Further Researches on the Polarity of the Diamagnetic Force .
By JOHN TYNDALL , F.R.S. , Membre de la Socidtd Hollandaise des Sciences ; Foreign Member of the Physical Society of Berlin , and Professor of Natural Philosophzy in the Royal Institution .
Received November 27 , -Read December 20 , 1855 .
INTRODUCTION .
A YEAR ago I placed before the Royal Society the results of an investigation " On the Nature of the Force by which Bodies are repelled from the Poles of a Magnet* .
" The simultaneous exhibition of attraction and repulsion in the case of magnetized iron is the fact on which the idea of the polarity of this substance is founded ; and it resulted from the investigation referred to , that a corresponding duality of action was manifested by bismuth .
In those experiments the bismuth was the moveable object upon which fixed magnets were caused to act , and from the deflection of the bismuth its polarity was inferred .
But , inasmuch as the action is reciprocal , we ought also to obtain evidence of diamagnetic polarity by reversing the conditions of experiment ; by making the magnet the moveable object , and inferring from its deflection the polarity of the mass which produces the deflection .
This experiment would be complementary to those described in the communication referred to , and existing circumstances invested the experiment with a great degree of interest and importance .
In fact an experiment similar to that here indicated was made by Professor W. WEBER , previous to my investigation , and the result was such as to satisfy its author of the reverse polarity of diamagnetic bodies .
I will not here enter into a minute description of the instrument and mode of experiment by which this result was obtained ; for the instrument made use of in the present inquiry being simply a refinement of that made use of by M. WEBER , its explanation will embrace the explanation of his apparatus .
For the general comprehension of the criticisms to which M. WEBER'S results have been subjected , it is necessary , however , to remark , that in his experiments a bismuth bar , within a vertical spiral of copper wire , through which an electric current was transmitted , was caused to act upon a steel magnet freely suspended without the spiral .
When the two ends of the bar of bismuth were permitted to act successively upon the suspended magnet , a motion of the latter was observed , which indicated that the bismuth bar was polar , and that its polarity was the reverse of that of iron .
Notwithstanding the acknowledged eminence of M. WEBER as an experimenter , this result failed to produce general conviction .
Mr. FARADAY , in his paper " On the polar or other condition of diamagnetic bodies* , " 9 had shown that results quite similar to those obtained by M. WEBER , in his first investigation with bismuth , were obtained in a greatly exalted degree , with gold , silver and copper ; the effect being one of induction , and not one due to diamagnetic polarity .
He by no neans asserted that his results had the same origin as those obtained by M. WEBER ; but as the latter philosopher had made rno mention of the source of error which Mr. FARADAY'S experiments rendered manifest , it was natural to suppose that it had been overlooked , and the observed action attributed to a wrong cause .
In an article published in his 'Massbestimmungen ' in 1852 , M. WEBER , however , with reference to this point , writes as follows:- " I will remark that the article transferred from the Reports of the Society of Sciences of Saxony to POGGENDORFF'S ' Annalen ' was only a preliminary notice of my investigation , the special discussion of which was reserved for a subsequent communication .
It will be sufficient to state here , that in the experiments referred to I sought to eliminate the inductive action by suitable combinations ; but it is certainly far better to set aside this action altogether , as has been ( lone in the experiments described in the present memoir .
" One conviction grew and strengthened throughout these discussions-this , namely , that in experiments on diamagnetic polarity great caution is required to separate the pure effects of diamagnetism from those of ordinary induction .
With reference to even the most recent experiments of M. WEBER-those to which he has referred at the conclusion of the above citation-it is strongly urged that there is no assurance that the separation referred to has been effected .
In those experiments , as already stated , a cylinder of bismuth was suspended within a vertical helix of covered copper wire , and the action of the cylinder upon a magnet suspended opposite to the centre or neutral point of the helix was observed .
To increase the action , the position of the cylinder was changed at each termination of the minute swing of the magnet , the amplitude of the oscillations being thus increased , and the effect rendered more sensible to the eye .
Now , it is urged , there is every reason to believe that in these motions of a metallic mass within an excited helix induced currents will be developed , which , acting upon the magnet , will produce the motions observed .
The failure indeed to demonstrate the existence of diamagnetic polarity by other neans has , in the case of some investigators , converted this belief into a certainty .
Among the number whom M. WEBER'S experiments have failed to convince , M. MATTEUCCI occupies a prominent place .
With reference to the question before us this philosopher writes as followst:- " In reading the description of the experiments of M. WEBER , we are struck on beholding the effects produced by moving the bismuth when there is no current in the spiral .
Although the direction of oscillation in this latter case is opposed to that observed when the spiral is active , still the fact excites doubts as to the trtuth of the conclusions which have been drawn from these experiments* .
To deduce rigorously the demonstration of diamagnetic polarity , it would be necessary to substitutefor the bismuth , masses formed of insulated fragments of the metalt , to vary the dimensions of the cylinder , and above all , to compare the e , ffcts thus obtained with those which would probably be obtained with cylinders of copper and silver in a state of purity .
" We are obliged to make the same remarks on another series of experiments which this physicist has made to obtain anew , by the effects of induction , the proof of diamagnetic polarity .
It is astonishing that after having sought to neutralize the development of induced currents in the moving cylinders of bismuth , by means of a very ingenious disposition of the spiral-it is astonishing , I repeat , that no attempt was made to prove by preliminary essays with metals possessing a higher conductibility than bismuth , that the same end could be obtained .
