On the Contact of Curves .
By WILLIAM SPOTTISWOODE , M.A. , P.R.S. Received October 15 , -Read November 21 , 1861 .
LET U=O be the equation to the curve with which the curve V=O has an " m-pointic contact ; " in other words , let the curves U and V have m consecutive points in common .
The degree of contact of which V is capable is equal to the number of independent constants contained in its equation ; i. e. to the number of terms in its complete expression , less one .
Thus if n be the degree of V , the degree of contact will be -= ( n + 1 .
1.2 If the curves U and V have only a single point in common , then the only conditions are U=0 , V=0 ... .
( .
) If they have two consecutive points in common , then beside ( 1 .
) we have also b ax aU dU z= dx+ die + dz 0 , dx + V ... ... .
( 2 .
) a xd+ die z ; az which , as is well known , lead to the conditions U. BZ Bu .
dx die dz =aV av av'V* ( 3 .
) dx * die dz ' and if V be linear , lx+my+nz , ( 3 .
) will suffice to determine the ratios 1 : m : n , and fix the position of the tangent V. The conditions ( 3 .
) may be expressed by a single equation thus : if a , 3 , y be any arbitrary quantities , then the equation y -0 ... ... ... ( 4 .
) bU Bu bU by v brv dx die dz abV av aV dx die dz considered as identical in a , ( 3 , y , may be regarded as an expression for the required conditions .
The developed form of ( 4 .
) is / u aVU dV / au bu\ by / u au 'av ( y die 0 dzJ dw+tM dz 7 dz y+ dd * * so that , writing ' aU aU u , au aU 'a v / bu au\ aY die y dzJ dz + -r -dJ die +P dx die ) dz= ' .
( 6 .
) the effect of the operation O upon V is equivalent to the elimination of dx , die , dz , from ( 1 .
) and their differentials ( 2 .
) , and is expressed by the equation = ... ... . .
( 7 .
) If the curves have three consecutive points in common , we have , in addition to former conditions , Ud2+ d y+--d u +2 d 2+ 2U dy2U+ a 2+2a d +2U 2U dd x+y d+--z dz dxd-t+ ay -k dz2 dydz+ d-ddzdx+ dxdy -0 sv-+ , BV- , .
av- , d , v.y - , d2z+yv , , y'+ , yv/ , .
( z __ av 6V b2V -62V _2V ja2v 2 ( 8 .
) d X+ die die + dz+ ddz d2+d y2dy dy2+ dz 2+2\^ dydz 3 ?
dzdx ?
dVdxd ) -0 from which dx , die , dz , d2x , d2y , d2z are to be eliminated by the help of ( 1 .
) and ( 2 .
) , or ( 3 .
) .
Instead , however , of differentiating ( 2 .
) , we may differentiate ( 3 .
) , or , what is the same thing , ( 4 .
) ; and we shall then have an expression free from d2x , d2y , d2z .
The results of the elimination may , moreover , in this case be grouped into a single expression .
Writing for convenience bU a bu b da BU a au b=bU B bu die d-d die dz dd z-y dd--= Dy3 ' .
( 9 .
) ( 3 .
) may be expressed by any two of the equations D , V=0 , D2V==0 , D3V=0 ... ... ( 10 .
) Differentiating these and combining their differentials with the first of ( 2 .
) , we may form the quadratic system , D2V =0 DD2V=-0 DD3V= D2D , V=O D2V =0 DD , V=O ... ... ( 11 .
) D3D , V=0 D,3D , V= DJV =0 , J all of which are comprised in the one equation V= o ... ... ... ( 12 .
) And generally , by a similar train of reasoning , the constants of a curve V , having an m-pointic contact with U , will be determined by the equations V=0 , OV=O,. .
" V-0 ; ... ... ( 13 .
) and if V=(a , b,. .
1kx , y , z ) =av +bkdv ( 14 .
) da db dk , then a : b:. .
k=V av by -i da db " dk Dv ov Z3v 0V_u da ?
db ' ?
dk The equations ( 11 .
) are , however , not all independent .
In the first place , as in ( 10 .
) any one of the three equations is a consequence of the other two , so in ( 12 .
) any one column or row is a consequence of the other two .
Secondly , if any pair of binary combinations of the Ds , e. g. D , D2V and D2D , V , be developed , they will , with the help of ( 10 .
) or ( 3 .
) , be found identical .
This reduces the system ( 12 .
) to three independent conditions , of which D2V=0 , D , D2V=0 , DV=0 ... ... .
( 16 .
