On the Conic of Pive-pointic Contact at any point of a Plane Curve .
By A. CAYLEY , Esq. , FER .
S Received March 1 , -Read March 24 , 1859 .
TfHE tangent is a line passing through two consecutive points of a plane curve , and we may in like manner consider the conic which passes through five consecutive points of a plane curve ; and as there are certain singular points , viz. the points of inflexion , where three consecutive points of the curve lie in a line , so there are singular points where six consecutive points of the curve lie in a conic .
In the particular case where the given curve is a cubic , the last-mentioned species of singular points have been considered by PLOCKER and STEINER , and in the same particular case , the theory of the conic of five-pointic contact has recently been established by Mr. SALMON .
But the general case , where the curve is of any order whatever , has not , so far as I am aware , been hitherto considered ; the establishment of this theory is the object of the present memoir .
1 .
Investigation of the E !
quation of the Conic of Five-potic Contact .
1 .
I take ( X , Y , Z ) as current coordinates , and I represent the equation of the given curve by T=(*)tX , Y , Z ) =O .
Let ( x , y , z ) be the coordinates of a given point on the curve , and let U-(*3Xx , y , Z1 , Y be what T becomes when ( x , y , z ) are written in the place of ( X , Y , Z ) ; we have therefore U=O as a condition satisfied by the coordinates of the point in question .
2 .
Write for shortness DU-(X36 , +YbY+Z6Z)Uj D2U=(X3bt+Y6Y+ZbZ)2Uj and let 11=aX+bY+cZ=O be the equation of a line .
It is easy to see that D2U-1l.DU= 0 will be the equation of a conic having an ordinary ( two-pointic ) contact with the curve at the point ( x , y , z ) .
In fact the equation DU= 0 is that of the tangent at the point in , question , and the equation D2U 0 is that of the penultimate polar ( or polar conic ) of the point , which conic is touched by the tangent ; the assumed equation represents therefore a conic having an ordinary ( two-pointic ) contact with the polar conic , and therefore with the curve .
It may be added that the two conics intersect besides in a pair of points , and that the line joining these , or common chord of the two conics , is the line represented by the equation H=-0 ; and this being so , the constants ( a , b , c ) of the line II1O can be so determined as to give rise to a five-pointic contact .
Consider the coordinates of a point of the curve as functions of a single variable parameter ; then for the present purpose the coordinates of a point consecutive to ( x , y , z ) may be taken to be x+ dx + 1 , d ?
x+*d ?
x+#4-d4x , y+ die +4d2+NdV+ ?
d4yj z +dz +Id2z +'d$z +W 4z , values which , substituted for X , Y , Z , must satisfy the equationrs T=O , D2U-17.DU=O .
4 .
1 write for shortness a1=dx ?
+ die +dza 2S -d ; xd +d2gfO +d2zt B4=dZx+dfyr+d4zt , then the consecutive value of T is exp .
( b1 +2+t3 +Q4)U ( Read exp .
z , exponential of z , -e- ) , which 'is ( 1 +12 , + 2+W ?
t ) X(1 +3)X ( 1 ++* ) J +663 +_b , _U+ alU+ +~~~ ~~~ l 2a1+a +a @U +2 21J-o + 2 ) 2 1J = -U , 62U = -E6+M243+~U Next , preparing to substitute in the equation D2U-_E .
DU=O , the consecutive value of DU is ( x+dcx+PPd2X+ + d3ncx++-d4x)-bU + &amp;c. =( +a6+22+R3+ -24a4)U , where a6 u= ( w+yay+zba)U= nU .
Reducing by the above results , the consecutive value of DU is _-I 2a6u 1(+3l2 2 ~4 16~+4l3+ 3b2)lj .
( 3 6 ) 6A ~ 6 .
Hence also writing P=ax +by +ez , ~bP=adx +bdy +cdz , bP=adx+bd~y+ed2z , the consecutive value of -IDU is -(P+bP+12P ) multiplied 'into the consecutive value of DU , and the product is =P .
Ia2lU +P 1)+P3+3+ 2 +-U+p .
I2U2U +P.__j_(b4+Gab2 24l3+32)u+-alp .
_1(a3+bau - .
2a~U .
7 .
The consecutive value of D2U is = ( x+ dx+d 2X+ -id3X+ -1d4s)2'x2U + &amp; C. _2+ 2xdx + Xd2X+ ( dX)2 + &amp; C. + _I Xd3X+ dxdx ] +-1fXd4X+ d d$d3X+ ?
( d24X2 j which is = 2a o1+ 2303 '2+ aO02+a U+ i3O33+3i32 + +T1-T60'4+-11al3*+X2 and observing that b2 U=M(m-1 ) U , 0c2Uc ( c-1)a2U3 b'k3U= ( M-1)B3u1 MDCCCLIX .
~~~~ ' &gt; 3 DT-tm-1~AT and reducing as before , the consecutive value of D2U is -(-T 2)abU 3 r-(rn-1)33+3(m%-2)3l32]U I [ ( M_ 1))(-+ 6 O2)+(m-2)(4-33+ 3-2)]U .
S. Substituting in the equation D2U -I.DU=- , we obtain as the conditions of a five-pointic contact ( m-2)1U ?
P 42U I [ ( M j)-a 3+ 3(mn2)3162 ) +P .
l( ?
3+3 2)U+ IP b2U -0 --l[(in1)(4+ 64 22)+(in2)(46 I63+ 3a2)]U 1P 21['4+6-62-24l3 '62]U+-6jP.[-a-L3+ _1_'u 2 2U -l0r +P.24 3 ; or reducing P 2(r 2 ) , a46P=2 1U21+ 2 ] U4 a3U 31 + ba 2]U 22P -2u -9 2u a'U which are the conditions of a five-pointic contact : it is to be remarked that if only the first and second conditions are satisfied , we have ea four-pointic contact , and if only the first condition is satisfied , a three-pointic contact .
9 .
We have to reduce the last-mentioned equations ; suppose that A , B , C 'ire the first derived functions of U , then the equation bU=0 may be written Adx+Bdy+Cdz=0 , and this will be satisfied identically if dx=BP -Cp , die = C0 -Av , dz =AP , -BB , where A , k , P are arbitrary multipliers , which may be taken to be constants .
W ~e hav-e( therefore a =D , where D _(Bv C)x + ( CxAv)b + ( Ap B4)3 .
10 .
The resulting expressions for b2Ul , b'U , ''U may be exhibited in the reduced forms given by HESSE , viz , if S=Xx+--y +vz , we have = uP2U 2 , aU=P3UQ3 2= P4UU 1 =uP4U-Q4S2 where the values of P2 , P3 P4 ; Q2 , Q3 , Q4 are as follows , viz. if ( a , b , c , J , g ) are the second derived functions of U , and if H= a , Ai , g Oh , 4i , f g , f , c be the Hessian ; if , moreover , he= -(h , v a , , git t It , ,5 if be the bordered Hessian ( we may also write )( R3 , C , J , i , P Y , v ) where ( P , Xi , , 4f 7 , Hi ) are the inverse coefficients of ( a , 4 , ,f , g , h1 ) viz. J=( _ -f2 ) &amp; C. ) ; and finally , if for shortness we write Z)1.= b ( D *bL4+ if -a +H.b D -HaI then we have P2= any &lt; , =(in l)QH , 2~n I Q2 ( D = D &lt; Q3=(nI 1)D H , _mD2(rn-I ) 2l2H-1 2 ) 41 ( m-l)2 o Q4-( )D ( -)3 + m-1)3 In the present case U= 0 , and we have I U=-Q2 2 , dU= -Q45 .
11 .
