Researches on the Decomposition and Disintegration of Phosphatic Vesical Calculi , and on the Introduction of Chemical Decomponents into the Living Bladder .
By S. ELLIOTT HOSKINS , M/ I.D. Communicated by P. M. ROGET , 1I.D .
, Sec. R.S. Received December 8 , 1842 , -Read February 23 , 1843 .
IN the following account of my 1hurnble investigations , I shall confine myself , as much as possible , to the physical plhenomena which have fallen under my observation ; reserving those of a physiological or pathological character for a sphere more exclusively professional .
Although FoURCROY strongly expressed it as his opinion , that calculi would , sooner or later , be dissolved by the introduction of chemical agents into the living bladder ; and , although some eminent wrLiters of the present day are of the same opinion ; there are others , no less eminent , who entertain doubts as to the adaptation of any direct chemical means to so desirable an end .
I must here state , that my reason for clinging to the creed of the former rather than to that of the latter , was founded on the increasing list of new agents , which chemistry is daily placing at the disposal of the experimenter .
Amongst these I hoped to discover some agent which should be more energetic in its action on calculi , and less obnoxious to the living tissues , than any hitherto proposed .
For several months my efforts were confined to attempts at dissolving uric acid and the urates , knowing that they constitute a predominating variety among calculous concretions : and , although I met with sufficient success to encourage perseverance , reasons not necessary to mention , induced me to abandon these experiments , and to prosecute others on phosphatic calculi .
The results of the latter it is now my purpose to detail .
A series of experiments was undertaken with the whole range of acids , vegetable as well as mineral , combined in various ways and in various proportions .
There could be no doubt as to the solvent power even of the weakest ; but their irritating effect on the tongue , and on the conjunctival membrane , was equally obvious .
Not one among them was found calculated to fulfil the two indications I required ; a circumstance which tends to corroborate , in a great degree , Dr. PROUT'S statement , - " that uncornbined agents of the alkaline or acid kind are ill-calculated to act as solvents for calculi ; and that solvents are to be sought for among a class of harmless and unirritating compounds , the elements of which are so associated as to act at the same time with respect to calculous ingredients , both as alkalies and acids .
" * PROUT on the Stomach and Urinary Diseases , p. 458 .
" At present , " continues Dr. PROUT , " no such class of compounds of a decided character are known , or appear likely to be discovered yet , as no chemical fact can be stated a priori , we know not what remains in store among the arcana of nature .
" The conviction I had acquired of the truth of these observations induced me to abandon all attempts at positive or direct solution , but rather to try the effect of indirect means , namely those of decomposition and disintegration ; as preliminaries to solution by some bland fluid , or to mechanical removal , by the injection of a continuous stream of liquid through a double current catheter .
It appeared , hitherto , to have been the object , to act on calculi by single elective affinity only ; that is , to dissolve the base before it was disengaged from its associated acid .
This mode having failed to produce agents sufficiently active on the one hand , and mild on the other ; it seemed more in accordance with chemical principles , and more likely to effect the desired end , if complex affinity could be brought into play .
It frequently happens , that reactions occur under the influence of double decomposition , which are not produced by simple affinity : thus , ammonia alone will not decompose nitrate of lime , though carbonate of ammonia answers the purpose readily .
The triteness of this example will , I trust , be excused in favour of the aptitude with which it illustrates my meaning .
For the above purpose an agent is required , the base of which shall be so attractive of the acid of the calculus , as to withdraw it from its allegiance ; whilst the acid of the agent unites with the basic ingredients of the calculus , to form with them salts of easy solution .
This view of the subject seems to reveal a class of agents so mild as to come directly under Dr. PROUT 's category .
During their employment , the combined acids are set free only in combining proportions , to be neutralized in their nascent state by the proper base , and removed out of the sphere of action before they have time , as it were , to act upon the animal tissues .
Whereas , free acids of sufficient strength to act on the concretion , and in sufficient quantity , cannot be prevented from irritating , in a greater or less degree , the animal membranes withi which they happent to be in contact .
The facility with which salts of lead decompose the phosphates , a facility which has led to their employment as tests of the presence of phosphoric acid , pointed them out as agents well-fitted for the present purpose .
