Account of Experiments on Torsion and Flexurejfor the -Determination of Rigidities .
By JOSEPii D. EVERETT , D.O.L. , Assistant to t &amp; e Professor of Mathematics in the University of Glasgow .
Conitnicated by Sir WILLIAM THoMsoN , P.B.S. Received January 25 , -Read February 7 , 1867 .
IN my Paper read February 22nd , 1866 , the intention was expressed of continuing miy experiments on rigidity with a modified form of apparatus .
This intention was carried out during the past summer , and I have now to report the results .
In the former experiments , the rod operated on was supported at both ends , and was bent or twisted by hanging a pair of equal weights so as to act symmetrically on both ends ; and the amounts of flexure and torsion were measured by , the movements of two images formed by reflection upon a screen .
In the new apparatus , the rod was firmly held at one end in such a manner that this end could undergo no movement whatever , while the other end was acted on by &amp; a couple composed of the direct action of a weight and the upward putll of one arm of a balance produced by weighting the other arm .
The effect produced was observed , as in KIRCHHOFF'S experiments , by means of two telescopes looking down into two mirrors which reflected a scale of lines crossing each other at right angles placed horizontally overhead .
AB ( Plate IX .
fig. 1 ) is the rod operated on , entering a socket in the cylindrical iron bar C , in which it is firmly secured by screws ( three in each set ) which clamp it at two places about 2 inches asunder .
The other end A passes through a brass socket ( shown in cross section at fig. 2 ) , to which it is also secured by screws in two places .
This socket forms part of a piece of brass , which is shown on a larger scale in longitudinal section in fig. 3 , where n is a point or cone to be supported by a ring ( M , fig. 1 ) hanging from one arm of a balance , while the lower part consists of a short cylinder n ( for receiving the crosspiece shown in fig. 4 and indicated by dotted lines in fig. 3 ) terminated by a screw which receives the nut pp. The circular hollow shown in the centre of the cross piece ( fig. 4 ) fits the cylinder m , and the crosspiece can either be rotated about it or slipped off on loosening or removing the nut .
The four arms of the crosspiece are all of equal length , and each of them has on the upper side near the end a cone or point for supporting a weight by means of a ring .
FF is a cast-iron box , on the top of which the cylinder C rests in two notches one at each end , in which it turns freely when not secured by the clamp G. H is a graduated circle for turning the cylinder ( and with it the rod A B ) through any required angle .
K. L are two mirrors clamped to the rod , and adjustable by footscrew~s into any position nearly parallel with the rod .
One of them is shown onL a larger scale at fig. 5 .
By partially releasing the clamps , it was easy to rotate the mirrors about the rod without longitudinal sliding .
The point it , fig. 3 , is supported by the flat brass ring M , which hangs by the wire N from one arm of the balance D , and a counterpoise is placed in the pan P just sufficient to keep the rod AB free from strain .
The experiments were conducted in the Natural Philosophy Lecture-room .
The box FF rested on the floor , the height of mirrors above floor being 270 millims. The scale reflected by them consisted of a large sheet of paper ruled in two directions at right angles to each other with lines about a tenth of an inch apart , and was firmly fixed at the height of 4597 millims. from the floor by stretching it on a board and screwing this to two joists whose primary office was the support of a cistern .
The light , which was naturally good , was improved by using a concave mirror to illuminate the scale .
Two telescopes , not shown in the Plate , were clamped to a firm three-legged table , their objectglasses being about 970 millims. above the floor .
They were in fixed positions , directed one towards each mirror , and were as nearly vertical as was compatible with an unobstructed view of the reflection of the scale .
Their deviations from two vertical planes , one parallel and the other perpendicular to the rod , were from '- ?
to -2in circular measure .
They were inverting achromatic , of I '-inch aperture and 10 inches focal length , with cross wires in focus of eyepiece .
A damper , consisting of a piece of thin card pressing lightly against the end A of the rod , was used on and after July 17th for the purpose of checking vibration .
The mode of observing for flexure-was as follows:-The mirrors having been adjusted so as to bring the central portion of the scale into view in both telescopes , a pair of equal weights were placed , one in the scale-pan P along with the counterpoise , the other on the point 8 , and readings were taken in both telescopes .
