On the Structure , Functions , and Homologies of the Manducatory Organs in the Class ROTIFERA .
By PHILIP HENRY GOSSE , Esq. Communicated by THOMAS BELL , 7VP .
R.S. , Pres. L.S. Received January 5 , -Read February 22 and March 1 , 1855 .
1 .
AN exalnination of the whole alimentary system in the class ROTIFERA would include-The buccal funnel ; the manducatory apparatus , with its muscular bulb and the muscular bands by which it is retained in situ ; the salivary glands ; the oesophagus ; the pancreatic glands ; the stomach ; the hepatic follicles ; the caeca ; the intestine ; the rectum ; and the cloaca .
Of these , however , the manducatory organs will occupy my principal attention ; and I shall endeavour to trace them throughout the class ; and to show , that the various forms which they assume can all be reduced to a common type .
I also propose to inquire , what are the real homologues of these organs in the other classes of animals ; and what light we can gather , from their structure , on the question of the zoological rank of the ROTIFERA .
2 .
Considering the attractive appearance which the Wheel-animals present , and the facilities which are afforded for their investigation by their abundance-since they are found in great variety in almost every river , lake , pond , and ditch , -it is rather remarkable that they have been so little studied .
3 .
The foundation of our acquaintance with the organization of the ROTIFERA was broadly laid by Professor EHRENBERG , in the 'Transactions of the Berlin Academy , ' as early as 1830 ; and in 1838 he published his ' Infusionsthierchen , ' a work which , in spite of its mistakes and deficiencies , must be considered a magnificent monument of industry and scientific acumen .
It is true , LEEUWENHOEK , BAKER , JOBLOT , and other early microscopists had figured a few species ; and RoSEL , SCHAFFER , and especially MULLER , had attempted to resolve the internal anatomy of some ; but all that had been accomplished amounted to little more than vague guessing , when EHREN took them up .
He penetrated into the minute organization of these animals ; resolved and figured , with a precision and minuteness up to that time unattempted , the nutritive , circulatory , nervous , muscular and generative systems ; and , though the details.of some of the organs which he has described existed only in his imagination , and the functions of others which he clearly saw were quite misunderstood , it would be absurd to deny that his elaborate plates and descriptions are generally faithful representations of these minute creatures .
4 .
M. DUJARDIN , like his great predecessor , included the ROTIFERA , by the name of Systolides , among the INFIUSORIA , in his work on the subject published in 1841 .
In many particulars his observations , which were largely polemical , have advanced our knowledge of the subject ; but in some respects they are a retrogression .
His personal acquaintance with species was greatly inferior to that of the Prussian zoologist , and insufficient for satisfactory generalisation .
5 .
Since then , I am not aware that any naturalist has attempted , from personal observation , a revision of the class , or even of any considerable number of species ; and the science has advanced , chiefly , by isolated papers on individual species , and by critical examinations of the facts already accumulated .
These memoirs I shall enumerate in chronological order .
6 .
In 1843 , Dr. KOLLIKER published a memoir *on Megalotrocha , confining himself to the segmentation of the egg , and the ( so-called ) seminal threads .
Dr. OSKAR SCHMIDT , in 1846 , gave a resutme of what was then known of the organization of the ROTIFERA generally .
In the same year , the late Dr. MANTELL , in his 'Thoughts on Animalcules , ' though chiefly founded on EHRENBERG , added some information of interest and value on the development of the young in Stephanoceros and Melicerta .
In the 'Annals of Natural History ' for 1848 , Dr. DOBIE described with minuteness two new species of Floscularia ; and Mr. BRIGHTWELL recorded his important discovery of the dioecious character of a ROTIFERON which I have since named Asplanchna .
The same species formed the subject of a valuable memoir by Mr. DALRYMPLE , read before the Royal Society in February 1849 .
Meanwhile , however , some additional observations had appeared by Dr. LEYDIG ?
, on the egg-segmentation of Notommata , Euchlanis , and Megalotrocha ; and in the same year ( 1848 ) , Dr. FREY had published a work on the class generally [ 1 , which I have not been able to see .
In 1850 I published several memoirs on ROTIFERA in the 'Transactions of the Microscopical Society ' and the 'Annals of Natural History , ' viz. " On the Habits of Melicerta ringens ?
[ " ( January ) ; " On the Anatomy of Notommata aurita " ( May ) ; On Asplanchna priodonta** " ( July ) ; and " On Notommata parasita " ( December ) .
In 1851 I published a catalogue of 108 species that I had observed , including descriptions of five new genera and thirty-two new species* .
In this latter year M. D'UDEKEM published in the 'Memoirs of the Brussels Academy ' two papetrs , the one on the circulatory system in Lacinularia socialis , the other on Floscularia cornuta ; the latter as if a new species , but which had been described and figured by Dr. DOBIE four years before .
The foirmer of these animals , Lacinularia socialis , became the subject of two very valuable papers in the year 1852 ; the one by Mr. HUXLEY+ , and the other by Dr. LEYDIG ? .
In the following year appeared a " Memoir on the Anatomy of Melicerta ringens , " by Professor WILLIAMSON 11 , closely followed by a second ?
[ on the same species , by myself .
7 .
In this enumeration I believe I have included all that has been published on the subject of the ROTIFERA , from original observation : should anything , however , have been omitted , it is because it has eluded my most careful scrutiny .
8 .
What changes may have been produced on the state of our knowledge of the nervous , vascular , glandular , muscular and reproductive systems of the ROTIFERA , by these researches , it is not my province here to inquire .
My present business is with the digestive system , and particularly with the organs of manducation ; and of these , I think it is no more than the truth to say , our knowledge is almost exactly where EHRENBERG placed it five-and-twenty years ago .
9 .
This assertion seems strange after so many memoirs , of more or less value , by different observers , on various species ; but the wonder is much lessened by a reexamination of their subjects .
Of the thirteen monographs enumerated , two are on Floscularia , three on 3Melicerta , three on Lacinularia , three on Asplanchna , and two on Notommata .
Now in Melicerta and Lacinularia the manducatory apparatus is of the same type , and that an abnormal one ; in Floscularia and Asplanchna the types of structure differ widely from the former , and as greatly from each other .
These three types are in fact unintelligible in themselves , and can be explained only by tracing the organs from their normal development , through their modifications and degenerations .
Nothing then , in fact , has been attempted towards an explanation of the jaws , in the great families of Hydatincea , Euchlanidota , and Brachioncea the true types of RoTIFERA-except my own two memoirs on Notommata in 1850 .
And I freely confess , that , in spite of many and persevering efforts , I had not , at that time , been able to attain any satisfaction on the true structure of these organs .
10 .
Nothing is easier than to see the forms of the various parts , in outline , in some one aspect ; to obtain , for example , a dorsal or ventral view of the jaws in Brachio* Ann. Not .
Hist. Sept. 1851 .
Bull .
de l'Acad .
Belg. xviii .
pp. 39,43 .
" Journ. Micr .
Soc. i. ( Trans. ) p. . ?
SIEB .
et KOLL .
Zeitschr .
, Feb. 1852 .
11 Journ. Micr .
Soc. i. ( Comm .
) p. 1 . ?
Ibid. p. 71 .
NoTE.-Since the presentation of this paper to the Royal Society , there has appeared in the 'Journal of Microscopical Science ' an abstract of another memoir by Dr. LEYDIG , " On the Structure and systematic Position of the Rotifera .
" The original I have not yet had an opportunity of examining.-P .
H. G. 3K2 421 nus , or a lateral one in Furcularia : but when we have done this , we have gone but a little way towards such an understanding of the whole form , and the relation of the complex parts to each other , as will enable us to project them , or to form an ideal model of the whole .
A little more light is shed on the structure by crushing the animals between plates of glass , or under the graduated pressure of a compressorium : but the distortion of the parts is very great ; and some of them , especially those which form the intermediate piece ( incus ) , on which the greatest obscurity rests , are almost invariably broken into a multitude of separate fragments in the process of flattening ; and thus the result merely tantalizes the expectation .
11 .
Little more seems to be yet known of the structure of the manducatory organs ( I speak of the normal forms ) than can be obtained by these modes , and the published descriptions of them are vague and unsatisfactory .
12 .
Thus EHRENBERG describes the general structure as follows:- " The no-ral intestinal canal in the ROTIFERA consists first of a globose muscular throat-bulb ( schlundkopf ) , in which are fixed two toothed jaws , and the anterior opening of which is placed in the midst of the wheel-organ , somewhat towards the belly [ side3 .
` ' " In all the forms there is a moving manducatory organ ( kauorgan ) , furnished , in forty-eight genera , with indubitable teeth , and evidently mninistering to the alirnentary canal .
" Again , in proposing a division of the class , according to the teeth , he groups the ROTIFERA as , i. Toothless ( Agomphia ) ; ii .
Free-toothed ( Gymnogomphia ) , where the teeth resemble the fingers of a hand fastened to the jaw-franme behind , but free in front ; iii .
Bound-toothed ( Desmogomphia ) , where the teeth are fastened across upon the jaw , like an arrow upon a bow + .
The most laboured description of the normal structure the same zoologist has given under the genus Hydatina , which he professedly makes the vehicle for a rdszumd of his acquaintance with the typical forms of the class .
" The nutritive system , " he observes , consists of a great buccal cavity , chiefly enclosed and formed by the rotatory organ , as an upper lip ; in the bottom of which , near the ventral side , lies the spherical four-muscled throat-bulb , with two many-toothed jaws .
In each jaw are held five conical teeth , resembling a hand , somewhat converging towards the bottom , diminishing in size inwardly .
Sometimes a minute sixth tooth appears to be developed .
The five teeth of each jaw , which are perceived , on crushing the body between glass plates , to be the only hard and solid parts , are jointed into a cartilaginous frame , which serves for the attachment of the muscles , and has the form of a shoulder-blade .
This is the proper jaw , which is composed of several parts .
Inwardly , both jaws are in connexion with a frame of cartilaginous throat-arches , which is very complicated , and seems more fitted for the support and attachment of the masticatory muscles than for proper activity ? .
" 13 .
I shaii presently show that these descriptions are both very imperfect and very * Trans. Berl .
Acad. 1830 , p. 29 .
f Infusionsth .
p. 385 .
+ Ibid. p. 386 . ?
Ibid. p. 414 .
incorrect and the figures , with which they are illustrated , are but rude approximations to verisimilitude .
14 .
M. DUJARDIN sums up his observations on the same organs in the following words .
After alluding to the TARDIGRADA , which he includes in his SYSTOLIDES , the genus Enteroplea , which is said to be toothless , and the genera Floscularia and Lindia , which he describes ( incorrectly ) as lacking a ciliated mouth , he observes , " All the other SYSTOLIDES , having jaws enclosed in a muscular pharyngeal bulb , which is moveable and protractile , at the bottom of a ciliated vestibule , may be distinguished according to the form of these jaws .
Thus the Rotifers have their jaws in the form of a stirrup , opposed by the base , and bearing two or more small teeth , laid parallel , like arrows on a bow .
The outer border , which is semicircular , furnishes a point of attachment for the muscles of the pharyngeal bulb ; and , drawn by them , it is strongly elevated and depressed , to produce , during manducation , the movement of the jaws .
Their inner border is composed of two transverse bars , a little arched outwardly ... ..All the others .
have jaws more resembling those of articulated animals , and composed of an assemblage of articulated pieces , which we may , up to a certain point , compare to the two pairs of mandibles and jaws , to the lips , to the tongue , and to the labial palpi of insects .
In fact , in many of the SYsToLIDES we observe a central odd piece , on which are articulated two simple branches , which bear upon each other , or meet as by a hinge , in the midst of moveable and articulated pieces , supporting the jaws properly so called , and transmitting to them , thus , all the effort of the median muscular mass , to make them bite upon the prey , by furnishing to them apoint d'appui , when the lateral muscles draw back the external branches which carry the jaws * .
