On the Dissolution of Urinary Calculi in dilute Saline Fluids , at the Temperature of the Body , by the aid of Electricity .
By HENRY BENCE JONES , M.D. , F.R.S. , Physician to St. George 's Hospital .
Received October 12 , -Read December 16 , 1852 .
IN the year 1842 I published a statement of some of the attempts which had been made to dissolve urinary calculi .
I did not then know that MM .
PREVOST and DUMAS had made any researches on this subject .
Some time afterwards I was told that they had used electricity , but I could not obtain the reference to their original paper ; as no practical use was made of their experiments , I did not search for the record of them until after my own experiments were completed .
In 1845 I. first devised the investigation which from circumstances I did not commence until 1848 , when I made some experiments on the solution of uric acid calculi .
It appeared to me not unlikely that when a solution of nitrate of potassa was made to divide into potassa and nitric acid by means of electricity , if a piece of uric acid were held between the electrodes of the galvanic battery , then the potassa at the negative electrode and the nitric acid at the positive electrode would both act on the calculus .
Thus I expected that the fluid about the negative electrode would dissolve the uric acid , whilst the fluid about the positive electrode would decompose the uric acid .
I considered that no great excess of acid or alkali would result , because after passing round the calculus I expected they would recombine , re-forming a neutral solution .
The battery used consisted of six pairs of GROVE'S plates .
The action was continued about four hours .
There was an effect produced on the uric acid at the negative pole , but no very decided result was obtained .
A second experiment gave so little encouragement that for the time the experiments were discontinued .
In the year 1851 I proposed again trying , under the same circumstances , the effect of nitre on uric acid , of sulphate of potash on oxalate of lime , and of lactate of soda on phosphatic calculi .
I was unable to make any experiments until July 1852 , when , through the kindness of Dr. FARADAY , I was allowed to have the use of the batteries at the Royal Institution , and I had the valuable assistance of MrANDERSON , by which the perfect action of these batteries was ensured , On the Solution of Uric Acid Calculi .
After a few prelilninary experiments , on the 3rd of July the first experiment was made ; a piece of very compact uric acid calculus was put into a saturated solution of nitrate of potassa , between the electrodes of a battery consisting of ten pairs of GRovE'S plates .
The fluid soon boiled ; the action was continued between three and four hours , when the calculus was removed .
It was found to be so deeply corroded and worn on both sides , that apparently nearly half the piece of urlic acid calculus was gone ( see Plate XIV .
fig. ( a ) and ( b ) .
The solution of nitre was boiling the whole time .
On the removal of the stone a few drops of the liquid were evaporated , and the evidence of uric acid was most distinct .
The fluid was evaporated to dryness , treated with a drop or two of nitric acid , again evaporated to dryness , and exposed to the fumes of ammonia .
The characteristic reaction of uric acid was obtained .
Hence , by this qualitative experiment , it was certain that at a boiling temperature uric acid between the electrodes could be dissolved in a saturated solution of nitre .
The question immediately arose , what effect would be produced when the solution of nitre was diluted , and when the temperature was about that of the human body .
Experiment 2.-The number of plates in the battery was reduced to one-half in order that the temperature might rise less rapidly .
Only five pairs of plates were used .
Ten cubic inches of saturated solution of nitrewere mixed with thirty cubic inches of distilled water ; the specific gravity of the mixture was 1029 .
The temperature was kept low by changing the solution in which the calculus and the electrodes were placed .
Each glass contained nearly a pint of the solution of nitre .
The piece of calculus weighed 48 grains , and it consisted of very compact uric acid .
The action began at 9h 45m A.M. and was continued to 1 P.M. , the temperature of the solution being between 65 ?
and 108 ? .
The action recoinmenced at 2h 10m P.M. and was continued to 5 P.M. , the temperature being between 65 ?
and 112 ? .
Total time 6h 5M .
The calculus was then removed and perfectly dried in a water-bath .
It was not washed with water , so that some nitre probably remained on the calculus ; when perfectly dry the uric acid weighed 37 grains .
Hence , in six hours at least , 11 grains of uric acid were dissolved .
The solution appeared to take place chiefly at the negative pole .
The nitre solution became very slightly alkaline .
Experiment 3.-I was then anxious to know whether a larger piece of calculus and increased power of the battery would give me a satisfactory result ; the piece of calculus , weighing 113 grains , consisted chiefly of uric acid , but the nucleus was oxalate of lime .
The battery consisted of ten pairs of plates , and the electrodes and solution were the same as in the last experiment .
202 The action began at 10h IOmA .
M. and was continued to 1 P.M. , the temperature of the solution being between 670 and 104 ? .
The action was recormmenced at 211 l0m P.M. and was continued to 5h 30m P.M. , the temperature being between 70 ?
and 108 ? .
