Account of Experiments on Torsion and Flexure for the Determination of Rigidities .
-Third Paper .
By JOSEPH DAVID EVERETT , D.C.L. , Professor of Natural Philosophy in Queen 's College , Beyfast .
Communicated by Sir WILLIAM TH : OMSON , F.B.S. Received January 13 , -Read January 30 , 1868 .
THESE experiments are a continuation of those described in my papers read February 26th , 1866 and February 7th , 1867 .
They were made during the Winter Session of 1866-67 , in the same place , and with the same apparatus as the later experiments on the steel rod ( see p. 150 of last paper ) , the observer being Mr. ZACCHEUS WALKER , student of Engineering , who has been already mentioned as joint observer in the experiments on the steel rod .
I personally inspected the apparatus from time to time , and assisted in the taking of those measurements which only required to be made once for all in the case of each rod .
The weights , in air and water , of the portions of rods operated on , were observed by Mr. JOHN TATLOCK , Laboratory Assistant to Sir WILLIAM THOMSON , who also performed this portion of the labour in the previous experiments .
The rods operated on in the experiments now to be described were three in number , and were of malleable iron , cast iron , and copper respectively , those previously operated on being of flint glass ( two specimens ) , brass , and steel .
-Experiments on Malleable Iron Rod .
The mean values of T ( proportional to torsion ) and F ( proportional to flexure ) were as follows , the pointer-readings indicating the amounts by which the rod had been rotated about its axis from a certain initial position .
PointerPointerreading .
T. F. reading .
T. F. 30§ 210-3 165-3 1200 210-7 165-0 600 212-0 164-8 1500 210-1 165-0 90§ 210-3 165-3 1800 210-8 165-2 Combining , as theory requires , those positions which are mutually at right angles , we haveFrom 300 and 1200. .
Tz=210-5 F=165'2 60 ?
, , 1500 ... , , 211-0 , , 164-9 , , 900 , 1800. .
, 210-6 , 165-2 The cross-piece on whose arms the weights are hung , ought to have been turned through a right angle in passing from the position 90I to the position 1200 , in order to MDecCaLXYIII .
3 E destroy the effect of inequality in the length of the arms .
This operation was , however , omitted through oversight and it is therefore necessary in comparing the torsional and flexural rigidities , to correct for this difference .
The arm of couple , that is the distance SS ' or TT ' in fig. 1 of last paper , was 55-71 centims. for torsion and 55583 for flexure .
Also the units in which the numbers T and F are expressed , being tenths of scaledivisions perpendicular and parallel to the rod respectively , are slightly different , being 23-88 and 2 3 &amp; 97 centims. for torsion and flexure respectively .
17 10 1 71 0 The corrections for these two inequalities are in opposite directions .
Their resultant T is a correction of *0016 P to be subtracted .
T The values of E thus corrected areFrom 300 and 1200 ... 1272 , 600 , , 1500 ... 1278 , 900 , , 1800 ... P273 , which when diminished by unity are determinations of a or POISSON'S ratio , subject to two other corrections , which we now proceed to calculate .
For the mechanical correction the data areTorsion in portion of rod between mirrors ... *00661 , Flexure in portion of rod between mirrors ... *00519 , these numbers ( which are in circular measure ) being obtained by dividing T and F respectively reduced to centimetres by 445'6 , which is twice the height of scale above mirrors .
They must now be multiplied by 452 , which is the ratio of all that portion of the rod subjected to torsion and flexure to the portion between mirrors , and also by the constant number -729 ( see last paper , p. 143 ) .
The products thus obtained are '0074 and *0058 ; hence the mechanical corrections of T and F are +'0074 T and +-0058 F. The optical correction ( which I am told was too briefly described in my last paper ) is dependent on the fact that the ray from scale to mirror is not precisely vertical , and therefore not truly perpendicular to the scale , which is horizontal .
It is determined by measuring(1 ) Height of scale above mirrors .
( 2 ) Distance of vertical through centre of scale from line joining centres of mirrors .
( 3 ) Distances , resolved parallel to rod , of vertical through centre of scale from centre of each mirror .
These three distances suffice to determine the corrections both for torsion and flexure , on the hypothesis that the centre of the scale comes into the field of view of both telescopes in every observation , an hypothesis which , though not strictly fulfilled , gives a fair approximation to the actual obliquities .
Let / 3 ( as in last paper ) denote the quotient of one of the distances ( 2 ) or ( 3 ) according as we are dealing with torsion or flexure , bythe distance ( 1 ) .
Then since P is the tangent of a small angle ( which call B ) , we have b tan Bz_(1+ tan2 B)B_(1+32)MB , and therefore the angle turned by mirror ( SB ) is found by dividing the observed deflection ( b tan B ) by 1 +P2 , or , what amounts to the same thing , multiplying it by 1 iP .
