The Lignites and Clays of Bovey Tracey , Devonshire .
By WILLIAM PENGELLY , F. G.S. Communicated by Sir CHARLES LYELL , F.R.S. Received November 16 , -Read November 21 , 1861 .
THE little town or village of Bovey Tracey , in Devonshire , nestles at the foot of Dartmoor , very near its north-eastern extremity ; it is situated on the left bank of the river Bovey , about two miles and a half above the point at which it falls into the Teign , and is about eleven miles from each of the towns Exeter , Torquay , and Totnes , -bearing south-westerly from .
the first , north-westerly from the second , and northerly from the last .
A considerable plain stretches away from it in a south-easterly direction , having a length of six miles from a point about mile west of Bovey to another nearly as far east of Newton ; its greatest breadth , from Chudleigh Bridge on the north-east to Blackpool on the south-west , is four miles .
It forms a lake-like expansion of the valleys of the Teign and Bovey rivers , especially the latter , whose course it may be said to follow in the higher part , where it is most fully developed ; whilst the Teign constitutes its axis below the junction of the two streams .
Its upper , or north-western portion , immediately adjacent to the village , is known as " Bovey Heathfield , " and measures about 700 acres .
On its west and north-west , rise the lofty granite hills of Dartmoor , with their border of metamorphic rocks ; on the north , the trappean elevations of Hennock ; on the northeast and east , e the Greensands of the aldons , and the traps and limestones of the Chudleigh and Kingsteignton districts ; and on the south , the traps , Devonian limestones , and associated rocks extending from Newton towards Ashburtont .
Contrasted with this rugged and elevated country , the so-called " plain " is not without some claim to the appellation , though by no means characterized by evenness of surface .
Shafts and other excavations have shown that the deposits in this basin consist of an accumulation of coarse gravel ( mixed with sand and clay ) , of variable thickness , unconformably covering distinct strata of lignite , clay , and sand , which are familiar to geologists as the " Bovey deposit , " whilst the lignite is equally well known as " Bovey coal .
" This deposit not only occupies the plain which has been described , but is continued , in a narrow southerly prolongation , from Newton to near Kingskerswill , about three and a half miles from Torbay .
This entire prolongation is a divergence from the Teign .
Where it crosses the estuary of that river it is about four miles from the coast .
The most important of the excavations is that known as the " Coal-pit , " which is situated on the Heathfield , somewhat less than a mile south of the village , and about the same distance from the western margin of the deposit .
It is open to the day , and * The distances throughout are measured in straight lines on the Ordnance Maps .
t See Map , Plate LII .
6z is , in form , a rude parallelogram , having its longest side , about 960 feet , in the direction from S. 75 ?
E. to N. 75 ?
W. , whilst the shortest measures 340 feet , and has a bearing of N. 35 ?
E. to S. 35 ?
W.* Its greatest depth , at the western end , is nearly 100 feet .
Subterranean excavations have been carried on very extensively , in various directions , by means of tunnels opening out of the pit at its bottom .
At present the working is confined to one tunnel , extending 190 fathoms , almost in a straight line , in the direction N. 65 ?
W. from the western end of the pit .
The lignite was formerly used in large quantities in an adjoining pottery ; at present but little is employed there , and its use is almost entirely confined to the poorer cottagers of the immediate district .
A very offensive sulphurous smell , which it emits during combustion , prevents its general domestic use .
The refuse matter , consisting of clay and waste or valueless lignite , is lodged on the surface around the pit .
Iron-pyrites occurs in it in considerable quantities ; and spontaneous combustion is common in fresh refuse , especially after much rain .
The fire is not generally visible near the surface in the day-time , but its presence is indicated by smoke and the very offensive odour previously mentioned .
Cracks , having their sides lined with flowers of sulphur , cross the burning mass in various directions .
Occasionally , crystals of sulphate of alumina are also formed .
The attention of both the scientific and the commercial world has long been called to this deposit ; several accounts of it have been laid before various learned societies , and otherwise given to the worldt .
Many of these , besides descriptions of the characters and arrangement of the strata , contain speculations and discussions on various topics , especially the mineral or vegetable origin of the lignite , the mode in which the materials of the deposit were accumulated , and the place of the formation in the chronological series of the geologist .
These may be said to have resulted in a settled conviction that the lignite is of vegetable origin , that the clays and sands had been furnished by the disintegration of the Dartmoor granite , and that the whole is of supracretaceous age-and a general belief that the plants had not grown on , but had been transported to , the area they now occupy .
The exact chronology of the formation was by no means agreed on , further than that there seemed to be a prevalent but vague opinion that , geologically speaking , it was very modern .
The only definite expression that had been given on the question was the provisional one that the deposit belonged to the Postpliocene epoch ; this was based on a cone said to have been found in one of the uppermost beds of lignite , and which was identified by Dr. HOOKER as belonging to the Scotch fir ( Pinus sylvestris ) * .
This and some small seed-vessels , described by Dr. HOOKER under the name of Folliculites minutulus , were the only identifiable fossils which , prior to the late explorations , had been found at Bovey .
Indeed , so recently as 1839 , Sir H. DE LA BECHE stated that , " excepting the lignite itself , no organic remains had been found in the deposit"t .
Many geologists , however , were unwilling to accept this chronology as conclusive , nor were they without hopes that , on a careful and thorough examination being made , the beds might be found to contain fuller and more reliable evidence on the question .
During the spring of 1860 , Dr. FALCONER made several visits to Bovey and various localities in its neighbourhood where clay-works were , or had been , carried on .
The result was a strong impression that the deposit would be found to belong to the Miocene period .
In one of these visits he was accompanied by the Rev. R. EVEREST , F.G.S. , and collection of specimens of the lignite made by the late Dr. CROKER .
Soon afterwards Dr. FALCONER introduced the subject to Miss BURDETT COUTTS as one which , for the credit of British geology , it was eminently desirable to have very fully investigated .
After a visit to the Bovey " Coal-pit , " Miss COUTTS , with characteristic liberality , furnished me with means to undertake the work .
I received the most prompt and cordial co-operation from the proprietor , JOHN DIVETT , Esq. , and was so fortunate as to secure the services of Mr. H. KEEPING , the well-known fossil-collector , of the Isle of Wight .
The lignite-beds , having suffered less from the weather than the iinterstratified clays and sand , stand out in relief , like a series of rude mouldings , on the wall of the pit , especially on its southern side ; so that it is not difficult to make out , in a rough way , the succession of the beds .
