Supplementary Memoir on Caustics .
By A. CAYLEY , P.B.S. Rieceived November 15 , -Read November 22 , 1866 .
IT is near the conclusion of my " Memoir on Caustics , " Philosophical Transactions , vol. cxlvii .
( 1857 ) , pp. 273-312 , remarked that for the case of parallel rays refracted at a circle , the ordinary construction for the secondary caustic cannot be made use of ( the entire curve would in fact pass off to an infinite distance ) , and that the simplest course is to measure off the distance GQ from a line through the centre of the refracting circle perpendicular to the direction of the incident rays .
The particular secondary caustic , or orthogonal trajectory , of the refracted rays , obtained on the above supposition was shown to be a curve of the order 8 ; and it was further shown ( by consideration of the case wherein the distance GQ is measured off from an arbitrary line perpendicular to the incident rays ) that the general secondary caustic or orthogonal trajectory of the refracted rays was a curve of the same order 8 .
The last-mentioned curve in the case of reflexion , or for h 1 , degenerates into a curve of the order 6 ; and I propose in the present supplementary memoir to discuss this sextic curve , viz. the sextic curve which is the general secondary caustic or orthogonal trajectory of parallel rays reflected at a circle .
i. .
For parallel rays refracted at a circle , taking the equation of the circle to be x2+y2-l , and the incident rays to be parallel to the axis of x , then if x= n be an arbitrary line perpendicular to the direction of the incident rays , the secondary caustic is the envelope of the circle , p2{( av2+(yv)2_($M)2=0 , where ( as , P3 ) are the coordinates of a variable point on the refracting circle , and as such satisfy the equation a 2+12=1 .
Or , what is the same thing , writing Mcos 0 , 3= sill 0 the secondary caustic is the envelope of the circle -p2 ( COS0)'(y-+ sin 0)2 } ( ( -M)2 0 , where 0 is a variable parameter .
2 .
The equation may be written A cos 20+B sin 2d+C cos d+D sin d +E=O , where A =1 , B _0 , C= 4p2x4m , D =42y5 E-=-2p2(x2+y2)-2p2+1 +2A2n and which in the case of reflexion or for p= -1 , become A=1 , B-O , C =4a-4m , E =-2(x +2)-1 + 2r2 , viz. the equation of the variable circle is in this case cos20+4(x-2nm)cos0+4ysin0I+ 2m21-2(2 +y2)= O. 3 .
Now in general for the equation A cos 20+B sin 20+0 cos 0+D sin 0+E=O , where the coefficients are any functions whatever of the coordinates ( x , y ) , the equation of the envelope is S3-T2 =o where S =12(A2+B 2)-3(C2+1D2 ) +4E2 , -T=27 A(C D2)+54BCD-(72(A +B2)+ 9(C2+D2))E+8SE3 .
4 .
Hence , substituting for A , B , C , D , E the above reflexion values , we find S12 -48((x 27)2+zf)+4(2n2-1-2X2 -2y2)2 -T=2432 ( ( XM)2_y2 ) --72 ( 12 +144(xiS2y ) ( 22neI2 , ttO2 ?
y ) + 8(2M2-1-2 .
2 g2)3 Writing in these equations ( X-rn)2 +y2=.y222 + 2)nx+ 2+ ) ( X_Mi)2_y2= 2X2 MtX2_ ( X2 + y2)1 then after some simple reductions , we find S=16{(x2+y2_-n2_1)2++6( x-m ) } , T=2 32 { 2(x2 +y2_e2 1)3+ 18m( rn)Q+2 ?
22 1 ) -27(x-rn)2 } , and thence S3-T2't1024(x--M)2U , where U= 4(+ ?
l 2 _mn2_1)3 + 49n2(v2+-m2_ _ 1)2 +36)n ( X2+y2_M22-1)(xn ) -27 ( x-.m)2 or , what is the same thing , U4(x2 +y2)3 -(8m2+12 ) ( X2 +y2)2 +(36nx+4mr4-20n2+12 ) ( XI2+y2 ) 27x2+(-4rn2+18)mx+mn2_-4 ; so that the equation of the secondary caustic is U= 0 , ' or the secondary caustic is , as stated above , a sextic curve .
5 .
