On the Equation for the Product of the Differences of all but one of the Boots of a given Equation .
By ARTHUR CAYLEY , Esq. , F.R.S. Received November 30 , 1860 , -Read January 10 , 1861 .
IT is easy to see that for an equation of the order n , the product of the differences of all but one of the roots will be determined by an equation of the order n , the coefficients of which are alternately rational functions of the coefficients of the original equation , and rational functions multiplied by the square root of the discriminant .
In fact , if the equation be pv=(a , ... tv , l)n=a(v--)(v-f- ) ... , then putting for the moment a=l , and disregarding numerical factors , V/ , the square root of the discriminant , is equal to the product of the differences of the roots , and p ' &amp; is equal to ( a-3)(a-y ) ... , consequently the product of the differences of the roots , all but c , is equal to\/ O C- ' , and the expression 1 is the root of an equation of the order n , the coefficients of which are rational functions of the coefficients of the original equation .
I propose in the present memoir to determine the equation in question for equations of the orders three , four , and five : the process employed is similar to that in my memoir " On the Equation of Differences for an Equation of any Order , and in particular for Equations of the Orders Two , Three , Four , and Five* , " viz. the last coefficient of the given equation is put equal to zero , so that the given equation breaks up into v=0 and into an equation of the order n-1 called the reduced equation ; and this being so , the required equation breaks up into an equation of the order n-i ( which however is not , as for the equation of differences , that which corresponds to the reduced equation ) and into a linear equation ; the equation of the order n-1 is calculated by the method of symmetric functions ; and combning it with the linear equation , which is known , we have the required equation , except as regards the terms involving the last coefficient , which terms are found by the consideration that the coefficients of the required equation are seminvariants .
The solution leads immediately to that of a more general question ; for if the product of the differences of all the roots except a , of the given equation pv=(*X( , 1)n=a(uv-c)(v-3 ) ... =0 ( which product is a function of the degree n2 in regard to each of the roots ( , y , S. .
) , is multiplied by ( x-aMy)n-2 , the function so obtained will be the root of an equation of the order n , the coefficients of which are covariants of the quantic ( *)x( , y ) ) , and these coefficients can be at once obtained by writing , in the place of the seminvariants of the former result , the covariants to which they respectively belong .
In the case of the quintic equation , one of these covariants is , in regard to the coefficients , of the degree 6 , which exceeds the limit of the tabulated covariants , the covariant in question has therefore to be now first calculated .
The covariant equations for the cubic and the quartic might be deduced from the formulae Nos. 119 and 142 of my Fifth memoir on Quantics* ; they are in fact the bases of the methods which are there given for the solution of the cubic and the quartic equations respectively ; and it was in this way that I was led to consider the problem which is here treated of .
1 .
The notation ~ ( a , 3 , y. .
) is used ( after Professor SYLVESTER ) to denote the product of the squared differences of ( a , { , y. .
) , and the notation 4( ( a , y. .
) to denote the product of the differences taken in a determinate order , viz. , p , , Y..)=(M--)(-y)(-~). .
( ~3-yX)( -). .
( y-~). .
2 .
The product of the differences of the roots of an equation depends , as already noticed , on the square root of the discriminant ; and in order to fix the numerical factors and signs , it will be convenient , in regard to the equations ( a , b , clv , 1)2=0 , ( a , b , c , dcv , 1)3-0 , ( a , b , c , d , eDv , 1 ) =0 , ( a , b9 c , d , e , fv , 1)5=0 , to write as follows : ?
( o , P ) a/ -(4ac-b2 ) =1 / , 2(o , F , y)= -aV/ -(27ad+4ac3+-. .
) =a -o , ( a0 , p y , )= , --~3/ 256aCe'-27a'd4+ =---~ ( 6 ( 3 , y8 )=c/ 3)125(a4:f4+256a e"+ .
- .
= / , where it is to be observed , for example , that writing in the last equation = 0 , and therefore f=O , we have ( os , , y , , 0))=--e4/ 256a3e3+. .
, which agrees with the equation V(al , 7 , l , 0)= j3y3( , , 6)3y , )= ( a , , 7 , 6 ) , if for V(a , , y , S ) we substitute the value given by the last equation but one .
For the cubic equation ( a , b , c , dvV , 1)3=0 ; 3 .
We have to find the equation for d=--(a , 3)=~--3 ; the roots are = -Philo , 0 =y-a , = .