Total time 6h lOm .
The calculus was then removed , dried in a water-bath , after which it weighed 99 grs. , so that in six hours about 14 grains of uric acid were dissolved .
The external surface of the calculus which had been in contact with the negative electrode was corroded , whilst the internal surface , which consisted of oxalate of litne and which had been in contact with the positive electrode , was apparently very slightly acted on .
The solution of nitre was much discoloured , and on evaporating , even a few drops , uric acid was immediately detectable .
Experiment 4.-A whole uric acid calculus , weighing 111 grains , was put in a solution of nitre of specific gravity 1024'5 .
Ten pairs of plates were employed .
The action began at 911 35m A.M. and was continued to Ih 5m p.MV .
, the temperature of the solution being between 67 ?
and 100 ? .
The action recommenced at 2h 10"O P.M. and was continued until 5 P.M. , the temperature being from 70 ?
to 102 ? .
Total time 6h 20m .
The calculus when dried weighed 95 grains , so that in little more than six hours 16 grains of uric acid were dissolved .
The solution took place almost entirely at the negative or alkaline electrode .
The solution of nitre became slightly alkaline .
I was now desirlous of trying whether the form of the electrodes at that part which was in contact with the calculus made any perceptible difference .
Instead of a piece of thick platinum wire flattened , of the exact size and form of fig. 2 , the wire was not flattened but only bent back .
The breadth and length of the electrodes was nearly the same as in the previous experiments , but the surface in the former case was continuous , in the latter interrupted by a small space between the bent portions of the wire .
Experiment 5.-A whole calculus , consisting chiefly of uric acid , with a thin external coating of oxalate of limre with a little phosphate of lime , was employed .
It weighed 57 grains .
At first the lower electrode was made positive , and the upper electrode negative .
The power of the battery and the strength of the solution were the same as in the last experiment .
The action began at 911 30m A.M. and was continued to 1 P.M. , the temperature of the solution being between 64 ?
and 110 .
The action recommenced at 2 P.M. , the electrodes were then reversed , the negative being below , and the action was continued to 5 P.M. ; the temperature was from 70 ?
to 120 ? .
Total time 6h 45m .
When dry the stone weighed 45 grains , so that the loss was 12 grains .
Very little action was apparent on the calculus until the alkali was evolved from below .
At five o'clock a voltameter interposed in the circuit showed that 2 cubic inches of mixed gases were produced in three minutes , but at this time the action of the battery was going down .
No deduction could be made as to the influence of the different forms of the electrodes .
Being anxious to know whether increased power of the battery and a better arrangement for keeping the temperature about that of the human body would be attended with advantage , another uric acid calculus was taken .
It was very flat , and had been divided .
The half used weighed 107k grains .
The electrodes were those used in the first experiments .
The portions not in contact with the calculus were covered with glass .
The negative electrode was on the external surface of the stone , and was below .
The solution consisted of the same strength of nitre as before , but to three pints of the solution eight ounces of urine were added ; this being taken as the largest quantity likely to be secreted during the time that the experiment was likely to be continued in the human body .
The battery consisted of twenty pairs of GROVE'S plates .
By means of a siphon leading from the vessel in which the calculus was placed , and by means of a reservoir with a stopcock , a continuous current of the solution was allowed to flow around the stone ; thus the temperature could be most easily regulated .
Experiment 6.-The action began at 91 28m AbM .
, the temperature of the solution then being 64 ? .
At 9h 55m A.M. , the voltameter showed that 1 cubic inch of mixed gases was evolved in thirty-five seconds .
The action was stopped at 12h 45m .
Total time 31 17m .
The calculus when dry weighed 80 grains , so that the loss was 27grains in three hours and a quarter .
There was a deep red stain on the calculus when it was removed from the solution ; this increased on drying , but it was more niarked at the negative than at the positive electrode .
The calculus was partially cut in halves .
( See fig. 3 .
) On the negative electrode there was a deposit , which , when scraped off and examined , proved to be earthy phosphate , probably a deposit from the urine .
The calculus itself on the surface , near the negative electrode , was made white from a slight deposit of earthy phosphate .
The current of the solution of nitre was continuous throughout , and the temperature was kept between 90 ?
and 106 ?
; when the action was stopped , the fluid was still slightly acid from the urine which was originally added .
No other experiments were made with uric acid calculi , so that no deductions have to be made for unsuccessful experiments .
204 The results may be thus arranged : Exp. 1 lasted 4h in saturated solution of nitre , temp. 212 ?
with 10 pairs .
