On the Archeopteryx of VON MEYER , with a description of the Fossil Remains of a Long-tailed species , from the Lithographic Stone of Solenhofen .
By Professor OWEN , F.R.S. &amp;c. Received November 6 , -Read November 20 , 1862 .
THE first evidence of a Bird in strata of the Oxfordian or Corallian stage of the Oolitic series was afforded by the impression of a single feather , in a slab of the lithographic calcareous laminated stone , or slate , of Solenhofen ; it is described and figured with characteristic minuteness and care by M. HERMANN VON MEYER , in the fifth part of the 'Jahrbuch fur Mineralogie* .
' He applies to this fossil impression the term Archeopteryx lithographica ; and although the probability is great that the class of Birds was represented by more than one genus at the period of the deposit of the lithographic slate , and generic identity cannot be predicated from a solitary feather , I shall assume it in the present instance , and retain for the genus , which can now be established on adequate characters , the name originally proposed by the distinguished German paleontologist t. At the Meeting of the Mathematico-Physical Class of the Royal Academy of Sciences of Munich , on the 9th of November , 1861 , Professor ANDREAS WAGNER communicated the discovery , in the lithographic slate of Solenhofen , of a considerable portion of the skeleton of an animal with impressions of feathers radiating fanwise from each anterior limb , and diverging obliquely in a single series from each side of a long tail .
These and other particulars of the fossil Professor WAGNER gave on the authority of M. WIT , Law-Councillor ( Oberjustiz-Rath ) in Hanover , who had seen the fossil in the possession of M. HXBERLEIN , District Medical Officer ( Landarzt ) of Pappenheim .
Upon the report thus furnished to him , Professor WAGNER proposed for the remarkable fossil the generic name Griphosaurus , conceiving it to be a long-tailed Pterodactyle with feathers .
His state of health prevented his visiting Pappenheim for a personal inspection of the fossil ; and , unfortunately for palseontological science , which is indebted to him for many valuable contributions , Professor WAGNER shortly after expired .
I thereupon communicated with Dr. HXBERLEIN , and reported on the nature and desirability of the fossils in his possession to the Trustees of the British Museum : they were accordingly inspected by my colleague Mr. WATERHOUSE , F.Z.S. ; and an interesting and instructive selection , including the subject of the present paper , has been purchased for the Museum .
The specimen is divided between the counterpart halves of a split slab of lithographic stone : the moiety ( Plate I. ) containing the greater number of the petrified bones exhibits such proportion of the skeleton from the inferior or ventral aspect .
The lower half of an arched furculum ( merry-thought , 58 ) marks , by its relative position to the wings , the fore part of the trunk .
From this portion of the furculum to the root of the tail measures 4 ' inches ; the length of the caudal series of vertebrae ( Cd , Cd ' ) is 8 inches ; but the terminal tail-feathers extend 3 inches further , making the length of the tail 11 inches .
From the end of the tail to the anterior border of the wing-feather impressions is 1 foot 81 inches .
From the outer border of the impression of the left wing ( d ) to that of the right wing measures 1 foot 4 inches .
The front margin of the slab of stone has been broken away short of the anterior border of the impression of the outspread left wing , and the head or skull of the specimen may have been included in that part of the quarry or stone from which the present slab has been detached .
The preserved parts of the feathered creature indicate its size to have been about that of a Rook or Peregrine Falcon .
The exposed bones on one moiety of the split slab ( Plate I. ) areThe lower portion of the furculum ( 58 ) above mentioned .
Portion of the left os innominatum , showing part of the ilium ( 62 ) and ischium ( 63 ) , with the acetabulum , ( a ) .
Twenty caudal vertebrae ( Cd ) in a consecutive and naturally articulated series .
Several slender curved ribs ( pl ) , most of them sternal ( A ) , irregularly scattered about the region of the trunk .
Left scapula ( 51 ' ) .
Proximal half of left humerus ( 53s ) , entire , and part of the distal half .
Left radius ( 54 ' ) and ulna ( 55 ' ) .
34 Left carpus ( se ' ) and portion of a metacarpal bone ( 7 ' ) .
Right scapula ( 51 ) .
Right humerus ( 53 ) , wanting part of the bony wall and the proximal end .
Right radius ( 54 ) and ulna ( 55 ) .
Two metacarpal bones ( 57 ) .
Two unguiculate phalanges ( i and nI ) .
Right femur ( 65 ) , tibia ( 66 ) , and bones of the foot ( 68 , i , ii , iii , iv ) .
Left femur ( 65 ) and tibia ( 66 ' ) .
Impressions of the quill-feathers of the wings and tail .
Impressions of parts of finer feathers and down at the side of the body .
The opposite moiety of the split slab contains only one claw-bone ( Plate I. fig. i ' ) , belonging to the impression of the unguiculate digit ( I ) of the right wing , and a few slender curved rib-like bones , in addition to those shown on the lower moiety ; of which bones the counterpart displays the impressions , and in some instances , as in the femora , the thin outer crust of the shaft .