Nevertheless the clay and sand have been so much washed over the surface of the wall that it is impossible to do more than this ; hence it was decided to make a fresh section-in fact , to cut a series of steps , on a large scale , by which to descend the face of the artificial cliff from top to bottom , and thereby accomplish the double work of collecting fossils and disclosing the geology of the deposit .
As we descended , the thickness of each bed and the amount and direction of its dip were carefully measured ; a sample , and when necessary more than one , of every bed was taken , each in a separate box , and every important fact , as to the character of the bed and the occurrence or not of fossils in it , was carefully noted .
The mean of the several measurements , all very near the average , gave a dip of 12- ?
towards S. 35 ?
W. ( magn .
) .
The results of this systematic exploration are exhibited below .
Section 1 , of the Bovey Deposit , in the south wall of the " Coal-pit , " near its western end .
Dip 12 } ?
towards S. 35 ?
W. ( magn .
) .
Beds .
Thickness .
Totals .
ft. in .
ft. in .
17676 SANDY CLAY.-Contains a large number of angular and subangular stones , without anything like regularity in their arrangement .
This is locally termed " The Head .
" The upper two inches is a peaty soil , also containing stones .
226 10 0 CLAY.--Plastic .
Contains a few fragments of lignite .
The uppermost four and the lowest two inches are of a buff colour ; the middle band dark , approaching to black .
3.6 3 16 3 SAND.-Quartzose , with a ferruginous clay at the base .
429 19 0 CLAY.-The uppermost ten inches more or less dark , sometimes approaching to black , in colour .
57 19 7 LIGNITE.-Woody and brittle .
6 11 20 6 CLAY.-Very dark .
Contains much broken lignite .
713 21 9 LIGNITE .
In some places woody , in others a mass of Sequoia Couttsiw , HEER , and fern debris .
85 22 2 CLAY.-Dark .
Some broken lignite .
Graduates into sand at the base .
920 24 2 SAND .
10 20 26 2 CLAY.-Tough .
Light lead-colour .
Contains lenticular patches of sand , and , at the base , much fragmentary lignite .
11 8 26 10 SAND.-Sometimes ferruginous ; in some cases cemented into a coarse grit or very fine conglomerate .
12 26 29 4 CLAY.-Light lead-colour in the upper part , darker towards the base .
Contains fragments of lignite .
13 10 30 4 LIGNITE.-Woody , loose , very brittle .
The bed ill-defined , graduating into clay at each surface .
14 29 33 1 CLAY.-Sandy and brittle .
Contains a few fragments of lignite near the base .
The uppermost and lowest parts of the bed are dark , the middle lighter , in colour .
15 7 33 8 LIGNITE.-Woody , loose , and brittle .
16 40 37 8 CLAY.--Rather light in colour towards the top .
Contains two bands of almost continuous broken lignite , one twelve , the other thirtyinches above the base , the uppermost being the least persistent .
The clay is not laminated ; it breaks into irregular-shaped fragments , generally quite angular and with plane faces .
17 15 39 1 LIGNITE.-The lowest part of this bed abounds , in some places , with dicotyledonous leaves ; where they do not occur , the lignite is very woody .
18 29 41 10 CLAY.-Not laminated .
Light in colour .
Contains fragments of lignite .
Beds .
Thickness .
Totals .
ft. in .
ft. in .
19 21 43 11 LINITNE , -Contains much clay in almost continuous bands .
20 12 45 1 CLAY.-Laminated .
Brittle .
Rich in fragments of lignite .
21 34 48 5 LIGNITE.-Hard .
Brittle .
Broken .
Contains a few seeds .
22 20 50 5 CLAY.-Dark .
Rather brittle .
Coarsely laminated .
23 10 51 5 LIGNITE.-Contains much clay .
24 10 52 5 CLAY.-IDark .
Brittle .
Contains a few portions of lignite .
25 62 58 7 LIGNITE.-Contains patches of dark clay .
Seeds , flat in form , occur in the uppermost portion .
The base is commonly a mass of large leaf-like forms and fronds of ferns ; the former are Dr. CROKER'S " flabelliform leaves " * .
26 21 60 8 CLAY.-Light drab colour .
Extremely rich in fossil stems , leaves , and fruits of Sequoia Couttsice , seeds of various kinds , and dicotyledonous leaves .
An almost continuous band of broken lignite occurs at the base of the bed .
27 11 1 71 9 SAND.-Quartzose .
Very coarse in the uppermost part , but becomes gradually finer towards the base .
Contains somewhat large lenticular patches of clay .
Ferruginous stains and bands are common .
28 59 77 6 CLiA.-Light colour .
Near the top it is somewhat sandy .
29 32 80 8 CLAY.-Dark .
Contains a considerable number of fragments of lignite .
30 10 81 8 LIGNITE.-Rather brittle .
Not very woody .
Contains ferns .
31 8 82 4 CLAY.-Yery dark .
Some broken lignite .
32 11 83 3 LiGNITE .
Very woody , tough , and extremely hard .
33 22 85 5 CLAY.-Dark lead-colour .
Contains broken lignite .
34 10 86 3 LONITE .
Very woody and rather tough .
Contains seeds .
35 22 88 5 CLAY.-Dark lead-colour .
Contains pieces of lignite lying at all angles to the plane of the bed .
36 1 88 6 LIGNITE .
37 1 11 90 5 CLAY.-Yery dark lead-colour .
Very brittle .
Rich in pieces of lignite ; the thickness of the bed somewhat variable .
38 4 90 9 LIGNITE .
Woody , and rather tough .
39 10 91 7 CLAY.-Readily falls into fragments , which generally have plane , but sometimes curved surfaces .
Contains pieces of lignite .
40 10 92 7 LIGNITE.-This bed is very uniform in thickness , and well-defined at each surface .
Very compact and rather tough .
Contains a few seeds .
One specimen of Sequoia Couttsice was found here .
41 16 94 1 CLAY.-Dark .
So brittle as to fall in pieces at the least touch .
Contains pieces of lignite .
42 9 94 10 LIGNITE.-Extremely brittle .
The bed is somewhat irregular in thickness and obscure in definition .
43 9 95 7 CLAY.-Lead-colour .
44 6 96 1 LaGNITE.-Irregular in thickness .
Occasionally intersected by veins of clay , commonly at right angles to the plane of the bed .
45 7 96 8 CLAY.-Dark .
Fragments of lignite very abundant .
46 9 97 5 LIGNITE.-Very compact and tough .
Abounds in seeds .
47 14 98 9 CLAY.-Dull lead-colour in the upper part , changing into a darker hue towards the base ; the upper band is tougher than the lower ; the latter contains many pieces of lignite .
48 7 99 4 LmGNiTE.-Compact .
Contains seeds , and a few young circinate fern-fronds .
