On Supersaturated Saline Solutions .
By CHARLES TOMLINSON , P.R.S. Received April 21 , -Read May 28 , 1868* .
I. History .
THE phenomena of supersaturation have been studied chiefly with reference to solutions of GLAUBER'S salt .
In 1809 , Ziz of Mayencet showed that the sudden crystallization of these solutions is not due to agitation ; that the vessels containing them need not be hermetically sealed , but if put under a bell-glass , or loosely covered as with a capsule , they can be preserved during a long time ; that solids brought into contact with the solutions act as nuclei and produce instant crystallization , especially when dry ; if wet or boiled up with the solution they become inactive .
The best nucleus is a crystal of the salt itself .
Air , if artificially dried , ceases to be a nucleus .
Three varieties of the sodic sulphate are noticed , i. e. the anhydrous , the ordinary 10-atom hydrate , and also a modified salt formed when supersaturated solutions are left to cool down in closed vessels .
This salt contains less water of crystallization than the ordinary salt , and is more soluble .
If the vessel in which it is formed be suddenly opened , or a nucleus touch the mother-liquor , this instantly solidifies into the 10-atom hydrate , and the crystals of the more soluble salt become opaque , like the boiled white of egg .
In 1819 GAY-LUSSAC$ referred the state of supersaturation to the inertia of the saline molecules , the molecular condition of the sides of the vessel , and other causes .
He also showed that solutions of some other salts besides GLAUBER 's salt exhibit the phenomena of supersaturation .
In 1832 the number of such salts was stated by Dr. OGDEN ?
to be not less than 21 .
In 1825 FARADAY 1j published some experiments on the supersaturated solutions of GLAUBER'S salt .
GRAHAM ?
T , TURNER** , UR , and others also contributed new facts ; but the most elaborate inquiry was made by M. LMWEL between the years 1850 and 1857 , the results of which are contained in six memoirstt .
According to this writer , the modified salt is formed in consequence of a molecular change which takes place when a solution saturated at 218 ?
FAHR. cools down to 640 .
The modified salt is much more soluble at ordinary temperatures than the 10-atom hydrate , its maximum solubility being at 80§ 6 .
The sodic sulphate has three maxima of solubility , viz. 93§ 2 for the 10-atom hydrate , 78§ 8 to 80§ 6 for the 7-atom hydrate , and 62 ?
6 to 640.4 for the anhydrous salt .
At these three temperatures the saturated solutions are about equally rich in salt .
The 7-atom hydrate and the anhydrous salt can only maintain their molecular constitution when in contact with the mother-liquor in closed vessels , in which they are sheltered from the air and from other bodies that act upon them as nuclei .
No sooner are they exposed to the air than they become opaque and warm , and assume the molecular constitution of the 10-atom hydrate as well as its solubility .
Hence the conclusion is that supersaturated solutions of the sodic sulphate are not really so , since they hold a salt of much greater solubility at common temperatures than the ordinary salt .
It is also stated that the solutions of the sodic carbonate and of the magnesic sulphate form salts of a lower degree of hydration , and of greater solubility than the normal salts .
L6WEL'S general conclusion is that all cases of supersaturation are such in appearance only , and not in fact .
As to the function of nuclei and the inner sides of the flasks in determining crystallization , he regards it as the effect of one of those mysterious contact actions known as catalytic , of which science has not yet been able to give a satisfactory explanation .
Bodies that appear to be active in inducing crystallization are designated catalytic or dynamic ; while bodies that are apparently inactive are termed non-catalytic or adynamic .
" It appears certain , " he says , " that but for the mysterious action which the air and other bodies exert on supersaturated solutions , we should obtain sulphate of soda only in the modified state ; that is , crystallized with seven equivalents of water , and possessing at ordinary temperatures of the air a much greater solubility than that of the ordinary 10-atom salt .
" Later inquirers have endeavoured to explain the action of nuclei .
GERNEZ *tried 220 solids , and of these he selected thirty-nine that were active in inducing crystallization , of which eighteen were insoluble : these were carefully washed in distilled water , and dried out of contact with air .
When dry they were found to be inactive .
The twentyone soluble substances were purified by recrystallization , and they all became inactive .
Hence it is concluded that sulphate of soda is the only nucleus for solutions of the same salt .
That is to say , whenever a glass rod or other body acts as a nucleus , it is contaminated with minute portions of the salt itself , which is supposed to exist in the air , not only of towns , but in the country .
According to this view , the supersaturated solution of any other salt can only be crystallized by a saline nucleus of its own kind .
II .
Definitions .
In the present memoir the terms chemically clean or chemically unclean , or simply clean and unclean , are to be taken with the following limitations:1 .
A chemically clean surface is one that has not a greater attraction for the dissolved matter than for the liquid which dissolves it .
