On the Anatomy and Physiology of Cordylophora* , a contribution to our knowledge of the Tubularian Zoophytes .
By GEORGE JAMES ALLMAN , M.D. , M.R.I.A , Professor of Botany in the University of Dublin , and Examiner in Zoology and Botany in the Queen 's University in Ireland .
Communicated by Professor EDWARD FORBES , F.R.S. Received May 31 , -Read June 16 , 1853 .
THOUGH the attention of several physiologists has been directed to the Tubularian Zoophytes , and though the elucidation of many points of interest in their structure and in the physiological phenomena presented by them has been the result , yet in numerous most important particulars our knowledge of the Tubulariadce is still very imperfect , notwithstanding the great value which a more thorough acquaintance with these simple organisms must possess in its bearing upon some of the leading questions in physiology .
It was with the view of filling up some of the deficiencies which still exist in our knowledge of the lower zoophytes , that the following researches were undertaken ; and Cordylophora lacustris , affording as it does a fine typical example of tubularian structure , and being easily kept alive for months , was deemed peculiarly favourable for prolonged and careful observation ; the results , moreover , which have been obtained from the investigation of this zoophyte , have been in many instances confirmed and extended by corresponding inquiries , instituted at the same time into the structure of allied genera .
It is certain that considerable confusion as well as much cumbrous circumlocution might be avoided , by giving greater precision and completeness to the terminology employed in the description of structure among zoophytes .
With this view , I propose in the first place to employ the word polype in its most restricted sense .
This word is used ambiguously by writers , being often employed to designate the entire composite fabric , the aggregate result of gemtmation ; while at other times it is intended to indicate each of those peculiar organisms which , almost always furnished with a mouth and tentacula , are developed upon various points of a common living basis , and are eminently characteristic of zoophytic form .
In the following paper I shall use the term polype strictly in the latter signification ; and for the entire mass , whether consisting of a single polype , as in Hydra , or of many united into a more or less definite assemblage , it will be sufficiently convenient to employ merely the term zoophyte* .
Besides the more definite limits within which it is thus necessary to confine the term polype , the requirements of precise description demand the use of a few additional terms .
To the common living basis by which the several polypes in a composite zoophyte are connected with one another , I propose to give the name of conosarct , and every composite zoophyte will thus consist of a variable number of polypes , developing themselves from certain more or less definite points of a common ccenosarc .
The term polypary has been used with just as little precision as polype , being sometimes employed to express this common connecting basis , and at other times being applied exclusively to the solid protective structures , whether forming for the zoophyte an external covering or constituting an internal axis ; the ambiguity which thus results will be got rid of by using the word coenosarc as here defined , and restricting the term polypary to the solid protective structures of the zoophyte .
All the hydroid zoophytes can be proved to consist essentially of two distinct membranes ; to the external of these mrembranes I shall give the name of ectodermt , and to the internal that of endoderm ? .
ORGANS FOR THE PRESERVATION OF THE INDIVIDUAL .
1 .
Ectoderm and Polypary .
( a. ) Ectoderm.-The ectoderin ( Plates XXV .
and XXVI .
figs. 3 , 4 , 9a , a , a ) is a welldefined membrane ; it is composed of cells , and forms the external layer of the polypes and coenosarc .
Multitudes of thread-cells aredevelopedin thesubstanceofthe ectoderm .
The thread-cells , when in a quiescent state ( fig. 5 ) , present the appearance of minute ovate capsules , slightly curved at one end , and with a transparent cylinder occupying about two-thirds of the axis .
Under the influence of excitement , one extremity of the capsule becomes suddenly prolonged into a conical projection , surrounded near its apex by a circle of very minute curved spicula , the capsule at the same instant appearing empty ( fig. 6 ) .
This phenomenon seems to consist in the sudden eversion through one end of the capsule of a delicate sac which had previously lain invaginated within it , and is generally immediately followed by the projection of a long and fine filament from the free end of the everted sac .
The structure of these thread-cells , and the phenomena consequent on excitement , closely resemble what we find in the " hastigerous organs " of Hydra .
The greater minuteness however of the threadcells in Cordylophora rendets it much more difficult to obtain a satisfactory examination of their structure .
The thread-cells are developed in the interior of mothercells ( fig. 7 ) , which are themselves secondary cells formed within the ectodermal cells ; but I was not able to determine how far their development devolves exclusively upon certain cells of the ectoderm specially devoted to this office .
The ectoderm of the tentacula differs slightly from that of the rest of the zoophyte , in the fact of the thread-cells being for the most part collected into groups , which present the appearance of little wart-like excrescences resembling the disposition of the corresponding organs in the tentacula of Hydra .
At the extremity of the tentacula numerous thread-cells are crowded together , but there is no approach to the capitate terminations which are so striking in Syncoryne , and which , among other characters , zoologically distinguish that genus from Cordylophora .
( b. ) Polypary.-The polypary ( fig. 3 b , b ) is a cylindrical tube investing the stems and btranches of the zoophyte , and terminating just behind a short fleshy neck which immediately supports the polypes .
