On Symbolic Forms derivedfrom the Conception of the Translation of a Directed Magnitude .
'By the Rev. M. O'BRIEN , M.A. , Late Fellow of Caius College , Cambridge , and Professor of Natural Philosophy and Astronomy in King 's College , London .
Received April 21,.-Read June 19 , 1851 .
PART I. GENERAL INVESTIGATION OF THE SYMBOLIC FORMS .
( 1 .
) THERE can be no doubt , that time and ingenuity have been often wasted in devising systems of notation , and new methods of algebraical representation , which have never proved of any service in advancing the cause of science .
It is not surprising , therefore , that symbolical innovations , if they have not the strongest and most obvious reasons to recommend them , are generally received with little favour by mathematicians .
At the same time , it must not be forgotten , that the mind has wonderfully enlarged its powers of research by the symbolization of its abstract conceptions , and that the various additions which have been made , from time to time , to mathematical notation , have contributed largely to the progress of physical investigation , ; witness , for instance , the applications of the negative sign , indices , logarithms , coordinate equations , the differential algorithm , &amp;c. A new notation , or a new application of an old notation , ought , in all cases , to be called for by some want in science , that is , by the existence of some important and often occurring conception for which there is no adequate , or at least no sufficiently general mode of representation .
It should be neither artificial nor complicated , but natural and simple : it should also be based on principles of established authority , and framed according to allowed precedents .
And , lastly , it should be capable of something more than mere elementary applications , and be recommended by its utility in the higher and more abstruse branches of science .
With these cautions before me , and on these grounds , I venture , in the present paper , to propose a new use of an old notation , which appears to me to supply a want of considerable importance , as I hope to show by the remarkable simplifications which it introduces into many difficult investigations .
There is an operation , if I may so call it , of constant occurrence in Geometry and Physics , which consists in the translation of a directed magnitude , that is , the parallel motion of a magnitude possessing the property of direction , such , for example , as a force , a velocity , traced line , or the like .
This translation , as it may be easily shownn is always an operation MpCCCLHI .
If of the kind called " distributive , " and from its distributiveness all its properties in a great measure follow as necessary consequences .
Now this is a fact of great importance to be borne in mind , a thing to which the truly mathematical adage " 'when found make a note of " fully applies .
There is no notation actually in use for this purpose ; but there are two nearly obsolete signs , which by an easy and natural generalization , and according to the most approved rules of mathematical interpretation , might be made to serve effectually as representatives of the effects produced generally by the translation of a directed magnitude .
My design , in what follows , is to show this , and establish the laws according to which these signs are to be used in their enlarged signification .
Afterwards I shall endeavour to justify the proposed innovation , , if such it is to be considered , by showing its utility in a variety of cases .
( 2 .
) Instances which suggest the proposed symbolization.-There are three elementary conceptions which have suggested to my mind the principles which it is the object of this paper to develope , and they will serve here as means of introducing the subject , and furnish the best foundation to build upon .
They are the following I st. The generation of surface by the parallel motion of a right line , Fig. 1 .
of which the simplest instance is a parallelogram ABCD supposed B to be generated by the motion of AB , parallel to itself , along AD.2ndly .
The effect produced on a rigid body by the translation of a force A acting upon it from one point A to another B , the direction of the Fig. 2 .
force remaining unaltered ; which effect , as is well known , consists in that peculiar tendency to motion that results from the action of the couple composed of the force at B , and a force equal and oppo3 site to the original force at A.-3rdly .
The effect produced by the B translation of a force resulting from the actual motion of its point of application ; which effect is now usually designated by the term work .
If the point of application be supposed to describe the path ADB , the force Fig 3 .
all the time acting parallel to its original direction , a certain amount of work is accumulated in consequence of the translation of the force , and this is the effect I allude to. .
Now in each of these cases the conception in the mind is that of Az / the effect produced by the translation of a directed magnitude ; and what is worthy of special remark is this , that in each of these cases the effect alluded to is represented by the product of twofactors , one being the translated magnitude , and the other the amount of translation it undergoes .
Thus , in the case shown by figure 1 , the surface generated is denoted by the product of AB into the perpendicular or lateral distance between AB and CD ; of which , AB is the translated magnitude , and the perpendicular the amount of translation that fakes place laterally .
In the case shown by figure 2a , the effect is also represented by the product of the translated magnitude , that is , the force , into the amount of lateral translation .
In the case shown by figure 3 , if we suppose BV to be the direction of the force produced backward to meet a perpendicular AC let fall from A upon it , the effect produced , that is , the work accumulated , is represented by the product of the translated magnitude ( the force , namely , ) into the amount of translation which takes place , not laterally , as before , but longitudinally , that is , along the direction of the force , which longitudinal translation is manifestly CB. ( 3 .
) From these three instances the idea naturally arises of some necessary connection between the translation of a directed magnitude and the product of the two factors , the magnitude translated and the amount of translation ; or , to say the least , there appears to be some ground for conceiving that the product in question may be the proper form of notation for representing the translation .
And , secondly , the necessity of distinguishing between lateral and longitudinal translation is clearly indicated , inasmuch as the longitudinal effect is zero in the first two cases , while the lateral effect is zero in the third case , 'faking my clue from these suggestions , I shall now proceed to explain my proposed method of notation ; observing , that my object is to make it as general as possible consistently with definiteness and utility , and that for this reason , I shall employ all the generalizations of the elementary algebraical signs which are now admitted by mathematicians .
I shall also adopt , to a certain extent , the views of Symbolical Algebra taken by the late Mr. GREGORY , and published by him in several papers , but especially in one read before the Royal Society of Edinburgh on the Foundations of Algebra .
I may observe , however , that my proposed method of notation does not assume the correctness of these views , and might be enunciated independently of them ; but they appear to my mind to form the most satisfactory theory of Symbolical Algebra .
I. PRELIMINARY DEFINITIONS , STATEMENTS , ETC , ( 4 .
) Directed Magnitude.-I use this term to denote any of those magnitudes which we represent graphically by arrows ; remarking that an arrow represents three things , viz. an origin or point of application , marked by its feather-extremity ; a particular magnitude represented by its length ; and a particular direction shown by the barb .
( 5 .
) Translation , Lateral and Longitudinal.- " TranslaFig .
4 , tion " is the term employed to denote that peculiar and D simplest change of position of a rigid body which consists / in the parallel and equal motion of all its component / particles .
I shall use the same term to denote a change / of position of a directed magnitude without change of A ; direction , as is shown in fig. 4 .
The translation therefore / / of a directed magnitude consists in simple alteration of , / le " origin , " as from A to B in the figure .
I/ But this alteration of origin is of a twofold nature , being partly lateral and partly longitudinal .
If CD be the indefinite line of direction in which the arrow at A lies , and OF that in which the atrow at B lies , the transla- .
tion from A to B consists of two distinct motions ; namely , the shifting of the line of direction from CD to OF , and the shifting of the origin along the line of direction through a space amounting to GB .
The former I shall call lateral and the latter longitudinal translation .
If v denote a directed magnitude which is supposed to be transFig. .
lated from A to B , and if u denote the line AB , I shall speak of the translation as that of v along u ; a proper mode of expression , be/ cause every point of the representative arrow v undergoes a motion equivalent in magnitude and direction to u. The translation of v along u is lateral when the angle at A is 900 and longitudinal when o0 .
( 6 .
) Distributiveness.-If f ( x ) be a function of x which possesses the property expressed by the equation fAX ) +(X ' ) =f(X+x ' ) ) it is said to be a distributive function of x. If x be any number positive , negative , integral or fractional , it may be shown from this equation that AfV ) = CX , C denoting a quantity independent of * , namely the value of f(x ) when x= 1 .
If x be not a number , but some symbol , whether of specific quantity or operation , the notation Cx has no meaning recognised in ordinary algebra .
Hence , following the well-known precedent of indices * , we may generalize the meaning of Cx by assuming it to be the symbolicalform for denoting everyfunction f ( x ) which is distributive .
If we further suppose , that f(x ) , and therefore C , is a distributive function of another independent variable y , we shall find that CC'y and.- .
Cx-C'xy .
Thus we may , by the same process of generalization , assume C'xy to be the symbolical form for denoting everyfunction of x and y which is distributive with regard to both *x and C ' here is manifestly the value of the function when x1 and y=1 .
Now if we adopt C ' to be the unit of the function , as , in fact , we do in many cases of ordinary products , the symbolic form for denoting the function becomes simply xy .
( 7 .
) This appears to me to be the simplest and best method of defining the notation xy in Symbolical Algebra though I need not avail myself of it here as it is not necessary for my purpose .
All I require is some simple notation for denoting-a distributive function of two variables ; for , as I hope to show this distributiveness is a characteristic of great importance to be distinctly " noted " in the case of the translation of a directed magnitude .
Now there are three different forms in which a product is written in ordinary algebra , viz. xy x.y and xxy : of these , the latter two are now seldom used , and there is no necessity whatever for this redundancy of forms for denoting the same thing .
Instead , therefore , of inventing new symbols for representing distributive functions , I shall venture to appropriate the almost obsolete forms x.y and xxy to the purpose .
At the same time it must be borne in mind , that , according to the views of many eminent mathematicians , the product of x and y in Symbolical Algebra may be defined to be any distributive function of x and y , and thus the appropriation of x. y and xxy here proposed is nothing more than a legitimnate application of these forms .
( 8 .
) I shall therefore assume x.y and Xxy to be symbolical forms for denoting distributive functions of x and y ; in other words , I shall consider x.y and xxy to be completely defined by the equations x.y+x'.y=(x+x').y xxy+x'xy=(x+x ' ) Xy x-.y+X.y-X-(Y+Y ) zXy+ X9'_xx ( y+y ) ) just as the symbolic form am is completely defined by the equation ea =ae+4 .
( 9 .
) Whether x.y and x Xy are " 'Commutative " functions of x and y/ , i. e. whether x.y=y.x , and xXy=y Xx , does not appear from these defining equations , and therefore it must be decided by the particular nature of the quantity or operation which each of these forms is assumed to represent .
( 10 .
) Signijfication of the sign + .
In Symbolical Algebra the sign + may be regarded as simply an abbreviation for the words " together with , " and thus u+v means simply u " together with " v , or u and v " put together .
" Now these words " together with " may be taken in a great variety of senses , as the following examples taken from ordinary algebra show , viz. 3+5=8 , 3-t+5s.=780d .
, 3+4/ 1=(2+V-_ 1)2 , 5 miles east+5 miles west=0 , &amp;c. &amp;c. In the first example + means a " putting together " by simple numerical addition ; in the second , a " putting together " of certain pieces of gold and silver , withireference to a certain conventional value set on them ; in the third , a mere symbolical " putting together ; " and so on .
Hence it is clear that in using the sign + as an abbreviation of the words " together with , " the precise nature of the " putting together " is supposed to be understood in each case .
I shall therefore define the notation , u+v , to mean , u and v put together in a sense supposed to be understood .
Now in some cases it is very important that the precise nature of the " putting together " denoted by the sign + should be clearly understood , and therefore distinctly specified .
This it will be necessary for me to do here with reference to two remtarkable significations which have been given to the sign + .
( 1 1 .
) The first is that signification given to + in Symbolical Geometry .
If u and v denote two lines of certain magnitudes and drawn in certain direcFig .
6 .
tions , then u+v is assumed to denote M and v put together as in the figure 6 ; that is , the beginning-point or origin of v coinciding with the V endpoint ( if I may so use the words ) of u. The second signification A/ is that given to + in Symbolical Mechanics .
If u and v denote two Fig. 7 .
forces of certain magnitudes and directions , u+v is assumed to denote u and -v put together as in figure 7 that is , the origin of v coinciding , not 5 with the end-point , as before , but with the origin of u. The distinction I allude to here is of considerable importance , and requires to be very closely attended to in applying lines to represent forces generally , as will appear .