) is a type ; as it should do .
These three equations will suffice to determine the three independent constants of V , when it is capable of a 3-pointic contact , and no more , with U. The actual calculations may be considerably simplified by using , instead of ( 13 .
) , the following system , V=0 , DV=O , D2V=0 ( where , as before , D stands for any one of the symbols D , , D2 , D3 ) .
Of this system ( 16 .
) is a consequence .
By way of example , we have for the ordinary tangent V=ax+ by+cz=0 , DV=aDx+bDy+cDz=0 , whence a : cx D.y ... . .
( 17 .
) Dx Die Dz =yDz-zDy : zDx--xDz : xDy-yDx U die dU =d : die dz ... ... ( 18 .
) The equation of the circle of curvature may be put in the form hr2+ 2(ayz + bzx + cxy)0 ; to which are to be added , hD r2-1 2(aD yz+ bD zx+cD xy)=O , hD2r2+2(aD2yz+bD2zx+cD2xy)=0 , G2 43 whence r2 2yz Dr2 2Dyz D2r2 2D2yz h : a : b : c 2zx 2Dzx 2D2zx 2xy 2Dxy 2Dwxy ; ... ( 19 .
) also Dui4 ' bu Dr2 =2(z'a_U ) a. U au D--2 die + =dz/ d+2 zD ?
]-yDJ-dd Dyz 2-y zDD Dyz-= ?
z die 'au 'au 'yau au D2yz= -2 +yDdy zD dz ' Dz =D2zx=xD~ xU Dxy dbU D2xy = -xD U Moreover the minors formed from the first two rows of the matrix , and from the columns below written , have the following values:2_ , U du 'U r , 2yz = x{_(y_z ) + dz } r2 , 2zx =x{ -y U Z22 ) aU +y dz } --c , &amp; + die --/ dz 2y= zaU bU 2_y2)U r~ , 2x--=x --ydx Z-dy + , 2x , 2yz=2Xy2 , U whence , finally , dz ' 2yz , 2za =2xzz2 d ; h : a:b:c _aU aU au 2xyz dx dyx -d die d n-( 1-)2u 2u ; ( U +( x2-y2 -2 ) ( ; _i ?
H ?
2-{ y )+ ( x~y+z ) ( n H , 2 au 'au)2 ( 3U 2+(_X2_y2 Z2 ) zH dz { dx dy )}( ) ( 20 .
) where H is the Hessian of U. 44 Proceeding by the same principles , we shall have merely to replace E by D in ( 15 .
) , and there will result a system of expressions for the constants of the curve V having an m-pointic contact with a given curve U. The following method of reduction may sometimes be used with advantage .
Let 5 , 5 , ,. .
p , X , 4 stand for the powers and products of the variables forming the various terms of V. Then the coefficients of the curve V having an m-pointic contact with U will be proportional to the determinants of which the following is a type : Dm-2~ Dm-l. .
Dm- ' , D -2 Dm-2. .
Dm-2^ .
JDMBm-DmD"m-37 D"-S ; . .
D'm_-'i. .
D"-3 % A. .
24Dm-2%. .
3 Dm-S3. .
; 7 t ? ? ?
2 .
Dm-39 ( P : D , ~ Dm-3X Dm-3s ' Dm-4x Dm-441 X At =(--)2Dm-2q B Dm-37 D2 Dm-3. .
Dm-3x Dm-2 4 D-4. .
D-4X D-4 g. .
, x , =(_)m-2 2Dm"-2 ED-3Sr. .
2DB D1-2 B DX D ; / x4 e ... ( 21 .
) In the case of the conic of 5-pointic contact this becomes -SED3S2 ID2y2Dz2D3 2Dzx 2Dxy zx xy I now proceed to the calculation of the conic of 5-pointic contact .
This may be effected by any of the three methods indicated above , viz. ( 1 ) by means of the symbol O , getting out the factors ( cx+f3y+yz)P ; ( 2 ) by means of the symbols D ; ( 3 ) by the reduced formula ( 21 .
) .
As most of the steps have been calculated by two methods , I subjoin some of the leading formulae and transformations which occur in the process .
But this 45 =(_ )2 D , D , t-3 ; 7D Dm-3. .
D. .
; .
Writing for convenience au abu Uu vu 'u au X-~-dydz ' d= dz dx ' P d ; dyand putting V= ( abcfghixyz)2 , the general expressions ( 13 .
