On Thallium .
By WILLIAM CROOKES , Esq. Communicated by Professor G. G. STOKES , Sec. R.S. Received February 5 , -Read February 19 , 1863 .
Occurrence , Distribution , and extraction from the Ore. 1 .
SINCE the date of the last paper on Thallium which I had the honour of communieating to the Royal Society* , I have been unremittingly engaged in attempting to find a source from which this metal could be extracted in quantity .
Having first discovered thallium in the deposit from the chambers of a sulphuric-acid manufactory , I naturally turned my attention towards similar deposits from English oil-of-vitriol works where pyrites was burnt .
Applications were accordingly made to several large manufacturers for specimens of the pyrites which they used , and also for some of the deposit from their leaden chambers .
These requests , with scarcely an exception , were readily responded to , and in a short time I was in possession of specimens from nearly thirty different establishments .
In many instances thallium was detected in the pyrites , but I was disappointed to find that the deposits of sulphate of lead from the chambers contained no thallium whatever .
I then applied to manufacturers who I had ascertained were constantly burning thalliferous pyrites , and obtained from them specimens of the products in different stages of their manufacture , but in no instance did I find an accumulation of thallium in any part of the operations .
2 .
In the operation of burning the pyrites , the thallium oxidizes with the sulphur and volatilizes into the leaden chambers ; .
it there meets with aqueous vapour , sulphurous and sulphuric acids , and becomes converted into sulphate of the protoxide of thallium .
This being readily soluble both in water and dilute sulphuric acid , and not being reduced by contact with the leaden sides , remains in solution and accompanies the sulphuric acid in its subsequent stages of concentration , &amp;c. It is not probable therefore that any thallium can accumulate in the insoluble deposit , but it will remain dissolved in the liquid , where indeed I have found it--not however in quantities sufficient to be worth extracting , as it is present in scarcely a larger proportion than in the original pyrites .
That this view of the path followed by thallium is correct , I am satisfied both from careful analyses of products from various manufactories , and also by experiments tried on a small scale in my own laboratory .
M. LAMY states that he extracts thallium from similar deposits to those which I have examined ; but as I have experimented on residues from English manufactories in which they burn pyrites almost , if not quite , as rich in thallium as that used in M. KUHLMANN'S works , there must be some cause or local arrangement in their manufactory , different from what is usually adopted in this country , to occasion so large an accumulation of thallium at one particular stage of the operations* .
3 .
Having failed in my endeavours to find a residue from a manufactory which would yield thallium , I turned my attention to the ores in which it was likely to occur .
The unique collection of minerals brought together at the International Exhibition of 1862 enabled me , through the kindness of the various commissioners and class-superintendents , to verify the opinion which I had formerly expressed as to thallium being a very widely distributed element .
It most frequently , indeed almost invariably , occurs in iron pyrites containing more or less copper ; but I have also detected it in native sulphur , in zinc , cadmium , bismuth , mercury , and antimony ores , as well as in the manufactured products from these minerals .
Thallium is confined to no particular country , but is at the same time by no means uniformly distributed in mineral veins from the same locality , or even in adjacent rocks in the same mine .
Hitherto I have detected no approach to law in its distribution .
In every country mineralogically represented in the late Exhibition I have detected the presence of thallium , when the minerals examined were at all numerous and could be regarded as fair average samples of the different deposits .
Doubtless much of this apparent abundance is to be attributed to the extreme delicacy of the test employed , as ores in which thallium is present , only in the proportion of 1 to 100,000 , give evident traces of it in the spectroscope .
Many pyrites , however , contain more than a mere trace of thallium : it is present , in sufficient quantity to be readily extracted by direct treatment , in pyrites from various parts of North and South America , France , Belgium , Spain , as well as Cornwall , Cumberland , and many parts of Ireland .
4 .
The optical process of detecting thallium in a mineral is very simple .
A few grains only of the ore have to be crushed to a fine powder in an agate mortar , and a portion taken up on a moistened loop of platinum wire .
Upon gradually introducing this into the outer edge of the flame of a Bunsen 's gas-burner , the characteristic green line will appear as a continuous glow , lasting from a few seconds to half a minute or more , according to the richness of the specimen .
By employing an opake screen in the eyepiece of the spectroscope to protect the eye from the glare of the sodium line , I have in half a grain of mineral detected thallium when it was only present in the proportion of 1 to 500,000 .
After a few experiments of this kind , and having a thalliferous pyrites of known richness for comparison , it is easy to give a rough estimate as to the quantity of thallium present .
5 .
One of the richest thalliferous minerals in the Exhibition was the prominent block of pyrites , weighing nearly two tons , which formed so conspicuous an object in the Belgian department ; it was exhibited by the Societe Anonyme de Rocheux et d'Oneux of Theux , near Spa ( Belgium , Class I. , No. 18 in the Catalogue ) .
Accompanying the principal block were several smaller specimens from different parts of the same locality .
Thallium was detected in all , but in very varying proportions .
By the great kindness of Professor CHANDELON of Liege , one of the jurors of Class II .
, I was enabled to examine a series of examples from four separate chambers , and eight different rocks from the mine whence these specimens were brought , he having most courteously taken the trouble to visit the locality and select the specimens for me .
In some , as in rocks C , D , and G , no appreciable quantity of thallium was present ; in chamber No. 1 there was a trace only , whilst in chamber No. 2 , and in rock H , it was present in comparative abundance .
Professor CHANDELON , to whom I desire to offer my hearty thanks for his uniform courtesy and valuable assistance , informs me that those portions of the mineral vein which I have found most rich in thallium are close to a vein of blende and calamine , which is worked in the neighbourhood for zinc .
I am promised some of this blende and calamine for analysis ; and it will be of some interest to know the relative quantity of thallium they contain in comparison with that in the adjacent pyrites .
I have already found considerable quantities of thallium in metallic zinc and cadmium manufactured from this ore .
Professor CHANDELON not only troubled himself to make several journeys from Liege to the mines on my account , but likewise induced M. RENARD ( the manager ) and the proprietors to present me with upwards of two tons of the mineral carefully selected from those parts of the mine which I had found to be richest .
This arrived in September last .
6 .
Numerous experiments have led me to adopt the following process for extracting the new metal from its ore .
The pyrites is first broken up into pieces about the size of a walnut , and placed in cast-iron retorts , capable of holding 201bs .
each ; five of these are arranged in a reverberatory furnace , so that the flame may lick round and heat them uniformly ; iron condensers being luted on , the temperature is raised until the retorts become of a bright red heat , at which they are kept for about four hours .