It might be well to distinguish these two significations of + by appropriate terms .
I cannot think of any better words , for the purpose , than the two , " successive , " and " simultaneous ; " the putting together in fig. 6 is manifestly effected by tracing the two lines in imme- .
diate succession .
, while that in fig. 7 is a simultaneous application at the same origin .
I shall therefore call the putting together in fig. 6 successive addition , and that in fg .
7 simultaneous addition .
( 12 .
) kSignfication of the sign = .
Like + , the sign = denotes equivalence in a certain sense supposed to be understood ; thus in the example , 38C+5s.=780d .
, it denotes equivalence as regards the conventional value of certain coins .
In Fig. 8 .
Symbolical Geometry = has reference to the change of position of the tracing-point by which lines are supposed to be drawn .
Thus if u , v , w A , denote three traced lines , the equation , u+v=w , means , that the tracing of u+v is the same thing as the tracing of w , so far as the change of position of the tracing-point is concerned .
In this sense it is clear , that w must be the third side of the triangle in fig. 8 .
In Symbolical Mechanics _ has reference Fig. 9 .
to mechanical effect .
f Thus if u , v , w be three forces , the equation , U+V=W , means , that the mechanical ejfct of u+v is the same as that ' ' of w ; in other words , it means , that w is the resultant of u and v. ( 13 .
) Representation of Forces by Lines .
The suitability of lines to represent forces is obvious enough in ordinary Mechanics , where + has the signification of mere numerical addition ; but when we come to Symbolical Mechanics this suitability is no longer a thing to be assumed .
A little consideration will show that the question , " Can we assume lines to represent forces generally ?
" may be stated symbolically as follows , viz. If the lines u and v respectively represent the forces U and V , in magnitude and direction , will u+v also represent U+V in magnitude and direction ?
if not , the graphical mode of representation becomes inadmissible symbolically .
Now , it is clear , by reference to figures 8 and 9 , that this question amounts to asking , whether the Parallelogram of Forces is true or not ?
for the peculiar signification of + in Symbolical Geometry makes u+v denote the diagonal of the parallelogram constructed on u andyv as sides ; whereas the Mechanical signification of + in U+V makes it denote the resultant of U and V. Hence it follows that the general representation of forces by lines assumese the truth of the Parallelogram of Forces as a necessary condition ; and , consequently , any symbolical proof of the Parallelogram of Forces which assumes that lines may be taken generally as representatives of forced , amounts to reasoning in a cirele* .
My object here , however , in the remarks just made , is to point out the importance of distinctly marking the two significations of the sign + .
( 14 .
) In all cases that I shall be concerned with , successive and simultaneous addition are virtually equivalent , so far as the representation of directed magnitudes by lines is concerned .
As regards the statical teffect of forces , the Parallelogram of Forces shows this : as regards the dynamical / jJect , the Second Law of Motion ( I mean NEWTON 's 2nd Law ) does the same .
As regards velocities and displacements the thing is obvious .
( 15 .
) Directed Units .
I shall call an arrow of a unity of length ( whether it represents a traced line , a force , a velocity , or any other kind of directed magnitude ) a " directed unit .
" I shall always reserve the letters a , I , y to denote a set of three directed units at right angles to each other .
Hence , if AX , AY , AZ be Fig. 10 .
three rectangular axes to which a , P , y are respectively parallel ; z and if x , y , z denote numerically the three coordinates of any point P ; xa , ye , zy will be the symbols representing these three I Cy~ ~~ ~~ Z coordinates in magnitude and direction , inasmuch as xa means AVxx directed units put together by successive or geometrical addition , all in the direction parallel to AX ; and so also as regards ye and z/ .
Also if u be taken to denote the line AP in magiiiT tude and direction , we have , by successive addition , u=xa+yf3+z7 .
The point P is often called the point ( xyz ) , I may therefore speak of it as the point ( u ) , inasmuch as u completely defines its position .
If X , Y , Z denote numerically three forces parallel to AX , AY , AZ , it is clear that their complete symbolical representatives are Xa , Y3 , Zy .
Also , if U denote the resultant of these three forces , we have UXa+Yp3+ZY .
But here + denotes simultaneous addition : we may , however , assuming the truth of the Parallelogram of Forces , regard it as the successive + , if we please .
( 1 6 .
) As just observed , I shall always suppose a ' , 3 , y to be a set of three rectangular directed units ; I shall suppose the same also as regards a ' , j3 ' , y ' ; a " , ( " , Iye &amp;c. , using the dashes to denote different sets of directed units ; but the three in each set are always assumed to be at right angles to each other , unless the contrary be specified .
In speaking of lines as regards magnitude and direction , I shall always use the word " direction " as equivalent to " directed unit ; " thus I shall call a the " direction .
" of the line xa .
The complete symbol of a line may be therefore described as its direction multiplied by its magnitude .
( 17 .
) If r denote the magnitude , and o ' the direction of u , ul=ra , and therefore , putting for u its value above , we find xyz or a1 ~~~~~~~~zaa~1:+bi+~ where a , b and c denote the cosines of the angles which a ' Makes with a , , and y respectively .
If an ' lies in the plane ( a3 ) , and if v denote the angle which a ' makes with a , this -expression becomes ac'=a cos d+1 sin d. ( 18 .
) According to the principles of Symbolical Algebra , we have as a=2p M-75 ( -=/ But it is to be remembered that the sign here does not denote the same identical operation in these three cases ; nor is it necessary that it should , any more than the sign- .
The true state of the case is this , that ( -`)a .
is defined by the equation ( A ) ( - ) and the general solution of this equation is -oV=P cos +ey sin 0 .
where V is perfectly arbitrary .
Consequently the extraction of the square root ofgives , not simply two values , positive and negative , as in ordinary extractions of the square root , but an infinite number of values , namely the whole circle of directed units at right angles to a. I shall have no occasion to make any use of the sign -- , or any reference to the connections just given between a , 13 and V , except in some future applications of my method , chiefly in Geometry .
The statement just made is intended to show what 1 , 13 , y are with reference to the square roots of ( or I ) , and to point out distinctly that o , , A , y are not supposed to be square roots of unity , but merely direction-units .
( 19 .
) Remarkable signifcation of dc , d/ 3 , die .
This signification I pointed out and made use of in a paper read before the Cambridge Philosophical Society ( Nov. 1846 ) , and it may be briefly stated here for the purpose of reference in certain applications of the present method .
If a and a ' be two directed-units at an inFig .
11 .
definitely small angle to each other , we have a'addo ; but a-a , is the line joining the extremities of a and &amp; a ' , and this line is at right angles to cc and ca ' ( ultimately ) , because a and o , ' are lines of equal length .
Hence Acl is the expression for an indefinitely smaill line at right angles to a. This signification of do is one of great importance in Symbolical Geometry and Mechanics : thus for example , if a , 13 , y denote direction-unitsfixed in a rigid body , the angular velocities of the rigid body are represented , in magnitude and direction , by da d13 d7 dt ' dt dt inasmuch as da , d13 , die represent , in magnitude and direction the small angles described in the tinme t by the extremities of these three direction-units .
Of course I mean by the word " sangle , " here , the circular are which measures it .
The importance of this signification of do , do , die will be manifest in many parts of what follows .
The Effects symbolized.-It has been shown that the translation of v along u is , generally , of a twofold nature , partly lateral and partly longituFig .
12 .
dinal ; it is my object to express symbolically the ejfects produced , whether they are geometrical or mechanical effects , by the two kinds of translation .
The effect produced by the lateral part of the translation of v along uI shall call the lateral effect , and that produced by the longitudinal part , the longitudinal effect .
( 21 .
) T~he two Ejficts are , each , Distributive Functions of u and v. Let f ( u , v ) denote the lateral effect of the translation of v along u ; Fig. 13 .
let u and u ' represent the lines AB and BB ' ; produce the arrows ( v ) both ways indefinitely to show the lines of direction in which v lies in the three parallel positions at A , B , and B ' ; draw AGH and BG ' at right angles to these parallel lines of direction ( CD , OF , E'F ' ) .
Observe , that v , u and u ' are not necessarily in the same plane .
i Now , as assumed , f(u , v ) denotes the effect produced by the shifting of the line CD to the parallel position OF ; fAu ' , v ) denotes that by a farther shifting , namely / from OF to the parallel position E'F ' : which two shiftings " put together " come to the same thing as one shifting from CD to E'F ' .
Now since AB ' is represented by u+u ' , the effect of this last-mentioned shifting is denoted byf(u+u ' , v ) : we have therefore f(U , V)+f(U ' , v)=f(u+u ' , v ) , that is , the lateral effect of the translation of v along u is a distributive function as regards u. In precisely the same way it may be shown , that the longitudinal effect is also a distributive function as regards u. For it is manifest that the three translations , viz. that along u , that along u ' , and that along u+u ' , amount respectively to GB , G'B ' , and LIB ' , as regards longitudinal effect , and we have HB'=GB+G'B ' .
Whence the conclusion is evident .
It remains to show that both effects are distributive functions Fig. 14 .
as regards v also ; and this is immediately obvious : for the transA lation of v along u " together with " that of v ' along U , is the same thing as the translation of v+v ' along u ; and thus , whetherf denote the lateral or longitudinal effect , we have f(U , V ) +f(u , V ' ) =f(u , v+v ' ) .
Both effects therefore are distributive functions with respect to v as well as u. It is important to observe , here , that the + in u+u ' denotes successive , while that in v+v ' denotes simultaneous addition .
( 23 .
) Notation adopted to represent the two effects .
I have stated above the reasons why u.v and uxv may be appropriated .
to denote , simply , any distributive functions of u and v. I have here shown the existence of two such functions , very important to be " noted " syrnbolically , and to be distinguished from each other .
I shall therefore venture farther to employ the notation u.v exclusively for the purpose of representing the lateral effect of the translation of v along u , and the notation ua Xv exclusively to represent the longitudinal effect .
( 24 .
) As regards the order of the factors , I shall always suppose that the second factor is the translated magnitude , and thefirst factor the line along which it is translated .
( 25 .
) In using these notations I am not warranted to attribute to them , without proof , any property of an ordinary product , except its distributiveness : for example , I must not put u.v=v.u , without investigating whether this equation holds as regards the effects represented by u.v and v.u. Nor again , if m and n be any numbers , can I , without proof , put ( mu).(nv)-mn(u.v ) .
These points I shall now consider .
( 26 .
) May Numerical Coefficients , occurring in u. v or u xv , e brought out and incorporated by actual multiplication ?
-Supposing m , and n to denote pure numbers , may we put ( mru).(nv)=mn(u.v ) , and ( mu ) x ( nv)=mn(uxv ) ?
Or , to express the question in words is the effect produced by the translation of nv along mu equivalent to mn times the effect of the translation of v along u ?
It is very important to bear in mind , as regards this question , that nv means v+v+v+ &amp;c. " put together " by simultaneous addition ; while mu means u+uau ?
&amp;c. " put together " by successive addition ( see art .
22 ) .
Hence it will not be difficult to show that u.(nv)=n(u.v ) in virtue of the distributive property ; but , that some additional consideration is requisite to determine whether ( mu).v=m(u.v ) .
( 27 .
) First , as regards u.(nv ) .
The nv ' here have the same origin Fig. 15 .
A , and they are translated simultaneously from , A to B. This translation is manifestly the same as if each v were translated separately it/ from A to B : and thus it follows that the translation of nv along u Am is the same thing as n translations of v along u ; or , in symbols , u. ( nv ) =n(u.v ) , and uX ( nv ) =n(u X v ) .
Indeed this is nothing more than a re-assertion of the distributive nature of the translation of v along u , as regards v. ( 28 .