Half dissolved , Exp. 2 lasted 6h 5m " , nitre , { water , average 109 ?
with 5 pairs , 11 grs. dissolved .
Exp. 3 lasted 6h l0m , -nitre , 3 water , average 101 ?
with 10 pairs , 14 grs. dissolved .
Exp. 4 lasted 611 20"1 , nitre , water , average 100 ?
with 10 pairs , 16 grs. dissolved .
Exp. 5 lasted 611 45m , { nitre , water , average 106 ?
with 10 pairs , 12 grs. dissolved .
Exp. 6 lasted 3h 17 " , I nitre , 3 water , average 98 ?
with 20 pairs , 271 grs. dissolved .
So that uric acid calculi can be dissolved in 4 moderately dilute solution of nitrate of potassa at the temperature of the human body , by the aid of electricity , at the rate of from two to nine grains an hour .
SECTION II .
On the Solution of Oxalate of Lime Calculi .
My original conjecture was , that sulphate of soda would prove the best solvent of oxalate of lime .
Having however obtained so good an action on uric acid by a solution of nitre , I determined first to see what the effect of the same solution would he on oxalate of lime .
Experiment 1.-Half a small oxalate of lime calculus , weighing 42*5 grains , was taken .
The battery consisted of only five pair of GROVE'S plates .
The solution of nitre was of the specific gravity 1028 .
The action began at 9h 25m A.M. , the temperature of the solution then was 65 ? .
The action was stopped at 4h 35m P.M. , the temperature never rose above 90 ? .
Total time 7h 10m .
The calculus was then removed and perfectly dried ; it then weighed 42 grains , so that in upwards of seven hours only half a grain was dissolved .
Experiment 2.-The same calculuis , weighing 42 grains , was again placed in the same solution .
The strength of the battery was doubled , being ten pairs .
The action began at 9h 35m A.M. and was continued to 11h 151 P.M. , the temperature of the solution being between 70 ?
and 115 ? .
The action recommenced at 2h 30m P.M. and continued to 5h 50m P.M. , the temnperature being between 75 ?
and 104 ? .
Total time 71 .
For the last two hours there was a great diminution in the power of the battery , The calculus when dry weighed 40 grains , so that in seven hours only 2 grains had been dissolved .
It appeared that the divided surface was the one attacked ; to this the positive electrode had been applied .
Experiment 3.-As the nitre solution had so little action , I proceeded to try the effect of a solution of sulphate of soda .
A solution of sulphate of soda was made , having the specific gravity 1034 .
The battery was of the same strength as in the previous experiment , and the same calculus was used , so that the comparative action of the solution of nitre and the solution 2E2 205 of sulphate of soda might be determined .
The weight of the calculus then was 40 grains .
The action commenced at 911 1Om A.M. and was continued to 1 P.M. , the temperature of the solution being between 64 ?
and 104 ? .
The action recommenced at 2h 5m P.M. and was continued to 4h 30m P.M. , the temperature being between 70 ?
and 102 ? .
TIotal time 6h 15m .
The battery was in good condition throughout the day .
When the calculus was dry it weighed 38 grains , so that in six hours and a quarter only 2 graiens had been dissolved .
Comparing this with the previous experiment , there is no advantage in using the sulphate of soda instead of the nitrate of potash .
I proceeded to try whether a solution of chloride of sodium would be more efficacious than the sulphate of soda or nitrate of potash .
Experiment 4.-The calculus was taken which had already been used in the previous experiments , in order that the comparative result might be as conclusive as possible .
The chloride of sodium was dissolved in undistilled water , and the specific gravity of the solution was 1053*5 .
The battery was of the same strength as before .
The action began at 911 30 " A.m. and was continued to 1 P.M. , the temperature of the solution being between 68 ?
and 108 ? .
The action recommenced at 2h 15m P.M. and was continued to 4h 30m p.M. , the temperature being between 70 ?
and 100 ? .
Total time 5h 45m .
During the whole action much chlorine gas was evolved .
The stone was perfectly bleached in places .
When dry it weighed 37 grains .
In five hours and three quarters only I grain was dissolved ; thus it was evident that a solution of common salt was inferior to a solution of Glauber-salt or of nitre .
In consequence of these experiments , it appeared most desirable to try whether the solution of nitre could be made still more active , either by increasing the strength of the battery , by adding other substances to the solution of nitre , or by increasing the strength of the solution of nitre .
For determining these questions the following experiments were made , Experiment 5.-The battery was increased to double the number of plates ; that is , to twenty pairs .
The calculus was the same as before , and the solution of nitre had the specific gravity 1026 .
