On the Sextactic Points of a Plane Citrve .
By A. CAYLEY , F.R.S. Received November 5 , -Read December 22 , 1864 .
IT is , in my memoir " On the Conic of Five-pointic Contact at any point of a Plane Curve"* , remarked that as in a plane curve there are certain singular points , viz. the points of inflexion , where three consecutive points lie in a line , so there are singular points where six consecutive points of the curve lie in a conic ; and such a singular point is there termed a " sextactic point .
' The memoir in question ( here cited as former memoir " ) contains the theory of the sextactic points of a cubic curve ; but it is only recently that I have succeeded in establishing the theory for a curve of the order m. The result arrived at is that the number of sextactic points is =sm(12nm-27 ) , the points in question being the intersections of the curve m with a curve of the order 12v--27 , the equation of which is ( 12n.2-54m+57)H Jac. ( U , H , Q ) +(m2)(12m-27 ) HJac .
( U , H , lu ) +40(m--2)2 Jac. ( U , H , ,k )=0 , where U=O is the equation of the given curve of the order m , H is the Hessian or determinant formed with the second differential coefficients ( a , b , c , f , g , h ) of U , and , ( I , 33 , C , f , ( , % ) being the inverse coefficients ( A=bc--f2 , &amp;c. ) , then Q=(2 , X , ?
3 , M , , X , ba , b )2H , *=(I , 3 , ; , X , fba .
H , YH , BZH)2 ; and Jac. denotes the Jacobian or functional determinant , viz. Jac. ( U , H , b)= ; Ub U , U ablU , baH , aH , H , H baH4 , aye , a , b ~ and Jac. ( U. H , 12 ) would of course denote the like derivative of ( U , H , 2Q ) ; the subscripts ( f , u ) of 1Q denote restrictions in regard to the differentiation of this function , viz. treating Q2 as a function of U and H , =Q=(S , 3I , C , , ' , c ' , f ' , 2f ' , 2 .
' , , 22 ' ) , if ( a ' , 1/ , c ' , f , g ' , I ' ) are the second differential coefficients of H , then we have Q=-(a,. .
X a',. .
) ( = arz ) +(,. .
3a'. .
) ( =a , BQ ) ; viz. in A2iQ we consider as exempt from differentiation ( a ' , b ' , ' , fJ g1 ' , I ) which depend upon H , and in cb , uQ we consider as exempt from differentiation ( q5 , 3 , f ; , 9 @ , L ) which depend upon U. We have similarly ayQ= ByQH +ay , and a Q=_afQ +bauI ; and in like manner Jac. ( U , H , Q)= Jac. ( U , H , QH , )+Jac .
( U , H , Q ) , which explains the signification of the notations Jac. ( U , H , Q2 ) , Jac. ( U , H , Qf ) .
The condition for a sextactic point is in the first instance obtained in a form involving the arbitrary coefficients ( x , pi , v ) ; viz. we have an equation of the order 5 in ( x , p , v ) and of the order 12m-22 in the coordinates ( x , y , z ) .
But writing 3=x-x+ Pie +-z , by successive transformations we throw out the factors a2 , ) , , , thus arriving at a result independent of ( X , p , v ) ; viz. this is the before-mentioned equation of the order 12m-27 .
The difficulty of the investigation consists in obtaining the transformations by means of which the equation in its original form is thus divested of these irrelevant factors .
, Article Nos. 1 to 6.--Investigation of the Conditionfor a Sextactic Point .
1 .
Following the course of investigation in my former memoir , I take ( X , Y , Z ) as current coordinates , and I write T=(*xX , Y , z)=0O for the equation of the given curve ; ( x , y , z ) are the coordinates of a particular point on the given curve , viz. the sextactic point ; and U , =((xy , y , Z)m , is what T becomes when ( x , y , z ) are written in place of ( X , Y , Z ) : we have thus U=O as a condition satisfied by the coordinates of the point in question .
2 .
Writing for shortness DU -(X)+YU+Zz ) u , D2U ( xab+YL3 +Z3 , )2U , and taking HIIaX+bY+cZ=O for the equation of an arbitrary line , the equation D2U-I1DUO is that of a conic having art ordinary ( two-pointic ) contact with the curve at the point ( x , y , z ) ; and the coefficients of TI are in the former memoir determined so that the contact may be a five-pointic one ; the value obtained for II is 1= : DH+ ADIEU , where A= --(3QH+4 , ) .
3 .
This result was obtained by considering the coordinates of a point of the curve as functions of a single arbitrary parameter , and taking x+d + d2x +dx + +a*d4x , y+ &amp;c. , z &amp;c. for the coordinates of a point consecutive to ( x , y , z ) ; for the present purpose we must go a step further , and write for the coordinates x+dXl-d2x dsx+-d'l X+-jd 5 y+ die + d2y+d3y +d 4Y+214 d5d , z+ dz +12z + d'yz + -1d4z +-i dz .
4 .
Hence if a , =dxb^ +-dybys+q-dzb , , b , =d2x q-+dxyy y dazb , , &amp;c. , we have , in addition to the equations bU-0O , d , U=O , + 624u=ao , ( b~+2B , )U o , ( a+3a , a , +a , )u=0 , ( a4+Ba2a+^)U=03+3 , +a4)U-o , ( 1+6c2+4e1e , +s3e+e4)U=0 , of my former memoir , the new equation ( a+loa10a , + 0loa ?
a3+1s5S+5sa5l4+10b2a3+a5)u=o , and in addition to the equations , ( P=ax+by+cz ) , ( m-2)36U+P .
12U =0 -[(m-l)a+ 3(m-2)a6 , a2]U+P .
( a3 +3a ; a , )u+aP .
aZu=o , -1[(m-1)(Of + 6s32 ) + ( m2)(4ea3+ 3 ; )]U +P.--4 ( a + 6al2 + 4 , a 3+ )U+-alP .
( a + 3aa12)U+ -aP .
a2u=o , giving in the first instance P=2(m2 ) , P=-_3 aaUI auu ap_ .
( a4+6la2)U a a(--.+3)al ) a -2 alU 9"~aU ~]U and leading ultimately to the before-mentioned value of HI , we have the new equation -T-l [ ( m-l)(a5+l10^ , t+10 ?
a 3+l5s-12)+(2)(5334+10623)]U + P. io(a+Sloaa+loa0a , +15a +5sa , a+loa03 ) u+ blP.2 ( a-+ -6aa24a1a3+ 3a2)u +_j , P. P ( S3+ 3 , -a2)U +a3 , P. i a2u=o .
This may be written in the form 2[(n-l)(a 10+10a3 + I1a23+15a , a5 +( m-1 22)(saa+0oaa3)]u + P( +lo+b , +oa13+15oala2 +5s,4+1boa3 ) u+ 5o6P( o4+ 6 -f , + 4a13 + 32)U +1oa2P( aI+ 3aa2)U +10oaP( a2u ) o ; or putting for P its value , =2(n--2 ) , the equation becomes 2(a5+loaba , + 1oaa3+saRb3)u + 5-aP(34+ 6a2+ 42 13+ 3a2 )U +102P(a+ 3aa12)U +10.3P .
b2U= ; or , as this may also be written , 2(a +loaa2+loa a3+15saa2)u +5b1P.b4U+10b2P.Y3U +103P.b2U=0 .
6 .
But the equation H=I HDH+ ADIEU , which is an identity in regard to ( X , Y , Z ) , gives a , P=3aH , 1 62P= 3 - , H H+ AZ , U2 , Z3p= 32 Z33H+A3U ; and substituting these values , the foregoing equation becomes 2(ao+ loa,3+lo+12a3+j5lsa2)U +(5a , Ua , H+103 , Ua2H + 10dU23H ) ? ?
3 +A .
20a2UU= ; or putting for A its value , =-y(3QH+4T ) , and multiplying by 9H2 this is 9H2( + oaa10 2+10 oa 3+ 5lsa )u + 15H ( a , ua H+2a3Ua2H + 2D2Ub3H ) +H ( -3QH + 4 ) .
10D2U3U=O0 , which is , in its original or unreduced form , the condition for a sextactic point .
Article Nos. 7 &amp; 8.-Notations and Remarks .
7 .