I cannot leave you ignorant that the doubts which I have ventured to advance against the experiments of M. WEBER are supported by the negative result which I have obtained in endeavouring to excite diamagnetic polarity in bismuth by the discharge of the Leyden jar .
" It will be seen in the following pages that the conditions laid down by M. MATTEUCCI for the rigorous demonstration of diamagnetic polarity are more than fulfilled .
The conclusions of M. WEBER find a still more strenuous opponent in his countryman Professor v. FEILITZSCH , who has repeated WEBER'S experiments , obtained his results , but who denies the validity of his inferences .
M. v. FEILITZSCH argues that in the experiments referred to it is impossible to shut out ordinary induction , and for the rigorous proof of diamagnetic polarity proposes the following conditions+ .
" To render the expeiriment firee from the action of induced curirents two ways are open .
The currents can be so guided that they shall mutually neutralize each other 's action upon the magnet , or the induced currents can be completely got rid of by using , instead of a diamagnetic conductor , a diamagnetic insulator .
" To test the question , M. v. FEILITZSCH resorted to the latter method : instead of cylinders of bismuth he made use of cylinders of wax , and also of a prism of heavy glass , but in neither case was he able to detect the slightest action upon the magnet .
" However the motions of the prism might be varied , it was not possible either to cause the motionless magnet to oscillate , or to bring the magnet from a state of oscillation to one of rest .
" v. FEILITZSCH pushes his experiments further , and finds that when the bistmuth is motionless within its spiral , the position of the magnet is just the same as when the bismuth is entirely withdrawn ; hence his final conclusion , that the deflection of the magnet in WEBER'S experiments is due to induced currents , which are excited in the bismuth by its mechanical motion up and down within the spiral .
T'rlese divergent opinions upon a question of such vital bearing upon the general theory of magnetic phenomena , naturally excited in me the desire to make myself acquainted with the exact value of M. WEBER'S experiments .
The most direct way of accomplishing this I considered to be , to operate with an instrument similar to that made use of by WEBER himself ; I therefore resolved to write to the constructor of his apparatus , but previous to doing so the thought occurred to me of writing to M. WEBER , to inquire whether his further reflections on the subject had suggested to him any desirable modification of his first instrument .
In reply to my question he undertook to devise for me an apparatus , surpassing in delicacy any hitherto made use of .
The design of M. WEBER was ably carried out by M. LEYSER of Leipzig , and with the instrument thus placed in my possession I have been able , not only to verify the experiments of M. WEBER , but to satisfy the severest conditions proposed by those who saw in the results of these experiments the effects of ordinary induction .
DESCRIPTION OF APPARATUS .
A sketch of the instrument made use of in the present investigation is given in fig. 2 .
BO , B'O ' is the outline of a rectangular box , the front of which is removed so as to show the apparatus within .
The back of the box is prolonged , and terminates in two semicircular projections , which have apertures at H and H ' .
Stout bolts of brass , which have been made fast in solid masonry , pass through these apertures , and the instrument , being secured to the bolts by screws and washers , is supported in a vertical position , being free from all disturbance save such as affects the foundations of the Royal Institution .
All the arrangements presented to the eye in fig. 2 are made fast to the back of the box , but are unconnected with the firont , so as to permit of the removal of the latter .
WW ' are two boxwood wheels with grooved peripheries , which permit of motion being transferred from one wheel to the other by means of a string ss ' .
Attached to this string are two cylinders , mn , op , of the body to be examined : in some cases the cylinders are perforated longitudinally , the string passes through the perforation , and the cylinders are supported by knots on the string .
HE , H'E ' are two helices of copper wire overspun with silk , and wound round two brass reels , the upper ends of which protrude from H to G , and from H ' to G ' .
The internal diameter of each helix is 0*8 of an inch , and its external diameter about 1'3 inch ; the length from H to E is 19 inches , and the centres of the helices are 4 inches apart ; the diameters of the wheels WW ' being also 4 inches .
The cross bar GG ' is of brass , and through its centre passes the screw R , from which depends a number of silk 240 fibres which support an astatic arrangement of two magnets , the front one of which , SN , is shown in the figure .
An enlarged section of the instrument through the system of magnets is shown in fig. 4 .
The magnets are connected by a brass crosspiece , in which is the point of suspension P ; and the position of the helices is shown Fig. 1 .
Fig. 2 .
Fig. 3 .
0 10 lo cr rI v ~1 rL ---Fig .
4 .
to be between the magnets .
It will be seen that the astatic system is a horizontal one , and not vertical , as in the ordinary galvanometer .
The black circle in front of the magnet SN , fig. 2 , is a mirror , which is shown in section at M , fig. 4 ; to balance the weight of this mirrolr , and adjust the magnets in a horizontal position , a brass washer , W , is caused to move along a screw , until a point is attained at which its weight has brought both the magnets into the same horizontal plane .
There is also another adjustment , which permits of the magnets being brought closer together or separated more widely asunder .
The motions of the compound magnet are observed by means of a distant scale and telescope , according to the method applied to the magnetometer of GAUss .
The rectangle da , d'a ' , fig. 2 , is the outline of a copper damper , which , owing to the currents induced in it by the motion of the magnet , soon brings the latter to rest , and thus expedites experiment .
It is well known that one end of a magnet attracts , while the other end repels the same pole of a magnetic needle ; and that between both there is a neutral point which neither attracts nor repels .