) Secondly .
In the expression ( mu).v the us have not the same origin , but are " put together " successively , as is represented in fig. 16 , Fig 16 .
making up the line AB ( supposing , for a moment , that r ' M_5 ) .
It is clear , then , that ( 5u).v means a translaA AAAA tion of v from A to B , while 5 ( u.v ) means five translations of v from A to A ' .
lence , before we can decide whether ( mu).v-m(u.v ) , we must determine whether the translations of v from A to A ' , from A ' to A " , from A " to A " ' , &amp;c. are equivalent to each other in effect ; for , if they are , it makes no difference in ejfect whether we repeat the translation of v from A to A ' five times , or simply translate v from A to A ' , from A ' to A " , from A " to A " ' , and so on to B. The question then comes to this-Are we to regard translations as equivalent to each other , in effect , when the magnitudes translated and the lines along which they are translated are respectively equivalent to each other , whether the translations take place in the same part of space or not ?
( 29 .
) Fundamental Assumption.-I am thus led to make the following Assumption the basis of my proposed method ; viz.-That parallel and equal Fig. 17 translations of parallel and equal magnitudes are equivalent to each other both as regards the lateral and longitudinal effects ; or , sym$ bolically , if u ' and V ' be respectively parallel and equal to u and v , then ' u'.v'=u.v , and u'Xv'auxv .
This assumption holds true , manifestly , in each of the three suggesting cases from which I have taken my start ( see art .
2 ) , and I am therefore justified in adopting it , with the understanding , of course , that it be shown to hold true , or tacitly admitted , in all cases to which the notation may be applied ; or else , should the occasion require it , be abandoned , and , with it , the property expressed by the equation ( mu).v =m(u.v ) .
( 30 .
) Returning to fig. 16 , we have , by the Assumption just made , AA'.v=A'A".v=A"A"'.v= &amp;c. &amp;c. ; .*.m(u .
v ) =m ( AA'.v ) ==AA'.v +A'A " ' .
v+ A"A " ' .
v+ &amp;c. = ( AA'+A'A"+A"A"'+ &amp;c. ).v = ( mu ) .
v. And generally , by what has been proved , we have ( mu ) .
( nv)=n{(mu).v } =mn(u.v ) ; and , simiilarly , ( mu ) X ( nv ) =mn(u X v ) .
It appears thus that numerical coefticients , occurring in the symbolic forms u.v and UX v , may always be brought out and incorporated by actual multiplication* .
( 31 .
) May the order of the factors u and v in the symbolic forms u. v and uXv be changed , or not ?
-First , as regards u.v , may we put u.v=v.u ?
HIe-re I may repeat that the second factor always denotes the translated magnitude , or rather , the representative arrow .
Thus the question is-as regards lateral effect , is the translation of the magnlitude represented by the arrow v along the line u equivalent to the translation of that represented by the arrow u along the line v. This is easily decided as follows .
( 32 .
) It is clear that the lateral effect of the translation of a magnitude in its own direction is zero : it follows therefore that u.u=O , v.v=O ; also that ( u+v ) .
( u+v ) = O,.u .
u+u.v +v .
u+v.v-O..X .
u.v+v.u=O , or v.u-u.v .
It appears then that u.v and v.u are equivalent as regards magnitude but opposite in sign .
( 33 .
) Secondly , as regards uX v , may we put vX uzu X v ?
This question is determined by observing that the longitudinal effect of the translation of a magnitude at right angles to its direction is zero , as follows .
Let u=mc , v=ma ' , a and a ' being the directions ( directed units ) , and mn and m ' the magnitudes of u and v. Then , by article 30 , uXv=mn(cXo ' ) and vXu=mn .
( o'c ) Fig. 18 .
Now it is clear , from figure 18 , that &amp; +a ' and o-o ' are lines at right angles to each other ; therefore ( a+V ' ) X ( M -M)-0=(O--M ) &gt; X ( O+o ) ; .
, therefore , , oitting common terms , we find -V~1+a &amp; a=Xodo'Xc , Xv And thus it follows that uXv=vXu .
It appears then that uXv and vXu are equivalent as regards both magnitude and sign .
( 34 .
) Thus u.v is commutative with change of sign , while uXv is simply commutative .
The reason of the change of sign in the former may be Fig. 19 .
easily interpreted as follows .
An arrow has two distinct sides , which , for the sake of fixing ideas , I may call right and left , *i and which may be defined by supposing that I stand on the nti'kit fE plane of the paper looking in the direction of the arrow .
Now , referring to fig. 19 , it is clear that the translation of v along i is laterally a motion to the right side , while that of u along v is to the left , the translated magnitude in both cases being that with reference to which I speak of right and left .
Thus the meaning of the equation v.u= u.v is obvious .
III .
MEASUREMENT AND SUMMATION OF TRANSLATIONS .
( 35 .
) Units of Translation.-I shall take the translation of a Fig. 20 .
unit along a perpendicular unit to be a unit of lateral translation ; and the translation of a unit along itself to be a unit of longitudinal translation .
Thus ( see art .
16 ) ac.,.y , P '43 ' , &amp;c. are units of lateral translation ; and at X as , 3x 3 , oa ' X a ' , &amp;c. are units of longitudinal translation .
All Units of Longitudinal Translation are equivalent to each other .
For let M and oe ' denote any two directed units whatever ; then , as above , ( a+d ) X ( M-a)=0 ; wherefore , since cX ac ' = at X o , we have E XA M X. In illustration of this result the third suggesting instance , that of Mechanical Work , may be quoted ; inasmuch as work is the effect of longitudinal translation , and all units of work are equivalent to each other , no matter in what directions the working forces act .
( 37 .
) All Units of Lateral Translation , in the same or in parallel planes , are equivalent to each other.-Let ce , f3 , ce ' , ( 3 ' lie in the same plane , and let V denote the angle which ce ' makes with o , and therefore that also which ( 3 ' makes with ( ( art .
16 ) : then ( art .
17 ) arsv mcos O+f sin V ( '=occos ( + ?
) ?
sin 0+ observing that &amp; e. &amp; e=f343=O , and c.p4=-f3.ce , we have a'.(3'=ce.ce(cos2 O+sin ' 0)=c.c .
Hence all units of lateral translation in the same , or in parallel planes , are equivalent to each other .
In illustration of this result , the second suggesting instance , that of a Couple , may be quoted ; for all unit-couples in the same or in parallel planes are equivalent to each other .
( 38 .
) Directrix.-IIence , in expressing a unit of lateral translation , it is only necessary to specify a plane parallel to that in which the translation takes place ; or , what is better and immediately suggested by the theory of couples , it is only necessary to specify a line at right angles to the plane of translation .
Such a line I shall , however , designate by the word " directrix , " not axis ; because there is no idea of rotation involved in the present theory , translation being a kind of motion essentially different from rotation .
I shall assume y to be the directrix of ve.f and of all units of lateral translation in planes at right angles to y ; and , generally , I shall define the directrix of any unit of lateral translation to be a directed unit at right angles to the plane of that translation .
( 39 .
) But , since ce.(=-f.Ce , it is necessary to distinguish posiFig .
21 .
tive from negative translations ; and this may be done by giving an appropriate sign to the directrix .
I shall therefore assume 11.1 generally , that my is the directrix of m , m.f , m being any number 1f1 lt positive or negative .
Thus -y will be the directrix of &amp; e.3 , that is , of 3.c_ .
And , hence , I may adopt the following , criterion of a sign .
I shall suppose myself standing at right angles to the plane of translation in such a position that the translated magnitude points to the right , while I face the direction in which the translation takes place ; and then I shall take an arrow pointing from foot to head as the directrix .
According to this criterion the letters written underneath the following translations are their respective directrices ; viz. 06 .
lyy7O.M O.3 o~ rM3 --M ( 40 .
) Measurement of a Translation.-Let u.v , or ux v , be the translation , a the direction of u , ( ap ) the plane of u.v , d the angle which v makes with u , m and n the magnitudes of u and v ; then u=maG , v=n(ac cos 0+13 sin 0 ) ; u.v=mn sin ( &amp; s.1 ) , ( since M. &amp; =O ) .
Hence there are mu sin 0 units in the translation u.v : mn SiDn , therefore , is the nutnerical magnitude of u.v , and its directrix is ( mn sin 0)y .
Again , uXv=mn cos d(aXca ) , ( since czX,3 = ) .
Hence the numerical magnitude of uXv is mncos0 .
( 41 .
) It is worth remarking that mn sin 0 , the nutnerical magnitude of u.v , is the area of the parallelogram completed on u and v as sides .
( 42 .
) The Directrix of the Sum of two translations is the Sum of their Directrices .
Let the two translations be mz.f and mt'cf.j3 ' , and their directrices , of course , my and mnl'r ; let EB be the intersection of the two planes of these transFig .
22 .
lations , and take AB=m and BC=m ' , AB and BC being drawn at right t gles to BE , AB in the plane of z.f , and BC in the plane of a , 3 ' .
D Now , since all t Wits of lateral translation in the same plane are equivalent to ach other , I may turn M and 1 , a ' and 13 ' about in their respc tive planes , until both M and tz coincide A -------w .
with BE ; in whicL case 1 and 1 ' will coincide with AB and BC respectively then AB will become mn/ , and BC m'1 ' .
Let the third side of the triangle ABC be " / 3 " as shown in the figure .
Then the sumn of the two translations is mcs.1 3+ m%'s.3 ' , which , since t'=M becomes as .
( MP + x'( ' ) ; and this , since mI3+m'f3'm"P3 " , becomes Let m"y " be the directrix of this : then it is clear that r , r ' and y " , being each at right angles to a , , lie in the plane of the triangle ABC , and consequently m7 , m'ry and M yt are the three sides of the triangle ABC , supposing it to be turned round in its plane through 900 .
It follows therefore that m~y " =mr+m'r ' , that is , the directrix of the sum of the two translations is the sum of their directrices .
( 43 .
) Generally , it is manifest from this result , that the Directrix of the Sum of any number of Translations is the Sum of their Directrices .
It is not necessary to point out the importance of this rule as regards the summation of translations , nor its identity with the well-known rule in the Theory of Couples .
( 44 .
) For the sake of convenience it will be worth while to employ some abbreviated mode of specifying the directrix of any translation ; for this purpose I shall adopt the following notation , which , it will be found , will answer all purposes , and at the same time very distinctly mark that property in which the peculiar relation between a translation and its directrix consists .
The property I allude to is the theorem just proved in article 42 .
I shall employ the letter D to stand as an abbreviation for the words " directrix oJ , " and thus D(u.v ) will mean the directrix of the translation u.v. It will be borne in mind , then , that D(u.v ) denotes a line at right angles to the plane of u.v , and containing as many units of length as there are units of area in the parallelogram constructed on u and v. ( 45 .
) Distributiveness of the Operation thus represented.-It is most important to notice the distributive nature of the symbol D. By art .
42 , we have immediately D(u.v)+D(u'.v')=D(u.v+u'.v ' ) ; whence , D denotes a distributive function .
( 46 .
) Consequences hence resulting.-From the equation in art .
45 it follows , that , if m denote any numerical coefficient , positive or negative , D(mu.v ) =mD(u.v ) .
Again , since D(u'.v ' ) -D(u.v)= D(u'.v'u.v ) , we have , passing to limits , d(D(u.v ) ) =D(d(u.v ) ) ; whence also , f(D(u.v ) ) =Df(u .
v ) .
In short , in all operations in which differentiation and integration are concerned , D is to be regarded as if it were an ordinary constant coefficient .
Again ; if we have an equation of the form U.V+U.V+U v.+ &amp;c. = O..(1 .
) there result from it D(u.v)+D(u'.v')+D(u".v")+ &amp;c. =O .
( 2 .