The furculum , pelvis , and bones of the tail are in their natural undisturbed position , as in the skeleton of the animal .
The left scapula has been displaced backward , and lies outside of , and nearly parallel with , the left os innominatum .
The left humerus extends outward and a little forward from its scapular articulation , from which it , has not been dislocated .
The antibrachium is bent directly inward towards the trunk ; and the wing-feathers , of which twelve primaries may be counted , diverge about an inch or less in advance of the carpus .
The right scapula retains almost its natural relative position to the trunk , and is imbedded in the matrix , exposing its lower sharp margin .
The right humerus extends backward ; the right antibrachium is bent forward , outside of and close upon the humerus ; the two metacarpal or proximo-phalangeal bones ( 57 ) extend forward in the same direction , but have been dislocated inward .
Impressions of about fourteen long quill-feathers , from 6 to 7 inches : in length , like those of the left wing , diverge from an extent of about 3 inches , parallel with and outside of the metacarpo-phalangeal bones .
The right femur extends from its acetabular articulation backward and a little outward , reaching as far as the eighth caudal vertebra .
The tibia extends directly outward and backward from the knee-joint ; the metatarse is bent upon the tibia obliquely forward and inward ; and the toes extend in nearly the same direction , the foot being contracted .
The left femur is dislocated from the pelvis ; its head is opposite the eighth caudal vertebra ; the shaft extends forward and a little outward ; the tibia extends from the knee-joint more directly outward and a little forward .
The best-preserved impressions of the quill-feathers of the wing measure 6 inches in length , with a breadth of vane of nearly 1 inch ; the anterior series of barbs being the shorter , or the anterior part of the vane being less broad than the posterior part ; and the end of the vane is obtusely rounded , as at d , Plate I. , and in fig. 7 , Plate IV .
The G2 3s area covered by the diverging quill-feathers of the left wing measures 6 inches across its widest part , near the ends of the feathers ; that of the right wing occupies a space of 11 inches from before backward ; but this difference is due to the three posterior primaries being dislocated from the rest and directed backward .
The under part of the wing being exposed , a few shorter feathers , ' under-coverts , ' are seen crossing rather obliquely the 'primaries ' : one of these ( Plate IV .
fig. 7 a ) is exquisitely preserved .
The impressions of the tail-feathers may be discerned from the third to the last caudal vertebrae ( Plate I. Cd ) , the right series being complete ; the anterior fifth of the left series being wanting .
Twenty feathers succeed each other , from before backward , on the right side ; and the last thirteen feathers of the left side are preserved .
The principal tail-feathers correspond in number with the tail-vertebrae , and diverge , outward and backward ( a pair from each vertebra ) , at an angle of 45 ?
with the line of the tail , becoming more acute towards the end ( Plate I. Cd ' ) , where the two feathers forming the pair from the sides of the last caudal vertebra extend nearly parallel with each other , and in the axis of the tail , about 31 inches beyond the end of that vertebra .
The length of the anterior tail-feathers is about an inch , and they gradually increase to a length of about 5 inches in the 15th , 16th , and 17th pairs ( Plate IV .
fig. 8 ) ; and gradually decrease , with a more backward direction , to the last pair , which have a length of 3 inches 8 lines .
Thus the tail , which is about 11 inches in length , gradually expands to a breadth of 3inches opposite the last two vertebrae , and terminates by an obtusely rounded or almost squared or truncate end .
In general shape and proportions it resembles rather the tail of a Petaurus or Squirrel than of a modern bird ; while the wings , in their present state of preservation , agree in form and proportion with those of the Gallinaceous or 'round-winged ' birds .
The scapula ( Plate I. 51 ' and Plate II .
fig. 1 , 51 ) is 1 inch 10 lines in length , 4 lines across the articular end , 21 lines across the neck , and very gradually expanding , towards the base , to a breadth of 3 lines .
In its slightly bent , lamelliform or sabre-shaped figure , and in the concavity between the glenoid articulation and the short acromial projection on the outer side , it closely resembles the scapula of a bird .
In the Pterodactyluts suevicus ( Plate II .
fig. 3 , 51 ) , a species which accords in general size with the Archeopteryx , the scapula is broader in proportion to its length , and exhibits a slight double or sigmoid flexure lengthwise .
The extent of the furcular arch ( Plate I. 58 , and Plate IV .
fig. 1 ) , or connate clavicles , which is preserved , measures from end to end , following the curve , about 2 inches ; the breadth at the apex of the curve is 2 lines ; but this is obtuse , and the piers diverge at a right angle , but curving from each other ; so that the arch is an open or rounded one , not contracted and pointed as in the true Gallinaceous birds ; the furcular bone , moreover , is as thick as the slender part of the shaft of the humerus .
No skeleton of the Pterodactyle has shown a furculum .
