Comrjparison of Magnetic Disturbances recorded by the Self-registering Magnetometers at the Royal Observatory , Greenwich , with Magnetic -Disturbances deduced from the corresponding Terrestrial Galvanic Currents recorded by the Self-registering Galvanometerss of the Royal Observatory .
By GEORGE BIDDELL AIRY , Astronomer Royal .
Received December 20 , 1867 , -Read February 6 , 1868 .
IT would be difficult , even at this early stage in the history of the treatment of Spontaneous Terrestrial Galvanic Currents , to say how the science began Z. As far as relates to my own acquaintance with it , it originated in some general knowledge of the existence , on special days , of currents disturbing practical telegraphic operations , which were soon -found to synchronize with magnetic storms , and in Icommunications with Mr. EDWIN CLARK and Mr. LATIMER CLARK , both of whom volunteered their assistance , but more particularly in conversations , and subsequently in correspondence , with CHARLES V. WALKER , Esq. On several occasions , tabular numerical statements were transmitted by Mr. WALKER to me , and copies of the Greenwich magnetic photograms were transmitted by me to Mr. WALKER ; Mr. GLAISHER also went to Tunbridge several times , to discuss the subject with Mr. WALKER .
It is not necessary here further to allude to the important papers in the Philosophical Transactions by Mr. W. H. BARLOW ( 1849 ) and by Mr. WALKER ( 1861 and 1862 ) , or to the subsequent observations of Dr. LAMONT , except for the purpose of remarking that these philosophers possessed no means of maintaining a constant record by self-registering apparatus .
The history of the establishment of apparatus at the Royal Observatory is as follows .
In my Annual Report to the Board of Visitors of the Royal Observatory,1860 , June 2 , I submitted to the consideration of the Board , " It may be worth considering whether it would ever be desirable to establish in two directions at right angles to each other ( for instance , along the Brighton Railway and along the North Kent Railway ) wires which would photographically register in the Royal Observatory the currents that pass in these directions , exhibiting their indications by photographic curves in close juxtaposition with the registers of the magnetic elements .
" The subject having been thus formally opened , and various communications having passed with Mr. WALKER as Superintendent and Engineer of the Telegraphs of the SouthEastern Railway ( in which capacity Mr. WALKER has rendered very important services to the Royal Observatory ) , I again , on 1861 , June 1 , brought the matter before the Board of Visitors , in these words : " I alluded in my last Report to the possible esta* Allusion will be made hereafter to the paper by the late Professor BARLOW in the Philosophical Transactions , 1831 , of which , however , the subject is different from that treated here .
blishment of galvanic wires which would record , perhaps upon the same photographic sheet which bears the declination and horizontal force , the magnitude and direction of earth-currents in two directions .
I conceive that this may be justly regarded as an important physical experiment ; and I hope to be able shortly to lay before the Visitors some details of plan , and to ask their opinion in a more precise form .
" The Board , after consideration of my proposals , resolved " 1 that it be recommended to the Board of Admiralty that two lines of insulated wires be established from the Royal Observatory to the stations near Dartford and Croydon , with suitable apparatus at the Royal Observatory for the purpose of registering the intensity and direction of terrestrial galvanic currents dependent on natural causes at present obscure .
" Mr. WALKER , in his paper in the Philosophical Transactions , 1861 , alluded to the matter as having come before him , and as having been the subject of his Report and Estimate ; and added , " I have , to a certain small extent , made progress in anticipation .
" On 1861 , August 14 , I submitted a Memorial to the Lords Commissioners of the Admiralty on the advantage of erecting the necessary wires and recording apparatus , at an estimated expense of ?
250 ; and on August 19 I received Their Lordships ' sanction to my placing that sum on the Navy Estimates for the Financial Year 1862-1863 .
On August 24 I made formal application to the Directors of the South-Eastern Railway for permission to place the wires on the poles of their Telegraph , and on December 20 I received their assent .