) And , conversely , ( 2 .
) gives ( 1 .
) .
( 47 .
) Inverse of D.-If w be the directrix of u.v , and therefore w=D(u.v ) ; I may of course , according to the true force of the index ( -1 ) , assert , that u.v=Draw .
Thus D-'w comes to be an abbreviation for the words- " the translation whose directrix is w. " It may be well to observe that the following relations result from what has been said , viz. D~z.f3)=r DD3.y)= whence &amp; C. &amp;c. &amp;c. ( 49 .
) Symbolfor Units of Longitudinal Translation.-It has been shown that these units are all equal to each other ; a unit of longitudinal translation is therefore an absolute constant .
No distinctive symbol is necessary , therefore , to represent these units , and it will be allowable to employ the common unit ( 1 ) for the purpose ; just in the same way that we denote all units , whether they be linear , superficial , cubical , mechanical , by this common symbol .
I shall therefore always represent a unit of longitudinal translation by 1 ; and thus put osf _1 , 3X(3=1 rXr 1 , and generally , if m and n denote the magnitudes of u and v , we have ( art .
41 ) uXv=rnncos , d being the angle made by u and v. ( 50 .
) Hence if a and an ' be any two " directions , " we have cx a'= cosine of angle made by a and a ' .
To this may be added magnitude of.='-sine of same angle .
( 51 .
) Projections represented by the lateral and longitudinal translation products .
It is clear from the principles just established , that , if a , 3 , r denote the directions of three coordinate axes , and v any line , the projections of v on the three axes are , numerically , a XV , , f3Xv , yXv .
Again , since uXu is the square of the magnitude of the line u , the projection of v on u is , numerically , u xv V ' x which , putting for u and v the values x &amp; a+yP+zr , x'a+y'p+z'r , becomes by longitudinal multiplication , XXI + yy'+ ?
zzf Vx2+y2+z2 I may use the terms " lateral and longitudinal multiplication " to designate the operations denoted by u.v and u Xv ; for the word " multiplication " has quite lost its original and proper signification even in ordinary algebra .
( 52 .
) If AB represent v , AC the projection of v on u , the magFig .
23 .
nitude and direction of u being m and o ; then CB=AB-AC &amp; v(oxxv)a .
uI think CB might be advantageously called the Complement of the Projection of v on u , for CB added to AC makes up or completes v ; A &lt; and thus , emnploying the usual abbreviation , we may call CB the +my coprojection of v on u. Hence the operation ( z(ez x ) performed on v gives the projection of v on u , and the operation ( I -(oa X o ) the coprojection ; where a denotes the " direction " of u , i. e. UUmuxU ( 53 .
) Since a.v=o-.(AC+CB)=a.CB , it is clear that the symbol ac.v denotes , in magnitude , the coprojection of v on a ; and it also represents the plane of projection .
But Di.v is a better symbol to use ; for its magnitude is the same as that of a.v , and , in direction , it denotes a line at right angles to the plane of projection .
( 54 .
) Repetition of the Operation ( Dac .
) .
This operation is often to be performed twice in investigations , and , on this account , the following relation is important , viz..)2a * =6 ( a6 X Ml )O OC _ Ml .
*** * 4/ _ 1 , because the latter is indefinite , not distinguishing what particular root of is meant ; but the former is perfectly definite , inasmuch as it indicates one particular root of - , namely , that root which denotes rotation through 900 about a as axis* .
The lateral translation-product is therefore well adapted to denote rotation .
Thus ( always supposing that v is at right angles to ae ) , the symbol of a line making an angle d with v , and in a plane at right angles to ca , is SODZ'V which in fact is the same thing as { cos d+(Dac .
) sin 0}v , for cos d and sin 0 represent 02 04 1.2+1.2.3.4 ' and B_ 03~ _______ a 1.2.3+1.2a3.4.5 and sOD " is the symbolic form for expressing +(D c')+(MID whence , since ( Dc.)2= ( DO,.)4='+ &amp;c. , the symbolic equivalence of the forms 6ODS and cos d+(D .
) sin d is manifest .
But the quantity operated upon must necessarily be at right angles to a ; for , otherwise , ( Da)2 is not equivalent to - , as appeals from art .
54 , equation ( 3 .
) .
( 58 .
) Concluding Remarks.-I have now said enough , I think , to explain the nature of the proposed symbolization , and the general rules which regulate the application of the two translation-products .
I have based the whole theory simply and exclusively on the conception of translation , taking my clue front the three suggesting instances , the parallelogram , the couple , and work .
As regards the lateral effect of translation , the theory is nothing but a general development of our geometrical notion of multiplication ; for what is a rectangle , AB(D , considered apart from arithmetical measure , but the effect or product of the translation of Fig. 24 .
AB along AD ?
and this we represent by writing AD before or after C AB .
But this method of representation is clearly incomplete when we put for AB and AD their numerical representations ; and why ?
AD because the special superficial unit then is omitted .
For , suppose AB-3 AD4 , ; then , if we say that the rectangle ABCD is the product of 3 and 4 , or 12 , we mean , 12 superficial units .
Now , by omitting the superficial unit in our representation , we leave out all conception of the plane in which the rectangle lies .
All that I have done above is to restore the superficial unit , and determine its proper representative symbol .
As regards the longitudinal-effect ( suggested by the conception of work ) , it appears that all units are absolutely equivalent , and therefore may be all confounded in the common symbol of unity .
I now proceed to give Applications of the Symbolic forms* u.v and uX v , &amp;c. The geometrical applications which may be made of the principles and notation just explained are of great variety and importance ; but , as I am anxious to dwell chiefly on physical applications , I shall only touch on this part of the subject .
( 59 .
) Surface symbolically considered .
In Symbolic Geometry the symbols of lines represent , not merely length but also direction .
A line is supposed to be the geornetrical effect of the motion of a tracing-point , and the equivalence of lines is considered altogether and exclusively with reference to the change which Fig. 25 .
they represent in the position of the tracing-point .
We consider that X AB is equivalent to A'B ' , uwhen the two lines are of equal length , X parallel , and traced the same way ; for then they represent equivalent changes of position of their respective tracing-points .
It is usual to employ the notation AB to denote the line AB traced from A to B. and BA to denote the same line traced from B to A ; and thus AB=A'B ' , but BA= -A'B ' .
It is clear then that equivalent lines must be , not only of equal length and parallel , but also mDust be traced the same way .
Again , the equivalence being considered only with reference to the tracing-point 's change of position , AC+CB is equivalent to A'B ' .
Now , following this analogy , and regarding surface as the effect of the motion of a tracing-line , just as a line is the effect of the motion of a tracing-point , we may employ symbols to denote surfaces , not merely as regards their Fig. 26 .
numerical area , but also with reference to the manner in which they e___ are generated by their tracing-lines ; and we may also define the 1 ?
\ equivalence of surfaces altogether and exclusively with reference to the change which they represent in the position of the tracing-line .
A Thus , if ABA'B ' , BCB'C ' , ACA'C ' be three parallelograms , and if we conceive them to be generated , respectively , by the translations of A'A along A'B ' B'B along B'C ' , and A'A along A'C ' ; it is clear that ( ABA'B')+(BCB'C ' ) is equivalent to ( ACA'C ' ) , just in the same sense that ( AB+BC ) is equivalent to ( AC ) .
Again , if ABCD and A'B'C'D ' be two parallelograms , AB and Fig. 27 .
AD being respectively parallel and equal to A'3 ' and A'D ' , we may I consider these parallelograms as equivalent to each other , in the same sense exactly that the lines AB and A'B ' are regarded as equivalent .
Only , just as it is necessary for the equivalence of AB and A'B ' , that they should be traced the same way by their rex spective tracing-points , so it is necessary to the equivalence of ABCD and A'B'C'D ' , that they should be traced the same way by their respective tracing-lines .
Now here it is to be observed that a tracing-point is devoid of two important properties which a tracing-line possesses ; I mean , direction and two-sidedness ( if I may so speak ) .
An arrow lying on* a plane , not only points in a particular direction , but has two distinct sides , right and left ( see art .
34 ) .
Hence when we speak of lines described the same way by their tracing-points , and parallelograms described the same way by their tracing-lines , the expression CC same way " includes much more in the latter than in the former case .
For example , the parallelograms generated by the translation of AB along AD , and of DC along DA , though coincident , are described opposite ways .
Again , the parallelograms generated by the translation AB along AD , and of AD along AB , though coincident , are described opposite ways ; for the former is described by a right-side motion , and the .
latter by a left-side ( see art .
34 ) .
( 60 .
) Definition of Surface by reference to Lateral Translation.-It appears to me that the simplest way of including the considerations just alluded to in the general conception of surface requisite in Symbolical Geometry , is to define Surface by reference to the Lateral Effect of the Translation of one line along another .
The Funda , mental Assumption ( article 29 ) is justified in this case , as appears from the remarks just made , and the peculiar relation u.v= -v.u is naturally interpreted ( see art .
34 ) .
I shall therefore define Surface in Symbolic Geometry to be the Lateral Effect of the Translation of one line along another .
By " Effect " here I mean simple Geometrical effect , i. e. change of position in space .
Also I only speak of lateral eJfJct ; because all notion of longitudinal effect is excluded by our ordinary conception of surface , and we may assume that no shifting which a line undergoes in its own direction can generate surface .
( 61 .
) Longitudinal Efftct consideredgeometrically.-But though the shifting of a line in its own direction generates no surface , it produces alteration of position ; and hence it constitutes an important conception .
The only difficulty , in considering the longitudinal effect geometrically , consists in this-How is it that all units of longitudinal translation are equivalent ( see arts .
36 , 37 ) , while those of lateral translation are not , and on what principle can this difference be interpreted ?
The answer appears to be this : that a.p denotes the effect of translating the unit ( 3 along the perpendicular unit o. ; that this operation conveys the conception of a particular plane , and we must think of rz.p , P.y as different operations because they are performed in different planes .
On the contrary , the translation of o along a , or cx a , conveys no conception of a particular plane ; in fact aX o and f3 Xj may be regarded as performed in the same plane .
Thus , that which before made the difference does not exist in this case .
Generally , u. v=u'.v ' , when the two parallelograms geneFig .
28 .
rated are equal in magnitude , and lie in the parallel planes ; iv but uxu and u ' X u ' may be always considered as lying in the same plane ; and consequently difference of magnitude only remains to constitute a difference between uxv and u ' X v ' .
Again , as regards sign , there are four varieties of the form u.v , namely u.v , ( -u ) .
( v ) , both +ve and ( .u ) .
v , u. ( -v ) , both-ve .
But there are only two varieties of the form uXv when v becomes identical with u ; inasmuch as v must be the same as u in sign as well as in magnitude , and consequently the notation does not admit of the variations ( -u)Xu and uX(-u ) .
Nowthe other remaining variations are uXu and ( -u ) X-(-u ) , and these have both the same signs .
Hence ( supposing that u and v are units ) , since units of lateral translation may differ from each other in two particulars only , namely , sign and plane of translation , and since units of longitudinal translation are incapable of differing in these particulars , we may see the interpretation of the result in art .
37 , and its perfect consisten-cy with that in art .
36 .
( 70 .
) Symbol of a line drawn from a given Point.-If we assume that simple letters , such as u , v , w always denote lines of particular lengths and drawn in particular directions , but all starting from the Origin of Coordinates 0 ; then Fig. 29 .
the proper symbol for denoting a line v drawnfrom the point P , OP being u , will be v+u.v+u X v ; for v denotes the line v drawn from 0 , and u.v+u xv the lateral and 0 longitudinal effects of translating it from 0 to P , which effects , as above stated , have reference only to the change of position of P. I shall reserve the consideration of this symbolization for a future occasion , as a striking instance of the same thing will be given in the next section .
II .
