On Curves of the Third Order .
By the Rev. GEORGE SALMON , Trinity College , Dtublin .
Communicated by ARTHUR CAYLEY , Esq. , F.R.S. Received May 20 , -Read June 17,1858 .
THE following Notes are intended as supplementary to Mr. CAYLEY'S Memoir on Curves of the Third Order* .
If in a cubic U we substitute x+Xx ' , y+V ' , z+xz ' for x ' , y ' , z ' , let the result be written U+ 3xSj+ 3x2P+X3U ' , where S and P are evidently the polar conic and polar line of xy'z ' with respect to the cubic , and dU _dU IdU ( dU\ ' dU d 38=x +Y +z 3P=xxy , ,+yy +J In like manner let the result of a similar substitution in H be written H1+ 3x + 3X211++x3H ' , where N and II are the polar conic and polar line of x'y'z ' , with respect to the Hessian .
Then the identical equation which Mr. CAYLEY has given , p. 442 , may with advantage be replaced by the following , 3(Sfl P ) = HV V11 an equation which can be easily verified by the help of the canonical form U=X3+y3+z'+ 61xyz .
When x'y'z ' is on the curve U , the identical equation just written enables us to write the equation U= 0 in the form SII-P12=0 , a transformation from which many important consequences may be deduced .
In the first place , the equation shows that the lines P , I1 intersect on the cubic ; hence the tangential of the point x'y'z , that is to say , the point where the tangent P meets the cubic again , is the intersection of P with 11 , the polar of x'y'z ' with regard to the Hessian .
Again , the points of contact of tangents from x'y'z ' are known to be the intersections of S with the cubic ; and the equation shows that the points in question are the intersections of S , L Further , the equation shows that S=pl and P=p11 ( where pi is arbitrary ) intersect on the cubic .
But the second of these equations is the polar of x'ylz ' with respect to the former .
hence the cubic may be generated as the locus of the points of contact of tangents from a point xcy'z ' to a system of conics passing through four fixed points .
Let the conic S=p:u break up into two right lines ; then P=plcI obviously passes through the intersection of these lines : this intersection is therefore a point on the cubic and P-Pifl the tangent at it .
Hence the four points of contact of tangents to the cubic from x'y'z ' form a quadrangle , the three centres of which are on the cubic , and are the three points co-tangential with xy'z ' , that is to say , having the same tangential I. Formation of the Equation of the Conic through five consecutive Points of a Cubic .
Mr. CAYLEY has communicated to me an investigation of the equation of the above conic in the case where the cubic is given by the equation x , +zf+z3+6lxyz=O .
The investigation of the general case presents no greater difficulty , by the help of the identity with which we commenced .
Since S touches the cubic and P is the common tangent , the general equation of a conic touching U must be of the form S-aP ( where a =Ax + By+Cz denotes any right line whatever ) .
But by the identity referred to , the equation of the cubic may be written I-I(SUP ) =P( &gt; Mual ) .
Hence the four points where SaP meets the cubic again are its intersections with -al-l , and if the latter conic pass through xly'z ' , the former will pass through three consecutive points of the cubic .
But on substituting x'y'z ' for xyz , we have Y'= II ' H ' , and the condition that s-all shall pass through x'y'z ' is simply Mi'=1 .
In order that S-aP may pass through four consecutive points , E-all must have P for a tangent at the point x'y'z ' .
Now the tangent to .
alI ( being the polar of x'y'z ' with respect to this conic ) is 2 11 saTI al'i or , since oa=1 if-H ' , is II-all ' .
But this quantity must be proportional to P. Hence we have a= XP+ HtjII .
The general equation therefore of a conic through four consecutive points is : S -XPJ H ' I2 and passes through the two points where the former conic meets the cubic again .
Since these two conies have P for a common tangent , it will be possible , by adding the equations ( multiplied by suitable constants ) , to obtain a result divisible by P , and the quotient will be the line joining the points where the conic meets the cubic again .
It * See Mr. C.YEYs Memoir , p. 444 , and my 'Higher Plane Curves , ' p. 134 .
is necessary , then , in the first place to determine pi so that AS+ 112 may be divisible by P , which we do simply by equating to 0 the discriminant of this equation .