Beds .
Thickness .
ft. in .
MR. PE3NG-ELLY ON TTHE LIGNITES AND Totals .
ft. in .
49 10 100 2 CLAY.-Rather light lead-colour .
Somewhat tough .
Contains pieces of lignite smaller than usual .
50 10 101 2 LIGNITE.-Compact .
Very tough .
Yields large slabs of " Board Coal " .
51 9 101 11 CLAY.-Very dark .
Contains a few pieces of lignite .
52 3 102 2 LIGNITE.-Loose and soft .
53 7 102 9 CLAY.-Brown .
Pieces of lignite abundant in the upper part , less so towards the base .
54 23 105 0 LiaGNTE.-Compact , tough , woody .
Yields large slabs of " Board Coal " having a mottled appearance .
Contains a few seeds .
55 10 105 10 CLAxY.-Very dark blue .
Of resinous aspect .
Contained a piece of lignite six feet long and two inches broad ; smaller fragments rather numerous .
56 32 109 0 LIGNITE.-Very woody .
Frequently has a " charred " appearance .
57 5 109 5 CLAY.-Blue .
Brittle .
58 18 111 1 LIGNITE.-Woody , " charred " and mottled .
Contains a few seeds ; none occur where the lignite appears " charred .
" 59 4 111 5 CLAY.-Some parts blue , others dark drab .
60 18 113 1 LIGNITE.-Woody , hard , brittle .
Has a fracture resembling that of ordinary coal .
Contains seeds .
61 4 113 5 CLAY.-Blue and dark drab .
62 24 115 9 LGNITE.-This bed consists of two bands : the upper , nine inches thick , breaks into irregularly shaped " glassy " pieces ; the lower is very hard , light-brown , less heavy than the lignite usually is , brittle , woody , and has a fracture resembling that of ordinary coal .
This band contains seeds , none of which appear in the upper .
The bands graduate into one another through a thin layer of " charred " lignite .
63 6 116 3 CLAY.-Light lead-colour .
Contains seeds , probably more than one species .
One stem of Sequoia Couttsice was found here .
64 13 117 6 LIGNITE .
E.-Very hard and compact ; not quite so tough as some of the beds above it , but by no means brittle ; possesses traces of the " charred " character .
65 3 117 9 CLAY.-Lead-colour .
Resinous in aspect .
Contains numerous pieces of lignite .
66 14 119 1 LIGNITE .
In all respects like the 64th bed .
67 2 119 3 CLAY.-Resinous appearance .
68 14 120 7 LiGNITE .
In all respects like the 64th and 66th beds .
69 2 120 9 CLAY.-Very brittle , laminated , and resinous in aspect .
70 3 121 0 LrGNITE .
71 1 121 1 CLAY .
72 40 125 1 LiaGTE.-Termed by the workmen the " Last Bed"'t .
In order to ascertain whether the succession and characters of the beds are the same in other parts of the pit , two other sections were made , also in the southern wall , one about 460 , and the other 680 feet eastward from the first .
The results are given below .
* So named from having an appearance resembling " deal boards .
" t This section is exhibited in Plate LIII .
Section 2 , of the Bovey -Deposit , in the south wall of the " Coal-pit , " 460 feet eastward from Section 1 .
Dip 12 " ?
towards S. 35 ?
W. ( magn .
) .
Beds .
Thickness .
Totals .
ft. in .
ft. in .
16262 SANDY CLAY.-With angular and subangular stones ; the upper six inches peaty soil , in which the stones also occur .
24 10 11 0 CLAY.-Contains some fragments of lignite .
37 10 18 10 SAND.-Quartzose and ferruginous .
4 10 5 29 3 CLAY .
In some parts sandy and of a buff colour , in others dark with vegetable debris .
Much fragmentary lignite .
59 30 0 LIGNITE.-Woody and brittle .
617 31 7 CLAY.-Dull lead-colour .
715 33 0 LIGNITE.-A matted mass of debris of Sequoia Couttsice and ferns .
820 35 0 CLAY.-Light drab .
Roughly laminated .
Contains broken lignite .
91 10 Do not occur in this section .
11 J 12 13 36 3 CLAY .
In some parts black with vegetable matter , in others light drab ; the former most prevalent .
13 4 36 7 LGNITE .
-Much broken .
14 21 38 8 CLAY.-Light drab .
Much broken lignite near the top .
15 6 39 2 LIGNITE.-More compact than in the higher beds .
16 22 41 4 CLAY.-Dull lead-colour .
Somewhat resinous aspect .
Broken into fragments having more or less curved surfaces .
17 10 42 4 LIGNITE.-Contains dicotyledonous leaves .
18 19 44 1 CLAY.-Dark drab colour .
Much broken into angular fragments .
Contains pieces of lignite .
19 12 45 3 LiGIiTE.-Contains a considerable quantity of clay , in almost continuous bands .
20 12 46 5 CLAY.-Rich in fragments of lignite .
21 25 48 10 LIGNITE.-Compact .
22 13 50 1 CLAY.-DUtll drab colour .
23 10 50 11 LIGNiTE.-Much broken ; the fragments having well-defined clay-stained surfaces .
24 9 51 8 CLAY.-Light drab .
Broken .
Resinous in aspect .
25 5 10 57 6 LiGNITE.-Contains patches of clay .
Ferns and the so-called " flabelliform leaves " occur near the base .
26 36 61 0 CLAY.-Light drab .
Rich in stems , leaves , and fruits of Sequoia Couttsice .
27 17 62 7 SANI.-Quartzose and ferruginous .
Contains lenticular patches of clay .
28 6 63 1 CLAY.-Light colour .
29 39 66 10 CLAY.-Dark colour .
The nature of the ground prevented the second and third sections being satisfactorily continued below the 29th bed .
There is reason to believe , however , that the still lower beds are uniform in character and order throughout the pit .
In the third section the materials comprising the various beds will be named without remark , since those which agree numerically agree very closely geologically .
Section 3 , of the Bovey Deposit , in the south wall of the " Coal-pit , " 680feet eastwardfrom Section 1 , and 220 feet from Section 2 .
Dip 12- ?
towards S. 35 ?
WT ( magn .
) .
Beds .
Thickness .
Totals .
ft. in .
ft. in .
1 10 9 10 9 SANDY CLAY.-With angular and subangular stones .
210 11 9 CLAY .
3 12 6 24 3 SAND .
420 26 3 CLAY .
56 26 9 LIGNITE .
610 27 9 CLAY .
719 29 6 LIGNITE .
8A 9~~~10 jtyDo not occur in this section .
10 11 12 18 31 2 CLAY .