The best-preserved specimens , such as the Pterodactylus suevicus , figured by QUENSTEDT * , exhibit the scapula and coracoid entire , without a trace of clavicle , separate or confluent .
The prominence beyond the left scapula ( Plate I. 51 ' ) suggested at first view the humeral end of the coracoid , but I believe it to be part of the humerus corresponding with the tuberosity on the ulnar side of the sessile semioval head , overarching the pneumatic foramen in the bird .
The humerus of Archieopteryx ( Plate 1 .
53 , 53 ' and Plate II .
fig. 1 , 53 ) is nearly 3 inches in length , with the same slight sigmoid flexure as in the bird .
The pectoral ridge ( ib. b ) has a basal extent of 1 inch : the breadth of the humerus at this part is 6 lines , one-half of which breadth appears to be due to the pectoral ridge .
In contour it most resembles that in the Corvidw ( Plate II .
fig. 4 ) , the border being continued almost straight down from the low upper angle ; but there is a better-marked lower angle in Archeopteryx , where the border of the process curves with a slight concavity to subside in the shaft .
The Pterodactyle ( Plate II .
fig. 3 , 53 ) presents a well-marked difference from the bird in the greater extent to which the pectoral ridge projects from the shaft of the humerus , and in the minor relative extent of its base .
The humerus , moreover , is straight , shorter in proportion to the antibrachium , and thicker in proportion to its length , with a different character of the distal articulation .
In Archeopteryx the humerus closely resembles that of the bird , and presents about the same proportion , in length , to the trunk as in the Peregrine Falcon ( Plate II .
fig. 2 , 53 ) , the Touraco , and most Gallince .
The radius ( Plate I. 54 , and Plate II .
fig. 1 , 54 ) is slender and straight .
The ulna ( ib. 55s ) is thicker , rather longer , and slightly bent , leaving a well-marked interosseous space between the two bones : it expands at both ends to contribute the chief share in both the elbowand wrist-joints .
The right ulna ( Plate I. 55 ) shows the convexity at the part of the proximal end next the radius , as in modern birds .
Both ulna and radius closely resemble the antibrachial bones of the bird .
The length of the ulna is 2 inches 8 lines-bearing nearly the same proportion to the humerus as in some Scansores and Gallinacece .
In Pterodactyles ( Plate II .
fig. 3 ) the radius ( 54 ) and ulna ( 55 ) are of equal thickness , are straight , leave no interosseous space , take equal shares in the formation of the elbowand wrist-joints , and the antibrachium is always much longer than the humerus .
A single carpal , of large size , NVedged between the end of the radius and the base of a metacarpal , is shown on the left side of Archeopteryx ( Plate I. 56 ) , indicating a structure of the wrist like that in the bird .
On the right side an irregular mass of spar occupies the position of a thick carpus or metacarpus , twisted inward at right angles to the antibrachium ; but this is a doubtful indication .
An inch from the antibrachium , nearer the medial line , but , like the antibrachium , directed forward , are two longish bones , with expanded proximal articulations and straight shafts , growing slender to their distal ends , which come in contact ( Plate I. 57 , and Plate II .
fig. 1 , 57 ) .
The proximal articular surfaces are convex , indented by grooves ; that of the shorter bone is 4 lines in advance of that of the longer .
The latter is 1 inch 5 lines in length , or about half the length of the ulna ; its small distal end is obtuse , and may have been articular .
The contiguous shorter bone extends beyond the end of the other , and seems to terminate by a small convex condyle .
These appear to be metacarpals ; they bear the same relation of length to the antibrachium as do the two terminally coalesced metacarpals in the bird ( Plate II .
fig. 2 , 57 ) .
If they be the homologues of these , they retain their origin.al individuality or distinctness , and they are more equal in thickness .
If they be proximal phalanges of the two digits answering to those which constitute the penultimate joint of the pinion of the bird ( Plate II .
fig. 2 , iv ) , they differ in being relatively longer and more equal in length and thickness .
Half an inch from the outer of the two bones of the pinion , and external to , but on the same transverse parallel as , its distal articulation , is the impression of a slender bone , about 11 lines long , extending forward in the same line or direction as the above pinion-bones .
At the distal end of the slender bone is the impression of part of a compressed curved bone , grooved along the side , 4 lines in length , 1 line in breadth ; this dimension slightly decreasing as the bone recedes , curving from the longer slender supporting bone : it is most like the basal half of an ungual phalanx , supported by a long and slender penultimate phalanx ( Plate I. ii ) .
In advance and external to the foregoing is the bone itself , of a corresponding penultimate phalanx , 11 lines in length , half a line in thickness of shaft ; expanded at both ends , but most so at the distal one , which supports a beautifully perfect claw-phalanx , preserved in the opposite slab ( Plate I. I ' ) , and indicated by its impression ( ib. I ) in the moiety which retains most df the bones of Archeopteryx .
