On the Influence of the Ocean on the Plumb-line in India .
By the Venerable J. H. PRATT , M.A. , Archdeacon of Calcutta .
Communicated by Professor STOKES , Sec. R.S. Received December 7 , 1858 , -Read January 6 , 1859 .
§ 1 .
Preliminary remarks .
1 .
THE present paper is a sequel to two former communications to the Society on the effect of Mountain Attraction on the Plumb-line in India .
In the first of these ( communicated in 1855 ) the deflection of the plumb-line caused by the Mountain Mass north of Hindostan is calculated ; and in the second ( forwarded during the present year ) the effect of a small excess or defect of density prevailing through extensive tracts of the earth 's mass is found ; with a view to determine whether any compensating cause can possibly exist below , to counteract the large amount of deflection caused by the superficial mass lying above the sea-level .
A survey of the causes of disturbance of the plumb-line cannot be complete without taking into consideration the influence of the ocean .
To approximate to this is the object of the present Paper .
2 .
The geographical position of Hindostan is somewhat remarkable .
The highest mountain-ground in the world lies to the north of it ; and an unbroken expanse of ocean extends from its shores down to the neighbourhood of the south pole .
The excess of matter presented by the first causes a deflection of the plumb-line towards the north , decreasing in amount as we travel southwards .
The deficiency of matter arising from the second causes a deflection of the plumb-line also towards the north , but decreasing in amount as we travel northwards .
The consequence is , that while these two causes conspire to increase the deflection at the different stations , their combined action tends to reduce in amount the errors the mountain attraction causes in the amplitudes .
But the attraction of the mountains northwards , and the deficiency of attraction of the ocean southwards , which last is in fact equivalent to a repulsive force northwards , combine to produce another effect upon the measures of the Survey besides the deflection of the plumb-line , an effect of some importance .
They have a sensible influence in changing the sea-level , so as to make the level of Karachi-to which a great longitudinal chain of triangles is brought down from Kalianpur in the centre of India-many feet higher than the level at Punnce , near Cape Comorin , the south extremity of the Great Arc of meridian .
3 .
If the density of the sea were the same as that of the superficial stratum of rock , there would be no disturbing force .
The deficiency of matter arising from the smaller density of the ocean , produces , therefore , a northerly repulsive force exactly equal to the attraction of a mass of the same form in superficial extent and depth , but having a density equal ' to the excess of the 'density of rock over that of sea-water .
5KE2 Hypothesis regarding the form of the bottom of the sea .
4 .
To calculate this force , it is necessary , in our ignorance of the form of the bottom of the sea , to resort to hypothesis .
In doing so it should be remembered , that as we want to find the aggregate effect at certain places comparatively near each other , being all in India , and not to find the law in passing from one point to another over the whole surface of the ocean , an average representation of its form will be quite as good for our purpose as an accurate knowledge of all its variations of depth .
Fig. 1..30 Ilk o*0f 9t 1 11 The hypothesis I assume I will now describe .
Let the preceding diagram ( fig. 1 ) represent an outline of the ocean and bounding countries under consideration .
Let A , B , C ( as in my former Papers ) be Kaliana , Kalianpur , and IDamagida , the three terminal stations of the two higher portions of the Great Arc : P is Punnce , the station close to Cape Comorin .
Draw EPF east and west , meeting Africa in E and the Malay Peninsula in F. I call the depths at the middle points , viz. at a and b , of these lines at the opening of the Arabian Sea and Bay of Bengal into the Indian Ocean , a and b : and I assume that the bottom slopes up gradually from these points in lines due north to m and n , near Karachi and the Sandheads of Calcutta ; and that the bottom shelves down to these lines from every part of the shore .
Thus to find the depth at any point H , we must draw hHk at right angles to am , ; first find the depth at h in terms of a , from the measured ratio of mh to ma ; then find the depth at H in terms of that at h , and so in terms of a , from the measured ratio of Hk to hk .
In this way the depth at all points in the Arabian Sea and the Bay of Bengal may be found in terms of a and b. I next assume that at a point D , 360 south of Cape Comorin and nearly midway between Madagascar and Australia , the depth is D ; and that the bottom slopes down gradually to D from all sides-from the bottom at FP and PE , from the shores on the east and west , and from the neighbourhood of the south pole .
It will soon be seen that any uncertainty regarding the depth down towards the south pole is comparatively unimportant .
From this description it will be seen that the depth along any line PI may be found as follows:-The bottom slopes down to L from both shores : the depth at L is known in terms of a and D from the ratio of aL to LD .
Again , the depths along a line CMNQ are found thus .
The depth at M is found in terms of a from the slope of Pa. From M to N the bottom slopes to a depth which is found in terms of D by the relative distance of N from Madagascar , the nearest shore , and D. By this contrivance the depths of all parts of the ocean under examination can be found in terms of one or more of the arbitrary depths a , b , D : and by rightly choosing these quantities I think we shall have a very good average representation of the volume and general form of the ocean , as far as its effect on the stations in India require a knowledge of it .
The effect of the ocean to the right of the eastern peninsula and archipelago I have omitted , as it would be about the same for all the stations .
§ 3 .
Calculation of the attractions and deflections .
5 .
