On some Physical Properties of Ice .
By JOHN TYNDALL , F.R.S. , Professor of Natural Philosophy in the Royal Institution of Great Britain .
Received December 17 , -Read December 17 , 1857 .
THE observations upon Glaciers , to be recorded in a subsequent paper , led me to make some experiments upon the physical properties of ice , the results of which are , I hope , of sufficient interest to justify me in presenting them to the Royal Society . ?
I. 1 .
I availed myself of the fine sunny weather with which we were favoured last September and October , to examine the effects of solar heat upon ice .
The experiments were made with the Wenham Lake and Norway ice .
Slabs were formed of the substance , varying from one to several inches in thickness , and these were placed in the path of a beam rendered convergent by a double convex lens 4 inches in diameter , and possessing a focal distance of 101inches .
The slabs were usually so placed , that the focus of parallel rays fell within the ice .
Having first found the position of the focus in air , the lens was screened ; the ice was then placed in position , the screen was removed , and the effect was watched through an ordinary pocket lens .
2 .
A plate of ice an inch thick , with parallel sides , was first examined : on removing the screen the transparent mass was crossed by the sunbeams , and the path of the rays through it was instantly studded by a great number of little luminous spots , produced at the moment and resembling shining air-bubbles .
When the beam was sent through the edge of the plate , so that it traversed a considerable thickness of the ice , the path of the beam could be traced by those brilliant spots , as it is by the floating motes in a dark room .
3 .
In lake ice the planes of freezing are easily recognized by the stratified appearance which the distribution of the air-bubbles gives to the mass .
A cube was cut from a perfectly transparent portion of the ice , and the solar beam was sent through the cube in three rectangular directions successively .
One was perpendicular to the plane of freezing , and the other two parallel to it .
The bright bubbles were formed in the ice in all three cases .
4 .
When the surfaces perpendicular to the planes of freezing were examined by a lens , after exposure to the light , they were found to be cut up by innumerable small parallel fissures , with here and there minute spurs shooting from them , which gave the fissures , in some cases , a feathery appearance .
When the portions of the ice traversed by the beam were examined parallel to the surface of freezing , a very beautiful appearance revealed itself .
Allowing the light from a window to fall upon the ice at a suitable incidence , the interior of the mass was found filled with little flower-shaped figures .
Each flower had six petals , and at its centre was a bright spot , which shone with more than metallic brilliancy .
The petals were manifestly composed of water , and were consequently dim , their visibility depending on the small difference of refrangibility between ice at 320 FAHR. and water at the same temperature .
5 .
For a long time I found the relation between the planes of these flowers and the planes of freezing perfectly constant .
They were always parallel to each other .
The development of the flowers was independent of the direction in which the beam traversed the ice .
Hence , when an irregular mass of transparent ice was presented to me , by sending a sunbeam through it , I could tell in an instant the direction in which it had been frozen .
Allowing the beam to enter the edge of a plate of ice , and causing the latter to move at right angles to the beam , so that the radiant heat traversed different portions of the ice in succession , when the track of the beam was observed through an eye-glass , the ice , which a moment before was optically continuous , was instantly starred by those lustrous little bubbles , and around each of them the formation and growth of its associated flower could be distinctly observed .
6 .
The maximum effect was confined to a space of about an inch from the place at which the beam first struck the ice .
In this space the absorption , which resolved the ice into liquid flowers , for the most part took place , but I shave traced the effect to a depth of several inches in large blocks of ice .
7 .
At a distance , however , from the point of incidence , the spaces between the flowers became greater ; and it was no uncommon thing to see flowers developed in planes a quarter of an inch apart , while no change whatever was observed in the ice between these planes .
8 .
The pieces of ice experimented on appeared to be quite homogeneous , and their transparency was very perfect .
Why then did the substance yield at particular points 1 Were they really weak points of crystalline structure , or did the yielding depend upon the manner in which the calorific wave impinged upon the molecules of the body at these points ?
However these and other questions may be answered , the experiments have an important bearing upon the question of absorption .
In ice the absorption of the rays which produce the flowers is fitful , and not continuous ; and there is no reason to suppose that in other solids the case is not the same , though their constitution may not be such as to reveal it* .
I have applied the term " bubbles " to the little bright disks in the middle of the flowers , simply because they resembled the little air-globules entrapped in the ice ; but whether they contained air or not could only be decided by experiment .
Notwithstanding the incomparable diathermaneity of the substance , M. KNOBLAUCn finds that when plates of rock-salt are thick enough , they always exhibit an elective absorption .
Effects like those above described may possibly be the cause of this .
213 9 .
Pieces of ice were therefore prepared , through which the sunbeams were sent so as to develope the flowers in considerable quantity and magnitude .
These pieces were then dipped into warm water contained in a glass vessel , and the effect , when the melting reached the bright spots , was carefully observed through a lens .
The moment a liquid connexion was established between them and the atmosphere , the apparent bubbles suddenly collapsed , and no trace of air rose to the surface of the warem water .
10 .
This is the result which ought to be expected .
The volume of water at 320 being less than that of ice at the same temperature , the formation of each flower ought to be attended with the formation of a vacuum , which disappears in the manner described when the ice surrounding it is melted .
Similar experiments were made with ice in which true air-bubbles were enclosed .
When the melting liberated the air , the bubbles rose slowly through the liquid and floated for a time upon its surface .
11 .
Exposure for a second , or even less , to the action of the sun was sufficient to develope the flowers ( 4 ) in the ice .
The first appearance of the central star of light was often accompanied by an audible clink , as if the substance had been suddenly ruptured .
The edges of the petals were at the commencement definitely curved thus : ; but when the action was permitted to continue , and sometimes even without this , when the sun was strong , the edges of the petals became serrated thus : the beauty of the figure being thereby augmented .
