Analytical Researches connected with STEINER'S Extension of MALFATTI'S Problem .
By ARTHUR CAYLEY , M.A. , Fellow of Trinity College , Cambridge .
Com.municated by J. J. SYLVESTER , Esq. , F.R.S. Received April 12 , -Read May 27 , 1852 .
THE problem , in a triangle to describe three circles each of them touching the two others and also two sides of the triangle , has been termed after the Italian geometer by whom it was proposed and solved , MALFATTI'S problem .
The problem which I refer to as STEINER'S extension of MALFATTI'S problem is as follows:- " ' To determine three sections of a surface of the second order , each of them touching the two others , and also two of three given sections of the surface of the second order , " a problem proposed in STEINER'S memoir , 'Einige geometrische Betrachtungen , ' Crelle , t. i , The geometrical construction of the problem in question is readily deduced from that given in the memoir just mentioned for a somewhat less general problem , viz. that in which the surface of the second order is replaced by a sphere ; it is for the sake of the analytical developments to which the problem gives rise , that I propose to resume here the discussion of the problem .
The following is an analysis of the present memoir:41 .
Contains a lemma which appears to me to constitute the foundation of the analytical theory of the sections of a surface of the second order .
§ 2 .
Contains a statement of the geometrical construction of STEINER'S extension of MALFATTI'S problem .
§ 3 .
Is a verification , founded on a particular choice of coordinates , of the construction in question .
§ 4 .
In this section , referring the surface of the second order to absolutely general coordinates , and after an incidental solution of the problem to determine a section touching three given sections , I obtain the equations for the solution of STEINER'S extension of MALFATTI'S problem .
4 5 .
Contains a separate discussion of a system of equations , including as a particular case the equations obtained in the preceding section .
44 6 and 7 .
Contain the application of the formulae for the general system to the equations in § 4 , and the development and completion of the solution .
§ 8 .
Is an extension of some preceding formulae to quadratic functions of any number of variables .
Lemma relating to the sections of a surface of the second order .
if ax2+ by2+ cz2+ dw2+2fyz +2gzx+2hxy+2lxw +2myw +2nzw= 0 be the equation of a surface of the second order , and %x2+)3y2+-Cz2+)w2 ?
2J ?
+2'zx+21ix+2JLxw +2*yw+2Xzw=0 the reciprocal equation , the condition that the two sections Xkx +bPy +YZ +gw =0 X'x+#y+vz+g/ w=O kx'y + Y'Z + ?
'w= O may touch , is ~~~~~ +jp+,20 , vX+2I , +2L~ T~ J ( t2+ 2+e12+jjp1 2+( V2+ 3De1 26+De2g2+ gi )l ; X ( 2X'2 ?
BL/ 2+XVP'2+ P !
2 + 2fJ &gt; +20 X++2U1X't ' +2U ' ?
' + 2pgJP ' ?
+ 2'Q+ )-')i = ( Cx ' ?
+3d ' + v++ +D &amp; + J( ' ?
' 'v ) +g ( vXP + S)t+(y +()+L( ) + ; fl(0 ?
, + Pg ) + jD+(Vg+ V ' ?
) ) And in particular if the equation of the surface be ax2+ +b2+ cz2+2fyz + 2gzx+2hxy+pw2= 0 the condition --of contact is ( 42 f2$2+C 2 ?
22+2If &gt; 'v'+ 2tv'X'+2kLX ' .
+KP2)3 = ( Ax'+ v ' + sPP'+ Jr(TV'+ ( .,4 ) +@ Qv'X'+v'X ) + Lp ( xd ' ?
x '~ ) +P g ' ) , in which last formula ~=bc.-f2 23 B=ca_ g2 , i abh2 , Jf=ghaf , @=hf-bgI =fig.ch , , K_1 abcaf2 bg2 -ch2+2gh .
§ 2 .
In order to state in the most simple form the geometrical construction for the solution of STEINER'S extension of MALFATTI'S problem , let the given sections be called for conciseness the determninators * ; any two of these sections lie in two dif .
ferent cones , the vertices of which determine with the line of intersection of the planes of the determinators , two planes which may be termed bisectors ; the six bisectors pass three and three through four straight lines ; and it trill be convenient to use the term bisectors to denote , not the entire system , but any three bisectors passing through the same line .
Consider three sections , which may be termed tactors , each of them touching a determinator and two bisectors , and three other sections ( which may be termed separators ) each of them passing through the point of contact of a deterrminator and tactor and touching the other two tactors ; the separators will intersect in a line which passes through the point of intersection of the determinators .
The three required sections , or as I shall term them the resultors , are determined by the conditions that each resultor touches two determinators and two separators , the possibility of the construction being implied as a theorem .
The a posteriori verification may be obtained as follows ?
3 .
Let x=( , y=O , z=O be the equations of the resultors , w=O the equation of the polar of the point of intersection of the resultors .
Since the resultors touch two and two , the equation of the surface is easily seen to be of the form 2Yz+2 ; zx+2xy+w2-0* .
The determinators are sections each of th em touching two resultors , but otherwise arbitrary ; their equations are -ax+ +1 += ox-13i +2x +w=0 2j-x+-2y-y +W=0 .
The separators are sections each of them touching two resultors at their point of contact ( or what is the same thing , passing through the line of intersection of two resultors ) , and all of them having a line in common .
Their equations may be taken to be y-b .
0 , az-cx=0 bx-ay=O , the values of a , b , c remaining to be deternined .
