Hlgg 7 " ^--^ y Cm Cm K~ +I : UiII It 11 I. , " 7 , -r1 ( \ , I , --I 1 , , , -- ; : ; : I , " , !
" , E. , :I'll-It " .
--I .
, I i , , llhi .
f -v .
x I. , " , / .
' .
; " ... .
I. , , M 4 , ' .
, .
I7 77 On the Dioecious Character of the Rotifera .
By PHILIP HENRY GOSSE .
Communicated by THOMAS BELL , F.R.S. , P.L.S. , F.G.S. , Professor of Zoology in King 's College .
Received February 19 , -Read March 13 and April 3 , 1856 .
1 .
WHEN Dr. EHRENBERG , in 1838 , published his 'Infusionsthierchen , ' containing his matured conclusions respecting the ROTIFERA , he defined the Class as consisting of animals all the individuals of which are hermaphrodite , oviparous , and ovipositing .
The hermaphroditism , or " dualism of the sexual system , " he described as consisting of " an ovary , simultaneously developing a few great eggs ; two thread-like male sexual glands , thicker and club-shaped in front , and a contractile bladder , placed near the cloacal orifice , uniting the hermaphrodite organs for self-impregnation .
" 2 .
These conclusions remained unchallenged till 1848 , when Mr. BRIGHTWELL announced his important discovery of separate sexes in a Rotiferous animal , since named Asplanchna .
The presence of the tortuous threads in both sexes , and of the contractile bladder in the female , at once negatived the conclusions of EHRENBERG , that these were male impregnating organs , though their functions were still undetermined .
3 .
This single example , however , was by no means sufficient to overthrow the presumed hermaphroditism of the Class as a whole ; though it naturally threw doubt on statements as yet unhesitatingly received .
The case might have been one of those solitary exceptions , which occasionally mock our generalizations ; like the exception to the law of metamorphosis in Gecarcinus and Astacus ; or to that of immediate relation of impregnation to birth , in Aphis and DJaphnia .
4 .
In the " Annals and Magazine of Natural History " for July 1850 , I published some observations on a second species of Asplanchna ( A.priodonta ) , in which I described and figured the male .
Soon afterwards I had the pleasure of repeating and verifying those of Mr. BRIGHTWELL and Mr. DALRYMPLE on A. Brightwellii .
5 .
The dioecious character was thus extended from a species to a genus .
Since then , I believe , no advance has been made in our knowledge of the sexual relations of the ROTIFERA , from actual observation , save the discovery of a third species of the same genus .
Dr. FRANZ LEYDIG , in a recent able memoir * on this Class of animals , announces that Notommata Sieboldii has distinct sexes ; and that the male , while exhibiting some curious peculiarities of external form , agrees with that figured by Mr. DALRYMPLE , in all essential points .
He appears not to have been aware of my observations on A. priodonta .
It is manifest , however , that the animal which the German zoologist describes as a Notonmmata must be referred to my genus Asplanchna ; and that its alliance with A. Brightwellii is still more intimate than is that of A. priodonta .
Thus we have still no absolute proof that the dioecious character is not confined to a single genus .
6 .
Dr. LEYDIG , however , conjectures , and supports his suggestion with many plausible reasons , that several animals , described and figured by EHRENBERG as distinct species , may be really the males of other recognized forms .
Thus Enteroplea hydatina he ventures to assign as the male of Hydatina senta , grounding his conclusions on the descriptions and figures of EHRENBERG and DUJARDIN .
The close resemblance of Enteroplea to Hydatina , its smaller dimensions , and the absence of a manducatory apparatus , had been noticed by EHRENBERG , who found the eggs which produced the animal , among those from which were evolved Hydatince .
What EHRENBERG described as an undeveloped ovary , Dr. LEYDIG considers to have been analogous to the sperm-bag of Mr. DALRYMPLE ; in other words , a true testicle .
This last interpretation is further confirmed by the figure given by DUJARDIN ; in which , moreover , additional evidence is found , in the absence of a true alimentary canal , in the presence of certain " toufes des granules pedicellees " in the posterior part of the body ( which Dr. LEYDIG interprets as " masses of spermatozoids " ) , and of " un organ cilie entre les muscles de la queue , " which Dr. LEYDIG supposes to have been the excretory duct of the testicle , i. e. the penis .
7 .
To these conclusions I entirely assent ( perhaps with the exception of his interpretation of DUJARDIN'S " touffes pedicellges " ) ; and they are still further confirmed by the observations which I have presently to offer .
8 .
For reasons of a similar character , Dr. LEYDIG presumes Notommata granularis of EHRENBERG to be the male of X. Brachionus , and Diglena granularis of WEISSE to be the male of D. catellina .
9 .
The first occasion on which I saw a male of this Class was on the 9th of August , 1849 , when , however , I was too inexperienced in the study of the ROTIFERA to be aware of the true character of the animal which I was observing .