On the younger branches it forms a thin , and almost colourless pergamentaceous investment ; but in older parts of the zoophyte it is of a yellowish-brown colour , and composed of numerous layers .
At the origin of the branches from the main stem , the polypary presents a number of annular corrugations .
The cavity of the polypary appears by no means accurately filled by the coenosarc , and we almost always find a considerable interval between the ectodermn of the ccenosarc and the walls of the polypary ; this interval is crossed transverisely by numerous processes of the ectoderm ( fig. 3 c , c ) .
It seems , however , almost certain that a very delicate living membrane is in actual contact throughout with the inner surface of the polypary , at least in all its younger portions ; and the space which appears to exist between the polypary and the coenosarc is then nothing but a large lacuna of the ectoderm , crossed by fleshy processes , which keep up a communication between its opposite walls .
I have distinctly demonstrated the presence of such a membrane in Syncoryne , where I have traced the formation of the space in question from a simple lacuna of the ectoderm , though I have not succeeded in so decidedly making out these points in Cordylophora .
No trace of organization can be detected in the polypary , which in all respects resembles a mere secretion deposited in layers from the ectoderm .
Where the polypary terminates anteriorly , an exceedingly delicate transparent pellicle may be traced in continuity with it over 3c 2 the neck and clavate body of the polype , at least as far as the roots of the posterior tentacula .
It is certain that the cavity of the polypary increases in diameter , up to a certain point , with the growth of the animal , a fact which we can reconcile with the account just given of its formation , only by attributing to it a capacity of distension subsequently to its original deposition .
2 .
The Endoderm and its Cavity .
The endoderm ( fig. 3 , d , d ) constitutes a very distinctly cellular layer ; it is in contact throughout with the ectoderm , but is nevertheless distinguishable from it by a very decided boundary , and can only be considered as directly continuous with it at the mouths of the polypes .
It forms the walls of an uninterrupted cavity , which , extending through the axis of the entire zoophyte , opens extelnally at the polypemouths .
This cavity may be divided into four distinct regions , namely , thepost-buccal cavity , the stomach , the tentacular canals , and the canal of the cwtnosarc , a division which , though in some degree arbitrary , will be found very useful in description .
( a. ) Post-bzlccal cavity.-The post-buccal cavity ( fig. 3f ) is situated immediately behind the mouth ( fig. 3 e ) , which is a simple unarmed orifice placed at the extremity of a conical projection , into which the body of the polype is continued anteriorly .
The post-buccal cavity lies in the axis of this projection ; its walls are formed of elongated cells , with their long diameter perpendicular to the surface , and its interior is quite destitute of rugue .
It is usually in the form of a narrow tube , and is capable of complete obliteration by the temporary approximation of its walls ; it is sometimes , however , dilated into a globular space , and sometimes spread out by a kind of semiieversion into a nearly flat disc , which I have seen employed by the animal as an organ of adhesion .
( b. ) Stomach.-The stomach ( fig. 3g ) occupies the whole of the interior of the clavate body of the polype ; as the endoderm passes backward from the post-buccal cavity to 'constitute the walls of the stomach , we find it forming a peculiar tissue composed of elongated cells , whose rounded ends project in prominent masses into the cavity of the stomach , where they constitute large irregular rugas .
The tissue of these rugae is very remarkable ; the cells composing it ( fig. 4 b ) are mother-cells , giving origin in their interior to several free secondary cells with distinct nuclei .
In some of these secondary cells the contents are colourless and transparent , and the nuclei are then very evident ( fig. 4 c ) ; others contain a brown granular matter , by which the nucleus is more or less obscured ( fig. 4 d ) ; while others may occasionally be found filled with a brood of young cells ( fig. 8 ) .
Lying apparently free in the mother-cells may also be generally seen , besides the free secondarycells , some rather irtregular masses of a deep briown granular substance ( fig. 4 e ) .
I have found in Hydra a structure in all its essential characters entirely similar to this , and we cannot refuse to recognise in it an example of true glandular structure .
The secondary cells are obviously true secreting cells , destined by their own rupture and that of the mothercells to discharge their contents into the cavity of the stomach ; while the free granular masses in the interior of the mother-cells were most probably originally contained in secondary cells , of whose secreting action they are the product , and which at a subsequent period had disappeared .
( c. ) Tentacular canals.-The tentacula are hollow processes from the sides of the polypes , and their cavities are simple continuations of that of the stomach .
This view is certainly opposed to the appearances presented on a superficial examination , and is at variance with the accounts given by other observers of the structure of the tentacula in the marine Hydroida ; very careful and repeated observations , however , have convinced me of its truth .
It must be admitted , that at first sight , the tentacula , even under well-managed microscopical examination , have exactly the appearance of tubes whose cavity is interrupted at regular intervals by completely formed transverse septa ; I have , however , satisfied myself that in Cordylophora , and probably also in all the other Hydroida , the tube of the tentacula is perfectly continuous .