Writing , as in my former memoir , A , B , C for the first differential coefficients of U , we have By -C( , Cx-Av , A( h-Bx for the values of dx , die , dz , and instead of the symbol ) used in my former memoir , I use indifferently the original symbol a , , or write instead thereof a , to denote the resulting value 1 , ( = )=(BYC()kS+(Cx-Av)}y+(ABh)d and I remark here that for any function whatever E2 , we have -Q= A , B , C =Jac .
( U , a , Q ) , X , ?
, v 3 , Q , byQ , bQ where ==--x+ pie +-z .
I write , as in the former memoir , i &gt; =(t , , a , , , px , )2 ; and also V=( , ( , 3 , , J , ( , x ) , Ya , a , a , ) , which new symbol V serves to express the functions 1I , O , occurring in the former memoir ; viz. we have II=2Vq ) , O =2VH , so that the symbols II , O are not any longer required .
8 .
I remark that the symbols a , V are each of them a linear function of ( 6 , , ay , 'X ) , with coefficients which are functions of the variables ( x , y , z ) ; and this being so , that for any function II whatever , we have a(VII)= ( .
v)n +VIIn , viz. in b(VFJ ) we operate with V on II , thereby obtaining VII , and then with a on VII ; in ( .
V)II we operate with b upon V in so far as V is a function of ( x , y , z ) , thus obtaining a new operating symbol a.V , a linear function of ( b , , by , a , ) , and then operate with a.V upon II ; and lastly , in aVII , we simply multiply together a and V , thus obtaining a new operating symbol aV of the form ( a , ay , ,)2 , and then operate therewith on Il ; it is clear that , as regards the last-mentioned mode of combination , the symbols a and V are convertible , or bV=V_ , that is , aVII==VaH .
It is to be observed throughout the memoir that the point ( .
) is used ( as above in a. V ) when an operation is performed upon a symbol of operation as operand ; the mere apposition of two or more symbols of operation ( as above in dV ) denotes that the symbols of operation are simply multiplied together ; and when bV is followed by a letter HI denoting not a symbol of operation , but a mere function of the coordinates , that is in an expression such as bVI , the resulting operation 2V is performed upon II as operand ; if instead of the single letter TI we have a compound symbol such as HUE or HVa , so that the expression is bHU , aHV7 , aVHU or aVHVS- , then it is to be understood that it is merely the immediately following function H which is operated upon by a or 6V ; in the few instances where any ambiguity might arise a special explanation is given .
Article Nos. 9 to 11.-First Transformation .
9 .
We have , assuming always U=-0 , the following formulae ( see post , Article Nos. 31 to 33):(a 5+ 36+1l0B4 3+15-l , -2)u ( 1)4 { ( 27 2e-96m1+ 81)H e+ ( 17M2-_56 m+51)I)PH } 3 + , m-1 ) { ( -1422)( .
V)H~ -(10on-18 ) VH } a4 -=-( -y { ( 6n2+18n2-12)IPB +(-1 -617n 260m-55)HD)H }+ ( m_1)4 { ( 2m-2)H(b .
V)H +(8m-16)bHVH } ~4 +(m1=l)4 { ~-QH } , BUb3 u--4 H3H .
2 UD3U= ( m1)4 10 .
And by means of these the condition becomes 0= ( mI)4 { ( 153m2-594m-+549)HDII +(-102m2+396m+366)qPH } +(m { ( 96m+168)H( .
V)H+(-90im+162)HbVH+(120mn-240)aH7VH } +(m-4{9H2bQ-45mHm2H+40*Hj } , being , as already remarked , of the degree 5 in the arbitrary coefficients ( k , p , v ) , and of the order 12n-22 in the coordinates ( , y , ) .
11 .
But throwing out the factor 9 , and observing that in the first line the quadric functions of m are each a numerical multiple of 51m2-198+183 , the condition becomes 0= ( 51m2--198m+183)H2(3H &lt; )--24 &gt; 3TH ) +s { ( --96qm+168)H2(a .
V)H+(90m+162)Ha2bVH+(120m-w-240)HIIH } + 2{ 9H2a-f1 45fHQbtI+40PTH } .
Article Nos 12 &amp; 13.-Second transformation .
12 .
We effect this by means of the formula ( m-2)(3Ha4 &gt; -20aH)= Jac. ( U , 1E , H),. .
( J ) , for substituting this value of ( 3H1c-2cI35H ) the equation becomes divisible by ; and dividing out accordingly , the condition becomes 5 1m2-198m + 183 .
( , --112 Jac. ( U , ) , 11 ) +(96m+168)HW(a .
V)H +(90.m+162)H2aVH+(120in240)HaHVH + S(9H2Q45HQH + 40T'H)=0 .
13 .
aWe have ( see post , Article Nos. 36 to 40 ) Jac. ( U , ) , )=-(a .
V)H ; and introducing also a. VH in place of bVH by means of the formula bVH=Ia(VH)-(a .
V)H , the condition becomes 5 l2-198m 83(Gm~----a-2 ( 6.m-6 , H ) 2 ( a. V)H + ( -90m + 162)H2a(VH ) +120(m2)HaHVH +-[(9 H2 Q-451HQa H+40THra)O , or , as this may be written , ( 45n2180+ 7l)H2( .
V)H + ( 90om+ 1 62)(m2)H2a ( v)+ 120(m2)21HVH +(m2)-(9aH2Q 2-45HQH+40tH)=0 .
Article Nos. 14 to 17.-Third transformation .
14 .
We have the following formulae , Jac. ( U , VH , H)-(5m-ll)bHVH+(3m-6)H(VH)=0 , ... .
( J ) Jac. ( U , V , H)H--(2m--4 )IHVHI +(3m-6)H(b .
V)H=0 , ... .
( J ) in the latter of which , treating V as a function of the coordinates , we first form the symbol Jac. ( U , V , H ) , and then operating therewith on H , we have Jac. ( U , V , H)H ; these give 5m-51 H3(VH)= 3( ) H-Jac .
( U , VH , H ) , 3(m-2 ) H(b V.)HI= ]0HVH-3(m-2 ) Jac.(U , V , H)H ; and substituting these values , the resulting coefficient of HbHVH is ( 452 --180m+171)2 +(-90m+162 ) 5m+120( m-2)2 , which is =0 .
Hence the condition will contain the factor 3 , and throwing out this , and also the constant factor , it becomes m-2 ( -15m2+-60m-57)HJac.(U , V , H)H +(30m-54)(m -2 ) HJac .
( U , VII , H ) + ( 2)2(9H2 fZQ-45HQ2H + 40 , TH ) = 0 .
16 .
We have.a , ( VH ) =( , .
V)H + WVH , viz. in ( , .
V)H , treating V as a function of ( x , y , z ) we operate upon it with Z , to obtain the new symbol 9a .
V , and with this we operate on H ; in a , V we simply multiply together the symbols a , and V , giving a new symbol of the form ( a2 , jby ) , aB3 ) which then operates on H. We have the like values of a ( V7H ) and a ( VH ) ; and thence also Jac. ( U , VH , H)= Jac. ( U , V , H)H+ Jac. ( U , VH , H ) , viz. in the determinlant Jac. ( U , V , H ) the second line corresponding to V is 'b .
V , aby. .
V ( V being the operand ) ; and the Jacobian thus obtained is a symbol which operates on H giving Jac. ( U , V , H)H ; and in the determinant Jac. ( U , VH , H ) the second line is VIVH , a , VH , ZV7H ( V being simply multiplied by a. a b , y , respectively ) .
17 .
Substituting , the condition becomes ( -15n2 + 60Gm-57 )H Jac. ( U , V , H)1 +(30m--54)(m 2){H Jac. ( U , V , H)H + Jac. ( U , VHI , H ) } + ( m2)2 { 9H2Q-54HQH-H+40TH}-=0 , or , what is the same thing , ( 15mn2-54m+51)HJac .
( U , V , H)11 +(30m-54)(m--2)H Jac. ( U , VH , H ) +(m-2)2{9IH22Q-45HQ2 H+4Ot H } =0 .
Article Nos. 18 to 27.-FourthI transformation , and final form of the condition for a Sextactic Point .
18 .