Then the weight at S was transferred to 8 ' , and readings were again taken .
The difference of readings in further telescope diminished by difference of readings in nearer telescope is assumed to measure the effect , on the portion of rod between the two mirrors , of a bending couple whose arm is the distance between the two points S , S ' , and whose power is the force of gravity on the moveable weight .
The weight was then transferred first to T and then to T ' , both telescopes being read in each case .
The differences were taken in the same way as above , and the result is assumed to measure the effect , on the same portion of the rod , of a twisting couple whose power is the same as above , and whose arm is the distance between the points T , T ' .
The weight was then again transferred to S ' and S , then again to T ' and T , and so on everal times , both telescopes being read in each position of the weight , and no change being made in any of the adjustments .
The facility of thus passing from observations of flexure to those of torsion , and vice versed , gives the present form of apparatus a great superiority over that emiployed the previous year .
It has been observed that the arms of couple in flexure and torsion are the distances ~S S ' .
T T ' r espectively , which , though nearly equal , are not absolutely identical .
This defect was easily remedied by turning the crosspiece through a right angle , so as to make S S ' change places with T T ' .
Another source of error to be guarded against is want of perfect circularity in the rod operated upon .
This is completely removed , if the deviation from circularity be small , by turning the rod itself through a right angle by means of the graduated circle H. This change has no effect on the torsional rigidity ; and its effect on the flexural rigidity is such that the mean fiexure in the two positions is the true mean for all positions , inasmuch as the flexural rigidity in any position is proportional to the moment of inertia of a section about a horizontal diameter through its centre of gravity , and by a well-known theorem the sum of the moments of inertia about two rectangular diameters is constant .
For greater security the rod was turned into six different positions , differing by 300 among themselves , so that the first and fourth positions furnished one mean , the second and fifth another , and the third and sixth another .
In every one of the six positions observations of both flexure and torsion were taken ; and the operation of turning the crosspiece through a right angle so as to make the arms of couple for flexure and torsion change places , occurred between the third and fourth positions .
The first rod experimented on , after much time spent in preliminary arrangements , was a flint-glass rod from the works of A. and R. COCHRAN , Glasgow .
The weights employed for producing flexure and torsion were a pair of lead weights of 100 grms. each .
One of them ( distinguishable by its ring ) was hung in turn on each of the four arms , and the other was always placed in the counterpoise pan .
The first complete set of observations in six positions were made July 17th and 18th , with the following results : I ( a ) .
Pointer at 135 ' Torsion 539 Flexure 43542 ( a ) .
, , 1650 54713 438 3 ( a ) .
, , 1950 , , 546 , , 4461 1 ( 6 ) .
, , 225 , , 548 , , 454 2 ( b ) .
, 255 ? ?
5491 a 454 3(b ) .
, , 2850 , , 546 , , 447- .
The numbers here given as representing the amounts of torsion and flexure , are expressed in tenth parts of the scale-divisions , and are therefore approximately hundredths of an inch .
Combining those positions which are mutually at right angles , we have the following means:1 ( a ) ( b ) .
Torsion 543k Flexure 444k 2(a)-(b ) .
, , 5481 , , 446 3 ( a ) ( b ) .
, , 546 , , 447k .
The scale-divisions were somewhat longer in one direction than in the other , being 75 of a millimetre for torsion and 189 millims. for flexure .
In order , then , to find the true ; MIDccCLxYII .
u ' ratio of torsion to hexure , we must divide the numbers in the first column by those ill the second and diminish the quotients by +- ?
of their mounts .
The quotients thus corrected are I ( a ) ( 6 ) , 1P222 ; 2 ( a(1 ) , IP 230 " ( a ) ( b ) , 1P221 , whence we obtain at once for POISSON'S ratio ( u ) the values 222 , 2300 , 221 .
Some small corrections will be applied to these values hereafter , only affecting the third decimnal place ; but we deei it 'important ti us early to direct attention to the strength of evidence Showing that PoissoxEsI ratio for the substance in hand is less than X. 4 .
An earlier set of observations , in only four positions of the rod , were taken July 13th , 14th , and 16th , the apparatus being at this time less favourably arranged , inasmuch as the rod wals more distant from a vertical through the centre of the scale than in the later set .