5 .
To apply the method above explained , write y=O , and therefore also d=O ; the roots thus become 01=3- , 0=--c , 0= -P3 , and we have the quadric and linear equations ( 9+o)(X-3)=0 , 0(c-3)=-0 , where ( a , ( 3 ) are the roots of the equation ( , 6 , ci , 1)=0 .
Hence , writing Z=-4ac-b2 , we have and the two equations become 0-a+dV/ -Z-c=O , da-/ --Z=0 ; or multiplying the two equations together , 3Oa2+ 20 +(3ac-b )+ / Z= 0 , which is what the required equation becomes , on putting therein d=O ; the coefficients of the complete equation are seminvariants , and the terms in d are to be inserted by means of this property .
The coefficient 3ac-62 is reduced to zero by the operator 3ab- , +26b , c+cb , it is therefore a seminvariant , and remains unaltered .
The coefficient cV/ -Z is what V/ E becomes ( D being the discriminant of the cubic equation ) on putting therein d=0 , it is therefore to be changed into i/ O. Hence 4 .
For the cubic equation ( a , b , c , dXv , 1)3 the equation for 0(=-(cc , f ) ) is 0= axE V-u x( +1 0 +3 ac +1 0l ) -1 b3 ' For the quartic equation ( a , b , c , d , e ?
v , 1)4-=0 ; 5 .
Here 0= -(C , , Y)= -(--3)(Y)(Y ) , the roots are 1-= -(7 , ) , the signs being in this case and indeed for an equation of any even order ) alternately =4( 7 ) the signs being in this case ( and indeed for an equation of any even order ) alternately positive and negative ; in fact , if the equation is represented by v=-0 , then the roots divided by r(a , j3 , y , b ) should respectively be p 'm , 'p3 , &lt; 'y , ' and this will be the case if the signs are taken as above .
H2 47 Putting now ==0 ( and therefore e=-0 ) the roots become 0 ==3 PIE ( P -Y ) , 2 =ya(y a ) , 8=3 , -p( ) , ?
4-4 where ( a , 3 , y ) are the roots of ( a , b , c , dXv , 1)3-0 .
Let Z denote the discriminant of the cubic function , then j(a3 , r)=v'/ -Z , and we have thus the linear equation ; the cubic equation is II,3{ P(y3 ) }=O , the coefficients of which can be calculated by the method of symmetric functions ( see Annex No. 1 ) .
7 .
The cubic equation being thus obtained , we have the two equations 03 .
a4 0.a2 +02 .
_ a2VZ +o2.-a2-Z +i/ -'Z -+ .
-9ad'+ 4abed--bd + ' d2/ 2 Z =0 =0 ; and multiplying these together , the resultant equation is 04 .
a6 +0 ' .
0+ 42 .
a2(9a2d2'+ 4abed-b3d+ Z ) +d .
( 8a2d+4abc--b)d -/ -Z -dZ -0 , where the coefficients have to be completed by adding the terms which contain e. We have v/ D in the place of d/ -Z , and O in the place of --dZ .
The coefficient -8a2d+4abc-b3 is a seminvariant , and requires no alteration .
The coefficient 9a2d2+ 4abedb d+Z is 9a2d2+ 4abed -b3d + 27a'2d-2 18abed+ 4ac3+ 4b3db22 ; that is , +18a2d2 14abed + 4ac3 + 3b3d lb2C2 48 and the terms in e to be added to this , in order to make it a seminvariant , are easily found to be -16ace + 6abe .
8 .
Hence , for the quartic equation ( a , b , c , dXv , 1)4 , the equation for 0(==*(a , ,3 , y ) ) is 0= ( a4X a2 a/ Xx / O x ; x +1 .
41 a 0a --16 a"ce -8 a+d 1 ]- ?
+18 a2d2 +4 abe ++6 ab2c1 a -14 abed s #i +4 ae3 +3 bd i , " 1 5V ; I ; 1 b2e". .
: 5 ~~ 1 t'@I " w &gt; ttlxlS wt : w Ss : ' : stt .
rwa : : rrtt s_ w~ ~+ tt " ' f-X8 &lt; t-* P3w0:\ t sttv &gt; x-t wsw l rg , ,rttl:t fs / s^ , 51 : .
te r/ --Ju ra ? ? ? ? ?
i s. .
sts w.w.X. .
