On the Vertebral Characters of the Order Pterosauria , as exemplied in the Genera Pterodactylus ( CUVIER ) and Dimorphodon ( OWEN ) .
By Professor OWEN , F.B.S. , Superintendent of the Natural History Departments in the British Museum .
Received February 23 , -Read March 24 , 1859 .
ALTHOUGH the skeletons of the extinct Flying Saurians of the mezozoic strata have been discovered in a more complete condition than those of any other contemporary Reptiles , they have not , hitherto , owing to the delicate texture and commonly crushed state of the bones , afforded satisfactory observations of the structure of the vertebrae .
Yet the vertebral characters of a saurian skeleton are of peculiar interest to the Paleontologist and Comparative Anatomist , on account of the many and strongly-marked differences which they present in the extinct members of the Reptilian class .
In the existing species , the articular terminal surfaces of the centrum , with the exception of those of the Geckos , Rhynchocephalus * , and of some single vertebrae in the column of other Reptilest , are concave in front and convex behind .
But in extinct Reptiles some genera ( Streptospondylus ) show reverse positions of the cup and ball ; others ( Ichthyosaurus ) show both surfaces concave ; others show both surfaces slightly concave ( Teleosaurus ) ; others show both surfaces flat ( some Plesiosauri ) ; others are subconcave behind and flat before ( Cetiosaurus ) ; with many minor modifications .
It is only on arriving at the uppermost of the mezozoic series of rocks in an ascending survey , that we find Lacertian genera ( Mosasaurus and Leiodon$ of the Chalk ) and crocodilians ( Crocodilus basifissus , from the Greensand of New Jersey ?
) presenting the proccelian type of vertebra which prevails in tertiary and modern reptiles .
-No fossil vertebra from secondary rocks has come under my observation or knowledge with characters of the articular ends of the centrum which distinguish the vertebrae of birds , viz. a concavity in one direction and a convexity in the other , the directions being reversed at the two ends of the centrum .
All the foregoing considerations have tended to invest the question of the vertebral characters of the Pterodactyles with peculiar interest ; and , especially , seeing the adapta* Catalogue of the Osteological Series , Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons , 4to .
1853 , p. 142 .
t Biconcave fifth cervical vertebra in .
Chelone Mydas ; biconvex first caudal vertebra , Crocodile.-Cata .
logue of the Physiological Series , Museum of the Royal College of Surgeons , 4to .
vol. i. 1832 , pp. 52 , 53 .
$ History of British Fossil Reptiles , 4to .
p. 188 . ?
" Notes on Remains of Fossil Reptiles discovered in Greensand Formations of New Jersey , " Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society , vol. v. 1849 , p. 380 .
11 Report on British Fossil Reptiles , 8vo .
1841 , p. 65 .
tion of their reptilian type of structure for flight , in reference to carrying out the comparison of their skeleton with that of birds .
I have therefore thought the summary of observations might not be unworthy the attention of the Royal Society , which I have made , as opportunities presented themselves , for some years past , on the vertebral characters of different species of the order Pterosauria .
Before entering upon such summary , I may briefly allude to the recorded observations on the subject .
Baron CUVIER , in his celebrated memoir establishing the reptilian character of the Ornithocephalus of SOEMMERING , which he , thereupon , proposed to call 'Pterodactyle , ' almost restricts himself to a comparison of the number of the cervical and dorsal vertebrae in the Pterodactyle and Bird* .
Five of the cervical vertebrae of Pterodactyllus longirostris are stated to be large and prismatic like those of longnecked birds"'t .
With regard to the dorsal vertebrae , " the spinous processes of the anterior ones are a little longer , those of the posterior ones are short and cut square$ .
" The able editors of the posthumous edition of the ' Ossemens Fossiles ' found nothing to add , in 1836 , to the above-cited brief notices by the Baron on the vertebrae of the Pterodactyle , nor has anything material been with certainty determined and stated since that time .