Hence , substituting for Q2 and Q , their values , the first and second of the equations for the five-pointic contact give P=2(m-2 ) , a Pi= 2 DH , and observing that FI is a linear function of ( X , Y , Z ) , and consequently that P , bP denote simply the values which 11 assumes when ( a , y , z ) , ( da ; die , dz ) are respectively substituted for ( X , Y , Z ) , we see at once that these two conditions will be satisfied if we put I= 2 1DH+A.DU , where A is an arbitrary constant , or , what is the same thing , an arbitrary function of ( x , y , z ) .
We have thus the general equation of a conic of four-pointic contact .
12 .
The above value of II gives 'A P-3 I 'AT3 AA and the third equation of the system of conditions for a five-pointic contact is therefore 2 L~H 3 +Ab2U-a ui [ 4+ 6-2]U 4 bU [ b3+3ab2]U 211 21 U4 ~~~1 1 which leads to the value of A. 13 .
We have in general a~~u = ~m-1 4 &gt; t1 _)2 l -3U _ NJD .
UH-l oD11 a2 m-1 ( M1 a+ 1a2)U=m_1DP .
U-( I1)2D.u I ? ?
612)u j-1 ( 232 ? ? ?
?+D _ 1n)u ( _rn-2)(2)2l+DH O4)Hm )2 the last two of which have not yet been demonstrated .
The value of 'I11 ( which , however , is not required for the present purpose ) is 3(m-2 ) ~1fl bH m_1 M-LO+_1 which also is not yet demonstrated .
14 .
Putting U=O , we have a uM =-( 42 HWS ( 13+ 33 = ( rn )2DHl .
2e 36162 ) ( rn-i D1I .
2 ( -a4 2( ___ 3(rn-2 ) 2 )0(rn-i)k2M 2H+D " ?
rn 0iC rn-i 1 and substituting , 3 Elj a)X + .
] )2 H[2~2 A3 ft ( 2a2H+D 2H+ ? ?
1$ HP ) _(DH ) where the term involving 2II disappears ; the equation may be written 9H3V2 A 3-hD2u+ 0o 3(9n-2 ) HO -4(DH)2 ( i-1)2 M~n 1 r-i .
which II will represent by ( -)11 23)e A=3R R42-4R the values of Pt2 , 1U ) 1R being R3 =DH , ]t4 R= 2H +o 3(m-2)H m-1 m-1 15 .
We have IR .
IIi , and it will be shown that ( m-1)21R2=9(rn-2)2H2lk + 3(mn-2)1Hoa ( _-1)2R1=-12(m--2)2114 + 4(m-2 ) Da where for shortness T=( % 33 , fi~X4 H8)2ttS and hen e writing 911V2A= 3R , ( n1)2R , 4 -1 )21R2 we have 9H3A=_3f2H+4TP ; or replacing t7 , T by their values , 3-(j , 36 , C , ffi eSy tie )2 H.Hl A_= 9H 5 +4(213 e ; 110 ffa H Hj32Ib BH ) b ?
X2 Hand A having this value , the equation of the five-pointic conic is D2U1 D11H+ ADIEU )DU=O , where it will be recollected that the current coordinates are ( X , Y , Z ) , and that I ) denotes X6 + y+Z6 .
16 .
I remark , in passing , that the problem of finding the circle of cnurature at a given point of a plane curve , is in fact that of determining the conic having with the curve at the given point a three-pointic contact , and besides passing through tvo given points .
The equation of a conic having an ordinary contact , is D2U-IIDU=O , where 1=aX+bY+cZ , and the condition of a three-pointic contact is a +hby+cz=2(m-2 ) Let the coordinates of the two given points be and let ( D2 U)1 &amp;c. be the corresponding values of D2U &amp;c. , them we have D2U aX+6Y+cZ= DU ' axi +by1 +cz1-DU D ) ( D2U\ aX2+ by2 + CZ2( DU 12 ; and if from the four equations we eliminate a , b , c , we find XDU , YDU , ZDU , D2U =0 X3 3t S:z , 2(m-2 ) 7 D2U ) X2 1 Y2 1( DU 12 for the equation of the conic in question ; x , y , z being the coordinates of the point o , contact and X , Y , Z current coordinates .
II .
Demonstration of Identities assumed in the preceding section .
Proof of the expressions for ( a++3a1a)U and ( a+ 6a~2)U 17 .
It will be remembered that bl , a2 stand originally for dxc 6 , + die + dz a , d2xa +d2y y+d2zd , and that A , B , C being the first derived functions of U , dx , die , dz are changed into " , Bv-Cp4 , 0CkAy A%-XB ; X mnd that the resulting value of '6 , viz. ( ByC)3+ ( CX-Av)bY+(Ap &amp; )3zj is also , represented by D , so that a =D .
The corresponding values of d2 , d2y , d2z are d2x=v dB-PdC , d2y=xdC-Y dA , d2z =pdA-xdB , where we have dA=adlx+hdy+gdz , &amp;c. , in which dx , die , dz are to be replaced by the values BY----Cpj , C4 AAy Ap-BX ; and 62 really denotes what d2X~ + d2y6y +d z3 becomes when the above values are substituted for d2 , d2y , d2z .
But in the expressioAs 3aU , i23 , U &amp;c. , the symbols '6 a , a contained in a , and k2 operate only on IT , and not on the variable quantities A , B , C , &amp;c. contained in 'b and ib2 .
18 .
If now we treat a6 as an operand , that is , perform the differentiations on the variable quantities A , B , C which enter into b , we obtain or , what is the same thing , operating on b6U with 6 , the result is -lajU-b2U+a u(a'a2 and in like manner.a 2U=(63+2 lj2)U , -a t , -aU=(a64+alau ~~,.~U ( ?
~+ 3162 ) U It is , in fact , upon these principles that HrissiEs values of b1U , X aU &amp;c. were obtainedI .
and we may by means of them obtain the other expressions assumed in the preceding section .
19 .
In fact , starting from HESSE'S equation , 2j= ?
n __U__ 12 we h'ave ( brl2n 1J)z-H H. 125D2 But we have identically DU= 0 , 3D20 , and this equation becomes therefore ( 1+2lZ2)U= , UDinDH . ?
S2 n-i ( rnz-i ) But this is precisely HESSE'S value of 63U , or we have 'bl62U=:0 , and therefore 13 3a 1'62)UU = al UD'5'-7S_ )2 DX HS in~~~-1 ( rn-i1)2 .
20 .
In like manner starting from the expressiol of bU , we have ( +3 2.)U= mZ ( fU D PD+UDDI ) ) ( DhI.22Db+ D. Dh1 ) ; or since 1U and Da vanish identically , and the values of .
WP , .
fill ar2eCD .
'62II+ 1D2H we have ( al a~a)u m 1U(a2 D_ ( , ,)5( &gt; +D~l and if from the double of this equation we subtract H-lEssE 's equation , '64U=-~ TT(T2 , TI)-FN Cp2/ 2(T___ 2 +3(m-( ) we find the required relatiou , ( I+ &amp; P2)U-m ( 2a2i+DP+ 1 r ) u Proof of the expression for '2fi 21 .
We have whereJ dA=adx+hdygdz , dB=h +bdy +fdz , dC =ydx +fdz , +cdz , in which dx , die , dz are to be replaced by their values ; we have therefore 'a2H-6 H{ { ( bC -fB ) +( fA-hC)vp+(hB-bA ) [ ( fC-cB ) ?