Among many specimens of Brachionus pala , which I had just obtained from a pond near London , was one with seven or eight eggs excluded and attached to the posterior extremity of the lorica .
One of these eggs was discharged from the ovary in my sight , so that I was sure of their origin .
When extruded , the ovum displayed a substance slightly granular , and almost colourless , except that a slight tinge of smoky black pervaded the whole .
In an hour or two this pellucid interior became turbid , and soon after was marked with indistinct corrugations , which gradually acquired more definiteness .
The waves of the frontal cilia were next seen at one extremity of the egg , sometimes moving transversely , sometimes longitudinally , but conveying , in either case , no accurate idea of the organs which produced them .
The vacant space occupied by these waves became larger , and presently the eye became visible , as an undefined pale red spot , near the middle of the egg .
About the same time two or three amorphous masses of opake substance were seen near the posterior extremity .
See Plate XV .
fig. 1 .
After about five hours from extrusion the motions of the enclosed embryo become very vigorous : the folds of the body are continually changing their places , and the working of the cilia is strong and rapid .
Presently the regularly elliptical form of the egg undergoes a slight alteration , becoming more elongated , then slightly constricted in the middle , apparently by the pushing outwards of the two extremities of the body , and by the inflation of the fore-parts .
At this moment the anterior half of the egg-shell is pushed off ; the cilia are instantly seen expanded and rotating for a second or two ; the little new-born Brachionus ( see fig. 2 ) sits in the hinder half of the shell , as in a nest , and then glides away .
11 .
The infant Brachionus swims rather feebly at first ; but , acquiring vigour as it goes , presently darts along with amazing swiftness , so that the eye -can scarcely follow it .
When several of the young were hatched , they whirled and shot round and round the live-box in which they were enclosed , in the most headlong manner , and were every instant coming into contact with the parent , when , almost invariably , the course of the little creature would be arrested , and it would play around the body of the mother , or grasp with its pincer-like toes her cilia .
As I have already said , I had at that time no notion of these being males , having seen no offspring but these produced from this species .
I had , however , seen the birth of several young of Brachionus urceolaris , which were exactly like the parent , whereas these were very dissimilar ; a circumstance which excited my curiosity , as did also the fact that both eggs and young were notably smaller than those of B. urceolaris , in proportion to the adult .
The actual dimensions of the eggs in question were h-4th of an inch in the longer diameter ; of the new-born male , -2 o6th ; of the parent , y1oth , exclusive of the foot .
12 .
I shall not here describe the structure of the male , because I shall presently have occasion to recur to the species again , in recording observations made with the advantage of more experience .
13 .
In April 1850 I first saw eggs of two different dimensions , attached to the same species .
This was Brachionus rubens , several specimens of which carried each seven or eight small eggs ( fig. 3 ) , measuring -g oth of an inch in length , while others carried few eggs ( two or three at most ) , nearly twice as large , viz. jth of an inch in length .
One of the latter , under slight pressure , freed prematurely a young one , enveloped in a spined lorica , agreeing in all respects with the parent .
I then crushed several of the smaller eggs .
From such as were nearly mature , numbers of spermatozoa were expressed : these had a round body , and a short tail which was vibrated in a serpentine manner .
" They measured about -s6-oth of an inch in the diameter of the body , and the length of the tail was about the same ( fig. 4 ) .
These were sufficiently numerous to make it appear as if the eggs had been entirely filled with them .
The less mature eggs yielded spermatozoa also , but without motion , with the tail undeveloped , adhering together , and somewhat resembling blood-disks .
14 .
Others of the smaller eggs produced the young by natural maturation .
These were quite diverse from the parent , having no perceptible lorica , nor any spines ; no mastax or jaws ; no alimentary canal ; nor any distinct organization within , except a large red eye near the middle of the body .
The whole interior , with this exception , appeared to be filled with a granular mass , in the midst of which , near the posterior region , were two or three amorphous lumps of opake substance .
The foot was short ; the frontal cilia very large and strong , and the little animal shot to and fro with great swiftness ( fig. 5 ) .
15 .
My next observations were made on Brachionus amphiceros .
Here again I met with large and small eggs in individuals of the same species ; the former -rth of an inch in length , the latter a-~7th .
As before , the larger eggs ( fig. 7 ) produced young exactly like their parent ; the smaller ( fig. 6 ) yielded animals quite dissimilar , but agreeing in all essentials with the small young of B. pala and B. rubens .
16 .
One of these latter was hatched under my eye .
The little animal ( figs. 8 , 9 , 10 ) was several seconds in escaping , after the broad ciliated head was outside the egg-shell .
Then it swam swiftly away , and remained traversing the live-box with indefatigable perseverance all the time I looked at it .
