Discussion of Tide Observations at Bristol .
By T. G. BUNT , Bristol .
Communicated by the Astronomer Royal .
Received October 24 , -Read December 6 , 1866 .
THIS paper contains the result of an attempt to discover empirically the Laws of the Diurnal Inequality of the Times and Heights , and of the Solar Inequality of the Times of High Water at the Port of Bristol .
The observations employed in this discussion are those that have been taken by the Bristol Self-registering Tide-Gauge , which has been kept steadily at work , with a few occasional interruptions , from the period of its erection in 1837 to the present time .
This instrument consists essentially of a Clock , a Cylinder , a Float , and a Pencil , by means of which every tide marks a curve on a sheet of paper , from which the time and height of high water are ascertained .
Its details are described , and an engraving of it given , both in the Philosophical Transactions for 1838 , Part II .
, p. 249 , and in the Article " ; Tides and W~aves " in the Encyclopoodia Metropolitana , written by the present Astronomer Royal .
During the far greater part of these twenty-nine years , the Tide-Gauge has been at work under my own continual inspection ; and it may be important to remark that the clock has , from the commencement , been carefully adjusted to Bristol mean time by transit observations : viz. during the first fourteen years by comparison with the Transit Clock of Messrs. MUSTON and GATH , chronometer makers in this city , besides frequent sextant altitudes of the sun taken by myself , and for the last fifteen years by a transit instrument in my own house .
Sooon after the Meeting in 1836 of the British Association in Bristol , I was employed under its auspices , in assisting the late Dr. WHEWELL in his discussions of the Bristol Tides ; the results of which appeared in a succession of papers in the Philosophical Transactions , extending from 1837 to 1840 .
The Diurnal Inequality of the Tides was that branch of the subject to which Dr. WHEWELL'S attention was specially directed .
In explanation of this term , if any such be necessary , it may be stated briefly that successive tides do not increase or decrease by a MIDCCCLXVIJ .
B regular progression , but are alternately higher and lower than such a progression would require .
The intervals also between the times of high water and the preceding lunar transit to which they are referred , are found to be alternately longer and shorter , so as to present a similar irregularity .
The Diurnal Inequality of Height in the Tides of Bristol , though of no great magnitude , averaging only 2 ' inches up and down , is at once apparent on the most cursory examination ; the inequality of time is not quite so easily detected .
It was indeed stated by Sir JOHN LUBBOCK so lately as in 1839 , in his 'Elementary Treatise on the Tides , ' p. 39 , that " the diurnal inequality in the interval is inappreciable on our coasts ; " and again , at p. 40 , " the diurnal inequality in the time of high water on our coasts is too minute to be detached from the inevitable errors of observation .
" There will , I apprehend , be little difficulty in showing that this remark of Sir JOHN LUBBOCK'S is not applicable to the port of Bristol .
For although the diurnal inequality in the times of high water is not large , its average magnitude , on comparing two successive intervals , being little more than four minutes between both , or two minutes for the single inequality in each , yet it is almost always perceptible in the Tide-Gauge Obser'vations in tolerably calm weather .
In the accompanying Plates of six months ' observations in 1865 , the diurnal inequality of both times and heights is everywhere apparent .
At Dr. WHEWELL'S request , I bestowed much time and labour from the first , in endeavouring to trace out the laws of both these inequalities , and especially that of the times , but for several years with but little success , chiefly for want of a greater number of observations .
After several modes of arrangement which Dr. WH1EW9LL suggested had been tried , he at length arrived at the conclusion that , in order to succeed , we must divide our observations , first into twenty-four groups for the twenty-four half months , and then each of these into twenty-four smaller groups for the twenty-four hours of lunar transit .
It thus became evident that little progress could be made in this investigation , until a large mass of observations had been accumulated .
These being now obtained , I have again taken the subject in hand , and embodied the results in the accompanying Plates .
For the Inequality of the Times I have taken nearly the whole of the observations .
The anterior epoch employed throughout is that of the third preceding lunar transit , averaging an interval of about forty-four hours .
The time of every high water had been already calculated ( for my annual tide table ) by adding to the time of moon 's transit the corresponding semimenstrual interval , with the corrections for lunar and solar parallax and declination .
