On the Veined Structure of Glaciers ; with observations aupon White Ice-seams , Air-bubbles and -Dirt-bands , and remarks upon Glacier Theories .
By JOHN TYNDALL , FIRS .
, Professor of Natural Philosophay , Royal Institution .
Received February 24 , -Read February 24 , 1859 .
§ 1 .
Introduction .
ON the 20th of May , 1858 , I communicated a paper to the Royal Society , containing an account of observations made upon the Mer de Glace of Chamouni .
In addition to the questions there discussed , another of great importance occupied my attention during my sojourn at the Montanvert , and that was the veined structure of the ice .
To obtain information on this head , I visited almost every portion of the Mer de Glace and its tributaries ; I examined the Talefre and Lechaud glaciers , and spent several days amid the seracs of the Glacier du Geant .
To investigate the connexion , if any , between the structure of the glacier and the stratification of its never I ascended the Col du Geant , and afterwards inspected the magnificent ice-sections exhibited in the dislocations of the Grand Plateau and other portions of Mont Blanc .
During this investigation my convictions were by no means fixed ; cases strongly suggestive of the influence of pressure , in producing the structure , came before me , and again other cases appeared which suggested , with almost equal force , the influence of stratification .
The result , however , of the observations on the Mer de Glace was a strong opinion that pressure was the true cause of the phenomenon .
But I could not help feeling that the facts and arguments which I was in a position to bring forward would still leave the question an open one .
They might influence the opinions of others , as they had influenced mine ; but I had nothing to advance on which the mind could rest with perfect certainty .
In short , neither the Mer de Glace nor its tributaries furnished facts capable of completely deciding the question .
The subject being one on which a great deal had been written and retracted , I was unwilling to swell the bulk of the literature connected with it , while a possibility remained that what I had to say upon the subject might also require withdrawal .
I therefore -thought it better to wait another year ; to extend the range of my observations , to visit glaciers in which the mechanical conditions of strain and pressure were different from those of the Mer de Glace .
Thus by varying the circumstances , and observing Nature at work under different conditions , I hoped to confer upon the investigation the character and precision of an ex~perimental inquiry .
The course of the inquiry in 1858 was as follows:-I first examined the glaciers of Grindelwald ; crossing the Strahleck , I ascended the lower glacier of the Aar to the Grimsel , thence to the glacier of the Rhone , thence to the great Aletsch glacier , in the neighbourhood of which I remained eight days .
I afterwards spent eleven days at the Riffelberg , and explored the entire system of glaciers between the Monte Rosa and Mont Cervin .
I thence proceeded to the Matmark Alp , and remained for five days in the vicinity of the Allalein gla ier I afterwardg visited the Fee glacier , and completed the xpedition by a visit to the Mer de Glace and its tributaries , and a second ascent to the summit of Mont Blanc .
The present paper contains the evidence derived from the sources thus opened to me ; and I shall take these sources in the order in which they come before me ; the evidence is therefore necessarily of a varied character , and it will I think be found conclusive .
Besides those sections which are immediately devoted to the subject of structure , the paper contains others on the cause of the flattening of the air-bubbles in glacier ice , on the problem of glacier motion , and on the origin and cause of the Dirt-bands of the Mer de Glace .
§ 2 .
General Aspect of the Veined Structure .
The general appearance of the veined structure is well known .
The ice of glaciers , especially midway between their mountain sources and their extremities , is of a whitish hue , owing to thenumber of small air-bubbles enclosed in the mass the residue , doubtless of that air which was originally entangled in the snow of which the ice is composed .
Through the general whitish mass , however , at some places , blue veins are drawn , so numerous indeed , in some cases , as to cause the blue ice to predominate over the white .
A laminated appearance is thus conferred upon the ice , the cause of the blueness being , that for some reason or other , the bubbles distributed throughout the general mass do not exist in the veins , or exist there in much smaller numbers .
In different glaciers , and in different portions of the same glacier , these veins exist in different stages of perfection .
On the clean walls of some crevasses , and in the channels worked m the ice by glacial streams , they present a most beautiful appearance. .
They are not to be regarded as a partial phenomenon , or as affecting the constitution of glacier to a small extent only .
Vast masses of some glaciers are thus affected : by far the greater part of the Mer de Glace , and its tributaries , is composed of this laminated ice .
The lower portion of the glacier of the Rhone , from the base of the ice cascade downwards , is entirely composed of it , and numerous similar cases might be cited .
To observe the structure of a glacier it is not even necessary to see the blue veins .
Those who have ascended Snowdon , or wandered among the hills of Cumberland , or even walked in the environs of Leeds or other towns in Yorkshire and Lancashire , where the stratified sandstone of the district is used for architectural purposes , will have observed the exposed edges of the slate rocks , and of the stratified sandstone , to be grooved and furrowed by the action of the weather .
In fact some portions of such rocks withstand the action of the atmosphere better than others , and these more resisting portions stand out in ridges while the softer portions between them are worn away .
An effect exactly similar is observed upon the surface of the glacier .
The laminated ice , exposed to the sun , and to wasting atmospheric influences , melts in a manner similar to the wasting of the rocks ; little grooves and little ridges are formed upon the surface of the glacier , the latter being due to the more resisting ice , while the grooves are produced by the melting of the less resisting mass between them .
The consequence of this is , that the light dirt scattered by winds and avalanches over the surface of the glacier is gradually washed into the little grooves , thus forming fine lines , which to the practised eye are an infallible indication of the structure of the ice underneath .
Visitors to the Jardin have ample occasion to observe these strive , for they are finely shown upon the surface of the Mer de Glace between the Augle and Trelaporte .
When they are followed until they are intersected by a fissure or a stream , it is seen that the superficial groovings always mark the direction of the veined structure within the glacier .
§ 3 .
Structure and Stratification:-Miarginal St 'ructure .
Opinions at present are very diverse as to the origin of these veins .
Professor FORBES first regarded them as being caused by the freezing of water which filled fissures in the ice , but he now discards the notion of freezing , and supposes the " ' incipient fissures " to be closed by " time and cohesion .
" M. AGASSiZ despairs of rendering an account of them , but calls them " bands of infiltration .
" The Messrs. SCHLAGINTWEIT have also treated the question , but with no greater success .
In the paper published by Mr. HUXLEY and myself , pressure is referred to as the probable cause of the phenomenon , but we were unable at the time to furnish proofs of this .
Apart from those who give public expression to their views upon the subject , I know that there are many who reject the pressure theory , and adopt instead of it the explanation that the blue veins of the glacier are merely the continuation of the strata of the never ; a view which has recently been upheld by Mr. JOHN BALL in the Philosophical Magazine .
The matter indeed so stands , that in a recent resume of glacier investigations , Professor MoussON of Zurich omitted the subject of structure altogether , for the express reason that the question is still in complete obscurity .
I will not take up the time of the Society in discussing the vague , involved , and often absurd explanations which have been given of the blue veins of glaciers , but state broadly that the question now rests between the pressure theory , and that of stratificar tion .
Taking the parallel geological phenomena , the question then is , Does the veined structure of glaciers correspond to the stratification or the cleavage of rocks ?
In reply to this question , I will remark , in the first place , that the veins are not always , nor even generally , such as we should expect from stratification .
The latter ought to furnish us with distinct planes extending parallel to each other for great distances through the glacier ; this is by no means the general character of the veins .
We observe blue streaks , some a few inches , some a foot , and some several feet in length upon the walls of the same crevasse , and varying from a fraction of an inch to several inches in thickness .
In many cases the blue spaces are definitely bounded , giving rise to the lenticular structure described by Mr. HUXLEY and myself , but more usually they lose themselves as pale washy streaks in the general mass of the white ice .
In fig. 1I have endeavoured to give an idea of a very common Fig. 1 .
aspect of the veined structure .
Such a structure is not that which we should expect from bedding .
Again , taking the Glacier du Geant as a representative case , we have first of all the slopes of the Col du 'i Geant , the collectors of the snow by which the glacier is formed .