" 15 .
The eminent French naturalist , in this description of the jaws , which appears to be drawn from the type found in such genera as Diglena and Albertia , has touched a key which might have unlocked the structure , not in a few genera only , but in the whole class of ROTIFERA .
As it is , however , I cannot agree with Dr. OSKAR SCHMIDT , that the arrangement and function of the teeth , and of the surrounding bulb , are so manifest as to need no further observation t. 16 .
It may not be out of place to describe the manner in which the following observations were made .
The desideratum was to obtain views of various aspects of the same animal ; particularly of the dorsal and ventral aspects , of the lateral , and of the vertical or frontal .
But the minuteness of the objects , ranging from 30-6 to 5-1th of an inch , precluded the possibility of affixing them to a needle , or other machinery , by which they could be made to revolve while in the field of vision ; and the more , since , being aquatic animals , they must be viewed immersed in water ; a momentary removal causing the death of most species .
The incessant activity of these little animals is also a great bar to accuracy of observation , if they be allowed freedom ; and if we confine them by means of the compressorium , the form of their bodies causes them to present almost invariably the same aspect to the observer , viz. that in which the greatest width is at right angles to the line of vision ; so that we may examine specimen after specimen , till patience is exhausted , and acquire no new information , because we look each time at the same aspect .
17 .
In the course of expeirnients with various chemical reagents on these animals , I found that a solution of potash had the effect of instantly dissolving the flesh , and most of the viscera ; leaving the general integument , the walls of the pharyngeal bulb , and all the solid parts of the manducatory apparatus uninjured* .
In most cases , also , the last-named organs are expelled from the visceral cavity by the contraction of the integuments ; so that they float at large , in brilliant clearness , undimmed by intervening tissues , and as patent to observation as when crushed betweetn plates of glass ; with the advantage of all the parts being unbroken , and retaining their relative positions .
Now , by turning the screw of the compressorium , flattening or deepening the drop of water , waves were communicated to it , by means of which the floating bulb , being nearly globulari , was made to revolve irregularly , and thus to present , in succession , various aspects to the eye .
18 .
The observations which I am about to record were made with one of POWELL and LEALAND'S microscopes , with a power of 560 diameters ; except those on Stephanoceros and Diglena , on which the powers employed were 220 and 300 diameters .
19 .
For the sake of precision in description , it may be well here to mention a few terms that I shall employ , and to define the sense in which they will be used .
The symmetry of the ROTIFERA is truly bilateral , the genera Stephanoceros and Floscularia alone retaining a lingering remnant of radiism , in the arrangement of the frontal lobes ; even in these , htowever , the whole of the anatormy besides , botht external and internal , is bilateral .
In most cases this arrangement is obvious ; the motions of the animal , like those of the footed larvae of insects , being performed on the belly , with the head foremost .
Where this is not the case , as with those genera which , either with or without an enveloping tube , adhere to foreign substances by the tip of the foot , and elevate the body in an erect position , the dorsal aspect is always deterininable by the eye or eyes being towards that surface , by the stomach and intestine passing down it , and by the cloaca being on that side of the foot .
The ventral aspect has the manducatory apparatus , and the ovary .
The anterior extremity carries the vibratile cilia ; the posterior is terminated by the foot .
In such species as are clothed with a lorica , I shall call the anterior termination of the dorsum , the occipital edge ; and the anterior termination of the venter , the mental edge .
Other terms will be defined in the process of description .
20 .
As the manducatory bulb , with its complex contents , is the principal subject of these observations , I shall commence with it ; treating the other parts as accessory to it .
In most ROTIFERA this organ forms a prominent object , conspicuous from its form and motions .
By old observers the vigorous workings of its internal parts caused it to be mistaken for a heart ; but it las long been recognized as an organ of mastication .
Dr. EHRENBERG sometimes calls it Kauorgan , but more generally Schlundkopf , and its contents Kau-apparat .
M. DUJARDIN speaks of it as le bulbe pharyngien .
VON SIEBOLD calls it a pharynx ; and English zoologists have generally used the term gizzard .
I hope to prove that it is neither a gizzard nor a pharynx , but a true mouth : in the mean time , however , whatever its homological value , it is doubtless a form of apparatus which has no parallel in other classes of animals , and therefore deserves a proper appellation .
I propose then to appropriate to the subglobose muscular bulb , which contains the manducatory organs in most ROTIFERA , the term mastax .
21 .
The mastax , with its contents , is found in the highest degree of development in the genera Brachionus , Euchlanis , and some of the Hydatinwa .
It is usually more or less globose in form , composed of three lobes , which are confluent anteriorly , with a common rounded outline ; but separated posteriorly , one lobe diverging towards the ventral side , the others laterally , and a little dorsally ; so that a posterior aspect would assume the outline of a trefoil .
The general form is sub-hemispheric in Brachionus and its allies ; that of an oblate spheroid in Euchlanis ; a prolate spheroid in Notommata aurita ; coIdate in Notommata petromyzon ; sub-triquetrous in Plagiognatha ; triglobular in Notommata clavulata ; purse-like in Mastigocerca ; irrlegularlly oblique in Synchceta and Polyarthra ; and wanting in Floscularia .
22 .
In substance it varies from a state in which its walls are thick and solid , conmposed of dense muscular fibre , with little cavity , as in Brachionus , to one in which it forms a capacious sac , with thin , apparently membranous , parietes , as in Furcularia .
23 .
The anterior side of the mastax is perforate , its walls here merging into the tube of the buccalfunnel .
It is perforate also on its dorsal aspect ; whence the wsophagus issues to join the stomach .
24 .
Let us now examine in detail the mastax , in the modifications which it assumes in various species .
In Brachionus urceolaris ( Plate XVI .
figs. 1 to 10 ) , it is a dense , colouirless , highlyrefractive mass of muscles , sub-hemispherical , distinctly trilohate posteriorly , and cleft deeply on the ventral side of its anterior surface ( fig. 1 ) .
Within it are placed two geniculate organs ( b ) , which , from their resemblance in form and action to hammers working on an anvil , I have elsewhere named mallei ; and a third ( f ) , still more complex , which I call the incus .
These three pieces are not arranged in the same plane ; for the mallei approach each other a little dorsally , while the incus is placed on the ventral side of the centre , its stem pointing considerably towards the same side .
Thus each of the three organs corresponds to , and occupies the centre of , one of the lobes of the mastax .
This obliquity of the parts with respect to each other , and to the planes of the body , is one cause of the great difficulty which attends an endeavour to reconcile the various aspects of this organ in any intelligible manner .
25 .
Each malleus consists of two principal portions , articulated with each other by 425 a powerful joint , which seems to be ginglymate in its character , admitting of motion in one plane only .
The two opposing surfaces appear to be united by elastic ligaments , while their irregularities lock into each other .
26 .
The inferior portion of the malleus , which I shall call the manubrium ( c ) , is an irregularly-curved piece , shaped somewhat like the scapula of a mammal , knobbed at its head , and flattened at its lower or free end , where also it is twisted to one side .
Ridges run down it , on both the interior and exterior surfaces .
The head is obliquely truncate ; and it is this oblique surface ( d ) , that is jointed to the superior portion ( e ) , which , from its prevalent form in other genera , rather than in this , I call the uncus .
27 .
The uncus , when at rest , is placed nearly at right angles to the manubrium , but is capable of considerable change of relative position by means of the joint .
It consists of five or six finger-like processes ( figs. 2 , 3 ) , set parallel to each other , and separated by narrow interspaces , which appear to be occupied by a thin membrane .
These are not joints , moveable inter se , but resemlble the teeth of a comb in their mode of origination .
They are slender , rough , and enlarged at their tips ; and the ultimate one of the series , next the dorsal side ( fig. 3 ) , is an offshoot from the penultimate .
Their extremities are bent abruptly downward , approaching each other ; and they are so arranged , that the whole uncus forms a segment , about one-third , of a cylinder , or a drum with incurving sides , with a broad truncate end ( fig. 4 ) .
28 .
The incus ( f ) also consists of distinct articulated portions .
Tie principal are two stout rami ( g ) , together vase-like in ventral aspect ( fig. I ) , resting on what appears to be a slender pedicel ( fulcrum , h ) .
But viewed laterally , the fulcrum is seen to be a thin plate ( fig. 5 ) , o one edge of which the rami are jointed , in such a manner that they can open and close , like a pair of shears .
Each ramus is a thick , somewhat trigonal piece , with the outer side rounded , the upper side hollowed , and the inner side flat , and in contact with the corresponding face of its fellow , in a state of repose .
The uncus of each malleus , respectively , falls into the concavity of each ramus ; and is fastened to it by a stout triangular muscle ( i ) , which is seen passing from the hollow of the ramus to the under surface of the uncus .
29 .
Such are the firm parts ; which , whatever their material , have great strength , solidity , and density .
Their density , however , is not uniform ; for , in some parts , they appear to merge insensibly into membrane , or into the muscular bands .
They are perfectly transparent and colourless , and have a high refractive power .
Their substance is not affected by a solution of potash , but is instantly dissolved , without effervescence , by hydrochloric , nitric , and acetic acid .
Sulphuric acid also dissolves it , without any ebullition that appears to originate from the contact .
30 .
The special muscles which move these organs are numerous , and several of them massive .
The walls of the mastax themselves are , as has been already said , muscular , and so thick as to leave the internal cavity but small .
There are indications of muscles , which I have not been able satisfactorily to define ; but the following are well made out .
A thick muscle ( j ) embraces the upper and outer angle of the articulation of the malleus , and is inserted in the wall of the mastax immediately over against it .
A semi-crescentic band ( k ) is inserted , by its broad end , into the inferior and basal palrt of the uncus , and by its slender end into the middle of the inner side of the manubrium .
The former of these ( j ) may be considered as an extensor , the latter ( k ) as a flexor .
A broad and powerful band ( I ) is inserted along the whole inner side of the manubriurn , and also apparently into the basal part of the uncus , and passes inwards towards the posterior or lobate wall of the mastax ; into which it probably merges , as I have not been able to trace its inferior insertion .
31 .
The movements of these organs are very complex .
The most conspicuous is an alternate approach and recession of the two unci , by a perpendicular motion on the hinge-joint .
The opposing faces come into successive contact , and bruise down the particles of food in the manner of mullers .
But a moment 's observation shows that there are other movements besides this .
The manubria move also at the same time ; their free extremities are made to approach each other , as the unci mutually recede ; and that with a peculiar twist , which greatly alters the apparent figure of these organs .
[ See figs. 6 to 8 ; of which 6 represents the right manubrium when the unci have receded , 8 the same when the unci approach , and 7 an intermediate condition .
] The incus also has considerable motion .
Sometimes the fulcrum is elevated and the rami depressed , so that the former is invisible : the rami open and shut with the working of the mallei , being fastened to them by the strong triangular muscle above-mentioned ; but it is also evident that they have a mnotion of separating and not very often exercised .
Again , when substances are brought into contact with the jaws , which , for any reason , are not acceptable , they are thrown up through the buccal funnel , by a peculiar scoop-like action of the unci , which is very curious to witness .
32 .
I have seen this action many times ; but , in particular , on one occasion , in which much intelligence seemed to be displayed .
I was watching a Brachionus pala in water , in which a number of that beautiful , mulberry-like animalcule , Syncrypta volvox , were revolving .
One or two of these had been devoured , and were very visible in the intestinal canal of the Brachionus , which appeared excited by the enjoyment to unusual efforts .