The same is the case with the helices HE , H'E ' ; so that when a current is sent through them , if the astatic magnet be exactly opposite the neutral point , it is unaffected by the helices .
This is scarcely attainable in practice ; a slight residual action remains which draws the magnets against the helices ; but this is very easily neutralized by disposing an external portion of the circuit so as to act upon the magnets in a direction opposed to that of the residual action .
Here then we have a pair of spirals which , when excited , do not act upon the magnets , and which thetefore permit us to examine the pure action of any body capable of magnetic excitement placed within them .
In the experiments to be described , it was always arranged that the currtent flowed in opposite directions through the two spirals ; so that if the bodies within them were polar , the two upper ends of these bodies should be poles of opposite names , and consequently the two lower ends opposed also .
Supposing now our two cylinders to occupy the central position indicated in fig. 2 : even if the cylinders became polar through the action of the surrounding current , the magnets , being opposite to the neutral points of the cylinders , would experience no action from the latter .
But suppose the wheel W ' to be so turned that the two cylinders are brought into the position shown in fig. 1 , the upper end Fig. 4 .
o of op and the lower end n of mn will act simultaneously upon w the suspended magnets .
For the sake of illustration , let us sup " l. pose the ends o and n to be both north poles , and that the sec_ | tion , fig. 4 , is taken when the bars are in the position shown in s fig. 1 .
The right-hand pole o will attract S ' and repel N , which attraction and repulsion sum themselves together to produce a deflection of the system of magnets .
On the other hand , the left-hand pole n , being also north , will attract S and repel N ' , which two effects also sum themselves to produce a deflection in the same direction as the former two .
Hence , not only is the action of terrestrial magnetism annulled by this arrangement , but the moving force due to the reciprocal action of the magnets and the bodies within the helices is increased fourfold .
By turning the wheel in the other direction we bring the cylinders into the position shown in fig. 3 , and thus may study the action of the ends m and p upon the magnets .
By means of the screw R the magnets can be raised or lowered ; and at the end , t , of the screw is a small torsion circle which can be turned independently of the screw ; by means of the latter the suspending fibre can be twisted or untwisted without altering the level of the magnets .
The front of the box is attached by means of brass hasps , and opposite to the mirror Ma small plate of glass is introduced , through which the mirror is observed ; the magnets within the box being thus effectually protected from the disturbances of the external air .
A small handle to turn the wheel W ' accompanied the instrument from its maker ; but in the experiments , I used , instead of it , a key attached to the end of a rod 10 feet long ; with this rod in my right hand , and the telescope 242 and scale before me , the experiments were completely under my own control .
Finally , the course of the current through the helices was as follows:-Proceeding from the platinum pole of the battery it entered the box along the wire w , fig. 2 , which passed through the bottom of the latter ; thence through the helix to H ' , returning to E ' ; thence to the second helix , returning to E , from which it passed along the wire w ' to the zinc pole of the battery .
A commutator was introduced in the circuit , so that the direction of the current thus indicated could be reversed at pleasure .
EXPERIMENTS.-DEPORTMENT OF DIAMAGNETIC BODIES .
A pair of cylinders of chemically pure bismuth , 3 inches long and 0'7 of an inch in diameter , accompanied the instrument from Germany .
These were first tested , commencing with a battery of one cell of GROVE .
Matters being as sketched in fig. 2 , when the current circulated in the helices and the magnet had corn to rest , the cross wire of the telescope cut the number 482 on the scale .
Turning the wheel W ' so as to bring the cylinders into the position fig. 1 , the magnet moved promptly , and after some oscillations took up a new position of equilibrium ; the cross wire or the telescope then cut the figure 468 on the scale .
Reversing the motion so as to place the cylinders again central , the former position 482 was assumed ; and on turning further in the same direction , so as to place the cylinders as in fig. 3 , the position of equilibrium of the magnet was at the number 493 .
Hence by bringing the two ends n and o to bear upon the astatic magnet , the motion was from greater to smaller numbers , the position of rest being then fourteen divisions less than when the bars were central .
By bringing the ends m and p to bear upon the magnet , the motion was from smaller to greater numbers , the position of rest being eleven divisions more than when the bars were central .
As the positions here referred to will be the subject of frequent reference , for the sake of convenience I will call the position of the cylinders sketched in fig. 1 , Position 1 ; that sketched in fig. 2 , Position 2 ; and that sketched in fig. 3 , Position 3 .
The results which we have just described , tabulated with reference to these terms , would then stand thus:-I .
Bismuth cylinders .
length 3 inches .
diameter 0'7 .
Position 1 .
468 Position 2 .
482 Position 3 .
493 In changing therefore from position 1 to position 3 , a deflection corresponding to twenty-five divisions of the scale was produced .
243 Wishing to place myself beyond the possibility of illusion as regards the fact of deflection , I repeated the experiment with successive batteries of two , three and four cells .
The following are the results : II .
2 cells .
3 cells .
4 cells .
Position 1 .
450 439 425 Position 2 .
462 450 437 Position 3 .
473 462 448 In all the cases cited we observe the same result .
From position 2 to position 1 the motion is from larger to smaller numbers ; while from position 2 to position 3 the motion is from smaller to larger numbers .
It may at first sight appear strange that the amount of the deflection did not increase with the battery power ; the reason , in part , is that the magnet , when the current circulated , was held in a position free from the spirals , by forces emanating partly from the latter and partly from a portion of the external circuit .