The fissures on these slopes exhibit beautiI { I1 The lines of bedding may be seen as far down as the summit of the great ice-fall between the Rognon and Ii the Aiguille Noire ; and on the castellated masses at the summit of this fall , to which the name seracs has been I applied , the lines of stratification may be distinctly ii| seen .
Escaped from the confusion of the fall , the ( hi glacier flows gently through a long valley towards its A Iii t( Il junction with the Lechaud and Talefre at the Tacul .
Throughout the entire length of this glacier the planes of the structure are vertical or nearly so ; sometimes they dip a little forward , but at other places they dip an equal quantity backward .
Now let the mind figure , if it can , an agency which as the mass descends the fall , shall turn up the horizontal strata of the Col du Geant and set them vertical , without a single break , throughout the entire length of the Glacier du Geant , and I imagine the effort to conceive of such an agency will be followed by the conviction that the change indicated is inconceivable .
Further , we often find , in the central portions of a glacier , the structure feeble , or scarcely developed at all , while at the sides it is well developed .
This is often the case where the glacier moves through a valley of tolerably uniform inclination , and where no medial moraines occur to complicate the phenomenon .
But if the veins mark the bedding , there seems to be no reason why we should not find them as clearly defined at the centre as at the sides ; the fact , however , certainly is that we do not so find them .
Let me here show the true significance of this fact .
If a plastic substance , such as mud , flow down a sloping canal , the central portions will flow more quickly than the lateral ones which are held back by friction .
Now the flow may be so regulated that a circle stamped upon the central portion of such a mud-stream shall move downwards without sensible distortion , thus proving that the central mud is neither compressed nor stretched longitudinally ; for if the former , the circle would be squeezed to an ellipse with its major axis transverse to the axis of the stream ; and if the latter , it would be drawn out to an ellipse with its major axis parallel to the line of flow .
A similar absence of longitudinal compression exists in many glaciers , and in such ice-streams there is no transverse central structure developed .
But let a circle be stamped upon the mud-stream near to its side ; owing to the speedier flow of the centre , this circle must be distorted to an ellipse , because the part.of the circle furthest from the side moves more quickly than the part nearest the side .
Hence we shall have an ellipse formed with its major axis inclined downwards , indicating that the mud is compressed in one direction and expanded in another .
An exactly similar state of things occurs in many glaciers ; the ice near the sides is subjected to a pressure and tension like that here indicated , and we have marginal crevasses as the result of the tension , while the veined structure is , at all events , found associated with the pressure .
Fig. 2 will perhaps render my meaning Fig. 2 .
more intelligible , in which cb , cb represents the sides of a glacier moving in the direction ) of the arrow .
Here , while the central circle retains its shape , the side ones are squeezed ( 0 and drawn out to ellipses .
Marginal crevasses occur parallel to the lines m n , or perpendicular to the tension , while the dotted lines mark the direction of the blue veins which are at right angles , or nearly so , to the crevasses .
I have dotted the line marking the direction of the structure along the margins al , ab .
In connexion with this point , I would refer to the instructive papers of Mr. HoPKINs * , who has shown that in glaciers which move through valleys of uniform width , the directions of maximum pressure and tension are at right angles to each other , each of them enclosing an angle of 45 degrees with the side of the glacier .
I have simply said that the structure in the case described is " associated with the pressure ; " thus confining myself within the strict limits of the facts .
But what has been said shows that the pressure theory affords , at all events , a possible solution of a difficulty , which , without violence to fact , is inexplicable upon the hypothesis of stratification ; the difficulty , namely , that a finely developed structure often exists along the margin of a glacier , while it is excessively feeble , or entirely absent , in the central portions .
§ 4 .
Transverse Structure.-Glaciers of Grindelwald , the Rhone , &amp;c. In many cases , however , the structure is not thus limited to the margins , but sweeps across the glacier from side to side , without interruption , being as well developed at the centre as at the margins .
The stratification theory is wholly incompetent to account for this ; the pressure theory requires that to produce this transverse structure the glacier must , at some portion of its route , have been forcibly compressed longitudinally .
It was not till after my return from the Mer de Glace in 1857 , that the full mechanical significance of a change of inclination in the glacier occurred to me .
Bend a prism of glass , we have compression on one side and extension on the other , with a neutral axis between , the mechanical conditions of the mass being shown by its action on polarized light .
The same is true of any other substance , the concave surface of the bent prism is compressed .
Now at the bases of steep glacier slopes , where the inclination suddenly changes , we have a case of this bending , and along with it a thrust of the mass behind .
The concave surface is turned towards us , and that surface is thrown into a state of compression corresponding to the thrust , and to the change of inclination .
Hence it occurred to me , that the bases of the ice-falls , where the requisite change of inclination occurs , were likely to be the manufactories of the transverse structure .
The experience of 1858 completely verified this idea .
In illustration of my position I will take a representative case ; and to render my observations capable of being easily checked , I will choose one of the most accessible glaciers in the Alps , the lower glacier of Grindelwald .
One portion of this glacier descends from the Viescherh6rner ; but there is another branch which descends from the Schreckhorn , Finsteraarhorn and Strahleck , and it is to this latter branch that I now wish to direct attention .
Walking up this glacier from its place of junction with the tributary from the Viescherh6rner , we come at length to the base of an ice-fall which'forbids further advance upon the ice .
Let the glacier be here forsaken , and let the flanking mountain side , either right or left , be ascended , until a position is attained which affords a complete view of the fall and of the glacier stretching downwards from the base of the fall .
The view from such a position will furnish a key to the development of the transverse structure .
It is , in point of fact , a grand experiment which Nature here submits to our inspection .
The glacier , descending from its neeve , reaches the summit of the fall and is broken transversely as it crosses the brow .
It descends the fall as a succession of broken ; cliffy ridges , with transverse hollows between them .
In these latter the ice debris and the dirt collect , partially choking up the fissures formed in the first instance .
Carrying the eye downwards along the fall , we see , as we approach the base , these sharp ridges toned down , and a little below the base they dwindle into rounded protuberances which sweep , in curves , across the glacier .
At the centre of the fall there is not a trace of the true structure to be observed .
At the base of the fall it begins to appear , -at first feebly , but soon becomes more pronounced ; until finally , at a short distance below the fall , the eye can follow the structural groovings right across the surface of the glacier , while the mass underneath has become correspondingly laminated in the most beautiful manner .
It is difficult to convey , by writing , the force of the evidence which the actual observation of this great experiment places before the mind .
The ice at the base of the fall has to bear the powerful thrust of the descending mass ; but more than this , the sudden change of inclination which it suffers throws its upper portion into a state of violent longitudinal compression .
The protuberances are squeezed more closely together , the hollows between them wrinkle up in submission to the pressure ; the whole aspect of the glacier here gives evidence of the powerful exertion of the latter force ; and exactly at the place where it is exerted , the structure makes its appearance , and being once manufactured , is sent onwards , giving a character to other portions of the ice-stream which have no share in its production .
An illustration , perhaps equally good and equally accessible , is furnished by the glacier of the Rhone .
Above the great icefall which the traveller descending from the Furca has to his right , the horizontal bedding is exhibited in a more or less perfect manner , to a certain depth , upon the walls of the huge and numerous crevasses here existing .
I have also examined this fall from both sides , and an ordinary mountaineer will find no difficulty in reaching a spot nearly opposite the centre of the fall , from which both the fall itself and the glacier below it are distinctly visible .
Here a similar state of things to that already presented to his view reveals itself .
The fall is structureless ; the cliffy ridges are separated from each other by transverse hollows , following each other in succession down the slope ; those ridges are toned down to protuberances at the base of the fall , becoming more and more subdued , until low down the glacier the transverse swellings disappear .
As in the case of the Grindelwald glacier , the squeezing of the protuberances and of the spaces beFig .
3 tween them is visibly manifested .