The mode in which it directed its ciliated flaps towards the spot where a Syncrypta was whirling , or suddenly stretched forward to the extent of the long foot , as if it would seize the prey , seemed to indicate a perception of its presence ; as did , still more , the manner in which it depressed the lip-like lobe of the rotatory organ on one side , when the prey was in the vortex on that side , and the eager haste with which it shrank down into the lorica , the instant the animalcula dropped at length into the buccal funnel .
Now , however , arose a difficulty ; the black , millstone-like unci opened and stretched forward to grasp the little victinm ; they touched the globular investing case , but could not embrace it .
The Brachionus redoubled his efforts ; the jaws gaped vigorously , but could only selrape the sides of the little globe , which at every touch slipped away , the expanse of the unci being not quite sufficient to grasp it .
At length the animal appeared indignant ; the jaws no more endeavoured to grasp , but , with a very distinct and sudden upward jerk , threw out the prey , which until then had been retained and pressed downwards by the contraction of the sides of the buccal funnel .
Several times I saw this scene occur , with the same violent efforts , and the same ill success .
A smaller Syncrypta , how.ever , was bruised down by the jaws , while under my eye , and passed quickly into the stomach .
33 .
This incident I have described with some minuteness , not only as illustrating the particular movement in question , but also because of its bearing upon the general functions of the organs under review the prehension and manducation of food .
And it may be well , before I notice the modifications of the mastax in other forms , to say a few words on the structure and functions of the buccal funnel , and of some other contiguous organs .
34 .
The broad vibratile disk of Brachionus is deeply cleft at its mental edge , the incision reaching down to the summit of the mastax .
The sides of the cleft can be brought into contact ; and hence the structure is visible only at certain times , as when food is taken in .
But the interior is a wide infundibuliform cavity , narrowing to a slender tube at its lower extremity , where its sides merge into the parietes of the mastax .
This is the cavity which I have called the buccalfunnel .
35 .
In Brachionus amphiceros the strong setiform cilia of the disk-lobes overarch the incision ; and its upper edges , for a short distance downward , are irregularly jagged or crenated .
In other species , as B. Bakeri and B. dorcas , the margins are smooth .
In every case , however , the interior surface of the funnel is set with fine cilia , and currents , or ciliary waves , may constantly be seen pouring down the tube .
36 .
The sides of the funnel , in all cases , are formed of irregular bulbous masses of transparent flesh , which may be presumed to be muscular .
Those masses which encircle the rim are usually large , and more regular .
The parts are very flexible and mobile .
The tube can be quite closed by the contact of its walls , even while the upper part of the funnel remains expanded : in B. Bakeri I have seen a globose mass occasionally pushed up from behind the tube to a considerable distance up thefunnel , and presently retracted .
It may be that some function analogous to taste is exercised by this organ .
37 .
Attached to the tube of the funnel , resting on the summit of the mastax , are seated a pair of large , clear , vesicular organs ( see fig. 9 , n ) , which , from their appearance and their situation , may be assumed to be salivary glands .
In Brachionus they are of great size , and are generally twoor three-lobed .
In Asplanchna ( fig. 56 ) , also , they are very large , and kidney-shaped .
In the genera Euchlanis ( fig. 12 ) and Anurcea , similar , and probably homologous vesicles are seated on the wsophagus , just below its exit from the mastax .
38 .
The tube of the buccalfunnel ( m ) invariably opens upon the spot where the unci meet .
The particles of food , or the minute animalcules , which form the prey of the ROTIFERA , are drawn by the discal vortices into the funnel , and lodged at this point , within the mastax .
The unci , and the rami of the incus , conjointly work on them ; and they are speedily dismissed to the tips of the rami , immediately below which , on the dorsal side of the mastax , the oesophagus opens ( p ) ; a membranous tube , capable of great expansion and contraction , but varying much in length and diameter in different genera .
A current of water appears to be almost constantly setting through the funnel , along the rami , in a direction towards their extremities , and thence through the oesophagus into the stomach .
39 .
In general , the ciliary vortices are sufficient to bring the prey within the funnel ; but in several genera of the family Euzchlanidota , as Metopidia , Colurus , Monura , and Stephanops , there is a curious accessory organ , which aids in the capture of prey ; at least , I am sure it is so employed in several species of Metopidia .
40 .
Thus , in M. acuminata ( fig. 1 1 ) , the frontal region is foirmed by an arched fleshy process occipitally , which is approached by a small one at the mental side ; and between these is the wide entrance of the buccalfunnel .
The occipital process is protected by a horny crystalline plate , forming a segment of a sphere , and when viewed laterally taking the appearance of a curved horn .
It can be partially protruded and retracted , and also bent down to meet the mental lobe .
41 .
This apparatus , when the animal is taking food , is kept in vigorous action .
A strong vortex is produced by the ciliary wheels ; and as the floating atoms whirl by , the moveable plate is thrown forward with a grasping motion , the fleshy head being , at the same time , protruded ; and , when the lobes are in contact , retracted .
This is repeated almost every instant , with manifest eagerness and discrimination , the manducatory apparatus working vigorously all the while .
42 .
The same curious organ is frequently employed in another way .
It is bent considerably downward ; and , as the animal crawls deliberately up and down the stems of aquatic plants , it is used to rake and grub among the floccose deposits , the minute Diatomacece , &amp;c. , that adhere to them .
( See fig. 11 .
) 43 .
Taking the structure described in Brachionus as the standard , I now proceed to examine how it is modified in other genera .
In Euchlanis deflexa ( figs. 12 to 15 ) , the fulcrum of the incus ( h ) is thinned off ventrally to a blade-like edge , which is minutely jagged , and dilated laterally at the foot .
The rami are very large ( g ) , expanding at the sides in a triangular , pointed form ; and arching across the mastax towards the dorsum , where each terminates in an elongated , curved , descending spine .
The two points approach each other in a forcipate manner .
44 .
The rami are crossed at right angles by the four-fingered unci of the mallei , which by their motions evidently open the rami ; though these latter do not appear , as usual , to be separable to thefulcrum , but to be united into one piece , with an ovate excavation between them ( fig. 14 ) , that does not reach to the fulcrum .
45 .
The manubria are more developed than in Brachionus .
Instead of the thickened knob , to which the uncus is articulated , the upper portion of the manubriuni 3L2 429 forms a broad laminar dilatation , down which run several carinee , or ridges , of solid material ; the interspaces , apparently , being filled with membrane , or softer and more fleshy substance ( c ) .
The ridges enclose three areas , of which the central one extends through the whole length of the manubrium , and the two external ones are smaller , and compose the dilatation .
This structure is worthy of notice , since it is highly characteristic ; and , as we shall presently find , will help us to identify this organ under very modified fortns .
46 .
The parietes of the mastax are much thinner than in Brachionus .
A stout muscle ( j ) embraces the articulation of the malleus , including a portion of the manubrium , and of the uncus .
In E. hipposideros , a fan-shaped muscular band spreads along the interior side of both these parts , filling the angle , and stretching from one to the other : it is evidently a powerfulflexor .
47 .
In this genus we see a structure of the incus , which prevails extensively in the class : each ramus is produced into an angular projection on either side of thefulcrum .
To this projection , which I shall call alula ( o ) , a muscular band is fastened , which passes down , and is inserted into the fundus of the mastax .
Another more slender band or ligament connects the projection with the foot of the fulcrum .
48 .
The tube of the buccal funnel ( m ) is very wide .
The oesophagus ( p ) is also wide , and short .
On the latter duct are seated two globose clear salivary glands ( n ) , each of which encloses a spherical nucleated nucleus .
These must not be confounded with the pancreatic glands , which are imuch larger , and seated on the stomach , below the entrance of the oesophagus .
49 .
In Notommata aurita ( figs. 16 to 21 ) , while there is much resemblance to Euchlanis , the structure is in some respects peculiar .
The form of the mastax is prolate , the longitudinal diameter exceeding the transverse , -a figure which is dependent on the fact , that the fulcrum of the incus , and the manubria of the mallei , are greatly produced in length , and are all extended nearly in the same direction ; viz. that of the longitudinal axis of the body ( see figs. 16 &amp; 17 ) .
50 .
The manubrium , as in Euchlanis , is three-looped , and dilated at the summit , unsymmetrically ( see fig. 20 ) .
The uncus is broad , composed of five fingers , which are somewhat divergent , and is arched transversely as well as longitudinally .
It is furnished , on that side which is next to the dorsum , with a peculiar , semicrescentic process ( q ) , strengthened by a carina : the points of these two processes are opposed to each other at their tips , beyond the tips of the rami of the incus .
51 .
The fulcrum of the incus , when viewed ventrally , might be mistaken for a straight slender rod , with a round , dilated foot ( fig. 16 ) .
It really consists of two slender curved rods , united by a thin lamina : the exterior of these , which is dilated laterally at the foot , is more curved than the interior , whose extremity it receives in the hollow of its own ( fig. 17 ) , as the chord of a bow joins the extremity of the arc .
The sumit of thefulcr is obliqely truncate , and to this oblique surface are articulated , by a hinge-joint , the two rami .
The rami here take the form of moveable blades or jaws ( figs. 16 , 21 ) , which arch across the vault of the mastax towards the dorsum , and receive , on their convex surfaces , the unci , which are tied to them near their extremities .
The rami are capable of being widely opened ( fig. 21 ) , when several jagged teeth are seen on their opposing edges , which lock into each other when closed .
In the act of expansion , an obtusely pointed lamina is seen below their arch ( fig. 21 , r ) , which is capable of being slightly protruded or contracted , independently of the motion of the rami or unci .
The rami themselves , though opened and closed with the mallei , are not dependent on the action of the latter , for they evidently possess a powerful spontaneous motion in opening and closing .
This movement is doubtless produced by the muscular bands which ( as we saw in Euchlanis ) connect the lateral processes ( alulce ) of the rami , which are greatly developed , with the fundus of the mastax , and with the foot of the fulcrum ( t and u ) .
53 .
The muscles of the malleus differ from those which we have seen in Brachionus and Euchlanis .
A long band passes from the summit of the manubrium to the fundus of the mastax ; another ties its lower extremity to the paris , immediately below it ; while a third passes upward from the inner face of the same piece , probably to the inferior surface of the uncus ( fig. 16 ) .
54 .
The entrance of the buccalfunnel into the mastax is , in this species , protected tenuit any and fagility that I have not been able to resolve them satisfactorily .
55 .
Notommata clavulata ( figs. 22 to 26 ) , a species of large size and of peculiar beauty , is remarkable for the great development of the mallei .
The buccal funnel is here shallow , but richly ciliated ; its short tube merges insensibly into the mastax ( fig. 23 ) , which consists of three lobes , more than usually marked , and nearly spherical .
Each manubrium is , as usual , dilated above , where the lateral loops are trigonal , and attenuated below .
A broad trapezoidal uncus ( figs. 25 , 26 ) is articulated to it , of eight fingers , of which the second and third are branches of the first .
The fingers are arched both transversely and longitudinally , and their extremnities are connected by a web ( fig. 26 ) .
A transverse process crosses their inferior surface , doubtless a point of attachment to the ligament , which fastens them to the ramus of the incus , and which corresponds to the triangular ligament ( i ) described in Brachionus ( ? ?
28 ) .
The elasticity of this ligament is well shown in the working of the jaws ; for the uncus is elevated to a considerable distance above the level of the incus ( see fig. 24 ) , when the appearance and action of the pair are exactly those of curved dentate mandibles , opening and snapping across the tube of the buccal funnel .
The incus is placed nearly horizontally , or at right angles with the plane of the manubria ; but , during the vigorous working of these organs , they are alternately depressed and elevated to so great a degree , that the fulcrum appears now above , now below their level .
56 .
The fulcrum is rather short , much compressed , and thickened at its free extrerity ; its direction scarcely deviates from that of the rami , in this respect contrasting widely with Not .
aurita .