The action began at 911 35 A.M. and was continued to 1 P.M. , the temperature of the solution being between 67 ?
and 130 ? .
The action recommenced at 2 P.M. and was continued to 4h 45m P.M. , the temperature being between 70 ?
and 100 ? .
Total time 6h lm .
The action of the battery diminished at one o'clock , so that the full action was only 3h 25 " .
The calculus when dry weighed 32 grains , so that the loss was 6 grains in 6h 1011 .
The solution was chiefly on the cut surface of the calculus , which was in contact with the positive electrode , Thus it appeared that by increasing the intensity of the battery the solution of nitre acted more energetically .
The calculus however was a very small one ; it originally weighed 42T grains only .
One quarter of this however was dissolved .
Experiment 6.-The addition of other substances to the nitre solution was then tried ; and first , phosphate of soda was employed .
To each pint of the nitre solution two ounces of a saturated solution of phosphate of soda were added .
A divided oxalate of lime calculus was taken which weighed 173 grains .
The battery consisted of twenty pairs of plates .
The action commenced at 9h 30m A.M. and was continued to 12h 49M A.M. , the temnperature of the solution being between 66 ?
and 110 ? .
The total time was 3h 19m .
The calculus when dry weighed 172 grains , so that in 311 19m the loss was only I grain .
The calculus was exceedingly compact .
There was no action whatever apparent at the negative or alkaline electrode which was on the upper and cut surface ; the solution was of course alkaline thrugoughout the whole time .
The battery was in excellent action .
Experiment 7.-Two ounces of a strong solution of bichromate of potash were then added to each pint of the nitre solution .
The same calculus was taken ; it weighed 172 grains .
Twenty pair of plates were again used .
The action began at 9h 30m A.M. and was continued to 1211 45m A.M. , the temperature being between 65 ?
and 120 ? .
The total time was 3h 15m .
When the calculus was dry it weighed 170 grains , so that the loss in three hours and a quarter was only 2 grains .
Apparently this was taken from the cut surface of the calculus .
The external surface , which was exceedingly hard , was not attacked , though it was in contact with the positive electrode .
Finding thus no success I returned again to the nitre solution .
Experiment 8.-The solution of nilre was taken of double the strength of that which had previously been used , that is , one-half saturated solution and one-half distilled water .
I was desirous of knowing whether the oxalate of lime would be more soluble in this than in a weaker solution ; the battery and the calculus were the same as before .
The calculus weighed 170 grains .
The action began at 9h 30m A , M. and was continued to 12h 47m A.M. ; the temperature of the solution was between 64 ?
and 110 ? .
Total time was 3h 17m .
When dry the calculus weighed 167 gra t te total loss ins three al lss ihours and seventeen minutes was only 2grains .
There was very slight action on the 207 external surface of the stone which was in contact with the positive electrode .
The cut surface around the nucleus appeared most acted on .
The very frequent changes of the solution consequent on the resistance being lessened , led to the adoption of a continuous stream of solution .
Experiment 9.-It appeared from the last experiment , that by doubling the strength of the solution no corresponding increase in the action on the calculus occurred .
To be still further convinced , the same calculus with the same battery was taken , and a solution was used of only half the strength of the previous one ; that is , it was onefourth saturated solution of nitre and three-fourths water , by means of a small tube siphon which carried off an ounce of fluid in twenty seconds , and a vessel with a stopcock which supplied fresh fluid .
The temperature of the solution in which the calculus was kept remained about 920 , never rising higher than 96 ? .
The action began at 10 A.M. , the temperature then was 64 ? .
The action was stopped at 1211 50M A.M. , the temperature then was 92 ? .
Total time 2h 50m .
The calculus when dry weighed 165 grains , so that in two hours and fifty minutes of continuous action 2 } grains only were dissolved .
By comparing this experiment with the previous one , it is so far certain , that , by increasing the strength of the solution of nitre , no more action on the calculus was obtained .
The next question was whethler , by increasing the strength of the battery , the solution of the oxalate of lime would more rapidly take place .
Experiment 10.-The same calculus was used as before ; it weighed now 165 grains .
The solution of nitre was the same strength as in the last experiment .
The battery was increased to forty pairs of GROVE 's plates .
The temperature was kept down by about six pints of nitre solution , and as the liquid passed out of the decotmposing glass it was cooled by ice , and then returned to the reservoir .
The temperature was thus kept throughout the whole experiment from rising above 1020 ; one ounce ran through in five seconds .
The action began at 911 25m A.M. , the temperature then was 66 ? .
The action began at 9h 47m A.M. A voltameter placed in the circuit showed that 1 cubic inch of mixed gases was evolved in twenty seconds .
