On the Dicynodont Reptilia , with a Description of some Fossil Remains brought by H.R.H. PRINCE ALFRED from South Africa , November 1860 .
By Professor OWEN , F.R.S. &amp;c. Received January 23 , --Read February 20 , 1862 .
ON the return of His Royal Highness PRINCE ALFRED from the Cape of Good Hope , in 1860 , he honoured me by transmitting some fossil remains , with the following Note : " DEAR PROFESSOR OWEN , " In the course of my journey in South Africa I met with two very interesting Fossil Remains ; one , the larger , being the head of a Dicynodon : and I hope you will accept them from me as being the best specimens I obtained , upon the PRINCE CONSORT'S suggestion , on the occasion of your last Lecture , of which I retain the most agreeable recollection .
Yours truly , ; ; ALFRED."T " Windsor Castle , November 15th .
" ALFRED .
I feel it a duty , at the present season of grief at a National bereavement , which becomes daily more appreciated , to communicate to the Society this evidence of the lamented PRINCE CONSORT'S unfailing interest in our sciences , as manifested by his desire that Lectures on Natural History should be delivered before the Royal offspring ; and also as showing that , amidst the manifold occupations of the PRINCE CONSORT , he allowed no opportunity to escape in which his influence could be , in any way , exerted to aid in the direct advancement of science .
In the present instance , this influence , through the zealous fulfilment by PRINCE ALFRED of his father 's suggestion , has procured for us valuable additional evidence of the peculiar structure and characters of some rare extinct animals , which , under any circumstances , I should have felt bound to submit to the Royal Society .
Some delay has been occasioned by the necessity of removing the very hard matrix from the varied and intricate surfaces of the imbedded petrified bones , -a labour requiring to be performed under my immediate supervision , or by my own hands .
The smaller of the two fossils referred to by H.R.H. PRINCE ALFRED , has thus proved to be one of the most perfect specimens of the petrified skull of a dicynodont Reptile which , hitherto , has come under my observation .
It is figured , of the natural size , in Plates XIX .
&amp; XX .
figs. 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 &amp; 5 .
3q2 Ptyclognathus Alfredi , OWEN .
By the angular contour of the profile ( figs. 1 &amp; 3 ) , in which the almost straight line of the vertex ( v o ) meets the equally straight occipital line ( o b ) at a right angle , and the straight facial or naso-premaxillary line ( v n ) meets that of the vertex at an obtuse angle , the specimen belongs to the subgeneric form of the dicynodont family called Ptychognathus .
The occiput ( fig. 4 ) shows the same crocodilian extent of ossification as in other members of this singular family .
The articular tubercle is formed , as in Ptychognatlms declivis* , by the basioccipital ( fig. 4 , i ) at the lower and middle part , and , in less proportions , by the exoccipitals ( ib. 2 ) which just meet at the upper part of the tubercle .
The foramen magnum is a rather narrow oval , with the small end upwards , exclusively bounded , externally , by the exoccipitals ; the basioccipital appearing at the interspace of the exoccipitals immediately within the cranial cavity .
The basioccipital in advance of the tubercle , has its lower surface at first concave , and then convex , lengthwise ; and is more deeply concave transversely ( fig. 5 , i ) through the production of its sides into the short and thick hypapophyses , figs. 4 &amp; 5 , hy .
Its junction with the basisphenoid ( fig. 5 , 5 ) is by an almost straight transverse harmonia .
The hypapophyses ( hy ) are divided by a short notch from the paroccipitals ( fig. 4 , 4 ) , which abut , as in Crocodilia and Chelonia , against the inner side of the tympanics ( 28 ) , but here against their lower half , fixing these bones more firmly in their position .
The paroccipitals , which , as in the Crocodile , are exogenous growths of the exoccipitals ( ib. 2 ) , are divided by a wider and more shallow notch from the exoccipital and mastoid , s. The superoccipital ( fig. 4 , 3 ) forms the upper part of the occipital surface , is of a vertically oblong or subtriangular form , with the apex downward , and terminating some distance above the foramen magnum .
The sides of the superoccipital concavity are formed by the backwardly projecting and slightly diverging hinder end of the parietals ( fig. 4 , 7 ) ; between which and the exoccipitals and tympanics the broad and angular mastoid ( ib. 8 ) are wedged , forming the upper , outer , and posterior outstanding backwardly bent ridge , for the attachment of the cervical muscles , and presenting the sutural surface to the upper end of the tympanic , 28 .
The upper surface of the parietal ( fig. 2 , 7 ) presents a roughish nonarticular tract of about 8 lines in breadth , at the fore part of which is the venous foramen .