I write ( 5m,12)Q H(3z--6)HIa2= )Jac.(U , Q , H ) ( MQH+ HSQ= a(QHn ) , and , introducing for convenience the new symbol W , -5-aH+ H3Q=W , so that 5m--12 , -(3m--6 ) , h Jac. ( U , Q , H ) =0 , 1 , 1 , a.QH -5 , 1 , W or what is the same thing , ( 8nm18)W+62 Jac. ( U , Q , H)+(10nz-18)s(QH)=0 , we have W=HQ-5bH 5 I= 4m 9 Jac.(U , Q , H)5m-9(QH ) 19 .
We have also ( 8m-18)tabH-(3nm-6)H lTJac .
( U , , H)=O , ... . .
( J ) that is n tH 4-2 9 mJac .
( U , 'P , H)+ 4m-9 H and thence 9HW+40*IbH = 9H92 Q-45HQ H+403 1H 9(5m-9 ) 60(m-2 ) 4m9 HmH ) ? ?
4m-9 I4-9 +4m { -27 HJac.(U , Q , H)+40 Jac. ( U , P , H ) } .
20 .
The condition thus becomes ( 15m2-54m+51 ) ( 4--9 ) HJac.(U , V , H)H +6(5m9)(m2)(4n9)I Jac. ( U , VH , H ) +3(n2){ 3(5m9)(m-2)H ( QH)+20(m-2)2HbT } + ( m-2)2 { -27H Jac. ( U , Q , H)+40 Jac. ( U , P , H ) } =0 , which for shortness I represent by 3HU+(m--2)2 { --27t Jac. ( U , Q , H)+40 Jac. ( U , P , H))=0 , so that we have 11= ( 5m2-l18n+17)(4m-9)Jac.(U , V , H)H +2(5n9)(mn-2)(4nm-9 ) Jac. ( U , VH , H ) +(iz--2){3(5m-9)(m-2)b(QH)+20(m-2)2 .
a } .
21 .
Write 1-=(S2 , 3 ' , , 13 ' , ' , ' A,.'3A B , C)2 , where ( A , B , C ) are as before the first differential coefficients of U , and ( a ' , 6 ' , c ' , f ' , g ' , ' ) being the second differential coefficients of H , ( a ' , 3 ' , C( , 7 I , @ , ' ) are the inverse coefficients , viz. , '= b'lc'--f'2 , &amp;c. We have --(m-l )2al =(3m6)(3m7)a(Q2H)-(3m-7)2aP ( see post , Nos. 41 to 46 ) , that is ( 3mn6)a(b(H)=(3an7)a N(m 1)a ~MI~DCOCLXYV .
5 F7 MDcccxV .
5 F and thence II= ( 5m2--18m+17)(4m--9 ) Jac. ( U , 7 , H)H + 2(5m-9)(m--2)(4m9 ) Jac. ( U , VH , H ) +(m-2){(5 2-18m+17 ) + ( m2(5m-9 ) }=0 .
22 .
Now T=(C , 3 , $ , , f , 3 , A ' , B ' , C')2 , CI =(T ' , = , ' , $ ' , 1 , 1'(A , B , C)2 , and writing for shortness ET =(a , ... A ' , Bt , C')2 , FT =(-,..A ' , B ' , C'PXa , 3 ' , ' , ) , ET , =-(a',..A , B , C)2 , Fr-=(~',..:(A , B , C Xa( , 2a , a5 ) , ( we might , in a notation above explained , write ETP=bH , F4'= T-Vu , and in like manner EP , =a ; tu , Fr-=5-~ ) , then we have a*q=E4+2F ' , b-=ET , +2FT1 .
We have moreover Jac. ( U , VH , H ) E=-m 7 1E , post , Nos. 47 to 50 .
Jac. ( U , V , H)H=-E , J post , Nos. 51 to 53 .
23 .
The just-mentioned formulae give 1= -(5sn2-18n-+17)(4m9)E -2(5nm-9)(m--2)(4m-9 ) 3m-7 FT +(m-2)(5n2-18mn+17)(ET +2FT ) +(5m-9 ) ( m1)2(m 2 ) ) 3m-7 ( ExP~.~ 2E , ) , that is I=-(3nm-7)(5m218n +17 ) ET +2(m-2)(5mz-218m ?
+17 ) FT +(5m-9 ) ( m-1)2(m--2 ) 3m-7 or , as this may also be written , ( 3m-7)11(5m2-18m+17){-2(m-1)( m-2)F1l +(3m7)2ET } -(5m-9)(m-2 ) { ( m-1)(3m-8)r , +(3m -)(-73m-8)Frl-( m-1)2ETI , } +(25m2-103m+106)(m-2){ -( m--)FTI+ ( 3m-7)FT } But recollecting that Q=(I 3 , ( ; , , , , ax , L , B)2H =(9I5 , t i , ?
; $f , j , la ' , c ' , c ' , 2f ' , 2 ) , and putting EQ=(b ; , ... .
' , ... ) ( =BQg ) , FQ_=( p , ... a ' , ... ) ( =aQu ) , we have , post , Nos. 41 to 46 , -2(n l)(m-2 ) Ft1 +(3m7)2E=(3m6)(3m7)HEQ ( m-1)(3m-8)F'1+ ( 3m-7)(3m-8)FJ-( qm-1)2E-l=(3m-6)(3m-7)HFQ -( m-1)FtI+ ( 3m--7)Fr = ( 3m-7)Q2H , and the foregoing equation becomes ( 3m-7 ) -= --(5m2--18m+17 ) ( 3m-6 ) ( 3m--7)HEQI -(5m 9)(m-2)(3m-6 ) ( 3m-7)HFQ +( m 2)(25m2-103m-106)(3m--7)QItH .
25 .
But we have S Jac. ( U , , H2)-(3m-6)HE + ( 2m4)QbH=0,. .
( J ) SJac.(U , H , Q)-(3m-6)HFQ+(3nm-6)QBH=-0 , ... .
( J ) that is 3(m-2)HEQ=2(m2)QbH+ Jac. ( U , H , QH ) , 3(m2)IHFQ=(3m8)aQH+2 Jac. ( U , H , Qu ) , and we thus obtain -l=-(5m2-18m+17){2(m-2)Qbth H+ Jac. ( U , H , aQ ) } -(5m-9)(m-2 ) { ( 3m8)QbH+s Jac. ( U , H , Q ) } +(25m103m+106)(m-2)iQaH , where the coefficient of ( m-2)fQH is -(10m 36m+34 ) -(5m9)(3m8 ) +(25m2-1 03m+-106 ) , which is =0 .
Hence I --(5m2 -18m+17)a Jac. ( U , H , fQ ) -(5m-9)(m-2 ) SJac .
( U , H , Qu ) .
26 .
Substituting this in the equation 3HII+(m2)2{ -27H Jac. ( U , Q , H)+40 Jac. ( U , I , H ) } =0 , the result contains the factor 5 , and , throwing this out , the condition is 3H{-(5m2 18m+17 ) Jac. ( U , H , QE)-(5m-9)(m-2 ) Jac. ( U , H , H ) } +(-2)2{27 HJac .
( , H , 2)-40 ac.(U , H,.)}=0 , 5r2 or , as this may also be written , --(15m1254m+51)1 Jac. ( U , H , iH)3(5m9)(m-2)H Jac. ( U , H , QU ) +27(m-2)2 { H Jac. ( U , H , Qii)+ H Jac. ( U , H , QU ) } -40(m-2)2 Jac. ( U , H , )=0 .
27 .
Hence the condition finally is ( 12mn2-54nm+57 ) H Jac. ( U , H , Z )+(m--2)(12m--27)H Jac. ( U , H , Qu ) 40(m 2)2 Jac. ( U , H , t)= 0 , or , as this may also be written , -3(m)H Jac. ( U , H , r)+(nm-2)(12m-27)H Jac. ( U , H , n ) -40 ( m-2)2 Jac. ( U , H , )-=0 , viz. the sextactic points are the intersections of the curve mn with the curve represented by this equation ; and observing that U , H , Hfl and t are of the orders 9n , 3m-G , 8n--18 respectively , the order of the curve is as above mentioned =12m--27 .
Article Nos. 28 to 30.-Application to a Cubic .
28 .
I have in my former memoir , No. 30 , shown that for a cubic curve Q-=(R , ]I , ; , , , 3 a , a , , aZ)'H= -2S .