A supersaturated aqueous solution , for example , whether of a salt or of a gas , will adhere perfectly to such surface , and there will be no separation of salt or of gas .
2 .
But as there is little or no adhesion between water and a fatty , oily , or greasy surface , while there is strong adhesion between a salt or a gas and such surface , the presence of such a surface in a supersaturated solution will cause a separation of the salt , or of the gas .
3 .
Hence a surface contaminated ever so slightly with oily , fatty , or greasy matter will act as a nucleus in such solutions .
4 .
A nucleus may be defined as a body that has a stronger adhesion for the salt or the gas than for the liquid which holds it in solution .
65 .
Bodies that have been exposed to the products of respiration or of ordinary combustion , or that have been handled or wiped with a cloth , are covered more or less with a greasy film , and act as nuclei in aqueous solutions .
So also the dust of the room raised into the air is more or less contaminated with greasy or organic matter , and acts as a nucleus .
6 .
By washing such bodies in a solution of caustic alkali , in sulphuric acid , in ether , &amp;c. , such oily or greasy film is got rid of .
In this way the sweepings of a room may be made inactive as nuclei .
It is proposed to name bodies or surfaces that have been treated in this way catharized , from KaOapo ? .
III .
Action of Nuclei .
This action may first be illustrated by taking care to ensure the absence of nuclei .
Previous observers insist on the great sensitiveness to cold of sodic sulphate solutions ; but if precautions be taken to ensure chemical purity , this sensitiveness disappears .
For example:-Two ounces of large crystals of this salt ( which had been purified by repeated crystallization ) in a dry and slightly efflorescent state were put into a clean flask with one ounce of distilled water , and the flask was carefully heated so as to avoid the deposit of anhydrous salt , and then boiled .
Two thin glass test-tubes , each of 11 oz. capacity , and about i inch in diameter , were filled with strong sulphuric acid , emptied , and left to drain with their mouths under water .
A glass funnel washed with spirits of wine , had a clean filter adapted to it , and the boiling solution was passed through the filter into the two tubes .
These were immediately plugged with cotton-wool , and passed over the flame of a spirit-lamp , when one of the tubes gave a kick , and threw down a small quantity of anhydrous salt .
Both tubes were now placed in a vertical position in a rack , and left to cool .
At about 50 ?
F. they .
were put into a freezing-mixture in which a thermometer rapidly sank to 100 ; the tubes were moved about in the mixture , and then left in it during some hours , while the temperature slowly rose from 100 to 400 , when the solution in one tube was still liquid , bright , andtransparent ; and equally so in the other tube , only at the bottom there was a small group of 7-atom crystals , built , as it were , , on the deposit of anhydrous salt already referred to .
The cotton-wool was now taken out so as to admit a nucleus from the air , and crystallization instantly set in at the surface , spreading rapidly downwards , and carrying with it sufficient water to convert the whole solution into the 10-atom hydrate , and also to impart to the 7-atom hydrate three additional equivalents of water .
There is a considerable rise of temperature 4X:2 accompanying this action .
By cautiously fusing the salt after each experiment , these phenomena may be repeated with the same solution a number of times .
It is very possible , however , that the tube may cease to retain its condition of chemical purity perfect ; in which case the ordinary phenomena consequent on reduction of temperature will take place .
It is not easy to maintain a chemically clean surface .
A short exposure to the air , or a mere touch , will often suffice to impart a greasy film , or motes or dust , which prevent or lessen adhesion , and render a so-called " inactive " solid " active .
" When a glass rod has been kept in water or passed through flame and dried , or cooled not in contact with the air , it is more or less chemically clean , and remains so while being sheltered .
When Herr Ziz found that a knitting-needle was " active " in one solution , and that by passing it through the cork which confined another solution it became inactive , he simply made the wire chemically clean by the friction .
Some liquids , such as spirits of wine , act as nuclei by combining with a portion of the water of the solution , and liberating a little salt which acts as a nucleus .
My experiments lead me to the conclusion that air , in its pure state , is not a nucleus ; for not only may a supersaturated solution be briskly shaken up in a bottle half-full of air * , but air if previously passed through water may be made to bubble through a supersaturated solution without producing any separation of the salt .
When air appears to act as a nucleus , I believe that it is simply performing the part of a carrier of some solid particle not chemically clean .
If a boiling solution be poured into a bottle , which is then tightly corked , or the stopper inserted , the solution in cooling down will have a partial vacuum over it .
If , now , the cork be loosened , air will rush in , and almost certainly drag in with it a solid nucleus .
But if the flask be plugged with cotton-wool , motes &amp;c. will be kept back while the air streams in as the solution cools , and the plug may be removed without always producing immediate crystallization .
Thus a solution opened in a garden , on a fine clear still day , is less likely to crystallize than if opened in a room , where a step across the carpet raises a cloud of solid particles .
