Observations on certain cases of Elliptic Polarization of Light by Refjexion .
By the Rev. BADEN POWELL , M.A. , F.R.S. , F.G.S. , F.R.A.S. , Savilian Professor of Geometry in the University of Oxford .
Received November 10 , 1842 , -Read January 26 , 1843 .
Introduction .
THE peculiar character impressed on light , originally polarized in a plane inclined to that of incidence and reflected from a metallic surface , discovered by Sir D. BREWSTER* , and named by him elliptic polarization , has been since shown to coincide with what , from a different analogy , is termed elliptic polarization in the undulatory theory ; and which is also exhibited by an interposed plate of mica , or by total internal reflexion , as in FRESNEL'S rhomb .
The most distinct experimental test of the existence of this property and a measure of its amount , is the well-known dislocation of the polarized rings , seen by a plate of calc-spar and a tourmaline , in light of this kind .
And this , as in other similar cases , is represented theoretically by a formula for the intensity at any part of the plate , in the case of the rhomb , for circular polarization , as in Mr. AIRY'S tract on the undulatory theory ( Art .
160 .
) ; and for elliptic , as in the same author 's paper on quartz- .
A general formula for the rings in light of all degrees of ellipticity , not restricted by the peculiar conditions of the rhomb , has not been hitherto published : but I am indebted to Mr. AIRY for the communication of such a formula , which will be given in the sequel , as leading to some remarkable applications .
With immediate reference to the experiments of Sir D. BREWSTER on thin jilmst+ Professor LLOYD , in 18 iivestigated on the principles of the undulatory theory , theo he general case of light previously polarized in any azimuth , and reflected from a thin plate , at any angle ; and by generalizing the methods of M. POISSON , found expressins both for the intensity , the changes corresponding to different incidences , and the phase of vibration of the pencils reflected from the two surfaces , which in general differ in retardation and are polarized , one in the plane of reflexion and the other perpendicular to it : whence it follows that the resulting light should be in general elliptically polarized ? .
Professor LLOYD'S theory seems completely to explain the various phenomena ob* Philosophical Transactions , 1830 .
t Cambridge Transactions , 1831 .
% Philosophical Transactions , 1840 . ?
See Reports of British Association , 1841 , Sectional Proceedings , p. 26 .
served by Sir D. BREWSTER , including those of Mr. ATRY* on the colours of thin plates in polarized light .
But Professor LLOYD also infers the further application of the same principles to the case of elliptic polarization in the reflexion from polished metals , on the hypothesis that their superficial laminae may be regarded as thin plates , or at least act in an analogous manner .
Before I was acquainted with Professor LLOYD'S theoretical investigations , I had pursued an experimental examination of the phenomena of elliptic polarization in the reflexion frorrm various surfaces , in the course of which I was led to some cases which seem to have a more special bearing upon theory , particularly in connexion with the views just referred to .
My observations were all conducted by the method of observing the modifications of the polarized rings under different conditions , both of surface and of incidence ; and were directed to ascertaining both the existence and amount of ellipticity shown by the dislocation of those rings , as also to the peculiar character indicated by the direction in which the dislocation takes place ; the protrusion of the alternate quadrants appearing in certain cases in one direction and in others in the opposite .
The observations are reducible to two classes:-1st , those designed to contribute to the inquiry what substances possess the property of elliptic polarization ?
, by examining the light reflected from various bodies ; of which I here notice only a few cases which appeared remarkable ; 2ndly , observations on certain cases of ilms of several kinds , including those formed on metal by oxidation , or other action upon the metal itself , as well as by extraneous deposition .
In these cases the ellipticity generally exists in different degrees , and with different characters as to direction , while in some instances it is destroyed or reduced to plane polarization .
I at first noticed these effects as produced in some cases of highly polished metal which had become tarnished by long exposure , and in which iridescent films had formed on the surface without destroying the polish .
And again , in trying the effect of heating a metal plate , while observing the rings , I found the ellipticity disappear , but soon perceived that the effect was due to the coloured films formed on the surface , and remrained when the plate was cold .
I was thus led to institute more exact experiments of the same kind , in which the tints were formed in regular succession , as well as to examine steel in different stages of tempering .
From these cases I was naturally led to those of the fillns of metallic deposit produced by the galvanic process of NOBILI ; specimtens of which were kindly furnished me by Dr. DAUBENY .
In these films it is well known the colours follow , at least generally , the orders of NEWTON'S scale ; the thickest film being deposited where the action is most intense , or where the surfaces in connexion with the two poles most nearly approach one another .
In all these instances , then , I had a succession of films formed upon metal , in which the changes effected in the polarization could be traced in regular order .