The following were the results obtained : I ( a ) .
Pointer at 90 ?
Torsion 5551 Flexure 452 11(a ) .
, , 450 , , 550 , , 430 II ( a)* Am 45 as 550 7 4591 I ( ) .
, , 1350 5441 , 43732 Giving the following means , I(a ) ( b ) .
Torsion 552z Flexure 441 II ( Ca ) ( b ) .
AS5471 a 4481 2 whence we , obtain , after correcting for inequality of divisions , the values of POISSON'S ratio '246 , '220 , the largeness of the former number being due to the large angle made by the rays of light with the vertical plane containing the rod .
A correction for this defect will be applied in the sequel .
After the observations of July 17th and 18tfh , the rod Was removed from its placeand cut at the places wThere the mirrors had been attathed .
The 1enoth of the central portion was found to be 235-6 millims. , and its weights in air and , waterr espectively 32'002 and 21'112 grms. , the teuiperature of the ate r being'13 ?
3 Reanum .
The distances S S , T T ' were 558 2 and 557 2 millims , , so that the mean arm of couple was 557-7 m illimas .
, the force being the weight of 100 grns .
The height of the scale above the mirrors was 4327 millimns .
; but since the deviation of a reflected ray is double of the angle turned by mrror , it will be no essary to divide the arcs traversed on the scalel by twice this distance , or 8654 millins .
, in order to find the angles turned .
The scale-divisions for torsion were d milhim .
, but as they vere subdivided by estimation to tenths and it is in these tenths that the abone torsioninumbers are expressed , the unit is to be regarded as the 138 8of a millimetre .
In like manner the unit for the xlexure-numbers is the { 8_ of a millimetre .
We shai denote the torsion-numbers and fexure-numbers , expressed in these units , by the letters T and F. From the observations of July 17th and 18th we have the mean values T= 546 F=446 1 , which , reduced to centimetres , are 13-68 and 11P24 .
The whole torsion and flexure in the portion of the rod between mirrors are therefore 1 3'6 8 _0158 nearly in circular measure , and i16-2,4.0130 , I We shall now investigate the corrections which must be applied to the above results .
There is , in the first place , a mechanical correction depending on the fact that the plane which contains the four points S , 8 ' , T , T ' , and which also happens to contain the centre of gravity of the bending apparatus ( i. e. of the crosspiece and other pieces rigidly attached to it ) , does not contain the point n on which the apparatus is supported .
Let a denote the distance of this plane below the point nd and W the weight of the bending apparatus .
Also let A denote the horizontal distance of one of the points S or T from n , and w the weight hung at S or T , and let 0 denote the angle through which the end of the rod is bent or twisted .
Then the couple which produces bending or twisting is IV(AA-AO ) , and this is resisted by two couples , WaO , due to the weight of the bending apparatus , and tO or f , due to the torsional or flexural rigidity t or f We have therefore , wA wA for torsion , wV(A-aO)=t0 -t+Wa0 , whence t=-v ( W +w)a .
The first term , T is the uncorrected value of t , and we see that it requires a subtractive correction which bears to its whole amount the ratio ( W+ w)aO* Hence T , being proportional to the reciprocal WA of t , requires an additive correction bearing the above ratio to its whole amount .
The correction for F is expressed by the same formula , 0 having , however , a different value .
In the present case we have , in grammes and centimetres , W= 373 , v= 1O0 , A=27 9 , aC4 3 , hence ( + , 729 .
Again , since the whole length of rod subjected to torsion wA and flexure was about 42 8 , whereas the portion between the mirrors was only about 23-6 , we have For torsion , 04 2 6x 0158=-0286 , For flexure , 04O 2 6-0130=O0236 , and the products of thesevalues of 0 by *729 are *0208 and *0172 .
T and F therefore require the additive corrections 0208 T and 0172 F. There are also two optical corrections to be considered , viz. , 1st .
Correction for obliquity of ray from scale to mirror .
Let j3 denote this obliquity , that is to say , the angle which the projection of the ray on a vertical plane perpendicular or parallel to the rod , according as we are dealing with torsion or fiexure ; i , makes with a vertical line .
