On the Equation of Differences for an Equation of any Order , and in particular for the Equations of the Orders Two , Three , Four , and Five .
By ARTHUR CAYLEY , Esq. , F.RB .
S. Received March 2 , -Read March 29 , 1860 .
THE term , equation of differences , denotes the equation for the squared differences of the roots of a given equation ; the equation of differences afforded a means of determining the number of real roots , and also limits for the real roots , of a given numerical equation , and was upon this account long ago sought for by geometers .
In the Philosophical Transactions for 1763 , WARING gives , but without demonstration or indication of the mode of obtaining it , the equation of differences for an equation of the fifth order wanting the second term : the result was probably obtained by the method of symmetric functions .
This method is employed in the ' Meditationes Algebraice ' ( 1782 ) , where the equation of differences is given for the equations of the third and fourth orders wanting the second terms ; and in p. 85 the before-mentioned result for the equation of the fifth order wanting the second term , is reproduced .
The formulae for obtaining by this method the equation of differences , are fully developed by LAGRANGE in the ' Traite des Equations Numeriques ' ( 1808 ) ; and he finds by means of them the equation of differences for the equations of the orders two and three , and for the equation of the fourth order wanting the second term ; and in Note III .
he gives , after WVARING , the result for the equation of the fifth order wanting the second term .
It occurred to me that the equation of differences could be most easily calculated by the following method .
The coefficients of the equation of differences , qgu functions of the differences of the roots of the given equation , are leading coefficients of covariants , or ( to use a shorter expression ) they are " Seminvariants* , " that is , each of them is a function of the coefficients which is reduced to zero by one of the two operators which reduce an invariant to zero .
In virtue of this property they can be calculated , when their values are known for the particular case in which one of the coefficients of the given equation is zero .
To fix the ideas , let the given equation be ( * &gt; v , 1)=-0 ; then , when the last coefficient or constant term vanishes , the equation breaks up into v-= 0 and into an equation of the degree ( n-1 ) , which I call the reduced equation ; the equation of differences will break up into two equations , one of which is the equation of differences for the reduced equation , the other is the equation for the squares of the roots of the same reduced equation .
This hardly requires a proof ; let the roots of the given equation be o , , 1y , y , &amp;c. , those of the equation of differences are ( -j3)2 , ( f-y)2 , ( --)2 , &amp;c. , ( 3-7)2 , ( 3--)2 , ( y)2 , &amp;c. ; but in putting the constant term equal to zero , we in effect put one of the roots , say oa , equal to zero ; the roots of the equation of differences thus become 32 , y2 , 2 , &amp;c. , ( 3--y)2 , ( P3--g)2 , ( y-_)2 , &amp;c. The equation for the squares of the roots can be found without the slightest difficulty ; hence if the equation of differences for the reduced equation of the order ( n-1 ) is known , we can , by combining it with the equation for the squares of the roots , form the equation of differences for the given equation with the constant term put equal to zero , and thence by the above-mentioned property of the Seminvariancy of the coefficients , find the equation of differences for the given equation .
The present memoir shows the application of the process to equations of the orders two , three , four , and five : part of the calculation for the equationl of the fifth order was kindly performed for me by the Rev. R. HARLEY .
It is to be noticed that the best course is to apply the method in the first instance to the forms ( a , b,. .
v , 1)"=-0 , without numerical coefficients ( or , as they may be termed , the denumerate forms ) , and to pass from the results so obtained to those which belong to the forms ( a , b,..)1v , 1)= 0 , or standardforms .
The equation of differences , for ( as-3)2 , &amp;c. , the coefficients of which are seminvariants , naturally leads to the consideration of a more general equation having for its roots ( -_3)2 ( x-_y)2 ( x-y)2 &amp;c. , the coefficients of which are covariants ; and in fact , when , as for equations of the orders two , three , and four , all the covariants are known , such covariant equation can be at once formed from the equation of differences ; for equations of the fifth order , however , where the covariants are not calculated beyond a certain degree , only a few of the coefficients of the covariant equation can be thus at once formed .
At the conclusion of the memoir , I show how the equation of differences for an equation of the order n can be obtained by the elimination of a single quantity from two equations each of the order n-1 ; and by applying to these two equations the simplification which I have made in BEZOUT'S abridged method of elimination , I exhibit the equation of differences for the given equation of the order n , in a compendious form by means of a determinant ; the first-mentioned method is , however , that which is best adapted for the actual development of the equation of differences for the equation of a given order .
The equations successively considered are ( a , b , c IV 1.)2= ( a , 6 , c , d Xv , 1)3=0 , ( a , b , c , d , e fXv , 1)4=0 .
The equation of differences for the quadric , and that for the squares of the roots , are considered to be known , and the other results are derived from them : it will be convenient to write down in the first instance the results for the quadric , the cubic , and the quartic equations , and then explain the process of obtaining them .
94 For the quadric equation , Equation of differences is , 0= Equation for the squares of the roots is , O= 1)2 .
For the cubic equation , Equation of differences is , 0= 1)3 1 ) .
Equation for the squares of the roots is , 0= o2 95 For the quartic equation , Equation of differences is , O0= a6x I a4 x +1 +8 ac -3 b2 ( a2x +8 a3e + 16 a4ce 2 a2bd +26 a4d2 +22 a2C2 6 a'b2e -16 ab2c -30 a3bcd +3 b4 +28 aC3c3 +8 ab23d -24 a2b2c2 +8 ab4c 1 66 -112 a4e2 + 56 a3bde + 24 a32e + 48 a3cd2 32 aSb2ce 25 a262d2 54 a2bc2d + 17 a2c4 +6 a4e + 38 a63ed 12 ab2ac 6 65d 2 b4c2 -192 a3e2 +4256 a3e3 + 216 a3d2e -192 a2bde2 + 72 a2b2e2 -128 a2c2e2 -120 a26becde + 144 a2cd2e 54 a26bd3 27 a'd4 + 32 a2c3e +144 ab2ee2 + 18 a2c2d2 6 a62d2e + 18 ab3de 80 abc2de 6 ab2c2e + 18 abed3 + 42 ab2ed2 + 16 ac4e 26 abc3d 4 aced2 +4 aeI 27 b4e2 9 64d2 + 18 b3cde +6 b632d 4 b63d 1 62c4 4 b2c3e +1 b2c2d2 Equation for squares of the roots is , a2x +1 +2 ae --1 62 +2 ae +2 ce +1 e ' 4 -2 bd -1 d2 + Ile". .