This median tract is made slightly concave across by the elevation of the ridges ( t , t ) bounding the smooth , longitudinally concave , tracts affording origin to the temporal muscle .
The frontals ( 11,1i ) form the chief part of the flattened vertex or upper platform of the cranium ( figs. 2 &amp; 4 , f ; t ) .
They extend longitudinally from the foramen parietale forward to about one-third of an inch from the prefronto-nasal ridge ( fig. 2 , f ) ; and transversely to the superorbital ridges ( s ) , of which they form about the middle third part .
The median or frontal suture may be traced along a great part of their extent : the surface is slightly raised at this part , and is depressed laterally , between the median M Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society , vol. xvi .
( April 1859 ) p. 49 , pl. 1 .
figs. 3-5 .
456 rising and the slightly elevated orbital borders .
There is no trace of the pair of tubercles which , in Ptychognathus declivis* , stand transversely on the frontal platform , in the line bisecting the middle of the orbits : they have not been chipped away in clearing off the matrix , either in the present skull or in that of Ptychognathus latirostrist .
The median rising at the frontal suture is continued backward over the part where it divides to go to each tubercle , leaving an intermediate shallow depression , in Ptychognathus declivis .
The frontal tubercles may be , therefore , reckoned among the cranial characters distinguishing Ptychognathus declivis from Ptychognathuts latirostris , ald from the skull of the species under description .
In this , as in the previously defined species of Ptychiogathus , the vertex or upper surface of the skull is bounded anteriorly by a low ridge ( fig. 2 , f , f ) , extending transversely with a slight curve , convex forward , from the fore part of one superorbital border to the other .
The ridge is formed by the nasals ( fig. 2 , 15 ) at the middle , and by the prefrontals ( ib. 14 ) at the sides .
The latter are strong , large , angular bones ( figs. 1 , 2 &amp; 3 , 14 ) , dividing by a prominent tuberosity the fore from the upper borders of the orbit : the frontal surface of the prefrontal is divided by the before-described ridge from the facial surface ; both are slightly concave , the latter of greater extent , reaching almost to the hinder angle of the external nostril ( figs. 1 &amp; 3 , n ) , and articulating with the nasal ( ib. 15 ) above , and with the lacrymal ( ib. 73 ) below .
The nasals ( 15 ) , divided by a median suture , bend abruptly , at the prefronto-nasal ridge , from the upper to the fore or facial part of the skull , at an open angle .
They are united for about an inch as they slope upon the face ( fig. 2 ) , and then diverge to form the upper border of the nostrils , receiving at the angles , so formed , the upper and hinder ends of the coalesced premaxillaries , ib. 22 .
The premaxillaries continue the facial line , begun by the nasals , straight to the upper margin of the mouth , which is directed forward .
There is a slightly elevated line along the place of the obliterated medial suture ( fig. 2 , mn ) , parallel with which is a pair of similar linear ridges ( fig. 2 p,5 ) , dividing the median from the lateral surfaces of the premaxillary : these surfaces have almost the same breadth , except that the lateral surface ( fig. 1 , 22 ) increases near the oral border ; it is narrowest where it forms the fore part of the nostril , n. The maxillary ( figs. 1 &amp; 3 , 21 ) is chiefly remarkable , as in the rest of the genus , for the strong ridge-like prominence ( r r ) of the socket of the long and large canine tusk , c. Between this and the outer premaxillary ridge ( fig. 1 , p ) the sides of the face are slightly sinuous , the convexity above gradually changing to a deeper concavity below , in the transverse or vertical direction ; lengthwise the sides of the face are slightly concave as they converge towards the mouth ; except at the canine alveoli , which are a little convex lengthwise at their fore part .
Above , the maxillary bounds the lower part of the nostril , and there unites with the premaxillary ( 22 ) and lacrymal ( 73 ) ; below , it is , continued from the canine-socket inward and downward , forming the edentulous sectoral border which meets the corresponding part of that border of the mandible ( 32 ) , the fore part of which , in advance of the maxillary , is strongly bent upward ( 32/ ) to meet the eden@ Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society , vol. xvi .
p. 50 , pl. 1 .
fig. 3 .
t Ibid. p. 51 .
457 tulous trenchant border of the premaxillaries , n. The back part of the maxillary is continued beneath the orbit in a pointed form , articulating by a strong , oblique and extensive suture with the malar ( fig. 1 , 26 ) , by which and the lacrymal the maxillary is removed from the orbital border itself .
The lacrymal ( 73 ) , forming the middle of the fore part of the orbit , extends upon the face apparently to the nostril .
