On the Conditions fJr the existence of Three Egjual Boots , or of Two Pairs of Equal Boots , of a Binary Quartic or Quintic .
By A. CAYLEY , F.B. &amp; 8 Received November 26 , 1867 , -Read January 9 , 1868 .
IN considering the conditions for the existence of given systems of equalities between the roots of an equation , we obtain some very interesting examples of the composition of relations .
A relation is either onefold , expressed by a single equation U0 , or it is , say k-fold , expressed by a system of k or more equations .
Of course , as regards onefold relations , the theory of the composition is well known : the relation UV= 0 is a relation compounded of the relations UO , V=-0 ; that is , it is a relation satisfied if , and not satisfied unless one or the other of the two component relations is satisfied .
The like notion of composition applies to relations in general ; viz. , the compound relation is a relation satisfied if , and not satisfied unless one or the other of the two component relations is satisfied .
I purposely refrain at present from any further discussion of the theory of composition .
I say that the conditions for the existence of given systems of equalities between the roots of an equation furnish instances of such composition ; in fact , if we express that the function ( *(x , y)T , and its first-derived function in regard to x , or , what is the same thing , that the first-derived functions in regard to x , y respectively , have a common quadric factor , we obtain between the coefficients a certain twofold relation , which implies either that the equation ( *Xx , y)"=0 has three equal roots , or else that it has two pairs of equal roots ; that is , the relation in question is satisfied if , and it is not satisfied unless there is satisfied either the relation for the existence of three equal roots , or else the relation for the existence of two pairs of equal roots ; or the relation for the existence of the quadric factor is compounded of the last-mentioned two relations .
The relation for the quadric factor , for any value whatever of n , is at once seen to be expressible by means of an oblong matrix , giving rise to a series of determinants which are each to be put =0 ; the relation for three equal roots and that for two pairs of equal roots , in the particular cases n= 4 and n= 5 , are given in my " Memoir on the Conditions for the existence of given Systems of Equalities between the roots of an Equation , " Phil. Trans. vol. cxlvii .
( 1857 ) , pp. 727-731 ; and I propose in the present Memoir to exhibit , for the cases in question n= 4 and n= 5 , the connexion between the compound relation for the quadric factor with the component relations for the three equal roots and for the two pairs of equal roots respectively .
Article Nos. 1 to 8 , the Quartic .
1 .
For the quartic function ( a , , c , -d , e3X , y)4 tXISTENCE the condition for three equal roots , or , say , for a root system 31 , is that the quadrinvariant and the cubinvariant each of them vanish , viz. we must have I=ae-4bd+ 3c 0 , J=ace-ad'-b2e+2bcd-C3'=0 .
2 .
The condition for two pairs of equal roots or for a root system 22 , is that the cubicovariant vanishes identically , viz. representing this by ( A , B , 5C , IGD , 5E , F , Gyx , y)6=0 , we must have A= a2d-3abc+24 ' =0 B= a2e +2abd-9ac2+6b2c=0O C= ate-3acd+2b 'd =0 , D=-ads + b2e -0 , E=ade+3bce-2bd2 =0 , F=-ae2 -2bde+9cWe-6cd'=0 , G=-be ' 4 3cde 2d3 =0 .
3 .
But the condition for the common quadric factor is a , 3b , 3C , d =0 , b , 3e , 3d , e a , 3b , 3c , d b , 3c , 3d , e and the determinants formed out of this matrix must therefore vanish for ( I , J ) 0 , and also for ( A , B , C , D , E , F , G ) =0 , that is , the determinants in question must be syzygetically related to the functions ( I , J ) , and also to the functions ( A , B , C , D , E , F , G ) .
4 .
The values of the determinants are1234=3x 1235=3x 1245= 1345=3X 2345-3X +1 alce -1 a'de -1 a2e2 -1 abe +1 ace2 3 a 'd ' +4 abee +2 abde +4 acde -1 ade 1 ab'e +1 abd ' +9 acle -3 ad3 3 b'e ' +14 abed -3 acVd -9 aed 2 +1 b2de +14 bed 9 aC -3 bMe -9 b'ce -3 bee -8 bd3 8 bd +2 bcd +8 'd +2 bed2 9 ce +6 bH+ 6 c2ded 5 .
The syzygetic relation with ( I , J ) is given by means of the identical equation y4 -4xy , 6x2 , -4 xy 4 =-6L .
HUE +9J.U , a , 3b , 3c , d b4 3c 3d e a , 3b , 3c d bf 3c , 3d , e or , as this may be written , ( 1234 , 1235 , 1245 , 1345 , 2345)1x , y)4 -61 .