The multiplication of the equation of differences and the equation for the squares of the roots of the quadric equation , gives the equation , 0-= a4x a2 x+ 4-14-+6 ac +9 ac2 +4 ac ' _-2 62 6 abc 1 6c 2 J , 1 ) , +1 64 where all the coefficients except the last are reduced to zero by the operator 3aab+2b^+ Cad , and they are consequently ( without any alteration ) coefficients of the equation of differences of the cubic equation : the last coefficient is not reduced to zero by the operator , and requires therefore to be completed by the adjunction of the terms in d ( the series , here and in every other case , is of course a finite one , the number of terms might easily be calculated apriori ) .
Let the value be L0+L , d+L2d2+ &amp;c. , we have Lo+4ac3 -lb2c2 and putting for shortness V ' 3a6 , +2^56 , the operator which reduces this to zero is V'+cd ; we ought therefore to have 0= V'Lo+ d V'LI+ d2 V'L2+. .
+ cL , 2cL2 3cL , P , t)6 .
96 and consequently L1=V'Lo , L2 =-V'L , L3=---V'L , &amp;c. , giving L= c{ ( 6+24=)18abc2-4b3c } =-8abc+ 4b3 , 12 2={-54ac+(36 -36=)O ab2}+27a2 , L3=O , &amp;c. , and consequently for the last coefficient the value above written down ; it will be presently seen how in more complicated cases the calculations should be arranged .
Again , multiplying together the equation of differences and the equation for the squares of the roots of the cubic equation , we obtain an equation which it is not necessary to write down , as it can be at once formed by putting e=O in the equation of differences for the quartic equation .
And from the equation so obtained , by the adjunction of the terms in e , we find the equation of differences for the quartic equation , viz. each coefficient is of the form Lo-+Lie+L2je+ &amp;c. , where L0 is known , and such coefficient is reduced to zero by the operator 4a6b +3ba ++2c + e ; or putting for shortness V'_ 4ab+ 3b + 2cd , the operator V+ de .
We have therefore LI=---|V'L = , L=--dVa L -dV'L2 , &amp;c. It is to be observed that the last coefficient of the equation of differences is the discriminant , and that the above method of calculating the coefficients of the equation of differences , as applied to the last coefficient , is nothing else than the method of calculating the discriminant given in my Fourth Memoir on Quantics .
The multiplication of the equation of differences , and the equation for the squares of the roots of the quartic equation , gives , in like manner , the equation of differences for the quintic equation , except as to the terms involving f ; and these are obtained as above , viz. each coefficient is of the form LO+Llf+L ?
f2 ?
&amp; c , where Lo is known ; such coefficient is reduced to zero by the operator 5a , +b + 4bc-+ 3cbd + 2d , e +eaf ; or putting for shortness V'=5abb+4bR+ ?
3c1+2d , the operator V'+eaf .
We have , therefore , I'e L ' 2e'L , .
L---VL~ , &amp;c. , which give L , L2 , &amp;c. by means of Lo .
For the calculation of V'L ( where L is any one of the coefficients Lo , L1 , &amp;c. ) , it is proper to separate the terms involving 97 the different powers of e , and write L=Mo+M , e+M2e2+ &amp;c. , V'=V"+2db , where V"-=5a^+46-]+30Cd .
We have then VL= V"MO+ e V"M1+ e2 V"M2+ &amp;c. , +2d M1 +4dM2 +6dM3 , or , what is the same thing , eVL= V"M1+ e V"M.+ ... +4dM2 +4dM3 ; and as an equation which should be satisfied identically , and which would therefore serve as a verification , V"0Mo+2dM , =0 ; but as a verification was obtained by other means , the equations of this kind were not used for the purpose .
It may be interesting to give the actual calculation of one of the coefficients , say of coefficient d2 ( which , with coefficient 0 , was calculated by Mr. HARLEY ) .
98 Calculation of coefficient 02 in equation of differences for the quintic equation ( a , b , l , d , e , fi , 1)5=0 .
Calculation of Lo .
99 2ae -2bd +c2 2ce -d2 e2 Coeff .
0 ? .
Coeff .
o .
Coeff .
2 .
In eq. of diff. for quartic , a4e +512 -112 +400 a3bde3 -384 -512 + 56 -840 a3c ee -256 + 256 -384 + 24 -360 a3cd2e2 + 288 +432 +192 + 48 +960 a3d4e 54 -216 -270 a2b2ce + 288 + 144 32 + 400 a2b2d2e2 12 +384 72 25 +275 a2bc2de2 -160 +256 -192 -240 54 -390 a2cbede + 36 -288 -108 +120 ; -240 abd5 + 54 + 54 + 108 a24e2 + 32 -128 + 64 + 17 15 a2c d2e 8 +144 + 36 32 +140 a2c2d4 27 18 45 ab4e 54 +6 48 ab3cde2 + 36 -288 + 36 + 38 -178 abd3e 8+ 12 18 14 abW23e2 8 +144 12 12 +112 ab2c2de +2 +160 -6 + 84 +6 +246 abcd4 36 42 78 abc4de 32 80 52 -164 abcd3 +8 +18 + 26 +52 ac6e +16 +8+ 24 acd 2448 b'de2 +54 6+ 48 64c2e2 27 +2 25 b4cd2e 36 18 54 b4d4 +8+9+ 17 b'c'de +8+ 18 + 12 + 38 3cd 246 12 6bc'e 426 b2c4 d2 1+ +1+2 Lo-=A + Be+Ce2 + De3+Ee4 , suppose , then , -B= .