The general result in all these cases , is that , from any one tint to another , through each entire order of tints , the form of the rings in the reflected light undergoes certain regular changes , passing from a dislocation in one direction , to that in the opposite , through an intermediate point of no dislocation , or of plane polarization : and this , exhibiting a dark and a bright centred system alternately , as long as the orders of tints are preserved pure .
Now these are precisely the changes in the form of the rings expressed by successive modifications of Mr. AIRY'S formula , corresponding to the increments in the retardation which belong to the periodical colours of the films .
In the instance of the metallic films it is a question whether in any case the existence of elliptic polarization be due to the action of the film simply , or whether the subjacent metallic surface have any share in producing it , while the film acts as a retarding plate , which would render the conception of the mode of action more complex .
These are points on which , perhaps , at present we cannot form a decisive opinion .
But the fact that the ellipticity , to whatever cause it may be due , undergoes the changes just mentioned , affords an interesting comparison with theory , and may aid future advances towards a knowledge of the nature of the action which produces elliptic polarization in these cases .
Apparatus and Method of experimenting .
The arrangement of my apparatus was , essentially , as follows : the light was polarized by transmission through a Nicol-prism ; this was attached to a small graduated arc , so that it could be adjusted to throw the polarized ray at any required incidence on the surface under examination ; and could be turned about its own axis , so that the plane of polarization might be inclined to that of incidence .
After reflexion , the ray was received by an analysing apparatus , containing a plate of calc-spar and a tourmnaline , capable of a corresponding adjustment to different inclinations , by which were exhibited the polarized rings in the several modifications they underwent in different cases .
This part had also a motion about its own axis , measured by a graduated circle .
It will hardly be necessary to state more details as to the construction of the apparatus , except perhaps to observe that an arrangement , by which the surface under examination could be slid horizontally under the polarizing apparatus , was necessary when the object was to examine the changes presented in passing from one part of some surfaces to another .
In many cases where the reflexion from parts of a surface of varying character was to be examined , I fitted to the eye-piece a lens of short focus , between the calc-spar and the reflecting surface , which enabled me to see with great distinctness the rings in light from very small portions of the surface , which could be isolated by covering the rest .
In all cases the analyser is supposed in the position to give the dislocated rings with 37 the nearest approach to the dark cross with the plain metal ; the circular systems alone being precisely described as dark or bright centred .
The direction of dislocation is distinguished by the quadrants in which the dark patches near the centre occur .
The position of the line joining them , upon plain metal , is taken as the zero for comparison in other cases .
The observations were repeated at several different incidences , but for the purpose of the comparisons here in view , it suffices to give the results at one incidence , the relative appearances at others being similar .
They are arranged in a tabular form in each case .
Observations.-Professor FORBES'S Mica .
The original observations of Sir D. BREWSTER were confined to pure metals and a few metallic ores ; in all which the ellipticity is insensible at incidences less than about 30 ?
, and comes to a maximum at between 70 ?
and 80 ? .
Besides these , as far as I am aware , the only instance is that announced by Professor FORBES *of elliptic polarization in the reflexion from mica when reduced to the particular state in which he used it for his experiments on heat .
On repeating the experiment I observed that it has its maximum at an incidence between 20 ?
and 30 ?
, and the direction of dislocation , 90 ? .
But the films thus formed do not lose their crystalline structure or retarding property : it may therefore be doubtful how far the effect may be explicable in the ordinary way .
Decomposed Glass .
In some specimens of glass , whose surface is in a well-known peculiar state of decomposition , not only iridescent , but having a singularly metallic lustre , I found elliptic polarization , though none was perceptible in other specimens , however highly iridescent , which had not the metallic appearance .
There are , however , anomalies with other metallic reflexion , for the maximum effect appears at small incidences ( about 30 ?
or 40 ?
) , and the direction of dislocation is 90 ? .
Minerals , 8Sc .
Among a variety of metallic ores , I have found elliptic polarization produced only by a few having a decided metallic lustre .
What proportion of metal may be necessary to give ellipticity , is an interesting question for future research .
But one remarkable instance is that of plumbago , which gives a small though distinct ellipticity ; while its composition is well known to be doubtful : but on the highest estimate it contains 95 of carbon to 5 of iront .
In some ores exhibiting a natural iridescence , the results seem analogous to those about to be described in artificial surfaces of this kind .
Oxidation .
The common effect of oxidation is to reduce the elliptic into plane polarization .
This is the case with the oxidation produced on copper , &amp;c. by a drop of dilute acid , and with the dull tarnished surface of most metals after long exposure .
A transparent film on the surface of polished metal may diminish or destroy the ellipticity , obviously from its refraction causing the rays to fall on the metal beneath at too small an angle .
Mercury , when pure , gives a large elliptic polarization ; and even when the surface is coated with the film of oxide which so readily forms upon it , the ellipticity remains unaltered : the surface of the oxide , however , has a sort of metallic appearance .
Daguerreotype Plates .