Fragments of phosphatic calculi were accordingly immersed in solutions of neutral acetate of lead , of various degrees of concentration , and at different temperatures , but without result ; even when the assay , reduced to powder , was placed in these fluids and viewed with the microscope , no chemical action , however slight , was discernible .
I was disappointed , but nevertheless induced to try some other combination of the metal .
Dr. PROUT mentions , in his valuable work before cited , that fluids containing malic acid possess peculiar powers in arresting the deposition of the phosphates .
The same gentleman informed me that the solvent powers of the Alchemilla arvensis reside in the malic acid which this plant contains , My own experience has unequivocally 8 proved to me the efficacy of cider , as an ordinary drink , in cases of phosphatic urinary deposit accompanying rickets , and diseases of the lumbar vertebrae .
From these circumstances I was inclined to believe , that although the acetate had failed , a malate or super-malate of lead would be likely to act as a decomponent of phosphatic concretions .
Another reason for selecting malic acid was the solubility of the salts it forms with the bases of these calculi , viz. magnesia , lime , &amp;c. Having no readier means of procuring the malate , I sought to prepare it from cider vinegar , or what is called cidre-aigre in contra-distinction to vin-aigre , a liquid commonly used as a substitute for wine or malt-vinegar , in the farim-houses and cottages of the Channel Islands .
To this cidre-aigre a watery solution of neutral acetate of lead was added , till precipitation no longer took place .
The liquid , on being filtered , was clear , devoid of acidity or acrimony ; and , as Dr. CHRISTISON states , with respect to acescent wines to which lead has been added , it possessed " a very pleasant sweetness , quite unmingled with metallic astringency* .
" The whole of the passage , rielating to French wines , from which the above sentence is quoted , seems particularly applicable to the liquid under consideration .
In default , however , of any authentic analysis of cider-vinegar , my observations induced me to believe , that the acids it contained were the acetic , malic , and tartaric ; but as I was unwilling to interrupt the course of experiments , in order to analyse it , I am unable to determine this point with the necessary accuracy .
Nevertheless , whatever may be its composition , the immersion of fragments of phosphatic calculi in the liquid formed as before stated , was followed by very striking results : rapid chemical action ensued , visible to the naked eye ; when viewed by means of a low microscopic power , vehement decomposing action was manifest , the calculous particles becorning surrounded by areolcv or nebulw of white sediment , which continued increasing until each fragment was reduced to a pulpy state resembling mortar , perfectly soluble in very dilute nitric acid .
On suspending a fragment of fusible calculus , by means of horse-hair , in a testglass containing the fluid , it became at once involved in a white cloud , from which a continuous stream of precipitate gravitated to the bottom of the glass .
After the lapse of half an hour the calculus was found to have lost weight .
This was an important fact , without which it might have been supposed that decomposition of the solution alone had given rise to the precipitate .
Being inclined to doubt the evidence of m'y senses , rather than arrive at a false conclusion , I repeated the experiment .
Another particle of triple phosphate was placed in a fresh quantity of the liquid ; at the moment of immersion chemical action commenced , and purisued the same course , until the fragment became a semi-solid mass , readily disintegrated .
After a time nothing remained but the shreds of mucus , or other animal matter , which had cemented the earthy ingredients together .
The result of analogous experiments , performed subsequently , warrants me in sta* CHRISTISON on Poisons , p. 407 .
ting that the precipitate in the present instance was chiefly phosphate of lead* ; it may likewise be fairly inferred , that the other ingredients composing the calculus had formed soluble salts with the malic and acetic acids of the decomponent .
For it was manifest that the acids contained in cidre-aigre had formed soluble salts with oxide of lead , and that these salts , even when dissolved in such a quantity of fluid as to possess scarcely any taste and no pungency , were capable of decomposing phosphatic calculi .
The liquid in this state , however , was objectionable , in a practical as well as a scientific point of view , on account of its colour , odour , and indeterminate strength .
It therefore became desirable to attempt the formation of some definite salt , of analogous composition , which , by solution in water , should form a decomposing agent , of a strength which might at all times be depended on ; capable also of being varied according to circumstances .