-C= D= -E=_ a2d3 +270 a3ed2 -960 a3bd +840 a4 -400 abed3 +240 a2b2d2 -275 a3c2 +360 a2c3d2 -140 abec2d +390 a2b2c -400 ab3cd3 + 14 a2c4 + 15 ab4 + 48 ab2c2d ' -246 abed +178 abc4d + 164 abc3 -112 ac6 24 b5d 48 b4cd2 + 54 b4c2 +25 b3c3d 38 b2c5 + 6 Calculation of L1 .
Teims of L , f not involving e. 5a ?
b +4b00 + 3Cd 4d -f(VB + 4dC ) viz. .
_4 -B -C a3cdf +1200 +3240 -3840 +600 ab2d3f + 210 + 960 -1100 + 70 abc2d2f -2460 -1680 +2160 +1560 -420 a2c4df + 820 840 + 60 + 40 abi3cd2f +1080 -1968 + 126 + 712 50 ab2c3df 570 +2624 -]476 448 : +130 abc5f + 60.576 + 492 24 65d2f + 216 192 + 24 6 b4c~df 456 + 324 + 100 32 i b3cf &amp; *:+ 120 114 +6 Terms of Lf involving e ' ... ... ... . .
5ab + 4b5 + 3Cd 6d -ef(V"C+ 6dD ) viz. _---__ _ ... . .
_ -c -Da3cbdcef -2750 -3840 + 5040 = -1550 aIc2def + 1950 -5760 + 2160 -1650 ab2cdef +2670 +3120 -1650 -2400 +1740 abc3ef -1120 + 240 +1170 i+ 290 ab4def -1200 + 712 + 288 200 ab3c2ef + 500 -1344 + 534 310 b6cef + 200 144 + 56 Terms of L1 f involving e2 .
iabb 4bb 3cbd 8d e2f(V"D+8dE ) viz. .
- .
I -D -E 4ey2 +4200 -3200 =+ 1000 a3beef -4000 +2880 +2520 +1400 a 2b3ef + 960 -1600 640 Calculation of L , .
L1=A+Be+Ce2 , suppose , where --B= -C= abd2 + 775 a4d -500 a3c2d + 825 .
3bc -700 a2b2cd -870 a2b3 +320 a2^e3 -145 ab4d +100 abc2 + 155 b5c 28 1.00 Terms of L2 f2 not involving e. 5abb 46bc 3cbd 4d -f'(V'"B+ 4d ; C ) viz. ---IB -IC a4df2 +3875 -2000 = +1875 a3bedf2 -8700 +6600 +4650 -2800 250 ac3f2 725 +2475 +1750 a2b3dfa + 2000 -3480 +1280 200 a2cb2Cf2 + ?
2325 -1740 -2610 -2025 ab4cf2 700 +1240 + 300 + 840 ab6f2 112 112 Terms of L2 f2 involving el .
5abb 4b6c 3Cbd --ef"2V"C viz. --IC a4cef2 -3500 -1500 = -5000 a3b2ef2 + 4800 -2800 +2000 Calculation of L3 ( gives L3=0 ) .
L2 , =A+Be , Terms of L3 3 .
5abb 46^bc 3cd rf -_ f6V6B viz. +6v= 0 a4bfs3 | -i6666j +6666 -2 0O3 _ ... -.-.- .
-.r._And the required coefficient of 02 is Lo+Llf+L2f2 .
All the coefficients were calculated in this manner , except the last coefficient , which was deduced from the known value of the discriminant for the standard form .
And we have thus the complete expression of the equation of differences for the general quintic equation under the denumerate form ( a , b , c. d e , f~ v , 1)= -0 , viz. MDGCOLX .
P Equation of differences for ( a , b , c , d , e , f. v , 1 ) 5=0 is 010 09 6S 70 66 05 04 ax X a6x a4x a2x +1 +10 ac +10 a3e +50 a4ce +200 a6df +625 a6f2 + 1750 a5cf2 4 b2 4 a2bd +25 a4d -5 a a6e2 -250 abef 950 a5def +39 a2c2 -20 ab2e -120 a5bef +400 a cdf + 40 a5e3 -30 ab2c -50 a3bed +36 a5bde -360 a5cea 130 a4bcef +6 b4 +80 a3c3 -124 a5cSe +260 ad2e 700 a4b2f2 +16 a2bad + 92 ared2 -110 a4b2df + 142 a4bde2 -81 ac2be2 + 32 a463 +169 a4b2e2 + 380 a4bdf +30 ab4e 98 a4bce -240 a46ce -f 522 a4c2e2 4 66 44 a4b2d2 -104 a4bede 240 a4cdf -160 a4bc2d -104 a4bd3 + 708 a4dSe + 95 a4c4 +196 a4c3e 53 a4d4 + ; 418 a3b4e +118 a4c2d2 + 128 a3b3ef +116 a-'3cd +150 ab3cf + 388 a3b2ce2 -104 a3b2e3 10 a3b3de 394 a32cdf 20 a2b5d 0 a3 ab22e 378 a3b2d2e + 45 a264c2 + 20 a32ed 144 a3be3f 10 ab6Ce 220 a3bc3d 480 a3be2de +1 b8 + 66 a3 156 abed3 ' 24 a2bf + 194 a3c4e + 66 a24ce + 52 a33d2 3 a264d2 + 66 a264df + 192 a2b3c2d 84 a264e ' 66 a262c4 + 194 a263ce 8 ab6e + 330 a2b3cde - .
66 ab6ed + 92 a2b3d2 + 24 ab4c3 152 a262c3e +8 67d + 174 ab62c2d2 3 boc2 140 a26b4d + 25 a2c6 ~~~~(.~~~~~~~~~ ~~-70 ab6cf 42 ab ?
de + 32 ab4c2e 144 ab4cd2 -+ 100 ab9ed jI~ ~ ~~~~ I'~~~~~~~~ 18 ab2C5 +8 f. -2 b6ce + 22 b6d2 16 b652d +3 b4c4 .