With one of these plates on which a picture had been formed , at incidences of 60 ?
and 700 , I could perceive no difference in the degree of ellipticity , or direction of dislocation , between those parts of the surface which remained bright , and those which had been most powerfully acted upon .
Tempered Steel .
With reference to the same objects I tried plates of steel in its ordinary state , and in two stages of tempering , viz. the yellow or straw-coloured , and the blue .
The former is well known to be that formed at the lowest heat .
The film or state of surface thus produced occasions changes both in the amount and direction of the dislocation .
Dr. THONISON* , in describing the process of tempering , observes that it is a question whether the changes in colour be due to thin plates of an oxide simply , or whether there may not be different oxides produced in succession .
This last opinion agrees with the nature of my results , as well as with the absence of change of colour on altering the inclination .
The results are as follows : Incidence .
Surface .
Polarization .
Centre .
Direction of dislocation .
70 ?
Steel , plain ... .
Elliptic , large ... ... . .
0 ?
Steel , tempered .
Yellow .
A { Elliptic , very small , }Dark ... 0 ?
or none ... ... .
Blue ... ... .
Very small ... ... .
Dark ... 90 ?
ii iiiiii i ii Coloured Films on Steel by Heat .
To examine the phenomena more precisely in their order of succession , I formed coloured films on plates of highly polished steel , about five inches square , by applying to the under side , at the centre , the flame of a spirit-lamp , when colours soon be* Chem. i. 386 .
6th Ed. 39 gan to appear on the upper surface , and assumed the form of rings round the point of application of the heat .
Each tint appeared in succession , first at the centre , and thence extended itself .
The first tints succeeded each other in the course of a few seconds ; but the latter more slowly ; until at length , after the heat had been continued for a considerable time , no further change took place .
The tints , proceeding in order from the outermost to the centre , may be described and grouped as follows:1 .
Reddish brown , crimson , deep purple , dark blue , light blue , faint yellow .
2 .
Faint red , light blue , pale reddish brown ( at the centre ) .
The last two colours were very faint , and seemed covered with a sort of cloudy whiteness .
It is difficult to compare these tints with any part of NEWTON'S scale : but I have here grouped them in two divisions which seem clearly marked by a periodicity , while in the last two tints a peculiar character appears to prevail .
The supposition of a change in the degree of oxidation before referred to , seems to accord with the peculiar appearance of the later tints , while the periodicity of the former agrees with the supposition of thin plates up to that point .
In the observed phenomena of ellipticity there appear distinctions corresponding to the regular orders of tints ; for in passing them in succession under the apparatus , corresponding changes in the amount and direction of dislocation occur , as far as the red of the 2nd set ; while in the remaining part , the ellipticity is greatly diminished , and no change in direction takes place .
The figures 1 , 2 , &amp;c. distinguish successive parts of each coloured space at which the changes occur .
Incidence .
Surface .
Polarization .
Centre .
Direction of dislocation .
70 ?
Steel , plain ... .
Elliptic , large ... ... ... ... .
0 ?
Films by heat .
1st Red ... ... Elliptic , large ... ... ... ... 0 ?
Ble .
fi1 Plane ... ... ... ... Bright .
e2 Elliptic , large ... ... ... ... 90 ?
Yellow ... ... .
Plane ... ... ... ... Dark .
2nd Red ... ... Elliptic , large ... ... . .
0 Blue , &amp;c. .
Small ... ... ... . .
ark. .
0 Coloured Films on Copper by Heat .
I formed colours in exactly the same way on plates of copper of the same size .
The tints here do not appear exactly the same as those on steel , though there is some general correspondence : they follow this order , commencing from the outermost .
I st. Red , purple , pale yellow , yellow .
2nd .
Red , green , dull brown .
40 The last two tints have a sombre appearance , different from the metallic lustre of the others : this ( as in the last case ) may accord with the supposition of a different degree of oxidation .
Here also I find similar changes in the ellipticity through the first tints , but none in the last two .
Incidence .
Surface .
Polarization .
Centre .
Directionof dislocation .
70 ?
Copper , plain. .
Elliptic , large ... ... ... 0 ?
Films by heat .
1st Red ... ... Elliptic , large ... ... .
0 ?
Purple ... ... Plane ... .
Bright .
Yellow .
{ 1 Elliptic , large. .
90 ? ?
2 Plalne ... ... ... Dark .
2nd Red ... ..-Elliptic , large ... ... .
0 Green , &amp;c. ... .
Small ... ... . .
Dark. .
0 ?
, ii ii iii iii iiiiiiiL~ i lllllllllll NOBILI'S Coloured Films .
Besides furnishing me with several specimens of these films on steel plates , in which very brilliant tints were developed as far as the 3rd order , Dr. DAUBENY kindly caused other plates to be prepared in his laboratory , in order to trace the order of the effects produced .
