-lz..rm-zu .
MD CCCXLIV : Plate XIVI .
R. 32- .
- .
- ? .
' X , k* ' .
y , , .
J ?
.^ .
^A 2 .
: , &lt; ... ... t/ ; z3 S ; ?:o " i. t " t ; R ' .
, 88.fi &gt; . .
r. i ; { ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~"n ?
j:~rh:-d . ?
*~ ~~~~C`'~ ; 0.*~ SP ; ;f S , ; *. .
' 94 .
81 .
R.L. s724'.Deo .
21z§ 3 ' 217or- , .
J.Barz-e.cS .
_Phl .
Tr. ' .
-MDCCCXIII _PZlae l. p.3z ... ... , .
- ' 7 2 . ? . ?
~2 2D .
2Res .
320 49 ' 27b0r1 6 S6 '7 0.X Ir r 9I. .
I 3 .
' Xor 8 IY 7 -Dec .
320 49'3 Nor32 13 .
20k ?
o 1 &amp; ' 1-1§ 47 ?
]Jo .
j.O '13 ' 3 .
, - . ?
a- , FW s5 &amp; .
Observations on some of the Nebule .
By the Earl of RossE , F.R.S. , &amp;c. Received June 10 , -Read June 13 , 1844 .
As every addition , however trifling , to the little we know with certainty respecting the nebulae can scaricely be considered wholly uninteresting , I have ventured to communicate a few observations made with the speculum of three feet aperture described in the Philosophical Transactions for 1840 .
In using that instrument , the object was rather to test its powers , and to decide the merits of progressive experiments , than to seek for astronomical results , and therefore the micrometer was not employed ; in every case , however , the sketches were repeatedly compared with the originals , and having usually the advantage of the opinion of one or more friends , and always of that of my assistant , I believe they will be found to be tolerably correct .
Without accurate micrometrical measurements any sketch can be of comparatively little value as an astronomical record , since it would be scarcely safe under any circumstances to consider it as decisive evidence , where the question was whether any change had or had not taken place in the general outline or internal structure of a nebula , or in the relative positions of the remarkable stars in or near it .
Still measurements to be valuable must be exact ; and it would perhaps have been misspent time to have employed the micrometer with an instrument not well suited to the pturpose , when there was a prospect of being under the necessity of repeating the same operations againl , prlobably at a very short interval , in making a complete examination of the nebulae with the instruments now in progress .
Fromn these trifling sketches , however , we may perhaps faintly see some indications of the course which our speculations on the physical structure of the nebulae are likely to take under the guidance of increasing information .
Some estimate may also perhaps be made of the amnount of knowledge to be gained by an examination of all the lknown nebtulae with instruments like the present telescope , which astronomers favourably circumstanced may construct without any very serious difficulty .
The actual time in one year during which a powerful telescope can be used effectively is so short , that where observations must be accompanied by sketches , the progress is necessarily slow ; and it is still more so when the micrometrical rieasurement of faint objects becomes an essential portion of the work .
Out of a considerable number of tolerably good working nights there are very few , and even then often but for a short time , when high magnifying powers can be employed ; so that upon the whole a great deal cannot be accomplished by one instrument in a limited period .
As to the present telescope , it has not been constantly employed .
Unless the beginning of the night was favourable nothing was ever done ; a regular system of observing would have been quite incompatible with the constant care and attention required in the progress of the molre important work , the construction of a telescope of greater power , so that much fewer objects have been examined than would otherwise have been practicable ; and even with the great facilities afforded by Sir JOHN HERSCHEL'S invaluable catalogue , the whole amount of work done has been no more than the examination of about two-thirds of the figured nebulae , and a few others in the general catalogue , many of them , or rather , perhaps , most of them , under circumstances but moderately favourable .
The sketches were originally made in the gallery of the telescope , and represent the objects placed as they appeared , not as they actually exist in space .
1 have copied them without alteration , not thinking that anything would be gained by placing them approximately in their true positions , while they would perhaps be less convenient for future re-examination and correction .
The references are to Si ' JOHN HERSCHEL'S Catalogue .
Plate XVIII .
fig. 88 is one of the many well-known clusters ; I have selected it merely for the purpose of showing that in such objects we find no new feature , nothing which had not been seen with instruments of inferior power ; the stars , of course , are more brilliant , more separated , and more numerous .
I fear that no amount of optical power will make these objects better known to us , though perhaps exact measurements may bring out something .
Fig. 81 is also a cluster ; we perceive in this , however , a considerable change of appearance ; it is no longer an oval resolvable Nebula ; we see resolvable filaments singularly disposed , springing principally from its southern extremity , and not , as is usual in clusters , irregularly in all directions .
Probably greater power would bring out other filaments , and it would then assume the ordinary form of a cluster .
It is studded with stars , mixed however with a nebulosity probably consisting of stars too minute to be recognized .