The terms on which this assent was granted were most liberal ; no stipulation being made except for the nominal annual rent of five shillings for the use of the poles and five shillings for the maintenance of the wires in a state of repair .
And I take this opportunity of adding that , when it was found that , by the adoption of insulators of a high class , the expense was made to exceed the estimate , Messrs. SILVER , the contractors for the insulators , at once resigned all profit .
The whole of the wirework has been done at cost price .
The wires were completely established under the superintending care of Mr. WALKER about the autumn of 1862 .
The wire is that technically called No. 8 , 64 inch in diameter , annealed iron wire , coated with zinc by galvanic deposit .
The insulators consist each of a double ebonite cup with outer porcelain cup .
From the Observatory to the Railway , the wires at different times have been led by different channels , but are now led underground .
The connexions with earth have been made in various ways , but at present they are made at each of the.three stations by soldering the wires to water-pipes .
The plan for forming , on a revolving cylinder ( covered with photographic paper ) , a spot of light whose position should depend on the galvanic current passing through the wires , was arranged at the beginning of 1863 .
Each wire communicates with the coil of a galvanometer .
It may be mentioned here that the current has proved far stronger than was anticipated .
At first , a nearly astatic combination of needles was provided ; it was speedily found necessary to turn the red* ends of the needles in the same direction ; and subsequently the coils were reduced .
At present , the entire number of turns of the wire about the acting needle of each galvanometer is 200 , and the length of the acting needle is a little more than 1 inch .
The needle is suspended by a human hair .
A stalk below carries a small plane mirror , whose surface is about I inch by l inch .
With the assistance of cylindrical lenses , a very neat spot of light is thrown upon the revolving barrel by the following arrangement .
The beam of -light from the lamp falls upon a fixed vertical cylindrical lens , and is made to converge in the horizontal plane .
In this state it falls on the plane mirror , converging in the horizontal plane , diverging in the vertical plane .
It leaves the plane mirror in the same state , only having received the change of direction corresponding to the play of the galvanometer-magnet ; and it then falls on a fixed horizontal lens , which makes it converge in the vertical plane .
( This is the plane of a transverse section of the revolving cylinder , which defines the direction of the time-abscissa of the photographic curve .
) A single lamp gives light for the recording apparatus of both wires .
The revolving barrels , which had been used for many years in conjunction with the self-registering magnetometers of the iRoyal Observatory , were of glass , selected with great care , first by Mr. BROOKE , afterwards by Mr. GLAISHER , from the extensive stock of a large manufacturer ; and their circularity and cylindricity of form were almost perfect .
I was desirous , however , of using for the earth-current-apparatus a barrel turned in the lathe .
After endeavourink in vain to obtain glass so turned , I succeeded in procuring a barrel of ebonite , manufactured by Messrs. SILVER .
The difficulty of securing this occasioned nearly a year 's delay in the completion of the apparatus .
Another year was added by the excavation of the Magnetic Basement in which the apparatus was to be placed , and by the caution necessary to be used while the walls were damp .
Finally , the apparatus was brought into action and the records were made as a matter of routine , on 1865 , April 1 , and from that time the registers are almost perfect ; the principal interruption being that produced by the great snowstorm of 1866 , January .
I The instrumental elements on which it appeared desirable to maintain a constant check are the following : the freedom of the barrel from end-shake , and the uniformity of its rotation ; the zero of time on the line of time-abscissa ; and the zero of galvanic measure for the ordinates .
And the checks are thus made .
In regard to end-shake of the barrel , a small lamp throws a light through a definite hole in the cover of the barrel , which , as the barrel revolves , forms a photographic line parallel to the line of time-abscissa , usually called the " photographic base-line .
" In regard to the uniformity of rotation , it has been the practice , since self-registering apparatus was established , to produce an interruption in the register , by stopping off the light for a few minutes , three times every day ; the observer registering from the clock-dial the times of stopping and readmitting the light .