STATICAL APPLICATION OF THE SYMBOLIC FORMS .
( 71 .
) Equivalence of Parallel and Equal Translations.-As a necessary preliminary the Fundamental Assumption in art .
29 must be justified .
To do this it is only neces'sary to bear in mind that all statical problems are reducible to the case of balancing forces acting on the same rigid body .
Now let AB and CD be Fig. 30 .
any two parallel and equal lines in the same rigid body ; join AP and D , C and B ; the intersection E bisecting the two joining lines ; and let P and Q be two equal parallel forces acting at ABA and D. a Then P and Q are equivalent to P+Q at E , and P+Q at E is equivalent to P at B and Q at C. We may therefore translate P from A to B , provided we , at the same time , translate Q from D to C. Whence it follows that the translation of Q from C to D must be equivalent to the translation of P from A to B. Thus the fundamental assumption is justified .
( 72 .
) Representation of Forces-by Lines.-It will be remembered that the general symbolic representation of forces by lines assumes the truth of the Parallelogram of Fories .
As a muatter of curiosity it may be asked , is it possible to apply this Symbolization of Translation to prove the Parallelogram of forces .
, without assuming that forces are represented by lines ?
It may be done very simply , and I give the proof here as an example of the application of the method .
It may be seen , on referring to art .
21 and the following articles , that there is no assumption whatever of the possibility of representing forces by lines generally .
The arrow representing the translated magnitude is used merely as a conventional symbol , just as a letter in algebra .
I therefore may apply the notation u.v to the present question , provided I consider v to be the symbol of a force , and not of a line representing that force .
I must not however employ the reasoning in art .
32 , for that distinctly assumes the point in question .
The following then is the proof I shall give .
( 73 .
) Parallelogram of Forces.-Let A , B , C denote any Fig. 31 .
three units of force , and a , b , c units of length ( directed Ze units ) parallel respectively to A , B , C ; let X , Y Z , xyz / T7c be pure numbers ; suppose that the forces XA , YB , ZC sin balance each other , and that xa , yb , zc are the three sides of a triangle formed by lines drawn parallel to the forces .
Then by successive addition we have xa+yb+zc=O , ... .
( I. ) and by simultaneous addition XA+Y.B+ZC=O .
( 2 .
) Hence , from ( L. ) and ( 2 .
) , we have ( -c).(ZC ) = ( xa Jryb ) .
( XA + YB ) ; or , observing that ( since no lateral effect is produced by translating a magnitude inits own direction ) c.C , a.A , b.B are each zero , we have O=xY(a .
B)+yX(b .
A ) .
( 3 .
) Now , without altering the directions of the units A , B , a , b , let us put X=Y ; in which case it is self-evident , that ZC must become equally inclined , to XA and YB , and therefore zc must make equal angles with xa and yb , which gives x=y .
Thus ( 3 .
) becomes a.B+b.A=O , or b.A--a.B .
Wherefore , restoring the inequality of X and Y , we find from ( 3 .
) , ( xY-yX)a.B=O , or xY-yX=O .
And similarly , we may show that yZ-ZY=O zX-txZ=O ; whence X:Y:Z::x.:y:z .
And this is , virtually , the Parallelogram of Forces .
Thus it appears that the notation u.v is capable of affording a simple proof of the great fundamental theorem of Statics ; this application of the method is given , however , as I stated above , merely to show by example what can be done in this way .
I may observe that the whole of the proof here given depends simply upon two things , the distributiveness of u.v , and the fact that numerical coefficients may be brought out and incorporated by actual multiplication .
I now proceed to give , generally , the mode of applying the notation to determine the conditions of equilibrium of a rigid body , or a system of particles .
( 74 .
) Remarkable symbolization ( rf a Force acting at a Spec jfed Point of a Rigid Boay .
One of the most remarkable symbolizations which my proposed method leads to appears to me to be the following .
Let U denote a force ( in magnitude and direction ) acting at any assumed origin A , then UJ+u.U will completely denote the same force supposed to act at the point u , that is , at the point ( P ) whose distance from the origin is , symbolically , u. For if we apply the force at the origin A and then translate it to P , it will be the Fig. 32 .
same thing as if we applied the force directly at P. Thus z effect of force at P=effect at A ( or U ) / +effect of translation from A to P. But , the lateral effect only of the translation need be considered , for the longitudinal effect is zero , inasmuch as we may suppose a force to act at any point of its line of direction on a rigid body .
/ Hence the effect of the force acting at P is symbolically represented by the force U+ lateral effect of translation , or U+u.U .
( 75 .
) Symbol of a Couple.-Let the couple consist of two forces , U Fig. 33 .
at the point u , and -U at the point u ' : then these two forces are comr U pletely represented , as regards their effect on the rigid body , by the UU expression A -v ( U+u.U)+( -U+u'.(-U ) ) or .
( u-U , ) .
U , which is the general symbol for a couple ; as indeed is clear beforehand from the fact , that the couple is that which translates the force U from the point ( u ' ) to the point ( u ) , i. e. along the line ( u-u ' ) .
It will be generally simpler to employ the symbol in the form U. U , u here denoting , symbolically , the line drawn from the point of application of the force ( U ) to that of the force ( U ) .
The directrix of this , i. e. the axis of the couple , is D(u.U &gt; ) ( 76 .
) To combine a given Set of Couples.-Let us put ( see art .
15 ) u-zXa+y03+Z7 U-Xa+Yi3+Zr .
Then we find , by lateral multiplication , U.* Up= ( xY -YX ) a. + ( YZ Y)# * .
' y ( 2XxZ)y 7a Hence , if we suppose the given couples to be u.U , u'.U ' , ji .
U"l &amp;c. , and if we put , for brevity , :(xY mmyX ) =N , N(yZ-zY ) = L , N ( zX xZ)=M , the combined effect of the couples will be * U ) = L3 .
r+ My .
a ?
+ NaM =D-'(L ?
+MP+Ny ) ( art .
48 ) .
Heuice , if we assume G to denote the magnitude and r ' the direction of Lvc+MI3 ?
Ny , which gives ( art .
17 ) G L2+ +N .
( 1 .
) , ... . .
L(2 .
) ; we find:u.U=D-'(Gy ' ) -Ga.pf ( arts .
48 and 16 ) .
Here c2.4 ' denotes a unit-couple in a plane at right angles to y ' ; and thus the resultant is a couple G in this plane ; G and y ' being given by ( l. ) and ( 2 .
) .
( 77 .
) To combine a given Set of Forces acting at given Points of a Rigid Body .
Let the forces be U , U ' , U , " &amp;c. , and their points of application u , u ' , u " , &amp;c. ; then , by art .
74 , their combined effect will be.(U+u.U ) .
Hence , if we put X=X ' Y=YI ' Z=ZI and employ the notation of the preceding article , the ( eombined effect becomes Xca+Y1+Z , ?
+Ga'.P3 ' , or RcaI+Gacl .
P ' , where R2=X2+Y2+Z2,.(3 .
) and r.=Ih I +_'+..r. .
( 4 .
) RI Rip ]I , Thus it appears that the set of given forces are combined into a single force RI , ( given by ( 3 .
) and ( 4 .
) ) , and a single couple Gvz'43 .
( given by ( I. ) and ( 2 .
) previous article ) .
From the result just obtained the various well-known conditions and equations , relating to the effect of a set of forces on a rigid body , immediately follow .
To exemplify the method I shall apply the formula Ra , +Gov'.3 ' to the following question .
( 78 .
) To combine the set of forces into Two Forces.-Let us so Fig. 44 .
choose a ' and 3 ' ( which are arbitrary , except so far as they are perpendicular to r ' ) , that 3 ' shall be in the same plane as rY and y ' ; , and let 0 be the angle which tie , makes with If .
Then , by article 17 , 0 7y=7 cos O+3 ' sin d ; Ryr+Gc .
P3'=(R , cos O)r'+(R , sin d)t'+Gx'43 ' ( R cos d)y'+(R , sin 0)'+ ( R Oa ' &gt; ( R sin t)X3 .
Now by article 74 this is the expressidn for the effect of two forces , viz. RX cos d in the direction v- ' , and R , sin 4 in the direction 3 ' , the former acting at the origin , and the latter at a point whose distance from the origin is R sin 9 drawn in the direction a ' .
R , G , V and y , are given by the equations ( 1 ) , ( 2 ) , ( 3 ) , ( 4 ) above ; a ' is determined because it is at right angles to the plane ( and 3 ' , because it is in the same plane , and at right angles to y ' .
As regards 0 , we have , taking the longitudinal product of ( 2 .
) and ( 4 .
) , LX , +MY , +NZ , LR1 ~ --f X 71=cos0 .
( 79 .
) Centre of Parallel Forces.-Let the magnitudes of the parallel forces be R , R1 ' , W , &amp;c. , 7 , their common direction , and u , u ' , U"1 , &amp;c. their points of application .
Then their combined effect is &gt; ( Ret ) + &gt; S Roy ) = ( .
R)l *(R Y4R Now , by art .
74 , this is the symbol for a force : R , acting in the direction 7 , , and at a point whose distance from the origin is Y.Ru Y- ; Rx Y.Ry Y-Rz or a+ =I3 ?
TP+ 7 which expresses the common formulae for the centre of parallel forces .
III .
APPLICATION OF THE SYMBOLIC FORMS TO DYNAMICS .
( 80 .
) EIfctive Force , Vis-Viva , Work.-If u be the distance of a movring particle m from the origin at any time t , it is clear .
that du represents , in magnitude and direction , the space .
described in the time dt ; and thus the complete symbol of the velocity becomes du Also d( ) represents , in magnitude and direction , the alteration of velocity in the time dt ; and thus the complete symbol of the effective force is d2u Again , if U denote any force acting on m , it is easy to see that the symbol of the work accumulated , while m is moving from the point u to the point u ' , is U1 f UXdu .
Lastly , if for U here we put the effective force , the effective work will be , u ' d2u jyp meXdu m dut du ' du du\ or -*tX t dtX t ) d Here du X du denotes the square of the velocity ( art .
49 ) , and thus the expression denotes the ordinary vis-viva .
( 81 .
) Description of Areas.-It is clear that 2u.du is the area described in the time dt by u ; for it is the half parallelogram formed on u and du .
But it is to be noticed that 2u.du represents this area , not only in magnitude , but also in position .
If we put u. du=Adt , we find dA It d2u du du du du dt-=tU.de +t *dt and 7t* t= ( art .
32 ) ; dA 1 d2( whence d=vd2- ... ..\ .
A , here , is a symbol which represents two important things:-lst , in magnitude , it is the ordinary rate of description of area ( r2= ) ; 2ndly , its plane is the plane containing the radius vector and the direction of motion , i. e. the plane of the orbit of m. DA is the symbol of a line perpendicular to the plane of the orbit , and , equal in magnitude to the rate of description of area .
If we put u=xcs+yp+zy , and perform the operation indicated in equation ( 1 .
) , we d(DA ) d 1y d2 , x / d2z die \ ( d2e d2z\ find , dt ( Xdt2 -yd)r+ ( .dt2 -d -)Zr+ 1Zdt2X ft3 .
( 82 .
) Expressionfor Effective Force with reference to radius vector , angular velocity , and plane of orbit.-Let r denote the magnitude and M the " direction " &lt; of u ; let f3 denote a direction in the plane of the orbit of m ( and , of course , at right angles to a ) ; then y will be a direction always perpendicular to the plane of the orbit : lastly , let X denote the angular velocity of u , and 0 ' the angular velocity of the plane of the orbit about u , w and di being numerical quantities .
On referring to art .
19 , the following relations are manifest , dc .
dj3 _ u=rc Tt= dt =a+w ' for dt and denote , in magnitude and direction , the veloFig .