U=0 , this implies Jac. ( U , H , Q2)= 0 , and hence if one of the two Jacobians , Jac. ( U , H , Qu ) , Jac. ( U , H , in ) vanish , the other will also vanish .
Now , using the canonical form U=x3+y3 +-z3+ 61xyz , we have Q=(a,. .
)X , ... ) = ( yz--l_xI , zX-ly , xy-l_z , Plyz -lx , 12zx-ly , l12'y_-lz2 X -31x , 31y , -312z , ( 1+21)x2 , ( 1+21)y , ( 1+21)z ) , the development of which in fact gives the last-mentioned result .
But applying this formula to the calculation of Jac. ( U , H , 2Qu ) , then disregarding numerical factors , we have 2-=-(yz-2I .
1yz-z2 , ,.,..312 , 0 , 0 , ( 1+21 ' ) , 0 , 0 ) = 31 ( yz1x )+ ( 1+213 )(12yzx2 ) =(1+ 14)(x2 +2 y)= sau ; and in like manner bf2u =SbU , bfQu=SBU , and therefore Jac. ( U , H , 2u)=S Jac. ( U , H , U)=0 , CUfRVE .
557 whence also Jac. ( U , H , fQi)=O ; and the condition for a sextactic point assumes the more simple form , Jac. ( U , H , ,P)=0 .
29 .
Now ( former memoir , No. 32 ) we have *h=( j , 33 , C , f , 11,2H , xw H , b H)2 ( 1 + 813)2 ( yz3 +z33+x3y3 ) +(-9 6 ) ( X3+y3+3 ) +-(--21-514-2017 ) ( x3+y3 +z3)xyz +(-1512_7815+1218)X2y2z2 , or observing that 3+y ' + Z3 and xyz , and therefore the last three lines of the expression of 4 are functions of U(-3+y3+z'+61xyz ) and H(=12(X3+y3 +z3)+(1 +213)yz ) , and consequently give rise to the term=0 in Jac. ( U , H , t ) , we may write *=(1+ 813)2(yz3 + z3x3+x3yl ) .
30 .
We have then , disregarding a constant factor , Jac. ( U , H , t ) =Jac .
( x3+y3+z3 , xyz , y3z3+zx33+x3y3 ) X2 y2 z2 yz , zx , xy X2(y3+z3 ) , y2(z3+x3 ) , z2(X3+y3 ) = x3(y6 -z6 ) +y3(z6_6 ) + z3(6 -y6 ) = ( y3 -z3)(z3_ -)(x-_y3 ) , so that the sextactic points are the intersections of the curve U=x-3+y3+z3+61xyz-O , with the curve ( y3 z3)(3x3)(x3_y3)= .
Article Nos. 31 to 33.-Proof of identitiesfor the first transformation .
31 .
Calculation of ( a+ 1oaa+ 10 , +a315 , a12)U .
Writing b in place of D , we have ( former memoir , No. 20 ) ( -_4_____b 3m-6 2\ ( +60aad)U= ( m ( -2aH-2 H+ m_HC D 1VH ) .
But 6m12 2 _2 -22=-H m1 H--m ' -iVH , former memoir , -H ( 3m 6 ) ( 3 )H 6m-14 )2 Nos. 21 &amp; 22 ; ( rni)2 ( rn_121 ( m_ and thence ( 4 +62 , )U= ( m_1)4(18Sm2-66m+ 60)H +(M -1)(-l1f+18)VH +4+ ( m-i ) ( 2 ) ; whence operating on each side with 'a , =a , we have ( a , +loa0a , +6a,2b3+12ala6)u= ( m2-U(ls8M2 -66m+6o0B)(H aD+ aH ) +(n-l-)4 Om(-0+ 8 ) { ( ( .V)H+ lVH},34 +(m -)4b2 We have besides ( see Appendix , Nos. 69 to 74 ) , oau= p(m-1)3 { ( 3m6)HbS +(-m+3)PbH } +(m 1)3 { ( .V)H } , a , a:U= ( m.(-(HaO+saH ) ; and thence ( 4a233+ 3-1)U= ( m 1 ) , { ( ( 90m-21)H(fD+(-m+9)DBH}J + ( m-1 ) { -{4(a .
V)H } ; and adding this to the foregoing expression for ( a +loa1 + 6bo3 +12b^ 2)U , we have ( a5 + 10 3+ 10aa3 + 151a2)U= ( m--1)4 { ( 27Wm2-96nm+ 81)HB )+ ( 17m2-56mn+51))bH } +(mi )4 { ( -14m+22)( .
V)H+(-lOm+18)aV .
H } a4 +(m -1)4 32 .
Calculation of a , ua1H + 2 ?
3U , H + 2b , Ub3H .
We have __U= m_ 1 _-Ia+U---(m l1H , b2H=bH , 252 1 a2U=-(m1 ) H , b3H= ( -3m+6)s)aa-bH+ m ( a. V)H , for which values see Appendix , No. 58 .
And hence the expression sought for is = ( 13{ ( ( m1)(I2H + 2H ) -HF -2VH ) H +2(nm-l)6Ha2H +2H((-3m+6)Hi4a -~aH+s(-b .
V)H ) } , which is =m-1)3{ -lBW3( 1)6H + ( 1)I HbH + ( -6m+12)H2a --3H4IbH } +(m_3{2H(a .
V)H-23HVVH } .
But we have , former memoir , Nos. 21 &amp; 25 , a2H=(3m-6 ) Hq ) VH , m-1 m-1 ( 3m-6)(3m-7 ) 6nm 14 H-_ ( m-1 ) H ( m1)2 ( m1 ) ' so that the foregoing expression becomes -(m-1)3{--(8S16)H(D-H+ sHVHI -^6m^+ ' 14 h6HVr-1 __ ( 3m--6 ) ( 3m-7 ) 6m + m14 HV m-1 m-I m--1 -~3H4RH-(6m-12)HII2M }+(){ 2H(b .
V)H--aHHVH } ; or finally b4U a , H+ 2d3UT2H + 2a , Ub3H =(m n )4{ ( 6i2+18 n12)H2 +( 17 ?
n2+60m-55)H4)HI }+ ( n 1i)-4{(2i-2)H( .
V)IH-+(8i-16)BHVH } +(m1)4 QH } Calculation of bUXBU .
This is,4 ( m1)4HH Article Nos. 34 &amp; 35 .
-The Jacobian Formula .
34 .
In general , if P , Q , R , S be functions of the degrees p , q , r , s respectively , we have identically pP , gQ , rR , sS =0 , baP , BaQ , aZR , ZaS aP , aZQ , a , R , azS , or , what is the same thing , pP Jac. ( Q , R , S)-Q Jac. ( R , S , P)+rR Jac. ( S , P , Q)-sS Jac. ( P , Q , R)=0 .
Hence in particular if P=U , and assuming U=0 , we have --Q Jac. ( R , S , U)+rR Jac. ( S , U , Q)--sS Jac. ( U , Q , R )=0 .
If moreover Q=- , and therefore q=1 , we have -Jac .
( R , S , U)+rR Jac. ( S , U , S)--sS Jac. ( U , D , R)=-0 ; or , as this may also be written , -Jac.(U , R , S)+r RJac .
( U , a , S)--sSJac .
( U , a , R)=0 ; that is --5 Jac. ( U , R , S ) +rRS -sSR= 0 .
35 .
Particular cases are ( 2m-4 ) &lt; bPH-(3m--6)Hb( =S Jac. ( U , V , H ) , ante , No. 12 , ( 5m-ll)VHBH-(3m-6)IHIS(VH)=_ Jac. ( U , VH , H ) , , 14 , ( 2mn4)V : H-(3m-6)H.V = Jac.(U , V , H ) , ( 5m-12 ) QaIH-(3m-6)HaQ =Jac .
( U , , H ) , , , 18 , ( 8sn-18 ) T3HH-(3m-6 ) HIT =S Jac. ( U , , H ) , , , 19 , ( 2m4 ) QaH-(3m-6)HEQ =a Jac. ( U , QH i H ) , , , 25 , ( 3rn8 ) QbH-(3m--6)HFQ2 = Jac. ( U , 2u , H ) , , , where it is to be observed that in the third of these formulae I have , in accordance with the notation before employed , written b.V to denote the result of the operation a performed on V as operand .
I have also written V : aH to show that ; the operation V is not to be performed on the following H as an operand , but that it remains as an unperformed operation .