For the test of circularity , this has been done on a limited number of days , six times in the day , at moments extending with approximate uniformity of intervals through the twenty-four hours .
The operation to which I have alluded , even if performed only three times in a day , when used in conjunction with pasteboard scales carefully adjusted to exhibit 24h for ASTRONOiMER ROYAL ON THE COMPARISON OF the revolution of the barrel , gives ample information whereby a time-scale can be laid down applying to every part of the photographic curve .
The zero of galvanic measure is obtained by simply interrupting the wire-circuit .
I desire to state that great attention has been given to every one of these adjustments , more especially to those which relate to time .
At an early epoch in the comparison of the two classes of measures , it became obvious that questions of simultaneity would arise .
Great care has been taken by Mr. GLAISSHER in the formation and application of all the time-scales and I am confident that I can answer for the simultaneity or nonsimultaneity of the phenomena , to one or two minutes of time .
Before entering into details of our observations , I will remark that it is perfectly certain that atmospheric influences have produced no effect on our records .
This appears in two ways .
First , that the Croydon currents ( which convey almost the whole of the , terrestrial galvanism ) have , at all times , an aspect totally different from that of the Dartford currents ; secondly , that whenever a wire is broken , at whatever place on the wire , the galvanometer-needle then remains motionless at the zero point .
It one or two instances the wire has been broken at a considerable distance from the Observatory , and has fallen so that its end lodged in the ground ; and then it has conveyed a -very good terrestrial current .
We thus obtain simultaneous galvanic indications from the two instruments , measurable by the parts of scales of sensibly equal value .
IT proceed to explain the method by which they have been treated .
From the Map which accompanies this communication , it appears that the azimuth of *~~ ~~~N ?
N / /'\~~~~~~~~ i'1/ ~~~1\ me toytdo 7Z .
/ th Drfodsttonasvewdfrmth Ryl lsv/ oy measrdfo4temgei north in the direction N. , E. , S. , W. , is 122 ; 'o ; and that of the Croydon station is 229j0 .
Let C be the measure of a galvanic current from Croydon , D that of a current of the same kind ( as referred to a battery-pole ) from Dartford ; and assume these to be caused by a galvanic current N of the .
same kind towards the north , and a galvanic current W of the same kind towards the west ; and that these north and west currents admit of being resolved according to the rules of resolution of mechanical statical force .
Put a for the azimuth of Croydon , oa ' for that of Dartford .
Then it is easily found that W=~~C .
os 2D Cos a W=~COSX DeC~ Sill ( aat ) sin ( aca ) C Sinai _D ~sing a sin ( ac-a ) sin ( a-a ) which , converted into numbers , give W=* -C X 0'55800+D x0 68259 , N= +C X0 88437 +D x0 79218 .
Now , upon interposing .
a battery in the course of each of the wires , with its graphite or copper pole towards Greenwich , it was found that , on the Croydon wire , it gave an ordinate upon the photographic sheet in the direction which we are accustomed to measure as positive ; and on the Dartford wire it gave an ordinate upon the photographic sheet in the negative direction .
Let C ' and D ' be the measured quantities ; then C'= + C , DI= -D ; and Graphite current towards W=-C ' x0 55800 D ' x0 68259 , Graphite current towards N= + C ' x 0-88437-D ' x 01 '9218 .
Conceiving this graphite current , if it is really a terrestrial galvanic current acting on our magnetometers , to be below them , it will deflect any part of a magnet possessing red or austral magnetism to the right , estimated with reference to the direction of the current 's course .
Hence we obtain Magnetic tendency to N= -C'x 0'55800-D'x 0-68259 , Magnetic tendency toW= -C ' xO88437+D'x0179218 .
It was found that when the ordinates as measured from the photographic sheet were multiplied by these factors , they gave results larger than those on the magnetometer sheets with which I desired to compare them ; and , in order to diminish their magnitude , they were multiplied by 0-5437 .