13 10 32 0 LIGNITE .
14 24 34 4 CLAY .
15 14 35 8 LIGNITE .
16 30 38 8 CLA .
Y. 17 20 40 8 LIGNITE .
18 20 42 8 CLAY .
19 20 44 8 LIGNITE .
20 6 45 2 CLAY .
21 31 48 3 LIGNITE .
22 10 49 3 CLAY .
23 11 50 2 LIGNITE .
24 6 50 8 CLAY .
25 53 55 11 LIGNITE .
26 32 59 1 CLAY .
27 10 59 11 SAND .
28 7 60 6 CLAY .
29 32 63 8 CLAY .
On comparison , it will be found that the 9th , 10th , and lth beds of Section 1 the first and last being sand and the second clay-do not occur in either of the other two sections , and that in Section 3 another clay-bed is also missing .
This last is supposed to be the 8th , but it would probably be difficult to determine between it and the 12th .
It is possible , moreover , that the bed numbered 12 in the third may represent both the 8th and 12th of the two other sections .
The same numbering has been retained in all the sections to facilitate comparison .
The total thickness of the missing beds amounts to no more than about 5 feet ; the fact , however , that they are not present may be significant .
It amounts to this : by removing 460 feet further into the ancient Bovey lake ( for such I assume the area to have been)-460 feet further from its ancient shore , that shore being the granitic region of Dartmoor , we leave behind two thin beds of sand , which do not reappear when we advance 220 feet further in the same direction .
Eliminating these beds , we have no sand in the series below the uppermost bed of lignite ( No. 5 ) excepting No. 27 , which occurs in all the sections , and , indeed , constitutes a marked feature in the deposit as exposed at the " Coal-pit .
" It is 133 inches thick in the first section , no more than 19 in the second , and dwindles to 10 inches only in the third ; but no bed is more continuous or better marked : its comparatively bright colour catches the eye , and indicates its presence along the entire length of the excavation .
It attains a still greater thickness in the western wall of the pit .
Between the first and third sections it forms an inclined plane 680 feet long and 123 inches high ; or base : height =8160 : 123=rad : tan 52 ' ; so that , great as the attenuation is , it merely produces a gradient of 1 in about 66 , or an inclination of less than one degree .
The sections show that a similar eastward diminution of thickness characterizes the 28th bed .
This attenuation , like the thinning out of the beds previously mentioned , ( which , it may not be out of place to remark , is in the direction of the Strike of the deposit , ) is probably an indication , were one needed , that the detrital layers were formed at the expense of the Dartmoor granite .
The sections agree in naturally dividi:ng themselves into three parts or series , viz.1st .
The bed No. 1 , of SANDY CLAY , containing angular and subangular stones .
No stones of any kind were met with below this .
2nd .
The beds from the 2nd to the 27th , both inclusive , composed of sand , clay , and lignite .
3rd .
All the beds below the 27th , consisting of clay and lignite only* .
It appears th that portion of the age of the deposit , which is represented by the first ( that is , lowest ) forty-five beds was unmarked by the deposition of sand within that area .
Forty-four beds of lignite and clay , having an aggregate thickness of upwards of 47 feet , succeed each other alternately in regular unbroken order ; the next bed , however ( 28th in the sections ) , instead of being a mass of vegetable matter , as was w due , is a second bed of clay , and , in the first section , of unequalled thickness ; this is followed by a thick bed of sand , the first which presented itself .
Clearly some change must have occurred .
Had the accumulated deposit so far sf hallowed the waters of the ancient lake Had it conveyedits western margin so far eastward , that sand was to be henceforward deposited in the area hitherto appropriated to clay , instead of further west as heretofore 1 If so , it might have been expected that the change would have been less sudden .
No sand whatever had previously occurred .
Moreover , on this hypothesis it is reasonable to suppose that sand would have been largely deposited in future , instead of which the old order ( of clay and lignite alternately ) is continued for eighteen additional beds , increasing the depth of the deposit by nearly 40 feet ; indeed , omitting the two arenaceous beds ( 9th and 11th ) which occur only in the first section , we have no more sand until the uppermost bed of lignite in the sections had been formed .
In no instance does the lignite rest on or support sand , but always clay .
Almost all the clay-beds contain fragments of lignite , which are commonly , at least approximately , parallel to the plane of stratification .
One or two exceptions to this were met with , the most marked being that of the 35th bed , where they occur at all angles to that plane .
, Though when first dug the clay is not generally characterized by lamination , exposure to the atmosphere , in most cases , developes this quality .
Fossils were found in only fifteen of the beds , namely , one of clay and four of lignite in the second series , and one of the former and nine of the latter in the third or lowest .
It is only necessary to particularize the 7th , 25th , 26th , and 46th beds .
The 7th is chiefly remarkable as being a mat composed of fragments of the coniferous tree Sequoia Couttsice , HEER , and of the fern Pecopteris lignitum , GIEB .
The 25th is that in which the so-called " flabelliform leaves " chiefly occur ; a few were also met with in the 17th bed .
Professor HEER has identified them as the rhizomes of ferns .
Some of them were fully 5 feet in length , but too brittle to be got out entire .
In most cases the large specimens have a curved outline .
The lowest three inches of the bed is commonly a mat of fragmentary fronds of the ferns Pecopteris lignitum and Lastrea stiriaca , UNG .
, the first being the most prevalent .
Above this lie the rhizomes , in a continuous band about 6 inches thick .
Though these bands generally preserve a well-marked separation , they sometimes inosculate , but never so as to show whether the fossils were parts of the same plant .
The uppermost portion of the bed consists of slabs of " board coal " of great length , and of a width indicating the existence of trees ( probably Sequoia Couttsice ) fully 6 feet in diameter .
Bodies occur in this bed having the appearance of roots , with rootlets passing into the clay below .
Mr. KEEPING reported one such " root " having a part of the stem of a tree still attached to it , the latter being almost perpendicular to the plane of stratification .
The lignite in this stratum not unfrequently presents a fretted aspect , as if from some kind of corrosive action ; in these cases it is crossed by cracks or fissures of variable width , having rugged walls , and filled with yellow ochre .
The 26th is the most important bed in the series , being rich in both the number and the variety of its fossils .
The lowest six inches contain a large number of dicotyledonous leaves , most of them crushed and valueless ; occasionally , however , nests or patches of such leaves occur in a better condition .
A few twigs of Sequoia Couttsiaw are also found in this lowest band ; whilst quite at its base are numerous branches of the same plant , measuring in some instances 3 feet in length and from a quarter of an inch to 4 inches wide .
In most cases the large specimens are extremely brittle .