Now before fixing the values of these quantities we may find three sections each of them touching a determinator at a point of intersection with the section which corresponds to it of the sections cy-bz=0 , az-cx=0 , bx-ay=0 , and touching the other two of the last-mentioned sections ; and when a , b , c have their proper values the sections so found are the tactors .
For , let Xv+ pie +vz+gw=0 be the equation of a section touching the determinator -ax+ y+-z+w=O , and the two sections bx-ay=0 , az-cx=0 , and suppose A2-X2+2+ -y-2yg 2 ?
p 2 ' , the conditions of contact with the sections bx-ay=0 , az-cx=0 are found to be ( b+a)A=(b+a)X-(b+a)p(b-a &gt; ) ( c~a)A= ( c+a)X-(c-a)fp-(c+a)P , values , however , which suppose a correspondence in the signs of the radicals .
Thence 2i56 MR. A. CAYLEY'S ANALYTICAL RESEARCHES CONNECTED WITH ( b+a)pj=(c+a)v ; or since the ratios only of the quantities X , d , v , f are material , th=c+a , P=b+a , and therefore A2= 22(2a+b+c)2 , +(bC)2-2e= ( X-b-c)2 or 2= 2 ( ax+bc ) .
Whence the equation to a section touching bx-ay=0 , az-cx=0 is Xx+(c+a)y+(b+a)z+V-2(aX+bc ) lw=0 .
And to express that this touches the determinator in question , we have + ?
( X-b-c)= ( 4+a)-(z(2a+b+c)+2V-2(ax+bc ) ; and selecting the upper sign , -X-2a &amp; =-2 -2( ) whence ?
=-24(a &amp; -V-2hc),./ -2(aX+bc ) = ( 2am-V2bc ) ; or the section touching the determinator and the sections bx-t-y=O , azcx=O is -2a(az-V-2bc ) +(c+a)y+(b+a)z+(2am-V--2bc)w=0 ; and at the point of contact with the determinator 2.yz + 2zxY + 24xy + w= 0 2.yz+2 x+2 q+w20O .
Eliminating w between the first and second equations and between the second and third equations , V-2bc( x+F ?
y++-z +cy+bz=O , ( oax +y ) +2yz=-0 ; and from these equations ( cy-bz)2=O , or the point of contact lies in the section c ?
-bz=0 .
It follows that the equations of the tactors are -2m(ao- &lt; 26c)x+ ( c+a)y+ ( b+a)z+(2ae-A2bc)w=0 ( c-4b)x-213(b1 V-2ca)+ ( a+b)z+(2b3-V-.-2ca)w=0 ( b+c)x+(a+c)y-27(cyV-2ab)z+(2cy-V'-2ab)w=0 , where a , b , c still remain to be determined .
Now the separators pass through the point of intersection of the determinnators ; the equations of these give for the point in question , ::Y : z : W=_ ( 2ry+ 1)(c &amp; a4+ry+2c3y ) : 320r2- .
1 ) -+ez -2+P2+r2 ; and the values of a , b , c are therefore a In c=(2f rb1)(-+I+r2fy):(2rx+l1)(c-As+r+2c43):(2 ap+ l ) ( + fge+ 2y ) which are to be substituted for a , b , c in the equations of the separators and tactors respectively .
Now proceeding to find the bisectors , let Xx+ pie +vz+gw=O be the equation of a section touching the determinators , x-,3W y+ Iz+w=O , 2y+2yY-yz+w=O .
And suppose , as before , A2=x2+ 2 +2_ 2pv-20x2\p22 , the conditions of contact are ?
f3L~f3X(3+X &gt; +p4+-2g +pr 7x+rx7 yy)-where it is necessary , for the present purpose , to give opposite signs to the radicals .
For if the radicals had the same sign , it would follow that or the equation xx+ pie +yz+gw=O would pass through the point I122 x:y:z : W=0 ; ' or the section would be a tangent section of the two determinators of the same class with the resultor =0 , which ought not to be the case .
The proper formula is ~[i~ ( 3+/ &gt; ?
I3v-+p-2 ] +1[ry+yr ( r+DY-2 ] =0 .
And this equation being satisfied , the section Xx+PyYvz+gw=0 passes through a point 1122 x : y : z : w=2:-2P -~72 --a The bisector passes through this point and the line of intersection of the determinators ; its equation is 3(2x-PY ?
+ w ) -x+,24z-+w/ z ) =0 ; or reducing and completing the system , the equations of the bisectors are 2Y +2 Z+ -(1 22 Z+( +20X ) ( 2 p2-2 ) + ai W =0-~ 2-/ ~~ 2L And in order to verify the geometrical construction , it only remains to show that each bisector touches two tactors .
Consider the bisector and tactor ( 1+ 2x+ ( 1+2-a.Y+(21 / ( IjI 1I -2 &amp; ( am , --V-2bc)x+ ( c+a)y+ ( b+a)z+ ( 2a-4V-2bc~w=n ; and represent these for a moment by Xx+ Pie +vz+ ?
w=O , X'+P'y+vz+ew=O .
If A be the same as before , and A ' the like function of I ' , Ac , y ' , a also if ( D XXI f+ pip , p-v'+ p'v)-(A+A xtV)_ then A2= 2+ A2= _(2z22aV-2bc+b+c)2 , 2a ( 2 Jr -92a_ 2M-2 bc ( 2+ ; a c( +p and the condition of contact AA'=(D ( taking the proper sign for the radicals ) becomes ( 2+ ; I- , ( 2ae8-2aV---2bc fb+c)=ao ?