The malar curving back along the lower part of the orbit , the border of which it there forms , bifurcates behind to connect itself with the postfrontal ( figs. 2 &amp; 4 , 12 ) above and with the squamosal ( fig. 1 , 27 ) behind ; but their limitary sutures I cannot satisfactorily make out .
There is no other bony bridge overspanning the temporal fossa except the normal malo-squamosal zygomatic arch .
The squamosal combines with the mastoid in affording the articular sutural surface to the upper end of the tympanic .
The squamosal ( fig. 1 , 27 ) is compressed , of 8 lines in vertical extent , by 2 in transverse ; and increases vertically as it passes backward .
The tympanic pedicle is of great length , broad and compressed from before backward at its upper part , becoming narrower as it descends , but gaining in thickness to where it receives the broad abutment of the paroccipital ; below which it slightly expands in every direction to form the convex articular surface for the mandible .
The tympanic pedicle is fixed immovably , and by its size and connexions forms an unusually strong 'point d'appui ' for the vigorous actions of the lower jaw .
It consists of two bones , united by a broad overlapping squamous suture .
The upper portion includes the mastoid and squamosal elements ; the latter extends to near the articular condyle , along the fore part of the pedicle ; the lower portion , or tympanic proper ( 28 ) , forms the lower half of the back part of the pedicle , and expands below to form the joint .
The mandible of PtychognathJus ( fig. 1 , 30-32 ) resembles that of the Chelonia in its edentulous condition , general proportions , and comparative simplicity of structure , and that of the Crocodilia in the vacuity left between the dentary ( 32 ) , angular ( 31 ) , and surangular ( 30 ) elements ; but it is peculiar and ptychognathic in the sudden vertical expanse and upward curve of its symphysial end ( 32 ' ) , the vertical diameter here being three times that of the articular end .
I cannot distinguish an articular from a surangular element : the suture between this and the angular extends near and runs parallel with the upper border of the surangular to the vacuity , towards which it bends .
No coronoid process is developed , nor is there any coronoid or complementary ossicle as in modern Lizards , Chelonians , and Crocodiles .
The splenial element ( fig. 5,29 ) extends far back , as in Chelonia .
The dentary elements , confluent at the symphysis , are deeply notched at their narrow hinder part , the upper projection being the longest .
A horizontal ridge extends from the upper part of the notch forward as far as the depression , lodging the end of the canine tusk when the mouth is shut .
The vacuity is situated halfway between the two ends of the mandibular ramus , not in the posterior third as in the Crocodile .
The symphysis is broad as well as high , and the rami meet there so as to form , below , an arch or curve , concave backward , fig. 5 , s. The fore part of the symphysis is convex both vertically and transversely .
The longitudinal ridge on the outside of the dentary , parallels that formed by the canine alveolus of the maxillary ; and the alveolar borders in both incline inwards , to meet at the oral margin behind the great tusks .
The mandibular ridge resembles the maxillary one in Oadenodon ; and one is led to speculate whether in that genus the maxillary ridge may have related to a rudimentary upper canine , and the mandibular ridge to that of a lower one , in the embryo .
In both Ptychognathus and Oudenodon , however , these parallel ridges in the upper and lower jaws , with the inward convergence of the alveolar plates , recall the structure of those parts in Scelidosaurus * , and which is indicated by the mandibles to have existed , in a certain degree , in Hylceosaurus and Iguanodon .
The fossil skull above described was obtained from a greenish sandstone of the Rhenosterberg .
As it manifests specific distinctive characters , I propose to refer it to a species of Ptychognathus , under the name of the young Prince by whom it has been made available in advancing our knowledge of South African fossils .
The PtychognathJus Alfredi , like Ptychognathus latirostris , differs from Pt. declivis in the more circular orbits , the absence of the frontal tubercles , the right angle at which the occiput and vertex meet , and the greater depth and thickness of the facial part in proportion to its length .
But , on comparing Ptychognathus Alfredi with Ptychognathus latirostris , the facial part of the skull presents less breadth in proportion to its length and depth , and the lower jaw is narrower in proportion to its length ; the paroccipital is also relatively narrower .
The occipital region in Ptychognzathus declivis ( Plate XXI .
fig. 2 ) shows nearly the whole extent of the masto-tympanic pedicle , and well exemplifies the singular breadth of the hinder surface of the cranium in these dicynodont reptiles .
It also shows the precondyloid foramina , and the small vacuity between the exoccipital and masto-tympanic bones .
The side view of the skull of Ptychognathus latirostris ( Plate XXI .
fig. 1 ) well exemplifies the ridged structure of the jaws and the composition of the mandible .
In the corresponding view of the skull of Ptychognathus Alfredi ( Plate XX .
fig. 3 ) is shown the extent of the pulp-cavity of the canine ( c ) , closely conforming to that in the instances of ever-growing tusks in the mammalian class .