It is an easy object , and I have shown it to many , and all have been at once struck with its remarkable aspect .
Everything in the sketch can be seen under moderately favourable circumstances .
Plate XIX .
fig. 26 , on the contrary , is a difficult object ; it requires an extremely fine night and a tolerably high power ; it is then seen to consist of innumerable stars , mixed with nebulosity ; and when we turn the eye from the telescope to the Milky Way , the sirmilarity is so striking that it is impossible not to feel a pretty strong conviction that the nebulosity in both proceeds from the same cause .
Fig. 29.-The annular nebula in Lyra ; 2 is the star in Sir JOHN IERSCHEL'S sketch ; I have inserted the six other stars as in some degree tests of the power of a telescope .
Near star 3 there are two very minute stars seen with great difficulty ; the others ate easily seen whenever the night is sufficiently good to show the nebula well .
The filainents proceeding from the edge become more conspicuous under increasing magnifying power within certain limits , which is strikingly chatacteristic of a cluster ; still I do not feel confident that it is resolvable .
I am howeverl disposed to think that it was never examined when the instrument was in as good order , and the night as favourable , as on the several occasions when the resolvable character of fig. 26 was ascertained .
Fig. 47 is one apparently of another class .
It has a star in the centre , and is of unequal brightness ; the nebulosity is in patches , and I have sometimes fancied , though probably erroneously , that I could discover in it a faint resemblance to fig. 26 .
The star in the centre is easily seen , and there is nothing peculiar in its appearance ; it is exactly like other stars seen in nebulae ; still it may really be but the brilliant condensed centre of a very remote cluster .
I have not , however ' , detected any gradual increase of brilliancy towards the centre .
Not to mtultiply sketches which soon may require correction , I shall merely add that in fig. 32 we also find a star in the centre , and in fig. 85 likewise a star in the centre , and many other minute stars in and close .
to it , so that it is really a cluster .
The double nebula ( fig. 72 ) consists of two clusters , between which there is a star easily seen on even an indifferent night .
In fig. 49 there are minute stars between and about the three large stars , and I think there can be no doubt it is a cluster .
Fig. 25 abounds in stars mixed with nebulosity ; I have not seen it on a very fine night , but it was observed by my assistant , and by a gentleman who was with hinm , and they had no doubt but that the centre was completely resolved .
In the little annular nebula , fig. 48 , 1 see nothing remarkable , farther than a star in the north preceding edge ; it is tolerably conspicuous , and is about half-way between the exterior and interior circumference of the annulus .
Fig. 45 is a very remarkable object .
It is no longer a planetary nebula , but an annular nebula , like that of Lyra , with a similarly fringed edge , though much less distinctly seen : it is oval , but the central portion is not so dark as that of Lyra ; it velry closely resembles the annular nebula of Lyra seen with an instrument of inferior ' power .
In several of the other figured nebule something has been discovered as to matters of detail .
In some we have found perhaps a few minute and apparently accidental stars , in others a larger extent of nebulosity , and consequently a different form of outline , but nothing of sufficient importance to make it desirable further to prolong this paper .
It appears to me , however , to be an important fact , that all we have seen strongly confirms the accuracy of Sir JOHN HERSCHEL'S judgement in selecting the nebulae which he places in the class designated as resolvable .
It is important from its bearing on future researches ; for where the power of our instruments is insufficient to do more than to bring to light distinctly the peculiar characteristics of resolvability , these once observed with due caution and their reality ascertained beyoind doubt , we shall conclude with little danger of error , that the object is really a clutster .
We should err , however , were we to assume the converse of the proposition , that the absence of all symptomins of resolvaility was evidencec conclusive that the object was not a cluster .
In some instances , with increasing optical power , the resolvable 323 character has become clearly developed , as in fig. 26 , and a further increase of power has shown the object resolved .
It is also perhaps important to observe , that now , as has always been the case , an increase of instrumental power has added to the number of the clusters at the expense of the nebulae , properly so called ; still it would be very unsafe to conclude that suckh will always be the case , and thence to draw the obvious inference that all nebulosity is but the glare of stars too remote to be separated l)y the utmrost power of our instruments .
The magnifying powers I have usually employed vatry from 250 to 800 ; occasionally much higher powers have been useful ; but to see every thing described in this paper , a power of 600 with perfect definition is sufficient .
In my paper on the Reflecting Telescope , in the Philosophical Transactions for 1840 , there is an error which I am anxious to take this opportunity of correcting .
In page 523 , line 14 , instead of " to the polisher , " it should have been " to the bar which moves the polisher measured on the edge F of the tank .
" We have always estimated the effect of the excentric G by the space on the edge of the tank traversed by the bar : the numler 27 was entered down at once from the jounal-book , whereas , to have suited it to the form of expression made use of , it should have been reduced to the centre of the polisher .