The method of calculating the attraction is precisely the same as that adopted in my Paper of 1855 for the Mountains .
Thus for the station P. Through P imagine great circles drawn ( not given in the diagram to prevent confusion ) at 30 apart .
These will divide the surface into lunes reaching to the antipodes .
The lines drawn in the diagram are the middle or dividing lines of these lunes , along which the attraction acts .
Around P describe a circle with radius =50 ; and beyond this other circles with the radii noted in the Table in page 782 .
The property of this law of dissection is , that the attractions of the masses of the several compartments into which this process divides the surface , are proportional to their average depths ; or if d , d2 d3 ... be the depths , the attractions of the masses on P are as d d2d3 ... The attraction of each mass* 4= 4osin 15 ?
xdepth .
Now the density of sea water =1-028 X dens .
of distilled water .
Radii of circles .
Radii of circles .
1 ~~~5.0 16 2 1-4 2 5*5 17 23-6 3 6-1 18 26,1 4 617 19 28.8 574 20 318 6 812 1 35'3 7 89 22 38-9 8 9.8 23 43-1 9 10.8 24 48-1 10 11.9 25 53 9]1 1311 26 60-7 12 14-4 27 68.9 13 16-0 28 79 3 14 17 6 29 93-3 15 19*4 30 1 16-7 !
The next is beyond the antipodes .
Also mean density of the earth= 566 times that of distilled water .
Also mean density of the earth g=gravity , r=4000 miles .
The density of Schehallien , which is a 4 , r r ggaiy fair representative of the density of rock at the surface , = 2* 75 X dens .
distilled water ; 6=excess of density of rock above that of sea-water 1-722 madesoferh=3 1722 g. = 5766 mean dens .
of earth =7r 5660 r also sin 150=0.2588 , attraction of mass in any compartment=0'000009079xdepthxg =tan ( 0 " 185 ) depth xg , deflection caused by this =0"-185 depth , as is easily seen by the resolution of forces .
Hence the deflection caused by the whole of any one lune is found by adding together all the depths of the compartments , and multiplying the sum by the cosine and sine of the azimuth , reckoned from the south to the left , to find the North and East force produced by the deficiency of matter in the ocean .
These added together for all the lunes will give the total effect of the portions of the surface beyond the first circle .
6 .
In parts where the compartments are broken into by the shores , or the lunes must be narrowed in consequence of the land , I introduce the correction by reducing the depths in proportion , and leaving the constant multiplier 0"-185 unchanged .
Thus too in the third lune to the west , the middle line lies along the shore , and therefore half the lune is on land , and the depth along the middle line , being zero all along , does not represent the average depth of the compartments .
I therefore take the depths along the middle line of the half lune , that is , along a line making an angle 7§ 30 ' with the shore ; and besides this I take half only of the result , as the width of the lune is diminished in that ratio .
Again , the most important lune , that which has its middle line due south , needs consideration .
The middle line lies at the greatest depth in all the compartments .
The depths of the middle of the compartments will therefore be all larger than the average depth of the compartments .
The average depth of the compartment in the latitude of D , it is easily seen , is about 6 D. This , therefore , I shall adopt as the depth at D for all lunes which have their middle line in APD .
7 .
I have not yet considered the portion within the first circle .
It is easy to show by the Integral Calculus , that the attraction of a small horizontal pyramid , of depth d at its vertical base , =-U .
d , irrespectively of its length , d being the width .
Hence , by integration , 2 ?
sin 150 .
d is the attraction for the whole width of the lune .
And the consequent deflection caused by this portion of the ocean =2 Asin 15 ? .
d= 0I-.185 X2 d. Hence the deflection caused by the whole lune =0".185 ( 2 d+dl+d2+d3+ .
8 .
We are now prepared to enter into Tables the deflections caused by the several lunes .
The process I follow is partly graphic .
I take a strip of paper and mark it , to be used as a scale .
After the zero-point the first mark is at 5 ?
distance , this being the radius of the first circle about P bounding the compartments .
The distances of the remaining circles , as noted in the Table in page 782 , are next marked on the scale .
It will be observed that the distances of the circles from each other are at first very small , but they afterward rapidly increase , and the 29th compartment terminates at 116 ?
from P , and the next stretches beyond the antipodes .
The rapid increase of the dimensions of the compartments in the southern ocean renders it unimportant to know the depths of those regions with any degree of accuracy , as I have already noticed .
The scale thus formed is laid upon the diagram ( fig. 1 ) , along the middle lines of the several lunes , the zero-point being at P. The values of d d , d2 d3 ... are then , without much difficulty , determined from the diagram for P , and similarly for other stations , as noted down in the six Tables which follow .
The deflections are resolved north and east .
Of the six stations I have chosen ( for reasons which will appear ) , one has no name , as there is no known-place there .
I therefore call it " Near-Goa .
" It is half-way between Punnce and Karachi .
TABLEL1-IDeflections at Kaliana .
First Lune .
Second Lune .
Depths .
Central Lune .
East .
West .
East .
West .
d0000 ___ 21000 d ... ... ... ... ... ... . .