They are then allowed to cool , and the product removed from the condenser ; 100 lbs. of pyrites usually give from 13 to 17 lbs. of sulphur .
The sulphur is of various colours , according to the temperature attained , sometimes being orange , sometimes purple-brown , sometimes bright grass-green , and is always highly crystalline .
' Experiments tried at various times during the distillation , show that thallium is present in the first portions of sulphur which distil over , as well as in the last , although the proportion somewhat increases towards the end .
When the heat has been sufficient , and the yield of sulphur above 15 per cent. , scarcely a trace of thallium remains behind in the retorts ; but with a low heat , the sulphur is almost pure yellow in colour , and contains very little thallium .
Each operation lasts about five hours ; the iron retorts frequently serve for two , and sometimes for as many as five or six heatings .
They gradually , however , become converted into sulphide , and then melt away .
This sulphide of iron contains no thallium .
Within the last three months I have distilled upwards of 16 cwt .
of iron pyrites , yielding me 2cwt .
of thalliferous sulphur .
The results are appended : November 8 , , , 14 , , , 29 , December 11 , , , 13 , 15 , , 16 , January 3 , l , 5 , 7 , , 8 , , , 9 , , , 10 , 12 , , , 14 , 24 , ? ?
26 , , , 27 , , , 29 , , , 30 , 1862 , 14 lbs. , , 24 , 120 , , 70 100 100 , , 100 1863 , 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 100 1828 It may be of some interest to state tl air-dry state , I invariably get from eac distilled over before the sulphur comes of pyrites yielded lbs. ozs .
26 of sulphur .
, , , , 3 8 , , , ,,5 12 7 , , , , 8 12 , , 9 , , , 12 5 , , , , , , 12 8 , , , , 14 5 , ,,9 13 5 , , , , , 12 9 , , , , , 11 4 , , , , 15 4 , , , , , , 14 7 , , , , , , 14 13 , , 16 3 , , , , 15 2 , , 16 4 , , , ~ , 13 13 , , , , 17 2 , , 14 5 9 , , , 11 9 , 252 3 rat , although the mineral is put in in its ordinary sh 100 bs .
of pyrites about half a pint of liquid 3 .
Upon evaporating this down , water , having a peculiar empyreumatic odour , goes off , oxide of iron is precipitated , and sulphite of the protoxide of iron separates in large , nearly colourless crystals : no thallium is present .
7 .
I have met with great difficulty in extracting economically , and without loss , the whole of the thallium from this sulphur .
On the small scale , nothing is easier than to boil it , finely powdered , in fuming nitric acid or aqzua regia , until the residuary sulphur is of a pure yellow colour , and then to extract the thallium from the solution by processes to be hereafter described ; but such operations are impracticable when working by the hundredweight .
An attempt was made to separate the thallium by converting the thalliferous sulphur into chloride .
Half a pound w+as treated in this manner ; but upon rectifying the product , thallium was found in the distillate as well as in the residue .
An immense number of experiments were tried to extract the thallium from the chloride of sulphur , but with no success , unless indeed means were employed which would have been equally easy and economical upon the original sulphur .
The simplest plan would doubtless be to dissolve out the sulphur with bisulphide of carbon , in which sulphide of thallium is insoluble ; and this is a plan that I hope before long to have in full work ; hitherto , however , I have found the following the readiest method : In a large cast-iron caldron dissolve 12 lbs. of good caustic soda in 1l gallon of water , heat it to the boiling-pcint , and then add 18 lbs. of the sulphur in large lumps , just as it comes from the receivers .
A few pounds should be added at a time , as dissolved , and the mixture kept gently boiling , water being added from time to time to replace that lost by evaporation .
When no more sulphur can be dissolved , dilute the mixture with four or five times its bulk of water , and allow it to cool .
A voluminous black precipitate will separate , which must be collected on a calico filter .
The greater portion of the thallium remains in this precipitate in the form of sulphide , together with iron , copper , &amp;c. ; but some passes through dissolved in the alkaline liquid .
I have hitherto been unable to recover the thallium from this solution without an incommensurate expenditure of both acids and time .
After a slight washing , the black precipitate is transferred to a large dish , and boiled in sulphuric acid until sulphuretted hydrogen ceases to be evolved ; nitric acid is then added in small quantities , and the mixture is boiled until all solvent action has ceased ; it is then diluted with water , and filtered .
Evaporate down until all excess of nitric acid is removed , and then add hydrochloric acid and sulphite of soda to the liquid ; this produces an immediate precipitation of the thallium in the state of protochloride as a white crystalline precipitate , only slightly soluble in water ; as , however , a certain quantity of this chloride remains dissolved , it is advisable to add , after the sulphite of soda , iodide of potassium , which precipitates the whole of the thallium in the form of an insoluble yellow iodide .
If the solution turns almost black upon adding the iodide of potassium , or the precipitate comnes down of a dirty grey colour , it is a sign that an insufficient quantity of sulphite of soda has been added ; a further addition will remedy this .
A little copper , which is generally present in the sulphur , will likewise be precipitated in the form of subiodide .
The iodides are to be filtered off , and washed until they are free from iron .
They may now be decomposed by heating with oil of vitriol , which converts them into sulphates ; but the temperature required for this being very high , and the decomposition difficult to effect perfectly without loss of thallium by volatilization , I prefer the following , though somewhat longer process:-Boil the iodides in excess of suLlphide of ammonium until they are entirely converted into sulphides ; filter , and wash with weak sulphuretted water until no iodine can be detected in the washings ; then boil the precipitate with strong sulphuric acid , adding a little nitric acid from tinme to time ; evaporate until the sulphuric acid begins to go off in white vapours , and then , after dilution with water , add an excess of ammonia .
Now add cyanide of potassium until the blue ammoniacal solution of copper is decolorized , and then a slight excess of sulphide of ammonium , and gently warm .
Filter and wash with dilute sulphuretted water until all the cyanide of potassium , &amp;c. is removed , and boil the precipitated 177 sulphides with strong sulphuric and nitric acids until the mass becomes perfectly white .
Drive off the whole of the nitric acid and the greater portion of excess of sulphuric acid by heat , and then boil the residue for some time in water .
l'inter , and wash well .