HUE + 9J .
U where HUE is the Hessian of U , .
ac 2ad ae 2 be ce -( b2 -2 be +2 bd -2 ed -d2 y)4 .
-3 c2 6 .
That is , we have 1234=( acb2 , a ; 6I , 9J ) , 4 .
1235=(2ad-2bc , 4b -6I , 9J ) , 6 .
1245=( ae+2bd-3c2 , 6c7(-6I , 9J ) , 4 .
1345=(2be -2cd , 4d)-6I , 9J ) , 2345=( ce d2 , e -6I , 9J ) .
7 .
The determinants thus vanish if ( I , J)=O , that is , for the root system 31 ; they will also vanish without this being so , if only ( 3J ac-b2 ad-bc ae+2bd-3c2 be-cd ce-d2 .
t2I J a2b 6c 2d c and we may omit the first member ( 3= ) , since if the remaining terms are equal to each other they will also be = The equations may then be written 8 ac _b2 , ad-bc , ae+2bd-3c2 , be-cd , ce-d2 1= ?
a , 2b 6c , 2d , e and the ten equations of this system reduce themselves ( as it is very easy to show ) to the seven equations ( A , B , C , D , E , F , G)=O , which , as above mentioned , are the conditions for the root system 22 .
8 .
It may be added that we have ABCDEFG *.1234= c -4b +3a.1235= c -3b +a 0= d -3c +a 1245= -e +4d -3c 0= -.e +6c -a 0=d+ 3c b3 1345-e +3d c0=e+ 3c b X. 2345= -3e +4d -c where it is to be , noticed that the four equations having the left-hand side =0 , give proportional to the determinants of the matrix d , -3c , , a -e , .
, 6G .
, -a -d , 3c , -b , -e , .
, +3c , -b the determinants in question contain each the factor c , and omitting this factor , the system shows that B , C , D , E , F are proportional to their before-mentioned actual values .
Article Nos. 9 to 15 , the Quintic .
9 .
For the quintic function ( a ?
be c , d , e , fad( , y ) ' , the condition of a root system 41 is that the covariant , Table No. 14 , shall vanish , viz. we must have A=2(ae-4bd+ 3c2 ) =05 B= af-3be+2cd==0 , C=2(bf-4ce+3d2)=O .
10 .
The condition of a root system 32 is that the following covarianf , viz. 3 ( No. 13)2(No .
14)-25(No .
15)2 , shall vanish , where No. 13 ( a , b , c , d , e , f a , y)5 the quintic itself .
No. 14( -41 -36e b4eKz No. 4_ ] _4 ad |-3 bef -4 ce| ?
3 c2 +2 cd +3 d2 No. 15 ( ac3 ad 3ae af 36/ f 3 cf df 1X -6 -3 be +3 bd +7 be +3ce -3d | -ede -6 C2 c-8d -G6 d2 11 .
The developed expression of the foregoing function is as follows.(+ 3 as +3 af + 33 a2bf + 10 a2cf90 a2df 114 a2ef 19 a2f2 114 af2 90 acf +0 adf2 + 33 aef2 +3a +3f3 y2 12 a2bd + 21 a2be 102 a2ce 390 a2de 195 a2e2 264 abdf 608 abef 264 acef + 360 adef + 155 ae2f 102 bdf2 + 21 bef2 -12 cef 16 a2c2 -144 a2cd 216 a2d`2 + 155 ab2f + 360 abc| 990 abe2 + 537 acdf + 468 ad2f + 225 ae3 | 390 bCf 2 +135 beef 144 cdjf2 -16 c2f + 50 ab2c + 30 ab2d +135 ab2e + 100 abce -1500 abde + 468 ac2f 245 ace2 + 900 adle2 _ 195 bf2 + 100 bdef -216 cf2 2+ 30 ce2f +50 de2f -25 b4 +240 abc2 +120 abed 600 abd + 900 ac2e +1320 acde + 1740 ad2e 990 b2ef 1500 beef + 125 be3 +120 cdef +240 d2ef -25 e4 -150 b3c +480 ac3 +1600 ac2d +1800 acd2 +1080 ad3 245 b2df +1320 bedf + 900 bdcf 600 c2ef -150 ce3 150 de3 -150 b3d + 125 b3e + 225 b3f + 900 b2cf -1700 b2e2 -2700 bce2 +1800 c-df +1600 cdf +480 df| 300 b2X2 _-1000 b2cd -1500 b2d2 -2700 b2de +1740 bc2f + 900 bd2e -|1500 c2e2 -1000 cde2 -300 d2e + 900 bc2 e -2000 bed +1080 c~f 600 bcd2 + 600 bda 600 c2cde + 600 c~e _______________________ -~~~~ ~~400 c2d ' The conditions for the common quadric factor are a , 4b , 6c , 4d , e =09 a , 46 , 6c , 4d , e 6 , 4c , 6d , 4e , ,f b , 4c , Gd , 4e , f the several determinants whereof are given in Table No. 27 of my " Third Memoir on Quantics , " Philosophical Transactions , vol. cxlvi .