As in former specimens of true Dicynodon , the section made to show the base of the tusk exhibits no trace of any germ of a successional tooth .
The tusk curves forward , downward , and slightly inward .
The points of both tusks have been broken away .
Dicynodon tigriceps , OWEN .
The larger fossil , obtained by H.R.H. PRINCE ALFRED from the Karoo-beds , in the district of Graaf Reinet , is a skull of a true Dicynodon , equalling in size that of the Dicynodon tigricepst .
It has been obliquely crushed , but under circumstances of sir * " Monograph on British Fossil Reptiles , " Paleontological Society 's volume for 1860 , p. 12 , pls .
4 &amp; 5 .
t Transactions of the Geological Society , 2nd Series , vol. vii .
p. 233 .
459 rounding support , which have kept the lower jaw in its natural connexions with the tympanic pedicle .
In the breaking up of the hard rock in which this fossil has been imbedded , the right maxillary , tympanic , and zygomatic arch have been removed ; the fore part of the upper jaw , from the beginning of the sockets of the canine tusks , and the corresponding end of the lower jaw , are also broken away .
The length of the remaining portion of the skull now exposed is 1 foot 6 inches ; but this is somewhat more than it would naturally be , owing to the left half of the broad occipital region ( Plate XXII .
4 , 28 ) having been bent backward from the transverse to almost the longitudinal position , in the line of the skull 's axis , and this with so little disturbance of the connexions of its elementary bones as exemplifies , with other similar condition of the skull , the gradual operation of the disturbing force , and the condition of surrounding support that has made the pressure act upon the brittle fossil as if it had been a plastic material .
For , after close observation and reflection upon all the appearances presented by this fossil , I infer that the cosmic movements affecting the matrix have operated after the sediment in which the dead body of the old reptile was buried had become , with its contents , hardened into stone .
After careful removal of the matrix from the remaining petrified bones of the right side of the skull , the occipital tubercle ( i ) was worked out in its whole length : it projects from the lower plane of the basioccipital ( h ) to the extent of 1 inch 8 lines , and from the foramen magnum ( f ) about 1 inch 4 lines ; the vertical diameter of the base of the tubercle is 1 inch 6 lines ; it slightly expands to its articular convexity .
The right side of the tubercle having been broken away , the compact or close granuloid texture of the bone is here displayed .
The occipital hypapophyses ( h ) are 2 inches in length ; the left paroccipital ( 4 ) expands to a breadth of 5 inches , where it abuts against the broad masto-tympanic pedicle ( 2s ) .
An extent of 6 inches by 4 inches of the smooth posterior surface of this singularly expanded lamelliform bone is here preserved .
The small vacuity ( a ) between the parand exoccipitals has been converted into a foramen by the meeting of extensions of ossification from 2 to 4 .
The foramen magnum ( f ) , naturally of a vertically oval form , is here made narrower by the slow lateral squeezing of the occiput ; its long diameter is 1 inch 4 line lines .
The lower angle of the superoccipital ( 3 ) is preserved , making an extent of the well-ossified occipital plane reaching to 4 inches above the occipital tubercle .
The removal of the outer part of the maxillary and the zygomatic arch has brought into view part of the interorbital septum , and the upper and outer part of the bony palate ; structures that have not been shown by previous specimens of Dicynodon .
The descending cranial plate of the frontal , where it forms the inner wall of the orbit and the rhinencephalic continuation of the cranial cavity , is shown at 1 , Plate XXII .
The basisphenoid ( ib. 5 ) is short and deep , and sends out a process uniting with one from the pterygoid , to abut against the tympanic pedicle .
The presphenoid ( ib. 9 ) projects forward as a compressed plate 10 lines in vertical diameter ; in its length or extent of ossification it exceeds that in the Chelonia , and more resembles that in the Crocodilia ; at its base there arise some thin rays of ossification , which ascend to unite with a similarly attenuated lamelliform base of the orbitosphenoid .
I infer that there was persistent cartilage in this part of the skull .
The orbitosphenoid ( ib. 1o ) becomes thicker as it ascends to unite with the under part of the hindei third of the frontal , and with part of the parietal .
It is perforated by a foramen opticum of elliptical form , 6 lines in long diameter .
Below and anterior to the presphenoid is seen a small part of the vomer ( ib. 13 ) , where it expands laterally to join the palatine ( ib. 20 ) and pterygoid , ib. 24 .
The pterygoid , about 5 inches in length , contracts as it extends backward , bounds above or mesially the outer part of a long elliptical foramen ( posterior nostril , ib. n ) , and then bends downward and outward to join the basisphenoid and abut against the lower end of the tympanic .
