LECTURE.--Experimental Researches in Electricity.--Twenty-second Series .
By MICHAEL FARADAY , Esq. , D. C.L. , F.R.S. , Fullerian Prof. Chem. Royal Institution , Foreign Associate of the Acad. Sciences , Paris , Ord .
Boruss .
Pour le MIrite , Eq. , Memb. Royal and Imp .
Acadd .
of Sciences , Petersburgh , Florence , Copenhagen , Berlin , Gottingen , Modena , Stockholm , Munich , Bruxelles , Vienna , Bologna , &amp;c. Syc .
Received October 4 , -Read December 7 , 1848 .
§ 28 .
On the crystalline polarity of bismuth and other bodies , and on its relation to the magnetic form of force . ?
i. Crystalline polarity of bismuth .
T ii .
Crystalline polarity of antimony .
iii .
Crystalline polarity of arsenic .
2454 .
MANY results obtained by subjecting bismluth to the action of the magnet have at various times embarrassed me , and I have either been contented with an imperfect explanation , or have left them for a future examination : that examination I have now taken up , and it has led to the discovery of the following results .
I cannot , however , better enter upon the subject than by a brief description of the anomalies which occurred , and which may be obtained at pleasure .
2455 .
If a small open glass tube have a bulb formed in its middle part and some clean good bismuth be placed in the bulb and melted by a spirit-lamp , it is easy afterward , by turning the metal into the tubular part of the arrangement , to cast it into long cylinders : these are very clean , and when broken are seen to be crystallized , usually giving cleavage planes , which run across the metal .
I prepare them from 0 05 to 0*1 of an inch in diameter , and , if the glass be thin , usually break both it and the bismuth together , and then keep the little cylinders in their vitreous cases .
2456 .
Taking some of these cylinders at randomn and suspending them horizontally between the poles of the electro-magnet ( 2247 .
) , they presented the following phe nomena .
The first pointed axially ; the second , equatorially ; the third , equatorial in one position , and obliquely equatorial if turned round on its axis 50 ?
or 60 ?
; the fourth , equatorially and axially under the same treatment ; and all of them , if suspended perpendicularly , pointed well , vibrating about a final fixed position which seemed to have no reference to the form of the cylinders .
In ll these cases the bismuth was strongly diamagnetic ( 2295 , &amp;c. ) , being repelled by a single magnetic pole , or passing off on either side from the axial line between two poles .
A similar piece of finely-grained or granular bismuth was , under the same circumstances and at the same time , affected in a perfectly regular manner , taking up the equatorial position ( 2253 .
) , as a body simply diamagnetic ought to do .
The cause of these variations was finally traced to the regularly crystalline condition of the metallic cylinders .
ft i. Crystalline polarity of bismuth .
2457 .
Some bismuth was crystallized in the usual manner by melting it in a clean iron ladle , allowing it partly to congeal , and then pouring away the internal fluid portion .
Pieces so obtained were then broken up by copper hammers and tools , and groups of the crystals separated , each group or piece consisting only of those crystals which were symmetrically arranged , and therefore likely to act in one direction .
If any part of the fragments had been in contact with the iron ladle , it was cleared away by rubbing on sandstone and sand-paper .
Pieces weighing from 18 grains to 100 grains were thus easily obtained .
2458 .
The electro-magnet employed in the first instance was that already described ( 2247 .
) , having moveable terminations which supplied either conical , round , or flatfaced poles .
That the suspension of the bismuth might be readily effected and unobjectionable as to magnetic influence , the following arrangement was generally adopted .
A single fibre of cocoon silk , from 12 to 24 inches in length , was attached to a fit support above , and made fast below to the end of a piece of fine , straight , well-cleaned copper wire , about 2 inches in length ; the lower end of this wire was twisted up into a little head , and then furnished with a pellat of cement , made by melting together a portion of pure white wax , with about one-fourth its weight of Canada balsam .
The cem ent was soft enough to adhere by pressure to any dry substance , and sufficiently hard to sustain weights up to 300 grains , or even more .
When prepared , the suspender was subjected by itself to the action of the magnet , to ascertain that it was friee from any tendency to point , or be affected ; without which precaution no confidence could be reposed in the results of the experiments .
2459 .
A piece of selected bismuth ( 2457 .
) , weighing 25 grains , was hung up between the poles of the magnet , and moved with great freedom .
The constituent cubes were associated in the usual manner , being attached to each other chiefly in the line joining two opposite solid angles ; and this line was in the greatest length of the piece .
The instant that the magnetic force was on , the bismuth vibrated strongly about a given line , in which , at last , it settled ; and if moved out of that position it returned , when at liberty , into it ; pointing with considerable force , and having its greatest length axial .
2460 .
Another piece was then selected , having a flatter form , which when subjected to the magnetic power , pointed with the same facility and force , but its greatest length was equatorial : still the line according to which the cubes tended to associate diametrally , was , as before , in the axial direction .
Other pieces were then taken of different forms , or shaped into various forms by rubbing them down on stone , but they all pointed well ; and took up a final position , which had no reference to the shape , but was manifestly dependent on the crystalline condition of the substance .
2461 .
In all these cases the bismuth was diamagnetic , and strongly repelled by either magnetic pole , or from the axial line .
It was affected only whilst the magnetic force was present .
It set in a given constant position perfectly determinate ; and , if moved , always returned to it , unless the extent of motion was above 90 ?
, and then the piece moved further round and took up a new position diametrically opposed to the former , which it then retained with equal force , and in the same manner .