So also a narrow-necked bottle is less likely to catch nuclei than a wide one .
LMWEL found that he could keep his solutions from crystallizing longest in tubes of narrow bore .
Those in tubes of from -1 to A-inch bore , crystallized on being opened ; in those of less than half an inch the solutions remained longer in the liquid state , and they could be kept for weeks exposed to the air in tubes of 4-inch bore .
All this seems intelligible without recurring to any mysterious undiscovered force , such as M. L6WEL so frequently refers to .
By using chemically clean vessels and thermometers , we get rid of various anomalous cases of crystallization referred to by previous observers .
And not only so ; but we reduce most of the phenomena of supersaturation to the case of nucleus or no nucleus .
In chemically clean vessels there is no nucleus , and the modified salt , if formed at all , is the result of certain conditions which will be examined in the next section .
But it by no means follows that supersaturated solutions in cooling down undergo any change in molecular condition , or produce a modified salt of a lower degree of hydration .
Strong solutions of many salts may be cooled down below the freezing-point of water , and become viscous without crystallizing .
For example:-Five parts of sodic acetate to one part of water were boiled , filtered , and boiled again at 2400 , in a flask , with a thermometer in the solution , the neck being plugged with lamp-cotton .
The solution was left in a cold room during about twenty hours , and then placed for some hours in a freezingmixture .
The solution remained some time at 14 ?
, when the thermometer being gently lifted up several times , without being taken out of the flask , the viscous solution ran off from the bulb like a thickish syrup .
The thermometer was restored to its place , and a wire passed down so as to touch the liquid .
It immediately and rapidly crystallized into an amorphous mass , and became quite solid ; the temperature rose to 104 ?
, thus showing a sudden rise of 900 .
Now here is a solution which in an open evaporating-dish crystallizes at 150 ?
and becomes solid a few degrees below this ; yet it can be cooled down to 14 ?
or lower , and be kept in that state for hours without crystallizing .
It becomes viscid at this low temperature , and so far it undergoes a molecular change ; but this solution has no tendency , so far as I am aware , to form a salt of modified character .
It may be cooled at least 1400 below its point of crystallization and yet not crystallize , simply because there is no nucleus to start the action .
In the open evaporating-dish , on the contrary , no sooner is the boiling solution in contact with the air , than its surface becomes dotted with specks and filaments that are floating about .
If these be carefully watched , one or more of them will be seen to increase in size by the aggregation of saline particles about it , and suddenly from this point fans of crystals begin to radiate .
In the meantime the sides of the vessel are active in separating the saline molecules , and the more so in proportion to the absence of chemical purity .
The sodio-potassic tartrate also gives remarkable results .
Two ounces and a half of newly formed crystals were fused in their water of crystallization , one ounce of water was then added , and the solution raised to the boiling-point .
The solution cooled down to the temperature of the air without depositing crystals .
The flask was then kept for some hours in ice and water , and afterwards in ice and salt until the temperature of the solution was 14 ? .
The flask was repeatedly moved round and round in the freezing .
mixture , but the solution remained perfectly fluid .
The flask was now taken out , and the thermometer lifted up several times , then quite out of the flask ; the solution was also touched with a wire , but crystallization did not set in until the side of the flask had been scratched with a wire not chemically clean .
( If clean , it would have had no effect .
) The scratches instantly became chalky white , and crystallization set in very gradually ; each crystal as it was formed dragged a viscid line as it slowly descended .
There was at first but little rise of temperature , but in the course of half an hour the mercury gradually rose to 640 , thus showing a rise of 50 ? .
The sodic arseniate may be taken as another example .
Two parts of this salt to three of water were boiled at 2230 , and filtered into a clean bottle with a thermometer passing through the plug .
As the solution cooled it became viscid ; but at 35 ?
there was no sign of crystallization .
The thermometer was taken out of the flask for an instant , and then reinserted .
The effect was striking .
The thermometer had caught up some chemically unclean particles from the air , and these acted as nuclei .
The whole of the immersed portion of the thermometer became at once covered with crystalline tufts which propagated their action , and the temperature rose to 540 .
Cases like these may be multiplied ; for it must not be supposed that I am dealing with exceptional instances with respect to these motes and particles .
The air of every house is full of them ( as a sunbeam often reveals ) ; they come in contact with solutions and start crystallization , or they enter by the necks of flasks and bottles , and render their inner surfaces " active .
" The cotton-wool used in plugging the vessels is not chemically clean ; it induces crystallization if the solution touch it for an instant , as it may sometimes do on inclining or shaking the flask for the purpose of watching the effects of cooling .
We can also induce crystallization in any part of the vessel by making that part chemically unclean .
For example , a large tube was washed out with a caustic alkaline solution , rinsed first with water , then with spirit , and again with water , when a boiling solution of sodic phosphate was poured into it , and in another experiment sodic sulphate ( 5 salt to 1 water ) ; but before plugging it , the upper part of the inside of the tube was touched with a finger slightly greased .