There appears to have been a part of the interorbital space unossified , about 3 inches in length , 1inch broad below , but suddenly contracting to a width of 1 an inch at the upper part .
The exposed bottom of the right socket of the canine tusk ( ib. fig. 1 , c ) shows the similarly exposed pulp-cavity of the beginning of that tusk , which measures 1-1 inch across .
The walls of the tusk increase in thickness to about 3 lines in an extent of 1inch .
A greater extent of the left socket ( Plate XXII .
fig. 2 ) is preserved , showing the concentrically lamelliform structure of the base of that tusk .
Sufficient of the mandible is preserved to demonstrate its characteristic dicynodontal composition .
The alveolar border of the dentary element is toothless .
The ramus rapidly augments in depth towards and at the symphysis , where a portion is broken away .
The posterior part of the dentary ( ib. fig. 1 , 32 ) is notched or bifurcates to form an oblong vacuity at the middle of the mandibular ramus .
Traces of a long surangular ( ib. fig. 1 , 30 ) , which developes no coronoid process , of a broader or deeper angular ( ib. 31 ) , and also of a splenial ( ib. 29 ) , are discernible amongst the elements of the lower jaw .
As a whole , the present instructive specimen exemplifies the near equality in size of some of the strange extinct two-tusked reptiles of South Africa to the existing Walrus ; it also shows that in the structure of the bony palate the Dicynodon combines , as in other parts of the skull , crocodilian with chelonian and lacertian characters .
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATES .
PLATE XIX .
Fig. 1 .
Side view of skull of Ptychognathus Alfredi : not .
size .
Fig. 2 .
Upper view of the same skull : not .
size .
Fig. 3 .
Side view , with section of tusk , of the same skull : not .
size .
Fig. 4 .
Back view of the same skull .
Fig. 5 .
Under view of ditto .
PLATE XXI .
Fig. 1 .
Side view of skull of Ptychognathus latirostris : not .
size .
Fig. 2 .
Back view of Ptychognathus declivis .
PLATE XXII .
Dicynodon tigriceps .
Fig. 1 .
Side view of skull : 3 not .
size .
Fig. 2 .
Socket and base of canine tusk : not .
size .
( II .
) On the Pelvis of the DICYNODON .
By Professor OWEN , F.B.S. &amp;c. The following description is taken from a part of the petrified skeleton of a Dicy- , nodon equalling in size the species , D. tigriceps , Ow .
, to which the cranium described in , the preceding paper belongs , and exemplifying the structure of the pelvic part of the , trunk of that extinct animal .
This instructive fossil is from the same locality in the Graaf Reinet district : as that : from which the specimen of the skull of the JDicynodon tigriceps was obtained which is described in the seventh volume of the 2nd Series of the Geological Transactions * .
It formed the nucleus of a huge nodule of greyish-blue argillo-ferruginous limestone , transmitted from that locality by A. G. BAIN , Esq. , F.G.S. , and is now in the British Museum .
In a front view of this specimen ( Plate XXIII .
fig. 1 ) seven successive vertebrae are seen ; but there is an appearance of slight dislocation at the expanded and co-adapted , articular ends of the two anterior of these ( D &amp; s 1 ) , which indicates that they were not anchylosed together ; the rest seem to have coalesced , although traces of the intervertebral articulations remain .
One-half of the last vertebra ( Plate XXIV .
s 6 ) is broken away .
The length of the six entire centrums is 1 foot 2 inches .
The first vertebra ( Plate XXIII .
fig. 1 , D ) supports a pair of long , comparatively slender curved ribs ( pl ) , articulated to strong outstanding transverse processes ( d ) .
These were the last or hindmost pair of free ribs , and indicate great breadth in that part of the trunk .
The second vertebra ( ib. s i ) , which is the first of the sacral series , sends out a pair of broad and thick parapophyses ( ib. p ) , to each of which is attached a longer and broader pleurapophysis ( ib. pi ) .
This rapidly expands as it extends outward , and underlaps , or passes anterior to , the iliac bone ( ib. 62 ) .
It resembles in shape the human scapula , but is much thicker .
The hinder and inner border of this sacral rib is thick , and smoothly rounded ; the front border is thinner , and is slightly concave ; the outer border appears to have been straight , but is somewhat mutilated .
This expanded termination of the rib rests on the ventral side of the ilium , concealing much of that bone in a front view of the pelvis .
It has not been anchylosed therewith ; decomposition of the ligamentous uniting matter , and subsequent partial dislocation , have allowed the matrix to insinuate itself between the sacral rib and the ilium , as seen at a , fig. 2 , Plate XXIII .