The next fifteen inches constitute a middle band , containing some Sequoia-debris and a considerable number of crushed leaves , the latter suggesting the idea that they had been deposited on a very uneven surface .
A thin layer of " charred " lignite , several feet in length , was found in the middle of this band .
The remaining part of the bed ( the uppermost four inches ) abounds in seeds of various kinds ; but it is chiefly marked by remains of Sequoia .
It is not too much to say that 1028 every museum in the world might readily be supplied with thousands of specimens of this plant from this band .
It is represented by branches , twigs covered with leaves , fruits ( sometimes , but more frequently not , attached to the twigs ) , and seeds .
A few dicotyledonous leaves occur here also .
Though most abundant in this bed , the Sequoia occurs also in the 7th , 40th , and 63rd -that is , the highest and lowest beds which have yielded fossils .
The Bovey deposit evidently represents but one flora .
The 46th bed yielded a very large number of small seed-vessels ( Carpolithes nitens , HEER ) , which , like those described by Dr. HOOKER , in 1855 , under the name of Folliculites minutulus , but which Professor HEER has identified as Carpolithes Websteri , BR .
, are c " thickly strewed over the surfaces of the laminae of lignite , and slightly imbedded in them as if the latter had been soft when the deposit was formed .
They lie in all directions , but always on their flat surfaces"* .
They are by no means co:nfined to this bed , though more abundant in it than elsewhere .
Nothing resembling the cone of Pinus sylvestris , described by Dr. HOOKER , was found during our exploration .
But for its complete " carbonization and bituminization , " I should believe that it belonged to a neighbouring bog , mentioned by several writers , " from which have been taken , several feet below the surface , many trees of the fir kind ; several 18 inches in diameter , together with pine-nuts , but no coal"j .
In some of the lower beds , close-fitting joints not unfrequently occur in the lignite , the surfaces of which ( rarely planes ) have a high polish : the workmen call such pieces " glassy ; " and the term aptly expresses the character .
They also call them " slides , " believing them to be " Slickensides .
" There do not appear to be any " faults " in the beds at the pit .
It has already been stated that the lignite often has a " charred " appearance ; and indeed it is somewhat difficult to believe that it has not ignited spontaneously ; nor are we without facts which give some support to this opinion .
It is well ascertained that the combustion so prevalent in the heaps of refuse is spontaneous , and the lignite beds are sometimes found to be on fire in the tunnels or " ends .
" Mr. DIVETT , writing me on this question , says , " Some ten or twelve years since , I found a fire raging in an ' end ' at the western extremity of the pit , which had been abandoned for some months .
I enclosed the main western ' end ' with a dam of timber and clay , in the hope of extinguishing the fire , but only succeeded in checking it .
This part of the pit was buried by a run of clay from the north for many years , and was excavated again about twelve months since , when the fire was still burning .
It is now again buried by 'run ' sand .
I have never doubted that this ignition was spontaneous .
" Mr. HATCHETT , however , who gave much attention to the chemistry of the lignite , was of opinion that there was no evidence of true combustion$ .
Newly exposed surfaces of the laminae of the lignite are sometimes more or less covered with stellate crystals of selenite .
Their beauty is very striking , and is enhanced by contrast with the dull dark surface on which they lie ; unfortunately it is by no means durable ; the stars first lose their brilliancy , after which many of them disappear altogether .
Fragmentary pieces of lignite occasionally occur in the " coal-beds " as well as in the clay ; some of them are perfectly flat slabs , of various sizes , having sides and ends as true and angular as if they had been something more than rough-hewn in a carpenter 's shop .
Others have an appearance resembling stranded drift-wood ; I found a wellmarked piece of this character in the 72nd bed .
The flattened form which the " board coal " commonly assumes is by no means confined to the lowest beds ; it is as characteristic of the 5th , or uppermost , and of that portion of it which most nearly reaches the surface , as of any bed in the pit sections .
As pressure must be regarded as essential to this flatness , though probably not its sole cause* , it seems impossible to avoid the conclusion that much of the superior portion of the deposit has been removed by denudation .
It must not be supposed , however , that all samples of " board coal , " taken from any one bed , are equally flattened .
Examples occasionally present themselves , of portions of stems and branches , in which the original curvature of outline is not entirely obliterated the transverse section distinctly showing the rings of annual growth converted into ellipses of great excentricity .
Good instances of this have been met with in the lowest beds .
The stones so abundant in the " Head , " or uppermost division of the pit sections , are sufficient to show that it was formed under conditions dissimilar to those which produced the two lower series .
Moreover , it lies unconformably on them .
Nowhere in the excavation do the lignite and interstratified beds reach the surface ; they are cut off at distances varying from 3 to 7 feet below it , as is shown in Plate LIII .
It has already been stated that the stones of the " Head " are generally angular or subangular ; occasionally , however , some occur that are much rounded .
They vary in size , from blocks upwards of a foot in mean diameter to pieces not larger than hazelnuts .
On Bovey Heathfield they are fragments of granite , metamorphic rock , carbonaceous grit , and trap , with a very few of flint and chert .
The two last increase in number eastward-that is , with increased proximity to the Cretaceous district , and in some localities are even more abundant than other detritus .
In no instance have I found or heard of limestone-fragments on the Bovey Heathfield .
A transporting current from the north or north-north-east seems to be required to meet the facts of the case .
Were it not for the samples of flint and chert , a movement from the west or north-west , or even south-west , might have supplied the materials .
No agent progressing from any part of the compass between the north-east and southwest , through south , could have furnished the granite-blocks or failed to transport large quantities of limestone-debris .
On the whole I incline to a transportation from a northerly direction , rather east than west of true north , -that is , a current , or other agent , moving in a line nearly at right angles to that in which the sands and clays of the true Bovey beds travelled from Dartmoor-a fact , concurring with those previously mentioned , in favour of a great chronological interval between the " Head " and the deposit it covers .
Nor are we without organic evidence of the lapse of time between these formations .
During our exploration at Bovey , I had an opportunity of examining and measuring a section made by workmen digging clay , in the " Head , " on the Heathfield , about a quarter of a mile east of the pit .
The results were as below .
Section 4 , of the " Head " at Bovey Heathfield .
Beds .
Thickness .
Totals .
ft. in .
ft. in .
1* 66 PEAT .
22630 SAND.-Fine , white , quartzose .
33060 CLAY AND SAND .
In separate masses , but not distinctly stratified .
The clay more abundant than the sand .
40 10 0 CLAY.-Yery white .
5 unknown .
SANDY CLAY.-With angular and subangular stones .
