On the Sextactic Points of a Plane Curve .
BY WILLIAM SPOTTISWOODE , i.A. , F.R.S. , &amp;c. Received June 15 , -Read June 15 , 1865 .
THE beautiful equation given by Professor CAYLEY ( Proceedings of the Royal Society , vol. xiii .
p. 553 ) for determining the sextactic points of a plane curve , and deduced , as I understand , by the method of his memoir " On the Conic of Five-pointic Contact " ( Philosophical Transactions , vol. cxlix .
p. 371 ) , led me to inquire how far the formulae of my own memoir " On the Contact of Curves " ( Philosophical Transactions , vol. clvii .
p. 41 ) were applicable to the present problem .
The formulae in question are briefly as follows : If U=O be the equation of the curve , H=0 that of its Hessian , and V=(a , b , c , f , g , h)(x , y , z)2=O that of the conic of five-pointic contact ; and if , moreover , a , 3 , y being arbitrary constants , 6=ax 4 y+yz , o =(yr ?
U-,3u)a , +(a &amp; u-yau)U+( , +(U-)a U-a ) , J then , writing as usual a , U== , byU=v , bzU==w ; baH=-p , 3yH=q , -a , H=r , a:u=u , ,. .
aau= .
a =. .
azH=p. .
( 2 ) _piltVl_g/ 2 ) .
( 2 ) { == --^v2W--U,. .
f=v'w'--uu',. .
vry-w= ?
=k , Wma-Uy=-p , u--w-v^ , the values of the ratios a : b : c : f : g : h are determined by the equations V= -0 , D EJV=0 , =03V0 , V=0 , D4-V .
( 3 ) Now , if at the point in question the curvature of U be such that a sixth consecutive point lies on the conic V , the point is called a sextactic point ; and the conrdition for this will be ( in terms of the above formulae ) 5-V=0 .
From the six equations V=0 , V= 0,. .
05V=0 , the quantities a , &amp; , c , f , g , h can be linearly eliminated ; and the result will be an equation which , when combined with U=0 , will determine the ratios x : y : z , the coordinates of the sextactic points of U. But the equation so derived contains ( beside other extraneous factors ) the indeterminate quantities a , 3 , y , to the degree 15 , which consequently remain to be eliminated .
Instead therefore of proceeding as above .
I eliminate a , , y beforehand , in such a way that ( W=0 representing any one of the series V==0 , V= 0,. .
from which ax , / , y have been already eliminated ) the equations W=0 , OW==0 , O2W=0 are replaced by axw yWWv a AWE awe uvw w=H ( 4 ) where z is a numerical factor , and A=(a 3 , 0 , e , ,)( )0 , , 3 )2 ?
... ..9 ( 5 ) To this preliminary transformation the first section of the paper is devoted * .
The second section contains the actual elimination of the constants of the conic , and the reduction of the resultant to six forms , =0 , if=0 , }=O , L'=0 , t'=0 , -'=0 ; of which t and t ' , t and W ' , g and j ' differ respectively only by one and the same numerical factor , viz. ( n-2)3 .
All these forms , however , contain extraneous factors , the determination of which is the object of the remainder of the paper .
The third section is devoted to the establishment of some formulae of reduction , the demonstrations of which are rather too long to be conveniently inserted in what would otherwise be their more natural place ( § 4 ) .
Besides these I have established many others of a like nature ; but the specimens here given will doubtless suffice to suggest the mode of proof of the rest to any one desirous of pursuing the subject further .
In the fourth section it is shown that all six forms,. .
t',. .
are divisible by the Hessian of U , and that X , L'are also divisible by tu , 41 , 4W by v3 , and R , Q ' by w3 , and that the result of these divisions is a single expression of the degree 12n-27 .
§ 1 .
Preliminary Transformation .
The first two equations of the system ( 3 ) are , as is well known , equivalent to the following , viz. av -av v 0 , --X V..V ( 6 ) uvw where 0 is indeterminate .
The third equation , viz. Dl2V=0 , when written in full , is 0= El V+ El D V+ ElZV++22V+T2^V+^V2 +2(^ , V+ V+ ) ( 7 ) o_== o xa vtVv yv+ 2a + V4ayV+ aa +2( 2 ayzy azV+ va zbzv+ pia , ayV ) .