It was totally different from the other young of the same species , and from the parent : it had no lorica , no jaws , no mastax , no stomach , nor any viscera , except a large mass of opake matter , apparently surrounded by traces of a vesicle near the hinder part .
It had a red eye placed near the middle of the body , and an ample rotatory organ , of which the central cilia were sometimes made to converge , as in the parent ( fig. 9 ) .
The body was wide , nearly cylindrical , gibbous at the posterior part , where it was abruptly attenuated to a stout cylindrical foot ( fig. 8 ) .
But this organ exhibited a remarkable peculiarity ; for , from behind the foot , proceeded a stout cylindrical organ , truncated and ciliated atits extremity , whence a blunt point was sometimes protruded : this organ , from its direction and size , might easily be mistaken for the foot itself , for the latter was much shorter and smaller , and projected almost like the thumb of a mitten , but it was readily known by its two little soft toes ( fig. 10 ) .
The body seemed to be hollow , with thick walls , but a great number of bubbles hindered the transparency .
Pressure did not reveal the slightest trace of jaws .
The colour of the fore-parts was buff , like that of the parent ; but the rest was colourless , except the opake mass and the red eye .
I put this specimen and a newly-born female together , and watched them for an hour ; but though , in their devious wanderings , they once or twice touched each other , no apparently voluntary communication took place .
I left them together all night , and in the morning the female was dead .
The male , however , was still active , and lived till the middle of the day .
17 .
About the same time B. pala occurred again to my notice , and this time with both male and female eggs .
The observations now made may perhaps be most distinctly given in the words of my journal .
12h 45mP .
M. I isolated a specimen with five small eggs attached , in two of which the embryos were vibrating the cilia ( fig. 1 ) .
There was in the ovary , nearly ready for exclusion , another egg , similar in size and appearance to the least advanced of the five attached .
Ih 5Sm .
The egg last named was extruded under my eye , but took its place with the other five , not differing from them .
The small egg , when deposited ( and for some time before ) , is pellucid and colourless , except that many yellow oil-globules are contained in it , which are aggregated into two ( or three ) masses .
The pellucid interior has a delicately granular appearance , which after a while begins more distinctly to form cells , and becomes more turbid .
3h 30m .
A male was hatched from the most advanced of the small eggs .
It is almost indistinguishable from that of amphiceros ; but the toes are rather more developed ( fig. 2 ) .
The opake masses in the posterior region are aggregated together , and very conspicuous .
This aggregate mass seems to be contained in a central irregular bladder , which is connected with the protrusile organ .
I distinctly saw , many times in succession , the penis behind the foot everted and protruded beyond the toes , when the tip was seen to be ciliated : a sort of thick ( two-lobedl ) piston ( probably the thickened retractor muscles ) was thrust rapidly down when it was protruded .
It is frequently retracted with the foot into the abdomen .
18 .
I put it , almost as soon as born , into a live-box , with a half-grown female , and managed to enclose them together , by means of cotton fibres , in a cell sufficiently small to be contained in the field .
I watched them long : the male was very wild , trying to escape : several times , in darting round , he stopped near the hinder part of the female , and momentarily protruded the penis , and turned it towards her , and once , as I thought , actually introduced it into the cloaca , but only for an instant .
The female appeared conscious of excitement while the male was near , whisking about the foot and feeling him with it .
19 .
The next day I collected about a dozen females , half-grown and adult ( which I could easily take up with a tube from the numbers in the water ) , and placed with them two lively males that had been hatched during the night .
I directed my attention principally to one of these , as I could not watch them both .
It soon came near some of the females , when it seemed to become animated by a sort of frenzy ; describing , with excessive rapidity , a circle , of which its head formed the circumference , and its foot the centre : the extremities were incurved in the direction of its circular movement .
After a while it left off and began to play about the body of a female , moving over and round the lorica , while she whisked about the foot , as if to lay hold of him ; at length she drew in her foot , and that of the male appeared to adhere to it , and I distinctly saw the thick penis presented to the cloaca , and for a moment inserted about half its own length ; then it was instantly drawn out , and the male began his frenzied gyrations again .
Two or three times I saw similar play between him and females , but could not see any actual intromission again .
Sometimes he moved his body in quick waves , the foot being the fixed point .
20 .
Next I examined the little new species that I have named B. angularis , which was swarming in a bottle of water dipped from a pond near Tottenham .
Many carried two eggs each , measuring -9ath of an inch in length , others several , which measured only -oth .
One of the latter produced a little male ( figs. 13 , 14 ) , which appeared covered with a tortoise-like lorica .
Its length , exclusive of the foot , was.th of an inch .
A constriction indicates the distinction between the head and the body .
The foot has a thick penis united to it behind ( fig. 14 ) , the tip of which is protrusile and ciliated .
No internal organs are visible , except a red eye near the middle of the back , and a mass of opake matter at the hinder part .