The action was stopped at J2 225 A.M. , the temperature throughout was between 98 ?
and 102 ? .
The total time 3h .
The calculus when dried weighed 160 grains , so that the total loss in three hours was only 5 grains .
There were very slight marks of action on the external surface .
The hardness of this surface was between that of fluor and cale spar ; Mr. TENANT placed it for me at 3'5 .
The current was continuous for three hours ; the battery was in perfect order , though diminishing in action towards the end of the experiment .
The result of these experiments with oxalate of lime may be thus arranged : Average temp. Pairs of Grs .
dissolved .
hm plates .
Exp. 1 lasted 7 10 , in solution nitre , 4 water ... 900 51 Exp. 2 lasted 7 10 , in solution ?
nitre , | water ... 104 10 2 Exp. 3 lasted 6 15 , in sulphate of soda ... 101 10 2 Exp. 4 lasted 5 45 , in common salt ... .
102 10 1 Exp. 5 lasted 6 10 , in nitre 4 , water. .
108 20 6 Exp. 6 lasted 3 19 , in nitre with phosphate of soda .
110 20 1 Exp. 7 lasted 3 15 , in nitre 4 with bichrom .
of potassa 111 20 2 Exp. 8 lasted 3 17 , in nitre 1 , water 4 ... 110 20 2 Exp. 9 lasted 2 50 , in nitre - , water ... ... 92 20 2Exp .
10 lasted 3 , in nitre , water ... 100 40 5 Hence oxalate of lime calculi can be only very slowly dissolved in the solution of nitrate of potassa , which acts most energetically on uric acid calculi .
The solution of the oxalate of lime is from Ia grain to 2 grains nearly an hour , so that the action is certainly four times as slow as in the case of uric acid calculi .
Such being the result when the calculus consisted of oxalate of lime only , it appeared desirable to determine what would be the effect when the calculus consisted of oxalate of lime with uric acid , or of oxalate of lime with the earthy phosphates .
Experiment 11.-Half an oxalate of lime calculus , which contained uric acid also on the external surface , weighed 258 grains .
The solution of nitre , consisting of onefourth nitre and three-fourths distilled water , with twenty pairs of plates , was employed .
The action began at 9h 35m A.M. and was continued to 1 P.M. ; the temperature of the solution was between 64 ?
and 120 ? .
Total time 3h 25m .
When dry the calculus weighed 254 grains , so that in three hours twenty-five minutes the loss was 4 grains .
There was very little action on the calculus at the positive or acid electrode .
The negative electrode was in contact with the external surface , and there the action had taken place .
Experiment 12.-The experiment with the same stone was repeated with the same solution and the same strength of battery .
The solution was changed thirty-three times ; the temiperature was 1 0 ?
; the time of action was three hours twenty-three minutes , in which the calculus lost 5 grains .
There was very little action at the positive electrode , but very distinct at the negative electrode , which was on the upper and external surface , Experiment 13.-Another small half calculus , consisting of oxalate of lime and uric acid , weighing 64 grains , was submitted to the action of twenty pairs of plates , whilst in a continuous stream of nitre of the same strength as before .
The action began at 9g 32m A.M , the temperature throughout was from 900 to 980 .
and was stopped at 1211 48m A.M. The total time 3 16.m .
209 ' When dry the stone weighed 60 grains , so that in three hours and a quarter 4 grains were dissolved .
The loss was chiefly on the cut surface , which was in contact with the negative or alkaline electrode .
The surface was not regularly attacked , but some ridges were left , one very distinct , consisting of oxalate of lime .
The external surface was below , and the acid appeared to have little or no effect on it .
It seemed from these experiments that uric acid and oxalate of lime together were more easily dissolved than oxalate of lime alone .
To determine whether oxalate of lime with the earthy phosphates was more soluble than oxalate of lime alone , the following experiments were made .
Experiment 14.-A whole calculus , consisting externally of oxalate of lime with phosphate of lime , weighing 186 grains , was acted on by twenty pairs of plates in the solution of nitre of the same strength as before .
The action began at 9h 30"m A.M. and was continued to 1 P.M. , the temperature of the solution being between 68 ?
and 120 ? .
The action recommenced at 2h 5m P.M. and was continued to 31 35m P.mw .
, the temperature being between 70 ?
and 100 ? .
The total time was 5h .
The last hour there was very little action of the battery .
The calculus when dry weighed 159 grains , so that in five hours 27 grains were dissolved ; the result in this experiment was so much beyond my expectation that the same calculus was again submitted to the same reagents .
Experiment 15.-One grain having been removed for analysis the calculus weighed 158 grains .