The claw-phalanx is 8 lines in a straight line , 21 lines broad at the base , with a degree of curvature equal to that of the claw-phalanx of a Raptorial .
bird ; grooved along the side ; with the base produced , at the under or concave side , for the insertion of the flexor tendon , and with a sharp apex .
This claw resembles that of the mid-claw of the hind foot ( Plate I. iii ) ; but the bone , which plainly appears to be in penultimate phalangeal relation with it , is twice as long and only half as thick as the penultimate phalanx in the foot , and the repetition of the same character of penultimate phalanx in the less definite or less perfect indication of the other claw ( Plate I. II ) indicates that the hand of Archeopteryx , besides being concerned in supporting the remiges or quill-feathers of a wing , also supported two moderately long and slender free digits , each terminated by a strong , curved , sharp-pointed claw ( as in the restoration , Plate II .
fig. 1 , 57 , I , II III , iv ) .
It is true that the parts of the present skeleton show a certain amount of dislocation , and one of the claw-bearing digits might have belonged to the left wing ; but this is less probable than that they are on their right side .
So much of the skeleton of the hand as is exposed to view in the present specimen unquestionably accords in its proportions with that of the bird ( compare fig , 1 , 57 , with fig. 2 , 57 , Plate II .
) .
38 The anterior of the three digits which are developed in the bird 's pinion ( ib. fig. 2 , ii ) remains free , and in some species supports a claw or spur .
The digit answering to the middle one in the pinion of birds of flight , supports , in Apteryx , a terminal curved claw .
But if my interpretation of the appearances above described in the present fossil be correct , Archeopteryx differs markedly from all known birds in having two free unguiculate digits in the hand ; and these digits , in the slenderness of the penultimate phalanx , do resemble the unguiculate digits in the hand of the Pterodactyle ( Plate II .
fig. 3 , ii ) .
But the claw has not the characteristic depth or breadth of that of the Pterodactyle ; and there is no trace of the much-lengthened metacarpal and phalangeal bones of the fifth digit , or peculiar wing-finger , of the ; flying Reptile ( ib. v ) .
Had the manus of Archeopteryx been constructed for the support of a membranous wing , the extent to which the skeleton is preserved , and the ordinary condition of the fossil Pterosauria in lithographic slate , render it almost certain that some of these most characteristic elongated slender bones of the wing-finger ( Plate II .
fig. 3 , v , i , 2 , 3 , 4 ) would have been preserved if they had existed in the present specimen .
But , besides the negative evidence , the positive proof of the ornithic proportions of the hand or pinion , of the existence of quill-feathers , and the manifest attachment of the principal ones , or 'primaries , ' to the carpal and metacarpal parts of a short terminal segment of the limb , sufficiently evince the true class-affinity of the Archeopteryx .
The pelvis is chiefly represented by a bone on the left side ( Plate I. 62 ) , bearing the nearest resemblance to the iliac bone of a bird .
A circular acetabulum , 3 lines in diameter ( ib. a ) , is defined by a sharp border backed by matrix , not by bone .
An oblong plate of bone extends in advance of the acetabulum 11 lines , with a breadth at the acetabulum of 7 lines , diminishing to a breadth of 4 lines , and then expanding to one of 5 lines .
The margin of the bone next to the sacrum is nearly straight ; the opposite or outer border is sinuous , being concave as it leaves the acetabulum , and then convex with an obtusely rounded anterior end .
The exposed surface is smooth and polished .
Transversely this surface is concave at the medial , convex at the lateral half .
The bone is continued backward along the medial side of the acetabulum , of a breadth equal to that of the cavity ; and behind it for the same extent , with a breadth of 7 lines , where it is interrupted by the well-defined curve of the anterior border of a large oval vacuity , one boundary of which is broken away at 6 lines ' distance from the acetabulum .
I conclude that here is shown the left os innominatum , including the anterior twothirds of the ilium , and the anterior half , or more , of the coalesced ischium .
The anterior iliac border of the acetabulum ends abruptly and obtusely , precisely at the part where the acetabular end of the os pubis articulates with the ilium in the young * E. g. Syrian Blackbird ( Merula dactyloptera ) , Spur-winged Goose ( Anser gambensis ) , Jacana ( Parra jacana ) .
The Screamer ( Palamedea cornuta ) has two spurs ; the Megapode ( Megapodius ) has a tubercular rudiment of a pinion-claw .
39 bird ; the ischium , however , appearing to meet that part of the ilium at a lower level ( in the exposed surface of the fossil ) , and sending a very short process towards the acetabulum .
The ischium ( Plate I. 63 ) , behind the acetabulum and external ( as it lies ) to the oval interspace between it and the ilium , shows the anterior curved boundary of a smaller or narrower vacuity , which I take to have intervened between the ischium and pubis .
We have here , therefore , plain indications of a large ischio-iliac interspace , answering to that called ' great ischiatic foramen or notch ' ( ib. i ' ) , and the smaller ischio-pubic vacuity called ' obturator foramen ' ( ib. o ) , under conditions of size , formation , and relative position to the acetabulum , known only in the class of birds .