) become 0= ( abefghjxyz)2 , 0= ( abcfghiYjv(xyz ) , O= ( abcfgh3jx p)2 + ( abcfhi'gh^ 0 El El p0 &gt; xyz ) , 0 3(abcfgh1j D El ED p:xy , Xv ) + ( abcfgh)E 2 EO DD 2Xxyz ) , O= 3(abcfgh El X El D Y)2+ 4(abcfgh El 2E2 El 2v'Xp ) + ( abcfghX D 3X ED 3pE 3)xyz ) , whence a : 6 : c : f : g : h 3EX+C+xD2X. .
3( +Er)+y v3+ so 22 , X2+xX. .
2Pv+yE +zx C E+ .
( 22 .
) xX. .
y~-pzv. .
x2 y2 z ? ?
2yz 2zx 2xy .
The most convenient method for developing these formulae is to begin with forming the 15 minors derived from the last two lines ; and by means of them , the 20 minors derived from the last three lines ; and so on .
It may be noticed that in order to pass to the corresponding expressions in D , e. g. D1 , it is only necessary to make 03=0 , y= 0 , and to divide out the as .
This gives bu bu x-=0 , -dZ ) , =-dy The results of the calculations are as follow : the third minors , formed from the two lower lines of ( 22 .
) , and from the columns the lower constituents of which alone are written down , will be 2I 2 M.u '2 My z= -Yz- ; - ' z , -=z- , x , y dz 2x , 2=x_y-Z u2bU *2z y_ zU , 2zxJ , 2xy=2,2 ' 2xy , 2yz=2y2 2yz , 2zx=2z-- , 2zx~ ' X dW , 2yzz2d-U dz 20z x e , 2x=xN x2 , 22-2 , , / 2yz=a U 22U -3U 2,2 -2U Y $I YVIdy -Z dz J ' ' die x ' 2dy=zdz ' d dX ) ~,2 , 'r-dz ' 2 , 2auy z2 , za , 2zx= ( -2 ' Z2 , 2*y=z d , d-2 die dx I , z2#z zzUdy Z 2XYz dx die 46 Similarly , for the second minors , xa2 , 2xy , 2xz=x3(n--1)-2H , 2xy , y2 2y=y3(n-1)-2H , 2xz , 2yz , z2 =z3(n-1)-12HI , x2 , 2z 2zx=2 ( )U 2JaU ( n-1)-2H , xy2 , 2yz 22( U)2 ' x(n1)-2 2zx , 2xy , z2=2 d ( j-d X2(n-1)-2H , 2 , y2 , 2z = { Q U)2 aU ?
2(_2-l)-2H } 2x 2 , z u ( zu ) ' a= +2(n-l)-2H , y2 , y2 2 , ={( )U 2 +2(n--2 z2 , y2,2iz={(aU ) 2 +.2/ ( 1)-2H } t2 y2 z2_=_au_aU 'au 2)E 2yz , x,2zx=2 d die z2 &amp; 2 2yiz = aU\2'U iZ2X2(nJ)-2H1 2x , 2x , 2z= -)2 + ( n-1)H , x2 t , y- , 2d ( -6 U2d)y } , yz2z,2,2 __ + bu r -1)-2H a &gt; !
y '2 -(fo _j_ _fe + X2y )-2/ 2^ , 2^ , 2xy=+ zx~~-1)-1I-I , , 2= ~ __ ( n H x2 ' y~ z2U b\au _yz(n_l)_2 , H , ?
L~ : ~ ' --dx die dz Z 2yz , 2zx , 2xU U2 2x#z(n_l)_2H .
2yrz , 2zx , 2x# --2 ~ , )x die dz Similarly , for the first minors , ,y,2 z,2 2z 'U au au aH a b\ d aU au bu ayu\ x2 , y2 , z2 , 2xyz-dx dx dx dzdy dyxdzcdx dz dxzdyy a y'2 z2 aU Jau " aUabH au aH 3H au au au u\ ) 2 , z , 2 , z , 2 , y--d die -dx -dx dx dz -0 dx dydxdx dJydzj u2 2 2x 'U au ?
u HUE 'aH ) ?