A white insoluble residue will generally be left , containing a little thallium ; but the greater portion of this metal will be in the solution in the form of sulphate .
8 .
From this solution the metal is readily obtained in the metallic state by voltaic precipitation .
Two or three cells of a Grove 's battery , with platinum terminals dipping into the aqueous solution of the sulphate ( either acid or rendered alkaline with ammonia ) , produce an immediate reduction , oxygen being evolved at one pole , and the metal coming down at the other .
The appearance presented when a tolerably strong solution of thallium is undergoing reduction is very beautiful .
If the energy of the current bears a proper proportion to the strength and acidity of the liquid , no hydrogen is evolved at the negative electrode , but the metal grows from it in large crystalline fernlike branches:spreading out into brilliant metallic plates , and darting long needle-shaped crystals , sometimes upwards of an inch in length , towards the positive pole , the appearance strikingly resembling that known as the tin tree .
Some of the tabular crystals , as seen in the liquid , are beautifully sharp and well defined , their angles being temptingly measurable ; considerable difficulty is , however , met with in disengaging them from the electrode , and removing them in a perfect state from the liquid .
So long as thallium is present in the solution , no hydrogen is evolved with a moderate current ; as soon as bubbles of gas begin to form , the reduction may be considered complete .
The crystalline metallic sponge may now be squeezed into a compact mass round the platinum terminal , and , being disconnected from the battery , quickly removed from the acid liquid , rinsed with a jet from a wash bottle , and transferred to a basin of pure water .
The metal is then carefully removed from the platinum , and kneaded with the fingers into as solid a lump as possible .
It will be found to retain its metallic lustre perfectly under water , and coheres together readily by pressure .
The lump may now , after having been dried with blotting-paper , be put into a steel-crushing mortar and strongly hammered until it assumes the form of a solid ingot .
To obtain this in a fused mass , the best plan is to break it up into small pieces , and drop them one at a time into a crucible containing fused cyanide of potassium , at a low red heat ; they melt at once and run together at the bottom of the crucible into a brilliant metallic button : allow the crucible to cool , and dissolve out the flux with water , when the thallium will be left in the form of an irregular lump , owing to its remaining liquid and contracting after the cyanide has solidified .
As long as the surface is wet , either with the solution of cyanide or with pure water , the metal presents a highly crystalline appearance , resembling tin when washed with acids ; this disappears upon exposure to the air , owing to the formation of a pellicle of oxide .
Physical Characteristics of Thallium .
9 .
Thallium has a distinct colour of its own , not being absolutely identical with any 178 other metal .
The true colour can be seen by scraping a piece of the metal under water , or fusing it in hydrogen and allowing the melted globule to flow away from the dross .
In appearance it most resembles tin and cadmium , not being so brilliantly white as silver , but without the blue tinge belonging to lead .
It is susceptible of taking a very high polish : by rubbing it under water with a fine polishing stone , the surface can be made smooth and bright , reflecting as perfectly as a mirror .
It oxidizes in the air with almost the rapidity of an alkali-metal .
When freshly cut with a knife , if the eye follows the blade , the proper colour of the metal will be seen to assume , in a few seconds , a yellowish cast , caused by a thin coating of the protoxide , which continues to increase until the metallic lustre is obscured by a grey film , scarcely distinguishable from the superficial tarnish of metallic cadmium .
At this stage the oxidation appears to be almost arrested , and the metal may be freely handled and exposed to the air , with scarcely any further change .
After having remained in the air for some weeks , the surface becomes covered with a white powder , which easily rubs off , and has a strong biting taste .
When rubbed between the fingers , a faint peculiar smell may be observed , unlike that produced by any other metal under the same circumstances .
If a perfectly bright surface of thallium is applied to the tongue , no taste whatever is observed ; but a tarnished surface tastes strongly alkaline , and somewhat sweet like oxide of lead ; whilst if the surface is more oxidized than usual , from the metal having been long exposed to the air , or previously raised to a high temperature , the taste is very caustic and biting , remaining on the tongue for some hours , and resembling that observed when the tongue is applied to the terminals of a voltaic pile .
10 .
Thallium is the softest known metal admitting of free exposure to the atmosphere : it can be cut , pressed out , and moulded with the finger-nail with the utmost ease ; and whilst it is incapable of abrading the surface of a piece of lead , this latter metal scratches thallium with great facility .
Thallium marks paper as easily as lead : the streak is blue at first , but almost instantly turns yellowish , and in the course of a few hours nearly fades out , from oxidation .
The writing can , however , be restored at any time to more than its original blackness by exposure to sulphuretted hydrogen or sulphide of ammonium .
Thallium is too soft to file well or be cut with a saw , as it clogs up the teeth directly , and it does not become brittle when exposed to a low temperature .
It has very little tenacity , being inferior to lead in this respect .
It is very malleable , and may be hammered out into leaves as thin as paper ; it may also be moulded and pressed in a die , taking a very sharp impression .
When repeatedly hammered , it does not appear to get sensibly harder or require annealing .
I have succeeded in drawing it into wire ; but , owing to its want of tenacity , this is a matter of some difficulty ; the wire may , however , be obtained in a very easy way by pressure .
Dr. MATTHIESSEN has been good enough to prepare for me several specimens of wire by pressing the metal with a powerful vice through a fine hole in a steel box , receiving the wire as it issued forth in tubes filled with dry carbonic acid , and various liquids : I have also prepared it since in similar apparatus of my own .
It is squeezed into wire more readily than lead , and when received into dry carbonic acid or petroleum , without contact with air , and instantly sealed up , its true metallic lustre and colour are very apparent ; if , however , a very minute trace of air obtains access , it assumes a deep blue appearance .
This is remarkable , as the first superficial coat of oxide which forms on a freshly cut surface , freely exposed to the air , is distinctly yellow .
11 .
I have carefully determined the specific gravity of thallium .
It varies according to the treatment the metal has previously undergone .
A lump melted and allowed to cool slowly under cyanide of potassium , was found to have a specific gravity of 11 *81 .
The same lump , after being strongly hammered in a steel mortar , had its density increased to 1188 .
Another portion , experimented on in the form of thick wire , had a density of 11-91 immediately it had been squeezed through the die .
I believe that thallium is capable of undergoing still greater condensation .
If in the process of squeezing it into wire the vice is screwed up until the thallium is just making its appearance through the fine aperture , and the pressure is then kept stationary , the issue of metal proceeds for a few seconds and then stops .