Sometimes a number of elementary flowers grouped together to form a thickly-leaved cluster resembling a rose .
Here and there also amid the flowers a liquid hexagon might be observed , but such were of rare occurrence .
12 .
The act of crystalline dissection , if I may use the term , thus performed by the solar beams , is manifestly determined by the manner in which the crystalline forces have arranged the molecules .
By the abstraction of heat the molecules are enabled to build themselves together , by the introduction of heat this architecture is taken down .
The perfect symmetry of the flowers , from which there is no deviation , argues a similar symmetry in the molecular architecture ; and hence , as optical phenomena depend upon the molecular arrangement , we might pronounce with perfect certainty from the foregoing experiments , that ice is , what Sir DAVID BREWSTER long ago proved it to be , optically speaking , uniaxal , the axis being perpendicular to the surface of freezing . ?
IL 13 .
On the 25th of September , while examining a perfectly transparent piece of Norway ice , which had not been traversed by the condensed sunbeams , I found the interior of the mass crowded with parallel liquid disks , varying in diameter from the tenth to the hundredth of an inch .
These disks were so thin , that when looked at in section they were reduced to the finest lines .
They had the exact appearance of the circular spots of oily scum which float on the surface of mutton broth , and in the pieces of ice first examined they always lay in the planes of freezing .
14 .
As time progressed this internal disintegration of the ice appeared to become more pronounced , so that some pieces of Norway ice examined in the middle of November , appeared to be reduced to a congeries of water-cells entangled in a skeleton of ice .
The effect of this was rendered manifest to the hand on sawing a block of this ice , by the facility with which the saw went through it .
15 .
There seems to be no such thing as absolute homogeneity in nature .
Change commences at distinct centres instead of being uniformly and continuously distributed , and in the most apparently homogeneous substance we should discover defects , if our means of observation were fine enough .
The above observations show that some portions of a mass of ice melt more readily than others .
The melting temperature of the substance is set down at 320FAHR .
, but the absence of perfect homogeneity , whether from difference of crystalline texture or some other cause* , makes the melting temperature oscillate to a slight extent on both sides of the ordinary standard .
Let this limit expressed in parts of a degree be t. Some parts of a block of ice will melt at a temperature of 32t , while others require a temperature of 32 + t : the consequence will be that such a block raised to the temperature of 32 ?
will have some of its parts liquid , and others solid .
16 .
When a mass exhibiting the water-disks was examined by a concentrated sun-beam , the six leaved flowers before referred to iwere always formed in the planes of the disks .
17 .
In all my earlier experiments I found the rule to hold good , that both disks and flowers were developed in the planes of freezing , but I was subsequently surprised to find , in the self-same mass of ice , the disks lying in different planes .
On examining such pieces I found them traversed by hazy surfaces of discontinuity , which divided the apparently continuous mass into irregular prismatic segments .
When examined by allowing the red light of a fire to cross it , such ice had a beautiful appearance .
The interior walls of the segments were thickly covered with rich liquid disks ; in some cases the vision plunged unimpeded into the ice to a depth of several inches , while in others the prismatic segments were dotted with disks to their very centres .
Fig. I Fig. 1 .
represents one of a number of cases of this kind which I had an opportunity of examining .
The network of lines are the intersections of the bounding surfaces of the segments with the surface of the slab of ice : the short lines in each segment represent the sections of the disks ; and it will be observed that while in each single segment their directions are alike , in no two segments is this the case .
The flat rings denote that the disks , at these places , were parallel to the surface of the ice slab , while in all the other cases they were perpendicular to it .
18 .
I placed this slab ona table which could be caused to rotate , and bringing it into the path of a concentrated sunbeam , caused the beam to travel all round it .
The little flowers started into existence with extreme suddenness and beauty .
In all cases the planes of theflowers were _parallel to the planes of the disks .
19 .
Hence the conclusion that the flowers are always parallel to the surface of freezing , must not go without qualification .
There is no doubt that each of the fragments above referred to , possesses an optic axis perpendicular to the planes of the flowers developed in it ; the directions of these axes being therefore as various as the planes aforesaid .
How is this result brought about ?
Has the molecular structure of the ice been always what the last experiments show it to be ?
Sir DAVID BREWSTER'S observations are in opposition to this idea .
Or can it be that the ice has changed , by a rearrangement of the constituent particles of each segment , this arrangement producing the surfaces of discontinuity by which the segments are bounded ?
At present we are confined to mere conjectures , but I hope the coming winter will enable me to investigate this highly interesting question . ?
III .
20 .
What has been already said will prepare us for the consideration of an associated class of phenomena of great physical interest .
The larger masses of ice which I examined exhibited layers in which bubbles of air were collected in unusual quantity , marking , no doubt , the limits of successive acts of freezing .
These bubbles were usually elongated .
Between two such beds of bubbles a clear stratum of ice intervened ; and a clear surface layer , which , from its appearance , seemed to have suffered more from external influences than the rest of the ice , was associated with each block .
In this superficial portion I observed detached air-bubbles irregularly distributed , and associated with each vesicle of air , a bleb of water which had the appearance of a drop of clear oil within the solid .
The adjacent figure will give a notion of these composite cavities : the unshaded circle represents the air-bubble , and the shaded space adjacent , the water .
21 .
When the quantity of water was sufficiently large , which was usually the case , on turning the ice round , the bubble shifted its posi/ ;77~ / 9 )0 / -1 / 767 7/ tion , rising always at the top of the bleb of water .
Sometimes , however , the cell was very flat , and the air was then quite surrounded by the liquid .
These composite cells often occurred in pellucid ice , which showed inwardly no other sign of disintegration .
This is manifestly the same phenomenon as that which struck M. AGASSiZ so forcibly during his earlier investigations on the glacier of the Aar .