3H( u a2u au au2 ^y , z2 , 2zy , 2yz=-d d/ x dxd d3H d d_ d , dz da dx die die dx d d-x\dd dzy~ dzdy die adzdxj 32 2 bU 'auU -fu _ T( u aau 62U d'~ dz d xy d dz d ) dz dyydxd dx dydzj -6 aU -a6e gI iau zu 11u aU H2 2 22 x , 2yz U U/ Zu H BU H\ o/ Zu a2u uy dx SzY-zdy dx id die ddx dx dxz ) y2 , Z2 , 2 zx 2yaU U Z)U aH a6U aH\ , au a2u a'au 'a2U y , X2 ; , 2x , 2C Cdx Kydx x ?
die ) d dxyddy J)'2 2Uaurauau H 'U aH .
aU a2UaU a2U , z2x 2y , 2z u-j_-3 H Z2 , XS2ZI2 ZX1 22-dY/ dly K dx die die dz did dyddz dz dy2 , J ' 2 a9 2_ 36(u u UH bU HY OU ZBU aU ayU\ z , x , 2xy , 2yz dH_ -dx x , z / d2Yzx -1 yd dz dx die die dx / die dxdzdx _ubu U bH -u a\ , U au UubMU H2 Zx , y2 , 2yz , 2zx die d die die d 3H d dyx-d d did , 21y , 2zx , 2x , r-U )U aU QH UZ ) H U ) 1 au au )2 U } e 2 , y2 2Uz , 2xy =I _ fUy U\ H6H '-2 f--\ bU z\y2 dz z , ^ die dz dz die , 1\d dydxz dz , dx x ydzJ '22 2ax-Z Ud UZH aUdH\ 'au dyu aU 'a2 u 2yz , 2z , 2 z,2 2-2-3H I_ dz &amp; dz y dz dz ydd dzdz dxd yz\ U bU 'aH 'au bHX '/ U'2U 'aU.a2U 2vz 2za 2a-v ^H aU a a^25d a+ a H2 z , X , ^d Z_ u duz -d .
dz dx d x. ~ dz ydxy ) ~d ~dydz ~ ( n2 2x 2 =2 23 U dI3Ua)311 Z ) yy $ 48 Proceeding to the calculation of the final expressions for the coefficients a , b , c , f , g , h of the conic of five-pointed contact , which is given rather more in detail , we have , dU dU dU writing -~=- , -dy-=V , z- , =2 y2 , z2 , 2zx , 2xy=D4x2(y2 Z2 , 2zx , 2xy ) +D4y2(z2 , 2zx , 2xy , x2 ) +DD4z2(2zx , 2xy , x2 , y2 ) +2D4zx(2xy , x2 , y2 , z2 ) +2D4x y(xq , y , z2 , 2zx ) --(3(Dw)2+4wD2w-yD3w)v ( v D H3HD v ) +(3(Dv )2+4v D2v +zD3'v )w( , wD H3HD w ) ( xD3v )w(wDH -3HD2w ) D3w)v ( v D , H 3HD , w ) =3(w2(Dv)2-v2(Dw )2)DH+4vw(wD2v -vD2w)DH + ( w2zD3v+vyDow)DH-x(2D3'vD2H+v2D3wD1H ) + 3H { 3DvDw(vDwwDv ) + 4vw(DvD2DwD2v ) -yvDvD'w zwDwD'v + xvD vD3w+xwD2wDyv } -3(wDvvDw)D(w)DH + 4vwD(wDvvDw)DH 9(wDv-vDw)DvDwH+12vw(DvD2wDwD2v)H +Dv{w2(zDH-xD2H)3Hw(zDw-aD2w ) } -D3w { v(yDH --D , H ) -3Hv(yDv -xDv ) } =:(n)-2x2{ 3D(vw)HDH+ 4vw(DH)29DvDwH2 } +12v-wH(DvD2w -DwD2v ) + 3vwHD2(vDw-wDv ) 3vwH(DvD2w-.wD2v ) , which , omitting the common factor ( nw-1)-2x2 , =3D(vw)HDH+ 4vw(DH)2+ 9(n-1)-2H3d 9vwaH2 +9 3(n-2 ) H2 x+_ ) 3(HH HDH n-cx Ii 49 But 33 ( n -2 ) 2 'a H 'xx die +H 3D(Vw)HDH+63 nU)vwlH2-6 nL awH( ad+ H+@ dd ) , B(vL)e\/ uD~)( 'aH 'a H\ H 'a_H 3(vDw+wDV)(d die )H+6v Uw(Dwdy dz )H =(3v2Dw+3vwDv-6vwDv)H d -(3vwDw+3w2Dv-6vwDw)Hdy ' 3H wH =3Hv(vDw-wDv ) d3Hw(wDv--vDw ) 7 .