** * 1)1 ?
=0 , viz. the function in S is 09 .
02 .
0 .
00 .
m~~~~ I ... ... ... .-3750 a5ef2 + 1500 a4bdf2 +1500 a4be !
f +2500 a4cef2 -2150 a4cdef 80 a4ce3 + 700 a4d3f +570 a4d2e2 40 a3b2def -2450 a62cf 2 118 a'b2e3 +290 a3bc2ef -400 a3bedy 158 a3bede2 596 a3bd3e + 80 a3c3df 308 a3c3e2 + 612 a3e2d2e 102 acd4 + 490 a2bf2 + 180 a26bcef + 112 a26bd2 + 92 a263de2 + 86 abe2c2df + 388 a62bc2e2 + 150 a262cd2e + 160 a262d4 48 a2bc4f 504 a2bc3de + 106 a2c5e 7 a2c4d2 68 ab5ef 86 ab4cdf 178 ab4ce2 54 ab4d2e + 234 ab3c2de + 34 ab3c3f 148 abcd3s 56 ab2c4e + 112 ab2c3d2 34 abc5d +4 ac7 + 16 b66df + 26 b6e 6 b52f 30 b5cde + 28 b5d3 +8 b4c3e 24 64c2d2 +8 b3c4d 1 b2c6 -5000 a4cef2 +1875 a4d ?
f2 +1000 a4de !
f + 400 a4e4 +2000 aab2ef2 250 a3bedf2 + 1400 a3bcef -1550 a3bd2ef 840 a'bde3 + 1750 a3e3f2 1650 a3c2def 360 a3c2e3 + 600 a3cdf + 960 a3cd2e2 270 a3d4e 200 a26bdf2 640 a2b6e2f --2025 ab262f 2+ 1740 a2b6cdef + 400 a2b2ce3 470 a2bd3f + 275 a2b2d2e2 + 290 a'bc3ef 420 a2bc2d2f 390 a2bc2de ' 240 a2bed3e + 108 a2bd ; + 40 a2c4df 15 a2c4e2 + 140 a2c3d2e 45 a2c2d4 + 840 ab4cf2 200 ab4def 48 ab4e3 310 ab3c2ef 50 a^ed2f 178 ab3cde2 14 ab3d3e + 130 ab2c3df + 112 ab2c3e2 + 246 ab2c2d2e 78 ab2cd4 24 abe5f 164 abc4de + 52 abc3d3 + 24 ac6e 8 aced2 112 b6f2 + 56 b5cef + 24 b5d2f + 48 b6de2 32 b4c2df 25 b4c2e2 54 b4cd2e + 17 64d4 +6 bc4f + 38 b633de , 12 6b32d3 6 b6c2e +2 62c4d2 -6250 a4df3 + 5000 a4e2f2 + 3750 a'bef3 250 a3bdef2 -2000 a3be3f -3750 a3c2ef2 + 3000 a'd2f 2 -4200 a3cde2f + 320 a3ce4 450 a3d3ef 40 a3d2e3 -1000 a2b3e3 + 1950 a2b2cef2 -1150 a2b6d2f2 + 1170 a26bde2f + 72 a226e4 -2100 a2bc2df2 + 1380 a6c2 e2f 550 abced2ef 504 a2bcde3 + 180 a2bd4f + 138 a2bd3e2 + 675 a2c4f2 330 a2c3def 224 a'cee + 60 a2c2d3 + 434 a2c2d2e2 198 a'cd4e + 27 a2d6 240 ab4ef2 + 1320 ab3cdf2 -1230 abcef 12 ab3d2ef + 18 ab3des 450 ab2c3f 2+ 594 ab2c2def + 282 ab2c2e3 154 ab2cdY 114 ab2cd e2 +6 ab2d4e 72 abc4ef + 24 abc3d !
f 186 abc3de2 + 116 abc2d3e 18 abed ' + 36 ace'e2 - ' 24 ac4d2e +4 ac3d4 192 b'df2 + 216 b6e2f + 72 b4e22 120 b4cdef 54 b4ce3 + 32 b4d3f + 18 b4d2e2 + 18 b3c3ef 6 b3c2d2f + 42 b3c2de2 26 b3cd3e +4 b3d5 9 b2c4e~ +6 b2c3d2e 1 b2c2d4 +3125 a4f4 -2500 a3bef3 -3750 a3cdf3 + 2000 a3ee2f2 + 2250 a3d2ef2 -1600 a3deyf + 256 a3e5 + 2000 a262df3 50 a2b2e22 + 2250 a2bcef3 -2050 a2bcdef2 + 160 a2bceY3 900 a2bd32 + 1020 a2bd2e2f 192 a2bde4 900 a2c3ef2 + 825 a2c2df 2+ 560 aec2def 128 a2c2e4 630 a2cd3ef + 144 a2cd2e3 + 108 a2d5f 27 a2d4e2 -1600 ab3ef3 + 160 ab3def2 36 ab3e3f + 1020 ab22ef 2+ 560 ab2cd2f2 746 ab2cde !
f + 144 ab2ee4 + 24 ab2d3ef,6 ab2d2e3 630 abc3df2 + 24 abc3e2f + 356 abc2d2ef 80 abc2de3 72 abcd4f + 18 abcd3e2 + 108 ac5f2 72 ac4def + 16 ac4e3 + 16 ac3d3f 4 ace3de2 + 256 bf 3 192 b4cef2 128 b4dcf2 + 144 64dey 27 b4e4 + 144 b3c2df2 6 b3c2eY 80 bcd2ef + 18 beede3 + 16 b3d4f 4 b3d3e2 27 be4f2 + 18 b2cedef 4 b2c3e3 4 b62d3f +1 b2c2d2e 0 , 1)'1 i II I IA IiII iI ii _I It may be remarked , that if w is an imaginary cube root of unity , then the roots of the equation ( 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1lv , 1)5=0 are -1 , co , 2 , , -2 ; the differences of the roots are -1~ , --21_ ?