Then the indicated distances on the scale are always too great in the ratio of 1 1+32 .
If the angles through which the two mirrors are turned are in the ratio of rn , mn2 , in2 being the greater , and if the corresponding values of / 3 are l and 12 respectively , the observed values of T and F will be too great in the ratio of 1 : 1u 2 In the present case the ratio in1 : m2 is about 1 : 3 , and the values of ; for the centre of the scale in the position occupied by the apparatus on July 17th and 18th were , For torsion , f3 =-2-10 , 32=- ; for flexure , 3-414 P23-2 .
Hence we find by the above formula that T is too great by *0025 T , F , , , , 0013 F. 2nd .
Correction for change of distance between mirror and telescope .
If the mirror is moved parallel to itself to or from the telescope by the amount 6 , and if P denote the angle between incident and reflected ray ( or rather between their projections on a vertical plane perpendicular or parallel to the rod ) , the change produced in the scale-reading is 6t .
In the present case this correction was found to be insensible .
For the total corrections applicable to the observations of July 17th and 18th , we have therefore +-0208 T-*0025 T=+-0183 T , +-0172 F-*0013 F=+ 0159 F , T. and the resulting correction of the quotient E is TT ( 0183-.0159)F -p-0024 PA ' This correction reduces the values of PoISsoN 's ratio derived from the observations of those days to *225 , *233 , -224 .
For the observations of July 13th , 14th , and 16th , the correction of F is the same as above .
As regards the optical correction of T , a distinction must be made between the observations marked I ( a ) ( b ) and those marked II ( a ) ( b ) .
In the former , the central portion of the scale was on the cross wires of the telescopes , in the latter a portion of the scale nearly vertical over the mirrors .
The optical correction for T applicable to the centre of the scale on the date in question was -0089 T , and we shall apply this correction to the values I ( a ) ( b ) , so that the total correction of T for these values will be + 0208 T0089 T= + '0119 T , T and the corresponding correction of P will be 5TT( ( )119.-*0159 F -004 - , which reduces the value *246 of POISSON'S ratio to *241 .
To the values II ( a ) ( b ) we shall apply the same corrections as to the observations of July 17th and 18th , and the value '220 of POISSON 's ratio is thus reduced to '223 .
The corrected values of POISSON'S ratio '225 , *233 , '224 , '241 , '223 give the mean value *229 ; and it will be noted that every one of the five determinations ( whether corrected or uncorrected ) is less than onefourth .
The five determinations of T and F uncorrected and corrected , are given below .
The correcting factor for T is , as already shown , 10183 , except for I ( a ) ( b ) , for which it is 10119 .
The correcting factor for F is in every case 1P0159 .
Uncorrected .
Corrected .
A. A._ &amp; _ C_-_AT .
F. T. F. 1 ( a ) ( 1 ) .
54365 444'7 553a4 451.8 2 ( a)(b ) .
548'5 446'0 558'5 453'1 3 ( a ) ( b)1 546'0 447-5 556'0 454'6 I ( a ) ( b ) 552'7 441'0 559-3 448'0 II ( a ) ( 1)4 547'1 448'5 557'1 455'6 Mean of corrected values. .
556'9 452'6 We now proceed to deduce , as in our former paper , the values of t , f , n , M , and Ik , the units being the centimetre and the weight of a gramume .
For t and f , the torsional and flexural rigidities , we have the expressions ttwice distance X force X arm x length X T7 f twice distance X force x arm x length X7 01J1 F , where twice distance =865'4 , force =100 , arm =55'77 , length =23'56 .
Hence we have log t=9'65670log r6.9l1092 logf=9'65440log F-6'99869 .
The volume of the rod was 10'902 , being the loss of weight in water multiplied by 1'00111 , which is the factor proper to the temperature l33 lR .
The length being 23-56 , we find ( putting r for radius of rod ) zr2='46273 , r=-38378 .
For YOUNG'S modulus we have Mi = 585,100,000 ; for the rigidity , i. 4-2=239,020,000 ; for the resistance to compression , k -3Mn -353,264,000 ; for POISSON 's ratio , M= f1=y--1=*2299 The values found last year for another specimen of flint glass , by a different maker ( see former Paper ) , were M=614,330,000 , n=244,170Q000 , k =423,0.10,00 , u='258 , the specific gravity of the present specimen being 2'935 , while that of last year 's waas 2 942 .
