Supplementary Observations on the Structure of the BELEMNITE and BELEMNOTEUTHIS .
By GIDEON ALGERNON MANTELL , Esq. , LL. D. , F.R.S. , F.L.S. , Vice-President of the Geological Society , 8yc .
Received November 5 , 1849 , -Read February 14 , 1850 , As several eminent naturalists have expressed doubts of the correctness of my interpretation of some of the facts described in the Memoir on the Belemnite and Belemnnoteuthis , published in the Philosophical Transactions , Part II .
1848 , I am induced to lay before the Royal Society the following additional observations in confirmation of the opinions advanced in my previous communication on this subject .
That distinguished naturalist , Mr. J. E. GRAY , has especially controverted my statement that the phragmocone of the Belemnites of the Oxford Clay* possessed a pair of elongated shelly processes , which extended beyond the peristome or upper border of the conical chambered shell ; the aperture resembling in this respect that of certain species of Ammonitest .
In the recently published " Catalogue of the Mollusca in the Collection of the British Musezm+ , " Mr. GRAY remarks , " Dr. MANTELL has figured a specimen which appears to have an elongated process on each side , like the processes on the sides of the mouth of certain Ammonites ; but on examining his specimen I am very doubtful if this appearance does not arise tiom an accidental fracture of the upper part of the conical shell .
" Since the publication of my former Memoir , three Belemnites with phragmocones , in which the parts in question are unequivocally manifest , have come under my observation .
Two of these interesting fossils are in the Gallery of Organic Remains in the British Museum : the third is in my possession .
In addition to these examples , evidence in proof that this structure is normal , and not the result of accident , has been afforded by numerous detached portions of belernnital phragmocones from the Oxford Clay and Lias , which display well-defined vestiges of the expanded bases of these processes : and that eminent palaeontologist , Mr. JOHN MORRIS of Kensington , informs me that he has recognized their presence in specimens from various strata and localities .
In the three examples above mentioned , that part of the process which extends beyond the upper or basilar margin of the phragmocone is well defined ; and in each of these specimens the extension of the longitudinal plates or bands may be distinctly traced downwards , almost to the distal end or apex , as a thin nacreous shelly plate , striated longitudinally , and having obliquely divergent lines on the ventral margin .
The finest specimen from Wiltshire in the British Museum ( Plate XXVIII .
fig. 1 ) , like that discovered by my son* , consists of the osselet or guard ( b ) partially invested by its capsule , with the phragmocone in natural apposition : the latter is shattered and pressed almost flat , but preserves a conical outline , and has on the upper part the right process ( e ) , which extends 5 inches above the peristome or border of the chambered cone : a portion of the left process is seen at f ; c , denotes the lower termination of the process .
Fig. 2 represents the upper portion of this fossil of the natural size , and so clearly shows the parts described that further detail is unnecessary .
I would particularly direct attention to the evident extension of the base of the process ( x , x , x ) down the phragmocone as a nacreous band or plate finely striated .
Under a slightly magnifying power this expansion appears like a thin shelly integument deposited on the external surface of the chambered cone , and is marked with curved diverging lines on the lateral border .
In the former Memoir the number and position of these processes could not be determined with precision ; the specimrens recently obtained show that thetre were but two , ---one on each side the aperture or peristome , and these were situated nearer to the dorsal than to the ventral aspect .
The siphunculus always occupies the median and ventral side of the phragtnocone ; and its excentric apex is directed towards the same region , in which is also situated the sulcus of the guard ( see Plate XXIX .
fig. 5 ) .
In the fragment of a large uncompressed belemnital phragmrocone from Lyme Regis , for the loan of which I ain indebted to Mr. MORRIS , the relative position of the parts above described is distinctly exhibited , Plate XXIX .
: fig. 3 , / f , the remains of the lateral processes ; g , the siphunculus , occupying the ventral aspect ; h , the dorsal line .
The outline , Plate XXIX .
fig. 4 , is intended to express concisely the facts described .
With regard to the osselet ( the distal solid part of which is generally termed the guard or rostrum ) , I would remark , that since my former communication I have inspected many hundred specimens from various localities , and have ascertained that although in detached examples ( the ordinary condition in which these fossils occur ) the rostrum appears to terminate by a well-defined line at the upper part , yet this is not really the case ; for the same radiated structure originally extended upwards , and surrounded and protected the phragmocone as a sheath , and gradually became confluent with the investing capsule or periostricum ; probably terminating in a horny flexible integument .
A fragment of the receptacle taken from the upper part of a specimnen , and which is not thicker than stout paper , is delineated under a mag* Philosophical Transactions , 1848 , Plate XV .
fig. 3 .
394 nifying power of eight diameters in Plate XXIX .
fig. 6 .
In this section are clearly seen the outer integument or periostricum ( a ) , the radiated structure of the osselet ( b ) , and the shell of the phragmocone ( c ) .