( a ) 22+a 2a.2(c2+_2 or reducing , aa-bt+c2a3 +=I An equation which is evidently not altered by the interchange of a , a and be P. The conditions , in order that each bisector may touch two tactors , reduce themselves to the three equations , ace-b3+2 = ?
a 2S+1 +2-cy1O , -aa+ b ++cfy=O , which are satisfied by the values above found for the quantities a , b , c. The possibility and truth of the geometrical construction are thus demonstrated .
4 .
Let it be in the first instance proposed to find the equation of a section touching all or any of the sections x=O , y=o , z=0 of the surface of the second order , a2+ ax ' + by cz2+ 2jS +2gz+2 hxy f pw2 =0 Any section whatever of this surface may be written in the form ( aX+k+gv+ + ( kx+ &lt; bp+fGd+( ?
+ cv)z +-p7~Wo , where v2= aX2+ b 2+ cv2 § 2fi.w+ 2gv X+ 2h xjK , where X , o , v are indeterminate .
And considering any other section represented by a like equation , ( aX'+ hp ' +gv')x+ ( hx ' + bth'+fJV)y+ ( gX ' +fr ' + cy ' ) z+V-pv'w =0 , where V'= aX'2+ bW2h+ c P2r+ fh'V + 2g ' X ' +2 hX'1.d K , it may be shown by means of the lenmma previously given , that the condition of contact is aXX'+ bpy , + cvv'+fQ~v + p'v ) +lg(vX ?
'+v'x ) + hkQE ' +x ' ' ) ?
K =VV ' Suppose that X ' , ji , ' , V satisfy the equations hxl-b .
, I~y~ .
I~A'+bp " -fv'0 , gx +f4+ cy ' =o , so that the last mentioned section becomes x0 ; and observing that the first of the above equations may be transformed into K csX ' + hlp ' +gv'= j it is easy to obtain X'=A/ v , c'= v / .
The condition of contact becomes K 0 , ,+ K =O .
And taking the under sign , x=V , / , so that if in the above written equation we establish all or any of the equations X=A- ' , V5/ we have the equation of a section touching all or the corresponding sections of the sections x=0 , y=0 , z=0 .
In particular we have for a solution of the problem of tactions , the following equation of the section touching x=0 , y=O , z=O , viz. ( aV !
+ hkV +gVX)x+ ( hkV + bVY6+fVi)y+ ( gV +fiJ/ 3+ cV L)z + XA/ 2 ( A/ Bi ; iF ) ( V'AL - ) ( A/ - ) ) w =O .
Anticipating the use of a notation the value of which will subsequently appear , or putting f= V/ W -jF , gV RC0 , h =/ V23V - ) , J= V24/ B , values which give 2_f4_ 44 2f 2 ~~~~4f2geh2 K2=-_f4-g4h4+2g2h2+2h2f 2+f2g2_ -Jthe equation of the section in question is f Sf 2 +2 +_ 2_ fght)V + ff2_Z..2ih2\i U_ 22 0J proceed to investigate a transformation of the equation for the section with an indeterminate parameter X , which touches the two Sections y=O , z=O .
We have av2= ( tAX+k{t+g )2+ ( 4t~ral2 Fw~v2-2t &gt; )C+jT2 ; or putting for p and v their values */ B , ; in the second term , -~ ~~ av=a +hgy)2 + ( ; or introducing instead of X an indeterminate quantity X , such that a ?
+hk rgv= ( VB-4t)X we have aV2 =( s/ 9s-JFos/ I + X2 L Also introducing throughout X instead of X , and completing the substitution of C/ for th , v , the equation of the section touching y=- , z=O , becomes ( a+h ry~ z)X y +S/ i X2.w=0 .
And it may be remarked in passing , that this is a very convenient form for the demonstration of the theorem ; " If two sections of a surface of the second order touch each other , and are also tangent sections ( of the same class ) to two fixed sections , then considering the planes through the axis of the fixed sections and the poles of the tangent sections , and also the tangent planes through this axis , the anharmonic ratio of the four planes is independent of the position of the moveable tangent sections ; " where by the axis of the fixed sections is to be understood the line joining their poles .
The sections touching z=0 , x=O , , and v=0 , y=O , are of course xV +(h +ky+fz)Y+zV1+V =bpVI+Y2.w=0 wx / +y\/ + ?
( gx+fy+Cz)Z+V c+ Z0w here h4'+ bI+fyt(s-@ tA= d -'=t2 The conditions of contact of the sections represented by the above written equations would be perhaps most simply obtained directly from the lemnma , but it is proper to deduce it from the formula for contact used in the present memoir .
If for shortness di= aX'X"+bri4 .
' , +cv'v"fQi " 2( , ; t+M8v')+g(v ' " +v " ' ) +k(k 'p +Xttp/ ) ?
K , where the symbol &lt; ( + ) is used in order to mark the essentially different character of the results corresponding to the different values of the ambiguous sign , then bcD(- ) =f(hkx +bk +fv ' ) ( etA " +ft"+cP ) , + ( MPJI'-I])x " ) ( IzX + bth+fV ' ) +V'P"'(9f ) +vX Affi +CV )O GK -fK .
-f(hx ' + bi'+fJ ' ) ( gX " +1(1 + cP " ) + VAIi(V~( &amp; 0 ) ( gx"+fri'+ cvO ) + v'S(VA/ -Ii)(hk ' + bz+ffi ' ) Mf(hx ' +p ' +fy ' ) ( g ; " +Of " + cV " ) + VI(x/ 'M 0 ) ( gJ ' +ffpW+ cv " ) +v'/ ( VI 3 -a ) ( hi ?