The Pterodactylus suevicus described and figured by Professor QUENSTEDT in 1855 , was perhaps in the best condition to have thrown some additional light upon the subject ; but the most important 'remark relates to one of the dorsal vertebrx , in which " the articular surfaces of the body are convex at the back end , as in the Crocodile , concave at the fore part .
At least so it seems ; " writes the author I. In regard to the cervical vertebrae , the author says , " ; they seem not to have the trochlear joints as in Birds , yet a small cavity may be observed on the articular surfaces If .
" Accordingly , Professor PICTET , in the able summary of the characters of extinct reptiles in the last edition of his ' Paleontologie ' ( 8vo , 1857 ) , limits his notice of the vertebral characters of the Pterodactyles to their number in the different regions of the spine .
From observations made on species of Pterosauria , extending from the period of the Lias , as exemplified by the -Dimorphodon macronyx , to the Upper Greensand , as exemplified by the Pterodactylus Sedywickii and Pter .
Fittoni , I am now able to state that , both with respect to the cervical and dorso-lumbar vertebrae , the terminal articular surfaces of the vertebral bodies are simply concave anteriorly ( Plate X. fig. 1 ) , convex posteriorly ( ib. fig. 2 ) * ; and that they consequently manifest the earliest known instance of the 'procoelian ' type which now prevails in the reptilian class .
But in no other reptile are those articular surfaces so narrow vertically in proportion to their breadth as they are in the cervical vertebrae of the Pterosauria ( ib. figs. 1 , 2 , 12-14 , b , c ) : in the dorsal series the cup and ball present more ordinary saurian proportions .
This fact , being established , will give new and increased interest to the working out and examination of any detached vertebrae from secondary rocks which resemble in texture and size those of Birds and Pterodactyles .
It has been alleged , for example , on microscopic characters of the osseous tissue , that certain pneumatic wing-bones found fossil in Stonesfield slate , are those of birds .
But every such vertebra from that lower oolitic bed which I have yet seen , has the simple terminal articular concavity or convexity characteristic of the Pterodactyle .
A single specimen showing the interlocking joint , i. e. a transverse concavity and vertical convexity , or the reverse , would establish the fact of the existence of birds during the period of deposition of the stratum containing such fossil vertebra .
There is but one exception , so far as I know , in the whole class of birds , to the foregoing type of vertebral structure ; this occurs in a bird ( Aptenodytes ) which does not fly , but has the wing-bones dense , solid , and modified in form to serve the office of a fin , and is exemplified in but a small part of the vertebral column .
In the third to the eighth dorsal vertebrae inclusive , the fore-part of the centrum is simply convex ( ib. fig. 22 , c ) , the hind part concave , and this part is concave in the second dorsal ; but the fore-part of this dorsal vertebra is concavo-convex , as .
in the cervical vertebrae of the Penguin , and in the cervico-dorsal vertebrae of all other birds .
But , besides the reverse positions of the cup and ball in the above dorsal vertebrae of the Penguin , as compared with the dorsal vertebrae of the Pterodactyle , the latter might be distinguished by the absence of the large bifurcate hypapophysis ( ib. fig. 22 , hy ) which projects from the dorsal vertebrae of the Penguin ; the inferior surface of the dorsal vertebrae in the Pterodactyle being smooth and simply convex transversely , and slightly concave longitudinally .
The anterior cup becomes more shallow in the last lumbar and first sacral vertebrae of the Pterodactyle ; the confluent articular surfaces of the sacral vertebrae are flattened .
In the caudal vertebrae of the Pterodactyle the anterior transversely-elliptical cup and posterior ball are resumed at the articular end of the centrum ; at least in most of the anterior caudal vertebrae of the great Pterodactyllus Sedgwickii ( ib. figs. 36 , 37 ) .
The cervical vertebrae average seven in number , counting the coalesced atlas and axis as one .
They are characterized by their superior size , and especially length , as compared with the other vertebrae in the same skeleton ; but differ in different species in this respect , being longest in those Pterodactyles with long , light and slender jaws , shortest in those with shorter , stronger and thicker jaws .