+(oA--gC)p+(gB-fA)X ] } + &amp; C. , where the coefficient of 3aH is Ox2+(gC-cA)h 2+(hB-bA)Y2 +(2fA-gB-hC)(hv+(bC-fB)vX+( B-fC)xp , orsnc wNe hta~ve ( m-1)A=a +11Y+Yz , ( m-1)B=hxbY++fz , : ( m)C =gX+ fie +CZ , the coefficient , omitting the factor m1 ' which will be afterwards restored , is 0x2 +[ gI(g+fy+c4)-c(ax+hy+gz ) ] 2 +1 h(hX+by+fz)-b(aX+hy+Yz)]V2 +[2f(ax+k +yz)-g(h +by+fz)-h(gx+ +ez ) ] pie +E b(gx+ fie +cz)-f hx+6Y+fz)}xk +[ C(14+fY+C)-f(g +fy+ez)]X Ox2 +(-_3X+ Tie )p2 +(-2T+@y+o Lz)pv ?
&amp; Iex+ z)Y + I-X+ay )Xpj ) which is equal to -(Z2+3p+pv2+ , 24fiii+ 26v +2 2(p)w + ( Ax HR4 + ei0(x$+1ky+ vz ) .
The coefficients of a6 , H , a6H , have a similar form ; and uniting the three terms , observing that xw , H+y ?
jyH+z6 , H is equal to 3(rn-2)H , and attending to the values of , C3 , 2 , we have , restoring tde omitted factor m-i ' a 2H -3(m-2 ) Hq &gt; + E1 a.S inI 7n-i Proof of the expressions for ( DHU)2 and D21 : 22 .
These are obtained ( for the particular case m= 4 , which makes but little difference ) in Mr. SALMON'S ' Higher Plane Curves , ' pp. 88 and 89 , and I merely reproduce his investigation ; we have ( DH)2= { ( ByC%)b8H + ( CAv)byH +'(A h-BX)6_H }2 , or , what is the same thing , ( DH)2= { 1~ -B3Z)H+1'(Ai caX)H+ ( Ba-Ab)H}2 ; and if we consider first the term which contains X2 , the coefficient is { ( City-B6_)H } 2 .
Now making use of the equations ( in1)A = ax+hy + , gz , ( m-1)B=h xby+fz , ( m-1)C =gx+ fie +oz , and m(rn-l )U =ax2 + by2 + cz2 + 2fyz + 2gzx + 2hUy =0 , we have ( M_-1)2C2 = ( yx + fie + cz)2 -_c(ax2 + by2 + cz2 + 2fyz+2gzx ?
2hxy ) Jf~~~2~ ~~xy-~y xz+zxyzh ( m-12BC= ( h$x+2by~x ?
1-A+y2+z-~t^ y c2+2y+2z+2~y ( in1)2B2 = ( hX + by +fz)2 _ b(aX2 + by2 + cz2 +2fylz +2gzx +2hkx ) = _C2 + 26xz _2Z2 ; and hence ( M_ 1)2 ( ( Ca -Bb)H)_ ( -ZX2+ 21xy -y2)(6yH)2 +2( _-^fX2+ x y+lxz-2yz)3H .
H+ ( _ $2 +2z -ox -2)(bH)2 -( 43C CbyH , bH)2 + 2x(yayH +z36H)(2)H + H ) -n(diH+z1)2 ad ; so that the term is _X,2(33 l 3y 3H)2 + 2x(3(rn-2)H-z11 H ( yH+ 3bIi ) ( 3(m-2)H-zabH ) ; or reducing M 1-)2 1 ( CyB H2 +6 ( m2)Hx(2l36 , ,H + 1 ?
byH + 0-6zH ) -9(n-2 )2ZH2 .
23 .
The other terms may be obtained in a similar manner ; and it is easy to see that , collecting all the terms , the sum will be -( ( .h ?
/+yZ)2(2[ 43,1 ; C , , ffi t , H9 yH,6zH )2 + 6(M2I~$yv)(~p@~XlI ( X ] 1+ , fli)aH+( &amp; x+ , y ?
+v}bglII } --9(nbt-2 ) H2( ) ) ) ) _ , y)2 ; or , attending to the signification of the symbols a , ID , E , I , we have ( M-1)2(DH)2= -9(M-2)21121D +3(m-2)H LJ 2 24 .
Next D21= ( ( By-2CH ) ?
( Cx -Av)a , +(A-Bx)D)2H , or , what is the same thing , D2H1 ={ J(C B+ pi(AaCQ)+P(B6 A ) } 12H ; and if we attend first to the term which contains X2 , the coefficient is ZCyB)2H .
N ow substituting for C2 , CB , B2 as before , we have M 1-)2(C)Y -B M)2H( 33X2 +2hy _ Xa !
/ )b 21-+2 ( _ yx2 + Ox +3_ xzyz ) ?
y531-1 +(C X2+2 &amp; xz _R2)b211 =.X2(33 Jf , Clay )211 + 2x(yby +z-6_j(jkby +06 , j1-1 -+Y3 Z3 Z)2H7 where it is to be observed that the symbols of differentiation affect H only .
WT have ( y ?
/y + Zz)2H= ( X-6 , +y+ Z-6)211 +2(xabJ , +yay+b-)SI + ( X-6 , )2 H , wh ere 1-1 is a homogeneous function of the degree 3m6 ; vr .
H , since the x is not affected by the differentiation , must be treated as of the degree 3m7 , and ( x b)2H for the like reason , stands for x2ll ; we have ( yay+z Z)2H =(3m6)(3m-7)H -2(3m7)x6 , H +x2'62H .
In like manner , a+ a)IJg ea,11 = ( 3sn 7)(k~y+ea)1 -aata+ )H ; and hence Mft 1)2(CB Bb )2H x2(35 f , ( El-b , - , &amp; )2H +2x[(347)(j ?
'y+ &amp; b , , ) H-x63t( ?
By+0B , )H ] -2[(3m6)(3m-7 H-2(3m-7)x-bvH+x1'62H ] =-X2(31 ]31 el f 'a B ya)2H + 2(3m7)x(24 +16 + x)H ( 3m-6)(3m-7)aHI .
25 .
The other terms are formed in a similar manner ; and collecting all the terms , we have ( M1)2D2H ( 3m 6)(3m 7)(2l5X , th V)X p)2H + 2(3an-7)( x+ 'yx+ vz)(( 7 +It + v ) 11+ ( ILPx+ +v ) H +( &amp; +1f + ; v ) -( ; X$+pjw+V)2(a , J , ( El fl 01 1 ?
:Cbx byl 6_)2Hl or , attending to the signification of the symbols F , D , 0 , l2 , this is ( M-1)2D2H= -(3m-6)(3m-7)H1D +(3m7)o O Q2 Proof of the expressons for ( i1)2I , ( m 1)2R4 , : 26 .
We have ( ft , )R3= ( M1(DH)2 -9(m2)2H2CD +3(im-2)Hoa ( M_-1)2R4=(M_1)2D2H1+(M1)a 0 -(3m-6)(m1)11 12(m-2)2H'D + 4(nm-2)0a which are the expressions required .
Proof of corresponding expressions for ( in1)6Q ' , ( in1)4Q427 .
We have ( rn-I )6Q 23 ( m-1)2(DH)2 = -9(m-2)2HkF +3(m-2)HlU ( 'ft 1)4Q4 =(m4 VD 2H_(Ml)ao +(3m-6)(m7-1 )Eio 6(m-2)(m-3)H11D + '2 ( m3 ) ci Q2 rTo which I join ( n,1 )2Q2 = IH .
28 .
We have consequently ( n1)6(3QQ4Q)= 9(m2)(m-4)H21k +3(qn-4)Hoa + ( -32H ?
