On the -Double Tangents of a Plane Curve .
By A.CAYLEY , Espq .
, F.B.S. Received March 17 , -Read April 14 , 1859 .
IT was first shown by PLUCKER on geometrical principles , that the number of the double tangents of a plane curve of the order m was 12m(m2)(n2_ 9 ) : see the note , " Solution d'une question fondamentale concernant la theory generate des Courbes , " Crelle , t. xii .
pp. 105-108 ( 1834 ) , and the " Theory der algebraischen Curven " ( 1839 ) .
The memoir by HESSE , " ; Ueber die Wendepuncte der Curven dritter Ordnung , " Crelle , t. xxviii .
pp. 97-107 ( 1844 ) , contains the analytical solution of the allied easier problem of the determination of the points of inflexion of a plane curve .
In the memoir , " Recherches Sir l'elimination et sir la theory des Courbes , " Crelle , t. xxxiv .
pp. 30-45 ( 1847 ) , I showed how the problem of double tangents admitted of an analytical solution , viz. if U=0 is the equation of the curve , L , M , N the first derived functions of U , and D= ( MaxNM ) +P(NyLbg ) + 7(L ZMax ) ( where a , P3 , y are arbitrary ) , then the points of contact of the double tangents are given as the intersections of the curve U=0 , with a curve the equation whereof is in the first instance obtained under the form [ Y]=0 ; [ Y ] being a given function of D2U , D3U , DmU of the degree m2 en6 in respect of ( x , f3 , ry ) , the degree m--2n_2-lOrn+12 in respect of ( x , y , z ) , and the degree M2+m_ 12 in respect of the coefficients of U. It was necessary , in order that the points of intersection should be independent of the arbitrary quantities ( oz , ( 3 , y ) that we should have identically [ Y]= A. U+N .
IIU , N being of the degree in2-m6 in ( o , is , r ) , and consequently 1IU a function of ( x , y , z ) without ( ex , AS , r ) .
Guided by HESSE'S investigation for the points of inflexion , I asserted that it was probable that N was of the form ( ov+I3y+rz)nM2-M6 ; which being so , flU would be of the degree ( in2)(M2_ 9 ) in respect of ( x , y , z ) , and the degree M22+M12 in respect of the coefficients , and I was thus led to the theorem , " On trouve les points de contact des tangentes doubles en combinant avec 1'equation de la courbe un equation HUE =0 , de l'ordre ( n 2)(M2 9 ) par rapport aux variables et de l'ordre r2+mn-12 par rapport aux coefficients-c'est a dire , puisqu'il corresponde deux points de contact a un tangente double , le nombre de ces tangentes est egal " a ' -1qn-2)(rn-2-m9 ) : theoreme demontre indirectement par M. PLUCKER .
" HESSE , in the memoir " Ueber Curven dritter Ordnung , &amp;c. , " Crelle , t. xxxvi .
pp. 143176 ( 1848 ) , showed how the components D2U , D3U,. .
DmU of [ Y ] could each of them MJJCCCLIX .
2 D be expressed in a simplified form , and he thus effected the actual reduction of [ Y ] to the form A.U+(car+ Pie +rz)4(m-3)R , where R still contained the arbitrary quantities ( ac , f3 , y ) in the degree ( , m--2)(m3 ) .
In particular for a quartic curve , the equation iR=0 was shown to be 3Q2Q4_Q3=0 , where the left-hand side is of the degree 2 in ( a , j3 , y ) and the degree 16 in ( x , y , Z ) ; and which should therefore by means of the equation U=0 be reducible so as to contain the factor ( o &amp; IG+ pie +rz)2 .
JACOBI'S paper , " Beweiss des Satzes , dass eine Curve n-ten Grades im allgemeinen In(n -2)(n2-9 ) Doppeltangenten hat , " Crelle , t. xl .
pp. 237-260 ( 1850 ) , did not , I think , materially advance the solution of the question .
In a letter to JACOBI , dated the 30th December , 1849 , published at the conclusion of the last-mentioned paper , HESSE gave the equation of the curve of the 14th order for the points of contact of the double tangents of a quartic , viz. in my notation , ( A , X3 , C9 J , fj(D J ?
3(taH5 - , Hj BxH )2 H(21 35 , d ; , JT , dD , ejat , aye 'a )2 =o , and the demonstration is given in HESSE'S paper , " 1 Ueber die ganzen homogenen Functionen von der dritten und vierten Ordnung zwischen drei Variabeln , " Crelle , t. xli .
pp. 285-292 ( 1851 ) , and is reproduced in Mr. SALMON'S Treatise on the Higher Plane Curves ( 1852 ) .
Two very interesting memoirs by HESSE and STEINER , Crelle , t. xlix .
( 1855 ) , relate to the geometrical theory of the double tangents of a quartic , and it is not necessary to refer to them more particularly .
It is to be observed that the curve which determines the points of contact of the double tangents is not absolutely determinate ; for we may , it is clear , in the place of HU=0 , write HIU+M.U=0 , where M is an arbitrary function of the proper degree : a very elegant transformation in the case of the quartic is given in HESSE'S paper , " Transformation der Gleichung der Curven 14ten Grades , welche eine gegebene Curve 4ten Grades in den Beriihrungspuncten ihrer Doppeltangenten schneiden , " Crelle , t. lii .
pp. 97-103 ( 1856 ) .
Mr. SALMON'S work above referred to , contains the fundamental theorem of the tangential of a cubic , viz. a tangent to a cubic meets the cubic in a third point which lies on the second or line polar of the point of contact with respect to the Hessian .