2 ... ... ... ... .4 ... .
d(1.7 ... ... ... ... ... ... d(1 ... ..9 ... ... ... ..o..to ... ... ..o.to~ ~~~~~~~~~1 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~3from 0btooIb from 0ato0a d~l ... ... .
Fve romNine depths =0 =3a d~~9 Nine depths from 2b to *D Seven depthseths Si ~~2o from 0 to ~~~~~~.D ( =3b+9 D ) frommb ao tor ... toD ( d.7D)(=63aD d17 d __N _ no _depths Threebto from ... ... . .
d(19 fo t See depth ( .4vn5ets ... ... ... frm20 t from a to D orfo ( 125 ( =2.357D ) ( ... ..D ... .to. .
'21 ~~~~~~(=.45D ) Totas ... ... ..D ?
.67b ... +4 ... ... .~9 Sum 1"15D 0"2 +0"8 D+ 0to a1 0"D ?
" 1 De5N 1"15 " 4 +0~4b " 7 " ~ +0'0 Sin azim .
pth 0evendepth *8656 from. .
AD to04 Four3b0"4 aro ... ... + ... 1 Totals 6-Total 6 efecio at alina Nort , Di"60 a+ " 6 +0 aa Diff ... .
Total Deflection at Kaiana East Of-8 a"0 D3-b"466 +0 ' 1aa Deflections at Kalianpur .
Depths .
Ceiltral L~~ine .
First Lune .
-Second Lune .
Third~ Lume .
East .
West .
East .
West .
East .
West .
d0~ ~~~~ i000000000000 Eight Tn d 6 ... ... ~ ~~~~~depths ... d ~~~~~~ ~ ~~~~~frtoiu depths , ... ... d~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~27 0 to 10a ... .omro d ~~~~~~~ ~Eight depths Eight depths ( =1.1 b)ji I4 ro d9 ~~~~~~~from 0 to Ab from 017a 229t~i ... 0 to A~a dc ... .
( =-3 ' =-52 a ) Six ... d12 ~~~~~~~~~depths ... ... 4 from d13 ~~~~~~~~~~~from 2 , to 0 d14 b~~~~~~~~~~~$to 0 Nine ... ... ) dl( ; Twelve ~~~~~~( = ' 89 b ) depths ... d17 depths fro ~Nine depths Nine de~pths atom ... ... .
d17 depths from LOL a to ... ... ... ..~7 5 d18 0o ~-D rom -~b to D from L--a , tob ... . .
'I 5 18 ( =6D ( =3-85 b+ P29 D)(=2'83a+0-81D ) ... =-5 ) ... ... .
d20 ... ... ... .
d21 ... ... ... .
d25 , Seven Eight depths Eight de pths ... ... .
d2 ; depths from , from 2D to 0 from aI ) to 0 ... ... ... .
d27 1Dto ... O ... ... ... dq t ( =1.14 D ) ( =-75 D ) ( =2.921D ) ) ... ... ... ... 'rotals ... .
7.929 1 ) 0.43 D 1-56 D 2-08 b 5-59 a4+ 7.2 8 5-35 a DefleetiOns1 1"47 1 ) 0V'45 I ) 0"29 D 0"I-38 b I1"f03 az 0 0f'.09 a ff + ?
0'799aC Sums ... .
" 1147 D 0".f74 D I)+'I35 b+ 00.99 a 0.'38 b+ 1"'03 a 0"-09 a Cos azim .
1 -866.500 0 Def. N ... 1 ?
f.47 D 0"1-64 D ?
O , " 90 b +o"-87 a 00.-19 b ?
O"1181 a0 Diff ... . .
0 -0'-i6 DI)f-135 b ?
0"'99a( V-038 b ?
1"-03 a 0".09 a Sin azimn .
0.3(j)( ~866 Def. E ... 0 V-008 1)- .
0 '-67 b ?
+0 ' !
-50 a -0'1-33 b ?
0'8s9 a 0"09 a Total Deflection at Kalianpur , Noi~ik , 211-17 D+ 1lf-09 b+ 1"1-68 a. Total Deflection at Kalianp-ur , East , -0"'f08 D -1I"f0 b+ 1"1-48 a. Deflections at Damiargida .
Depths .
Central Lune .
First Lune .
Second Lune .
Third Lune .
Four-th Lune .
East .
West .
East .
West .
East .
WVVest .
East .
West , d000000000 J~Id 000000000 d , ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ~Eight d2 Nine ... . .
depths Ten .
leve d 3 ... ... ... ... ... Ndepts Eee from Te ... .
E un d ... ... ... Seven depths death Elve S todepths depths d ... ... ... fr ... ... from depths 271b from ... .
from 13m to to Afrom -ll'0 to 0oyd7 ____ = 2a 1-17b)t - , a(=2.14a ) ... .
-.33 c ) d8 ~~~~~~~~~~(=4-85a ) ... d9 4 from ... djo 8 ~~~~~~~~~b to 0 d~~~~~~~l ~~Sen(=0.59b ) 4 from ... .
3 froui d12 Sewn.3 ~~~~~~~~~~~a to 0 ... . .
-atoO0 d13 ~~ Ffte depths fo ( = 0085a ) ( =.09 a ) Fifteen deThs rteen detl ro Ten ... ... .