, -I+ ?
, --1+ -+_ , 02 , 2w , 2 +w ' , w+w , 22w , -~+w2:2 v , 9 , --1+ -1+2 , / --,2 , 2c , --1 , -1 , 2 , w--+ , and the squares of the differences are w7 J , 3a ?
-3w -32 -3 5 4o2 , 1 , 1 4ao -3 from which the equation of differences is found to be ( 2++ O )(02 30+ 9)(02 40+16)( 220+1)(0d+ 60+ 9)-0 ; or multiplying out , it is ( 1 , 6 , 21 , 46 , 108 , 546 , 493 , -1410 , -567 , -540 , +12961d , l)10=0 ; which is what the preceding expression of the equation of differences becomes upon writing therein a=b-=c-d-=e-=f=l .
Moreover , upon passing ( as will presently be done ) to the standard form , and then writing a=b=c=d=e=f=1 , all the coefficients ( except the first coefficient , which is equal to unity ) should become equal to zero ; these two tests afford a complete verification of the result .
The following corrections have to be made in WARING'S result , as given by himself and LAGRANGE ( WARING , Phil. Trans. 1763):WARING , Meditationes Algebraicae , p. 85:for + 169 q3s read +196 q3s ( in coefficient w5 ) .
LAGRANGE , Equations Numeriques , p. 108:for +1200 CE read +200 CE ( in d ) for 169 B3D read 196 B3D ( in e ) for 25B6 read + 25B6 ( inf ) for + 27 C4D2 read 27 C4D2 ( in k ) .
It may be noticed , that if in the coefficients of the several powers of 0 ( as they are written down in the columns , without regarding the power of a which multiplies the entire column ) , we attend only to the terms independent of a , we have the series 1 , -4b2 , +6b 46 , +1 +8b7d , + 8yf , &amp;c. 3b2 , 2b6ce +22b6d2 -16bOcWd + 3b4c4 , the law of the first terms of which , up to the term +1b8 , is obvious ; but the term + 1b8 , which is the last term of this initial series , is also the first term of a terminal series , the terms of which are deduced from the coefficients in the equation of differences for the 104 quartic equation ( a , b , c , d , ev , 1)=4-0 , viz. these coefficients are asx a4 x ax2 +1 +8ac + 8a3e 3b2 -2a2bd +22a2c2 -16ab2c &amp;c. + 3b4 ; and by writing b , c , d , e , f in the place of a , b , c , d , e respectively , and multiplying by b2 , we have the above-mentioned series , +lb8 , +867d , &amp;c. 366c2 .
It is easy to see , a priori , in the case of an equation of any order , that this property holds good .
Passing now to the standard forms , For the quadric ( a , b , c)I , 1)2=0 , the equation of differences is , 0= a2X 4X( +1 +-aC-01 1).e For the cubic equation ( a , b , c , d)v , 1)3=0 , the equation of differences is , 0= ?
a4X 18a2X 81 x 927x r -mc---mA__+1 +1 1 ac +1 a22 +1 a2d 1 b2 -2 ab -6 abed I +1 b4 +4 ac3 +4 b3d --3 b2e2 _ .
t ... ... .
_ _ , ... ... .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 0o , 1 ) ' .
For the quartic equation ( a , b , c , d , e(v , 1)4-0 , the equation of differences is , 0= 48a4x +1 ac -1 b2 8a x+1 a3e 4 a2bd + 99 a2c2 -192 ab2c + 96 b4 32 xc --3 a4ce + 13 a4d ' 3 a3b2e 90 a'bcd + 189 a3c3 + 64 a2b3d -432 a'2b2C + 384 ab4c -128 b6 16x m7 a4e + 56 a3bde +54 a3e2e t+ 288 a3cd2 192 a2b2ce 400 a2b'd2 -1944 a2beed +-1377 a2c + 96 ab4e + 3648 ab6cd -2592 ab2c3 -1536 b5d +-1152 b4c2 1152 X1 a3ee2 +3 ad 2e +1 a2b2e2 -10 abecde -12 a2bd3 +6 a2c3e +9 aec2d2 + , 4 ab3de -3 ab2c2e + 56 ab2cd2 -78 abc3d + 27 ac5 -32 b4d2 + 48 63C2d -18 62e2 256 x+1 a3e3 1 ` a'2de ' 12 a26de : 18 a22e + 54 a2cd2e 27 a2d4 + 54 ab2ce2 6 ab2de -180 abc2de + 108 abed3 + 81 ac4e 54 aced2 27 64e2 + 108 b3cde 64 b3d3 54 b2cee + 36 b2C2d2 6x +1 ( 105 0 , 1)6 .
For the quintic equation ( a , b c , d , e , f v , 1)5 ==0 , the equation of differences is , 010 99 98 07 on 05 04 a8X 100o X 50 a4X 500 a2 X 12 5 +1 +1 ae }1 42 +1 4 !
+ 78 150 + 75 aae a2bd ab2c b4 +1 a4ce +I a4d2 -a3b2e -1 a3bed + 32 a3c3 +8 a2b3d -81 a2b2C2 +75 ab4c -25 46 + 16 a6df 19 a6e2 48 a5bef + 72 a'bde 4496 a5c2e + 736 a5cd2 + 32 a4b3f 980 a4b2ce 880 a4b2d2 6400 a4b2d +7600 a4c4 + 450 a3b4e +-11600 a3b3cd -20800 a3^2cs 5000 a2b5d +22500 a2b42 -12500 ab6e -a 3125 68 625 x '+ 1 a6f2 10 a5bef + 64 a5cdf 144 a'ce2 -+ 208 a5d2e .
44 a462df 169 a4be 192 a4bc2f 416 a4bede 832 a4bd3 + 1568 a4c3e + 1888 a4c2d2 + 300 a3b3cf .