The tentacula consist in reality , like all other parts of the animal , of an external or ectodermic layer ( fig. 9 a , a ) , which is a simple continuation of the general ectoderm of the body , and of an internal or endodermic layer ( fig. 9 b , b ) , which is in the same way a continuation of the endoder of the stomach .
The tentacular ectoderm has been already described .
The endoderm consists of rather large cells with very delicate walls ; it constitutes athick ling the tube , and nearly fils of the nnentire cavity ; and indeed this cavity , by a temporary approximation of its walls , appears capable of occasional obliteration .
The cells of the tentacular endoderm are glandular , and may be generally seen to contain the peculiar brown granules characteristic of the general endodermic secretion .
The appearance of transverse septa is probably due to the occurrence at regular intervals , of interruptions in the continuity of the endodermic layer .
Though the tentacula of Hydra present no appearance of the transverse septa , their structure is nevertheless essentially the same as that of the tentacula of Cordylophora , the only difference being in the fact that the endoderm forms a thinner stratumr in Hydra , and thus encroaches less on the cavity of the tube , and does not present the successive interruptions which in Cordylophora give rise to the fallacious appearance of transverse septa .
( d. ) Canal of the Cwnosarc.-The cavity of the stomach is continuous posteriorly with the canal of the coenosarc , fig. 3 h. The rounded masses of cells constituting the large rugue into which the endoderm of the stomach is thrown , cannot be traced further back than the posterior extremity of the clavate body of the polype , and from this point , which may be conveniently though somewhat arbitrarily assumed as the posterior termination of the stomach , the canal of the coenosarc commences , and thence extends as a continuous tube through all the ramifications of the coenosarc .
In that portion of the canal which immediately succeeds to the stomach , and which is here much contracted , the endoderm resembles in all respects that of the stomach , except in the absence of distinct rugae ; but as the coenosarc passes backwards under cover of the polypary , the cells lose their elongated form , the endoderm becomes thinner and the canal proportionately wider .
Tlhroughout all the rest of the coenosarc the endodelrm is formed of a compact tissue destitute of rugae , but whose component cells continue to retain their glandular character ( fig. 10 ) .
The canal of the coenosarc is filled with a fluid containing globular and irregular corpuscles of various sizes ; these corpuscles may be observed to exhibit a kind of circulatory movement , which however is very irregular ; they may be sometimes seen running from below upwards and again turning round in order to take a retrograde course ; the motion of each corpuscle is generally confined to a small circuit , frequently not exceeding the diameter of the canal somretimes many of the corpuscles stop altogether and allow others to pass them , while sometimes no motionl whatever can be observed in any of the contents .
The corpuscles while moving in their linear paths have besides a peculiar vibratile r treemulous motion in themselves , and this motion may generally be witnessed while the corpuscles are otherwise entirely at rest .
The motion of the corpuscles may be traced all through the stems and branches , and even into the stomach .
The cause of this phenomenon is very obscure ; the existence of vibratile cilia on the walls of the canal might be adduced as an explanation , but these organs have never been made the subject of direct observation , notwithstanding the most careful attempts to demonstrate them ; it appears to me that the true cause is to be found in currents produced by the active vital processes going on in the secreting cells of the endoderm , processes which we can hardly imagiine to take place without causing local changes in the chemical constitution of the fluids in immediate contact with the cells , and a consequent disturbance of the stability of these fluids .
3 .
Muscular System .
Under this head may be described the only specialized motor apparatus which these animals present .
It consists of numerous longitudinal fibres , which are in close contact with the inner surface of the ectoderm .
These fibres ( fig. 3 i , i , fig. 4f , fig. 9 c ) may be seen in all the naked potrtion of the ccenosarc , and in the body of the polype , and may be thence easily traced into the tentacula , in which they can be followed to the remote extremities of these organs , but they disappear where the coenosare passes under cover of the polypary .
There can be little doubt that we are correct in considering them as the representatives of a muscular system , and in attributing to them the chief share in effecting the various changes of form which the polypes are perpetually presenting .
Similar fibres may be witnessed in Coryne , Syncoryne , and other marine Tubulariadce , in some of which they are even more distinct than in Cordylophora .
In none could I detect the least trace of transverse striae .
The researches of modern naturalists , especially of EHRENBERG , LOVEN , VAN BENEDEN , SARS , and DUJARDIN , have thrown much light on the embryology of the inferior zoophytes , and their observations have brought to our knowledge many remarkable and unexpected facts , though physiologists are by no means of one mind as to the true signification of several of the facts with which we have thus become acquainted .
During the later summer and autumn months Cordylophora lacustris may be seen with numerous oval capsules borne upon the ultimate or polypiferous ramuli , fig. 2 .
Each ramulus generally carries one , two , or three of these capsules , which are situated alternately on either side of the ramulus at some distance behind the body of the polype , and where the branch is still covered by the polypary , the more advanced capsules being always nearer to the main stems .
They are nearly sessile on the supporting branches , and when fully developed are somewhat larger than the club-shaped bodies of the polypes .
They are surrounded externally by a delicate continuation of the polypary , and as they approach towards maturity are found to contain within them either ova or spermatozoa .