The acetabulum itself , moreover , instead of being a bony cup , is a direct circular perforation of the os innominatum , as in birds .
Sufficient is known of the pelvis of the Pterodactyle to show that the ilium is relatively shorter and narrower than in the present fossil ; that the pubic and ischial bones are distinct , short , broad , subtriangular plates , and that they contribute to form , with the ilium , a bony cup for the head of the femur .
Whether the pubis has retained its individuality in Archeopteryx , or has been broken away from the part of the ilium indicative of the place of its original attachment and relations to the acetabulum , I cannot determine .
So far as the appearance of the pelvis can be discerned and , by me , interpreted , they give no evidence of a reptilian structure .
A confused mass of coalesced vertebrae , much shorter and broader than those of the tail , covers the proximal end of the right femur , and extends forward between it and the left innominatum .
The sparry material which has crystallized in the vacuities of all the widely and apparently pneumatically excavated bones of the Archeopteryx chiefly represents the sacral portion of the spine , in which a series of six or seven short and broad transverse processes , in close contact on the right side , can alone be distinguished .
From this indication , the sacrum would seem to have been at least 2 inches in length , and nearly 1 inch in breadth .
The inferior or central surface , as in the case of the slightly dislocated left innominatum , is towards the observer , but is much mutilated .
The broad , subquadrate , short , compressed spines of one or two lumbar vertebrse are dimly discernible in front of the sacrum .
No trace of the vertebral column in advance of these is visible , nor any part of the sternum ; trunk , neck , and head are all wanting .
The remains of Archeopteryx , as preserved in the present split slab of lithographic stone , recalled to mind the condition in which I have seen the carcase of a Gull or other seabird left on estuary sand after having been a prey to some carnivorous assailant .
The viscera and chief masses of flesh , with the cavity containing and giving attachment to them , are gone , with the muscular neck and perhaps the head , while the indigestible quill-feathers of the wings and tail , with more or less of the limbs , held together by parts of the skin , and with such an amount of dislocation as the bones of the present specimen exhibit , remain to indicate what once had been a bird .
40 Perhaps the most decisive mark of the class-relationship of the Archeopteryx is afforded by the bones of the pelvic appendage or extremity , especially , of the foot .
The mark of reptilian nature on which CUVIER mainly relied in his masterly analysis of the Pterodactyle 's skeleton , was the separate state of the tarsals , and of the metatarsals supporting the digits , with the different number of joints in each digit .
In the present specimen , a single coalesced tarso-metatarsal bone ( Plates I. &amp; III .
fig. 1,68 ) articulates at one end with the tibia ; at the other , by a trifid trochlear end , with three toes ( ii , iii , iv ) directed forward : a shorter opposing toe ( i ) is connected with the metatarse a little above and behind the inner trochlea .
The femur ( Plates I. &amp; III .
fig. 1 , 65 ) is 2 inches 41 lines long , and 2 lines in diameter at the middle of the shaft , which is slightly bent , with the concavity backward .
In the Pterodactyle ( Plate III .
fig. 4 , 65 ) the femur is straight .
In some birds ( Corythaix , Plate III .
fig. 2 , 65 ) it shows the same bend as in Archeopteryx .
The tibia of Archteopteryx ( ib. fig. 1 , 66 ) is 3 inches 2 lines long , with a shaft of I. line in diameter ; it is straight .
On the left side ( Plate I. 66 ' ) , where its back surface appears , it shows the division of the hinder border of the upper articular surface into two lobes ; but these are thicker , more rounded or convex , and with a deeper mid-cleft than in those birds that best show this division .
In the fossil , however , the sharper contour of this part of the bone is indicated by the thin layer imbedded in the depression on the counterpart slab .
The right tibia ( ib. 66 ) exposes its inner or tibial side , and neither the bone nor the impression exhibits a procnemial ridge .
The head of the tibia is produced obtusely below the fore part of the knee-joint .
The procnemial production varies much in different birds ; in some Raptores ( Falco trivtrgatus , Plate III .
fig. 3 , 66 ) , and in most Volitores , it would not leave a more marked indication than in Archeopteryx .
The distal end of the tibia expands anteriorly , and the contour shown by the inner surface of the right tibia , and the hinder and inner part of the left one , agrees with the peculiar structure of that part in birds .
In the proportion of the tibia to the femur , exceeding as it does the latter bone by rather more than one-fourth of its own length , Archeopteryx ( Plate III .
fig. 1 ) resembles some birds ( Grouse , Touracos ( ib. fig. 2 ) , many Insessores ) ; but the ' thigh is proportionally longer in Archeopteryx than in the majority of birds , especially those ( e. g. Cursores , Grallatores ) which are remarkable for the length of leg .
In the Pterodactyle ( ib. fig. 4 ) the tibia ( 66 ) is more nearly of equal length with the femur ( 65s ) .
