On the Comparative Anatomy of the Tlhyroid Gland .
By JOHN SIMON , Esq. , Assistant-Surgeon to the King 's College Hospital , and Demonstrator of Anatomy in King 's College .
Communicated by JOSEPH HENRY GREEN , Esq. , F.R.S. , Senior Surgeon to St. Thomas 's Hospital , Prtofessor of Anatomy to the Royal Academy , 8Sc .
ec .
&amp; 8c .
Received June 1 1 , -Read June 20 , 1844 .
FEW portions of coumparative anatomy appear in a less satisfactory condition than that relating to the organs which have been classed together as glands without ducts .
Since any attempt to illustrate the obscure physiology of these bodies must of necessity be founded on a precise knowledge of their distribution in the animal kingdom , the deficiency cannot be considered unimportant ; and I accordingly venture to hope that the following details may not appear devoid of interest to the Royal Society .
In recent researches I have had occasion to examine how far the presence of a thymus gland extends in the scale of organization : in the present paper I confine myself to the comparative anatomy of the thyroid body ; and I hope , on some future opportunity , to communicate the result of similar investigations in regard of the remaining two organs of the class , viz. the spleen and supra-renal capsule .
In pursuing the present subject , and particularly in that part of it which treats of Reptiles , I have been under the greatest obligation to my friend Mr. GRAY of the British Museum , by whose kindness I have enjoyed opportunities of examining many animals which I could not otherwise have procured .
I have likewise owed much to the liberality of the Council of the Royal College of Surgeons , who have permitted me access to their rich assortment of store-preparations .
The careful dissections of MECKEL and CUVIER ( as recorded in the former 's Abhandlungen aus der menschlichen u. vergleichenden Anatomy u. Physiologie , Halle , 1806 , and in the latter 's celebrated lectures ) leave no question as to the universal existence of a thyroid gland in the class of inamimiferous animals .
It is therefore unnecessary to dwell upon this point , and I proceed at once to consider the anatomy of the gland in the other classes of Vertebrata .
I. Birds .
Some writers on the comparative anatomy of Birds have described " two glands , one on each side of the trachea , very near the lower larynx , and frequently attached to the jugular veins ; which they regard as the analogues of the thyroid gland* .
" They were first , I believe , mentioned by PERRAULT* , and were afterwards described in several genera of Birds by BALLANTIt and UTTINI .
Various later observers have since noticed these bodies ; some considering them as thyroid glands ; while others , among whoml are MECKEL , CUVIER and IIAUGSTED , entertain a different opinion of their nature .
In all such uncertainties the microscope is the only conclusive test .
By repeated and careful examinations , I have satisfied myself that the ultimate structure of these doubtful organs is identical with that of the thyroid gland in Mammalia .
They consist , namely , of a dense aggregation of closed vesicles , whereof each is constituted by a delicate homogeneous membrane , is invested by a close capillary net-work , and contains in its interior either floating cytoblasts , or mature cells , corresponding to those of the true glands .
My dissections of Birds have included all the orders , and , in most instances , several families from each : I have never failed to find the thyroid gland , or to recognise its peculiar structure : I accordingly presume that it is universally present in this class of animals .
Of its relative position it is unnecessary to say much more than is included in the notices of previous observers , and I will merely mention that its relation to the larynx seems neither essential nor constant .
A more uniform and more important relation is included in the fact , that the gland always colrresponds to a particular spot of the vascular system ; namely , that it lies on the cervical vessels , and receives its supply of blood just opposite to the point at which the veirtebral and carotid arterlies diverge to their respective destinations .
II .
Reptiles .
It is unaccountable that in this class of animals , where the thyroid gland is universally manifest , it should have been so generally overlooked .
Where noticed , it has been , with rare and partial exceptions , either mistaken for the thymus , or confounded with it in a common description .
A. Chelonia .
BOJANUS , in his excellent monograph on the freshwater Tortoise , figures with perfect fidelity the body , which I shall directly mention as the thyroid gland ; but he does so under the erroneous impression that it is a thymus , and describes it by this name : CARUS likewise falls into the same error as to its true nature .
The position of the thyroid in this order of Reptiles is very definite and uniform ; it lies in the median plane of the body , just above the base of the heart , between the right and left carotid arteries .
The thymus , for which it has been mistaken , lies away from the median line , along the outer side of the carotid on each side , between it and the subclavian artery .
B. Emydosauria .
In this order the thyroid gland is a single rounded organ , situate in the median plane of the body immediately above the base of the heart .
A careful dissection in this region will first brxing into view the thymus gland , which reaches on each side from just below the skull to within the thorax , and conceals the thyroid by the expansion of its pericardiac lobes in front of the base of the heart ; these being drawn aside the thyroid gland will be distinctly seen lying between the two carotid arteries .