' + by ] +fv ' ) -fvs-)v -0 7.e .
bc(-)= ( VI-)(V 3 1 ) ) { f YZ+V ( Y+Z)-f } What , however , is really required* , is the value of cl(+ ) ; to find this , bccP(+ ) =bc ?
( - ) +2bcK ( V+ 2 9 ) ( Vac -i ) { fYZ+V(Y+Z ) +f the second line of which is -2( V(c-(@)(/ )Z where and consequently bcP(+ ) = ( V~a-@ ) ( AA -a ) f YZ + VA(Y + Z ) +f+ 2 '/ 2 } , a reduction , which on account of its peculiarity , I have thought right to work out in full .
The condition of contact is P ?
( + ) =V'V"= v 'i-5 )(V / 3 i2f +YVb ez2 .
Or finally , the condition in order that the sections xVZ +(hx+by+fz)Y ?
+ &lt; zV ?
/bpil I +Y2w =0 xVV ?
+yVj+(gx+ fie +cz)Z+ ?
cpx1 +Z2w=0 ( the former of which is a section touching z=0 , =0 , and the latter a section touching x=O , y=O ) may touch , is f YZ+VX(Y+Z ) + ( f+20O/ 7 ) -Vbcv ' +Y211 +Z20 .
The preceding researches show that the solution of STEINER'S extension of MALFATTI'S problem depends on a system of equations , such as the system mentioned at the commencement of the following section .
Consider the system of equations a+P(y+Z)+ryZ+YVI +y2X ' +Z2_0 ez +p/ ( Z+X)+yIZX+'vlf+Z2vl+X2=O M ' +PfY(X+Y ) +ryfXY+ + VI +X2 , i +y2=0 .
These equations may , it will be seen , be solved by quadratics only , when the coefficients satisfy the relations rI/ r =-1=II 177 I2 +y 72_2 132 +y'2l2 1312 ?
v/ 12 &amp; 112 72_a 12 112 112 equations which it should be remarked are satisfied by 0=0 , P -0 , Pff=0 , ty=65 'Ifb y " y " Or if we write the equations become by a simple reduction , Y2+Z2 ?
21lYZ=1l2_ Z2+X2+2mZX=m21 X2+y+2 X_2 X2Y+2nXY=n_ 1 which are equivalents to the equations discussed in my paper " On a System of Equations connected with MALFATTI'S Problem and on another Algebi'aical System , " Cambridge and Dublin Mathematical Journal , t. iv .
p. 270 ; the solution might have been effected by the direct method , which I shall here adopt , of eliminating any one of the variables between the two equations into which it cuters , and combining the result with the third equation .
Writing the second and third equations under the form A'+B'X+C'V1 X2=o A"+B"X+C"VI1 +X2=o , the result of the elimination may be presented in the form A'A43+B'B " 3 CC " 1A'2.+B-2_ C12/ A'"2+B'2 -C"2 , which is most easily obtained by writing X= tan p and operating with the symbol cos- ; but if the rationalized equations be represented by X'+ 2tX+ VYX2= 0 and X"+ 2pb"X+ y"X2=0 , the form 4(x-t 12 ) ( Xllyff_ f/ 2 ) =(XIVII k &gt; -2d ) leads easily to the result in question .
The values which enter are A ' = ' ?
f30'Z A " = rxt'+i3"Y B'z='+r'Z B"=1"+r"1Y C't'\7 1+Z2 C " " Vi +Y2 ; whence , in the first place , by the equation connecting Y , Z , C'C"= ( Y+Z)+ WZ It is obviously convenient that A'A"+B'B " should be symmetrical with respect to Y and Z , and this will be the case if x ' !
3"+131r " =t"P'+t3"r ' , i. e. if '(yf-atI ) " ( 7'-i ' ) .
Or assuming that the equations are symmetrically related to the system , we have the first set of relations between the coefficients , relations which are satisfied by and the values of &amp; , &amp; , ' a " will be considered henceforth as given by these conditions .
We have A'A"t+ B'B"'C'C"= o ' &amp; '+P'P " +( r'13y"+rt3'+ 2tpj3'X( ) ( Y+Z ) + ( I3 !
3"+r'rrI)YZ +-8 -M+j3(Y+Z)+rY~Z } .
The quantities A'2+B'2-C'2 , A"2+B"2C " are quadratic functions of Z and Y respectively , and with proper relations between the coefficients , we may assume ( A'2+B'2C2 ) ( A"2+1B"2 C"2 ) =12s2{U2+k[(a+@(Y+Z ) +7YZ ) _2(j +Y2)( I +Z2 ) ] } in which U is a linear function of Y+Z and YZ , and k and Is are constants .
The first side must , in the first place , be symmetrical with respect to Y and Z , or 1,2 + P2 , _ 12 ( at + y1)P ' P toe+ rry _ Of2 must be proportional to 112 + ( 12 _f ( z " 4 r")3 ' ( 3 112 4 r"2 _ 3jI2 But since are proportional to 7t_ 2 212_ 2 it is only necessary that 3124+ V2 f2j ( 3124+ .
12 -11 should be proportional to 712 _d~ 72 a1_ g2 , Or since the equations are supposed symmetrically related to the system , we must have the second set of relations between the coefficients .
Suppose 2 ?
ryp t2 p'2 ?
r'2..2 P"2+V'2 -a"2 _.p =~.2 . ?