The action began at 91 40"m A.M. and was continued to 121 45m A.M. , the temperature being between 650 and 130 ? .
The total time was 3h 5m .
When the calculus was dry it weighed 143grains , so that in three hours and five minutes the calculus lost 14grains .
The result of these experiments withi oxalate of lime and uric acid , and with oxalate of lime and phosphates , may be thus arranged : Average temp. Pairs of Grs .
dissolved .
hm0 plates .
Exp. 11 lasted 3 25 , in solution of nitre - , water .
109 20 4 Exp. 12 lasted 3 23 , in solution of nitre } , water .
110 20 5 Exp. 13 lasted 3 16 , in solution of nitre - , water .
94 20 4 Exp. 14 lasted 5 , in solution of nitre - , water A. 103 20 27 Exp. 15 lasted 3 5 , in solution of nitre 1 , water .
113 20 141Hence the oxalate and urate together can be slowly dissolved in the nitre solution , whilst the oxalate and phosphate together are very rapidly dissolved , namely , at the rate of from 4-L to 51 grains an hour .
It appears then from these experiments that calculi consisting of oxalates with phosphates are very easily dissolved in a dilute solution of nitre at the temperature of the body by the aid of electricity ; but that calculi consisting of oxalates with urates are dissolved with difficulty , whilst calculi of oxalate of lime alone are acted on very slowly .
SECTION III .
On the Solution of Phosphatic Calculi and of Carbonate of Lime .
Having found the solution of nitre so efficacious in its action on uric acid , and as it was at least as good if not better than any other solution in its action on oxalate of lime , it was most desirable that it should be found efficacious in its action on phosphatic calculi .
Experiment 1.-A piece of very hard phosphate of lime calculus , weighing 64 grains , was put into the nitre solution ( one-fourth saturated solution and three-fourths distilled water ) .
A battery of ten pairs of plates was first tried .
The action began at 9h 15m A.M. and was continued until Ih 30m P.M. , the temperature being between 68 ?
and 106 ? .
The action recommenced at 2 P.M , .
and was continued until 5 P.M. , the temperature being between 70 ?
and 106 ? .
The total time was 71 l15 .
The calculus when dry weighed 49 grains .
Hence in seven hours and a quarter 15 grains were dissolved .
The solution took place chiefly at the part in contact with the positive electrode .
Experiment 2.-A divided fusible calculus , weighing 85 grains , was subjected to the action of a battery of twenty pair .
The solution of nitre was the same as before , but to three pints of the solution eight ounces of urine were added , being the quantity , or more than the quantity which would be secreted during the time of the experiment .
The action began at 9h 271 A.M. ; the temperature of the solution was 70 ? .
The action was stopped at 10h 40m A.M. ; the temperature was kept between 90 ?
and 102 ? .
The total time was 1l ' 13m .
The calculus when dry weighed only 54 grains , so that the loss in one hour and thirteen minutes was 31 grains .
The current was continuous throughout .
When the stone had been some time in the liquid , it was taken out with the electrodes still in contact .
It then appeared that the stone had imbibed sufficient water to allow of the action going on through the wet stone without any liquid surrounding it .
Hence probably the very rapid action which took place .
The negative electrode was found to be coated with earthy phosphates .
The solution remained feebly acid throughout .
The positive electrode was below in contact with the external surlface of the calculus which was cut through .
See fig. 4 .
On the Solution of Carbonate of Lime .
Expeiriment 3.-A piece of imarble , weighing 170 grains , was put into the solution of nitre of specific gravity 1026 .
A galvanic battery of ten pairs of plates was employed .
The action began at gh 30n A.M. and was continued until 1 P.M. , the temperature being between 66 ?
and 106 ? .
The action recommenced at 2 P.M. and was continued until 4 P.M. , the temperature being between 70 ?
and 108 ? .
The total time was 5lh .
The piece of marble when dry weighed 142k grains , so that in five and a half hours 271 grains were dissolved .
The solution became slightly alkaline ; the marble was dissolved at the part in contact with the positive electrode .
See fig. 5 .
Experiment 4.-Another mass of marble , with the same battery , was tried in a solution of sulphate of soda , specific gravity about 1034 .
The action began at 9h 30m A.M. and was continued until 1 P.M. , the temperature being between 87 ?
and 100 ? .
Tte action recommenced at 2 P.M. and was continued until 5 P.M. , the temperature being between 100 ?
and 106 ? .
The total time was 61h .
When the marble was dry it weighed 156 .
grains .
Hence in six hours and a half only 4grains of marble were dissolved .
See fig. 6 .
Without doubt the difficult solubility of the sulphate of lime was the cause that hindered the solution of the marble .