Some time afterward we found a considerable number of dicotyledonous leaves , lying in the white clay , nine feet below the surface of the plain , and immediately below them lay some large roots .
Professor HEER assigns the leaves to a period much more modern than that represented by the lignite-beds , yet to one characterized by a " colder climate than Devonshire has at the present day , " thus confirming Mr. GODWIN-AUSTEN'S opinion , that the " Head " belongs to the " period prior to the most recent change of climate " .
The position of the leaves is indicated in fig. 1 , which is drawn on the scale of 0-2 inch to 1 foot .
Fig. 1 .
Peat ... .= ... ... ... . .
=_a _'_________ Cand ... ... ... . .
k _________ _____ ___ _______ Clay andSand .
SnE W ` \ , Leave } Roots .
S Te bs in ts andnd those whi do not rep t te which bear te samey with stones .
} Though in the pit section No. 1 the 5th is the highest , and the 72nd the lowest bed of lignite , it would manifestly be unsafe to conclude that no higher or lower beds exist ; and indeed Mr. DIVETT , in a letter on this point , says , " In a shaft sunk 135 fathoms south of the pit " ( i. e. in the direction of the dip of the beds ) " I had , in 99 feet sinking , some good beds of coal .
When we ceased to sink we had , I believe , some six or seven fathoms between us and the top of the uppermost bed of lignite in your sections .
" This estimate , as to the depth at which the " 5th " bed would have been cut , is fully borne out by the dip of the beds and the distance of the shaft , if we assume that no " fault " exists in the interval and the dip remains constant .
On both these points we have direct confirmatory evidence for the distance of sixty-three fathoms south of the pit , as subterranean workings have been carried so far , " by driving down the dip , " and show that the beds exist in unbroken continuity and uniform inclination ; that is , the beds have been followed to a depth of 80 feet below the bottom of the " Coal-pit .
" Though the workmen have named the 72nd the " last bed , " it is no more than an expression of the fact that it is the last or lowest they work .
That there are still lower beds is certain , since Mr. DIVETT says , " I sank a shaft about 13 feet " ( below the bottom of the pit ) " and cut two tolerable beds of coal .
" The workmen speak of still earlier and deeper borings , and state that thin layers , or " shells , " of lignite were found separated by thick beds of " muddy clay .
" Omitting these traditions , however , we are now in possession of the following figures .
The 72nd , or " last " bed is , at the western end of the pit , about 100 feet vertically below the surface of the plain ; or , measured at right angles to the plane of stratification , we have , to the base of this bed , a thickness for the deposit of 125 feet* ; the pit beds have been followed 80 feet lower , and lignite has been cut 13 feet below the so-called " last " bed ; giving an aggregate of 218 feet , inclusive of the " Head , " or upwards of 35 fathoms for the true Bovey deposit ; exclusive of the beds mentioned by Mr. DIVETT as occurring in his shaft 135 fathoms south of the pit , and irrespective of the facts that the bottom has certainly not been reached , and that there are sufficient reasons for believing , as I shall now proceed to show , that denudation has swept away very much of the superior portion of the formation .
Though no trace of a " C fault " exists at the pit , one has been detected a short distance east of it .
" It runs , " says Mr. DIVETT , " about N.E. and S.W. , crossing close to the old engine-shaft " ( 56 fathoms east of the pit ) .
" I drove towards it in many places , and always found the 'coal ' fail and replaced by hard and wet 'deady ' clay .
At one place I drove further and cut into a bank of sand full of water , which ran into the shaft and ' starved ' the pump for some time .
I never got through the sand , and had great difficulty in keeping it out of the shaft .
This was at about 80 feet from the surface .
The section of the beds in the " ( old engine- ) " shaft is identical with those in the pit .
" The accompanying diagram ( fig. 2 ) may serve to illustrate the foregoing facts .
Let the surface of the paper represent a horizontal plane , on the level of the bottom of the coal* See Section 1 , page 1024 .
1032 pit , at its eastern end , about 80 feet below the surface .
Let AB be a portion of a tunnel , or " working , " on that level , on the eastern side of the pit , running , about N.E. Fig. 2 .
IN .
E. B/ DD d.Dr A and S.W. , near and parallel to the plane of the " fault .
" C the old engine-shaft , 56 fathoms east of the pit .
D and F various places at which Mr. DIVETT drove horizontally from the eastern side of the tunnel .
In doing so he " always found the coal fail and replaced by hard and wet ' deady ' clay ; " at F he " drove further , and cut into a bank of sand ; " in fact he seems here to have cut through , but elsewhere into , a dyke composed of heterogeneous materials ; beyond which he encountered a bed of " sand full of water ; " doubtless the 13th bed in the following section ( No. 5 ) , which , it will be seen , exists at the required depth ( " 80 feet below the surface"* ) .
Mr. DIVETT proceeds to say , " About 70 fathoms east of the shaft , I bored , in 1855 , 99 feet , when I obtained the following section .
" Section 5 .
70 fathoms east of the Fault on Bovey Heathfield ( furnished by J. I)IVETT , Esq. ) .
Beds .
Thickness .
Totals .
ft. in .
ft. in .
1 13 0 13 0 GRAVELS AND CLAYS.-( " HIead .
" ) 2 11 0 24 0 SAND .
340 28 0 BLACK CLAY .
420 30 0 " ' DEADY GRoINDW .
" 560 36 0 SAND .
636 39 6 CLAY .
746 44 0 SAND .
Beds .
Thickness .
Totals .
ft. in .
ft. in .
880 52 0 CLAY .
9 13 0 65 0 SAND .
10 70 72 0 CLAY .
11 2 72 2 COAL .
12 10 73 0 CLAY .
13 11 0 84 0 BLUE SAND .
14 30 87 0 WHITE CLAY .
15 6 87 6 COALY CLAY .
16 16 89 0 SAND .
17 10 0 99 0 COALY CLAY* .
I learn from the workmen , that the 13th bed of sand was " full of water , " like that encountered by Mr. DIVETT , and that it gave them great trouble by running into the boring whenever the instrument was withdrawn .
The foregoing section is situated , from the first three , as nearly as possible in the direction of the Strike of the formation .
It has a depth about the same as the pit at its western end , where a vertical line cuts 27 " coal " beds having an aggregate thickness of nearly 36 feet ; instead of the solitary layer of 2 inches only in the Table just given .
Those beds are known to exist , in unbroken continuity , along the entire length of the western tunnel and the coal-pit , and onwards to the old engine-shaft , a distance of nearly half a mile ; here they suddenly cease and their place is supplied by a series of beds having the characteristics of the uppermost portion of the second division of the pit sections .
The contrast of the two will be seen in Plate LIV .