In theory , the nearest approach to an agent of this kind seemed to be a super malate of lead ; for , although the neutral tnalate was known to be insoluble in water , it was deemed possible that , by some modification , its solubility might be increased .
This I found to be the case .
Crystals of malate of lead , in fine powder , were diffused in water , and thoroughly decomposed by sulphuretted hydrogen , so as to leave malic acid in solution ; this was filtered and boiled to expel the gas .
While still hot , friesh crystals of malate of lead were added to the fluid , which was then allowed to cool , and again filtered .
On suspending specimens of phosphatic calculi in this liquid ( which , though sensiblyacid when tested , was perfectly insipid ) , chemrical action took place , but by no means rapidly .
This was , nevertheless , one step towards the acquirement of a definite compound .
Recurring to my former conjectures as to the nature of the salts held in solution by the filtered aigre , pure crystals of malate of lead were gradually added to warm dilute acetic acid- .
This mixture was heated gently for some time , and afforded a better decomponent than the former , but still not so active as the original cidervinegar compound .
After a long series of experiments to the same effect , which it is unnecessary to detail , I arrived at the following conclusions:--1st , that malic acid , unless concentrated , exerts but little solvent action on phosphatic calculi ; 2nd , that a weak solution of super-malate of lead does act as a decomponent ; 3rd , that a solution of acetomalate , if I may be allowed so to call the liquid last described , is tolerably active ; but finally , that none of the preparations of malic acid , already alluded to , are so active as the cider-vinegar solution .
The close resemblance said to exist between genuine malic acid , procured from the Sorbus aucuparia , and the factitious , pirepared by the action of dilute nitric acid on sugar , induced me to turn my attention to what , by some chemists , is called saccharic , by others oxal-hydric acid .
By slightly varying BERZELIUS'S process+ , so as to avoid the discoloration produced , as he says , by hutnic acid , a very pure saccharate of lead was prepared .
From this , saccharic acid and super-saccharate of lead were obtained by the aid of sulphuretted hydrogen , as described when speaking of the.malates of lead .
Saccharic acid , however , unless concentrated , exerted no greater influence on phosphatic concretions than malic acid ; the neutral saccharate of lead was likewise inert , whereas the supersalt proved so active , and yet so mild , that it seemed better calculated than any agent hitherto tried , to fulfil the prescribed conditions .
But as the sulphuretted hydrogen process was tedious and unpleasant , THENARD'S statement as to the solubility of the malate in acetic acid was applied to the saccharate of lead : a preparation of this kind seemed the more likely to answer from its similarity to the cidre-aigre solution .
An aceto-saccharate was , in the first instance , formed according to BERZELIUS'S directions* ; but as this process was likewise somewhat elaborate , I endeavoured to abbreviate it as follows:-Five parts of saccharate of lead , and the same number of minims of strong acetic acid , were added to a fluid ounce of distilled water , which was gently heated for a short time ; a small quantity of the lead salt was thereby dissolved , not more than half a grain .
This solution , although perfectly tasteless , acted speedily and with energy on any phosphatic fragment of calculus suspended in it .
The solution on the most careftl evaporation yielded no crystals , but was converted by heat into a viscous syrup , which ultimately became a species of caramel .
The liquid , therefore , although available for experimental , was not sufficiently definite for practical purposes .
But as LIEBIG mentions no less than three definite compounds of oxide of lead with saccharic acid , I did not despair of succeeding in the formation of a salt , such , in all respects , as I required .
" L'acide saccharique , " says LIEBIG , " est tres r6marquable par le grand nombre de combinaisons qu'il form avec les bases .
" It now became my oblject to form an acid saccharate of lead , which was accomplished thus:-a portion of pulverised saccharate of lead was dissolved in a sufficient quantity of cold dilute nitric acidt .
The solution , after being filtered , and gradually evaporated , yielded a quantity of perfectly transparent , amber-coloured crystals , in the form of regular hexagonal plates or prisms .
I have reason to believe that the colour is essential to the salt , for when I endeavoured to purify it by re-solution in dilute nitric acid , although it still formed hexagonal crystals , the salt had lost its activity as a decomponent .