In my " Memoir on Curves of the Third Order* , " I gave an identical equation relating to the tangential of a cubic , but which is not there exhibited in its proper form ; this was afterwards effected by Mr. SALMON , in the paper " 1 On Curves of the Third Ordert .
" The equation , as given by Mr. SALMON , is in the notation of the present memoir,.U+3 DU-4DH .
BT+H .
T= 0 , an equation which in fact puts in evidence the last-mentioned theorem for the tangential of a cubic .
The idea occurred to me of considering , in the case of the higher plane curves , the tangentials of a given point of the curve , viz. the points in which the tangent again meets the curve ; for by expressing that two of these tangentials were coincident , we should have the condition that the given point is the point of contact of a double tangent .
But I was not able to complete the solution .
Finally , Mr. SALMON discovered the equation of a curve of the order m-2 , which by its intersections with the tangent at the given point determines the tangentials , and by expressing that the curve in question is touched by the tangent , he was led to a complete solution of the Double-tangent problem .
Mr. SALMON'S result is given in the note , " On the Double Tangents to Plane Curves , " in the Philosophical Magazine for October 1858 .
The discovery just referred to led me to the investigations of the present memoir , in which it will be seen that I obtain , for a curve of any order whatever , the identical equation corresponding to the before-mentioned equation obtained by Mr. SALMON in the case of a cubic ; which identical equation puts in evidence the theorem as to the tangentials of the curve , and may thus be considered as containing in itself the solution of the Double-tangent problem : the identical equation is besides interesting for its own sake , as a part of the theory of ternary quantics .
1 .
Mr. SALMON'S solution of the problem of double tangents is based upon the following analytical determination of the tangentials of any point of the curve .
Let T==(*X(X , y , Z)n=O be the equation of the given curve , ( X , Y , Z ) being current coordinates ; and let ( x , y , z ) be the coordinates of a point on the curve , so that we have U =(*XX , y , Z ) O , a condition satisfied by the coordinates of the point in question .
Then the tangent V=(Xa+YaYfZa)U= 0 at the point ( x , y , z ) , meets the curve besides in ( n2 ) points , which are the tangentials of the given point ( x , y , z ) , and which are determined as the intersections of the tangent V=O with a certain curve , =(t2 x , y , )n2 =0 .
2 .
To express the equation of this curve , let U1 , U2,. .
be the successive emanants of U , taken with the facients of emanation ( x , , y , , z , ) , viz. 1 .
' X)U , U2=n(n 1 ) ( Xi Y +y , where it should be noticed that the numerical determination is such , that putting ( x , y , z ) for ( x1 , y , , z ) z ) then U , U2,. .
become respectively equal to U. Suppose also 2DX2 that II , 11H , H2 , ... are the Hessians of U , U1 , U2 , ... , viz. H is the determinant formed with the second derived functions of U with respect to ( x , y , z ) , H , the like determinant with the second derived functions of U1 with respect to the same quantities ( X. y , z ) ; and so on .
Moreover let D 21H ( Xb +Y-a+Z H ) , fl , denote the ( n-2)thic emanant of H with respect to the current coordinates ( X , Y. Z ) as facients of emanation ; and similarly let D4-2H1 ) 1:)f-2H2 .
denote the ( n-2)thic emanants of HH in respect to the same facients of emanation-it being understood that in all these functions , ( x , , y , , z1 ) are after the differentiations to be replaced by ( x , y , z ) .
It is to be observed that Ur is of the degree ( n-r ) in ( X , y z ) , and consequently H1 .
of the ( legree 3(n-2-.r ) ; hence D-2Hr is of the degree 3(n-2-r)-(n-2 ) , =2(n-2)-3r , which implies that rc-2 ( nX2 ) , for otherwise D-2Hr would be identically equal to zero .
Upon replacing ( S , y , z ) by ( x , y , z ) , D-2 H ( r satisfying the above condition ) becomes of the degree 2(n-2 ) in ( x , y , z ) , and it is obviously of the degree 3 in the coefficients of U , and of the degree ( n2 ) in the current coordinates ( X , Y , Z ) .
3 .
This being premised , we have l ( tjXt Y Z)n-2 n-1 =DI-2H_ D1 n-2H.+ &amp;c. =O for the equation of the curve of the order ( n2 ) , which by its intersection with the tangent gives the tangentials of the given point ; the numerical coefficients are the binomial coefficients of the order ( n-1 ) taken with the signs + and alternately , and the series is continued as long as the terms do not vanish , that is , if as before r denote the suffix of H , for so long as r743 ( n-2 ) ; but of course the value will not be altered by continuing the series to r=n-1 .
In particular , for the quartic we have fl=D2H3D2H , for the quintic = D3H -4D3H , +6D3H2 , and so on .
The function fl , like the several component terms , is of course of the degree 3 in the coefficients of U , and of the degree 2(n-2 ) in ( x , y , z ) .
4 .
It is to be remarked that the formula applies to a cubic ; we have here simply 2l =)DH , which agrees with a result already mentioned .
It may be noticed also that in the general case the formula gives at once the condition for the points of inflexion in fact , if the point ( x , y , z ) be a point of inflexion , then one of the tangentials must coincide with this point , or the equation 7=1 0 will be satisfied by writing therein ( x , y , z ) for ( X , Y , Z ) ; but when this is done D4-2H D"-21H &amp;c. reduce themselves ( to numerical factors prs ) to H , and the equation becomes simply H 0 , which is the well-known condition for the points of inflexion .
5 .
