On Paleocoryne , a Genus of Tubularine Hydrozoa from the Carboniferous Formation .
By P. MARTIN DUNCAN , F.R.S. , Sec. Geol .
Soc. , and H. M. JENKINS , PF .
G.S. , Sec. Royal Agric .
Soc. Received June 14 , -Read June 17 , 1869 .
CONTENTS .
I. Introduction .
V. Classification .
II .
Minute anatomy .
VI .
Description of the species .
III .
Zoological position .
VII .
Remarks .
IV .
Terminology .
VIII .
Palseontological relations .
I. Introduction.-The lower shales of the Carboniferous limestone series of Ayrshire and Lanarkshire are very fossiliferous in many places , and the organic remains found in them are remarkable for their perfect condition of preservation .
There are large numbers of fossil Brachiopoda , Polyzoa , Crinoidea , and Madreporaria in the black shales of Roughwood and Broadstone , near Beith , and of Auchenskeigh , and of Gare , near Carluke .
Associated with the Polyzoa are numerous small pedunculated radiata , whose external appearance differs from that of any extinct organism hitherto discovered .
They are usually found attached to the margins of the polyzoarium of Fenestellae , or they may be discovered in a more or less fragmentary condition amongst the small pieces of broken Polyzoa and Crinoid stems which compose the fossiliferous layers of the shales .
The attachment is by a dactylose base , which , when broken or cut , is proved to be cellular internally .
The base contracts as it increases in height , and is continued upwards in the form of a cylindrical stem , which is faintly enlarged in its middle portion , and which is surmounted by a symmetrical structure resembling a reversed obtuse cone , the margin of whose base is produced into several tentacular processes .
The tentacular processes are in one whorl ; they radiate from the margin of the upper part of the conical body , and they are separate at their point of origin .
They are long , slender , tapering , and occasionally irregular in their length and thickness .
Their direction is not at right angles to the stem , but they project obliquely upwards and outwartls .
The inferior surface of the tentacles is continuous with the outside of the conical body , and the superior surface is continued on to the upper surface , or reversed base , of the conical body , which has a much greater diameter than the supporting stem .
This upper surface is flat in many specimens , but in a few it is elevated centrally into a crateriform process , which has an opening on its apex .
The height of the form is not more than 11inch , and the length of the longest tentacular process is about 1 inch .
The fossils are composed of carbonate of lime .
The symmetry and elegance of the little fossil are heightened by its minute but elaborate ornamentation .
The proportions of the body , stem , and base are those of the most symmetrical architectural pillars ; and the elegant outlines of the tentacular processes are rendered more striking and less monotonous by the presence of spicules and of long fluted lines of delicate depressions , whose little spines are occasionally preserved .
The upper surface of the body is granular , and the stem is ornamented with longitudinal flutings and minute processes .
The general appearance of the fossil is that of a long straight-armed starfish reversed and fixed on a stiff stem with an expanded base .
There was more than one species of this organism in the blocks of shale examined* , and many specimens had their tentacular processes in different stages of development .
It is evident that the organism had attached itself to Fenestellc , but that it did not derive its nourishment from that Polyzoon .
The delicate polypary of the Fenestelloe being slightly flexible and containing great numbers of ciliated Polyzoa , they afforded an excellent foundation and support to the stiff-stalked and rigid-limbed little radiate animal that forms the subject of this communication .
The associated Brachiopoda , Madreporaria , Crinoidea , Polyzoa , and the small pedunculated radiata were dwellers in rather deep water .
Their modern representatives live at considerable depths ; and the stoneless condition of the shales in which the fossils are found , and the perfect condition of the organic remains , indicate their deposition on a sea-bottom where there was no rapid current , but , on the contrary , a comparatively quiet state of things .
II .
Minute anatomy.-The base , stem , body , and tentacular processes are hollow , and their cavity is continuous throughout the cells of the attachment , the ascending stem , the expanding body , and the radiating processes ; and it has one upper and central communication with the outside .
The cavity occupies a large proportion of the animal , and the enclosing hard structure is but a thin shell .
The body is not , however , a simple hollow cavity surrounded by a thin layer of hard structure through which the canlal-like cavities of the tentacular processes enter ; for these processes continue to be separate for some distance within the body , and their canals only unite very centrally with the cavity of the body .