One grain of this salt , which I shall call nitro-saccharate of lead , moistened with commences , and then instantly removing the spirit-lamp .
The fumes continue to be disengaged for some time , and when they have entirely ceased , decomposition by lime , and precipitation by acetate of lead may ensue .
five drops of pure saccharic acid , and dissolved in a fluid ounce of distilled water , formed a bland liquid without any astringency , although it possessed slight acid reaction .
It acted with rapidity on various specimens of phosphatic calculi , forming around each , at the moment of immersion , the dense nebula formerly described , from which a white precipitate subsided .
Chemically speaking , this was the most active agent yet experimented with , whilst its sensible character was so mild as to be tolerated with perfect impunity by the urethral and conjunctival membranes .
The following experiments , selected from a great number of others , to the same effect , will suffice to show the results of the action of this nitro-saccharate solution on human phosphatic calculi .
Experiment I,.-Seven fragments of various sizes and figures , taken indiscriminately from a collection of phosphatic specimens , were placed in distilled water until airbubbles ceased to be disengaged from them : they were found to weigh collectively , after being allowed to drain for a minute or two on bibulous paper , one hundred grains .
These fragments , each suspended by a horse-hair , were placed in ten fluid ounces of the above-mentioned nitro-saccharate solution for twenty-five minutes , during which time the temperature of the fluid was maintained at 98 ?
FAHR. They were then removed and plunged into ten ounces of fresh solution , of the same strength and temperature , for a quarter of an hour .
In both cases , copious precipitation took place from each fragment , and accumulated at the bottom of the glasses .
The calre-weighed , were found to have lost twelve grains * .
The two portions of solution , together amounting to twenty ounces , were then passed through a filter ; and the precipitate , after being washed and carefully dried , was found to weigh eleven grains .
A small quantity of it , heated alone on charcoal by .
mneans of the blowpipe , gave indications of the presence of phosphate of lead .
In order , however , to determine the nature of the acid contained in the lead precipi'tate , another portion of it was dissolved in dilute nitric acid ; to this solution was added a drop or two of nitrate of silver , and on being cautiously neutralized by weak liquid ammonia , a yellow precipitate , characteristic or the presence of phosphate of silver , made its appearancet .
A third portion of the dried precipitate was mixed with borax , and fused by the blowpipe on charcoal ; the bead thus formed was transfixed by a fine needle , and strongly heated in the interior flame ; on being broken after cooling , it was found to consist of magnetic 'particles of phosphuret of iron , affording another proof of the presence of phosphoric acid in the precipitate .
With respect to the filtered solution , half of it , amounting to ten ounces , on being cautiously evaporated to dryness , yielded rather more than nine grains of solid residue , which , however , was not analysed .
The remaining ten ounces were treated with sulphuretted hydrogen , so as to decompose the whole of the salt of lead : it was then filtered , boiled , and tested with oxalate of ammonia , which produced after a time a trifling precipitation of lime : the superaddition of liquid ammonia gave no evidence of the presence of magnesia .
At the commencement of the experiment the solid materials amounted to 120 grains , viz. Seven calculous fragments ... = 100 grs. Nitro-saccharate of lead in solution ... ... 20 120 After the operation the following seems to have been the arrangement of the ingredients : Calculous fragments after immersion for forty minutes .
= 88 grs. Precipitate separated by filtration and dried ... .
11 Residue of filtered fluid after evaporation ... . .
19 Unaccounted for ... 2 120 Supposing the precipitate from the calculi to have consisted entirely of plhosphate of lead , the equivalent of acid would , on a rough calculation , have been 2-4 ; so that , had the assay been inorganic , or definite in composition , the exact amount of decomposed salt might have been estimated .
Under existing circumstances rude approximations are sufficient ; but I hope to be enabled to illustrate this part of the subject at some future period , by more careful and extended analyses .
The second experiment was conducted by suspending a fiagment of fusible calculus , weighing thirty grains , in five ounces of the nitro-saccharate solution for half an hour .
At the expiration of this period the fiagment had lost eight grains , and the precipitate arising from its decomposition , when carefully dried , weighed rather more .