When the current increased , the magnetization of the bismuth increased also , but so did the force which held the magnets in their position of equilibrium .
To remove them from this position , a greater amount of force was necessary than when only the residual action of a feeble current held them there .
This fact , coupled with the circumstance that less heat was developed , and less disturbance caused by air currents , when a feeble battery was used , induced me for some time to experiment with a battery of two cells .
Subsequent experience however enabled me to change this for five cells with advantage .
Notwithstanding the improbability of the argument , still it may be urged that these experiments do not prove beyond a doubt that the bismuth cylinders produce the motion of the magnets in virtue of their excitement by the voltaic current ; for it is not certain that these cylinders would not produce the same motion wholly independent of the current .
Something of this kind has occurred to M. LEYSER in his experiments , and why not here ?
In answer to this I reply , that if the case be as here suggested , the motion of the magnet will not be changed when the current surrounding the bismuth cylinders flows in the opposite direction .
Here is the experiment .
III .
Position 1 .
764 Position 2 .
742 Position 3 .
704 We observe hereee that in passing from position 2 to position 1 the motion is from smaller to larger numbers ; while in passing from position 2 to position 3 the motion * Scientific Memoirs , New Series , vol. i. page 184 .
244 is from larger to smaller numbers .
This is the opposite result to that obtained when the current flowed in the opposite direction ; and it proves that the polarity of the bismuth cylinders depends upon the direction of the current , changing as the latter changes .
It was pleasant to observe the prompt and steady march of the magnet as the cylinders were shifted in the helices .
When the magnets , operated on by the bars of bismluth , were moving in any direction , by bringing the two opposite ends of the bismuth bars into action , the motion could be promptly checked ; the magnets could be brought to rest , or their movenient converted into one in the opposite direction .
I may add to the above a series of results obtained some days subsequently in the presence of Professors FARADAY , DE LA RIVE and MARCET .
IV .
Bismuth cylinders .
Position 1 .
670 Position 2 .
650 Position 3 .
630 The difference between positions 1 and 3 amounts here to forty divisions of the scale ; subsequent experience enabled me to make it still greater .
It was found by experiment , that when the motion was from lower to higher numbers it denoted that the poles NN ' , fig. 4 , were repelled from the spirals , and the poles SS ' attracted towards them .
When , on the contrary , the motion was from larger to smaller numbers , it indicated that the poles NN ' were attracted and the poles SS ' repelled .
In the position fig. 1 , therefore , of Tables III .
and IV .
the poles NN ' were repelled by the ends no of the bismuth cylinders , and the poles SS ' attracted , while in the position fig. 3 , the poles NN ' were attracted by the ends mp , and the poles SS ' repelled ; the ends n and o , therefore , acted as two north poles , while the ends m and p acted as two south poles .
Now the direction of the current in the experiments recorded in the two tables referred to was that shown by the arrows in fig , 4 .
Standing in front of the instrument , the direction in the adjacent face of the spiral H'E ' was from right to left , while it was from left to right in HIE .
From this we may infer that the polarity of the bismuth cylinders was the reverse of that which would be excited in cylinders of iron undet the same circumstances .
The assertion however shall be transferred from the domain of deduction to that of fact before we conclude .
Let us now urge against these experiments all that ever has been urged by the opponents of diamagnetic polarity .
The bismuth cylinders are metallic conductors , and in moving them through the spirals induced currents more or less powerful may be excited in these conductors .
The motion observed may not , after all , be due to diamagnetic polarity , but to the currents thus excited .
I reply , that in all cases the number set down marks the permanent position of rest of the magnets .
Were the action due to induced currents , these currents , being momentary , could only impart a shock to the magnets , which , on the disappearance of the currents , would return to their original position .
But the deflection is permanent , and is therefore due to an enduring cause .
In his paper on " Supposed Diamagnetic Polarity , " M ' .
FARADAY rightly observes , - " If the polarity exists , it must be in the particles , and for the time permanent , and therefore distinguishable from the momentary polarity of the mass due to induced temlporary currents , and it must also be distinguishable from ordinary magnetic polarity by its contrary direction .
" These are the precise characteristics of the force made manifest by the experiments now under consideration .
Further , the strength of induced currents depends on the conducting power of the mass in which they are formed .
Expressing the conducting power of bismuth by the number 1*8 , that of copper would be expiessed by 73.6* , the conductivity of the latter being therefore forty times that of the former .
Hence the demand made by the opponents of diamagnetic polarity , to have the experiments repeated with cylinders of copper ; for if the effect be due to induced currents , they will show themselves in copper in a greatly increased degree .
The following is the result of a series of experiments made with two copper cylinders , of the same dimensions as the bismuth ones already described .
V. Cylinders of Copper .
Position 1 .
754 Position 2 .
754 Position 3 .
755 Now if the effects obtained with bismuth were due to induced currents , we should have the same effects forty times multiplied in the case of copper , in place of which we have scarcely any sensible effect at all .
Bismuth is the only substance which has hitherto produced an action in experiments of this nature ; another illustration , however , is furnished by the metal antiInony , which possesses a greater conductive power , but a less ( liamtagnetic power than bismuth .
The following results were obtained with this substance : VI .
Cylinders of Antimony .
length 3 inches .
diameter 0'7 .
Current directt .
Current reversed+ .
Position 1 .
693 244 Position 2 .
688 252 Position 3 .