CARUS* notices the elongated thymus of the Crocodile , and proposes the vague opinion that it may perhaps fulfil the double function of thymus and thyroid .
C. Anzphisbcenia .
The thyroid gland in the Amrphisbeenians occupies exactly the same site and relations as in the true Serpents .
D. Sauria .
In this order it is not quite so easy as in the preceding ones to verify the existence of the gland , for it occupies different positions in different families , and is therefore very likely to elude superficial search : in some it is single and mesial , in others double ; in some it lies high in the neck , in others low .
1 .
Among the Lacertidce , the arrangement of the gland is not quite constant for the family .
In the true Lizards , and in the Teius , the gland is single , and of considerable transverse diameter , being so situated as to overbridge the trachea a little above the chest : in the Monitors , on the contrary , it is double ; one portion is placed on each side of the neck , in front of the carotid artery , and is connected with the inferior extremity of the corresponding half of the thymus gland .
2 .
Among the Iguanidce likewise the anatomical relations of the gland are not quite uniform : in the Agamoe and Iguant it is single , and lies transversely across the trachea ; while in the Istiurus , as in the Monitors , it consists of two portions , one lying in front of each carotid low in the neck .
3 , 4 , 5 .
Among the Geckotidce , Chamceleonidc and Scincidce , the same general form prevails as in the true Lizards ; the gland is single , and elongated transversely so as to reach across the trachea .
In the Chameleon it is rather higher ( nearer to the os hyoides ) than in the other families , and is overhung by the sacciform dilatation of the larynx .
TREVIRANUS+ , in his dissection of the Chamceleo carinatus , noticed this body , and suggests of it that it " may be compared to a thyroid gland .
" Ophidia .
In the true Serpents the thymus and thyroid are in such close juxtaposition , and are in many genera so additionally obscured by the presence of a large fat body , that it is not easy to judge , from the vague descriptions of authors , how far the thyroid gland itself has actually been discerned .
The organ which BLASIUS* described as a thymus " vasis circa collut situatis accumbens , firmae admodum conditionis , hordei magnitudinem vix excedens , " was probably the thyroid gland ; CHARASt likewise figured it faithfully , though with the same mistake as to its nature .
CuvIER had certainly dissected it , and describes its exterior conformation with his wonted accuracy , stating his impression that it is " analogous to the thyroid gland : ' The following description applies to all the true Serpents:--The gland lies , as in the Crocodile , just above the base of the heart , between the right and left carotid arteries : it is a little hidden by the thymus of each side , which lies on the carotid for some distance from the pericardium upwards ; and in those genera which possess a fat body ( as is , for example , eminently the case with the Python ) this large organ lies conspicuously in front of both the thymus and thyroid .
F. Batrachia .
Among Batrachia , CARUS has recognized the th tyroid glands of the common Frog ; but his statement of their nature appears , like most of the opinions I have quoted , to be delivered vaguely and with hesitation .
The organs which he represents are unquestionably thyroid glands ; they are situated on the carotid arteries , just beside the cornua of the hyoid bone , one on each side .
HUscHKE , in adopting CARUs 's description , suggests that these bodies probably have their origin in the shrinking of the branchiae , and he proceeds to apply the theory so obtained to the thyroid gland in other animals , stating the common mode of origin of this organ to lie in the transformation of the branchial arches in the early embryo ? .
But this hypothesis appears sufficiently refuted by the anatomy of the Menobranchus lateralis ; for in this perennibranchiate reptile the thyroid gland exists no less certainly than in those which possess the branchial apparatus only for a time .
I have found the gland in this animal , consisting of two symmetrical portions connected with the inferior border of the os hyoides , one on each side , at the junction of the body and lateral portions of that bone .
In the Menopoma I have likewise detected the gland , occupying nearly the same relative position as in the Menobranchus .
In the Siren and Proteus I have had no opportunity of making satisfactory examinations .
In the Salamandride the same arrangement prevails as in the Ranidm .
In the anomalous Lepidosiren paradoxa the thyroid gland appears also to exist .
in his elaborate dissection of that animal* , discovered a minute glandular organ , adjoining the anterior extremity of each isolated cornu of the os hyoides , and inclined to consider it as a salivary gland .
I have had no opportunity of examining this rare reptile , but BISCHOFF 's account is so complete and circumstantial as almost to supply the absence of personal observation .
The minute body in question cannot be viewed as a salivary gland , for it is expressly stated by BISCHOFF to be destitute of an excretory duct .
This last point almost decides its true place in the animal economy ; and further , its position , in regard to the hyoid bone , is so exactly that occupied by the thyroid gland in the Menopoma and Menobranchus , that ( from BISCHOFF'S description ) I cannot hesitate in ascribing to it the same nature .
III .
Fishes .
I am not aware that any author has hitherto suggested the possible existence of a thyroid gland amongst this class of vertebrate animals .