Whatever trace or proportion of the fibula may have existed in Archeopteryx , if preserved , is buried in the matrix beneath the exposed parts of the tibia .
There is no indication , in either the fossil bones or their impressions , of a separate or distinct tarsus .
The upper end of the coalesced metatarsals ( Plates I. &amp; III .
fig. 1 , 68 ) shows the calcaneal process and the tendinal groove on its inner side .
The thin bony crust of the inner side of this single composite bone adheres to the impression on the counterpart slab ; the cast of the medullary cavity in the usual clear , light-coloured spar reprets i the tajor part of ' thesh-aft ; but the innermost arid the middle of the three distal condyles , or trochlear joints , are well preserved .
The length of the tarso-metatarsal , to , the end of the mid-trochlea is 1 inch 10 lines , to the end of the inner trochlea 1 inch &amp; 8 lines : this characteristic bird-bone in Arc Ieopteryx thus resembles the same in Gallimacea ald some other groups in which the inner trochlea is least produced , and differs from the Raptores ( plate III .
fig. 3 ) and others in which the trochlese terminate on the : same or : nearly the same level..The short metatarsal of the innermost or back toe ( Plate III .
fig. 1 , i ) begins at the lower third of the metatarsus ( 6s ) ; has an extent of attachment , shown to be ligamentous ; by.a linear tract of matrix , of 2-j lines ; and its convex articular end is about the same distance above the inner trochlea as that is above the middle trochlea of the connate ri , tatars'als .
Th-us the proportion of the metatarsus to the tibia resembles the average or common proportion in birds ( ib. fig. 2 ) , having neither the extreme length of the rall-atolrial , the extreme ' shortness of the Volitorial , nor the robustness of the Raptorial moldifications '(ib , 'fig .
3 ) of this characteristic bonei The ; difference from the Reptilian structure , and especially from the Pterosaurian modification thereof ( Plate III .
fig.:4 , es ) is here most striking .
The tarsus ( ib. a T ) is a distinct segment in the volant reptiles arid the metatarsals ( ib. 68 ) equally retain their distinctness , and correspond in number with the toes .
The entire tarso-metatarsal segment of the limb in the Pterodactyle is much shorter in proportion to the tibia than in AriheopteTryx and most birds .
The innermost or back toe:of Archeqpterys ( Plate III .
fig l , i ) consists of two phalanges , each 4 lines in length : the second phalanx is curved , slender , pointed , with an obtue process on the under or plaitar side of the articulation , closely resembling the claw-phalanx of the bird : the toe is shorter and , more slender than in the Raptores ( i fig. 3 , , 2 ) , longer and more slender than in the Rasores , more curved than in the arallttores , corresponding in its proportions , as in the relative length of the proximal phalanx , with the same toe in perching birds .
The second toe ( ib. fig. 1 , ii ) , the innermost ofr the three directed fdrward , consists of three phalanges ( , ` 2 , 6 ) of nearly equal length , that of the 'entire toe being 1 inch 3 lines .
The third ( ib. iii ) , or mid-toe of the three front ones , is 1 : inch 9 lines in length , and consists of four phalanges , the second ( 2 ) and penultimate ( 3 ) being rather the .
shortest .
These , toes , with their claw-phalanges , equally accord in structure and proportions with the Insessorial type of foot .
The termination of the claw-.phalanx of the outermost ( fourth ) toe ( ib. iv ) projects beyond and from beneath that of the second toe , indicating a length intermediate between that of the second and third toes , but more nearly that of the second toe : traces of the other joints of the fourth 'toe are sufficiently plain to determine that it was not bent back , but that it accorded in position and direction with the Inse8sorial , not the Scansorial , type of foot .
All the claw-bones correspond in the proportions of breadth to length with the bird-type of 'those bones , and not with the compressed deep form which they present in Pterodactyles .
The structure of the foot , and the proportion which its metatarsal bone bears to th tibia , lead me to restrict the account of the closer comparisons of the bones of Archey .
yteryx with those of other birds to the species of Insessores and Raptores which best accord with the fossil in general size .
The furculum of Archeopteryo ( Plate IV. .
fig. 1 ) presents the proportional strength , thickness , and span of the arch which characterize the diurnal Raptores ( ib. fig. 3 ) : but the piers or crura do not arch into one another below by so open a curve ; they have converged in a form more angular , more like that in the Owls ( ib. fig. 4 , Nyctea nivea ) , and still more like that in some Grallcw , with a strong furculum , as , e. g. , in the Spoonbill ( Platalea leucorodia ) and Argala ( ib. fig. 5 ) ; only , as before remarked , the type of pelvic limb precludes any useful comparison with birds of the Wading order .
The furculum in Colunmbid and Cracide ( ib. fig. 6 ) is feeble in comparison with that of Archeopteryx : in the more typical Galliadcex , the still more slender piers of the furculum meet at an acute angle , and develope a compressed plate of bone from the apex .
The furculum of Archeopteryx is that of a bird of a more powerful flight than in the true Gallinacec .