This phenomenon is general in all the results I have to refer to , and I will express it by the word diametral:-diametral set or position .
2462 .
The effect occurs with a single magnetic pole , and it is then striking to observe a long piece of a substance , so diamagnetic as bismuth , repelled , and yet at the same moment set round with force , axially or end on , as a piece of magnetic substance would do .
2463 .
Whether the magnetic poles employed ( 2458 .
) are pointed , round , or flatfaced , still the effect on the bismuth is the same : nevertheless , the form of the poles has an important influence of a subordinate kind ; and some forms are much more fitted for these investigations than others .
When pointed poles are employed , the lines of magnetic force ( 2149 .
) rapidly diverge , and the force itself diminishes in intensity to the middle distance from each pole .
But when flat-faced poles are used , though the lines of power are curved and vary in intensity at and towards the edges of the flat faces , yet there is a space at the middle of the magnetic field where they may be considered as parallel to the magnetic axes , and of equal force throughout .
If the flat faces of the poles be square or circular , and their distance apart about one-third of their diameter , this space of uniform power is of considerable extent .
In my experience the central or axial portion of the magnetic field is sensibly weaker than the circumjacent parts ; but , then , there is a small screw-hole in the middle of each pole face , for the attachment of other forms of termination .
2464 .
Now the law of action of bismuth , as a diamagnetic body , is , that it tends to go from stronger to weaker places of magnetic force ( 2267 .
2418 .
) ; but as a magnecrystallic body it is subject to no effect of the kind ; and is as powerfully affected by lines of equal force as by any other .
So a piece of amorphous bismuth , suspended in a magnetic field of uniform power , seems to have lost its diamagnetic force altoB 2 gether , and tends to acquire no motion but what is due to torsion of the suspending fibre , or currents of air : but a piece of regularly crystallized bismuth is , in the same situation , very powerfully affected by virtue of its magnecrystallic condition .
2465 .
Hence the great value of a magnetic field of uniform force ; and , if , hereafter , in the extension of these investigations to bodies having only a small degree of crystalline power , a perfectly uniform field should be required , it could easily be given by making the form of the pole face somewhat convex , and rounded at the edges more or less .
The required shape could be ascertained by calculation , or perhaps better in practice , by the use of a little test cylinder of bismuth in the granular or amorphous state , or of phosphorus .
2466 .
In addition to these observations it may be remarked , that small crystals , or masses of crystals , and such as approach in their general shape to that of a cube or a sphere , are better than large or elongated pieces ; inasnmuch , as if there be irregularities in the force of a magnetic field , such pieces are less likely to be affected by them .
2467 .
When the crystal of bismuth is in a magnetic field of equal strength , it is equally affected whether it be in the middle of the field or close up to one or the other magnetic pole ; i. e. the number of vibrations in equal times appears to be equal .
Much care , however , is required in estimating it by such means , because , from the occurrence of two positions of unstable equilibriurm in the equatorial direction , the vibrations in large arcs are much slower than those in smaall arcs ; and it is difficult in different cases to adjust them to the same extent of vibration .
2468 .
Whether the bismnuth be in a field of intense mtagnetic force or one of feeble powers ; whether the magnetic poles are close up to the piece , or are opened out until they are five or six inches or even a foot asunder ; whether the bismnuth be in the line of maximum force , or raised above , or lowered beneath it ; whether the electric current be strong or weak , and the magnetic force , therefore , more or less in that respect ; if the bismtnuth be affected at all it is always affected in the same manner .
2469 .
The results are , altogether , very different from those produced by diamagnetic action ( 2418 ) .
They are equally distinct from those dependent on ordinary magnetic action .
They are also distinct from those discovered and described by PLUCKER , in his beautiful researches into the relation of the optic axis to magnetic action ; for there the force is equatorial , whereas here it is axial .
So they appear to present to us a new force , or a new formr of force in the mnolecules of matter , which , for convenience sake , I will conventionally designate by a new word , as the marnecrystallic force .
2470 .
The direction of this force is , in relation to the magnetic field , axial and not equatorial ; this is proved by several considerations .
Thus , when a piece of regularly crystallized bismuth was suspended in the magnetic field , it pointed ; keeping it in this position , the point of suspension was removed 90 ?
in the equatorial plane ( 2252 .
) , so that when again freely suspended , the line through the crystal , which was before horizontal in the equatorial plane , was now vertical ; the piece again pointed , and generally with more force than before .
The line passing through the clrystal , coincident with the magnetic axis , may now be taken as the line of forlce ; and if the process of a quarter revolution in the equatorial plane be repeated , however often , the crystal still continues to point with the assumed line of force in the magnetic axis , and with a maximum degree of power .
But now , if the point of suspension be removed 90 ?
in the plane of the axis , i. e. to the end of the assumed line of force , so , that when the crystal is again freely suspended this line is vertical ; then , the crystal presents its peculiar effect at a minimum , being almost or entirely devoid of pointing power , and exhibits in rielation to the magnet , only the ordinary diamagnetic force ( 2418 .
) .
2471 .
Now if the power had been equatorial and polar , its maximum effect would not have been produced by a change of the point of suspension through 90 ?
in the equatorial plane , but by the same change in the axial plane , and any similar change after that in the axial plane , would not have disturbed the maximum force ; whereas a single change of 90 ?
in the equatorial plane , would have brought the line of force vertical ( as in PLiCKER'S case of Iceland spar ) , and reduced the results to a minimum or zero .