There can be no doubt that these facts are evidence of a great fault ; that the beds on the east of it are an upper portion of the Bovey deposit , preserved , through the intervention of a vertical displacement of at least 100 feet , from the denuding action which swept it away on the west , after it had , by its pressure , assisted to flatten the timber in the uppermost stratum of lignite at present existing there ; and that this denudation occurred before the deposition of the " Head , " since this is found covering the deposit alike , without considerable variation in its thickness , on each side of the " fault .
" It will be understood that it is by no means intended to intimate that this is the only fault in the Bovey formation ; the occurrence of beds of lignite , near the surface , in various parts of the Heathfield , renders it probable that there is , at least , another .
Nor is it meant to express the opinion that the " Head " itself may not have lost much by denudation ; so far as they are at present understood , certain facts seem to imply that it may have suffered much in this way .
Though the neighbourhood of Bovey was necessarily regarded as the head-quarters of the formation , it was felt to be desirable that some attention should be given to certain other localities , in various parts of the basin , where clay-pits exist .
The clay-works at Aller , in the parish of Abbotskerswill , adjacent to the road from Torquay to Newton , and about two miles from the latter , have been abandoned some years .
Lignite seems to have been found there in considerable quantity .
Samples of it , shown me by one of the old workmen , displayed the common woody character so usual at Bovey , but no traces of leaves or other fossils .
There appear to have been seven distinct beds of lignite alternating with as many of clay , the latter from 2 to 4 feet thick .
Of the former , the lowest were the most compact , and were from 3 to 31feet in thickness , whilst the upper ones were thinner and contained a considerable admixture of clay .
The whole were covered , unconformably , with gravel to the depth of 20 feet .
Clay is largely dug at the Decoy , in the parish of Woolborough , about half a mile south-west of the Newton railway station .
In an artificial dyke , or water-course , two beds of lignite , separated by a layer of black clay , are well exposed .
The entire cutting is about 10 feet deep , the uppermost three feet being coarse gravel surmounted by a thin layer of peat .
The larger stones in the gravel are commonly flint and chert , the smaller are partly , perhaps mainly , Dartmoor debris .
Beneath this are the Bovey beds dipping towards north 80 ?
East , at an angle of 60 ?
at the top and 50 ?
at the bottom , the beds having somewhat curved surfaces .
The western , or lowest bed of lignite is 9 feet thick , the eastern 6 feet , and the intermediate clay about 5 feet ; the whole lies between clay similar to the interstratified bed .
Further west , or still lower , is a valuable bed of " pipeclay , " whilst on the eastern side is a good bed of the black , or " potter 's clay .
" Though we spent some days seeking fossils here , the only things found were two small bodies , probably seeds , and one undoubted twig , with leaves , of Sequoia Couttsice .
The latter , though a very inferior specimen of this fossil , is valuable as a link of identification between the lignite of the Decoy and that of Bovey Tracey .
Considerable quantities of both white and black clay are also excavated in the parish of Kingsteignton , about two miles north of Newton , very near the eastern margin , of the deposit .
I measured the following section in one of Mr. WHITEWAY'S " black pits .
" Section 6 , of the Bovey -Deposit near Kingsteignton .
Beds .
Thickness .
Totals .
ft. in .
ft. in .
1 15 0 15 0 s"HEAD , " consisting of angular and subangular flint , chert , and Dartmoor debris .
228 17 8 CLAY.-Black .
" Not Saving .
" 316 19 2 CLAY WITi LIGNITE .
440 23 2 CLAY AND SAND.-Contains root-like portions of lignite .
540 27 2 " SovEL r SAN.-Thickness variable .
680 35 2 CLAY.-Black .
" Saving .
" 730 38 2 CLAY.-Black .
" Short .
" Thickness variable .
8 12 0 50 2 " BBOTTOM " CLAY.-"Saving .
" 9 Thickness unknown .
SAND .
The workmen denominate the clay " Saving " or " Not Saving , " according as it has or has not a commercial value .
Sand so loose as to be capable of removal by the use of a spade or shovel only , is termed " Shovel " Sand .
Clay but slightly plastic is spoken of as " Short ; " and " Bottom " Clay expresses the fact that no argillaceous deposit , having commercial value , is found below it .
None of the workmen appear to have found or heard of anything in the shape of gravel at the base of the clay series * .
Sometimes , but not frequently , small , well-rounded , smooth quartz pebbles , about the size of a common pea , occur in the best clay ; and mundic is said to be not uncommon .
The dip of the beds at this pit is about 8 ?
towards N. 50 ?
W. It is said to vary somewhat both in amount and direction , but is generally less northerly than the above .
As at the Decoy , the white clay underlies the black .
Though lignite occurs here , it is less abundant than in either of the other areas which have been mentioned ; from the report of the workmen , however , it is occasionally found , especially in the pits more removed from the margin of the deposit , in larger bodies than in the section just given .
Our search for fossils was altogether without success .
At the suggestion of Dr. FALCONER , and also of Sir CHARLES LYELL , it was decided to submit the collection of fossils , which we had made at Bovey , to Professor HEER of Zurich , in the hope that he would succeed in extracting from them their chronological secret .
Accordingly , the necessary arrangements having been made by Sir CHARLES LYELL , I sent him all the drawings of the fossils , prepared by Mr. FITCH of Kew , together with a large and , so far as I could judge , characteristic series of the specimens themselves , and in a short time had the gratification of learning that he had determined forty-five species of plants , of which forty-one were from the lignite series and four from the " Head , " the former being decidedly of the lower miocene age , whilst the latter were much more modern .
Though , when he subsequently reached this country , Professor HEER failed to detect , in the remainder ( the bulk ) of the collection , any species which he had not previously seen , he was more fortunate at Bovey ; where , in the few days he was able to devote to the deposit , he added nine new species of fossil plants to the list , and , by the discovery of an insect , Buprestes Falconeri , detected the first evidence of animal life which has been exhumed there .
From the decision just mentioned , it appears that the Bovey lignites are the contemporaries of the " Hempstead Beds " in the Isle of Wight , first discovered by the late lamented Professor EDWARD FORBES in 1852 , and described by him in the following yearf .
Though their discoverer always regarded them as Upper Eocene , they have recently been grouped amongst the Lower Miocene$ ; this , however , is a question of classification ; wherever they find a resting-place , the Bovey beds must accompany them , since they are on , or very near , the same horizon .
The ancient miocene lake of Devonshire which we have been considering , must have been of great depth ; the lowest figures mentioned in an earlier page give at least 35 fathoms , whilst , if to this we add those obtained from the " fault , " it amounts to fully 50 fathoms ; indeed the clay-workers assert that their borings sometimes amount to quite this depth .