Hence , putting e=0-68259X 05437 , f=0-55800X 05437 , g=079218xO05437 , h=0X88437x0 5437 ( the order of C ' and D ' having been accidentally inverted ) , Magnetic tendency to N=-D'xe-C'xf , Magnetic tendency to W+ D ' x gC ' X h. It now became important to consider how , from the photographic curves of the Earthcurrents , these Magnetic Tendencies could be most conveniently obtained .
For my owin preliminary trials , I had four proportional compasses constructed by Mr. SIMMS , by means of which I took the proportional part ( as expressed by the factor e , orf , &amp;c. ) of the ordinate to which that factor applied , laid it down on a new ordinate , and laid , at the top or bottom of the ordinate , the other part which was to be added or subtracted , and thus formed curves for Magnetic Tendencies without the use of any numerals whatever .
But this method is not suited to a junior computer .
After having satisfied myself that there was good ground for proceeding further , I arranged , for the work of the younig assistants , the following process .
Four pasteboard scales were prepared , with different graduations : " Scale E for Dartford , " with graduation =X graduation of Horizontal-Force-Magnetometer , measuring negatively ; " Scale F for Croydon , " with graduation =y X graduation of Horizontal-Force-Magnetometer , measuring negatively ; " Scale G for Dartford , " with graduation =X X graduation of Horizontal-Force-Magnetometer , measuring positively ; " Scale H for Croydon , " with graduation =h X graduation of Horizontal-Force-Maga netometer , measuring negatively .
Then , the times for which the measures were to be taken having been previously prelpared , the ordinate D was measured with scale E , and the ordinate C ' was measured with scale F ; the numbers were set down in parallel columns and added together , and the sum was used to form a new ordinate of Magnetic Tendency to N. Similarly D ' was measured with scale G , and C ' with scale H , and their numbers were added to form a new ordinate of Magnetic Tendency to W. At every point where the zero of ordinate had been obtained by breaking the wire-circuit , the ordinate was measured in the same way .
In this manner were formed all the curves , exhibiting Magnetic Tendency to N. and W. inferred from Galvanic Measures , which I now exhibit to the Society .
( Plates XXV .
to XXX .
) For the other curves , that which exhibits Magnetic Force to the North is simply a copy , on an altered scale , of the record of the Horizontal-Force-Magnetometer ; and that which exhibits Magnetic Force to the West is derived from the record of the Declination-Magnetometer , the angular deviations being converted into proportionate parts of horizontal force , and laid down on the same scale as the ordinates of the Horizontal-Force-Magnetometer .
The days were selected as exhibiting rather bold curves .
I was prevented from taking several which I should have thought preferable , from some scruples ( which afterwards proved to be entirely unfounded ) about the accuracy of the time-scale .
I now proceed to remark on the comparison of the two systems of curves .
It is impossible , I think , to see these curves without being struck with their general agreement .
In particular , those which exhibit the irregularities of Northerly Magnetic Force are extremely accordant .
Yet there are some minor points of discordance , both general and special , which merit most careful attention ; and to these I now call the attention of the Society .
The remark of most extensive application is , that the irregularities of the curves derived from the Galvanic Currents are more numerous than those derived from the Magnetometers .
I know not whether this is inherent in the nature or origin of the currents , or whether the Magnetic apparatus is less sensitive than the Galvanic apparatus .
The next remark is , that the irregularities derived from the Galvanic Currents almost always precede those derived from the Magnetometers .
These intervals of time , as I have already remarked , are perfectly certain .
There are a few instances ( as West Force , 1867 , April 8 , 14h , and June 1 , 15h 50m ; and North Force , 1867 , May 28 , o7 20m , and June 1 , 12k and 13h ) in which the Galvanic irregularity appears to follow the Magnetometer irregularity ; and a greater number , especially in the North Force , in which their coincidence of time is sensibly perfect ; but in very far the greatest number , the Galvanic irregularities precede the Magnetometer irregularities .