100 a36bde 3600 a3b2c2e + 800 a3b2ed2 -17600 a3bc3d +10560 a3ea 120 ab4f + 3300 a2b4ce 300 a2b4d2 +38400 ab23c2d --26400 a2b2c4 1000 able + 33000 ab5ed 24000 ab4c ' + 10000 b7d 3750 b62e 2500X +7 acf2 19 aSdef +2 a5e3 13 a4bcef 7 a4bf2 + 71 a4bde2 + 76 a4bd2f 522 a4e22 +96 a4W2df + 1416 a(4cd2e 212 a4d4 + 32 a3b3ef + 970 a3b2ce2 394 a3b2cdf 1890 a3b2d2e 288 abec3f -4800 a3be2de 3120 a3bed3 7 3880 ace4e + 2080 ace3d2 + 165 a2b4df 525 a2b4e2 + 970 a2b3e2f - ? ?
8250 a2b3cde + 4600 a2b3d3 7600 a2b2c8e + 17400 a262c2d2 -28000 a2be4d +10000 a2c6 875 ab5ef 2625 abhde + 4000 ab4 c2e -36000 ab4cd2 +50000 ab3c3d d -18000 ab2c 250 b7f 625 b6ce 13750 b6d2 --20000 b5e2d + 7500 b4c4 '106 ( I 0=( O , 1)1 ?
=0 , viz. the function in a is e3 .
02 .
0 ? .
1250 x 62500 x 62500 x 3125 x3 a5ef2 + 12 a4bdf2 30 a4be2f 440 a4c2f2 172 a4cdef 16 a4ce3 + 112 a 4df + 228 a4d2e2 -8 a3b2def 98 a3b2f 2 59 a3b2e3 + 116 a3bc2ef 320 a3bed2f 316 a3bede2 384 a3bd3e + 128 a3c3df 1232 a3c3e2 + 4896 a3c2d2e 1632 a3cd4 49 a2b4f2 + 180 a2b3cef + 224 a2b3d2f +460 a2b3de2 + 344 a2b2c2df 43880 a2b2c2e2 + 3000 a2b2Cd2e + 6400 a2b2d4 384 a2bc4f ---20160 a2bC3de 48480 a2c5e 1120 a2c4d2 170 ab'ef 860 ab4cdf 4450 ab4ce2 2700 ab4d2e + 23400 ab3c2de + 680 ab3c3f 29600 ab3cd3 -11200 ab2e4e +44800 ab2c3d2 -27200 abed + 6400 ac7 + 400 b6df + 1625 b6e2 300 b*cf 7500 b5cde 14000 b5d3 + 4000 b4c3e -24000 b4c2d2 + 16000 b3c4d 4000 b2c6 4 a4cef2 +3 a4d ?
f2 +4 a4de2f +4 a4e4 +4 a3b2ef2 2 a3bedf 28 a3bee2f 62 a3bd2ef 84 a3bde3 + 98 a'3cf2 132 a3e2def 72 a3c2e + 96 a3cd3f + 384 a'cd 2e 216 a3d4e 4 a23df 2 32 a2b3e2f 81 a2b2c2f2 + 348 a2b2cdef + 200 a262ce3 + 28 a2b2d3f + 275 a2b2d2e2 + 116 a2bc3ef 336 a2^c2d2y 780 a2bc2de2 960 a2bcd3e + 864 a2bd .
+ 64 a2e4df 60 a2c4e2 + 1120 a2c3d2e 720 a2c2d4 + 84 ab4ef2 100 ab4def 60 ab4e3 310 ab3c2ef 100 ab3df 890 ab3cde2 140 ab3d3e + 520 ab2c3df +-1120 ab2c3e2 + 4920 ab2c2d2e -3120 ab2cd4 192 abcY -6560 abc4de + 4160 abe3d3 +-1920 ac6e -1280 ac5d2 28 66f2 + 140 b5cef + 120 b5d2f + 600 b5de2 320 64c2df 65 b4c2e2 -2700 b4cd2e + 1700 b4d4 + 120 b3c4f + 3800 b3c3de -2400 b3c2d3 -1200 b2cSe + 800 b624d2 1+2+3 20 30 + 48 +8+ 32 2 36 + 39 46 + 117 + 18 168 + 276 220 504 + 144 + 276 + 108 264 448 + 96 + 1736 -1584 + 432 12 + 264 615 12 + 45 180 + 1188 + 1410 616 -1140 + 120 288 + 192 -3720 + 4640 -1440 + 1440 -1920 + 640 96 + 270 + 72 600 675 + 320 + 450 + 180 120 + 2100 -2600 + 800 900 41200 400 a4df3 a4e2f2 a3bef3 a3bdef2 a36be3f a3c2ef2 a3cd2f2 a3cde !
f *a3ce4 a3d3ef a3d2e3 a2b3fs a2b2cef2 a2b2d !
f 2 a2 b2 de !
a2b2e4 a2b6c2df2 a2bc'e2f a2bed2ef a2bede3 a2bd4y abd3e2 a2c4f2 a2c3def a2c3e a2c2d3f a2c2d2e2 a2cd4e a2d6 ab4ef2 ab3cdf2 ab3cef ab3d2ef ab3de3 ab2c3f2 abc2def ab2cdf ab2ccde2 ab2d4e abc4ef abc3d !