14 e pth fomfrom Ihir epis d detsfo oiDfrom Aa to -D 7T1to0depths dO to 5D 8 ( 3a -3 fr omn 17 ( =6.265D ( =25 ) a1D ) ) ( 0 , b 1a toO0 ... ... ... ... ... dj9 ... ... ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ : ... ... ... d24 N in ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ~25 Eight depths Nine depths d26 depths from from from " D to 0 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 32 d27 AD to0 Dto 01-(=.27 D ) ... ... ... ... ... ... ... d 28 ( =3.33 D ) ( 1.S D ) 29 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... d,30 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... Totals..9-58 D4D 3-1 D 2-08 b.9-26 a 1-7 b 9.9 9 ( 1 0 0-42 a ?
4-62 az Deflect " " 1 " 17 D 0"`74 D 0`57 D 0.'I38 b 1`~71 a 0-3l1 ' 0"off56 ta 0 0"-08 at + 0-85 a sums ... 1"-77 D1 " -31 D+ 0"'85a 0"-38 b+ 1 " 71 a 0 ; " 131 b +0"'-56 a 0"_08 a Cos azim .
1 -866 *500 0 50 Def. N ... .
1 " '77 D Il"13 D+ 074 a 0"',1 9b +0'f85 a0 004t Duff ... .
0 -0"lfI7 D ?
+0 'I85 a G"'I38 b41."71 a -0"1-31 b +0"lf56 a 0".08 a1 Sin azim .
0.50( ) -866 1 -866 jDef'.E ... .
0 -0"ff08 D+ 0A-2a -0"'-331b+1I'"48 a 0"'-31 b +0 ' !
.56 a 0'1-06 Total Deflection at Damarg ida , North , 2'1-90 D+ 0 ' !
-19 b+1 " '55 a. Total Deflection at Darnargidta , Eatst , V-008 D -0"-64 b+ 2'52 a. IV.-Deflections at Punnce .
First Lune .
Second Lune .
Third Lune .
Fourth Lune .
Fifth Lune .
Depts .
entrl Lne .
East .
West .
East .
West .
East .
West .
East .
West .
East .
West .
d1 Df D 2D -L D +J I)D+ I8a 46 ba -~L b A1a 2 ~d 1-25 D 0-87 D 0-98 D 072 D 0-76 D 52.256 3-89 a 2-43 b2a 0-37 b 0-26 a+ 4'53 b+ 3-62 a d1 Seven from d1 2 D+L-lb Ten depths Eight Six from ( 3 to from depths Ten Nin jibto 1b Ten ( 4 - : " , D ?
4I D+b A from depths depths Twelve ( ='27b ) depths ( 13 ( =.~~~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~72 D to b6to b from bobdepths f~rom -4-ua d7 + 4'53b ) ~TID +-L9a ( =6 b ) 10a to a iW Wi _ from to gLa d 8i=127 D =6-85a)(3 -I6 a ato 4a 4 from ( = '48a ) d wet Nineteen Nineteen + 5'73a , ) ( =4-57a ) ( =O'tob ) 9 dethsfo depths from depths from Sixfro0______ 4bro di dpts r0'D1 D to'I D3D to -LD 6i trom 4b troO d -45yD to 5-DT32 1 6bto0 ... 11 6 ~(5.54 D).5-05 D ) t4 from d3 ( =9-52 D)(3b9 ... 12 ~~~~~~~~~~~Fifteen ( 6 ) Eight ( =1lI16 ) 3-ro- , a to 1.3 ~~~~~~~depths from depths ( =0.1I4a ) d '~~~~~~3 D+ 1 ... 6at1 Twelve _ _from ... to ... _ d13 to 0 depths from ... .
a to 0 08a d16 ~~~~~~ ( 1'0.2.D , D + 1ika ... .
( 4a ) ... ... ... ... . .
d17 + ~~~~~~6.486b ) toO0 ... ... ... ... ... dis ~~~~~~(=2D+9a ) ... ... _ 21 ( 123 Eleven Eleven d4 Ten depths depths from depths from ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... .
d5 from 'Dto 0 3-D toO0 ... ... ... ... ... ... . .
~27 ( -1D ( 2175D ) ( ='2A41 D ) ... . .
27 Totals ... 15-54 D 9-16 D 8-44 D 2-46 D 4-03 D 14-25 b 14-74 a 7-08 b 7-43 a 0756 O 088 a § 1554b + 14-73 a Deflect~s ~2"f81 D 1"1-69 D i"-56 D O'-46 D 0"'75 D 2V'64 6 2"173 a 1"131 61 " -37 a O"-1 46 O"1-16 a+ 2-87b 2-73 a Sums ... 2 '81 D 3"25 D 1"121 D+2"'87b+21"-73a 2'64 b6+2"13 a 1"1131 6+1 " 37 a O"14 b ?
" 016 -ia Cos azim .
1 o-866 0.500 0 -O-5OO -0-866 Def. N ... .
2'.s81 D 2"1-81 D O"'60D+1ff-43b+1"1-36a 0 -O"-6,5bO'l-68a -Of"12b-O"Kl13a Duff ... .
0 -O"'1-3 D 0"-29 D-2"87b+2"`73a -2'164 6+ 2`t13 a -I1"-31b6 ?