The structure and development of these capsules and their contents are exceedingly interesting .
The capsule on its first appearance presents itself as a small tubercle , consisting of a simple hernia-like protrusion , or diverticulum of the coenosarc ( fig. 1 a ) , enveloped by a delicate production of the polypary ( fig. 11 b ) , and as the cavity of the diverticulurn continues to communicate with the common canal of the branch , the contents of the latter pass freely into its interior .
As the tubercle increases in size , we perceive that the external investment from the polypary immlediately surrounds a sac of distinctly cellular structure , having the diverticulum from the ccenosarc projecting into it below , and having a remarkable system of branched tubes developed on its internal surface ( figs. 12 , 13 , 14 ) .
These tubes spring from the sides of the diverticulum with whose cavity their own cornmunicates they occasionally inosculate with one another , and passing upwards in close connection with the walls of the cellular sac , extend to the summit of the sac where their branches terminate in caeca ; they are lined with a layer of cells , which contain secondary cells and brown granules , and which thus resemble the general endoderm of the zoophyte .
Thread-celis occur in the walls of the cellular sac , which is plainly referable to the ectodermnal system .
Between the cellular sac and the diverticulum is a considerable interval , which is filled with a granular fluid .
We next find that in those capsules which are to contain ova a number of spherical dark grey or bluish bodies ( fig. 14f ) have become apparent in the midst of the granular fluid : these are ova ; in most of them we may perceive the germinal vesicle in the form of a minute clear point , but the germinal spot is not apparent .
The germinal vesicle soon disappears , and when the ova are now examined , the phenomenon of yelk-cleavage may be distinctly perceived in them , fig. 16 .
In the mean time a delicate structureless pellicle ( fig. 13 e ) has been formed on the external surface of the cellular sac ; it is evidently a mere secretion from the surface of the sac , resembling the secretion of the polypary from the coenosarc .
Soon after the commencement of segmentation of the vitlus , the celcelular sac with its system of ramified tubes disappears , and the cluster of ova is now distinctly exposed ( fig. 15 ) lying upon the diverticulum from the coenosarc , and immediately enclosed by the delicate structureless sac formed by the pellicle which had been secreted on the outside of the cellular sac , while the whole is included within the external pergamentaceous investment from the polypary .
The ova vary in number ; in many capsules I have counted ten , twelve , or even more , while sone few contained only two or three .
The mulberry-like condition of the ova at length disappears , and these bodies now begin to elongate themselves , and when viewed by transmitted light , present a transparent margin ( fig. 17 ) .
As development advances the ova become more and more elongated , and they soon exhibit a slow but evident motion in the interior of the contaning sac ( fig. 18 ) .
They are now in the condition of free embryos , only waiting for the rupture of the enclosing structures to escape into the surrounding medium and enjoy an independent existence .
We accordingly soon find that tese structures no longer confine them , and the embryos may now be seen escaping from the torn summit of the capsule in the form of infusorial animalcules clotlied with short cilia , and swimming freely through the surrounding water ( fig. 19 ) .
The embryos on their escape from the capsule are usually of an elongated oval figure ( figs. 19 , 20 ) , but very contractile , and capable of undergoing considerable change of form ; they frequently assume a pyriform shape ( fig. 21 ) , but they never appear compressed , and the comparison with a Planaria , to which DALYELL and others have likened the embryos of Campanularia , will not here strictly apply .
They are included in a distinct ectoderm , and contain in their interior a cavity which is separated from the ectoderm by a cellular interval representing the endoderm of the adult zoophyte , but in which the brown granules have not yet shown themselves .
No mouth is yet evident , and the ectoderm seems in this early stage destitute of thread-cells .
After the embryo has continued for some time in the condition now described , the period of its final fixation approaches ; the cilia disappear ; one extremity becomes expanded into a kind of disc , by which it soon attaches itself to some fixed object ; the mouth has now become apparent , and thread-cells are developed in the ectoderm ( fig. 22 ) ; the embryo increases in length and thickness , and from the free extremity , which has begun to assume a clavate form , a single series of tentacula soon shoot forth ( fig. 23 ) ; these are about four in number , and are situated a little behind the anterior end the portion of the body which lies before them becomes the postbuccal cavity of the adult ; the gastric cavity has become prolonged through the young stem ; a delicate polypary has begun to invest it ; and its walls begin to be coloured by the characteristic secretion of the endoderm ; other tentacula soon shoot folrth behind those first formed , and the little Cordylophora resembles in all respects , except in size , a full-grown stem with a solitary polype .
Its solitary condition however is not long retained ; prolongations have already been sent out from its base ; these attach themselves to the body on which it grows , and constitute the system of prostrate adherent tubes , while gemmae are soon formed from these tubes and from the free stem , and convert the young single-polyped zoophyte into the adult many-polyped Cordylophora* .
But besides the ovigerous capsules , a second kind ( fig. 24 ) is developed on certain branches .