2472 .
The directing force , therefore , and the set of the crystal are in the axial direction .
This force is , doubtless , resident in the particles of the crystal .
It is such , that , the crystal can set with equal readiness and permanence in two diametral positions : and that between these there are two positions of equatorial equilibrium , which are , of course , unstable in their nature .
Either end of the mass or of its molecules , is to all intents and purposes , both in these phenomena , and in the ordinary results of crystallization , like the other end ; and in many cases , therefore , the words axial and axiality would seem more expressive than the words polar and polarity .
In presenting the ideas to my own mind , I have found the meaning belonging to the former words the most useful .
2473 .
On placing the metal in other positions , and therefore in a constrained condition , no alteration of the state or power of the bismuth , either in force orL direction , is produced by the power of the magnet , however strong its enforcement or long its continuance .
2474 .
It is difficult readily to describe the position of this force in relation to the crystal , though most easy to ascertain it experimentally .
The form of the bismuth crystals is said to be that of a cube , and of its primitive particle a regular octohedron .
To me the crystals do not seem to be cubes , but either rhomboids or rhombic prisms , approaching very nearly to cubes .
My measurements were very imperfect and the crystals not regular ; but as an average of several observations , the planes were inclined to each other at angles of 91 ?
and 881 ?
; and the boundary lines of a plane at 87- ?
and 921 ? .
Whatever be the true form , it is manifest upon inspection , that the aggregating force tends to produce crystals having more or less of the rhomboidal shape and rhombic planes ; and that these crystals run together in symmetric groups , generally in the direction of their longest diameters .
Now the line of magnecrystallic force almost always coincides with this direction where the latter is apparent .
247.5 .
The cleavage of bistnuth crystals removes the solid angles and replaces them by planes ; so that there are four directions producing the octohedron .
These cleavages are not ( in my experience ) made with equal facility , nor do they produce planes equally bright and perfect .
Two , and more frequently one , of these planes is more perfect than the others ; and this , the most perfect plane , is that which is produced at the most acute solid angle ( 2474 .
) ; and is generally easily recognized .
When a bismuth crystal presents many planes of cleavage and is suspended in the magnetic field , one of these planes faces towards one of the magnetic poles , and its corresponding plane , if it be there , towards the other ; so that the line of magnecrystallic force is perpendicular to this plane : and this plane corresponds to the one which I have already described as being , generally , the most perfect , and replacing the acute angle of the crystal .
2476 .
A single crystal of bismuth was selected and cut out from the mass by copper tools , and the places where it had adhered were rubbed down on sand-paper , so as to give the fragment a cube-like form with six planes ; four of these planes were natural .
One of the solid angles , expected to be that terminating or in the direction of the line of magnecrystallic force , was removed , so as to expose a small cleavage plane , which was bright and perfect , as also was expected .
When suspended in the magnetic field with this plane vertical , the crystal instantly pointed with considerable force , and with the plane towards either one or the other magnetic pole ; so that the magnecrystallic axis appeared now to be horizontal and acting with its greatest power .
When this axial line was made vertical , and the plane therefore horizontal , the position being carefully adjusted , the crystal did not point at all .
Being now suspended in succession at all the angles and faces of the cube , it always pointed with more or less force ; but always so that a line drawn perpendicularly through the indicating cleavage plane ( representing therefore the line of force ) was in the same vertical plane as that including the magnetic axis : and , finally , when the bright cleavage plane was horizontal and the line of directive force therefore vertical , inclining it a little in a given direction , would make any given part of the crystal point to the magnetic poles .
2477 .
A group of bismuth crystals , the apex of which was terminated by a single small cleavage facet , was found to give the same results .
2478 .
Occasionally groups of crystals ( 2457 .
) occurred which did not seem capable of being placed in some one position in which they lost all directive power , but seemed to retain a minimum degree of force .
It is very unlikely , however , that all the groups should be perfectly symmetric in the arrangement of their parts .
It is more surprising that they should be so distinct in their action as they are .
In reference to bismuth , and many other bodies , it is probable that magnetic force will give a more important indication in relation to the essential and real crystalline structure of the mass than its form can do .
2479 .
I have already stated that the magnecrystallic force does not manifest itself by attraction or repulsion , or , at least , does not cause approach or recession , but gives position only .
The law of action appears to be , that , the line or axis of MAGNECRYSTALLICforce ( being the resultant of the action of all the molecules ) , tends to place itself parallel , or as a tangent , to the magnetic curve or line of magneticforce , passing through the place where the crystal is situated .
2480 .
I now broke up masses of bismuth which had been melted and solidified in the ordinary way , and , selecting those fragments which appeared to be most regularly crystallized , submitted them to experiment .
It was almost impossible to take a small piece which did not obey the magnet and point more or less readily .
By selecting the thin plates with perfect cleavage planes , I readily obtained specimens which corresponded in all respects with the crystals ; but thicker plates or angular pieces often proved complicated in the results , though apparently simple and regular as to form .
Occasionally , the cleavage plane , which I have beforehand taken for that perpendicular to the line of force ( 2475 .
) , has proved not to be the plane supposed ; but , after observing experimentally the direction of the magnecrystallic power , I have always either found , or else obtained by cleavage , a plane corresponding to it , possessing the appearance and character before described ( 2475 .
) .
Bismuth plates from the one-twentieth to the one-tenth of an inch in thickness , and bounded by parallel and similar planes , when broken up often proved , upon ocular examination , to be comnpounded and irregular .