In many fishes it is undoubtedly present ; I have found it in the Carp ( Cyprinus ) , Anableps-- , Pike ( Esox ) , Exocetus - , Cod ( Gadus ) , HIaddock ( Morrhua ) , Whiting ( Merlangus ) , Eel ( Anguilla ) , Sturgeon ( Acipenser ) , Callorhynchus t , Shark ( Squalus ) , Skate ( Raia ) , and questionably in the Lamprey ( Petromyzon ) .
It has appeared , on the other hand , to be absent in the Perch ( Perca ) , Mullet ( Mugil ) , Gurtnard ( Trigla ) , Mackerlel ( Scomber ) , Tench ( Tinca ) , Salmon ( Salrno ) , Triout ( Salmofario ) , Herring ( Clupea ) , Plaice ( Pleuronectes ) , Holibut ( Hippoglossuts ) , Turbot ( Rhombus ) , Sole ( Solea ) , Cyclopterus , Gymnotus and Balistest .
This part of my inquiry has been attended with extreme difficulty .
According to varying circumstances the gland may occupy any one of three different positions ; these positions , moreover , related to each other ( as would appear at first sight ) by no very obvious analogy .
It was long after discovering a thyroid gland in the Skate , and vainly searcthing for it in the corresponding region of the body in other fishes , that a second probable spot occurred to me , in which I succeeded in finding the gland in the Cod , Haddock and Whiting ; and it was yet longer before I ascertained the organ 's third occasional site .
Such having been the case , it has of course been no easy matter to arrive at trustworthy results as to the absence or presence of the gland in each particular instance .
In forming the negative conclusion , there was always some fear of having overlooked the organ , -always some doubt of its occupying an unexplored space .
The positive certainty , which alone is valuable in investigations of this nature , cannot often be derived from examining preparations preserved in spirit ; and , therefore , although I have made many such dissections , I refer to them in very few instances , and draw my inferences from those only which I can quote with entire confidence .
The positions in which I have found the gland are the following , viz.1 .
In those cartilaginous fishes* which possess it , as likewise in the Eel , it is a single organ , and is situated in the median line , in connexion with the anterior surface of the cartilages , which bind together the branchial arches of the opposite sides of the body .
Within this line it may be more or less removed from the mouth of the animal , sometimes advancing so far upward as to come into contact with the lingual bone ; but its position is always defined , as the spot where the great trunk of the branchial aorta distributes its terminal branches .
It lies in the angle of this bifurcation , and sometimes ( as in the Sturgeon ) extends some little way behind it ; it is coverled by the sterno-hyoid or sterno-maxillary muscle , and also by the mylo-hyoid and genio-hyoid , when these are present .
Situated at the anterior extremity of the first branchial arch , it receives its supply of blood by means of a recurrent branch given off in this direction by the first branchial vein , while yet within the gill .
It never receives the smallest share of supply from the branchial artery with which it is in contact .
2 .
In the Gadidce the gland is double ; one portion lies on each side , not as in the last case , at the anterior extremity of the first branchial arch , but near its posterior or vertebral end .
Here it occupies part of a recess which is bounded by the gill below , and above by the outer extremity of that transverse fold of nlucous membrane which limits the extent of the palate ; it is merely covered by mucous membrane , which leaves it apparent to the eye without need of any express dissection .
Its vascular supply is reflected to it from the ophthalmic artery , which arises , before the formation of the systemic aorta , from the first branchial vein close to the origin of the proper encephalic artery .
3 .
In the Carp , Anableps , Pike and Exocetus , the gland is placed at the inner extremity of the same duplicature of mucous membrane , and more toward the palate , so as to lie upon the fibres of the pterygoid muscle .
It requires more dissection , in order to be made apparent ; in the Carp especially it is at considerable depth , being hidden by the extraordinary thickness of the soft palate , and imbedded between the surface of the pterygoid muscle and the outer extremity of the branchial bone .
Amid these differences in the relative anatomy of the gland there is constancy in respect of one point , which I am inclined to consider essential ; the organ , whether placed in the median plane or otherlwise , whether at the vertebral , or at the hyoidal extremity of the gill , is always so placed as to receive its blood from the first bran* The questionable trace of a thyroid , noticed in the Petromyzon marinus , was in a depression of the base of the skull , between the palate and the posterior confluence of the branchial veins ; it would resemble the above in being single , but otherwise would be nearer to the thyroids of the osseous fishes .
chial vein , and is thus brought into connexion with the encephalic nervous centre by a certain community of vascular supply .
Nothing could at first sight appear more capricious and uncertain than the presence of the gland in fishes ; it would seem almost hopeless to account for its being found in the Carp , yet not in the Tench ; in the Eel , yet not in the Gyrmnotus , &amp;c. Further research , however , tends to justify the belief that its distribution is governed by a simple and uniform law ; namely , by the existence or non-existence of another organ , with which its presence alternates .