The interior is occupied with a vast number of minute granules or globules irregularly clustered .
Its movements were very rapid ; it darted incessantly about the live-box , so that it was impossible to keep it for more than a moment in the field ; several females were enclosed with it , some of which were without eggs , while others carried them .
By means of a small microscope I watched , them awhile , and had the satisfaction of seeing what I had no doubt was a sexual conjunction , though it was but momentary , with one of the females without eggs .
21 .
All the observations I have mentioned ( except the first ) were made in April and May 1850 .
Leaving what I have to say of other genera for the present , I shall go on with Brachionus , detailing all I have learned of the males of this genus together .
In August of the same year I examined many specimens of B. Bakeri .
One of these had two eggs attached to its body , which , from their size and appearance , I judged to be male eggs ( fig. 11 ) : they measured --j th X 5-roth of an inch .
After a while , one of these began to show the ciliary action ; then the eye became visible ; and at length the well-defined foetus moved vigorously in its transparent prison ( fig. 11 c ) .
Meanwhile , the egg that had been developing was at length extruded , and took its place beneath its two fellows ( fig. 11 b ) .
The evolution of the fletus from these eggs being delayed considerably beyond the usual period , I endeavoured to promote it by artificial pressure , and in one case succeeded in cracking the egg , so that the animal was enabled to escape ( fig. 12 ) .
It was very inert and feeble , did not swim rapidly away as usual , but remained in the same place .
It resembled other male Brachioni ; there was manifestly a simple enveloping lorica , cup-like , without points .
On killing it by pressure , the viscera were forced out in the form of globose vesicles of various sizes ; the eye was resolved into three or four atoms of pigment , and the opake white spots that are so characteristic of males seemed composed of an immense number of moving atoms , excessively minute , which , when they were freed from the body , continued for a moment or two to move spontaneously .
These were probably spermatozoa ; but , from subsequent observations , I have reason to think I was mistaken in supposing them to have proceeded from the opake masses .
22 .
About the same time I procured from Walthamstow a very fine and elegant species , described by myself under the name of B. Dorcas .
One specimen carried a female egg nearly matured , in the ovisac , and the empty shell of another ( fig. 15 ) attached to its lorica .
Another had three male eggs attached , and one maturing : the dimensions of male eggs were i 0thx -loth of an inch : fig. 16 represents one of these , with the feetus nearly ready for exclusion ; the thick penis-foot is seen turned up to one side .
23 .
The female is represented at fig. 17 , an hour after birth .
I had the pleasure of seeing this hatched .
The egg is of a bluish-grey hue , and shows the large mastax with the jaws , long before hatching .
I was surprised at the great size of the newly-born young , not only in proportion to the parent , but even to the egg from which it was just escaped .
For , when I delineated it an hour afterwards ( during which I did not perceive any manifest increase ) , its length , from the tip of the frontal antlers to the posterior tubercles , was 9sth of an inch .
The dimensions of the empty shell ( fig. 15 ) , which still retained its form , were T7-fth X -0th of an inch : this continued attached to the parent for hours afterwards .
This increase I suppose to be effected by the expansion of the lorica ( at first flexible and membranous ) , which in the egg had lain in many folds , and by the imbibition of water into the cavity of the body .
24 .
Soon afterwards I had a young male of the same species hatched .
I selected a specimen with two small eggs attached , and isolated it in the live-box , examining it at intervals .
At length I perceived the young male whirling rapidly about the box , and on looking at the adult , saw that one of the eggs was but an empty shell .
By the aid of cotton filaments and the compressorium , I was enabled to keep it steady , and to examine and draw it with care ( see figs. 18 , 19 ) .
It is of the usual shape , with a well-marked neck , up to which a flexible lorica appears to reach .
The head is broad , truncate , or subconical , with vibrating bristles set on the cone , and rotating bristly cilia around the margin .
A head-mass , of irregular , rounded , or sacculated lobes , bears a lozenge-shaped red eye on its dorso-posterior angle ( fig. 19 ) .
From each side of the head a chain of irregular masses runs down to the posterior part of the body , probably'answering to the tortuous glands of the female .
A large mass , similar in appearance to the head , but distinct from it , occupies the middle of the body , extending down into the penis-foot .
This great mass is continually moved by quick contractions up and down , but it does not appear to be tubular and hollow .
The common white , opake , granular masses are enveloped in it , near the hind part of the body .
25 .
From this time I made no further investigation into the subject until the autumn of the present year ( 1855 ) , when I had an opportunity of examining the beautiful and interesting marine , species B. Miilleri , and of seeing , with satisfaction , that in the point of its oeconomy , which is the subject of this memoir , it differs not from its congeners of fresh water .
The males , however , displayed an internal organization more developed than in any species that I had yet seen , with the exception of the Asplanchnse .
26 .