2481 .
When a well-selected plate of bismuth ( mine are about 03 of an inch in length and breadth , and 0'05 , more or less , in thickness ) is hung up by the edge in the magnetic field , it vibrates and points , presenting its faces to the magnetic poles , and setting diametrally ( 2461 .
) .
By whatever part of the edge it is suspended , the same results follow .
But if it be suspended horizontally , the cleavage planes of the fragment and of the magnetic axis being parallel to the plane of motion of the plate , then it is perfectly indifferent ; for then the line of magnecrystallic force is perpendicular to the line of magnetic force in every position that it can take .
2482 .
But if the plate be inclined only a very small quantity from this position , it points , and that with more force as the planes become more nearly vertical ( 2475 .
) ; and the phenomena before described with a crystal ( 2476 .
) , can here be obtained with a fragment from a mass , and any part of the edge of the plate made to point axially , by elevating or depressing it above or below the horizontal plane .
2483 .
If a number of these crystalline plates be selected at the magnet , they may afterwards be built up together , with a little good cement ( 2458 .
) , into a mass which has perfectly regular magnecrystallic action ; and in that respect resembles the 7 crystals before spoken of ( 2459 .
2468 .
2476 .
) .
In this manner , also , the diamagnetic effect of the bismuth may be neutralized ; for it is easy to build up a prism whose breadth and thickness is equal , and this being hung with the length vertical , points well and without any interference of diamagnetic action .
2484 .
By placing three equal plates at right angles to each other , a system is obtained , which has lost all power of pointing under the influence of the magnet , the force being , in every direction , neutralized .
This represents the case of finely crystallized or amorphous bismuth .
The same result ( having the same nature ) may be obtained by taking a selected uniform mass of crystals ( 2457 .
) , melting it in a glass tube and resolidifying it : unless the crystallization is large and distinct , which rarely happens , the piece obtained is apparently without magnecrystallic force .
A like result is also obtained by breaking up the crystal and putting the small fragments or powder into a tube , and submitting the whole to the force of the magnet .
2485 .
These experiments on bismuth are not difficult of repetition ; for , except those which require the sudden production or cessation of the magnetic force , the whole may be repeated with an ordinary horse-shoe magnet .
A magnet , with which I have wrought considerably , consists of seven bars placed side by side , and being fixed in a box with the poles upwards , presents two magnet cheeks , an inch and a quarter apart , between which is the magnetic field , having the lines of force in a horizontal direction .
The poles of the magnet should be covered , each with paper , to prevent communication of particles of iron or rust .
The best place for the piece of bismuth is , of course , between the poles ; not level however with their tops , but from 0'4 to 10 inch lower down ( 2463 .
) , that the effect of flat-faced poles may be obtained .
If it be desired to strengthen the lines of magnetic force , this may be done by introducing a piece of iron between the poles of the magnet , and so , by virtually causing them to approach , lessen the width of the magnetic field between them .
2486 .
The magnet I used would sustain 30 Ibs .
at the keeper ; but employing small pieces of bismuth , I have easily obtained the effects with magnets weighing themselves not more than 7 ounces , and able to sustain only 22 ounces ; so that the experiments are within the reach of every one .
2487 .
Whilst the crlystal of bismuth is in the magnetic field , it is affected very distinctly , and even strongly , by the near approximation of soft iron or magnets , and after the following manner .
Let fig. 1 represent in plan the Fig. 1 .
position of the two chief magnetic poles , and of a piece of / / crystallized bismuth between them , which , by its magned crystallic condition , points axially .
Then , if a piece of soft / /b/ iron be applied against the cheek of the pole , as at e , and / also near to the bismuth , as at a , it will affect the latter and cause its approach to the iron .
If the iron be applied in a similar manner at f , g , or h , it will have a like result in causing motion of the bismuth ; and the parts marked b , c and d , will in turn approach it , seeming to be attracted .
If the soft iron do not touch the magnetic pole , but be held between it and the bismuth so as to represent generally the same positions , the same effects , but in a weaker degree , are produced .
2488 .
Though these motions seem to indicate an effect of attraction , I do not believe them to be due to any such cause , but simply to the influence of the law of action ( 2479 .
) before expressed .
The previously uniform condition of the magnetic field is destroyed by the presence of the iron ; lines of magnetic force , of greater intensity than the others , proceed from the angle a of the iron in the position repre sented , or from the corresponding angles in the other positions ( the shape of the pole now approximating more or less to the conical or pointed form ) , and therefore the crystal of bismuth moves round on the axis of suspension , that it may place the line of magnecrtystallic force parallel or as a tangent to the resultant of the magnetic forces which pass through its mass .
2489 .
When in place of the group of crystals a crystalline plate of bismuth ( 2481 .
) is employed , the appearances produced under sinilar circumstances , are those of repulsion ; for if fig. 2 be allowed to represent this state of Fig. 2 .
things , the piece of iron applied at e causes the plate to / ~T i / / recede from it at a , or if applied at f ; g , or h , it causes recession of the bismuth from it at the points b , c , and d. / // / Now though these effects look like repulsion , they are , as I / // / : conclude , nothing more than the consequences of the en-/ --/ .
Z deavour which the bismuth makes , under the law before expressed ( 2479 .
) , to place the magnecrystallic line of force parallel to , or as a tangent to the resultant of magnetic force passing through the bismuth .
2490 .