It will be observed that I-h112 denotes a pair of lines drawn through xy'z ' to touch : : hence in the discriminant that part vanishes which is not multiplied by A ; and because these two lines intersect on S , the part multiplied by p also vanishes .
Likewise the coefficient of p2 in the discriminant of !
S+:E vanishes , and the coefficient of p in the discriminant of pS +112 is the function which Mr. CAYLEY has called 0* .
Hence the discriminant of PS +E H17p is simply &amp; ' -%2jp , and therefore , if P"= Hin this conic will break up into two right lines , and we may write S+ ?
-4l 1'2=-f3P .
By the help of this equation , the equation of the cubic can be transformed from the form Tns-P:=o to the form ( P+p ) SPP2( + P ) } The form of the equation shows that 11+pP is the tangent at the point of the cubic which is tangential to the given one , and that j3--PHtl passes through the point where that tangent meets the cubic again , or , as we shall call it , through the second tangential of the given point .
The theorem contained in the last equation , viz. " that if a conic pass through four consecutive points of a cubic at x'y'z ' , the chord joining the remaining points passes through the second tangential of xiy'z ' , " may easily be deduced independently .
In fact , if abc=def be the equation of any cubic , any conic ab=-de meets the , cubic again in two points whose chord vczGf passes through the fixed point cf. And hence , as is well known , all conics through four points on a cubic meet the curve again in a chord passing through a fixed point which I call the opposite of the four given points , and which is constructed as follows : Let the line joining the points I and 2 meet the curve in a point 5 , let the line joining the points 3 and 4 meet the curve in a point 6 , then the line joining 5 , 6 meets the curve in the point 7 required .
Now when 1 and 2 , 3 and 4 coincide , the points 5 and 6 both coincide with the tangential of that point , and consequently 7 is the second tangential .
It follows immediately that the conic through five consecutive points meets the curve again in a point which is found by joining the original point to its second tangential , and taking the point where the joining line meets the curve again .
We deduce hence at once M. PLUCKER'S determination of the points at which a conic can osculate a cubic in six points .
In fact , if the point just determined were to coincide with the original point , the first and second tangential should coincide ; or in other words , the tangential should be a point of inflexion .
There are then twenty-seven conics which can meet a cubic in six consecutive points , and the points of contact are the points of contact of the tangents drawn from the nine points of inflexion .
We return to complete the algebraic solution of the problem to determine the equation of the conic meeting a cubic in five consecutive points at x'yz ' , and it is obvious that what remains to be done is to determine X so that the line may pass through x'y'z ' .
The only difficulty is to determine the result of substituting x'y'z ' in 3 .
Now if we differentiate , with regard to x , y , or z , the equation jS+:-H RI =(3P , and substitute a ' , y/ , z ' for x , i , z in the result , we get f31=2p. .
Hence , since Il'=H ' , Pt=O , we have ( 3 H1 tI ( II +bfP ' ) =-XIEI O. , which determines X in terms of p , which has been found already .
The equation , then , of the conic having five-point contact with U is ( +P){SI P(-+ pip ) =P2{u K( } It appears then that II+pP , the tangent at the first tangential , is the chord of intersection of the five-point conic with the polar conic S. We are thus also able to construct the five-point conic geometrically , since five points of it are given , namely , the two points of intersection of the tangent at the first tangential with S ; the point where the line joining the original point to the second tangential meets the curve again ; and of course the original point and its consecutive one .
Working with the equation x3 +y3+z3+lZxyz=0 Mr. CAYLEY has calculated the equation of the five-point conic , and thence the coordinates of the point where it meets the curve again .
I shall now form the coordinates of the same point , deriving them from the geometrical construction for that point which I have just given .
Let xyz be the coordinates of the point of contact , and XYZ those of its second tangential ; then the coordinates of the point required must be a+PXj y++ PIE , Xz+PZ , where X=x(X2+21YZ ) +y(Y2+ 21ZX)+Z(Z2+ 2lXY ) =X(e + 2lyz ) +Y(yz+ 2lzx ) +Z(Z2+ 2lxy ) I write for abbreviation a , 3 , ry instead of X3 , y3 , Z3 ; then the coordinates of the first tangential are and those of the second tangential X=x(I-r){13(r-ci4-r(a--)3 } ; Y=y(r-a){ry.-13)3.-a(f3-r)3 } Z =Z(a- ) { cz(3-y)3-(y-a)3 } .