The cavity of the body , thus enlarged , opens below into that of the stem , and above by means of a very small foramen , the oral orifice .
This orifice is closed when the upper surface of the body is flat , and then only a continuous granular layer of hard tissue is to be seen .
Slight scraping with a knife soon exposes the orifice .
When the upper surface of the body is swollen and projecting , the central opening is at the extremity of the crateriform process , whose sides are marked with radiating lines very much like the margins of the oral plates in young Pentacrini* .
It would appear that this projection depended upon the condition of the nutrition of the animal before its entombment .
The tentacular canals diminish in size with the length of the processes , and they are not continuous with the irregular spinules ; but whenever the distal end of a long tentacle can be examined , a small central puckering is observed on it .
It is very probable that the cavity of the tentacular process was continued into a soft and ciliated prolongation through this orifice .
The union of the tentacular canals with the cavity of the body produces , in transverse sections of that part of the animal , an appearance like that of the rosette in the Crinoidea .
Transverse and longitudinal sections of the stem show the papillary and faintly spinose and pitted ornamentation of the outside of the hard parts , and delicate striae running from the inside externally and horizontally , but there is nothing like an opening between the large internal cavity and the outside to be seen .
The base is formed of the external hard tissue which grasps and includes its own cellular structures and those of the Polyzoon .
Its length varies .
III .
Zoological position.-The absence of any structures resembling basal or basoradial plates and of joints in the tentacular processes , renders the opinion that the fossil should be referred to the Echinodermata untenable .
The isolation of the individuals , each possessing but one external opening , and the general characters of the tentacular processes , preclude any reference to the Polyzoa .
The internal anatomy , the structure of the hard parts , and the nature of the tentacular processes , prevent classification with the Zoantharia .
Were it not for the calcareous investments , there would be no difficulty in admitting the fossil amongst the Hydrozoa ; and had we not been able to avail ourselves of the affinities of the very anomalous genus Bimeria ( Wright ) the difficulty could hardly have been overcome .
There are many kinds of periderm amongst the recent Tubularine Hydrozoa , and the genera Monocaulos ( Allman ) , Corymnorpha ( Allman ) , Eudendriun ( Ehren .
) , and Bimeria ( Wright ) , afford examples of a gradation in structure from a condition of great tenuity and delicacy to one of a chitinous character , and up to the peculiar pergamentaceous nature of the polypary of the last-named genus .
But the ccenosarc of Monocaulos , Corymorpha , and Eudendrimun is the only part covered by the periderm .
In the genus Binmeria , however , the semi-solid investment not only covers the ccenosarc , but is also continued over the greater part of the tentacles and over the upper part of the body , leaving an opening for the mouth on the metastome .
The resemblance of the fossil under consideration to the trophosome of Bimeria vestita ( Wright ) is very decided .
Bimeria vestita ( Wright ) was found on the Bimer Rock on the west coast of Ireland , and its organs of nutrition and generation have been examined by its discoverer and Dr. ALLMAN* .
In its early period of trophosome it is a simple or solitary hydrozoon ; but during growth it becomes compound , and every succeeding branch is terminated by a tentaculate polypite .
The gonosome of the fossil organism may be traced in a stout projection from the junction of the stem with the body in one speciment , and possibly in the presence of some circular depressions on the under surface of the tentacular processes in others .
As yet our material is not sufficient to enable us to decide upon the nature of the gonosome .
The presence of the spinose ornamentation and the compact nature of the periderm of the new form distinguish it from all other Hydrozoa .
It is probable that , like Bimeria vestita , the tentacular processes of the fossil form had ciliated ends projecting beyond the periderm , and that the metastome projected at certain times and not invariably .
The zoological position of the fossil is amongst the Hydrozoa in the Order Tubularidae and near the Eudendridae .
IV .
Terminology.-Being satisfied that the fossil should be admitted amongst the Hydrozoa , its anatomical structures must assume the following names .
The dactylose base is the hydrorhiza , the stem is the hydrocaulus , the tentacular body with the broad upper surface , with or without an evident metastome , is the polypite .
The ornamented hard external tissue is the periderm or polypary .
The faintly traced generative structures constitute the gonosome , and the rest are embraced under the term trophosome .
The term hydrosome refers to the whole .