'Y)52 and ( i.-1)6(3(rm-2)Q2Q4-2(m--3)Q ' ) ( -3(mn-2)f2H+2(m-3)TF ) , which for m= 4 become 729(3Q2Q4Q)=(3QH+I)32 .
29 .
In the case mn=4 , we have HESSE'S theorem , that the equation 3QQ4Q3= gives a curve of the 14th order , which passes through the points of contact of the double tangents , viz. substituting for Q2 , P their values , the equation of this curve is -3H(i7 b~ , J , &lt; 3 y , I , )21j + ( SO 39 ) &gt; !
170 , tH x yHo 'bH)2= 0 .
I have added these remarks for the sake of pointing out the striking resemblance of the expressions which occur in the double-tangent problem for i-=4 , and in the present theory of the five-pointic conic for any value whatever of nt .
It has not hitherto been Thown what the expressions 3(mn-2)Q2Q4-2(m3)Q2 and -3(in-2)fiI+2(n3)T respectively denote , except in the particular case m=4 .
III .
Application of the Formnulw to the Cubic .
80 .
I shall apply the formula for the five-pointic conic to a cubic ; to avoid confusion to a numerical factor , I write U ' , HI ' in the place of U , EI , so that we have _ 1~~ -(2 ba Is5C9 $1 2t 1 3b .
: IV X)2 HI .
HI 9 It +4(2 , , C. Jr. 0 .
- ) 261LaJII _tH')2 J and then the equation of the five-pointic conic is D2U_- &amp; ( , QDH'+ ADU ' ) DU'=0 .
I take as the equation of the cubic , U=X3+y3+z3+61lyz=0 ; the formulae Table No. 70 of my Third Memoir on Quantics* , putting H for HUE , give ll =12(X3 +y3 +z3 ) -(1 +2 13)xtyz .
Hence writing U'=*I(3 y3Z3 + 6Gxyz ) , the first derived functions are , ( X2+2lyz ) _(y2+21zx ) , _(Z2 +2xy ) ; the second derived functions , or ( a , b , G9 f , g , h ) , are ( x , y , z , ix , lie , lz ) .
whence '_-H ; the inverse coefficients ( 1 , 1 &amp; , l , jj 0 , I ?
) are ( yZ _ 22 Z 12y2 , X-_12Z2 , 2yz _ X2 , 12ZX _y2 , txyIz2 ) and putting U'=- !
U and HI= -H , we have A---1 f-3( , 35 ; , I &amp; JF , @ , 1I3aX,1 0 , )2H.H 1 4(21 , 3 &amp; , e , ( DI di , 3ExH b ZH)2 and the equation of the five-pointic conic is D2u( DH+BADUDU=)o .
31 .
We have ( yz_12X2 ) .
612x + ( Z1y2 ).6l2y + ( xy 12Z2 ).612z +2(lyz-i ) .
)(1+213)x +2(12zXz_ fy2)._(1+213)y + 2(1-xy , -J2 ) .
( 1+213)zI which is =1 812J yz-6l14(3+y3+Z3 ) -6121 +213)Xyz+21(1 +2P)(x3+yz+z2 ) ( 12121215)xyz+(21214)(X3+y3 +Z3 ) 2(1-14)(s3+y3+Z3+ 61xyz ) , or we have where S is the quartinvariant ( see the Table No. 70 ) .
For the prese t purpose hi KI and consequently ( 2-7.3 , lr ( 65i lfax Ay -az)=n .
cS 6 MR. A. CAYLEY ON THE CONIC OF FIVE-POINTIA,32 .
Next , ( 1 .
, 33X C , jiS 6YH azH a ) = ( yz 122)[3122 -(1 +213).yZ]2 + ( ZX2 ) [ 3ly'-/ ( 1+2l13)z , ]2 + ( X _ 12z2 ) [ 312z2 ( 12+23)xj +212yz(2)[312y2-(1+213)zx][312z2-(l +213)tv ] +2(12zxy2)3l2z2-( + 213)xy][3l2 + 213)yz ] +2(12xy 1Z2)[312e-(l+2l3)yIz][312y2 ( 1 + 213)zx3 , the first three lines of which are 914Xy(3 +y3+ Z3)-1812(1 +211 )X2y2Z2+ ( 1 +23)2(yl3zl3+ 3 ?
.X3y ) -916( 6+y6+z6)+614(1+213)xyz(3+y3 +z 3)-312(1+213)2X2y2 z o)r collecting and reducing , ( -916 )(x + +Z ) +(1+41P+ 416 )(y3z3 + z3X +X3y3 ) +( 1514+1217 )(a3 +3 +z3 )x z+ ( -2112-4815-121 " ) X2y2Z2 .
the second three lines are 1816(y3Z3+z3 Z+ y3)1214(1 +2l)Xyz(X3+y3+z3)+ 612(1 + 213)2 &lt; y5z 5415 2y2z2+1213(1 +213 ) &amp; 3Z3+Z3X3+ ?
3y3 ) -21(1 +213)2xyz(x3+ ?
+Z3 ) or collecting and reducing , ( 1213+ 4216 )(y3z3 ?
z3l + x3y3 ) + ( -21-2014-3217 )(X3 +y3 +Z3 _VyZ +(612-3015+2418 ) X2y2Z2 .
Henuce in the first part replacing the top line by -916( 3 +y3+Z3)2+ 18 &amp; 3Z3+z3 ++ 3y3).d uniting the two parts , we find 13 , C , J,0 ffi )3aul aY a ( 1 + 813)2(y3Z3+z3 3+X31y3 ) +( &amp; 9)(+ y " +Z3 )2 +( 2I5142,0 )(3 +y3 + Z3 )XyZ +(-1512 _7815+1218 ) y2z2 ; and referring to the Table No. 70 , and writing ?
for OU , we have where ?
is the first of the three functions which may be chosen to represent the octicovariant of the cubic .
33 .
We have thus 40 and thence D2U D2u DH-22 )DU=o as the equation of the five-pointic conic : the investigation has been conducted by meams of the canonical form of the equation of the cubic , but the form of the result shows that it applies to the equation of the cubic in any form whatever .
34 .
If , however , we continue to represent the cubic by the canonical equation x3 +y3 ?
+ 61xyz= O , the result may be further reduced .
We have , putting U= 0 , or writing x3'=y3+ &amp; -:'= -_ Gl7 ?
// H1 ( 1+813)Xyz ; moreover , putting U=( , the Table No. 70 gives ?
=(1 + 813)2(y3z3+z33Xa+ y3)312112 ; or substituting for H the last-mentioned value , and putting for shortness Q-y3z3 +z3x3 +x3y3 _ 312xV2y2/ z2 we have ?
=(I+ 813)2Q ; and with these values of H and Q , the equation of the five-pointic conic is DU+(3 + 813)XyZD i-2 7 -(Il+ 813a ) 3y3-Z3 DU ) DU =0 where DU -3{ ( X2 +2 lyz)X + ( y2 +2 lzx)Y + ( Z2 +2 lxy)Z } D2U=6 { ( X2+ 2IYZ)k + ( Y2+ 2IZX)y+ ( Z2+ 2IXY)z } , or , as it will be convenient to write it =6(x , y , z , 1z y zX)Y ) DEL=(12Xc2 _(+ 13)yz)X ( 12y2 _ ( I +2Sz)Jr(12Z2_( 2).y ; whence , finally , the equation of the five-pointic conic of the cubic X3+y3+Z3+61XYZ= O at the point ( x , y , z ) is 9(1+813)X3y3Z3(X9 y , Z7 J.go Jy ) Iz : X Y~ Z)2 + { ( x2+2lyz)X+(y2+2lZX)Y+(Z2+21lx)Z } Xf 3x yz[( 312x ( 1 + 21 )yz ) X+ ( 312y2y ( 1 ? ?