1'fh37a -O0".l4b+Oihl6 a Sin azim .
0 O'500 o0866 1 0-866 O*500 Def. E ... 0 0"406 D O"f-25 D 2"A9b + 2 " 36a V-64 6+ 2"73 a -I1"'1136b+1"119 a -O"f-O7b6+O"-O8a Total Deflection at Punn~ce , North , = 6'22 D+ o"l66 6+ G'-55 a. Total Deflection at Punnce , East , -O-1 9D -6"ff33 b +6"-36 a. V.-Deflections at Near-Goa .
First Lume .
Second Lune .
Third Lune .
Fourth Lune .
Fifth Lune .
liejtbsCentral L one .
_________________________________ East .
West .
East .
West .
East .
Wet Es .
West .
East .
West .
d5a 1a a0 5k 0 -3a 0 10 Aa 742 49 21 ~d 3-09 a 0-25 a 3-o6 a0 4-38 a0 I3-E8 a0 1-17 a0 o-26Ga d SiISve2 Seven ... .
Six ... .
Five ... ... .
Five d etsfo depths ... .
depths ... .
from ... .
Seven ... .
from d 5at 't 1a from ... .
from -12 a ... .
5a ... .
depths ... .
aa to !
A aa2 ~~~~~~~~~~~1 640 IT7 19 3-a toa to1 4 =-245a ) to -nT8_ 11 ... .
4o 2a ... o a ... from ... .
to 20a~ d6 ( -.~~~~~21a to a ... . .
3'5a ) ... .
( =3.59a ) ... .
a to 1a ... .
=1ai d -26 a ) ~(=4-08a ) ... ..( ... 1-0.9a ) ... d ... ... ... .
4 from d , ~~~~~~Eight Sevei 210.a.to d9 ~~~~~~depths Fie depths Five ... ... ( -1 a ) dio ~~~~~~~from romv0 from ... .
Fivo ... ( -Ia II ~~Fifteen Tite 0tob Furteen to b-6 a to 01o I ' d 12 ~~h depths ( =46 ) dephs 29 6 ) ... . .
5 a). .
d Sixteen depths from from ( =9 ) =5a ) ... d depths from from are n ... ... . .
14 0.a to 5D Ta to9 ia to 0 ~15 ( =6'67D to 'I ) D depthsa ) de 2 -50 r t--b to 0 ... ... ... ... ... d17 +474 a ) ( -.36 a ( =_0 2fo =52a 37ro dIg 37D +,93D ) 6 to 0 ( =.44b ) ... ... ... d fo frmI. .
d24 ... ... ... .o. .
, ... Toas25 1 '7 ~4D 7 3~3 ~8 ~ ... ... 0 ... ... . .
Sus..1 " D to 0 3D to S0 ~0 +"4 " 266 " 5 0~7a01 +1~~90a 118D +2~~~~~.4 ... ... ... ... ... ... .
0 ... ... ... ... ... ... 9 Duff.s 0D -05 &lt; 6 i4 ?
D.73 -"3b+21'313a 1 -382b+8"629 a 0"2576a 0 " i5a Sin0azim .
+0 5(86 a866 '86 19a DeflEct- .
0f-8 Di-06~3 D+0"f-0 a 1"'1-3 b+2"'104 a 00"'266+ 1"'59 a0 0A-57a 0 V'15a T -0 otial Defecio at erGa ot , =3~3D+0~56+5'2a Sums I ~r,5 D Total Deflection at Near-30 oa .
, ,4 East o-".2 38+ Df-5 9a +411.9 a.011 rLrB LJ VI.-Deflections at Karachi .
First Lune .
Second Lune .
Depths .
Central Lune. .
East .
West .
East .
West .
d 2 , a _a 100 __ _ 88 1 , 0 0a d2 } 3a 0'12a 105 a00 d2 Seven ... . .
d depths from ... ... d4+ I -tW cz to O ... ... ... ... .
d Thirteen ( 35 a ) ... ... ... d depths from Fften ... ... ... ... . .
ds 2v a to ... ... .
}ie ... ... d7 7atoa depths from 8 8(= 36 a ) Ia to 1a .
| ... ... djo(= 77a ... ... ... ... ... ... . .
d , I ... ... ... ... ... ... . .
d12 ... ... ... . .
I d13 ... ... ... ..I d14Sxfrt i ... ... ... .| ... ' de8 lie V tO ?
fr~~~~M 2D to 0 ~~ ... ... ... ... ... .
d15 Five_ Dive d30 ... ... ... ... froi0tob ... ... d1 .
__ ... ... . .
_ ... ... .
d17 ~~E leven ( -5b dota8 ... ... D1-8 z 3 ?
5D 13 14 17 d depths from Nine b djg a to a6D depths from +2 from 32 b0 51 284D ) at -1 D 2fo~b d2l ( I5 ?
a ?
6.D ) ... .b d2 ( =~~~~~41 a+ 2.25 D ) 23 ... ... ... ... ... d27 ~J Dto 0 fromkID to 0 ... ... .
( d1.75 D ) ( 1.5 D ) Totals .