=-3(n-1)-2x2H2 ( w +V H ) Hence , excepting the common factor ( n-1)-2x2 , the total expression forf ( V l\^2 2TT3U 91 12 2112u ( H.U aH\ =9(n-1)-2l 2H ) a3 U 3(n-1)-2 &amp; 2H2 aH +U aH die ) v-w{3H(D ( ab HH+ H ) 3 ( n-2 ) H~-_4(DH)2 } And comparing this with Mr. CAYLEY'S expressions in arts .
14 and 15 of his memoir " On the Conic of Five-pointic Contact , " in the Philosophical Transactions for 1859 , pp. 376 , 377 ; and bearing in mind that in his formulae we must make x=l , ==0 , v=0 , in order to institute a comparison ; and lastly , dividing throughout by ( n-1)-2x29H3 , and multiplying by 2 , the expression above written becomes ayv 21H au H 'Ua 2 aU aU 2 dydz-3 H\ die dz + dz die A ' die dz ' which is in fact the coefficient of YZ in his general formula , viz. aX+Y a +Z 2 ) U2 ( H(xH H+YH+z'H ) ?
( XuHu+u xa ( y +z a)=uo xx d$ +Y + dZ=0 .
The identity of the expressions forf , as deduced by the present method , with that deduced by Mr. CAYLEY having been thus demonstrated , it is unnecessary to pursue the calculations further .
The following are the principal subsidiary formulae used in the foregoing calculations .
=U X+ Pie +yz z , bU zbU bU You tf dx xv die [ -y X d+ d yv--z _I , z\OX--x xv=d xO -y\--yOX d b'u 'u b ~yD~-y-zD/ =D ry , zD &gt; --Dy=D _0 .
, ,b+ abU abUo 50 Also writing we have also dxo+ die + dz pDv--DvO=ajI , vDXA-XDv=p= , XD --~DX=yHI ; -n= )2U dx b2U dydx y2u dxdy d)2 dy2 b2U a2U dzdx dzdy dbu by dx die c0 b2u dxdz ba2 dydz C O9TT bu dx au die 7 TT 2H , ( n-1 ) f r-u Cu dz7z 7 3U 0O dz y0O where H is the Hessian of U. The corresponding reduced form of i. e. when a=l , 3=O , y=0 , is / aU\ 2yu aU bU ayu au\2 a2u H2 dz dy-2 dz die did + die dz2 ~ ( n-1)H And by means of these we may deduce the following:this expression , wDv-v Dw=(n-1)-2 H , wD , v -v D , t=(n--l)-2yxH , wD2v --v D2=(n-1)-2zxH , uDw-wDu=(n-l)-2xyH , uD , w-wDl , u=(n-1)I2y2 H , uD2w--wD2 =(n-l1)-2zyH , vDu--uDv=(n-l)-T2xzH , v D , u -uD , v=(n-1)-2yz H , v D2u-uD2v =(n-1)-2z2H .
Again , bU bU yD , H-zD , H=3(n-2)dH , zDH-xD2H=3(n-2 ) dyH , D , H-yDH=3(n-2 ) dH yD2U--zD , u=(n--1 ) ( d ) , zDw-xDw=xD , v-yDv=(n--1 ) -d dzTo which may be added , OXD u+ DOpD v+ aD w=MHA , D XD , u+ O pD , v+ O vD1w= H=M , O XD,22+ 0p , -D2v+ vD , w = Hy , uDv+vD , v+wD2v=O , D =-(n-l )- ' ( xH)3Au+3xH , D2v = -(n-1)-2 a ( x2H)-3Av , D'w= ( nl)-2 ( 2H)3Aw , 2 51 -.MRi .
W. SPOTTISWOODE ON THIE CONTACT OF : CURVES .
uYDv +vDD , v +wDDv =-(n-l)-'lvH , uDIw +vDD , Ul+wDD2w =-(n1)7lwxH , xDD1 , +yDD , v +zDDw = ( n-l)-2xyH , yDv --xD , v =xD2w--zDw=--(n--I ) vw , vDD2a -wDD2u= D{(n--1)-2yzH}--(n--1)-1vyH , uDD , u -uDDv = D{(ln-1)-lyzH}--(n--l)-wzH , zD , u -yD2a =-(n-1)V , ~4 , DvDw= ( n-1)-x2H U , DvD2w-DwD2Ov=(n-l)-22{Dw I I-DH vd -aH } , bH bH -Dv -=(n-)13(--2 ) --+ 6 a-H H ) } , D ' dz ( nd &amp; die Hd whence DvD2wDw D2v==(n-l ) -I(3 ( )-_ ) IH --(a + i. ) } to which many others light be added .
to which many others might-be adlded .
52