Let B1 , / 31 and B2 , P2 be the values of B , / for the nearer and further mirrors respectively ; then tan B , -~ tan B =(1++3PB2-(1+P2 ) 3Bj , which may be shown to be equal to M8SBI ) I+ 2 m92Ml m2 and mi being any two numbers which have the ratio b tan B2 : tan B. .
The observed values of T and F are proportional to 6 tan B2-w tan B1 , and must therefore be multiplied by the correcting factor 1_r2m1 , which , when 3 , and / 2 are equal , becomes simply In the present series of experiments P , and P2 were sensibly equal , their common value being about *069 for torsion and 064 for flexure .
By squaring these numbers we obtain the corrections -0047 T and -0041 F , which are applicable not only to the experiments on the malleable iron rod , but also to those on the cast-iron and copper rods .
Adding together the mechanical and optical corrections , we obtain the total corrections +-0027 T and +-0017 F. TT The resulting correction for is + 001 E " which applied to the values 1P272 , 1P278 , 1 273 gives , after subtracting unity , *273 , *279 , *274 as the corrected determinations of the value of a ' , and we adopt the mean of these , which is *275 .
We proceed to calculate the torsional and flexural rigidities t and f The mean values of T and F , uncorrected , are respectively 210-7 and 165 1 , which , when corrected as above , become 211P3 and 165-4 .
Now we have t= twice distance X force X arm X length X17 1 ?
*T .
f=twice distance X force x arm x length x17 *F , where , in centimetres and grammes weight , we have twice distance=4456 , force=100 , length=29'45 , arm=55-71 for torsion and 55'83 for flexure .
Hence log t=9X71893-log T-7X39403 , logf=9-71823-log F=7'49969 .
The rod having been cut at the places where the mirrors were attached , the central 3nE20 piece was weighed in air and water , the weights found being 100 485 and 87A400 grammes .
The temperature of the water was 10 4 Cent. , at which temperature the expansion of water is 1-0003 .
From these data the volume of the rod in centimetres is found to be 13-085 X 1P0003=13-089 , and the specific gravity 100 -485 ?
.13-089=7-6771 .
Dividing the volume by the length , which was 29-27 , we find the sectional area rr2= 44566 , r=-37664 .
Hence we have 4f _M ( YOUNG'S modulus)= , r4 = M9995400,000 , n ( Rigidity ) =trr4 783,790,000 , Mn k ( Incompressibility ) =(= -1,484,100,000 , o ( POISSON'S ratio ) =_A-1 -= 275 as above .
2n -Experiments on Cast-Iron Rod .
These experiments gave the following values for T and F:PointerPointer- .
reading .
T. F. reading .
T. F. 0§ 311-2 245-8 900 311-8 245-2 300 310-7 245-3 1200 310-8 245-0 600 311-8 244-7 1500 311-7 245-3 Combining positions at right angles , we haveFrom 0 ?
and 900. .
T=3115 F=245-5 , , 30 ?
, , 1200. .
, , 310-8 , , 245-2 , ,60 ?
, , 150 ? .
, 311.7 , ,245-0 Here no correction is required for difference of arms , as the cross-piece was turned through a right angle in passing from the third to the fourth position .
The values of Te corrected for difference of scale-divisions by subtracting one part in 266 , are 1-264 , 1-263 , and 1-267 , which are first approximations to 1+or .
To find the mechanical correction , we have length between mirrors 28-69 , length subjected to torsion and flexure 43-5 , height of scale above mirrors 222-8 , as before .
From these data , together with the above values of T and F , we haveTorsion in portion of rod between mirrors.0098 Flexure , , , , , , .
0077 which numbers being multiplied by 8-5X -729 , give -0108 and -0085 .
Hence the mechanical corrections are ++ *0108 T and + , *0085 F ; and the optical corrections being the same as before , the total corrections are + *0061 T and + 0044 F. rn ; T The resulting correction for A is + 0017 F the application of which gives as the corrected determinations of a ' , 266 , *265 , and *269 , and we adopt the mean *267 , The mean uncorrected values of T and F are 311P3 and 2452 , which , when corrected as above , become 313-2 and 246-3 .
For the torsional and flexural rigidities , we have t=445-6 x lO0 x 55'77 x 28 &amp; 69 x1 71* T. f=445'6 X 100 x 55-77 x 28 &amp; 69 x 1710 Hence log t=9-70805log T=7'21223 , logf=9-70641log F-7 31.495 .
The rod having been cut at the places where the mirrors were attached , the middle piece was found to weigh 90-110 in air , and 77-658 in water at temperature 90.9 C. The expansion of water at this temperature being 1P00026 , we have for the volume of the piece 12X452 x 100026=12A455 , and for the specific gravity , 90-110 § 12-455=7 2347 .