The third to the sixth inclusive preserve the same , or nearly the same , length ; the seventh becomes shorter , and exhibits other modifications transitional to the dorsal vertebrae .
The ordinary cervical vertebra in Pterodactylus Sedgwckii ( figs. 1-10 ) has a long depressed centrum ( b-c ) coalesced with the neural arch ( n ) , slightly concave lengthwise at the sides , slightly convex lengthwise below , at least in the fourth or fifth cervical ( fig. 5 ) .
It developes a pair of short obtuse processes ( p ' ) , which form the posterior inferior angles , and between these the under surface is concave transversely ; the articular ball ( b ) seems as if tilted up above the level of these processes .
There is a low obtuse hypapophysis ( h ) at the fore-part , the base of which is in some cervicals prolonged backward a short way as a rudimental ridge .
A large ' foramen pneumaticum ' ( figs. 5 , 7 , 8 , o ) perforates the middle of the side of the vertebra at the line of junction of the centrum and neural arch ; it conducts chiefly to the large cancelli in the centrum .
The neural arch is low ; broader , but shorter , than the centrum .
Viewed from above ( fig. 9 ) , it presents a subquadrate form , deeply emarginate before and behind , less concave at the sides , and with the four angles produced to form the zygapophyses .
The articular surfaces of the anterior pair ( z ) look upward , inward and forward ; those of the posterior pair ( z ' ) downward , outward and backward : both are flat .
The anterior zygapophyses ( fig. 10 , z ) project on a level with the sides of the anterior articular cup , some way in advance of it , the base of the process being divided by an oblique notch from the cavity .
The posterior zygapophyses ( fig. 7 , z ' ) do not extend quite to the hinder ball ; they project above its level ; there is a tuberosity ( mn ) above the articular surface in many vertebrae .
The neural canal ( fig. 6 , n ) is slightly expanded at its outlets , subcylindrical in transverse section , about half the length of the centrum ; consequently leaving a large proportion of the spinal cord unprotected by bone at the intervals of the successive neural arches .
The neural spine ( fig. 8 , ns ) is moderately produced , compressed and truncate ; its base is coextensive with the summit of the arch , and it contracts as it rises , with a sharp anterior border .
Not any of the cervical vertebrae possess the pleural elements which give the great transverse anterior breadth to the cervicals in the bird , and complete there the large vertebrarterial foramen on each side : nor is the hypapophysis double , forming a transverse pair , as in most of the neck-vertebrae of birds .
The processes answering to p ' in the Pterodactyle are rudimental , when present , in the bird .
The chief differences in seemingly answerable cervical vertebrae , in different individuals , perhaps species , of large Pterodactyles from the Upper Greensand , are seen in the degree of depth or depression of the centrum , with corresponding differences in the form of the foramen pneumaticum , as shown in figs. 5 , 7 and 8 ; with some slight differences in the hypapophysis affecting the lower contour of the centrum , and in the proportions of the articular surfaces of the zygapophyses .
In the sixth cervical vertebra the centrum becomes flatter below , and an anterior parapophysis ( p ) sometimes extends to the under part of the prezygapophysis ( z ) , circumscribing a small arterial foramen , as in fig. 11 .
In the last cervical ( fig. 12 ) the centrum becomes much shorter : a diapophysis ( d ) is more distinctly developed behind the prezygapophysis ( z ) , and these , with the parapophysis now completing a larger arterial canal , form a protuberance resembling that in the bird , on each side the fore-part of the vertebra .
In the dorsal vertebrae ( figs. 13-21 ) the centrums grow deeper as they shorten , with a proportionate expansion of the articular cup , as in fig. 17 , and ball , fig. 20 .
The posterior zygapophyses ( fig. 14 , z ' ) are more approximated , project from a higher level , are shorter , with the articular surfaces rather convex and looking more outward , and more distinct from the tubercle above ( fig. 15 , z ' , in ' ) .
The neural spine ( ns ) is thicker .
There is a small pneumatic foramen behind the base of each diapophysis .
The walls of the neural arch increase in height , expanding as they rise , to send out the diapophyses ( d ) to which the free ribs articulate .