The same appearances have been described by the Brothers SCHLAGINTWEIT , and finally attention has been forcibly drawn to the subject in a recent paper by Mr. HUXLEY , published in the Philosophical Magazine * .
22 .
The only explanation of this phenomenon hitherto given , and adopted apparently without hesitation , is that of M. AGASsIZ and the Messrs. SCHLAGINTWEIT .
These observers attribute the phenomenon to the diathermancy of the ice which permits the radiant heat to pass through the substance , to heat the bubbles of air , and cause them to melt the surrounding icet .
The apparent simplicity of this explanation contributed to ensure its general acceptance ; and yet I think a little reflection will show that the hypothesis , simple as it may appear , is attended with grave difficulties .
23 .
For the sake of distinctness I will here refer to a most interesting fact , observed first by M. AGASSIZ , and afterwards by the Messrs. SCHLAGINTWEIT .
In the ' Systeme Glaciaire it is described in these words : " I ought also to mention a singular property of those air-bubbles , which at first struck us forcibly , but which has since received a very satisfactory explanation .
When a fragment containing air-bubbles is exposed to the action of the sun , the bubbles augment insensibly .
Soon , in proportion as they enlarge , a transparent drop shows itself at some point of the bubble .
This drop , in enlarging , contributes , on its part , to the enlargement of the cavity , and following its progress a little , it finishes by predominating over the bubble of air .
The latter then swims in the midst of a zone of water and tends incessantly to reach the most elevated point , at least if the flatness of the cavity does not hinder it .
" 24 .
The satisfactory explanation here spoken of is that already mentioned : let us now endeavour to follow the hypothesis to its consequences .
Comparing equal weights of both substances , the specific heat of water being 1 , that of air is 025 .
Hence to raise a pound of water one degree in temperature , a pound of air would have to lose four degrees .
25 .
Let us next compare equal volumes of the substances .
The specific gravity of water being 1 , that of air is 4- ; hence a pound of air is 77(0 times the volume of a pound of water ; and hence for a quantity of air to raise its own volume of water 1 degree , it must part with 770 X 4 , or 3080 degrees of temperature .
Now the latent heat of water is 1420.6 FAHR. , hence the quantity of heat required to melt a certain weight of ice is 142 6 times the quantity required to raise the same weight of water 1 degree in temperature ; hence a measure of air , in order to reduce its own volume of ice to the liquid condition , must lose 3080 X 142-6 , or 439,208 degrees of temperature .
27 .
This then gives us an idea of the amount of heat which , according to the above hypothesis , is absorbed by the bubble and communicated to the ice during the time occupied in melting a quantity of the latter equal in volume to the bubble , which time is stated to be brief ; that is to say , the quantity of heat supposed to be absorbed by the air would , if it had not been communicated to the ice , have been sufficient to raise the bubble itself to a temperature 160 times that of fused cast iron .
Had air this power of absorption , it might be attended with inconvenient consequences to the denizens of the earth ; for we should dwell at the bottom of an atmospheric ocean , the upper strata of which would effectually arrest all calorific radiation .
28 .
It is established by the experiments of DELAROCHE and MELLONJI , that a calorific beam , emerging from any medium which it has traversed for any distance , possesses , in an exalted degree , the power of passing through an additional length of the same substance .
Absorption takes place , for the most part , in the portion of the medium first traversed by the rays .
In the case of a plate of glass , for example , 1 7-1 per cent. of the heat proceeding from a lamp is absorbed in the first fifth of a millimetre ; whereas , after the rays have passed through 6 millimetres of the substance , an additional distance of 2 millimetres absorbs less than 2 per cent. of the rays thus transmitted .
Supposing the rays to have passed through a plate 25 millimetres , or an inch in thickness , there is no doubt that the heat emerging from such a plate would pass through a second layer of glass , I millimetre thick , without suffering any measureable absorption .
For an incomparably stronger reason , the quantity of solar heat absorbed by a bubble of air at the earth 's surface , after the rays have traversed the whole thickness of our atmosphere , and been sifted in their passage through it , must be wholly inappreciable .
29 .
To the sifting power of the atmosphere we must add , in the case of the glacier , the absorptive power of the ice .
Some notion of this power , as compared with that of air , may be gathered from the following facts:-As regards the variation of the intensity of radiant heat with the distance , the law of inverse squares is capable of the strictest experimental verification in air , even when the source of heat is far below 212 ' FAHR. This implies that the absorption in the space of air through which the heat passes is too small to disturb the harmony of the law .
Now a plate of ice , one-tenth of an inch thick , is absolutely impervious to heat emanating from a source , not only of 212 ?
, but of 752 ?
FAHR. ; and is capable , moreover , of absorbing 99-i per cent. of the calorific rays emitted by an incandescent platinum wiref .
( La Thermochrose , p. 164 .
) * La Thermochrose , p. 202 .
tI can hardly forbear drawing attention here to the remarkable influence which the element hyydrogeni appears to exercise upon radiant heat , and the longer waves of light .
Wherever hydrogen enters into a Such , if I mistake not , are the properties of radiant heat which modern physics have revealed ; and I think they render it evident that the hypothesis of M. AGASSiZ and the Messrs. SCIILAGINTWEIT was accepted without due regard to its consequences .
But as the sun does reach the lower strata of the atmosphere , it may be thought that we are protected from its effects by the radiation from the air neutralizing its absorption .
The fact however is that air may be heated to an intense degree without showing any measureable amount of radiation .
The hot current from an Argand chimney produces , according to MELLONJ , no sensible effect upon a delicate thermo-electric apparatus .
Hence it is not because the air gets rid of its heat by radiation , but simply because its power of absorption is infinitely behind that supposed by the hypothesis of M. AGASSiZ and the Messrs. SCIHLAGINTWEIT , that animal and vegetable existence at the earth 's surface is possible .