It is easy to see that the foregoing envelope may be geometrically constructed as follows : viz. if from the point Q ( coordinates cos 0 , sin 0 ) on the reflecting circle we draw QM perpendicular to the line x-mn=O , and then from the point M draw MN perpendicular to QT , the tangent at T , and produce T MN to a point P such that PN=NM , then P is a point of the envelope ; and we thence obtain for the coordinates ( x , y ) of a point P of the envelope the values x= m-2(mcos0)cos20 , y= sin 0-2(ncos0)cosOsin0 , or , what is the same thing , x =2 cos3 0-m(2 cos2 0-1 ) , y= sin 0(2 cosO 0+1)2mn sin 0 cos 0 , or , as these equations may also be written , X=-3 COS 0-n cos 20+1 cos 30 , y=3 sin 0-rm sin 20+ 1 sin 30 .
6 .
This result may be verified by showing that these values satisfy the equation cos 20+4(x-em ) cos O+4y sin 0+2n-2 1-2(a9+y2 ) O , and also the derived equation sin 20+2(x-m ) sin 0-2y cos 0=0 .
We in fact have x sin 0-y cos 0= m sin 0-1 sin 20 , x cos 0+y sin 0= 3-n cos 0+ cos 20 , and thence ( x-m ) sin0 ycos= - ; sin 20 , which is one of the equations to be verified ; and also ( X-m ) cOS 0-+y sin 0=A-2m cos 0+1 cos 20 .
We have moreover $82 y_ 52+rnS-4m cos09+ 3cos 20 ; M DCCCLXVII .
C and , by means of these last equations , the other equation cos 20+4(x.-m ) cos 0+4y sin 0+2m2-.- &gt; -2Qv2+y2)=0O is also verified .
7 .
The foregoing values of ( x , y ) give dx=(sin 0+2rn sin 20-3 sin 30)d = -sin 20(3 cos 0 2m)dO , die ( 2cos 02m cos 20+ 2 cos 30)dO= cos 20(3 cos 0 2m)dA , or , what is the same thing , dx : dy=--sin 20 : cos 20 .
Hence taking for a moment ( X , Y ) as the current coordinates of a point in the tangent of the envelope , the equation of the tangent of the envelope is Xdy-Ydx=xdy-ydx , or , substituting for x , y , dx , die their values , this equation takes the very simple form X Cos 20-Y sin 20-2 cos 0+n=0 , or writing ( x , y ) in place of ( X , Y ) , that is taking now ( x , y ) as the current coordinates of a point in the tangent , the equation of the tangent is x cos 20-y sin 20-2 cos O+mq=0 ; whence observing that this equation may be expressed as a rational equation of the fourth order in terms of the parameter tan !
0 ( or cos 0+V 1 sin 0 ) , it appears that the class of the secondary caustic is=4 .
8 .
The secondary caustic may be considered as the envelope of the tangent , and the equation be obtained in this manner .
Comparing with the general equation A cos 20+D sin 204C cos 0+D sin 0+E= , O we have A x , B=C -2 , D=01 E=m , and thence S=4{3(X2+z2)+o2 3 } , T= 4{ 8m(x2 +y2 ) 27x2m'+ 9m } , givingS-Tz1V S3 .
T2 16V , if for a moment V=4f 3(x2+y2)+m23}3 { 18m(x2+y2)-27x-2m1+9m}2 .
The equation of the curve is thus obtained in the form V=O ; this should of course be equivalent to the before-mentioned equation U 0 ; and by developing V , and comparing with the second of the two expressions of U , it appears that we in fact have V=27U .
9 .
Taking as parameter tan I 0 , or if we please cos 0+ Isin 0 , the foregoing values of ( x , y ) in terms of 0 give ( x , y , 1 ) proportional to rational and integral functions of the parameter of the degree 6 ; so that not only the curve is a sextic curve , but it is a unicursal sextic , or curve of the order 6 with the maximum number , = 10 , of nodes and cusps ; that is , if b be the number .
of nodes and z the number of cusps , we have 3+X=10 .
Moreover , introducing the same parameter into the equation of the tangent , this equation is seen to be of the degree 4 in the parameter ; that is , the class of the curve is 4 : this implies 2w+3 &amp; =26 , and we have therefore t=4 , x-6 .
To verify these numbers , it is to be remarked that it appears by the equation of the curve that there is at each of the circular points at infinity a triple point in the nature of the point x '=0 , y=O on the curve y3=x ' ; such a point is in fact equivalent to two cusps and a node , and we have thus the two circular points at infinity counting together as 2 nodes and 4 cusps ; there should therefore besides be 2 nodes and 2 cusps , and I proceed to establish the existence of these by means of the expressions for ( x , y ) in terms of 0 .
10 .