These ribs are slender and hollow , as in Serpents ( fig. 23 , a ) .
In what appears to be a lumbar vertebra ( fig. 24 ) the neural arch again sinks , and the strong diapophysis ( fig. 24 , d ) projects far , without supporting a rib .
In the first sacral vertebra ( fig. 25 ) the fore-part of the neural arch ( d ) forms a broad transversely extended vertical wall above the small neural canal ( n ) , and the strong transverse process ( d..p ) sinks or extends its base vertically down to the lower border of the inferiorly flattened centrum ( fig. 25 , c and fig. 26 , c ) .
Fig. 27 shows parts of the bodies of three anchylosed sacral vertebrae of a neocomian Pterodactyle , the first having an anterior concave articulation ( ib. a ) , as in the larger specimen , fig. 25 ; the groove for the passage of the nerve notches the back part of the parapophysis close to the line of suture with the second sacral vertebra .
In this vertebra the corresponding nerve-notch is more advanced , leaving a short sutural surface behind , indicative of a position of the neural arch crossing for a short extent the line of junction of the second with the third sacral centrum .
The parapophyses ( p ) of the second vertebra are sent off almost .
on a level with the lower surface of the centrum , which is almost flat .
Atlas and aCis vertebrae of the Pterodactyle ( figs. 28-34 ) .
These vertebrae early coalesce with each other , but I have been able to separate them in a young specimen .
The atlas consists of a centrum ( figs. 28 , 29,30 , c ) and of two styliform neurapophyses ( ib. na ) ; in one specimen there seemed also to be a very small flattened neural spine .
The centrum is so short as to be discoid : it is flat where it joins and becomes anchylosed to the axis , and is concave for the occipital tubercle : this cup is circular ( fig. 28 , c ) .
The neurapophyses , resting on each side of the upper half of the centrum of the atlas , converge and articulate above with two small tubercles ( figs. 31 and 32 , z ) on the forepart of the neural arch of the axis , almost meeting but not uniting above the neural canal ( fig. 28 , n ) .
The body of the axis ( figs. 29 , cx ) is eight times larger than that of the atlas : it expands posteriorly , and terminates by a transversely elliptical ball ( b ) at the upper part of that end , and in a pair of thick short obtuse diverging apophyses ( p ' ) at the lower part .
There is a rudimental hypapophysial ridge ( fig. 33 , hy ) from the middle and toward the fore-part of the under surface of the centrum .
There is no trace of a hypapophysis , free or anchylosed , below the body of the atlas .
The centrum of the axis-vertebra is confluent with the neural arch : at the middle of the side , apparently crossing the line of junction , is a large subcircular aperture ( fig. 29 , o ) , which leads directly into the widely cancellous structure of the bone below the neural canal .
This vacuity , as in the other cervicals , answers to the 'foramen pneumaticum ' in the vertebrae of birds , and doubtless admitted a production from the air-cells extending along the neck of the Pterodactyle into the cancelli of the osseous tissue .
The neural arch ( nx ) rests upon the three anterior fourths of the centrum ; it expands as it passes backward ; and there , also , as it rises , until it sends off from each posterior angle the zygapophysis ( z ' ) , which has a tubercle above , and a flat articular surface below , looking downward and a little outward and backward .
The small tubercles at the fore-part of the neural arch ( fig. 31 , z ) , to which the neurapophyses of the atlas are ligamentously connected , may be the stunted homologues of anterior zygapophyses .
The neural spine begins by a low ridge between those tubercles , increasing rapidly in thickness behind ; but it has not been preserved in its full height in any specimen .
In the small atlas and axis ( figs. 32-34 ) the line of suture between the bodies of these two vertebrae is distinct .
In a somewhat larger specimen , the centrum of the atlas was separable by a smart blow , and showed the true anterior surface of that of the axis ( fig. 31 ) ; it is very slightly concave with a submedian prominence .
A vertical section of the anchylosed atlas and axis is shown in fig. 30 : the neural canal ( n ) expands at its posterior outlet : the large cancelli of the centrum are filled by the matrix .