2 = ry &lt; 2-c12 =o then since r2 a= r4 ( ry + I3 ) f3 , &amp;c. , , we have 2 =32 +r2 -4s(y + p1 ) 812 t.(12 +r2.-4s(r'+p3')f3 ' bJ12 _ INt + ( / 1r 4 ( r/ + po3 ) of and Y , b ' , ' " will be supposed henceforth to satisfy these equations .
We have next A'2 +132 _ Cf2=4(V+p13')p'(s+p+Z+.VZ2 ) A"2+ Bt"2-C"2= 4(7V1 +'p )3"(s+p+Y+sY2 ) which may be simplified by writing where p , v are to be considered as given functions of s and p. These values give A'2 +B'2 -C'2 =4(V/ +p ' )3s(Z+p)(Z+v ) A"12+B112C12=4(VI ' + ppg )3"ts ( Y+.a ) ( Y+ ) .
Hence , putting for simplicity 12= 4(V+'p13 ' ) ( V'+ ppf3")3'3 " we have 4(Z+ ?
) ( Z+v)(Y+p)(Y+Y)=U2+k[(cz+f(Y+Z)+ryYZ)2_-2(1 +y2)(l +Z2 ) ] , And the two sides have next to be expressed in terms of Y+Z and YZ .
If for symmetry we write t=1 , =-1Y+Z , 4=YZ , then 4( ( y2+C~+ +4 ) +kt2[(t--)2+ &amp; 1S = U2+ k(4+I3a , +r)2 .
And U is now to be considered a linear function of , , , The condition that the first side of the equation may divide into factors , gives an equation for determining k , since the condition is satisfied for k=O and k= oo , the equation will be linear , and it is easily seen that the value is k=-v)2 .
In fact = ( 2p+ ( p+ v ) , + 24)2+ ( 0)2( +4)2 Hence { 2Svy+(pQ+Y)4+2_}2 U= K2){ ( 2 2 And we may assume 2pvE+ ( p +v)nw+2 + U= A{ oEiwy ) ( + ) } 2p d+(p+Y)4+2t-U -vl{( E~p + 4)+8(f subject to its being shown that 4pj4+2(p+0n)+4t=6 8 ^A oa18y)A-')(+4 gives a constant value for A. The comparison of coefficients gives 4pjy=F ( A+X)0 ( a A } 2(+2v= 1 ( A+1 ) 4= -{A+ X ( A X 1 ) the first and third of which give which will be identical with the second , if 2(1 -pv ) __2p which follows at once from the equation 1 ?
Ihp Forming next the two equations A+1 2(+)12 A-H= ( ( k-v)f3{(P+v)y-2I3 } these will be equivalent to a single equation if ( ( , ,+V)2 2= { ( p'+p)r-2PI}2+ ( p( _ ) f3 i. e. if ( io+v)2b2= ( p+p)2(f2+r2 ) _4 b4 +v)Y3r4(v-1 )032 ; or finally , if 2_32+= 2 4s2 ( Up 7 &gt; 3 ) =p2+y2 _4s(y+@p)p3 which is in fact the case .
Writing the equations for A+1 , A- ' in the form +1 A2( ]i ( -2v)f3s &amp; -2f3s ) , and substituting in U-T{(A-k)(A++3'+y4)we have U= ; p{ ( y2js ) ( oa ?
134 ?
) _ 2(n+ ) } =sg{ lt(-I3+2sy+2 r ) + ( 7-21s3)4+(-P3+ 2sy+ 4sop3 ) } .
And consequently , multiplying by Is=-2s , -/ ( 7 ' + 01 ' ) ( y " , + pp3 " ) ' PIP ) we have A'2+B'2C12\/ Ah !
2+B"12C"12 = 8s(7l +@@dl ) ( +i3 +2s7 +22y ) + ( 7-22s83)4+ ( -f3+2sy+ 4sP3 ) } , or collecting the different terms ( d &amp; s '+P't")a+ ( / 3 " +y"I ' + 2pjY3'")4 ?
( 13'13 " + / V'y ) 4+-'-(c ?
34+ y4 ) 2 { ( -13+2sy+2py)f+(r-2sP ) ; 7+(-,3+2sy+4s@p)0 =0 , which , combined with the first equation written under the form ( Ma+p4+yr)2 b2[(_ C)2+42 ] =0 determines the ratios of X , , C , i. e. the values of Y+Z and YZ . ?
6 .
The system of equations ( f'+2 dV/ f + VI(Y +Z ) +fYZ 1+ / 2+y2=0 ~~~~~~~~~~~Z , I +X20 ( g+20V 3)+V'3(Z+X ) +gZX-N/ casi +Z201 +X20 ( h+20d/ V)+V &amp; ( X+Y)+hXYVa / 1 +X2V+Y2_0 , where 0=k(V +V vL on which depends the solution Of STEINER'S extension Of MALFATTI'S problem , is at OnCe Seen tO belOng tO the ClaSS Of equations treated Of in the PreCeding section , and we have p=d , s=O .
The equations at the conclusion of the preceding section become { VM3+gh+2O(gVs+hV'3)+442V3s}a+ { gVZ+h7B+2073C}8+ { VM3+gh } 2a [ ( f+u 20V ~+V/ Z+ffl]-^/ hcV(g+O &gt; / B ) ( h+OV/ s ) / M ( V/ 2-2of )E-I4 +jrs2 =0{ ( f+2OV !
)M+Vf/ A+fA}2bc{( -4 )2+n2 } =0 , which may also be written ( '/ ii+ , ; W ) ( E + 4 ) + ( aV/ ?~f+gV/ O+hs/ 3 +2OV/ ?M ) ( w+2Ot ) V -(g+OVI)(h+ )V , V bc}2 )c{ =0 { e+ )+ Ji+ 2 d ) }2_ bc{ ( E )2+ 2 } _0 .