In the Corvidce ( ib. fig. 2 ) , in which the furculum is narrower in proportion to its length than in Falconidw , the piers unite by a wider curve than in Archeopteryx .
The scapula of Archeopteryx ( Plate II .
fig. 1 , 51 ) bears nearly the same proportion in length to the humerus and femur as in some of the more slender-limbed Paleondce , ( Falco trivirgatus , Plate II .
fig. 2 , 51 ) .
But the humerus seems to have been more slender than in the Falcon ( Falco trivirgatus ) , which comes nearest to Archeopteryx in this respect .
The form of the pectoral ridge presets the difference previously pointed out .
In the Kites ( Milvus ) and Perns ( Pernis ) the humerus is prop ortionally longer than in Archeopteryx : in the Corvidw it is proportionally thicker ( Plate II .
fig. 4 , Corvs corax ) .
It is by the proportion of the antibrachium ( ib. fig. 1 , 54 , M ) to the humerus that Archreopteryx departs furthest from the Raptorial and Insessorial types , whilst it closely resembles the true Gallinace , the antibrachium being rather shorter than the humerus ; and this condition of the wing-bones accords with the indication of the proportions of the primary quill-feathers , as in the short rounded wing of Grouse and Pheasants .
The bones of the segment of the hand giving attachment to the prmaries are not preserved in the left wing of Archeopteryx ; two of those on the right side are preserved , and the manus shows , apparently , in the two distinct sets bf phalanges , terminated each by a compressed , curved , sharp-pointed claw , the departure , next in importance after the tail , from the structures of modem and known tertiary birds .
Few of the bones , even the best-preserved ones of Archeopery , permit a close or minute comparison of superficial features and markings with their recent homologies in birds or reptiles .
The osseous remains of Archeopteryx being included between the halves of a split slab , it might.be supposed that the configuration of the outer surface of the fossilized:2 4 bone must be demonstrable on one or other of the moieties : it is not so .
The long contact of the phosphate with the carbonate of lime has resulted in a certain degree of disintegration or partial decomposition of the former , which has baffled every attempt to detach the matrix from the bone , or the bone from the matrix , where they have come to hand in their original contact .
Only in the instances of the bones with the thickest osseous walls , as those of the feet , and especially the claw-bones , is the surface entire ; and this has been exposed by the splitting of the slab , and needs no working out by tool .
Were it not for the large proportional size of their cavities , the general configuration of the long bones of the limbs could not have been so well preserved and presented for the requisite comparison .
When these bones sank in the soft fine calcareous mud which has hardened into the peculiar stone which the progress of lithographic art has rendered so valuable , the sparry matter in solution , percolating the matrix and entering the cavities of the bones , has slowly crystallized there , and ultimately filled them by a compact body of spar .
The degree to which this represents the original bone gives the measure of the pneumatic cavities and cancelli in the skeleton of Archeopteryx , and shows that the proportion of the original osseous matter must have been that which we observe in the present day in birds of flight .
The great and striking difference , and that which gives its enigmatical character to this fossil bird 's skeleton , is the number , or rather the proportions and distinctness , of the caudal vertebrae ; their under surface is exposed , or rather the sparry casts of the cavities of their bodies , the thin crust of the bone adhering to the impressions of the counterpart .
The best view of the under surface of the caudal centrum , thus obtainable , shows a slight expansion of the two articular ends , which join those of the contiguous vertebrae by simple flattened surfaces , having the margin obtuse .
The mid-line of the under surface is slightly canaliculate , the impression probably of the caudal artery ( Plate IV .
fig. 8 ) .
There is no trace of hiemal arch , or spine , or articular surface for such , in any part of the caudal series ; nor is there any appearance of the ossified threadlike ligaments which are so conspicuous in the tail of the Pterodactyle .
The first five of these vertebrne show transverse processes progressively diminishing in breadth and length to the fifth caudal : no trace of such processes is visible in the succeeding vertebrae .
The length of the first caudal vertebra is 3-1 lines ; this dimension gradually increases to the eighth caudal , the centrum or body of which is 6 lines in length , and that dimension is retained to the sixteenth caudal , when it gradually diminishes to the last caudal , which is 5 lines in length , and terminates in a point .
The impressions of the quills of the anterior shorter tail-feathers show that they were attached , ligamentously , to the end of the transverse processes in the anterior ones , and in the succeeding caudals to the sides of the vertebrae , each of these vertebrae supporting a pair of plumes .
The under surface of the tail-feathers being exposed , the median groove of the shaft of the vane is clearly shown .
The barbs of the vane are as distinctly and inimitably preserved in this delicate and fine-grained lithographic matrix 44 ( Plate IV .
fig. 8 ) , as in the impression of the single shorter and broader feather from the same formation described by M. HERMANN VON MEYER* .
The narrower series at the fore part of one feather overlaps the margin of the broader series of barbs of the preceding feather .