The volume divided by the length , which was 28-66 , gives rr2= 43458 , r=37193 .
Hence we have M =1,374,100,000 , n= 542,340,000 , k= 982,180,000 , f= 267 .
Experiments on Copper Rod .
These experiments gave the following values for T and F:PointerPointerreading .
T. F. reading .
T. F. 0§ 365-0 265'0 900 365'8 264'8 300 365'2 265'0 1200 364i7 265'0 600 365'8 264'7 1500 365'7 265'2 Combining positions at right angles , we haveFrom 00 and 90 ? . .
T=365'4 F=264'9 , ,30 ?
, 120 ? . .
, 365 0,2650 a,60 ?
, 150§ 365-7 , ,264-9 T The values of F corrected for difference of scale-divisions , are 1'374 , 1'372 , and 1'375 .
To find the mechanical correction , we have length between mirrors 28'72 , length subject to torsion and flexure 45'S , height of scale 222'8 .
Hence we find Torsion in portion of rod between mirrors ... '0114 , Flexure , , , , , , , ... 0083 , which numbers being multiplied by -45 x '729 give *0132 and '0096 .
Hence the mechanical corrections are +'0132 T and +'0096 F , which being added to the optical corrections already specified , give the total corections + '0085 T and + 0055 F , and a resultant correction + 003 F.The application of this correction gives as the corrected determinations of a , '378 , '376 , and '379 , and we adopt the mean '378 .
The corrected values of T and F are 368X5 and 266'4 .
For the torsional and flexural rigidities , we have t=445'6 x 100 x 55 77 x 28'72 x10 445'6x100x55'77X28'72x 171 +F .
Hence log t=9'70850logT=7'14206 , logf=.9'70686log F= 7'28133 .
The rod having been cut at the places where the mirrors were attached , the middle piece was found to weigh 110'645 in air , and 98'136 in water at temperature 10 ' C. The expansion of water at this temperature being 1'00026 , we have for the volume of the piece 12'502 x 1'00026=12'5122 ; and for its specific gravity , 110'645.12'5122=8'84293 .
The volume divided by the length , which was 28'61 , gives -rr='43733 , r=-37310 .
Hence M=1,255,800,000 n= 455,640,000 , k =1,716,400,000 , a ' = '378 , the units of length and force being the centimetre and gramme weight .
The values of ni obtained by Sir W. THOMSON for brass and copper from observations on the torsional vibrations of wires* were , in millions of grammes weight per square centimetre , Brass , three specimens ... .
410'3 354'8 350'1 Copper , two specimens ... 448'7 448'4 .
Other specimens of copper in abnormal states gave results ranging from 393'4 to 472'9 .
The following Table contains the collected results of all my experiments , the figures I. , II .
, III .
indicating the paper in which the experiments are described and the results deduced .
The values of M , n , and k are given in millions of grammes weight per square centimetre. .
k ( Young 's mo(Rigidity ) .
( Resistance to ( Poisson 's Specific gravity .
dulus ) .
compression ) .
ratio ) .
Glass , flint ( I. ) 614-3 244*2 423'0 '258 2942 , , , , ( II .
) ... . .
58541 239'0 353.3 -229 2'935 Brass , drawn ( II .
) 1094'8 372'9 5701 ( ?
) '469 8'471 Steel ( II .
) ... ... . .
2179'3 834'1 1875'6 *310 7-849 Iron , wrought ( III .
) 1999'4 753'S 148441 *275 7677 , , cast ( III .
) .
1374 .
1 542'3 982'2 '267 7'235 Copper ( III .
) ... ... 1255'8 455'6 1716'4 *378 8.843 The values of M and n are derived directly from the observed amounts of flexure and torsion respectively , and their probable errors ( estimated as percentages ) may be considered equal .
Again , the comparison between flexure and torsion is so direct ( with the exception of M the first set of results for glass ) , that the probable error of M may be considered about equal to that of M or n. The values of a and k are deduced on the hypothesis that the substances operated on are isotropic ; and on this hypothesis , if e denote the probable error of M , the probable error of ' is 1 e , and that of k is 1+e nearly .
2 C ?
o ' .
For all the substances in the Table except brass , the value of the coefficient y- &lt; is from 5 to 11 , but for brass it is 47 ; hence the enormous value of k found for brass cannot be depended on .
The tendency of anything like fibrous structure in the rods operated on , the fibres being supposed to run in the direction of the length , is to make a and k come out too large .
This follows from the theoretical considerations adduced on page 152 of my last paper , and I have verified it by experiments on a rod of wood which gave values of T four or five times greater than those of F , whereas the ratio T for isotropic substances must always lie between 1 and 1'5 .
As the intention was expressed in my last paper of introducing a modification of the apparatus with the view of diminishing the mechanical correction , I should state by way of explanation that the experiments here described were nearly completed before that intention was expressed .