Ma &gt; .w.Xw-mwlrzw^w ... .
sW z:f &gt; e I0 , 1)4 .
For the quintic equation ( a , b , c d , , e , f(v , 1)5=0 ; 9 .
We have 0 =(c ( a , t , , ) , the roots being 0= -(3 , Y , k , e ) , which for s=0 becomes P3yS(P y , ) , o==(Y , , E , , ) , , , -Ys(7 % , , ) ) , 3=~( , a , ) G , , ) , , , , , ?
a( , a , 3 , 7 ) , =0(2 , a , , ) , , , ?
, -4p1(a , p , Y ) , o=2p(a , 1 , y , ) , , , , , ?
( , 5 , 3 , ) .
10 .
The linear equation is cda3+/ Z =0 the quartic equation may be written l4(0-0 , )=0 , for the determination of which see Annex No. 2 .
The two equations are +o'-a6/ Z + .
Ne3 Z+ eMZ --0 N and multiplying these together , the resulting equation is 0 , a12 +0 .
0 +0 .
ad(Me-Z ) +0 ' .
'( No +M)e/ Z +0 .
( N+a'e)e'Z + e3ZVZ=o , -0 .
a+ 0/ z -=0 ; 49. .
where the coefficients have to be completed by the addition of the terms inf .
We have v/ O in the place of eV/ Z , and therefore O in the place of e2Z 11 .
The value of Me-Z is +96-256= -60 + 192= -40+128= +27-144= + 27= + 47-144= + 6= -18+ 80= 18= + 416= + 4= 9+ 27= + 418= + 4= 1+ 4= 1= -160 a3e3 +132 a2bde2 + 88 a2C2e2 -117 a2Cede + 27 a2d4 97 ab2ce2 +6 ab22e + 62 abecde 18 abed3 12 ac4e +4 ac3d + 18 b4e2 14 b3cde +4 63d3 +3 b2c3e 1 b2C2d2 and the terms inf are found to be + 300 a3def --130 a2bcef -120 a2bdf + 40 a2cdf + 28 ab3ef + 66 abScdf 24 abc3f 16 b4df +6 b63f -125 a3cf2 + 50 a2b2f2 12 .
The value of No +M is -16+96= +80 a3e2 + 6-60= -54 a2bde + 4-40= -36 a2c2e +27= +27 a2cd2 5+47= +42 ab2e -18= -18 abc2d + 4= +4 ac4 " r 19= 8 b4e + 4= +4 bcd _ 1= .
1 b2C3 and the terms inf to be added thereto are found to be --50 a3df +30 a2bef 8 ab3f 50 The value of N+a3e is -15 a3e +6 a2bd +4 a2c2 5 ab2c +1 b4 which is a seminvariant , and requires no addition .
14 .
Hence , for the quintic equation ( a , b , c , d , e , f , Jv , 1)5=0 .
the equation for ( -=( , p3 , 7 , ) ) is Oa6 X0 -125 a3cf2 + 300 a3def -160 a3e3 4+ 50 a2b2f2 +132 a2bde2 -130 a2bcef -120 a2bdf + 40 aec2df + 88 a2c2e2 -117 a2cd2e + 27 a2d4 + 28 ablef 97 ab5ce2 +6 ab2d2e + 62 abc2de + 66 abcdf 18 abcd3 24 abc3f 12 ac4e : +4 ac3d 16 b6df + 18 b4e2 -14 b3cde +4 b3d3 +6 6b32f +3 b2c3e 1 be2C2d2 a3^ Ux -50 a3df +-80 a3e2 +30 a2bef -54 a2bde -36 a2c2e + 27 a2cd2 8 ab3 +42 ab2ce -18 abe 'd +4 ac4 8 b4e +4 b3cd 1 b2c3 Ix t- ... ----'h -15 a'e +6 a2bd +4 ( ae2 5 ab2c +1 54 15 .
As a verification of this result , I remark that , taking for the quintic equation v5+v4-+v'3+v2+-v+1=0 , the roots of this equation are -1 , w , c2 , -2 , -2 , where w is an imaginary cube root of unity ( 2+'-+l=O ) .
We ought to have ( a , , 3 , 8 , e ) ---/ = -36 ; and this will be the case if , for instance , ac , 3 , 7 , , S are respectively -1 , o , g2 , -2 , -- .
We have then c(3 , 7 , ,y )=-A.-l2+2.-+l 2- ?
a2- .