As regards the last two equations , it is to be remarked that the demonstration in the last preceding number depends merely on the homogeneity of the ftnctions , and the orders of these functions : in the former of the two formulae , the differentiation of Q is performed upon Q1 in regard to the coordinates ( x , y , z ) in so far only as they enter through U , and Q is therefore to be regarded as a function of the order 2n--4 ; in the latter of the two formulae the differentiation is to be performed in regard to the coordinates in so far only as they enter through H , and Q is therefore to be regarded as a function of the order 3mn8 .
The two formulae might also be written ( 2m-4)QbH--(3m--6)H3a2j = Jac. ( U , Qgj , H ) , ( 3m-8)Q2H-(3m6)HI5u= Jac. ( U , QU , H ) ; and it may be noticed that , adding these together , we obtain the foregoing formula , ( 5 m-12)QH-(36)HQ=a Jac. ( U , Q , H ) .
Article Nos. 36 to 40.-Proof of equation ( .V)H=Jac.(U , H , ) ) , tsed in the second transformation .
36 .
We have v=(a,..x , , , ( 31a , a , , a , ) =(za+ay+Qa Z , +3Sy+ ; , f^ 4^.a,.+^ , ; 3+ ?
Xpx , ) .
Also a =(BY-Ct)a + ( Cx-Ay)Ay + ( A -B)BaX =XP+-Q+ vR , if for a moment P , QR=caY-Ba , Aa , -Ca , Ba , -Aa3 .
Hence a.v = ( Px+QL+R).()S a+ a++ a , , ++J++a~ , , a+ +Ca , v ) , viz. coefficient of 2 =P +P +P z and so for the other terms ; whence also in ( b.V)H the coefficients of X2 , &amp;c. are ( Pl , +Pa~ +P rt)H , &amp;c. 37 .
Again , in Jac. ( U , H , ( D ) , where D=(R , S , 4f C , X , ( @ , , )2 , the coefficients of X2 , &amp;c. are Jac. ( U , H , S ) , &amp;c. ; and hence the assumed equation ( 6.V)H=Jac .
( U , H , ( ) , in regard to the term in X2 , is ( PrT , +Pay+P &amp; x)H=Jac .
( U , H , ) , and we have Jac.(U , H , A)= A , B , CA B , H , ,H , BH = [ a , H(Ca , -Bb a , )+ a H(A Ca , ) + aH(B , Aa , )]r = ( aH .
P+ aH .
Q+a_ , H. R ) ; 3 so that the equation is PMrH+PyllH+Pa , H =PxH+ QRy H+RlP I , or , as this may be written , [ ( Ba , -cay)-(ca , -AD )}^]ayH + [ ( BM , Ca)6 ( Ay B , )t3 , H=0 .
38 .
The coefficient of byH is =Ao , C+Bo^ , c(a*x+ which , in virtue of the identity , post , No. 40 , is =AZa~+Ba~ +Ca , e. And in like manner the coefficient of ab Z =-(AbilY +Bb +C O@ ) , so that the equation is ( A`az+Bb +c Bz + z)H-(A yA + BBY + cB )z-H=0 .
39 .
But we have Za+9h+(g=H , 2h+ +/ +Cf=0 , or multiplying by x , y , z and adding , ( m -1)(2A+ ?
B+@C)=xH ; whence also ( nl)(h +b +c+@ +Ay +By +caY)= xaH , that is ( m-l )(Aby + Bby + cay0 )=-a H ; and in like manner ( m-l)(A , nA+B-Z +Caz)=a , Bl , whence the equation in question .
The terms in %2 are thus shown to be equal , and it might in a similar manner be shown that the terms in p are equal ; the other terms will then be equal , and we have therefore ( .
V)H= Jac. ( U , H , 4 ) .
40 .
The identity a +ayl+aze =.o assumed in the course of the foregoing proof is easily proved .
We have in fact a +a 4+a , =_ ( b -f)+ , ( fych)+Z(fhbg ) =a ( f , +-a , g)+(a , a , h ) +f(-2 s+ a , g +a , h ) +(a)+ h( a , c+ a ) , where the coefficients of b6 , c , f , g , h separately vanish : we have of course the system a , S +b , -a + , az-O , bk + , af+=O , O0 .
Article Nos. 41 to 46.-Proof of identities for the fourth transformation .
41 .
Consider the coefficients ( a , b , c , / , g , h ) and the inverse set ( A , X , C , , ~ , i ) , and the coefficients ( a ' , 6 ' , c , f ' , g ' , h ' ) , and the inverse set ( ~t , 3h ' ?
I f , ,f , L ' ) ; then we have identically ( a,.)x , y , z)( ' , .
a,.(.)-( .
',..ax +hy +g,..)2 =(,..x , y , )( , X ... )-(,..'x+hy+g'z,..)2 , where ( ',..a,. .
) and ( 2,..(a',. .
) stand for ( A ' , 3 ' , C ' , g ' , ' a , ' , ,a c , 2f , 2g , 2Ah ) and ( A , X3 , C , I , X , a ' , 6 ' , cV ' , 2f ' , 2g ' , 2h ' ) respectively .
42 .
Taking ( a , 6 , c , f , g , h ) , the second differential coefficients of a function U of the order m , and in like manner ( a ' , b ' , c ' , f ' , g ' , h ' ) , the second differential coefficients of a function U ' of the order m ' , we have M(m -)U a.a , a , au2 ' -(m -1)26(Z !
... Cau , ayu , a , u)2 -m'( , '-l)U ' .
( ,.X .
, aI , a3 ) au -(I2-1l)2(l,.a',. .
U , U')21 ; and in particular if U ' be the Hessian of U , then m'= 3m--6 .
43 .
Hence writing Q =-(,. .
Xa a , aZ)H , ( ,..XH , H , 5 H)2 , -=(A',. .
Xax , aY , az2u , 1-=( ' , ... )a6.u , a , u , a , u)2 , we have m(m-)UQ1 , -(m1)21-=(3m6)(3m7)H ( 3m7)2T ; or if U=O , then -(1)2T1 =(3m6)(3m7)HQ(3m7)2T ; whence also -(m-l )2a'--= ( 3m6)(3m-7)(H Q+ lbH)(3m7)23 , which is the formula , ante No. 21 .
44 .
Recurring to the original formula , since this is an actual identity , we may operate on it with the differential symbol a on the three assumptions,1 .
( a , b , c , f , g , h ) , ( ~ , 1 , , I f , ( , ) are alone variable .
2 .
( a ' , b ' , c ' , f ' , g ' , h ' ) , ( A ' , 3 ' , C ' , J , ' , ' ) are alone variable .
3 .
( x , y , z ) are alone variable .
We thus obtain ( a,..X , y , z)2( ' , ,..Xa,. .
) +(~,..xI , y , OXA)..a,. .
) 2([',. .
x+ ~y + *g,..~xOa +yab+zxc,. .
) -(a',..a7x+hy+gz , .
) 2(a,.jx , ydx , , ayy , ax)( ' , s a,. .
) -2(3 ' , .
)ax+h-y+gz , .
Ca'+x+ +hhy.+z , .
) =(a',..X , y , ) , ( ba,..-a',. .
) -(0,..)a'x +h y g'z,..)2 , =(6a',. .
KX , y , Z)2(a,. .
a',. .
) +( ',. .
Y , z)(,..)a ',. .
) -2(A,..a'x +7'y+g'z,..x a't+yah '+zgy',. .
) , =2(a',..Xx , y , z ) ax , bay , -)( a,. .
',. .
) 2(g,.Ka'x+a y+g'z,..)a'ax +a 'ay+g 'az,. .
) .
45 .
If in these equations respectively we suppose as before that ( a , b , c , f , g , h ) are the second differential coefficients of a function U of the order m , and ( a ' , b ' .
c ' , f , g ' , h ' ) the second differential coefficients of a function U ' of the order m ' ; and that ( A , B , C ) , ( A ' , B ' , C ' ) are the first differential coefficients of these functions respectively , then after some easy reductions we have ( , -l)(m2)au ( ; , t..X,. .
) +m(m-l)u(-(i,.'.a,.b .
) -2(m-l)(qn-2)(R',..3A , B , CJBA , bB , BC ) n(m-)u(a~a',.Xa',. .