On comparing the atlas and axis of the Pterodactyle with that of the Bird , the Ostrich for example , the atlas in the bird is represented by the neurapophyses which have coalesced below with a hypapophysis , forming an irregular ring of bone .
The centrum has coalesced with that of the axis forming a small prominence convex anteriorly , and filling up the vacuity at the upper part of the cup excavated in the fore-part of the hypapophysis : the neurapophyses are broad in the bird , and overlap the anterior zygapophyses of the axis : they meet above the neural canal , but retain the separating fissure there in the Ostrich .
The centrum of the axis is broader before than behind .
A short process , like a connate pleurapophysis from the fore-part of the centrum , unites with a diapophysis from the neural arch to form an arterial canal .
The pneumatic foramen is behind the diapophysis , and conducts to the cancellous tissue of the neural arch .
The centruml is produced into a strong hypapophysis below the posterior articular surface , but not expanded laterally into transverse processes , answering to those marked p ' in the Pterodactyle .
The hinder articular surface of the centrum of the axis of the bird is convex transversely , but concave vertically , not simply convex , as in the Pterodactyle ; thus a portion of the vertebra of that reptile , notwithstanding its pneumatic structure , might be distinguished from the vertebra of a bird .
The caudal region of the spine is that which , in the Pterosaurica , as in the Bats and most other natural groups , is subject to most variety .
In Pterodactylus ( Rhamphorhynchus ) Gemmn'ngi , v. MEYER , from Solenhofen slate , the tail is very long , and most of the long and slender vertebrae , between thirty and forty in number , seem to have coalesced into a stiff style for supporting an expanded interfemoral membrane .
In Pterodactylus longirostris , Cuv .
the tail is short , and the small and short vertebrae are free .
In the large Pterodactyles from the Cambridge Greensand , it would seem that the tail was of moderate length and the vertebrae are free .
The collections examined by me included fifteen caudal vertebrae .
The largest of these ( figs. 35-37 ) measures 11 inch in length ; it is slightly contracted in the middle ; the fore-part of the under surface is a little produced ; the back part almost flat between the rudimental processes ( p ' ) : the shallow anterior concavity ( fig. 36 , c ) has resumed its transversely elliptical shape , and the hinder convexity is defined below by a shallow groove connecting the processes ( p ' ) .
There is no pneumatic foramen , unless a small hole on each side the hinder outlet of the neural canal have served as such .
The neural arch is long and low , of one piece with the centrum , which extends beyond it posteriorly ; it sends off short obtuse zygapophyses before and behind : those in front extend beyond the cup of the centrum ; the surfaces on those behind look downward and backward .
The base of the spine is coextensive with the summit of the arch , but is narrow .
The neural canal is much contracted .
There is no indication of a haemal arch , either by articular or fractured anchylosed surfaces .
The diameter of the middle of this vertebra is 6 lines .
The next caudal vertebra in size measures 1 inch 5 lines .
The base of the neural spine begins two lines behind the fore-part of the arch , but terminates nearer the hind part .
The nerve-grooves notch the hinder zygapophyses .
Three more slender caudal vertebrae present each a length of 1 inch 3 lines : the diameter at the middle is 5 lines in one , 4 in a second , and 31 in the third vertebra showing that they become more slender without losing length .
A caudal vertebra , 3 lines across the middle , appears to have been nearly an inch in length ; but both extremities are injured .
The most perfect vertebrae of other species of Pterodactyles from older formations which I have as yet had opportunities of examining , are those of a rather large species from the oolitic slate at Stonesfield .
Dr. BUCKLAND kindly transmitted to me , some years ago , two drawings of one of these vertebrae ( figs. 38 and 39 ) .
They are more slender in proportion to their length than in the larger species from the Greensand .
The articular cup and ball of the centrum have the same relative position and transverse breadth .
The hypapophysis ( hy , fig. 39 ) is further from the anterior border .
The neural arch has the same superior breadth , compared with the centrum .