Where this squeezing F. commences the transverse structure also commences , and t *fi i.i\ t_ n in a very short distance reaches perfection .
All the ice that forms the lower portion of the glacier has to pass through this structure mill at the base of the fall , and the consequence is that it is all laminated .
The case will be better appreciated by reference to figs. 3 and 4 , the former being a sketch , in plan , and the latter a sketch in section of a part of the ice-fall and of the lower portion of the glacier of the Rhone .
ae bf is the gorge of the fall , and fb its base .
The transverse r ridges are shown crossing the fall , being subdued at the base to protuberances , which gradually disappear further KA\ W 'tr f down the glacier .
The " structure " sweeps across the glacier in the direction of the fine curved lines .
On the plan I have also endeavoured to show the radial crevasses of the glacier ; they are at right angles , or StY nearly so , to the structure .
As would be inferred by those acquainted with what I have already written upon u the influence of curvature , the side bcd of the glacier is much more violently crevassed than the sidefgh .
Fig. 4 shows the cliffy ridges of the fall , and of the rounded protuberances below it , in section .
The shading lines below denote the structure .
The protuberances are so MNIDCCCLIX .
2 Q powerfully squeezed in some cases that they scale off at their surfaces .
Fig. 5 is a representation of such scaling off which I have observed at the bases of several cascades , Fig. 4 .
t1%1 ; ~~~t j ~~~~~~~o including those of Grindelwald , the Rhone , the Rognon , and the Tale'fre , each of which has also its " 1 structure mill " at the base of its cascade .
Fig. 5a is an example of scaling off which I have produced by artificial pressure .
Fig. 5 .
It is to be borne in mind that the structure once formed prolongs itself into places which have no part in its formation ; it would therefore be hasty to infer the relationship of structure and pressure from an observation of them at a particular portion of the glacier .
I have sometimes seen the veined structure parallel to the crevasses for a short distance : there are some transverse crevasses on the Glacier du Geant -a little above Trelaporte which illustrate this ; but it would be altogether erroneous to infer from this that the law which makes the structure perpendicular to the pressure , and hence , as a general rule , transverse to the crevasses , finds an exception here .
It is perfectly manifest that the structure which is brought into this unusual relationship to the crevasses has been developed far higher up ; that the change of conditions from longitudinal pressure to longitudinal strain is too weak and transitory to obliterate it .
To effect obliteration , a forci commensurate with that which produced the structure must be brought into play , and at the place now referred to no such force exists .
The Aletsch Glacier .
Having made the foregoing observations upon the glacier of the Rhone , I proceeded to the Aletsch glacier , and during a residence of eight days at the hotel upon the slope of the ?
ggischhorn , made frequent excursions upon the ice .
I had never previously seen this grand ice-stream , and my interest in it , at the time of my visit , was greatly augmented by the arguments which Mr. JOHN BALL had founded upon its deportment against the pressure theory of the veined structure .
I shall here limit myself to a few brief remarks upon this subject .
I have already stated , and this must be particularly remembered , that the veined structure often appears in places which have no share in its production .
The longitudinal structure in the centre of the stream of the Aletsch , for four miles above the base of the AXggischhorn , is not due to the lateral pressure endured by the glacier during these four miles .
It is due , as Mr. BALL himself suggests , to the mutual thrust of the branch glaciers , which unite to form the trunk stream ; and , once formed by this thrust , it perpetuates itself throughout a great portion of the trunk stream .
But it is urged against this view , that pressure exerted in new directions the longitudinal pressure , for example , endured by the stream in its descent , and acting through long periods , ought , -if pressure has the power ascribed to it , to obliterate the first structure .
Now here , again , it must be remembered that it is the portions of the ice near the bed of the glacier that yield , and that the upper portions of the ice , in many cases , are simply floated upon the moving under portions .
Were the uniform " long reach " referred to by Mr. BALL strictly examined , it would , in all probability , be found that the ice near the surface is no more compressed than a log of timber would be if placed upon the glacier , and permitted to share its motion downwards .
I may sum up by saying that a close examination of the glacier satisfied me , not only that it presented no phenomena which were at variance with the pressure theory , but also exhibited some which , as far as I could see , were perfectly fatal to the theory of stratification .
The state of Fig. 6 .
Base of EIyisIorn / f % / ye tin se , S ; 2ii _f_ I the ice at the base of the I-ggischhorn , as shown in fig. 6 , is certainly quite in harmony with the pressure theory ; another fact observed upon the glacier shall be referred to at a future page .
§ 6 .
Glaciers of Monte Rosa .
I will next endeavour to describe the phenomena of structure exhibited in the system of glaciers in the neighbourhood of Monte Rosa .
The general mechanical conditions of these glaciers will be evident to an observer stationed upon the G6rner G(rat , a point of view well known to travellers , and famous for the magnificence of the panorama which it commands .
As the observer stands here , facing Monte Rosa , the great Gorner glacier , coming down from the heights of the old Weissthor at his left , flows beneath him .
It is joined , in its course , by a series of glaciers from the sides of the opposite range of mountains .
First of all comes the western glacier of Monte Rosa , which really ought to give its name to the trunk stream , as it is the most considerable of its tributaries .
Into the glacier of Monte Rosa , and before the latter reaches the trunk valley , a glacier from the Twins , Castor and Pollux , pours its contents .
Afterwards we have the Schwarze glacier , which lies between the Twins and the Breithorn ; then the Trifti glacier , which lies upon the flank of the Breithorn , and afterwards the glaciers of the little Mont Cervin and of St. Theodule .
The accompanying sketch ( fig. 7 ) will render intelligible what I have to say regarding these glaciers .
Fig. 7 .
Mbnre .
Rosa Castor -Follux rei-thrn y'\~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~Peltlfont Cervini N'~~~~~~N / ll Slln tljA2L ; 1~ The small Gornerhorn glacier , which comes down the sides of Monte Rosa , 'is a very singular one .
In comparison with the western glacier of Monte Rosa its mass is insignificant , and it is abruptly cut off by the latter along the line a b , amoraine occurring here , which may be regarded as forming , at once , the terminal moraine of the one glacier and the lateral moraine of the other .
Thus the smaller glacier coming down the mountain side abuts against its more powerful neighbour , and we should infer from the inspection of the glacier that its terminus is subjected to great pressure .
Let the observer now suppose himself transported to the G6rnerhorn glacier , at some 'distance above the terminal moraine a b ; he will find there the transverse structure , if at all developed , excessively feeble and defective ; let him now walk downwards towards the moraine a b : every step he takes brings him to a place where the ice is subjected to a greater pressure , and every step also brings him to a better structure : both phenomena go hand in hand .
At the end of the glacier , alongside the terminal moraine and under it , the structure is finely developed .
If the observer now cross the glacier and ascend the rocks called Atuf der Plate , from which he can command a near view of the Gdrnerhorn glacier , and embrace a large portion of it , he will be able to observe the gradual perfecting of the structure as the region of pressure is approached .
Towards the extremity of the glacier the surface becomes wrinkled , the groovings denoting the structure become more and more pronounced , the dirt strive being more closely squeezed together ; and from these external aspects he may infer , with certainty , the gradual perfecting of structure within the glacier .
The western glacier of Monte Rosa next commands our attention .
This great stream occupies the valley between Monte Rosa and the Lyskamm , receiving the snows of the opposite sides of both .
The branch of the Gdrner glacier coming down from the Weissthor throws itself across the flow of its powerful neighbour , and deflects the latter , both of them afterwards moving together down the trunk valley , with a moraine , as usual , between them .
Before quitting the " 1 Plate , " we will suppose that the observer has endeavoured to form some idea of the mechanical conditions of the Monte Rosa glacier .
He would see the mass arrested in its descent by the G6rner glacier , and compelled to accompany the latter .
A certain component of the weight of the glacier is borne by the ice where it comes into contact with the G6rner glacier .