The differences in these determinations of M and n , being only about five per cent. in the former case and two in the latter , are probably real , the denser specimen being also the more rigid .
The values of k and a are liable to a larger percentage of error ; but this remark is more especially applicable to last year 's results , as our present apparatus affords greatly increased facilities for determining the ratio of flexural to torsional rigidity .
With respect to the composition of the two specimens , I am unable to give precise informiation , as the ingredients are mixed according to no definite rule .
The ghass rod having been taken down , a rod of drawn brass was mounted in its place ) the apparatus remaining in precisely the same position as in the experiments of July 17th and 18th .
The following results were furnished by the first set of observations , July 27th and 28th : I ( a ) .
Pointer at 0 ?
Torsion 408 Flexure 276 II ( a ) .
, 300 , , 406 , , 2741 III1(az ) .
: , 6-0 ?
, , 404 , , 275 I ( b)@ .
90 ?
A 404 Ax 280 -PI ( I ) .
me 1200 404 , , 76 III ( b ) .
5 : 150 ?
a 407 , , 275+From these we obtain the following means : 1(a ) ( b ) .
Torsion 406 Flexure 278 , II ( a ) ( b ) .
, , 405 , , 275,5 III ( a ) ( b ) .
, 405-5 , , 2754 , whence , after correcting as before for difference of scale-divisions , we obtain for PoIssoiNT 's ratio the values 451l , *461 , 465 .
The weights used in these observations were the same as for the glass rod .
A second set of observations were made July 31st , August Ist and 2nd , in which , besides the old weights , which were each 100 grms. , weights of 200 grims .
were also employed .
These latter , however , could only be used for fexure , as when the attempt was made to employ them for torsion , it was found impossible to prevent the rod from turning in its socket .
In consequence of turning ivhich took place from this cause at the commencement of this set of observations , the follo rving pointer-readings are not precisely comparable with the foregoing , that is to say , the zero-point may be regarded as having shifted between the two sets of observations .
A slight change was also made in the position of one of the telescopes , between observations 3 ( a ) and 1 ( b ) , for the purpose of obtaining better light , and at the same time a string was attached to the " damper " in such a manner that the observer could pull the damper away from the rod without removing his eye from the telescope .
The following were the results , the two sets of flexure-numbers being obtained with wreights of 100 and 200 germs , respectively .
( a ) .
Pointer at 1650 Torsion 4061 Flexure 277 , '550 0~~~~~~ 2 ( a ) .
, 195 ?
, 406 , 276 ) 551 3 ( a ) .
, 225Q , 409L , 272 , 547 1(6 ) , , 2550 , , 410 , , 276 , 552 2 ( b ) , 285 ?
, 408 , , 279 , 554 3(6 ) .
, , 315 , 404 , , 282 , 552 From these we have the following means I ( a ) ( b ) .
Torsion 408'1 Flexure 276 5 , 551'2 2 ( a ) ( b ) .
, , 407'0 , , 2775 , 552 '5 3(a)(b ) .
, , 407'0 , , 277-0 , 549'8 Correcting for difference of scale-divisions , we derive the following values of PoissoN &lt; s ratio .
From torsion at 100 grms. compared with flexure at 100 grms. , *468 , 459 , -461 .
From torsion at 100 grins .
compared with flexure at 200 gims .
, 473 , '465 , *473 .
Collecting all the results obtained with the brass rod , we find the mean val ie of T to 'be 406'4 .
The m ean value of F from the six results for weights of 100 grms. is 276'6 , and from the three results for weights of 200 grms. 5512 .
We shall denote these two numbers by IF , and F2 respectively .
Reduced to centimetres , these become TX --1 58O= 10'19 , F1 X =6B 97 , X90 which , being divided by 865'4 or tw-s.7ice distance of scale from mirrors , give as the amounts of torsion and fiexure in circular measure , Torsion , '01178 ; Flexure , '00805 and '0161 .
