On the Law of the Resistance of the Air to Rifled Projectiles .
By CHARLES W. MERRIFIELD , F.R.S. , Principal of the Royal School of Naval Architecture .
Received March 19 , -Read April 23 , 1868 .
AT the beginning of this month Lieut.-Colonel H. R. HALFORD applied to me to obtain for him the law of atmospheric resistance resulting from his experiments in shooting with METFORD'S match-rifle , a small-bore with increasing pitch .
I found the resistance to vary as the cube of the velocity .
As the calculations and experiments were all made without any notion of the resulting law , and without any knowledge of the work already done by Professor HMLJE and Professor BASHFORTH , they afford a remarkable confirmation of the results obtained by those gentlemen .
This is the more worthy of notice , as their data belong to pieces of large calibre , and mine to small-bore bullets .
The experimental data originally submitted to me were simply the elevations found necessary to give the different ranges of every 100 yards from 100 to 1100 .
These were as follows : Yards range .
Elevation .
100 9 30 200 20300 31 30 400 44 500 57 30 600 1 12700 1 27 30 800 1 44900 2 130 1000 2 201100 2 39 30 I was informed that these were the means derived from a great number of selected trials , bad shots being of course discarded .
The laws of the motion were arrived at tentatively .
I began the calculations from an assumed velocity of 1360 feet per second , which is seen by the shorter ranges to be very nearly true , of necessity .
I then found that the law of the squares did not fit the results at all , but that the law of the cubes very nearly did so , and a slight alteration in the assumed velocity made them do so with exactness .
dv The method used was to determine the coefficient of resistance mo , in dt=-enmy , which gives m= 2tv " ) , sv being the initial velocity , s the actual range , and 0 the inclina0~~~~~~~~~~ tion .
The time t was that of the range in vacuo due to the supposed initial velocity and given elevation .
It was assumed , first , that the vacuum time might be taken to represent the real time , and , second , that the horizontal resistance might be taken to vary as the cube of the horizontal velocity .
The result is given in the following Table .
Calculation of Resistance , supposed to vary as the Cube of the Velocity .
Initial velocity taken as 1358 feet per second .
Reduction ~Th~h~Coefficient Fnl velocity Angle of Actual Range Redaneti y of ligt of resistDeparture veloclty , lost in each Actual elevation .
range , in vaco , ance profrom mean in feet per 100 yards , range , infeet .
in feet .
min feet .
in seconds .
portionate value .
second .
in feet per in yards .
_ _~ 30 I3166 16.2-31 L __ i_ ---_i ' to seconid .
6,6 19*62 023o316 i 316-620 -0-018 1222-4 135-6 100 20 600 666-57 66-57 0-49085 16-643 +0-005 1111-5 110-9 200 31 30 900 1049-81 149-81 0-77309 16-647 +0-009 1018-8 92-7 300 44 1200 1466-32 266-32 1-07985 16-647 +0-009 940-6 78-2 400 57 30 1500 1916o02 416-02 1-41115 16-643 + 0-005 873-4 67-2 500 1 12 1800 2399-00 599-00 1*76695 16-654 +0-016 815-2 58-2 1 600 1 27 30 2100 2915-04 815-04 2-14732 16-644 +0-006 764-3 50-9 700 1 44 2400 3464-11 1064-11 2-55206 16-634 -0-004 719-4 44-9 80 21 30 2700 4046-12 1346-12 2-98133 16-639 +0-001 679-4 40-0 900 12 20 3000 4660-92 1660-92 3-43504 16-633 0-005 643-7 35-7 1000 2 39 30 3300 5308-37 2008-37 3-91317 16-616 -0-022 611-5 32-2 1100 These two columns Mean ... ... 16-638 contain the data .
Resulting Coefficient of resistance =0-00000 02723 .
The coefficient of resistance , so determined for each range , has no sensible variation , thus proving that the facts are exactly met by the law that the resistance varies according to the cube of the velocity , with a coefficient of resistance , for this particular bullet , of 0-00000 02723 .
This is subject to the assumptions previously mentioned .
It is further either involved or assumed that the bullet presents an invariable aspect in a horizontal direction .
These assumptions are sufficiently right for such a very low trajectory as is given by 2 ' 40 ' for 1100 yards , giving a vacuum height of 64 feet .