When cold the solution was brought into contact with different parts of the tube that were clean , without producing crystallization ; but the moment the solution came upon the edge of the finger-mark , crystallization set in , and the solution became solid .
I believe this experiment will explain the statement so often made as to the necessity of keeping supersaturated solutions quite still ; for if stirred or agitated they suddenly deposit the excess of salt .
In such cases , no care having been taken to produce chemically clean surfaces , the solution itself does something in that direction to the extent that it occupies in the vessel ; but agitation brings a portion of the solution against the upper and more " active " part of the sides , or the rod used for stirring is equally " active , " and either may perform the part of a nucleus accordingly .
The salt used for making a solution is likely to be unclean .
During its formation in an open evaporating-dish , and its subsequent handling , packing , &amp;c. , it contracts various impurities , among which may often be found hairs and other greasy substances , which do not always lose their property of becoming nuclei during the boiling of the solution .
They may be removed by filtration ; but as they often contaminate the vessel in which the salt is boiled , it is desirable to filter the hot solution into a second clean flask , in which it may be boiled up again .
In the case of the acetates , a few drops of acetic acid should be added to the second flask to make up for any loss during the boiling .
But in such case the temperature may pass beyond the boiling-point without giving any signal whatever , until the liquid bursts into vapour with explosive violence , or is simply turned out of the flask without any noise at all .
Five ounces of sodic acetate were fused in its water of crystallization , boiled , and set aside to cool .
The liquid contained a number of hairs or motes .
At 150 ?
it began to crystallize , and the whole solution became filled with crystalline needles .
The salt was again raised to the boiling-point , and it boiled quickly and readily with the usual symptoms , both before and during the boiling .
The solution was now filtered into a chemically clean flask wet with acetic acid , and again placed over the lamp .
It rose to 240 ?
without any sign , and a few degrees above this it suddenly burst into vapour .
I have not repeated this experiment ; but have no doubt that , instead of crystallizing at 1500 , the clean solution might be reduced to a very low temperature without crystallizing , simply from the absence of the nuclei which were so abundant in the unfiltered solution . ?
IIt is said that the most powerful nucleus is a crystal of the salt itself This statement must be received with reference to the condition of clean and unclean .
When supersaturated solutions are lightly covered , so as to allow a portion of the water to escape , a crystalline crust often forms on the side of the flask .
This crust does not act as a nucleus , because it is clean ; and the solution , being supersaturated , does not dissolve it .
I have kept such a solution of ammonium-phosphate in contact for days together with the crystalline crust that had formed above it with little or no corroding action .
These crusts may be readily formed in the case of the magnesic sulphate solution ( 2 salt to 11 water ) in clean tubes placed in strong sulphuric acid under an exhausted receiver .
A crust will form on the surface of the cold solution in about twenty minutes , and this may be allowed to fall through the solution without acting as a nucleus .
Or a solution of the magnesic sulphate ( 4 salt to 4 water ) may be made in a flask , and filtered into a clean flask ; and while this is boiling , perfectly clean crystals ( made so by washing in sulphuric acid and rinsing in water ) , contained in a clean , short tube , are to be suspended by a clean wire in the neck of the flask while steam is pouring off from it .
The cotton-wool plug may now be inserted , the lamp removed , and the flask left to cool during twelve hours or so .
The tube may then .
be lowered into the solution , and the crystals will not act as nuclei in inducing crystallization .
In a similar experiment with sodic sulphate the salt in the short tube became , of course , converted into the anhydrous salt ; but it was quite inactive as a nucleus on the cold solution .
Exposed to the air for a few moments it acted powerfully as a nucleus .
] Such cases as the above lead me to the conclusion that the state of supersaturation is simply a case of no nucleus .
There is nothing to start the action which produces change of state , and there is no reason why the state should change , unless indeed , as may sometimes happen , mere reduction of temperature is the efficient agent in inducing crystallization by bringing the particles so close together that cohesion can prevail over adhesion .
But in such cases it more often happens that the solution completely solidi* Those paragraphs within [ j formed the subject of a Note sent in to the Royal Society , August 13,1868 .
fies into the normal salt than partially into a salt of a modified character .
The formation of the modified salt , which has given rise to much speculation , will next be considered .
IV .
On the Formation of the modified Salt .
Two ounces of zincic sulphate and one ounce of water were heated in a clean flask until the solution boiled briskly .
The solution was then filtered into chemically clean test-tubes , made so by washing them out with strong sulphuric acid .
The tubes were plugged with cotton-wool and set aside to cool ; they were bright and transparent ; but on cooling to about 70 ?
they became troubled by the formation of a monohydrated salt , which gradually subsided and formed a small deposit at the bottom of the tubes .