A piece of iron wire about 1inch long , and 0'1 or 0'2 of an inch thick , being held in the equatorial plane to the edge of the plate Fig. 3 .
( fig. 3 ) , did not alter its position ; but if the end e were inclined to either pole , the plate began to move , and moved / // / most when the iron touched the pole as in the figure .
/ ./ ^ / When it approached or touched the N pole , the inclination of the crystal plate of bismuth was as indicated by / // .'/ // / the dotted figure .
When it touched the S , the inclina. .
, e_ tion was the contrary way .
If the end e were kept in contact with the N pole , and the other end of the soft iron lrod placed in the position m , the bismuth was not affected ; but if then this subsidiary pole were moved the one way or the other towards the edge of the plate , the latter turned as the pole moved , always tending to keep its face towards it , and evidently by the tendency of the magnecrystallic axis to place itself parallel to the resultant of magnetic force passing through the bismuth .
The same results were obtained with the crystal ( 2487 .
) under similar circumstances , and corresponding results were obtained when the soft iron rod was applied between the S cheek of the magnet and the bismuth .
The like effects were also obtained with plates of arsenic and antimony .
2491 .
When a magnet is used instead of soft iron , corresponding effects are produced ; only , it must be remembered , that if the chief magnet be very powerful , it may often neultralize , and even change , the magnetism of the small approximated magnet ; and this can happen with the latter ( as to external influence ) whilst in the magnetic field , even though when withdrawn it may appear to remain unaltered .
2492 .
Thus , when the plate of bismuth was suspended between the cheeks of the horse-shoe magnet ( 2485 .
) , fig. 2 , and the north pole of a small magnet ( the blade of a pocket-knife ) was placed at a or b , it caused recession of the part of the bismuth near it , and precisely for the same reasons as those that existed when the soft iron was there .
When the extra pole was placed at c or d , the action was more feeble than in the former case , and consisted in an approximation of that part of the bismuth to the pole .
As this position of the subordinate pole would terminate and neutralize certain of the lines of magnetic force proceeding from the south pole of the horse-shoe magnet , so the resultant of the lines of force passing through the bismuth would be changed in direction , being rendered oblique to their former course , and precisely in the manner represented by the motion of the bismuth , in its tendency to place its line of force parallel with them in their new position .
2493 .
An approximated south pole caused motions in the contrary direction .
2494 .
When the subordinate pole was applied to the edge of the plate , the little magnet being in the equatorial position ( fig. 3 ) , then instead of being neutral , as the iron was , it caused the plate to move in a tangential direction , either to the right or the left , according as it was either a south or a north pole , just indeed as the iron didt when , by inclining it , the approximated end became a pole ( 2490 .
) .
This effect was shown in a still more striking degree by using the crystal of bismuth ( 2487 .
) , because , from its form and position the magnetic curves most affected by the extra pole were more included in the bismuth than when the plate was used .
2495 .
Innumerable variations of these motions may be caused , and appearances of attraction or repulsion , or tangential action be obtained at pleasure by the use of crystals having the magnecrystallic axis corr esponding with their length , or plates where it accords with their thickness ; and either permanent or temporary subsidiary magnetic poles .
By making the moveable pole travel slowly round the bismuth from the neutral point m to the other neutral point n , fig. 3 , a summary of the whole can be obtained , and it is found that they all resolve themselves into the general law before expressed ( 2479 .
) : the magnecrystallic axis and the resultant of magnetic force passing through the bismuth , tending to become parallel .
2496 .
Hence a small crystal or plate of bismuth ( or arsenic ( 2532 .
) ) may become a very useful and important indicator of the direction of the lines of force in a magnetic field , for at the same time that it takes up a position showing their course , it does not by its own action tend sensibly to disturb them .
2497 .
Many of these motions are similar to , and have relation with , those described by PLUCKER , REICH , and others , as obtained by the action of iron and magnets on bismuth , in its simple diamagnetic condition .
These results are by them and others considered as indicating that the bismuth , as I had originally supposed ( 2429 , &amp;c. ) , has really in its diamagnetic state , a magnetic condition the reverse of that of iron .
I am not acquainted with all of them , or with the reasoning thereon ( being in the German language ) ; but such as I am aware of , and have reobtained , seem to me to be simple results of the law I formerly laid down ( 2267 .
2418 .
) , namely , that diamagnetic bodies tend to proceed from stronger to weaker places of magnetic force : and give no additional or other proof of the assumed reverse polarity of bismuth than the former cases of action which I had given , coming under that law .
2498 .
Supposing that the intervening or surrounding matter might , in some manner , affect the magnecrystallic action of bismuth and other bodies , I fixed the magnetic poles at a given distance ( about two inches ) asunder , suspended a crystal of bismuth in the middle of the magnetic field , and observed its vibrations and set .
Then , without any other change , I introduced screens of bismuth , being blocks about two inches square and 0'75 of an inch in thickness , between the poles and the crystal , but I could not perceive that any change in the phenomena was produced by their presence .
2499 .
The bismuth crystal ( 2459 .
) was suspended in water between the magnetic poles of the horse-shoe magnet .
It set well in accordance with the general law ( 2479 .
) , and it took five revolutions of the torsion index at the upper end of the suspending silk filament to displace it , and cause it to turn into the diametral position .
This is , as well as I could observe the results , the same amount of torsion force required to effect its displacement when the crystal was placed in the same position , but surrounded with air only .
2500 .