If two of the tangentials coincide , or what is the same thing , if the tangent V=O touches the curve =)0 , then the point ( x , y , z ) will be the point of contact of a double tangent .
The equation which expresses the condition in question , treating therein y , z ) as current coordinates , is consequently that of a curve , intersecting the given curve ( now represented by U= O ) in the points of contact of the double tangents .
The process leads to a determinate form IFIU =0 , of the curve in question , but of course any curve whatever , F1U +M .
U-0 , will intersect the curve U =0 in the points of contact of the double tangents .
6 .
I write for the moment = ( A , ... CX bY Z ) ? ? ?
?f-2= 05 V-MX+iY+4Z -O for the two equations ; the coefficients ( A , ... ) , as already mentioned , are of the degree 2(n-2 ) in ( x , y , z ) and of the degree 3 in the coefficients of U ; or as we may express it , A , ... ( a.*)l~gvy Z)2( ? ? ?
?f-2 ) In like manner I , a4 are of the degree ( n1 ) in ( x , y , z ) , and the degree 1 in the coefficients of U , or we may write el ) = _(a.l X)1( y , Z)n7 .
The equation which -expresses that the line V-O touches the curve f2=0 , is F0 , where the facients of the Reciprocant F2 are the coefficients ( I ) a , 4 ) of the linear function .
This equation is of the , form ( A f* n-(3)(E , )(n-2)(n_ .
3 ) _0 or attending to the forms of ( A , ... ) and ( d , a , C ) , it is of the form .
( a )6(n-3)2r(n-2)(n--3)(Xg )($2(-)+r-)r-)n3 or what is the same thing , the form ( a,.)(nf+4)(n-3 ) ( X Z ) )(-A2)( , l2_9 ) =0 viz. the curve through the points of contact of the double tangents is a curve of the order ( n-2)(n2 9 ) , and its equation contains the coefficients of the equation U=O of the given curve in the degree ( n+4)(n3 ) .
And since each double tangent corresponds to two points of contact , the number of double tangents is fn(n 2)(n29 ) .
This agrees with the before-mentioned results .
8 .
The whole problem is thus reduced to the demonstration of Mr. SALMON'S expression for the curve = 0 .
To fix the ideas , consider the case of a quartic curve T= ( *X , Y , Z)4= 0 , and let the function U= ( *Xx , y , Z)4 ( or as for shortness we may write it , U= ( X , 'y , Z)4 ) and certain of its emanants be represented as follows , viz.a-(x , I Z ) b =(x , y , Z)3(X , Y , Z ) , c= ( X y , :)2(X ) Y , Z)2 d= ( x , Y , z ) ( X , Y , Z)3 , e. .
( X , Y. Z)4 , a ' =(xy , Z)3 .
* ( X ' Y ' , Z ' ) b ' =Q(I , y , Z)2(X , Y , Z ) ( XI , Y , Z ' ) I= ( X , y , Z ) ( X , Y , Z)2(X ' , Y ' , Z ' ) , d=. .
( X , Y , Z)3(X ' , Y , Z ' ) , a"=(x , i. ( Xi ' YV Z')2 b " = ( x , Y , z ) ( X , Y , Z ) ( X ' , Y ' , Z')2 , =f. .
( X , Y , Z)2(X , YVI Z')2 , where ( X ' , Y ' , Z ' ) are new arbitrary facients ; but , as before , ( X , Y , Z ) are taken to be current coordinates , and ( x , y , z ) the coordinates of the given point on the curve : e=0 is the equation of the curve ; d= 0 , the equation of the first or cubic polar of the point ( x , y , z ) ; b= 0 , the equation of the last or line polar of the point ( x , y , z ) , or what is the same thing ( the paint being on the curve ) , the tangent of the curve at this point ; a=O , the condition which expresses that the point is on the curve .
9 .
Imagine now an identical equation , la+IIb+IIId4+JVe=0 ; then , since a= 0 , we have IIb+IIJd+IVe=O ; and if in this equation we write b-O , e=O , it becomes JIId=0 , that is , the points of intersection of the curve e= 0 and the tangent b=0 lie on one or other of the curves d=O , 111=0 .
But the points in question do not lie on the curve d=O , consequently they lie on the curve III=0 .
10 .
To explain the law of formation of the multipliers I , II , 111 , IV , I form the matrix ( a , b , c , d ; a ' , 6 ' , c ' ) b , c , d , e ; b ' , ct .
d ' a ' , I b15 c ' d ' ; a"/ , b"t , c"1 and then we have I=id , el b +I di blet If emI d , Iee el ' di d , el , 6 " d , 6 ' , d " !
11=d , c , a ' d , b ' d , a , c ' e , d , 6 ' eCee 6 , d ' d ' , dC a"/ d 6 ' , bt d ' , a ' , cf III=az , 6 , od a , c b6 a ) d , a ' b , c , d ' 6 , d , el b6 e , b6 a ' , bt , c " a ' , el b6 a ' , d a " IV= a , , b6 + a , c , a ' 6 , c , c ' b , d , b ' a ' b ' b " a ' , ' , a " values which , as I proceed to show , satisfy the identical equation Ia+IIb ?
IIId+IVe= O. 11 .