From this computed time , the observed time of high water had been subtracted , and the residue , or error , with its proper sign , recorded ; being supposed to consist mainly of the uncorrected diurnal inequality .
The amount of the inequality was taken thus .
Let a be the error of a time of high water computed from a south transit of the moon , and 6 , 1 ' the preceding and following error , then ( a6b)+(a ' ) will be _4 times the inequality of the high water which has the error a. The quadruple inequality of every south transit observation was thus taken , and inserted in its proper group .
The ( 24 X24=)576 groups thus formed being completed were then cast up , averaged , and divided by 4 : the quotients were the terms out of which the fig 1 , Plate I. was constructed .
Fig. 2 , the diurnal inequality of height , was obtained in a precisely similar manner , except that only about fourteen years ' observations were employed in its construction .
The tide to which both these figures refer , is that which follows the south transit at an interval of about forty-four hours .
In each figure the twenty-four vertical lines represent the twenty-four hours of this south transit , apparent time .
The twenty-four horizontal lines represent the half months , and are the axes from which the curves are measured , upwards and downwards the scale being of an inch to a minute of time in fig. 1 , and --Iof an inch to an inch of height in fig. 2 .
When the curve is above the axis , it indicates in fig. 1 that the time is later , in consequence of the inequality ; and in fig. 2 that the height is greater than it would have otherwise been , and vice versed .
The distances between these horizontal lines , or axes , are arbitrary , being merely a matter of convenience .
Both these sets of curves were laid down exactly according to the averages of the groups , without any arbitrary alteration whatever .
In forming the groups , a very few enormous residues , evidently the effects of storms , or other accidental causes , were excluded .
Their number was , I believe , much less than 1 per cent. Of a still less number of residues , one half of their amount only was taken , instead of the whole .
My next attempt was to improve the solar inequality correction , or that which is due to the variations of the solar parallax and declination .
This was a more laborious affair , requiring the recalculation of the 19,000 observed times of high water , in order that the same formule , or curves of lunar correction might be employed throughout .
The residues found after these new calculations were arranged , as those for the diurnal inequality had been , for each half month , and each of the twenty-four hours of transit ; as I wanted to see whether anything would be gained by keeping the observations taken during the first half lunation separate from those taken during the second .
I have never made this separation in arrangements for finding or improving any of the lunar curves , nor ever until now in those for the solar inequality ; nor am I aware that it has ever been done by any other person .
These results are contained in Plate II .
fig. 3 .
For the purpose of more easily comparing together these two portions of the curves , I have dotted in a copy of the curves lying between the hours 1211 54m and 0O1 54m upon those of the first twelve hours of transit .
The difference in many places is considerable , and evidently systematic .
The circumstance which caused the average of each group to fall on the fifty-fourth minute of the hour , was , that the residues were not posted singly , but in pairs , the error of the ternm computed from a south transit of the moon being in every case combined with the following one .
In order to separate , at least approximately , the effects of the solar parallax and declination from each other , the following method was adopted .
The curves of June 8th and June 23rd were combined in one pair , and those of December the 8th and 23rd in another .
Their mean parallaxes and declinations , according to the Nautical Almanac for 1866 , became as follows:0) 's Decl. ( D 's H. Par. June 8 ... 22 51 8-45 June 23 .
* 23 26 8.44 Mean .
23 88 445 Dec. 8. .
22 44 8 71 Dec. 23 ... 23 27 8-72 Mean. .
23 58 715 Here we have a difference of 0 " 27 of parallax , with only 00 3 ' of declination .
From these pairs of curves are obtained the solar parallax curves in Plate II .
fig. 4 .
In like manner , by combining eight curves in two sets of four curves in each , we obtain the following means ' .
0) 's Decl. 0) 's H. Par. 0 March23. .
1 34 8.60 April 8. .
7 14 8.56 Sept. 23 3058 555 Oct. 8. .
5 54 8.59 Mean ( from squares of the declinations ) 4 40 8-576 June 8 ... 22 51 8-45 June 23 ... 23 26 8-44 Dec. 8 ... 22 44 8'71 Dec. 23. .
23 27 8-72 Mean. .
23 7 8'58 Here the mean declinations are 40 40 ' , 23 ? ?
7 ' ; while the parallaxes differ only 0"004 .
These give the solar declination curves in Plate II .
fig. 5 .