The same bismuth was then suspended in a saturated solution of protosulphate of iron ( adapted as a magnetic medium ) , it set as before with apparently no change of any kind ; and when the torsion force was put on , it still required five turns of the index , as before , to cause the displacement of the crystal , and its passage into the dianetral position .
2501 .
Whether therefore crystals of bismuth be immersed in air , or water , or solution of sulphate of iron , or placed between thick masses of bismuth , if they be subject to the same magnetic force , the magnecrystallic force exerted by them is the same both in nature , direction and amount .
c2 ll It seemed possible and probable that magnetic force might affect the crystallization of bismuth , if not of other bodies .
For , as the force affects the mass of a crystal by that power which its particles possess , and which they give to the crystal as a whole by their polar ( or axial ( 2472 .
) ) and symmetric condition ; and , as the final position of the crystalline mass in the magnetic field may be considered as that of the least constraint , so it was likely enough that , if the bismuth in a fluid state were placed under the influence of the magnetism , the individual particles would tend to assume one and the same axial condition , and the crystalline arrangement and direction of the mass upon its solidification , be in some degree determined and under government .
2503 .
Some bismruth , therefore , was fuzed in a glass tube and held in a fixed position in the strong magnetic field until it had become solid ; then , being removed from the glass , it was suspended so that it might assume the same position under the influence of the magnet ; but no signs of magnecrystallic force were evident .
It was not expected that the whole would become regularly crystallized , but that a dif erence between one direction and another might appear .
Nothing of the kind however occurred , whatever the direction in which the piece was suspended ; and when it was broken open , the crystallization within was found to be small , confused , and in all directions .
Perhaps if longer time were allowed , and a permanent magnet used , a better result might be obtained .
I had built many hopes upon the process , in reference to the crystalline condition of gold , silver , platina , and the metals generally , and also in respect of other bodies .
2504 .
I cannot find that crystals of bismuth acquire any power , either temporary or permanent , which they can bring away from the magnetic field .
I held crystals in different positions in the field of intense action of a powerful electromagnet , having conical termlinations very near to each other ; and , after some time , removed them and applied them instantly to a very delicate astatic magnetic needle ; but I could not perceive that they had the least extra effect upon it , because of such treatment .
2505 .
As a crystal of bistnuth is subject to , and obeys the influence of , the lines of magnetic force ( 2479 .
) , so it follows that it ought to obey even the earth 's action , and point , though with a very feeble degree of power .
I have suspended a good crystal by a single long filament of cocoon silk , and sheltered it as well as I could from currents of air by concentric glass tubes , and I think have observed indications of a set or pointing .
The crystal was so hung that the magnecrystallic axis made the same angle with the horizontal plane ( about 70 ?
) as the magnetic dip , and the indication was , that the axis and the dip tended to coincide : but the experiments require careful repetition .
2506 .
A more important point , as to the nature of the polar or axial forces of bismuth , is to know whether two crystals , or uniformly crystallized masses of bismuth , can mutually affect each other ; and if so , what the nature of these affections are ?
what is the relation of the equatorial and terminal parts ?
and what , the direction of the forces ?
I have made many experiments , in relation to this subject , both in and out of the magnetic field , but obtained only negative results .
I employed however small masses of bismuth , and it is my purpose to repeat and extend them at a more convenient season with larger masses , built up , if necessary , in the manner already described ( 2483 .
) .
2507 .
I need hardly say that a crystal of bisrnuth ought to point in a helix or ring of wire carrying an electric current , and so that its nagnecrystrallic axis should be parallel to the axis of the ring or helix .
This I find experimentally to be the case .
ii .
Crystalline Polarity of Antimony .
2508 .
Antimony is a magnecrystallic body .
Some crystalline masses , procured in the manner before described ( 2457 .
) , were broken up with copper tools , and some excellent groups of crystals were obtained , weighling from ten to twenty grains each , in which all the constituent crystals appeared to be uniformly placed .
The individual crystals were very good on the whole , and much more frequently full at the faces and complete than those of bismuth .
They were very bright , having a steel-gray or silvery appearance , and to the eye appeared more surely as cubes than bismuth , though here and there distinctly rhomboidal faces presented themselves .
Planes of cleavage can be made to replace the solid angles ; and , as with bismuth , there is one plane generally brighter and more perfect than the others .
2509 .
In the first place , it was ascertained that all these crystals were diamagnetic , and strongly so .
2510 .
In the next it was ascertained , as with bismuth , that all of therm exhibited the magnecrystallic phenomena with considerlable power , showing the existence of a line of force ( 2470 .
) , which , when placed vertically , left the crystal free to mrove in any direction ( 2476 .
) ; but when placed horizontally , caused the crystal to point , and in so doing took up its own position parallel to the resultant of magnetic force passing through the crystal ( 2479 .
) .
This line proceeded , as in bismuth , from one of the solid angles to the opposite one , and was perpendicular to the bright cleavage plane just spoken of ( 2508 .
) .
2511 .
So , generally , the action of the magnet upon these crystals was the same as upon the crystals of bismuth ; but there are some points of variation which require to be more distinctly stated and distinguished .
2512 .
In the first place , when the magnecrystallic axis was horizontal , and a certainr crystal used , upon the evolution of the magnetic force , the crystal went up to its position slowly , and pointed as with a dead set .
If the crystal were moved from this position on either side , it returned to it at once : there was no vibration .
Other crystals did the same imperfectly ; and others again made one or perhaps two vibrations , but all appeared as if they were moving in a thick fluid , and were , in that respect , utterly unlike bismuth , in the freedom and mobility with which it vibrated ( 2459 .