) -( , l)2(3a',..3XA , B , C)2 2(m-)l)BU(a.a',. .
) -2(m-1)(~t',..XA , B , C)aA , aB , bC ) = nlO '-1)'( ' -l)u,..XI,. .
) -(l'-b l)2)(a2 , ... A ' , B ' , C')2 , = ( m'l)(0 , ')av'(a,. .
',. .
) +m'(m '-1)(.ua',.a , .
) -2(m'-l)(Wm'-2)(a,. .
A ' , B ' , ' , C3aA ' , aB ' , ac ) -= 2(m'-l ) u(2 .
B',. .
) -2( , 'l)(i,..xA ' , B ' , C'e A ' , aB , W ' ) , equations which may be verified by remarking that their sum is m(m){a u(l a ... )+U[(a ',..a,..)+ ( . .
] , .
) } -(m-l)2'{ ' , *..(A , B , C)2 ?
+( ' , ... A , B , CPAB , aB , aC)}=m'(i'-1 ) &amp;c. , viz. , this is the derivative with b of the equation m(m-1)U(5',.a,..)--(m-1)2(K',..AA , B , C)2= '(m'-l ) &amp;c. 46 .
Taking now U'H , and therefore m=n3m-6 ; putting also U-O , aU=O , and writing as before _T_~~~~~A Io IT , I ZN IN F~q --(0,. .
E -=(2,. .
ET =(c ' , .
F(=(,. .
El -=(0 , .
Ffl -=(R , I ... .A ' , B ' , C')2 , XA , , C ' , BB ' , , B , ),.3XA , B , C)2 , 3A , B , CpaA , bB , aC ) , I.)a,..),.3 a',. .
) , then the three equations are -2(m--1)(m-2)FT =(3m-6)(3m7)HE Q-(3m-7)2ET , -(m-_1)2E , T = ( 37)(3m-8)QbH +(3im-6)(3nm-7)HFQ-2(3w7)(3m-8)FT , -2(vm-l)FtIP =2(3m-7)a2H-2(3m-7)Ft , whence , adding , we have ( M1)2(Et1+ 2F1 ) = ( 3m7)2(Et+ 2FT ) +(3m6)(3nm-7 ) { QH+H(E + FQ ) } ( that is -(m-l ) =-(31)-7)2-+(3m-7 ) ( 3m6(33m7 ) . ?
QH , which is right ) .
And by linearly combining the three equations , we deduce ( 3m--6)(3nm-7)HE2Q=-2(m-l)(nm-2 ) Ft , +(3m--7)2E ( 3 , m-7)QabH= -(m-1 ) Ft1 +(327 ) Ft , ( 3m--6)(3m7)HFQ= ( m--1)(3m8)FtQ + ( 3m7)(3m8)Ft(m1)2E , , which are the formule , ante , No. 24 .
Article Nos. 47 to 50.-Proof ' of an identity used in the fourth transformation , viz. , Jac. ( U , VH , H)=-3m Ft , 3m-7 or say Jac. ( U , H , VH)= 3m-7 ( ',..XA , B , C)XA , aB , ac ) .
47 .
We have v=(,. .
X , A , Py~O , j r , ,)b = ( ( a , ~ , Xpi , , v ) , ( M , 3 , 3jXC , P , ) , ( 0 , $ , 63x , , )X5 , a , , ) ; or , attending to the effect of the bar as denoting the exemption of the ( ( ,. .
) from differentiation , Jac. ( U , H , VH)= ( pi , , @X , v , V ) Jac. ( U , H , ' , H ) +( ?
, 3 $XI , p , v ) Jac. ( U , H , BYH ) + ( O , j , 5X , , v ) Jac. ( U , H , aJ ) .
48 .
Now Jac.(U , H , a , H)= , -_ Jac. ( U , xaxH+yabH+zbH , xH,1 and the last-mentioned Jacobian is =bYH Jac. ( U , XI , axH)+SyH Jac. ( U , y , x , H ) +- , H Jac. ( U , z , Ba , H ) +y Jac. ( U , B , H , b , H)+z Jac. ( U , b , H , B , H ) , 3 where the second line is = -y Jac. ( U , ~H , aH ) +z Jac. ( U , 9aH , ,H ) , or writing ( A ' , B ' , C ' ) for the first differential coefficients and ( a ' , b ' , c ' , f ' , g ' , h ' ) for the second differential coefficients of H , this is =-y A , B , C +z A , B , C ad , h ' , g ; g ' , f ' , c ' h ' , 6 ' , f : a , h ' , g ' = -y( ' , f ' , I'XA , B , C)+z( ' , z ' , ,f'A , B , C ) .
The first line is A , B , C A ' , B ' , C ' a ' , h ' , g ' = A(B'g ' 'h ' ) +B(C'a'-A'y ' ) + C(A'hw'B ' ) , or reducing by the formulae , ( 3m-7)(A ' , B ' , C')=(a'x+h'y+g'z , h'x+b'y+f'z , g'+ fie +c'z ) , this is =3m-_7 { A('y+ ?
z ) + B(- , y+3fz ) + +C(-'y + , Fz ) } =3m= 7 -Y({ -( , 4f ' , XA , B , C ) +z(jT ' , ' , IJ')XA , B , C ) } .
Hence we have Jac.(U , H ^H)-= ^ ( 1+H3 , ) { -y( ' f1 .
c'XA , B , C)+z( ' , B , JFA , B , C ) } ~=3n { -Y ; I-y( F ' $ ' , e')(A , B : , C)+C , , 6 , J'F3tA B , C ) } ; and in like manner Jac. ( U , H , by H)-3m7 { -z( ' , ' , B'A , B , C)+x( ' , ( ; ' , C'XA , , C ) } , Jac.(U , H , bzH)=3m7 { --x( ' , 3 ' , ,F'(A , B , C)+y(l ' , ' , 3'X)A , B , C ) } .
49 .
And we thence have Jac. ( U , H , VH)=3-(7 &amp; XA , ,C ) , ( ',3y , FXx , B , ) , ( ,4f , j , Av ) , ' , 'B ) ( , , ' , C , 'ABA , C , C ) , ( A , , C)@ , , XA , B , C ) x y , or multiplying the two sides by H , = a , h , h , 6 , f g , f , c , the right hand side is 1 -3m-7 which is Hx , X , ( m-1)A , yI , Y , ( w-l)n , z ( mi1 ) C , H m--1 7 , h , v X , Y , Z A , B , C , if for a moment x=(A',..':3A , B , cXa , a , g ) , Y=(c',. .
)IA , B , Cih , b , / f ) , Z =(',..A , B , Cg , f , c ) .
50 .
Hence observing that these equations may be written X=(A ' , ... IA , B , C( , ,A , o , B , b , C ) , Y=(A',..:A , B , CX6 , A , a , B , a , C ) , Z =( ' , ... -XA , B , cX3ZA , azB , azC ) , and that we have a= x , UI , V a3 , ay , a3 A , B , C , we obtain for H Jac. ( U , H , V , H ) the value =-or t7(,.t t.A , B , C A , r , htr ) or throwing out the factor H , we have the required result .
Article Nos. 51 to 53.-Proof of identity used in the fourth transformation , viz. , Jac. ( U , V , H)IH= -ET , or say Jac. ( U , H , V)H=(a , ... IA ' , B ' , C')2 .
51 .
We have V=((~ , % , I ?
rI c , P ) , ( 1 M , ,3 , TI X , ) , ( &lt; @ , ; 'F , ?
1 , )3jr , a , , , ) , and thence B. v =((ab , a ?
, ae , IA , .
, 0 ) , , , af , , , 0 , , a , xz , , P)ap , :a , , a ) , and ( a. V)H= ( ( ,2a , ax ?
, bX.3CX , v ) , ( Y ) , a. , a.flx , , Y ) , )a , a Jf , bx , I , v)XA ' , B ' , C ' ) , I with the like values for ( b. V)H and ( 3 , .
V)H .
Jac. ( U , H , V)H= A A ' a. v)H , POINTS OF And then BB ( , .
V)H , A PLANE CURVE .
C. )C ' ( 3z .
V)H , in which the coefficient of A'2 is =(ca , -By a)( , g , , t , ) ; or putting for shortness the coefficient is 52 .