The contrast between the solution of nitre and the solution of Glauber-salt is very remarlkable ; the former being seven and a quarter times more efficacious than the latter .
The result of these experiments on the earthy phosphates and carbonate of lime may be thus arranged : Average temp. Pairs of Grs .
dissolved .
hm plates .
Exp. 1 lasted 7 15 in nitre solution ... ... 102 ? ?
10 15 Exp. 2 lasted 1 13 in nitre solution ... .
96 20 31 Exp. 3 lasted 5 30 in nitre solution ... ... 104 10 27 ?
Exp. 4 lasted 6 30 in Glauber-salt ... . .
101 10 42 Hence it is evident that calculi consisting of the earthy phosphates or of carbonate of lime can be most rapidly dissolved in a nearly neutral dilute solution of nitre , at the temperature of the human body , by the aid of the galvanic battery .
Conclusions .
Thus , then , by the aid of electricity , from 2 to 9 grains of uric acid.calculi can be dissolved in an hour , whilst in the same time from 2 to 25 grains of phosphatic calculi can be dissolved in a neutral dilute solution of nitre at the te[nperature of the body .
However , only from half a grain to 2 grains of oxalate of lime can be removed by the same means in the same time .
Still , if the stone consists of oxalate with urate , from 1 to 2 grains may be dissolved in an hour ; and if it consist of oxalate with pllosphate , from 42 to 5grains can be taken away in an hour .
212 Such at least are the results which can be obtained with calculi which have been long removed from the bladder and have been dried at 212 ? .
The harder the calculi the greater the difficulty in dissolving them ; and as previous to their removal from the bladder they are far less hard than they are after they have become dry , and as calculi which are wet may perhaps allow of the passage of the electricity through their substance , instead of only through the surrounding solution , there is good reason to expect that there will be less chemical difficulty in dissolving them in the bladder than out of it .
The skill which has been acquired in catching calculi in the bladder , the art of plating with platinum , the manufacture of vulcanized India rubber , will , with Mr. WEISS 's help , I hope , enable me to state at some future time what can be done in the body as well as out of it .
Looking back now from the results that have been obtained , it appears as if they might have been foreseen .
The uric acid and the phosphatic calculi are produced by the opposite states of over acidity and alkalescence occurring in the urine for a considerable time .
By means of the galvanic battery acting on a saline solution , acid and alkali can be made to appear at any desired spot , in any quantity and for any time .
Thus these opposite conditions may be produced on the surface of the stone at the spot , and only at the spot , where the action is wanted to correct the consequence of too much acidity or alkalescence ; whilst around the place of action an almost neutral solution will remain in contact with the bladder without causing irritation .
I cannot conclude without stating what is due to MM .
PREVOST and DUMAS .
Their note is printed in the Annals de Chemie , vol. xxiii .
p. 202 , 1823 , Sir rEmploi de la Pile dans le traitment des Calculs de la Vessie* .
In this note the mechanical action of the mixed gases ( evolved from the decomposition of water ) on a fusible calculus is stated to have been 12 grains in 12 hours ; twenty-five pairs of plates being used and recharged each hour .
The possibility of dissolving uric acid calculi is rejected , and no mention is made of calculi consisting of oxalate of lime .
In a postscript it is said that the addition of a " certain quantity " of nitre gave , with phosphatic calculi , a better result than when water alone was used .
M. DUMAS appears afterwards to have occupied himself with experiments on the possibility of employing currents of electricity within the bladder of living animals , and not with the determination of the chemical action of substances evolved by the galvanic battery on the surface of different kinds of calculi .
I am indebted to Dr. Du Bois REYMOND for a reference to a paper , vol. i. p. 154 , Oesterrichische Medicinischen Jahrbucher 1848 , On the Effect of Galvanism on Urinary Calculi , by Dr. LUDWIG MELICHER of Vienna .
He has employed the electric current for the electrolysis of the calculus itself , not for setting substances free which can act chemically upon it .
He has made experiments on the living human body in two cases , it is said , with success .
Appendix to a paper on the Solution of Urinary Calculi in dilute Neutral Solutions , by the aid of Electricity .
By HENRY BENCE JONES , M.D. , F.R.S. , Physician to St. George 's Hospital .
Received December 18 , 1852 .
SINCE the original paper was communicated to the Royal Society , it has appeared to me desirable to try whether more dilute solutions of nitrate of potash would have sufficient effect , when the strength of the battery and all other circumstances were the same as in the previous experiments .
The solution of nitre was therefore made to contain only 10 grains of nitre to an ounce of water ; it had a specific gravity of 1015 .
Two ounces of urine were added to three pints of the nitre solution .