To find the cusps , we have dx d9 =-sin 20(3 cos 0-2m ) =0 die da_ cos 20(3 cos 0-2n ) = O , which are each of them satisfied if only 3 cos 0-2rn= 0 , or cos= O = ; the corresponding values of ( a , y ) are found to be *8m3 74m 2\ and we have thus two cusps situate symmetrically in regard to the axis of x ; the cusps are real if m &lt; 3 , imaginary if mn &gt; 3 ; for m= 32 , the two cusps unite together at the point x= 1 on the axis of x , giving rise to a higher singularity , which will be further examined , post , No. 12 .
11 .
The curve is symmetrical in regard to the axis of x , and hence any intersection with the axis of x , not being -a point where the curve cuts the axis at right angles , will be a node .
Hence , in order to find the nodes , writing yy=0 , this is sin 6(1 2n cos 0+2 cos2 0 ) =0 , giving sin 0=0 , that is , 0=0 , x= 2-no ; or 0=7r , x=-2-rn ; but these are each of them ordinary points on the axis of x ; or else giving 1-2m cos 0-+2 cos2 0O , that is , cos 0=-(m+ ?
Vrn2-2 ) .
c 2 The corresponding values of x are x cos 0(2 cos20-2m cos 0 ) +m , =m-cos 0 , = ( rn 2 ) ; each of the points in question , viz. the points x=1i(m:FVrn 2 ) , y=0 , is a node on the axis of x. 12 .
It is to be observed that for m &lt; V/ 2 the nodes are both imaginary ; for m=/ '2 they coincide together at the point x=z7g ; for m &gt; V2 they are both real : it is to be further noticed that node X=2(M+Vm2-2 ) corresponds to cos0=1(mi-Vm2-2 ) , where ( m being &gt; / 2 ) the point ( cos 0 , sin 0 ) is a real point on the circle x2+y2=1 ; in fact for m &lt; 3 ( that is , m=V/ 2 to m=432 ) we have !
( Oz - ) &lt; -im , that is , cos0 &lt; 4 ; butzm= or &gt; x , then cos0= ( m m J)+ Vm2-2 is = or &lt; I and node x=I(m - , V/ 2-2 ) corresponds to cos 0=i(m+V/ m2 -2 ) , where ( m being &gt; V/ 2 ) the point ( cos 0 , sin 0 ) is a real point on the circle x2+y2=1 so longas m is not &gt; 3 , that is , from m=V\2 to m=3 ; but if m &gt; , then the point in long ~~~2'2 question is an imaginary point on the circle-whence also the node x= ( m.-VWm2-2 ) is an acnode or isolated point .
In the case m= 3we have node x=1 corresponding to cos 0=or 0 =60 ?
, , , X-2 , , cos0=l or O=00 , the last-mentioned point x=being in fact the point of union of two cusps in the case Mn=4 now in question .
Hence in this casewe have at ( x==2 y=O ) a triple point equivalent to two cusps and a node ; visibly , there is only a single branch cutting the axis of x at right angles .
In the case mnV/ 2 , the nodes coincide as above mentioned at the point X= g2 on the axis ; for this value of rn the coordinates of the cusps are x=l l ( =/ 2 _22-which is &lt; ) ; I+ ?
27X 13 .
Starting from the equation 1024 ( x-m)2U-=S3-T2=O , it is clear that the cusps are included among the intersections of the curves S=0 , T= 0 ; these two curves intersect in 24 points which lie 9+9 at the circular points at infinity , 2+2 at the points x= m , y2-l-=O0 and 1+1 are the cusps , or points x=e-8 , Y=l To verify this , 27 ' 9%. .
oeiyhs writing for a moment S1 ( x 2+y2-m,2 I)2+ 6mn(x-m ) , T ' 2(x2 + ?
-ni21 ) ' + 18m(x-m)(ce2+y2--.21)27(x -nz)2 , then we have T2(x2 + y'-1)S'= 6m(x-m)(z2+y-in2 1)-27(x_ m)2 =3(x-m){2m(x2+y2-_2 1)9(X-m ) } ; so that the equations S-0 , T-0 , or , what is the same thing , S'=O , T'=O give ( x-m){2m(x2+y m2 I)- .
9(-_m ) }=0 , that is , xm=0 , or else s2+22-m2 7-1=n ( x-m ) .
And combining herewith the equation SI=(x2+ &amp; i2-2-1)2+6m(x-m)=0 , we have x-m=0 , ( y2_1)2=0 , or else ( !
2+y 2 , M2 12 , I )2 ( *a-M)2 = 6m(x-m ) , and therefore ( X-m ) { 27(xn)8rns } =0 , the second factor of which gives x-m--28 3 , and thence x2a+y2 m2 1= -3 m2 , that is , X2+y2=l Inm2 , and therefore y2=(1-_m2)_(m-8 m3)2 =(1 -m2)3 that is , we have 8 I3 y2=(IAM2)3 which , as appears above , gives the two cusps .