, ( 7 ) Now n being the degree of U , we may without difficulty establish the following formulae given by CAYLEY ( 1 .
C. p. 381 ) : ( n)U2 B2+2f -y2 , ( nl)v2 X2 2 z-IZ ( n1)w2= y2 +2 ?
yX3X92 , ... ... ( 8 ) ( nl)vw= -J ; F2xyLxz + ~yz , ( n-1 )wu= - ?
yx+'-I0 yz x , ( n--l)vw= --zx-zy + z2 +z xy , o In a paper recently published in the 'Quarterly Journal of Mathematics , ' vol. vii .
p 114 , I have given a transformation having the same object in view ; but its form is partial and in some sense incomplete , and the mode of proof less direct and obvious than that given in the text .
whence writing =(a , b , c , f , g , h)( , , , y)2 ... .
( 9 ) we may derive ( n-1)x2 = -2g+ 2x(s +l+y)-x2 , ( n -1)Y2 =-3+2y(ka+ , + !
y)_ ( n-l)v , =-2 ; +26z(~+$a + ; t+zy)-22 * , ( n1)P= -2 ~+xZ(~ + $~ + ) ( ~l+ ~+ ~)-Yzx , ( -1 )Yv = _+24+Tr()+f f+sy)+y((cg+1j3+ ?
y ) -yZ , I ( nl)v=-_2 + y(ift +3 + l+y ) +Sx( +P +$y)--xyz .
, But , as will be found on calculating the expressions , ( n-1 ) 0D = ( 2A a+ -+@)-xd , 1 ( n1 ) O+=(+ Y3 + ) ) - , y ... ... ... ( 11 ) ( n-1)l)v =6(+a+p+Cyr)-z .
, J so that ( n1)2X2 =2 +2(n-l1)x OD +x2(I , ( -_1)2p2 =--23+2(--l)yO f +]Y .
( ~-l)2 =--26 +2(~-l ) Die +c , 2i , ( n-1)2v2 2=-2+2(n ... 1 ) .
( 12 ) ( -l)2 ) ' = , $+(n-l)( yOD+ z Op)+yza ' , ( n -1)2vx = 2$ +f(n--)(z )0 x+x0v )+zxz .
, ( n1)2x= -12 +(n-l)(x EOp+y D x)+xy .
Hence , if m be the degree of V , ( nl ) { ; v+ V+V V+2(p , V+ + x , V+ ^ V ) } =-2(2a , 3S , C , 6 , ( , )( , a , )2V+2(n1)(m1)( 46d , ,V+ ohyV+ d^ , V ) , whence , substituting in ( 7 ) , and bearing in mind that ( n-l)au+v+ @w)=H-x , ( n1):u+v v+fw)=Hy , .
( 13 ) ( n-l)Omu+fv+ ?
w)= Hz , we have ( n-l)2 ( l+ 2(m-1 ) ) ( E xav+ dbyV+ O , V ) , a , _2( , , , 1L)(6 , a , ' , )2v=0 .
But CDXa , V+ oDayv+ DvoaV=d(UfDX+vOP+wDv ) = , { ( aul +Wv+6 w)a + ( Ik +tv + , fW ) ( +.fv + ~CW)y } Oa2 H --(n1 ) 4 4x2 so that ( 7 ) finally takes the forms ( Pa , , , e , , el)(ai a , )2V_-(1+2. .
( 14 ) or , in the case where V is a conic , and consequently m=2 , n+l.( 2a+Jb+gc+2(J+f ++h)-2 n:H=O ; ... .
( 15 ) and in general making w =l+ ( _l ) ( 14 ) takes the form indicated above , viz. AV--wH=0 , or or ZV av zV a.v _.AV * ( 16 ) uvw wH 2 2 .
Elimination of the Constants of the Conic of Five-pointic Contact .
Before proceeding to the application of the formulae ( 16 ) to the investigation of the sextactic points , it will be convenient to premise that if s , t be any two homogeneous functions of x , y , z , the nature of the operation A is such that Ast=sAt+tAs+2(Iaj 3 , , fF , i , )(s , a , s , aS)( , b , t , t ) , .
( 17 ) and also that AV=-3HA , Au=p Av=q , Aw=r ... . .