Since this law , if discoverable , must be an important step toward ascertaining the function of the thyroid gland , I beg leave to offer a few observations on the organ alluded to .
In many fishes ( take for instance any one of our common Acanthopterygii or Pleuronectee ) there exists a peculiar appendage to the branchial apparatus , first described by BROUSSONET* , and subsequently with more detail by MECKELt .
It has the aspect of a minute supplementary gill , and is situated between the outer extremity of the palatine duplicature of mucous membrane on the one hand , and the dorsal attachment of the first true gill on the other .
It must not be confounded with the large opercular gill , found in some fishes ( as for instance very largely in the Sturgeon ) , from which it essentially differs .
The vascular supply of this small appendage is a point of extreme interest in its history .
Its vessels communicate on the one hand with the systemic veins about the base of the craniunm , on the other , by a single long trunk with the first branchial vein .
RATHKE ?
and CUVIERII consider the former to be its afferent , the latter its efferent vessel .
But it surely must be erroneous to describe any part of the circulation in a fish as commencing in a systemic vein , and attaining a branchial vein without having previously traversed the heart : and I cannot doubt that the supply of this branchiola is after the analogy of organs in the systemic circulation , -that it comnmences , namely , in the branchial vein , and terminates in those veins which are conveying blood to the heartT .
The supplementary gill occupies in those fishes which possess it , exactly the same relative position as the thyroid gland in the sub-brachian Malacopterygii : a careless examination of the Cod , Haddock , or Whiting , where the gland shines through the membrane , might almost lead an observer to suppose that the supplemental branchia was there , as in the Pleuronectoe ; so similar is the arrangement in the two cases .
Equally exact , according to the above argument , would be the agreement of the two organs in respect of their vascular supply ; both deriving their affiux of blood from the first branchial vein , both rendering it up again by the readiest channel toward the heart , both as it were participating in the cerebral circulation .
But ( it may be contended ) this arrangement , which is comprehensible for the gland , is not equally so for the gill ; why should this organ , which , in regard of structure at least , is clearly branchial , derive its supply of blood from a stream no longer requiring aetration ?
It cannot assist the respiratory process , which is already accomplished for the blood arriving there : it cannot do more than maintain the previous oxygenisation of the fluid which traverses it .
I can conceive no other theory for the supplemental gill , in agreement with the preceding facts , than one which interprets it as a diverticular appendage to the first branchial vein , and contemplates its uses in reference to the parts supplied by that vessel .
Such then is the organ which , -obtaining the same nutritive supply as the thyroid gland , and occupying a correspondent , position , -found only where that gland is absent , absent only where it is found , -may fitly be considered as its partial and rudimentary representative* .
The general results of the preceding inquiry are as follows ; viz. 1 .
The thyroid gland , or an organ representing its place and office , may be found in all vertebrate animals .
2 .
It does not appear ( as is the case with some organs ) to belong to these animals , merely in behoof of the greater general completeness of their organization ; but seems to have particular reference to that specific character- , which binds them together as a natural section of the animal kingdom , -namely , the aggregation and more perfect development of their nervous centres ; for 3 .
The gland , shifting its position most variously , yet always maintains an intimate relation to the vascular supply of the brain ; always is so nourished that it can alternate a greater or less nutrition , according to the activity or repose of that nervous centre .
4 .
The organ , which in certain fishes represents a rudimental form of the thyroid , is plainly a mere diverticulum to the cerebral circulation : in the remaining fishes ( where a more perfect thyroid exists ) , as likewise in the ascending scale of vertebrate animals , there is no essential change from the vascular organization of the branctliola ; there is simply the super-addition of a glandular structure .
The thyroid is but a higher development of the branchiola : what was a mere capillary plexus , now has gland-cells intermingled with its texture .
Probably then the use of the secretory actions occurring in the thyroid gland is to be found in harmony with the obvious intention of its vascular supply ; as the latter is diverticular , so we may expect the former to be vicarious , or alternative .
Such are the conclusions which Comparative Anatomy may warrant , and beyond these the proposed scope of the present paper does not permit me to advance .
I would but in ending remark , that the views here suggested seem to me to receive equal sanction when contemplated in the light of the other physiological sciences .
The peculiarly occasional and intermitting character of the cerebral functions , the morphology of the thyroid gland , and its evident adaptation ( as I have elsewhere shown ) for a merely temporary , and , as it were , alternative secretion , the known ability of arteries to regulate and proportion the supply of blood transmitted through them , the diseases of the gland , -its turgid throbbing in hysterical lipothymia , the mnysterious relation of goitre and cretinism ; -these are topics on which it would be inconvenient now to dwell , but a glance at which is sufficient to show that comparative anatomy by no means exhausts the available arguments for the connexion suggested .