2 .
C+Wa .
2w &lt; 2 = 6 , ( 3 , y , , ) , ) , _w-w2 .
W+2 .
2wo .
2O2 .
, a2+W .
--_2+ = -12 , %y , 8 , ?
, a)= 22 .
+w.o2+ .
+}._2+1 _+.-2 2+1._-+l =+6()-_ai ) , t(0 , g , a , 3p)=-2+W.-+1 .
2-+ .
-w+l .
-2w .
-l-= --6(w--U2 ) , t(E , c , , 3 , r)=-k-c+t1.-2wo .
_W_W2 .
-_-L.-_l2 .
, =_-2 6 .
a12 X +1 ( n 1V X +1.g , 1 ) .
The equation in 0 is thus ( 0-6)2(d+12)(d2+108)=0 , or multiplying out it is ( 1 , 0 , 0 , +432 , -11664 , +46656I , 1)4=0 , which in fact ( observing that v/ D=36 ) is what the preceding formula becomes for the equation ( 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 , 1 , X1v , 1)5=0 .
The analogous verifications for the cubic and the quartic equations are as follows ; 16 .
For the cubic , if the assumed equation is v3+v2+v4-+=0 , the roots whereof are - , i , --i ( i2= -1 ) , then we should have ^(ao , 3 , y)= / -D =4i , which will be the case if a , / , ry=-1 , i , -i , respectively , and the roots y3--y , - , a--3 of the equation in 6 then are 2i , -i+1 , -i-1 , so that the equation in 6 is ( 02+2i--2)(0-2i)=0 , or ( 1 , 0o , 2 , 4i ~0 , 1)3=0 , which ( observing that y/ O =4i ) is what the formula for the equation in d becomes for the equation ( 1 , 1 , 1 , lXv , 1)3=0 .
17 .
For the quartic equation , taking this to be v4+v3+v2+v+1=0 , the roots are &amp; , 2 , c3 , 5 , where w is an imaginary fifth root of unity ( '4+W3+c2+c+1= 0 ) , and putting os , , y3 , , equal to w , 2 , , co4 respectively , we have -V/ O=( , j , r , y)= -5(~+Q4-CJ-W3 ) , giving , as it should do , 0 =125 .
The equation in D is therefore by the formula ( 1 , 0 , 0 , -25W+W4_-w2_-3 , 12501 , 1)4=-0 .
But the roots are d1= ( ^P7r , ) ( -2__3)(~2^_4)(W3_-4)= 2+ a2-23= 2 -X 0= -(r(y , s)= _(-_4)(-3_ )(4-_ )= -1+3w+2 2+ 3= --1+Y , == ~(~ , , 3)=(w'-w)(a'-_)(W -w)=-4-3~-s2 ~=-4-Y , 4=--( , ,y )=-( -2)(-_3)(-2_-3 ) 3+ ww2+2= 3+X , if , for shortness , X-~+2 3 , Y=3q+2-a2+-3 .
The equation in d is therefore ( 2+X)(+ 1 -Y)(d+4+Y)(3 -X)=0 , where the left-hand side is the product of the factors ( 0-2+X)(0-3-X)=02-50+6X-X2=-2-5+10-5(w +,4 ) and ( 0+1Y)(0+4+ Y)=+50+ 43Y-Y2=d2+50+10 5(-2+ 3 ) ; and the equation in 0 is , therefore , as it should be , ( 1 , 0 , ,-25w+4_ 2_--- , 1250d , 1)=0 .
Passing from the denumerate to the standard forms ; For the cubic equation ( a , b , c , d3v , 1)3 =0 , the equation for O(==(i3 , y ) ) is 0ax 9x t-270 x(+0+ ac +1 )3 .
-1 62 19 .
For the quartic equation ( a , b , c , d , eXv , 1)4=0 , the equation for -(= ( oa , p , r ) ) is 0= ( a6x 96a2x 512V'n x 256I x+101 a2ce -1 a 'd +1 +3 a2d2 +3 abe +1 ab2e -2 63 -14 abed +9 ac3 -+ 8 b3 6 62e2 0 , 1 ) ' .
20 .