Upon now applying the flame of a spirit-lamp to the die , a piece of wire from an eighth to half an inch long quickly shoots out .
This cannot be due to ordinary expansion by heat , as it commences and terminates abruptly at an apparently definite temperature .
Were it expansion by heat , the formation of wire would proceed nearly uniformly as the temperature increased .
The most probable explanation is , that the application of heat gives the metal power suddenly to release itself from an abnormal state of condensation into which the enormous pressure had forced it .
Thallium wire is almost devoid of elasticity ; it retains any form into which it is bent with scarcely a tendency to spring towards its former position .
When freshly prepared , thallium wire is perfectly amorphous , and remains so if kept at the ordinary temperature in petroleum or carbonic acid ; in water , however , it gradually assumes a superficial crystalline appearance , resembling the moire metalliqule of tin plate : this effect is immediately produced when thallium in wire , ingot , or plate , tarnished or clean , is boiled in water .
12 .
In fusibility thallium stands between bismuth and lead , its melting-point being 550 ?
Fahr. : it does not appear to become soft and pasty before undergoing complete fusion .
Two pieces of the metal , when perfectly clean , are capable of welding together in the cold by strong pressure .
I have repeatedly filled the steel die with small scraps and cuttings of thallium , and squeezed them out into one continuous length .
Wire so made is apparently as tenacious as that obtained from one lump .
Thallium volatilizes easily : when heated out of contact with air , it evolves vapours at a red heat , and boils below a white heat .
In a current of hydrogen gas it may be easily distilled at a red heat ; it does not , however , condense very perfectly ; for if the hydrogen be ignited , even after traversing four or five feet of cold glass tube , it burns with a bright green flame .
Thallium is a pretty good conductor of heat and electricity .
My friend Dr. MATTHIESSEN is at present engaged in the quantitative determination of these constants of the metal , upon specimens with which I have supplied him .
Its electro-chemical position is very near cadmium , being precipitated from the sulphate by zinc and iron , but not by cadmium or copper .
Professor WHEATSTONE is examining in this respect specimens of the metal specially purified for the purpose .
Thallium is strongly diamagnetic .
A small permanent horseshoe magnet was suspended vertically , poles downwards , to one arm of a very delicate balance , capable of turning to 0'0005 of a grain .
After being accurately counterpoised , a lump of metallic thallium , weighing about 200 grains , was placed beneath the magnet , very close , but not touching .
Upon now observing the weight of the magnet , it was seen to be decidedly repelled by the metal , losing in weight 0'003 of a grain .
By the kindness of Professor FARADAY , who himself tried most of the experiments , the above observation was verified with the large electro-magnet belonging to the Royal Institution .
Upon suspending a long cylindrical helix of thallium wire horizontally in the magnetic field , and maling contact with the battery , it was strongly driven to an equatorial position .
A lump of the metal , suspended almost in contact with one of the magnetic poles , was repelled from it , being permanently deflected nearly a tenth of an inch from the perpendicular .
From a comparison with bismuth under somewhat similar circumstances , I am inclined to believe that thallium is one of the most diamagnetic bodies known .
14 .
Thallium readily alloys with other metals .
With 95 per cent. of copper it forms a hard button , flattening somewhat under the hammer , but soon cracking at the edges ; the further addition of thallium produces a very hard and brittle gold-coloured alloy ; and when the proportion of thallium is further increased , the colour of the copper is entirely lost .
A very minute quantity of thallium , less than half a per cent. , melted with copper , greatly diminishes its malleability and ductility , acting in this respect like arsenic .
I believe that the variation in the physical properties of different specimens of commercial copper ( a variation which has never yet received satisfactory explanation ) is to be attributed to the presence of more or less minute traces of thallium , as I have found it present in many samples of bad copper , as well as in some specimens of crystallized sulphate ( 29 ) .
This subject is still under investigation .
Five per cent. of thallium alloy readily with tin , when they are melted together under cyanide of potassium ; the resulting compound is perfectly malleable .
With mercury , thallium forms a solid crystalline amalgam .
Thallium melts readily with platinum : if a portion of the metal is placed on the end of a platinum wire and heated to redness , a fusible alloy is obtained , which is crystalline , very hard , and almost as brittle as glass under the hammer .
If this alloy is heated before the blowpipe , the characteristic green colour is vividly communicated to the outer flame ; before the oxyhydrogen blowpipe the green light is of extraordinary splendour .
A similar alloy is left when the platinochloride of thallium is heated to redness in a crucible , chlorine going off together with a little thallium .
The remarkable simplicity of the spectrum of thallium has given rise to repeated experiments with a view to ascertain whether , and under what circumstances , it could be obtained compound .
I have already stated* that " a flame of sufficient temperature to bring the orange line of lithium into view produces no addition to the one thtlliumline ; and an application of telescopic power strong enough to separate the two sodium lines a considerable distance apart still shows the thallium-line single .
" The former observation has lately been verified and extended by Dr. W. ALLEN MILLER , who has also noticed that at the high temperature of the electric spark several new lines , especially fwo green and a blue line , make their appearance .
The latter observation , as to the unresolubility of the green line , was recently put to a crucial experiment .
My friend Mr. BROWNING , the well-known philosophical-instrument maker , kindly allowed me to examine the thallium-spectrum in a spectroscope which he is making for Mr. GASSIOT .
This instrument is furnished with nine flint-glass prisms of large size ; and although as yet unfitted with the elaborate adjustments with which it will be ultimately furnished , it is even now capable of producing , with a moderate magnifying power , an apparent separation of the eighth of an inch in the two sodium-lines , at the standard microscopic distance of ten inches .
Under this enormous amplifying power the thallium-line was still seen single , being as fine and sharply defined upon the black ground as either of the constituents of the double sodium-line .
I have stated that in a spectroscope of the ordinary size the line appears to be identical in refrangibility with the line 6 in the barium-spectrum ; a comparison of the two spectra in this large instrument showed me that these lines do not coincide in position .
The delicacy of this optical test for thallium is very great .
I prepared a standard solution of sulphate of thallium , and diluted it until it was in the proportion of one grain dissolved in fifteen gallons ( or about 1,000,000 grains ) of water .
Upon dipping a platinum wire loop into this solution , and holding the moistened end in the flame of the spectroscope , the green line was distinctly visible .
The quantity of liquid taken up by the platinum wire was about the fifth of a grain , containing , therefore , no more than 5 , o00o , o0th of a grain of sulphate of thallium .
