br .
) , is articulated to the distal , or " epibranchial " ( e.br .
) , by a mass of connective fibre ; the proximal ( lower ) piece is soft above , and the upper piece at both ends .
When the outer table of the dense aged skull is removed , the semicircular canals ( Plate LXXXVII .
fig. 9 , a.s.c. , h.s.c. , p.s.c. ) are seen to be imbedded in a moderately delicate diploe : in the figure the outer tympanic walls are removed , and show the fenestra ovalis and fenestra rotunda ( f.o. , f.r. ) on the surface ; a bristle is shown as passing along the tortuous canal for the internal carotid artery .
The figures , as compared with what is seen in Aerial Birds , show what every one is familiar with in the natural skull , namely the non-typical coarseness and strength of the whole skull and face* .
Concluding Remarks .
Having thus , with as much expedition and brevity as I have been competent to , run through the ten arbitrary but not unnatural stages in the morphological history of the Fowl 's head , I would conclude by hinting at the importance of the various isomorphisms displayed by the skull and face of this one type in its stages of growth .
I have described it iTpwards , but my long and really anxious labour has been in the opposite direction ; the stages were traced from that of the old bird downwards to that of the chick of the 4th day of incubation .
Whilst at work I seemed to myself to have been endeavouring to decipher a palimpsest , and one not erased and written upon again just once , but five or six times over .
Having erased , as it were , the characters of the culminating type-those of the gaudy Indian bird-I seemed to be amongst the sombre Grouse ; and then , towards incubation , the characters of the Sand-grouse and Hemipod stood out before me .
Rubbing these away , in my downward work the form of the Tinamou looked me in the face ; then the aberrant Ostrich seemed to be described in large archaic characters ; a little while , and these faded into what could just be read off as pertaining to the Sea-turtle* ; whilst , underlying the whole , the Fish in its simplest Myxinoid form could be traced in morphological hieroglyphics .
I have but little used the suggestions of comparison , which have almost been burdensome at times ; but other monographs must follow ; and that of the Osseous Fish , which I hope to offer next , will show how gentle and gradual are the metamorphic changes by which the skull and face of a Vertebrate animal grow into harmony with the most diverse conditions and habits of life .
DESCRIPTION OF THE PLATESt .
PLATE LXXXI .
First Stage.-Head of Enmbryo , from beak to occiput , 3 lines long : 4th Day of Incubation .
Fig. 1 .
Under view of head .
X9 diameters .
Fig. 2 .
Upper view of basis cranii .
X9 diameters .
Second Stage.-Head 4 to 5 ?
lines long : 5th to 7th Days of Incubation .
Fig. 3 .
Vertical section of skull and face of an embryo with head 4 lines in length .
X6 diameters .
Fig. 4 .
Ditto , with brain removed , of an embryo with head 5 lines long .
X6 diameters .
Fig. 5 .
Side view of same .
X6 diameters .
Fig. 5A .
Part of the last ( auditory region ) .
X 16 diameters .
Fig. 6 .
Section of the same through nose and palate .
X 12 diameters .
Fig. 7 .
Part of the last section .
X 160 diameters .
Fig. 8 .
Floor of skull , from above , of a somewhat older embryo .
X 12 diameters .