The whole length of rod operated on was in the present case of the port ion between mirrors ; hence the values of 0 for the mechanical correction are -4 7 of the above angles , or '0229 , '0157 , '0313 .
The values of the factor+ are respectively wA '729 , -729 , '442 giving as the values of the mechanical correction ?
-J-0167 T , '-0114 Fl +-0138 F2 .
The first optical correction is the same as for July 17th and 18th , , viz. -00)25 T , -'0 013 F , ,.0013 F , and the second optical correction is still inappreciable .
We have therefore as the total corrections to be applied +'0142 T , +'0101 F1 , +'0125 F2 , TTTT from which we deduce for and -l the corrections + '0041 and + 0017 iF ' Hence the corrected values of PoissoN 's ratio areFrom T and F1 ... '457 , '467 , '471 , '474 , 465 , '467 , From T and F2 ... '476 , '467 , '476 .
The mean of these nine values is '469 , which we therefore adopt as the value of o for brass , being nearly double of our value for glass .
The comparison of our results for these two substances with those of other experimenters is somewhat startling .
It stands thus : Glass .
WERTHEIM , '33 , MAXWELL , '332 , EVERETT , '239 , Brass .
KiRciIopFF , '387 , X , '469 ; id our two results , '239 and '469 , were obtained with the same apparatus in the same position , each of them being the mean of several determinations , which for glass ranged fromin 223 to '241 , and for brass from '457 to '476 .
The followingo are the values , uncorrected and corrected , of T and F , the latter including both F1 and 41F2 ' Uncorrected .
Corrected .
T. F. T. F. I ( a ) ( b ) .
406'0 278'0 411'8 280-8 II ( a ) ( b ) .
405'0 275'5 410'7 278'3 III ( a ) ( b ) .
405'5 275'1 411'3 277'9 1 ( a ) ( b ) .
408'1 276'5 413'9 279'3 2 ( a ) ( b ) .
407'0 277'5 412'8 280'3 3 ( a ) ( b ) .
407'0 277'0 412'8 279'8 1 ( a ) ( b ) .
275.6 279'0 ) 2 ( a)( ) .
IF2 276'2 279'7 -IF 3 ( a ) .
{ 274'9 278'3J Means of corrected values. .
412'2 279-3 The elements for deriving t from T , and f from F , are the same as for the glass rod , except that the length between mirrors is 24'54 instead of 23'56 .
We thus find log t= 9'67439 -log T= 705928 , logff 9'67209-log F-7'22602 .
To determine the radius r of the rod , we have weight in air=91'361 , weight in water =80'578 , the temperature of the water being 7'3 R. Hence volume in centimetres -10'783 X 1'0002=1C785 , which , being divided7by the length 24'54 , gives AA2 43949 .
Hence we find for brass , MI =-4-1,094,800,000 , Tnr4 n=fl 372,890,000 , k=aMn __ 700,700,000 , M 62 1-.469 .
-2n From comparing the above value of k with its values for the two glass rods experimented on , it would appear that brass is from 131 to 16 times more incompressible than glass ; but this result is to be received with caution , for reasons which will be stated further on .
A rod of cast steel was next operated on , with the following results , the weights used being the same as for the brass rod .
I(a ) .
Pointer at 310 ?
Torsion 204* Flexure 1551 , 313 II(a ) .
, , 2800 , , 205 , , 155 , 307 III ( a~e , , 250 ?
, 207 , , 154 , 316 I ( b ) .
, , 2200 , 206 , , 157 , 313 IS ( b ) .
, 1900 , 2064 , , 154 , 313k III1(b ) .
, , 1600 , 2066 , , 156 , 313* Hence we have the following means I ( a ) ( b ) .
Torsion 20541 Flexure 156-2 , 313.0 II(a)(b ) .
, , 2059 , , 1545 , 31041 III ( a ) ( b ) .
, , 206-9 , , 155-0 , 314-7 Correcting for difference of scale-divisions , we obtain the following , determinations of POISSON'S ratio .
From torsion at 100 grms. compared with flexure at 100 grmns .
, -305,.325 , *327 .
From torsion at 100 grms. compared with flexure at 200 grms. , ~304 , *321 , *308 .