Upon this deposit , after some hours , a fine crop of acicular crystals had sprung up , leaving the mother-liquor clear , but still supersaturated ; for on taking out the cotton-wool from one tube , crystallization set in from the surface .
On gradually raising the other tube to the temperature of 1000 , or from that to 106 ?
, the acicular crystals melted down and formed a dense lower stratum .
This experiment throws much light on the behaviour of those supersaturated saline solutions that form salts of a modified character , and of greater solubility than the normal salt .
When the richly hydrated salts , which best display the phenomena of supersaturation , enter into solution at high temperatures , they give up all , or nearly all , their water of crystallization to the aqueous solvent .
In the case of the sodic sulphate , for example , I quite agree with the accepted theory , that from the boiling-point of an aqueous solution down to about 600 it is the anhydrous salt that is held in solution ; but I differ from that theory which supposes a molecular change to take place in the supersaturated solution at and below 600 , and the molecules to arrange themselves into the constitution of the 7-atom hydrate .
There is no experimental proof that such is the case .
We can get the 7-atom hydrate , it is true , when a strong solution is cooled down below 600 ; but this is no proof that the solution passed through the molecular change which has been insisted on .
I have already given a case in which a strong solution of the sodic sulphate , contained in a tube made chemically clean with special precautions , was cooled down to 10 ?
F. without any separation of the salt , in consequence of the absence of a nucleus , and the strong adhesion of the solution as a whole to the sides of the tube .
If a strong solution of sodic sulphate be filtered into a tube washed without any special precautions to make it chemically clean , and the mouth be closed with cotton-wool , such a solution may be cooled down to 500 or less without depositing any salt .
If we now place this tube in ice-cold water , and watch it carefully , a small number of octahedral crystals ( the form of the anhydrous salt ) will separate from the solution and subside , liberating heat-currents as they fall and when resting at the bottom .
This experiment has been performed with'supersaturated solutions of sodic sulphate of varying strengths and with the same result , unless crystallization set in from the surface by the dragging in of a nucleus consequent on the cooling , or on the separation of a fragment of cotton-wool , and then the whole solution immediately became solidified into the 10-atom salt .
The deposit of a few anhydrous crystals , as stated above , is , I think , a sufficient proof that the solution undergoes no molecular change at 600 or under , but continues to be a solution of the anhydrous salt until , by a proper reduction of temperature , it deposits the excess that it can no longer hold .
That which takes place in the case of the zincic sulphate solution applies equally here .
The anhydrous sodic sulphate thus thrown down at 32 ?
liberates heat , and the crystals partially enter again into solution .
Or should the atmospheric temperature rise a few degrees , the operation is further assisted ; the anhydrous crystals become wholly or partially dissolved , and a dense lower stratum is thus formed , containing not water enough for the formation of the 10-atom hydrate , but only sufficient for the 7-atom ; and thus we have a comparatively small group of crystals of the 7-atom hydrate formed at the bottom of the solution .
In this way , as it appears to me , the formation of the 7-atom hydrate may be accounted for and rendered intelligible without having recourse to the doctrine of molecularity of which we really know so little .
The mother-liquor resting on this 7-atom hydrate is still a supersaturated solution ; so that if the flask be opened crystallization proceeds rapidly from the surface-downwards , and carries down sufficient water to form the 10-atom salt throughout , and also to convert the 7-atom hydrate into the 10-atom ; and in appropriating the three additional equivalents of water , the 7-atom hydrate becomes of an opaque white , from the breaking up of the mass into a multitude of minute 10-atom crystals .
It is important to bear in mind the difference of locality in the formation of the two hydrates ; the 7-atom hydrate originates at the bottom of the solution under circumstances which do not allow of sufficient water being present to form a salt of a higher degree of hydration than the 7-atom ; whereas the 10-atom salt originates at the surface , and carries down in close well-packed crystalline lines sufficient water to form the 10-atom salt .
These lines form so quickly , and are packed so closely together , that there is neither time nor space for the formation of the usual crystal ; they pass to the very bottom of the vessel , and seem to penetrate while they render opaque the transparent crystals formed there .
M. LMWEL states that supersaturated solutions of the sodic carbonate form two modified hydrates , viz. the 7HO a and the 7HO b , which , he says , not only differ in solubility from each other , but also from that of the 10-atom salt .
He admits that the sodic carbonate differs in behaviour from the sodic sulphate , since the carbonate does not deposit crystals from the supersaturated solution merely by a reduction of temperature ; " but such solutions remain saturated until , in consequence of lapse of time , and above all of low temperature , the inner surfaces of the flask have recovered their peculiar catalytic properties of determining crystallization which heat had deprived them of the cause of which remains unknown .
" In chemically clean vessels I have not been able to reproduce M. LOiwEL 's results .