683 261 On comparing these numbers with those already obtained with bismuth , we observe that for like positions the actions of both metals are alike in direction .
We further observe that the results are determined , not by the relative conductive powers of the two metals , but by their relative diamagnetic powers .
If the former were the determining cause , we should have greater deflections than with the bismuth , which is not the case ; if the latter , we should have less deflections , which is the case .
The third and severest condition proposed by those who object to the experiments of M. WEBER is to substitute insulators for conductors .
I call this condition severe for the following reasons:-according to the experiments of FARADAY* , when bismuth and sulphur are submitted to the same magnetic force , the repulsion of the former being expressed by the number 1968 , that of the latter will be expressed by 118 .
Hence an action which , with the means hitherto used , was difficult of detection in the case of bismuth , must wholly escape observation in the case of sulphur , the 'ntensity of whose excitement is nearly twenty times less .
The same remarks apply , in a great measure , to all other insulators .
But the admirable apparatus made use of in this investigation has enabled me to satisfy this condition also .
To Mr. FARADAY I am indebted for the loan of two prisms of the self-same heavy glass with which he made the discovery of diamagnetism , The bismuth cylinders were withdrawn from the helices and the prisms of glass put in their places .
It was now necessary to have a perfectly steady magnet , the expected result being so small as to be readily masked by , or confounded with , a motion arising from some extraneous disturbance .
The feeble warmth developed in the helices by a current from two cells I found able to create air currents of sufficient power to defeat all attempts to obtain the pure action of the prisms , To break up these currents I stuffed all unfilled spaces of the box with old newspapers , and found the expedient to answer perfectly .
With a fresh battery , which delivered a constant stream throughout the duration of an experiment , the magnet was admirably steady- , and under these favourable conditions the following results were obtained ; VII .
Prisms of Heavy Glass .
length 3 inches .
width 0-6 .
depth 0'5 .
Current direct .
Position 1 .
664 Position 2 .
662 Position 3 .
660 Thus in passing from position 1 to 3 , or vice versed , a permanent deflection corresponding to four divisions of the scale was produced .
By raising or lowering the respective prisms at the proper moments the amplitude of the oscillations could be considerably augmented , and , when at a maxirnum , could be speedily extinguished by reversing the motions of the prisms .
In six different series of experiments made with this substance the same invariable result was obtained .
It will be observed that the deflections are in all cases in the same direction as those produced by bismruth under the same circumstances .
The following results were afterwards obtained with the same prisms in the presence of M. DE LA RIVE ; the current was " direct .
" VIII .
Position 1 .
652 Position 2 .
650 Position 3 .
648 On the negative result arrived at with this substance , it will be remembered that M. v. FEILITZSCH bases one of his arguments against the conclusions of M. WEBER .
Calcareous spar was next submitted to experiment .
Two cylinders of the transparent crystal were prepared and examined in the manner already described .
The results are as follows : IX .
Cylinders of Calcareous Spar .
length 3 inches .
diameter 0'7 .
Current direct .
Position 1 .
699'5 .
Position 2 .
69815 .
Position 3 .
697*5 .
Here , as in the other cases , the deflection was permanent , and could be augmented by the suitable raising or lowering of the respective cylinders .
The action is small , but perfectly certain .
The magnet was steady and moved promptly and invariably in the directions indicated by the numbers .
It will be observed that the deflections are the same in kind as those produced by bismuth .
The intrusion of other employments compelled me to postpone the continuation of these experiments for several weeks .
On taking up the subject again , my first care was to assure myself that the instrument retained its sensibility .
Since the experiments last recorded it had been transported over several hundred miles of railway , and hence the possibility of a disturbance of its power .
The following experiments , 248 while they corroborate the former ones , show that the instrument retained its power and delicacy unimpaired : X. Bismuth cylinders .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
612 264 Position 2 .
572 230 Position 3 .
526 200 The ( leflections , it will be observed , are the same in kind as before ; but by improved manipulation the effect is augmented .
In passing from position 1 to 3 we have here a deflection amounting in one case to 64 , and in the other to 86 divisions of the scale .
To Mr. NOBLE I am indebted for two cylinders of pure statuary marble ; the examination of these gave the following results : XI .
Cylinders of Statuary Marble .
length 4 inches .
diameter 0'7 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
601 215 Position 2 .
598 218 Position 3 .
596 220 Here , in passing from position 1 to 3 , we have a permanent deflection corresponding to five divisions of the scale .
As in all other cases , the impulsion of the magnet might be augmented by changing the position of the cylinders at the limit of each swing .
The deflections are the same in kind as those produced by bismuth , which ought to be the case , as marble is diamagnetic .
An upright iron stove inlfluenced by the earth 's magnetism becomes a magnet with its bottom a north and its top a south pole .
Doubtless , though in an immensely feebler degree , every erect marble statue is a true diamagnet , with its head a north pole and its feet a south pole .
The same is certainly true of man as he stands upon the earth 's surface , for all the tissues of the human body are diamagnetic .
A pair of cylinders of phosphorus enclosed in thin glass tubes were next examined .
XII .
Cylinders of Phosphorus .
length 3'5 inches .
diameter 0'63 .
249 Current direct .
Series I. Series II .
Position 1 .
620 670 Position 2 .
618 668 Position 3 .
616 666 Current reversed .
224 226 228 The change of the bars from position 1 to 3 is in this case accompanied by permanent deflection corresponding to four divisions of the scale .