The observer would infer , from mere inspection , that if the structure be due to pressure , it ought to be most fully developed near the moraine which separates the Monte Rosa from the Gbrner glacier .
If he now pass from the " ' Plate " to the ice , and cross to the centre of the Monte Rosa glacier to A , he will find the structure there excessively feeble , if at all developed .
Let him now walk straight down the glacier towards B , where the pressure is most intense .
Every step he takes downwards brings him to more perfectly veined ice ; and I am not acquainted with a more splendid example of laminated structure than that exhibited by this glacier along the moraine , and for some distance from it , at its southern side .
The system of glaciers which next come under review are exceedingly instructive .
In no place in the whole range of the Alps are the effects of pressure and the phenomena of structure more strikingly exhibited .
I have endeavoured , in the sketch , to render the aspect of these glaciers intelligible .
The Schwarze glacier moves down a steep mountain slope , and welds itself to the Monte Rosa glacier at the bottom .
But the great mass of this latter enables it to pursue its way without being compelled to swerve sensibly by its feebler neighbour .
The latter is forced to bend abruptly , and from a wide irregularly-shaped field of never , it is squeezed between the Trifti and the Monte Rosa glaciers to the narrow band represented in the figure , and moves thus downwards .
The Trifti glacier itself is perhaps a still more striking illustration of the power of ice to yield when subjected to pressure for a long period .
The aspect of the real glacier is much the same as that shown upon the sketch .
It also is compelled to change its direction , and to flow as a narrow stripe along the trunk valley , being hemmed in between the strip of the Schwarze glacier and that of the glacier of the little Mont Cervin .
A beautiful system of bands is to be seen at the lower portion of this glacier .
The inspection of the sketch will show better than words the modifications of shape which the lower portion of the glaciers undergo by the pressure of their higher portions , and the resistance of the trunk stream .
They are turned aside , firmly welded together , and form a series of parallel narrow bands , separated from each other by moraines .
They are all well seen either from the G6rnergrat or the summit of the Riffelhorn .
I have examined each of these glaciers , and find the same to be true of all of them .
High up the structure is feeble ; as we descend it becomes more pronounced , and at the places where the tributaries join the trunk , and the ice has to bear the full thrust of the mass behind it , we have a finely developed structure .
§ 7 .
Coexistence of Structure and Stratification.-The Furgye Glacier .
The evidence of the association of pressure and glacier lamination which I have thus far laid before the Society , will , I think , be admitted to be very strong .
I have no hesitation in saying that the stratification theory has nothing to urge at all to be compared with it in point of cogency .
Still I cannot help feeling how a critical and well-informed mind might weaken the force of what I have adduced .
Difficult as the conception is , it might be urged that the structure , so fully developed near the margins of glaciers , may be due to a turning up of the strata edgeways , in consequence of a wide never being squeezed into a narrow channel , -just as a sheet of paper , if forced through a groove less than itself in width , would turn up at its edges .
It might also be urged that the structure developed alongside and under the medial moraines , is due to the placing side by side of these folded-up strata ; the perfect welding of both and the clearer development of the structure being conceded as possible consequences of the mutual pressure .
This indeed is Mr. BALL'S view of the subject ; and M. AGASSiZ assumes such a folding-up of the strata of the Unteraar glacier .
With regard to the transverse structure also , it might be said that we do not know how the interior of the mass is affected in descending the ice-falls .
The mind , it is true , finds great difficulty in conceiving of any agency which could set the strata which were horizontal above the fall , vertical below it ; still this difficulty may be due to our ignorance of the mechanical conditions of the mass during its descent .
In this way it would be quite possible to fritter away conviction to a mere opinion , and hence arose a strong desire on my part , either to confirm these surmises , or to place the pressure theory , once for all , beyond the power of such attacks .
One conclusive observation is still wanting to establish the analogy between glacier lamination and the cleavage of slate rocks .
In the latter case the arrangement of the strata has been traced by their organic remains ; and , indeed , stratification has often been visibly exhibited coexistent with cleavage , both crossing each other at a high angle .
If a similar state of things could be detected upon a glacier , it would at once lay the axe to the root of all the scruples above referred to , and place the pressure theory upon an unassailable basis .
The consciousness of this was sufficient to stimulate me in the search of such evidence .
I had visited all the glaciers hitherto mentioned , and others not mentioned , without obtaining more than one clear case of the kind : this case I observed upon the Aletsch glacier on the 6th of August .
Not far from the junction of the Middle Aletsch glacier with the trunk stream , a crevasse exposed a wall of ice 50 or 60 feet in height , upon which the stratification was exposed , and cutting the stratification at a high angle were the groovings which marked the true veined structure .
The association was distinct ; my friend Professor RAMSAY was with me at the time ; I drew his attention to the fact , and to him the case was perfectly conclusive .
Thus the Aletsch glacier , which had been referred to by Mr. BALL as furnishing evidence against the pressure theory , gave us a fact , which , as far as I could see , was perfectly fatal to the theory of stratification .
But the case was solitary , and although inspiriting at the moment , its effect upon the mind became feeble as time passed , and no repetition of the observation occurred .
I had remained at the Riffel from the 9th to the 18th of August , exploring all the adjacent -glaciers , and adding each day to my stock of knowledge ; but I met no case in which the structure and the bedding were so clearly and independently exhibited , as to leave an adherent of the stratification theory no room for doubt .
Wednesday the 18th of August was to be my last day at the Riffel , and it was devoted to the examination of the Furgge glacier , which occupies the space between the pass of St. Theodule and the Matterhorn .
Crossing the valley of the Gorner glacier , I climbed the opposite mountain slope , and passing the Schwarze See , soon came upon the glacier referred to .
I walked up it until I found myself in a kind of cul de sac , flanked by precipitous ice-slopes , and opposed in front by a cascade composed of four high terraces of ice .
The highest terrace was composed principally of broken cliffs and peaks of ice , and it had let some of its frozen boulders fall upon the platform of the second terrace , where they stood like rockingstones on the [ point of falling .
The whole space at the foot of the fall was covered with quantities of crushed ice , while some coherent masses , upwards of 200 cubic feet in volume , were cast to a considerable distance down the glacier .
Upon the face of the terraces the stratification of the never was beautifully shown .
Above the fall the never extends as a frozen plain , quite undisturbed , so that the bedding took place with great regularity ; and being broken through for the first time at the summit of the fall , the lines of stratification were peculiarly well defined and beautiful .
Towards the right of the fall , looking upwards , this was particularly the case ; for here no pressure had been exerted upon the beds sufficient to contort them or to rupture their continuity .
The figure of a vast lake pouring its waters over a rocky barrier , which curves convexly upwards , thus causing the water to rush down it , not only longitudinally over the vertex of the curve , but also laterally over its two arms , will convey to the mind a tolerably correct conception of the appearance of the fall .
Towards the centre the ice was powerfully squeezed ; the beds were bent , and their continuity often ruptured , so as to exhibit faults ; but they were as plain , and as easily traced , as in any other portion of the fall .
I thought I saw structural groovings running at a high angle to the stratification .
Had the question been an undisputed one I should have felt sure of this , for the groovings were such as always mark the structure .
The place being dangerous , I first observed it from a little distance through my opera-glass ; but at length , resigning the instrument to my guide , and leaving him to watch the tottering blocks overhead , and to give me warning in case of their giving way , I went forward to the base of the fall , peeled the grooved surface away with my axe , and found the true veined structure underneath , running , in this case , nearly at right angles to the stratification .
The superficial groovings were not uniformly distributed over the whole face of the terrace , but occurred here and there where the ice had yielded most to the pressure .
I examined several of these places , and in each instance found the superficial grooving to be the exponent of the true veined structure underneath , the structure being in general nearly vertical , while the lines of bedding were horizontal .
The coarse bands which marked the division of the beds were also seen underneath , when the surface of the ice was removed .
Having perfectly , and with deliberation , satisfied myself of these facts , I made a speedy retreat ; for the ice blocks were most threatening , and the time of day that at which they fall most frequently .