The rami , when closed , assume a pyriform or lozengelike outline , but are cleft to their base ; and as the unci are attached to the terminal half of their length , they open widely ( fig. 24 ) .
57 .
The whole manducatory apparatus in Anurcea acuminata bears a resemblance , singularly exact , to this of Not .
clavulata , notwitllstanding the external diversity of the two animals .
The similarity extends even to the manner in which the unci , which are seven-fingered , are protruded into thefunnel , and fiercely snapped .
58 .
Notommata petromyzon ( Plate XVII .
figs. 27 to 31 ) is remarkable for the extreme simplicity of the parts under review ; a circumstance which makes it peculiarly valuable as a study .
It is one of those species in which the ciliated facial disk is very oblique , being nearly on the plane of the venter .
Hence the buccalfunnel is short at all times , and can be quite obliterated , the entrance of the mastax opening on the facial surface .
This organ is a delicate sac with membranous walls , of obcordate form ( fig. 31 ) , deeply trilobate at the fundus .
59 .
The fulcrum of the incus ( fig. 31 ) is thin and blade-like ; , straight , except that its free extremity is slightly incurved , very deep , and truncate at its articulate extrenity .
The ramni ( fig. 29 ) , when united , form an isosceles triangle , cleft to the flcrum and arching downwards .
60 .
The mallei are equally simple .
The manubrium ( figs. 28 , 31 ) is a slender rod , with a projecting process near its articulation .
The uncus ( fig. 28 ) consists of two fingers , membranous in texture , and at times evanescent , which work on the ramus near its extreniity ; and two muscular threads are seen connecting the former with the latter .
61 .
Notwithstanding the simplicity of the organs in this instance , a comparison with Not .
aurita will show that the structure is essentially the same in the two species .
62 .
In Notommata lacinulata ( figs. 32 to 34 ) the mastax is very large , subtrihedral , with the orifice at the surface of the disk or protruding from it ; so that there is no buccalfunnel .
The incus , though somewhat simple , is very large ; and the rami , when closed , form a hemispherical dome of thin texture ; so as to resemble , when viewed obliquely from above ( fig. 33 ) , a globe of glass standing on a pedestal ( the fulcrum ) .
The similitude is enhanced by lines passing in different directions over the vault , like the astronomical circles .
The mallei ( fig. 34 ) are slender rods , hooked at the bottom ; and soldered at the upper part across the domne , where they become very much attenuated , without any distinct division into manubrium and uncus .
63 .
The rami of the incus are divided to their base ; in use , they are protruded considerably , and are distilnctly organs of prehension ; their edges being employed vigorously , in nibbling at the floccose matter that accumulates on aquatic plants , as the little animal crawls , by means of its two-toed foot , up and down the stalks .
64 .
M. DUJARDIN has constituted a genus ( Plagiognatha ) for this species and Not .
'felis of EHRENBERG ; mainly , however , because they have " machoires a branches parallMles tourn6es du meme co6t , et recourbees verse le board cili6 , avec un tige centrale ( fulcrum ) droite , trls-longue , elargie a sa base * .
" This description is so vague , that it might embrace a multitude of widely iemnote species and genera ; while it does not at all indicate the true peculiarity of the organs it professes to define .
65 .
Furcularia gibba ( figs. 35 to 37 ) comes , in the form of its jaws , very near to Not .
lacinulata ; but most of the species of this genus , as described by Professor EHRENBERG ( not by M. DUJARDIN , who includes in it a number of dissimilar species , already well defined and separated by his Prussian predecessor ) , are distinguished by the manubria being dilated laterally at their free extremity , so as to resemble the foot of a towel-horse .
These expansions are doubtless for the attachment of muscles ( which , however , I have not been able to define ) ; and as the simple uncus is affixed to the edge of the ramus only by its point ( fig. 36 ) , a greater play is probably afforded it by such muscles , in the combined action of the jaws upon the prey .
66 .
The rami are broad , glassy , vaulted , cleft throughout , capable-of widely opening ( fig. 36 ) , and produced into long decurved points ( fig. 37 ) .
Their lower edges are thickened , so as to form a marginal band .
67 .
Furcularia marina has its manducatory organs formed on another type , approaching that of Diglena ; as I shall presently notice .
68 .
Notommata gibba ( figs. 38 to 40 ) prepares us for the remarkable modification of these organs which we find in Synchceta and Polyarthra .
It is a minute species , having much of the appearance and habits of Not .
lacinulata ; but remarkable for the length and lozenge-form outline of the mastax , owing to the great posterior development of the ventral lobe , which is itself dependent on the great elongation of the fulcrum .
The manubria ( fig. 39 ) are long and incurved at their free extremities ; the unci are single-toothed , and soldered to the rami .
The latter are curved , glassy blades ; along the middle of each runs a line , which is difficult to understand : after much study , I think it to be the angle of depression of the surface , as represented ideally at fig. 40 .
69 .
In Synchcta and Polyarthra , the mastax and its included organs attain their maximum of developiment as regards dimensions , though not as regalds complexity .
In some species of the former genus fully one-third of the entire bulk is occupied by these organs .
Owing , however , to the extreme delicacy of the parts , particularly of the mallei , and the unequal refiaction produced by the prismatic form of the animals , the structure is unusually difficult to resolve .
EHRENBERG evidently did not understand it : the points of the unci he appears to have seen , in S. pectinata , but no more ; and the frontal styles he mistook for accessory jaws .
In Polyarthra , he merely says that " there are two single-toothed jaws + .
" His figures give little or no light on the true structure in either genus .
70 .
DUJARDIN knows nothing of Synchewta , no species of which he seems to have seen ; but concludes , most groundlessly , that it is not distinct from Hydatina .
Of Polyarthra he merely says , " Machoires unident6es ?
; " and though he figures a spe* Infusoires , p. 651 .
t Infusionsthier .
p. 437 , + Ibid. p. 440 . ?
Infus .
p. 641 .
433 cies* , he gives no details of the internal structure , but represents two projecting articulated setae , which he calls " appendices de la bouche .
" Of the latter , however , I Inust confess , after the examination of dozens of specimens , I can discern no trace , with a power of 560 diameters .
71 .
In 1850 I had discovered , in a species of Synchcta , what seemed to me a most anomalous condition of the manducatory organs .
As the species appeared new , I described it , in 1851 , by the name of S. mordax .
The peculiarity consisted in two pairs of hooked jaws , exactly resembling the mandibles and maxillae of a beetle , now and then projected from the front , and opened with a sudden snapping motion , and instantly withdrawn .
Each pair imoved independently of the other , but in evident connexion with two pairs of bulbous muscles , seated deep in the breast .
They could scarcely be discerned , when withdrawn beneath a sorlt of metnbranous lip that forrmed the fiontal outline ; and no trace of them could be recognized after the animal had been subjected to the compressorium .
72 .
Until recently , this structure completely baffled my endeavours to solve it .
It was totally unlike anything that I was acquainted with in the whole class ; and yet I was quite sure of the exactitude of the observation , having witnessed the phenomena on many occasions .
Very lately , however , I have succeeded , by means of the solution of potash , in defining the whole structure of the solid parts , and can demonstrate them at pleasure .
I found , with surprise , that there is in them no deviation from the normal type , while the function and hornology of the organs are greatly illustrated by their action .
73 .
The mastax , as befole stated , is of large size , ventricose , globose , or subeubical in figure , with both the incus and the mallei so much bent , as to form , when viewed laterally ( fig. 43 ) , each two sides of a quadrangle .
The fulcrum is a slender , compressed rod , slightly arcuate .
The rami are thin , elastic blades , nearly straight when viewed laterally ( fig. 43 ) , but arched in a forcipate manner ; the internal edges not in contact , but approaching at the points , which are somewhat twisted .
The mallei are slender ; the manubrium much bent ; the uncus a single , pointed finger , connected with the ramus by a delicate membrane , cut into teeth , -at least in S. tremula ( fig. 42 ) .
The points of the unci form the anterior , as the points of the rami form the posterior , pair of snapping teeth .
74 .
The vigorous action of these jaws would lead us to expect powerful muscles , and we find them peculiarly thick and bulbose .
The great convergent pair with clubbed summits , that form a conspicuous V-shaped object in the midst of the animal , are muscles , which envelope the mallei ( fig. 41 ) , and are seen , during the momentary protrusion of their tips , like thick gumtns around the bases of the teeth .
A thick , clavate muscle also proceeds from the articulation of the uncus , and lines the globosity of each lateral lobe of the mastax ( fig. 41 ) .
In S. mordax a pair of muscular bulbs are placed , one on each side of the foot of thefulcrum : these are probably the extremities of fasciaw , that extend to the rami ; as the motions of the latter are synchronous with twitchings in these bulbs .
75 .
There is a subtle clear membrane stretched over the whole apparatus , but not in contact with it ; for it has a slight power of independent contraction and protrusion .
It is of considerable breadth , with a blunt point in the centre , which is simple in S. mordax , bifid in S. tremula ( fig. 41 ) .
As there is no buccal funnel , this must be the occipital ( or rather frontal ) margin of the mastax , the teeth being evidently extruded from beneath it ; there must also be a mental , or inferior , margin , but I have not defined it .
76 .
Polyarthra differs little from Synchteta in the form of its jaws .
The mastax is more oblique ( fig. 47 ) , its central lobe being much produced , and pointing towards the venter .
The muscles of the upper portion are so dense ( fig. 44 ) as to shut out all sight of the interior , until they are dissolved away by potash ( fig. 46 ) .
77 .
The rami are very broad , somewhat square at the base , flat , but much arched longitudinally ( fig. 47 ) .
They open and shut vigorously , with a snapping action , but are not protruded from the front : their whole interior edges come into contact .
78 .
The mallei are simple , slender , bent rods , apparently without distinct articulation ( fig. 48 ) .
During life they are thick , and irregular in outline ( fig. 46 ) , owing , doubtless , to their being invested with muscle , as in Synchceta .
79 .
There is a clear vaulted membrane , spreading like a dome over the jaws , when viewed vertically ( i. e. from the front ) , which is certainly the paris of the mastax : it has an advancing and receding margin ( fig. 49 ) , which is placed considerably towards the mental aspect , where the mastax opens at the bottom of a shallowfunnel .
80 .
From these forms , especially that of Synchceta , the transition is easy to Diglena , Eosphora , Albertia , and Furcularia marina .
Thus , in Diglenaforcipata ( figs. 50 , 51 ) , the incus is a true forceps ; the rami proj.ecting in Ilearly the same plane as the fulcrum , and the hooked points coming into contact .
The edges have a peculiar structure , being delicately ridged transversely ; while from the terninal points of the ridges spring slender setae in a double row , which project so as to oppose those of the other ramus .
This curious structure I find also in Diglena grandis .
The fulcrum is compressed .
81 .
The mallei have nearly straight manubria , slightly enlarged at the free extremity , and clubbed towards the joint , where they are invested with thick muscle .
The uncus is a simple curved piece , so far as its point of attachmtent to the ramus ; but at this point there is articulated to it a stout curved acute spine , which , when the rami are closed , crosses its fellow of the opposite uncus , and plays over the setae of the ramus ( fig. 50 ) .
In Diglena grandis there are two spines on each uncus , the one much shorter than the other ; as there are also in Eosphora aurita .
In the latter species these tooth-like spines are projectile , as a formidable .
pair of jaws ; and I doubt not that such is their function in Diglena also , though I have not seen them so used ; especially as , in both genera , the ciliated disk is prolonged on the prone surface nearly in the longitudinal plane of the venter ; so that the aperture of the mastax is brought to the surface , without the intervention of any appreciablefunnel .
82 .