During the remarkably fine weather of the summer of 1865 , 1 found the curves drawn by the pencil of the tide-gauge on the sheet of paper wrapped round the cylinder , more symmetrical and regular , and the agreement of the registered times of high water with those predicted in my tide-table closer than I had ever known them before .
The mean error of the predicted times ( found , not algebraically , by taking the balance of those + and those - , but by adding all the magnitudes together , regardless of signs ) was from the 10th of April to the 24th of October only 2minutes ; and during about six weeks , namely , from the 17th of August to the 27th of September , it was less than 1'9 minute per tide .
The diagram No. 4 shows the whole of these six months ' times and heights of high water , both as predicted and registered ; and is interesting chiefly because it so clearly exhibits the two Diurnal Inequalities .
No one who looks at it can fail to detect , in an instant , the existence of them both ; and the one is as manifest as the other .
The agreement everywhere seen between the computed and observed Diurnal Inequalities , the laws of which it has cost me so much labour to attain , has , I confess , afforded me no small gratification .
Accompanying this diagram , I have enclosed a sheet taken from the Cylinder of the Tide-Gauge , containing the original markings of the pencil , on which an ink line has been very carefully drawn .
It registered some of the tides of the remarkably tranquil period which has been already referred to , and is sent as a specimen of the great regularity which the curves sometimes exhibit* .
POSTSCRIPT .
Received October 27 , 1866 .
Barometric Inequality .
In a letter of mine inserted in the Report of the British Association in 1841 , I stated that from a comparison of three or four years ' computed and observed Heights of High Water at Bristol , I had found that a fall of 1 inch in the mercurial column was accompanied by an average rise of about 13 2 inches of tide .
I have since obtained for fourteen additional years the following proportions of tide and mercury : Tide .
in .
1841 ... .13-01 1842 ... .
114 1843 ... .
132 1844 ... 11-4 1845 ... .
1016 1846 ... 14 7 1847 ... .
16-0 sto 1 inch of mercury .
1848. .
l 1a7 1849 ... .10 0 1850 ... .
9.5 1851 ... .
11 0 1852 ... .
117 1853. .
12-0 1854 ... .
1209 14)170-2 Mean. .
12-157 inches of tide to 1 inch of mercury .
The mean of all the twenty-one years I have thus examined , viz. 1834 to 1854 , is 12-772 inches of tide to 1 inch of mercury .
It has not been deemed n:ecessaryt to give a Plate of this Tide-Gauge Sheet , or of Diagram No. 4 .
The latter is , however , preserved in the Archives of the Society , accompan~ied by a detailed explanationi .
On comparing , inter se , the curves of the diurnal inequality of time , a very close resemblance is found between those which differ 6 months in respect of date , and 12 hours in respect of transit .
For example , the curve for April 28th , 011 , 611 , 121 , 181 , Oh , is almost identical with that of October 28th , 12h , 1811 , Oh , 61 ' , 12h .
The curves of the diurnal inequality of height present a good deal of the same resemblance.-April 1867 .
/ ara Iy -PhfAdnTram .
lv DCCtLVI TI I. -i tn -1 Iig .
l. TIME .
C^1 -r .
1 | !
1 Fe .
Sj i : 22 _ L_ -= =_ : *tW , gIWX 1 v. li ___111_ HIGH2 .
H El 0 HT .
LI4 + 23 3 tL_ 3_:3 = : X &gt; ~~_ _ __ _I ; 4l &lt; ==1 *I~ 1 / ~ --I lii7i~ =t -.17 1 { = ; Fig 3 .
Slar TIM E. 712 -54 5544.Mar .
864--_ lii= 1'-1 ji -1 --3-----t_-1 F 231e =.+:Ltz~~le , &lt; j I &gt; = rf ft4 f !
1 1|z / !1 : t !
&lt; 1~~~~~~~~~~~I I Iat I t_ I0 I I ?
' S ' zF- &lt; J I 'Ttr AaI } 4 , _ ~~~~~~~~~~ pi1 - &lt; --- &lt; -= -F 0 ---i= Oct.~ ~~ ~ , 20 Fig. B ML .
O6~~ Park7m 054Al 7v-n i,4 7K --5454I -Pig.h 1--71 ~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~3 XX if - &amp; &amp; t , J.Ba &gt; 6u5 r u