V. Classification .
Class HYDROZOA .
Order TUBULARID3E .
Family PALLEOCORYNID)E .
Genus PALEOCORYNE .
Family PALEOCORYNIDA.-Hydrozoa , whose hydrosoma is fixed by a hydrorhiza .
Polypary organized , calcareous , dense and ornamented , investing the whole of the Hydrozoon , except the opening for the mouth and probably the terminations of the tentacles .
Tentacular processes long , and more or less spined .
Genus PALJEOCORYNE , gen .
nov .
Trophosome solitary .
Tentacles few in number , long , in one verticel and ornamented .
Hiydrocaulus shorter than the tentacles , straight , cylindrical , broad and rigid , its ornamentation definite .
Polypite either flat on the oral aspect , or elevated more or less *T .
STRETHILL WRIGHT , M.D. , Edin .
New .
Phil. Journ. vol. x. N. S. 859 , p. 105 .
ALLMAN , Ann. Mag. Not .
Hist. S. 3 .
No. 77 , p. 355 ( 1864 ) .
t Plate LXVI .
fig. 11 .
to form a metastome , the periderm being granular and marked with ridges .
Hydrorhiza more or less cellular within , broad and dactylose .
Gonosome.-Gonoblastidia at the junction of the hydrocaulus and the body of the polypite ( .
) .
VI .
Description of the species.1P .
Palwocoryne Scoticum , nobis .
2 .
Paloocoryne radiatum , nobis .
1 .
PALEOCORYNE SCOTICUM .
Plate LXVI .
figs. 1 &amp; 6 .
The trophosome is short .
The hydrorhiza and the body of the polypite are nearly equal in size .
The tentacles are about seven in number ; they are , when fully developed , several times longer than the hydrocaulus and are slender , tapering and irregular in their length , size , and distance ; their periderm is spined , and is marked with pits , grooves , dentations , and serrations ; and it is generally ornamented above and below with ridges , which are continued on to the oral surface or downwards on to the sides of the polypite .
The hydrocaulus is slender , terete or slightly polygonal , and its periderm is ornamented with alternately larger and smaller flutings , pits , and small spines .
The hydrorhiza has one or more cellular processes , and an ornamented polypary , and it grasps the margin of foreign bodies .
The oral surface is either flat or slightly concave and granular ; or is convex and marked with radiating ridges terminating at the oral orifice and limiting the metastome .
The oral opening is often invisible .
Height of fossil without tentacles -~inch .
Length of tentacles ( extreme ) X inch .
Fixed on Fenestelloe in the lower shales of the Carboniferous formation of Ayrshire and Lanarkshire .
2 .
PAL^OCORYNE RADIATUM .
Plate LXVI .
figs. 2 , 5-8 , 11 .
Trophosome.-The polypite body is small .
The tentacles are from seven to eleven in number ; they are moderately long , equidistant , subequal , rounded , tapering , closely striated , faintly spined , and rarely marked with lateral dentations .
The hydrocaulus is short , cylindrical , faintly bulging , ornamented with subequal rounded flutings , the periderm being abundantly pitted , but not spined .
The oral surface is concave , and the projecting metastome is small .
The gonosome.-Processes covered with periderm are developed from the base of the polypite near its junction with the hydrocaulus .
Gonoblastidia t Localities.-Auchenskeigh and Roughwood , Ayrshire , in the lower Carboniferous shales .
The tentacles of Palcocoryne radiatum are shorter , stouter , and more finely striated than those of the other species .
VII .
Remarks.-The tenuity and length of the fully developed tentacles , and the manner in which some of them are curved and waved , indicate that , although their periderm was dense , there was some power of movement in them ; otherwise the slightest contact with a moving body would have fractured them .
There is much diversity in the length of the tentacles and in their thickness , and most of them are marked with transverse cracks , the result of post-mortem violence .
The distal ends of the longest tentacles are very delicate , yet a long ciliated process might pass out from the free termination as in Bimeria vestita .
The metastome is visible in a specimen of both species ; but usually the granular polypary of the oral surface shows no opening , and it is only when the exact spot of the mouth is worn down to in sections that any trace of it can be found .
The ridges of this surface are usually connected by festoon ornamentation .