In the instance of West Force , 1866 , October 4 , 9h 40m , and probably in some others , the advance of the Galvanic irregularity is nearly half an hour .
, .
In several instances , the proportions of consecutive rise and fall are not the same in the two systems of curves .
Thus on 1866 , October 4 , 5h to 6b , the proportions are unequal for the West Force , and , in a minor degree , for the North Force .
So also for the West Force , 1867 , May 28 , 711 to 81 " , and June 1 , 101 to 11 ] ' .
In this element , as in the times , the accordance is better for the North Force .
On 1867 , June 7 , 3h , there is a remarkable salience of the Galvanometer curve for the West Force .
Mr. GLAISHER suggests an explanation of this which I believe to be correct .
The circuits had been interrupted in order to make time-marks , and the wires had probably taken a galvanic charge , which apparently burst out with great force when the circuits were restored .
On 1867 , April 4 , West Force , there is discordance which is completely explained by ordinary acceleration of Galvanic results and inequality in the proportions of rise and fall .
On 1867 , June 2 , West Force , there is discordance of which it is possible the explanation may be different .
The day was the Sunday following the Visitation , and it is possible that the instruments may have been disturbed , and that the disturbances may not have been corrected .
[ It is now believed that the movement of the Declination Magnetometer was impeded by contact with its box .
] After all attention has been given to these points , I think that , on repeatedly examining the agreements of the two systems of curves , it is impossible to avoid the conclusion that the magnetic disturbances are produced by terrestrial galvanic currents below the magnets .
Yet there remain some points to be explained before we can state that galvanic currents as we observe them will account for all that we observe in the magne .
tometer records .
MDcccaLxvIJ .
3 u One point , of considerable importance , is the relation of the new curves to their zeros .
I have stated that the readings by means of Scale E , Scale F , &amp;c. have been taken in the same way for the zeros ofi galvanic ordinates as for the points of the curves ; and , by means of these , zero-lines have been laid down on the diagrams .
From general inspection of these , it would seem that , on the days of magnetic storms , the North Force , as shown by the galvanic currents , is on the whole increased .
But I believe that in all examinations of magnetometer results for North Force during magnetic storms , and certainly for those in the Royal Observatory ( see the Analysis of 177 Magnetic Storms , Philosophical Transactions , 1863 ) it is found that the North Force is diminished .
I cannot at present explain this discordance .
The other discordances , both of time and measure , may not improbably depend on the following circumstance .
The south-western ( Croydon ) wire is entirely south-west of the Royal Observatory ; and the southeastern ( Dartford ) wire is entirely south-east of the Royal Observatory .
It is probable therefore that the times and magnitudes of the terrestrial currents which pass through these wires , correspond rather to places near the middle of the straight lines connecting the Royal Observatory with Croydon and Dartford than to the locality of the Royal Observatory itself .
It might be a question whether , in continuing these observations , the length of wires might not be considerably redu'ced , and whether an attempt might not be made to give such terminations to each that the recording apparatus should be nearly in the middle 'of the length of each .
In the actual topographical circumstances , it may not be easy to secure the latter condition .
At present we are unable to say whether the records of the galvanic currents throw any light on the origin of the diurnal variations of the magnetic elements .
On one point , however , we seem to be able to speak with confidence ; they do not explain the existence of the principal part of terrestrial magnetism .
The hypothesis of Professor BARLOW in the Philosophical Transactions , 1831 , plausible as it undoubtedly was , is not supported by the discovery of galvanic currents competent to explain the earth 's general magnetism. .
_9L~~~~~~~~~FT~~~~~~~~hzb.ff~5N C ~.X N.F OR CEBYM AG NET O.M ETE R. N FORC EBYEAR TH CURRENT st ISCA LE _HOURS , GREENWICH MEAN SOLAR TIME ISCALEI 1~~~ ~~~ 3S t9 it t3 15 M7 21 &lt; * E t. EMi 'f'S~~~ 1 .