35 .
cities of the extremities of the directed units oa and IS , and T the figure will show what their values are in terms of we and J/ .
-ro / W dh dtt Hence we immediately find the required expression for the effective force d2u by simple differentiation , as follows , du dr da dr ?
Mr ~=T+rcWP dt dt0 +dt Id ?
+rl dl'u d'r , dr da drw do di-2 =o dtM tg+ dt P+revdt-7 +'u 2 I ?
d(w)p or effective force = ( dU rw2 ) ( + x+ d ))3 ?
+rwcVr .
Hence it appears that the effective force is equivalent to the well-known expressions along and perpendicular to the radius vector , together with a third part , red perpendicular to the plane of the orbit .
( 83 .
) The use of the forms u. v and uXv exempljfed in the case of motion about a centre of force varying as r`.-This case appears to me to afford so good an illustration of the use of these forms , that I shall give it here briefly .
Assuming a , A , r , r as in the preceding article , it is clear that the symbol of the central force is P-2M and therefore we have d2U whence u.Tt=O , since u=raz , and a. &amp; =O , therefore ( by art .
81 ) , d= .
This indicates that there is no variation of A , and consequently ( see art .
81 ) that the plane of the orbit , and the rate of description of area is constant .
du ~~du d___ If we put for A its value ( art .
81 ) -u .
Tt and for u and their values rot and ( rt ) 2 ~~~~~~~~~dt ' dct observing that at-=I , we find As=2ra ado+rwp -r2wtoz .
P , o0 , by ( 2 .
) , A=-hat.3 ( h=r2c , as usual ) .
Now it is singular that ( 1 .
) admits of immediate integration , instead of requiring the I dj9 well-known transformations : , for , in it , put for a its value , did ( see art .
82 ) , and we have d25u _ d13 d,3 dt2 r2w dth dt ' wherefore , integrating , we find du- &gt; 3+ constant .
du Here put for dt its value , and there results dt a+r43= , f3+ constant ( Ca ' suppose* ) .
Multiply this longitudinally by 3 , and , since P3 X CG=0 , PX XI l , and ( X X A'=ac X ax = cos 0 , we find rw=p +c Cos 0 ; or , since rcn =- , this gives I kC --rh2+h cos a , the well-known equation .
0 being the angle which a ( the direction of the radius vector ) makes with ioM ' ( an arbitrary constant direction ) .
The manner in which the symbolic forms have effected this integration appears to me to be worthy of notice .
( 84 .
) General Expression for the Momentum of a Rigid Body moving in any manner.-The Momentum of a particle ( m ) , moving with a velocity ( t ) , is do~~~~~~~~d du mdT .
And this symbol represents the Momentum in direction as well as magnitude .
Now momentum is really aforce , estimated , however , somewhat differently from ordinary pressure , on the principle that the true dynamical effect of a force is proportional to absolute intensity and the time of its action conjointlyt .
Hence , regarding the momentum of m as a force , its complete symbol will be ( by art .
74 ) , mdu , mdu\ dt +u* d Thus the symbol of the total momentum of the rigid body will be +u.t *( .
) ( 85 .
) If ii denote the distance of the centre of gravity from the origin , and u ' the distance of the point ( u ) from the centre of gravity , we havie u=~i+u ' , and thus , since 1mu ' 0 , ( 1 .
) becomes ( putting M for ] ?
n ) du+i dii .
/ du'\ Md +u ( Md)+ tm( ?
'.-).(2 .
) Now here , by ( 1 .
) , M + .
Mdt is the expression for the momentum of M concentrated into the centre of gravity , and:m(u ' .
- ) is the momentum of the body as regards its motion relatively to the centre of gravity ( as is evident from ( 1 .
) , for , if du the origin have no. momentum , :tm n ) .
In Section V. I shall show , that E~m Ut D ) =-(Awl &amp; + Bw213+ Cw .
, y ) , that is , a couple whose axis is Awlo+Bx2P+Cwty .
Here A , B , C are the moments of inertia about the three principal axes , of which A , ( 3 , y are supposed to be the directions ; and c , , wX , wk are the well-known component angular velocities .
( 86 .
) General Expressionfor the Energy of a Rigid Body moving in any manner .
I venture to suggest the word " energy " as a proper designation for the total effective force by which the motion of a rigid body is produced , inasmuch as evevpyeta means force actually exerted and effective .
The symbol , then , of the energy of a rigid body will be Emdt2 +b.dt2 .
du du Now , observing that dt *d =0 we have d2 / du\ 8 .
t2=du .
t. Hence the expression for the energy is d:E / du du ] wt jmd+t dtj Comparing this with the expression for the momentum in art .
84 , we have d ( momentum ) energy = dt. .
( l* ) ( 87 .
) This , though a very simple result , is really one of importance ; thus if the centreI of gravity be fixed , we find ( by art .
85 .
) d energy =D-l dt(Awm+Bc43+Cw3y ) .
Now it will be shown in Sect. V. that dt w d=Dt PI p =Dt .
, where =wla+ 2+ 37Hence , performing the differentiation , and observing that D'ao=P.y , D-'3=1y.c , D-1y= &amp; o3 , and DT'D=1 , rw " Bw dw3 wefind energy=Adtt + -Y4-Bry.o+Cd m +X .
2+'CW7 ) .
Lastly , if we perform the lateral multiplication denoted by x. here , we find energy ={A + ( C B)W2W3 } *Y + { B d2+ ( AC)ws , )y +{ CL03+ ( B-A)IZ2)ap .
1 need not point out the meaning of this formula in relation to EULER'S equations for a rigid body .
( 88 .
) General Expression for the " Vis-Mortua ' " or " Dead Pull t on a Rigid Body .
-1 may use the almost obsolete word " s Vis-Mortua " ( which has been so well translated by the familiar expression " ( Dead Pull " ) in the sense in which it was originally employed to denote simple pressure or impressed force .
I shall therefore designate the total mechanical effect of the impressed forces acting on a rigid body as the VisMortua or Dead Pull on that body .
If U denote the force acting at the point ( u ) , we have , therefore by art .
74 , VisMortua=:(U+u .
U ) this of course is the same expression as that in art .
77 .
If we put , as before , u=u u ' , this expression becomes 1U+u.2+U ?
u'l .
U. Here WU+u.ITJ is the symbol of the force : U acting at the point ( -a ) , and Nu'.U is ( art .
75 ) the symbol of a couple .
( 89 .
) As an example , the result of which I shall require in Sect. V. , I shall calculate the Vis-Mortua of a rigid body acted on by the attraction of a distant particle in ' , taking the centre of gravity of the rigid body as origin , and a , [ 3 , y as the directions of the three principal axes ; assuming also u ' to denote the distance of mn ' , r ' the magnitude of u/ , and r that of u. Here U is a force acting along the line joining the two points ( u ) and ( u ' ) , and inversely proportional to the square of the magnitude of -that line .
The line alluded to isu ' a-u its magnitude is V &lt; ( u'-u ) X ( u'u ) , and its direction therefore is u'-u Hence U=mm ' ( U ' U ) { ( u'-U ) X(UbW)V Also { -U ) X ( U'-U ) ( U X_ 2u Xu+uX u ) ( r-22u X u+r2 &gt; )2 I ?
1 3u)xu l =Ht1+rte )nearly .
Hence , observing that u.u=o , and Emu=O , we have lu .
U= r-5 Nm(U ' X u ) ( U *U ' ) 3m ' =-_7-u ' .
{ : m(u ' Xu)u } .
Now Im(u'x u)u= =En(xx ' '+yy'+ zz ' ) ( xac+y3+ zry ) = ( jmx)X'ca+ ( Im~y').y'F3+ ( Imz2)z'r , by properties of principal axes , ( 2mr'-A ) x'e+ ( 2mr 2B)y'j + ( Imr2 C)z'r = ( Imr2)u ( Ax'i + By'3 + C'y ) .
Wherefore , observing that u ' .
u'= 0 , we find 3m ' u. U=-ru = ' .
( Axz ' + By'(3 + Cz'y ) .
Also ~ U=hzmu-u .
3u'xu Also : EU= -Immn rs-p(neglecting.2 for obvious reasons ) =Mm7 , l { mu=o .
Hence we have t ' 3m ' Vis-Mortua=Mm ' , + +-u'.(Axa+Bsy'f3+Cz'y ) , which expresses a force Mm ' U !
acting at the origin , and a couple , 3m ' 7m-u ' ( Ax%+By'pi+Cz'y ) .
If we perform the lateral multiplication indicated by ( u ' .
) , this couple becomes { ( C B)y'z',.7+ ( AC)z'x'y .
a+ ( BA)x'y'ez which gives the three well-known couples in the theory of Precession and Nutation .
IV .
APPLICATION OF THE SYMBOLIC FORMS TO DETERMINE THE CORRECTION FOR THE EARTH'S ROTATION IN PROBLEMS RELATING TO MOTION ON OR NEAR THE EARTH'e SURFACE .
( 90 .
) The best way of defining that which is commonly called the Centrifugal Force appears to be the following , viz , that it is an imaginary force which may be introduced as a correction for the error of not taking into account the rotation of the radius vector r. Suppose P to denote the accelerating force acting along r , and let us for a moment forget that r has an angular velocity ( d ) , then we put but this is erroneous , and we must correct it for the rotation by adding to P the ( d~2 term r , as is well known .
Hence we may regard the centrifugal force as a correction for neglected rotation .
But it only corrects the error so far as the motion along r is concerned ; another correction ( supposing still the rotation is neglected or forgotten ) is necessary to be applied at right angles to r , namely , the imaginary force dt I dt ) Thus the true and complete correcting force is the resultant of the two forces do Id / r2dG rsdt anddt4d J It appears to me that the idea here suggested might be applied with great advantage to cases of motion on or near the earth 's surface .
The beautiful pendulum experiment which made so much noise last year , and the various investigations respecting it , give great interest to such cases of motion .
I propose therefore to investigate here , by the aid of the Symbolic Forms , the proper symbol of the imaginary force which corrects completely for the -earth 's rotation supposed to be neglected .
By the aid of this symbol , it will be found that the greatest possible simplicity is introduced into investigations such as those relating to the pendulum experiment .
It will enable the investigator to forget altogether the earth 's rotation in framing his equations of motion , and at the same time to correct his error by the introduction of a simple term .
( 91 .
) Let w denote a line pointing in the direction of the earth 's polar axis ( north suppose ) , and representing , by its length , the earth 's angular velocity .
In other words , let w be the directrix of the earth 's rotation , then ( as will be shown in Sect. V. ) it is easy to see , that , if u denote ( symbolically ) the distance of any point from the earth 's centre , the velocity communicated to it by the earth 's rotation ( if it be fixed to the earth ) is represented by the symbol * TM.u .
Now let d , denote differentiation ( of u ) on the erroneous supposition that the earth is fixed , and w the true and complete differentiation ; then the true velocity of the point u is dt and this must be the resultant of the erroneous velocity ( / ) and the velocity ( Dc.u ) due to the rotation .
Hence we have $u du dt= d +Dw.u .
The effective accelerating force will be obtained by the true and complete differentiation of the correct velocity , that is , or die ) +Dw . ?
t ( observing that 4 is a constant ) , which , putting for the above value , becomes d2u du + 2D+ .
-+DwD .
A(D.u Hence if U denote ( symbolically ) the resultant of the accelerating forces , whatever they may be , which act on the point ( u ) , we find dlu du dt2 +2DwJ .
t +.(D.)'u=(U ... ) I may observe , in passing , that , since d+(Dw .
) represents the complete differentiation of U , we might have written down the equation of motion immediately , in the form { d+ ( Dwo .
) } 2=U5 which , expanded , is identical with ( 1 .
) .
Now , if we had forgotten the earth 's rotation , we should have put , instead of ( 1 .