) .
2513 .
In the next place , when the crystals were so suspended as to have the magnecrystallic axis vertical , there was no pointing nor any other signs of magnecrystallic force ; but other appearances presented themselves .
For , if the crystalline mass was revolving when the magnetic force was excited , it suddenly stopped , and was caught in a position which might , as was found by experience , be ally position ; but if the greatest length was out of the axial or equatorial position , the arrest was followed by a revulsive motion on the discontinuance of the electric current ( 2315 .
) .
This revulsive motion was never great , but was most when the length of the mass formed about an angle of 45 ?
with the axis of the magnetic field .
2514 .
On further examination it appeared that this arresting and revulsive effect was precisely the same in kind as that observed on a former occasion with copper and other metals ( 2309 .
) , and due to the same cause , namely , the production of circular electric currents in the metal under the inductive force of the magnet .
Now , the reason appeared why , in the forer case , th fe crystals of antimony did not oscillate ( 2512 .
) ; and why , also , they went up to their position of rest with a dead set ; for the currents produced by the motion are just those which tend to stop the motion ( 2329.)* ; and though the magnecrystallic force was sufficient to make the crystal move and point , yet the very motion so produced generated the current which reacted upon the tendency to motion , and so caused the mass to advance towards its position of rest as if it moved in a thick fluid .
2515 .
Having this additional knowledge respecting the arrest and revulsion of the antimony ( effects dependent upon its superior conducting power , in this compact crystalline state , as compared with bismuth ) , one has no difficulty in identifying the magnecrystallic force of this metal writh that of the former , and the correspondence of the results in all essential characters and particulars .
In most of the pieces of crystals of antimony the force seemed less than in bismuth , but the fact may not really be so , for the inductive current action just described , tends to hide the magnecrystallic phenomena .
2516 .
Different pieces of antimony also seem to differ from each other in their setting force , and also in their tendency to exhibit revulsive effects ; but these differences are either only apparent , or may easily be explained .
The arresting and revulsive action depends much upon the continuity of the mass , so that one large piece shows it much better than several small pieces , and these again better than a powdered substance .
Even the revulsive action of copper may be entirely destroyed by reducing the single lump to filings .
It is easy to perceive , therefore , that of two groups of antimony crystals , each symmetrically disposed within itself , the one may have larger crystals well connected together , as regards the induction of currents through the whole mass , and the other smaller crystals less favourably united .
These would present very different appearances , as regards the airest of motion and succeeding revulsive action ; and further , on that very account , would differ in their readiness to present the magnecrystallic phenomena , though they might possess precisely equal degrees of that force .
2517 .
On proceeding to experiment with plates of antimony , further illustrations of the effects resulting from the causes just described were obtained , with abundant accompanying evidence of the existence of the magnecrystallic condition in the metal .
The plates were selected from broken masses , as with bismuth ( 2480 .
) .
Some were soon found which acted simply , instantly , and well ; their large surfaces were bright cleavage planes .
When suspended by any part of the edge , these planes faced towards the magnetic poles ; and the plate oscillated on each side of its final position , gradually acquiring its state of rest .
2518 .
When these plates were suspended with their planes horizontal , they had no power of pointing in the magnetic field .
When they were inclined , the points which were most depressed below and raised above the horizontal plane , were those which took up their places nearest the magnetic poles ( 2482 .
) .
2519 .
When several plates were arranged together into a consistent bundle ( 2483 .
) , the diamagnetic effect was removed , and the magnecrystallic oscillation and pointing became very ready and characteristic .
2520 .
Thus it is evident that , in all these cases , there was a line of magnecrystallic force perpendicular to the planes of the plates , and perfectly consistent in its position and action with the force before found in the solid crystals of antimony .
2521 .
But another plate of antimony was now selected , which had every appearance of being able to present all the phenomena of the former plates ; and yet , when hung up by its edge , it showed no signs of magnecrystallic results ; for it first advanced a little ( 2310 .
) , then was arrested and kept in its place , and if standing between the axial and equatorial positions , was revulsed when the battery current was interrupted , exhibiting effects equal to those of copper ( 2315 .
) .
Many other plates were tried with precisely the same result .
2522 .
When this plate ( 2521 .
) was placed in the field of intense power between two conical magnetic poles , it exhibited the same phenomena ; but notwithstanding the arresting action , it moved slowly until it stood in the equatorial position ; a result which was probably due to the exertion of both magnecrystallic and 'diamagnetic force .
When the plate was suspended with its planes horizontal , the arresting and revulsive actions were gone ; for the induced currents which before caused them could not now exist in the necessary vertical plane ; further , it had no setting power , 15 which showed that there was no axis of magnecrystallic force in the length or breadth of the plates .
2523 .
Other plates were then found able to produce mixed effects , and those in different degrees .
Thus , some , like the first , vibrated freely , pointed well , and presented no indication of the arrest and revulsive phenomena .
Others vibrated sluggishly , set well , and showed a tendency to be arrested .
Others pointed well , going up to their place with a dead set , but moving as if in a fluid ; or , if the magnetic force were taken off before the piece had settled , it was revulsed feebly : and others were caught at once , did not set ( within the time of my observation ) , and were strongly revulsed .
2524 .
Finally , a careful investigation , carried on by means both of the horse-shoe ( 2485 .
) and the great electro-magnet ( 2247 .
) , made the cause of these differences in the effects apparent .
2525 .