For the quintic equation ( a , b , c , d , e , f v , 1)5=0 , the equation for O(=-(a , / 3 , y ) ) is 0-625 a6x racaef2 + 24 a3def 32 a3e3 +2 ^b2f2 + 264 a2bde2 52 a2bcef 96 a2bd2f + 64 a2c2df + 352 a2e2e2 936 a2cd2e 432 a2d4 + 28 ab3ef 970 ab2ce2 + 120 ab2d2e + 264 ab2cdf + 2480 abe2de -1440 abed3 192 abc3f 960 ac4e + 640 ac3d2 160 b4df + 450 64e2 -1400 b6ede + 800 b3d3 + 120 b3c2f + 600 b2ce 400 62C2d2 12500^ DV ax1 adf +4 a3e2 +3 a2bcf 27 a2bde 36 a2c2e + 54 a2cd2 2 a6f +-105 ab2ce -180 abc2d + 80 ac4 50 b4e + 100 b3cd -50 62C 15625 ox3 a3e +12 a2bd +-16 a2c2 --50 ab2e +25 b4 76125n vnL -+1 +1 21 .
I remark , with respect to the equation in 0 , for the cubic , that it leads at once to the equation of differences .
In fact we have a"23+9(ac-b+)O+/ -27 O =HI{--(c--3 ) } , a2x +1 0( 53 whence changing the sign of 0 , a203+9(ac-b2)d0--27 D-H3{0+(o-- ) } ; or multiplying the two equations and putting u for 02 , u{a1u+9(ac-b2)}2+27 D =-H3{u-(~--I)2 } , that is , the equation of differences is a43-+18(ac--b2)a"2+81(ac--b2)2u+27 El =0 ; but this mode of composition of the equation of differences is peculiar to the case of the cubic .
If in the several equations in d we substitute for the seminvariants the covariants to which they respectively belong , we obtain as follows:22 .
For the cubic equation ( a , b , c , d)v , 1)'=0 , the equation for ( =(-y)( -y ) ) is U ' x 9x V/ -27ox x( +1 0H +-1 23 .
For the quartic equation ( a , b , c , d , e(v , 1)4=0 , the equation for ( -( -~y)(y-_)(S(y)2 ) iis U6 x 96U2x 512 4/ x 256 x+ 3JU + +1l 1)4=0 .
+ 21H 24 .
And for the quintic equation ( a , b , c , d , e , f v , 1)5=0 , the equation for ( = ( y-)( -)( Y X)(yr-)()( -)(y)3 ) is r UT2 , 0O 625U6(A , B , C , D , E , F , Glx , y)O , 12500/ D U3{4U(No .
14)2-U(No .
20)-50(No .
15)(No .
16 ) } , ( 5 , 1)5=0 , 15625 13 { -3U2(No .
14)+25(No .
15)2 } , 76125 EI/ 3 where the covariant which enters into the coefficient of 23 being of the sixth degree in the coefficients , is not given in the Tables .
Its value ( completed for me , from the first term , by Mr. DAvis ) is 54 a32 + 24 eadef 3S a3e3 +2 a2bf 2+ 264 a2de2 52 a2bcef 96 a2bdf + 64 a2df + 352 ac2e2 936 aed2e + 432 ad4 28 ab3ef 970 ab2ce2 + 120 ab2d2e + 264 ab2edf +2480 abe2de 192 abc3f -1440 abed 960 ac4e + 640 ae3d2 160 b4df + 450 b4e2 -1400 b3cde + 120 632f + 800 b3d + 600 b2e3e 400 622d2 + 18 a3df2 48 a3e 66 a2bf2 + 348 aMbdef + 48 a26e3 + 624 a2ceef 936 a2ed2f 576 a2cde2 + 648 a2d3e + 48 abf ?
2 -1596 ab2cef + 210 ab2de2 48 ab2d2f +3504 aBc2df + 720 abcee2 -2160 abc2e -1728 ac4f + 960 ac3de + 720 b4ef -1920 b3edf 450 b3ce2 +1200 b3d2e + 1080 b2ce 600 b ec2de 30 a'ef2 + 210 a2bdf + 60 abe2f + 180 a2cCf2 + 120 a2cdef 480 a2cee -1080 a2df +1080 a2d2e2 840 ab2cf2 540 ab2def + 450 abSe3 + 960 abceef +4560 abed !