A flame strongly coloured with thallium can be obtained by passing hydrogen over chloride of thallium at a high temperature and then igniting it .
The absolute monochromatic character of the light renders everything illuminated by it either green or jet black : coloured sealing-wax , ribbons , a bouquet of flowers , as well as coloured precipitates , are entirely altered in appearance , whilst the human face assumes a horrible , corpse-like green hue .
The green thallium-line can be reversed in the spectrum ; but this is an experiment of some difficulty .
The effect can , however , be well seen by adopting the plan which I have used to show the same phenomenon in the case of sodium--by holding a small thallium-flame in front of a larger one coloured with the same metal , the mantle of the front flame being projected as a black line on the hinder flame .
If a trace of lithia is added to the larger flame , insufficient to destroy the green colour , the effect of contrast is very striking ; the border of the front flame being opake to thallium , whilst it is transparent to lithium , the flame appears of a beautiful green colour with a crimson edge .
16 .
The atomic weight of thallium has been a subject to which my attention has been directed for some months , in fact ever since I commenced to obtain the metal in sufficient quantities to enable me to purify it to the requisite degree without too much diminishing my stock .
The investigation is far from concluded as yet , and the numbers which I have obtained must be regarded as only approximate .
M. LAMY* gives the equivalent as 204 .
As , however , he gives no statement respecting the processes adopted to arrive at this figure , and we are not even informed of the number of experiments of which this is the mean result , of the quantities of material operated upon , or the divergence of each result from the mean 204 , it is impossible to know what value is to be attached to it .
Below I give the results of five separate determinations by different methods : I admit they do not agree so closely as one would like in experiments of this sort ; indeed the discrepancies are beyond the probable error of analysis , and seem to point to some other disturbing cause not yet ascertained .
I give , however , all the necessary figures , and the results may be taken for what they are worth .
About 200 grains of thallium , prepared as already described , were specially tested for , and purified from , metals with which it was likely to be contaminated , by processes appended in the analytical notes , and were obtained in the form of sulphate .
This was recrystallized twice , and the metal precipitated from its aqueous solution by two Grove 's batteries , platinum electrodes being employed .
The metal was then fused under cyanide of potassium , and , after being cleaned in dilute acid , preserved for use in a dry bottle filled with coal-gas .
Some of this purified metal was then dissolved in dilute sulphuric acid , the solution was evaporated down , and the residue heated until sulphuric acid ceased to come off ; it was then redissolved in water , and the sulphate of thallium allowed to crystallize .
The salt was then considered to be sufficiently pure for analysis .
I. Some of the crystals were heated to incipient fusion and weighed , they were then dissolved in water , and iodide of potassium was added until no further precipitation of iodide of thallium took place .
The precipitate was then warmed and allowed to settle , collected on a tared filter , washed with water , dried in a water-bath and weighed .
II .
Another portion of sulphate of thallium was heated and weighed as above described , and the aqueous solution precipitated with nitrate of baryta .
The precipitated sulphate of baryta was then collected as usual , well washed , and weighed .
III .
A third portion of sulphate of thallium was weighed as before , dissolved in a small quantity of warm water , and mixed with a slight excess of pure hydrochloric acid ; alcohol was then added , and the precipitated chloride of thallium collected on a tared filter , washed with alcohol , and weighed .
IV .
A piece of metallic thallium was weighed and converted into sulphate .
The $ Comptes Rendus , December 8 , 1862 .
2c2 183 i8MR .
W.i CROOKES ON THALLIUM .
excess of sulphuric acid being driven off by heat , the remaining sulphate of thallium was heated to its fusing-point and then weighed .
V. The sulphate of thallium obtained in experiment IV .
was dissolved in water and mixed with an excess of bichloride of platinum .
The precipitated platinochloride of thallium , which is more insoluble than the potassium salt , was then collected on a tared filter , washed , and weighed .
The following Table shows the experimental results obtained : Experiment I. 7*342 grains of sulphate of thallium yielded 9-655 grains of iodide of thallium .
Calling x the equivalent of thallium , we have the following proportion , 7-342 : x+48 : : 9-655 : x+127,. .
x=202-73 .
Experiment II .
9-883 grains of sulphate of thallium gave 4-577 grains of sulphate of baryta .
9-883 : x+48 : : 4-577 : x+116-5,. .
x=203-55 .
Experiment III .
8-555 grains of sulphate of thallium yielded 8-127 grains of chloride of thallium .
8-555 : x+48 : : 8-127 : x+35-5,.- .
x=201-85 .
Experiment IV .
10-113 grains of thallium yielded 12-503 grains of sulphate of thallium .
10-113 : x : : 12-503 : x+48,.- .
x.203-1 .
Experiment V. 12-503 grains of sulphate of thallium yielded 20 312 grains of platinochloride of thallium .
12-503 : x+48 : : 20-312 : x+205-2,.- .
x=203-56 .
I have therefore adopted the mean result 202-96 or 203 as the equivalent of thallium , writing the protoxide T10 and the sulphate T10.S03 , unless , indeed , as appears probable from theoretical considerations , these compounds have to be expressed T120 and T120.SO3 , in which case the atomic weight would be half this number .
Chemical Properties of Thallium .
17 .
Thallium does not decompose pure water , either at the common temperature or when boiling .
If , however , steam be passed over the metal at a red heat , it is decomposed , with formation of oxide of thallium and separation of hydrogen , the gas evolved burning with a decided green flame .
The oxide which forms superficially when thallium 184 is exposed to the air is the protoxide , a powerful base , soluble in water , forming a liquid which is strongly alkaline to test-paper .
If a lump of thallium , weighing 50 or 100 grains , is placed , after exposure to the air for a few days , in an ounce of water and boiled for a few seconds , the solution will be found to possess alkaline characters .
It turns litmus paper strongly blue , browns turmeric paper , has a metallic alkaline taste , and perfectly neutralizes acids .
It also precipitates alumina from a solution of alum , evolves ammonia from chloride of ammonium , and reacts with hydrochloric acid , iodide of potassium , sulphide of ammonium , &amp;c. , in the characteristic manner of a thallium-salt .
As might be imagined , thallium is readily acted on by air and water jointly ; and by shaking up pure thallium wire in a bottle with an insufficient quantity of water to cover it , allowing fresh air to have access from time to time , a strong solution of oxide of thallium can be obtained .