A I=5iX f~~~~~~~~ IA KA= t5 1111 &lt; -Zoe |I ~~~~I II JV 11TW1 1H __0 == a ; t : 4 , 'a-.*WS1 . !
!1 11 t___ _e _ 0 , ARE A. +4/ I -~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ -~~~~1 ~ APw -h ; zlT- .
Nr .
D CC IX2ILla W W. F OR CEBYMACNETOMETE R. W.FO RCE WY EARTHCURRENT S. HOURS , -GENIHMEAN SOLAR TIME $~ ~~ ~~~J. .
7EE*1.N3WI1CH .
X IF T-~1 IARA AIZ[ |1111 IVT^ I , I A1 It ITIII IV ITl VASi a. f.11 Al-~.A 7I ~I 11\1 1II1 r1 1.1 n--v x n_v IN US T/ I W~~~~wk V , A TI .
UM I I. , Jt Sl AfV _ _= .
, _ .
=j ... ... . .
, = ' , _17 Pkzb .
Tra .
DCCOLXI .
PlzeXX N.F ORB Y. MAGNET OM ET E R. N.F O RC EY EA RTHCURR ENTS .
HOURS , OREENWICH MEAN SOLAR TIUE St. A7 = =1 7ii2 _v __ T. 0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 0 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0 _ .
s_$= ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I .
7 05~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~z E*sS|w s-wmm_ ~~~~~~~~~~ ~~-a - ... --Oda-o -T-I 01,01 ~~~~~~~~ T- ' : '1 l''.1 .
r|ia -A-----T -~~~f !
al '[ ziZlranzs.1DCCCLXVI1Lf t &amp; lVI W ' .
FORC E BY M AG NET OM ET ER .
W. FORC E8YEARTHCU RR E NT S. -_____________.HOURS , G-RENWICH tAEAN SOLAR YMEM ' 12Z 761 '00~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ____ _ ?
_ _a 15f i1111r'1r 'I , I -[-----I--o~ ' % -r--r-A-r ---I 1z| | ?
z| a-E-r l11r -----1----= -S -r------l --l ---T ----1--boo.-Mo ---------1 1A ~e 1M &gt; -+ +. .
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~A .
0_ _ ; ;f~~~~~~~~~~~J If ZNW++F-4@ ~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ __ _ ... ... .._.1 _tW _P ss _ ... . .
w ... ..S a___ _____ _ __-_a___--a _ , , , ... ..D ... .
, , .
, .
5 , , , ,~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ... ... Are _P &amp; Z. Trans. MDCG GLXT I 1 .
Rwe , DOX.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Pz ; .r~sM C C~~li~eE X N. FORC E BY MAGN ETOM ETE R. N. FORCE BY EA RTH CURRENTS .
ttstE| 1a ~~~HOURS , GREENWICH M EANK SOLAR TIME .
X|CL EfE IIl 19-H'q17.9 1 is Ii I11 17 19 1 123 SCL ea6 __rf 11. .
_ ___ .
^ .
7_9I *~~~~005 +.004 +~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-0 _ .
_.4 , - ' .
I OO'1-Cfx l. .
_ Af~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~^ I.q , MO PIM VWA % __e ----~~~*.__ iJf i ?
, f/ diaz.1VDCCQL IT &amp; t ?
wL ) !
XX .
W. FOR CE sBY M AG N ETOWM ET ER .
W. FO RCE BY EARTH CURRENTS .
&lt; _ __ HOURS , GREENWICH MEAN SOLAR TIME L S^ w~~~ ... ..=7 it la.=. .
i7 --19 wo ... _ .
_ __ _ _r_ _\ _s __ ~_I __ vI 1. .
_2tS2 XS oM t.\ l\\ i. _. .
7 !
-_ ____ .
_ __ ____ JAi_|r __ __* i18r 1+./ qie 1w71 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~L--li 11.00 C U~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-v