f -4200 abede2 -2880 ac3df +2400 ac3e + 480 blf2 600 63bef -2400 b35df +2250 bsde2 + 1800 b2c2df -1500 b62ce2 110 aY3 + 30 a2bef2 + 680 a2cdf2 320 a2cef --1320 ad2ef + 960 a2dcZ 320 abcf2 + 290 ab2e ' -1320 abce +4160 abedef -3200 abcee + 960 abd'f 600 abd2e2 + 960 ae3e -2560 ac"d2 +1600 a2cde2 + 960 be3f2 --3200 63de +2250 b3e3 600 b2c2ef +1600 bcd &amp; f -1000 b6ede2 30 + 210 + 180 840 + 480 + 60 + 120 540 + 960 600 -1080 + 4560 -2400 -2880 + 1800 480 + 450 + 1080 -4200 +2250 + 2400 -1500 a2bf3 a2d'f2 a'de &amp; f a2e4 ab2ef2 abedfI abceef abdSef abdea a , y2 aedef ac2e3 acd3f acd2e b3df2 b3e !
f b2 &amp; -f2 6bedef b2ce 3 b2d3f 62d2e2 62d ' 2s + 18 a2qf3 66 a-def2 + 48 a'ef 48 a/ bfy + 348 abeef2 + 624 abd2f2 + 720 abe4 -1596 abdef2 936 aeCdf2 48 ae2ef +3504 acd2ef -1728 ady -1920 acde3 +1080 ad3e2 + 48 b3ef2 576 'bedf2 + 210 62ce2f + 720 bSdSef 450 b2de3 + 648 c3f 2 -2160 bc'def +1200 bce3 + 960 bed3f 600 bedcc2 2 adf 3+2 aef 2+ 24 at/ t3 52 abdeff + 28 abedf 96 ac"ef2 + 64 acdYf + 264 acde2 160 ace4 192 ad3ef + 120 ad"e3 32 b'f3 + 264 b2ceef ' + 352 b6d2f 2 970 bdeSf + 450 b'e4 I 936 belcdf2 +2480 bedef + 120 bc2eef -1400 bede3 960 bc4f + 600 bdea + 432 e4f2 i-1440 cdef + 800 c3e + 640 c2d3f 400 c2d2e2 In the following two Annexes , the notation of the symmetric functions is te same as in my " Memoir on the Symmetric Functions of the Roots of an Equation* , " and the values of the symmetric functions are taken from that memoir , the powers of a being restored by the principle of homogeneity .
The suffixes of the 2 indicate the number of terms in the sum ; thus in the first Annex 3ry(ry)(ry-a)=),3(pr 2yr-y3+ 2 ) ; the terms 3(pry2+ry2 ) are equal to Z:e2P , the complete symmetric function ; the correct result will be obtained ( though of course neither of these equations is true ) by writing Y -2 = 232 , y2 3s --2a62/ , and so in similar cases ; the insertion of the suffix to the Y very much facilitates the calculation , and is a check on its accuracy .
Annex No. 1 , containing the calculation of the equation II , ( O , )--0 , where =fry(-yr ) , O , =y'(y-C ) ) , os -=(z-3 ) , c , 3 , y being the roots of the cubic equation ( a , b , e , dXv , 1 ) =0 .
We have zr , = 3Py(P-y ) =-( ?
-p )(p -)((y-r =U(Mv 3 y ) = a2 / V-Z ?
where Z=27a2d2+ &amp;c. is the discriminant of the cubic .
23O81=2 3py(y)y &lt; ( yc ) =y3y(f -y)(r1 ) , d where a3y= and 3( -Y)(Y ) = Z3(Py2Yy3+y2 ) = M3 -=( 3)= 3a3d3abc+1 b4 + 62/ 3 + ( 21 ) 43ad-labc -3zaj3y -3(13 ) + 3a2d -= ( 9a2d-4abc+l b3 ) , and therefore , ,= -a ( 9ad24abed +1 b3d ) .
And lastly , 11203 , or 01a0203=2 r ( a_3)( -y)(y ) =-a2p2r2Y(f ) , / , r ) d2 a4 v Z. So that the equation is the one given above , No. 7 .
Annex No. 2 , containing the calculation of the equation 14(0 , )==0 , where 01=/ 3yZW)( , y , 6 ) , 02=-y^z2(y ) ( , a ) , 83=a3( a , a , ) , and 04=-Iy(ac , / 3 , ) , a , p , y , B being the roots of the quartic equation ( a , b , c , d , e(v , 1)4=0 .