f abc3de2 abc2d3e abcd5 ac5e2 ac4d2e ac3d4 b5df2 Y5e2f b4ec2f2 64cdef b4ce3 b4d3f b4d2e2 b3c3ef b3c2d2 b3c2de2 b3cd3e b3d5 62c4e2 b2c3d2e b2c2d4 +1 a4f 20 a3bef 120 a3cdf3 + 160 a3ce2f2 + 360 a3d2ef2 640 a3de3f + 256 a3e5 + 160 a2b2df3 10 a2b2e22 + 360 a26c2f3 1640 a2bedef2 + 320 a26ce3f 1440 a2bdf2 + 4080 a26d2e2f 1920 a2bde4 1440 a2ceef2 + 2640 a2ed2yf + 4480 a2c2de 2560 a2c2e _-10080 a2cd3ef + 5760 a2cd2e8 + 3456 a2df 160 a2d4e2 640 ab3cf 3+ 320 abdef2 180 ab3e3f + 4080 ab2e2ef2 + 4480 ab2cd 2 -14920 ab2ede2f + 7200 ab2ce4 + 960 ab62def 600 a62d'2e -10080 abc3df2 + 960 abc3e2f + 28480 abced2ef -16000 abc2de3 11520 abed4f + 7200 abcd3e2 + 3456 ac5f 2 -11520 ac4def + 6400 ac4e3 + 5120 aced3f 3200 ac3d2e2 + 256 b53 1920 b4eef2 2560 b4df 2+ 7200 b64def 3375 64e4 + 5760 632df 2 600 b632e2f -16000 63cd2ef + 9000 b3cde3 + 6400 63d4f 4000 b3d3e2 2160 62e4f2 + 7200 b2c3def 4000 62c3e3 3200 bc2d3fY + 2000 62c2d2e2 107 X14 , )1 ) The coefficients in the preceding equations of differences are functions of the seminvariants of the quantics to which they belong ; for instance , in the case of the quartic , the coefficient of 64 is that of S is 8a2 { a2(ae46d+ 3c2)+ 96(ac-b2)2 } , that of 0s is 32 { 3a3(ace-ad22e+2bcd-)+16a2(ac-b2)(ae--4bd 32)+ 128(ac-b2)3 and so for the other coefficients ; and by replacing each seminvariant by the covariant to which it belongs , we pass from the solution of the original problem of finding the equation for 0=(as-3)2 , to that of the problem of finding the equation for 0= ( &lt; 3 ) ' ( x y)"( ' -Ay)2 ' The results are as follows : For the quadric ( a , b , c1x , y)2 , the equation in 0 is , == ( U2 , 40X0 , 1 ) , where U is the quadric , O the discriminant .
For the cubic ( a , b , c , d3(x , y)3 , the equation in 0 is , 0=(U4 , 18U2H , 81H2 , 27 D0 , 1)8 , where U is the cubic , H the Hessian , O the discriminant .
For the quartic ( a , b , c , d , e)x , y)4 , the equation in 8 is , 0= ( U6 , 48U41 , 8U2(U2I+96H2 ) , 32(-13U3J+16U2HI+128H3 ) , 0 , 1)6 , 16(-7U2I-288UHJ+384H2I ) , 1152(-3UIJ+2HIP ) , 256( 3 -27J2 ) , where U is the quartic , H the Hessian , I and J the quadrinvariant and the cubinvariant respectively .
For the quintic ( a , 6 , c , d , e , fj(x , y ) ' , the equation in 0 , as far as it can be expressed in terms of known covariants , is , O= 1 00U6(Tab .
No. 15 ) , 50U4[U2(Tab .
No. 14 ) 75(Tab .
No. 15)2 ] , 3125 Discriminant(=Tab .
No. 26 ) where the Tables referred to are those in my Second Memoir on Quantics .
108 The form of the preceding results may be modified by writing == .
U2 ; we have thus the equations for = 2(-_ )'2(_ yy)2( _ y)2 ... ; thus for example , in the case of the cubic ( a , b , c , d3x , y)3 , the equation for 3[=a2( --)2(x-y)2 ] is 0=(1 , 18H , 81H2 , 27 DU2X , 1)3 .
This equation may be written ( a+ 9H)2S+27 0 U2=0 ; or putting v=V/ 5 , we have V3+ 9Hv+ +U/ -27 =0 , an equation the roots of which are and which leads to the formula , given in my Fifth Memoir on Quantics , for the solution of a cubic equation .
But this decomposition of the equation in 9 is peculiar to the cubic .
The equation of differences for an equation of any order may be found by the following entirely distinct method .
Let the proposed equation ( *v , 1)-=0 , be for shortness represented by pv=0 , and let x , y be any two distinct roots ; we have not only px=0 , py=O , but also x+py=O , , x'Y=-0 .
Writing -=(x-y)2 , s=x-+y , we have x=-(s+/ ) , y=2(s/ ) , values which are to be substituted for x , y in the equations xIS+ y=O , fX 0 We have thus two equations rational in s and d , and the elimination between them of the quantity s leads to the required equation in D. But it is proper to modify the form of the system ; in fact the two equations are , as regards s , the first of them of the degree * , the second of the degree n-1 ; but if we write n( + , y ( X -+[Y ) ( ; X Y ) ( x-y -_yo ~n((x+ey ) v+y )w x-~=0 , x-*yo ' X-Y X--y then each of the equations will be of the same degree n-1 in s. For instance , let pv=(a , b , c , d)jv , 1)3 , then x= I(s+ , V ) , yI= ) ( s+JB ) ; the equations px+Y=/ =0 , X =---O , are X--y s3a+3s22b+3s(4c+aO)+8d +6b=0 , 3s2a+-3s 4b+ 12c+a =0 ; and multiplying the first equation by 3 and the second by -s , adding and dividing by 2 , we have an equation s23b+s(12c+ 4a0 ) +12d+ 9bd0 .
109 The second equation and this equation may be written ( 3a , 12b 12c +adO s , 1)2=0 , ( 3b , 12c+4aO , 12d+9b60s , 1)2=0 , and the elimination of s from these equations gives the required equation in 0 .
The result may be obtained under either of the two forms , { a202 + ( 15ac--272)-36(bd--C2 ) } { a28+3 ( ac-b2 ) } +3{2ab6+3(ad--bc)}2=0 and { 4a2D2+(24ac-27b2)0-36(bd 2 ) } { a20+ 12(c-b2 ) } +3{ ab6+6(ad-be ) }20 , the expansions of which respectively coincide with the before-mentioned result .