8#17D+16'86tt 3-75 D+ 130a 1-40 a 1'75 b0 Deflectns 1 11-i1 D +3"1f-2 a 0"f-69 D +0"ft24 a 00.-26 a 0"'-32 b0 Sums ... .
1'151 D+ 3'12 a 0o 69 D ?
0,50 a 0"*32 b Cos azim .
1 *866 -500 Def. N ... .
1 " 51 D+3 , " 12 a 0"1 60 D+0 " 43a 0o16 b Difl ... .
0 -O'f69 D+ 0O)02 a 0o32 b Sin azim .
0 -500 -866 Def. E ... .
0 -0"1 35 D-0 " 01 a -O V.28 b Total Deflection at Karachi , North , 2".111 D+0O"1i6 b+3"-55 a. Total Deflection at Karachi , East , -0^'f35 D-Oth28 b-Ol-01 a. The results gathered from these Tables areNorthl .
East .
1)eflection at Kaliana. .
160 D+0 ?
76 b+0 80 a , -0 04 D-0 46 b+0'56 a. Deflection at Kalianpur .
2 17 D+1 09 b+P168 a , -0 08 D--100 b+P148 a. Deflection at Damargida .
2 90 D+0K19 b+1P55 a , -008 D-0 64 b+2 52 a. Deflection at Punnce. .
6-22 D+0-66 b+0 55 a 0:19 D-6-33 b+6 ?
36 a. Deflection at Near-Goa .
3 03 D+ 0'65 b+5 22 a , -0-38 D-1'39 b+4-98 a. I1)eflection at Karachi. .
2-11 D+0 16 b+3 55 a , -0 35 D-0 28 b-0 01 a. 'When the values of D , a , and b are known , these formulae will give the deflections .
There have been no deep-sea soundings in the Indian or Southern Oceans. .
Thec results , therefore , at which I arrive in what follows must be looked upon as demonstrating that the effect of the ocean on the plumb-line is of importance , rather than as determiining its amount .
10 .
The widths of the openings of the Arabian Sea and Bay of Bengal are as 4 to 3 .
11n this ratio I shall take a to b. Also DI shall suppose 3 times a , and therefore 4 times b. The formula then becomeAt 2i At Kalianap .
deflection North 2306 D , deflection East 0103 P. At Kalianpur .
deflectionl : North 3 00 D , deflection East 0-16 D. At Damargida .
deflection North 347 D , deflection East 0 60 D. At Punnce. .
deflection North 6-57 D , deflection East 0)73 D. At Near-Goa .
deflection North 4 93 D , deflection East 093 D. At Karachi .
deflection North 3.33 D , deflection iEast-042 P. 1i .
It appears front the chart of the North Atlantic in Lieut. MAURY'S interestincworn on the ' Physical Geography of the Sea , ' that between North Africa and the West India Islands-a width about three-fourths of that of the Indian Ocean , where I have placed the depth D-many depths have been measured between 3 and 4 miles .
If .
then , we make D=3 , which will hardly be too much , the formula becomeAt Kaliana. .
deflection North 6'18 , deflection East 0 09 .
At Kalianpur .
deflection North 9 00 , deflection East 0 48 .
At Damargida .
deflection North 10 44 , deflection East 1 80 .
At Punnec. .
deflection North 19 71 , deflection East 2-19 .
At Near-Goa .
deflection North 13 83 , deflection East 2e79 .
At Karachi. .
deflection North 9 99 , deflection West 1 26 .
These at any rate serve to show that no calculations of the Figure of the Earth derived from the measurement of arcs in India can safely be depended upon , for great exactness , if the effect of the ocean is neglected .
The effect of the Ocean on the Ellipticity of the Great Arc of Meridian in India .
12 .
The results in the last paragraph increase the amplitudes of the two arcs Kaliana -Kalianpur and Kalianpur-Damargida by the quantities 2 " 82 and 1"44 .
In former communications I have shown that the effect of mountain attraction is to decrease these amplitudes by 14"'896 and 5"257 .
The effect , then , of the ocean is to reduce these to 12 " 88 and 4"12 .
In my Paper of 1855 I obtain the following formula for calculating the effect of errors in amplitude on the ellipticity .
If 15"'885(1-u ) and 5"f059(1-v ) be corrections to be added to the astronomical amplitudes of these two northern portions of the arc , then the ellipticity of the arc =0 0023464-0 0003693u0-001046v .
Put , therefore , 15-885(1-ut)=12 88 and 5-059(1 v)=4 12 ; u=0*18918 and v=0 18S561 and ellipticity= 0003614=276.7 This is nearer to the mean value of the ellipticity than the hypothesis of deficiency of matter below will make it , if the deficiency extend no deeper than 300 miles below the surface ( see my last Paper ) .
The allowance , therefore , for the effect of the ocean brings back the curvature of the Indian Arc , as deduced by the comparison of the computed and observed amplitudes ( the latter being corrected for the effect of mountain and ocean attraction ) , more nearly to the mean curvature , and thus far acts in the right direction .
I may also observe , that the increase of amplitude between Damargida and Pumnce deduced from the last paragraph , taken in combination with the decrease which the mountains produce ( as far as we can infer this latter amount by supposing the law of attraction between A and C to extend to P ) , is not very different from the error which Colonel EVEREST deduced ( p. clxxvii of his volume of 1847 ) for that portion of the are .