401= *24Pr ( P , y , )=-(a-P3)(y)(-S)(-)(0-)(y-t ) _ , ~ 3 , , ) where Z=256a3e3+ &amp;c. is the discriminant of the quartic .
60102 , = =60 , =04 , / , 3 ) X yr(M / 3 , r ) = 262 6(sc-s )(=--)(c- ) X -y(a-3)(r)(3-y ) =y3r6 ( -)02(c -y)(--)( y)(P3 ) , where cA3ys=-- , and -3)(-y)(-s))(--7)(13-a ) = 26c()I222{ 2-3(c+P)(r7+ )+(c2+32)1r+c(4+)2-r s( + 7+ )+ } =:16 a " ( )",1 ViZ .
&gt; 6M ( a-rn2 ( M0izviz .
2(f-3(+f)2( y +1 + ) , viz. + &amp; 78Y , ( -_3)2(a2+32 ) , viz. + 62p2(a-3)2(7 +)2 , viZ.:12 5p3 2:C,6vs~y + !
32 + -3124C3 -2 2,63 a +2 a 16,2/ 3P a ? ?
2:~,121%40y2 2:El2az3P3r2 +2 e112a/ 3 a1 -46e 2 -(3 r2 , ( a-+3)2(o+3))(ry+ ) ' viz. 2a12o2 P+22 +2-a:eIA2P7 -+ / 3ry6(^--/ 3)2y7 , viz. ]2 , j33 -2 64 ~s.5P2y +:24437 +2 2 , ,t31 -2 1l2a 3/ 3y2 e4 +23 , ae -2e,2a3p3 a 12 19 -12 + ae12aP7 e12 --12 a " where for a moment a is put equal to unity .
The value of the last-mentioned expression is then calculated as follows : , _2 e2 -4 -12 88 -8 -8 -12 -8 -4 -12 -12 = -96 bde +1 +16 +10 +10 +2 +12 +2 +4 +3= +60 c2e +8 +8+4 +8 +4 +6 +4 -2 +40 b2ce -9 -8 -11 1 -4 -12 -2 -47 b4e +3 -3 +33=+9 ed2 -7 851 -4 -2 -= -27 b2d2 +3 -4 +12 +2 0bc2d +6 +8 +3 1= +18 b3cd -3 -1 4c -2-2 2=4 b2c2 +1 =+1 And restoring the powers of a by the principle of homogeneity , and putting ( 53 ) -2(42 ) -1(521 ) +1(431 ) +2(422 ) -2(322 ) += 3e(4 ) -2e(31 ) 2e(22 ) + 3e(212 ) -12e2 , [ 57 M= +96 ae2 -60 a2bde -40 a2c2e +27 a2ed2 +47 a62ce -18 abc2d +4 ac4 -9 b4e +4 b3cd 1 b2C3 we have 210A= Me .
Next , 4412O3=N4f3yp7}f , r ) t ) )xry8 ( r , 6 , os ) X ^( , , 3 ) = 24z(3y -rX)(i-3)(r--)x -y(a(r--)(y)(X ( x am(G-c)( -)(c-a ) = )(~-()(a-))(~-)())(r)(4 -(-y)( )= a232(y2t~2( , 3 , y , 9 ) , ~)(~)(~-a ) and observing that ( a , b , c , d , e ; v , 1)4=a(v-_)(V-_)( -7e)(v6 ) and therefore 4av3+bv2+2cv+d=a(v-i)(v-y)(v--)+ &amp;c. , which , putting v=oS , gives 4ac+ 3b2+ 2dc2+ aCd=a(a-))( -y)(-- ) , we have ( ~~3)(y)(oa)=| ( 4a 4+ 3b2a3+2 2a2+ d ) =4(4)+ 3b(3 ) + 2c(2 ) +d(1 ) where for a moment a is put equal to 1 .
This is calculated by e -16 = -16 bd +16 -9 -1 =+6 ' c2 8 -4 == +4 b2c --16 +9 +2 = -b4 : +4 --3 +1 ''* A't ' , / -~i .
t tv --_.~ % .
__ __ .
or restoring the powers of a , and putting -N= 16 a3e +6 a2bd 4+4 a2c2 ; 5 ab62 +1 b4 I I..i we have 14014203 = Ne2Vz .
Lastly , :1E1A2O3O4 or 124MA30 =2P2 , X282V(j3 ( rh b P ) and the equation fl4QJ-4)=O is thus found to be the one given above , No. 10 .