When air-bubbles occurred in those portions of the ice where the liquid disks appeared , the associated water spread out on planes parallel to those of the disks , evidently in consequence of the freer yielding of the ice in these planes .
Keeping this remark in view and comparing fig. 1 with fig. 10 , plate 4 of M. AGASSIZ ' Atlas , the resemblance of both phenomena will at once be perceived .
The glacier ice , like the compound , I think it may be predicted that it will destroy the longer undulations .
For the present I will avoid speculation upon this subject , and confine myself to facts .
If we examine the list of solid substances whose power to transmit radiant heat instantaneously have been examined by MELLONr , we find that those at the lower end of the list , that is , the most imperfectly diathermanous substances , all contain hydrogen .
In no single case , where this element occurs , is the substance capable of transmitting rays from a source of 752 ?
FAHR. ; while in every case where it does not occur , the power of transmitting rays from this source is manifested in a greater or less degree .
Amber , gum , citric acid , alum , sugar-candy , tartrate of potash and soda , are the substances which exercise this destructive agency UpOnl the longer undulations ; ice being the most non-dliathermanous transparent body hitherto examined .
Turning to MELLONI'S list of liquids , the same fact reveals itself .
There is a sudden fall in the power of transmission at the place where hydrogen enters the list .
Protochloride of phosphorus transmits 62 per cent. of the rays incident upon it , but the next substance , hydrocarburet of chlorine , transmits only 37 per cent. From this point to the end of the Table the substances named all contain hydrogen , the list being closed by distilled water , which transmits only 11 per cent. of the calorific rays from an Argand lamp .
To the same element , I believe , is to be referred the difference between Sir W. HIERSCHEL and SEEBECK as to the place of maximum heat in the solar spectrum .
HERsCEL found this place to be beyond the extreme red , but SEEBECK , with a prism of sulphuric acid , found it to be in the orange , while with a prism of water he found it in the yellow .
MELLoIi has shown that this is due to the destruction of the less refrangible rays by the two liquids , the sulphuric acid being regarded by him as acting in a manner analogous to water. .
In both the water and the sulphuric acid used by SEEBECK , I believe the hydrogen to be the agent which gives the observed character to the results .
The colour of ice and water is also a necessary consequence of this hostility of the element hydrogen to the instantaneous passage of the longer undulations .
The mathematical theory of undulation is , perhaps , perfect , but the physics of the process , that is , the real affections of light and heat in their passage through bodies , are wholly unknown to us .
Cases , therefore , like the foregoing , which single out a particular substance as exhibiting a special department towards light and heat , are , I think , of great value .
Increased knowledge will probably enable us to connect these effects with the other properties of this substance , and thus establish physical relations which axe now unknown to us .
Norway ice with which I experimented , is divided into segments by surfaces of discontinuity .
The airand water-cavities are represented as flattened , but , as in the lake ice , they seem flattened in all directions .
M. AGASSiZ regards the flattening of the cavities as a certain proof that they have been squeezed flat by pressure ; and he attributes the different directions of flattening to a power of independent motion possessed by each fragment .
The perfect similarity , however , of the phenomena presented by the two kinds of ice must render us cautious in accepting an explanation which may apply to the one , but excludes the other . ?
IV .
30 .
But the question still remains , how are the water-chambers produced within the ice ?
Mr. HUXLEY throws out the suggestion , which our knowledge at the time of his observations rendered most probable , namely , that the water had never been frozen at all , but had preserved itself , like the liquid in the cavities of a Gruyere cheese , from the never downwards .
31 .
One simple test will , I think , decide the question whether the liquid is or is not the product of melted ice .
If it be , its volume must be less than that of the ice which produced it , and the bubble associated with the water must be composed of rarefied air .
Hence , if on establishing a liquid connexion between this bubble and the atmosphere a diminution of volume be observed , this will indicate that the water has been produced by the melting of the ice .
32 .
From a block of Norway ice , containing such compound bubbles , I cut a prism , and immersing it in warm water , contained in a glass vessel , I carefully watched through the side of the vessel the effect of the melting upon the bubbles .
They invariably shrunk in volume at the moment the surrounding ice was melted , and the diminished globule of air rose to the surface of the water .
I then arranged matters so that the wall of the cavity might be melted away underneath , without permitting the bubble of air at the top to escape .
At the moment the melting reached the cavity the air-bubble instantly collapsed to a sphere , possessing , in some cases , far less than the hundredth part of its original volume .
The experiments were repeated with several distinct masses of ice , and always with the same result .
I think , therefore , it may be regarded as certain that the liquid cells are the product of melted ice* .
33 .
Considering the manner in which ice imported into this country is protected from the solar rays , I think we must infer that in the specimens examined by met , the ice in contact with the bubble has been melted by heat which has been conducted through the substance without visible prejudice to its solidity .
34 .
Paradoxical as this may appear , I think it is no more than might reasonably be expected from a priori considerations .
The heat of a body is referred , at the present day , to a motion of its particles .
When this motion reaches such an intensity as to liberate sufficiently the particles of a solid from their mutual attractions , the body passes into the liquid condition .
Now as regards the amount of motion necessary to produce this liberty of liquidity , the particles at the surface of a mass of ice must be very differently circumstanced from those in the interior , which are influenced and controlled on every side by other particles .
But if we suppose a cavity to exist within the mass , the particles bounding that cavity will be in a state resembling that of the particles at the surface ; and by the removal of all opposing action on one side , the molecules may be liberated by a force which the surrounding mass has transmitted without prejudice to its solidity .