We have in fact I= d ( d6 " c02 +ad'-b 'd ' ) +e ( 6W -6+'c'-bc " ) +d'(cc ' -db'+bd'cc ' ) where the last line is bd'2d- 'd ' ; II= d(b 'd a"d+b'b"c+a 'd ' -bc " ) ?
e ( ca"'ale ' +bb6"62 +act ad ) +d '(a 'd 6 ' +6c 6be ' + bc ' ad ' ) , where the last line is da 'd ad'2 ; III= a ( b6'd'+co"+c'2 b"d+b'd'l -eal ) +( bc " -b'c'+b"c-b'c'+alda 'd ' ) + a( cc ' -6b ' +bd-cc ' +a'e -6bd ) , where the last line is -ba'd'+ea ' ; and IV= a(b6"c-b'c'+da " -b'c ' ) +b ( b '2 -bb"l+ aloc ' atle ) + al(becJ b'c + cbl a 'd ) , where the last line is 6a'd-d'2 .
And these values may be expressed as follows I= a( 0 ) +b( d'2 ) ( 12 ) + d( b"d+c"c-b6 'd ' c'd'b ' ) ( 13 ) +e(btlc -c +b6'd+cb6 ' ) , ( 14 ) +b(O + d(and-6b"cc"b + ad'+'c'+c'b ' +d'a ' ) ( 23 ) +e( a ec +6"b+c"a a'd-b ' ' -6 c'a ' ) ( 24 ) III= a( -b6d-c"d+b'd'l+cc'+d'b ' ) ( 31 ) +b( a"d+b"c+c"b -a 'd ' -b'c ' -c'b ' -d'a ' ) ( 32 ) +d( 0 ) +e(-a~a+a'a ' ) , ( 34 ) IVa( P"c+c"b Y'c ' cdb ' ) ( 41 ) b( -a"cbb c"a+a'c'+b'b'+c'a ' ) ( 42 ) +d(.a"a -a'a ' ) ( 43 ) +e( 0 which are of the form I=a 0 +b(12)+d(13)+e(14),.II=a(21)+b 0 +d(23)+e(24 ) , III=a(31)+b(32)+d 0 +e(34 ) , IV=a(41)+b(42)+d(43)+e 0 where ( 12)= -(21 ) &amp;c. , and which therefore satisfy the equation Ja+IIb+IIId+IVe=0 .
12 .
The equation of the curve which by its intersection with the tangent gives the tangentials , is III=a 6 , el a , c , b ' a , , d , a ' =0 , 6 , c , d ' 6 , d , c ' b , e , b ' a ' , b6 , ell ac 6 " a ' , t d ' , al the degrees of which are in the coefficients of U , 3 , in ( x , z )***6 , in(X , Y , Z ) ... 4 , in ( X ' , Y ' , Z ' ) ... 2 and it only remains to divest this equation of a factor which it contains , x , i , z 2 , x , y , z XI , Y. Z ' which being thrown out , the equation will be independent of ( X ' , Y ' , Z ' ) and of the degrees in the coefficients of U , 3 , in(x , y , z ) ... .
4 , in ( X , Y Z ) ... .
2 , and will in fact be the before-mentioned equation Q= D2H -3D2H =0 .
Write for shortness , x , y , z A , X , Ye Z xl , y ' , Zi it is to be shown that III=-'sA2(D2H3D2HA ) .
14 .
To effect this I remark that we have identically a , b , a ' =A2H ; 6 , c , 6 ' a , b ' , a " and I proceed to operate upon this equation with D=Xb , +Yb , +Za , .
I notice that a , b , G , d , e ; a ' , b6 , c , d ' ; a " , 6 " , c " are in regard to ( x , y , Z ) of the degrees 4 , 3 , 2 , 1,0 ; 3 , 2 , 1 , 0 ; 2 , 1,0 ; or what is the same thing , since for the case in hand n= 4 , of the degrees n , n-1 , ... ; X-1 , n-2,. .
; n-2 , n-3 , .
and we have Da=nb , Db=(n-1)c,. .
Da'=(n-1)b ' , Db'=(n-2)c',..Da/ '=(-2)b " 15 .
In the determinant a , b , a ' , =A2H , 6 , G. 6 ' at 6 ' , a " ' the degrees of the terms ( other than each top term , the degree of which is higher by unity ) in the several columns are n-1 , n-2 , n-2 ; if then we operate on the determinant with D , and as regards the top terms we write Da =b +(n-1)b , Db =c +(n-2)c , Da'= '+ ( n2)b ' , we have in the first place a term 6 , cw 6 ' 6 , c , 6 ' a ' , b ' , a " which vanishes , and next the terms ( n1 ) b , b , a ' +(n-2 ) a , c , a ' +(n-2 ) a , b , b ' , el , b'i b , d &gt; , b ' 6 , ,a b6 bf a"f a ' , d , a " a &gt; ' , VI b6 MDcccL~x .
2 E the first of which vanishes .
On the right-hand side DA=O identically , and therefore D. A21H= A2'DH , or we have ( n -2 ) a , c , a ' +(n-2 ) a , b , 6'=A2DH .
6 , d , 6 ' 6 , c , c ' a !
' , c ' , a &gt; " at , bl b6 " 16 .
I repeat the operation D : we have ( n-2)(n-1)1 b , c , a ' J ( n-2)(n 1 ) b , 6 , b ' c , d , b ' C , c , ' b , Ct 1all b ' , by ' bit +(n-2)(n-3 ) Ga , d , a +(n-2)(n-2 ) a , c , 6 ' b , c , 6b b d , c ' l=A2D2H ; a ' , d ' , a " a ' , o ' , b6 " +(n-2)(n2)1 a , c , ' +(n-2)(n3 ) a , b , c ' b , d , c ' b , c , d ' aC c ' , 6b at6 ' , c " J or collecting the different terms , ( n-2)(n-3)'a , b , c ' +2(n-2)2a , c , b6 +(n-2)(n-3)a , d , a ' +(n-2)(n-1)b , c , a ' |=A2D2H .
bc , d ' dlbd , e b6 , e,6bl cG d,6 ' a ' , 6b , c"t al ' C/ , b " | a ' , d ' , a " | 6t ' , c ' , a"t 17 .