I have tried numerous experiments with solutions containing and 2 parts salt to 1 of water : the solutions have been left to themselves , or they have been placed in freezing-mixtures at various temperatures ; but the general result is a sudden crystallization from some point near the surface of the solution , rapidly converting the whole into a solid , with a rise of temperature of 350 or 40 ? .
M. L6WEL also points out three varieties of the magnesic sulphate , the ordinary 7-atom salt , which he names 7110 a , a modified salt , 704 b , and also a 6110 salt .
In the case of this salt also I have placed highly charged supersaturated solutions ( 2 salt to 1 water ) , contained in chemically clean tubes , in freezing-mixtures without any effect in producing crystallization .
In one experiment a solution made with two ounces of salt and one of water was boiled and filtered into five tubes , four of which were chemically clean , while the fifth had been used for a solution of this salt and left lying on the table for two or three days .
All five tubes on being filled were plugged with cottonwool , and set aside to cool .
When cold the four clean tubes were put into a freezingmixture at 100 , and when this had slowly risen to between 30 ' and 400 , another freezingmixture was prepared , to which the tubes were transferred ; but still after another half hour the solutions remained perfectly bright and transparent .
One tube was removed from the mixture and opened , when on touching the surface with a metal point , crystalline tufts , like thistle down , were propagated downwards , and soon the whole solution had solidified into the usual 7-atom salt .
The fifth tube , which was not chemically clean , did not retain its solution in the liquid state : on examining it some hours after it had been filled , the contents had solidified into the ordinary salt .
The other three tubes , on being removed from the freezing-mixture , showed no disposition to crystallize .
The magnesic sulphate parts readily with an atom of water and becomes milky white .
A group of these milky crystals is sometimes deposited at the bottom of a long tube containing a strong and still warm solution of the salt , and partly immersed in cold water .
A certain difference in density between the lower and upper portions of supersaturated solutions is favourable to this result .
Indeed there is a tendency to stratification during the cooling of all these solutions , as may be seen on gently shaking the flask , when the effect is that of the mingling of layers of different densities , as when water is resting on syrup .
I long thought that when a salt of a lower degree of hydration is produced , it was due to the formation of denser and more highly charged saline substrata .
GAY-LussAc 's experiment* teaches that saturated solutions contained in long tubes , and maintained at the same temperature during many months , are of the same density at every part of the column !
; and it seems probable that such is also the case with supersaturated solutions when cold and left undisturbed some time ; but there are various difficulties in the way of determining this point experimentally .
When the denser lower stratum is formed at all , it is , I believe , by the process already explained in the case of zincic sulphate and sodic sulphate .
A salt of a lower degree of hydration , or an anhydrous salt , is thrown down on a reduction of temperature of the supersaturated solution , and the heat given out during a change of state , assisted by a rise of atmospheric temperature , enables the salt to go into solution , and thus a dense lower layer is formed from which the modified salt is produced .
The ammonium phosphate is another example of this action .
A solution saturated at 212 ?
was filtered into a clean flask wetted with liquor ammoniav , and left some weeks as a supersaturated solution .
It was then placed in a freezing-mixture , when it threw down a white powder , probably the anhydrous salt : the flask was now set aside , when after a few days the powder had partially disappeared , and a crop of transparent crystals had formed .
But this result is not so readily produced if special means be taken to secure clean vessels .
Five tubes were filled with sulphuric acid , rinsed with water , filled up with liquor ammoniae , emptied , and a boiling saturated solution of the ammoniumn phosphate filtered into them .
When cold , these tubes were put into a freezing-mixture composed of sodic sulphate and hydrochloric acid , and after half an hour transferred to a similar mixture , without producing any immediate effect .
On examining the tubes next day a small quantity of white powder was found at the bottom of three of the tubes , with transparent crystals in the form of flat quadrangular prisms .
Strontic nitrate would appear to be favourable to the exhibition of this class of phenomena since a strong solution on cooling down to about 62 ' deposits anhydrous octahedral crystals .
But these are bright , hard , and transparent , and apparently not affected when the tube is put into water at 212 ?
, or into a freezing-mixture at 10 ?
, or when the crystals are touched with a wire .
On removing the cotton-wool and scratching the side of the tube , the scratches became immediately filled up with minute crystals , and a copious shower of the hydrated salt took place with the liberation of heat-currents .
After a time these formed a considerable mass , and on putting the tube into water at 700 the salt melted down , but more rapidly at 900 ; at 200 ?
the remaining part of the mass fell down into an opaque white powder , from which the original octahedra emerged as sharp and transparent as when first formed .
Many salts behave like the sodic carbonate in maintaining a state of supersaturation down to a certain temperature , and then suddenly becoming solid throughout .
The rhombic sodic phosphate does this , as also the plumbic acetate .
A boiling solution of plumbic acetate ( 21 salt to 1 water ) was left to cool slowly down to about 40 ?