Supposing , for example , that solidity is limited by molecular vibrations of a certain amplitude , those at the surface of the internal cavity may exceed this , while those between the cavity and the external surface of the ice may , by their reciprocal actions , be preserved within it , just as the terminal member of a series of elastic balls is detached by a force which has been transmitted by the other members of the series without visible separation A 35 .
Where , however , experiment is within reach , we ought not to trust to speculation ; and I was particularly anxious to obtain an unequivocal reply to the question whether an interior portion of a mass of ice could be melted by heat which had passed through the substance by the process of conduction .
A piece of Norway ice , containing a great number of the liquid disks already described , and several cells of air and water , was enveloped in tinfoil and placed in a mixture of pounded ice and salt .
A few minutes sufficed to freeze the disks to thin dusky circles , which appeared , in some cases , to be formed of concentric rings , and reminded me of the sections of certain agates .
Looked at sideways , these disks were no thicker than a fine line .
The water-cells were also frozen , and the associated air-bubbles were greatly diminished in size .
I placed the mass of ice between me and a gas-light , and observed it through a lens : aft6r some time the disks and water-cells showed signs of breaking up again .
The rings of the disks disappeared ; the contents seemed to aggregate so as to form larger liquid spots , and finally , some of them were reduced to clear transparent disks as before .
36 .
But , an objection to this experiment is , that the ice may have been liquefied by the radiation from the lamp , and I have experiments to describe which will show the justice of this objection .
A rectangular slab , 1 inch thick , 3 inches long and 2 wide , was therefore taken from a mass of Norway ice , in which the associated airand watercells were very distinct .
I enveloped it in tinfoil and placed it in a freezing mixture .
In about ten minutes the water-blebs were completely frozen within the mass .
It was immediately placed in a dark room , where no radiant heat could possibly affect it , and examined every quarter of an hour .
The dim frozen spots gradually broke up into little water parcels , and in two hours the water-blebs were perfectly restored in the centre of the slab of ice .
When last examined , this plate was half an inch thick , and the drops of liquid were seen right at its centre .
* Of course I inteud this to help the conception merely .
A s econd piece , similarly frozen and wrapped up in flannel , showed the same deportment .
In an hour and a half the frozen water surrounding the air-bubbles was restored to its liquid condition .
Hence no doubt can remain as to the possibility of effecting liquefaction in the interior of a mass of ice , by heat which has passed by conduction through the substance without melting it .
38 .
I have already referred to the formation of the liquid cavities observed by M. AGAssIz , when glacier ice was exposed to the sun .
The same effect may be produced by exposure to a glowing coal fire .
On the 21st and 22nd of November I thus exposed plates of clear Wenham Lake ice , which contained some scattered air-bubbles .
At first the bubbles were sharply rounded , and without any trace of water .
Soon , however , those near the surface , on which the radiant heat fell , appeared encircled by a liquid ring , which expanded and finally became crimped at its border , as shown in the adjacent figure .
The crimping became more pronounced as the action was permitted to continue* .
A second plate , crowded with bubbles , was held as near to the fireas the hand could bear .
On withdrawing it , and examining it through a pocket lens , the appearance was perfectly beautiful .
In many cases the bubbles appeared to be surrounded by a series of concentric rings , the outer ring surrounding all the others like a crimped frill .
39 .
I could not obtain these effects by placing the ice in contact with a plate of metal obscurely heatedt , nor by the radiation from an obscure source .
Indeed ice , as before remarked , is impervious to radiant heat from such a source+ .
The rays from a common fire also are wholly absorbed near the surface upon which they strike , and hence the described internal liquefaction was confined to a thin layer close to this surface .
40 .
But not only does liquefaction occur in connexion with the bubbles , but the " flowers , " already described as produced by the solar beams , start by hundreds into existence , when a slab of transparent ice is placed before a glowing coal fire .
They , however , are also confined to a thin stratum of the substance close to the surface of incidence .
In the experiments made in this way , the central stars of the flowers were often bounded by sinuous lines of great beauty .
41 .
The foregoing considerations show that liquefaction takes place at the surface of a mass of ice at a lower temperature than that required to liquefy the interior of the solid .
At the surface the temperature 32 ?
produces a vibration , to produce which , within the ice , would necessitate a temperature of 320+x ; the increment x being the additional temperature necessary to overcome the resistance to liquefaction , arising from the action of the molecules upon each other .
42 .
Now let us suppose two pieces of ice at 320 , with moistened surfaces , to be brought into contact with each other , we thereby virtually transfer the touching portions of these pieces from the surface to the interior , where 32+x is the melting temperature .
Liquefaction will therefore be arrested at those surfaces .
Before being brought togetiier , the surfaces had the motion of liquidity , but the interior of the ice has not this motion ; and as equilibrium will soon set in between the masses on each side of the liquid film and the film itself , the film will be reduced to a state of motion inconsistent with liquidity .
In other words , it becomes frozen tand cements the two surfaces of ice between which it is enclosed * .
If I am right here , the importance of the physical principles involved are sufficiently manifest : if I am wrong , I hope I have so expressed myself as to render the detection of my error easy .
Right or wrong , my aim has been to give as explicit utterance to my meaning as the subject will admit of .
V. 43 .
Mr. FARADAY'S experiments on the freezing together of pieces of ice at 320 FAHR. , and all of those recounted in the paper published by Mr. HUXLEY and myself , find their explanation in the principles here laid down .
The conversion of snow into never , and of nev6 into glacier , is perhaps the grandest illustration of the same principle .
It has been , however , suggested to me that the sticking together of two pieces of ice may be an act of cohesion , similar to that which enables pieces of wetted glass , and other similar bodies , to stick together .
This is not the case .
There is no sliding motion possible to the ice .
When contact is broken , it breaks with the snap due to the rupture of a solid .