In July last , my kind friend Mr. BRIGHTWELL of Norwich sent me a small phial of sea-water much filled with this species .
I immediately divided the contents among my Aquaria , where they increased rapidly .
Many of the females have two or three male eggs attached , which are 2 oth of an inch in length , and others carry one or two female eggs --ith of an inch long .
The male young ( fig. 20 ) is -l oth of an inch long , exclusive of the foot , and about 3-oth of an inch wide , with a distinct , but very flexible lorica , of which the anterior edges seem to become membranous .
There is a great conical head ( fig. 20 a ) , set with large setiform cilia all over the front , and behind descending into a rounded mass of several lobes , with a red eye ( b ) on the truncate apex of the posterior lobe .
Several muscle-threads ( c ) pass longitudinally from this headmass to the hinder mass ( d ) , which is connected with the foot ( g ) and the great protrusile penis .
In the midst of this latter mass is situated the group of opake white granules ( f ) , which are always so conspicuous in male ROTIFERA .
The central part of the body is occupied by the spermatic sac ( e ) , -a great pyriform vesicle , connected by a bottle-like neck with the head-mass , and apparently terminating posteriorly in a round form , where , however , a distinct corrugation probably'marks an orifice closed by a sphincter , which leads to the discharging duct .
On pressure , this sac is seen to be filled with bodies having a vermicular motion , and , on the pressure being continued , it bursts , giving issue to a number ( about thirty ) of spermatozoa ( fig. 22 ) .
These spermatozoa are comparatively of great size , being oth of an inch long ; they consist of a slender , nearly cylindrical body , merging into a long whip-like tail , which keeps up a quivering undulatory motion for several minutes after exclusion .
With these are also extruded many spicula-like bodies ( fig. 23 ) , much more minute , somewhat fusiform , slightly curved , and motionless .
The penis ( fig. 21 ) is , as usual , thick , and united to the foot , terminating in a short truncate tube , which I could not see to be ciliated .
A few crimson pigment-cells , exactly agreeing with those of the eye , are usually seen in some part or other of the body , apparently in contact with the inner surface of the integument .
27 .
In the middle of the summer of 1850 I discovered the males of two or three other genera .
The first of these was the curious form which I have named Sacculus viridis* ( fig. 24 ) .
I have had no opportunity of seeing the birth of females of this species , all the specimens that came under my observation ( that bore eggs at all ) carrying either one or two eggs of like size and appearance .
From one of these eggs ( fig. 25 ) , which , before maturity , are much clouded and spotted with granules and globules , a young was produced in my live-box , which was , I doubt not , a male ( fig. 26 ) .
I could not detect any eye ( though this organ is conspicuous in the parent ) , nor any internal organization ; nothing'but a confused assemblage of granules and globules ; even the ordinary opake masses were not present .
The form somewhat resembled that of an amphora with a short wide neck ; the frontal cilia were very large , but the motion was not rapid , nor was the animal wild , as male ROTIFERA usually are .
28 .
Polyarthra platyptera is another form , which , from its habit of carrying its deposited eggs , affords facilities for investigations regarding its sexuality .
Finding it numerous in July , with eggs attached , I discovered that these presented the same diversity that I have mentioned above ( ? ?
13 , &amp;c. ) .
I isolated one with six small eggs attached , measuring 700th x s-th of an inch .
Presently afterwards I found another , with a single egg attached , measuring 2-2nd x 437th of an inch .
This egg was truly oval , being sharper at 'one end than at the other .
Several of the smaller eggs were hatched together , about twenty-four hours after isolation .
They each produced a little animalcule ( figs. 27 , 28 , 29 ) , which , in its form , brightness , and motions , greatly resembled a free Vorticella .
Its length was j-oth of an inch .
The head ( fig. 27 ) is very large , and the body tapers quickly to the posterior part , but both extremities are truncate .
The front bears two warts , between which the rotatory cilia are placed , but the cilia are longer ( perhaps setce ) on the warts .
The hinder part is bifid ( figs. 28 , 29 ) , the smaller division being the caudal extremity or toeless foot , and the larger a protrusile truncate penis , ciliated at the tip .
No internal organization is discoverable .
In one there was a globule in the midst of the great head , but under sunlight it reflected no colour , and it was wanting in another .
Towards the posterior dorsal parts , a few irregular dark specks were visible , but generally the whole animal was clear , colourless , highly refracting , and showing an indistinct granulation .
Its motions were swift and impatient , gliding about the field with headlong speed , occasionally remaining in one place for a few minutes , but not in stillness , for it was rapidly oscillating to and fro , and quivering .
29 .
The last observation that I have to offer is on Synchceta tremula .
This genus does not carry about its eggs after their escape from the ovary , and as I did not see the hatching of the male I am about to describe , I cannot identify it with positive certainty .
30 .