) , d2u_ L=U .
Hence it appears that , if we neglect the rotation in forming the equation of motion , we may correct the error , by supposing that there is the imaginary force r dt -{2Dc~ .
dt+ ( Dov.)2uj ... ... ... ..(2 .
) acting in addition to the real force represented by U ; for on this supposition we find d~u du dt =U D ... ( 3 .
) which is equivalent to ( I. ) .
As regards terrestrial problems , however , the expression ( 2 .
) admits of an important simplification ; for the accelerating force of gravity ( g ) , which of course is included in U , is supposed to be the resultant of the earth 's attraction , and the common centrifiugalforce .
Now this common centrifugal force is that which is conceived to be in action upon a particle rigidly connected with the revolving earth ; in other words , it du is what ( 2 .
) becomes when yt=0 .
Wherefore the expression for the common centrifugalforce is.(D .
) U..(4 .
) As this therefore is included among the forces which U represents , it ought to be omitted in the equation ( 3 .
) .
Thus we find that du -2D .
( 5 .
) is the force which must be supposed to act on the point ( u ) as a correction for the neglected rotation .
We may , therefore , in all problems of motion relative to the earth , forget altogetber the earth 's rotation , provided we introduce the force ( 5 .
) , in addition to the accelerating forces , whatever they may be , which are really in action upon the point ( u ) ; it being understood that the common centrifugal force is allowed for in g. ( 92 .
) In ( 5 .
) Tt is the apparent velocity of the point u ( apparent , that is , to an observer unconscious of the earth 's motion ) ; and if n denote the earth 's angular velocity , and y ' the direction of the polar axis , w=n'y ' .
Thus ( 5 .
) becomes 2nD7 .
dt .
( 6 .
) du Now this represents a force at right angles to V and t , z. e. to the polar plane in which the apparent velocity is taking place at the instant t. Also the magnitude of this force is 2n times the apparent velocity ( u ) multiplied by the sine of the angle fdu\~~~~~~~~~~~~d it Idt makes with the polar axis ( y ' ) .
Fig. 36 .
( 93 .
) This force may be expressed with reference to horizontal and vertical coordinates at any place , as follows : A~~ -O Let 0 be the place , #y the vertical at 0 , and then the plane ( ap3 ) will be horizontal : also let oa be chosen so as to lie in the meridian plane ; and let I denote the latitude of 0 ( i. e. the angle y ' makes with a ) .
Then 7M cos l+# sin 1..(7 .
) Also if we take u to denote the distance of the moving point from 0 at any time t4 and therefore put u=-ea+yP3+Zy,.(8 .
) du il etesm stedu du dt will be the same as the dt in ( 6 .
) , for all that we have to express by d is the apparent velocity of the point u. Hence , differentiating ( 8 .
) , and performing the operations indicated by 2nD7 ' .
, ( 6 .
) becomes -2nD(a cos l+y sin 1 ) .
++ or 2n{( y sin l)a+ ( -t sin dz lCos ( cos l)y(9 ) Hence the ordinary equations of motion will be d~~~~~x~d dt =X+2ndt sinl 1 !
!2=Y-2ndT sin 1+2ndT cos I.(10 .
) d2z 2ndy Cos I* Originally u was measured from the earth 's centre .
2 c2 where X , Y , Z represent the accelerating forces , whatever they may be , that are in action on the point U. ( 94 .
) The formation of these equations , here given , affords a good example of the use of the symbolic form u.v : but , to illustrate the method more clearly , it will be worth while to employ , in some particular problem , the general equation , dtu U du .
du which includes the three equations ( 10 .
) , U denoting Xom+YP+Zy .
The problem I shall choose will be that of the Pendulum Experiment .
Fig. 37 .
Let QP represent the string at any time t , QO its vertical position , c its length ; then OQ:cy , OP=u , PQ=cy-u , cr also direction of PQ=u- .
Let T denote ( in magnitude ) the tension of PQ ; and then , since the direction of T is that of PQ , the symbol of the tension is T uC ; to which if we add -gy , the symbol of the force of gravity , we find U=T -tc-gfy=(T-.o , y--u .
UTC ' ) u Hence ( 11 .
) becomes d~u T du d=(T-g)y--u-2nDy'.d ... ( 12 .
) Now , for greater simplicity , I shall suppose that u represents a small excursion , and ca long string .
On this supposition we may regard u as always horizontal .
Also , if we put for ry ' its value ( 7 .
) , the equation ( 12 .
) becomes dC du T iF U { t+2nsin1Dy.dT--U B+ 2ncoslDa .
d-(T-g~}o du du du Hence , since Tt is horizontal , Do.t is vertical , and Die .
t is horizontal , The equation ( 12 .
) , therefore , is separated into two parts , horizontal and vertical , which , being equated to zero , we obtain d2u du T dte + 2n sin IDfy Wit-c u.u ... ( I13 .
) ( T-g)y= 2ncsD .
( 14 .
) dt .
1 .
We have to substitute for T in ( 13 .
) its value derived from ( 14 .
) , which on account of the smallness of n , and the fact that T is multiplied by c in ( 13 .
) , gives Tg for a first approximation .
Hence ( 13 .
) becomes Now , here , the operation , ( Die .
) is performed only on lines at right angles to y ; we may therefore put V'-1 for ( Die .
) ( see art .
55 ) ; and thus ( 15 .
) becomes d2u dug 2n sin Is/ -i d-9u=0 .
( 16 .
) The roots of the equation ( d ) 22n sin IVf(d ) = are -n sin IV-i ?
/ sing2 1_ C or ( +-n sin Mr)V if , for brevity , we put n2 sin2 1+4=m2 .
Hence the solution of ( 16 .
) is C _6 .
( 17 .
) The constants A and B here denote two arbitrary lines in the horizontal plane .
If the earth were fixed , the form of the solution would have been =As { for then m2=c } Now 8-ntsinlV--1 indicates a uniform backward rotation of Asmtwl ?
+Be-mt^'-J with an angular velocity n sin 1 .
Thus it appears that the apparent curve of motion of the pendulum will be the same form as if the earth were fixed , only there will be a slow angular regression of the whole about the vertical as axis at the rate n sin 1 per second .
I may observe , in passing , that the simplest interpretation of ( 17 .
) is this ; that the motion of the point ( u ) results from the superposition of two motions , Ag(m-nsinl)tV-1 and B1-(mensinl)tV 1 ; and these are two uniform circular* motions , the former that of the line A forward with an angular velocity ( m-n sin 1 ) ; the latter that of B backward with an angular velocity rn-n sin 1 .
( 95 .
) As my object is simply to exemplify the application of my notation , I shall not proceed to a second approximation ; which however is very easily effected by substituting for T in ( 13 .
) its complete value given by ( 14 .
) , after having put for u in ( 14 .
) the value ( 17 .
) just obtained .
The result is important , especially as regards motion near the equator .
The symbolic forms u.v and uxv are singularly useful , as it appears to me , in all cases of the Motion of a Rigid Body in space , especially as regards Rotation .
Considerable simplification is also gained by employing da , dp , die to denote the angular motions of the three axes oa , A , y. I shall now proceed to consider this case .
I shall take a , F3 , y to denote three rectangular directions fixed in the Rigid Body , and x , y , z the coordinates of any particle ( i ) of the body .
On this supposition x , y , z are constants as regards t , while cc , 3 , y are variables .
The origin is the fixed point ( the centre of gravity , namely , ) about which the body moves .
u denotes the distance of ?
n from the origin , and therefore ( 97 .
) Now the rigidity of the body requires that the velocity ( d ) of m shall be at right angles to u always ; this may be expressed ( see art .
44 ) by putting Idu D. u ... .
( 2 .
) where w denotes some unknown line .
It may be shown , as follows , that w is a function of t only , or , in other words , that w is the same for all points of the body , i. e. for all values of u. Let ( u ' ) be any point in space , and let us assume , as we may , that this point moves always with a velocity Dc.u ' ; then du ' D.u ... ( 3 .
) and hence , by ( 2 ) , d(u ' -u)=DW -u.4 dt =Dw.('-.u).(4 .
) Now u'-u is the line joining the two points ( u ) and ( u ' ) , and the square of its length is *~ ~ ~~~~~~ ( ( Ur ) X ( ma -u ) , d d(u'- ) and dj{(u'--u ) X ( U'--u ) =2 dt X ( u-u)=O ; d(u'-u ) for ( 4 .
) shows that dt and u'-u are at right angles .
Consequently the length of the line u'-u is invariable .
In precisely the same way ( 3 .
) shows ( what indeed is otherwise obvious ) that the line u ' is of invariable length , Hence the point ( u ' ) is rigidly connected with the origin and with the point ( u ) ; and consequently ( u ' ) is a point of the rigid body .
rherefore , comparing ( 2 .
) and ( 3 .
) , it appears that a ; does not vary when we pass from one point to another of the rigid body .
This result is of great importance , and furnishes , in the simplest possible manner , every formula necessary for determining the motion of the rigid body .
( 98 .
) The symbol X represents , in direction , the instantaneous axis of rotation .
For ( 2 .
) shows that , when u coincides in direction with x , =dt 0 ; consequently all the points of the body which lie in the direction of w are quiescent at the instant t. ( 99 .
) The mag nitude of X is the instantaneous angular velocity .
For , let at denote any unit line fixed in the body at right angles to x ; then ( see art .
19 ) d is the angular dc41~~~~~d velocity , at least in magnitude .
But , by ( 2 .
) , d =Do.d ; and , since w is at right angles to af , Dw.cd ' has the same magnitude as X ( see art .
40 .
) .
Wherefore w has the dcl ' same magnitude as W - , and therefore represents the angular velocity in magnitude .
( 100 .
) Hence the result above obtained , namely , du dt Dw .
u ... . .
* .
***** * pletely expressed by ( 4 .
) ; for , if it be required to find the effect of the superposition of two angular velocities represented by w and a ' , we find by ( 4 .
) that the velocity produced by w in any point ( u ) is Dw.u , and that produced by J is D/ .u .
The actual velocity of ( u ) will be the resultant of these , that is , Dw.u+Da".u , or D(w+w').u .
Now by ( 4 .
) D(a'+a).u is the effect of an angular velocity represented by a'+a " .
Hence it follows that the two angular velocities c and a " superposed produce the same effect as the angular velocity '+wi ; and w+a is the third side of the triangle formed of the two lines a and a " .
( 103 .
) The equation of motion of a rigid body acted on by any forces ( about its centre of gravity ) is easily obtained as follows .
Let U denote the accelerating force in action on m , i. e. at the point ( u ) ; then , by Sect. III , we have.mu Ybu which is the same thing ( see art .
S6 ) as d(2mud# =:m U , .
Now , putting for u its value ( 1 .
) , and supposing that a , , y are the principal axes of the body ; we find du di dc t\ d dt ( a*d)TZ aldt)myJ(D l/ But , by ( 4 .
) and ( 5 .
) , dca dt=DVD-t , +r Das.d2a'2I+a'r Similarly D and Dyrq=Woa'1+2P3 ; whence , introducing D , we find 2mDu.t= ( a43+a ' , )pmx + ( a'3roa'1c)rny2+ ( aa+a2f3lmz2Awla +Ba2'4+ Cw ' , r , where A , B and C denote respectively nM(y2+z2 ) , :m(z2+x2 ) , In(x2+y2 ) .
Thus ( 7 .
) becomes d d(Awla ++Bo23+ Caw37y ) =mDu .
U. .
( 8 This is the general equation of motion of a rigid body about a fixed point .
It gives the three well-known equations immediately by equating the coefficients of os , A 2* .
But the equation ( 8 .
) as it stands is more available for the solution of problems , and furnishes results much more simply , than the three equations alluded to .
Along with ( 8 .
) we must employ the equation du d=JDh ... .(9 .