The filtered fluid , treated as in the former experiment , contained a small quantity of lime .
In the course of the present experiment some very curious and interesting phenomenon were observed .
A copious , dense , white sediment , descended as usual in a stream from the calculus ; but , besides this , an ascending current was remarked : it consisted of air bubbles , bearing with them a white stream , similar to , though smaller than that which was seen descending ; on arriving at the surface the bubbles escaped , and the white particles theyhad rendered buoyant , subsided steadily , like sparks from an exploded rocket .
This circulation , similar to the ascending and descending currents produced in liquiids by heat , continued until decomposition fiotro saturation of the solution , or other causes had ceased .
The same friagment was afterwards immersed in other solutions of a simiilar kind , with a view of ascertaining its rate of decomposition:-but after decomposition had been going on steadily for some time , precipitation suddenly ceased .
Under the idea that precipitation had ceased in consequence of the solution having become saturated , fresh quantities were tried , but without any renewal of chemical action ; although other phosphatic fragments plunged into the same fluid were readily acted on .
The cause of cessation , therefore , could only be attributed to sonime change in the character of the assay ; on examination , instead of being white , friable , and homogeneous in texture , it had become fawn-coloured , dense , and striated ; and yielded unequivocally , uric acid reaction .
This accounted for the abrupt cessation of chemical action , and bore testimony to the effects of the saturnine solution on the phosphatic ingredients ; for it was evident that the latter had constituted the outer coating of an uric acid nucleus in the fragment under examination .
The result of experiments with other salts of lead , as well as with those of nercury , baryta , and others , confirm the facts already stated ; viz. that almost all supersalts of lead , especially with vegetable acids , act as ready decomponents of the calculi under consideration .
Even the acetate , which in its neutral state is inert , becomes active by the superaddition of a minute quantity of its own proper acid : and , in like manner , the addition of a few drops of lactic* , malic , racemic , or formic acids to solutions of their neutral salts , produces a class of active decomposing agents , so effectual , that either of them rmay be considered to afford secure means for discrimtinating the phosphatic from other varieties of calculi .
An interesting and perchance important circumstance connected with this part of the subject , relates to the strength of the solution , which appears to be in inverse ratio to its decomposing power .
Thus , a saturated solution of acetate of lead , acidulated pretty strongly with acetic acid , is inactive ; whereas , one grain of the salt , with five drops of the acid , dissolved in one fluid ounce of tepid water , produces rapid and steady decomposition .
This fact has been carefully verified by repeated experiments ; for instance , the moment a porition of calculus , which had been steadily decomposing in a weak solution , is plunged into a stronger , action abruptly ceases ; it is as suddenly re-established when the assay is returned to the weaker solution .
This alternation from weak to strong , and the reverse , was often repeated with solutions variously modified , but invariably with the same general result .
On first remarking the above circumstance , I was not aware that BERZELIUS had previously recorded a somewhat similar fact in relation to the action of weak solu* When a fragment of phosphatic calculus is placed in a solution of super-lactate of lead , under the microscope a dense areola at first surrounds it ; from this , after a time , radii proceed , until the assay assumes a stellar appearance , of dazzling whiteness .
14 tions of borate of soda on uric acid ; and that , on the authority of WETZLAR , he had stated that uric acid is soluble in weak solutions of carbonate of potash .
The preceding experiments being apparently conclusive as to the decomposing effect of certain salts of lead on phosphatic calculi , out of the body ; the next point to be determined was the effect likely to be produced by the introduction of their solutions into the living bladder .
They had been found , on repeated trial , inoffensive to the eye and to the urethra ; they are constantly applied to abraded and inflamed surfaces , as well as used internally , with the greatest advantage : and , although some of these salts , by long-continued absorption , are apt to produce a train of specific morbid symptoms , it has been stated by physicians of eminence , that lead acts deleteriously only when imbibed in the shape of a carbonate ; that when the acetate appears to produce colica pictonum , it does so from being converted , after its reception into the body , into a carbonate ; and furthermore , that this conversion may be avoided by super-acidulation , the salt may then be administered with perfect safety in large and efficient quantities .