We now resolved to try the ascent of the glacier to the right ; it was much riven , but perfectly practicable to a good iceman .
To me it was also perfectly delightful ; in fact , as regards the relationship of structure and stratification , this glacier taught me more than all the others I had visited taken together .
Our way lay through fissures which exposed magnificent sections , and every step forward added further demonstration to what I had already observed at the base of the fall .
The bedding was perfectly distinct , and the structure equally so , the one being at a high angle-sometimes at a right angle to the other .
Among these crevasses the pressure was in some cases greater than on the fall , and the structure proportionally more pronounced .
The crumpling of the beds demonstrated the exercise of the pressure , and the structure went straight through such crumplings , thus furnishing me with numerous parallels to the case observed by Professor S"EDGWICK , Mr. SORBY , and others , of the passage of slaty cleavage through contorted beds .
Indeed I question whether the phenomena of cleavage and bedding , in the case of slate rocks , were ever exhibited , side by side , with a distinctness equal to that of the stratification and " structure " of ice in the present instance .
Fig. 9 represents a crumpled portion of the ice , with the lines of lamination passing through those of bedding at a high angle .
Fig. 10 represents a case where a fault Fig. 9 .
, \\N\ I_ Fig. 10 .
OIL/ occurred , the veins at both sides of the line of dislocation ab being inclined towards each other .
The lines inn , mn represent of course the lines of bedding , and the lines crossing them the structure .
These observations are conclusive as regard the claims of the rival theories of structure and stratifications .
§ 8 .
On the Thite Ice-seams of the Glacier dut Geant , and their relation to the Veined Structure .
From an elevated point at Trelaporte I observed a remarkable system of white bands sweeping across the Glacier du Gleant in the direction of the structure .
From one of the moraines near the junction of the three tributary glaciers , the same system of bands present a very striking appearance .
They consist of a hard white ice , more resistant than the general mass of the glacier , and in some cases rising to a height of three or four feet above the surface .
On close examination I found that they penetrated the Fig. 11 .
glacier only to a limited depth .
In fig. 11 I have given the sections of two of these While correcting this proof , I find a case of this kind figure~d by M. AGAssiz in the atlas to his I Syst'eme Glacia~ire , ' pl. 8 .
fig. 3 .
veins , about 15 feet deep , which were exposed on the walls of a crevasse high up the glacier .
They constituted a kind of inverted glacier trap , and I was led to a knowledge of their origin in the following way .
In one of my earliest visits to the base of the ice-fall of the Talefre , I observed a curious disposition of the veined structure on the walls of some of the crevasses : fig. 12 represents one case of the kind , and fig. 13 another , and numerous similar ones find a place Fig. 12 .
-E &lt; Fig. 13 .
I~ in my note-book .
In the former case the veins fell backward as well as forward , being vertical through the central portion of the curve .
In fig. 13 the position of the veins varies in a very short distance from the vertical to the horizontal .
I found that the portions of ice which showed the phenomena , formed , when seen from a point of view sufficiently commanding , a part of a system of crumples or protuberances which swept round the base of the fall , between the moraine which descends along it from the Jardin , and its highest lateral moraine .
I have already referred to the protuberances which sweep across the Strahleck branch of the Lower Grindelwald glacier , and of those of the glacier of the Rhone : those to which I now refer were of the same character .
Right and left from the position where the crumples were most pronounced they gradually became subdued , shading off to a mere undulating surface ; the sides of a crevasse intersecting this surface longitudinally presented the structural arrangement shown in fig. 14 .
It will be observed that the directions of the veins change in accordance with the undulations of the surface .
Supposing the squeezing of the mass to become so violent that the gentle undulations shall become steep crumples , the deviation of the structure from parallelism with itself would , of course , be augmented .
This prepares us to understand the exact phenomena observed at the base of the Talekfre cascade .
Fig. 15 represents a series of crumples following each other in succession at the place referred to ; at the base of each I found a vein of white ice , a , a , wedged into the mass .
This interrupted the continuity of the structure ; the abrupt change in its direction at opposite sides of the white band being , as shown in the figure , in every case observed .
I found that the width of the seams was exceedingly irregular , varying , at different portions of the same seam , between 6 inches and 3 or 4 feet .
I also found that a seam sometimes became forked so as to form two branches which thinned gradually off until 1~~~~~~-7 they finally vanished .
Fig. 16 is an example of this kind : the seam was divided at the point a ; one of its branches ran UP the face of the crumple , thinned off and disappeared at 6 ; the other widened considerably , but finally thinned off and also vanished .
Along the bases of the crumples the fillets of water which poured down their faces Fig. 16 .
/ 0 were collected and flowed .
The streams thus formed ran in many cases alongside the existing veins of white ice , and had worn for themselves deep channels in the glacier .
The thought soon suggested itself , that the seams themselves were formed by the gorging up of those channels by snow in winter , and the subsequent consolidation of this snow during the descent of the glacier .
Indeed the channels of the streams seemed the exact matrices of the seams of white ice .
* The fact of one branch of a vein running up the face of a crumple , seems to prove that the ice , which at one time constitutes the base of a crumple , does not always remain so ; the bases of the crumples are sometimes lifted up by the squeezing .
The horizontal structure at the fronts of many of the crumples seems due to a local forcing forward of one protuberance over that next below it .
Were the matter tested by strict measurement , I think it would be found that different portions of the crumples move downwards with different velocities .
According to this view , upon the general motion of the glacier there are local motions superposed .
afterwards traced the seams of white ice of the Glacier du Geant to their origin amid the ridges and hollows at the base of the great ice-fall of Le Rognon .
In some cases the seams opened out into two branches , which , after remaining for some distance separate , would unite again so as to enclose a little glacial island ; at other places lateral branches were thrown off from the principal seam , presenting the form of a glacier stream which had been fed by tributary branches .
Fig. 17 is the plan of an actual Fig. 17 .
stream observed at the base of the ice-fall ; fig. 18 is the plan of a seam of white ice Fig. 18 .
observed the same day lower down the glacier ; their relationship is evident .
I may remark that I have observed other seams produced by the gorging of crevasses with snow , and the subsequent closure of the fissures .
Considering the place where they are formed , these channels cannot escape compression ; but let me remove all uncertainty on this point , by proving that not only at the base of the seracs , but throughout almost its entire length , the Glacier du Geant is in a state of longitudinal compression .
The first proof I have to offer is that the transverse undulations of the glacier , to which reference has been so often made , become gradually shorter as they descend .
A series of three of them , measured along the axis of the glacier on the 6th of August 1857 , gave the following respective lengths-955 , 855 , and 770 links , the shortest undulation being the furthest down the glacier .
Now these undulations , as I shall subsequently show , are due to a regularly recurrent action , and are doubtless originally of the same length ; that the lower ones are shorter than the higher must therefore be due to compression .
The following observation is , however , more conclusive .
About three-quarters of a mile above the Tacul , and to the left as we ascend , there is a green patch upon the craggy mountain side .
From this spot , as a station , I set out with a theodolite a line ( No. 1 ) transverse to the axis of the glacier .
From a station lower down , chosen in a couloir along which the stones are discharged from the end of a secondary glacier which hangs upon the slope of Mont Tacul , I set out a second line ( No. 2 ) transverse to the axis of the glacier .
A third line ( No. 3 ) was set out across the glacier about a quarter of a mile still lower* .
The mean daily motion of the centres of these three lines is given in the annexed Table , and also their distances apart .
Mean daily motion of three points upon the axis of the Glacier du Geant .
inches .
Distances apart .
No 1..I 2055 2477 links .
No. 2 ... 1543 No. 3. .
1275 } 2215links .
The advance of the hinder lines upon these in front is most strikingly shown by these measurements ; and the proof that the Glacier du Geant is in a state of longitudinal compression is thus complete .
Here then we have a vast ice press , and here we have the pure snow filling the transverse channels of the streams .