When thallium is melted in the air , it behaves very similarly to lead , rapidly oxidizing and becoming coated with a fusible oxide resembling litharge .
Upon continuing the heat , this increases , whilst the bright globule in its centre diminishes in size .
The fused oxide is absorbed by bone-ash , and I have ascertained that a silver-thallium alloy can be cupelled like silver-lead .
When the metal is strongly heated on charcoal before the blowpipe , it volatilizes in brownish fumes , which are without odour .
Upon removing the heat , the red-hot globule of metal continues to bum and give off vapours for some time afterwards , like pure antimony under similar circumstances .
On cooling , the adjacent parts of the charcoal are coated with globules of sublimed metal .
The oxide resembling litharge is the same as that formed by the superficial action of air on the metal , or steam at a high temperature ; it may also be prepared in strong solution by decomposing sulphate of thallium with baryta water and filtering .
The oxide may be obtained in the crystalline and anhydrous state by evaporating this solution to dryness in vacuo .
Its physical characters having been fully described by M. LAMY , I have not further experimented with it .
Alcohol exerts a curious action upon thallium .
A coil of pure thallium wire was placed in a tube with some absolute alcohol , just sufficient to cover it .
At first no action was apparent , except a slight opalescence of the spirit .
In the course of a few hours this had disappeared , and upon close examination needle-shaped crystals , together with a few drops of a colourless heavy liquid , were observed adhering to the sides of the tube and sinking in the alcohol .
In three days the wire was nearly eaten away , whilst the oily drops had considerably increased in bulk .
The alcoholic liquid was carefully decanted from the heavy oil and tested : dilution with water produced no change in it ; .it was strongly alkaline to test-paper , and reacted in other respects like a strong solution of protoxide of thallium .
Upon the addition of a drop of hydrochloric acid , a thick curdy precipitate of protochloride of thallium was produced .
The oily liquid was decomposed upon the addition of water , solidifying to a yellow orystalline mass of protoxide of thallium , which dissolved on further addition of water and heating .
185 Upon evaporating the alcoholic liquid over a water-bath , a further formation of the heavy oil took place .
The production of this oily liquid , by dissolving oxide of thallium in alcohol and evaporating , has been previously observed by M. LAMY , who calls it Thallic Alcohol .
18 .
Thallium dissolves in sulphuric acid with ease , evolving hydrogen .
The gas given off burns with a flame in which thallium can frequently be detected with the spectroscope , although I have hitherto failed in proving the existence of a gaseous compound of hydrogen and thallium .
Upon evaporating the solution , sulphate of thallium crystallizes out .
I have little to add to M. LAMY'S description of this salt .
It forms large , well-defined colourless crystals ; when heated to a little above the boiling-point of sulphuric acid , they fuse to a clear liquid , which on cooling appears glassy and slightly crystalline .
The salt is soluble in twenty or thirty times its weight of cold water , and in much less when boiling , crystallizing out with facility upon cooling .
Thallium dissolves with the utmost rapidity in nitric acid .
A piece of the metal thrown into this acid mixed with half its bulk of water , runs about on the surface like sodium on water , rapidly dissolving , and evolving nitric oxide mixed with nitrous oxide .
I have not found any ammonia produced in this reaction .
When the liquid cools , it becomes almost solid , from the crystallization of nitrate of thallium , which is nearly insoluble in nitric acid , although it is very soluble in water .
Hydrochloric acid attacks thallium but slowly , the action soon ceasing , owing to the formation of a layer of difficultly soluble chloride of thallium .
When hydrochloric acid or a soluble chloride is added to a solution of the protoxide of thallium or one of its soluble salts , a white curdy precipitate of protochloride of thallium , Tl Cl , is thrown down , scarcely differing at first sight from chloride of silver .
It has , however , a crystalline appearance , is slightly soluble in cold water , moderately so in boiling water , from which it crystallizes out on cooling like chloride of lead , and is insoluble in alcohol .
When boiled in nitric acid or aqua regia it is converted into a higher chloride , crystallizing out in large spangles of a yellow colour .
The same chloride is formed by the action of nitrohydrochloric acid upon the metal or its sulphide .
It is more soluble in water and acids than the protochloride , and is precipitated in the latter form upon the addition of sulphite of soda to its solution .
I have already described * the properties of the sulphide of thallium and some other of its insoluble salts .
Having since worked upon purer as well as larger quantities of the metal , I have an addition or two to make to my previous descriptions .
Thus the protiodide of thallium is of a bright yellow colour , the red tinge which I formerly noticed in it being due to the presence of a persalt of thallium .
It is insoluble in excess of dilute solution of iodide of potassium , being soluble only when the latter is concentrated .
The protocarbonate is soluble in water .
Concentrated acetic acid dissolves thallium slowly when heated , forming a soluble acetate ; very dilute cold acid has no action upon thallium .
Owing to the solubility of the oxide of thallium , no precipitate is produced in the protosalts of this metal by potash , soda , or ammonia .
Neutral or slightly acid protosalts of thallium are incompletely precipitated by sulphuretted hydrogen , and not at all when a large excess of acid is present .
Sulphide of ammonium , as I have already stated , precipitates them perfectly , reducing the metal to the state of protosulphide when in a higher state of oxidation .
19 .
The compounds of thallium are not only volatile when heated in the dry state , but many of its salts volatilize when their aqueous solutions are boiled .
The chlorides are especially volatile , insomuch that loss is experienced in evaporating them down .
Ten grains of pure metallic thallium were dissolved in a considerable excess of nitrohydrochloric acid , and the solution was gently boiled down in a retort .
Upon testing the acid distillate by supersaturation with ammonia and addition of sulphide of ammonium , a considerable precipitate of sulphide of thallium was formed .
Nitrohydrochloric acid was then -added to the residue of sesquichloride of thallium remaining in the retort , and the distillation was repeated over a water-bath , care being taken that the evaporation in this case was conducted below the boiling-point of the liquid .
Upon now testing the distillate , traces of thallium were still found in it : the metal in this case could not have been carried over mechanically , as the liquid in the retort had not once entered into ebullition .
Having for upwards of a year had considerable quantities of liquids containing thallium evaporated in open dishes in my laboratory , it was natural to anticipate , after the above experiment , that some quantities of the metal had been thus volatilized along with the aqueous vapour , and would be found adhering to the walls and deposited with the dust on the upper shelves of the room ; a small portion of dust was accordingly removed from a shelf at a height of above 10 feet from the ground , and tested for thallium .