I got out a graphical solution of the resisted time of a bullet thrown with a velocity of 64 feet per second ( which corresponds to that height ) and with a coefficient of 0 -000001 , and I found the variation in time too small to detect in fine curves carefully drawn with ordinates of nearly 2 feet in length .
I consider this as amounting to proof that the difference between real and vacuum time is insignificant in this problem .
The second assumption , as to the horizontal resistance varying as the cube of the horizontal velocity , is justified by the low trajectory .
On the question of aspect , my present knowledge does not authorize me to form any decided opinion .
The graphical method mentioned above was devised to evade the arithmetical difliculties of the question ; and I hope shortly to be able to publish an account of it* .
Colonel HALFORD has since been so obliging as to communicate to me the following notes of the experimental data .
These are as follows : " The means by which the angles of METFORD'S match-ri/ 1es were arrived at .
" The rifles were shot at 121 yards to get the zero on the tangent-scale .
" This distance is taken because , with a radius of 12yards , -8 of an inch is one minute of angular space , an easy quantity to deal with .
Corrections made for height of fore sight above axis of bore , and for fall of bullet , at 12yards , taken as one minute .
" The tangent-scale is then carefully cut for radius between the sights to read to minutes with a vernier .
It can be read to 15 " by careful inspection .
The Table of angles is then made from careful registers of shooting in all weathers , but especially calm weather , at different distances , but chiefly at 200 yards , 500 , 600 , 800 , 900 , and 1100 yards .
Nine times out of ten the angles will be found to be perfectly correct i calm weather .
Difference of barometrical pressure will make a slight difference .
The Table furnished [ i. e. of elevations corresponding to ranges ] was drawn out by Mr. METFORD , and has been very heavily tested by myself , and tallies exactly with my experience .
The angles have been compared with those used by other men using similar rifles , and have been found to tally , making slight allowance for the little differences of speed which different barrels will give-usually not more than is due to 0 ? ?
2 ' of elevation in 1000 yards .
I must have fired from 8000 to 9000 shots .
I have most of my shots registered .
I should say that the Tables have been worked out from results given by at least 30,000 shots .
Ranges Elevations , Elevations , Elevations , g Table No.1 .
Table No.2 .
Table No.3 .
Yards .
0 , O , , / , , 100 915 9 30 10 30 200 19 30 20 20 30 300 30 45 31 30 32 30 400 43 44 45 15 500 56 15 57 30 59 600 1 1030 1 12 1 14 700 1 25 45 1 27 30 129 30 800 1 42 1 44 146 30 900 1 59 30 2 130 24 45 1000 2 17 30 2 20 223 1100 2 36 45 2 39 30 242 30 " No. 3 Table is not perfect in itself ; it is a Table used occasionally with a head wind , and has not been so carefully worked out as the others ; a head wind is so disturbing in its effects that , practically , it is almost impossible to verify it .
The other Tables are reliable within very small fractions .
" Details of bullet , &amp;c. " METFORD'S match-rifle : calibre 0'4605 inch .
" Char e : 90 grains , CuRTIs and HARVEY 's No. 5 powder .
" Length of bullet ... 145 inch .
" Diameter at base ... 0451 2 inch from base 045 , , -8 inch from base 0'447 " Weight : 530 grains .
" Material : lead hardened with alloy .
" Shape : cup-shaped in rear , nearly cylindrical for the first inch , and gradually rounding off from there to a spherical or paraboloidal head , not pointed .
" These notes were not given to me until after my calculations had been made .
It will be observed that the data originally supplied , and from which I worked , are those of Table 2 .
This appears to be the most reliable , being very near the mean of the other two .
On the whole , I consider myself singularly fortunate in having had such a very good series of experiments from which to calculate .
It will not fail to be noticed that the velocity of sound is intermediate between the initial and final velocities of the bullets at the longer ranges .
Xote added 3rd August 1868.-For the sake of comparison with other results , I give the reduction of this coefficient of resistance to the standard of one pound weight avoirdupois , and one inch transverse section , on the ( doubtful ) assumption that the coefficient varies inversely as the weight , and directly as the transverse section .
Coefficient reduced to 1 lb. weight and to one square inch section 0 00000 01267 , Ditto , and to one circular inch section. .
0'00000 00995 .