Among the numerous Belemnites I have examined , not the slightest trace of an ink-bag or its contents , the sepia , could be detected .
BELEMNOTEUTHIS.-Some uncompressed examples of the distal end of the phragmocones of this Cephalopod have lately been discovered , which must dispel any remaining doubts as to the generic distinction , first established by the late Mr. CHANNING PEARCE in 1842 , being based on natural characters .
The specimen figured , Plate XXIX .
fig. 7 , appear:s to me to afford conclusive evidence on the points in dispute .
By a reference to my former paper , it will be seen that the longitudinal ridges , which are always present on the distal end of the phraginocone of the Belemnoteuthis , are regarded by those observers who contend that the latter belong to Belemnites , as plaits , or folds , originating from fracture and lateral compression .
In the fossil before us these ridges are entire and well-defined ; two are situated on the ventral and one on the dorsal region .
Fig. 7 is a transverse section , enlarged four diameters , in which are shown the forrm of the ridges and the radiated structure of the solid part of the phragmocone : I scarcely need observe , that in the true Belemnite the cone is chambered to the extreme apex .
These characters will remind the palaeontologist of the very analogous organization of the Beloptera of the tertiary strata , alluded to in my former memoir* .
In fact it is now proved that the Belemnoteuthis ( as was originally suggested by Mr. CHANNING PEARCE and Mr. CUNNINGTON ) possessed an osselet of a radiated structure containing a chambered siphunculated cone , but without an extended rostrum or guard ; thus forming an interesting transition to the Belemnite , from which it is generically distinctt .
From the facts before us , our knowledge of the organization of the genus Belemnites comprises the following structures:1 .
The investing periostricum or capsule , which enveloped the osselet , and extending upwards , constituted the external parietes of the receptacle .
2 .
The Osselet , characterized by its radiated structure , composed of trihedral prismatic fibres , which terminated distally in a solid rostrum having an alveolus or conical hollow to receive the lower portion of the chambered phragmnocone , and proximally in a thin cup-like expansion , which became confluent with the capsule , and formed the receptacle for the viscera .
3 .
The Phragmocone , or conical siphunculated chambered internal shell , the apex of which occupied the alveolus of the rostrum , and the upper part expanded into a capacious chamber , from the basilar margin of which proceeded two elongated testaceous processes .
Some of the specimens in the British Museum and in my own cabinet exhibit on the space around and between the processes , delicate striae , apparently produced by the imprint of the muscular fibres of the mantle or other tissues ; and these I believe are the only indications hitherto observed of the soft parts of the animal to which the Belemnite belonged .
In fine , the Belemnite is characterized by its rostrum and the investing capsule , and its phragmocone chambered to the extreme apex and having a pair of testaceous processes at the basilar margin of the peristome* ; while the Belemnoteuthis has simply an osselet of a radiated fibrous structure , enclosing a conical chambered shell that terminates distally in a solid obtuse point+ .
Whether the Belemnite resembled the Belemnoteuthis in possessing an ink-bag , and having a body with eight uncinated arms and a pair of long tentacula , future discoveries can alone determine .
Although this communication may be devoid of interest to those who do not especially cultivate the department of natural science to which this inquiry belongs , it will not I trust be deemed unimportant by the palaeontologist , since the new facts herein described tend to remove in some degree the obscurity which veils the original structure of a race of highly organized beings , that swarmned in the seas of every patt of the globe+ during the secondary geological periods , from the Lias to the Chlalk inclusive , and which appears to have become extinct with the contemporary Cephalopoda , the Ammnonites , at the close of the cretaceous epoch ? .
Chester Square , Oct. 1849 .
additional Note .
February 14 , 1850 .
Since the previous observations were communicated to the Secretary of the Royal Society , I have been so fortunate as to obtain from the Oxford Clay of Wiltshire , a Belemnite in which the two dorsal processes of the'phragmocone are more perfectly displayed than in any specimen hitherto discovered ( see Plate XXX .
) .
From the rarity of such fossils , and their extreme fragility and perishable nature , tI ] , z7 .
rjrav{j A~ " ' iVI iL,.BPzate 4I2 )07osal demnW p4z ?
e oft AylUesvaunis 1 " ial ; .5ze zS , r/ ) J Duk t eZk d % eI2 6N l27 IPr+nte,7 hy J. P sjx N,.9 , -I [ ? ?
9'/ I1t1A.^ J 4 ' TOrQ a !
?T ' , I , 717 IN .
Z ' / c , " !
i , ; . .
, ) .
K I , ' ?
,.yv ' &amp; 0'.5wo : T ' '.l '::'/ .'l'w ' ' .
: / ; , ' - , t 11 -/ ~-A-r l Taws .
DI)CCCL .
eXXTX .
397 .
5 ~5 9 10 , \ / i/ / Q/ XS ' , * IY,3 ?
r t ?
'l , , / 2 ) 1is b.(I b.I !
:i ii7b0 7 " ' 4 .