2l1)zx)Y+ ( +31 z ( 1+ 21 )ay)jZj Il -Q[(x2+2 lyz )X ( y2i+ 21zx )Y+ ( Z2+ 2ly )Z ] a result which I had previously obtained by a special method .
35 .
But the expression may be exhibited in a different form by a transfo1rn7tio suggested by a geometrical theorem of Mr. SALMON'S .
In fact the tangent at the point ( x,1 ' y , z ) meets the cubic in the tangential of this point , and the coordinates of the tangential are X(y3-z3)+y(Z3-Y3 ) , Z(X3-y3 ) .
Calling these , o , 4 the equation of thec tangent to the cubic at the tangential is .
+-21nK)X+ ( 42 +2 kZ)Y + ( t +2 1E)Z=Oe Now we have identically , 3X2y2z2 { ( 322_ ( 1 +21P)yz)X+ ( 312y2_ ( 1 + 21)yz)Y+ ( 312z2(1 + 21 )zx ) Z Q{ ( X2 + 2tyz)X+ ( y2+ 21zx)Y+ ( Z2+21xy)Z } { ( V2+2l8)X+ ( n2 + 2l)Y + ( 42 +2 ln)Z }+U { x22( -y3-3 ?
2lyz)X+yf( z3-x3+21zx)Y +z2(-x3 y +2Ucxy)Z } .
In fact this relation will be true if only 3x 2y2Z2(3122 _ ( 1 +2l13)yZ _-Q(X2+2lyz ) +2 ln8 ) UX2( -y3 z3+ 2 lyz ) .
And substituting for 4 , 7 , C and Q their values , the left-hand side is .
3 2y2z2(3l2S2 ( 1 +213)yz ) ( x2 + 2lyz)(y3z3 +z3X3 +X3y3 -312ey2z2 ) _ , t ; 2(y3 _5z3)2 2lyz(Z3 X3)(X3 _y3 ) ; and expanding and reducing , the result is i2( _(y3+Z3)2_ 3(y3+ ?
Z3 ) ) +21yz(2X3(y3 Z3 ) +6)+ 12l1X2Z1 .
whence , dividing by x2 , the equation becomes _ ( y +z3)(3 +y3+Z3 ) + 2lxyz ( a3 2(y3+Z3 ) ) +1 l2X22y2z2 =(3 +2 lyZ)(X3+y3+Z3+6 xyz ) , which is identically true .
36 .
Hence in the identical equation putting U=O , we see that the equation of the five-pointic conic may be written 9(1+ 813)X3y3z3(Q , y , z , lX , lie , lIz(X , Y , Z)2 + { ( X22+2lyz)X+(y2+2lzx)Y+(Z2 ?
+21xy)Z } x { ( Z2 + 2il4)X+(n2 + 21 ; )y+(42+2 ln )Z } -0O .
where , n7 , U stand for X(y3-Z3 ) , y(z3-X3 ) , Z(X3-y3 ) , the coordinates of the tangential of the given point , and which puts in evidence the geometrical theorem above referred to , viz. Theorem .
The conrnion chord of the five-pointic conic and the polar conic is the tangent to the cubic at the tangential of the given point .
The five-pointic conic meets the cubic in the point of contact , considered as five coincident points , and in a remaining sixth point or point of simple intersection .
The process by which I originally obtained the equation of the five-pointic conic , led also to the equation of the line joining the point of contact with the point of simple intersection : the equation of this line is r XX((I+ 813)X4+ ( 41+4114)x2yz +(-212+2l15)y2Z2)i 9X 3y3z3 +Yy ( ( 1 + 813)y4 +(41+ 41 14)y2z+ + -2l+ 215)z2x2 ) 1+ Zz ( ( + 813)z4 ?
( 4l 41l4)z2Xy+ ( -2l2+ 2)x2Jy ) 3 -6Q 2y2Z2 X(312e2-(1+ 213)yz ) +Y(312y2_(1 +213)zx ) + Z(312z2 -(1 + 21)xy ) } + Q2 { X(x2+2lyz)+Y(y2+2lzx)+Z(z2+2lxy ) } =0 .
38 .
If the conic meet the cubic in sit coincident points , that is , if the point of contact be a singular point of the kind already spoken of , or , as we may term it , a sextactic point , then the last-mentioned line must coincide with the tangent at the point .
Represent for a moment the equation of the line by AX+BY+CZ= Q , then this line is to coincide with the line ( x2 + 2lIyz)X+ &amp; y2+ 2lzz)Y+ ( z2+ 2lxy)Z = 0 , or we must have B(Z2 +21xy)C(y2+21zx)0 , C(x2+21yz)-A(Z2 +21xy)=0 , A(y2 +21zx)-B ( x2+21yz)=0 , which must be equivalent to a single condition .
The terms of A , B , C , which contain aY2+ Slyz y2+2lzx , z2+2lxy respectively , may , it is clear , be omitted , and omitting also a factor 3X2y2z2 , we may write A= 3x2yz((1 + 813)x4+(41+ 4114)x2yz+ ( -212+ 215)y2z2 ) 2Q(312X2 _ ( 1 + 2l1)z ) B=3xy2z(( 1+ 81')y4 + ( 41+4114)y2zx+ ( -212+21 )z2 2 ) _2Q(312y2 _ ( 1+21)z ) , and the like value for C. The last of the three equations is 3 ( y2+ 2lzx)((1 + 813)X5+ ( 41+4114)X3yz + ( -212+2l5)xy2z2 ) l-(2+ 2 lyz)(1 + 813)y5 +(41+ 4114)y3ZX+ ( 12+215)yz2X2)T -2Q{ ( 2+2l1zx ) ( 3l22 ( 1+2l1)yz ) 2+ 2 lyz)(3l2y2-( 1+ 21 1)zx ) } =0 , where the function on the left hand is + ( 1 ?
i8.3)Qxy2_x2y5+ 21(x6z yIz ) = 3xyza +(41+4114)2l(X4yz2 Xt4zj2 ) ) } t+( ' 212+2l5 ) ( Xy4z2 X4Z2 ) -2Q { -(1+2l8)(fsz-x'z ) +6l2(x'z-y3z ) } , MDcccLIlx.3 or , what is the same thing , throwing out the factor z , it is ={ 3(1 + 8l3)X3y3 + 61(1 + 813)Xylz(X3+y3 ) + 3012(1 + 813)X2y2z2 } ( x3 -y3 ) -2Q(1+ 813)(X3-y2 ) ; or throwing out the factor ( 1 + 813 ) and substituting for Q its value , it is ={ 3x3y3 +6xyz(w3+y')+3012x2y2z2 2(y'z2+z3x3+xy3 .
3l2x2y2z2 ) } ( X3_ y ) .
The first factor , reducing by the equation X ' +y3+ Z3 + 6lxyz , is 3X y ( X ' +y3)(X ' +y3 +z3 ) + ( x +y ?
+z )2 2(yZ3 + Z3X3 +x y3 ) =3 3y3+Z3(X +y3z+Z3)2(y3Z3 +Z3X3+X3y3 ) Z= -z3 ( -X'+yl ) +3y3 = ( z 3_ 3)(z3_y3 ) .
39 .
Hence putting for the moment M 3_ ( y-:3)(Z3_XS3)(X3_y3 ) ' it appears that the last of the three equations is Mz=O ; the first and second are of course Mx= O and My=O , and the required condition is M= O , that is , ( y3 _ z')(Z3 XI)(X ' _y3 ) = 0 , the equation which , combined with the equation of the curve x3+y'+z3+ Gxyz= 0 , gives the sextactic points .