Or observing that g+ % Ov~=(v's+T ) ( ja+I ) ; h+0/ s=K(/ B+ &gt; f ) ( vkQ+'6 ) a Va+ hk/ +gV ' + 2O V ?
= O(VC+1T)5 and putting for a moment and therefore V(g+Ov"B ) ( h+aV/ P)V= ( UM +~flx , the first equation divides by ( Vs33+1f ) , and the result is ( ffi+0 +O(n+2Ov ) bC{V2(i+4 ) -f &amp; ( +20 ; ) } =0 .
And by an easy transformation the second equation becomes { V !
( A+t ) r)-An(+204 ) }2 J 4bct ( g+ t ) +0(n+2d%)-(j1 + d2)0)=_ Or putting *VbC/ ( +4 ) -fQ+20ff))= P the equations become ^ai ( D2+4T{0 ?
( 1 +2O)f}=O .
Whence eliminating D , ( 2)I+02)(I ?
02)(1 1 ?
02 ) or observing that 1+02= ) and reducing , K2 ?
{ _ _._j ( A/ ta + 0 ) A/ 903)(*/ i + T ) ) K -/ 2LC , Also ?
-2 ?
4P gives K§ 2V(/ ( 7+0)( VAB+P ) VISO Suppose v'O +~ff , VB-f~o o. ctza=Ka V/ 6k ?
@=13 , V/ S-@3=i31 13/ 1==Kb V/ 2+3 + 7r , V13S-T= , ry , =Kc ; then substituting 4bc _ eV ; that is , 4/ 2 V/ a +aI{V(f+ ) f(+2O ) } 4bc(a +a , ) IA/ _ , ___ which may be written L0+ M ; ;+N 4=O L'E+M ' ; +N'f= 0 , where L=1+202V2V ( V/ 22f ) M=d+ N=1I Lb(a+a , ) V ) Ma N=1 Or since , - , 1 are equal to 1 , Y+Z , YZ respectively , I:Y+Z:YZ=MN'-M'N:NL'-N'L:LM'-L'M 4bc(a~a , ) A V/ a~al alVA2)(/ +iaVE~~~~~~r , ~ ~ f+ OVI ) 2 V/ a~a , } V~,7)JV ) 4bc(a+a)Q ?
/ A/ af+a ( 0 ) a/ 2 / a +af I -7 f Also K f3 , Kbc whence +z _2 4/ 2 V/ a2 +a ' ) -0 %/ A/ o3ey / a 29-o fie Yz 2 / 2 VA/ + av/ Ql V/ ?I af 1And by forming the analogous expressions for Z4-X and ZX , X+Y and XY , the values of X , Y , Z may be determined , But the equations in question simplify themselves in a remarkable manner by the notation before alluded to .
Suppose f= , / // BDf , g= / B v7D , h=-/ CVV/ i ?
, J=V2/ / , these values give KV/ g 2f 2(1- ; ~ ) _J2 K I~c ~ / /=2gh J2 Kf 2g2h2 K~ =f2-g2_h2+ 2g KO -f2_ -g2-h2 2J2 K2 =-f -g4-h4 +2g2h2+2 h112f2 +2 f 2g2 _4fg2h Applying these results to the preceding formulw and forming for that purpose the equations V2Va + J2 Vo2 f 2s/ 2Vc~o , Vf3y,4gh , v'-s/ gh ' 4a7J ghK0+ , Kf= ( J2_ gh ) ( f 2 ( gh)2 ) -2gh(g-h)2 , we have K(Y+Z)+2K0=4(J2-gh)(l -j K2YZ+K2 =4{ ( J2_gh)(f 2_ ( g-h)2 ) -2gh(g-h)2 } ( j ) ; the former of which , combined with the similar equations for Z+X and X+Y , gives for X , Y , Z the values to be presently stated , and these values will of course verify the second equation and the corresponding equations for ZX and XY .
Recapitulating the preceding notation , if x=O , y=O , z=O are the equations of the given sections , w=O the equation of the polar plane of their point of intersection with respect to the surface ax2+ by2+ cz2+ 2fyI+ 2gz+ 2hxy +pw2 =0 , n the equation of the surface , 2 , ]1 , C , , ; , 7 , , K as usual , and OK ( V23SaI ; + IF/ ala+ diV153+1s/ VI)5 then the equations of the required sections are ( ax+hy+gz)X+yVZ+zVF3+v-apv1 +X2w=O xV/ Z+(hx+by+fz)Y+zV/ +V-bpV1/ +Y2W=O xVj/ +y/ ~(+ ( gx+ fie + cz)Z+V/ -cpv i +Zw _0 , where X , Y , Z are to be determined by the following equations , ( f+2DV )+ VI(Y+Z ) +f YZ -vbcV/ 1+Y2V1 +Z20 ( g +2 dj36 ) + V/ ( Z +X ) +gZ X/ cV i+-Z2V/ +X~2 =0 ( h+2aVs ) + VC ( X+Y ) +hXY -VabV I +X2V1 +Y20 ; and the solution of which , putting f=/ / /i ; ig = tSo/ l z ; h =4i ; /sNi &gt; / 2~Z is given by the equations KX=1 +(-f+g+h)2 22(f+g+h)J KY= 2fgh(f-g+h)2_2(f-g+h3i KZ= 2 KZ 2fg+(f+9-h ) _2(f+g-b)J* .