Scarcely differing from this structure is that of the curious little Albertia vermiculus , first found by M. DUJARDIN , living entozoically in Lumbricus and Limax , and which I have found in the intestine of Nais proboscidea ( figs. 52 , 53 ) .
Whether the uncus has an accessory tooth , or not , I cannot certainly say , owing to the minuteness of the parts ; the animal being only T-Elth of an inch in length , and the dental apparatus being unusually minute in proportion .
It is , however , frequently protruded , to the extent of fully half of the apparatus , from the front , and vigorously snapped .
83 .
Furcularia marina ( figs. 54 , 55 ) is another species , in which these organs are greatly protrusile ; the whole of the long mallei being sometimes exterior to the frontal disk ( fig. 54 ) .
The incus ( fig. 55 ) seems to me a simple , much-arcuated forceps ; and the mallei to be without unci , the manubria ( simple incurved rods ) being articulated to the bases of the rami .
M. DUJARDIN describes and figures them differently* , but I believe he is mistaken .
84 .
We are now prepared to understand the form of dental apparatus , which has hitherto appeared perfectly anomalous in this class , -that of Asplanchna , as described and figulied by Mr. BRIGHTWELL and Mr. DALRYMPLE , in the case of A. Brightwellii , and by myself in that of A. priodonta .
To these must be added Notommata myrmeleo , and N. syrinx , of EHRENBERG ; referrible doubtless to the same genus .
A moment 's comparison of the jaws of A. priodonta ( Plate XVIII .
figs. 56 to 59 ) with those of Synchceta tremula , or of Diglena forcipata ( Plate XVII .
figs. 41 , 50 ) either opened or closed , will show that the former constitute an incus , with thefulcrum much diminished ; the very row of teeth that runs , like the edge of a saw , along the interior of the ramus ( figs. 58,59 ) , having its counterpart in the ridges and setae of Diglena ; as also in the teeth of these organs in Notommata aurita .
85 .
The mallei , at first sight , seem wholly wanting in Asplanchna ; but they are really present , though in a state of extreme attenuation and degeneration .
Mr. DALRYMPLE thought he saw an occasional glimpse of an accessory curved point , outside the tip of each jaw , in A. Brightwellii ; and I have invariably observed the same in both that species and A. priodonta ( figs. 58 , 59 ) .
It is a curved pointed rod , which , at its lower end , that ordinarily would be free , is attached to a process , which is itself attached , I believe , by a transverse ligament , to the ramus , near its articulation .
It is most evanescent ; yet it is not dissolved by treatment with potash , and I have no doubt that it represents the malleus .
86 .
The fulcrum , though short and thin , is very deep ; the depth in fact exceeding the length ( fig. 59 ) ; and it affords a clear insight into the nature of the articulation of the rami-a ginglymus of the simplest kind ; the articulating parts having straight parallel edges , united by an interposed membrane .
87 .
Another peculiarity in this genus is the absence of the mastax ; at least in its ordinary form of a chamber enclosing the trophi .
Theifulcrum is attached to a reniform muscular cushion ( fig. 56 ) ; with the rami projecting fireely into the buccalfunnel ; and , under graduated pressure , protruded from the front , when they snap vigorously .
But when we consider that the normal form of the mastax is that of three lobes , of which one belongs to the incus , and two to the mallei , it is natural to expect that the evanescence of the mallei would be accompanied by the evanescence of their muscular lobes .
And this I conclude is the true state of the case : the cushion is the lobe of the incus , and therefore the sole representative of the mastax ; the lateral lobes having become obsolete .
88 .
I was unwilling to interrupt the regular gradation , through which we have traced the degeneration of the mallei to evanescence ; but I now retrace my course a little , to notice how the same organs degenerate in other modes .
In a beautiful and common species , well known to most microscopists , Mastigocerca carinata ( figs. 60 to 62 ) , the dental apparatus occurs under an unusual form .
The mastax is a somewhat slender sac , much produced in length , and with the component lobes greatly and irregularly developed .
The incus has a fulcrum of great length and slenderness , a straight rod with a dilated foot ( fig. 62 , h ) .
The rami are small , forcipate , and resembling those I have lately described ; but with the alulce greatly produced ( o ) .
The mallei have long , slender , incurved manubria , and simple unci .
89 .
But the remarkable circumstance is the non-symmetrical character of the apparatus .
The left side is much more developed than the right .
The left alula of the incus ( o ) descends to a greater distance than the right ( o ' ) ; and its extremity is dilated into an expansion , with several irregular angles , to which muscular threads are attached .
The ramus also of the same side is larger than its fellow .
So with the mallei .
The manubrium of the right ( c ' ) is comparatively short , very slender , and of uniform thickness ; with a long , slender , rod like utncus ( e ' ) , doubly bent in the middle .
The left is much longer , irregularly swollen , clubbed at the articulation , and bearing a thick , curved , knobbed uncus , which terminates at a point not precisely opposite the tip of its fellow ( e)* .
90 .
In Monocerca ( fig. 63 ) , -from which Mastigocerca can scarcely be said to differ generically , though Professor EHRENBERG places it in another family , the right malleus entirely disappears , not a vestige of it remaining ; though the left ( b ) is long , and well developed .
The incus is a straight rod , with a high carina ( f ) , with the rami almost obliterated : the alulce , however , are rather large , but unequal .
91 .
This want of symmetry is a remarkable character of the genus , and is displayed in other particulars .
For example , in Monocerca bicornis , the little projecting tubular organ , which EHRENBERG has called the respiratory tube , but which I consider a rudimentary antenna , is double ; but the two are unequal .
In the same species , and also in M. porcellus , the lorica terminates frontally in two spines , of which , again , the left is considerably larger than the right .
The lorica , in Mon .
rattus , and much more promninently in Mast .
carinata , is furnished with a dorsal carina , running along the median line ; the elevation of this ridge is not perpendicular , but leans considerably over to the right side .
Even the singlefoot-spine , which is so characteristic of the genus , must be considered either as representing the ordinary pair soldered together , or as single through the obsolescence of the other .
That the latter is the true solution is the more probable , since , in Mastigocerca , there is , at the base of the foot-spine , another spine , very minute , but distinctly jointed to the foot-bulb .
This unsymmetrical development is not without parallel in higher animals ; of which it will be sufficient to allude to a single example , in the case of the projecting tooth of the Narwhal .
92 .
The figure of the incus-fulcrum in Monocerca porcellus , and the obsolescence of its rami , make an approach to the structure which we find in a very curious form , Scaridium longicaudum ( Plate XVII .
figs. 64 , 65 ) .
The whole organization of the manducatory apparatus is here so abnormal , that I shall describe it in detail ; especially as DUJARDIN has not noticed the genus at all , and EHRENBERG confines himself to the vague remark , that " the Schlundkopf ( Pharynx ) is oblique , with unequal , pincer-toothed ( one-toothed ) jaws .
" 93 .
The mastax is somewhat obconic , or shaped like the heart of a mammal ; a muscular sac , on the parietes of which transverse rugc appear ( 3 ) .
The eye ( x ) , a large flattened capsule , with the crimson pigment not quite filling it , is attached to its occipital surface ; apparently not connected , as usual , with the large occipital ganglionic sac ( y ) ; which , however , presses upon it from above and behind .
The sunmmit of the mastax projects into a point , which , though within the level of the ciliated ridges of the front ( fig. 64 ) , seems to be in contact with the surrounding water , without the intervention of a buccal funnel .
This point is cleft deeply ; the incision being transverse , from right to left , but obliquely upwards ( fig. 65 ) .
The occilital division separates widely from the niental one , with a gaping or snapping action , very frequently performed ; but with so great a rapidity and suddenness , that it needed long-continued observation to enable me to understand the parts .
The structure is as follows .
94 .
Behind the occipital division , and from its point , spr ing seveiral alrched setae ; and an apparatus of hooked teeth is visible within its concavity .
The mental division ( ; ) is slightly bifid , with rounded points ; between which , at the moment of gaping , several hooked sete are projected , and instantly retracted ( s ) .
These setae , or teeth , are connected , by prolongations of their bases , which are doubly geniculate and appear jointed , with the summit of the fulcrum ( g ) ; and must therefore be the representatives of the rami .
The fulcrum itself is a straight rod , with a strongly developed carina ( h ) , arcuated somewhat in the same way as that of Notommata aurita ( see fig. 17 ) .
95 .
The mallei consist each of a thin uncus ( e ) , working on the ramus , and of a manubrium ( c ) , singularly looped , but of such extreme tenuity , as to require the most delicate adjustment of focus to resolve it .
Indeed , I have never been able to see more than one in a lateral view ; but infer the existence of the other , from the symmetrical appearance of the apparatus , in a dorsal aspect .
Singular as the form of this organ is , I think we can recognise in it the three loops which constitute the solid framrework of the manubrium in Euchlanis , &amp;c. ( ? ?
45 ) .
96 .
We have now traced the same common organs of manducation , through various phases , from what I ventured to call their normal ( levelopinent in Brachionus and Euchlanis .
Viewed generally , these modifications may be considered as successive degenerations of the mallei , and augmentations of the incus .
I shall now return to the same starting-point , and trace a chain of tnodifications in another direction ; a chain of fewer links , it is true , but all tending to the same point , the degeneration and final obsolescence of the incus , and ( in the final stage ) of the mallei also .
97 .
Though the types of structure , in the manducatory organs of the species which we have now to consider , are few , being not more than three or four , the species and genera are numerous ; and they may all be distinguished , by a rematrkable peculiairity , from those with which we have been hitherto engaged .
They no longer assume a prone position when at rest , with the venter towards the support , but take an erect posture , the body elevated in the same line as the foot , the tip of which is the point of attachment .
Many of the members of one of the great groups , and all of another , inhabit cylindrical cases , made of gelatinous matter , thrown off from their own bodies , absurdly called " loricae " by EHRENBEBG , for the purpose of giving a semblance of unity to his artificial arrangement , but really having not the slightest analogy with the stiff integument of Brachionus , Euchlanis , &amp;c. , which is an organic part of the animal .
98 .
The genera Pterodina and Triarthra may seem exceptions to this generalization ; for the former has a distinct lorica , as has also the allied genus which I have named Pompholyx ; and Triarthra has a posterior stylet , which , with the anterior pair , has been compared with the pinnse of Polyarthra ; while yet all these display modifications of the manducatory apparatus , belonging to the type which I am about to describe .
99 .
I am not in this place occupied with the principles of a new arrangement of the ROTIFERA , and shall therefore merely say , that the above exceptions are apparent rather than actual ; though they may be considered as osculant groups .
100 .
Dismissing these , I come to examine the mranducatory organs as they appear in the genera Triarthra , Pompholyx , Pterodina , lEcistes , Limnias , Melicerta , Conochilus , Megalotrocha , Lacinularia , and Tubicolaria .
So far as my examinations reach ( which include eight of these ten genera ) , there is no appreciable variation in the structure of these organs in them all ; and in one of the two , which I have never been so fortunate as to meet with , the deficiency has been well supplied ; since it is the species ( Lacinularia socialis ) which forms the subject of the admirable memoirs of Mr. HUXLEY and Dr. LEYDIG , already referred to ( ? ?
6 ) .
439 Professor EHRENBERG had simply described the apparatus as consisting of teeth , which , like the arrow on a bow , are fastened across the jaw* ; and M. DvJARDIN does little more than repeat the description .
He says , " all these animals present a pair of jaws , almost in form of a stirrup , composed of an arch traversed by a bar , on which lean , by the free extremity , the parallel teeth splinging from the bow of the stirrup , which is engaged in the fleshy bulb+ .
" 102 .
Dr. LEYDIG , who complains of the inaccuracy ofEHRENBERG 's figures , describes the apparatuls as consisting of " two bent quadrangular plates , across which several lines are stretched ; the three foremost , which are stouter than the rest , jutting out as three teeth .