( 1856 ) , pp. 627-647 .
13 .
These determinants must therefore vanish , for ( A , B , C ) -0 and also for ( X , 3,3 ... .
X , At)=0 , that is , they must be syzygetically connected with ( A , B , C ) , and also with ( [ , 36 , ... .L , R1 ) .
The relation to ( A , B , C ) is in fact given in the Table appended to Table No. 27 , viz. this is Cx ?
Bx +Ax 1234= +6 a2 12 ab +16 ac-10 be 1235= +6 ab 2 ac-10 b2 +6 ad 1236= 2 ac + 8b2 +6 ad-18 be 2 df +8 e2 1245= +18 ac 6 ad-30 bc +8 ace10 bd 1246= +12 be +4 sle4 bd-24 c2 +4 be+ 8 ed 1345= +24 ad 8 ae-40 bd +4 of+20 be 1256= 1 aed+ 4bd+ 3 ce +1 af+ 5 be-18 ed 1 bf+ 4 ce+ 3 &amp; 2345= +20 ae+4Obd30 c -80 be+20 ed +201 b+40 ce-30 d &amp; 1346+ 4 ae+ 8bd+ 6 C2 -36 ed +4 f1+ 8 cen+ 6d2 2346= +4 af+20be 8 bf4 ce +24 ef 1356= +4 be + 8-cd +4 bf4 ce -24 d ' +12 de 2356= +8 bf +lOce 6 cf-30 de +18 of 1456= +6 ce +6 cf-18 de 2 df+ 8 e2 2456= +6 cf -2 df-lO e+6 ej 3456= +16 df-lOe2 -12 ef +6f 14 .
Between the expressions 2 , 35 , &amp;c. , and 1234 , 1235 , &amp;c. , there exist relations the form of which is indicated by the following Table : Q~~~~~~~ Rf Gm nmc6aadcb ab &lt; edcbacaaye ed cbatdcb hba aa6fedcbaedCccbaaa I~~~~~~~~~~~~ fedeba flee C ddbcb ba aaa f||edcbaefd de ebaaa|dc6afeeddc6fed fe eff of cbffeed ffe viz. these relations are of the form H ( )e+( )0'j3+()aC5 + )a.1234 -0 , ( ( )d3 +( )bC +( )a]3 +( )b.1234+( )a.1235=0 , &amp; C. where the brackets ( ) denote numerical coefficients , determinate as to their ratios .
Assuming the existence of these relations , we have for the determination of the numerical coefficients in each relation a set of linear equations , which are shown by the following Tables , viz. referring to the Table headed cG , 6Z , at , a.1234 , if the multipliers of terms respectively be A , B , C , X , then the Table denotes the system of linear equations oA+ 3B + 33C + OX=0 , 3A +0 B -102C -16X-0 &amp;c. , that is , nine equations to be satisfied by the ratios of the coefficients A , B , C , X , and which are in fact satisfied by the values at the foot of the Table , viz. A : B : C : X=66 : -11 : +1 : +6 .
There would be in all fourteen Tables , but as those for the second seven would be at once deducible by symmetry from the first seven , I have only written down the seven Tables ; the solutions for the first and second Tables were obtained without difficulty , but that for the third Table was so laborious to calculate , and contains such extraordinarily high numbers , that I did not proceed with the calculation , and it is accordingly only the first , second , and third Tables which have at the foot of them respectively the solutions of the linear equations .
16 .
The results given by these three Tables are , of course , 66ca110b]+ 1aC+p6a.1234-0O 330dZ+110c3-55bC+9aM-105 a.1235=0 , +266478575 e2 -617359490 dB3 +144200810 cl + 9656911 bD + 9090785 at -721004050 c.1234 + 90914175 b.1235 -160758675 a.1245 + 11559295 a. 1236=0 .
It is to be noticed that the nine coefficients of this last equation were obtained from , and that they actually satisfy , a system of fourteen linear equations ; so that the correctness of the result is hereby verified .
17 .