With the exception of the caudal vertebrae , and possibly of the bi-unguiculate and less confluent condition of the manus , the parts of the skeleton preserved in this rare fossil feathered animal accord with the strictly ornithic modifications of the vertebrate skeleton .
The main departure therefrom is in a part of that skeleton most subject to variety .
In Bats there are short-tailed and long-tailed species , as in Rodents , Pterodactyles , and many other natural groups of air-breathing vertebrates ; and it now is manifest that , at the period of the deposition of the lithographic slate , a like variety obtained in the feathered class .
Its unexpected and almost startling character is due to the constancy with which all birds of the neozoic and modern periods present the short bony tail , accompanied in most of them with that further departure from type exemplified by the coalescence and special modification of the terminal vertebrae , to form the peculiar ( ploughshare bone ' supporting the coccygeal glands , and giving attachment to the limited number of fanwise radiating rectrices , constituting the outward and visible tail in existing.birds .
All birds , however , in their embryonic state exhibit the caudal vertebrae distinct , and , in part of the series , gradually decreasing in size to the pointed terminal one .
In the embryo Rook ( P1 .
III .
fig. 6 ) , the proper extent of the caudal vertebrae is shown by the divergence of the parts of the ilia ( 62 ) to form the acetabula ( a ) ; and as many as ten free , but short , vertebrat are indicated beyond this part ( Cd ) .
Five or six of the anterior of these subsequently coalesce with each other and with the hinder halves of the ilia , lengthening out the sacrum to that extent .
The tail is further shortened by the welding together of three terminal vertebre to form the ploughshare bone .
In the young Ostrich from eighteen to twenty such vertebre may be counted , freely exposed , between the parts of the iliac bones behind the acetabula ; of which vertebrae seven or eight are afterwards annexed to the enormously prolonged sacrum , by coalescing with the backwardly produced ilia ; while two or three vertebroe are welded together to form the terminal slender styliform bone of the tail , without undergoing the ' ploughshare ' modification .
In Archeopteryx the embryonal separation persists with , such a continued growth of the individual vertebrae as is commonly seen in tailed Vertebrates , whether reptilian or mammalian .
The modification and specialization of the terminal bones of the spinal column in modern birds is closely analogous to that which converts the long , slender , symmetrical , many-jointed tail of the modern embryo-fish into that short and deep symmetrical shape , with coalescence of terminal vertebra into a compressed lamelliform bone , to which AHECIMOPTERYXthe term homocercal applies ; such extreme development or transformation passing through the protocercal and usually the heterocercal stages , at which latter stage , in palaeozoic and many mesozoic fishes , it was in different degrees arrested .
Thus we discern , in the main differential character of the by-fossil-remains-oldest .
known feathered Vertebrate , a retention of a structure embryonal and transitory in the modern representatives of the class , and a closer adhesion to the general vertebrate type .
The same evidence is afforded by the minor extent to which the anchylosing process has been carried on in the pinion , and by the apparent retention of two unguiculate digits on the radial side of the metacarpo-phalangeal bones , modified for the attachment of the primary quill-feathers .
IBut when we recall the single unguiculate digit in the wing of Pteropus , and the number of such digits , equalling that in Pterodactylus , in the fore foot of the Flying Lemur ( Gcaleopithect 's ) , the tendency to see only a reptilian character in what may have been the structure of the manus in Archeopteryx receives a due check .
The best-determinable parts of its preserved structure declare it unequivocally to be a Bird , with rare peculiarities indicative of a distinct order in that class .
By the law of correlation we infer that the mouth was devoid of lips , and was a beak-like instrument fitted for preening the plumage of Archeopteryx .
A broad and keeled breast-bone was doubtless associated in the living bird with the great pectoral ridge of the humerus , with the furculum , and with the other evidences of feathered instruments of flight .
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATES .
PLATE I. .
The moiety of the split slab of Lithographic Slate , containing , with the impressions of the feathers , the:major part of the fossilized skeleton of Archeopteryx:-nat .
size .
n. Concretionary nodules : the larger one consists of matrix , which filled a cavity , n , formed by a thin layer of brownish and crystalline matter ; which may be , as suggested by Mr. JOHN EvANS , F.G.S. , part of the cranium with the cast of the brain of the Archeopteryx .
n. Cavity with a layer of brown matter , in the counterpart slab , which was applied to the nodule , n. Fig. 2 .
Fore part of the brain of a , Magpie ( Corvus pica , L. ) .
Fig. 3 , p ' .
Premaxillary bone and , fig. l , p , its impression , resembling that of a fossil ' fish .
The other letters and figures are explained in the text .
PLATE II .
Wing-bones-of the Arctieopteryx ( restored , fig. 1 ) , of a Bird ( Falco trivirgatus , fig. 2 ) , and of a Pterodactyle ( ( Pterodactylmus suecs , Quenst .
, fig. 3 ) , and the-humerus of a Raven ( Corwus c. ax , fig ; 4 ) .
46