There seems to have been rather more development of the process uniting , the base of the anterior zygapophysis to the centrum .
The cervical vertebrae of the Pterodactylus ( Dimorphodon ) macronyx , from the lower Has of Dorsetshire , present the same type of structure .
EXPLANATION OF PLATE .
PLATE X. All the figures are of the natural size , and with the exception of fig. 22 ( Aptenodytes patachonica ) , belong to the Pterodactyle ; and of these , all , save figs. 23 , 38 , and 39 , are from the Upper Greensand , near Cambridge .
The details are explained in the text .
Fig. 1 .
Front view ) Fig. 2 .
Back view Fig. 3 .
Under view s of a middle cervical vertebra , Pterodactylus Sedgwiclcii .
Fig. 4 .
Upper view Fig. 5 .
Side'view J Fig. 6 .
Vertical longitudinal section of a similar but more mutilated vertebra .
Fig. 7 .
Side view of a middle cervical vertebra , Pterodactyl &amp; us Fittoni .
Fig. 8 .
Side view of probably fifth cervical vertebra , Pterodactylus Pittoni .
Fig. 9 .
Upper view of a middle cervical vertebra , Pterodactylus Fittoni .
Fig. 1 0 .
Under viewf Fig. 11 .
Front view of sixth cervical vertebra , Pterodactylus Pittoni .
Fig. 12 .
Front view of seventh cervical vertebra , Pterodactylus Fittoni .
Fig. 13 .
Front view of last cervical or first dorsal vertebra , Pterodactylus Sedgwickii .
Fig. 1 4 .
Back view Fig. 15 .
Side view of a dorsal vertebra of a smaller Pterodactyle , with the transverse Fig. 16 .
Front views .
processes broken off .
Fig. 17 .
Side view of a more posterior dorsal vertebra .
Fig. 18 .
Under surfacel Fig. 19 .
Hnder surface of centrum of large posterior dorsal vertebra .
Filg .
1 9 .
Hinder surfaces Fig. 20 .
Back view of a middle or posterior dorsal vertebra .
Fig. 21 .
Under surface of the dorsal vertebra , fig. 16 .
Fig. 22 .
Front view of fourth dorsal vertebra , Aptenodytes patachonmca .
Fig. 23 .
A rib of Pterodactylus Buciklandi , from Stonesfield Oolite .
Fig. 24 .
Front view of a lumbar vertebra , Pterodactylqus Sedgwickii .
Fig. 25 .
Front view of first sacral vertebra , Pterodactylus Sedgwickii .
Fig. 26 .
Under view of first and second sacral vertebra , Pterodactylus Sedgwickii .
Fig. 27 .
Front and under view of centrums of first three sacral vertebrae of a smaller , probably younger , Pterodactyle .
Fig. 28 .
Front view of atlas and axis vertebrae , Pterodactylus Sedgwickii .
Fig. 29 .
Side viewJ Fig. 30 .
Vertical longitudinal section of atlas and axis , Pterodactylus Sedgwickii .
Fig. 31 .
Front view of axis vertebra , Pterodactdylus Sedgwickii .
Fig. 32 .
Side view Fig. 33 .
Back view tof atlas and axis vertebrae , Pterodacty~lus Fittoni .
Fig. 34 .
Under view !
Fig. 35 .
Under view of an anterior caudal vertebra , Pterodactylus Sedgwiclkii .
Fig. 36 .
Front view J Fig. 37 .
Upper view of a cervical vertebra , Pterodactylus Buclklandi , from Stonesfield Fig. 38 .
Under viewr Oolite .
MWDcccLIx .
2 A in Tpwlq .
_NMDCCCCj IX ?
.FP/ e X. IU S Pi'~~~~~~~~~J 7 2 ' fls 1/ / _ 1f'{ .
' ... ... . .
, BCM A , s Z ' i t~~~~~~~2 %ettta.~~~~~~~~~d IP Df~~t~~i 'a a , { ft a , ~~3 2,3~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ } / /t ' VEREBA F TEODCWX E