13 .
The effect of the mountain and ocean attractions is shown in the accompanying diagram ( fig. 2 ) .
SDPmN is the meridian line in the longitude of Cape Comorin or Punnce ( P ) , on the supposition that the ocean is of the same density as superficial rock , and that the mountain mass is all removed .
D is 36 ?
from P , and Dd = the depth which measures the deficiency of matter arising from the inferior density of sea-water -about 1-878 miles .
From d the curves dP and dS slope up to Punnc and the neighbourhood of the south pole , so as to make the change of depth vary in arithmetical progression .
The curve dP produced through P reaches a height at M ( 25 ?
from P , and where the axis of the Himmalayas crosses the meridian ) = Mm=1-878 x 25 .
36 =1X3 mile .
The average height of the whole mountain mass ( in the Enclosed Space ) is only about one mile ; also the greatest height between Punnce and the beginning of the Himmalayas , which is about half-way , does not exceed half a mile ; and about Kaliana it is only onefifth of a mile .
Hence the curve PAM decidedly lies above the general curve of Asia from Punnce towards the north pole ; and the curvature of the actual meridian line is greater than the average curvature .
This is the result to which the ellipticity deduced in the last paragraph has also brought us .
Thus while the effect of mountain attraction alone ( as the diagram shows , and my former calculations have shown ) would bring Fig. 2 .
-:- : - &lt; 1 / X~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~i / , did AA out a curvature flatter than the uea n , when the effect of the ocean is also considered , the curve deduced is more convex ; and , as the calculation of the last paragraph shows , is nearer the mean .
The Figure of the Earth is , however , more distorted from the mean than if one only of these causes acted .
For althoug h the curvature of the portion of the meridian under consideration is not so much affected , the poiton of this portion has , so to say , a tilt northwards and a slope southwards , so as to break the continuity of mthe ellipse ; and at all the stations of the arc in India the plumb-line hangs more , northerly from the operation of both the mountains and the ocean , than if one of these~ , causes only existed .
§ 5 .
Changye of the &amp; ea-level produced b~y the ]Jountains and the Ocean .
14 .
Both the positive attraction of the mountains and the deficiency of attraction of the ocean have the effect of raising the sea-level at Karachi , near the mouths of the Indus in latitude 250 , above that at Cape Comorin .
If the difference of level 'is at all sensible , 'it 'is impoitant to calculate it , as the Great Surveyv has brought down two of its chains of triangles to these two places on the coast .
In order to estimate the effect of these disturbing forces upon the sea-level , it is necessary to find their value along some line joining the two places , and to , substitute them in the equation of fluid equilibrium .
The line I choose is the straight line joining Cape Comoriand Krachi , which uns about 300west ofnorth I he of the ocean on the point half-way , which I have called " Near-Goa , " as well as upon Punne and Karachi , the two extremities , with a view to obtain the approximate law of the force along this line .
The formulae of par .
9 show that the chief part of the effect arises from the portions of the sea which depend on D , down in the south at a considerable distance from Hindostan .
The law , therefore , along the above line may be obtained approximately by assuming a formula in powers of A , or the difference of latitude of any point on the line and Punuce .
The value of this difference is 80.5 at " 1 Near-Goa , " and 17 ?
at Karachi .
The east and west parts of the force I neglect , as not modifying the force northwards at all materially .
In this way I obtainDeflection =19 " 7101585x+0 " 00084x2 .
This , as may be seen by substitution , gives the deflections of par .
11 at the three stations , Punnce , Near-Goa , and Karachi .
It is easily seen , by the resolution of forces , that the ratio of the force producing this deflection to gravity equals the tangent of this deflection .
Hence , calling the force W , =0'000095556839-0'000002836162 ?
+0*000000004072x2 , x being expressed in degrees and parts of a degree .
15 .
We shall soon require the integral of this force multiplied by the element of its direction , taken between X= 0 and -=17 .
I will therefore calculate it at once .
fW dx=0'000095556839A-0 000001418081x2+ 0 000000001357W ' =0-0012215 in parts of a degree =448-25 feet .
This , it will be soon seen , is the rise of the sea-level at Karachi above that at Cape Comorin in consequence of the deficiency of attraction of the ocean , on the hypothesis as to depths which I have assumed .
16 .
I will now consider the force arising from mountain attraction .
It has been proved ( in my Paper of 1855 ) that the Himmalayan Mass attracts points between A and C ( in the diagram , fig. 1 .
) as if it were a dense prism of great length and small transverse dimensions running about W.N.W and E.S.E. , and cutting the meridian of the Great Arc at about 3§ 30 ' north of Kaliana .
The law of attraction for places between Kaliana and Damargida varies as the distance from this line inversely .
For distances from this line greater than Damargida this law needs modification , for the following reason .
A prism attracts a point opposite its middle with a force varying inversely as the product of the distances of the point from the middle and from either of the extremities .
Hence when the point is not far from the prism in comparison with the prism 's length , the force will vary nearly as the inverse distance ; but when at a considerable distance , it will vary more nearly as the inverse square .
The point where the line joining Punnce and Karachi cuts the 200 parallel of longitude is about equally distant with Damargida from the above fixed line ( or axis ) of the Himmalayas .