The present surface of the plain , however , is , at the pit , no more than 15 fathoms above the ordinary level of spring-tide high water , so that the bottom of the lake would be at least 35 fathoms below the level of the sea .
Yet , says Professor HEER , and apparently on unimpeachable data , " it was a fresh-water lake .
" The country , then , must have stood at a much higher level than at present , or a barrier existed between the lake and the sea .
Unless , however , there have been very local changes of level , the former hypothesis is disposed of by the fact that the Hempstead beds are of fluvio-marine origin , and must therefore have been formed at a level much below that which they at present occupy .
A barrier , then , must have existed somewhere in the present tidal estuary of the Teign , over which the surplus waters of the lake passed to the ocean , or which , by its superior height , caused the waters to find an outlet in Torbay .
Judging from the physical features of the two valleys leading from Newton to the English Channel , one by Teignmouth and the other by Torquay , the former is far more likely than the latter to have been the course followed .
The period represented by the Bovey beds must have been of considerable durations .
So far as the strata themselves show , it was , in the district under consideration , one of ; great tranquillity .
A long series of beds , alternately vegetable matter and fine clay , succeed each other in scarcely interrupted order ; the three intruded arenaceous layers probably mark nothing more than a somewhat increased velocity in the current , or river , which conveyed the detritus of the granite hills of Dartmoor into the area of deposition , but which , instead of being permanent , was as short-lived as it was unusual .
The late investigations at Bovey , then , have been so far successful that they have settled the vexed question of the age of the deposits occurring there , -added forty-nine species to the fossil flora of this country , of which twenty-six are new to science , -recognized the first traces of animal life which the deposit has yielded , -detected another British fragment of the miocene page of the earth 's history , which , until 1857 , was supposed to be totally unrepresented in England , -taken us back to a remote period when the slopes of Devonshire were clothed with a luxuriant subtropical vegetation , and separated , by a wide chronological hiatus , the lignite and associated beds from the gravels overlying them-a hiatus evidenced by the dissimilarity and unconformability of the two series , by a change in the direction by which detrital matter reached the Bovey area , by great vertical displacements of the lower series , followed by denudation of the consequent surface-inequalities prior to the deposition of the upper , and by the exchange of an extinct flora , requiring a high temperature , for an existing one , which is now confined to arctic and alpine regions .
Remote , however , as was the earliest of the two periods thus represented , the great leading geographical features of the district were pretty much as at present .
The Teign and Bovey rivers .
were then in existence , but instead of the latter being tributary to the former , their mouths were three miles apart , and both fell into the same deep , sluggish , fresh-water lake ; occupying the site of the present Bovey plain , and guarded by Dartmoor and the other hills which still constitute the prominent characteristics of the district .
Is copied , with very slight alterations , from the twenty-sixth sheet of the Map published by the Geological Survey of Great Britain ; and , like the original , is on the scale of 1 inch to a mile .
PLATE LIII .
Is a section of the Bovey formation , in the plane of the Dip of the beds .
It is drawn , from the measurements obtained in the " first section , " given in the text ( see p. 1022 , &amp;c. ) , on the scale of T- , or 1 inch to 14 feet .
The Dip amounts to 12~- ?
, and is in the direction S. 35 ?
W. magnetic .
The beds in which fossils were found are those the numbers of which are placed opposite them in the margins .
PLATE LIV .
Contains two sections of the formation , in the plane of the Strike of the beds , and is intended to show the nature of the evidence for the existence of the " Fault .
" The scale of thickness , in each , is -io- , or 1 inch to 10 feet ; and the total depth below the surface is 99 feet .
The symbols have the same meaning in both .
a is the " old engine-shaft .
" b. The eastern end of the " Coal-pit ; " 56 fathoms west of a. c. Mr. DIVETT'S boring ; " 70 fathoms east of a. d , 80 feet below the surface , is a horizontal excavation very near the engine-shaft , and opening eastward out of a " working " which runs parallel and adjacent to the " Fault " ( see fig. 2 ) .
of is the hypothetical plane of the " Fault .
" With the omission of a few unimportant local differences , the western section represents the ascertained succession and thickness of the beds from a to nearly half a mile westward .
They are probably continued much further in this direction , but are known to terminate eastward abruptly at the " Fault , " of , immediately east of a. The lowest bed shown is the 62nd in the " pit " sections .
The eastern section is drawn from the data obtained in Mr. DIVETT'S " boring " at c , ( p. 1033 , ) and shows all the beds cut there .
These are assumed to extend , in the same order , westward to e f ; and though no excavations have been made at the surface in the intermediate space , the assumption is by no means gratuitous , since a bed of sand , having the same characters and at the same depth below the surface , has been met with both in the " boring " c and the excavation d. Though the existence and situation of the " Fault " has been well ascertained , the angle which its plane ( ?
) , e f , makes with the horizon is not so well known .
In the absence of complete evidence on this point , it has been thought best to draw it at right angles , more especially as the evidence , so far as it goes , is to that effect .
*nf / 3Svg i K\\~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~\ '~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I U !
i.'/ ~ : , -.'/ :)..i'..:..i. .
&lt; _ . !
- .
: : : } ' , ::':'i:. .
' ?
: !
' ' ! !
, i : ~~ ; \\ j\\\~~~~~~~~ iiiztr~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ?
7 c ?
7 : ?
7 ; v$LZ vi .
( K K &gt; 9/ *4 .
'CL K &gt; ( 1 )\.\ w V3 cl * ?
fr\ k0 % J ?
$4 9 * ' , i. : : " ' .
" ' : ' : : .
' i'.:':'.:. .
'.- .
' ' .
: -:'- .
" ' : ' : ' .
' : ' .
: : .
' }'..-':""'}* i{'..'-i : : ! ~:.:''.:-*-. .
' , -. .
, . !
' ' ' : " , " .
, - ' " ... '/ ' " .
' " ' !
.::- ' , :.'{ ' .
'i ' ' , - : : ' : : " ' ; - , ' - .
, ' .
' " ' - ' .
" " .
-.',.* " .':- , ' '''0 '':e " , ?
'- .
*-::*.''.'.'-.'* .
' .
' .
' " ::* , : , ~. .
' ' .
' ' ' ; ' " ' .
' ' ' ' ' " ' ' .
' .
'. .
' ' -'.'- .
' '.'.'.- , ' .
' , ' V ' C 'lr'AT f 1IXTOC92.llK '0w-0 ' T Ii9 I NK 10 0 / 4WJ V\\ N1 I\1:~\\ I ,