The deflection indicates the polarity of diamagnetic bodies .
The magnet was remarkably steady during these experiments , and the consequent clearness and sharpness of the result pleasant to observe , XIII .
Cylinders of Sulphur .
length 6 inches .
diameter 0'7 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
658-5 222 Position 2 .
657 223-5 Position 3 .
655-5 225"5 Position Position XIV .
Cylinders of Nitre .
length 3'5 inches , diameter 0*7 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
1 .
648'5 263 3 .
647 265 Finally , as regards solid diamagnetics , a series of experiments was made with wax ; this also being one of the substances whose negative deportment is urged by M. v. FEILITZSCH against M. WEBER , XV .
Cylinders of Wax , length 4 inches , diameter 017 .
Current direct , Position 1 , 624'5 Position 3 .
623 Current reversed .
240 241 The action is very small , but it is nevertheless perfectly certain .
The argument founded on the negative deportment of this substance must therefore give way .
25O0 When we consider the feebleness of the action with so delicate a means of examination , the failure of M. v. FEILITZSCH to obtain the effect , with an instrument constructed by himself , will not excite surprise .
Thus in the case of seven insulating bodies the existence of diamagnetic polarity has been proved ; the list might be augmented without difficulty , but sufficient , I trust , has been done to remove the scruples of those who saw in M. WEBER'S results an action produced by induced currents .
A portion of the subject hitherto untouched , but one of great interest , has reference to the polar condition of liquid bodies while under magnetic influence .
The first liquid examined was distilled water ; it was enclosed in thin glass tubes , corked at the ends , and by means of a loop passing round the cork the tubes were attached to the string passing round the wheels WW ' .
Previous to using , the corks were carefully cleansed , so that any impurity contracted in cutting , or by contact with ferruginous matters , was completely removed .
The following are the results obtained with this liquid : XVI .
Cylinders of Distilled Water .
length 4 inches .
diameter 0'65 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
605 246 Position 2 .
603 248 Position 3 .
601 250 The experiment was many times repeated , but always with the same result ; indeed the polarity of the liquid mass is as safely established as that of iron .
Pure water is diamagnetic , and the deflections produced by it are the same as those of all the other diamagnetic bodies submitted to examination .
From the position which it occupies in Mr. FARADAY'S list* , I had also some hopes of proving the polarity of sulphide of carbon .
The following results were obtained : XVII .
Cylinders of Bisulphide of Carbon .
length 4 inches .
diameter 0'65 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
631 210 Position 2 .
629 213 Position 3 .
626 216 As in the case of distilled water , we observe a deflection in one direction when the current is " direct " and in the other when it is " reversed , " the action in the first case , in passing from position 1 to 3 , amounting to five and in the latter case to six divisions of the scale .
The polarity exhibited is that of diamagnetic bodies .
DEPORTMENT OF MAGNETIC BODIES .
Thus far we have confined our examination to diamagnetic substances ; turn we now to the deportment of magnetic bodies when submitted to the same conditions of experiment .
Here we must select the substances suitable for examination , for all are not so .
Cylinders of iron , for example , of the same size as our diamagnetic cylinders , would , through the intensity of their action , quite derange the apparatus ; so that we are obliged to have recourse to bodies of smaller size or of feebler magnetic capacity .
Besides , the remarks of writers on this subject render it of importance to examine whether bodies through which the magnetic constituents are very sparingly distributed present a veritable polarity the same as that exhibited by iron itself .
Slate rock usually contains from eight to ten per cent. of oxide of iron , and a fragment of the substance presented to the single pole of an electro-magnet is attracted by the pole .
A cylinder of slate from the Penrhyn quarries near Bangor was first examined .
It was not found necessary to increase the effect by using two cylinders , and the single one used was suspended in the right-hand helix H'E ' .
The deportment of the substance was as follows : XVIII .
Cylinder of Penrhyn Slate .
length 4 inches .
diameter 0'7 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
620 280 Position 2 .
647 240 Position 3 .
667 198 Comparing these deflections with those obtained with diamagnetic bodies , we see that they are in the opposite direction .
With the direct current a change from position 1 to 3 is followed , in the case of diamagnetic bodies , by a motion from higher to lower numbers ; while in the present instance the motion is from lower numbers to higher .
In the former case the north poles of the astatic magnet are attracted , in the latter they are repelled .
We also see that a direct current acting on diamagnetic bodies produces the same deflection as a reverse current on magnetic ones .
Thus , as we promised at a former page , the opposite polarities of diamagnetic and magnetic bodies are transferred from the region of deduction to that of fact .
252 Cylinder of Caermarthen Slate .
length 4 inches .
diameter 0'7 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
664 300 Position 2 .
690 235 Position 3 .
720 185 The deflections in this case are also indicative of magnetic polarity .
These two cylinders were so taken from the rock that the axis of each lay in the plane of cleavage .
The following experiments ; made with a cylinder of the same size , show the capability of a rock of this structure to be magnetized across the planes of cleavage .
XX .
Cylinder of Slate : axis of cylinder perpendicular to cleavage .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
655 240 Position 2 .
678 205 Position 3 .
695 192 Chloride of iron was next examined : the substance , in powder , was enclosed in a single glass tube , which was attached to the string passing round the wheels WW ' of the instrument .
XXI .
Cylinder of Chloride of Iron .
length 3'8 inches .
diameter 0'5 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
185 990 Position 2 .