Instead of the direct but very tedious process by which these values of X , Y , Z have been obtained , we may substitute the following a posteriori verification .
We have K2(1 +X2 ) =4(-f+g+h)2J2(1 + ) ( f 1- ) ( 1 _h ) K2V I+ Y2 , / 1 + Z2 =4 ( f2 _ ( g g11)2 J2 ( 1-Jh/ 1J2\ -2 K2(1 +YZ ) =4 If ( i 2_gb ) ( f2 _(g-h )2 -2gh(g-b 2 } K(Y+Z)-2f2_ g2 21h2+4J2-4(1 J(J2 gh .
Putting also f2g22h2+ 2g2hQ ( f2_( h)2 &gt; 2gh(J2-gh ) K2 ( f2_ ( gh)2 ) ( ( g+h)2 f2 4g2h2 ) 4g2h2(g-h)2 we have ( f2 _ g2 _2+2j ) K2(1 +YZ ) -4 ( 1 _ ){f -_(gh ) J_ gh ) ( _ gt2)-2gh(g _h)_ -2gh( J2g 4g2h2(g -h)2(J2-gh ) + J2 K2{K(Y+Z)2f2-2g2-2h2+4J2 } ( ( ){(f 2 ( g_ h)2 ) [ ( J2gh ) ( ( g +h)2 f2-4g2h2 ) ] 4g2h2(g-h)2(J2-gh ) Also , since ( 2_ ( g_ h)2 + ( ( ~ ) 2_ 4f 24 )4 ( J2-Jgh ) , we have ( f'.g2h2+2 ) 1EK2(1 +YZ ) + K2{ K(Y+Z)-2f22g2 2h2 } =4 I)f _gt 2gh ( 1J2)( ) And the values obtained above give also 2ghv i-.1 1J2 K / 1 + Y-2V,2 =4 ( 1J(f 2_ ( g-h )2 ) 2 hj I 1I -P ?
) which shows that the relation between Y and Z is verified by the assumed values of these quantities , and the other two equations are of course also verified .
The solution of the problem will be rendered more complete if the equations of the required sections and of the auxiliary sections made use of in the geometrical construction are expressed in terms of f , g , h , J. ?
7 .
First , to substitute in the equations of the required sections or resultors .
Writing the first equation in the form 2 V230{Xt + ( hX+ V(P)y + ( gX + 3)z + V-ap/ l + X2W " =O the coefficient of x will be f2 ( 1 f22 fgh ( -ffg+h ) 2-2J(-f+g+h ) 01 , as it is convenient to write it , ( 1 + )f(-f+g+h ) -( 1-f ) ?
+2g + h ) -f+g+h }2J MDcccLlI .
2 N The coefficient of y is 2_2f{( 2_g2 + b2 2( _f+g+ h)2-2J(-f+g+h ) ) -f 4_g4-h4 +2 g2h2 +2 h2f 2+2 2f2g2_ 4f2g2 h2 } or , after all reductions , f h~ Jfg 2Jf2+g2h2 ( 1_Jf(-_f+g+ h ) Vs l-J{ f+ g+ h ) +fg+b2 fg } and similarly the coefficient of z is I__ f2_ 2h f2 )2fgh vgt(_f0+2_hb2+ J2 , )(g+ ( _f+g+11)2 2J(-f+g+h ) ) 4f2g2h -f4-g4 -h4+2g2h2+2h2f2+f 2g2_ 4Jh or , after all reductions , hIh -2fgh +f I2(fg2+h2 } ( i)f(-f+g+h)4j(1 { Jfgh+f+gh1+ ) and the coefficient of w is ( 1 +N(-f+g+h)2N/ KA , / _I 1 J\1_J/ ..~~~~J Whence , forming the equation of the resultor in question , and by mneans of it those of the other resultors , the equations of the resultors are ( g hf+h2J ) Yf f(lj &gt; +Q(71-f+ &gt; h ) ?
f~g+h ?
2J f2+gf2h2 ) g __ + J-+g+h ) ~2 2fh+h ) h ( 1-h)5 +2V/ K/ 'l _\/ 1-4_A/ 1--jV-pw =Ao -2fgh f+ + h+2J f2 ?
+ g2 -h2 __ -_ ( Jfg 2~gh2 2fg )/ 7 +( 2fgh 2f g_ + h2J , ( )+ ( J(-fg+h)+f+g-h+2J f+g/ ?h CI + 2fgh f42 2g h2 +2V/ KV 1f/ 1 -V7hvJ= -2fgh .
____ ___ f_ ( J(f+gh)-f+g-V+2JW2h ) ( ?
( J(42 ?
h +f-g+h+2J = ) + h2 43$(j1 Jg + J(4 +h ) +f+g-h-2J ) --(I J)z +~ ~~ 2sK,1 J &lt; _h ) / h , / Z values which might be somewhat simplified by writing i , a , W , Z instead of 14=[(-j ) X X ] ( 1g-Y AE Jz ' 2(\/ ]--1 1J A\]JA/ Pie And it may be also remarked , that the coefficients as well of these formula as of those which follow may be elegantly expressed in terms of the parts of a triangle having f , g , h for its sides .
The equations of the separators are found by taking the differences two and two of the equations of the resultors ( this requires to be verified 'a posteriori ) ; thus subtracting the third equation from the second the result contains a constant factor , J(f2(g-h)2)gh{4fbh J(f2 ( gh)2)((g+ h)2 equivalent to l~f ( a4i2g2h2 _J2(K2+ J2 or .