A brilliant green line in the spectroscope showed me that this metal was present in more than minute traces .
20 .
Thallium may be determined quantitatively by precipitation , either as protochloride , iodide , or double chloride of platinum and thallium .
The chloride must be washed with alcohol , as it is slightly soluble in water .
The iodide and platinochloride are practically insoluble .
Position of Thallium amongst elementary bodies .
21 .
When I discovered thallium two years ago , owing to the excessively minute portion of substance which I had under examination , misled by , its constant occurrence with sulphur and selenium , and basing my conjectures upon some of the properties first noticed-namely , its complete volatility below a red heat , its precipitation in the elementary form by zinc , its non-precipitation from an acid solution by alkalies , and its solubility in water when fused with nitre and carbonate of soda-reasoning upon these observations , ILventured to suggest that it was probably a metalloid belonging to 187 the sulphur group , although , I added , " I hesitate to assert this very positively"* .
In speaking of a metalloid of the sulphur group , I should explain that I had in view , not a decidedly non-metallic body like sulphur , but one of the connecting links between metals and non-metals-a metalloid in the strict meaning of the word , like tellurium or arsenic .
If I had formed any particular view upon the matter , knowing so little of the properties of the new body , it was that it might possibly prove to be a higher link in the sulphur , selenium , and tellurium chain .
It was not long before further research showed me that the body under examination had , in addition to the characters already mentioned , others which gave it strictly metallic characters ; and although no formal publication of this isolated fact was immediately made , the element was commonly spoken of in scientific circles as a new metal , and was so described by me at the Exhibition on the 1st of May last .
I enter thus into details on so trifling a subject because French chemists are inclined to attach undue importance to the term , and misinterpret the meaning of metalloid .
Even with our present knowledge of the chemical and physical characteristics of thallium , it is not easy to assign its true position in the scale of elements .
I cannot admit , with the French chemists , that it is an alkali-metal .
Almost the only property which thallium possesses in common with the alkali-metals is the solubility of its oxide , and perhaps its forming an insoluble platinum-salt .
But oxides of lead , silver , and mercury are also soluble in water , reacting in many respects like alkaline solutions ; and oxide of thallium is far more analogous to these than to potash and soda , inasmuch as it has scarcely any affinity for water , becoming anhydrous , in a vacuum , even in the cold .
In opposition to these reasons for classing it with the alkalies , we have numerous facts to prove that its true position is by the side of mercury , lead , or silver .
The ready dehydration of its basic oxide the insolubility of its sulphide , iodide , chloride , bromide , chromate , phosphate , sulphocyanide , and ferrocyanide-its great atomic weight-its ready reduction by zinc to the metallic state-and , according to Dr. MILLER , the complexity of its photographic spectrum-all prove that thallium cannot consistently be classed anywhere but amongst the heavy metals , mercury , silver , lead , &amp;c. 22 .
Those who remember how readily figures can be moulded to suit any theory , will attach slight importance to the argument adduced by M. DUMAS in favour of thallium being related to potassium and sodium because its equivalent is rather near a figure obtained by adding twice the atomic weight of one metal to four times the atomic weight of the other .
By similar processes of addition , multiplication , or subtraction it would not be difficult to prove a relationship between thallium and any desired group .
Thus twice the equivalent of tellurium added to that of arsenic would make one equivalent of thallium , an argument in favour of its being a metalloid ; one equivalent of mercury and one equivalent of lead added together make one equivalent of thallium , as also do one equivalent of silver and two equivalents of molybdenumeach proving it to be a heavy metal of the silver and lead group .
Were it worth while to pursue these relati-eships further , it would not be difficult to find many coincidences less strained than the one brought forward by M. DUMAS .
Analytical Notes on Thallium .
23 .
The chemical identification of thallium when associated with other metals is not difficult .
I have already discovered very exact methods of detecting the presence of thallium in , and separating it from , most of its associated metals , and further expeliment will doubtless still more increase the accuracy of its analytical detection and estimation .
In starting with the analysis of a thalliferous mineral by the ordinary analytical tables , in which Group I. is precipitated by hydrochloric acid , Group II .
by hydrosulphuric acid , Group III .
by ammonia , and Group IV .
by sulphide of ammronium , a slight analytical difficulty will be at first met with , as , unless special precautions are taken , thallium will appear in all four groups .
Thus if the thallium be in the state of a sesquisalt , no precipitate will be produced in a moderately dilute solution upon addition of hydrochloric acid ; if , on the contrary , it be as a protosalt , the great bulk will comle down in this group .
In either case it will be advisable to reduce the remainder of the metal to the state of a protosalt , by passing sulphurous acid through the filtrate and heating .
If , upon allowing the solution to cool after this treatment , a white crystalline precipitate of protochloride of thallium is produced , it will show that the metal originally existed in the state of a sesquisalt .
This precipitate may be filtered off and examined separately .
In the filtrate from this , even were there sufficient acid present to prevent the sulphide of thallium by itself from being precipitated by sulphuretted hydrogen , it will be partially carried down by other metals of this group which may be present .
What escapes this precipitant will in a similar manner be partially carried down with the oxides of the third group , whilst the remaining thallium escaping the first three group-tests will be precipitated by sulphide of ammonium .
Thallium may be very accurately separated from most metals .
Some of the analytical methods which I have employed for many months are very delicate ; others , on the contrary , still require elucidation .
24 .
Thallium from Zinc.-(I will assume that a piece of commercial zinc has to be tested for thallium .
) Dissclve the metal in sulphuric acid , adding a little nitric acid towards the end to effect the perfect solution of the black residue .
Evaporate to drive off nitric acid ; dissolve in a small quantity of water ; filter from sulphate of lead , if any be present , and heat the moderately acid solution with excess of sulphite of soda .
Allow the liquid to cool , andadd a few drops of solution of iodide of potassium .
A yellow precipitate of iodide of thallium will be thrown down .
Many specimens of commercial zinc , tested in this manner , will be found to contain thallium .
25 .
Thallium from Iron ( thalliferous iron pyrites).-Dissolve 30 or 40 grains of the finely powdered mineral in nitrohydrochloric acid ; evaporate with excess of hydrochloric acid to drive off the nitric acid ; redissolve in water ; add sulphite of soda in excess , and heat until all the iron is reduced to the proto-state ; and then add iodide of potassium .
Iodide of thallium will be precipitated .