230 Position 3 .
990 185 The deflection here indicates ordinary magnetic polarity .
The action was very powerful .
When swiftly moving in any direction , a change in the position of the cylinder instantly checked the magnet in its course , brought it to rest , or drove it forcibly in the opposite direction .
The numbers 185 and 990 mark indeed the utmost limit between which it was possible for the magnet to move ; here it rested against the helices .
Two glass tubes were filled with red oxide of iron and examined .
The action of the poles of these cylinders upon the magnets was so strong , as to efface , by the velocity imparted to the magnets , all distinct impression of the numbers on the scale .
By changing the position of the tubes within the helices , the magnets could be driven violently through the field of view , or could be held rigidly against the respective helices .
As in all other cases , the centre of the cylinders were neutral points , and the two ends of'each were poles of opposite qualities .
The polarity was of course the same as that of iron .
A small quantity of iron filings were kneaded thoroughly in wax , and a cylinder formed from the mass .
Its deportment was also very violent , and its polarity was of coursejust as clear and pronounced as that of a solid cylinder of iron could possibly be .
Sulphate of iron was next examined : the crystallized substance was enclosed in two glass tubes and tested in the usual manner , XXII .
Cylinders of Sulphate of Iron .
length 4*5 inches .
diameter 0*7 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
510 510 Position 2 .
600 370 Position 3 .
700 220 The red ferroprussiate of potassa is a magnetic salt ; with this substance the following results were obtained : XXIII .
Cylinders of red Ferroprussiate of Potassa .
length 4*5 inches .
diameter 0'65 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
610 250 Position 2 .
630 220 Position 3 .
655 197 In this case also the crystallized salt was enclosed in glass tubes .
Two glass tubes were next filled with carbonate of iron in the state of powder : the following are the results : XXIV .
Cylinders of Carbonate of Iron .
length 4 inches .
diameter 0'5 .
Current direct .
Position 1 .
185 Position 2 .
620 Position 3 .
740 254 In all these cases the deflections show that the bodies are polar after the manner of iron .
As the complement of the experiments made with diamagnetic liquids , we now pass on to the examination of the polarity of magnetic liquids .
A concentrated solution of sulphate of iron was enclosed in two glass tubes and submitted to examination , xxv .
Sulphate of Iron solution in tubes .
length 4 inches .
diameterl 065 .
Current direct .
Position 1 .
548 Position 2 .
600 Position 3 .
648 .
A solution of rmuriate of nickel , examined in the same manner , gave the following results : XXVI .
Muriate of Nickel solution in tubes .
length 3'6 inches .
diameter 0*65 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
605 224 Position 2 .
632 200 Position 3 .
650 185 A solution of muriate of cobalt yielded as follows : XXVII .
Muriate of Cobalt solution in tubes .
length 3'6 inches .
diameter 0'65 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
630 262 Position 2 .
645 235 Position 3 .
660 202 In all these cases we have ample evidence of a polar action the reverse of that exhibited by diamagnetic liquids .
These , I believe , are the first experiments on which the action of either liquid magnets or liquid diamagnets upon a suspended steel magnet has been exhibited .
2L2 255 Thus far then the following substances have been submitted to exatination : Diamagnetic bodies .
Magnetic bodies .
Bismuth .
Penrhyn slate .
Antimony .
Caermarthen slate .
Heavy glass .
Slate perpendicular to cleavage .
Calcareous spar .
Chloride of iron .
Statuary marble .
Sulphate of iron .
Phosphorus .
Carbonate of iron .
Sulphur .
Ferrocyanide of potassium .
Nitre .
Oxide of iron .
Wax .
Iron filings .
Liquids .
Liquids .
Distilled water .
Sulphate of iron .
Bisulphide of carbon .
Muriate of nickel .
Miuriate of cobalt .
Every substance in each of these lists has been proved to be polar under magnetic influence , the polarity of the diamagnetic bodies being invariably opposed to that of the magnetic ones .
In his investigation on the supposed polarity of diamagnetic bodies , Mr. FARADAY made use of a core of sixpenny pieces , and obtained with it the results he sought .
Wishing to add the testimony of silver as a good conductor to that of copper , two cylinders were formed of sixpenny pieces , covered with paper and submitted to experiment .
The following are the results obtained : XXVIIIo Silver cylinders ( sixpenny pieces ) .
Current direct .
Position 1 .
724 Position 2 .
774 Position 3 .
804 The action here was prompt and energetic , strongly contrasted with the neutrality of copper ; but the deflection was permanent , and could not therefore be the result of induced currents .
Further , it was a deflection which shows magnetic polarity , whereas pure silver is feebly diamagnetic .
The cylinders were removed and examined between the poles of an electro-magnet ; they proved to be magnetic .
On observing this deportment of the silver , I tried the copper cylinders once more .
The results with a direct current were , XXIX .
Position 1 .
766 Position 2 .
767 Position 3 .
768 Here almost the same neutrality as before is evidenced .
256 Deeming that the magnetism of the cores of silver was due to magnetic impurity attaching itself to the paper which covered them , a number of fourpenny pieces were procured , washed in ammonia and water , and enclosed in thin glass tubes .
The following were the results : XXX .
Silver cylinders ( fourpenny pieces ) .
Current direct .
Position 1 .
490 Position 2 .
565 Position 3 .
660 HIere also we have a very considerable action indicative of magnetic polarity .
On examining the cylinders between the poles of an electro-magnet , they were found decidedly magnetic .