Of the short , thick , transversely extended ribs of the five succeeding sacral vertebrse , the left of the penultimate ( pt ) is the best preserved towards the pelvic cavity ; it presents a smooth convex or rounded surface about an inch in breadth , is slightly bent with the concavity towards the outlet of the pelvis , and abuts against the ischium .
The bodies of the sacral vertebrae ( s ... .5 ) are contracted at the middle , and slender there in proportion to them pelvis , but are rapidly and much expanded at their articular ends ; consequently they are very concave lengthwise , both below and at the sides ; but are smooth and convex transversely , yielding a semicircular transverse section .
The parapophyses go off near the base of the neural arch .
The first centrum ( s i ) is nearly ; 3 inches in length , and as much in breadth at the articular end , but is only 1 inch 3 lines across the middle ; the rest ( 2 ... 5 ) slightly diminish in length as they approach the tail .
The ilium ( Plates XXIII .
and XXIV .
62 ) is a strong straight triangular bone , at least 10 inches in length from the upper border of the acetabulum ( Plate XXIII .
fig. 2 , c ) ; above which it is contracted to a breadth of 3s inches and a thickness of 2 inches , and then expands to a breadth of 8-1 inches , measured along its oblique anterior border or labrum , Plate XXIV .
fig. 4 , 11 .
The front part fr aontnterior two-part of thirds of the ilium expands into a rough flattened surface , 6 inches in length , and 3 inches in breadth anteriorly ( ib. fig. 4 , r ) , to which the back surface of the expanded first sacral rib is ligamentously attached .
The inner surface of the ilium extends 6 inches behind this articulation , and is almost flat , but rather sinuous : coarse bony ridges or rays of ossification appear on this surface , near the labrum ( i ' ) , diverging thereto .
The outer surface of the ilium is moderately concave transversely .
This anterior expanded part of the ilium passes behind and in advance of the last pair of free ribs ; the relations of which , and of the first sacral ribs , remind one of those of the answerable vertebrae in the pelvis of birds .
The ribs of the second and third sacral vertebrae also abut against the ilium .
The ischium ( Plates XXIII .
and XXIV .
63 ) , behind or beyond the acetabulum , forms a short and very thick prominence ( ib. fig. 2 , t ) which receives the abutment of the ribs of the fifth sacral ( Plate XXIV .
pl s ) : below or behind this it receives a similar abutment from the ribs of the last sacral vertebra ( p1 6 ) .
The space , corresponding to the 'great ischiadic foramen ' in Edentate mammals , is thus divided into two vacuities .
The ischium becomes thinner , but is of great breadth where it forms the lower wall of the pelvis and converges towards its fellow to form , with the pubis , the long symphysis ( Plate XXIII .
fig. 2 , y ) ; here it again increases in thickness .
A fracture , with a slight dislocation on the left side , has taken place where the suture with the pubis may originally have existed ; but on the right side no trace of such suture is visible ; and the perfect state of the surface of the pelvis at this part demonstrates as complete a confluence of the two bones , with each other and the ilium , to form a large 'os innominatum , ' as in mammals .
The pubis ( Plates XXIII .
and XXIV .
63 ) is remarkable for the bold and broad anterior convexity ( b ) of its iliac half , the inner part of which is perforated by an elliptical aperture ( figs. I &amp; 4 , f ) , answering to that in the pubis of the Monitor .
The outer part of the bone is produced into a short obtuse process ( r ) , less developed proportionately than that in the Monitor 's pubis .
Beyond this process the inferior border of the pubis bends downward and forward , rendering the antero-inferior surface of the half of the bone next the symphysis concave .
The symphysis makes a slight angle near its beginning ( Plate XXIII .
fig. 1 , y ) , projecting towards the pelvic cavity : the suture , there , is obliterated .
The inferior or symphysial wall of the pelvis measures 14 inches across in a straight line from the border of one acetabulum to that of the other .
The length of the symphysis ( ib. fig. 2 , 63 , Y , 64 ) in a straight line cannot have been less than 8 inches ; but the upper or anterior margin is wanting ( ib. fig. 1 , 63 ) .
Its external contour is first concave , then convex , lengthwise .
The broad , subquadrate ischio-pubic walls of the pelvis on each side the symphysis are slightly concave , outwardly , both vertically and transversely ; the hinder three-fourths of these appear to have been formed by the ischium ( 64 ) : there is no ' obturator ' space or vacuity , merely the outlet of the pubic perforation appears externally .
Both ischia and pubis combine to form a continuous tract of bone at the symphysis , which presents a thick protuberance at its lower or outer part near its termination ( Plate XXIII .