( the temperature of the room ) , when it suddenly crystallized with a considerable rise in temperature .
The whole formed a solid mass , not amorphous , but consisting of needles of the normal salt , as is nearly always the case when crystallization commences at the surface .
On gently warming the mass , these needles fell apart , and revealed the fibrous structure .
This is a common case in salts that have considerable solubility .
A boiling saturated solution of zincic acetate , on the contrary , not only cooled down to 400 without crystallizing , but continued liquid during some hours in a mixture of snow and water at 320 .
On removing the thermometer crystallization did not set in until the inner side of the flask at the level of the solution had been scratched , when the marks became chalky white as usual , crystallization of the normal salt set in , and small well-shaped crystals continued to fall during some hours with but slight rise in temperature .
The excess of salt beyond the point of saturation was 4yT2 deposited , and the mother-liquor was simply a solution saturated at the existing temperature .
The cupric sulphate , citric acid , and other salts are examples of this action .
In some cases supersaturated solutions , if not highly concentrated , may be frozen and thawed again , without any separation of the salt ; whereas if such solutions are much stronger , they cannot be frozen at temperatures varying from 10 ' to zero .
The cupric sulphate is a good example of this .
According to POGGIALE , 100 parts water at 860 dissolve 48-81 parts of the salt ; this is equivalent to 234k grains of salt to one ounce of water .
A solution of this kind was put into a freezing-mixture and sank slowly to about 160 , when it froze , and the thermometer rose to about 250 .
The solidified solution now appeared almost white , but on leaving the flask exposed to an atmosphere of 52 ?
during some hours , the solution thawed , and recovered its former brightness .
A much stronger solution was now made ( 468 grains salt to 1ounce water ) and filtered into a tube that had been washed out with sulphuric acid ; this was repeatedly kept in a freezing-mixture at 100 without any deposit of salt .
V. Anhydrous Salts .
The salts hitherto treated of in this memoir as presenting the phenomena of supersaturation are hydrated , and in general the phenomena are best exhibited in those salts which are richest in water of crystallization .
Whether anhydrous salts display these phenomena in their solutions is a point by no means settled ; for while some observers maintain that the solutions of a few anhydrous salts do become supersaturated , others deny that such is the case .
En perfectly clean flasks , and with clean solutions , I have never been able to detect a case of supersaturation in an anhydrous salt .
A few examples may be given .
Two ounces of nitre crystals were added to two ounces of water in a clean flask , say 100 parts of nitre in 100 of water , and the solution was raised to the boiling-point , filtered into a chemically clean flask , made so by washing it out with strong nitric acid .
In this flask the solution was boiled again ; the neck was then plugged with cotton-wool with a thermometer passing through the plug .
When the temperature of the solution had fallen to about 120 ?
, crystals began to grow up from the bottom of the flask .
These crystals were built up of short prisms , diminishing in width and becoming smaller as they rose into the hotter and weaker part of the solution above .
Now , according to GAY-LussAc 's Table , 100 parts of water at 1310 F. contain 97 05 of nitre .
My solutioncontained 100 parts .
Supposing that , owing to the absence of a nucleus , the solution were supersaturated between the temperatures 131 ?
and 1180 , , it could not remain so in consequence of the cohesive force of the saline particles prevailing over the adhesive force of the solvent ; it begins to deposit crystals , and then the action goes on rapidly ; the temperature rises a few degrees , then declines , ' and when cooled down to the temperature of the air , say 500 , the solution holds about 22 per cent. of the salt .
But is there any reason for supposing the solution to be supersaturated 1 When crystallization begins , it is at the coldest part of the flask that the action commences .
IPf .
CHARLES TOMLINSON ON SUPERSATURATED SALINE SOLUTIONS .
671 The coldest part is the bottom , and the coldest part of the bottom is that nearest the window .
If the flask be suspended in the air crystallization will first begin on the window side .
If the flask be placed on metal or other good conductor of heat , a ring of crystals will be formed at the bottom , while the thermometer is 60 or 80'above the point at which crystallization ought to take place ; the bottom of the flask and the ring of solution in contact with it are prematurely chilled , while the rest of the solution is above the point of crystallization .
If the flask be left on a thick block of wood or other bad heat-conductor , the crystals at the bottom will be formed later .
A solution containing 125 parts of nitre in 100 of water ought , according to the Table , to begin to deposit salt at 1t00 .
The flask containing such a solution at boiling heat was placed on a block of wood ; at about 1490 heat-currents suddenly rose like a cloud from the bottom of the solution to ' the surface , and crystallization instantly set in .
If , before crystallization begins , the flask be plunged into cold water , the sides become coated with a shell of crystals , while the rest of the solution is still hot .
It might reasonably be expected , from its great solubility , that nitre would form supersaturated solutions ; but it behaves as , I believe , anhydrous salts in general behave ; its solution cools down until it is exactly saturated , and then it begins to deposit crystals of the normal salt without any modification whatever .