Glass and ice cannot be made to stick thus together , neither can glass and glass , nor alum and alum , nor nitre and nitre , at common temperatures .
I have , moreover , placed pieces of ice together over night and found them in the morning so rigidly frozen together , that when I sought to separate them , the surface of fracture passed through one of them in preference to taking the surface of regelation .
Many sagacious persons have also suggested to me that the ice transported to this country from Norway and the MWenharn Lake may possibly retain a residue of its cold , sufficient to freeze a thin film enclosed between two pieces of the substance .
But the facts already adverted to are a sufficient reply to this surmise .
The ice experimented on cannot be regarded as a magazine of cold , because parcels of 'liquid water exist within it .
44 .
Nevertheless , as our present knowledge of the facility with which ice permits heat to pass through it by conduction is , as far as I know , absolutely null , I was glad to avail myself of an opportunity which presented itself of obtaining some approximate notion of this power .
I owe this opportunity to the kindness of Mr. HARRISON , who had devised and perfected a machine for the manufacture of ice by the evaporation of ether .
I first examined a mass of ice of the shape of the frustum of a cone .
The diameter of the base was 1O2 inches , of the top 71 inches , and the length of the frustum was 2 feet .
During the freezing of this mass a thermometer fixed on the ice showed a temperature of 80 below the zero of FAIIR .
, or 40 ?
of FAHR. below the freezing-point of water .
45 .
Fourteen hours after it had been frozen , the temperature of the mass , to a depth of 2 inches below the surface , was accurately 320 FAIIR .
At the heart of the frustum the temperature was 314 ? .
The superficial portions of the frustum had been the coldest , and we see that in fourteen hours the ice of these portions rose forty degrees in temperature .
46 .
On the 24th of April , Mr. HARRISON had the kindness to place his excellent machine entirely at my disposition .
The vessel which contained the water to be frozen was shaped like the inverted frustum of a cone , and was surrounded by a jacket , between which and the side of the frustum vaporized ether circulated ; the whole being placed in a vessel of water .
At 11 o'clock A.M. , I placed a thermometer ( A ) in contact with the side of the vessel , and about 2 inches below the surface of the water .
The machine commenced to act , an opalescence was soon observable on the sides , and after twenty minutes ' action the thermometer was firmly imbedded in the ice .
At 1 o'clock P.MNI .
, a second thermometer ( B ) , placed at a distance of an inch from the side of the frustum , was also surrounded by ice .
At 2h 20m P.am .
a third thermometer ( C ) was placed at a distance of 13 inch from the side of the vessel , and at 51 , 30m P.M. a fourth thermometer ( D ) was placed at a distance of 3 inches from the side .
The observed temperatures of these thermometers at the times stated are given in the following Table : Time of observation .
A. B. C. D. hm11 A.M ... ... ... .
32 11 20.24 1 ... .11 262 2.7e. .
27 21 3 ... ... ... ... . .
6 153 1 30 4 ... ... ... ... . .
23 13 24 a ... ... ... ... . .
9-120 8 .
3+4i +11 ?
~2 0A_ _ ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ..3 .
+ 4 ... +1 1.2 .
At 8h 30m p.M. the machine was stopped and the supply of ether was cut off .
The mercurial columns began to rise gradually , and at 10 o'clock P.M. they were found to be as follows : A. B. C. D. 2C ) 27 ? ?
270 ? ?
2877Q The machine rested throughout the night , and at 8 o'clock on the morning of the 25th all the thermometers stood at 320 .
47 .
The machine was set going at 8 A.M. on the 25th , and continued working until 2 o'clock in the afternoon , its office now being , not to freeze , but to cool the ice already frozen .
The thermometers were read off every quarter of an hour , but it is not necessary to record all the observations .
The following are the temperatures noted at 8 and 11h 30m A.M. and at 2 P.M.:Time .
A. B. C. D. hm00008 32 32 32 32 1130 +1 112 23 301 2 911 -.93 48 .
At 2h 45m the machine was stopped and the supply of ether cut off .
The upper surface of the ice was covered with 2 inches of hair-felt : the water surrounding the frustum and its jacket was at a temperature of 32 ?
; the thermometers were read off every half-hour , but I will limit myself at present to a few observations .
The temperatures at 2 o'clock were those stated at the close of the last Table .
Time of observation .
A. B. C. D. hm00003 15 P.M. +11 +9+6+24 15 18 17 14 1i1 5 15 24 221 20 18 815 281 28 ' 271 261 11 15 31 301 30 291 On the 26th the following temperatures were observed : A. B. C. D. hm ? ? ? ?
lam ~ ~~000 09 A.M. 32 313 311 314 1 30 P.M. 32 32 31A 311 At lh 30m a hole was bored in the centre of the frustum to a depth of 5 inches , and in this another thermometer ( E ) was placed ; its temperature at 3h 30m P.m. was 3010 .
At 8 o'clock in the morning of the 27th the observed temperatures were the following : A. B. C. D. E. 320 320 320 320 320 At the termination of the experiment the water surrounding the frustum was at a temperature of 360 FAHR. 49 .
These experiments show , that however bad the conducting power of ice , in comparison with other substances , may be , the assumption that blocks of it which have been preserved in this country through months of summer weather should still possess a magazine of cold beyond that due to a temperature of 32 ?
, is wholly imcompatible with the physical character of the substance .
In a very interesting paper communicated to the British Association during its last meeting , Mr. JAMES THOMSON has explained the freezing together of two pieces of ice at 320 in the following manner:- " The two pieces of ice , on being pressed together at their point of contact , will at that place , in virtue of the pressure , be in part liquefied and reduced in temperature , and the cold evolved in their liquefaction will cause some of the liquid film intervening between the two masses to freeze .
" I am far from denying the operation under proper circumstances of the vera causa to which Mr. THOMSON refers , but I do not think it explains the facts .