" He says that the two plates have a shears-like figure ; and notices at their union " an apophysis ( the fulcrum ) , which seems to enter into the circular mass of the gizzard .
" 103 .
Mr. HUXLEY , on the other hand , saw the analogy of this type with that which I have already considered ; but not with the stirrup-like form which is found in Philodina , &amp;c. He thus describes it : " The armature of the pharyngeal bulb is composed of four separate pieces .
Two of these ( which form the incus of Mr. GossE ) are elongated triangular prisms , applied together by their flat inner faces ?
: the upper faces are rather concave , while the outer faces are convex ; and upon these the two other pieces ( the mallei of Mr. GossE ) are articulated .
The last are elongated -concave internally , convex externally-and present two clear spaces in their interior ; from their inner surface a thin curved plate projects inwards .
At its anterior extremity this plate is brownish , and divided into five or six hard teeth , with slightly enlarged extremities .
Posteriorly the divisions become less and less distinct , and the plate takes quite the appearance of the rest of the piece .
" This is essentially the same structure as that of the teeth of Notommata [ =Asplanchna ] , described by Mr. DALRYMPLE , and by Mr. GosSE ( on the anatomy of Notommata aurita ) ; and very different from the true 'stirrup-shaped ' armature .
" 104 .
Professor WILLIAMSON describes the apparatus with elaborate care as he finds it in Melicerta .
His remarks are too long to quote , but they agree mainly with what was already known .
He notices " two broad elongated plates , " which he calls " c crushers , " from which " proceed laterally numerous parallel bars , somewhat thickened at their inner extremities , where they are attached to the plates ; whilst at their opposite ends they are united with others of the same side by a curived connecting bar , from the outer sides of which are given off various loops and processes ... .
From the upper extremities of the two crushers there project , upwards and backwards , two slender prolongations , united by a kind of double hinge-joint near their apex , where they not only play upon each other , but also on a third small central fixed point , lodged in a little conglobate cellular mass P. " Professor WILLIAMSON denies that the transverse teeth move on the plates , as affirmed by EHRENBERG , since they are firmly united with them .
He further states , that " the conglobate organ in which the apparatus is imbedded [ i. e. the mastax ] is composed of numerous large cells , each of which contains a beautiful nucleus with its nucleolus ; " and supposes that muscular threads penetrate it to reach the dental apparatus t. The statement of the cellular character of the mastax , and the presumption of penetrating muscles , are alike negatived by my observations , not only of this species , but of the whole range of the RoTIFERA .
The able and learned Professor has probably been misled , in the former conclusion , by some overlying tissues , perhaps similar to the salivary glands in Euchlanis ( see ? ?
48 ) .
105 .
My own observations on the same species , published in the same journal , did not succeed in dispelling the obscurity which still rested on the structure ; and I shall therefore here merely allude to them , ^as a part of the bibliography of the subject .
It appears , however , that though more attention has been bestowed on this type thatn on any other in the class , it still needs solution .
I shall therefore attempt to give it in detail , as it appears in Limnias ceratophylli ( Plate XVIII .
figs. 66 to 71 ) .
106 .
The mastax consists ( fig. 66 , a ) of three subglobose lobes , as usual ( not four , as stated by LEYDIG , and by EHRENBERG before him ) ; one on each side appropriated to each malleus ( b ) , and the third descending towards the ventral aspect , which envelopes the incus ( f ) .
The mallei are more intimately united to the rami of the incus than in the former type ; each uncus forming , with its ramus , a well-defined mass of muscle , enclosing the solid parts , and in form approaching the quadrature of a globe ( c ) ; two flat faces opposing and working on each other ( fig. 66 ) .
Across the upper surface of the mass the uncus is stretched ( fig. 71 , e ) , as three long parallel fingers , arched in their common direction , and imbedded in the muscular substance ; their points just reaching the opposing face of the ramuls , and meeting the points of the opposite uncus , when closed .
The manubrium ( c ) is much disguised , by being greatly dilated transversely , forming three bow-like loops of little solidity , to the chord of which the fingers are soldered , not articulated .
The surface of the dense muscular mass displays stric parallel to the fingers , and , as it were , continuing their number towards the dorsal extremity , becoming fainter till they are imperceptible .
These strice do not disappear when the muscular parts are dissolved by potash ; and hence I infer the existence of a delicate investiture of solid substance , similar to that of the teeth , &amp;c. , enclosing the muscular mass .
107 .
The incus , which cannot be separated from the mallei , thus consists of two portions ( g ) , corresponding to the rami in Brachionus , &amp;c. , each of which forms the * These two prolongations are , as I conceive , but the lateral outlines of thefulcrum ; and the joint is not at the point where they unite , as Professor WILLIAMSON supposes , but at the point of their widest separation , whence the rami diverge .
' Journ. Micr .
Sci. i. ( Comm .
) p. 4 .
441 lower part of the quadrantic mass above described .
At the ventral extremity they are articulated to a slender flcrum ( h ) , which is a little bent downward .
The solid fiamnework of each ramus sends off , from its inferior surface , a slender curved process ( o ) , which is connected with the extremity of the fulcrum , and is probably the analogue of the alula .
108 .
The action of this apparatus is as follows:-The ciliary vortices , produced by the waves of the coronal disk , pass together through the upper sinus , and are hurled in one stream along the centre of the face , nearly to the projecting chin .
Here is placed the orifice of the buccalfunnel , a perpendicularly descending tube of considerable width ( fig. 66 ) , slightly funnel-shaped at the top , the interior surface of which is strongly ciliated .
It descends straight upon the mastax , over the part where the unci unite .
But just above this point there are two valves projecting from the walls of the tube , also well ciliated .
These can be brought into contact , or separated in various degrees , at will ; and being very sensitive , they regulate the force of the inflowing current , and doubtless exclude hurtful or useless substances .
The current now flows along the two rami of the incus , as already described ; and , passing between their separated points , descends into the wsophagus , a slender duct opening beneath them ( p ) , and leading into the digesting stomach .
109 .
As this current passes , the manducatory apparatus acts upon the particles of food which it brings in its course .
The quadrantic masses approach each other and recede , with a rapid rolling movement , in the direction of the curvature of the mallei ; while , at the same time , the rami of the incus open and close their points , rise and sink , and occasionally perform a kind of shoveling action .
The points of the fingers of the unci , meeting each other , doubtless pierce and tear the InJusoria swallowed , and the striated faces of the quadrantic masses bruise , squeeze , and grind them down .
110 .
When the muscular investiturle is dissolved away by potash , the essential identity of the whole structure with that of the type already described becomes abundantly evident .
A comparison with Notommata clavulata , for example ( compare fig. 71 with figs. 25 and 26 ) , will show this .
Even the mallei , which in some aspects present difficulty ( figs. 67 and 69 ) , when viewed vertically are but little changed : the fingers are parallel , instead of divergent , and the ansate ctlaracter of the manubrium is lost ; but three areas , enclosed by loops or carinae of solid substance ( fig. 71 ) , reveal their true nature .
111 .
Another well-marked and easily recognized family , in this group , is that which EHRENBERG has named Philodincea , the first forams of Wheel-animals which attracted the notice of microscopists .
The buccalfunnel is here rather long and slender , and always permanent ; the manducatory apparatus having no power of materially altering its relative position in the body , and never being brought into contact with the exterior .
112 .
The mastax in Rotifer macrurus ( figs. 72 to 78 ) , which may be considered as a typical species , consists of the usual three globose lobes , of which the two lateral are somewhat produced above , to embrace the termination of the funnel .
The dental apparatus differs very little from the type which we have seen in Limnias and its fellows .
The mallei and the incus are soldered together , into two sub-quadranti-globular masses ( t ) , which appear to be muscular , but invested with a solid integument .
These contain the rami of the incus , and are crossed by two strong teeth , which rise frorti below the exterior edge of the mass , and descend upon its interior face .
113 .
The manubria are more obsolescent than in Limnias ; but they may still be recognized , in a vertical aspect ( fig. 74 ) , as three loops , of which the central one is chiefly developed ( c ) ; and in a dorsal aspect ( fig. 72 ) , as a translucent , reniform lobe , descending on the exterior of each quadrant .
Numerous delicate stria cross the quadrantic masses , on each side of the principal teeth , and these are permanent ( fig. 74 ) after potash-treatment .
A very minute and rudimentaryfulcrum ( fig. 75 , h ) is seen in the lateral aspect .
114 .
The structure and action of an apparatus of this type may be made more clear by a homely illustration .
Suppose an apple to be divided longitudinally , leaving the stalk attached to one half .
Let this now be again split longitudinally , so far as the stalk , but not actually separating either portion from it .
Draw the two portions slightly apart , and lay them down on their rounded surfaces ( fig. 76 ) .
They now represent the quadrantic masses in repose , the stalk being thefulcrum , and the upper surfaces being crossed by the teeth .
By the contraction of the muscles of which they are composed , the two segments are made to turn on their long axes , until the points of the teeth are brought into contact , and the toothed surfaces rise and approach each other ( fig. 77 ) .
The lower edges , however , do not separate , as the upper edges approach , but the form of the masses alters , becoming more lenticular ; so that when the toothed surfaces are brought into their closest approximation ( fig. 78 ) , the outline has a subcircular figure .
It is on account of this change of form , that I presume the masses themselves to be partially composed of muscle .
115 .
In Philodina ( e. g. P. roseola and P. megalotrocha ) the quadrants are connected by an elastic ligament , which crosses from the interior face of one to the other , just below the points of the teeth .
I find no trace of this in Rotifer .
The teeth are generally but two ; in P. aculeata , however , I find , as EHRENBERG does , three , and he indicates the same number in P. macrostyla and Monolabis conica , species which I have not met with .
116 .
It has been usual to call the divisions of the dental apparatus , in this family , " stirrup-shaped ; " but this comparison is grounded on a misapprehension of their true form , which I have proved , by numberless examinations , to be that of the quadrature of a sphere , as above explained .
117 .
It is no less evident that Mr. HUXLEY'S remark , above cited , that the jaws in Lacinularia ( =Limnias ) are " very different from the true stirrup-shaped armature " ( so-called ) , is founded on error ; the two forms bearing the very closest analogy , as will appear by a comparison of the figuires 66 and 72 , while I have alrleady proved the essential identity of the former with the structure in Brachionus , &amp;c. 118 .
We are now arrived at the most aberrant forms of the ROTIFERA , the genera Floscularia and Stephanoceros .
In the former ( figs. 79 to 82 ) , the position of the dental apparatus is even more abnormal than its structure .
The teeth appear to be enclosed in no mastax , and are placed far down in the abdominal cavity ; nearer to the cloaca , in fact , than to the flower-like disk .
I will endeavour to explain this .
119 .
The whole of the upper part of this elegant animal 's body is lined with a very sensitive , contractile , partially-opake membrane , which , a little below the disk , recedes from the walls of the body , and forms a diaphragm with a highly contractile , and versatile central orifice .
At some distance lower down another diaphragm occurs , and the ample chamber thus enclosed fo rms a kind of crop , or receptacle for the captured prey .
Below the second diaphragm is another capacious chamber , which we must consider as a stomach , since digestion evidently commences in it , and it opens into the intestine .
120 .
The mastax , as I have above stated , is wholly wanting ; the dental apparatus , which is very small , evidently springing from the common paris of the stomach , just below the second diaphragm .
That this absence of the mastax is real , and not illusive , is proved by the facts , that the Infusoria swallowed pass into the stomach , where they accumulate in its wide cavity ; that the jaws are seen to act on one and another , according as they come within reach ; and that , after such action , they pass off again into the same cavity , to undergo another mastication , when chance again brings them within reach of the teeth .
121 .