I shall therefore take the deflection there to be the same as at Damargida , MD/ ccI x. 5 M viz. 6 " 8 sec 22§ 30 ' or 7 " 36 , 6"S being the meridian deflection at that station Above this point , up to Karachi I shall suppose the deflection to vary as the inverse distance , and below it down to Punnce as the inverse square .
This will give results rather under , than over the mark ; for it makes the deflections at Punneo and Karachi only 2"'65 and 9"i-15 , as will be seen below .
Let b and n be the distances from the fixed line of Damargida and of any point on the line between Punnce and Karachi , of which , is the number of degrees of latitude above Punnel ; 6= arcl5 ?
cos22§ 30 ' , n= arc 250 cos 22§ 30'X sec 3O0 ?
sin 370 30 ' .
Hence from Punnce to the 20 ' latitude , the deflection ( tt 36 t 15 cos 220 301 26 25 cos 22§ 301-AX sec 300 sin 370 301 ) ( 32'860x)6 .
At Punuce this =2"'65 .
Calling M , the force producing this deflection , Ml tan 2860 " 60 0138666 g ( 3 26-X)2 ( 32 ' 86-X)2 ' 17 .
Also since dm=-do.sec 30 ?
sin 370 31'=-0-702937d ?
Sl dm=0-00 ?
97473{2 86-286 } ?
0001706 the limits of ?
being 0 and 12 .
This is in parts of a degree : in feet it =15-88 .
This , it will be seen , is the rise of the point between Punnce and Karachi above Punnce in consequence of mountain attraction .
18 .
From the point in latitude 20 ?
up to Karachi , the deflection l5 cos 220 30 ' 145"1.1 25 cos 220 30'-A see 30 ?
sin 370 30 32-86- ? .
At Karachi this = 9"15 .
The force producing the deflection being called M2 , M2 tan 145"'1 0(00070298 g 32-86-X 32X86-X rM 0'00049415 20'86 19 .
Also JL~g2 dqb=4d5 log 5.86 =0 0001355 in parts of a degree =50@44feet .
This is the rise of the sea-level at Karachi above the point in latitude 200 , in consequence of mountain attraction .
This , as well as the similar statements in pars .
15 and 17 , I now proceed to prove .
20 .
The equation to the surface of a fluid mass acted on by forces XYZ at the point XYZ is , constant =fiXdx+Ydy+ Zdz ) .
In the case of the ocean the forces are the centrifugal force , the attraction of the general 7 % mass of the earth , and these three disturbing forces W , M , and M2 which I have been calculating .
Let w be the angular velocity of the earth round its axis , O the latitude of any point of the surface , r its distance from the earth 's centre , a the semni-axis major-of the m ean meridian .
Then cw .
and '2 .
y is the centrifugal force parallel to x and y , z being the earth 's axis , and ld2a2 cos ' 0 is the corresponding part of the above equation .
Let V be the potential for the earth 's mass , supposed a perfect spheroid of equilibrium differing little from a sphere ; E the earth 's mass .
Then V differs from only by a small variable quantity depending upon the ellipticity : let it equal E(+ U ) .
Substituting these and the three disturbing forces , the equation of the surface now becomes const ( 1+U)+ Cd2 a2 cos2 d+SWdX-fM du-fM2du between the several limits , as already explained , or const =r ( 1+U)+I2 a2 cos2 4+L.g ; const =( +U+ wLa2aosQ ) Lg But 1= ( I-g sin2 K)-r(1- ?
+s cos2 0 ) is the equation to the surface , s being the ellipticity , when there is no disturbing force .
Hence the equation in the present case is 1 =a(I sin2 I ) +L .
ag ; r E~~~~ r a(1ssin26)+L , asg-a Let 4 be the angle through which the normal to the surface is thrown backwards .
Now the tangent of the angle between r and the normal l dr IldL =s = sin 2d+ a91 dL a TO and ds-rdO=ado being an element of the arc of the surface , the Elevation of the surface of the sea in passing northwards =-,9ds= L , between the limits X= 0 and X=17 .
Hence by adding together the values deduced in pars .
15 , 17 , 19 to obtain L , we have Elevation of sea-level at Karachi above that of Cape Comorin =448 25+15-88+50 44=514 57 feet .
This will alter all heights which depend upon Karachi , but is not of sufficient importance to affect the horizontal measures of the Survey .
21 .
This calculation shows , perhaps , the greatest extent to which the sea-level along our shores can be affected , as there is no part of the world where the disturbing causes can-be more influential .
Had these lateral forces been capable of drawing up the sea more , and changing the level from the mean more entirely , we should have no means of detecting large protuberances or extensive hollows , that is large departures from the spheroidal form either in excess or defect .
The sea is our only standard of measurement , to which the form can be referred ; and were these local departures from the mean figure capable of drawing the sea-level to a greater conformity with themselves , than the above calculation shows they are able to do , we might despair of ever obtaining an accurate knowledge of the form of the several parts of the.surface , however much they differed from the spheroid .
This problem , as it is , is sufficiently beset with difficulties .
It is therefore satisfactory that this is not added to their number .
Calcutta , October 25 , 1858 .