There are consequently twenty-seven such points , and it is at once seen that these are the points of contact of the tangents to the cubic from the points of inflexion , or , what is the same thing , that the twenty-seven sextactic points form nine groups of three each , such that the three points of a group have for their common tangential one of the nine points of inflexion .
In fact , let W be a cube root ( real or imaginary ) of unity , the three sextactic points of one of the groups will be given by x. lie _O , lx3+y3+z'+ Glxyz=0 .
Now consider the tangential of any one of these points , its coordinates are , = x(Y 3_ z3 ) Y1 =y(z _-X ' ) , z1 =z(X3 y ' ) ; or , reducing by the equation x-wy=O , X , = Wy(X3 _ Z3 ) , y= -y(x3 _Z3 ) , Z1 0 , or , what is the same thing x , i+CyQ =O , 1 =0 ; that is , the point ( x$ , y , ZI ) is one of the points of inflexion .
This is the construction of the sextactic points obtained by PLUCKER and STEINER .
40 .
Reverting to the equation of the line joining the point of contact of the fivepointic conic with the point of simple intersection , this meets the cubic in a third point , and Mr. SALMON has shown that this third point is in fact the second tangential ( tangential of the tangential ) of the point of contact , or , what is the same thingTheorem.-The point of simple intersection of the cubic and the five-pointic conic is the third point of intersection with the cubic , of the line joining the point of contact with the second tangential of this point .
41 .
I have not sought to verify this theorem by my formula .
I remark , that combining it with the before-mentioned theorem , the five-pointic conic is completely determined as follows ; viz. Theorem.-The five-pointic conic touches the conic at the point of contact ( two conditions ) ; it passes through the two points in which the polar conic is intersected by the tangent to the cubic at the tangential of the point of contact ( two conditions ) ; and it passes through the point which is the third point of intersection with the cubic of the line joining the point of contact with its second tangential .
42 .
The construction for the point of simple intersection leads at once to that for the sextactic points ; in fact , consider a point having for its tangential a point of inflexion : a point of inflexion is its own tangential , and the second tangential of the first-mentioned point is therefore the point of inflexion : the line joining the point with the second tangent is therefore the tangent at the point , and the point of simple intersection coincides with the point itself , that is , the point in question is a sextactic point .
43 .
1 represent the equation of the five-pointic conic by ( a , b , cf , , h)2X , Y , Z)2= 0 ; the value of a is = 9(1 + 813)X4y3z3 + 3X2y2z2(312X2 ( 1+213)yz)(x9+ 221yz ) Q(x2+ 2lyz)2 , in which equation Q=y3z3+z3x3+x3y'312X2y2z2 ; or reducing by the equation X3+y3+z3+61xyz=0 , -y3z3+X3(-X36Ixyz)3l2x2y2Z2 that is , -Q=x6+6lx4yz+312X2y2z2 -y3z3 and we have a= 9(1 + 813)xy3z3 + 3X2fz2(312a4+ ( -1 + 413)yz 21(1 + 213)y2Z2 ) +( +6lx4yz + 31 2xy2z2-_y3z3)(X4 + 41x2yz+41y2z22 ) .
We have in like manner 2f 1 8(1 + 813)1X4y3z3 + 3X2y2Z2{(312-y2(1 +213)zx)(Z2+21xy ) + ( 3lZ_(I +213)xy ) ( ,2+ 2izx ) } -2Q(y2+21ZX)(Z2+ 2Ixy ) ; the coefficient Of 3 2y2z2 in the second line is _6 12y2z2+ ( -1+ 413)x(l+3)_4l(1+23 3)x2 , Iz ; or reducing by the equation of the curve , =(1413)x4+ ( 213214)xz'+ 6 ly2z2 .
And the coefficient of -2Q is =y2z2+ 21x(y ' +z3)+ 411x ; yz ; or reducing by the equation of the curve , = -21x4-8l2x2yz+y2z2 .
And we have 2f= 181(l + 813)X4y3z3 + 3X2y2z2((14l')X4+(21-3214)x2yz+ 612y2z2 ) +2(x6+ 61x4yz + 312x2y2z2 -y'z')(2lX4 8l22yz +y2z2 ) .
Reducing the expressions of a and 2f , we find for the coefficients ( a , 6 , c , f , g , h ) , [ a= '10+101 , x8yz+40l2x6y2z2+(5 +12Ol3)X4y3z3-_ I0 JXy4Z1 412y5z , 2f= 41x'04Ol2x8yz+ ( 5120l3)v6y2z2+4Olx4y3z0_+ 812y4z4-2yz , which gives the completely developed form of the equation of the five-pointic conic .
44 .
1 investigate the coordinates of the point of simple intersection of the cubic and the five-pointic conic as follows : the equations of the two curves are X3+Y3+Z3+61XYZ -0 , ( or , -b el I , g , h:XX , Y Z)2 =0 or if we write oc~1 , A=c , y=61XY , B=2(gX+J ) t=X3 + y3l C =aX2+2hXY+by2 ; then the two equations are CZZ3 + yZ + 0 , AZ2+BZ+C-=O and the result of the elimination of Z will be ( oZ~ + rZ +B)(osZ +YZ2+ )=0 where Ze , Z2 are the roots of the equation AZ2+BZ+C= 0 ; that is , we have a2 C3 + Vy C(B2-2AC ) + &amp; 6(-B3+2ABC ) ==0 .
+72 CA2 7l BA2 tb~2 A3 | And substituting for A , B , C their values , but attending only to the terms which involve X6 and Y6 , the result is ( a3+c38g3+6acg)X6+* +(b3+C38f3+6bef)Y6= 0 .
45 .
But the result of the elimination must obviously be ( XyYx)5(Xy , Yx1 ) = 0 , if ( xI , y , , zl ) are the coordinates of the point of simple intersection .
Comparing the two results , and forming the analogous third equation , we may write x5x x=b3+c38f ?
+ 6bef , y5y ' =c3 +a38g3+6cag , z5z =a3+63 8h3+Ca6h , where the value of x5x , may also be written ( b+c-2f))(b+cw-2w2.f)(b +C &amp; ,22f ) , w being an imaginary cube root of unity , and so for the other two terms .
The factors of x5x , might be calculated from the identical equation by2 +2f YZ + CZ2 =9 ( 1 +8 13)w3yIz3(yy2+ zZ2 + 2lYZ ) + { ( y2 +2 lzx)Y + ( Z2 +21xy)Z } Xf 3X2y2Z2 [ ( 3l2y2 ( 1 + 213)zX)Y+ ( 3l2z2 _ ( 1 + 213)Xy)Z ] 1t_ Q[(y2+ 2lzx)Y+ ( z2+ 2lIxy)Z ] I remark , that putting x =0 , we have Y2 + 2f YZ + cZ2= _y3z3(y2y+Z2Z)2 , and hence writing 1 for Y , and -1 , -w , -wa for Z , we have b+ c2f~ =y z 3(y2_ Z2)2 , b+ ci 2wsf= _y3z3(y2_ W4z2)2 , b+C2_ 24= 3 3(y2 2Z2)2 and hence the product of the three factors is _ylZl(y2_z2)2(y2 _W 2Z2)2(y2 _W4Z2)2 , which is equal to -y9z9(y3z3)2(y3+ z3)2 , which vanishes in virtue of the assumed equation x=0 .
This shows that the function b 3+ C3 -_8f3 +6bcf contains the factor aX .