64 ) .
The thick posterior border of the ischium is concave below the acetabulum , lengthwise , expanding into an angular tuberosity .
The outlet of the pelvis ( Plate XXIV .
fig. 3 ) is of a semielliptic form , 9 inches in transverse and 4 inches in the fore-and-aft diameters .
If the inlet or brim of the pelvis ( Plate XXIII .
fig. 1 ) be defined by the smooth thick convex border of the first sacral ribs ( pl ) , it presents an oval form , and measures 11 inches in transverse and 10 inches in fore-and-aft diameters , the latter being taken from the middle of the first sacral vertebra to the symphysis .
From the study of the above-described most interesting portion of the dicynodont skeleton , we learn1st .
That there were no lumbar vertebrae , i. e. none bearing the technical anatomical characters of such f ; but that free ribs continued to be developed to the pelvic or sacral series .
2nd .
That the sacral series includes six vertebr.e .
3rd .
That the ilium , ischium , and pubis coalesce into an ' os innominatum .
' CVVIER , 'Ossemens Fossiles , ' pi .
17 .
fig. 39 , b. t This negative character is open to the same kind of objection as that relative to the 'hippocampus minor ' in animals below man .
464 4th .
That the junction of the ossa innominata with the vertebral columnl is effected in two ways-by an overlapping or squamous syndesmosis , and by the usual abutments : thus the anterior bony wall or surface of the pelvis , analogous to that formed by the expansion of the iliac bones in mammals , is here formed by the expanded ribs of the first sacral vertebra , 5th .
That the ischium of the right side joins that of the left , and the right pubis joins the left pubis ; and that both pairs of pelvic hemapophyses are coextended and confluent , not only along a continuous ischio-pubic symphysis , as in mammals , but so as to obliterate the intervening vacuities called 'foramina ovalia seu obturatoria , ' thereby repeating the character of the connate abdominal hemapophyses in the chelonian plastron .
In the comparison of this new and , at present , unique type of pelvic structure , it is interesting to observe , in connexion with the mammalian tusks in the skull , a mammalian condition of the ischio-pubic symphysis .
I lay less stress on the degree of coalescence expressed by the term ' innominate bone , ' because in some lizards I have observed a like confluence of iliac , ischial , and pubic bones , yet never with that amount of expansion of the iliac element which the Dicynodon shows , and in which , again , may be discerned a mammalian characteristic .
If the remains of the huge reptiles of the extinct IDinosaurian order had not revealed to us an extent of sacrum so much surpassing that of all living Saurians , one would have laid more stress on the character of the six sacral vertebrae in the Dicynodon , as repeating that in some mammalia .
But in this modification we may not be justified in inferring more than that , like the Miegalosaurus and Iguanodon , a heavy trunk was in part supported on a pair of huge hind limbs , and the weight thereupon transferred by a larger proportion of the vertebral column in the Dicynodon than in the prone , crawling Crocodiles and Lizards of the present day .
As the lacertian characters prevail in the skull of the Dicynodon , so likewise do they in the pelvis : the backward production of the iliac bones , their confluence with the ischium and pubis , never met with in Crocodiles or Chelonians , and , above all , the oblique perforation of the pubis near its acetabular expansion , are all repetitions of structures known only , among existing Reptilia , in the lizard tribes .
But the massive and entire anterior or ventral bony walls of the pelvis , the thick tumid acetabular halves of the pubic bones , and the great expanse of the overor rather under-lapping pleurapophyses of the first sacral vertebra , are dicynodontal specialities , and suggest immense strength in this part of the massive framework of these strange extinct Reptilia .
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATES .
PLATE XXIII .
Dicynodon tigriceps .
Fig. 1 .
Front view of pelvis : not .
size .
Fig. 2 .
Side view of pelvis : not .
size .
465 Fig. 3 .
Back ' view of sacrum and pelvis : } not .
size .
Fig. 4 .
Os innominatum , inner surface : 4 not .
size .
The outline restored by dots , where abraded .
( III .
) Notice of a Skull and parts of the Skeleton of RHYNCHOSARITUS ARTICEPS .
By Professor OWEN , F.R.S. &amp;c. The rocks in South Africa containing the Dicynodont Reptilia , appear , by other fossils , especially of some plants , to belong to the Triassic period .
It is in the New Red Sandstones of Europe and of our own island , that reptilian remains have been discovered which offer the nearest approach , though the gap is wide , to the dicynodont type .
A lizard which , in biting , with trenchant edentulous jaws , may also have pierced its prey by a pair of produced weapons analogous to the tusks of Dicynodon , has left its remains in the New Red Sandstone of the Grinsill quarries near Shrewsbury .