In a phial of water obtained near Leamington , this Synchceta was very numerous , but I am not aware that any other Rotiferous animal was present .
Among the hundreds which congregated , in their playful gyrations , just above the sediment , I found a specimen ( figs. 30 , 31 ) which was certainly a male , and , from its form , was probably of this genus .
It was about 2ith of an inch long , obconical , with a rounded front , set with many long cilia , and surrounded by a prominent ring , also set with long cilia .
The body was capable of taking a swollen or round form , when the separate foot was more distinct ( fig. 31 ) .
The organization differed not from that of males of other species .
A red eye sharply defined , a central granular viscus , contained in a longitudinal cavity , in the bottom of which lay a large , irregular , opake white mass , was all that could be traced internally .
The foot seemed to carry a great protrusile penis , and to terminate in two minute toes .
No spermatozoa were visible within , nor were expressed by the compressorium .
The animal was active and swift .
A constriction behind the wreath of cilia formed a well-marked neck .
31 .
From the following observations which I published in the ' Journal of Microscopical Science ' for January 1853 , I think I am justified in concluding that Melicerta ringens also produces separate male and female young:"Opening one or two cases [ of Melicerta ] , I freed one and another very curious egglike bodies , not symmetrical in shape , being much more gibbous on one side than on the opposite , and measuring Lo 0th X toth of an inch .
Each was encircled by five or six raised ribs , running parallel to each other longitudinally , somewhat like the varices of a wentle-trap .
Viewed perpendicularly to the ribs , the form is symmetrical-a long narrow oval .
The whole surface between the ribs appeared punctured or granulate , and the colour was a dull brownish-yellow .
Under pressure it was ruptured , and discharged an infinity of atoms of an excessive minuteness , but every one of which , for a few seconds , displayed spontaneous motion .
Their whole appearance , and the manner in which they presently changed to motionless disks , were exactly the same as of the spermatozoa which the male eggs of other ROTIFERA contain , except that these were so minute .
" From another I extracted an egg of the ordinary form and appearance .
It was very long , measuring -h-th X olth of an inch .
The contained embryo was well-advanced ; two red eyes were plainly seen by reflected and by transmitted light : the gizzard was transverse , very large in proportion , and the jaws worked vigorously : a little opake body , white under sunlight , was in the posterior part .
This embryo died without hatching .
" 32 .
Thus there is evidence of the dioecious character in the following genera and species of ROTIFEA : Asplanchna Brightwellii .
Brachionus amhiceros .
Asplanchna priodonta .
Brachionus angularis .
Asplanchna Sieboldii .
Brachionus Bakeri .
1 Synchecta tremula .
Brachionus Dorcas .
Polyarthra platyptera .
Brachionus Miilleri .
Brachionus Pala .
Sacculus viridis .
Brachionus rubens .
Mlelicerta ringens .
And it is presumed , with a high degree of probability , to mark also the following : Hydatina senta .
Diglena catellina* .
33 .
It must be borne in mind , too , that there is no direct evidence on the other side ; for no species has , I believe , been actually proved to be hermaphrodite .
Hence , I think , we may reasonably conclude a distinction of sex to be the normal condition of the Class , or at least of that great group which is most typical , viz. such as have articulated mallei working upon a separate articulated incs .
Whether the same rule prevails so generally in those which have the mallei and incus fused together into quadrantic masses , and in those in which these organs exist in a rudimentary condition , is a question yet to be determined .
As these are certainly the lowest forms of their Class , it is possible that hermaphroditism may be found in them-in the Philodinadw for instance .
34 .
In summing up the results of the herein-recorded , as well as of former observations , the most prominent thing that strikes us is the absolute and universal atrophy ( so far ) of the digestive system in male ROTIFERA .
It was first observed with admiration in Asplanchna Brightwellii , and has been found to belong , without exception , to every male since observed .
Mr. DALRYMPLE , indeed , remarked a little isolated congeries of vesicles in the cavity of the male of the species just named , and I have seen it also .
Possibly this may be the lingering rudiment of a stomach , but it is scarcely likely ; and Since this memoir was read , I have been enabled to add to the above list Notommata Brachions .
The male of this species much resembles those of the Brachioni , equalling in its organization the male of B. Miilleri .
Its form , however , is as conical as that of Synchcta .
whatever it be , no semblance of such viscera is to be traced in A. priodonta , or in any other male that has come under my observation .
35 .
Another curious peculiarity is the dissimilarity that always subsists between the sexes .
In Asplanchna and Hydatina the resemblance is at its highest point : in every other instance observed , the sexes are so unlike , that they would be taken for widely remote genera .
The male is always inferior in size , and also in organization , to the female .
36 .