I have not verified a posteriori , but I assume it to be true , that it contains in fact the factor X6 , and consequently that the expressions for a , y , , z1 are rational and integral functions of ( x , y , z ) of the degree 25 , and containing respectively the factors x , y , z. 46 .
In the theory of the cubic , a point which depends linearly upon a given point may be termed a derivative of such point .
According to a very beautiful theorem of Professor SYLVESTER'S , the coordinates of a derivative point are necessarily rational and integral functions of a square degree of the coordinates ( x , y , z ) of the given point ; and moreover , there is but one derivative point having its coordinates of any given square degree in2 , or , as we may express it , only one derivative point of the degree 4m2 .
The successive tangentials are derivative points of the degrees 4 , 16 , 64 , &amp;c. ; the third point of intersection with the cubic , of the line joining two derivative points of the degrees m2 and n2 respectively , is a derivative point of the degree ( mn+n)2 .
Thus the third point of intersection with the cubic , of the line joining the given point with its second tangential , is a derivative point of the degree ( 4+ 1)2 , and it is easy to see that the degree is not 9 ; it is therefore 25 .
The point of simple intersection of the five-pointic conic is a derivative point of the degree 25 ; it is therefore , according to Professor SYLVESTER'S general theory , identical with the point given by the former construction ; this agrees with the before-nentioned theorem of Mr. SALMON .
IV .
Independent investigation for the Cubic .
47 .
The following is , in substance , the method by which I first obtained the equation of the five-pointic conic , for the cubic X3+Y3+Z3+6lXYZ= O. Write for shortness U= x3+y3+z3+61xyz , V =(X2+21lz)X+( if +21zx)Y+(z2+21iy)Z , W= ( X2+ 2lYZ)x+ ( Y2+ 2lXZ)y+(Z2 + 2lXY)z , T =X3+Y3+Z3+6lXYZ , P =axlby+cz , [ =aX+bY+cZ .
Then X , Y , Z being current coordinates , and x , y , z the coordinates of a point of the cubic ( so that U= 0 ) , the equation of the cubic will be T=0 , and the equation of a conic having with it an ordinary ( two-pointic ) contact at the point ( x , y , z ) , will be* 2WIIV= 0 .
48 .
Now imagine from the point of contact lines drawn to the other four intersections of the two curves ; in the case of the five-pointic conic , three of these lines will coincide with the tangent V= 0 , and the remaining line will be the line joining the point of contact with the point of simple intersection .
The equations of the lines in question can be found by JOACHIMSTIHAL'S theorem , viz. if ( x , y , z ) be the coordinates of a given point , and ( X , Y , Z ) current coordinates , then if in the equations of any two curves we substitute for the coordinates , Xx+pX , Xy+p.Y , 7Xz+pZ , and between the equations so obtained eliminate X , p , the resulting equation will be that of the lines drawn from the point ( x , y , " z ) to the points of intersection of the two curves .
The point ( x , y , z ) is any point whatever , and it may therefore be a point of intersection , or , as in the present instance , a point of contact of the two curves ; the only difference is , that in either case the degree of each equation as regards ( x , p ) is reduced by unity , and the degree of the resulting equation in X , Y , Z is also reduced by unity : in the case of a point of simple intersection this is the only reduction ; but in the case of a point of contact , the result* I have introduced the factor 2 , to make this correspond with the form D2UrIDU=O , in the case in qulestion , rn=3 .
ing equation contains the equation of the tangent as a factor , and rejecting this factor , the reduction in degree is two units .
49 .
Applying the method to the two equations , T=o , 2W-IV=O , and substituting therein for the original current coordinates X , Y , Z the values ?
4x+ &amp; X , Xy+p-Y , 4z+p4Z , the equations become x3U+ 3x21JV+3x4,2W+pT= 0 , 2( 2U+ 24pV c42W)-(xP+(JJJ)(XU+ WV)= 0 ; or writing U 0 , and omitting from each equation the factor pv , the equations become x23V+x .
3W+p2T =0 , W , ( 4 -P)V + l(2W -I-IV ) -0 ; and putting in the first equation x=2WIIV , =-(4-P)V , the result of the elimination contains the factor V , rejecting which it becomes 3(2WflV)23(4-P)(2W-FlV)W+(4-P)2VYT-=O , which is of the fourth degree in ( X , Y , Z ) , as it should be , and represents therefore the lines drawn from the point of contact to the other four points of intersection of the conic and cubic .
50 .
The equation may be written -3(2W I-IV)((2-P)W+IIV ) +(4-P)2 YT=O , and we obtain at once the condition that this may contain the factor V , viz. this condition is P=2 ; and if this be satisfied the conic will have a three-pointic conic , and there will be three other points of intersection .
And writing P=2 , and throwing out the factorY Vwe find 3FI2V 611W+4T=O for the equation of the lines from the point of contact to the three points of intersection .
And we have now to determine HI so that the function on the left hand may divide by V2 .
51 .
I simplify my original method by the use of a theorem of Mr. SALMON'S , viz. writing T=X3+Y3+Z'+61XYZ , 3P =12(X3+Y3+Z3)-(1 +21')XYZX W=(X2+21YZ)x+ = '312X2(1 ?
+213)Yz V=(xv2+21yz )X+. .
, HI=(3l2X2-(1+213)yz U=X3+y3 , +z3+ 61xyz H =12(x3+y3'+Z3)-(1 +2P)z we have identically ITH-U ?
=Wl-1 VI ?
, and in the present case , since U 0 Hence , multiplying by H and substituting this value of TH , the equation becomes 3H Y-2V 6HIIVW+ 4WH1 -4V1 = or , as we may write it , V(3p1171411)+2W(2H , -3HIIh=O ; and we can at once make the equation divide by V , viz , by assuming 2Y-1 + 1AV , where A is arbitrary .
We have thus a four-pointic contact .
And substituting for 1 , and throwing out the factor V , the equation becomes 3H( I+A )41 ?
1+ 2W(-aHA)=0 or reducing , 16(H-.-3Hjj1)-36H2AW+24111I1AV+ 9H12A2Y2 0 which is the equation of the lines drawn from the point of contact to the remaining two points of intersection .
52 .
I write for greater convenience 43 being as yet indeterminate , the equation is thus reduced to 9H3 I H(H23H1 ) + eW } -6H12111V +0e2V2-0 .
And we have then to determine ?
so that the left-hand side may divide by V ; or , what is the same thing , we must determine 0 so that H(HV 3_MII1 ) + OW 3ay divide by V. This implies the existence of an identical equation , H(H2--3HI1)+OW=MU+NV , which for U=0 would give the decomposition in question ; but I have not investigated the values of M and N. -I assume at the outset U=0 , and putting , as before , Q-y3Z3+.e+.23y3_ 3 P2y52Z and writing also S= Xx[(l +8 13)x4+ ( 41+ 4114)ey+ ( -2P+2l5)y !
ZZ2 ] +Yy[(1+ 8tP)+ ( 41+ 41)y2Z +( 2l+2l5)z23 +Zz [ ( 1+813)Z4+(41+4114)z2xI+( &amp; 212+2P)xy2 ] , I remark that for U=0 we have -yzH +VS + ( I +8 8)(QW I3 _yetzLh)=_0 an equation which , obserxing that H_-(1 + 813)xy and assuming also =(1 + 813)2Q , may be written H(HS-SHY ?
) +OW= --(1 +81')VS , which gives the required decomposition , so that 0 having this value , the conic will have a five-pointic contact .
Reducing by the last equation , and throwing out the factor V , we find 9H13(1 + 813)V6H1201 + ?
2V= 0 for the equation of the line joining the point of contact with the point of simple intersection .