14 .
Similarly , in the equation 16V= S3-T2= 0 , the intersections of the curves S=0 , T= O must include the cusps ; the curves in question are the two circles 3 ( X2+y2)+m2-3=0 18m(2+y2)27x-2mwn3+9m=O , meeting in the circular points at infinity , and in the two cusps .
It is to be added that the tangent at the cusp coincides with the tangent of the last-mentioned circle , 1SM(X2 +y2)-27x'2nm3+9m= 0 , or , as this may also be written , 32 2( 4-9 2 3\2 12m ) 15 .
The axis of x meets the secondary caustic in the two nodes counting as 4 intersections , and besides in 2 points , viz. the points x= 2 -m , x2 -m ; these correspond to the values 00 and O= T respectively .
But to verify them by means .
of the equation 16V=SS3..-T3=O of the curve , it may be remarked that for y=O we have S= 4(3x2+m2-3 ) , T=4(18mx2-27x-2m ` + 9m ) ; and writing herein x= +2 in , we find S=4(2mT3)2 , T=8(2min+3)3 , values which satisfy the equation S'-T2=0 .
In the equation U=O of the curve , writing x-rn=O , the equation becomes 4(y2 1)3+ 4m2(y1)2= 0 , that is , 4(y2_ 1)(y2lI + rn ) -0 and the line ( x-.m)=0 is thus a double tangent to the curve touching it at the points x= m , y=+ 1 , and besides meeting it at the points x=m , y= + ?
V -n2 , that is , at the intersections of the line xm= 0 , with the circle x2+y .
17 .
The maximum or minimum values of y correspond to the values z=O =3X 44 O-i ' O-74 of 0 ; and we have for x2 y= V rn , 4 O-T x=-W2 , &amp; / = v'2+n , 0=- !
5 -W-s2 , y=-V/ 2-me , 4I0 ~~ W 2 , y=-s'2+rn .
18 .
It is now easy to trace the secondary caustic ; we may without loss of generality assume that in is positive , and the values to be considered are n=0 , -m-=1 , m=/ 2 , m= 2 with the intermediate values mn &gt; 0 &lt; 1 , &amp;c. ... and n &gt; -3 .
I have for convenience delineated in the figure only a portion of each curve , viz. the figure is terminated at the negative value x--V/ 2 , which corresponds to the maximum value y=V2+m ; as x increases negatively , the value of the ordinate y diminishes continuously from this maximum value , becoming =0 for the value x= -2-rn , and the curve at this point cutting the axis of x at right angles ; this is a sufficient explanation of the form of the curves beyond the limits of the figure .
Moreover the curve is symmetrical in regard to the axis of x , and I have within the limits of the figure delineated only one of the two halves of the curve .
19 .
For mn &gt; the cusps are both imaginary , the nodes both real , but one of them is an isolated point or acnode ( shown in the figure by a small cross ) .
The curve has an interior loop , as shown in the figure , and there is also the acnode lying within the loop .
For m=-Ln there is still an interior loop , but the acnode has united itself to the loop , the point of union , although presenting no visible-singularity , being really a triple point equivalent to a node and two cusps .
And in all the cases which follow there are two real cusps .
For m= &lt; 32 &gt; V/ 2 , the loop has altered its form in such wise as to exhibit the node and two cusps , the curve has therefore two real nodes .
For m=V2 , the two nodes unite together into a tacnode , so that the loop is on the point of disappearing ; and for m &lt; 12 &gt; 1 the nodes are imaginary , and there is thus no longer any loop .
In all the above forms the double tangent x=m touches the curve at the points y= 1 , but the other two intersections of the double tangent with the curve are imaginary .
For m=1 , the double tangent has the two coincident real intersections Y=0 , or it is in fact a triple tangent .
For m &lt; l &gt; 0 , the double tangent has with the curve two real intersections , viz. they are the points where the double tangent meets the circle v2 +y2 1 And finally , for m=0 , the points in question unite themselves with the points of contact , the double tangent x= 0 being in this case the common tangent at the two cusps x=0 , OY+l .
Added May 13 , 1867.-A .
C. 20 .
As remarked in the original memoir , p. 312 , the secondary caustic , in the lastmentioned case m=O , is a curve similar to and double the magnitude of the caustic itself ( viz. the caustic for parallel rays reflected at a circle ) , the position of the two curves differing by a right angle .
The secondary caustics corresponding to the different values of mn form , it is clear , a system of parallel curves ; and , by the remark just referred to , it appears .
that this system is similar to the system of curves parallel to the caustic for parallel rays reflected at a circle .