These differ neither in situation nor in visible organization from the capsules destined to contain ova ; their component sacs , internal diverticulum , and ramified canals entirely correspond with those of the ovigerous capsules ; but instead of containing ova , they are filled with a turbid fluid , in the midst of which innumerable minute corpuscles may be seen to exhibit a peculiar vibratory movement occasionally visible under slight pressure throughl the transparent walls , and the same motion is continued in these corpuscles after they are liberated from the containing capsule and spread over the field of the microscope .
IThat these capsules represent a male system with spermatozoa , there cannot be the least doubt .
When liberated from the capsule , the moving bodies show themselves under two different forms ; they are either oval corpuscles with an excessively delicate caudal filament ( fig. 24 c ) , or they are minute spherical cells ( fig. 24 b ) with a similar caudal filament ( by whose undulations the cells are moved about through the surrounding fluid ) , and enclosing a nucleus-like corpuscle , with which the filament appears to be connlected .
The former would seem to be the spermatozoa in their free and fully developed condition , while the latter appear to be " vesicles of evolution , " in which the body of the spermatozoon is still confined , the tail alone being disengaged .
It still remains difficult to explain the mode in which the spermatozoa gain access to the ova .
In some cases I have succeeded , under slight pressure , in forcing out the contents through a minute orifice which made its appearance in the summit of the capsule , but this orifice , notwithstanding its definite position , was probably the result of rupture , and I could not detect anything corresponding to it in the ovigerous capsules .
It would perhaps be more in accordance with analogy to suppose that the spermatozoa make their way into the cavity of the diverticulum , that they are thus conveyed into that of the ccenosarc , and ultimately reach the ova through the diverticulum of the ovigerous capsules .
The male and female capsules appear to be always borne on different stems .
From the description nowgiven , it is manifest that Cordylophora ( and there is little doubt that we are justified in extending the generalization to all the hydroid zoophytes ) consists essentially of two distinct membranes , enclosing a cavity which opens externally by one or more orifices ( polype-mouths ) , and which is prolonged into the interior of a variable number of filiform processes ( tentacula)* .
The two membranes appear to be essentially secreting structures , but the products of their respective secretory action strikingly differ from one another ; for while the cells of the endoderm give origin to secondary cells which secrete a coloured granular substance , which may be fairly assumed as representing the biliary secretion of higher animals , the ectodermal cells give origin to cells of a very remarkable kind , whose characteristic secretion is a peculiar filament , whose import and office are as yet but very imperfectly understood .
In none of these zoophytes can any approach to a specialized circulatory system be discovered ; the function of circulation appearing to be represented merely by a gradual transmission of the fluids from cell to cell , depending wholly on the permeability of tissue .
A respiratory system is equally without any special representative .
Whatever aerating influence the surrounding water exerts must be received through the entire surface of the zoophyte , though doubtless most powerfully through the portion not covered by the polypary .
The muscular system has begun to be specialized , but no trace of a nervous system can yet be detected .
The existence of an extensive system of lacunae , as described by DUJARDINt , in some marine Tubulariadce , and by ECKER+ in Hydra , where this anatomist describes them as constituting a network of ramified canals , has not been confirmed by my own researches .
The true signification of the reproductive capsules of the hydroid zoophytes is a matter of considerable interest .
On this subject much additional light will be thrown by comparing the embryological phenomena of Cordylophora with those which are known to occur in the allied genera of the sea .
In the marine Tubulariad ?
, two distinct kinds of bodies are developed besides the ordinary terminal polypes .
Of these one consists in medusa-like bodies , which are generally developed at the bases of the tentacula ?
, and which after a time have been seen to detach themselves from the supporting polype and swim freely away .
The other kind of bodies met with in these polypes are peculiar sacs , occupying a similar position to that of the medusoid bodies , but never detaching themselves from the parent , and always after a time filled with ova or spermatozoa* .
In Campanularia bodies of highly developed medusan conformation are produced , generally in considerable numbers , in external capsules situated on parts of the polypary always at a distance from the terminal polypes .
When arrived at a certain degree of maturity , they escape from the capsule and swim freely through the surrounding water .
In the capsules of Campanularia another kind of body has been also observed , in which the medusan structure is less complete , and these , after disengaging themselves from the cavity of the capsule , continue attached to its mouth , never becoming entirely free ; while a third kind of bodies , corresponding with the fixed sacs of the Tubulariadce , is also borne in the capsules of Campanulariat .
In some instances the free medusoid bodies of the Tubulariadwe have been found to contain ova , as has been observed by WAGNERt in a tubularian polype from the Adriatic , apparently referable to HIydractinia , VAN BENEDEN , by LOVEN ?
in a Syncoryne , and by DUJARDIN 11 in another species of Syncoryne , whose medusoid was seen to produce ova in the thickness of the stomach-walls .
The less perfectly developed iredusoids which remain attached to the mouth of the capsule in Campanularia have also been observed to contain ova as noted by LOVEN ; while the previous observation of LISTER** , who saw multitudes of moving bodies escaping from these medusoids , is possibly also an instance of a similar phenomenon , though the form of the moving bodies as described by LISTER leaves a doubt of their being truly embryos ; they are probably spermatozoa , and then LTSTER'S medusoids would be males ; a view supported by SHULTZ'St+ recent observation , that these attached medusoids of Campanlularia sometimes contain spermatozoa instead of ova .