We are thus furnished with an experimental test on a grand scale of the pressure theory of the veined structure .
In 1857 I examined a great number of these seams of white ice , and found in many of them a finely developed lenticular structure .
In 1858 I also examined the seams , and found some of them " ribboned " in the most exquisite manner by the blue veins ; indeed I had never seen the veins more sharply and beautifully developed .
This structmre was observed in portions of the seams at and near the centre of the glacier , where the differential motion observed at the sides does not exist .
This fact , I think , throws grave difficulties in the way of any theory which makes the veined structure dependent on differential emotion , and more especially a theory which requires " a a very considerable amount of this differential motion to produce any sensible degree of stratification in the vesicles .
" § 9 .
On the flatteninlq of Air-bubbles in Glacier Ice , and its relation to the Veined Structure .
Those who have given their attention to the subject , know that the bubbles contained in glacier ice are , in general , not spherical , but flattened ; and that from their shape conclusions of the greatest import have been drawn regarding the internal pressures of glaciers .
M. AGASSiZ draws attention to this subject in the following words:- " The air-bubbles undergo no less curious modifications ; in the neighbourhood of the never , where they are most numerous , those which one sees on the surface are all spherical or ovoid , but by degrees they begin to be flattened , and near the end of the glacier there are some that are so flat that they might be taken for fissures when seen in Profile .
The drawing , fig. 10 , represents a piece of ice detached from the gallery of infiltration ; all the bubbles are greatly flattened .
But what is most extraordinary is , that far from being uniform , the.flattening is different in each fragment ; so that the bubbles , according to the face which they offer , appear either very broad or very thin .
I know of no more significant fact than this , since it demonstrates that each frayqnent of ice is capable of undergoing in the interior of the glacier a proper displacement independently of the movement of the whole .
" The same flattening of the bubbles , " continues M. AGASSiZ , " 1 is found at a greater depth .
While engaged in my boring experiments , I observed attentively the fragments of ice brought up by the borer .
I found in them almost flat bubbles , perfectly similar to those of the fragment figured above , at all depths from 10 to 65 metres .
It follows hence that a strong pressure is exercised on the interior of the glacier .
" The description of the " flattening " here given is correct : all observers agree in corroborating it , and every observer with whom I am acquainted draws substantially the same conclusion from the phenomenon that M. AGASSIZ does .
Professor THOMsON'S speculation upon the subject is particularly refined and ingenious .
Mr. JOHN BALL converts the flattening of the bubbles into evidence against the pressure theory of the structure in the following way:- " As AGASSiZ has pointed out , " writes Mr. BALL , " and I have frequently verified his observations upon this point , though the air-cavities show traces of compression reducing them to the form of flattened lenses , the directions in which they are flattened are most various , and show no constant relationship to the planes of the veined structure .
Here then we have direct evidence that separate portions of the ice have been acted upon by pressure sufficient in amount to modify their internal arrangement , but that these pressures have not acted in the same , or nearly the same direction .
" Granting the inference that the observed flattening " efurnishes direct evidence " of pressure , the foregoing argument would , I confess , be a very formidable one .
If the bubbles are thus flattened by pressure , and if the veined structure , as I contend be the result of pressure , and approximately at right angles to the direction of the force , we ought to have the bubbles squeezed out in planes parallel to the structure .
The fact that the bubbles are not so squeezed out , would then afford a strong presumption that the structure is not produced by pressure .
I expect , however , to be able to prove that the shape of the bubbles is not a " ; direct evidence " of pressure , as hitherto assumed ; and 1 think , as I do so , it will be seen how necessary it is to associate experiment withan inquiry of this kind , if we would read aright our observations .
In a paper in the Philosophical'rransactions on the Physical Properties of Ice , I have shown that when a sunbeam traverses a mass of ice , the latter melts at innumerable points in the track of the beam , and that each portion melted assumes the form , not of a globule , but of a flower of six petals .
The planes in which these flowers are formed are independent of the shape of the mass and of the direction of the beam through it ; they are always formed parallel to the surface offreezing .
This is a natural consequence of the manner in which the particles of ice are set together by the crystallizing force .
By the slow abstraction of heat from water its particles build themselves into these little stars , and by the introduction of heat into a mass so built the architecture is taken down in a reverse order .
In watching the formation of artificial ice , by the machine of Mr. HARRISON referred to in my paper , I have seen little solid stars formed , by freezing , which were the exact counterparts of the little liquid stars formed by melting .
So far as I can see , the complementary character of the phenomena is perfectly natural , and presents no difficulty to the mind in conceiving of it .
When the beam is intense , and its action continued for some time , the flowers expand , so as to form liquid plates within the mass .
Looked at edgeways , these liquid spaces appear like fine lines ; which proves that the melting is not symmetrical laterally and vertically , but that the ice melts in the planes of freezing much more readily than at right angles to these planes .
If an air-bubble exists within ice , and if the ice melts at the concave surface of this bubble , as might be expected from the foregoing facts , the ice will so yield that the composite cell of air and water will not be spherical , even though the bubble of air may originally have been so .
In the planes of freezing the mass yields most readily , and the cavity containing the air and water will appear as if flattened by a force acting _perpedicular to these planes .
This is not a deduction merely , but an observation which I have made in a hundred different cases .
What I have here said applies to ordinary lake ice ; but glacier ice has no definite " planes of freezing .
" The substance is first snow , which sometimes , it is true , falls regularly in six-rayed crystals , as observed by myself on the summit of Monte Rosa ; but it is usually disturbed by winds , while falling , and whirled and tossed by the same agency after it has fallen ; the mountain snow is often melted , mixed with water and refrozen .
Even after it has become consolidated it is often shattered in descending precipitous slopes .
In such ice definite planes of crystallization are , of course , not to be expected .
If wre suppose a mass of lake ice to be broken up into fragments , and these fragments thrown together confusedly and reyelated in their new positions to a continuous mass , we have an exact image of the character of the glacier ice in which thisflattening of ?
the bubbles int different directions has been observed .
In the paper already referred to , I have given a sketch of a piece of ice composed of such segments , and have described the effects obtained with it .
That ice was sold to me as Norway lake ice .
I am not aware whether glacier ice is ever imported into this country from Norway ; but if it be , the piece in question must , I think , have belonged to it .
It is so like all the glacier ice that I have examined since that time , and so unlike all the lake ice , that I feel little hesitation in saying that it belonged to the former A. No matter how coherent and optically continuous a mass of ice may be , a condensed sunbeam would at once tell us whether it belonged to a lake or to a glacier .
* Perhaps formed from the connecting together of confused fragments .
have given in fig. 19 a sketch of a piece of ice taken from the end of the great Allalein glacier , on the Swiss side of the Monte Moro .
On reference to M. AGAssiz 's figure , it will be quite maniFib .
19 fest that we are both dealing with the same phenomenon ; we have the division of the ice into " 1 angular fragments , " o the flattening of the " bubbles , " and the non-parallelism of their directions in the different fragments .
Fig. 20 is a sketch of a piece of ice which showed the 0D veined structure .
The line AB was parallel to the veins , \0 and it will be seen that the " bubbles " are inclined to this line at different angles , and in different azimuths .
The circles indicate , of course , that the " bubbles " were there parallel to the horizontal face of the slab , while the lines indicate that they were perpendicular .
In one case the bubbles are seen in plan , in the other case in section .
The ellipses show the bubbles foreshortened where their planes are oblique to the surface of the slab .
Associated with the air-bubbles , and usually beyond comparison Fig. 20 .
more numerous in ice taken from the " ends " of glaciers , were the A/ round liquid disks which I have described in my paper on the Physical Properties of Ice .
Associated with each liquid disk was a / // / yacwuous spot , which shone with exceeding lustre when the sunbeams { 7 o , fell upon it .
That the spots were vacuous , and not bubbles of air , I | , o , proved by permitting them to collapse under warm water ; the cob | lapse was complete , and no trace of air arose from them .