We have and thence coefficient A'2-B-b=(PZ , PI , P(X , p , , )-(PL , QG[ , RTx , , , ) , which is where coefficient of d is and coefficient of v is =i { ( cayB~B ( t-(zca)ia } +v ( ( caBBz)@-(B~-a-y)RA } , =A ' -sBaZi ?
+C(A+lyj)m = ( A , ~z + Bbz+ cabz)= -m1 3zH , =+(AaX , f+Bsa +Ca~e)-ml xay H , so that coefficient A'2-a= -aHH ) .
53 .
And by forming in a similar manner the coefficients of the other terms , it appears that Jac. ( U , H , V)H-(aA , ... A ' , B ' , C')2 -- ?
i(A'x+B'y+C ' ) ' A ' , B ' , C x , ( H , v , H , ,bH , 3 , H. or since the determinant is A ' , B ' , C ' , =0 , , ( , Y A ' , B ' , C ' we have the required equation , Jac. ( U , H , V)H=(a , ... 3A ' , B ' , C')2 .
This completes the series of formulae used in the transformations of the condition for the sextactic point .
( Cay-Ba , , Aa , -Cb , , Ba , -Aay)=(P , Q , R ) ; ( PI , Pi ?
, PiXX , y , , v ) .
to 74 .
For the sake of exhibiting in their proper connexion some of the formul ; e employed in the foregoing first transformation of the condition for a sextactic point , I have investigated them in the present Appendix , which however is numbered continuously with the memoir .
54 .
The investigations of my former memoir and the present memoir have reference to the operations bi==dx6 + die 6y+dz 6zq a2 d2xa x+d2y + d2za , , a , = d3xbi+ d3 !
yby+ d3z-a , &amp;c. , where if ( A , B , C ) are the first differential coefficients of a function U= ( *Cx , y , Z)m , and X , , v are arbitrary constants , then we have dx=Bv-Cpg , dy=Ck-Av , dz=Ap-Bx ; so that putting a =(B C)b , + ( Cx .
Av)b + ( AtB ) )a = A , B , C X , B , v ax , a5 , a= , we have d -=- .
The foregoing expressions of ( dx , die , dz ) determine of course the values of ( d2x , d2y , d2z ) , ( d3x , d3y , d3z ) , &amp;c. , and it is throughout assumed that these values are substituted in the symbols 32 , b3 , &amp;c. , so that 'a , =a , and ' , 3 , t &amp;c. denote each of them an operator such as Xba+Yv , +Zb , , where ( X , Y , Z ) are functions of the coordinates ; such operator , in so far as it is a function of the coordinates , may therefore be made an operand , and be operated upon by itself or any other like operator .
55 .
Taking ( C , b , c , f ; g , h ) for the second differential coefficients of U , ( A , 33 , El , Cf , ( , jL ) for the inverse coefficients , and H for the Hessian , I write also ( I=(g ) , ... 3[ , and I notice that we have rU=2- , VU= H , l U=3H , VS= ( , V2U=HP , V.=0 , the last of which is proved , post No. 65 ; the others are found without any difficulty .
56 .
I form the Table aU=o0 , mU mU 2 , u=m ( -1 ) b ; U-=mi ba I luma1 +(m 1)2(-H ) + ( n-)2 ( 1 +(m 2(1H)blbU= O , mU _ mU 2m54 mU b =_ m_-1 ~ ?
m-i ) a , u-= mi ( bi 2 - , + , I ) 2 &gt; ^ m1 ( ( az ) )2 ( m 1)2 ( ZH ) , / , 22 3mn6 + 2 , +( _-)2 -3H m -Hq_ VH , ( m-1 ) m-1 m1 +(m_l ) -m-2 H~-- .
+(m( ( m)^2 ) -2H+m +1 HP+1 +VH ) a4U=mu ( ( -2+ ( m_ )232LV21 r+H-m 1 HVI , ) , 2H-_3m-6 HD+ H ' , Hrm-i --+ VH , and assuming U= 0 , 2=2 ( 3m--6)(3m-7 ) H 6m -14 2__ HH= ( 3M ^_^ 12(m VH--l ) ( m1)2 ( , H)2=(aH)2= ( 3m-2 H2+6m12HH ( m1)2 " ( -- ) VH-(m-1)2 which are for the most part given in my former memoir ; the expressions for 62U , a3U , which are not explicitly given , follow at once from the equations ( +a2)U=- , ( af+2a , 2+a3)u =0 ; those for bjDbU , ^2U , and d6U are new , but when the expressions for 'bb , U and Z2U are , .
2 known , that for b4U is at once found from the equation ( +6 6a 2+4a la+3B +a4)U=0 .
57 .
Before going further , I remark that we have identically ( a,..x ( a , y , )(.- , y/ k , z)P -fa)2 ax+hy+gz , hx+by+fz , gx+ fie +cz 2 O , P , v na *V PP r7= ( ,..pc , ( kj92-43 , Y , i-y)2 , ( if for shortness p=ax +3y+yz , =Xx+=-liy+vz ) = _p2(a,. .
, pj , y)2 -2p(S,. .
, .
, W , / 3 , y ) +2( , 3 , r)2 .
58 .
If in this equation we take ( a , b , c , f , g , h ) to be the second differential coefficients of U , and write also ( a , p , y ) =(- , by , b ) , the equation becomes m(m-l)Ur(m-l1)2-2 i4)(x , +ya+ , )2 -2a(xa , +yy +z a , )V which is a general equation for the transformation of 62(=b2 ) .
59 .
If with the two sides of this equation we operate on U , we obtain m(m-l)Uru-(Ml)2a2U= m(m-l)4 &gt; U -2(m-l)WVU +3Ds U ; and substituting the values r 2I , VU=2 , VU-_ _ H , o U=3H , we find the before-mentioned expression of b2U .
60 .
Operating with the two sides of the same equation on a function H of the order m ' , we find M(m-l)UrH_ ( M-_)2Z2H= m'(a'-l)oH -2(m'l)VH + a2[H ; and in particular if H is the Hessian , then writing m ' =3m-6 , and putting U=0 , we find the before-mentioned expression for b2H .
61 .
But we may also from the general identical equation deduce the expression for ( bH)2 .
In fact taking Ha function of the degree m ' and writing ( , 1 , y)=(aH , ayH , 5H ) , we have m(m-l)U(,..)X &gt; tZI-ayH , u , H-xa , H , x~H--^)H)2--( -1)2(H)2,2m'()H2--2XmHVH+-S2(,..3xH , 3ayH , )zHj2 ; and if H be the Hessian , then writing m ' -=3mn-6 and putting also U= 0 , e find the before-mentioned expression for ( 3H)2 .
62 .
Proof of equation b2 -I ( Xaw+Y ?
y+za+)+ 1 V. m-1 5mWe have which is where with the like we have and similarly and then 2 , =.{ ( ByCs)b + ( C-A-)dy + ( ABX ) , } .
( ( ca -B ) +p(AXC-a ) + v(Bb , A ) ) , =x(C'ay--B'a , ) +((A'~aC'a ) + ( B'-%A'y ) , A'=-A= a(By-C ) +h(CAy ) +g(Ap BX ) = ( hC-gB ) +(gAaC ) +v(aB-hA ) , values for B ' and C ' .
Substituting the values ( m-1)(A , B , C)=(ax+hy+gz , hx+by+fz , gx+ fie +cz ) , ( m 1)A'=x( -y k ) +$ ( $y-2S- ) + &lt; ( ?
yFx ) ; ( n.1)B ' =x(z ( ax ) ++(z - ; $x)+v(z x ) , ( in1)C ' = x(~xaty ) +3(xY ) + '(fLr4.y ) , +[x(,..(.~ , i , , , , X , )-(xa , , , + +zz ) ) ] +v [ X(@ , , ca ; )^ a &lt; a , ) -(a , +ya+za+ ) ] = ( a , ... 38 , ft , * , a , a , ) a--(a , % , ( @^ , * , x)(Xa+ya , +zb ) ; that is ( n--1)(C ' -B'ab)=V--((a , L 3( , , , , Y)( a , +yb+za .
) , and so ( m-l1)(Al , c ' , ) =yV ( I ?
, 3 , f3 , v)(x+yay , + Za+ ) , ( w-:l)(B'a , --Ao)=zV-( .