( 18 ) This being premised , our first object is to establish an equivalent for OCV=O , divested of the extraneous quantities a , f , y. Now , since ( w , Vub , V)=y x V , ( ubyVa , V)=z V , and 0 =0 , it follows that D( v , VV-WbyV ) =X V+xO2V , D ( wa , VUbazV)-rPI V+ y 2V , no(uav- , Va)= v , V+ Z2V ; and consequently not only do vb , V-waBV , w6v-UbaV , uVbyV-v , V vanish with DV , but , when this is the case , CO(vVV--wbyV),. .
vanish with 02V .
The same will obviously be the case if the operation D be continued ; so that , in general terms , we may , by operating upon vbV-wayV,. .
with the symbol 0 , 0 , 1 , 2,. .
times , form a system of equations equivalent to that formed by operating on V with the same symbol 1 , 2 , 3,. .
times .
And if we represent any of the three quantities vB_V--wbyV,. .
by W , the equations W=0 , W-=0 , 02W==0 will be equivalent to the system a , XW_W ay w AWE uIvw -WH'. .
*. .
( 19 ) U --V W CT.iH9 ' ... analogous to ( 16 ) .
More generally , if A , uA wH'6 , A2-=v A-w-HSy , A3=--wA--H , , and if A ' stands for any of the three symbols A , , A2 , A3 , then the equations V=0 , V= 0 are equivalent to -b v=-Yv=-wav ; the equations 2V= 0 , 03V=0 are equivalent to -aA !
VJ_^ A'V=A'V .
a , Av ay v= wa Av .
Similarly , if Al " stands for any one of the symbols Al , A2 , A , , either the same as A ' or not , then 04V=0 , 05V=-0 are equivalent to U:V W ud , A A V=a , a/ av=2iwa+a=v , and so on indefinitely , for O2iV= 0 , D2i+-V=0 .
If the series should terminate with D2i=0 , e. g. O6V-0 , then the last equivalent would be A"'A"A'V0 , where A " ' stands , like A " , for any one of the symbols Al , A2 , As indifferently .
The form W , however , presents peculiar advantages for the application of the operations A , as will be more fully seen in the sequel .
And it follows from what has been said above that , if W retain the same signification as before , we may replace the equations W=0 , OW=0 ( and consequently the equations OV=0 , 02V=0 ) by 1a , ,w= ?
yw-= .
awe , uo *v ?
w OSK and in.the same way the equations D02W=0O , D3W=0 ( and consequently 03V=0 , 4V= 0 ) by 1i1i1 'a , W= vA , W= Alb , W , and so on .
I do not , however , propose on the present occasion to pursue the general theory further .
Returning to the problem of the sextactic points , and forming the equations in W ( 19 ) , we have b ( v aV-wa v)=-Ba(V a2v-WaV)=-'I 1 av vba(V av-wa_ v ) l hV W(uavu aV ) = a(wNTVwa , V)= w ( , w ) 5H A(wA , V-U a , v ) i ( 20 ) X 1 , ( .V-_ D , V ) =Ba , ( wba , Vb , V)=B(waz W ).a( , - ) ( 20 ) ~'( ~yv-vB"V ) A('1 2(n-i ) _ But since W is of the degree n , ia , =l-+ -3 .
Also since 5BV , ayV , b , V are linear in x , y , z , it follows that A , v=o 0 , Ayv=o0 , a'Zv=o ; hence , applying the formulae ( 17 ) , ( 18 ) , av.v==av+2(~. .
F. .
)( , 2 ')(w , w , dB , B BaV ) .
But since 2tw'+ILv , ++u'=0 , ?
w'+b3v , +u'=H , w'+jfv , +C1'=0 , it follows that Av6_-V=q--bV+ 2Hb6b_V .
Similarly , Aw3aV=rbAV+ 2Hb,3yV , so that ( 20 ) become rbav-p-av=---(v ' 3~v-u~bV+ 2wa-2ug )= ... .
( 21 ) 31H rbzV-pbz , V= ; B(xiV-u ' , %V+2w^-2m)=. .
7 23yV--q-V=--(u1V-w'ZN+ , V-2uh--2va)=. .
whence , multiplying byp , q , r respectively , and adding , we have 0=P u2 a , +2 puag w ' aYv qvh 4 ... . .