From the ventral side of the ample crop that precedes the stomach , there springs , in F. ornata , a perpendicular melnbrane , or veil ( fig. 79 ) , extending partly across the cavity* .
This is free , except at the vertical edge , by which it is attached to the side of the chamber ; and being ample , and of great delicacy , it continually floats and waves from side to side .
At the bottom of this veil , but on the dorsal side , are placed the jaws , consisting of a pair of curved , unjointed , but free mallei , with a membranous process beneath each .
122 .
Each malleus ( fig. 80 ) is an uncus of two slender , arched , divergent fingers , united by a subtle web- : the back of each curves downwards , where , expanding and becoming membranous , it is connected with some delicate but definite processes ( figs. 80 , 81 ) with rounded outlines , which I should have supposed to be muscular bulbs , but that they remain after treatment with potash .
They are probably analogous to the loops in Limnias and Rotifer , representing the manubrium .
Across the uncus , about midway between the bifurcation and the tip , on the inferior surface , a membrane originates , which projects transversely and perpendicularly downwards to some distance , curving at the bottom towards its fellow of the opposite malleus ( fig. 80 ) .
I incline to think this the vanishing representative of the quadrantic mass in Limnias and Rotifer = the ramus of the incus .
124 .
The whole apparatus is very minute , and in soine specimens can , either not at all , or with much difficulty , be detected ; so that we may consider the dental apparatus of the ROTIFERA degraded to its lowest point in this genus .
125 .
Stephanoceros , the most elegant of ROTIFERA , affords peculiar facilities for observation ; since it is by far the largest animal in the Class , reaching to one-fifteenth of an inch in height* .
There are two capacious crops ( each bounded by a diaphragm ) , of which the lower seems to answer to that of Floscularia .
The jaws are placed in the latter , not in the stomnach , which is distinctly separated from it .
They are evidently imbedded in its dorsal paris , working freely in the cavity , without an enclosing mastax t. 126 .
EHRENBERG'S figures of the apparatus seem more than usually incorrect ; it is but fair to say , however , that he admits his observation to be susceptible of doubt .
Each malleus is an uncus , of three curved divergent fingers ( figs. 84 , 85 ) , whose extremities are united by an indented membrane , like the foot of a water-fowl .
There is no distinct manubrium , but the posterior part of the uncus forms a knob , which is enclosed in a large muscular bulb .
127 .
The incus consists of two very mobile and widely separable rami , somewhat quadranti-globular , but much flattened , and each furnished with a lengthened process , which unites with its fellow to form the hinge , without a fulcrum ( fig. 83 ) .
The uncus is connected with the ramus by an elastic ligament , by which means the latter is stretched open vigorously , while the teeth of the malleus act on the prey imprisoned in the crop .
128 .
Thus I have shown that the masticatory apparatus in the whole class of ROTIFERA is modeled on one common plan .
The organs , indeed , are considerably modified , and sometimes so much disguised as to be unrecognizable , on cursory examination : but a careful scrutiny proves that every modification ( for I have omitted none , that I am acquainted with , in which there is any variation of importance ) is , without any violence , referrible to the common type .
129 .
This form of the trophi , alone , isolates the ROTIFERA from other animals , and proves , in concurrence with other points of organization , that this class is a very natural and well-marked group ; since we find one type of structure running through the whole , which is yet widely different from that of any other class of animals .
130 .
As no group of animals , however , nor any set of organs , is so isolated as to have no relations of affinity with others , it is a subject of interest to inquire , What is the hornological value of the complex apparatus we have been considering ?
or , What organ or set of organs do they represent in other classes ? ?
131 .
It has been usual to compare the jaws of the ROTIFERA with the gastric teeth in the higher CRUSTACEA , but I do not think there is in them any homology with these appendages .
It is true that the great subcartilaginous crop in Asplanchna ( fig. 56 ) , a structure unparalleled by any other genus in the whole class , presents a curious similarity , in form and appearance , to the stomach of some of the Decapods , particularly that of Cancer pagurus ; but the resemblance diminishes on examination ; and the bising teeth ofhe Crab have no e alogy with the re expanding jaws of the Asplanchna , than with the complex apparatus of the more normal ROTIFERA .
The resetmblance lies in the circumstance that , in each case , the viscus consists of membranous walls , stretched , as it were , over a subcartilaginous framework , of a somewhat cubical shape .
But the positions of the afferent and efferlent orifices differ importantly , in the two viscera , in relation to the angles of the framework , in situ as well as inter se ; the pyloric olifice in the stomach of the Crab being situate at the extremity most remote from the cardiac , while , in the crop of the Asplanchna , the efferent orifice is placed close to the afferent , at the ventro-anterior angle .
132 .
But again ; this viscus in the CRUSTACEA is a true digestive stomach ; whereas the crop of Asplanchna is meirely a temporary receptacle , separated from the stomach by a long wsophagus : as there is thus no homology between the viscera themselves , there can be none between their respective appendages .
133 .
If the manducatory organs of the ROTIFERA were really represented by the gastric teeth of the CRUSTACEA , the small central piece of the latter would , of course , be the incus of the former : but this cannot be , since the central piece of the latter is affixed to the dorsal wall of the viscus ; whereas , in ROTIFERA , the incus springs from the ventral or inferior side , its muscles forming the ventral lobe of the bulb .
134 .
Once more ; the gastric teeth are simple masses of calcareous matter , deposited , in the form of tubercles , on the interior of the parietes of the stomach , to grind the food as it passes through the pylorus ; whereas , the jaws of the ROTIFERA are complex organs , distinctly articulated , tied by ligaments , moved by their own proper muscles ; and their function is , often , to seize prey without the mouth , and always to bruise or lacerate it before it enters the stomach at all .
135 .
Hoimology cannot consist with such diversities as these ; and , therefore , the gastric teeth of the CRUSTACEA have no true analogy with the jaws of the ROTIFERA .
136 .
If it should be objected that , in Floscularia , &amp;c. , we find the jaws affixed to the walls of the digesting stomach , I reply , that these are the most aberrant forms of their class ; and that we must not ground our deductions of analogy upon the condition of organs that are just vanishing , or merging into a remotely diverse type ; especially when the comparison would tend to unite opposite ends of a series ; as , in the present instance , the Flosculariadce are undoubtedly the lowest foirms of ROTIFERA , looking towards the POLYZOA ; whereas , it is in the highest forms that we must expect to find affinities with the ARTHROPODA .
137 .
To the ARTHROPODA I am convinced that the ROTIFERA belong the humblest members of that great group ; though , as my present business is with one system of organs alone , I am precluded , at this time , from adducing the various reasons derived from other parts of their economy , which have guided me to this conviction .
I think that they lead , however , to the INSECTA rather than to the CRUSTACEA .
138 .
The dental organs in ROTIFERA are true mandibulc and maxilice , and the mastax is a mouth .
This is a startling proposition , if we look only at Floscularia , where it is situated in the midst of the abdominal cavity , or at the Philodinadce , and the Brachionidca , where it is enclosed in the breast .
But I have shown that the apparatus is identical , in these families , with that of Diglena , Furcularia , and Synchweta , in which it is terminal and protrusile .
And this latter is the normal condition .
I have myself witnessed the protrusion of the jaws from the surface of the body , in the following genera ; -Furcularia , Pleurotrocha , Taphrocampa , Notommata clavulata , N. aurita , N. petromyzon , N. parasita ( all of which represent different genera ) , Plagiognatha , Scardium , Synchceta , Polyarthra , Diglena , Asplanchna , Mastigocerca , Monocerca , Salpina , Monostyla , and Anurcea .
139 .
The integument in the ROTIFERA is very flexible , and , especially in the frontal regions , is extremely invertible .
In those genera in which the buccal apparatus can be brought into contact withi the external water , it is ordinarily , to a greater or less degree , retracted within the body , by the inversion of the surrounding parts of the exterior ; while , in those genera in which it is permanently enclosed , analogy requires us to consider this condition as induced by a similar inversion , but of permanent duration .
If we imagine the head of a soft-bodied Insect -larva retracted to a great degree ( as is done partially by many Dipterous larvae ) , the skin of the thoracic segments would meet together in front , around a purse-like opening , which would be the orifice of such a buccal funnel as exists in most ROTIFERA .
In the latter , it is the normal condition ; in the former , it is merely accidental .
140 .
The delicacy and transparency of the mastax are , indeed , unlike the corneous and opaque mouths of Insects , and of most larvae ; but its walls are composed of the same solid materials as the teeth themselves ; since they are left after treatment with potash , which dissolves away the muscles* .
141 .
There is , then , no difficulty , I think , in identifying the mallei with the mandibles , and the rami of the incus with the maxillte , of Insects .
Perhaps the unci of the former more strictly represent the inandibles themselves , and the manubria the cheeks , into which they are articulated .
As in Insects , their usual form is curved , with the convexity outwards , and the extremity variously notched or dentated .
Tl'heir motion , as in that great Class , is chiefly a shears-like opening and shutting , in the horizontal plane ; combined with a kind of rotatory action , which , according to Mr. KIRBY , the mandibles of some insects possess* .
The same excellent entomologist enumerates several instances , in which the mandibles of Insects are not symmetrical , the one being developed more than the other ; or , at least , differing from it in form t:-a circumstance in which these organs curiously agree with the unsymmtetrical mallei in Mastigocerca , &amp;c. ( ? ?
89 to 91 ) .
142 .
A glance at the trophi of Diglena , Albertia , or Synchceta , is sufficient to show that the incus with its rami is the homologue of the maxillae , since they are placed , in these genera , nearly in the same plane as the mallei ( = mandibule ) , and within them .
There are not wanting , however , numerous instances , among Insects+ , in which the direction of the maxillae is not parallel to that of the mandibles , but inclined to it ; as is more generally the case in the ROTIFERA{ .
143 .
The rlaxille ' are much more constantly present , in Insects , than the mandibles ; the latter being either greatly deteriorated or entirely wanting in important groups , as in Lepidoptera , Aphaniptera , and some Diptera ; and this agrees with the evanescence of the mallei in many ROTIFERA , while the incus is almost invariably present .
144 .
The rami of the incus , then , form the maxillae proper ; but whether the fulcrum answers to the two cardines ( KIRBY ) , soldered together , or to the labium .
, I am not prepared to decide .
I incline , however , to the former hypothesis ; since , in Scaridium , as we have seen ( ? ?
93 ) , there appears to be a lower lip , though the fulcrum is large and distinct .
145 .
In Diglena , and its allies , the manducatory apparatus approaches most nearly to that of a predaceous insect ; the rami , in particular , being almost the counterparts of the maxillae of a carnivorous beetle .
The series of bristles , with which the inner surface is fiinged ( ? ?
80 ) , aids the resemblance .
Asplanchna also presents an instructive example of resemblance in these organs .
Here the extremity is two-lobed ( fig. 59 ) , as in many beetles ; while the interior edge is , in A. priodonta , cut into numerous teeth .
146 .
The lips ( labrum and labium ) seem to be lost in all the species which have the mastax permanently enclosed ; but in such as can protrude the jaws , the upper and lower margins of the mastax form distinct edges , more or less moveable by retractation and protrusion .
In some instances I have been able to see these margins ( which I must regard as representing the lips ) , or at least one of them ; as in Synchceta ( ? ?
75 ) , Polyarthra ( ? ?
79 ) , and Notommata aurita ( ? ?
52 ) ; but , in Scaridium , both are very distinct ; the labrum being furnislhed with stiff arched setae , the labiunin plain , but bifid ( ? ?
94 ) .
147 .
I am not aware that any trace exists , in the ROTIFERA , of any organs , or processes , answering to palpi , either labial or maxillary .
I was at first disposed to consider the processes at the bases of the rami , which ?
have called alulce ( ? ?