) And these two are completely equivalent to the six equations commonly employed .
( 104 .
) The line represented by the symbol Aw1cG+ BlP2f3+Coy has a remarkable relation to the instantaneous axis Wa +w23+w3y , which may be thus interpreted .
Suppose the rigid body to undergo a distortion or unequal expansion of such a nature , that all lines in it parallel to o become A times longer than before , all lines parallel to ( 3 , B times longer , and all lines parallel to y , C times longer .
The effect of this will be to convert the unit oa into AOa , f3 into BP , y into Cy ; and thus the line iac+w2 !
+wfy will be converted into Aw1ao+BwP2f+Ccd3y .
This latter line , therefore , I may call the Distorted Instantaneous Axis .
( 1 05 .
) The distortion here alluded to is one of great importance to be noted , because it indicates an operation which has immediate connection with many remarkable physical phenomena as well as with various theories in Solid Geometry .
As regards its geometrical meaning , if we conceive the rigid body to be a solid composed of spherical shells having a common centre at the origin , each shell will be converted into an ellipsoid by the distortion .
The sphere whose radius is unity will be changed into an ellipsoid whose axes are Am , BP , C7 ; and the axes of the other ellipsoids will be parallel and proportional to these .
The line represented by the symbol Aa+B@+Cy is an important detertnining'element .
If we assume a ' to denote what w becomes in consequence of the distortion , it may be easily seen that w ' is a distributive function of w and Aa+BP+CC ; and from this fact a number of curious symbolical relations may be deduced .
But I must not dwell upon this subject of distortion now further than my immediate purpose requires .
( 106 .
) Using c1 for brevity to denote the distorted instantaneous axis , Awl ?
sB &gt; R3+ Ccw3y , X may observe that the equation ( 8 .
) , that is , Xt =UmDu U , ... ... ... .
( 10 .
) *Observingthtdo c.a d~ D.d D~ , wefn3h inthat -I=Dw.cc , Dw q3 , -7 =Dw.y , we find the coefficient of y in the first member to be dt dt dC dt + ( B-A)W Wo2 dt 2 and putting U=Xa+Y03+Zy , ,we find , in the second member , M~~~~cccLH.:mxYyX CONCEPTIONgives the velocity of the point ( in ) in space , the differential letter , d , denoting absolute change of position .
But it is often important to determine the motion of this point relatively to the rigid body ; and this may be done as follows : Let us assume z to denote relative change of position with reference to the rigid body ; then it is evident that deof Bx .
t=--t+Dww .
; .
0. .
0* # ... . .
( 11 .
) for the velocity of the point ( wa ) is the resultant of two velocities , namely , that relative to the body , and that arising from the motion of the body ; the former is -t , and the latter , by ( 9 .
) , is DOi'. .
Hence , and by ( 10 .
) , we find -= mrnD u.U-.Di ... ( 1 2 .
) This equation gives the velocity of the point ( gi ) relatively to the rigid body .
Now it is clear that if we can solve ( 10 .
) and ( 12 .
) the motion of the rigid body is determined ; for we shall then know ( by ( I 2 .
) ) how the line at moves in the rigid bodgy , and by ( 10 .
) how al moves in space ; and thus , by the intervention of a , ' we shall obtain the motion of the rigid body in space .
( 107 .
) As an example of this I shall take the case of the earth attracted by the sun , and point out briefly how ( 10 .
) and ( 12 .
) determine the notion of the polar axis .
In this case A=B , and C=(1+X)A , when Xis a small number : also the instantaneous axis w very nearly coincides in direction with the polar axis y. Hence , and by art .
89 , we have ai=A(a'+Xw3r ) Im~u.V =A3m ' EmDu .
U:Ayir7-5Du ' .
( u ' ?
Xz'r ) Here u ' denotes ( symbolically ) the sun 's distance , r ' is the magnitude of u ' , m ' the sun 's mass .
Thus , observing that Du'.u ' and D. are zero , ( 10 .
) and ( 12 .
) become dco d(W37 ) 3mI dt + dt =Xywz'Du'.r ~~+x-~= X-Z.Du X'r.7 dt + di t1 P-5 yfz~zy In the terms multiplied by A we may approximate on the supposition that y is fixed and awn=y , where n is the earth 's angular velocity about its polar axis .
This reduces the two equations to do 3m ' -dt-x r15 t'DU'.y ... .
X. + .
* * Now let us take new directions ( a ' , so'y'- ) so , that y ' shall coincide for a moment with the polar axis y , while the plane ( c'2 ) contains the sun 's distance u ' ; then II 16+ It Du'.y O ' wherefore ( 14 .
) becomes I 3mI -XxitX ) The coefficient of at'here , being multiplied by X , may be regarded as invariable during one day , inasmuch as x ' and z ' take a year to go through their values : also , since b implies that the earth is considered as fixed , the sun , and therefore the direction 63 ' , must be supposed to revolve about y from east to west , through 3600 in the day .
The velocity therefore is constant in magnitude but changes its direction ( which is always perpendicular to y ) uniformly through 3600 in the day .
It appears therefore that the point ( C ) describes a daily circle , and therefore the line C describes a daily cone about y. From this it follows ( observing that c and y make a very small angle with each other ) , that the mean daily angular motion in space of y and that of the direction of w ( manifestly n very nearly ) are identical , Wherefore dt=n ldt = r ; 53z'Du'.y , by ( 1 3 .
) ; or , since z'=u ' X y , -d-smo ( ul xy ) ( 15 .
) If now we assume r to be at right angles to the plane of the ecliptic , and a ' to point towards the first point of Aries , we have u ' =r'(a ' cos n't+ ' sin n't ) , where n't is the sun 's longitude , n'2 being A. Wherefore , observing that y is at right angles to a ' , we find d ( yx PI ' ) sin n't ( cos n'tD &amp; !
.y+ sin n'tDP'.y ) .
If we integrate this between the limits 0 and A , we find the annual variation of y , which therefore is 3n1X PI ) ff(Y X )DP'.y. .
This represents in magnitude and direction the actual space described by the point ( y ) in one year , i. e. the angular motion of the pole , or the precession .
If denote the obliquity of the ecliptic , -~y -cos -+I3 ' sin - , and .
X rX = sina Df3'.r=t cos w. Wherefore the annual precession of the pole is ( 3n o.n a , VnCOS fir Siln rt &amp; b indicating that its direction is perpendicular to the solstitial colure , and retrograde as regards the sun 's motion .
I have gone through this example because in every step it shows the use of the symbolic forms .
VI .
APPLICATION OF THE SYMBOLIC FORMS TO PHYSICAL OPTICS .
( 108 .
) The use of the symbolic forms u.v and uXv in Physical Optics is very remarkable ; but as this paper is already so long , I can only just allude to the subject .
In the Transactions of the Cambridge Philosophical Society I have shown ( in a paper read March 17 , 1847 ) , that if v denote the displacement at the point ( u ) of an uncrystallized medium , where U=x &amp; +.y3+zr v= +3 + tr , and if A and B be two constants ( namely , the coefficients of direct and transverse elasticity ) ; then , v As d d2 4P dddd od !
=Bt +d s v+(A-B)t ; B+ d ti +yd And this result I obtained by merely considering the disarrangement of the medium about the point u , without any assumption respecting the constitution of the medium , except that it possessed direct and transverse elasticity .
Now if we employ the letter il to denote the operation ddd the above equation , by the aid of the symbolic forms , immediately assumes the simple form d2v dd-= AM ( U X V)-B ( DQ f )2v .
( .
) The symbol Q has a very important signification when written before any qnantity , U , which is a function of x , ,y and z : for the direction of the line IiU is that direction perpendicular to which there is no variation of U ; while the magnitude of f !
U is the rate of variation of U in that directi'on , i. e. as we pass from point to point of the medium in the direction of lU .
Again , Qxv denotes the rarefactian of the medium , at the point ( a ) , resulting from the displacements represented by v ; while i2.v denotes , ' in magnitude and plane , the lateral disarrangement of the medium .
It is clear , therefore , that the symbolic forms u.v and u Xv must be of great use in Physical Optics ; indeed the facility they give of following out ' investigations respecting undulatory movements is so great , that the whole subject of reflexion and refraction , in crystallized as well as in uncrystallized media , and the mathematical explanations of the phenomena connected with polarization , double refraction , &amp;c. , may be reduced to a state of simplicity which could hardly be expected in such a difficult subject .
( 109 .
) In the paper above alluded to , I obtained also the equation of vibratory motion generally , for any crystallized medium , without any of those assumptions which mathematicians have found it necessary to 'make in order to render the investigation manageable ; especially , without assuming the vibrations of a plane polarized ray to be in the plane of polarization , which appears to me to be a highly objectionable assumption .
By the aid of the symbolic forms , the general equation of vibratory motion , where the transmission of transverse vibrations is possible , is thus expressed : dt = ( A4m ?
+A2p+ ?
A4Y)T( XV ) +DQ.{ ( 2d~z-3 die ?
) ( 3dX-~dz P+ ( Bdy B2WX7 *(( Here Al , A2 , A , are coefficients of direct elasticity , corresponding to A in equation ( 1 .
) ; and B , B2 , B , , &amp;c. are six coefficients of transverse elasticity , corresponding to B in(l ) .
FRESNEL'S hypothesis , that the vibrations of a plane polarized ray are perpendicular to the plane , makes B1=B/ , B =B1 , B -B , while the hypothesis , that the vibrations are in the plane of polarization , makes B-B2 , B2=BT , B3=B1 .
On the former hypothesis the equation becomes dt-A(^Adx+A die + Aid ) ( f x v)-(D &amp; .)2(Bg+B2 , I3+B3,1 ) ; . .
( 3 .
) whiile , on the latter , it becomes dt2 = ( AlWd-+A -+AdY ) ( 2 X v ) ( * ) { B , t+B2 3dz ) +B3 1j ) F4rJ.(4 .
) For transverse vibrations the rarefaction ( Q x v ) ( see above ) is zero , which further simplifies ( 3 .
) and ( 4 .
) .
By equating the coefficients of a , A , y in ( 4 .
) , thus simplified , we obtain MACCULLAGH'S three equations .
The equation ( 3 .
) coincides in every way with FRESNEL'S theory .
The conception of distortion alluded to in Sect. , V. applies to ( 3 .
) in a very remarkable manner ; for if we put lda +{d +Clydz =f2 , A1aWX+B43~+Cr S2 aB1+B28 +Bryev ' , then S2 ' ismf2 distorted by the line A1a+AP2+Ay ; and v ' is v distorted by the line B1a +B2P+B3y .
In using the expressionc " distorted by , " I anticipate a signification which I hope to explain in a future paper ; but the fact is , f ' is a distributiveffunction of f2 and Aa+A2P+Ay ( see art .
105 ) , and therefore , symbolically , f2 ' is-e .
multiplied 4y Aja+A2 +A3ry .
Now the equation ( 3 .
) becomes d 2V =d2 =ap .
V ) ( Dfl.)2v , or , for transverse vibrations , simply d2v2 ( D52 V.jV ' .
But I must reserve the consideration of this remarkable equation , merely remarking here that it shows very clearly how the force brought into play by the disarrangement of a medium resulting from transverse vibrations:is altered by the crystallization .
In the uncrystallized medium the force is , by ( 1 .
) , ( Do.)(}+rA2 ) and in the crystallized medium it is ( D$.)2(B- ?
a+B2n43+B,3r ) .
In one case it is found by performing the operation -(D2 .
) ' on v , in the other by performing the same operation on v distorted as by the threefold expansion of the medium , consisting of a drawing out in the direction a in the proportion of B1 to B , in the direction j , of B2 to B , and in the direction ry of B. to B. Upper Norwood , Surreys April 19 , 1852 %