Whether certain individuals produce only male , and others only female young , or whether separate impregnations are required for the production of the separate sexes , I do not know ; but from all my observations , I gather that the development of the one sex never takes place coetaneously with that of the other ; for male and female eggs are never seen attached to the same parent , and the immature eggs in the ovary invariably develope themselves into the same sex as those which are already extruded .
37 .
The duration of life in the male is always very brief .
I have never been able to preserve one alive for twenty-four hours .
Their one business is to impregnate the females , which is the work of a few minutes , probably , in a state of freedom ; and for this momentary occupation no supply of loss by assimilation of food is wanted ; and hence we can understand the lack of the nutritive organism .
38 .
Some organs are found , with greater or less distinctness , in all .
The ( presumed ) male of Hydatina senta received its names of Enteroplea and Organ-Jisch from EHRENBERG , on account of the copiousness of its internal organization .
A muscular system is well-developed there , and in the males of Asplanchna and of Brachionus Miilleri ; and , from the varied movements of all , its existence may be inferred where it is not detected .
The frontal cilia are , in almost all cases , much more developed than in the females ; the result of which endowment is seen in the excessive rapidity with which the male shoots in all directions through the water .
The great head-mass of granular substance is generally distinct ; and in several cases ( as in the Asplanchnce and in Br .
Dorcas and Miilleri ) the great occipital ganglion is well-defined , with the red eye seated on it as in the other sex .
Even where the ganglion is not apparent , the eye is conspicuous , with the exception of Sacculus and Polyarthra ; and in this last instance the small size of the animal must be borne in mind , and the density of the anterior parts .
39 .
In the ( presumed ) male of Hydatina , in those of all the Asplanchnce , and of Brach .
Dorcas , there are organs answering to the lateral convoluted threads of the female ; and , in AspI .
Brightwellii , at least , these are accompanied by tremulous tags , and by a contractile bladder .
40 .
A large mass of substance , which , being perfectly opake , appears black by transmitted light , but is white when the rays are reflected , is so generally found in male ROTIFERA , as to be characteristic , though it is not universally present .
I do not find it in the Asplanchne , nor in Sacculus .
On the other hand , I have observed it in the young of Stephanoceros , Floscularia complanata , and F. cornuta ; and EHRENBERG mentions it in P. ornata and Lacinularia .
In Stephanoceros , it was certainly associated with well-developed jaws ; and hence I presume it is not exclusively an indication of the male sex .
2u2 323 ROTIFElA .
The mass is sometimes broken up into fragments of irregular size and shape , and sometimes apparently pulverulent .
In general , it appears to lie loosely in the midst of the granular amorphous matter that occupies the posterior region of the body-cavity ; but in Brack .
Pala , and especially in B. amphiceros , I have fancied that I discerned traces of a vesicle , within which the white substance seems to be contained .
41 .
On the nature of this substance I have no light from personal research .
Dr. LEYDIG , however , considers it to be a urinary concretion ( Harnconcremente ) , analogous to the chalky fluid which is discharged by many insects , immediately after their evolution from pupa .
42 .
In the male of Asplanchna Brightwellii , there is , as its discoverer observes , 'a conspicuous round sperm-vessel , or testis , in which ... . .
spermatozoa in active vibratile motion may be seen* .
" Mr. DALRYMPLE , and subsequently myself , also saw these , both within the sac and discharged by pressure .
Each spermatozoon , according to my own observation , consists of an oblong body , 1-715-oth of an inch long , and an abrupt , slender , vibratile tail , of equal length .
In the sperm-sac of A. Sieboldii , Dr. LEYDIG finds various seminal elements , viz. round cells ; pyriform cells , drawn out to a fine point , and adhering to each other by their rounded ends , in a stellate manner ; oblong bodies , with one side dilated into a free , undulating , membranous border ; and slender , stiff , rod-like bodies , with a central swelling ; all containing nucleated nuclei t. On the male of A. priodonta , my observations were too limited to determine more than the existence of the globular sperm-sac .
43 .
In Brachtonus rubens and B. Miilleri I found spermatozoa , which I have above described ( ? ? ? ?
13 and 26 ) .
In the latter , the sperm-bag is of great size , and contains , which may be the equivalents of the little rods described by Dr. LEYDIG in Aspl .
Sieboldii .
The sperm-bag ( in Br .
Miilleri ) is closed posteriorly , as it is also in Aspl .
Brightwellii by what appears to be a true sphincter ( fig. 20 ) ; and such I conjecture to be the explanation of those diverging lines which M. DUJARDIN saw in Enteroplea ( so-called ) , which he considered to be pedicels of his " touffes de granules , " while the " touffes " themselves I take to have been the masses of urinary concrement .
Dr. LEYDIG , however , considers the whole to have been masses of spermatozoids .
44 .
The outlet of the sperm-bag is , in all cases , by a thick protrusile and retractile penis .
Wherever a foot exists , this intromittent organ is continuously united to its dorsal side , and is often so greatly developed that the foot itself appears as an appendage .