For freezing takes place without the intervention of any pressure by which Mr. THOMSON'S effect could sensibly come into play .
It is not necessary to squeeze the pieces of ice together ; one bit may be simply laid upon the other and they will still freeze .
Other substances besides ice are also capable of being frozen to the ice .
If a towel be folded round a piece of ice at 320 , they will freeze together .
Flannel is still better .
A piece of flannel wrapped round a piece of ice freezes to it sometimes so firmly that a strong tearing force is necessary to separate both .
Cotton wool and hair may also be frozen to ice without the intervention of any pressure which could render Mr. THOMSON'S cause sensibly active* .
51 .
But there is a class of effects to the explanation of which the lowering of the freezingpoint of water by pressure may , I think , be properly applied .
The following statement is true off fifty experiments or more made with ice from various quarters .
A cylindpr of ice 2 inches high and an inch in diameter , was placed between two slabs of box-wood and submitted to a gradually increasing pressure .
Looked at perpendicular to the axis , cloudy lines were seen drawing themselves across the cylinder ; and when the latter was looked at obliquely , these lines were found to be the sections of dim hazy surfaces which traversed the cylinder , and gave it an appearance closely resembling that of a crystal of gypsum whose planes of cleavage had been forced out of optical contact by some external force .
Fig. 2 represents the cylinder looked at perpendicular to its axis , and fig. 3 the same cylinder where looked at obliquely .
Fig. 2 .
Fig. 3 .
To ascertain whether the rupture of optical contact which these experiments disclosed was due to the intrusion of air between two separated surfaces of ice , a cylinder of ice , 2 inches long and 1 inch wide , was placed in a copper vessel containing ice-cold water .
The ice-cylinder projected half an inch above the surface of the water .
Placing the copper vessel on a slab of wood , and a second slab of wood upon the cylinder of ice , the whole was subjected to pressure .
When the hazy surfaces were well developed in the portion of the ice above the water , the cylinder was removed and examined .
The planes of rupture extended throughout the entire length of the cylinder , just the same as if it had been squeezed in free air .
Still the removal of the cylinder from its vessel might be attended with the intrusion of air into the fissures .
I therefore placed a cylinder of ice , 2 inches long and 1 inch wide , in a stout vessel of glass , which was filled with ice-cold water .
Squeezing the whole , -as in the last experiment , the surfaces of discontinuity were seen forming utnder the laiid quite as distinctly as in air .
53 .
The surfaces are due to compression , and not to any tearing asunder of the mass by tension , and they are best developed where the pressure , within the limits of fracture , is a maximum .
A cylindrical piece of ice , one of whose ends was not parallel to the other , was placed between slabs of wood and subjected to pressure .
Fig. 4 shows the disposition of the experiment .
The effect upon the ice-cylinder was that shown in fig. 5 , the surfaces being developed along that side which had suffered the pressure .
Fig. 5 .
Fig. 4 .
- , IM s-/ / ' ' / 7~4%%/ /7Z ~27 / 7/ 7/ 7 / 7I 54 .
Sometimes the surfaces commence at the centre of the cylinder .
A dim small spot is first observed , which , as the pressure continues , expands until it sometimes embraces the entire transverse section of the cylinder .
55 .
On examining these surfaces with a pocket-lens , they appeared to me to be composed of very minute water parcels , like what is produced upon a smooth cold surface by the act of breathing .
Were they either vacuous plates , or plates filled with air , their aspect would , on optical grounds , be far more vivid than it really was .
56 .
A concave mirror was so disposed , that the diffused light of day was thrown full upon the cylinder while under pressure .
Observing the expanding surfaces through a lens , they appeared in a state of intense commotion ; this was probably due to the molecular tensions of the little water parcels .
This motion followed closely on the edge of the surface as it advanced through the solid ice .
Once or twice I observed the hazy surfaces pioneered through the mass by dim offshoots apparently liquid .
They constituted a kind of negative crystallization , having the exact form of the crystalline spines and spurs produced by the congelation of water upon a surface of glass .
I have no doubt , then , that these surfaces are produced by the liquefaction of the solid in planes perpendicular to the direction of pressure .
The surfaces were developed with great facility where they corresponded to the surfaces of freezing .
Wherever the liquid disks before described were observed , the surfaces were always easily developed in the planes of the disks .
By care I succeeded , in some cases , in producing similar effects in surfaces at right angles to the planes of the disks , but this was very difficult and uncertain .
I think the following new facts have been established in the foregoing paper : 1 .
The interior of a mass of ice may be melted by radiant heat which has passed through exterior portions of the substance without melting them .
2 .
In the dissolution of the ice thus effected , the substance yields by the formation of liquid spaces , each possessing the shape of a flower with six petals , a small vacuum being formed at the centre of each flower .
S. These flowers are generally formed in planes parallel to the surface of freezing , but some of the specimens of ice examined were divided into prismatic segments by surfaces of discontinuity .
Each distinct segment had its own system of flowers arranged in parallel planes , but the parallelism did not extend to the flowers of two distinct segments .
This subject requires further investigation .
4 .
The appearance presented by masses of lake ice composed of these segments , resembles that of certain specimens of glacier ice in which the airand water-cavities are flattened in different planes .
Hence the explanation of the latter , which refers them to actions peculiar to the glacier , must be received with caution .
5 .
The explanation hitherto given of the water associated with the air-bubbles in glacier ice is untenable .
In this paper the phenomenon is explained in accordance with the dynamical theory of heat .
It is sought to be shown that , owing to the mutual action of the ice-molecules , a quantity of heat which has been conducted through the substance without prejudice to its solidity may liberate the molecules which bound an internal cavity , and thus produce water-cells in association with the bubbles of air .
6 .