As the apparatus was disturbed in my absence , and the mirrors were moved from their places before any measurements had been made of their positions , it is impossible to determine with accuracy from the foregoing observations the torsional and flexural rigidities of the rod .
In order to determine PoIssON 's ratio as accurately as the data permit , we shall assume ( what is known to be near the truth ) that the ratio of the whole length operated on to the length between mirrors was the same as for the brass rod , and that the optical corrections are the same .
From these data , the mechanical corrections are found to be Qt 0084 T. + 0064FA , +0078 F , -MDcccL2CVJI .
' OiN THE RIGIDITY OF GLASS , which , together with the optical corrections -0025 T , --0013 F1 , -'0013 12 , make the total corrections +'0059 T+ -0051 F1 , +'0065 F2 , T which are so small and so nearly equal that the corrections of p may be neglected .
We therefore assume as the value of POISSON 's ratio from these experiments , the mean of the six determinations above given , which is *315 .
All the foregoing experiments were conducted by myself in the Lecture-room during the Vacation .
At the commencement of the Session , the apparatus was removed to another room , where experiments on the steel rod were continued , under my direction , by two students ( Messrs. KING and WALKER ) during the months of November and December .
The room selected for this purpose being on the ground-floor , and paved with asphalt , on which the apparatus rested , was superior , as regards steadiness , to the lecture-room , which is on the first floor ; and I may here remark that the inconsistencies ( such as they are ) which occur in the foregoing experiments , were found to be due mainly to the yielding of the floor under the feet of the observer .
On the other hand the new situation afforded less height , the scale being only 223-5 centimetres above the mirrors .
It was also rather dark ; but this defect was completely remedied by using a gaslight , aided by a concave reflector , to illuminate the scale .
The scale used was a new one , of the same kind as the old , but with the lines nearer together , their distances , as determined by taking the means of several measurements , being such that For torsion .
171 scale-divisions =23'88 centims. For flexure. .
171 scale-divisions =23'97 centims. The whole length of rod subjected to torsion and flexure was 46'8 , and the mirrors where attached at a greater distance apart than in any of the foregoing experiments , viz. 38-15 centims. The telescopes were at the same height above the mirrors as before , being clamped to the same table which had been previously used .
The weights employed were of 100 grins .
, and the system of observing was the same as in the later observations above described .
The following were the values obtained for T and F in terms of their respective scaledivisions , each of these values being the mean of sixteen determinations .
I ( a ) .
Pointer at 00 Torsion 25'62 Flexure 19'68 2 ( a ) .
, , 30 ?
, , 25'87 , , 1957ID ( a ) mu 60 ?
, 25 87 , ? ?
19 64 1 ( b ) .
, 900 , , 25'95 , 19'74 2 ( b ) .
, 1200 , , 25'85 , , 19'82 3 ( ) .
, , 1500 , , 25'84 , , 19'80 Hence we have the following means:1 ( a ) ( b ) .
Torsion 25'78 Flexure 19'71 2 ( a ) ( b ) , , 25'86 , , 19'70 3(a)(b ) , 25'86 , , 19'72 And applying the correction for difference of scale-divisions , which is now I part in 266 TT to be subtracted from W ' we have as the values of POISSON'S ratio , Or P-11 303 , '308 , 306 , giving a mean of '30G .
The mean values of T and F are respectively 25 83 and 19 71 , which reduced to centimetres become 3'61 and 2'76 ; and as twice the height of the scale is 447 , we find the amounts of torsion and flexure respectively in the portion of rod between mirrors , to be about *00808 and -00617 .
The values of D are 4 6-5 of these , or '00993 and '00758 , which are to be multiplied by '729 , as before , giving for the mechanical corrections the values +'0072 T and + ?
0055 F. No measurements were made to determine the optical corrections , we shall therefore assume them to be the same as in the experiments on the brass rod , viz. -'0025 T and 0013 F , making the total corrections +'0047 T and +'0042 F , whose difference is so small that the correction for T may be neglected .
We therefore adopt for POISSON 's ratio , as determined by these experiments , the above value '306 .
The corrected mean values of T and F are 25'95 and 19'79 , and we have t[=447'0 x100 x 55-77 x 3815 X--I-7-I.T f=447'0 x 100 x 55 77 x 38'15 x1 7 .