The potassic bichromate is cited , on the authority of OGDEN and others , as an example of an anhydrous salt that produces supersaturated solutions .
My experiments do not confirm this view .
According to KREMER'S Table , 200 parts water at 140 ?
F. dissolve 100 parts of the salt .
Such a solution in cooling down from 212 ' ought to deposit salt at about 140 ' , unless it becomes supersaturated .
One ounce of newly crystallized dry salt was boiled in two ounces of water , filtered into a clean flask and again boiled , and the flask was closed .
At 138 ?
an abundance of crystalline flakes was thrown down , heatcurrents ascended , and the temperature continued stationary for a minute or so .
The crystals formed a lining over about two-thirds of that part of the flask that was occupied by the solution , but the deposit was most abundant on the side nearest the window* .
Sal-ammoniac.-According to KARSTEN , 100 parts water at 650.75 dissolve 37-02 of the salt , or , what is the same thing , one ounce water ( 480 grains ) dissolves 177-6 grains of the salt .
Such a solution in cooling from 2120 began to deposit salt at about 66 ?
, and just below this the salt separated abundantly .
Sodic nitrate was also tried .
According to POGGIALE'S Table , 100 parts of water at 1580 will dissolve 129-6 of the salt , or 12 9,6 of 48 ?
-622 grains .
In such a solution raised to the boiling-point and allowed to cool down , the salt began to separate at 160 ? .
Potassic chlorate , potassic ferrocyanide , baric nitrate , and plumbic nitrate gave similar results .
Ammonium-nitrate solution gave apparently some signs of supersaturation ; but the observation is liable to error from the fact that at high temperatures ammonia is given off .
According to KARSTEN , 100 parts of water at 640-5 F. dissolve 199-54 &amp; parts of the salt .
A hot solution ( 2 salt to 1 water ) was filtered into a clean flask moistened with a few drops of liq .
ammon .
Such a solution remained during an hour or so at 400 when it suddenly crystallized .
I may , however , remark that a number of authorities differ in their determination of the solubility of this salt .
But if the observation be correct , the behaviour of this anhydrous salt resembles that of some salts that crystallize with only a small proportion of water of crystallization .
Baric chloride ( Ba Cl +2 Aq ) is a case in point .
According to BRANDE'S Table , 100 parts water at 990.5 F. dissolve 51 parts of the salt .
This is equal to 244 grains of salt to one ounce of water .
A solution of this kind cooled from the boiling-point to 1000 without depositing salt , and it was not until the temperature had fallen to about 66 ?
that the salt separated , and then it did so abundantly .
VI .
Summary .
My experiments lead me to the conclusions , first , that the state of supersaturation in saline solutions is a real and not an apparent one , and is due in the majority of cases , where the solutions are kept in chemically clean flasks , to the absence of nuclei or other predisposing cause to crystallization ; 2nd , that in the few cases where salts of a lower degree of hydration are formed in such solutions , the effect is not due to a predisposing molecular change in the solution , but to the deposit of a portion of the anhydrous salt , or of a monohydrated salt , which , entering again into solution , forms a dense lower substratum from which the modified salt crystallizes out ; 3rd , that anhydrous salts do not form supersaturated solutions .
The salts examined in this memoir may be arranged into five groups according to their behaviour : I. Salts of which the supersaturated solutions remain liquid at low temperatures .
Examples:-Sodic acetate .
Sodic sulphate .
Sodic arseniate .
Sodic succinate .
Sodic borate .
Sodio-potassic tartrate .
Potash alum .
Magnesic sulphate .
Baric acetate .
Calcic chloride .
C~upric sulphate .
Salts of which the supersaturated solutions suddenly solidify at low temperatures .
Examples:-Sodic carbonate .
Sodic phosphate .
Plumbic acetate .
Sodic hyposulphite .
Strontic chloride .
III .
Salts of which the supersaturated solutions deposit their excess of salt at low temperatures , or under the action of a nucleus , leaving the mother-liquor saturated .
Examples:-Zincic acetate .
Cupric sulphate .
Baric chloride .
Potassic arseniate .
Antimonio-potassic tartrate .
Citric acid .
IV .
Salts of which the supersaturated solutions form modified salts of a lower degree of hydration .
Examples:-Sodic sulphate .
Zincic sulphate .
Magnesic sulphate .
Ammonium phosphate .
It will be seen that the sodic sulphate and the magnesic sulphate also occupy a place in Class I. V. Anhydrous salts that do not form supersaturated solutions : Potassic nitrate .
Potassic bichromate .
Sal-ammoniac .
Sodic nitrate .
Potassic chlorate .
Potassic ferrocyanide .
Barie nitrate .
Plumbic nitrate .
Ammonium nitrate .