The converse of this takes place where two moist surfaces of ice at 32 ?
FAIIR .
are brought into contact .
Superficial portions are thus virtually rendered central ; liquefaction is checked , the film of moisture on the surfaces in contact congeals , and the pieces of ice freeze together .
To this process the term revelation has been applied .
7 .
By the application of pressure parallel surfaces of discontinuity are formed in lake and river ice perpendicular to the directions in which the pressure is exerted ; thus giving the substance the appearance of selenite , in which the planes of cleavage are not in optical contact .
The discontinuity consists in the liquefaction of the ice in these planes by the pressure .
Such surfaces are formed with great facility parallel to the planes in which the liquid flowers are formed by radiant heat , while it is very difficult to produce them perpendicular to these planes .
Thus , whether we apply heat or pressure , lake ice melts with peculiar facility in certain directions .
2uE2 Note from Mr. FARADAY .
MY DEAR TYNDALL , Have the following remarks , made in reference to the irregular fusibility of ice , to which you drew my attention , any interest to you , or by an occasional bearing on such cases , any value in themselves t Deal with them as you like .
Imagine a portion of the water of a lake about to freeze , the surface S being in contact with an atmosphere considerably below 32 , the previous action of which has been to lower the temperature of the whole mass of water , so that the portion below the line M is at 40 ?
, or the maximum density , and the part above at progressive temperatures from 400 upwards to 320 ; each stratum keeping its place by its relative specific gravity to the rest , and having therefore , in that respect , no tendency to form currents either upwards or downwards .
Now generally , if the surface 32 s -330 b 340 c 350 d 36 ?
e 370 f 38 ?
g390 A 400 i-----------M M ---------400 400 became ice , the water below would go on freezing by the cold conducted downwards through the ice ; but the successive series of temperatures from 320 to 40C would always exist in a layer of water contained between the ice and the dense water at 40 ?
below M. If the water were pure , no action of the cold would tend to change the places of the particles of the water or cause currents ; because the lower the cold descended , the more firmly would any given particle tend to retain its place above those beneath it : a particle at e , for instance , at 36 ?
FAHR. , would , when the cold had frozen what was above it , be cooled sooner and more than any of the particles beneath , and so always retain its upper place as respects them .
But now , suppose the water to contain a trace of saline matters in solution .
As the water at 320 froze , either at the surface or against the bottom of the previously-formed ice , these salts would be expelled ; for the ice first formed ( and that always formed , if the proper care be taken to displace the excluded salts ) is perfectly free from them , and PURE .
The salts so excluded would pass into the layer of water beneath , and there produce two effects : they would make that layer of greater specific gravity than before , and so give it a tendency to sink into the warmer under layer ; but they would also make it require a lower temperature than 32 ?
for congelation ; this it would acquire from the cold ice above , and by that it would become lighter and float , tending to remain uppermost ; for it has already been shown that the diminution of temperature below 320 in sea water and solution of salts , is accompanied by the same enlargement of bulk as between 32 ?
and 400 with pure water .
The stratum of water , therefore , below the ice , would not of necessity sink because it contained a little more salt than the stratum immediately below it ; and certainly would not if the increase of gravity conferred by the salts was less than the decrease by lowering of temperature .
An approximation of the strata between the freezing place and the layer at 40 ?
would occur , i. e. the distance between these temperatures would be less , but the water particles would keep their respective places .
When water freezes , it does not appear that this process is continuous , for many of the characters of the ice seem to show that it is intermittent ; i. e. either a film of ice is formed , and then the process stops until the heat evolved by solidification has been conducted away upwards , and the next stratum of water has been sufficiently cooled to freeze in turn ; or else the freezing being , so to speak , continuous , still is not continued at the same constant rate , but , as it were , by intermittent pulsations .
Now it may well be , when a layer next the previously-formed ice , and containing an undue proportion of salts , has been cooled down to its required temperature for freezing ( which would be below 320 ) , that on freezing , the congelation will pervade at once a certain thickness of the water , excluding the salts from the larger portion of ice formed , but including them as a weak solution within its interstices .
The next increment of cold conducted from the ice above would freeze up these salts in the ice containing them , at the same time that a layer of pure ice was formed beneath it .
Thus .
a layer of ice fusible at a lower temperature than the ice either above or below it might be produced ; and by a repetition of the process many such layers might be formed .
It does not follow necessarily that the layers would be perfectly exact in their disposition .
Very slight circumstances tending to disturb the regularity of the water-molecules would be sufficient , probably , to disturb the layers more or less .
Ice contains no air , and the exclusion of a minute bubble of air from the water in the act of freezing might disturb the direction and progress of the congelation , and cause accumulation of the extra saline liquid in one spot rather than another : so might the tendency to the formation of little currents , either arising from the separation of the saline water from the forming ice , or from the elevation of temperature in different degrees at those places where the congelation was going on at different rates .
The effect would not depend upon the quantity of salts contained in the freezing water , though its degree would .
The proportion of salts necessary to be added to pure water to lower its freezing-point 10 FAiiR .
may be very sensible to chemical tests , but the proportion required to make the difference l th or -ol-soth of a degree would be far less : and if we suppose that only 210th of a piece of ice is brought into the condition of melting before the rest of the mass , and that the salts in that proportion were originally in the whole of the water , then its quantity there may be so small as to escape detection except by very careful analysis .
However , it would be desirable to examine the water chemically which is produced by ice distinguished by having in its interior much , that liquefies before the rest .
It is easy to make ice perfectly free from air , and , as I believe , from salts , by a process I formerly described .
It would be interesting to see if such ice had within it portions melting at a lower temperature than the general mass .
I think it ought not .
Ever truly yours , M. FARADAY .
Royal Institution , 9th Decembber , 1 857 .