F whence log t=9983317logT=7'41903 , logf= 9'83153log F= 753508 .
The weights in air and water were respectively 132'94 and 116'00 grms. , the temperature of the water being 7'7 R. , and the length of the portion weighed being 38'1 centims. The correction for density at this temperature may be neglected , and we have volume in centim. = loss of weight in grammes =16'94 .
Hence / r2= 9 -44462 ri37620 .
M y= %r-j.24 179,300,000 , it 834,120,000 Mn ' -2-1='306 , nasabove ; x2 and as the experiments in the Lecture-room gave '315 as the value of o , I adopt the value *310 .
KIRCHOFF 's value for steel is *294 , and CLERK MAXWELL'S for iron *267 .
The following are the collected results of the experiments described in both this and the former paper , the values of M : , n , and k being reduced to kilogrammes ' weight per square millimetre .
Flint Glass , Flint Glass , Drawn Brass , Cast Steel , 1865 .
1866 .
1866 .
1866 .
M. 6143 5851 10948 21793 nx ... ... 2442 2390 3729 8341 k.4230 -3533 57007 18756 a1 ... .
*258 *229 '469 *310 Specific gravity .
2'942 2'935 8'471 7'849 Strictly speaking , the above values of M are the measures of resistance to longitudinal extension parallel to the length of the rods , and the above values of n " are the measures of resistance to shearing in planes rarallel or perpendicular to the length .
The values of k and are have been deduced on the hypothesis that the materials of the rods are isotropic .
If , however , as is probably the case , this hypothesis is not fulfilled , and if the deviation from isotropy be such that the resistance to shearing in planes parallel or perpendicular to the length is less than for intermediate planes , then the values of k and a ' above calculated are too large ; for longitudinal extension ( especially if accompanied by lateral contraction ) involves a certain amount of shearing in planes oblique to the length , and the resistance to this shearing is one of the constituents of M , whereas the shearing which takes place in torsion is perpendicular to the length .
Such a deviation from isotropy as we are now considering will therefore increase the ratio of M to n , and will therefore increase a , M which is equal to 1 .
It will also increase k , since the value of Qu may be written 3(1M2 This caution is specially important in the case of the brass rod , both because the operation of " .drawing " appears likely to produce such a deviation from isotropy as we have been describing , and also because the value of a ' for this rod comes out so nearly equal to that the factor 1-2c in the denominator of k will be greatly affected by small errors in the value of a ' .
For these reasons we are not disposed to attach much weight to the very large value of k which we have found for brass .
We append for comparison some of the principal results obtained by previous experimenters .
The values obtained by WERTHEIM for different specimens of glass ( crystal ) were , AM 3481 to 4429 , mean 4039 , n 1288 to 1687 , mean 1518 , k 3569 to 4476 , mean 3968 ; and for different specimens of brass , Ml 9665 to 10645 , mean 10054 , X 3600 to 3973 , mean 3745 , Ic 10216 to 11058 , mean 10631 .
experiments on the torsion of brass wire lead to the result n= 3682 .
KUPFFER'S values of M\ for nine different specimens of brass range from 8112 to 11617 , the value generally increasing with the specific gravity , and the two specimens which agree most nearly with our own in specific gravity show the following results : Specific gravity 8-4465 .
Value of M 10783 Specific gravity 8-4930 .
Value of M 11421 .
The values of M found by the same experimenter for steel range from 20569 to 21842 .
The values of a found by KIRCHHOFF , WERTHEIM , and MAXWELL have already been given .
They all differ widely from our own except in the case of steel .
In conclusion we may state that , as our present form of apparatus is found extremely convenient , it is intended to use it for continuing the series of experiments which have been begun , with , however , an important modification , which will be made for the purpose of diminishing or removing the " mechanical correction .
" 7lid J.Ams .
}AL GOCLX .
V1I .
APcd D-.X _ , D ... 0_ S_o_ _ , _._._ , iv~~~~~ F o6 &lt; 1Kg .
g. o.-IW--~ gig~~~~~~~~~~~~i 3 LU1I iffil T1 , ... 4~~I A._~~~~~~~~~~~w~e~