Now in Cordy , lophora I have never witnessed the production of medusoids , but I think nevertheless that it will be easily seen that the reproductive capsules of this genus have essentially the same organization as the medusoids of the marine genera .
These capsules in an advanced stage exhibit but little of a medusoid conformation , but at an earlier period of their development , as we have just seen , they present us with an orgatized sac having a hollow central and fleshy column projecting into it below , and furnished with a system of branctied canals which are developed on its walls , and communicate at their origin with the cavity of the central column .
In this structure we can have no hesitation in recognising a true medusoid type ; the organized cellular sac is homologous with the disc of the Medusa , the central fleshy column will represent the peduncle or proboscidiform storach , while the sister of branched tubes will correspond to the gastro-vascular canals++ .
It is true that neither disc nor stomach presents any obvious opening in the capsules of the polype , but this is merely a particular and non-essential modification of structure adapted to the function which morioe especially devolves on them , and it must be recollected that being in direct communication with the common cavity of the parent stem , they are in no need of the admission of nutritive matter from without .
Neither does the ramified condition of the tubes , nor the absence of the marginal canal , invalidate the view here taken , for we know that the gastro-vascular canals in certain true Medusa are ramified , while the closed condition of the disc brings with it the absence of the marginal canal * .
There is a difficulty in the determination of the exact part of the reproductive capsules , which is immediately concerned in the production of the ova or spermatozoa .
As soon as ever these bodies become apparent , they are seen to occupy the entire space between the diverticulum and the walls of the inner vesicle .
The observation already mentione(l , as made by DUJARDIN on a Syncoryne , in whose free medusoid the ova were produced in the substance of the stomach-walls , would render it probable that in Cordylophora also they had their origin in the part homologous , namely , the central diverticulum , and that from this they became liberated at a very early age to undergo subsequent development in the cavity of the capsule ; and this view is further supported by what I have myself observed in the fixed egg-bearing organs of Sertularia argentea , to be presently referred to .
With the reproductive capsules of Cordylophora we may now compare the fixed ovigerous sacs of the marine genera .
It will be seen that these also possess a true medusoid structure , though this is perhaps not quite so easily made out in every case as in Cordylophora .
In the marine Tubulariadce , the sacs in question consist of a closed vesicle composed of cells , and surrounded externally by a delicate structureless capsule ; into its bottom projects a large , hollow , cylindrical and contractile organ whose cavity is in connection with that of the supporting polype , and round which the ova are developed .
Now this central organ corresponds exactly to the central diverticulumn in the reproductive capsules of Cordylophora , and plainly represents the proboscidiform stomach of a Medusa , while the cellular sac h homologous with the disc .
It is true there is nothing here which evidently represents the gastrovascular canals of the Medusae and the ramified tubes in the capsules of Cordylophora , but there is yet quite sufficient essential resemnblance to justify us in referring the reproductive capsules of the marine Tubulariadce to the type of medusoid structure , to which we have just seen that those of Cordylophora admit of a close comparison .
In the Campanularice , besides the bodies of obvious medusoid structure which have been noticed by so many observers to escape from the capsule and then swim freely away , and those of less completely developed , though still obvious medusoid structure which remain attached at the mouth of the capsule , others are commonly seen in the interior of the capsule clustering round the central axis , and described by various naturalists as eggs .
In these so-called eggs , however , there may be detected a medusoid structure quite as manifest as in the ovigerous sacs of the marine Tubulariadce ; each of them is in fact a fixed Medusa developing within it true ova which possess the germninal vesicle and germinal spot , and present the phenomenon of yelk-cleavage , and after a time escape as locomotive ciliated embryos .
It is probable however that in some cases the production of spermatozoa instead of ova is the true office of these bodies .
In Sertularia argentea I have found the axis developed in the interior of the capsule into a body of very obvious medusoid conformation .
In this body the medusoid structure has experienced an advance over that of the reproductive sacs of the Tubulariadce ; both mouth and disc are open , and four unbranchled gastro-vascular canals are present , but it is permanently fixed , no marginal tentacula are developed , nor could I observe the least motion of the disc corresponding to the systole and diastole of the medusoids of the Tubulariade and the Campanulariw .
It is supported on a short stem , which springs from the bottom of the capsule , and is directly continuous with its stomach .
In this stem the ova originate and appear to escape from it into the stomach of the medusoid , to be discharged from the mouth into an external delicate vesicle , where they are retained during subsequent stages of their development .
If the views now taken be correct , the reproductive capsules of Cordylophora , and those of the marine oubulariadce , as well as the parts immediately concerned in the sexual reproduction of the Sertulariadce , must be regarded as distinct zooids* , presenting a more or less degraded type of medusoid structuret .
On investigations into the emtbryology of the lower polypes , an important influence was exercised by EHRENBERG'S determination of the signification of the ovigerous capsules of Campanularia and Coryne .