This , therefore , appears to be the common character of our silver coins .
The tubes which contained the pieces were sensibly neutral .
Knowing the difficulty of demonstrating the existence ot diamagnetic polarity in ordinary insulators , M. MATTEUCCI suggested that insulated fragments of bismuth ought to be employed , the insulation being effected by a coat of lac or resin .
I constructed a pair of cylinders in accordance with the suggestion of M. MATTEUCCI .
The following are the results they yielded with a direct current : XXXI .
Position 1 .
730 Position 2 .
750 Position 3 .
768 Here we have a very marked action , but the polarity indicated is magnetic polarity .
On subsequent examination , the cylinders proved to be magnetic .
This was due to impurities attaching themselves to the resin .
But the resin may be done away with and the powdered metal still rendered an insulator .
This thought was suggested to me by an experiment of Mr. FARADAY , which I will here describe .
Referring to certain effects obtained in his investigations on supposed diamagnetic polarity , he writes thus:- " If the effect were produced by induced currents in the mass , division of the mass would stop these currents , and so alter the effect ; whereas , if produced by a true diamagnetic polarity , division of the mass would not affect the polarity seriously or in its essential nature .
Some copper filings were therefore digested for a few days in dilute sulphuric acid to remove any adhering iron , then well washed and dried , and afterwards warmed and stirred in the air , until it was seen by the orange colour that a very thin film of oxide had formed upon them ; they were finally introduced into a glass tube and employed as a core .
It produced no effect whatever , but was as inactive as bismuth .
" ( Exper .
Resear .
2658 .
) 257 Now when bismuth is powdered and exposed to the action of the air , it very soon becomes tarnished , even without heating .
A quantity of such powder was prepared , and its conducting power for electricity tested .
The clean ends of two copper wires proceeding from a battery of GROVE were immersed in the powder ; but though the wires were brought as near as possible to each other , short of contact , not the slightest actiofi was observed upon a galvanometer placed in the circuit .
When the wires touched , the needle of the galvanometer flew violently aside , thus proving that the current was there , but that the powder was unable to conduct it .
Two glass tubes were filled with the powder and submitted to experiment .
The following results were obtained : XXXII .
Cylinders of Bismuth Powder .
length 3 inches .
diameter 0'7 .
Current direct .
Current reversed .
Position 1 .
640 230 Position 2 .
625 245 Position 3 .
596 260 These deflections are the same in kind as those obtained with the cylinders of massive bismuth .
This experiment responds perfectly to the conditions proposed by Mr. FARADAY .
We have here no cessation of action .
The division of the mass does not affect the result seriously or in its essential nature , and hence the deportment exhibits the characteristics of " a true diamagnetic polarity .
" In summing up the results of his inquiry on this subject , Mr. FARADAY writes thus:- " Finally , I am obliged to say that I can find no experimental evidence to support the hypothetical view of diamagnetic polarity , either in my own experiments , or in the repetition of those of WEBER , REICH and others ... . .
It appears to me also , that , as magnetic polarity conferred by iron or nickel in small quantity , and in unfavourable states , is far more easily indicated by its effects upon an astatic needle , or by pointing between the poles of a strong horseshoe magnet , than by any such arrangement as mine or WEBER'S or REICH'S , so diamagnetic polarity would be much more easily distinguished in the same way .
" I was struck , on reading this passage , to find how accurately the surmlise has been fulfilled by the instrument with which the foregoing experiments were made .
In illustration of the powers of this instrument , as compared with that made use of by Mr. FARADAY , I may be permitted to quote the following result from his paper on supposed diamagnetic polarity , so often referred to:- " A thin glass tube , 5 inches by three-quarters of an inch , was filled with a saturated solution of protosulphate of iron , and employed as an experimental core ; the velocity given to the machine at this and all average times was such as to cause five or six approaches and withdrawals of the core in one second ; 258 yet the solution produced no sensible indication on the galvanometer .
" Referring to Table XXV .
, it will be seen that the instrument made use of in the present inquiry has given with a solution of protosulphate of iron a deflection amounting to no less than one hundred divisions of the scale .
Mr. FARADAY proceeds:-"A tube filled with small crystals of protosulphate of iron caused the needle to move about 2 ?
... .
Red oxide of iron produced the least possible effect .
" In the experiments recorded in the foregoing pages , the crystallized sulphlate of iron gave a deflection of nearly two hundred divisions of the scale , while the red oxide gave a deflection as wide as the helices would permit , which corresponds to about eight hundred divisions of the scale .
The correctness of Mr. FARADAY'S statement regarding the inferiority of the means first devised to investigate this subject , is thus strikingly illustrated .
It might be added , that red ferroprussiate of potash and other substances , which have given us powerful effects , produced no sensible impression in experiments made with the other instrument .
Thus have we seen the objections raised against diamagnetic polarity fall away one by one , and a body of evidence accumulated in its favour , which places it among the most firmly established truths of science .
This I cannot help thinking is mainly to be attributed to the bold and sincere questioning of the principle when it seemed questionable .
The cause of science is more truly served , even by the denial of what may be a truth , than by the indolent acceptance of it on insufficient grounds .
Such denials drive us to a deeper communion with Nature , and , as in the present instance , compel us through severe and laborious inquiry to strive after certainty , instead of resting satisfied , as we are prone to do , with mere probable conjecture , Royal Institution , November 1855 , 259