47 ) , as maxillary palpi ; but , as muscle-bands , in many cases , are inserted into their points , it is manifest that they will not bear this character .
148 .
To sum up these observations we may consider a perfect mouth in the ROTIFERA as consisting of seven elements ; viz. a labrum , a pair of mallei , a pair of incus-rami , afulcrum , and a labium ; corresponding homologically to the labrum , the mandibles , the maxillce ( with their cardines ) , and the labium , of Insects .
149 .
But , if this parallel be truly drawn , it is interesting to trace the same organs to their extreme point of degradation , and to mark where they disappear .
Their minimum of development is attained in Flosculariac , and Stephanoceros , which ( notwithstanding the opinion of Mr. HUXLEY* to the contrary ) do certainly lead to the POLYZOA .
The latter , therefore , present the point where the two great divisions of the Animal Kingdom , the MOLLUSCA and the ARTICULATA , unite , in their course towards the true Polypes .
150 .
Now , in one genus of POLYZOA , there is a structure , which we may coinpare with the apparatus in ROTIFERA .
The oval muscular bulbs in Bowerbankia densa , which approach and recede in their action on food , as described by Dr. ARTHUR FAR , in his admirable memoir on the Ciliobrachiate Polypi+ , appear to me to represent the quadranti-globular masses of Limnias , Rotifer , and Stephanoceros , reduced to a lower condition of structure , and deprived of mallei .
151 .
I do not see that this conclusion in the least involves ( as Mr. HUXLEY supposes ) the denial of either the Molluscous affinities of the POLYZOA , or the relationship of the ROTIFERA with the VERMES ; the latter being clearly approached by another road , through the ANNELIDA .
It would be easy to show ( were this the suitable occasion for it ) that the ROTIFERA link with the latter , through Taphrocampa and Chcetonotus ; as they do with the ENTOZOA , through Albertia .
The figures of considerable portions of animals , are magnified 220 diameters ; those of the details were taken with a power of 560 diameters , but are not drawn to scale .
The following letters of reference indicate the same organs , or their representatives , in all the figures in which they occur:a .
Mastax .
b. Malleus .
c. Manubriuom .
d. Articulation .
e. Uncus .
f. Incus .
g. Ramus .
A. Fulcrum .
i. Muscle , connecting the uncus with the ramus .
j. Muscle for extending the malleus .
k. Muscle for bending the malleus .
1 .
Muscle for throwing-in the manubrium .
m. Buccal funnel .
n. Salivary glands .
o. Alula .
p. ( Esophagus .
q. Dorsal process of ulncus .
r. Labrum .
s. Pancreatic glands .
t. Muscular bands proceeding from the u.J alulae , helping to open the rami .
v. Domular structure in funnel .
x. Eye .
y. Ganglion .
z. Nervous chords .
Fig. 1 .
Brachionus urceolaris : mastax and dental apparatus ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 2 .
Brachionus urceolaris : jaws ; viewed nearly from above .
Fig. 3 .
Brachionus urceolaris : malleus , flattened by pressure .
Fig. 4 .
Brachionus urceolaris : the same ; as it appears during life .
Fig. 5 .
Brachionus urceolaris : mastax and dental apparatus ; lateral aspect .
Figs. 6 , 7 , 8 .
Brachionus urceolaris : manubrium ; illustrating its changes of position during action .
Fig. 9 .
Brachionus urceolaris : buccal funnel , salivary glands , mastax , and dental apparatus ; dorsal aspect .
Fig. 10 .
Brachionus rubens : incus ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 11 .
Metopidia acuminata : showing the frontal plate .
Fig. 12 .
Euchlanis deflexa : buccal finnel , mastax , dental apparatus , oesophagus , and salivary glands ; dorsal aspect .
Fig. 13 .
Euchlanis deflexa : mastax and dental apparatus , after potash-treatment ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 14 .
Euchlanis deflexa : the same ; frontal aspect .
Fig. 15 .
Euchlanis deflexa : the same ; viewed dorsally , and nearly frontally .
Fig. 16 .
Notommata aurita : mastax , &amp;c. ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 17 .
Notommata aurita : the same ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 18 .
Notommata aurita : the same ; frionto-ventral aspect .
Fig. 19 .
Notommata aurita : the same ; fiontal aspect .
Fig. 20 .
Notommata aurita : mallelTs .
Fig. 21 .
Notommata aurita : incus , opened ; with labrum .
Fig. 22 .
Notommata clavulata : ganglion , with its eye and nervous chords , mastax , jaws , oesophagus , pancreatic glands , and commencement of stomach ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 23 .
Notommata clavulata : mastax , &amp;c. ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 24 .
Notommata clavulata : the same , opened .
Fig. 25 .
Notommata clavulata : mallei and incus , after potash-treatment ; viewed frontally .
Fig. 26 .
Notommata clavulata : right malleus .
Fig. 27 .
Notommata petromyzon : the head , with the ganglion , mastax , jaws , oesophagus , stomach , and various muscles .
Fig. 28 .
Notommata petromyzon : mastax ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 29 .
Notommata petromyzon : the same ; fronto-ventral aspect .
Fig. 30 .
Notommata petromyzon : the same ; frontal aspect .
Fig. 31 .
Notommata petromyzon : the same ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 32 .
Notommata lacinulata : jaws ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 33 .
Notommata lacinulata : the same ; fronto-ventral aspect .
Fig. 34 .
Notommata lacinulata : mastax , &amp;c. ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 35 .
Furcularia gibba : jaws , closed ; latero-ventral aspect .
Fig. 36 .
Furcularia gibba : the same , opened .
Fig. 37 .
Furcularia gibba : mastax , &amp;c. ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 38 .
Notommata gibba : the head ; dorsal aspect .
Fig. 39 .
Notommata gibba : jaws ; nearly a ventral aspect .
Fig. 40 .
Notommata gibba : one ramus ; designed from study of various aspects .
Fig. 41 .
Synchceta tremula : mastax and jaws ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 42 , Synchceta tremula : the same , after potash-treatment ; expanded under pressure .
Fig. 43 .
Synchceta tremula : jaws ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 44 .
Polyarthra platyptera : mastax ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 45 .
Polyarthra platyptera : the same ; dorsal aspect ; with the oesophagus , pancreatic glands , and stomach .
Fig. 46 .
Polyarthra platyptera : mastax and jaws ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 47 .
Polyarthra platyptera : the same , after potash-treatment ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 48 .
Polyarthra platyptera : jaws ; viewed obliquely .
Fig. 49 .
Polyarthra platyptera : the same ; frontal aspect .
Fig. 50 .
Diglena forcipata : jaws , closed ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 51 .
Diglenaforcipata : the same , opened .
Fig. 52 .
Albertia vermiculus : jaws ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 53 .
Albertia vermiculus : the same ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 54 .
Furcularia marina : head , with the jaws protruded .
Fig. 55 .
Furcularia marina : jaws .
Fig. 56 .
Asplanchna priodonta : the anterior third of the animal .
Fig. 57 .
Asplanchna priodonta : jaws , closed ; frontal aspect .
Fig. 58 .
Asplanchna priodonta : the same , opened .
Fig. 59 .
Asplanchna priodonta : right jaw , interior surface ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 60 .
Mastigocerca carinata : mastax , &amp;c. ; dorsal aspect .
Fig. 61 .
Mastigocerca carinata : the same ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 62 .
Mastigocerca carinata : jaws , after potash-treatment ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 63 .
Monocerca porcellus : jaws ; ventral aspect .
Fig. 64 .
Scaridium longicaudum : the head ; showing the large ganglion , with the eye pressing on the mastax ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 65 .
Scaridium longicaudum : the lips opened , and the rami protruded , .
Rugae on mastax .
y. Setae of labrum .
k. Bifid labium .
s. Projectile setae of ramus .
Fig. 66 .
Limnias ceratophylli : mastax and jaws ; with the ternmination of the buccal funnel ; and the commencement of the oesophagus ; dorsal aspect .
Fig. 67 .
Limnias ceratophylli : the same ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 68 .
Limnias ceratophylli : jaws , after potash-treatment ; lateral aspect .
Fig. 69 .
Limnias ceratophylli : the same ; showing the elevation of the mallei , Fig. 70 .
Limnias ceratophylli : the same ; obliquely-ventral aspect .
Fig. 71 .
Limnias ceratophylli : the same ; frontal aspect .
Fig. 72 .
Rotifer macrurus : mastax , &amp;c. ; dorsal aspect .
Fig. 73 .
Rotifer macrurus : jaws , after potash-treatment ; fronto-dorsal aspect .
Fig. 74 .
Rotifer macrurus : the same ; frontal aspect .
Fig. 75 .
Rotifer macrurus : the same ; lateral aspect .
Figs. 76 , 77 , 78 .
Rotifer macrurus : diagrams , to illustrate the changes of form in the quadrantic jaws .
t. Quadrantic masses .
Fig. 79 .
Floscularia ornata : veil , or septurn , in crop .
Fig. 80 .
Floscularia ornata .
jaws ; dorsal aspect .
Fig. 81 .
Floscularia ornata : the same ; frontal aspect .
Fig. 82 .
Floscularia ornata : the same , closed .
Fig. 83 .
Stephanoceros Eickhornii : jaws ; dorsal aspect .
Fig. 84 .
Stephanoceros Eickhornii : uncus ; frontal aspect .
Fig. 85 .
Stephanoceros Eickhornii : the same ; oblique aspect , ssol5 d ':"ii--~ ... .L ' ?
iri~ 9 &lt; 1 v ? ? ? ?
1 , ; ?C i S. .
, .
1 &lt; - .
/ / i 67 TZ 0Z 9T 9f FzI 6 i1 " 47 : 3- ? ?
7i ?
I ~~~~~~ ?
~~~i / 4 ) f : 2 7 &lt; ) I i~~~~~~j '1 .
41 4 &gt; :j ?
.'~~~~~ 79 : e ?
:~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~9 1::::.7 ?
0 '14197 34f4'y[ pfj Ii I E ----- &gt; 7 &gt; &gt; 777 -1 / 7 %~ ?
7 '77$ -----/ - ?
1 $7707a-N , -,. .
^- , -:-..- , ,^ Sils , ,.._N ?
/- ... ... ... ... " 77~ ... .'I- &gt; ' ... ... ... . .
7 ... ... 7 ... i\ , - ?
r * , ... . .
'=.lc-7 N-'-7 7. .
, ' .
' , ''. .
&gt; -. .
7N 7 $7 1 ; '~ &gt; CN N &gt; - ' ; ii - &gt; 7 C----7~ E N &gt; Ii 77 &lt; / -- &gt; N cc -'7-,.\ z e~ -K 6 J\ )N &gt; $77 777~~~~~~~~~~~~~~C j:::1 ?
ir ' : -/ - ... ... " ... ~1 1 ~.~ _ i , '1 .
' " " i ; ?. .
: .
, r 'i^ ^ t , .
, ; ! !
~~~N --N 77- ?
N &gt; ?
N-- ?
p- " &gt; I ) Not P &gt; CiI Q$7 PhiZ .
JY7anis( .
1M1D CCCL'v .
fPlate XIIZT. .
63 68 9 ... p 7:. .
_ !
5..7 h. 7 ' iy 7 ... .
; ... ... ... ... h. ie 4 : : ' " ... C 69c Ii , ... KSi r~ ii7 99 0 xi 70,.1147,9 -iI 0- , 76 / -- .
x , j* ------ ; - ... ... ... ..:.-o e ',..p ( at ; , 9 i ; ,.i- , 80 : O 83 _ , , 82 iit a4 --- ... ... . .
I i , t\ : ; .P ... Goosse , d -,. .
a. Lz 9 ---0.-7 by ... Ic ... .
78 -.h J._:f , fi ' : , W.