The existence of these capsules was , as is well known , supposed by the celebrated Berlin micro rapist to indicate a distinction of sex in the polypes of a zoophyte , the ordinary terminal polypes being considered by him as non-sexual , while the ovigerious capsules were maintained to be female polypes .
This view was ardently adopted by LOVEN ?
, who , observing some of the free medusoids of a Syncoryne to be filled with ova , supposed these medusoids to possess the same signification as that which EHRENBERG had attributed to the fixed capsules .
STEENSTRUP , adopting with some slight modification the same view , has found in it one of the most striking of the facts which he has so skilfully collateid in his essay on " The Alternations of Generations ; " while VAN BENEDEN* , in two elaborate memoirs full of beautiful and accurate observations , has strenuously opposed it , maintaining that the ovigerous fixed capsules are merely organs , " ovisacs , " while the free inedusoids are larvae destined to undergo a series of transformations during a process of development into the form of the parent zoophyte .
M. VAN BENEDEN , however , though he has had the medusoids long under his eyes , has never witnessed an actual development into the form of the parent polype , and the changes which he has figured as occurring in them do not appear to show any tendency to such a transformation .
I have had the medusoids of a Syncoryne for more than a fortnight under constant inspection without perceiving the slightest change towards the form of the adult polype ; at the end of this period they perished .
DUJARDINt opposes the views both of EHRENBERG and VAN BENEDEN , and taking the medusoids for true Medusa , and viewing them even as distinct genera of Acalepha , he generalizes the observed instances of their production , and maintains that the claviform polypes are universally only inferior phases of the development of the Acalepha ; while he considers the bodies produced in the fixed sacs only as " bulbzillw , " by which he understands gernmae , which become detached at an early stage , and are then capable of an independent development .
The strong resemblance however between true Medusce and the medusoids produced by a process of geinmation from polypes does not afford sufficient grounds for maintaining that all Medusce are only advanced stages of tubularian zoophytes and of Campanularie , or that all these zoophytes are only earlier phases in the development of Medusce ; and M. DUJARDIN'S generalization , from which would result the complete abolition of the Campanularice and tubularian zoophlytes as distinct groups of the animal kingdom , is certainly destitute of sufficient foundation , while the bodies contained in the fixed sacs are undoubtedly not gemmce but ova , as their structure and the whole history of their development must render evident .
I cannot think , then , that either VAN BENEDEN or DUJARDIN has succeeded in overthrowing the theory of EHRENBERG .
The conclusion to which the facts sought to be demonstrated in the present paper would seem to lead , is that in the tubularian zoophytes there exist three kinds of zooids , all produced by a process of gemnmation from an original stolon , which is itself the immediate product of a true ovum .
These are , -1 .
the ordinary terminal zooids , on which devolves more especially the function of the reception , digestion , and elaboration of the nutrient material ; 2 .
the fixed reproductive zooids , in which every function is rendered subordinate to the production and development of the ova or spermatozoa , and in which a medusoid structure is more or less disguised ; and 3 .
the free medusiform zooids , in which a complete medusoid structure is obvious .
The office of these last is less exactly determined than that of either of the others ; sexual reproduction is probably , as in the fixed reproductive zooids , their characteristic function ; for as we have already seen , they have in several instances been found to contain ova ; yet in the greater number of cases no ova have been detected in them , and observations are still wanting to enable us to decide whether at one period or another of their existence a true generative office is not , under favourable circurstances , always performed by them .
It is certain that the other functions are not here so completely subordinated to reproduction as in the fixed sacs , for since the medusoid has become entirely detached from the parent , a more elaborate organization is necessary to enable it to niaintain an independent existence .
Uniting the functions of reproduction with extensive locomotive powers , it is probably destined to carry the ova to a distance from the parent stock , and thus provide for the dispersion of the species , for the motion of the ciliated embryo is too slow to be of any use in this respect .
In the Campanularice , besides these three forms of zooids there exists a fourth , in which the medusoid structure is also obvious , though not so completely developed as in the free medusoids ; the bodies belonging to this group remain permanently fixed at the mouth of the capsule ; their function is that of true sexual generation , and after giving birth to ova or spermatozoa they wither away .
The ovigerous sacs of degraded medusoid structure concealed in the interior of the capsules of Campanularia are quite different from these , and belong to the second kind of zooid enumerated above .
In Sertularia and its immediate allies no locomotive zooids have as yet been found , and the generative zooids of Sertularia argentea already described admit of comparison rather with the fixed medusoids attached to the mouth of the capsule in Campanularia , than with the ovigerous sacs of the Tubulariadwe .
It would seem then that EHRENBERG struck upon the true determination of the ovigerous sacs in Coryne when he called them " female polypes , " though he erred when , supposing the " ovarian vesicles " of Campanularia to be the homologues of the ovigerous sacs of Coryne , he called these vesicles also by the same name ; the true hotnologues of the reproductive sacs of the lTubulariadwe being , not the external capsules of the Campanularice , but fixed bodies with a disguised tmedusoid structure contained in the interior of these capsules* .