A fusible calculus , weighing when dry 352 grains , was placed in this solution between the electrodes of twenty pairs of GROVE 's plates .
The action commenced at 9h 201n A.M. , the temperature being 50 ? .
The action was stopped at 12h 45mA .
M. , the temperatulre being 98 ?
, so that the total time was 3h 231m .
The calculus when dry weighed 324 grains , so that the total loss was 67 grains .
See fig. 7 .
Hence a solution of nitre of one-half the strength of that previously used is suffi-cient when decomposed to dissolve a fusible calculus at the rate of 19 grains an hour .
In order to observe the effect of reducing the strength of the battery when a dilute solution of nitre was employed , another calculus , consisting externally of phosphates , was placed in a solution of nitre , specific gravity 1015 , and this was decomposed by ten pairs of GRoVE'S plates .
The weight of the calculus when dry was 217 grains .
The action began at 9 A.M. , the temperature then being 500 ; at 12h 45mA , M. the action was stopped , the temperature being 98 ? .
The action was recommnenced at 2 P.M. , temperature 60 ? .
It was finally stopped at 4h 45m P.M. , temperature 98 ? .
The total time was 6h 30m .
The solution of nitre did not require to be changed during the whole time , the temperature remaining constant .
After being acted on , the calculus when dry weighed 197 grains , so that the total loss was 20 grains .
Hence in twice the time not one-third of the effect shown in the previous experiment was obtained , though this was chiefly owing to the diminished power of the battery , yet the greater hardness of the calculus used in this last experiment no doubt influenced the result .
I then proceeded to try the effect of the dilute solution of nitre on a uric acid calculus .
214 A u ric acid calculus , weighing 403 grains , was placed in a solution of nitre , specific gravity 1015 , which was decomposed by twenty pairs of GROVE'S plates .
The action commenced at 8h 561A.M .
, temperature being 50 ? .
The action was stopped at 12h 45mA .
M. temperature being 98 ? .
The action recommenced at 2 P.M. , temperature 520 .
Finally stopped at 4h 41m p.M. , temperature being 97 ? .
Hence the total time was 6h 30m .
The calculus when dried weighed 381 grains , so that the total loss was 22 grains , or about 3A grains each hour .
See fig. 8 .
It appears then from this experiment that the effect on a uric acid calculus , when a dilute solution of nitre is employed , is less than one-half of the effect produced when a solution of nitre of double the strength is used .
From these experiments , it is evident that phosphatic and uric acid calculi can be dissolved in a very dilute solution of nitrate of potash , but the weaker the solution the longer the time required to obtain equal results .
Lastly , an experiment made on an undried phosphatic calculus , fresh from the bladder , showed that the action on the wet calculus was more rapid than when it was previously dried ; but the nature of the experiment does not admit of a numerical statement of the result .
See fig. 9 .
The electrodes in this experiment were much longer than those previously used .
The mechanical difficulties in making an instrument ( litholyte ) to be used in the body have not yet been completely overcome .
It is essentially requisite in such an instrument , First .
That the insulation should be perfect , in order that the chemical action may be transferred to the surface of the stone .
Secondly .
That no chemical action should be set up on the surface of the bladder or the urethra , whereby the mucous membrane might be injured .
Thirdly .
It may be necessary that a double passage for the injection of the solution of nitre should exist , in order to keep down the temperature and to admit of the escape of the gas evolved in the bladder .
Already many instruments have been made for me by Mr. WEIss , yet hitherto a perfectly safe one has not enabled me to make experiments on the solution of calculi within the body .
215 Representing the exact size of the calculi and the extent of action .
Fig. 1 ( a ) .
Uric acid before it was acted on .
( b ) .
The same after action .
Fig. 2 .
The electrodes of the exact size and shape used .
Fig. 3 .
Uric acid calculus acted on in the nitre solution .
Fig. 4 .
Phosphatic calculus in the same solution .
Fig. 5 .
Piece of marble in solution of nitre .
Fig. 6 .
Piece of marble in solution of Glauber-salt .
Fig. 7 .
Phosphatic calculus in a more dilute solution of nitre .
Fig. 8 .
Uric acid calculus in a more dilute solution of nitre .
Fig. 9 .
A calculus as moist as when taken from the bladder , acted upon in nitre with larger electrodes .
raw.d M )CDCCCLLIlIP XI .
Fig , ). .
' ... Fig. , Fg .
, la " 1C ) [ I I. Fg .
14 , Fig. 4- .
fi .
7 .
frtOafm .
M 'e !
/F , r J s , A T S. .
&gt; rtez-z/ hy Ji . ?
: B.2 .
/ : i : Il'I U. Si .
, , ... .