Ho These , I doubt not , are the " bubbles " observed by M. AGASSJZ | " 4near the end of the glacier , " and which were " so flat that they Xii might be taken for fissures when seen in profile .
" These " vacuum disks , " as I have usually called them , were invaluable as indicators of the planes of crystallization .
When a condensed sunbeam was sent through the mass , the six-petalled flowers , l ?
which always indicate the planes referred to , started into existence jQ parallel to the disks .
Consequently , as the beam passed through different fragments , flowers were formed in different planes , along Bo A the track of the beam .
True air-bubbles , associated with water , also occurred in these masses of ice , and such composite cells were always flattened out in the planes of the vacuum disks .
The fact then is that many of the so-called air-bubbles are not air-bubbles at all , and that the so-called " Jflatten ing " is in reality no flattening at all ; and that pressure , in the sense hitherto conceived , has had nothing whatever to do with the shape of these bubbles .
In glacier ice , as in lake ice , their shape is determined by the crystalline architecture .
The conclusion that they were squeezed flat seems to have been drawn by M. AGASSIZ , and reproduced by subsequent writers , without due regard to the difficulties associated with it .
That the pressures of a glacier are so parcelled out as to squeeze contiguous frayments of ice , not exceeding a cubic inch in size , in all possible directions , is so improbable , that reflection alone must throw great difficulties in the way of its acceptance .
It is with some diffidence that I here venture to express an opinion upon a question that I have not specially examined ; but it appears to me probable that the decomposition of glacier ice into large granules , regarding which so much has been written , may be connected with the foregoing facts .
The ice of glaciers is sometimes disintegrated to a great depth ; causing it to resemble an aggregate of jointed polyhedra more than a coherent solid .
I was very near losing my life in 1857 on the Col du Geant by trusting to such ice ; and last summer I found vast masses of it at the end of the Allalein glacier .
Blocks a cubic yard and upwards in volume , fell to pieces to their very centres on being overturned ; they were an aggregate of granules , whose average volume scarcely exceeded a cubic inch .
From the constitution which the foregoing observations assign to glacier ice , this disintegration seems natural .
The substance is composed of fragments which are virtually crystallized in different planes ; and it is not to be expected that the union along the surfaces , though they may be invisible when the ice is sound , is as intimate as that among the different parts of a mass homogeneously crystallized .
Besides , ice no doubt , and all uniaxal crystals , expands by an augmentation of temperature , differently in different directions , and hence a differential motion of the particles on both sides of one of the above surfaces when the volume of the substance is changed by heat or cold is unavoidable .
Such surfaces then would become surfaces of discontinuity , and perhaps produce that granular condition which has occupied so much of the attention of observers .
§ 1-0 .
Phiysical Analysis of the Veined Structure .
The relation of pressure and structure has been shown in the foregoing pages , but the mode in which the pressure acts remains yet to be considered .
As regards their causes , slaty cleavage and slaty structure have been reduced to one and the same ; but as regards the operation of that cause , no two things can , I imagine , in some respects at least , be more different .
In a note at page 336 of the 'Proceedings of the Royal Society ' for January 1857 , I refer to an experiment in which a clear mass of ice was caused by pressure to resemble a piece of fissured gypsum , and I there promised the full details of the experiment in due time .
In my paper on the Physical Properties of Ice this promise is fulfilled ; I have shown how a mass of compact ice may be liquefied by pressure , in parallel planes perpendicular to the direction of the force , and explained the effect by reference to the ingenious deductions of Mr. JAMES THOMSON from CARNOT'S maxim .
Let the attention now be fixed on the state of a glacier at the base of one of the MLDCCCLIX .
2 s ice-falls where it is bent so as to throw its surface into a state of longitudinal compression .
According to the above experiments , the glacier whose temperature is 32 ?
FAHR. must here be liquefied in fats , perpendicular to its axis .
A liquid connexion is thus established between all the air-bubbles which are intersected by any one flat , and a means for the escape of this air from the glacier is thus furnished .
The water produced is also partially expressed , partially absorbed by capillary attraction of the adjacent bubble ice , and partially refrozen when the pressure is relaxed .
It is , I think , perfectly manifest that such a process , each step of which may be illustrated by experiment , must result in the formation of the blue veins* .
All the experiments and observations recorded in the paper on the Physical Properties of Ice were made with reference to the glaciers , and one experiment there recorded illustrates the present point more forcibly than any words could do , -it is that in which I have thrown a prism of ice into a state of compression , which brings one side of it into the exact condition of the glacier at the base of an ice-fall .
Fig. 21 is precisely the Fig. 21 .
V/ / , ~ ~~~/ IIi I~~~~7 ~~p tl ~~~~~~ '7 Fig. 22 .
CA/ 7 II ) p same as that given at page 226 of my paper , the prism being placed horizontal instead of vertical , so as to show its bearing upon the present point more distinctly .
The original shape of the piece of ice is given in fig. 22 , which by compression between the surfaces AB and CD is reduced to the shape and condition of fig. 21 .
The vertical lines represent the planes of liquefaction , and they correspond exactly to the planes of the blue veins in the glacier .
The application of the same principles to all cases where pressure comes into play is sufficiently obvious .
In the experiments with the hydraulic press , the portion of ice between each two liquefied flats transmits the pressure without sensible yielding .
We have no difficulty in conceiving that the same holds true of glacier ice , and that pressure may be transmitted through one portion of a bubbled mass of ice and produce the liquefaction of another portion , without sensible distortion of the bubbles contained in the former .
One of the objections which have been urged against the pressure theory is thus , I conceive , completely answered , the objection , namely , that the white ice which transmits the pressure ought to have its bubbles flattened .
Indeed this objection continued to be of weight only so long as it was imagined that the observed flat bubbles had been squeezed to this shape ; a notion , which I think will no longer be entertained .
Renarks on Glacier Motion .
It is only by slow degrees that .
we master from actual observation , a problem so large as that presented by the glaciers ; the muscular labour alone being such as to render the expenditure of a considerable amount of time unavoidable .
The examination of the various questions connected with glaciers , has been therefore , in my case , distributed over some years , and not until last summer was I able to devote the requisite attention to the subject of the present section , which , however , is essential to a right comprehension of the physics of glacier motion .
It would be a problem eminently worthy of any geologist , to lay down upon a trustworthy map of Switzerland the directions of the striap on the rocks over which ancient glaciers have moved ; and to one who sees its importance and desires exact information upon this subject , it must be a matter of surprise that nothing of the kind , in a systematic way , has yet been attempted .
A suitable map furnished with such lines of direction , carefully and conscientiously drawn , would impart more satisfactory information than all the volumes that ever have been , or ever will be written upon the subject .
Here is a piece of work loudly calling for accomplishment , and one on which any young geologist may base an honourable reputation .
Mr. HoPxINs , I believe , was the first to urge the existence of roches _polies at the ends of existing glaciers and along the continuations of existing glacier valleys as an evidence in support of the sliding theory .
That such facts exist is known to every body , and that the rocks are thus polished and rounded by the glaciers sliding over them is incontrovertible .
Let a traveller , if he wish to obtain a wealth of information upon this subject , transport himself to the terminus of the Unteraar glacier , and walk thence down the valley through which the river Aar now flows .
On all sides he will obtain the most striking evidence that the base of the valley was once the bed of the glacier .
The rocks are polished and striated , and present at some places the appearance of huge rounded mounds , which , at first sight , would appear to offer an insuperable barrier to the motion of the glacier , but which show by their aspect that the ice actually moved over them , grinding off their angles and furrowing their summits and sides .
All along the valley towards Meyringen , similar evidences exist .
In fact , the phenomenon is very common , and admitted on all hands .
The conclusion which Mr. HOPxINs has drawn from these facts is unavoidable ; the glaciers must have sldden over the rocks on which such traces are left .
To an eye a little practised in those matters , the precise limits reached by the ancient glaciers are perfectly visible .