In calculating the expressions for X and , I have found the following theorems useful .
Let ( 13-r)2+ ( rM)2+ ( a-f)2=2A , t(1-y)2+1 ( r )2 ?
r ( o-0)2= B , *2(f r)2+iP2(rV)2+ r2(f)2 2C , ( a-)(f-r)(r-a)=Q .
Then ( 13-r)4+ ( r-a4_ + ( a-_)4 =2A2 , Ax(AC Q2 ) QX , Ay(AC Q2 ) Qy , Az(AC Q2 ) Qz $ .
The condition , then , that these coordinates should be the original x , y , z , is Q=0 .
But Q denotes the nine lines joining the points of contact of tangents drawn from the point of inflexion .
This , then , coincides with M. PLtCKER'S determination , already referred to , of the points of contact of osculating conics .
Osculating Culbics .
If through eight consecutive points of a cubic several cubics be drawn , these all meet the curve again in a fixed ninth point , which can easily be determined .
In fact , if we consider the nine points of intersection of two cubics , the opposite ( see page 537 ) of any four lies on the same conic with the remaining five .
For let the equation of one be AU=BV and of the other CU=IDV , where A , B , C , D represent right lines and U , V conics ; then the intersections of UV are points common to both cubics , and AB , CD the opposite points in each cubic .
But by combining the equations , we get for the equation of the conic through the remaining five points of intersection AID BC , which passes through the two opposite points .
Q. E. D. The theorem may be otherwise stated in what is easily seen to be an equivalent form : the opposites of any two sets of four out of the nine points of intersection lie in a right line with the ninth .
Now we have already proved that , in the case of four consecutive points the opposite is the second tangential to the original point .
Hence , in the case of eight consecutive points , the point through which all cubics through these meet the curve again , is simply the third tangential of the original point .
In other words , at the given point A draw a tangent meeting the curve again in B ; at B draw a tangent meeting the curve in C ; at C draw a tangent meeting it again in D : then D is the point through which all osculating cubics must pass .
If AC meet the curve again in E , it has been already shown that E is the point through which all osculating conics must pass ; and it is to be observed that the intersection of AD and BE lies on the cubic .
It may be proposed to determine the points at which it shall be possible to draw cubics osculating the given curve in nine points ; or in other words , such that the third tangential ID may coincide with the original point A. It is evident that in this case the points E and C will coincide ; that therefore the coordinates of E , given at the top of this page , must reduce to X , Y , Z ; and it has been proved that the condition that this should happen is A(AC -Q2)==0 .
Since A is the sum of three squares , it is evident that A= 0 can denote no real locus .
* These coordinates are of the 25th degree in the original coordinates .
Mr. CAYuFv has informed me that Mr. SYLVESTER has established that the degree of the coordinates of every derivative point is necessarily a square number .
I am led by induction to believe that in the case of three derivative points in a right line , the sum of the square roots of their degrees taken with proper signs is always cipher .
Also , since 4AC-B2=3Q2 , the condition ACQ2=0 may be written B2-Q2= 0 , and breaks up into the factors B+Q= 0 , or x3(y3_ z3)2+y3(z3--x3)2+z3(93 -y3)2+(X3-_ y3)(y3_z3)(z3_X3 ) = 0 , or X6y3+yzz3 +z6x334lyIz3= 0 , and v3y6t+y3z6+zIX63a3y3z3 = 0 .
Hence there are in general seventy-two real or imaginary points of contact of osculating cubics .
When a point on a cubic is determined such that it is its own third tangential , it , together with its first and second tangential , determines a system of right lines , in terms of which the cubic can be transformed to the new canonical form xly +y2z + z2x+ 2x2mxyz= 0 , in which form the points of inflexion are determined by the right lines x3+y3+33xyz= 0 .
It may be observed that , according to circumstances , one of the two canonical forms is simpler than the other .
Thus for the case S=0 , when the Hessian is one real and two imaginary lines , the canonical forms are e +yty2Z +Z2X= 0 and 3 +y3+z3+ 6xyz= 0 , the former being the simpler .
On the contrary , when the Hessian is three real lines , the form x3+ y3+z3 is simpler than X2y +y2z +z2x+ 2mxyz , where m3= 3 .