( 22 ) r v ' , aV rwg Substituting for b , V=du , byV=4v , B , V=dw , ( 22 ) becomes pu 2a--dO =0 ; qv 2h--w ' ... ( 23 ) rw 2g--v ' and writing vr-wq=X , wp--ur=Y , u-v-=Z , u , X+w'Y+v ' Z=P w'X+VIYY+u'Z=Q 1 ... .
( 24 ) v ' X+ ' Y+w1Z=R , j ( 23 ) takes the form 2(aX+hY+gZ)---P= 0 ; or finally substituting 2(ax+hy+gz)=dt , and forming similar equations in Q and R , we have the system a(UX-xP)+h(UY-yP)+g(uZ-zP)-0 h(v X--xQ)+ b(v Y--yQ)+g(v Z-zQ)=0 ... ( 25 ) g(wX-xR ) +f(wY--yR ) +c(wZ -zR)=O , J which may be regarded as the three forms by any one of which 03V=0 may be replaced .
Before proceeding further , it will be convenient to notice that the quantities uX--xP,. .
are capable of being transformed in a manner which will be useful hereafter , as follows : P= X- , x + ( ww ' v')px+ ( v'qw'r)ux =Xux + ( ww'-w')(3n2Hqy-rz ) ( v'q-w'r)(vy-wz ) =X( , x+w 'y + 'z ) + 3(2)H(ww'w ' ) = ( n1)uX + 3(n2)H(ww'-w ' ) , e. i. e. -uX+xrP=(n-2){uX-3H(w ' -ww ' ) } -uY+yP=(n-2){Y-3H(wj , -uv ' ) } ***** * And as , it ' differ only in respect of a numerical factor , any other factor that can be predicated of L may be affirmed of Z ' , and vice versed ; and similarly for the other pairs , fl ' ; a^ , ' § 3 .
Formulce of Reduction .
The degree of the expressions ( 28 ) or ( 29 ) is 18n36 ; it remains to show that existence of certain extraneous factors , which when divided out will reduce the degree to 12n-.27 , and at the same time render the three forms identical .
But before entering upon this , it will be convenient to premise the following formulae , the first group of which are easily verified .
yZ-zY = 3(n-2 ) Hue zX-xZ =3(n-2)Hv xY-yX= 3(n-2)Hw ybZ za , Y = ( 3n7)uq -(n-l- ) up + 3(n--2)Hw ' yaaZ so , Y =(3n 7)ur ( n l)wp + 3(n -2)Hvl zX--xabZ =(3n-7 ) up -(n-l1)uq +3(n-2)Hw ' zx , X-xa , Z =(3n7)vq -(n-l)v +3(n-2)Hvl zbX--x , Z -(3n7)vr -(n-1)wq+3(n2)Hu ' x3a , Y -ybX:= ( 3n7)wp -(n-l)ur + 3(n-2)Hv ' xaY -yayX=(3n-7)wq-(n-1)vr +3(n-2)Hu ' xazY -yazX=(3n-7)wr -(n-l)wr + 3(n-2)Hw , .
And writing -P =Xp , +Yr ' +Zq ' ] -Q , =Xr'+Yq , +z'. .
( 32 ) -R1E=Xq'+Y'+Zrl , j then also Ya , Z-ZaY=--(P P+UP ) Z aX-X a , Z=-(P + up , ) X , Y-Y ?
X=-(rP+wPr , ) Y ?
, Z--Zb , Y= -(pQ+uQ , ) ZaX-X--XyZ=-(gQ+vQ , ) XbaY-YBX=--(rQ+wQj ) ( 33 ) Ya , Z-ZaY==-(PR +uRI ) Z6 , x-xa z Z=-(qR+vR , ) X ?
, Y-YbX=-(rR+wRj ) , Moreover , writing with Professor CAYLEY , ( 1 , ?
, ,$ , 0 , ~)(@ , Xa , y az)H= i , Qu=(a , , c5 , , , ~)( , ( a , az ) ?
, a2 , u-. .
, , =* .
( 34 ) LA1i=(a , L , B , a , ; , a , , a. )(a , ax , ) H , aH=..* a , H= .
, and noticing that Xa,2~u+Y , Qu+Za2u=Jac .