And if in this equation we write H -=-(1 +83)xyz , and 0 ( 1+813)2Q , we obtain , finally , for the equation of the line in question , 9x y z'S 6x'g'z2QH , + QV= 0 , which is the before-mentioned result .
53 .
It only remains to verify the assumed equation -xyzH 2+VS+ ( 1 + 813)(QW-_ 3X2y2z2 % ) 0 .
We may write -Q=xi+6l4yz+ 3122y2z2yz3 and then observing that W= XX2+. .
+ 21a ' YZ+~1=3l2xX2+. .
-(1+213)xYZwe find at once ( 1 +813)(QW -3x2f2IL )= F ( x7-+ 6lx5yzz+ 1 212x3yz -Xy3Z3)X2 -(1+ 81 &gt; i + ( 21X7+ 1212x5yz3x3y2z22x1 3z3)YZ Next writing Hi= ( 312X2_(1 + 213)yz)X+ V ( X +21yz)X+. .
, S= x{(1+813)X4+ ( 4l+414)X2yz+(12+215)y2z2}X+ and forming the expression for -xyzH2+VS , the coefficient of xK2 is xyz { 312X2 _(+213)yz}2 +(x2+21yz)x{ ( 1 + 813)4+ ( 41+ 4114)2yz + ( -212+215)y2z2 } , which is = ( 1 + 813)(X7 +6 lx5yz + 12 12X3y2z2 _ xyfz5 ) ; the coefficient of YZ is 2xyz ( 312 y2(I + 213)Z )(312Z _(1+213)xy ) + ( y2+ 2lzx)z{ ( 1 + 813)z4 + ( 41+ 4114)z2xy + ( 212+ 215)X2y2 } + ( z2 + 2lxy)y{(1 +813)V4+(41+ 4114),2zX+ ( -212+215)x2'2 } , MkDCCCLIx .
3 G which is =(I + 811 ) { ty z(y +Z3)+ 8$y3z3+ 1212'eyz(yf+z3 ) + 21 ( y/ + z6 ) 2x3y2z}e or substituting for y3+z3 and y/ + z6 the values -x361xyz and ( X3-l6Xyz)22y3z3 re .
spectively , this is ( 1 + 813)(2lx7+1212x'yz3X3y2z22lXy3z3 ) .
We have thus -xyzH2+VS ( I(+ 813 ) + +(217+ 1212x5yz3X2y2Z2layfZ3)YZ and the equation -xyzHll+VS+ ( I + 813)(QW_ 3X2y2z2mjl ) =0 is thus verified .
Addition.-The foregoing memoir was communicated to Mr. SALMON , and I am indebted to him for two notes , containing the extension to a curve of any order , of the preceding investigation for the case of a cubic ; I reproduce this extension in the following section .
V. Extens on of the last preceding method to a curve of any order .
54 .
Consider the curve of the m-th order T=o , and in the place of the coordinates write Xx+p(X , Xy+(hY , Xz+pZ , where , as before , ( x , y , z ) are the coordinates of the point of the curve , and X , Y , Z current coordinates ; the term involving Ail vanishes , and dividing out the factor d the equation becomes ?
4 -lDU +pX-20D2U +_e-3p2P3U+-xl ?
M-4m3D4U+ &amp; C. = .
Making the like substitution in D2U -_HDU -0 , the assumed equation of the fivepointic conic , the factor w divides out and the equation becomes 2 ?
( m-1)DU+p4D2 U--(P+piH)D2U= 0 , or , what is the same thing , XDU 2(m-l)-P +p(D 2U_ rIDU)= and if from the two equations we eliminate X , A , the result , throwing out the factor DU , is ( D IIJDU)m- ' ( 2(m-l)-P)D2U(D2u -I DU)m2+ &amp;c. = 0 , where all the terms after the second contain the factor DU ; the condition i order that the equation may divide by DU , is consequently 2(m-l)-P=2 , or P=2(m-2 ) , the condition of a three-pointic contact .
Substituting this value , and dividing by DU , the equation becomes hJ(D2U.-[DU)m-2+ ?
D3U(D2UUDU)A-3-_ 4U .
U(D2U IIDU)7-44+ &amp;c. = 0 , which will be divisible by DU if -HD2U+2D3U is divisible by DU , and the condition for this is found to be , as before , IT7=ThE DH+ ADIEU , where A is arbitrary ; we have thus the conditions of a four-pointic contact .
55 .
Substituting this value of HI , we see that DPU-AI DPH .
D2U divides by DU , viz. there exists an identical equation , D3U-HDH .
D2U=IU+J.DU ; and hence if U=O , DU( D. ) , where J is a quadric function of ( X , Y , Z ) .
I do not know the general form of this function , but Mr. SALMON has obtained a result which may be generalized as follows , viz , writing for X , Y , Z the values Bv-Ch , CX-Ay , Ap-Bx ( where , as before , A , B , C are the first derived functions of U and X , 1x , v are arbitrary ) , the expression for J is U ( D3UDH .
D 21)= ( m1 ) ( mI , IO5 a formula which will be presently useful .
56 .
The foregoing equation may be written ( P2U)m-3 ( -t 1D2U +23D3U ) + ( D 2U)mf-4 DU { m2 ) l2 D'U 2 ( m 3)1-ID3U -D4U }+ &amp;c. ( DU ) ' ... .-O ~~~ 0 ; ~~~~~ and the term -IID2U+2D3U is equal to ( D3U DH .
D2U ) -ADU .
D2U =JDU-ADU .
P2U .
Substituting this value the equation divides by DU , and throwing out this factor it becomes ( D2U)m-3(J AD2U ) + ( D2U)m-4 { ( 2 )LI2D2U-*(in--3)IID3U -PD4U }+ &amp;c. DU= O ; or observing that *IHP3U=H2D2U+ term containing DU , this may be written ( D2U)m-3(JAD2U ) + ( D2U)m-4(H2D2U-jD4U)+ &amp;c. DU= 0 .
57 .
If the equation divides by DU we shall have a five-pointic contact ; the condition for this is that -A(DP2U)2 + ?
3JD2U+ I-2D2U ID4U may divide by DU , or more simply that ---A(P2U)2+ 4_JP2U+9DH ) P2U--'D4U may divide by DU , or , what is the same thing , the function in question must vanish in virtue of the substitution of the values BP-Cp , CXAv , AK-B4 in the place of X , Y , A. 3Go2 The expression for J has just been given ; we have besides , 1DH ( Q2 , D 47U=-Qf , where the values of Q3 , Q4 are given ( ante , No. 27 ) ; we have , thus 5 8 .
4J rsu AH.rDu 3(m-2 ) 1 : 58:D3U'H[2 ?
M_ 1 ( &gt; -m-1)H ?
-A('fDH ) -_ 4(mr-2 ) +4 ( r-2)2 0 ' ty1 2 , JH 13(rn-I ) 3 ( rn-I)2 i9 ( rn-I)2 9I -141JU 2(m-2(m-3)H+ ( m-3 )4n D-)n and .
IV2U= ( M i1)2 lit whence IA 1_H2 !
= ( m1)4 213 2 ) D,2MY M-rn1H rnI1-~ry ( rniJ)H{ I+ ( rnm-V ( -2)0 ( --t2 4 )2)@(m I )2H ?
( 74-1)2 H } +a2{_ 2(m-2)(mr3)$H+2 ( m-3 ) I___ ( m1)4 ( rn-I &gt; 4 ' ( rn-I)4 9(D-)4 ( 4TMH)l -9(in I and consequently A= 4(4T3Q11 ) , which agrees with the result before obtained , and thus the present method gives the complete solution of the problem .