A little consideration will show that in this equation we may write n-1 for n , and H1 for H. In fact , putting for a moment = , we have corresponding to the equation a , b , a ' jA 21H , b6 a , b6 a ' , b ' , a " this other equation , { ~~~k =A , bb a2H , R 6 , be , b6 ' where ultimately ( x , ,-y , , z1 ) are to be replaced by ( x , My , z ) .
We may operate upon this equation with D , D2 , ... as before , the only difference being that in the first instance Iak , 6 , &amp;c. are as regards ( a , y , z ) of degrees lower by unity than a , b , &amp;c. , that is n1 must be substituted throughout in the place of n ; and when at the end of the process ( x , , y , , z , ) are replaced by ( a , y , z ) , then ka , Ml , &amp;c. become equal to a , 6 , &amp;c. , from which the truth of the asserted proposition is manifest .
Hence writing n=4 , we have 2a , b6 el +8 a , d , a ' +2 a , d , a ' +6 b , c , a ' A22D2H , b 6 , d ' b , e , ' b6 , e , b'cI d , b ' a ' , b ' , c " a ' , d ' , a ' at , d ' , aft b el ' a " 2 a , d , a ' +2 b , c , a ' A2D2H1 ; b , e , 6 ' d , b ' a , d ' , a " 6 ' , c ' , ea and hence 2 a , 6 , c ' +a c , 6+ a , d , a'~ 6 , c , d ' 6 , d , c6e6j =A2(D2H-3D2H , ) , a ' , 6 ' , c " a , c ' , a ' , d ' , a which is the required equation , III= -2 2(D2H3D2H1 ) .
19 .
It is to be added , that the equation for A2DH gives IV A2DH ; the values of II and I are at once obtained from those of III and IV by interchanging ( x , y , z ) and ( X , Y , Z ) .
Hence if we represent by A , i3 , &amp;c. the values which H , D , &amp;c. assume by this interchange , we may write I= 1 A2g1 , II= +1A 2(D21 _ 3j1 1 ) III= --A 2(D2 H-3D2 H , ) , IV=+'A2DH ; and the identical equation , Ia+IIb+IIId+IVe=0 , gives therefore -y .
U+ ( M23 _ 332 , )DU-*(D2H3D2HI)lT +DH .
T= 0 which is of itself sufficient to put in evidence the property that the curve D2H3D211 -0 gives by its intersections with the tangent DU= 0 , the tangentials of the point ( x , y , z ) .
The last-mentioned equation is the equation for a quartic corresponding to Mr. SALMON'S equation A.U+*30.DU*DH.0T+H .
T=0 for the cubic U-0 .
20 .
It is worth while to give the investigation of the equation for the cubic ; the matrix is ( a , b , c ; a ' , b6 ) b , c , d ; b ' , c ' a ' , 6 ' , d ; a " , 6 " and the identical equation is Ia+IIb+IIIc+IVd= 0 , where I= cl b6 ba , d , c , 6 , el bf bil dl el bJ di b el id 6 ' , a " ' c ' , b6t 6 , c , c ' a , d , 6t a ' , bI b6 " ad , c ' , a " IV= a , b , a ' 6 , c , 6 ' all bf all or , as we may express them , I= a( 0 ) +b( C12 ( 12 ) +c(6"tc-bt6'c''6 ' ) ( 13 ) +d(-b6b6b'b ' ) ( 14 ) II= 1(c2 ( 21 +c ( a"c-6b"+a'c'+6'b'+c'al ) ( 23 ) +d( a"6b +6a-a-'-'ba ' ) ( 24 ) III= a(-6"c+6'c ' ?
d6 ' ) ( 31 ) + 6( a"c+b"b-a'Cd-b6'b'-c'a ' ) ( 32 ) +c(0O ) , +Jd(aa ' + ' ) ( 34 ) IV= a(b"b -b'b ' ) ( 41 ) +b6(-ab-b"a+adb6+b6a ' ) ( 42 ) +c( ala -a'a ' ) ( 43 ) +d( 0 ) which verify the identical equation .
We have IIIA2DH , IV=A2H , and thence II= + A2WIL ?
, I= A21 ?
1 and thence the equation in question , -*.U+jI .
DU-*DH .
+H.T= .
One other example will be sufficient to render manifest the law of the formation of the multipliers I , II , III , IV .
In the case of a sextic curve we have the matrix ( a , 6 , c , d , e , f ; a ' 6J , ctI d ' el ) 6 , c , di e , f , g ; b ' , c ' , di ' el , ,f ' a ' , et cI d ' , el , f ; art bt cl/ d " , e " the identical equation is Ia+Ilb+lIIf+ IVg=0 7 and the expressions for the multipliers I , II , III , IV are1= f e , b+f d , c ' + f , cd+ f , b6 eJ g , f , e , d ' g , d , e g , el ft f , el , b't -f ' d , e'l fl , c ' f d , 6'b'fa e " f ' e ' a " f ' , d , b " f c ' del f 6 ' , di/ 21 , a , el 111=-1 a , 6 ' b , d ' e a , d , c ' a , e ' , 6l- .
a , f , a ' b.f ' b , d , el b , e , d'i b , f',5 b gXb ' af b ' , ell at , c ' e"l di d'l e"l at e'15 b"t asta IV= a , b6 , d ' + a , c el a , d ' aI e , a ' 6 b , c , e b6 d , dl b , e , c ' 6 , f , 6b a ' , b ' , d " a ' , d ' , c " a ' , d ' , b " a , el , a " 22 .