In forming one of these , the process was continued longer than before , and thus a 4th order of very faint colours succeeded .
In another instance the process was continued still longer , and colours were formed which went through the same series as before , but at the 4th order they became extremely dusky and obscure ; and the 5th order was barely visible from increasing opacity .
They followed one another in succession towards the circumference , where they were at length crowded together , forming a narrow fringe , within which the central space was of a deep brown or black , of a dull , opake , appearance ; and when this had occurred , the galvanic action being kept up for some time afterwards , no further change took place .
It can hardly be doubted that the increasing dullness in the later orders of tints , and final opacity of the film , are due to some change in the nature of the deposit which is superinduced at this stage of the process .
On bringing the coloured parts of the plate successively under the apparatus , the changes in the rings were clearly marked through the three orders of tints ; though they followed in very close succession , commencing upon the edge of the film ; and in the passage through the bright-centred system the variations of colour were striking , and at first somewhat perplexing .
The following general results were derived from repeated observations with different plates compared together .
Incidence .
Surface .
Polarization .
Centre .
Direction of dislocation .
70 Steel , plain ... ... ... ... Elliptic large ... ... ... ... ... .
NOBILI'S films .
r.A. , .
yellow 1 Elliptic , large ... ... ... 90 ylo ^ jy1 2 Plane ... .D ... ... ark .
First order .
Elliptic , large ... ... ... ... ... ... . .
X *^^4 Plane ... ... ... . .
Bright .
1 Elliptic , large ... r90 f , greei i P ... ... ... ... ... ... ark .
Second ordergreen 2 Plane .
Dark .
red 3 Elliptic , large ... .
4 Plane ... ... ... ... ... . .
Bright .
1 Elliptic , large ... .
90 grheen 2P lane ... ... ..D .
Dark .
Third order red 3 Elliptic , large ... ..0 4 Plane .
Bright .
Fourth order i green ... .
Elliptic , small ... .* Dark .
0 red ... .
Elliptic , very small ... ... a. k. 0 Black ... Elliptic , very small , or none Dark .
0 Analytical Investigation .
Mr. AIRY'S general formula is investigated as follows : In the usual notation of the undulatory theory , we suppose a vibration in a plane P , represented by a sin ( v t x ) incident on a metallic surface , so that P is inclined 45 ?
to the plane of reflexion R. Then ( the vibration perpendicular to R being accelerated in phase by g ) the resolved parts are a. 2s ^ sin v t-x ) ... in R. a 2 , r =2sin A ( v tx + ) .
perpendicular to R. Then for a plane Q in the crystallized plate inclined to R by an angle p ( omitting the constant coefficient ) the vibration perpendicular to Q , giving the ordinary ray , 0 , will be sin( ( v t+ g ) ) cos psin = 0 , and that in Q giving the extraordinary ray E will be sin ( v t+ g ) sin + sin ( vt ) cos =E But on emergence from the crystallized plate the latter is accelerated by 0 ( dependent on the thickness traversed ) , or it becomes sin ( in ( ( vt-x +)+ ) +cos sin(^ ( v t)+)= E ' .
The parts remaining after analysation in a plane A perpendicular to P will then be , O cos ( 45 - ) E sin ( 45 p ) .
These upon expansion are at length reducible to the form 2 sr 2 t-H sin ( v t -x ) + Kcos ( V t ) , whence , after reduction , we obtain H2 + K2 =I sin2 2p cos cos 2p sin g sin -cos2 2 cp cos , cos , which expresses the intensity of light at any part of the rings , assigned by p and 0 ; and is susceptible of variations according , to the value of ?
, or the changes in retardation which may arise from differences in the nature of the metallic films , as in the following Table : Expression for the intensity : ?
given .
Values Nature of the rings .
of .
For in general .
S 1O90 .
{ 2 .
135 IS 1 .
L 22 .
12700 .
3150 .
01 sin2 2p cos 2p cos 01 cos 0. .
01 cos. .
0 Dark-centred , circular .
1 cos 2p sin 0 ... ... . .
sin. .
11+ sin. .
1 Dislocated ( 1 ) .
1+ sin 22 +cos2 29 cos 1+ cos 0. .
2+ cos 8. .
2 Bright-centred , circular .
1+ cos 2p sin ... ... ... .
1+ sin. 11 sin. .
1 Dislocatedoppositewayto(l ) 2i1 sin2 2 cos2 20 cos 01 cos 0. .
01 cos 0. .
0 Dark-centred , circular .
&amp;c. &amp;c. &amp;c. &amp;c. &amp;c. &amp;c. &amp;c. &amp;c. These changes will accord with those observed through one order of tints , if the increase of ?
from 0 to 2X correspond to an increment of one wave length , or if 2rk = ' x and k be made successively =0 , &amp; C. 43