The seven Tables are First Table .
cA bJ3 a0 a. 1234 3bf +3+ 33 a3ce +3 -102 16 a3d2 -216 + 36 2be2 + 21 +135 + ]6 a2bcd -12 -144 +120 -152 a2C3 -i6 +480 + 96 ab3d + 30 -150 + 80 ab2c + ?
50 +240 -300 60 64C -25 -150 +66 -11 +1 +6 Second Table .
dft C36 b C , aD a. 1235 b. 1234 19"V +3+ 10 4 a3de +3 390 +24 a2b2f + 33 + 155 +4 a2bee + 21 -102 + 100 84 16 a2bd 2 -12 -216 600 -24 .
+ 36 a2c 'd -16 -144 +1600 +64 + 16 -ab3e +135 + 125 + 60 ab'cd +50 + 30 +120 -1000 -40 -1152 abc3 +240 +480 + 96 64d -25 -150 + 80 b 3C2 -150 300 60 +330 +]10 -55 +9 -105 0 Third Table .
es | d33 cc 6| ae c.1234 b. 1235 a. 1245 a. 1236 a~df ? ?
3 90 6 ?
6 a3e2 +3 195 +16 a2Bef + 33 + 10 + 360 -4 ?
6 22 a2bde -12 + 21 390 -1500 +24 26 6 a2c2e -16 -102 + ?
oo 16 -96 ?
16 a 2cd2 -144 -216 +1800 + 36 +96 abW |lll+ 155 + 225 +4 +16 abce +50 +135 + 100 + i6 -84 +90 -10 ab2d2 + 30 600 -1500 -24-80 abc d ?
240 ?
I 0 ?
+1600 -152 64 aC4 ?
480 ? ?
96 64e -25 + 125 +60 b3cd -150 -150 -1000 + 80 -40 b3c3 300 60 ?
266478575 -617359490 + 144200810 +9656911 +9090785 721004050 ? ?
90914175 -160758675 +11559295 Or586 PROFESSOR CAYIJEY ON THE CONDITION S FOR THE EXISTE~NCE Fourth Table .
fA e3$ dCA cb agJ d.1234 c.1235 b.1236b.1245a.1246a.1345 a3ef +3+3 -114 ?
4 a'baf -12 + 33 90 264 +664 24 a be2 + 21 -195 990 ?
16 4+ 64 aoe~f -16 + 10 + 468 4 -24 ? ?
24 a2cde -144 -10 390 +1320 16 +24 +24M -208 a2d3 -2916 ?
1080 +.36 +144 ab-cf ?
50 ? ?
155 + 360 ? ?
900 +4 -2.2 +6 +24 ab 2de + 30 + 135 -1500 -2700 + 166 -26 -20 -40 ab O +240 + 100 + 900 ? ?
900 -84 +16 -96 + 60 abed2 +120 -600 + 1800 -600 -152 -24 +96 -40 ac~ld +480 + 1600 +-F 96 +64 b4 -24 + 225 -116 bPce -150 +15 +60 -10 ?
90 b3d 2 -150 -1500 + 80 -80 bc2cd -300 -1000 -60 -40 Fifth Table .
f i3 .
e( d3D c~ b a~b e. 1234 d.1235 c.1236 cA 245 b.1246 b.1345 aJ1256 a.2345 a.1346 ayf2 -__ 3_ __ 19 + 1I a2bef + 21 + 33 -114 -608 +42 +16 a 2cdf -144 + 10 90 ? ?
537 -4 +66 -16 + 20 -36 22 a~d2e 216 -390 1+1740 + 361+24 + 16 80 -16 ab2df + 30 + 155 64j245 +-4 4 -24 -V1580 16 abe2 +135 -990 1700 ? ?
1.6 4+ 64 + 240 abcde +1024-10 + 360+ 468 +1740 -22 +6 -24 + 24 ? ?
60 + 36 abcde+120 100-1500 +1320 2000 -152 84 6 -26+21W4 208 , 860 -20 abd5 600 +1080 + 600 -24 +144 +960 ac 3e + 480 +900o + 6001 + 96 +16 -96 + 960 ac ~~~+1600 +1800 -400 +64 +96 320 63 , of -150 + 225 + 900 !
+16 +24 b~de 150 + 125 -2700 + 0+60 20 -40 b 22e 300 + 900 -60 -10 +90 + 60 b'cd ' 1000 -1500 -600 -40 -80 -40 Sixth Table .
IQP e~~~~ d~~ 6~~ a.~~~i !
.1034 e. 1235 d. 1236 d. 1245 c. 1246 c. 1345 5.1256 6.2345 6 .
1346 a.346 a.1356 a26f2 33 I 19 114 I ?