In the case of the quartic equation pv=(a , b , c , d)v , 1)4 =0 , we have s4a+4s32b+6s2( 4c+aO)+ 4s(8d+6b6)+16e+24c0+a20 , 4s3a+6s24b+4s ( 12c-+a)+ 32d+8b6 =0 , from which we derive another cubic equation ; and the two cubic equations are ( 4a , 24b 48c+ 4aO , 32d+ 8b6.s , 1)3=0 , ( 46 , 24c+10a , 48d+44bO , 32e+48c0+2a02as , 1)3=0 , from which , if s be eliminated , we have the equation in 0 .
Similarly , for the quintic equation pv=-(a , b , c , d , e , f(v , 1)5= 0 , we have s5a+ 5s42b+10s3( 4c+aO)+1082( 8d+6b ) +5s(16e+24c0+ a2)+ 32f+ 80dO+10b2= 0 , 5s4a+ 10s34b6+ s2(12e+a ) + 5s ( 32d+ 8b)+ ( 80e+40cd+ad2 ) =0 , from which we derive another quartic equation ; the two equations are ( 5a , 40b , 120c+ 10a0 , 160d+ 40b , 80e 40c0 + a02(s , 1)4=0 , ( 5b , 40c+20a0 , 120d+130b0 , 160e+280c0+12a02 , 8qf+200dO+25b62js , 1)4=0 , from which , if s be eliminated , we have the equation in 0 .
But to apply BEZOUT'S method to the two equations each of the order n-- , which result from the equation of the nth order pv = ( *(v , 1)= 0 .
The process is as follows : Suppose , in general , that s is to be eliminated from the two equations Fs=0 , Gs=0 , each of the order n-1 ; it is only necessary to form the expression FsGs'-Fs'Gs s-s which will be a function of s , s ' of the form a( 1o , l. 1 , n(s , l)- ' ao , ' ao , a._27s 1)}-2(S ' , 1)'~ -2 a1 , On:an-2 , 0 110 where the coefficients are such that ac , , =am , , ; and by equating to zero the determinant formed with these coefficients , we have the result of the elimination .
In the present case , writing for a moment p ( s-+ V0)=A , ( s-2/ O)-=B , and in like manner -s(s'+Vf / )=A ' , ( p(s'V=/ O)=B ' , we have Fs =n(A+B)(A ) Gs= s'(A -BI ) G Al ABl Fs'=n(A'+B ) s(A-B ' ) Gs and therefore FsGs'-F'Gs ( A + B)(A'-B ' ) ( A-B ) ( A'+ B ' ) _(s--')(A-B)(A'-B ' ) .
FsGs'--F s'Gs=n .
or reducing and dividing by s-s ' , FsGs'-Fs'Gs AB'-A'B ( A-B)A'-B ' s-s ' -n / ( s-s')+ Hence , substituting for A , B , A ' , B ' these values , we have the expression 92n P(s + / 0)(S/ V )(s-VS)p-(s'+ ?
V).n 2 ( s-s ' ) 20 +{vp(s+ VO)-ps^/ )}{p(s'+ ?
/O)--p(s'/ ' ) } ( S A Al Al which is of the form ( ao , , ao , ,. .
ao , , , _Js , 1)"-2(s , 1)"-2 al,0 an-2 , 0 and equating to zero the determinant formed with the coefficients , we have an equation in 6 which is the equation of differences of the given equation pv=O .
For instance , if the given equation is pv=(a , 6 , c , d(v , 1)3=0 , then we have 8((s+/ 0 )=(a , 2b+as/ O , 4c+4bV6/ +aO , 8d+12cV/ O+6b6+a6Vo/ )s , 1)3 =(A , B , C , D)s , 1)3 , 8p(s-V/ W)=((a , 26--aV/ , 4c-4b/ BV+ad , 8d-12c/ V+6b6-a4d/ N/ Os , 1)3 =(A ' , B ' , C ' , D 's , 1)3 ; and the function in s , s ' is f 3(AB ' -A'B)s2Y'2 +3(AC'-A'C)ss'(s+s ' ) 6+ ( AD'A'D)(s2+ss'+8)2 ) / O +-9(BC ' -B'C)ss ' + 3(BD'-B'D)(s+s ' ) ; + 3(CD'-C'D ) +j(A-A ' , B-B ' , C-C ' , D-D')]s , 1)3(A-A ' , B-B ' , C-C , D-D 's ' , 1)3 , Q2 111 which is equal to '-3a2 sa212 -12ab si(s+s ' ) 12 +(-12ac--a2)(s2+ss+s ' 2 ) +(36ac-72b2+9a2 &amp; )ss ' +(24ad-72bc+12ab)(s+s ' ) I +-96bd-144c2+(-48ac+72b2)3a202 J +4(3as2+ 12bs+12c +a)(3as 2+ 12bs'+12c+a ) ; or reducing and dividing by 32 , this is { 9(ac -b2)+3a2 0}s ' + { 9(ad-bc)+66abd}(s+s ' ) +36(bd -2)+(--15ac+ 27b2)-a2 , the terms in s2 , Sf2 disappearing , as they should do .
Writing this under the form ( 9(ac -b2)+3a2d , 9(ad-bc)+6abO.s , 1)(s ' , 1 ) 9(ad-bc)+6abO , 36(bd-c2)+(-15ac+27b2)--a2"2 and equating the determinant to zero , we have the required equation in d : the form is precisely that which is obtained by the ordinary process of applying BEZOUT'S method to the two equations ( 3a , 12b , 12c+ aOjs , 1)=0 , ( 3b , 12c+4a0 , 12d+Sb1Xs , 1)2= 0 , being in fact the before-mentioned equation ( a202+(15ac -2 72)O36(bd-c2))(a20+ 3(ac-b2 ) ) +3 ( 2ab+ 3(adbc))2= 0 .
But , as already remarked , this elimination process is less convenient for the complete development of the result , than the method first explained in the present memoir .