Rejecting the factor in question and forming the analogous two equations , the equations of the separators are and from the mode of formation of these equations it is obvious that the separators have a line in common .
The equations of the deterninators being xhO , y=O , z=O , the equations of the tactors are V~z-V~y~o , IV &amp; -V z=OV y-3xO f/ 352-s6y-Or V/ st J/ A O. V/ y s/ BC and if &amp; x+P3y+yz+iw=O be the equation of the tactor touching x=O , V/ x-V/ az=O and VAy-VJBx=0 , the conditions of contact are 2 ( 2M2+ 2 ) _(g~o + y ) 8/ g( , \/ XB K(2 &gt; 2 -I2 { ( V/ d3_k)(MV/ -PV)+r( TV-.-DV ) } n IQ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~2 2V/ ZI(V/ -)t 2(_ K2 ) ={(A O( -A )C VV whence -q ( A+ + &amp; = ( .P2(ACe~A ( ( y2 ) v s-~ , V2+bV V2f-)+_82+ p an I putting for a Moment P OJ3 After some reductions , and observing that the ratios oniy of the quantities a , , r are t raterial , K v &gt; ( Khv+fd ) K 7=_K f( M+ CP ) K w_ V/ -p~bV2+c,2+2k ; f and it is easily seen also that the coordinates of the point of contact are x=O , y=P , Z=P , 2 p ; also g_ Jh9 li And substituting and introducing throughout the quantities f , g , h , J. also forming the analogous equations , the equations of the tactors are { f2(_ f2+g2+ h2 ) + ( g ?
h)J(f2_ ( g_ h)-2 )h }_ 1 { f2_(g-h)2+2gh(g-h)}J g(g ) { g2(f2 g2+h2 ) + ( h+f)J ( g2h(h f)2 J }Jf { g2_(hf)2h(J)}j J ) + 2x/ K'Jhf ( 1 _ J ) ( i I_ ) ( g2_ ( h _ f)2)V/ pw=O + { h2(f 2 g2 h2 ) + ( f+g)J ( 12_ ( f-g)2_ 2fgh + 2v'K/ \/ fg ( 1-4 ) ( 1 _J ) ( _ ( -fg ) pw~ = It is ob~vious , from the equations , that : each separator passes through the point of contact of a tactor and determninator , it consequently onlyt remlains to be shown that each separator touches two tactors .
CSonsider the tactor which has been represented b~y osx+Iy+7z+tw=O , t~he unreduneed values of the coefficients give MV+k3 ?
@r z=K2VA MP+B3 ?
+fr= v-(+v ) v1= 71 X(2 M~ k nl i I2 =K~i-(fh2_ ( f~g)22gfJ- } , 19 h+2 = 1K(f2g ) _(fig)_ T Rereet fsobiuframomen the eqainta ahseparatorpasstoitf K2 K _~~~~~K ( fg2+h.f.)K22h thecondtifon of comntat bheomesaao Q { ( g +h f-g).Ji(I}_ .
Z= Or , forming the value of o2 and substituting f2(1 ) +g2(1- .
) +(f .
g)2(I h)2 +2(1 ) ( fg)g(l _ )(1 )-2(1 _J2 ) ( f g ) f(i--2 1-J2 -fg I =F2((f-g)2+bh(f+ g ) 2fgh)2 which may be verified without difficulty , and thus the construction for the resultors is shown to be true .
§ 8 .
Several of the formulae of the preceding sections of this memoir apply to any number of variables .
Consider the surface ( i. e. hypersurface ) ax2+ by2 + Cz2 +2fyz+2gzx+2hxy ... +p12=0 , and the section ( i. e. hypersection ) ( a , +hpj+gv ... )x+(hk+bp+ fie ... )y+ ( gX+fr++cv ... )z ... +V'-pvt=O , where v2=a +b-c+2gy h K , the condition of contact with any other section represented by a similar equation is a ?
.'+ bpp'+ cyy'+f(pQi+ p6A ) +gy ( A ' + Y ' ?
) +h(V +h7f ) ... K+ Kvv ' , where K is the determinant formed with the coefficients a , b , c , f , g , h , ... And consequently , by establishing all or any of the equations\7V , = , v=VI , ... we have the condition in order that the section in question may touch all or the corresponding sections of the sections x=0 , y_0 , z=0,. .
Let ni be the number of the variables x , y , z. .
, then K~ ' =$ e3f n02 also K. - .
) xr ( h ?
; + bp +f..)y r ( g74 rfp+ c* .
z*** =x y.z.el whence also K"-2t72__K)=_ x , v..K or Kf2V2zj1 it 2keXZk e~r .
pkBf fk 1r and the equation of the section in question becomes -I xy z* gnIt-lI &gt; wX_ ; tFo x YZ .
+A also the condition of contact with the corresponding section is -W ?
Z Z v.VX ( k t In particular the equation of the sections which touches all the sections x=0 , y=O , z=O. .
, is _Ixy Z. .
+K 2 --27 , / Again , the equations of the section touching y=O , z-O ... .
and the section touching x=O , z=O , ... are xy +K PV I -t= / 3 x3t I/ 3 xyZP l+ / %A Z/ to $s 4rf OU / s 1 and the condition of contact of these two sections is -W+ 1 x &gt; / Xis/ 3. .
v/ | W xs/ ft3 TV / 2 Ae d It would seem from the appearance of these equations that there should be some simpler method of obtaining the solution than the method employed in the previous part of this memoir .
2 Stone Buildins AJprz1 1852 .