The junction of the rounded and abraded portions of the mountains , with those portions which in ancient times rose over the then existing ice , is perfectly distinct ; and I should say in the valley of the Aar reaches to a height of more than a thousand feet above the present bed of the river .
The valley of Saas , in the Canton de Valais , furnishes magnificent examples of the same kind .
At all places , from the base of the ancient glacier to its surface , sliding must have occurred ; the evidence of it is perfectly irresistible .
The-summit of the Grimsel pass 2 s2 constituted the bed of an ancient never ; and the groovings and polishings , at the very summit of the pass , show that the ancient neves , as well as the ancient glaciers , slid upon their beds .
In company with my friend Professor RAMSAY , and assisted by his great experience , I visited the sites of other ancient neves , and found the same true of all of them ; they all slid more or less over their beds .
No investigator of glacier motion can shut his eyes to those facts , nor refuse to give them their proper weight .
The sliding theory is beyond doubt to some extent true ; and many of the objections raised against it , and still repeated in works intended to instruct the public , are altogether futile .
Here , as in other cases , we find that the extreme facts have been dwelt upon principally by rival theorists , and coexistent truths have , by partial treatment , been rendered apparently hostile to each other .
It is perfectly certain that a glacier changes its form by pressure like a plastic mass , but it is equally true that it slides over its bed .
§ 12 .
On the Dirt-bands of the ler de Glace .
In walking over the Mer de Glace , we soon observe differences in the distribution of the dirt upon its surface ; but while standing on the glacier itself , no orderly arrangement of the dirty and clean spaces is observed .
From a point , however , which commands a view of a large portion of the glacier , it is seen that the dirty spaces are arranged so as to form a series of broad brown curves , which follow each other in succession down the glacier .
They were first observed by Professor FORBES from the heights of Charmoz , on the 24th of July , 1842 , and from the same place , on the 16th of July , 1857 , 1 observed them .
Last summer I counted eighteen of them from the same position , and this agrees with the number observed by Professor FORBES .
This agreement , after an interval of sixteen years , proves the regularity of their occurrence .
These bands were different from anything of the kind I had previously seen , and I felt that the explanation given of the " 1 dirt-bands " observed by Mr. HUXLEY and myself would not completely account for those now before me .
They were perfectly detached from each other , and resembled sharp hyperbolas with their vertices pointing downwards .
From Charmoz , however , I could only see the existence of the bands , but could not see their origin .
To observe this , I climbed a summit to the left of a remarkable cleft in the mountain range between the Aiguille du Charmoz and Trelaporte , which strikes most visitors to the Montanvert .
The place is that referred to by Professor FORBES at page 84 of the ' Travels , ' and which he was prevented from reaching by the fire of stones which a secondary glacier sent down upon him .
From the pile of stones on the summit I , however , infer that he or some of his guides must have reached the place .
Fig. 23 represents what I observed from this excellent station .
From the base of the Aiguille du G'ant and the Periades , a glacier descends which is separated by the Aiguille and promontory of La Noire from the great glacier which descends from the Col du GIant .
A small moraine is formed between both , beside which the letter a stands in the diagram .
The glacier descending from the Col is bounded on the west by the small moraine 6 , and between b and the side of the valley is another little glacier derived from one of the lateral tributaries .
Fig. 23 .
/ e / AtydaGe~znt IontTheul , )14~oie _ , \~ ~ ~~( 'ak N~Wh1 1IAM}t#FA)'h TacIefr( A , I , - , With regared to the " odirt-bands , " ) the following significant fact at once revealed itself .
Th'e dirt-bandcs e tevnded over that portion of the Glacier dn Geant onlffy which f Ilay between the moraines a and b , o~r , in other words , were confined to the ice which had descended the great cascade between Le IRognon and La Noire .
It was perfectly evident that the cascade was in some way the cause of the bands .
The description which I have already given of the ice-fall of the IRhone and of the Strahleck arm of the Lower Grindelwald glacier , applies generally to the fall of the Glacier du Giant .
The terraces , however , are here larger , and the protuberances at the base of the fall of grander proportions .
These latter are best seen from a point near A upon the Glacier du Giant ; they are steepest on that side , in consequence of the oblique thrust of the western tributaries of the glacier .
All that I have said regarding the toning down of the ridges to rounded undulations which sweep in curves across the glacier , applies here also .
Referring to the section of the glacier of the Rhone in fig. 4 , it will be seen that the word " 1 dirt " is written opposite to each hollow .
In fact the depressions between the protuberances are , to some extent , the collectors of the fine superficial dirt .
This is also the case upon the Glacier du Geant ; but here I noticed that the frontal slopes of the protuberances were also covered with a fine brown mud .
Lower down the glacier the swellings disappear , but the dirt retains its position upon the ice , and afterwards constitutes the dirt hands of the Mer de Glace .
A remarkable change in the form of the bands occurs where the glacier is forced through the neck of the valley at Trelaporte .
They sweep across the Glacier du Geant in gentle curves with their convexity downwards ; but in passing Trelaporte the arms of the curves are squeezed more closely together , the vertices are pushed sharply forwards , so that on the whole the bands resemble a series of hyperbolas which tend to coincide with their asymptotes .
Looking down from the Convercle upon the Glacier du Talelfre , a series of swellings like those upon the Glacier du Geant are observed .
Along the intervening hollows streams run , and sand and dirt are collected , forming the rudiments , so to speak , of a series of dirt-bands ; but these latter never attain anything like the precision of those upon the Mer de Glace .
I saw no such bands upon the Lechaud , for here the necessary ice-fall is absent : if bands at all exist on this glacier , they must , I imagine , be of a very rudimentary and defective character .
I will not occupy the time of the Society in describing my various expeditions up the Glacier du Geant in connexion with these bands ; but one circumstance , to which the definite printing of the bands is mainly due , must be mentioned .
The Glacier du G6ant lies nearly north and south , being only 14 degrees east of the true north .
Standing with his back to the Col du G eant , an observer looks northward , and consequently the frontal slopes of the protuberances to which I have referred have a northern as/ pect .
They therefore retain the snow upon them long after it has been melted from the general surface of the glacier .
The summer of 1857 was unusually warm in the Alps , but its great heat was not sufficient entirely to remove the snow .
No doubt , in colder summers , the snow is retained upon the slopes all the year round .
Now this snow becomes the collector of a fine brown mud , which is scattered over the surface of the glacier .
It catches the substance transported by the little rills and retains it .
The edges of the snow still remaining , when I was on the glacier , were exceedingly black and dirty ; and in many cases the entire surface of the snow appeared as if fine peat mould had been strewn over it .
Lower down the glacier this snow melts , but it leaves its sediment behind it , and to this sediment the distinctness of the dirt-bands of the Mer de Glace is mainly due .
The regularity of the bands depends on the regularity with which the glacier is broken , and the ridges or terraces formed as it passes over the brow of the fall .
It is the toning down of these ridges which produces the undulations , which are to some extent modiflied by the squeezing at the base of the fall ; and it is the undulations which produce the bands .
Thus the latter connect themselves with the transverse fracture of the glacier as it crosses the brow of the fall .
In the figure I have given the general aspect of the bands , but not their number .
Thirteen of them exist on the Glacier du Ge'ant .
I may add that the bearing I have assigned to this glacier differs from that assigned to it on the map which accompanies Professor FORBES'S ' Travels on the Alps , ' and which I had with me at the Montanvert .
The reason is , that on the map the true north is drawn on the wrong side of the magnetic north , thus making the i ; Declination " easterly instead of westerly .
I have since learned that this error is corrected in the smaller work of Professor FORBES .
It has been affirmed that the dirt-bands cross some of the medial moraines of the Mer de Glace , and they are thus drawn upon the map of Professor FORBES .
Were this correct , my explanation would be untenable ; but the fact is , that the bands are confined to the Glacier du Geant from beginning to end .
Royal Institittion , February 1859 .