( U , H ) , ... . .
( 35 ) and that AX= va Qua-wbyu 1 'AY = w3uj-M2uQzur.(36 ) AZ = ztayQuvaQ , u , I then we have YAZ -Z AY=u Jac , ( U , H , Qu ) yAZ -zAY=(5n-12)Q2u 1Z AX-XAz =v Jac. ( U , HI , Q ) zAX-xAZ =(5n-12)v. .
( 37 ) XAY -YAX=w Jac. ( U , H , Qu2 ) xAY -yAX-(5n--12)Qw .
Again , if 't , ' , 0 ' , I ' , C ' , , ' be the same quantities with respect to H that a , X3 , ; , If , 0 , ?
are with respect to U , i. e. if a'=q , r-p',. .
Fl'q'r'-plp ' , and if =(a " , ' , t , ' , f ' , a ' , V')(u , W,. .
( 38 ) q_=(a , 5 , ?
, , T , )(p , q , r)2 , then u , a Y , ,Z=Jac .
( u , Y , Z , )=u , 1V pr+wp , -uq ' u1 , -w p+ur ' -Vp , w ' ayY ?
aZ w ' u''p-w'r+wr'--up ' wq--v1p+ul-vr ' v1 ' bY azZ v ' wip-v ' r+wq'-ur , v1 gq-up-+up-P-vg ' =Hp2 =Hp2-2Qp_+(p + ?
r +()p1b =Hp2-Qpl+3n 7H2+ tU -(Lr ' +431 +JIfp')pu ( L ?
p +( 3r ' +r q+ ' )pv +( ?
P , +- ' +fq')pv +(@p , +'I + ?
' )pw +(@g ?
1 +Ifr + ?
q')wp +( + u,1 + 'W'+ &amp; v'v)u2 +( &amp; u , + fw ' + &amp; t')wu + ( u1 1+3wS1 ' +fV')uv +(X@1 +LU'w ' + &amp; VF)U`2 + ( TU1 +)3'W ' +IfV)uV Similarly , Jac. ( , Z , X)=--u u1q-wp+ur'-vp2 w'r-v ' q-+vq ' -wr ' w ' w'g-vlpp+ uq- ' vr -u ' g+vp'wp1 v ' ' q--'p+up'-vq ' u'r-w1q+vr1--wp ' 3n-7 = Hpq =Hpl-Qpvv--(pr ' +il ?
1+ p')up =Hp-Q-pv+ , v+ -Hpq -( &amp; ' +fjp ' +gr , )rvp ( Ir ' + 1p , +p')uq +v , ; VP3ZUtytul j +(@r ' +fg1 + ?
pt )wp ( @r ' +fq1+ ?
p')ur -( &amp; @r +Iq1 +p ' )ur +(V , +Lq1+@P')up -(r ' +33q , +$( ' , )u +(r ' +3q+p ' ) up + ( alul +T+ 'v')uv + ( r ' +( fq , ++ p')wp +(_p ?
+fr ' +Lq ' )vr +(ai_ +r ' +@ ')pv +(kpi +13r ' +fq ' )vq +(p1+r ' ++fq')qv + ( Oolu + 3'w ' + , ' , V)v2 + ( olp ++r+ q'2)rv + ( 'D +$ , f'w + Cv')v w+ va o Hence 4(n--2 ) Jac. ( u , Y , Z ) H4(n H2 -(2Qp-3 u)+ 4(n-2 ) 4(n2 ) Jac. ( u , Z , X)H -(QPe , Q+)u Jac. ( b , X , Y ) 4 ) Hpr-(Qp-2 bO , u)w+lwxlTu-6uz%l*u 4(n-2 ) Jac. ( w , Y , Z ) l Hrp -(Qr-u(Q+-4lu -l w3 Jac. ( w , Z , X ) =4n-2)Hr -(Qr^ ?
u)v+^9^-lw^ Jac. ( w , X , Y ) =4( ) Hr2 -(Qfr--o ?
u)w.Again , 4(n--_2 ) Jac. ( w , Y , Z)yJac .
( , Z)+zJac .
( w , Y So )=(+ l)Jac .