The development of the periderm of the hydrocaulus from the coenosare may be inferred ; for in longitudinal sections there is an appearance of horizontal striation , and the strive indicate the former projection into the periderm of processes belonging to the ccenosarc .
VIII .
Palceontological relations.-Although the Hydrozoa are very abundant in fresh and in sea-water , they are very rarely found as fossils .
Their delicate structure and peculiar periderm would prevent their fossilization under ordinary circumstances .
M. FISCHER* has distinguished Hydractinie in the Cainozoic deposits of Dax and in the Cenomanien of Mans ; and the impressions of Medusae have been discovered in the Jurassic strata of Solenhofen .
In the Silurian division of the Palaeozoic strata are the fossils called Graptolites , which are considered by some Palaeontologists to be Hydrozoa .
The theory announced by AGASSIZ respecting the Hydroidean characters of the tabulate division of the Sclerodermic Zoantharia is still under consideration and requires confirmation .
The interest of the discovery of the Palceocorynidoz in the moderately deep-sea deposits of the Carboniferous period is therefore great .
The form of the Medusae of the species is of course unknown , but it is evident that they floated in the estuaries and shallow seas , and perhaps in the oceans of those Palaeozoic days , and deposited the ova which produced the trophosomes that have descended to the present time in a fossil condition .
The choice by both species of the margin of a polypary of Fenestella for their restingplace , suggests that some portions of the economy of the Polyzoon were beneficial to their more or less rigid associates .
Doubtless the gentle movement of the frond-like mass and the currents produced by the numberless polypes contributed to the supply of food for the Hydrozoa .
The ornamentation of the Fenestella is occasionally repeated on the tentacles of the Palceocoryne Scoticumr in a very striking manner .
Note.-The calcareous investment of Palmocoryne Scoticum and Palceocoryne radiatumn has not the peculiar cleavage of the hard structures of the Echinodermata.-September 6 , 1869 .
Illustrating the Structure of Palseocoryne .
Fig. 1 .
Portion of the trophosome of Palceocoryne Scoticum , showing the fluted periderm of the hydrocaulus , the cellular and dactylose processes of the hydrorhiza , and the base of three of the tentacles Magnified 15 diameters .
Fig. 2 .
Portion of the trophosome of Palaeocoryne radiatum , showing the same organs as fig. 1 .
Magnified 15 diameters .
Figs. 3 &amp; 4 .
Partial sections of similar portions of the trophosome of two individuals , showing the cellular nature of the hydrorhiza , the tubular nature of the hydrocaulus , and its connexion with the cavity of the polypite and the tubulated tentacles .
Magnified 15 diameters .
Fig. 5 .
Hydrocaulus and polypite of Paleocoryne radiatum , showing the number and arrangement of the tentacles .
Magnified 15 diameters .
Fig. 6 .
Hydrocaulus of Palwocoryne Scoticum , showing the relation of the hydrozoon to a portion of a polyzoarium of Fenestella .
Magnified 15 diameters .
Fig. 7 .
Polypite , metastome , and tentacles of a specimen of Jalceocoryne radiatum , showing their external structure and relations .
Magnified 10 diameters .
Fig. 8 .
Side view of a trophosome of Paleocoryne radiatumn , showing the hydrorhiza , hydrocaulus , polypite , and portions of the tentacles .
Magnified 15 diameters .
Fig. 9 .
Upper surface of the polypite of a species of Palceocoryne , showing the external ornamentation and the arrangement of the tentacles .
Magnified 30 diameters .
Fig. 10 .
A similar specimen ground down to show the internal structure of the polypite .
Magnified 30 diameters .
Fig. 11 .
Portion of the hydrosome of Palceocoryne radiatumn , showing the upper surface of the polypite , portions of some of the tentacles , part of the hydrocaulus , and an appendage to the latter supposed to form part of the gonosome .
Magnified 25 diameters .
yvd 'l1 ?
xYL g -fY 'gl .
'X I. }t . ?
, , A '31 I ' V , x I '01/ L4 'of ' .
, / 'X ; ' , -A ' ' I/ a.9 AJ 'Z'x ' kg'L X i6 ?
' sW &lt; tf^/ ZnYi/ m J.Z(AN '^ " iroD'I , - .
s-r '~~~~~~~~~~ fA--l ` -- !
~_)JUN"i , -P i