( '/ // , , : ' 3 1..I Ji .
; Z t -- , S a"l"u -P ) e e,114 a/ o Ir , with , / - , 5 -IV 7 7mbu , n.se , y , let .
i , Ii / I r~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ npg ' noNpm'g AMBRI " W SrZ Prl Rii W 9 ? ? ?
?~:-~I ; ?
: ~~~~~~~~~~~~~hj-.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:~~~~~~~ : ~~~~~ 'x ePk v.-~~ ?
Be1emmuitesJazosIun .
, sk/ ww ike upper p &lt; rt o/ fYpiT'hra .
Y mrrcone trvd the pair o/ deongalecdjprocesses ; from , i/ Oxfbrd Clay , 11i4t/ ac.l ( AhttZ ?
&amp; ossreS t J. Mffnsey , 6de , -_ ?
J_rde , en , , [ J. .
it is important to preserve faithful representations taken whilst the specimens are fresh from the stratum , for when the clay contracts by drying , the delicate shelly structure of the phragmocone but too frequently shrivels and flakesoff ; I know of no means by which this decomposition can be prevented , and am therefore desirous of adding to the illustrations of this communication the accompanying drawing , by Mr. MoUNsEY , of the beautiful fossil above mentioned , in which are shown the elongated processes of the phragmocone in their natural position on each side the dorsal line ; the interval between them is occupied by a thin pellicle of a dark integument marked with very fine diverging parallel striae ; this substance is probably the inner lining of the capsule of the sepiostaire in a carbonized state , a condition in which animal tissues so often occur in argillaceous deposits .
I likewise annex a drawing of another specimen ( Plate XXIX .
figs. 9 , 10 ) of the distal termination of the osselet of the Belemnoteuthis , in which the alveolus or hollow occupied by the chambered shelly cone is exposed ; the cavity is filled with calcareous spar , and is surrounded by a dense fibrous radiated structure , analogous to that of the osselet of the true Beletnnite ; an additional proof that in the Belemrnnoteuthis this investment is the osselet or guard of the phragmocone .
After this evidence , the presumed generic identity of the Belemnite and Belemnoteuthis must , I conceive , be abandoned by every accurate observer ; consequently the form and structure of the body and arms , and other soft parts of the Cephalopoda to which the Belennites belonged , have yet to be discovered .
DESCRIPTION OF THE PLATES .
PLATE XXVIII .
Fig. 1 .
Outline of a remarkably fine specimen of a Belemnite with the phragmocone and its elongated processes , from the Oxford Clay , Wilts .
In the British Museum .
The length of the original is 22 inches .
Fig. 2 .
Represents the basilar or upper portion of the above fossil of the natural size .
e. The right , and f , the left process .
x , x , x. The base of the process spread over the conical shell of the phragmocone .
PLATE XXIX .
Fig. 3 .
Part of the phragmocone of a Belemnite from the Lias , in the collection of JOHN MORRIS , Esq. 3 " Lateral view of a portion of the same , showing the remains of one of the longitudinal processes on the shell of the plhragmocone .
Fig. 4 .
Outline exhibiting all the known parts of the Belemnite in their relative position , the osselet being split asunder longitudinally , and one side removed to show the situation of the alveolus , &amp;c. 397 Fig. 5 .
The rostrum of the osselet of Belemnites Puzosianus from the Oxford Clay , Trowbridge , Wilts .
In this specimen the upper part of the guard is removed and exposes the distal extremity of the phragmocone lying in its natural position in the alveolus .
The ventral aspect is delineated to show the form and situation of the sulcus or groove ( the characteristic of this species ) in that region : the siphunculus is on the front of the phragmocone in this view .
The several parts represented in the above figures are indicated as follow : a , a. The pair of elongated processes of the phragmocone .
b. Osselet , rostrum , or guard .
b ' .
The upward extension of the expanded osselet .
c , c. Siphuncle .
d , d. The phragmocone .
e. Section of the capsule or outer investment of the osselet .
Jr The apical or distal termination of the phragmocone .
g. The alveolus or hollow in the rostrum in which the end of the phragmocone is situated .
h. Vertical section of the guard , showing its fibrous and radiated structure .
i. Ventral aspect .
k. Ventral sulcus or groove .
1 .
Section of the capsule investing the guard .
Fig. 6 .
Transverse section of a fragment from the upper part of the receptacle of the Belemnite near the base of the process ; magnified eight diameters .
In this thin pellicle are seen , a. the Capsule ; b. the radiated fibrous structure of the osselet distinctly visible , though taken several inches from above the line which is usually regarded as the termination of the spathose osselet ; c. the shell of the phragmocone .
Fig. 7 .
The apical or distal end of the phragmocone of the Belemnoteuthis , showing the ventral aspect , and the pair of ridges : natural size .
7 " .
A transverse section of the same , displaying the internal radiated structure of the phragmocone and its solid apex : magnified four diameters .
*