( U , Y , ; Jac. ( W , Z , X ) 4 ( n Hrq ( f2r -2)b ou)v + IVB zI VY'b u 4(n~ Hrf--(9 ) r2--~b~ov)vz , Jac. ( w , X , y)4n-I ) Again , x Jac. ( ?
, Y , Z ) +y Jac. ( v , Y , Z)+z Jac. ( w , Y , Z)=(n1 ) Jac. ( U , Y , Z ) ; whence , bearing in mind that X u+yayu + zb , u=2(3n7)-u , aeOj+yO+a , OU-=2(n1)u , , because in the differentiations X , ... A',. .
are supposed constant , it follows that 1T2(n-2)2 +V 3nl -7 , _3(n-2 ) H2+ 1 Jac. ( U , Y , Z)= 2(n-2)2 p+ { L-n-- ) HQ+ 12(n-2)2 ^ i3n-7 .
3(n-2 ) Jac. ( U , , Z , X)= ( n1^2-H2(+ n2 ) Hi2-}v. .
( 40 ) 12(n-2 ) H J3n 7 s3(n 2 ) Jac. ( U , X , Y)= ( n- ) r+ { 3n-7p n-- ) + w. Again , u , abTY B , Z=u , v'p-u , r+wp , -uq ' t , q-w'p+ur ' -v2p w ' ByY byZ wI u~p -Uw'rr+ ?
w ' -up ' w'r-v , p +uq , --vr ' V ' bY b , Z v ' w , p-v'r+wq'-ur , v'q --u6p +Up-'-vqI p2H ( 3r ' + 32S + fp')up + ( &amp; +1 + fJw'+ Cv )wu +(@pi +JcF ' + q ' )w+( ' +'w ' ++Wf )U2 -( &amp; ' +jfp'+ ?
rj)up + ( %fiu +'3w ' +jf'v')Uv +( ?
pi+ &amp; r ' + ; fjq')vp H +2 n-p H--up+( ' .
* " * The resultant equation which , when combined with that of the original curve , will determine the sextactic points , was exhibited in § 2 under six different , forms , there designated by E=0 , l=0 , =0 , '==O , 1=01O , '=0 .
Iow since t and K ' , 41 and 'J , gs and ' respectively differ only by the numerical factor ( n2)3 , we shall , in seeking to discover the extraneous factors , employ either,. .
or 'f,. .
as most convenient for the purpose .
And in the first place it will be shown that H is a factor of all these expressions .
Putting H =0 , L ' becomes a , UX a " , Y -uZ u =0 ; Y~uX y~uY , byuZ v 0aeX bauY 3buZ w AuX AtY AuZ z2NH AuX=pX+uAX+2HMX1 AtY =pY +uAY + 2Hb , Y AmZ =pZ +uZ +2Hb , Z ; ... .
( 43 ) ... ... ( 44 ) so that the above equation , .
written in full , is l , X +u aX w'X +U0byX v'X +utaX pX +uAX+2H0 , X u , Y +u , Y w'Y +ttayY v'Y +ut , Y pie +uAY+2Hb , Y u , Z +ua , Z w'Z + u , yz v'Z +- ?
, Z pZ +uAZ+2HD_Z Although this expression contains terms explicitly multiplied by H , which might on the present supposition be omitted , it will still perhape worth w behile to develope it completely .
Expanding in the usual way , it becomes.2SX it , B , vi aZm + tie Y , ,Z Xt +tt2Z u , 0 , X 0Y , w ' yY ayz v w ' , z ayX v w'bX , Y v v ?
0 , Y bzZ w v ' b , Z a , X w v ' a , X aY wp AY AZ2H AZ AX Z , XH p AX AY 2rH +u03 bX a , XY b , Z u , aX , aY byZ 0 , X a9Y b , Z w AX AY AZ VH +H u , X+ ub , X w'X+uayX *2 , uYly+u-Y w'Y+--kubY v ' Y+ukY 20BY also Vvw zD,2H .
w'lZ+a , yZ v ' Z+t-3-Z 2b , ,Z UV w0 In this the coefficient of -p =aX zaxY-Yaxz U +a ayx zayY-YaZ v a , d , a Za , YYd , Z wb ==^{^ , X+ ?