This test is sufficiently delicate to show thallium in a pyrites which does not contain more than 1 in 10,000 .
Thallium from Manganese may be separated as thallium from iron .
26 .
Thallitm from Mercury.-I have not yet ascertained a delicate and reliable method of separating thallium from salts of the suboxide of mercury .
It is , however , very readily separated from persalts of mercury ; and therefore the best plan is to peroxidize both metals by boiling with nitrohydrochloric acid ; then reduce the thallium with sulphite of soda , and add iodide of potassium to the almost neutral solution .
If much mercury be present , the precipitate will be almost pure scarlet ; but on further addition of iodide of potassium , drop by drop , the iodide of mercury will dissolve , and will leave the iodide of thallium as an insoluble yellow powder .
Upon warming the liquid the precipitate collects together and readily settles to the bottom .
This is a very delicate test .
27 .
Thallium from Lead.-Evaporate the solutions to dryness with excess of sulphuric acid , and extract with hot water .
Sulphate of lead will be left behind , whilst sulphate of thallium will be dissolved .
This is a very ready process , but is not quite so accurate as the succeeding one .
28 .
Thallium from Bismuzth or Lead.-Dilute the solution and add a sUight excess of carbonate of soda ; add solution of cyanide of potassium ( free from sulphide ) , and allow the mixture to stand for an hour at the temperature of about 1000 F. ; then filter and wash : the residue will contain all the bismuth or lead .
To the clear filtrate add sulphide of ammonium , and warm gently for some time ; the deep-brown sulphide of thallium will gradually collect together in flakes at the bottom of the vessel .
It must be washed with water containing a little sulphide of ammonium , as it readily oxidizes when moist , and might pass through the filter as sulphate of thallium .
This is an exceedingly delicate test for thallium in bismuth ; and by its means it can be detected in most specimens of commercial bismuth and its salts , even when sold as pure .
The presence of thallium in some samples of bismuth has been suspected by Dr. W. BIRD HERAPATH* .
The analytical method which he gives is not calculated to detect it except perhaps when present in comparatively large quantities .
By the above process it will be found to be a very frequent constituent of bismuth compounds , even when working upon no more than 50 grains of material .
29 .
Thalliu m from Copper.-To the acid solution add ammonia in excess , and then cyanide of potassium until the blue colour has entirely disappeared ; then add sulphide of ammonium , and gently warm for some time .
Sulphide of thallium will gradually collect together in the liquid .
By this test I have detected the presence of thallium in many specimens of copper as met with in commerce , as well as in crystallized sulphate of copper .
It is extremely delicate .
Through the kindness of Dr. MATTHIESSEN I have been enabled to examine for thal* Pharmaceutical Journal , Jan. 1 , 1863 .
190 lium a specimen of copper prepared in Spain by a process called " cementation .
" This consists in allowing copper pyrites to oxidize slowly , washing out the resulting sulphate of copper , and precipitating the solution with metallic iron .
The pulverulent copper is then heated until it coheres , and the metal sent into the market in the form of pigs , no further purification being attempted .
This metal was found by Dr. MATTHIIESSEN to have a conducting-power for electricity of about 15 , pure copper being 100 .
The exact metallic impurity which rendered it so preeminently bad had not been ascertained .
It was tested for thallium in the manner above described , and found to contain a large quantity .
It is evident , from the way the copper was extracted , that any thallium which might have been present in the pyrites would accompany the copper .
30 .
Thallium from Cadmnium.-To the acid solution of these metals add bichromate of potash , then excess of ammonia , and boil ; insoluble chromate of thallium will be precipitated .
This is not so delicate a test as some of the above , although by its means I have frequently detected thallium in metallic cadmium and its salts .
Commercial sulphide of cadmium , as sold for artists ' use , varies considerably in tint .
Darkcoloured samples frequently contain thallium .
I may especially instance , as being highly thalliferous , a beautiful specimen of this sulphide from Nouvelle Montagne , near Liege , which formed a prominent object in the Belgian department of the late Exhibition .
31 .
Thallium from Gold.-The gold may be separated by the usual process of reduction to the metallic state with oxalic acid , all the free nitric acid having been previously removed by evaporation with hydrochloric acid .
32 .
Thallium from Antimgony , Tin , and Arsenic.-A very good method of separating these metals is to add excess of sulphide of ammonium to the alkaline solution .
Sulphide of thallium will be precipitated , whilst the other sulphides will remain dissolved .
Most of the above processes have been tried with weighed quantities of the different metals , seldom taking more than 1 of thallium to 1000 parts of the other metal .
They can therefore be relied upon to that extent ; whilst some of them are much more delicate , as , for instance , the separation of thallium from iron , copper , bismuth , and lead .
It is advisable , in testing for small quantities of thallium , to appeal to the spectroscope for confirmatory evidence of the presence of this element in any precipitate suspected to contain it .
33 .
Thallium from Sulphuric and Hydrochloric Acids.-I have frequently met with specimens of commercial hydrochloric and sulphuric acids which contained almost enough thallium to be worth extracting .
I may especially mention a very crude yellow hydrochloric acid now to be met with at about 8 shillings the hundredweight .
Two ounces of this was neutralized with soda , and a few drops of sulphide of ammonium were added .
A black precipitate was obtained , which in the spectroscope showed evident presence of thallium .
At my request , Messrs. HOPKIN and WILLIAMS , the well-known manufacturing chemists , treated 112 lbs. of this acid in the above manner , and forwarded me 191 the black precipitate obtained .
It was worked up in the manner described in the first part of this paper ( 7 .
) , and yielded a little over four grains of metallic thallium .
From sulphuric acid it may be separated in a similar way .
It is not difficult to understand how thallium gets into these acids .
Messrs. CHANCE Brothers and Co. , of Birmingham , makers of the thalliferous hydrochloric acid , have obligingly informed me that the process by which it is produced is the ordinary one of decomposing common salt in cast-iron pans and fire-brick furnaces .
The acid is condensed in high stone towers or chambers filled with coke , and is afterwards collected in gutta-percha cisterns , and bottled or drawn off .
The sulphuric acid used in the manufacture is obtained from iron pyrites burnt in kilns .
Upon examining specimens of pyrites and lead-chamber-deposit forwarded by Messrs. CHANCE and Co. , I find that the former contains thallium , but scalcely any appreciable traces are in the deposit , thus agreeing with the results of my previous investigations on this subject .