We have in fact 1= a0 +6 -ge " +ff ' ) ( 12 ) +f( b6f+c le+ dtd +etlc -bf'c'e'd'd'-e e f-fb'6 ) ( 13 ) -"e-c"d-dd"c +b6e'+ctd'+d'c ' +e ' ' ) ( 14 ) II= a( e"g -yff ' ) ( 21 ) +b 0 +f( -a'f b"e-el'd-d"ee"b+af +b6el+c'd'+d'c'+e'b'+fa ' ) ( 23 ) +g9( la e+b"d+ct'c+dl6b a'e'b'd'cot'd'1 -e'a ' ) ( 24 ) III= a(-b6f-c"e-d"d-e"a +bf + ce ' + d 'd ' +ee'+f'6 ' ) ( 31 ) + b( alf+b6"e+c"d+dllc+e"6b-af'-b6ef'-o d ' -d'd-eb'6-f'a ) ( 32 ) +f 0 +g( a"la _a( ) , ( 34 ) IV=a( e"e+c"d+ d"c -ble'-c'dd'c ' eb'l ) ( 41 ) +b( -age-b6dc"e---d"b +a'e'+b'd'+c'c'+d'b ' +eta ' ) ( 42 ) +f( aea -a2 ) ( 43 ) +g 0 which are of the form I=a 0 +b(12)+f(13)+g(14 ) , IJ=a(21)+b 0 +f(23)+g(24 ) , II==a(31)+b(32)+f 0 +g(34 ) , IV-a(41)+b(42)+f(43)+g 0 , where ( 12)= -(21 ) &amp;c. , and the equation Ia+IIb+IIIf+ IVg-0 is consequently satisfied .
23 .
The expression III=a , b , e ' l a , c , d ' _ a , d , c ' a , f , a ' b , G , f ' 6 , d , e ' b , e , d ' g , b ' a'VI:e a ' I ' d"l a. ) d ' , c " af a , leads to III= A2(D4H15D4H1 + 10iD4H2 ) , and consequently the equation of the curve which by its intersections with the tangent determines the tangentials of a point of a sextic , is D4H-15D4H1 +10D4H2= 0 .
24 .
In the general case of a curve of the order n the matrix is ( a0 , a1 , a2. .
an- ; a ll c4 .
* an2 ) a| a , al 3 I. an ' ; al , a2. .
naI a0 , all , a2 .
aI .
; a0 , a1.-2 where , in analogy with what precedes , aO =(X , Y , Z)P al =(X , Y. Z)nf-l(2 ?
#I:)X ail-(X Ad )(no y1 Z)9t X and similarly for the accented letters , so that a=O 0 is the equation of the curve ; a , =0 is the equation of the first or ( n-l)thic polar ; =an- , 0 is the equation of the last or line-polar , or what is the same thing , since ( x , y , z ) is a point on the curve , the tangent at this point ; a =0 , the condition which expresses that ( x , y , z ) is a point of the curve ; and we have to form the identical equation Ia0+IIa1+IIIa , ~ , +IVa= ?
0 .
25 .
If , for shortness , the columns of the last-mentioned matrix are represented by 1 , 2 , 3 ... n , ( 1 ) , ( 2). .
( n1 ) , and the determinants formed with these columns respectively by a corresponding notation { 1 , 2 , ( 1 ) } , { 1 , 2 , ( 2 ) } , &amp;c. , then the expressions for the multipliers 1 , II , III , IV are as follows , viz. I= { n , n-1 , ( 2)}+{n , n-2 , ( 3 ) } *1 +{n , 2 , ( n-1)}l II=-{n , n-1 , ( 1)}-{n , n-2 , ( 2 ) } ... -{n , 2 , ( n-2)}-{n , 1 , ( n-1 ) } , III=-{1 , 2 , ( n-1)}---{1 , 3 , ( n-2 ) } ... -{1 , n-1 , ( 2)}-.-{1 , n , ( 1 ) }7 IV= { 1 , 2 , ( n-2)}+{1 , 3 , ( n-1 ) } ... +{1 , n-1 , ( 1 ) } ; the truth of the identical equation being shown , as in the foregoing special cases , by the transformation of the multipliers into the form I=a0 0 +aj(12)+af_(13)+a , ( 14 ) , II=a0(21)+aj 0 +a._j(23)+a.(24 ) , II1Ia ( 31)+aj(32)+a , _ , 0 +an(34 ) , IV=a0(41)+a , ( 42)+a , ,_ , ( 43)+an 0 where ( 12)=-(21 ) &amp;c. : the required expressions may be written down without difficulty .
26 .
Proceeding then to reduce the equation III -{1 2 , ( ns 1)}{1 , 3 , ( in2 ) } ... ... ... ... ... .{ 1 , en..1 , ( 2 ) } -{1 , n,9 ( 1)1 , we have the equation { 1 , 2 , ( 1 ) } =A2H , which is to be successively operated on with D. The degrees ( less unity ) of the columns 1 , 2,..n-1 , nz , ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) , *(n 1 ) , are n-1 , n-2,. .
1 , 0 , n-2 , n3,. .
0 ; and the rule is to operate on each column of the determinant , multiplying by the degree less unity , and increasing the symbolical number by unity .