The present state of our knowledge of the Tubularian and Sertularian polypes would seem to justify the generalization , that for the production of ova in these polypes a more or less perfectly developed medusoid organization is required , this organization being demonstrable not only in the free medusoids themselves , which are occasionally observed to give origin to ova , but in those reproductive capsules and imperfectly developed medusoids which remain permanently adherent to the parent .
DESCRIPTION OF THE PLATES .
PLATE XXV .
Fig. 1 .
Cordylophora lacustris , attached to a dead valve of Anodon cygneus .
Natural size .
Fig. 2 .
A branch magnified with the polypes in various states of expansion , and wit the reproductive capsules more or less developed .
Fig. 3 .
Longitudinal section of polype to show the details of its structure .
a. Ectoderm .
b. Polypary .
c. Processes from the ectoderm attached to inner surface of the polypary .
d. Endoderm .
e. Mouth .
J : Post-buccal cavity .
g. Stomach .
h. Common canal of the ccenosarc .
i. Muscles .
PLATE XXVI .
Fig. 4 .
Portion of the walls of the stomach more highly magnified .
a. Ectoderm , its cells containing thread-cells .
b. Endoderm composed of elongated cells , with true secreting cells in their interior .
c. Secreting cells with evident nucleus .
d. Secreting cells with the nucleus obscured by the opake contents .
e. Granular mass .
f. Muscles .
Fig. 5 .
Thread-cells previous to the exsertion of the filament .
Fig. 6 .
Thread-cells after the exsertion of the filament .
Fig. 7 .
A group of cells liberated under pressure from the ectoderm .
Some contain a single thread-cell , others a nucleus-like body , probably an undeveloped thread-cell .
They appear to have been originally contained as secondary cells within the proper cells of the ectoderm .
Fig. 8 .
Cells liberated by pressure from the endoderm of the stomach .
They are filled with smaller cells , which contain coloured granules , and seem to have been originally contained within the proper cells of the endoderm .
a. Nuclei of contained cells distinct .
b. Nuclei concealed by the coloured granules .
Fig. 9 .
Portion of a tentacle near its root , to show its structure .
a. Ectoderrn with thread-cells .
b. Endoderm , its cells containing coloured granules .
c. Muscular fibres .
Fig. 10 .
Cells containing secondary cells with granular contents from the endoderm , when covered by the polypary .
** , In figs. 11-14 the same letters are used to indicate corresponding portions of structure , viz. a. Diverticulum from the coenosarc .
b. External investment of the reproductive capsule continued from the polypary .
c. Cellular sac .
d. Ramified canals .
e. Structureless sac secreted on the outside of the cellular sac .
Fig. 11 .
Reproductive capsule-very early stage .
Fig. 12 .
The same more advanced stage ; the cellular sac and ramified canals are now visible .
Fig. 13 .
Ideal longitudinal section of a reproductive capsule of about the same period as fig. 12 ; showing the relation of the ramified canals to the diverticulum and cellular sac , and the presence of a delicate structureless sac which has been secreted on the outside of the cellular sac .
Fig. 14 .
Reproductive capsule in a more advanced stage ; the ova are now visible in its interior .
Fig. 15 .
Reproductive capsule still further advanced ; the cellular sac and ramified canals have disappeared , and the ova are now seen lying upon the extremity of the diverticulum , and immediately included within the structureless sac which had been formed upon the outside of the cellular sac .
Fig. 16 .
A more magnified view of an ovum from fig. 15 ; the germinal vesicle has disappeared , and the segmentation of the vitellus has converted the ovum into a mulberry-like mass .
Fig. 17 .
A capsule still further advanced ; the mulberry-like condition has disappeared , and the ova have begun to elongate themselves .
Fig. 18 .
A capsule in a still more advanced stage ; the ova have become still more elongated , and they now present a swarming motion in the interior of the capsule .
Fig. 19 .
Termination of the intra-capsular life of the embryo ; the enclosing sacs have become ruptured , and the embryos are escaping in the form of free ciliated infusoria .
Fig. 20 .
Embryo just after its escape from the capsule , more highly magnified ; it presents an internal closed cavity with ectoderm and endoderm .
Fig. 21 .
The same , showing the pyriform figure which it frequently assumes .
Fig. 22 .
Embryo subsequently to its locomotive stage ; the cilia have disappeared , and it has become permanently fixed by one extremity .
Fig. 23 .
Further progress in the development of the young polype ; the tentacula have begun to bud forth , and the stem is already surrounded by a delicate polypary .
Fig. 24 .
Male capsule with its contents .
a. Capsule with the contents escaping under slight pressure .
b. Caudate cells liberated from the capsule .
c. Spermatozoa .
_l 'Ial .
_7zalDCCC ; LIIIXz/ 6 ' XX XI 12~~~~~~ 0 2~~~~~~~~~~~1 -14~ ~~~~~~~~~ ) 12 J~~~~~ .
xQQ~~~~~~~~~~ &gt; 3 I 2~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~c G. ~ A/ loam .
&lt; Ztl ?
tie ,7~.SYjStr , , , ,0 .