^Y +r , Z PU payX+ ?
qY+rbyZ Qv piSX+NoY+rw3Z Rw Now ry X-azZZX U vi Xb3'Z-Zd3X V lxy X~ , ZZ6 , X w +)xz 3'6 +ua , Xx+vb , Y+w3axZ P , uayX+vaYY+wDZ Q , Uz ?
X+vbzY+wbZZ R , YaxX-XaZY ; } Ybzx-xbyY w u}=P1 PUv Q , Qvw RI R w. v W ' QI w ' Rt u w ' P1 , { x(P , +fQ , iQ+CR , )--z([P+-Q , +-R , ) } V Vt Q , W tl RI u v ' P , =-n-1 { y(.APl+ , Q Q , +R , )-x( ?
Pl+3QI + , jR1 , ) } v t ' Qi Wt W , RI ; so that multiplying these equations by X , Y , Z respectively , and adding , 1uP P , = n_{(0 P , +QI +R , )(yZ-zY ) vq Q , +(PI , +tSQ , +fR , )(zX-xZ ) , w R R , + ( ( P1 +fQ , -+-CR,1)(xY-yXX ) }= -I 2)H { ~++ ev w)P , + ( u+ ~3v+ fo)QU +( U+b +J ; , +Iw)V , } 3(n 2 ) = 3(n_I2 H2(P z+ Qly + R , z ) 3(n-2)(3n 7)(Xpyq Zr ) =0 .
( 45 ) Hence the whole expression =U 2{u , u Ya , Z-Za Y a , X+ -u u Za , X-X , Z , Y+uu xaYY-Yc w ' v YayZ-ZayY byX w ' v ZayX-xayZ 'yY w ' v XbaY-Yi v ' w Yb , Z--Z3Y ?
aX v ' w Za , X--X , Z xY v ' w XaY--Y H2H YAZ-ZAY AX .
2H ZAX-XAZ AY.,2H XAY-Y , +.au3X a , Y a , Z bYX byY byZ v d , X a , Y d , Z w AX AY AZ,2H ; ax b , z } yX byz a , x a , z AX AZ or in virtue of ( 33 ) , =U'2{u , u --(pP+uPI ) bX+~u , u -(qP+vP , ) a , Y+u , M -(rP+wP , ) b , Z } w ' v -(pQ+uQ , ) b , x w ' v -(qQ+vQ , ) ?
, Y w ' -(rQ+wQ , ) bZ v ' w --(pR+uR , ) a , X v ' w -(qI+vR , ) LIE v ' W -(rR+wR , ) a , Z 2Ha Jac.(U , H , Qu ) AX .
, Hv Jac.(U , H , 2Q ) AY .
w2H wJac .
( U , H , f2 ) AZ +u3 aX a , Y saz ' byX a , Y b , Z v z.X baY azZ w AX AY AZ ZW'H =2'a22H ul P1 P +u2 Jac. ( U , H , Q ' , ) a , l zP+ U2 Jac. ( U , H , Qu ) u , 'a P +U3 bX ax Y , Z w ' w ' QQ w'v Q w'v Q byX yY byZ v v ' RI R v ' wR v ' wR abX b , Y b , Z w AX AY AZ 2H .
But u , P , P =Z(PP , + 3Q , +4fR , )--Y(@P , +I , FQI + R , ) w ' Q , Q v ' Ri R =U(2 b ?
F j ?
)(p q r)(PiQiR , )-p(A 3C Jf ( 1)(u v w)(P , Q , R , ) since =u(w 1Sfa )(p g r)(P , Q1R , ) , ( 2 B( Jf ?
)((U , v , w)P , Q , RI)= n1H(P , x+Q , y+R , z)=O , also ( a Bcf j ?
)(P , Q1R1 ) = ( a..)(p q r)(pl r ' V)X +(a..)(p q r)(r ' q p')Y +(a..)(p r)(H ' p ' r , )Z = Jac. ( U , H , qu ) .
Hence the whole expression above written L , X..u =2u3 Jac. ( U , H , ')+ 3( 1H Jac. ( U , H , Qlu)}H+u3 'X. .
v But BAX ?
~Y i , Z Hu-(n-1 ) Jac. ( U , H ) , y X ?
yY b , Z v baX bzY bZ w AX AY AZ and ax a , Y b , Z =Jac .
( U , H , tu)Jac .