1 +4 a2c of -102 +10 114 264 i64 ? ?
424 4 a~2df -216 -90 .
+468 ? ?
36 +66+ 24 24 a2de2 390 -195 + 900 ?
24 +16 +24 ab~e +135 ? ?
155 -698 -990 + 16 ?
4-+1 +6 4 abcdf ?
120 ? ?
3060 264 ? ?
537 ?
1320 152 22 +64 -24 16 + 20 -36 --208 ? ?
24 abce2 + 100 990 245 2700 -84 -4 ? ?
64 ?
16 -80 -16 40 I-20o abd-e-60 10 +1740 + 900 24-6 -2 16 + 60 ?
36 + 60 acyf +480 ? ?
468 +1080 ? ?
96 24 ? ?
24 +144 ac'de +1600 + 900 ?
1320 600 ?
64 ?
16 -96 ?
24 -208 40 acd3 +1800 ?
1080 ?
96 ?
144 63df -150 ? ?
225 -245 + 80 1+1i6 -80 -8 -o16 6e2 + 125 1704-60 ?
2400 6c -300 1 ?
0 10 60 ?
24 ?
60 ?
,360 b~~cde -~1000 -2700 -2000 40 -10 ?
90 -20 40 -860 -20 b2d3 -1500 + 600 -80 9600 6c~ ?
900 ? ?
6001 ?
096 6c d2 -600 400 -032 Seventh Table .
fD C~~dJf ccT a* f1235 e. 1236 e. 1245 d. 1246 d. 1345 c. 1256 c.2345 c. 1346 b.2346 b.1356 a. 2356 a.16 a2Cf2 ?
1-19 10 4+ 1 -6 ?
64 ~ a2d~ef 390 -90 -114 + 360 ?
24 +66 ? ?
4+62 a2e3 -195 ? ?
225 +16 ?
14 ab f2 ? ?
155 114 19.5 ? ?
4+4 +1i6 abcef ? ?
100 + 360 608 264 -1500 -84 -2-2 +6 -2 ?
16 -24 -4 -26 abd'f 600 264 ? ?
468 ? ?
900 24 -4 -24 ? ?
24 -24 -96+1 abde 2 -1500 990 + 900 6 -26 4 ? ?
64 ?
24 +90 10 C ac2df ?
1600 ? ?
468 ? ?
537 +1i800 +64 24 ? ?
24 -16 ? ?
20 36 + 96 ac~e2 + 900 245 -1500 +16 -96 +16 80 16 -80Z acd2e +1800 ?
1320 ?
1740 +96 ?
24 -208 ?
16 ? ?
60 ? ?
36H ad4 ?
1080 + 144 bPef ? ?
125 + 225 990 + 60 +16 ? ?
64 -4 b2Cdf -1000 + 900 245 +1320 -40 ?
24 -15 80 16 208 +24 62ce2 -1700 -2700 -10 ? ?
90 + 240 40 -20 b2d2e -1500 -2700 + 900 -80 -20 40 ? ?
60 bc~f ?
1740 + 1080 + 60 ? ?
36 +144 bci2de ? ?
900 -2000 -600 + 60 860 20 40 bcd3 -600 ? ?
600 1 40 + 960 c4e ? ?
600 + 960 c-3d2 -400 1-320 And the remaining seven Tables might of course be deduced from these by writing ( , f e , d , c , b , a ) instead of ( a , b , G , d , e , f ) , and malting the corresponding alterations in the top line of each Table .
18 .
The equations =0 , 3-0= 0 =0 consequently establish between the fifteen functions 1234 , 1235,. .
3456 a system of fourteen equations , viz. the first and last three of these are 1234=-0 1235=0 -160758675.1245 + 11559295.1236=0 + 11559295.1456 -160758675 .
2356-0O 2456=0 , 3456=0 .
To complete the proof that in virtue of the equations 2I=0 , 3=0,. .
, =0 all the fifteen functions 1234 , 1235 , ... 3456 vanish , it is necessary to make use of the identical relations subsisting between these quantities 1234 , &amp;c. ; thus we have a. 1345+4b .
1245+6c .
1235+4d .
1234-0 b. 1345+4c .
1245+6d .
1235+4e .
1234-0 , which , in virtue of the above equations 1234=0 and 1235=0 , become a.1345+4b .
1245-0 b. 1345+4c .
1245=09 giving ( unless indeed ac-b2=0 ) 1245=0 , 1345=0 ; the equation 1245=0 then reduces the third of the above equations to 1236=0 , and so on until it is shown that the fifteen quantities all vanish .