My observations tend to prove , that this super-acidulation is essential to the due action of the decomposing fluids I propose .
Whatever salt of lead may be employed must be moistene(d with a small quantity of its own proper acid , or a few drops of pure acetic acid , PREVIOUS to the addition of water .
In a chemical as well as therapeutical point of view this is essential:-1st , it secures the perfect solution of the salt and its consequent activity as a decomponent ; 2nd , the superaddition of acid secures against the formation of any of the deleterious carbonate .
In order , however , that I might be perfectly satisfied as to the comparatively innocuous qualities of the before-named salts , I undertook a series of experiments with thei on sheep ; introducing the fluids into the bladder daily , for several weeks consecutively .
and having the animals killed at different periods during the inivestigation , In none of the sheep experimented on , were untoward symptoms excited , either general or local .
It may be objected , that the membrane lining the viscera of graminivorous animals is less susceptible than that which performs the same office in man ; but as , on trial , liquids which irritate and inflame the humnan organs , act in the same way , and with the same rapidity on those of the sheep , I see no reason to believe that the one is less susceptible of such impressions than the other .
Experiments of a personal nature , not necessary to particularize , were also resorted to , and contributed to the conviction , that no evil could accrue from the continued introduction of saturnine solutions into the bladdert .
The following cases not only prove this fact , but * " Quand la liqueur no contient qu'un demi pour cent de carbonate alcalin , l'acide urique s'y dissout assez rapidement .
" BERZELIuS , Traite de Chimie .
tI refrain , for obvious reasons , from entering into particulars as to the general effect of solutions of the salts of lead in various morbid states of the bladder ; although I may be allowed perhaps to direct attention to the property these salts possess of coagulating mucus , -a property they do not fail to exercise on the secretion from the living organ , independently of their decomponent effects on the phosphate of lime which that secrefurthermore that the solutions are freely tolerated by the organ , even when rendered morbidly irritable by the presence of the stone .
The first case to be mentioned is that of a gentleman , seventy years of age , who had long been suffering from vesical affection , accompanied by alkaline urine , phosphatic sediment , and the copious formation of ropy mucus .
The catheter , when introduced , was felt to grate over calcareous concretions imbedded in the prostate gland .
In this case , a very dilute solution of nitric acid , one drop to the ounce of water , could only be retained a minute or two , its use being followed by considerable pain , which lasted for several hours ; whereas the nitro-saccharate of lead solution , although retained forfifty minutes , produced no inconvenience , either at the time or subsequently .
It was repeated daily , or every second day , for upwards of a month , and has been again resumed at the patient 's request* .
The second case was one in which two calculi existed ; the one was crushed successfully .
The bladder was extremely irritable ; nevertheless , the solution , injected at frequent intervals , for a fortnight or three weeks , produced no greater uneasiness at the time , or irritability afterwards , than an equal quantity of warni water .
The fragments voided by this patient were found to consist of a mulberry nucleus with a coating of phosphatic material , readily acted upon by the solution .
The third case was also one of phosphatic calculus in an irritable bladder .
The solution of nitro-saccharate was used daily for a week , and retained for half an hour at a time , not only without annoyance , but often with positive comfort .
The gentleman , however , not having patience to await its action on the calculus , nothing further was ascertained .
It will be sufficiently evident , from these mere outlines , that the cases themselves were utterly unfavourable for testing the LITHONTRIPTIC powers of the solution : they are , nlevertheless , well-fitted to afford evidence of its being neither irritating nor injurious , when introduced with proper restrictions into the bladder .
The establishment of the latter fact , although an important feature in the present communication , is not more so than the results which tend to denote the advantage of using DECOMPONENTS , rather than solvents .
The latter view of the subject reveals a class of mild , but effectual , agents hitherto untried , and points out a principle , the application of which , I trust and anticipate , will lead to the discovery of similar agents for the decomposition of the other varieties of calculi which afflict the human race .
Guernsey , December 1 , 1842 .
tion often contains .
Other matters connected with the mechanical means for introducing the fluid , the action of various decomponents contained in the urine , &amp;c. , must be reserved for consideration elsewhere .