Thus D{1 , 2 , ( 1)}=(n 1){2 , 2 , ( 1)}+(n-2){1 , 3 , ( i)}+(n-2){1 , 2 , ( 2 ) } ( n-2){1 , 3 , ( 1 ) } +(n-2){1 , 2 , ( 2 ) } , since { 2 , 2 , ( 1 ) } vanishes identically .
The following Table shows the mode of effecting the operations : = 1 [ n-2j ?
[ n-2 ] ? ?
12(1 ) DH 11 [ n-2 ] ' [ n-211 12(2 ) 11 [ n-2 ] ' [ n2 ] ? ?
13(1 ) D2H 1=1 [ n-2]0 [ n-2 ] ' 12(3 ) 112 [ n 21 [ n-21 13(2 ) 11 [ n-2]2 [ n-2 ] ? ?
14(1 ) 1_1 [ n-211 [ n-2 ] ?
[ n-i]I 23(1 ) DVH 11 [ n-2 ' [ n--2 ] ' 12(4 ) 213 [ n-2]1 [ n-2]a 13(3 ) 123 [ n-2]2 [ n-2]1 14(2 ) 11 [ n-2]3 [ n-2 ] ? ?
15(1 ) 123 [ n 2 ] ' [ n 2gn En211 } l 23(2 ) 112 [ n_2]2 [ n-2 ] ?
I 24(1 ) D4H 1=1 [ n-2 ] [ n- !
2]4 12(5 ) 314 [ n -2 ] [ n2 ] 13(4 ) 336 [ n _2]2 [ n2]2 14(3 ) 134 [ En2]3 [ n-2]1 15(2 ) 11 [ n-2]4 [ n-2 ] ' 16(1 ) 336 [ nE-2 ] ' [ n-2 ] ' 23(3 ) 2338 [ n.-2]2 E ?
-2-1 [ n-i]l 24(2 ) 213 [ n-2]3 [ n2 ] ?
J 25(1 ) 22 [ n_2]2 [ n-2 ] ' [ n-1]2 34(1 ) D'H 11 [ En-2 ] ?
[ n -2]5 12(6 ) 415 [ n -2]1 [ n-2]4 13(5 ) 64 10 [ n-2]2 [ n-2]3 14(4 ) 46 10 [ n-2 ] [ n2]2 15(3 ) 145 [ n2 ][ n-2]1 16(2 ) 11 [ n-2]5 [ n-2 ] ? ?
17(1 ) 64 10 [ n2]1 [ n2]4 23(4 ) 866 20 [ n _2]2 [ En213 En-11 ' 24(3 ) 384 15 [ n-2 ] ' E [ n-2 25(2 ) 314 [ n_-2]4 [ n_-2]1 26(1 ) 28 10 [ n-2 ] ' [ n2]'1 [ n-i]2 34(2 ) 235 [ n-2 ] ' [ n2 ] ?
J [ 35(1 ) D6H 1=1 [ n-2 ] ?
[ n2]6 12(7 ) 516 [ n 2 ] [ n -2]5 13(6 ) 10 5 15 [ n--22 [ _n 2]4 14(5 ) 10 10 20 [ n'2]3 [ n-2]3 15(4 ) 5 10 15 [ nE2]4 [ n _2]2 16(3 ) 156 [ n-.2 ] ' [ n2]1 17(2 ) 11 [ n -27J [ En-.2 ] 18(1 ) 10 5 15 [ n-2]2 [ n-2 ] 4 23(5 ) 20 10 10 40 [ n2 ] [ n 2]31 24(4 ) 15 20 10 45 [ n-.2]3 [ n-2]'2 E[n-i1]l 25(3 ) 4 15 5 24 [ n_-2]4 [ n-2'1.26(2 ) 415 [ n2 ] ' En2]'J 27(1 ) 10 20 30 [ n-2 ] ' [ n-2]21 34(3 ) 5 10 15 30 [ n1-_2]3 [ n2 ] 1[n-1]2 35(2 ) 549 [ n -2]4 [ n2 ] J 36(1 ) 55 [ n2]3 [ n-2 ] ?
[ n-1]3 45(1 ) D7H1 &amp;c. where the first three columns show the numbers which give , by the addition of the numbers in the same horizontal line , the numerical coefficients of the factorials which multiply the different terms of H , DH , &amp;c. , and where in the last column 12(1 ) , &amp;c. are written for shortness in the place of { 1 , 2 , ( 1 ) } , &amp;c. 27 .
It is clear that we have in general A 2Dr H= Aft-2 ] ?
[ X_2]t { 1 , 2 , ( r+I)j + [ n.-2]1[n .
2]r-1{1 3 , ( r ) }+ { j [ n. 2]2[nt--2]r-2 { 1 , 4 , ( r-1 ) } +1 [ n-2]r{n-2]0 { 1 , r+2 , ( 1 ) } -+Ro [ n-2]l [ n-2 ] r-2 { 2 , 3 , ( ) +[ttf 1]1 +R , [ n-2]2 [ nz-2 ] r-3 { 2 , 4 , ( r 2 ) } tR._2[2 ] r-1 [ -2]0 { 2 , r+1 , ( 1 ) , +R " [ n.-2]2 [ n-2]r-4 { 3 , 4 , ( r-3 ) } +R , " - , En-2]I -2[n2]0 { 3 , r , ( 1 ) } [ 1]* { +Ri~r [ n-2]1 " [ n-2]0{.lr+l1 , r+2 , ( 1 ) } r even ; or r odd + +iRi(rl)[n-2]i'{n-2 ] { 2 ( r+l ) , 1(r+ 3 ) , ( 2 ) } 1+ir)[n22 ] ti[n2]0j1(r+1 ) , -(+5 , ( 1 } and the general term is [ n,116 R8[n 2]6+3[ 2]r-2--s { ; +II t+2+s , ( r28+1-s)j } where s extends from s=0 to s=r-2b , and b from t=0 to ; =- !
r or I(r-1 ) , according as r is even or odd .