, Bj , 1 , , )(xa=+yy+za , ; whence ( ml)2 , =(x + y+ vz)V( , ... ; 3 , , v &gt; '2(x+ya+zaZ ) =-V- , ( x , +yay +z a ) ; or finally 2=-m_1 ( x++ m_-1 2 , =m-1IY +Y~(d ?
~ly+Zz)+m-I This leads to the expression for a2U ; we have 2 -= ( m1 2(Da+ay za)2 92 -(m--~ , )~ 4)V(~a !
+y &gt; ~+ z &gt; O ) C2 ( m-1 )29 +(mrnI ) and operating herewith on U , we find a2U m((m 1 ) '-D2U 2O(m1 ?
2 2(m 1)~ + ( m)2 V2U or since VUI-H , V2U=Hc , this is mU bU(m_ 1)2 ( m 1)2H .
64 .
We have , a12U=O , and thence ( a2b , +aa3+a2)u=o , that is bU3U-= U-bU ; or substituting the values of b^2U and b:U , we find the value of b 3U as given in the Table .
And then from the equation ( a +6+aa , +4 la3+3 2+64)U , or ~au:=(a4+6 aa2+4a+3 2)u , we find the value of Z4U , and the proof of the expressions in the Table is thus completed .
65 .
Proof of equation V.b=0 .
We have V. a-=V.((B-C~)~ +(CX-A)ay +(Ac--B)3 =V .
( A(B , -v ) -+B ( vx-A )+ c(ap , .
) ) = VA(^aZa ) + VB(a)a+ ) + Vc(x ) ; and then VA=(e , w ... Xx , i , v(a , h , g)=-Hm , VB=(-( , ... Xx , = , Chj , / f)= HF , VC=(a , ... =h , ~ , v]g , f , )=H Hv ; or substituting these values , we have the equation in question .
Proof of expression for b3 .
We have 1_ b2= -m-_1 ( ( xba+yay + za)+ m_ V ; and thence operating on the two sides respectively with a , =b , we have 1 b3=ml { as(xxa + y^+ a aza.)+Da.(x , ++ya , a , ) } +m-il { 3V+a.V } ; or since a.(xa+yby+zb ; )= , aI=o0 , this is as7 -m-1 3 )(x+ya-yz ) 1+ m_1 a._ 67 .
Proof of expression for b3 , H. Operating with 3b upon H , we have at once 3m-6 1 3Hm-1 [ _n ri H+m_1 ( .V)H .
The remainder of the present Appendix is preliminary , or relating to the investigation of the expressions for , b12U and b233U , used ante , No. 31 .
68 .
Proof of equation V23U=bI)H--H3D .
We have identically ( g/ ... I , , ~)( , ... Xa , , .
a , a , -)2[( , ... x , , aX , a , a )]2 ( abc-- &amp;c. )(,..(a , -pa , xa , -va , , a , - , y)2 ; that is ( Do -V2=Hr ; and then multiplying by b , and with the result operating on U , we find q ) OU-v2bU=HrFu .
N'ow cOu=( % , ... a ) , y , a)2u -=( , ... 3Xa , b , c , 2f , 2g , 2h ) ; and thence DaU=(a , ... ( bal , ab , bc , 2af , 2ag , 2ah ) ; and observing that H= a , h , g h , b , f g,./ , c and thence that bH= ba , bh , , hg + a , h , g h , b , f ah , ab , af h , b , f g , , c f , c q , af , a =(w , e , iX^a , ah g)+(s , ta , aF , ab , af)+(t , , Cag , a ?
, ac ) =(~t , ... Pba , ab , ac , 2f , 2ag , 2Mah , we see that bU=-bH .
Moreover ru= ( a , ... )Y ~d,. .
)2U a(bv2 +cp2-2fY )+ b(c2 +av2-2gvx ) +c(a42b62 2h_7 ) +2f(-_f2 +g+-p +hv -_ap ) 4-2g( Jf p-g2 +hpbX )+ 2h( fyx +g.qp -h 2 cx ) ; and thence rau= ( a , ... Ya--oa , , ... )aU a(2ab6 + ca-22a pf ) + &amp;c. -= ( bc+cab -2f/ f ) + &amp;c. =(a~ , e~ , ae , a , e , as &lt; , a^ 1 , )2 , that is Fd U=D(i ) .
Hence the equation oDU-V2 U= HrF U becomes ( b)HV2bU=HZai , that is , V2bU= ( 3HHB P. 69 .
Proof of equation al12U= ( m 2()aH-Hb ) .
We have 1 2= ( M I)4)2(xa+ yay+Zz)2 V2 -(m-2+ 2 ( m_-)2 ; and thence multiplying by ab , =a , and with the result operating upon U , we find a2U=(m-1)(m2-( )2 ( mn 2 ) VU But au=o , and thence also V(aU)=O , that is ( V. )U +VU=O ; moreover V. =0 , and therefore ( V. b)U-O , whence also VBU=O .
Therefore 2U-(ml)2 U ; or substituting for 6V2U its value =4)'H-Hl4 ) , we have the required expression for a2a5u .
70 .
Proof of equation B6,2U=-(m- ) ( ( 3m-6)Ha4 ) +(-m+3)(IbH)+ ( n1)a -(b.V)Hl .
We have 33=-mi 1a )(+ybL + z)- , A + a. V , and thence multiplying by b-=b2 , and operating on U , m--2 1m 120u3= 1)-2U m , 3 _( .
M-z .
To reduce ( b. V)b2U , we have a(va2u)=va3u+ ( a.va2)U =a3 +[(a .
v)a2+v(a .
a2)]u =Vw3U+ ( a. v)}2U+2Vh2 , U , and since 2 m+ b2= - ] i(x- , +y , +zb ) +j V ; m-1multiplying by Va , and with the result operating on U , we obtain m--2 Va u =Vm _4 au+.iV -U V2U ; or since VbU=0 , this is vab , U m-m1v"br .
Hence 21 a(Va2U ) = Va3+(b .
V7)a'2U+-m iV2aU , that is ( a. v)a2U=-a ( va2U)va 3U V2U .
Substituting this value of ( 3 .
V)B62U , we find 62ZsU= m_-2 U i3aU +_ ( a(a2u)vau ) m-1 m-1 rn2-2 13 +)tlwl uu ) , the three lines whereof are to be separately further reduced .
For the first line we have 2U-(m3H , bU-(m ) and hence first line of B3Ju= ( -M 1 ) ( ( m2)HII + bH ) .
72 .
For the second line , we have v(a2U ) =vU + 2(V .
b)bU =Vb2U , since V. b=0 , and therefore ( V. b)aU=O ; that is *mm ( UV4)+(i)VU)-_mi ( VH + 2aHVa ) ; or writing U=O VU=-m H , V=-( , this is Vb2U= ( m-2)H 2VH ( m 1)( ( m1)2 V whence also a(va1u ) ( m-2 ) a ( 4aq + 'DH)a( ) a(Vo2U)= j m(H + H)(m-91)2(VH ) .
Similarly va3U= v(a3U ) =V(m1 -(m iH ) -mml ( vua ?
+uv(a ?
))-()m 142 5V(bH)+2^Va5bH ) ; or putting U-=O VU=m H V_=F , and observing also that V(bH ) , =VZH+(V .
6)H is equal to V6H , that is to dVH , we obtain V ( mu ( ( mI-Ha-2faH)(m,1)2bVH ; and then from the above value of '(Vb2U ) , we find a(Va2U)-VB3U= ( m_l)-2H4+m baH)+(m_)(a(VH)+aH ) ( 2 or observing that the term multiplied by ( m-1)2 is =--(b .
V)H , we find second line of B3U=(_)(-2H_+m H)+ ( , ,)(-(a .
V)H ) .
MDcccLxv .
~ , 5'(z~ no ) ~=i~-a ' ) 5i For the third line , substituting for V'bU its value =4I)H-H4)H , we have 2 third line of b`3 U=----(-(m_-l-HB ) .
74 .
Hence , uniting the three lines , we have ( a , vu= ( m_ , )((m --2)HaD BH ) + ( m1)s( -2HI-+ )+ ( m_ ( -( .
V)H ) + ( m_ 1)n ( ( 2m-2)H( +(--2 +2)4Ht ) , and reducing , we have the above-mentioned value of bS'aU .