( U , H , Ou ) .
, bX ZyY y , Z a , X , aY a , Z Hence , finally , the whole expression [ 6(n-2 ) 12(n-2)\ =u H{ Jac. ( U , , )+ --l ) I Jac. ( U , H , 2()(,2 Jac. ( U , H , Q)Ja ( 4 ) -u-H{ I ( Jac. ( U , H , TP)Jac .
( U , H , ou))6(n-2 ( n-3 ) , H ) which is therefore divisible by HU3 .
Consequently H is a factor of all the expressions X,. .
'. .
, which was to be proved .
Although not absolutely necessary to our argument , it is perhaps worth while to show , as may readily be done , that ]L is divisible by u. Omitting the terms explicitly multiplied by u in the first three columns , the equation becomes t , X--aXP u , Y--D6yP u , Z-zP u =0 .
w'X-P w'Y-yyP w'ZazP v* ( 47 ) ' X--axP v ' Y--yP v'Z--zP wIp X--AxP+2H , X p Y-AyP+2H1a Yp Z-AzP+2Ha , Z w , H In this the coefficient of zwH , P=(Yz-Zy ) w'o IP +P(Zx-Xz ) v'aP +P(Xy-Yx ) uI aP I vz P u. , aP w ' aP + P2(@UX+w'Y+v'Z)P2(xr , P+yayp + z-P ) -3 , which , writing K=u u , aP v w ' .
yP w v ' 32P = -2)(3 K+ 5r)P .
Similarly , it will be found that the coefficients of ( pXAxP+2H , X ) ( pie AyP +2H , ,Y ) ( pZ -Az P+2H , Z ) are -(n-2)(3HK+5P2)u , -(n-2)(3HK+5P2)v , -(n-2)(3HK+5P2)w respectively ; and consequently the whole expression ( n2)(3HK+5P2 ) { ( pXAxP + 2HX)u +( pie AyP +2 H , Y)v +(pZ -AzP+2H2 , Z)w +-HP } =-(n-2)(3HK+5P2 ) { -2HP--2(..)(u , v , w)( , P , byP , azP ) + THP } =-(n-2)(3HK+5P2 ) -2(n--I 2 ) +,2 HP .
But ~=1 -10(n2-2 ) But w2=l+ 1( n-2 ) so that the above expression =(n-2)(3HK +P2)HP .
Now -(n-2)(3HK+P2)=m vw nU u , w ' v ' ( n1)(u u ) pqr 3(n-2)H a , P ayP az 5(n-2)P =U Uw xu +yv +z 'U w ' vI Xul +yw ' +zv ' -(n-l)u .
( 48 ) pqr xp +yq +zr aP byP azP.xaXP+SP+zyP+ P =--(n--l)u fu S , P up _ , P vq byP wr aP ; j so that the whole expression is divisible by u. Similarly , it might be shown that M , or M ' is divisible by v , and N or N ' by w. It follows from what has gone before that L , TL , , , ' , ^ [ ' , Q ' are all divisible by H , that L , I ' are divisible by u , '1 , W ' by v , ^ , ^ ' by w , and consequently dividing out those factors , the three expressions L , 4J[ , 4 are of the form Au2 +B1 +C= O , Av2 +B2v+C=O , ... ..(49 ) Aw2 + B3+ C3=0 , in which the coefficients of uz2 , v2 , w2 are the same , viz. the expressions given in ( 46 ) .
From these equations it follows that B , u+C B v+C2_ B3w + C3 ( 60 ) u2 V w2 But as t , v , w do not in general vanish simultaneously , these relations can hold good only in virtue of B , being divisible by u , and C , by U2 ; B2 by v , and C2 by v2 ; B3 by w and C3 by w2 .
Whence , finally , L is divisible by Hu ' , 4 by Hv3 , A by Hw3 ; and he degree of the equation is reduced to ( 18n-36)3(--2)-3(n--1)=12n-27 .
Also , since the ratios ( Bju+Ct ) : u2 , ( B2v+C2 ) : 2 , ( B3w+C3 ) : w2 ere in virtue of ( 50 ) equal ( say =B ) , it follows that X , 1 , ^ , , , ^ ' all lead to the same result , viz. A+B =0 , which it was our object to prove .