It may be observed , in the first place , that sometimes a plate of antimony being selected ( 2517 .
) , having planes very bright and perfect in their appearance , and , therefore , giving reason to think that it may point well in the magnetic field , when submitted to the horse-shoe magnet does not do so ; but points obliquely , feebly , and perhaps in two undiametral positions .
This is , I have no doubt , because the crystallization is complicated and confused .
Such a plate , if it be sufficiently broad and long ( i. e. not less than a quarter or one-third of an inch ) , when submitted to the electro-magnet , will show the arresting ( 2310 .
) and revulsive ( 2315 .
) action well .
2526 .
In the next place , we have to remember that , for the development of the induced currents that cause the arresting and revulsive action , the plate must have certain sufficient dimensions in a vertical plane ( 2329 .
) .
The currents occur in the mass and not round the separate particles ( 2329 .
) , and the resultant of the magnetic lines of force passing through the substance , is the axis round which these currents are produlced .
Hence the reason why the effect does not occur with plates suspended in the horizontal position , which yet produce it well in the vertical position ; are esult which a disc half an inch in diameter of thin foil or plate , being copper , silver , gold , tin , or almost any malleable metal will show ; though the best conductors are the fittest for the purpose .
Now this condition is of no consequence in respect of magnecrystallic action , and a narrow plate has as much force as a broad one , having the same mass .
The first plate that I happened to select ( 2517 .
) was well crystallized , thick and narrow ; hence it was favourable for magnecrystallic action , unfavourable to the arresting and revulsive action , and showed no signs , comparatively , of the latter .
2527.When a broad and well-crystallized plate is obtained , then both sets of effects appear : thus , if the plate is revolving when the magnetic force is brought into action , it quickens its velocity for an instant , then is stopped ; and if the magnetic force is at once taken off , it is revulsed , exactly as a piece of copper would be But if the magnetic force be continued , it will then be perceived that the stop is only apparent ; for the plate moves , though with a greatly reduced velocity , and continues to move until it has taken up its magnecrystallic position .
It moves as if in a thick fluid .
Hence the magnecrystallic force is there and produces its full effect ; and the reason why the appearances have changed is , that the very motion which the force tends to give , and does give to the mass , causes those magneto-electric currents ( 2329 .
) which by their mutual action with the magnet tends to stop the motion ; and therefore its slowness and the final dead set ( 2512 .
2523 .
) .
2528 .
A magnet which is weaker ( as the horse-shoe instrument described ( 2485 .
) ) produces the currents by induction in a much weaker degree , and yet manifests the magnecrystallic power well ; hence it is more favourable , under certain circumstances , for such investigations ; as it helps to distinguish the one effect from the other .
2529 .
It will readily be seen that plates , whether of the same metal or of different metals , cannot , even roughly , be compared with each other as to magnecrystallic force by their vibrations ; for under the influence of these induced currents , plates of the same magnecrystallic force oscillate in very different manners .
I took a plate , and by cement ( 2458 .
) attached selected paper to its faces , and then observed how it acted in the magnetic field ; it set slowly , and it showed the arresting and revulsive effects ( 2521 .
) .
I then pressed it in a mortar , so as to break it up into many parts , which still kept their place ; and now it set more freely and quickly , and showed very little of the revulsing action .
2530 .
Though the indication by vibration is thus uncertain , the torsion force still remains to us , I believe , a very accutate indication of the strength of the set ( 2500 .
) ; and , therefore , of the degree of the magnecrystallic force ; and though the suspending silk fibre may give way a little , a glass thread , according to RITCHIE'S suggestion , would answer perfectly .
2531 .
Antimony must be a good conductor of electricity in the direction of the plates of the crystals , or it would not give , so freely , these indications of revulsive action .
The groups of crystals of antimony ( 2508 .
) showed the effect in such a degree , as to make me think that the constituent cubes possessed the power nearly equally in all directions .
A piece of finely crystallized or granular antimony does not , however , show it in the same proportion ; from which it would seem as if an effect equivalent in some degree to that of division occurs , either at the meeting of two incongruous crystals , or between the contiguous plates of the crystals , and affects the conducting power in these directions . ?
[ iii .
Crystalline Polarity of Arsenic .
2532 .
A mass of the metal arsenic exhibiting crystalline structure ( 2480 .
) , was broken up , and several plates selected from the fragments , having good cleavage plane slurfaces , about 03 of an inch in length , 01 inch in width , and 0'03 in thick ness .
These , when suspended opposite one conical pole , proved to be perfectly diamagnetic ; and when before it or between two poles strongly magnecrystallic .
I have a pair of flat-faced poles with screw-holes in the centre of the faces , and these so much weaken the intensity of the lines of magnetic force about the middle of the field , when the faces are within half an inch of each other , that a cylinder of granular bismuth 0'3 in length sets axially , or from pole to pole ( 2384 .
) .
But with the plates of arsenic between the same poles there was no tendency of this kind ; so much was the magnecrystallic force predominant over the diamagnetic force of the substance .
2533 .
When the plates of arsenic were suspended with their planes horizontal , then they did not point at all between the flat-faced poles .
Any inclination of the planes to the horizontal line produced pointing , with more or less force as the planes approached more or less to the vertical position , exactly in the manner already described in relation to bismuth and antimony ( 2482 .
2518 .
) .
2534 .
Thus , arsenic with bismuth and antimony are found to possess the nagnecrystallic force or condition .
Royal Institution , September 23 , 1848 .