The protrusion of the organ , at least in most of the examples that I have noticed , is by the eversion of the integuments .
When these are evolved to the utmost , the organ is seen to be a thick column , conical or nearly cylindrical , with the extremity truncate , and surrounded by a wreath of vibratile cilia .
It was , doubtless , the extremity of the penis that M. DUJARDIN saw , as " un organ cilie entre les muscles de la queue , " in the ( socalled ) Enteroplea .
The male of Sacculus viridis ( fig. 26 ) , a species which is footless in both the sexes , is the only example in which I have not seen the penis ; but the organ is probably wholly retractile within the body , and my observations , on the only individual of this sex that I saw , were insufficient to determine anything concerning it .
45 .
For a parallel to the curious facts thus established we must look only to the CRUSTACEA .
The economy of the Hectocotylus of certain Cephalopod MOLLUSCA , though perhaps even still more abnormal , is only remotely analogous .
Nor is the parallelism very close of those ENTOZOA in which the males are organically united to the females , as the genera Heteroura and Syngamus , described by Professor OWEN* .
46 .
In the Class CRUSTACEA , however , many examples occur of a sexual difference , which may instructively be compared with the one before us .
Thus , among the Isopoda , we find the parasitic genera Bopyrus , Phryxzus , and lone , in which the males are notably smaller than the females , very diverse in form , and in some respects inferior in structure .
In the Siphonostoma " the males are extremely small , and do not in the least resemble the femalestf , " though those of different genera bear a strong resemblance inter se , even when the females are very dissimilar .
So low is their grade of organization , that BvRMEISTER has attempted to prove these minute creatures to be embryonic or larval forms .
And , finally , in the CIRRIPEDIA , Mr. DARWIN has proved the existence of males in the genera 161a and Scalpellum , which are very minute as compared with their females , excessively abnormal in form , and in some respects in an embryonic condition , though unquestionably mature , as shown by the spermatozoa$ .
And , what is still more interesting , the same accurate zoologist observes , - " After the most careful dissection of very many specimens ... . .
I can venture positively to assert that there is no vestige of a mouth , or masticatory organs , or stomach ? .
" Again , he describes the internal structure as i ' a pulpy mass with numerous oil-globules , " and the sperm-vesicle as " a pear-shaped bag at the very bottom of the sack-formed animal , containing either pulpy matter , or a great mass of spermatozoa l , '-terms which might have been employed in describing some of the male Brachioni ( ? ?
26 , &amp;c. ) .
47 .
In all these analogies I conceive we may find additional reasons , to those that have been before adduced , for assigning to the ROTIFERA a zoological position among the ARTICULATA .
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATE .
PLATE XV .
Fig. 1 .
Brachionus Pala ; male egg , nearly mature .
Fig. 2 .
Brachionus Pala ; male , newly born .
Fig. 3 .
B. rubens ; male egg , nearly mature .
Fig. 4 .
B. rubens ; spermatozoa from the same egg .
Fig. 5 .
B. rubens ; male , newly born .
Cycl .
of Anat .
and Physiol. p. 142 .
t BAIrD 's 'Entomostraca , ' 325 .
+ Monograph of Lepadide , 198 . ?
Ibid. 235 , [ 1 Ibid. 236 .
Fig. 6 .
B. amphiceros ; male egg , just laid .
Fig. 7 .
B. amphiceros ; female egg , nearly mature .
Figs. 8 , 9 , 10 .
B. amphiceros ; males .
Fig. 11 .
B. Bakeri ; hinder part of an adult female .
a , male egg in the ovisac ; b , egg just laid ; c , egg nearly mature ; d , empty egg-shell .
Fig. 12 .
B. Bakeri ; male .
Figs. 13 , 14 .
B. angularis ; males .
Fig. 15 .
B. Dorcas ; empty shell of female egg .
Fig. 16 .
B. Dorcas ; male egg , mature .
Fig. 17 .
B. Dorcas ; female , newly born .
Figs. 18 , 19 .
B. Dorcas ; males , newly born .
Fig. 20 .
B. Miilleri ; male .
a , head-mass ; , b eye ; c , muscles ; d , posterior mass ; e , sperm-sac ; f , urinary concretion ; g , foot .
Fig. 21 .
B..Miilleri ; penis and foot .
Fig. 22 .
B. Miilleri ; spermatozoa .
Fig. 23 .
B. Mulleri ; spiculiform bodies .
Fig. 24 .
Sacculus viridis ; adult female , carrying male eggs .
Fig. 25 .
Sacculus viridis ; male egg , just laid .
Fig. 26 .
Sacculus viridis ; male , newly born .
Figs. 27 , 28 , 29 .
Polyarthraplatyptera ; males .
Figs. 30 , 31 .
Synchceta tremula ( presumed ) ; male .