In this singular species ( Rhyncizosauzrus articeps* ) the premaxillary bones , by their shape and structure the bony tissue of the produced tips acquiring the hardness and almost the texture of dentine-and by the production of their sharp end ( Plate XXV .
fig. 2 , 22 ' ) beyond the mandible ( zb .
32 ) , may have inflicted wounds and served a purpose , like those of the upper curved tusks of the Dicynodon .
I take the present opportunity of briefly noting a second example of this exceedingly rare fossil reptile , found , like the first , in the Grinsill sandstone , and liberally transmitted to me for examination and description by the Directors of the Museum of Natural History at Shrewsbury .
This fossil consists of the skull almost entire ( Plate XXV .
figs. 1 and 2 ) , with about fifteen of the anterior vertebre ( ib. figs. 3 and 4 ) more or less mutilated ; and in the same slab of stone are parts or impressions of several ribs , a humerus ( ib. fig. 3 , 53 ) , antibrachial ( ib. 54 , 55 ) and metapodial ( ib. 57 ) bones .
All these parts agree sufficiently in size and other characters with the first-discovered specimen to be referable to the same species .
The apparent greater breadth of the cranium is due to its having been crushed almost flat ( fig. 1 ) , which has correspondingly expanded the mandibular rami ( fig. 3 , 31 , 31 ) ; but the force has been applied either so gradually , or , whether gradually or suddenly , with such equable support from the surrounding matrix , that there has occurred little fracture or dislocation .
The temporal muscles have encroached upon the sides of the parietal ( fig. 1 , 7 ) , so as to develope a straight median crest along that bone .
The outer and back part of the temporal fossa is bounded by a strong triangular mastoid ( ib. s ) , which unites by an oblique suture with the long postfrontal , 12 .
The prefrontals are seen at 14 in fig. 1 .
A portion of the lower or true zygomatic arch , not preserved in the first specimen , is seen at 24 , in fig. 2 .
The long , slender , curved and dense premaxillaries ( 22 ) are in the same good state of preservation .
The lower jaw is likewise preserved in situ , as when the mouth is shut .
There is the same compound structure and entire or imperforate outer surface of the ramus as in the original specimen .
The symphysis is very short , fig. 3 , y. A long and slender bone , on the inner side of the articular end of each ramus , appears to be a part or 'cornu ' of the hyoid apparatus , fig. 3 , 40 , 40 .
The vertebrae are biconcave , with broad horizontally flattened zygapophyses and a moderately high , subquadrate compressed , fore-and-aft extended spine .
The ribs acquire thoracic length at about the eighth vertebra from the head , and are longitudinally grooved as in the Ichthyosaur .
There is an impression of a broad scapula ( i6 .
51 ) and broader coracoid ( ib. 52 ) near the remains of the proximal half of a humerus , ib. 53 .
The humerus has an expanded proximal end , and a concave outline behind ; it has also a large medullary cavity with a compact wall .
The radius ( ib. 54 ) and the ulna ( ib. 65 ) are distinct .
The remains of apparently a metatarsus show two of the larger and two of the rather more slender of these bones .
All bespeak a reptile capable of progression on dry land , as well of swimming in the sea ; of one that might leave impressions of its foot-prints on a tidal shore .
The skull of a rare New Zealand Lizard is figured in Plate XXV .
fig. 5 , as coming nearest to the Rhynchosaur in the proportions of the divided premaxillaries ( ib. 22 ) , each with a large and long tooth , which , were it completely confluent with the bone , would add still more to its resemblance to the New Red Sandstone fossil .
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATE .
PLATE XXV .
Rhynchosaurus articeps .
Fig. 1 .
Upper view of skull .
Fig. 2 .
Side view of skull .
Fig. 3 .
Under view of the mandible and fore part of skeleton .
Fig. 4 .
Portion of the vertebral column .
Fig. 5 .
Side view of the skull of Rhynchocephalus ( recent ) .
All the figures are of the natural size .
467 ?
di .
'uI ' ' " fi ?
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4 i. .
' ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ . ! .
S5E..1XX'tZrt/ ' '". .
( ... *I m ^ld " lI ')10(1M 1PO^T^ 1 I , ?
V'n~ ?
/ 1 ?
Ir ... I[V ?
Yi W-12 'd 2 ypjZW 17gy1j :/ .
; \ ' '\ I * , ^^P : 8\ i+s\\ 1 '** Wt4d~~~~~~~~"\.S2 d X* ai 'S,.\ , .
-x* " v ?
3 , ^ ^ 'fflI^JTIIDOaCl/ t^^ ^ '"''''-'^^ 1^