The expression for the coefficients R ?
is R-[r]S and that of the other coefficients R ' ( b= or &lt; 1 ) is not required for the present purpose .
28 .
According to a remark already made , the expressions for D rH , , DrH2 &amp;c. are at once obtained from that for Drf1 by merely writing n-1 , n-2 , &amp;c. in the place of n : it is however to be noticed , that the quantity within the [ ] must not be negative , and that on its becoming so , the factorial is to be omitted .
-29 .
I write now +s8=c , r-.23-s==f3 , MDcccLIx .
2FE and I consider the expression DrH _-2DrII , + &amp;c. ; the general term of which is Raf8+19 6+2+s , ( r-2+- ) x no-I]I[n-2 ] , x[n-2 ] 9 [ n n [ _ 2]'En3]a[n3 ] 9 l+ &amp;c. or as this may be written , putting q=n-6-1 , Ra , ,1+1 , Z+2+s , ( r-28+1 s)j C En-2]0 , En-2]1 x En-1]a E-ln -3 ] , ~n3]6 t+ &amp;c. J 30 .
I assume rl-2 , we have then c ?
+P=rbrn-b-2 , and therefore z+ &lt; 3 &lt; q The general term of the series in { } is ( -)a [ a]S n-2-b]a~n-2-aGil where the terms for which n2-a is negative are to be excluded , or what is the same thing , the series is not to be continued beyond a=n-2 .
But observing that [ q]5 vanishes for a &gt; q , that is , a &gt; n -1 , it is in fact the same thing whether the series is continued indefinitely or only to the term for which aY=n-1 , and we may consistently with the condition a ?
-.-2 , continue the series as far as a=n-1 , except in the case t=0 , when by doing so we include the term corresponding to 5=n1 , which in virtue of the condition ought to be excluded .
The expression for the term in question is ( -)[1 ] ?
[ -1]3 ; hence if the sum of the series continued to the proper point is S , the sum continued indefinitely ( in the particular case b= 0 ) is S+(--)`1[ 1]TE[1 ] , but in every other case the sum continued indefinitely is simply S. And by a well-known theorem in finite differences , the sum continued indefinitely is in fact zero .
That is , except in the case =0 , we have S=O , but in the excepted case S+( ) [ -1][1]E 1 0 ; or observing that o+p3(=r-b ) is in this case =r , and transforming the factorials , we have S=( )X-Y-TaTM]1-]3 , or substituting for a and 03 their values , S= ( )n-[s]s[r s]r .
Hence the general term of n-i DrH_ DrHI H+ &amp;c. vanishes except for t=O , but when b=O , its value is R,0{1 , 2+s , ( repls)j X ( -)n-r[s]s[rsr-83t ; or observing that R ?
is equal to [ r]r * .
[ s]8[r-s]1%ss the value is simply ( -).n-r[r]r{1 , 2+s , ( r+l-s ) } , that is , we have n1 DrH--_ IDrH , + &amp;c. =(_n-rr~tSjl ) 2+s , ( r+1l-s)j the summation in respect to s extending from s=0 to s=r .
In particular , giving to r the values n-2 and n-i , and attending to the expressions for III and IV , we find A2 Dn-2H-n 1 Dn-2Hi + &amp;c. . .
) = --[n2]-2 III , A2 ( Dn-3HW_ n-1 Dn-3Hl+ &amp;c. . .
) =-[n3]n-3 IV .
32 .
The equation III= 0 belongs to the curve which by its intersections with the tangent , gives the tangentials of a point of the curve U= 0 .
Hence the equation of the curve in question is Dn2H n-1 Dn-2H , + &amp;c. = 0 , which is Mr. SALMON'S theorem , leading to the solution of the problem of double tangents .
33 .
The expressions for I and II are obtained from those of IV and III by interchanging ( X , Y , Z ) and ( x , y , z ) , and reversing the sign .
Hence if , as before , A , X , &amp;c. denote the values which H , D , &amp;c. assume by this interchange , we have A22 ( n-21 ?
_n-1f-2H[+ &amp;c. ..)=[n2 ] 2 II A2 Mn-3 3 n-lI n-3H , + &amp;c. . .
) =[n3]f-3I , and the identical equation Iao + Ha1 + IIIa1 + Iva " , = 0 becomes therefore ( mn-31_ n2 1 an-3.1+ &amp;c. ) U +(2)( ( n2 1n 321 ?
+ &amp;c. ) DU l ( Dn-2H n-1 0-2 , ( Dn-3Hy1 Dn-3H1+ &amp;c. )r j which is the general identical equation referred to in the introduction to the present memoir .
34 .
It is to be noticed that for n=3 , the equation is ( a 2k1)U+* 31 .
DU-jDH .
UT-(H2H1)T-0 .
But we have H , =H , and in like manner , = , and the equation thus becomes DT 1DH .
CT + HT= 0 .
And so also for n= 4 , the equation is 31 )U+ 1 ( n2i _ 3 , t21 ?
)DU ( D2H-3D2Hl)MT -(DH-3DHI)T = O. But we have in general DH1=IDH , and therefore in the , present case DH , =ADH , and consequently , and the equation thus becomes ?
U+ I( , M21 ? ?
33Y2IL')DU ( D2H -3D2H1)3T+DHT0 , which agree with the results previously obtained for the two particular cases .

